Latest / The Feminine Manifesto / #15 Toxic Empathy: How Feelings Trump Truth Today
Transcript
- 0:15For too long, our culture has embraced and believed the lies of feminism,
- 0:19distorting God's design for women and leaving us burdened and unsatisfied.
- 0:24This podcast exists to confront the lies shaping our culture and boldly proclaim the truth of the gospel.
- 0:30True freedom is only found in Christ.
- 0:39Welcome back to the Feminine Manifesto podcast. Today, we're diving into a topic
- 0:43that feels compassionate on the surface, but is actually destabilizing our culture
- 0:47underneath. We're talking about empathy.
- 0:49Is empathy always good? Can empathy become distorted?
- 0:53And what happens when empathy becomes the highest moral authority in a civilization?
- 0:58Let's slow this down and really unpack it. If you Google a definition of empathy,
- 1:04something like this will come up.
- 1:05Empathy is the ability to understand and share the feelings of another person,
- 1:09to step into their shoes and resonate with their experience and respond with compassion.
- 1:14At face value, that sounds great. That sounds beautiful even.
- 1:18But here's the tension. When empathy becomes the highest moral authority above
- 1:22truth, above justice, above personal responsibility, it stops being a virtue
- 1:28and starts becoming destructive.
- 1:30Right now in our culture, empathy drives almost everything. If you support moral
- 1:35standards, you lack empathy.
- 1:37If you believe in law and order, you lack empathy. If you say actions have consequences, you lack empathy.
- 1:44That framing is not just simplistic, it's actually dangerous.
- 1:48Western civilisation, including Australia, was shaped by Christian foundations.
- 1:54At the core were a few stabilising truths. Firstly, humans are made in God's image.
- 2:00Secondly, moral truth is objective.
- 2:03Thirdly, actions have consequences.
- 2:06And lastly, personal responsibility matters.
- 2:10Compassion was central, but so was justice. Mercy and accountability were never enemies.
- 2:16The story of the world from the beginning has been to reject God's order,
- 2:19so this is no surprise to us. We see this throughout history.
- 2:22And when we do this, things don't go well.
- 2:26Likewise, in our culture, there is a rebellion against truth and against God's
- 2:30order in our modern society of 2026.
- 2:33And no surprise here, this is coming strongly through the push of feminism and
- 2:38the glorification of the feminine value of compassion played out in empathy,
- 2:43which has become the highest moral standard which we are to obey.
- 2:48Today, it shows up as emotional authority replacing moral authority.
- 2:52And that is where empathy, untethered from truth, becomes dangerous.
- 2:59Let's address something uncomfortable. Modern Western culture has shifted toward
- 3:04an emotionally dominant moral framework.
- 3:07And there's no surprise here that this has coincided with the rise of feminism.
- 3:12God designed men and women differently, and in the push to make women the same
- 3:16as men, we have blurred the lines of what it is to be a man and a woman,
- 3:20and have destroyed the uniqueness of our design, which is actually hurting our culture.
- 3:27God made man and then he created woman to be a helper to him,
- 3:31not in a demeaning way, but in a different capacity.
- 3:35We were created uniquely and differently to complement men.
- 3:39Likewise, male characteristics complement women.
- 3:43God designed men to be leaders of the home and to be leaders in the church.
- 3:47Ephesians 5, 23-25 For the husband is the head of the wife, even as Christ is the head of the church.
- 3:54Husbands, love your wives as Christ loved the church and gave himself up for her.
- 3:59In 1 Corinthians 11.3, it reads, I want you to understand that the head of every
- 4:05man is Christ, the head of a wife is her husband, and the head of Christ is God.
- 4:11We know this has been distorted because of the fall. In Genesis 3.16,
- 4:15the curse was that your desire shall be contrary to your husband,
- 4:19but he shall rule over you.
- 4:22So we see this playing out in our culture in real time.
- 4:25We see women leading their homes and the men begin to be feminized.
- 4:30These feminine values end up being heralded above anything else.
- 4:34A great example of this is in the whole gentle parenting movement,
- 4:38where kids' emotions are placed as the highest form of truth.
- 4:43There is zero responsibility or accountability for these kids because they are
- 4:48not seen as sinners, as the Bible says. They are just struggling with their emotions.
- 4:54Therefore, to discipline them is seen as being mean and shouldn't be done.
- 4:58This is wildly untrue and contrary to scripture.
- 5:03This entire movement has been pushed by women who are getting their husbands
- 5:07to submit to their ideas and feelings, which is causing so much havoc in our society.
- 5:13Just go and visit your local school and see the result of gentle parenting.
- 5:18This is compassion untethered to truth.
- 5:22We will get more into gentle parenting in another episode. This is not an attack
- 5:26on women. Compassion is beautiful and nurture is necessary.
- 5:30God has created women beautifully and these values are essential when it comes to motherhood.
- 5:36Why do kids generally want their mothers over their fathers?
- 5:40Because their mothers are the nurturers, the compassionate ones.
- 5:43Why does my three-year-old look at me with eyes of love when he's told to do
- 5:47something by his dad that he doesn't want to do?
- 5:49Because he knows I will be more likely to crack. Because of how I am wired.
- 5:55This beautiful nature God has designed and gifted us with is an essential characteristic
- 6:00for building up of our families, for inviting those who are hurting into our homes, for seeing pain,
- 6:06loving people, and in its right context, proves to build up our society in a positive way.
- 6:12The problem comes when the values typically associated with feminine emotional
- 6:18resonance, like validation,
- 6:21inclusion at all costs, avoidance of conflict, become the highest governing
- 6:26principles of a society.
- 6:28This is where the imbalance occurs.
- 6:31Structure then begins to look oppressive.
- 6:34Boundaries are unloving. Discipline is harsh and consequences feel cruel.
- 6:42The masculine coded virtues, generally like justice, order, protection,
- 6:46and authority, are reframed as toxic, and in a feminist society,
- 6:52these values are told to submit to women's emotional needs.
- 6:56But a healthy civilization requires compassion rooted in truth.
- 7:02If you remove truth, compassion becomes toxic.
- 7:07If you remove truth, compassion becomes toxic. Gad Saad calls this suicidal
- 7:12empathy and has written a whole book on it.
- 7:15Compassion that is so miscalibrated, it undermines the survival of the society extending it.
- 7:21You end up committing societal suicide all in an effort to be empathetic.
- 7:28Ali Beth Stuckey, a Christian commentator in the US, wrote a book called Toxic
- 7:32Empathy, which is incredibly challenging and helpful when thinking through this
- 7:36topic. It describes toxic empathy as empathy weaponized to silence truth.
- 7:43When you're pressured to affirm someone's feelings, even if those feelings lead
- 7:47towards sin and destruction.
- 7:49She goes on to say, it becomes toxic when it absolves personal responsibility
- 7:54and replaces justice with emotional comfort.
- 7:59This type of empathy labels accountability as cruel.
- 8:02It elevates victimhood above truth. And this is all through our society.
- 8:09Say, for example, imagine you see a homeless man on the street.
- 8:12You feel compassion. You see his situation. So you give him money.
- 8:16But what if he's addicted to drugs? What if he has repetitively rejects rehabilitation
- 8:21services and the opportunity to work?
- 8:24What if your money fuels the very behavior that is destroying him?
- 8:28If you pause and say, I'm not going to give you cash, but I'll support structured
- 8:31help, you're told you lack compassion. Why?
- 8:34Because empathy in our culture means emotional validation without discernment.
- 8:40Biblical love does not enable sin, though. True love sometimes says no.
- 8:45Empathy stops at the emotion that you feel.
- 8:49Wisdom asks, what actually is going to help this man? This is where it becomes even clearer.
- 8:54Think of the example where a violent offender stands before the court.
- 8:57We hear about his traumatic childhood, his absent father, his abuse,
- 9:01his socioeconomic hardship.
- 9:04All of those factors matter. They provide context, but increasingly context
- 9:08is becoming justification for their actions.
- 9:12The sentences are therefore reduced. Accountability is softened,
- 9:16and punishment is reframed as harmful because it doesn't consider his upbringing enough.
- 9:22We have shifted the moral weight from the victim to the perpetrator. And why?
- 9:28Because empathy for the offender overwhelms justice for the harmed.
- 9:33Let me just say that again.
- 9:35Empathy for the offender overwhelms justice for the harmed.
- 9:39But a justice system that erodes consequence erodes deterrence,
- 9:44and when deterrence erodes, communities suffer.
- 9:47And we see that playing in real time within our community.
- 9:52Compassion for background should never cancel responsibility for action.
- 9:56When we elevate explanation above accountability, we quietly teach that choices are optional.
- 10:04And we see this playing out through the abortion debate.
- 10:07A woman in crisis faces an unplanned pregnancy. She's scared,
- 10:11financially strained, unsupported.
- 10:13Empathy feels immediate and urgent. But when empathy leads us to affirm ending
- 10:18a child's life because her suffering feels visible and pressing,
- 10:22we have allowed emotion to override moral reality.
- 10:26We have allowed our feelings to murder the life of an innocent child.
- 10:32This is severely twisted. There is real pain involved.
- 10:36This woman is suffering, but true compassion does not mean we condone the sin
- 10:40of murder in an effort to alleviate pain.
- 10:43And in the case of abortion and in each of these scenarios, you actually end
- 10:48up hurting the person initially suffering immensely more by not bringing the truth.
- 10:53In the case of abortion, severely messing up with the women's emotions and postpartum
- 10:59hormones, which are designed to care for the mother and child.
- 11:03And more so, potentially not initially, but later, the guilt that this woman
- 11:07will feel when she realizes what she has done will be astronomical,
- 11:12knowing that she willingly murdered her child.
- 11:15This will be something she will carry for the rest of her life.
- 11:19Take the example of the gender ideology movement. A teenager expresses deep
- 11:24distress about their body.
- 11:26Our culture says the loving response is affirmation, immediate validation, medical transition.
- 11:32To hesitate is considered cruel. To even pray with them is outlawed in our culture.
- 11:38But when empathy rushes ahead of biological truth, irreversible decisions are
- 11:45made under emotional pressure.
- 11:47And especially for children, this is profound.
- 11:50We are mutilating children's bodies again on the altar of empathy,
- 11:55so that these kids' feelings in that one moment are validated.
- 12:00Feelings are real, but untethered to truth, they become destructive.
- 12:06Or finally, consider the ISIS brides who left Australia to join Islamic State.
- 12:11We see the interviews, we hear the children in camps, we hear the stories of
- 12:16regret, and as mothers and wives, our hearts respond and are pulled.
- 12:20We want to believe these women are good, but what is the truth?
- 12:24For all we know, these women voluntarily travelled to align with a terrorist regime.
- 12:30Their children have been brought up under this ideal, with their dads heralded
- 12:34as heroes, trained in the same brutal methods of their dads.
- 12:39A sympathetic response here is to not let these families back into Australia
- 12:43without any sort of accountability.
- 12:45When empathy alone drives the decision to repatriate without serious moral reckoning,
- 12:51we sideline justice and national safety.
- 12:55Compassion for adults who willingly participated in extremism must not erase accountability.
- 13:01A nation that can't distinguish between mercy and naivety will destabilize itself.
- 13:08All of these examples have the feeling of kindness initially,
- 13:12but they actually result in harm to the purported victim and wider harm to society,
- 13:18thus actually completely undermining the initial goal of the person.
- 13:22So whilst empathy feels like the right thing to do and the kind thing to do
- 13:28initially, we cannot allow our emotions to dictate truth.
- 13:33We must ensure we tether our emotions and feelings to truth,
- 13:37or else we risk literally killing ourselves and our society with kindness.
- 13:43It's like seeing someone drowning and jumping in without a rope.
- 13:46You feel connected to them now, but now you're both drowning,
- 13:49and no one has actually helped.
- 13:51So why is this relevant today, and why is it particularly relevant for Christians?
- 13:55This matters as Jesus is the truth. If we are in Christ, we must be concerned
- 14:00with preaching and living the truth.
- 14:03Jesus' example to us is the ultimate example we should seek to follow. And what did Jesus do?
- 14:09In Hebrews 4, verses 14 to 15, it says, Let us hold fast our confession.
- 14:14For we do not have a high priest who is unable to sympathize with our weaknesses,
- 14:19but one who in every respect has been tempted as we are, yet without sin.
- 14:25Jesus didn't empathize with our weaknesses. He sympathized and then he did something about it.
- 14:31If Jesus was to empathize with us in our sin, he would have come down from heaven,
- 14:36sat with us, validated how we are feeling, burdened and helpless in our sin,
- 14:41and held our hand through it.
- 14:42Now this sounds absurd, but this is what empathy is. We face real struggles
- 14:47in life, hardships and trauma.
- 14:49But in our world dominated by feelings and emotions, We do not need our feelings
- 14:54validated, especially when our feelings are a result of sin.
- 14:59Let's refresh ourselves as to what scripture says on this topic.
- 15:03In the book of Jeremiah, chapter 17, verse 9, it says, The heart is deceitful
- 15:08above all things and desperately sick. Who can understand it?
- 15:12In Proverbs 28, 26, Whoever trusts in his own mind is a fool,
- 15:17but he who walks in wisdom will be delivered.
- 15:21In Proverbs 14, 12, There is a way that seems right to man, but its end is a way to death.
- 15:272 Corinthians 5, verse 7, For we walk by faith and not by sight.
- 15:32In Hebrews 11.1, now faith is the assurance of things hoped for,
- 15:36the conviction of things not seen.
- 15:38Then on controlling our mind, 2 Corinthians 10.5 says, we destroy arguments
- 15:43and every lofty opinion raised against
- 15:45the knowledge of God and take every thought captive to obey Christ.
- 15:51Our minds must be renewed. We are not to rely on our thoughts to dictate our
- 15:57emotions and our actions.
- 15:59Romans 12, verse 2, do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by
- 16:04the renewal of your mind, that by testing, you may discern what is the will
- 16:08of God, what is good, acceptable, and perfect.
- 16:12And lastly, in Ephesians 4, 21 to 23, after just talking how we are to conduct
- 16:18ourselves as Christian,
- 16:19Paul, Christian, now this I say and testify in the Lord, that you must no longer
- 16:24walk as the Gentiles do in the futility of their minds.
- 16:27They are darkened in their understanding, alienated from the life of God,
- 16:32because of the ignorance that is in them due to their hardness of heart.
- 16:36They have become callous, have given themselves up to sensuality,
- 16:40greed, every kind of practice of impurity.
- 16:43But that is not the way you learned Christ, assuming that you have heard about
- 16:47him and were taught in him as the truth is in Jesus.
- 16:51To put off your old self which belongs to your former manner of life and is
- 16:56corrupt through deceitful desires, and to be renewed in the spirit of your minds.
- 17:01So it is clear from these verses that we must be distinct from the world.
- 17:05We are not to walk in the futility of our minds, giving ourselves up to greed, sensuality, impurity.
- 17:12We are to be renewed in the spirit of our minds, to take every thought captive,
- 17:16to realize that our heart is deceitfully wicked, and to walk by faith,
- 17:21not by what we see and feel.
- 17:24Now, Jesus was the most compassionate person, but he also confronted sin.
- 17:30He healed people, but he called people to repentance.
- 17:34Truth and love were never separated. The danger that we face today is we confuse
- 17:39niceness with righteousness.
- 17:41We don't want to be seen as harsh. We don't want to be labeled unkind.
- 17:45We don't want social backlash.
- 17:47So we soften. We soften the truth and we stay quiet on justice issues.
- 17:51We avoid hard conversations about responsibility and we allow policy shaped
- 17:57by emotionalism to go unchallenged.
- 18:02But empathy untethered from Scripture is not holiness.
- 18:06If anything, Christians should be the most grounded voices in these debates
- 18:10because we understand both human dignity and human depravity.
- 18:15We know suffering is real. We also know sin is real. And we have the truth that will set people free.
- 18:22So in applying this to our lives, we must examine our own hearts.
- 18:27Are we responding from biblical conviction or emotional pressure?
- 18:32Second, we need to distinguish between compassion and endorsement.
- 18:36We can acknowledge pain, but don't stop there. Tether it to the truth.
- 18:40Speak the truth in love. Don't leave people in their sin.
- 18:44Third, we can re-anchor empathy to truth. Empathy must sit under God's authority, not above it.
- 18:51God is the definition of love, justice, goodness.
- 18:55So when we choose to stay silent and not speak the truth, We are actually saying
- 19:00that we are more wise and loving than God, which is ludicrous and really is a form of idolatry.
- 19:07For Christian women especially, this is crucial.
- 19:10Our capacity for emotional attunement is powerful.
- 19:14God has designed us as nurturers, but when that strength is detached from discernment,
- 19:20it can be manipulated by culture.
- 19:22This is an area where it is for our benefit to submit our emotions and feelings
- 19:27to our husbands or to our father's guidance.
- 19:30God has created us as men and women to complement each other.
- 19:34A civilization cannot survive on feelings alone.
- 19:37Justice without compassion becomes tyranny.
- 19:40But compassion without justice becomes chaos. And right now we are watching
- 19:44the consequences of elevating empathy above truth.
- 19:48Our families are suffering, our children are suffering, and our society is crumbling.
- 19:54If God's truth covers our compassion, society flourishes.
- 19:58And that is the tension we must wrestle with courageously in 2026.
- 20:02Thanks for joining me on this episode of The Feminine Manifesto.
- 20:10Bye.