Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Monitoring US Immigration Raids" with Bellingcat, Evident and CalMatters
Transcript
- 0:04You're listening to a stage talk titled Monitoring
- 0:07US Immigration Raids. This week, we were joined
- 0:10by my colleague, Bellingcat researcher Kalina
- 0:13Koltai, and our long -standing publishing partners,
- 0:16Kevin Clancy, co -founder of Evident Media, and
- 0:20Sergio Olmos, an investigator from CalMatters.
- 0:23Together, we discuss the latest investigations
- 0:26from our collective, which focused on identifying
- 0:28the scale of immigration raid operations in the
- 0:31states, sharing advice for other researchers
- 0:34on what to look out for in bystander videos,
- 0:37and what, from patterns identified, could emerge
- 0:40over the next few months in other regions. This
- 0:43talk was hosted by me, Charlotte Moore, on Thursday
- 0:46the 17th of July 2025 in the Bellingcat Discord
- 0:50server. Welcome all to this week's Stage Talk.
- 1:03Since January 23rd, there's been an uptick in
- 1:06United States immigration and customs enforcement
- 1:08operations throughout the U .S. But the scale
- 1:10of these deportation raids have hit global headlines
- 1:13over the past few months. There's horror stories
- 1:16of people being picked up off the streets in
- 1:18unmarked cars, taken from places of work, and
- 1:21court hearings emerged. The latest statistics
- 1:23from ICE as of June 29th shows that there are
- 1:2757 ,861 people currently detained, with 41 ,495
- 1:34of those, 71 .7%, with no prior criminal convictions.
- 1:40Within this server, many of you have been monitoring
- 1:42the scale of these operations, looking into individual
- 1:45incidents and highlighting the latest news. Our
- 1:47speakers today have all been covering this for
- 1:49a few months. first looking at events in Vegas
- 1:52field, California, where border patrol agents
- 1:54were operating more than 300 miles from the U
- 1:57.S. southern border, and then to the recent June
- 1:59raids in Los Angeles, where patterns of arrest
- 2:02began to emerge. Kalina Koltay, a former Los
- 2:05Angeles local and a colleague of mine is here
- 2:07to speak on that recent work and how individual
- 2:10researchers could take some of the lessons we
- 2:12learned from that observation to other raids
- 2:14across the states. I want to also extend a warm
- 2:17welcome to our partners on these stories. Kevin
- 2:19Clancy, co -founder of Evident, and Sergio Olmas,
- 2:23investigative reporter for California -based
- 2:25CalMatters. After we've heard a breakdown of
- 2:28the two investigations, we'll be taking audience
- 2:31questions. As I've just mentioned, as we talk,
- 2:33please make sure to add your questions in the
- 2:35chat box, which is the right -hand side of your
- 2:38screen, via the message bubble icon. And please
- 2:41note within your question if you do not want
- 2:44me to read your username out, because as I mentioned,
- 2:47this is being audio recorded. I have already
- 2:49popped the two investigations in the chat, so
- 2:53have a read of those. And I'm going to pass it
- 2:55over to you now, Kalina, to run us through all
- 2:58this. Thanks, Charlie, for the wonderful introduction.
- 3:03And if any of my co -speakers want to chime in,
- 3:06please feel free to do so. So the two stories
- 3:10there, which is one that focus on Bakersfield,
- 3:13that's from a few months ago, which is a lot
- 3:16of agricultural and farmland, a little bit more
- 3:18towards like central California, if you're familiar
- 3:21with the state how it's like very long. And then
- 3:24the second story, which is focused on are the
- 3:28most recent like raids over the past month in
- 3:30June, but mostly within the Los Angeles area,
- 3:34but also within sort of like wider Southern California.
- 3:37So one of our colleagues, Carlos, who worked
- 3:40with, sorry, Joe and Kevin on our first piece
- 3:43here, we really should because we are, as Trump
- 3:47coming into office and there's all these talks
- 3:49about more and more immigration rates, we really
- 3:51didn't see border patrol stepping up the rates.
- 3:53And so one thing that was particularly interesting
- 3:56is that for our border patrol, their jurisdiction
- 4:00typically is when 100 miles of border, and it's
- 4:02of any border, so it could even be of the water
- 4:05dispenser had to be the U .S.-Mexico border.
- 4:07But that's typically where they are, sort of,
- 4:11their jurisdiction is. That is where they are
- 4:13during the patrolling. And so one thing that
- 4:16ended up becoming an interesting part and focus
- 4:19of this piece is that we noticed it's in Bakersfield
- 4:22or in areas that are much further with the border,
- 4:25over 300 miles away from the border. So something
- 4:27that was not within their area. So we decided
- 4:30to look at from our point of view, we went and
- 4:33found social media footage, video recordings
- 4:36from bystanders, people around these raids occurring
- 4:39in particular. One thing I thought was interesting
- 4:42that was one of the great bits about having the
- 4:43partnership is that Sergio did a variety of interviews,
- 4:47including talking with Chief Pavino, who said
- 4:49they weren't doing raids on farmlands, if I'm
- 4:52correct, remembering that. But we did find evidence
- 4:55of a raid occurring on farmland. And in particular,
- 4:58when they picked up a variety of agricultural
- 5:00workers, I believe our numbers are that they
- 5:05obtained 78 people. And of the 78 people, 77
- 5:09of them had no criminal history. They were not
- 5:12aware. They were not on Martin Schulz radar.
- 5:17And so I think what this really highlighted was
- 5:20sort of like the beginning of what we end up
- 5:22seeing later on happening in Los Angeles, and
- 5:24of course, possibly like across the US, is that
- 5:27there is these sort of like wordless. So without
- 5:30a war without sort of a sort of like judicial
- 5:33piece of paper so you can go and pick up this
- 5:34person, sort of these indiscriminate raids that
- 5:37are going on in areas where they suspect people
- 5:39who might be undocumented migrants might be working.
- 5:42So this is something that border patrols should
- 5:44not be doing. They don't necessarily have the
- 5:46authorization to be doing that. And they might
- 5:48say that they actually do have the authority.
- 5:50Because seemingly, in their mind, your level
- 5:54of criminality is as soon as you're entering
- 5:57into the US, you're essentially already a criminal.
- 6:01which I think sort of counters to what probably
- 6:03most people consider what they want in terms
- 6:06of immigration enforcement. So from our standpoint,
- 6:10we were able to, from BellyCast, we know we focus
- 6:12a lot on open source investigations. So we look
- 6:16at the social media. We rely on the social media
- 6:19content that's put out there. We're able to geolocate
- 6:21that content and also show that the footage that
- 6:23we're finding is of the appropriate time. It's
- 6:26not really old footage. that's being repurposed
- 6:29as a new footage. And then in some of those cases,
- 6:31we will find the original post of the person
- 6:33who recorded that footage and be able to get
- 6:35that eyewitness testimony that sometimes we don't
- 6:38always get to do from afar. So I think that's
- 6:41one of the wonderful things about our partnerships,
- 6:43is that we're able to couple with people on the
- 6:45ground and go talk to the people who are being
- 6:47affected, people who are recording the footage.
- 6:49But we do that by also being able to find the
- 6:51footage. And of course, with evidence, it's if...
- 6:54If you haven't already watched it, I really do
- 6:56recommend watching these videos because sometimes
- 6:59even when I send these stuff to my parents or
- 7:01friends, I know not everyone's going to read
- 7:03the article, but everyone will watch a video.
- 7:04So the video and the visual component, because
- 7:06I think that's what makes this so compelling
- 7:08in these investigations is being able to see,
- 7:12yeah, it's one thing to say 300 miles, but to
- 7:14see how far away 300 miles is another thing.
- 7:17So I think there's a really huge... important
- 7:19critical component in company visual stuff or
- 7:21being able to visually see people being chased.
- 7:24It puts a different sort of level of humanity
- 7:26into the story. And so from that investigation,
- 7:31ACLU was able to put an injunction on the type
- 7:35of rates that the El Centro Border Patrol unit
- 7:38was doing in Bakersfield. But as maybe no surprise
- 7:43to anyone that Chief Pavino, who is leading that
- 7:45District NED became the head of all of DHS. In
- 7:49Los Angeles, sort of right as like protests and
- 7:52raids were picking up within the Los Angeles
- 7:54area. And DHS, for those of you who are not in
- 7:57the U .S., is Department of Homeland Security,
- 7:59which includes things like what we call ICE or
- 8:02like Immigration and Customs Enforcement. It
- 8:04includes sort of TSA. It includes Border Patrol.
- 8:08It includes a wide, very, very, very wide swath
- 8:11of departmental agencies to be like the head
- 8:14of DHS in a such a large city like Los Angeles.
- 8:19So now if you like fast forward a few months
- 8:21into the summer, raids in Los Angeles were kicking
- 8:25up a lot more and really kind of like hit a I
- 8:28would say a boiling point but definitely sort
- 8:29of exploded in tension around June 6th, 7th,
- 8:338th that weekend. But the series of protests
- 8:36happening in Los Angeles in the Paramount area
- 8:39because raids were happening in places like Home
- 8:42Depots, which is not a place you you saw it happening
- 8:46in Vegas filled with car washes, farm workers,
- 8:49things where you imagine people who might be
- 8:51undocumented work in looking for employment or
- 8:54having some sort of form of employment. And so
- 8:57people in Los Angeles, which is a very strong
- 9:00immigrant community, really were not fans of
- 9:04this. So a lot of protesting started happening.
- 9:06but raids did not stop. So we, again, teamed
- 9:10up with Evidence and CalMatters and began collecting
- 9:14footage alongside with them. We started geolocating,
- 9:18archiving, trying to track down sort of voices
- 9:23in those pieces of people who are like the original
- 9:25posters, businesses in which these are happening.
- 9:28And I think one of the really highlighting things
- 9:32about this is that they're one, there is just,
- 9:34an overwhelming amount of footage. I think these
- 9:38are raised happening in a very densely populated
- 9:40area. Everyone has cell phones. These weren't
- 9:42things happening in the secret dead of night
- 9:44in a completely rural area where you don't see
- 9:46it, in places that seemingly felt very much warrantless
- 9:51in that way, that these agents would show up.
- 9:55According to the footage, what we have is they
- 9:57would just show up, go and try to round people
- 9:59up, and then leave without showing identification.
- 10:02without showing boards, without even not always
- 10:04clearly identifying who they are, so having unmarked
- 10:06vehicles. And so some of our interesting bits
- 10:09being able to take sort of like a wide macro
- 10:11view lens of the raids that were happening is
- 10:14that what we saw home depots, car washes, food
- 10:19stand workers, people who are hardworking members
- 10:23of society trying, who are the ones who are being
- 10:26targeted around them. And even with the car washes,
- 10:28we saw like locations being hit, car washes are
- 10:32being hit multiple times, so agents will come
- 10:34back on multiple days and go to the same location.
- 10:37And in some cases, we suspect customers also
- 10:40being rounded up with that, not just workers,
- 10:43which I think also really highlights that these
- 10:45were very indiscriminate rates. They're just
- 10:48going showing up to locations and seeing who
- 10:50they can pick up. These were without a warrant.
- 10:53And so very targeted and very racially profiled.
- 10:56I think the other kind of component about this
- 10:58is that agents were not very clearly marked.
- 11:01In some videos, we didn't see like a clear border
- 11:04patrol vehicle or a vehicle that had some sort
- 11:07of like, lately, a lot of them did not. In some
- 11:09cases, there were no license plates at all. So
- 11:11unmarked vehicle, no license plates, everyone's
- 11:14mask, not everyone's always wearing a clear,
- 11:15it might just say police, but you don't know
- 11:17what. a agency they're with, anyway can go and
- 11:20buy a vest that says police on it. And then also
- 11:25like an overwhelming I think show of like force
- 11:28and particularly with this play of like weapons
- 11:30from rifles to handguns to less than lethal in
- 11:34a way that says felt very inappropriate. It felt
- 11:36like if they were maybe maybe a Canada versus
- 11:40like in Los Angeles. So I think that it was something
- 11:45that was particularly stark in this footage.
- 11:47I think and even looking forward to it I also
- 11:51say like we don't have even a cut there was so
- 11:52much footage out there so many sightings I would
- 11:55say that I wouldn't even see like our map is
- 11:58Comprehensive of everything that's happened.
- 12:00There's probably things that were definitely
- 12:01missing So I don't want to say that that's just
- 12:03sort of the amount of footage we had I think
- 12:06a team of like four people on our side looking
- 12:08at footage and even then it was just so much.
- 12:12And even if any of the Discord members here were
- 12:14in any of the threads, you would just see those
- 12:16threads here on the channel. People share content
- 12:19all the time. So I think one thing that I also
- 12:23found particularly useful is that a lot of our
- 12:27bystanders were very thorough in terms of saying
- 12:30this is the exact time, this is the exact date,
- 12:33this is where we are, this is where it's happening.
- 12:35They would try to pan around. And so I think
- 12:38the public has a strong vested interests in being
- 12:42able to document this is happening. You know,
- 12:44a lot of this work can't happen without the public's
- 12:48work participation in it. And so that was what
- 12:51made this job or the particular work on this
- 12:53piece, I don't want to say easy, but it made
- 12:56it a lot more helpful versus just like footage
- 12:59being uploaded with no information along and
- 13:01try to say, guys, is this old? Is this new? Where
- 13:02is this? Is this Los Angeles? Is this New York?
- 13:06So I think that's a wonderful thing. And looking
- 13:10forward on this, I would say the work is certainly
- 13:13not stopped. I would say like, one thing that's
- 13:16nice is that there is an injunction currently
- 13:18in place that they shouldn't be doing any indiscriminate
- 13:20raids. So I will say it's been a little bit quieter
- 13:22this week. I haven't seen a raid in Los Angeles
- 13:25that's like out of Home Depot in a car wash.
- 13:27There's still arrests that are happening. But
- 13:29I think fortunately, this reporting and the work
- 13:34of lots of people on the ground has at least
- 13:37given a judge enough confidence to say, like,
- 13:40we're going to put an injunction in place right
- 13:42now for LA. But given that we've just had the
- 13:47big, beautiful bill here in the US that has allocated
- 13:51billions of more funding to ICE, I unfortunately
- 13:55don't anticipate this stopping anytime soon in
- 13:57Los Angeles, nor possibly nationwide. We do see
- 14:02rates nationwide as well. And I think that is
- 14:07only going to amp up. And I think if you go to
- 14:10Chief Favino's Instagram account, he says that
- 14:13we're still here. We're still doing rest in LA.
- 14:16He's not planning on leaving any time soon. So
- 14:19I think the work will continue. And I don't know
- 14:21if Kevin and Sergey want to pop in or add anything
- 14:25else to that. Otherwise, I will keep gapping.
- 14:36Kalina is right. No one reads the articles. Your
- 14:39parents won't. They'll see the video. Everyone
- 14:40does see the videos. That's on Kevin's part.
- 14:44But on the open source stuff, Los Angeles is
- 14:47the second biggest market. There's so much press
- 14:49here. I run a group chat of like 50 photographers
- 14:52here of all the major outlets. We caught maybe
- 14:56a handful, less than five actual rates. Everything
- 14:59was from just regular people on their cell phones.
- 15:02And without the open source stuff, there'd be
- 15:04no map. The open source thing is so important,
- 15:07especially if this goes to other cities where
- 15:08there's even less press. I mean, no, like, you
- 15:11know, having those hundred videos on there, like
- 15:13that blew my mind. And I've been watching this
- 15:15every day, you know, cause everything's so scattered.
- 15:17There's right here, right here. But even seeing
- 15:19those 15 separate home depots, I was telling
- 15:21Kevin like, Jesus, I like that blew my mind.
- 15:24And I see this every day. Yeah. Yeah, and I'll
- 15:29just I'll just chime in and say that, you know,
- 15:31Queen is right in thinking about the way that
- 15:32this could expand in the future. I think that,
- 15:34you know, the Big Beautiful bill is something
- 15:36that's going to continue. I mean, not only is
- 15:38ICE the now the single largest funded, you know,
- 15:41Department of Homeland Security, you know, the
- 15:44worst that we have in the United States. You
- 15:47know, the way that we have the ability to kind
- 15:50of combat some of these unconstitutional actions
- 15:52is basically a game of whack -a -mole. They will
- 15:55move to another city, another jurisdiction, another
- 15:58sector of the border patrol, and quite potentially
- 16:01just use these same tactics until somebody tells
- 16:05them to stop. They've basically already done
- 16:08that in California, moving from the Eastern District
- 16:10of California to the Central District, where
- 16:12they didn't have an injunction in place and used
- 16:14very similar tactics, as we saw in the video.
- 16:17One could assume that they would continue to
- 16:19do this across the US as well. ice as a shot
- 16:23in the arm from a funding perspective. The video
- 16:27itself, we would not have been able to produce
- 16:30something as compelling had we not had such a
- 16:33great partnership with everybody that's here,
- 16:35but we're really proud of where it went. It made
- 16:38it to the front page of our law on Reddit and
- 16:42it got over 4 million views or whatever it may
- 16:44have been. We have such a great product to put
- 16:49out there that people have the ability to kind
- 16:50of, you know, you know, resonates with audiences.
- 16:52But at the same time, like it really does make
- 16:55a difference to see it rather than just read
- 16:57it. Page of Reddit, the people's page, the real
- 17:00fun page. That's the real A1. Yeah, and I think
- 17:08it just it does highlight that. This work is,
- 17:12it's important. I think sometimes it like, I
- 17:15will say on our end, it's like, man, we're just
- 17:17like looking at footage all day. Is this going
- 17:19to mean anything? Is this going to help for anyone?
- 17:22There's a lot of like, I think what's nice is
- 17:23that there's a lot of like local reporting that's
- 17:26also coupled along with this. So like, like one
- 17:28of the local outlets in Los Angeles is called
- 17:30KTLA. They do a lot of like, we'll see a piece
- 17:33that happens social media. uh, pisco spiral someone's
- 17:36arrest and we're then we're there we're trying
- 17:37to like figure out victim's information our local
- 17:40reports we go and they'll actually go and like
- 17:41get to speak to uh the person who is detained
- 17:43like family members and so now we're like yes
- 17:45we are verified this is a nice thing like one
- 17:47thing I think um can sometimes make this uh piece
- 17:50difficult and other feature piece is that now
- 17:53people are so keen on reporting which is great
- 17:55but there'll be a lot of things that might be
- 17:57just like regular police activity that's not
- 17:59necessarily immigration related and so I think
- 18:01that's one thing that's also like a tricky component
- 18:04is that like which of these pieces, what bits
- 18:06of incidents are we going to include? Is this
- 18:09just like a traffic stop? Like that's just the
- 18:12right way someone ran a red light or is this
- 18:15a sort of a target detention that's using excessive
- 18:18force? And so the local reporting, I think it's
- 18:21like a great coupling to that because it gives
- 18:22us another sort of like check on it. And not
- 18:24every single piece we include has local reporting.
- 18:27And so, you know, we are relying on, you know,
- 18:31the video footage that we have, you know, there's
- 18:33some nice footage we don't include because we're
- 18:34just like unsure. And, you know, that's why we
- 18:36want to have also a high level of like transparency,
- 18:39a high level of trust. We want to verify it itself.
- 18:41She'll get all those sort of checks that you
- 18:43kind of expect with the bell and cat name. We're
- 18:45not just sort of adding everything into it. But
- 18:48I do think that it is very much a community effort
- 18:51because I will say that I even was looking at
- 18:54our press here as like instances that were added
- 18:57from community members in Discord. And I was
- 18:59like, oh great, I had missed that. Or there's
- 19:00aggregator Instagram accounts that would go and
- 19:03get stuff in the public. And it's, I think it's
- 19:06a community effort by far. I don't think this
- 19:09kind of work and the work going forward is on
- 19:12one person or one agency or anything like that.
- 19:15I think it's the work of thousands of people
- 19:18collectively together looking for accountability.
- 19:23um and uh history and i think that's that's why
- 19:27we do some of this is that it's not just to say
- 19:29like oh here's the thing we want like uh you
- 19:32know to like say like these guys are bad guys
- 19:34we want people to be held accountable for their
- 19:36actions and i think that is done through group
- 19:38efforts from our legal sense from um the open
- 19:41source sense from our reporting sense it's it's
- 19:44everyone has a piece of play and i feel like
- 19:46giving people the sense of power and agency and
- 19:49being able to make a change is like really important
- 19:51because i think Uh, and for myself or for others,
- 19:54if you feel that way, sometimes you feel very
- 19:56powerless, like there's all this bad stuff that's
- 19:58happening in the world and you made it feel like
- 19:59I can't do anything to do it. Like I'm just one
- 20:01person. I have my job. I have all these other
- 20:03things. And I feel like even being able to be
- 20:05like, Hey, here's the video that I found someone
- 20:07there and sharing that, um, I think actually
- 20:10adds to it. It's you still making a small piece
- 20:13and feeling like you're being some sort of agents
- 20:15of change and agent accountability and giving
- 20:17yourself, um, a bit of sort of control over that
- 20:22situation, because that is a help. So don't feel
- 20:25completely powerless. Like a lot of this work
- 20:27cannot be done without people like you. I feel
- 20:30like this is the perfect time for me to come
- 20:33back in. Thanks so much, Kalina, for the overview
- 20:36of basically what's been unraveling over the
- 20:39last few months in the States and what we've
- 20:42been witnessing here, not only in the server,
- 20:45but on all of our national news as well across
- 20:49the world. There's a lot of love for the video
- 20:53format as well in the chats. As I was reading
- 20:56some of the comments, it made me think actually,
- 20:58Kevin, that maybe we should bring you back for
- 21:00another stage talk or just about covering open
- 21:03source matters via video because I know a lot
- 21:06of people in here are quite passionate about
- 21:09open source and even do that in work. It might
- 21:11be of interest to how you approach that medium
- 21:15through. But going back to what we're speaking
- 21:23about today, I wanted to quickly throw to Sergio
- 21:26because I wanted to ask, at CalMatters, you've
- 21:29been covering the rates, particularly in Bakersfield,
- 21:35since January when Trump first kind of escalated
- 21:39these immigration rates. Were there any early
- 21:42signs, early warning signs looking back now at
- 21:45the cases of the surprise raids of farm workers
- 21:48back in January in Bakersfield that you may not
- 21:52have picked up on back then, but kind of can
- 21:55see clearly now? At the time, when I was in Bakersfield
- 21:59on January 7th, I was there for court records,
- 22:01completely unrelated. And then uncle gets a call
- 22:04in Spanish and he's like, and he hangs up and
- 22:07I was like, what's that? And he's like, well,
- 22:08someone said... Ice was at Costco. Then I go
- 22:11to Costco. And then we spent the whole next couple
- 22:13of days chasing like what ended up being border
- 22:16patrol. And later I go back with Kevin. We do
- 22:18this documentary. We find all the patterns, right?
- 22:21We find out kind of where they went, Bellingcat
- 22:23verified stuff. And we did that. And then when
- 22:26the raids happened in Los Angeles, it was like
- 22:28the exact same thing, but like ramped up to,
- 22:31you know, times 10, you know, home depots. They
- 22:34also went to farmland, started going to car washes.
- 22:36And, you know, in the court filings, it actually
- 22:40Right here in Los Angeles, there's a temporary
- 22:42restraining order that was granted Friday, like
- 22:44at 6 p .m. That means they put a pause on the
- 22:47raids, right? In the different core district
- 22:50where the Bakersfield is, there's a preliminary
- 22:51injunction saying, you know, no raids while this
- 22:53case is going on. In the filings, it actually
- 22:55says that what they saw in Los Angeles, you know,
- 22:58bears a striking similarity to what they saw
- 23:00in Bakersfield, Operation Return Descender, because
- 23:03they were doing the exact same things. I mean,
- 23:04it's not just... It wasn't, it's not just us
- 23:06finding those patterns, right? Like I think the
- 23:08YouTube video is called, there's a pattern here.
- 23:10You know, the court agreed, like they saw that
- 23:12that's, Hey, there's an injunction here and you're
- 23:14doing the same thing here. Just going up to workplaces,
- 23:16going to people who appear Latino and asking
- 23:18them for their papers, you know, and a judge
- 23:21in the Eastern district actually said in court,
- 23:23you can't just go to people with brown skin and
- 23:24say, you know, showing your papers. I mean, this
- 23:26is stuff that's pretty basic. It's actually,
- 23:28you know, like in terms of law, like it's, it's
- 23:30pretty basic, but, uh, seeing the scale of it.
- 23:33is important. You see how many home depots you
- 23:35see, exactly which places they're hitting. And
- 23:37then the other thing to remember is I think like
- 23:41with Bakersfield, if you go back in time and
- 23:44you see what was said, like on our side, on the
- 23:46media, we had to echo what, what border patrol
- 23:50gave us. It was the only information we had.
- 23:52And they were saying they went after criminals.
- 23:53They had a list of criminals. And so everybody
- 23:55was saying they went after, you know, child molesters
- 23:57and stuff. Cause that's what border patrol said.
- 23:59Later we discovered that wasn't true at all.
- 24:01Right. 77 of the 78 people they arrested in Bakersfield.
- 24:03They had no knowledge of criminal immigration
- 24:05history prior to encountering them. Here in Los
- 24:08Angeles, they're saying the same thing, but we
- 24:11all know now that they don't tell the truth,
- 24:14right? They're not telling the truth to the public.
- 24:16So all this work is very important. It takes
- 24:18time, but it's so important, I think. Absolutely.
- 24:26Just related to that, Opti Storm in the comments
- 24:28has just said, why don't we hear more from personnel?
- 24:33Border Patrol, ICE, DHS, is there peer pressure
- 24:37to kind of not speak out about some of the atrocities?
- 24:41Has anyone got any insight on that? Like why
- 24:43we're not hearing more whistleblowers? Well,
- 24:46Nick Miroff just did an incredible article for
- 24:47the Atlantic on, he talked to a dozen current
- 24:50and former ICE agents about how demoralized they
- 24:52are. And that's a great article for the Atlantic.
- 24:54I'll pop it in the chat. But if Colleen or Kevin,
- 24:57I mean, Kevin spent time with Border Patrol guys
- 24:59when we did the documentary. I mean, But we haven't
- 25:03published anything from the inside since then.
- 25:06We have, and we have seen, you know, visual evidence
- 25:09of some of those people that we spend time with
- 25:10in El Centro engaged in operations in Los Angeles.
- 25:14You know, some of the same people that we had
- 25:16met and spent time with and, you know, got to
- 25:19know who were genuine, like genuinely like kind
- 25:22and, you know, didn't necessarily give, you know,
- 25:25kind of the. the kind of the impression that
- 25:28they really wanted to go out and engage in some
- 25:29of these activities. I mean, I think it's just
- 25:31more or less like this is their job or they've
- 25:34been asked to do this by their chief. But with
- 25:37that being said, I mean, we saw them, you know,
- 25:39with masks on, you know, in Los Angeles, you
- 25:42know, engaged in some of this activity. And it
- 25:44just kind of shows, you know, the human side
- 25:46of it in a lot of ways. I mean, we knew they
- 25:49were we knew who they were when they weren't
- 25:51doing that. And then now we've seen them, you
- 25:53know, out and engaging in this activity. And
- 25:55it's just kind of Um, it's hard to see all these
- 25:57people with all these masks and think that there
- 25:59is going to be even side to that as well. Uh,
- 26:03kinder says that we've been, we look, we seem
- 26:05like good people. That's cause you haven't met
- 26:06Kevin in person. He's awful. He's a terrible
- 26:08person. Uh, I'm just kidding. I'm just kidding.
- 26:12Yeah. Yeah. Um, what I was going to say, uh,
- 26:19What I was going to say is one thing that's been
- 26:22under -reported as an unintended side effect
- 26:24probably with the masking component and being
- 26:28unmarked vehicles and all that, which I think
- 26:29is just egregious and something that we expect
- 26:35better from law enforcement. But I think because
- 26:38they're hiding their identities and they're masking,
- 26:42there's been bad actors and opportunists who
- 26:45have taken advantage of that, who are pretending
- 26:47to be ICE enforcement officers or border patrol
- 26:52to commit crimes. And I think that's also what
- 26:54makes it really difficult. It's like you really
- 26:56don't know, like if, if you did want to kidnap
- 26:58someone or wanted to carjack someone, just pretend
- 27:00you're an ICE member, because like, you're kind
- 27:02of under this guise of like, you know, yeah,
- 27:05that's the same sort of activity that they're
- 27:06doing. So I think, unfortunately, there is like,
- 27:10in a sense, it's given the opportunity to create
- 27:12more crime versus like preventing crime. Absolutely.
- 27:16By using unmarked vehicles. Yeah, and I think
- 27:20in the gender -based violence and misogyny channel
- 27:22yesterday, someone was sharing a case of that.
- 27:26I don't know if Settle Knife can maybe share
- 27:28that link in the chat for anyone who's not in
- 27:31that channel. But there was a thing about women,
- 27:35I think, being stalked and harassed by people
- 27:37pretending to be ICE agents, which is terrifying.
- 27:42I also wanted to ask, because we actually asked
- 27:46ISM Border Control about these unlocked offices
- 27:50that we saw in videos in LA. What was their response
- 27:55to that? I can take that. It was about as boilerplate
- 28:03as you could expect. I guess I could pull it
- 28:06up, but there really wasn't a whole lot actually.
- 28:10mentioned about what we asked about. It was more
- 28:13or less talking about the ICE agents that are
- 28:18conducting these raids are under threat and that
- 28:21there's been an increase in instances in which
- 28:24they've been targeted for their actions and they're
- 28:26brave. When asked about specific incidents, they
- 28:30just deflected. They didn't really give us anything
- 28:33that was kind of a concrete answer to any of
- 28:36the questions that we've asked them. seems to
- 28:39be kind of a common, you know, retort that, you
- 28:41know, the administration will, you know, give
- 28:43people, which is more or less just, you know,
- 28:46everything is fantastic. And, you know, the brave
- 28:48members of our Department of Homeland Security
- 28:50are the ones that are under under fire. I was
- 28:54going to say, I actually just pulled up one of
- 28:57their responses, which I feel like is fair because
- 28:59they send it to us. I don't mind sharing their
- 29:00response, which I was right, they. I feel like
- 29:04they didn't actually read our questions and just
- 29:06kind of like sent us stuff because they responded
- 29:08to things that we didn't even ask about. But
- 29:11one of the things they said, and this is quoting
- 29:13from their official quotes here, a lot of members
- 29:16of ERO slash HSI are working undercover. And
- 29:19by the way, critics have clearly never been on
- 29:22an ICE operation because they would see, one,
- 29:24they verbally identify themselves as ICE or Homeland
- 29:27Security. Two, they wear vests that say ICE slash
- 29:30ERO. or Homeland Security, and three, they are
- 29:32flanked by vehicles that also say the name of
- 29:34the apartment. These arguments are getting a
- 29:36little desperate, end quotes. So that's what
- 29:39they said, which I feel confident saying that
- 29:42is false because we have one, plenty of video
- 29:45evidence of people showing up with unmarked vehicles,
- 29:49not flanked by, unless the vehicles are way far
- 29:53back, nowhere anywhere near visual. We have videos
- 29:56of people being completely, in plain clothes,
- 30:00so not wearing vests. And they might say, I will
- 30:03say identifying themselves as ICE and Homeland
- 30:05Security, but I feel like that's pretty low bar
- 30:07just to say that you're ICE with no badge, no
- 30:11badge number, no last name, masked in plain clothes,
- 30:18or just like ballistic armor and unmarked vehicles.
- 30:23So I would say, They say they're quote, these
- 30:27arguments are getting a little desperate. I feel
- 30:29like they're probably a little bit more of a
- 30:31desperate response to address it. And let's just
- 30:35I would add to that. Sorry, it's not like there's
- 30:38a good faith. It's not like you're getting on
- 30:39the phone with DHS and they're talking. They're
- 30:41just emailing the same thing they tweet out.
- 30:43Like whoever that edge lord is, is tweeting out
- 30:45the DHS Twitter stuff. It's the same exact thing
- 30:48they post on there. They just email it to you
- 30:49and to everyone else. It, there is no good faith
- 30:51discussion of like, what's going on here. And
- 30:53they try to sit down and explain it. That's not
- 30:54happy. They literally sometimes some stuff is
- 30:56in all caps like that. It's literally the stuff
- 30:58they post on Twitter. Yeah. I've got to admit
- 31:02when I read the response, um, before we went
- 31:05to publish, uh, I did say it's a bit Trump -esque
- 31:07in terms of the language use. Uh, and as you
- 31:11say, the capitalization as well in spaces, um,
- 31:15Interesting, very interesting. I wanted to play
- 31:17Devil's Advocate for a second and ask you whether
- 31:20you had come across any false flag videos where
- 31:22people were claiming that immigration rates were
- 31:25taking place in their area, but you found, you
- 31:27geolocated or chronolocated that that wasn't
- 31:29the case. Let's just play, I don't know, I don't
- 31:33want to support ISO or suggest that that's happening,
- 31:37but is any of that the case? We had a comment
- 31:39in the... chat about not really wanting to verify
- 31:43in case they came across AI videos. I haven't
- 31:45come across any claims of that, but I have seen
- 31:48claims that people have been making false claims
- 31:51about deportations. I've seen every single video
- 31:57in our data sets, plus ones that we haven't published
- 32:01on yet. I would say for the AI one, because it's
- 32:04interesting, especially because I do a lot of
- 32:06the AI stuff normally. I have not seen a single
- 32:10AI generated video of like someone being arrested
- 32:14and I think that is very telling because you'll
- 32:18see this happen for like conflict or for other
- 32:21events and I think maybe because there's just
- 32:24so much genuine footage that no one feels the
- 32:26need to AI generate something, or maybe it just
- 32:30doesn't even go anywhere. I would say the only
- 32:32AI generate thing is that sometimes these like
- 32:34Instagram news accounts, and I use news very
- 32:37loosely, that'll use like an AI generated image,
- 32:40but then they'll have like a real description
- 32:42of like what happened, but the image is meant
- 32:44mostly as a chase holder, because you have to
- 32:45post like an image. But then so like the story
- 32:48of the accurate images were just like, dramaticized
- 32:52for like people clicking on it, you know, it's
- 32:53very clearly AI. Um, as far as things that are,
- 32:57uh, uh, people saying it's a nice rate, it's
- 32:59not, I think there are some things that are hard,
- 33:01um, that we may not include because, um, like
- 33:05it's, there's some things you just don't know.
- 33:06Like, if we just see someone being like, um,
- 33:09like, okay, there are some things that we may
- 33:10not determine. So I think, I think yesterday
- 33:12in Watsonville, there was a raid, um, at a farm
- 33:16that's a cannabis farm. And so this local sheriff
- 33:20said, this is not immigration related, it's just
- 33:22here. But a bunch of users who are posting video
- 33:24footage say like, ICE is here, ICE is here. And
- 33:27so like the question is like, okay, was this
- 33:29really an immigration thing, an ICE thing, because
- 33:31we didn't see border patrol, or is that what
- 33:34do we take the sheriff, local sheriff saying
- 33:36that this is not immigration related, it was
- 33:37really due to cannabis, although cannabis is
- 33:39legal in the state of California. So I think
- 33:42that is like there are questions like that. I
- 33:45think, you know, we sometimes see there are cases
- 33:48where we don't have very much context for what's
- 33:51happening. So it might be like, we saw one video
- 33:53that was like, very sort of like aggressive,
- 33:56there was scuffling happening. A woman's photo
- 33:58sort of taken and like dropped to the ground.
- 34:00We don't see it like we barely we get maybe a
- 34:02glimpse of a badge might say like ice. And then
- 34:04that's it and then we can't find anything else
- 34:06in there. And so we're like, is this immigration
- 34:09related? Is this something other like we don't
- 34:11sometimes we just don't know or another case
- 34:14in which uh someone there's so many instances
- 34:16so there's uh someone who's driving uh ice individuals
- 34:20came over and like ran their vehicle um hit the
- 34:23this this man who was going to take it he was
- 34:25um i believe he is a u .s citizen he was just
- 34:28at a protest and he was recording so we had like
- 34:30video footage uh and so they wanted to arrest
- 34:32him because of of whatever he did at the protest
- 34:35but for footage it seemed like he didn't really
- 34:37do very much um but like they ran his vehicle
- 34:40um his kids and his partner were in the car um
- 34:44as well And so you're like, is this immigration
- 34:46related? You might say it's ICE, but then it's
- 34:48probably due to an apprentice. So then it's like,
- 34:50where do we try to draw the line? Is it really
- 34:52just arrest or deportations? Or is it any sort
- 34:56of activity that Border Patrol is doing? It's
- 34:59ones that I was unsure because everyone is playing
- 35:01close. So someone might be saying, this is ICE,
- 35:05this is ICE, they're playing close, and then
- 35:06I do more research, and then I do find out it's
- 35:07ICE. Because sometimes I'm like, I just don't
- 35:10know. This is someone being kidnapped off the
- 35:12street. You literally don't know if people are
- 35:14in plain clothes. So I think there are a variety
- 35:18of instances, if that answers the question, that
- 35:20we sometimes have to leave a bit of doubt. Like
- 35:23every instance, we take a bit of doubt. Like
- 35:25I don't even say for sure that something is an
- 35:26arrest until I can say. that's clearly an arrest
- 35:29happening versus like people just showing up
- 35:31and talking to people. Yeah. And then sometimes
- 35:34it comes out later that like, oh, yes, that was
- 35:36for sure an immigration arrest. And the anonymous.
- 35:39Sorry, go ahead. Can I add to that? In Los Angeles,
- 35:42people got very quickly like the general public
- 35:45are very smart about figuring out what's ice
- 35:47and what's. like just regular police and the
- 35:50sheriff here for Los Angeles actually tweeted
- 35:52out a video identifying their uniforms because
- 35:54they were like just so you know this is what
- 35:56we are and we always dress this way we always
- 35:58have our badge out. The sheriff did that for
- 36:00Los Angeles County. I also say like California
- 36:02like when you guys are verifying stuff in other
- 36:04states as this spreads nationwide like California's
- 36:07we're lucky in the sense that there's this law
- 36:10here that police like the SB 54 police sheriffs
- 36:13the state police the California patrol and then
- 36:15we're actually by law allowed to go on immigration
- 36:16rates so. What's great here is, you know, LAPD
- 36:20and sheriffs will never be involved in immigration
- 36:21rates here. And so it's they always are identified.
- 36:24They always wear their badges out. They don't
- 36:26dress like they're contractors in a foreign war,
- 36:29unlike Border Patrol and ICE to dress like they're
- 36:30just like in a war zone. Right. And so it's it's
- 36:33kind of it's interesting that like now when I
- 36:36see someone in fatigues, I'm like, OK, that that's
- 36:38going to be immigration related because LAPD
- 36:40does not show in fatigues to calls. Right. Like
- 36:42the sheriff's doesn't do that. They're not going
- 36:43to go on immigration rates. So That's not going
- 36:45to be the case in other like Texas or Colorado,
- 36:47whatever, where police can assist immigration
- 36:49rates. That's the really cool thing to hear about
- 36:51California in that sense. I will say it did became
- 36:55apparent really quickly. Oh, I can see people's
- 36:58faces in this video. That must be, if you see
- 37:02someone who's masked, who doesn't make circular,
- 37:04I'm like, oh, that's better. I just, this is
- 37:09related and maybe this is again, a Kalina question.
- 37:12But for anybody who's listening, who might not
- 37:15be as familiar with open source, how important
- 37:20is the bystanders role in this, like to film
- 37:24and to capture that footage? And what kind of
- 37:26information are you looking for in the footage
- 37:29when trying to de -locate or chrono -locate these
- 37:32scenes? I cannot emphasize this enough. The work
- 37:39cannot happen without bystanders. There is no
- 37:42way for this kind of reporting and these kind
- 37:44of investigations to happen without the very
- 37:48brave people who decide to turn on their camera,
- 37:51record, and then post it online. And then there's
- 37:54some people who, of course, share it to a different
- 37:55account because they don't want to be associated
- 37:57because any people will post. There's footage
- 38:00we decided not to share because people are recording
- 38:02from their homes, and then it's easy enough to
- 38:04geoco -locate who is at that home and that apartment
- 38:06building. And we want to make sure we protect
- 38:08the public. So I think that's an important component
- 38:10of this. But I do think this work cannot happen
- 38:13without bystanders. There's a lot we're also
- 38:16missing. We just don't have, because maybe they're
- 38:17just not posted online. People are afraid of
- 38:20blowbacks. So I do think that is a very brave
- 38:22and important bit of this. I think one thing
- 38:26we found very helpful that people found really
- 38:28quickly was to try to get photos of faces, even
- 38:32though there are masks. identifying components
- 38:35of the people and of the vehicles. So we saw
- 38:37a lot of people going out of the way to make
- 38:39sure they were reporting license plates of vehicles,
- 38:42asking people for their names, for their badge
- 38:44numbers, trying to basically get as much information.
- 38:46People will say in the video, it is this date
- 38:48at this time, at this location, which I think
- 38:51is an extra level of verification because it's
- 38:54one thing to write it in a post, but people are
- 38:56saying it on camera as well. which is a little
- 38:59bit harder to think. So I do think that the public
- 39:03has taken... One thing I kind of personally wish
- 39:06is that we also got VIN numbers from vehicles.
- 39:08By the way, that's a lot harder, it's a bigger
- 39:10ask, only because we've now seen evidence of
- 39:14federal officers switching license plates on
- 39:17vehicles to mass, which is kind of a pain in
- 39:20the ass that someone was trying to track those
- 39:22vehicles. So that's probably the one big ask,
- 39:26I think. It's such a different type of video
- 39:29than what we've seen. If you think about like
- 39:31conflict related videos, you typically don't
- 39:33have one as much footage and also footage from
- 39:36like multiple angles to verify that this did
- 39:38happen at this time. Some people bring up, say
- 39:41like, yes, I took this footage. Here it is. This
- 39:44is what happened. Even like inside, I saw footage
- 39:47from that was in like Albuquerque of a man being
- 39:51tased and detained by orange hole. and the manager
- 39:56coming and asking the woman filming to leave
- 39:58because it's private property. And she's like,
- 40:00what? And she's like, from far enough. And she's
- 40:02like, she's not allowed to be there because she's
- 40:04built to film even with private property for
- 40:06Walmart. But Orbit told her there's a lot to
- 40:07go in and like pay as a customer. And that's
- 40:11fine. But I think like, you know, she posted
- 40:13that video and she put it out there and she's
- 40:16like, this is what happened to me. And I think
- 40:17that is. like we can't tell that story that that
- 40:20won't get like the local news coverage and additional
- 40:23follow -up happens if she didn't ever post that.
- 40:25So I think it is everyone has lots of bits and
- 40:29pieces to play and I'm very thankful for all
- 40:33the work people do in sort of holding people
- 40:36accountable, license plates, photos, names, times,
- 40:41dates, locations. It makes it much, much easier
- 40:43to geolocate. There probably would have been
- 40:45very hard to geolocate the inside of a Walmart
- 40:48if this woman didn't say in her pose, too, I
- 40:54was at this Walmart at this time, this is me
- 40:56in it. It would have been much, much harder to
- 40:58try to figure out exactly which one, where it
- 41:00was. You asked me to give me my VIN number right
- 41:02now. I couldn't. I couldn't give you my VIN number.
- 41:07The VIN number is great. There was a whole discussion
- 41:12about it, too, in our thread. So I recommend
- 41:15if you're interested in this, go check out our
- 41:16threads here about it. So it's a very hard piece
- 41:19of information to get, but they'll have it at
- 41:21the top of the vehicle. I also used to work at
- 41:24an auto repair shop, so we had to always do the
- 41:26VINs. So in theory, you could get the VIN. That
- 41:29way, that was a unique number that's always specifically
- 41:32that vehicle that someone would have to like,
- 41:35weld and remove out of like, or even like it's
- 41:37on the glass. So like, you would have to do a
- 41:39whole bunch of stuff to remove a change of in
- 41:41number versus just like a little dinky metal
- 41:43plate on the back of a vehicle or in some cases,
- 41:46they just have no place at all. So. I haven't
- 41:49seen them masking the bit numbers yet. You heard
- 41:51it here first. That's the thing to be collecting.
- 41:55Not that we're encouraging anyone to go out in
- 41:57the streets and risk their lives or safety filming
- 42:01this, but yeah, these are the things that are
- 42:04missing. I want to ask you a question about missing
- 42:07data in a second, but Edvin has asked, has any
- 42:10crowdsourcing platform been created or do you
- 42:12solely rely on social media? Are you aware of
- 42:14any movements to collate videos and evidence
- 42:19of immigration rates in one place. People Over
- 42:22Papers has a pretty good map, but it's not reportable,
- 42:26but it's a pretty good map. You guys can... Oh,
- 42:29by the way, when you said all that, I just pictured
- 42:31the next Bellingham investigation was just like
- 42:33a Maxar satellite investigation of all the parked
- 42:35cars and you just zoomed in on all the VINs and
- 42:37you got them that way. Like in my head, that's
- 42:39the fantasy that you guys are so good that you
- 42:40can see VIN numbers from Maxar footage. But People
- 42:43Over Papers has a really good map and there's
- 42:45been less... sightings of immigration officers
- 42:49since the TRO in Los Angeles. I was going to
- 42:53second people over papers. The one thing about
- 42:57people over papers is that it is not historical.
- 43:00So it's just day by day. So I like check it like
- 43:03every day. And that's a good place, I think.
- 43:07And there's a couple other subreddits. So I think
- 43:08like So I've read it like our ice underscore
- 43:12raids and then ice eyes on ice are also good
- 43:15options. And then there's also really good aggregator
- 43:19local accounts. So there's like a few are specifically
- 43:22Los Angeles, but then they'll be like really
- 43:23specific ones. Like I think actually El Monte
- 43:26means which is normally a meme channel actually
- 43:28does a lot of videos and footage that are specifically
- 43:32in El Monte. So there's like really specific
- 43:34hyper localized. And I know people say Facebook
- 43:38is dead. But I think Facebook is dead. But Facebook,
- 43:42the one thing they still thrive on is local,
- 43:44because people want to let information know that
- 43:47it was on Instagram. So I think there's a lot
- 43:49of local groups and a lot of original footage
- 43:51that come from Facebook that I'll find. So I'll
- 43:55look keywords. I found stuff from an incident
- 43:58and arrest in Denver on Colfax. Familiar with
- 44:02Denver. But that I found through Facebook, through
- 44:06keyword searching for posts from the recent so
- 44:10I think you can sometimes the old school like
- 44:14what's nice is that like normally for a lot of
- 44:16the work we do we have to go to more like niche
- 44:18alt like platforms like maybe a telegram or a
- 44:22gab or something like that here it's all mainstream
- 44:27main sort of like social media platforms and
- 44:29then one's like yeah people are papers but again
- 44:32it's not stores like one of those you have to
- 44:33check every day and they don't have like the
- 44:36source of office so it's a little bit of headache
- 44:37because it If people find something social media
- 44:40posted on there, they don't always post a link.
- 44:42So there's like imperfect components to it, but
- 44:45it is kind of giving you a sort of wide map overview
- 44:48of incidents, sightings, arrests, all sorts of
- 44:52stuff across the US. Super useful. And people
- 44:55have put in the comments as well, a couple of
- 44:56other sources. Someone shouted out Mr. Timothy
- 44:59Times, who's tracking them and publishing reports
- 45:01on TikTok and Substack. There's quite a few other
- 45:05spaces people are following developments. I wanted
- 45:08to ask about data before going to some more comments
- 45:11in the chat. You mentioned VIN numbers. In regards
- 45:16to data, we got praised for our investigation,
- 45:20and well done everybody here, for showing the
- 45:22scale, because a lot of reports have been focused
- 45:25on individual incidents rather than being able
- 45:27to show the scale of what's going on in a single
- 45:30region. kind of data is missing. Where are the
- 45:34data gaps when it comes to monitoring rates?
- 45:36What would you advise people start looking at
- 45:39that isn't being reported on enough, in your
- 45:42opinion? That's a Kalina question, for sure.
- 45:47Yeah, definitely. Yeah, Kalina, take it. OK,
- 45:51so I'm trying to eat like my daily vitamin gummy,
- 45:53hopefully, at the same time. OK, I think for
- 45:59us, it's like I... I'm trying to say what is
- 46:04under -reported. For me, I think the social media
- 46:08footage is obviously incredibly helpful because
- 46:10we have vehicles, we have license plates, we
- 46:15have some sort of sense of people generally.
- 46:19I think obviously there's a lot of work to be
- 46:21done if you want to focus on unmasking. There's
- 46:23been a handful of guys, particularly those who
- 46:26haven't been masked, that we could find their
- 46:28identity. Um, so I think like accountability
- 46:32on that, because I think it's sort of like, it's,
- 46:35it's kind of bad to say, but I think essentially
- 46:36like shaming people, uh, who are actively participating
- 46:40in these, in these raids, I think, um, could
- 46:43be a useful, uh, component. Uh, it's something
- 46:45we didn't focus on for, for this piece. Um, but
- 46:48it's something that could be in, in the future,
- 46:50like hearing people that are conducting this,
- 46:52because some of these are, um, they're obviously
- 46:55trying to protect their identities for, for.
- 46:57a doxing component, but also because they know
- 46:59that they are violating laws. I think this came
- 47:03out this week that in legal proceedings, they're
- 47:06also choosing not to name some ICE officials,
- 47:10if I'm correct. I might have to look at the source
- 47:12on that. I'm trying to say other data gaps. I
- 47:17think it'd be great. We don't know where people
- 47:19are ending up. I think that's a big component
- 47:22is that some people are being sent to their home
- 47:25country. Like just like there would be hard stories
- 47:27people like were picked up and then like few
- 47:28days later they're just dropped off on the street
- 47:30in Mexico. Some people they not heard from and
- 47:34they have no idea where they are. Some people
- 47:36are being held in detention facilities. So I
- 47:38think there's a lot of sort of gaps when I say
- 47:41gaps in data that sounds it's imperfect because
- 47:44it's really gaps of where people are ending up.
- 47:46What's happening after they get detained? And
- 47:49I think we just don't know for a lot of that.
- 47:51And I think that's like hard thing to do. by
- 47:53open source and that requires probably collaboration
- 47:56with other people. That's sort of my question.
- 48:00Just on that, in the Bakersfield investigation,
- 48:03we mentioned that the American Civil Liberties
- 48:05Union lawsuit had actually revealed that 40 people
- 48:08were deported after the Operation Return to Syndrome
- 48:11in Bakersfield, right? So some within days of
- 48:13being arrested. There is ways to find out, but
- 48:17it requires legal processes. And there is, as
- 48:20you said, quite a data gap there in terms of
- 48:23how long people are waiting in detention versus
- 48:26how many individuals are actually deported quite
- 48:29immediately. I think that data would be super
- 48:32useful. Can I add on the holes there? One on
- 48:37the mass thing. I was in court on Thursday last
- 48:40week when the federal The federal, like the attorney
- 48:44for the federal government was defending against
- 48:47this lawsuit, argued that when the judge was
- 48:50saying, yeah, these agents clearly aren't identifiable.
- 48:52They are wearing masks. And the government attorney
- 48:55was like, well, you know, since COVID -19, I
- 48:56think it's not uncommon for people to wear masks.
- 48:59And the judge actually cited that in her TRO.
- 49:01Like she actually put that as a footnote. Like
- 49:03the government speculated that COVID was one
- 49:05of the reasons. It was kind of, it was really
- 49:07absurd that they actually flouted that as the
- 49:09reason they're masked up because of COVID -19.
- 49:11Just want to put that out there. That actually
- 49:13happened in court. But on the data hole, you
- 49:16know, what's interesting now is there is a TRO
- 49:18in Los Angeles. There's an injunction in the
- 49:20Eastern District. And it's clear that the lawsuit
- 49:24after this TRO, you know, because it's temporary,
- 49:26they're going to argue for a preliminary injunction
- 49:28as well. Now, I think, you know, I think Bellingcat
- 49:31showed the scale and scope of this 15 different
- 49:33home depots and 100, you know. locations. But
- 49:36now you can actually see if if the government's
- 49:39violating those court orders. Right. Like now
- 49:41it's different if they're going up to people
- 49:43at car washes or they're going to people because
- 49:45they speak broken English. These videos now I
- 49:48think become important because hey look a federal
- 49:51judge says you can't do this. And if they're
- 49:53still doing it that's huge. Right. That's that's
- 49:55that's violating a court order. So I think there's
- 49:58a new data gap now like are they. using warrants
- 50:01or are they violating what the court said? That
- 50:03to me is interesting. And as this spreads to
- 50:05different parts of the country, it's going to
- 50:06be repeated. But right now in Los Angeles, to
- 50:08me, are they abiding by these orders or are they
- 50:12disregarding them? Yes, really good point. The
- 50:16one thing that I'll build on in that is the fact
- 50:20that as this continues to spread, one thing to
- 50:22note is that the ACLU or the way that these legal
- 50:25proceedings go forward is that they need plaintiffs
- 50:29to be able to try and bring a case. It's been
- 50:34really crucial to have footage of a snapshot
- 50:37of time of individuals being detained. Because
- 50:40there's this black box of where they go afterwards,
- 50:44basically, the lawyers are trying to follow up
- 50:46with any of the family members who are associated
- 50:48with people who have been taken to try and see
- 50:50if they can find them and learn about what happened
- 50:53to them so that they can build a case. Basically,
- 50:56what they're doing is because Border Patrol and
- 50:59ICE and these other entities know that once they're
- 51:02taken in these vans, no one really knows what
- 51:05happens, so do lawyers. Lawyers know that they
- 51:08have to work even harder to try and build what
- 51:10happens after that incident so that they can
- 51:14try and bring that to light and argue that in
- 51:17court. I think that's what makes these disappearances
- 51:22even more scary is that kind of lack of knowledge
- 51:26about where a lot of these people end up. I know
- 51:28we had a question earlier, I think we've got
- 51:30time for about two questions more. We had a question
- 51:33earlier about alligator alcatraz. Have you seen
- 51:36much footage coming out of detention facilities
- 51:39at all? And is there a data gap there in terms
- 51:42of knowing what's going on behind the scenes
- 51:44there? I know a lot of media houses are currently
- 51:46looking at that particular facility. Yeah, I
- 51:50mean there I work for Cal matters anything inside
- 51:51of California Doesn't exist I guess for me Yeah,
- 51:56no, it's once again. It's kind of it's kind of
- 51:58a bit of an unknown I haven't really seen anything
- 52:02in particular out of Florida or out of one time
- 52:06today or any of the other facilities It's yeah,
- 52:09I've no I've no real window into that. Maybe
- 52:12Kalina. I'm not sure Before just for people outside
- 52:17of the US. I just wanted The lawsuit is by these
- 52:20activist groups and ACLU is nonpartisan, American
- 52:23Civil Liberties Union. But you know who all signed
- 52:25on to that? The city of Los Angeles, the county
- 52:27of Los Angeles, the city of Pasadena, multiple
- 52:28cities around Los Angeles, and then the state
- 52:30of California. I have never in my life seen activists
- 52:34and local governments all signing on to the same
- 52:37thing. So it's not like the county or the city
- 52:39are against this. They're all on the same lawsuit
- 52:42against the federal government. So just to give
- 52:44a picture there. I don't think we've ever seen
- 52:48that. Or it's been years, you know, dozens of
- 52:51years since local governments and activists were
- 52:53all literally on the same page arguing the same
- 52:55thing. Yeah, I think like there's been a lot
- 52:59of media attention also with the detention center
- 53:02in Florida. I really hate the name Alligator
- 53:05Alcatraz. I'm going to call it Alligator Auschwitz.
- 53:08But I think that the because there's been such
- 53:13a media flurry I mean they even have merch available
- 53:15so they've had like people come in and show there's
- 53:18been like a decent amount of footage from inside
- 53:20not with like I think I have some people like
- 53:22but people actually there are people actually
- 53:24being held there um I haven't seen footage with
- 53:26the people in there so they'll send plenty of
- 53:28footage from inside if you go from outside because
- 53:30there's something to pay attention on it but
- 53:33I do think that um there might be more investigation
- 53:37to happen that'll come with other like current
- 53:39detention holding facilities because I think
- 53:41one of the big questions is basically how overcrowded
- 53:44are these because there's been such an uptick
- 53:47in detentions that have happened. It's like how
- 53:49many people are actually being held there? Are
- 53:50there like over capacity? What are the conditions
- 53:53from the reports that we've gotten from like
- 53:56people who've called like the student people
- 53:58have called 911 from detention facilities? It
- 54:02seems that it's pretty grim. And another big
- 54:05data why I just thought about it as we were talking
- 54:08is that like, you know, I think one of the big
- 54:11things that stuff hinges on is like, do these
- 54:14officials have award? And there's no really great
- 54:16way for us to look up award. And I think overwhelmingly,
- 54:19no, they do not have a warrant. And so I think
- 54:21that is one of these these big bits is that like,
- 54:24what we don't always know what agencies pick
- 54:26them up because you'll sometimes see people wearing
- 54:29an ice bat or an ice vest or they'll say, border
- 54:33security might just say police, it might say
- 54:35FBI, it might say HSI, which so it's like who
- 54:39are the people, where are the people going with?
- 54:40There's also contracting companies and so you'll
- 54:44see people being taken by contracting companies
- 54:46that are contracted through ICE. Maybe ICE picks
- 54:49them up and then just hands them off to the contracting
- 54:50company. I think there is a lot of stuff we don't
- 54:54know and you know from who's and also I think
- 54:58there's also this video footage I recently came
- 55:00out of like what appeared to be like children
- 55:03in chains and shackles. And we're like, so what's
- 55:07happening to minors that are being detained?
- 55:11And I think there's just like a lot of questions.
- 55:13So we've talked about the data gaps. I think
- 55:17a lot of the data gaps are things that may not
- 55:19always be available through open source means.
- 55:21And that's what makes it difficult. There's no
- 55:23open source, like look up for warts that I know
- 55:26of. So we just don't, we just don't know. I wish
- 55:29there was. I wish I was, you know, and so like,
- 55:34there's also like, we currently don't have to
- 55:37love that level of transparency of like being
- 55:39like, you can eventually get like information
- 55:40award, you can do like a FOIA request, which
- 55:42is Freedom of Information Act, or try to get
- 55:45it through some other means. But I think there
- 55:48is obviously a big issue also, and a big disconnect
- 55:51from what is being officially said, versus what
- 55:56the reality of things that are happening. And
- 55:57so it's about like, poking holes in that. And
- 56:00sometimes we just don't have the ability to poke
- 56:02holes. So they say like, oh, like if we have
- 56:04video footage or something, they're saying like,
- 56:05I think it might, um, the, the Pico Rivera case,
- 56:08uh, that they said like, oh, he did this assault
- 56:12thing. But if you look at all the footage, like
- 56:14he didn't assault anyone. So, you know, people
- 56:16might say like, oh, this person did this awful
- 56:18thing. And then when, if they want to put a charge,
- 56:20is that like awful thing? They said it's not
- 56:22actually like in a charge. Um, and so we, I think
- 56:25we need to continue to give pressure to see where
- 56:28we can Poking the holes in the data gap is where
- 56:30we're going to see pushing where those like gaps
- 56:36are is I think that they're really going to be
- 56:38the important components because pushing to see
- 56:41like where our people are pushing for those forms,
- 56:44push the things that we don't know because those
- 56:45are the holes. Those are the things I think being
- 56:47intentionally kept from us most often. So that's
- 56:51where we should be looking for is what information
- 56:54we are currently missing. Thanks so much. We're
- 56:58currently over time, so I don't want to keep
- 57:00us too long. I just wanted one word or one sentence
- 57:04response from everybody in terms of where you
- 57:06think people should be looking for next, in terms
- 57:10of what kind of states are you expecting these
- 57:13raids to hit next. We had a question similar
- 57:17to this earlier on, so I just wanted to address
- 57:19it and then we'll wrap. Kevin, maybe you can
- 57:22start. There's been an increase in funding to
- 57:28ICE very recently. So I think that ultimately,
- 57:32no matter what state they start to increase their
- 57:35operations, you're going to see a lot of the
- 57:37same tactics that have been used in California.
- 57:40So I wouldn't be surprised if Chicago and New
- 57:43York are starting to see similar raids in scale
- 57:47in the coming weeks and months. It's not that
- 57:50these places have not had. Uh, you know, significant
- 57:53activity, but, you know, now with this increased
- 57:55funding, I wouldn't be surprised if we see something
- 57:57the likes of what we saw in Los Angeles. And
- 58:00so, you know, I'm just going to keep my eyes
- 58:01there. Um, and just to, just to piggyback off
- 58:05of what everybody was saying about the kind of
- 58:07gaps, um, you know, we still don't know if there
- 58:10are people being taken to as well. I mean, ever
- 58:13since, um, the, uh, Brigo Garcia case, you know,
- 58:17everybody was pretty, you know. plugged into
- 58:19seeing, you know, the first kind of waves of
- 58:22people being taken to El Salvador, but it's kind
- 58:24of dropped off in attention. But there's some
- 58:26indication that, you know, there are still flights
- 58:28going there, and we don't know how many people
- 58:31are on those flights. So, you know, that's something
- 58:35I think I'll try and take a look at as well.
- 58:39I think it's going to get worse. The funding
- 58:42suggests, I mean, the funding is clear that there's
- 58:44going to be more of this in other cities. The
- 58:47poll just came out. This is wildly unpopular.
- 58:49Support for immigration is at its highest that
- 58:50they've ever measured it. To me, it's not about
- 58:53immigration so much as about power. bringing
- 58:56a city like Los Angeles to heel. I mean, Trump
- 58:59literally tweeted he's going to take this to
- 59:00other Democrat run cities like Chicago and New
- 59:03York. I think the show force ahead of MacArthur
- 59:05Park is exactly what they want to do is, you
- 59:08know, the treating it like it's a forward operating
- 59:09base. And they're in this is occupied territory
- 59:12and Stephen Miller calls Los Angeles occupied
- 59:14territory. So I think it's about power and less
- 59:16about immigration. I think it's it'll get worse
- 59:18in that sense. And I just before we go. Huge
- 59:22respect for fucking Bellingcat. Like, I cannot
- 59:24tell you the amount of times I have talked and
- 59:26I'm like, oh, we just did something that we commented
- 59:28as an evident. And Bellingcat literally didn't
- 59:30hear what I said before. They're like, Bellingcat?
- 59:32The amount of respect people have for Bellingcat
- 59:34is well -deserved. And every time Bellingcat
- 59:36does something, so feed me out. Let's do what
- 59:38Bellingcat does. So just, I have huge respect.
- 59:40Everybody in my newsroom is in awe of Bellingcat.
- 59:43Like, love Bellingcat. So you're just going to
- 59:47make me blush. Now I have to say some nice stuff
- 59:49about everyone else. Of course, we love being
- 59:55able to work with CalMatters and Evident because
- 59:58I think it's what makes the pieces strong. I
- 1:00:00think it's, you know, I think it is every like
- 1:00:06open source is just a part of the puzzle. And,
- 1:00:09you know, we need everything from visuals to
- 1:00:12people on the ground to our experts that, you
- 1:00:15know, Like, I don't have the level of calphery
- 1:00:19expertise that Sergio has. I don't have, I couldn't
- 1:00:22do a video at all like Kevin the cat. Like, I
- 1:00:25don't have those skills. So it's all about working
- 1:00:28together. It's all the different pieces of the
- 1:00:30pie. You can't just have, like, sugar. You need
- 1:00:34all the ingredients. I would say that Sergio
- 1:00:38took my Instagram, just saying, like, I just
- 1:00:40looked at what Trump tweeted. He literally gave
- 1:00:42out the list of cities he wants to hit next.
- 1:00:44So I think that's where we can look at. So I
- 1:00:50would say there's this question of where, right?
- 1:00:55Even though rates, I have seen over in Nebraska
- 1:00:58and some more red cities and states, I think
- 1:01:02he's going to focus still on Democratic strongholds,
- 1:01:07because of course he is. Um, so I think that
- 1:01:10is something we'll see. I don't think, I think
- 1:01:12it'll still happen across, but I think it'll
- 1:01:14be disproportionate to, um, sort of like what
- 1:01:17you would imagine blue city. So, um, yeah, I
- 1:01:20would say, yeah, you can look to, to New York,
- 1:01:22to, to Boston, to Chicago. You might even see
- 1:01:25Seattle where I am. Um, I think like Washington
- 1:01:29has tried to like prevent, but we've seen raids
- 1:01:31happening in Washington where I am too. Um, and
- 1:01:34I think there was just like a protest at, uh,
- 1:01:36I'm always mispronounced about Planter, Planter,
- 1:01:39the data company, there was a big protest here,
- 1:01:41just like this week. So I think like, because
- 1:01:45they're supplying, I think data to ICE. And so
- 1:01:47I think it's, you know, what we might even happen,
- 1:01:50like, I don't know if they're going to do, so
- 1:01:51I feel like LA was definitely the sort of like
- 1:01:54testing, I don't say testing grant, but like,
- 1:01:56essentially, they're like, can we do this on
- 1:01:57scale at a large scale? Like LA is one of the
- 1:02:00largest cities in the US. Can we basically do
- 1:02:03this? And are they going to basically scale?
- 1:02:05And I don't know if they're going to try to hit
- 1:02:07all the cities at once and overwhelm, or if they're
- 1:02:09just going to go from the focus of the city,
- 1:02:11then we're going to focus on this city, and then
- 1:02:13we're going to focus on the city. So that's,
- 1:02:14for me, the big question. It's not like which
- 1:02:17cities or when is whether or not they're going
- 1:02:19to do it all at once, or are they just going
- 1:02:21to be very targeted and put a lot of overwhelming
- 1:02:24force onto one and then go from city to city.
- 1:02:27That's my question. I think we'll see. I think
- 1:02:31it's going to get worse before it gets better,
- 1:02:33unfortunately. Well, as you just said, collaboration
- 1:02:36is key here. Working together to combat this
- 1:02:40huge and overwhelming problem is really important,
- 1:02:43and I couldn't have said it better. Working with
- 1:02:46all of you here has been fantastic on these two
- 1:02:48pieces. I encourage anyone in the audience, if
- 1:02:50you want to get involved with this kind of work.
- 1:02:53You can do so in this Discord server with each
- 1:02:56other and also with Bellingcat. You can look
- 1:02:59at the threads that I posted earlier in the chat.
- 1:03:02I'll also include them in the description of
- 1:03:03this podcast. And also, of course, check out
- 1:03:06the fantastic work that Evident and CalMatters
- 1:03:09are doing at the moment. It is absolutely groundbreaking
- 1:03:13and really important. And we'll pop the links
- 1:03:16to those in the description of this podcast and
- 1:03:18in the chat here. Thank you everybody for joining
- 1:03:22and we'll be back in two weeks time with another
- 1:03:25stage talk. Thank you so much. Thank you so much.
- 1:03:30Thanks everybody. Thank you for listening to
- 1:03:32the stage talk. If you'd like to catch a stage
- 1:03:35talk live where you can ask the guest questions,
- 1:03:39join the Bell and Cat Discord server by visiting
- 1:03:42www .discord .com. The music you've heard is
- 1:03:48titled Dawn by Newer Self and is courtesy of
- 1:03:52Artlist.