Latest / Consumerpedia / 54 - How to Shop for a Gym Membership
Transcript
- 0:01Exercise. It's one of the keys to living a
- 0:03long and healthy life. And yet, according to the CDC,
- 0:07only one in five adults in this country gets the recommended
- 0:10amount of physical activity each week.
- 0:13There are many ways to boost your activity level without a
- 0:15formal workout session. Take the stairs instead of an
- 0:18elevator? Park at the far end of the lot.
- 0:21Take a walk before or after dinner?
- 0:23For some, the way to go is to join a health club.
- 0:26They believe the facilities and the financial commitment of
- 0:28membership will provide the motivation they need to exercise
- 0:31more. I'm Her Weissbaum, the consumer
- 0:34man, a contributing editor at checkbook.org.
- 0:37Welcome to consumerpedia@checkbook.org,
- 0:40where the nonprofit that helps consumers select services, avoid
- 0:43trouble, and save money. Because we don't accept any
- 0:46advertising or take money from any business, we recommend you
- 0:50can rely on checkbook.org to be completely independent and
- 0:53objective. Now here's the host of
- 0:55Consumerpedia America's consumer expert, the consumer man Herb
- 1:00Weissbaum. In this episode, how to find a
- 1:03Jimmer Health Club that will work for you.
- 1:05How to avoid the common marketing tricks and traps that
- 1:08lead to complaints and a reality check.
- 1:11Why so many people join. And then stop going here to help
- 1:15us with all that Checkbooks executive editor and fitness
- 1:18guru Kevin Bressler. I don't know about fitness guru,
- 1:22but I do have some advice on picking the right fitness center
- 1:26or or maybe even on not picking one at all.
- 1:28And that advice is based on covering fitness Centers for
- 1:31decades. And quite frankly, your overall
- 1:33advice hasn't really changed much over the years.
- 1:35I was just thinking the other day that, you know, as part of
- 1:37my original job interview here at Checkbook, Robert Krughoff,
- 1:41our founder, asked me to brainstorm how to evaluate
- 1:44fitness centers. And that was nearly 30 years
- 1:47ago. And then after I got the job, I
- 1:49had to shop gyms for their membership cost info.
- 1:53Back then, it was really difficult to get prices out of
- 1:55fitness clubs, so they wanted customers to come in and visit
- 1:58their facilities. They wouldn't discuss them over
- 2:00the phone. The Internet really didn't
- 2:02exist, so you couldn't get prices there.
- 2:04And what they wanted people to do is come in so they could work
- 2:07them over and give them the hard sales pitch.
- 2:10So I ended up having to drive around and visit dozens of gyms
- 2:13and and get those hard sell sales presentations.
- 2:16It was really awful. So the good news though is that
- 2:19most gym sales Staffs, they're less aggressive these days.
- 2:23Not all but most of them are less aggressive.
- 2:25Some still give the hard sell, but for the most part fitness
- 2:28centers, they want to sign up members online and and most
- 2:31don't push like 3 year memberships and crazy things
- 2:35like that anymore. But the bad news is and then
- 2:38this is how our advice really remains the same is that most
- 2:41consumers who join gyms stop using them after just a few
- 2:46weeks or a few months but keep right on paying those monthly
- 2:49dues. And although there are some
- 2:51really affordable options now, I mean some gyms charge only $10 a
- 2:55month. Many gyms remain quite
- 2:58expensive. Some have large initiation fees,
- 3:01some have large monthly fees, Some charge ridiculous fees for
- 3:05classes or private instruction. But even if you find a low cost
- 3:09gym a $10 a month gym, it's a wasteful buy if you're paying
- 3:13for something that you don't use.
- 3:15And most of the people who join gyms stop using them pretty
- 3:18quickly. By the way, an indication of how
- 3:20things have changed as you noted, I've been reporting on
- 3:23this for decades as well and I remember in the mid 80s here in
- 3:26Seattle there was a lot of really high pressure sales tax.
- 3:29It's going on and they would keep people in a room for two or
- 3:32three hours making this high pressure sales pitch.
- 3:35And I talked to the people and I say why did you sign up and they
- 3:38say, well I had to get out of the room.
- 3:39Well, they weren't keeping you in their physically, were they?
- 3:42Well, he sort of was standing in front of the door and I thought
- 3:44I couldn't get out and people would join a gym because they
- 3:47felt that was the only way they could get out of the sales
- 3:49presentation. I mean, that's how bad things
- 3:51used to be. And it used to be they wouldn't
- 3:52give you firm pricing for hours. I mean they would wait to
- 3:55actually show you their pricing on this, you know, written up
- 3:59form. There was no price list for
- 4:01hours because at that point they knew, well, you know, they'll
- 4:03pay anything to get out of here. At this point I I would sit in
- 4:06gyms, you know, in these sales presentations for hours.
- 4:09You know, they're doing this fitness evaluation and all this
- 4:12nonsense just to keep you around and giving this long in depth
- 4:15tour and making sure they're introducing you to the most
- 4:18attractive instructors, things like that.
- 4:21And the whole time I would say, well, I just want to know what
- 4:23the costs are. I I don't want to go through all
- 4:25this. If I can't afford it, well, what
- 4:27can you afford? It was a lawless kind of, you
- 4:29know, gamesmanship and negotiations.
- 4:32And my excuse was always, well, I of course need to speak to my
- 4:34spouse and they'd say, well, you know, do you have to speak to
- 4:37your spouse before you buy a loaf of bread?
- 4:39I mean, these just ridiculous things that for the most part,
- 4:42gyms don't push three-year memberships and don't make their
- 4:46customers jump through somebody hoops anymore.
- 4:48So put on your behavioral scientist hat.
- 4:50Why do people join a gym or health club and then stop going?
- 4:54Yeah, I mean, I've written over the last 30 years that the
- 4:56entire fitness industry really counts on good intentions.
- 5:01Getting into shape or getting back into shape is similar to
- 5:04quitting a bad habit. I mean, you really do have to
- 5:07make a realistic plan and then work hard to stick with it.
- 5:11Exercise can require a lot of motivation, especially at first.
- 5:15You know, when your muscles are sore and it's just hard to find
- 5:18that motivation, you may not be seeing the results that you'd
- 5:20like to see so quickly. Fitness clubs and companies that
- 5:24sell at home workout machines and workout sessions, they know
- 5:28that and they know that if they're selling a service and
- 5:3180% of your customers will want to quit after about a month, you
- 5:34know, what do you do about that? How do you prevent, you know,
- 5:36losing all that money? You sell memberships.
- 5:39You get them on the hook with automatic payments.
- 5:41The the fitness industry, especially fitness centers,
- 5:44they're like the OG of automatic checking account withdrawals.
- 5:47They were doing that long before anybody else.
- 5:50The other thing about these good fitness intentions is that even
- 5:54among consumers who quit using gyms, a lot of them, at least in
- 5:57their minds well, they plan to go back.
- 5:59So they keep right on paying those membership dues every
- 6:02month for gyms that they're not using anymore.
- 6:05But they say and to themselves, well, at some point I do want to
- 6:08get back to going to the gym and so they just keep right on pain.
- 6:11So for listeners who have resolved to exercise more in the
- 6:14new Year, and so many did, where do they start?
- 6:17So if you've been a member of a gym before, then you probably
- 6:20have a sense of what you need and don't care about and whether
- 6:24you'll actually use a gym. But if you haven't been a member
- 6:27of a gym, really really important to consider
- 6:29alternatives and not commit long term to anyone, company or even
- 6:33one type of workout. The best place to start is to
- 6:37make a fitness plan. By doing this you might find out
- 6:40that there are many ways to workout without even joining a
- 6:43gym. You can go on long walks, you
- 6:45can take up running, you can do at home, exercise classes.
- 6:49There are tons of videos online. Great videos online to do that.
- 6:53You can even buy a treadmill for not much money.
- 6:55There are many, many options these days, but all require
- 6:59commitment and motivation. The more you enjoy the activity
- 7:03though, the more likely you'll succeed.
- 7:04So for example, I love playing basketball.
- 7:07I have several groups I play with each week and I also like
- 7:10to hike a lot. But I mean, I can't imagine
- 7:12pushing and pulling on weights in some smelly gym.
- 7:15That's just not for me and it's not for a lot of people, but
- 7:18unfortunately the fitness industry, it's kind of been
- 7:21successful in marketing and making gyms like the default
- 7:25option for getting in shape, but they're all these other options
- 7:28out there. By the way, just between us
- 7:29girls, I can't imagine you pulling some weights at a gym
- 7:32either. There's no way, man.
- 7:34There's no way. In addition to considering
- 7:37fitness centers, another option you suggest is using recreation
- 7:40centers. Tell us about that.
- 7:41Yeah. So many local governments
- 7:43operate community and recreational centers that are
- 7:46very well equipped. I mean they they charge prices
- 7:49that are far, far less than most gyms, but they're equipped like
- 7:53good fitness centers. They're also YMCAS.
- 7:56They offer, you know, non profit alternatives to fitness centers
- 7:59and between recreation centers and YMCAS they offer different
- 8:03types of programming. It's not just necessarily a
- 8:06workout regimen. They may have art classes and
- 8:08things like that that you might be interested in.
- 8:10I will say, though, that some consumers find that they do have
- 8:14to pay a lot more to keep up with their workouts, to keep
- 8:17motivated. I have friends, There are people
- 8:19on staff here at Checkbook who pay, You know, what I consider
- 8:22astonishingly high prices per class to work out at boutique
- 8:26exercise studios. But you know, that's what works
- 8:29for them. You know the key is to figure
- 8:31out what works for you. What will keep you motivated to
- 8:34do that. It often takes a lot of shopping
- 8:36around and trial and error. So for those who do sign up for
- 8:39some type of ongoing exercise program you advise, be realistic
- 8:44about your goals and commit to making this part of your weekly
- 8:47schedule. I found when I started going to
- 8:49the gym that was the key. It had to be on the calendar
- 8:51planned like I had a lunch appointment or something like.
- 8:54That so another thing to consider doing is make a list of
- 8:56reasons for why you're doing this in the first place, and
- 8:59then go back and refer to them. If you become you know less
- 9:02enthusiastic about things. If it's it becomes harder for
- 9:05you to keep these appointments on your calendar, these workout
- 9:07appointments. And I should also point out that
- 9:10if you're older than 40, review your plan with a physician
- 9:13before beginning. So you've looked at all the
- 9:15options. You decided that you are going
- 9:17to join a gym. How do you decide which one and
- 9:19what should you look for when you compare those options?
- 9:22We're going to talk about that next.
- 9:24I'm Her Weissbaum, the consumer man.
- 9:26And you're listening to Consumer Pedia powered by checkbook.org.
- 9:31Thinking of joining the gym? Checkbook has ratings for dozens
- 9:34of gyms and fitness centers in these metro areas.
- 9:37Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle, San Francisco,
- 9:41Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and Washington DC.
- 9:44If you live in or around one of these seven cities and haven't
- 9:47joined Checkbook yet, check us out.
- 9:49Get a free 30 day subscription to all our ratings by going to
- 9:52checkbook.org/consumer Pedia. OK, so you set realistic goals,
- 9:59you've looked at the options, and you've decided that a gym is
- 10:02the right place for you to get into shape.
- 10:04So how do you decide which one to join?
- 10:06Where I live, there are literally about 40 gyms within a
- 10:09five mile radius from very small little boutique places to big
- 10:13fancy health clubs. Kevin.
- 10:14Probably the most important thing is to check out gyms that
- 10:17are conveniently located. You usually have lots of
- 10:19options, but you're not going to want to sit in traffic for 30
- 10:23minutes or even 15 minutes to get to the gym that that's just
- 10:27going to present one more reason not to go work out beyond that,
- 10:31you compare what local gyms offer and how much they charge.
- 10:35We did that and we found that fees vary dramatically from club
- 10:39to club. We looked at pricing from gyms
- 10:41for six different profiles and found that for an individual
- 10:44membership, for example, you can pay between about $200 a year to
- 10:48more than $2000 a year depending on the facility you join.
- 10:53Now a big reason for cost differences is their facilities
- 10:57and amenities. Especially if a club offers
- 10:59indoor tennis courts or an indoor pool, for example, it's
- 11:02likely to have higher costs than, you know, a bare bones
- 11:05gym. But if you don't care about
- 11:06playing tennis or you don't care about swimming, then you can
- 11:09save a ton of money by joining a facility that just has a good
- 11:13basic, you know, workout facilities.
- 11:15But even among similarly equipped clubs, those that offer
- 11:18similar facilities and amenities, we find these big,
- 11:21big price differences for memberships.
- 11:23And I know, Kevin, you hate to pay full price.
- 11:25So I guess you suggest that we maybe ask for discounts or some
- 11:28sort of special rates? Well, you should definitely ask
- 11:31about them. You know, many clubs offer steep
- 11:33discounts, for example for older adults, if you're older than 50
- 11:36or 55 or so. You may also qualify for a
- 11:40discount through your employer or your school if you're a
- 11:42student or a teacher. Many gyms have agreements with
- 11:46employers for corporate rates. Those rates are typically 10 to
- 11:4920 lower than normal rates. And even if your emloyer doesn't
- 11:53have that kind of agreement, you might be able to recruit
- 11:55coworkers to join with you and get a group discount.
- 11:59You should also check with your health insurance plan to see if
- 12:02it offers fitness related benefits.
- 12:04Most Medicare Advantage plans, for example, their policyholders
- 12:08can get free or very low cost memberships at participating
- 12:12health clubs. Many private insurance companies
- 12:14will actually reimburse their members if they pay for gym
- 12:17expenses. Some of these plants, they're
- 12:19quite generous. They'll pay more than just
- 12:22fitness center costs. They may reimburse you for
- 12:24exercise classes and yoga classes, ski lift fees, things
- 12:29like that, even Weight Watchers. So you have to check to see what
- 12:32you get. And as with so many other
- 12:33purchases we make, you need to watch out for fake discounts
- 12:36that make the price seem better than it really is.
- 12:38Yeah. You know, especially this time
- 12:40of the year, many clubs print out membership fee schedules
- 12:43with, you know, really inflated prices so that they can, you
- 12:46know, cross out these BS higher prices and make it seem like
- 12:50they're giving you a great deal. During their sales pitch, those
- 12:53crossed out prices are usually meaningless.
- 12:55They exist only to make you think you're getting a great
- 12:57deal. And this is especially
- 12:59important. If a salesperson tells you that
- 13:01you have to sign on that moment that day in order to get this
- 13:04special discount, be very wary. The really sketchy places.
- 13:08They use these deadlines to pressure you into closing deals
- 13:12and to rush you into making a decision that you may not have
- 13:15made if you had more time to consider it, you know.
- 13:17Before you buy a car, you test drive.
- 13:19Before you buy a gym membership, you probably should try it out,
- 13:22right? This is crucial.
- 13:23The really good gyms and fitness studios.
- 13:26They'll let you try them out for free for a few visits, or
- 13:29they'll offer you a really short term membership, or you know, a
- 13:31package of seven visits or something like that to let you
- 13:34try them out. So if you can, definitely take
- 13:37advantage of these intro offers when you try them out, go When
- 13:41you think at times you think you'll usually work out so you
- 13:44can see whether it's crowded. A big complaint about gyms is
- 13:47that that they're really crowded during, you know, rush hour
- 13:49times, right? And also if you can take classes
- 13:53you think you'll want to take if you become a full member to see
- 13:57if the instructors are any good. You know, check to see if
- 13:59equipment there is working. Another big complaint about
- 14:01gyms, this stuff doesn't work. And also, if you can, ask
- 14:04questions of staff to see whether they're knowledgeable
- 14:06and responsive and helpful. And how clean the place is, like
- 14:09the locker room. That's another big complaint I
- 14:10saw, and I looked on the list of complaints.
- 14:12The place just wasn't kept up. Yeah, it's a huge complaint that
- 14:15the locker rooms are dirty, that equipments not working.
- 14:19The more you can inspect them, the more opportunities you get
- 14:22to try out a gym before you commit to a long term
- 14:24membership, the better. There are a whole bunch of
- 14:26reasons why gyms and health clubs generate a lot of consumer
- 14:29complaints, And a lot of that has to do with how those
- 14:32memberships are sold and how people pay for them.
- 14:35Some things you need to know before you sign on the dotted
- 14:37line. That's straight ahead.
- 14:38I'm Herb Weissbaum, and you're listening to Consumerpedia,
- 14:41powered by checkbook.org. Consumerpedia Fast Facts These
- 14:48fitness facts are from the website Statista.
- 14:50The average cost of a monthly gym membership in the United
- 14:53States in 2021 stood at almost $29.00.
- 14:57The most expensive gym memberships on average, were in
- 14:59the state of New York at about $75.00 a month.
- 15:03In 2022, 21% of American men said they participated in sports
- 15:08and recreational activities every day, compared to only 19%
- 15:12of women. A survey done in 2023 found
- 15:15hiking is the most popular sports activity in the US.
- 15:20When I was a local consumer reporter here in Seattle, Kevin,
- 15:23I'd get all sorts of complaints about gyms and health clubs.
- 15:26As I mentioned earlier, a big complaint was high pressure
- 15:29sales tactics. The other was signing up for
- 15:31automatic withdrawals from a checking account.
- 15:33The person would quit the gym and the withdrawals wouldn't
- 15:35stop. I would only pay with a credit
- 15:38card. Would you agree?
- 15:39Yes, as you said, canceling gym membership has been a problem
- 15:42for decades. This is crucial.
- 15:44Before signing any contract, especially check what happens if
- 15:48you want to quit. Many fitness clubs, they still
- 15:51make it very difficult on their members.
- 15:53They say, well, you have to come in in person and talk to us if
- 15:56you want to quit because they want that opportunity for their
- 15:59sales staff to work you over all over again.
- 16:01We have a big problem with this and that, You know, they're
- 16:04allowing consumers to sign up for memberships online and do so
- 16:07easily. But when they want to cancel
- 16:09their membership, they make it difficult to quit or they say
- 16:12you have to give us 60 days notice or all this kind of
- 16:14stuff. It's just really important, you
- 16:16know in advance what you'll have to do if you want out of this
- 16:18commitment. You know, the biggest problem I
- 16:21think remains is that consumers get the hard sell.
- 16:24You know, they sign a contract for a one year membership, they
- 16:27have to pay an initiation fee and 1st and last months dues and
- 16:30things like that. And then they only find out
- 16:32later that the gym they've joined is horrible.
- 16:35Equipment doesn't work, it's overcrowded, or class is always
- 16:39cancelled. The staff's incompetent.
- 16:41So then they really want to quit.
- 16:42But no, too bad. They signed on for a year and
- 16:46even though the place stinks, you know, literally so right,
- 16:49you got to keep paying some gyms, they kept right on
- 16:52charging customers through the damn pandemic.
- 16:54I mean, their gyms were closed, but no, they kept right on
- 16:57trying to collect those fees, and sometimes by doing it
- 17:00through automatic debit from checking accounts.
- 17:03Another problem is, you know, what do you do if you move or
- 17:05you get sick or injured? And good gyms will let you out
- 17:08of those types of commitments or let you freeze your deal until
- 17:11you get better. But bad gyms do things like, you
- 17:14know, they find a partner gym where you must continue your
- 17:16membership even if it's located 40 miles from your new home.
- 17:19So what consumers need to know here, though, is that most gyms
- 17:22continue to be ruthless about enforcing these contracts.
- 17:26You have to be very careful about reading them and making
- 17:29sure you know what you're getting into before you join a
- 17:31gym, unfortunately. And one tip I'd like to suggest
- 17:34is before you even start your search, you might want to go to
- 17:37the Better Business Bureau website and look for ratings and
- 17:39complaints for that company. I just went on today and found
- 17:42some very, very well known gyms had D&F ratings.
- 17:47Yeah, The big chains don't necessarily offer better
- 17:49experiences. And in our surveys of consumers,
- 17:52we find that usually it's, you know, the local outfits get
- 17:55better ratings by their customers than others.
- 17:57But overall, I would say that fitness centers among all the
- 18:00different types of of services we look at, get probably among
- 18:04the lowest ratings. They really are not well
- 18:07received and reviewed by consumers at all.
- 18:10And a lot of this has to do with, you know, making promises
- 18:12they don't keep or selling these memberships where they're just
- 18:16automatically charging you every month for something that that
- 18:18isn't very good, that you hoped would have been better,
- 18:21especially given the sales presentation you were given.
- 18:23And keep in mind what kind of person you are.
- 18:25I found that if I went to the gym with a bunch of people from
- 18:28work, I was more motivated to go on the day.
- 18:30I just didn't feel like going come on, let's go or get a beer
- 18:33afterwards or whatever. There is that social aspect that
- 18:36might be the motivator to make you continue to work out when
- 18:39you really don't want to. Yeah.
- 18:41And it's important to kind of again try out gyms.
- 18:44Every gym is kind of different, right?
- 18:45Some are are very family friendly.
- 18:47Some are very much, you know, geared toward people who are
- 18:50there to work out and and work out alone.
- 18:53Some are are, you know, social centers, some are are dating
- 18:56hookup places. And so the only reason you can
- 18:59kind of get a sense for what that specific gym is offering is
- 19:02to try it out. And the more you can try it out,
- 19:04the better. And the more places you can try
- 19:06out, you know you'll get the sense for what's the best fit
- 19:08for you. So we can't emphasize this
- 19:10enough. Chances are you're going to be
- 19:12asked to sign a contract. And before you do that, make
- 19:16sure you read it carefully and find out what you're obligating
- 19:19yourself to. Be really careful here.
- 19:21I mean, if a salesperson has made any promises, make sure
- 19:24that they're in writing. If someone tells you they're
- 19:26about to build a new indoor pool, get that in writing.
- 19:29If they tell you that you can cancel your membership for any
- 19:31reason at any time, get it in writing.
- 19:34Oral promises made by the sales staff.
- 19:36They don't count. Well Kevin, right now you've got
- 19:39me in the mood to work up a sweat, so I'm going to go change
- 19:42into my exercise gear and see if I can drop a few pounds for the
- 19:45new year. That sounds good.
- 19:46I'm going to sit here and continue writing about price
- 19:49matching policies. Well, that's it for this edition
- 19:52of Consumerpedia. We hope you'll rate this episode
- 19:54and follow us on Apple podcast, Spotify or wherever you listen
- 19:58to your podcast. Remember, we release new
- 20:01episodes every other Thursday. Another way you can support this
- 20:04show is to follow us on Consumerpedia on Facebook and
- 20:07Instagram, And at my Consumerpedia on Twitter.
- 20:11I'm Her Weissbaum. Thanks for listening.
- 20:13Consumerpedia is a public service of checkbook.org.
- 20:17We're a unique nonprofit that helps you save money and make
- 20:20smarter choices. You can count on Checkbook to
- 20:22help you find the best services and avoid the worst, with local
- 20:26ratings that are accurate and unbiased.
- 20:28If you live in or around these seven cities and haven't joined
- 20:31Checkbook yet, check us out Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia,
- 20:36Seattle, San Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and
- 20:39Washington DC To get your free 30 day subscription, go to
- 20:43checkbook.org/consumer Pedia. If you like what you've heard,
- 20:47we hope you'll become a supporter by using the link at
- 20:50the bottom of the show. Notes to make a small
- 20:52contribution each month. Consumer Pedia Empowering
- 20:55consumers to save money and make smarter choices.