Latest / Carbon Weekly News / This Kills carbon Deals with Dan Harburg | CWN EP03
Transcript
- speaker-0: Well, welcome back everyone to the next episode of CWN and you see we have one more person here, which is Dan, ⁓ which I'm super excited to have. And I ⁓ I got a lot of feedback from how to run CWN and it was always the intention to actually not do this alone, but sometimes my kind of I would say intrinsic urgency pushes me to just start things and then see where it ends up. And I was thinking, okay, who could be someone to run this with? And I was thinking a lot about what is the profile of the person to make this really worthwhile. And I was thinking actually the best would be an actual project developer, someone who's on the ground. Because I speak a l to a lot of corporates. That doesn't mean a project developer doesn't talk to corporates, right? But I mostly talk to corporates and I think really often what they are missing is a direct perspective on what a project looks like on the ground, but also be able to translate that to you to a customer. And then I was thinking about Dan and he met with my co-founder. They had a fun chat about it in London and here we are. That's how we ended up on this this episode together. So I'm super happy that Dan is here today and as You already know who I am. It's not that important anymore, right? ⁓ we thought about let's do a little bit of an intro on who is Dan, where does he come from? Why is he in New Mexico at the moment? And also a little bit around how did he end up in carbon markets and that Monback. So Dan, super happy to have you here. Maybe you can start a little bit with a mini intro and how you ended up in carbon markets. I think everyone has a really Different story how they end up in that market. speaker-2: Yeah, maybe worth starting a little before my entry into carbon markets. My very first paid job was when I was 13 years old and I was in the opera. And so I've always been a performer and somebody who has loved to be on stage. So I'll use this as my young self coming back out again. speaker-0: And so but you know, I I'm in South Africa right now, and actually how I ended up here and I never told that anyone is because during my masters in Denmark studying computational fluid dynamics, I was modeling on the side to finance my masters or the living costs in Denmark. And they sent me to South Africa back then to model in between. And that's actually how I fell in love with South Africa. But Maybe not Oprah vibes, but you still you have to age, right? speaker-2: Yeah, I stayed in show business for a little while. did theater and arts and stuff like that all throughout high school and a bit into college and so on. But yeah, I've been a technologist similar to you. I wasn't doing computational fluid dynamics, but I was an electrical engineer in college. And I was always interested in sustainability. Then I ended up doing a PhD. And during my PhD studies, I was focused really on energy efficiency and renewable energy. I started my PhD just at the time that all the startups were getting hot in Silicon Valley around thin film solar cells and new turbine designs for wind turbines that could be very compact. And it was just, there was all this energy around this new wave of clean tech. And between the time that I started a PhD and when I ended, which takes a little bit of time to do. Basically the moment had come and passed. My opportunity to jump into startups that were engaging in that space, all the companies blew up when China started dumping solar into the market, funding dried up for a bunch of the startups. And so it was really not a moment to get into sustainability right out of grad school. And so I'd wandered through a range of different startups because I always wanted to do startups. That was really the driving thing for me was entrepreneurship and being able to wear many different hats. As a scientist who's also a singer, but also a bit of a philosopher, I've moved 15 times in my life. I've lived in seven different countries. So I speak four languages. I am a person who loves to be able to do a bit of everything. And startups always seemed like the natural fit for me. And I started in robotics, doing some medical devices work and found my way into food and agriculture, mostly through robotics, because robotics was starting to have a bit of a moment where Some of the best application areas were in how do we get automation into the food industry a bit better? And that interestingly led me to Indigo agriculture, where at the time the CEO was trying to figure out how Indigo could do work in carbon. He thought this ought to be a good match. We ought to be able to help farmers earn extra money from carbon credits. So in 2018, I started a business inside of a startup to launch Indigo carbon. where I had originally thought I was going there to work on robots and agriculture and basically found my way back to this area. And now I've spent the last eight years thinking about carbon. speaker-0: Because Indigo 218, they were definitely one of the first movers, right? Like I think when I went into carbon markets and I looked at like what is the landscape? I think they were like one of the the big ones. What was that? 220 or something like that. And the big ones, there was not that much actually on project developer side that you actually could find, right? It was structured a little bit differently. But they were early. speaker-1: Alright. speaker-2: We had to write a methodology with Vera, the M42. So our team was responsible for that methodology. And our team also wrote the soil enrichment protocol with the climate action reserve. So really the kind of first two usable soil carbon methodologies in the space. then, yeah, Indigo was definitely early in the market. So it's been fun because it also created a bit of a mafia of Indigo who have now gone on to the... The leads of the Microsoft and Google carbon procurement teams are both Indigo folks. There's a bunch of startups that have Indigo people in them and they're scattered all over the industry now. So that's been really fun to see. And then I joined Mombac about five years ago now, a Brazilian based carbon project developer. At the time, the company was two weeks old, basically, when I joined. They didn't really have anybody who knew much about carbon. It was a bunch of forestry scientists and forestry engineers who knew how to do massive projects at scale. And then some really good entrepreneurs, successful ex unicorn folks who had founded the company with a really interesting lens of, we think we have a moment to raise money and build a large developer in Brazil where Brazil just has a bunch of unfair advantages to other parts of the world to be able to do carbon removal at massive scale. And so I've been there in a number of different roles during the time, but most recently chief commercial officer for the team. speaker-0: I think five years ago, I think it's around the same time that that we started Lizang with our speaker-1: Yeah. I I'm speaker-0: same kind of kind of mission and ⁓ went through ups and downs in the market. ⁓ that's that's crazy. But also how how do you how do you feel coming also from the engineering side and now being a a commercial or a chief commercial officer? I think it's just such a interesting journey. But also I think it's it works so well because this market is so complex, right? ⁓ it's almost impossible and we tried it. I'm I'm gonna Like I started a company and it's like after two and a half years I think it was like and I have to hire a chief commercial officer and I hired VP of sales, but the person had no clue about carbon and was now engineer, like had no background in that space and after half a year I was like, ⁓ damn, that is not working out. ⁓ I think ⁓ it it maybe works in like the software businesses, but carbon is not the place. speaker-1: No I And speaker-2: I started down this path of leveraging the technical skills that I had in sales in one of my first startups where we had some technical people already kind of in the back of the lab and investors wanted to understand what we were doing and outside market, our customers also wanted to understand what we were doing. And I participated in a few meetings and realized that one of these unique skills, I think maybe this combination of You know, having the kind of artistic side, having the language, understanding new cultures, just my ability to bridge the gap between, what is happening in the technical side and why does that matter? Why is it useful to the world? How do we tell the story to somebody that doesn't have the same technical skillset? That, that became clear to me really early on in my career that it was something that I was good at. You know, it matters just as much in a a technical area like robotics as it does here and probably more so here because here you're selling in a robotics company, right? You're selling to a very technical buyer. Here you may be selling to a non-technical buyer, something that is quite technical. And, you know, we have certification, remote sensing and measurement and monitoring and forest science and species selection. And even for a nature based project where there's no kind of tech in the CDR removal method. there's still a ton of technical elements of the sales process. And if you don't come off as credible to the buyer on the other side, ⁓ you just immediately lose trust and you can't close a sale. And so just as you said, we also thought, you know, okay, our first deals, let's just do these as kind of the founding team. So it was me and the two co-founders, like, we're gonna be the ones that talk to Microsoft and Google and others to close. initial deals. And think that was the right approach. And then we just thought, ⁓ yeah, well, let's hire somebody to manage the sales team. And we tried for over a year to do that. And ultimately, not that long ago, actually, we just said, let's have Dan do it. Let's change his team around and sort of drop some of these other responsibilities and try to build a, you know, better to build a team under rather than alongside of what Dan's been doing. speaker-0: To summarize the secret sauce to be commercially successful in car markets is combine a showman. That would be Oprah, but if you model it it's also fine. with someone who has some extra exact background, I think. speaker-2: You'd be the face of it, I'll be the voice of it, and from there we've got all sides covered. speaker-0: Yeah, because my voice, you know, I also have a newborn that he's ten weeks old. I start singing, he starts crying. So let's let's not stick to the to the voice of my side. So I'm happy to take it from you. So But it's a crate. We know the secret source now and could go out hiring again. Maybe because now I know speaker-2: It's complicated job description, but if you find that at wonder kid we get to go speaker-0: Easy. Okay, cool. Yeah, that's that's super exciting and speaker-1: Yeah, I mean I know the button. speaker-0: the mobic project now also quite well. But you're also now looking into to other pathways, right? speaker-2: The key insight for us was, again, Brazil's got really unfair advantages, really unique advantages in, if you look at forestry, the largest rainforest in the world, the best conditions in terms of temperature and rainfall to grow forest and a ton of sadly open land where once stood forest that ought to be reforested and if reforested, it has huge benefits from an environmental biodiversity and economic perspective for Brazil and for the, know, obviously for the forest, but for food security in the country for all kinds of other reasons. So, reforestation in Brazil has, from that perspective, the ability to really scale quickly and do so at a lower cost relative to other places, right? The faster I can get a tree to grow relative to what it might grow in Norway or the US or other places in the world. the cheaper I can make my carbon credit and I can make these projects attractive to outside buyers. And because Brazil is still considered developing by many metric, there's development bank financing that's available to projects in Brazil, both through the Brazil National Development Bank who've been extremely supportive of this area and other international development banks that couldn't invest in more mature markets. so. And MAMAC was fortunate to get the first World Bank outcome bond. was focused on a carbon project. ⁓ You just couldn't, you couldn't have an outcome bond like that in the, in Europe. You know, we saw another one actually in South Africa recently get placed, but you know, this is, these are extremely helpful tools to be able to keep the costs of operating these projects down. We started to do these reforestation projects. said, you know, reforestation is of course not the only spot that Brazil has advantage. It's got. enormous access to natural resources and minerals and mining. And enhanced rock weathering, but also, you you see biochar taking hold in Brazil. There are going to be, you know, river and ocean based carbon removal projects. There's all kinds of other ⁓ things that can be done well in Brazil. But for us, clearly the expertise of we know how to build partnerships with landowners. We know how to move large amounts of products around and coordinate the activities in the field because we're a vertically integrated project developer, right? We operate the entire end-to-end of the projects ourselves. those skills are sort of best applied in an area like enhanced rock weathering where we saw a huge opportunity. that has become the second method that we're deploying in Brazil. And we're looking at a few others now to continue to expand the business. speaker-0: Think this is exactly what we can get out of the show, right? I think it's super exciting to get this lens on now it's it's quite specific on on Brazil. It doesn't matter that much. It's more about like, okay, if you have really good conditions, what kind of methodologies, what kind of pathways can we even I mean, scale, but also bring into I would say in a development state where corporates are actually interested to ⁓ to interact with it, right? Because even when in enhanced rock weather, I what I always see, obviously we're really focused on European buyers. and it's maybe a little bit different to US buyers, but we see that US buyers already interact with it a little bit more because European buyers just by nature a little bit more risk adverse, or would say like the US buyer, they'll They also love the story about a new methodology that has a lot of potential and they're happy to find more ⁓ along these lines. Whereas in Europe you have maybe some ⁓ players like that, but mostly they are like, Hey, what can I what already has a certain kind of technological readiness level and so on and so forth. And I think with you we have like a really good view on these different pathways. Actually, like an open experiment almost. ⁓ you can try all these things and see what actually works. have like insights and maybe a little bit earlier than ⁓ has at the moment. So I think it's super exciting to have this different kind of perspective. And ⁓ also you on the other hand you also work with buyers that maybe even more international ⁓ than me. ⁓ whereas I probably ⁓ also interact with a lot of the I would say longer tail of the market. So obviously we're not only working with the T Mobiles, Doggy Telecoms, Vodafones, ⁓ and so on, but also with like midsized companies that maybe only have to procure like five thousand credits and ten thousand credits. And for that enhanced rock weathering is still miles away. But they're just opening up to things like biochar. And I think it's super interesting to see because we need that part of the market as well. ⁓ but it's just a on the longer tail of things. So I think we can have quite the insightful conversation. speaker-2: obviously spend a lot of time talking to buyers in general, our profile tends to be looking at the buyers who are going to be catalytic to helping us unlock new financing or, you know, what's the longest, largest agreement that I can do that helps to start the projects. But Monbeck also just issued its first batch of credits a month ago. And we we were fortunate enough to actually be quite early relative to our initial expectations for when we would be issuing credits. And as a result of that, we actually were able to go to the spot market with about 20,000 credits and try to figure out how to navigate this. It would be issuing credits. And as a result of that, we actually were able to go to the spot market with about 20,000 credits and try to figure out how to navigate this famous spot market that people talked about. No one had ever sort of At least we had zero experience selling and trying to figure out, you know, where the buyer's there, how do people interact? How do the credit around quickly when you actually already have the inventory and nobody cares about undelivery risk and all these other elements that make contracting so complicated? speaker-0: Exactly. Suddenly the contract is only three pages long. speaker-2: It's kind of fun because now we're getting the opportunity to deal with a whole different class of buyers. Still trying to think about how we don't want to just do a transaction with somebody that goes away and never returns as a buyer or isn't helpful for us to unlock some other component of the business. But it does give us a really unique lens now to think about how this market looks and how we maximize the opportunity for the project. speaker-0: Yeah, but also I I think about the spot market. Obviously it will always be a spot market, right? But what we see a lot with companies that we interact, that we first interact with them on the spot market because that's how they used to interact with the market in the past. And then just by educating them over time, like we basically now they partner for one year. But it's basically just a spot transaction, right? But there's a couple of things coming afterwards, like a little bit of ⁓ documentation for maybe the reporting and so on and so forth. So you you have like a year long relationship. But in that the education part is super important. And I think it's probably like ninety-five percent of them afterwards ⁓ say like it makes no sense to interact spot again. It took us so much time to go through all the offers and then we know already what is happening next year, at least to a certain extent. Let's at least try and look at three years ⁓ contracting. And that doesn't necessarily mean that they say we're only gonna do it with you, but at least we educate them on around like how the market can be steered in a I would I would say in an easier way, because you have way less risk on ex at least price and availability. But there are other other risks coming, as you just mentioned, like speaker-2: No, I agree. So we're seeing this opportunity to say, Hey, let me give you a thousand credits today. And then I'm going to sell you 20,000 credits over the next few years. And then while we're doing that transaction, you're also looking at a 10 year offtake. That's going to be helpful to open new land for us in the pipeline or something like that. So it's a sequencing of those agreements, but ideally in quite short succession so that it's all like, go do this one deal and go away, but rather, all right, we're gonna do this one now if you're also willing to do these two others right on the heels of this first transaction. I think that's really important to kind of build that momentum. It's funny, this is also the first time I've delivered something where you can't kind of check in with the person you sold the thing to after to say, how's your experience with the carbon credit? How's that credit working for you? It's a funny. customer journey to have, you the thing is sold and then it's just sort of like onto the next thing that I need to sell you again immediately as opposed to being able to really understand any user experience with it. But anyway, I think the follow-on deals are super powerful. We're already seeing that play out. speaker-0: The user experience like from our perspective it's like I just can always come back to education. Like I think what they value the most, like not only sell me a thing, and even if it's a really good thing, ⁓ sell me the best ⁓ in the markets kind of, but a lot about like okay This is maybe how a longer journey will look like. This is how the market is steering at the moment. Hey, these are new pathways. You're looking at biocha. Look, this and this is also upcoming. Maybe at a certain point they are ⁓ competitive in pricing and this and this is happening. And here's maybe some policy change that will drive prices up, prices down, and so on and so forth. And do this for free. Because in the past they were always used to pay for their consultancies and really often the brokers have also be consultants. So they had a consulting project. So I just talked to an a another a prospect and he's like, you know, my my consultant, I asked him, I also need credits on the spot. And then he offered me these and these credits. And then I was like, but how did you do due diligence? And he said that yeah, but it's just under gold standard and there. So I think this is what they were used to in the past. that basically the consultant is also the broker and maybe even is the I don't know, ⁓ couple accounting partner and so on and so forth. and I think this changed a lot ⁓ over the last one two two years. speaker-2: Yeah. The biggest thing we've seen changed in that relationship of broker is seems like a lot more companies now are wanting to have a partner help them build a portfolio. And so there are a number of deal. We started off in the market five years ago thinking we need a direct to buyer experience and every deal for us is going to be direct, directly contracted with the buyer. maybe for spot transactions that future spot market, if you'll come in spot deals, maybe that's a spot that will use, you brokers or, you know, some site to list and we don't need to know every buyer and so on. But, you know, we at least thought that we would be designing most stakes directly. But what we're seeing is that, again, a lot of these companies are, they want a portfolio. They don't have the expertise or skill or time themselves to build a portfolio. and so they're working with an intermediary to kind of broker that relationship and build a portfolio. And so we've, we've really redirected a lot of resources now towards building up these partnerships with intermediaries because we're seeing just how important that, that role is that they're playing for. For an end buyer. So it's quite interesting to see that evolve. Yeah. Our very first, ⁓ you know, we, we, the first credits that we issued were in the hands rock weathering credits and those to bank capital. or sorry, Bain and Company, but Bain through Rubicon Carbon. so our very first deal ever was that we're trying to, was actually through a broker as well. again, but then Bain you saw just recently participated in our reforestation sale. they bought enhanced rock-riding credits that brought them in, then they converted and became a customer on the, the Horstry project as well. So I think again, this, sort of momentum building and relationship building with the buyers is really playing out. speaker-1: Okay. speaker-0: Also like what I always say, like I don't mind if a company buy directly, even if I made an intro before. Because if they don't value what we're bringing, then why should I be I think like a a gate ⁓ keeper? I I think that's old market mentality I call it. ⁓ whereas in a new market, if there's no value for my business model, then there's no right for me anyways. And I think we bring the value about that portfolio building and maybe also the reporting and so on. It's quite easy through the platform and helping them on the due diligence part and so on. But if a company has all these capabilities in house, then I don't need it. That's the reason I or I don't need to be there. Then that's the reason also like there's some companies where realized, okay, there will never be a customer of ours. I don't think I will ever work with Microsoft that that doesn't really make sense from our perspective. There are quite a lot of big companies also that just say, like, hey, I don't have the in house capabilities. That's the reason I still work with someone like you. But there are other companies that just have a big team in-house. And why would they if they have the co com ⁓ the the knowledge and competence. So I really often think that. So same with your example. I think it makes a lot of sense and I Really, really think if a if a broker or an intermediate doesn't bring any kind of value, I really don't mind if they walk over me, even though it sounds weird, but speaker-2: Yeah, no. Well, thank you. I appreciate that. You know, obviously for a project developer, we never know how these projects are going to evolve and how the relationships are going to evolve. a first transaction plays a very different role from them being catalytic in a much bigger deal that I need to sign. could have very different characteristics. not need an intermediary in the same way that a first deal did where the person was looking for some combination of a portfolio to dip their toes in. so it'd be weird for an intermediary to stick in in those second kinds of deals where somebody's really doubling down on the supplier that they really like. So your perspective is not the same though, as all the intermediaries, as I'm sure you know, right? Some of them do still want that old market approach. You know, I saw I saw this first, therefore I ought to get a cut of everything that the project does or everything that's productive for the market. speaker-0: But let's get into the news part of the the show. And first thing is about a name that you hear a lot, which is Microsoft. I mean, ⁓ what newsweek would there be in carbon markets without Microsoft? but it's a it's a good one actually that they are active again on the market and assign an off take around a little bit more than twenty three thousand of crude carbon. It's actually wastewater based carbon. removal, which is quite s something novel, right? I mean I in Germany I think I would ask someone, or like in Europe I think I would ask a buyer and they would be like, and what? But ⁓ we actually just checked and they're already bigger than than a European buyer at least would would think. Because yeah, I see in front here I see at least on their page they have a lot of ⁓ speaker-1: That they are Here. speaker-0: Logos here already, there's Shopify, Autodesk, HM Crew, Salesforce, Workday, JP Morgan Chase. But you see, it's definitely a a US base. ⁓ I mean you have HM, but but that's it. I don't know. Already looked in this. speaker-2: I think it was through the Frontier deal. They may have also done a few separate deals beyond Frontier, but it's great to see that Frontier did a deal with them two years ago and then now there's a follow-on deal with Microsoft is exciting because I think that's something that a lot of the suppliers who have worked with Frontier where they're really trying to be the first catalytic offtake, that's the hope that they can then find another follow-on offtake. So it's great to see. this that happened in, in, in Cruz case. Yeah, this is a really interesting pathway in my mind because the infrastructure for wastewater treatment already exists is extremely advanced and highly monitored as well. And so if you're going to inject a new stream of some alkaline source into wastewater, again, you've already, you've already got the upstream and downstream monitoring because you're doing that monitoring for other things. And so the MRV costs can be extremely low. And essentially your costs are how do I retrofit the addition of this new feedstock into the process? How do I make sure that that's safe? How do I, maybe there's a little bit of additional monitoring, but I think I would imagine most of this is how do I move the rock or whatever feedstock I'm using and then mix it into the water? which is just huge from a cost advantage and also from a scale advantage because obviously we have wastewater treatment plants all over the world. And in general, they produce a fairly similar stream of wastewater from a quality and it can be fairly consistent in terms of what their input sources are. And so I'm excited about this approach. You see like run, ⁓ look at alkalinity enhancement in rivers, which is a similar carbon removal approach. but just in a different place where you're trying to find more acidic rivers and then add alkalinity, some alkalinity source to them to try to deacidify them. And then obviously people are working on this in the oceans as well. But I just really like that intersection of wastewater because again, I think it's already highly engineered and highly monitored today and just more consistent in terms of its throughput. And that's a lot of the stuff that you sort of struggle with in nature. as you try to wrangle these projects into a natural landscape. So I think the fact that the deal just got announced with Microsoft too is great news. It's good to see. ⁓ Microsoft's had a few deals that have kind of trickled across the finish line here. So it's not clear if they're actually back in it doing new deals or if this is just ⁓ a deal that already got approved many months ago and is just now being announced. My guess is that it's the latter, but I don't have any reason to believe that. It just seems like we're seeing a kind of trickle of deals that may have originated quite some time. speaker-0: So I actually also checked they the off tech agreement was thirty two point one million dollars with Frontier. And Isometric issues the credit, the first credit in May twenty twenty five. So it's already going for a bit. But then yeah, also in the last Frontier update it just talked a lot about the potential ⁓ of of this but also ocean alkalinity enhancement, right? Because like with all kind of biomass things, you're just limited at a certain point. And we see that already, ⁓ now coming up, there's also a lot of competition for the biomass. And it will only get bigger the competition. I mean, maybe in the global south, ⁓ it's not as pressing yet, but we already see it in Europe and even in the US and certain parts, that the competition for biomass is is stacking up and I think here you have just a different kind of I'll say scale potential if you get it right. speaker-2: Yeah, I think that's definitely true. You have a huge concentration too of, in fine places where you have feedstocks nearby that you can use, and those are close to large cities, then you have a kind of a perfect match because you know you're going to have a massive amount of wastewater processed year round that needs to be ⁓ deacidified and that you're going to transport the material fairly cheaply because it's over a short distance. If you look at a river system, if you tried to do this in the Amazon River, well, the Amazon River, even though it's a massive river, it still goes up and in water level all throughout the year. And you have a good rainfall or a bad rainfall year. Well, that's not the case for an industrial processing of wastewater. You're going to basically have the same amount of wastewater all throughout the year, every year, no matter what is happening to the climate. again, that's quite an exciting opportunity. those frontier credits, think the price was probably like $450 a ton for the first credits that they sold. But again, my guess is that, you know, there's a lot of first of it, first time setup costs associated with that price. certainly has the potential to, to scale much faster, even than where I would say enhanced rock weathering is today, where the fundamentals of the project, when you add up the cost of the MRV and the soil sampling and the feedstock and logistics and transportation and spreading and so on. Yeah, theoretically something like Crew's approach just has a much lower capital stack cost structure requirement ⁓ than an enhanced rock weathering project would. speaker-0: It's quite interesting on this last update on the frontier purchasing cycle. They said, hey, the gigaton scale portfolio is coming into focus and they make some some price forecasts for the future. And they're okay, they they don't have wastewater agreement, but they have ocean accolinity and then seventy to two hundred dollars. I mean that's a big span, but ⁓ I mean it's it's an interesting one for the future unless you scale over ten gigatons. It's quite interesting. But then for enhanced rock weathering, ⁓ seventy-five to two hours. So almost the same, but as you just mentioned, I think it's gonna be harder to achieve it. Yeah. than than the other way around. But also they say I mean enhanced rock weathering potential scale around one to two gigaton. So ⁓ I think it's it's probably bigger in my opinion, but it's a different topic. But you see what what they how they look at speaker-2: I think seems like an area that they are doubling down on and seeing Microsoft do that now as well is certainly positive news for that type of pathway. speaker-1: Yeah. speaker-0: And well a name that I actually on a carbon credit is at all, which is PayPal. ⁓ everyone knows it. And I think I also talked to them a couple of times, but in my opinion never the right person because obviously in bigger companies you have a lot of people that talk about sustainability and at zero is ⁓ so I was quite surprised when I saw that they actually now got active. They have a two fourteen at zero target. speaker-1: No. speaker-0: And now they have made a first purchase for Biochurn backs ⁓ via Free Decrease. I think Free Decrease is really coming from or is in the market for quite a long while. doing like brokering and other things and like across all sorts of assets, right? I think when I raised my first round ⁓ with Zang, like one of our investors was like, Hey, my friend, he runs this company and do you wanna talk and it never came to it but it was speaker-1: Yeah. speaker-0: ⁓ the CEO three decrees. and then I looked at it and I was like, you're a big pla like they're doing a lot of things, all sorts of commodities and so on. So it's always a good sign, I would say in my opinion, if if someone ⁓ comes to the market, even though they're competition, but I think they're really focused on in the US, we're not really ⁓ so it's fine for me. ⁓ but yeah, I think it's always good to have have new names on the market. speaker-2: Yeah, I completely agree. PayPal plays this out. You know, there are a few of these other groups like you can even lump Salesforce and Amazon and other kind of marketplaces or transaction platforms, Shopify that are kind of offering credits to their networks or through transactions that they're brokering. Right. You can sort of participate in these people's Stripe, August, well, yeah, exactly. So that, you know, I will say I'm not often to click that button in my own transactions, but it seems like a lot of people are opting to do that. ⁓ And we're seeing obviously with airlines and others kind of that direct to consumer experience. speaker-0: got an airline. I found it really interesting, at least in Europe. It's around three percent clicking that button. And that stacks up, right? I thought it's way less. I think in the US it's it's it's one percent. ⁓ or at least I I made that research like a year and a half ago or something like that. And obviously we also work with ⁓ with some airlines. We don't get insights from there, but I just get a feeling ⁓ that there is that there is volume, right? ⁓ No funny fact, on Stripe we started this called Zenken checkout for like very small customers because they always asked us like, Hey, can I buy a hundred tons of a portfolio? And I said, Well, sorry, our product's just not made for you. So we created this checkout function, which has been adopted quite well. But we used Stripe and then they texted me and probably we said so in climate, like, Hey, do you wanna integrate? our ⁓ climate or removal checkout function. And I was like speaker-1: Yeah. speaker-2: You could double up, you having it while you're checking out to buy your portfolio of carbon credits, you could double, you know, use that transaction to also. speaker-1: Buy from stripes, yeah. speaker-2: But now PayPal is the name that I have. We certainly haven't seen that at any events or conferences or speaking about their portfolio in the past. I agree. think this is a great, it's a great name. It's another one of these opportunities for more consumers to interact with, ⁓ with carbon credits. And, and so I see it as a really positive sign. speaker-0: also see artisanal biochem project in India, I think Carbone is and there's Varama. And then there's a BEX project in North Dakota, I actually also think and I know like it's some of the the bigger projects out there. So then I think for me, I'm not sure if if when you took to bias, but the next one around ⁓ ICBCM is for me actually a big topic at the moment, ⁓ especially over the last months because We see that they cleared three more registries, ⁓ which which is great. ⁓ Biocarbon, Sakabono and Plan Vivo. In our customer RFPs we see more and more that they're not even mentioning, hey, we ⁓ okay to buy from these and these registries. They're basically just reference I C V C ⁓ Maybe not yet the methodologies, ⁓ because not everything went through yet. But they say only from these registries and sometimes there's some even say only CCP approved methodologies as well. But most just say don't offer anything that has been excluded already. so so that's something we see. And we actually saw ⁓ projects from SAC Carbono, which are on Echo Registry, right? ⁓ and and we there was a really close relationship with them, like for instance. The managing director, I visited some projects in Senegal and so on back in the day. So like we met there first time ever. He speaks German, it's funny. ⁓ and he studied in Germany. But ⁓ it's it's great to see them on here as well because there's a lot of South American credits on on Sarcabono. I'm curious how the methodologies actually will then rank. I don't have too much ⁓ insight on that, but I can imagine that they will have to up some of the methodologies. And I'm not sure if they're already on it. I'm not sure if you know anything more about it. But it's definitely like ICVCM is a big thing for us. speaker-2: Yeah, it's a huge thing for us too. mean, we, you know, we made the transition actually from Vera to Isometric ⁓ for our reforestation projects. Our ERWs are also issuing credits on Isometric. at the moment where all of our projects are registered on Isometric. ⁓ But, you know, as I said before, I worked with Vera on VM42 and then had also worked with them when they were launching VM47 because it was the same. methodology team that wrote VM 47 that had written VM 42. So, Mombach had the opportunity to actually participate in some of the development of VM 47 and try to think about how this new performance benchmark based approach would work. And then VM 47 was the first of the forestry methodologies to get CCP approval. And we had a lot of buyers basically say, if you guys are going to consider a transition, you need to wait until the methodology has been CCP approved just so you're sort of transitioning to a like for like, you know, from, one methodology to another. And I think we see that in RFPs now all the time as well, but they just basically say CCP approved methodology. Yeah. It'll be interesting to see how this proliferation of registries and comparisons between some of the different methodologies. Clearly when VM 47 came out, Etric and ⁓ Equitable Earth both borrowed heavily from what they saw in that methodology to build their own. And then we're seeing continued revisions and upscaling as the technology improves as well in all these different approaches. I think for the betterment of the quality of the projects as well, we definitely see the isometric methodology as being far more rigorous. There are a bunch of reasons that it kind of goes way beyond what's required of a project developer and makes it more challenging to issue credits and. reduces the number of credits that actually can be issued by most projects as a result of that. But yeah, CCP approval, it'll be really hard for any methodology or any registry to do any transactions if they don't meet that minimum bar. speaker-0: Very hard. And I mean these massive price differences as well, right? There's a like I think there's a really interesting time on the market where let's talk about ARR especially, where if you have ARR credits from old ⁓ methodologies and then VM forty seven ⁓ or isometric, it's like a massive price difference. And some of the buyers are really shocked by it. They're like, what it's the same project, and then you have to go on the deeper and explain. Obviously if they're RFP is already saying only to CCP that they know when you compare apples with apples, but it is quite interesting to longer term market really often they're like, but this is also an ARR credit. This is also an AR credit. Why do I pay 15 here but like 40 here? It's like that makes no sense. I was like, well, it's not the same credit. And that I found really interesting. And then f I think for ARR. It's a bit more straightforward, but what I find really interesting is IFM improved forest management because the methodologies are so different. And I'm really curious how ICCM and in the CCP label will yeah, measure apples with how do you say in English English, apples with oranges? Yeah, in Germany apple with pears. speaker-2: Yeah, the one that's going to be interesting from my perspective is the red credits, The avoided deforestation credits, because in that one, you just see such a disparity of quality and of number of credits that a project can issue based on how you set that baseline. And so there are a few new methodologies in the works from a couple of different registries right now to actually create a high quality red. ⁓ credit or maybe they're going to rebrand it to something other than red, but the same concept. That I think could really bring some, you know, it's just a new wave of purchasing to the market where if you actually had a quality credit that could be trustworthy, but was from a deforestation avoidance project, a project like ours could certainly benefit from that as well. So we'll see where that. speaker-1: Okay. speaker-0: I think it very interesting, but we will hear more of C C P right. I'm very curious and also it we see obviously that through this a lot of or like most of the renewable energy projects are really out because still I think a lot of buying was happening in that space. And also quite some some Cookstoff projects are out and also some red and so on. So it's already interesting what it does to the market and and will do so in the future as well. Alright. And let's get to something that you probably have a lot to to say about. But I look the EU ETS revision came out right and you know and they were already talking for a long time. How can we implement carbon removal, CDR, durable removal to the EU ETS in its next phase, which is two thousand thirty one. And they came out and said like hey, we're gonna implement bags. speaker-1: Yeah. speaker-0: And in a certain kind of way where they have extra allowances, where they create an extra budget and then they're gonna purchase these credits. They also had an opinion on ⁓ enhanced rock weathering in biochem. And biochar that said it depends, basically like a consultant, but it won't be integrated. And then for enhanced rock weathering, they were talking a lot about the MRV not being yet at the technological readiness level, that they would feel comfortable to include it as a permanent removal. And I found it in tr in general interesting that conversation because DAX and BACs obviously very high price point and it can only be European projects, right? So for DAC mm because of the energy, like almost every location falls out. Maybe have Norway, Iceland. And then for backs, you there's more potential, but they have to buy a lot of credits. Like they I think they're gonna get the budget from 250 million allowances. And it'd say that hundred Euros is a big number. And I'm not sure if there even will be enough capacity from decks and bags. So then will need to be some ⁓ biomass storage and enhanced rock weathering. ⁓ but yeah, you what what's your perspective on the rock solid MRV is speaker-2: Yeah, I think we're in this unique moment in Enhanced Rock Weathering projects right now where the first set of projects have just started issuing credits within the last year. And most of those issuances have been very small. So essentially, most people have just been using this as an opportunity to say, do we actually even have working MRV? And even if we have big discounts on the uncertainties and so on. Can we generate a credit or 10, 20, a hundred credits, whatever the number is, in order to have a first proof point to buyers and investors and then pave the way for scaling. So we've not yet seen much scale being generated. And I think a lot of that is because there just are a lot of uncertainties still. And there are a lot of different methods for MRV. You can base things just on soil sampling. You can use water-based sampling as well. Isometric registry uses some of the water-based sampling as a way to validate the soil sampling. Now it looks like they're going to drop that in the next iteration of the methodologies and just allow for soil-based sampling, which could streamline things, even if with slightly higher uncertainties. ⁓ But also, you know, the dynamics of rock weathering and the models of where does that ⁓ weathered rock actually go and how quickly does the product go into the river and into the ocean and does it get trapped in places? Or if I have this condition or that condition of happening on my soil or in my river or in my ocean, does that disturb things? There's still a lot of work being done to resolve those mechanics. And so a lot of people are kind of waiting on the sidelines. But I will say that a lot of the big buyers, I mean, we're, as you said, right, Frontier was very bullish on weathering, but it They seem to focus more heavily on ocean weathering and not as much time in that piece on enhanced rock weathering. And I think that's because they're waiting for a lot of these early experiments to come back from their first set of projects that they've invested in before they figure out if this is something that they're really going to double down on. The data though do seem to be positive. know, conferences in this space, it seems more consensus that yes, rock is really weathering and yes, We can measure it indirectly, albeit, ⁓ but we can see what's happening and we believe that that is closely tied to the actual carbon removal process. So I think we'll get there. And I think the EETS will allow ERW as a result of that because it is a scalable method. People are doing this in Europe and obviously in other geography. think we'll get there. think the industry will get there. There may be a few product developers who sort of fall by the wayside in this. In this transition, we've already seen a few Enhanced Rock Weathering projects get higher or lower. speaker-0: tough if you're VC funded probably in that space, right? If this is your sole I would say revenue stream pound. That's the reason I think companies like yours are are well set up or if you start joint ventures, I saw that ⁓ this German company, Zero X, start a joint venture with Anglo American. ⁓ isn't it also in prison? I know and and why and I think this is a better way to set this up because there's uncertainty on the time perspective, right? I think everyone is s is kind of clear that it or like that it works, you just have to prove how. It's you don't know the the time scale. speaker-2: Yeah, I think from our perspective, this idea of, okay, forestry credits are here today, we can issue them today, we can be first movers in these new methodologies. At the same time, we can be experimenting with and exploring some of these other pathways that definitely will scale. And also on the cost side, right? Forestry projects are not cheap and we don't know what the cost curve is gonna look like of things like enhanced rock weathering or other project types. ultimately, we look... Five years out and we see some convergence of, forestry projects seem to be getting a bit more expensive, but at the same time, I can get to a hundred dollars or 70 to a hundred dollar credit from one of these durable methods, that's going to have a lot of demand for it. Of course, we still have tens of millions of hectares of land that needs to be reforested. So the co-benefits associated with reforestation, we may just shift and countries will start investing in the water benefits or the... biodiversity benefits or other things, but those projects are still going to be needed. But I think that this question of where do price points converge and what's the impact on projects is going to be really interesting to see. speaker-0: Alright, then I think this is ⁓ the news part. Fantastic. speaker-1: I speaker-0: I think this was ⁓ great. I enjoyed a lot to have here. And let's see if we can pull off another one. speaker-2: Sounds great. ⁓ I'll bring one of my opera outfits to the next one and expect to start the intro with some song. So maybe you can do a little runway walk or something for us too, just to kick off the next show. speaker-0: Force me. Don't force me to speaker-1: I'm like. speaker-0: That sounds sounds like a plan though. ⁓ thanks so much. Yeah, follow us on the on the socials, LinkedIn especially. So yeah, follow us and yeah, then you see the next episode airing at a certain point. See ya guys. Bye bye.