Latest / Building Real / Turning Bali's Garbage Crisis Into Nutrient-Dense Soil in 24 Hours | Tobias Wilson
Transcript
- Tobias - Shiva: I guess what I'd thought for my whole life was that waste disappears. You know, and inorganics, organics, you name it, right? it just I put it in my bin and then legends come and pick it up and it goes to a place where they They look after it and they they sort it out. And and they don't. Arjun Thomas: Tobias, thank you and good morning. you've had an early start today you mentioned at four o'clock in the morning. maybe let's let let's r let's let's remind us, at least remind me why you had an early start today. Tobias - Shiva: look mate that you know like it's being being the new kid in the room you know is something that I haven't been in that position for a very long time you know a 20-year career you know it it's kind of you s you get to that a bit groundhog day you know being there done that gotta go through the motions again today and at but being new to this space you know relatively new under the last three years has you know, there's so much to learn. There's always something to do, there's always something to know about, there's always you know always something especially with our technology and and that can be the physical technology, that can be the software, that can be the bioware, you know. So and so yeah, it was one of those things I I I I I woke up and I was like, I need to look into that. and I was, you know, just four o'clock so off we go. I'm not glorifying 4am, so you know I'm not I'm not out there saying, you know, the grind and the hustle and all of that. I'm not. I'll probably have a nap today, so you know, just to be make that very clear. But yeah, it was just one of those things that it's it's a a it's been a real source of motivation actually and and not motivation that I didn't think I had before, you know, before doing before you know, do doing the work that we're doing with Sheba. Arjun Thomas: So so maybe this is a good time to talk about Shiva because there is a cliche somewhere about an Aussie bloke landing up in Indonesia or Bali more specifically. so let's maybe dispel those notions about there's more to that story and I'd love to kinda get into how you landed up in Bali and what Shiva Industries is all about and and why you are energized to wake up at four o'clock in the morning when most people are just waiting for that extra couple of hours to kind of just No, let me just stay in bed for a little bit longer. So maybe start there. What's an Aussie bloke doing in Australia in Bali? Tobias - Shiva: Yeah, look, this this has come up more often than than I can count now. And sadly I am the cliche. Arjun Thomas: Okay. Tobias - Shiva: so you know, the the corporate career, burnout, health issues, midlife crisis, call it whatever you want, right? I need to get out of here. And and thankfully my wife was was was aligned to that, you know. So and and so we left we we left Singapore in twenty twenty three, early twenty twenty three, February, for something new. And and when we got to Bali we got a one year lease and we we just won't we didn't have any plans. It was just, you know, let's reconnect as a family. I needed to repair and and you know, fix myself, put myself back together. And yeah, that was really it. I wrote some kids' books and you know I I Played around the garden and you know, I I was doing drop offs and pickups and you know after school activities with the kids, which I hadn't been able to do before. and and that was that was really it. It was we don't know what we're gonna do, we don't know what we need yet, but we know that we don't want this, which was the life that we left behind. So I knew the before we left Singapore I'd already signed up for let Sungai Watch and things like that and start doing rural cleanups and and and beach cleanups and stuff. And I knew that waste was an area that Bali needed help in. And and and I'd I'd never minded getting my hands dirty. I I grew up in Beniger. so you know like is the farm work is dirty work. So it was it was the combination of leaving behind the old and having an idea just as a vocation, what I wanted to put some spare time into and and put some energy into. And and that's really where it all started, mate. it it started with beach cleanups and things like that and just doing cleanups with my kids. And then it evolved with, you know, from there. Arjun Thomas: Right. And do you think because for for different people taking a break means different things. and and was it a conscious decision to go back to the outside? Is that is do you trace that back to your roots, wanting to break away from a four boxed enclosure that l a lot of us in corporate lives grow up with, and and be connected to something physical and tangible? Was that the motivation, regardless of what that what form that took? Tobias - Shiva: Yeah, look, I I think COVID obviously is a great accelerant for that, right? especially in Singapore and Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Tobias - Shiva: being locked in an apartment with a with a a a decent family. I've got three kids. So yeah, and I remember at the time saying, I just want some horizon, you know, like I just want to be able be and see the horizon and and have access to the horizon, you know. so not this ten by ten box. So yeah, it was it was very much a conscious decision. And as we just started to come towards the epiphany of we need to leave or we want to leave, yeah, we looked around. you know, my wife's from the UK and her parents are Vietnamese, so you know, so we looked at both London and we looked at Vietnam. We looked at Australia, obviously, with me being Australian and And it just felt like we they were all big city options. and and don't get me wrong, London is more than just a city, or the UK is more than just London. and and Vietnam is is more than Ho Chi Minh or Hanoi or whatever, and and Australia certainly. but it Bali came up and and you know it's one of those pipe dreams, I think, you know, and and it's funny, I found a Facebook post from 15 years ago, and it was we we had been to Bali and Then somebody's like, that's awesome, you know. and I'd written life plan, move to Bali. You know. So I guess maybe there was some sub you know, my subconscious knew it was gonna happen at some point. But it was a pipe dream and he thought, could we make it work? And and you know, we we decided to go for it. That was yeah, that was that was really it. I think the the waste and getting into the whole nature side of things here probably was, you know, from my upbringing and and wanting to just do some good after being you know in in corporate and in city cities for twenty years. I wanted to just give back a little bit. and and as I've I I think I've said this before, but you know, in in other other podcasts and interviews, but you know, break a sweat for somebody else. which is Arjun Thomas: Mm. Tobias - Shiva: actually the advice that I give to everybody that calls me up and they're like, I need to get out of corporate. You did it. What where did you start? I don't know what to do. I don't know, you know how to pivot. And like go and break a sweat for somebody else. Cause it's it's incredible what That time does to you. You know, when you are working, you are physically working, not just sitting at a desk, you're breaking a sweat, but it's not for the benefit of you. And I think in in corporate and largely the you know, the the capitalist system, and it is you, you, you, me, me, me, my, my, my. So, you know, it's all just it's it's it's driven that way about your success and your growth and your, you know. so it was it's it's really nice to be sitting there doing something manual, physical and obviously all of the the the the endorphins and serotonin and all those the dopamine and things like that that that happens during physical exercise, but but also p to be doing that for somebody else. somebody else's benefit. It it's it's amazing what happens to your brain. And I I can't explain it. I'm not a neurologist, but that it it's that's when those epiphanies tend to come through. That's when that for me in particular, when I had that quiet time, I was able to really, I guess, tune into me and and what motivated me and Arjun Thomas: And maybe from an outsider looking in, you've got in a way an alignment of stars, ev even though that maybe sound again sounds very cliched, which is tracing back to your roots of being in the field, working with your hands, the the the need to want to give back the the fact that you want to spend time with the family, the the the fact that you want to spend time outdoors. it all lined up with I guess started with beach cleaning and then as part of the process what did you discover about about the the world that we live in. And and which which kind of took you down this rabbit hole over three or three or four year period. if you can just unpack that journey for us. as consumers, as most of us on this c podcast probably listening and ask more consumers than give us back. it'll be good to kind of understand what you discovered down that rabbit hole. Tobias - Shiva: Mm. I mean as eloquently as I can put it, I think we don't have our shit together. That's what I discovered. and and Arjun Thomas: Ha ha Tobias - Shiva: and specifically, you know, I I think i around waste in particular. And no country has this nailed yet. And what I was cleaning up was obviously the the downstream effects of of of that of us not having our shit together. And once again, this is not a a bar just a Bali problem or an Indonesia problem or a Southeast Asia problem. This is a global problem. And and I guess what I'd thought for my whole life was that waste disappears. You know, and inorganics, organics, you name it, right? it just I put it in my bin and then legends come and pick it up and it goes to a place where they They look after it and they they sort it out. And and they don't. And the fact is that they don't know what to do with it. And we're still trying things, carbonization or waste to energy and pyrolysis and anaerobic digestion, etc. And and so obviously the majority of what you pick up on the on the beaches, you know, is what you see and what you feel is the plastics. But and so I thought, you know what, I'm gonna come up. I'm gonna, you know, come up with some way to export plastics. And I connected with the plastics community and the sustainability community. And that was really where it started to gain momentum when I went from being me breaking a sweat in a river somewhere to connecting with this community and really, you know, learning, being the new guy in the room and finding out what all these cool technologies were and these cool people and these, you know, and it was it the opportunities were just were mind blowing and with other people making furniture or homewares or anything like this, you know, it's it was super cool for me. And I thought that's it. I'm gonna design stuff and and and from waste and export waste. How cool. You know, we're gonna create this Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: waste and I'm gonna export it. It's gonna be a net positive for everybody and you know what it what a joyous circle. What the trigger point for me though was pushing a little bit further into other waste streams. So construction waste And then starting to analyze the broader waste stream and and realizing that organics were the the large majority. and it's you know, seventy two percent here in Bali, it's about sixty four percent in Indonesia wide. And and so and Arjun Thomas: So sorry, sorry, I turbitch. I don't I w I wanna interrupt you there. Just for me to get a sense of the the switch in thinking, because the way you kind of articulated that story, which is you've identified a problem, you know, how cool we can take waste, convert it using design into something that I can export. Why didn't you stop there? I'm curious about that. Why did you go further and and and explore the bigger problem around waste? I'm curious about that. Okay, okay. Tobias - Shiva: Clumsily, in a word, you know, stumbled stumbled and fell my way around events and meeting rooms and coffees and stuff. But look the the plastics side I felt was reasonably well serviced here. And Arjun Thomas: Okay. All right. Tobias - Shiva: and I don't have the numbers ahead in front of me, but the investment that's gone into plastics and or inorganic recycling Arjun Thomas: Plastics globally, yeah. Tobias - Shiva: in the past sort of fifteen to twenty years is is compared to organics is is you know, a hundred X different. so it's well funded. It could be better funded. It's well serviced, could always be better serviced, obviously. We're not there yet anywhere. And and so I didn't see that much green field and I wasn't really drawn to to it. and and when I started to, you know, just by chance meet other people who were talking with different waste streams and then I I I sort of took the blinkers off around just plastics and I and I was like, hang on. And that's when I noticed this mountain of organics. and and so then I started to explore organics. And and look, I'm like most people who who watch this, I I would expect do not know, and I did not, know the the the harmful effects of or mismanaged organic waste. Arjun Thomas: Most I would surpr I would would assume wouldn't know. because you'd assume Tobias - Shiva: Yeah. Arjun Thomas: organics in the in the in the bin, in the earth, done, right? but th there's Tobias - Shiva: Right. Arjun Thomas: more to that, right? Tobias - Shiva: Yeah, yeah, exactly. So so and and back in the day, you know, a a hundred years ago, yeah, absolutely our organics were super manageable. but with eight billion of us, i it it's not. And and the analogy I use all the time i is kind of like that one banana, you throw one banana in in the in the soil next to your house and it's fine, you know, that the banana skin i it it's fine, it'll it'll be gone in three, six, nine months and You throw a million banana pills there and you're have a major problem. and you know, one of those, which is I think is fairly well documented, is is methane. So globally our food waste produces two point six times the amount of greenhouse gases than the entire airline industry. So that's one of those big stats for me that I I can't let go of. Arjun Thomas: Mm. Tobias - Shiva: it's it it's mind blowing to me that the we're all you know pushed towards you know, we should offset our flights and the carbon and you know, it's just it's terrible and you shouldn't fly and and all of this sort of jazz. But then we're happy to mix our waste and create something that's, you know, having a a a two point six X effect over the airline industry. So so that was what that was definitely one of those those factors that sort of helped push. and then and then it came down to really looking at the solutions, you know, like what solutions exist here, what solutions exist near shore and then and then offshore. and and then shortlisting a a number of different technologies and Arjun Thomas: And so so you've so you so focus shifted away from plastics, which like you said is well funded, well understood, and probably the thing that most of us associate with with polluting the planet because we've it's in it's in all media, it's stuff on the beach. You rarely see a banana peel floating up on on the beach, right? So it's not the first thing that pops into your mind in terms of efficiencies around waste recycling. So now your focus moves to kind of organics. and you go down that rabbit hole, you understand the impact of the plant. what did you understand about the landscape of how that problem is being addressed today? what are the solutions today that go after the organics problem? And w how what gap did you notice i in how it's being pro handled today? Tobias - Shiva: Well, I I think largely the the solutions for organics right now, Renewal processing, you know. composting Arjun Thomas: Dump in the landfill and that's it. Tobias - Shiva: and things like that. So, you know, I think we're we're starting to see more work around black soldier fly larvae, so maggots that process food waste and then obviously in turn create a protein source and a frass, so you know, sort of kind of a fertilizer product. vermi composting has been around forever, and but we're seeing a bit of a resurgence in that, which is great. but large scale, you know, en masse. daily volume sort stuff which we're we're seeing in these urban areas and stuff, you know, those those cannot deal with that. because you just require way too much land and way too much time. And so Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: we don't have that land and we don't have that time, certainly close to these large, large city centres. And and if we do, then it's just it's it's massive transport fees. And and don't get me wrong, I mean I won't name any specific areas or governments, but on the whole globally, you know, we are moving our waste further and further away because we need bigger and bigger holes and Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Right. Tobias - Shiva: and that r is requiring more and more trucks and you know it's compounding the problem versus actually dealing with it properly. And so if I do look at large scale error sort of organic waste processing, yes, okay, you know carbonization, but even then the the efficiency has dropped massively. so the because of the the moisture content. of organics. So those large plants are are definitely more suited for inorganic waste. Higher kilojoules, therefore higher output, either carbon black or even waste to energy. You know, you you you you want to increase your yield as high as possible because that's what the investors paid for for the plant. So yeah, organics will not get you there. There are some specific threads around anaerobic digestion to create for organics in particular. But They're they're largely unused. I think the world is focused on the plastics and the inorganic side. And because you can return those things back to a a a fossil fuel, you can return them back to an oil and in it with some technologies, you can turn them into a fuel, you can turn that process and the steam, etc., into energy. but the the a lot of the systems yeah are focused on processing plastics. and the interesting thing there is is that the The number one reason why our plastic recycling rate is is so low globally. And is the number one reason is organic waste contamination. So, you Arjun Thomas: Mm, yeah. Tobias - Shiva: know, so so actually w and I think what we've proven over the last 15 or 20 years of really focusing on plastics and is we cannot recycle our way out of a contamination problem. Arjun Thomas: Mm. Tobias - Shiva: and that's the big that's the big one for me. That was that was the the sort of the like Actually, you can fix plastics by going after organics. And so when I looked at all these different technologies, a lot of them were focused on plastics still. and then also the scale, you know, and and and being realistic about where I was and where I am, you know, in Bali. A lot of these plants are a hundred ton a day plants. And getting a hundred tons per day of clean, sorted organics was unrealistic. So then we had to sort of pivot a little bit and and think about w what at what scale c can we get access to clean, sorted organics and and what sort of technology would align with that. And that's how we we ended on and we landed on aerobic digestion. Arjun Thomas: Okay. So I think we've so far danced around what it is Shiva actually does, which maybe it's a good good time to kind of dive into that. so I'm not gonna set the stage so that so I understand the context and the specific s stage that Shiva kind of inter intervenes at. One, you've identified that organics are a problem that you want to go after. Second, you've identified that contamination is a big big issue. So I'm guessing further up the consumption chain before contamination occurs is where you want to kind of kind of target the the the opportunity. And the third thing that I probably want to touch upon a little bit is the value of the byproduct because you said the reason why people go after plastics is because you know in some form you can reuse it for energy purposes. So I want to kind of get your perspective on the value of the output of processing organics and the way you think about that. So maybe it's a good time to kind of talk about what Shiva Industries actually does, what's the product that you built and where it fits in into this really complicated chaos Tobias - Shiva: Yeah, look, Shiva, Shiva has we've we've invented a very specific type of automated thermophilic aerobic digestion. And so so an effective look, it's a rapid composting system. So our machines process any organic matter and within 24 hours we'll create a really nutrient-dense digest state at the other end, which we've had third-party verified and all that sort of jazz. That that's that's effectively it. And look, aerobic digestion is not new. And in fact, it's it's been around since the dawn of time. It's what happens in nature. so aerobic digestion is with air, anaerobic digestion is without air, oxygen. And and so and that's what creates methanes. So so yeah, look, that was that was really we thought we were going to import the technology when we landed on aerobic digestion, we thought we were gonna import the technology, and it was a chance meeting. with a guy called Heath from America that came through Bali that that I I I found aerobic digestion. and so through his connections, he's a digester expert and now a shareholder in in Shiba. He helped us build our first prototype. yeah, we we thought we were just gonna rep his tech out of the US. and we just couldn't make the commercial side of that work. And it's a hard place to import things into. There would have been no maintenance, no service, and it was expensive. So so we ended up going down the path of building it ourselves, which has turned out to be a great decision in the end. But was as you would know, I mean, it's definitely the harder thing to do. so and and we're the only aerobic digestion company in in the country. So there isn't this pool of resources, there isn't this pool of talent, there isn't this precedent, there isn't anything. which was part of the reason that we went for it. Because it was, you know, like I said, you know, the the plastic space I felt was quite well served and well funded and and there wasn't enough green space. and and with this I obviously it was it was a clean slate. So so yeah, so we we started building our physical first physical prototype November twenty twenty-three. and we're now onto a version three of our technology. We have I think twenty-six machines. Sold now and we have machines installed on five islands of Indonesia and we're processing just under two point five million kilos a year through those machines. Arjun Thomas: the what you mentioned was it it turns any organic waste into compostable c well nutrient rich com compost at Tobias - Shiva: Digest that, you know. Arjun Thomas: the end di digestate in twenty four hours. Tobias - Shiva: Yeah. Arjun Thomas: how long does it take normally in nature for that process to happen? Tobias - Shiva: Yeah, so so aerobic digestion, like I said, is a natural process. It's heat, oxygen and microbes. And and that can look that depends on the heat, the oxygen, the moisture, the microbes, and as to how fast you you can get that done. And so if we go back to our banana peel, in in your backyard, it might be three months. In your neighbors, it might be six months. In their neighbors it might be nine months. And and that's That's the thing specifically with thermophilic microbes, which are the digesting microbes, it they require a a specific temperature range. so in nature, obviously sun comes up, sun goes down. So we have fluctuating heat. we have rain, so we have fluctuating moisture. We and oxygen, like I said. So, you know, that's where landfills run into a lot of problems is you know, 98% of the landfill is anaerobically digesting because there's this crust over the top. And so the crust is aerobically digesting, yes, but everything underneath is anaerobically digesting, which is obviously spewing methane out. so it really depends. And and so that's where the I guess the biomimicry part of the technology comes in, is what are the perfect microbes? What is the perfect Arjun Thomas: Mm. Tobias - Shiva: moisture content? What is the perfect temperature and the perfect amount of oxygen to to keep it in in aerobic? aerobically digesting. And then how do we recreate that and how do we, you know, drive that consistently inside of the inside of the chamber? So so that's it's it's taking what nature does and and accelerating it. Arjun Thomas: So it's a function of ensuring that you identify those optimal temperature, pressure, oxygen mix and then keeping that consistent so that it's it's always processing at all times. And that's what kind of allows you to kind of hyper compress the the natural timeline into something that ki is is is kind of twenty four hours, which which makes a lot of sense. so the output is just the digest aid. Is there anything else that comes off in it comes of greenhouse gases or just the digest aid? And how do How did you land on the strain of bac bacteria? Because I think that's a super important bit, right? So there must be a hell of a lot of trial and error to figure out, you know, which one, how long does it survive? If I make, you know, it's like a marathon runner, like if I if I get a sprinter and make them run for twenty kilometers, they're gonna die at some point. Are those considerations valid or not? Tobias - Shiva: Absolutely, absolutely. And and look, there are millions of microbes. So, you know, it's Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Tobias - Shiva: hyper technical. We we did through Heath, we had a bit of a cheat code. We had an advisory panel of six experts help us initially. And they helped us on the hardware, the software, and the bio. So we and I think two of them are still at large digester companies globally, across and some in the US, some in Europe. so we were able to work from a a short list, doing it from scratch is is virtually impossible. it would just take incredibly a l an army of incredibly smart people and I can't even fathom the budgets that you'd need to go from Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Tobias - Shiva: scratch. thankfully, you know, thermophilic microbes like volcanic areas and and being in Indonesia we're we're quite fortunate with some of those conditions. So you know it it it could have been a lot harder. But it still was it still was technical. And I'll give you an example. So in the in the early days of the prototype, we actually I remember rejoicing with our first 24-hour digestion. And I don't know what load it was, but it was in the hundreds. And and then when we did the lab analysis on the on the output, it it wasn't it it dropped quality. And so so we'd gotten there, but with the wrong mix of hardware, software, and bioware. And so we had to go back to the drawing board. And initially, obviously, because it's it's a it's a bit more straightforward, we went after the engineering and and the automation. but it turned out to be a a microbial issue. And so we we changed our microbes at that point and and started testing new strains and and that's when we got to that's where we got to our first. first proper batch. and and that's been a real focus. And maybe look, maybe that is going back to my my farming background. But the big shift here, mate, was It this is gonna be a big one, but the key issue with the the industry that is waste management is it it says it on the tin. We we manage waste. Arjun Thomas: Mm. Tobias - Shiva: And and that's never gonna lead to the right outcomes. so the big thing for us is we wanted to be focusing on resource recovery. So we're we're so good at extracting every sort of minutiae and fine detail of resource that we have value on out of the planet. and you know, we we we'll dig we'll dig a kilometer down into the ground to get some gold, right? Arjun Thomas: Yeah, if the incentive structures are aligned, yeah. Tobias - Shiva: yeah, because we're resource, we're mining for a resource. But you know, we're we're we're I think the World the World Health Organization just released a report and I think it's that five or six percent of our organics are being composted, you know, globally. it's a we've got a ninety-four percent loss rate on that resource, which, you know, if we look at soil health across the planet and which is plummeting and our ability to grow enough food for the eight billion of us, plummeting, not to mention issues like the Straits of Hormous and fertilizer and urea and blah blah blah. the there's yeah, we we're we're facing major challenges in in one of the core staples of life food. but we're so our soils are going broke and we're throwing out the gold. so so yes, re so I guess for us, we wanted to make sure that we were recovering the maximum amount of that resource that was locked into this this this waste waste stream. And so The digestate for us was incredibly important from the start. And that's where I think we differ from a lot of technologies in the market, if you look globally. a lot of the technologies sort of are masquerading as digesters, but really they're just big microwaves. they they're just dehydrators. And and that poses two issues. Obviously, you're getting a a sawdust-like output, which is junk. but the other side of that is is that things like you know, E. coli, salmon salmonella, and all that sort of jazz. Can actually become dormant in that sawdust. And so when you do put it back into the the earth and and try to recompost it and reintegrate it into the earth, you can release some of those pathogens and things like that as well. So Arjun Thomas: I didn't know that. Okay. Tobias - Shiva: so and and that's because it's it's a mechanical process, you know. So that's a bit of a watch out if you if you're looking at technology and there's no talk of microbes, no microbes in, no microbes out, you know. so it it's a mechanical process and that's where you have to be careful. Whereas our microbes will actually go after those bacteria. and so we find that even in our test machines, we collect waste from the region and from around our our our factory. And and look, some of it sits there for a little bit, you know, and it's it's it's it's not that great when it goes in the machine. and it stinks and it's full of maggots and and all of that. But within about an hour or so, the bacteria that has caused those smells, etc. they're gone and that smell is gone. And last week I was fortunate enough. I I went up to see Gian up at Mason Elephant Park. And we're doing a content series at the moment called Will It Digest and we're going finding weird and wonderful sources of waste and then Thank Arjun Thomas: very cool. Wow. Okay. Tobias - Shiva: you. Thank you. Yeah. So stay tuned. I'm not going to give away the episode, but Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: maybe maybe I'll have to to make the point. But I don't know Arjun Thomas: Ha ha ha. Tobias - Shiva: if we have this crossover of audience mate. It's it's okay. Arjun Thomas: sí. Tobias - Shiva: So the yeah, we got this elephant poop, which it's poop, I mean it stinks. and and yeah, the it was a 13-hour digestion. and the output was just this beautiful, humic, dark, you know, soil, you know, living, living soil. so So yeah, and look, God, we put everything through. I mean, I did a an episode, the first episode we did with Gary from Sungai Watch, and we went and cleaned a barrier. And, you know, I don't want to gross out the audience too much, but you know, there's a big duck in there, obviously all dead. a chicken, there was a big koi fish that had been in there a long time. some a rat, some human feces. but we put in some horrific stuff into the machine, and once again, just a really beautiful output. So and that's the difference. This is nature doing what nature does, you know. Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: so these microbes are put on the planet, I'm guessing, I don't know, the the grand plan, but you know, to break down things and to to put get them into a state which they can return return to the earth and and be of benefit to the to the cycle of the planet. Arjun Thomas: So I think You hit the nail on the head, at least for me as you kind of articulated that story, which is if you in v align the incentive structures so that you put value on the product you get at the end, the market moves to to kind of adopt it. And that's what you guys seem to have done, which is not managing waste but resource recovery. So the output is where the value really is. of course the process is important. maybe I'm trivializing the work that you guys have done. in putting that but but but the you've created something that actually has real value and and once that resource has a value there's naturally incentives aligned to to go after that price and I want to connect that back to the point that you made which is which is calibrating the quality of the output. So what do you look for in the output to to get a sense that yeah we got it right or we didn't get it right or it's off by X. so so so what are you looking for in the output to to t to differentiate a good versus a bad output? Tobias - Shiva: Good question. Look, I I'll keep it super simple. you obviously want to look at your carbon, organic carbon compound, so composition, because the soils need that. so I guess the goal that we're looking for is soil health or or or environmental health. so from a soil health perspective, we want to know the carbon nitrogen ratio and the organic carbon is present, which it is you know. and I Arjun Thomas: what are the rule of thumb, what those ratios need to be? I mean, I know b I know it's a little technical, but you know, it is interesting. like Tobias - Shiva: It it depends on the application, but ours sits at about forty six percent. So so it it's Arjun Thomas: Of what? Tobias - Shiva: very very high of of the of the output is is a forty six percent carbon nitrogen ratio. the microbial activity is incredibly important. and there's some specific families that you want in there, you're trichodermas and and basilis and stuff like that. but and that's But that is i that's what we're rebuilding in the soil and that's what chemicals destroy. so so i if there is no microbial content and there's no activity, you know, and so it's gonna be much harder. you probably know about mycelium networks and how they are the nerve centers and they can connect different plants and different different Arjun Thomas: Everything here. Tobias - Shiva: outputs or outcomes on above soil into reactions below soil. Same with microbial activity. And so that's what gives soil life. Yeah. Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: the other part is more is is basic. And so that's soil health. So we want to look at, you know, really microbial content and carbon, you know, and and are are they there and are they there in the right ratios? So that's soil health. But the other part is more around plant growth and plant health, and that's NPK, so nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium. And put simply. Nitrogen helps the plant above the soil, phosphor phosphorus helps plants below the soil, and and potassium helps the whole the the up entire ecosystem. so it's yeah, so that's the nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium. Now look, your I think in here in Indonesia, your organic fertilizers, I think the it's it's mandatory to be around a two, two, two maybe a three three three NPK ratio. some of your chemical fertilizers and or crop based like broad broad acre farming stuff can be a 10, 10, 10, 10, 15, 10, 20, 20, 20, etc. So depending on how hard you want to push that crop in a specific amount of time. and and and the difference in crops, you know, like a a broadleaf is very different to a nightshade variety of plants. So your nightshades are your you know chilies and tomatoes and eggplants and stuff. And your broadleaf is gonna be your wheats, rice, etc. so for us, I think we sit just below a two two two coming out of the machine. Swings around, obviously, you know, and I'm not saying this is a standardized fertilizer product. It's not. You know, it it depends on what goes into the machine. But on, you know, we're now approaching what 2.5 million tons a year capacity. The Western alone has had their machine for two years and and processed over 500,000 kilos. and so and now with machines across different hotels and schools and hospitals and things like that, we're starting to analyze data across many different feed stocks. there's Billions of permutations of that. So it's impossible to to really understand it fully. And but we're starting to get a grasp on it. Where is our sort of mean, I guess, across standard mixed food waste. Now, if you're talking about monofeeding, so if you just wanted to put coconut husks through or rice husks and things like that, you know, you're gonna you're gonna get a very you're gonna get a high carbon output. you're probably gonna get a low in PK, but what you would find to be high in silicon. which is quite useful, obviously. And I saw something recently about you know, the they're starting to use crushed glass in Australia and put that on onto crops as a a a silica input, which is interesting. so so yeah, if we just process banana waste it would be really high in potassium. If we process coffee waste, it would be really high in nitrogen. Chicken manure, similarly very high in nitrogen, but also with between chicken manure and coffee waste, we see high salinity. so we also need to track that and and and and have an idea about that. But yes, in in for us, it's how do we look at things in two two frames really, and they're they're harmonious. Soil health, what what do we need to rebuild healthy soils? and then also what do we need to do to it to increase yields? And we've done hundreds of tests now with across different different crops. but we've spent quite a lot of time with a group of farmers up in Singaraja and they grow largely California papaya and and they call our digestate Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: magic dirt. so you know it it's actually pretty wild to see the control beds versus the the Shiva plants. And so yeah we did we did another test in Mahlung earlier this year. With a biochar company, Terabaru, and we looked at different permutations of of our digestate as a base. We had a chemical fertilizer as a base, the the traditional one, I think it was sweet potato, the crop, or maybe sweet corn. and then we had their biochar on its own, and then we had different mixes. Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: the highest performing mix outperformed the chemical fertilizer by 18.8%. So and their their char is made from agricultural waste and our digester is made from food waste. So we can outperform chemical fertilizers with these, you know, these things that we now call waste and we now want to manage and get them away from us. It's this incredible resource that we absolutely do need do need as the as a species, to have healthy Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: soils to to grow to grow healthy food. And not look one final thing on that, because I don't want to wax on too much, but Healthy soils are so much more than just a a a food bed, right? healthy soils it it gives us healthy air. you know, and I think the way that we are not slowing down carbon emissions as as a species, and proven that over how many dozen cops that we've had now. we're not slowing it down. We keep pretending that we will, and we sign agreements that we will, but we don't. So we need to be looking at things to like carbon drawdown. We're clearly not going to slow down emitting. as as a species. So how do we do things on the other side to help pull that carbon down back into the earth and make it make it usable again? So healthy soils do that. Whereas desertified soils, which is what we're seeing a proliferation of globally, do not you know they they they emit carbon. so that and also in a place like in Bali in Indonesia, we're heavily relying on groundwater. And so healthy soils are our filtration layer, you Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Tobias - Shiva: know. So it's so it's healthy air, soil and water, which can lead to healthy humans and food and and and the restoring the the soil microbiome, which is, you know, I think which is more closely aligned to our microbiome than than we than we know, than we think. Arjun Thomas: No, I you've made you've made some Fascinating points, I think very relevant points because as a human species I you're right, I don't see us slowing down the demand on energy as the the the emerging markets continue to push their populations into prosperity, and that's where most of the population sits. I don't see them stepping back at least taking the foot off the energy consumption pedal. so it takes approaches like yours to say, Hey, let's not worry as much about changing human behavior but think of innovative ways of rethinking how we deal with waste, which is you know, and how do we think about the whole circular economy and doing it in a in a in an incentive aligned manner to kind of derive benefit for for the population more broadly. I'm curious about the the strain that you use, is it can is it the same strain across all your twenty six installations? because the difference between fertilizer is that there's minimal variability in the input, right? They're able to control the input so the output is consistent. You mentioned yours is not a fertilizer, there is gonna be variations. But given that your your your your stock input is so varied, is the strain the same or do you have different strains depending on I'm curious. Tobias - Shiva: No, no, we have the same strain. Arjun Thomas: Okay. Tobias - Shiva: so and and look, don't get me wrong. Look, yes, the the inputs are are very are varied, but hotel waste is hotel waste, you know. They serve the same stuff. you know, they might serve it in different ways. And don't get me wrong, all of our customers Arjun Thomas: At its core, yes. True. Tobias - Shiva: are unique and different and amazing and and all the chefs Arjun Thomas: Ha ha. Tobias - Shiva: hopefully the chefs aren't watching this. They know it they know I love them. But but hotel waste is hotel waste, you know, hospital waste is hospital waste. school waste is school waste. So so like but the the the flip side of that would be Arjun is is are we the you know, would if we went to food processing plants or agricultural processing and we're mono feeding, you know, that would require further analysis. so as to what are the most effective microbes and micro Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: consortium to deal with with with a a monofed machine. because I I would you know I would think that some of our microbes would be beneficial and some would just would starve to death. You know, they they wouldn't they wouldn't get what they need and they they they'd tap out. So so and I think potentially it could evolve over a period of time if you if you had that time that that consortium would evolve itself a bit Darwinian, what happens inside the chamber, the strongest only the strongest survive. And but yeah, that that would require more research for sure. Arjun Thomas: Maybe it's a good time to talk about the commercial side of the business. So I'm curious about two subjects. One we can talk about a little later, which is you know, who are your customers? And this is generally where there's a high concentration of say food waste coming out. So, you know, hotels, hospitals, schools, I I guess r you know, individual households is a very separate conversation and like to get your perspective on it. I know that's probably not what you're focusing on, which which is fair enough. But But what is the what is the incentive structure for your your current customers? Like why do they want this machine? I mean, I I I can think of a couple of reasons why, but I'm curious about as you've had these conversations, what's driving their decision, make an investment in what you guys are building? what value are they seeing? And why are they doing what they're doing? Tobias - Shiva: No, I'm curious actually. I would like to hear what you think they are. you know, but i if you know because I'd like to I'd like to hear from an outsider, you know, what what do you think the the the benefits would be to a customer? Arjun Thomas: So the way I look at again completely as an outsider looking at you know a lay person Tobias - Shiva: Of course, of course. Arjun Thomas: who has little to no understanding of this industry, which is why I'm talking to you, is that when it comes to commercial conversations, I look at how their incentive structures are kind of aligned. One is obviously is this is this is this method cheaper to do than with my current the current I'm doing it. Secondly, depending on the kind of organization I am, is there inherent PR value? Can I spin this in some way? Is it good for environment? Is it does it increase my brand value by by taking this kind of a thing? And the third one, I think, you know, i is the regulatory environment such that I'm gonna get my ass handed to me if I don't and that's generally the first of the top three things when you look at most most large corporates they they have to be forced to told what to be told what to do, that's good. But those are the top three things that kind of c that come to my mind. But yeah. Tobias - Shiva: I mean, you know, I mean, look, it it's it's for us in the early, early days. I mean, when the West didn't backed us, you know, we were very early. and and at and they they we were put in contact with them and I went and saw them. Thankfully, Dane Fernandez, who was the at that time the exec chef and now the head of the sort of front of house, had used the dehydration had used Dehydrator, maybe a or a digester, something. He'd used technology before and and was a backer of it. But this was way before the regulation caught up and this was, you know, it was very early on and and you know, and that's probably a year after we started digging into it. So, you know, when we started there was no tailwinds, there was no real understanding in the market and very much plastics was you know the number one conversation still. And so no that so the I guess that's probably for me the the weakest reason is they wanted to do the right thing. and as you know and commercially that doesn't always fly. so but what we've started to see here is is and in other parts of the world definitely, is the I guess the understanding of food waste and and what it does to our environment. why it's important we keep it separated and what it also does to the inorganic side of things. So we've tried to recycle our way out of a contamination problem and have been wildly unsuccessful. So I I think people and governments are starting to to wise up to the fact that we we probably need to if we sort organics properly, then we'll actually increase our inorganic processing. And so the especially in Bali it's a bit of and Indonesia actually wide And there's been quite a lot of regulatory support over the past, you know, twelve to eighteen months and landfills being closed, particularly to organics. Arjun Thomas: Closed, yeah, I re read about that, yeah. Tobias - Shiva: so so and and what that what that is on on a broad sort of scale is is a formalization of an inform largely informal sector. And and and with that there obviously are some of the informal strains or streams or revenues that will go away. and you know I'm talking about the the dump trucks that are you know rusty and yeah yeah yeah yeah Arjun Thomas: And the collection agencies and the yeah, yeah. Tobias - Shiva: and going and dumping it. I can't go to the landfill I'll just go to the the ravine up the road you know and that's that's what an informal sector is, right? It's unregulated and it's it's wild. and it's waste management. Get it away from me. That's what I pay you to do and I don't care where you put Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: it. So the the the positive side of that and the opportunities that exist in the formalization process is you know a a a proper collections company with proper trucks, proper training and proper processing capabilities. and there's a number of those here in Bali and also in across Indonesia that will pick up your waste, if it's organics or inorganics or whatever, and and deal with it properly, whether they're composting, black soldier fly lava, vermicomposting. et cetera, et cetera. so then what the question becomes with when we go into customers is a they're like, well, I it's expensive to what I'm paying now with the the the dump trucks. Yes, but they they they they're on the ticking time bomb, right? Like they they don't they won't exist soon. They can't. they're part of the the informal sector. so then it becomes a comparison between us and the more formal waste collectors. Now we've done comparisons there. So so against one of the one of those formal waste collecting companies here, on one ton per day of throughput, our break-even is is actually in two years and 52 days compared to those guys. So which is quite a compelling commercial sum or argument and And then, you know, at that one tonne a day of throughput, then they're saving about five hundred million rupiah per per year after that. Arjun Thomas: Post that yeah, right. Tobias - Shiva: So and that includes everything. That's all of your CapEx, OpEx, et cetera, you know. So that's it it's it it's that's quite compelling in itself. The other things that have happened, Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Tobias - Shiva: you touched on it a little bit. Am I gonna get my ass handed to me? look, yeah, the Gen Z and and them and the Millennials are are in their buying power. The millennials, the largest generation of our time, they're smart. They can smell bullshit a mile off, and especially greenwashing. They're incredibly good at finding out greenwashing, right? So And they will they'll have a good experience, they'll tell 10 people, they have a bad, they'll tell a hundred. You know, they're almost vindictive on that side of things. so exactly. Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Human nature, right? across everything. Tobias - Shiva: Exactly. And and look, there's a number of there's a number of research papers out there on booking.com and Goder, etc., talking about how how how much these generations value sustainability. So and so much so that some of the OTAs require third-party validation of your sustainability actions. And that's why we have sort of GSTC and Green Globe and all these guys coming in and doing audits for tourism businesses to actually make sure that they get the stamp of approval. So so the commercial argument is strong and and we're able to to to do that because we manufacture here, we own the whole thing end to end. And there's some competition coming in with dehydration tech. other markets now but it's twice the price of ours so you know we still have a very strong commercial advantage and and we've priced it aggressively for that reason to be honest you know the market so the OTAs and and obviously the customers they they they're demanding this and government regulation support so you know closing of landfills mandatory source separation more of an importance on on-site processing. so a priority, sorry, on on on-site processing. So that's favorable for us, favorable tailwinds. The other thing that we've seen come through from multiple clients now is is staff satisfaction. so that Arjun Thomas: In what way? Tobias - Shiva: so actually that there's this because you know they're communicating this to their staff and there's this brand new shiny machine back of house. But they're communicating this to staff that they're they're no longer dumping, they're no longer, you know, using landfill. and as the conversations around organics increase, obviously that gets to the staff and they they don't want to work for polluters. so we've seen an uplift in staff satisfaction because they know that they're working for an employer who's doing the right thing by by nature and in particular here in Bali and as under sort of Trihitakarana. you know, like that's that's really important. So so yeah, so commercial side, yep, the market side, the OTA side and the regulatory side and and and and stuff. So it's it's it look, I think it's we've come up with a reasonably compelling product and offering. Not everybody's on board yet, of course. that's okay, but geez, it's it's a very different place. Arjun Thomas: So I'm curious about that. I'm curious about that. Sorry, but I'm curious about we say when you say not everybody's on board, what's the kind of pushback that that you're hearing from this This group or maybe multiple groups on why they're not on board. Because if the commercials make sense, it's a two-year payback. and it's it's basically free money after that point. If your staff are happy, if you are getting ahead of a regulatory door that's gonna shut an avenue for you anyway, for your business, it seems like you've kind of hit the all the check boxes. So I'm curious about what the what the pushback is at the for those that don't don't don't see it this way. Tobias - Shiva: Think it's twofold. One is there's a psychological gap. And and two, business is hard, you know. So I'll start with business is hard, you know, and I and I see this in every market to be honest, and I'm in heaps of groups and follow heaps of people, and it's it's a very similar thing. Is that this is another thing on top of businesses, another thing they have to do, you know. on top of everything else when budgets are getting squeezed or markets are getting squeezed and you know, we we have the the Iran stuff disrupting a whole lot of other things and fuel prices and inflation and, you know, it it I think business is hard, in general. and so this is just another thing on top of that. and another s you know, set of expenses that there there might not be a direct color correlation to immediate revenue. So that's, you know, and And and this is something that I struggled with in corporate, you know, we have these annual targets, but we're reporting monthly, you know, and and you know, like it just that that doesn't kind of work. And and look, a lot of these operators, whether they're ho hospitals or malls or schools or ports or hotels, right? they they have a a monthly budget meeting with owners. And and that's that's where I think something that I've really learned with the hotel scene. You generally you typically have an owner. and and that person paid a Hilton or Marriott or whatever to to rent the name and the operating gear and stuff underneath, to to run their property. And that's why you'll see Marriott suddenly turn into a Hilton, because that Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: deal has been done from a licensing perspective. So and a lot of these owners, I mean, they're they're not hoteliers. you know. Yep. Arjun Thomas: No, the landowners, yeah. The construction guys, the landowners, yeah. Tobias - Shiva: Yeah, and they might be from the airline industry or from the mining industry or from the booze industry or whatever, right? So all they look at is a cold balance sheet at the end of the month. They don't understand the nuances of dealing with customers and customers coming up to the buffet saying, This is so much waste, you should be ashamed of yourselves. And and that's a that's quote unquote, right? That's one of our customers here. like people coming up to the chefs at the breakfast buffet and giving them shit for you know food waste. the the owners don't understand that. So When business is hard, they are trying to make a business work numerically in balance sheet, et cetera, and they see an expense, a capex expense, and they don't get it. And so there's the that's that's a tough one to get to. And most of the GMs that we talk to, chefs, you know, heads of engineering, etc., are all in for it. They love it. They get they're they're Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: but getting through that final approval is difficult. And and it comes back to the I guess the the broader thing, which is the psychological gap. and and that is they know they should do the right thing, but actually they know they know they want to do something, but acting on that is is is another thing altogether. And whether or not look it's our technology or it's setting up a compost heap or moving from the the dumpers to you know another collections company or a a black soldier fly thing or vermi compost, whatever. action isn't Yeah, isn't a given, you know. and and change is really hard. And so so they're probably the big ones that for me that I that I run up against or not the team run up against is that psychological shift of I know I need to do something. And that's where, like you said, the regulatory support helps, because that's a bit of a push. It's like you're gonna get your ass lit up if you don't do this. That's that can generally be a good a good catalyst. Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: hopefully we're better as a species than that. you know, like sort of that meme where the house is burning around the person, they're going, I'm fine. that's where we're heading. You know, so hopefully we don't require regulatory push, but and a lot of our customers haven't. but but yeah, I I think it it's it pushing people into action is is is probably the biggest challenge. Arjun Thomas: I I where you're coming from, but as with with humans, we we are on a bell curve, right? We're in a spectrum. So you know, sometimes you do need external forces to to to correct behavior. I mean, as as parents we know we know we know what that is day in and day out. but as long as the incentive structures at the end make sense, both commercially, which it seems in your case it does, you know, having a ruler Is only a short term solution because the long term value is that inherently what we're getting you to do is good. and it's good for you and you will figure it out in a couple of years when your balance sheet starts looking a a lot healthier. So so I kind of get that analogy. I'm also curious about th the the commercial side of this. You said so this is a outright purchase, so it is a capex. Is there an opex element to the way you kind of set up the business? Is is there is there an optionality around a lead. Tobias - Shiva: Yeah, so it's i we started with a leasing structure. but as we're a very, you know, new business, there was obviously a loading on that. so you know, you could pay you know, round numbers, you $100 for the machine, or you could pay $120 for the machine if you wanted to to lease it over a certain period of time. I you know, our machines are I think the smallest machine now is about nine thousand US and the the the large one is about a hundred and fifty thousand. and six models in between. So the so you know, so that 20% extra is quite a lot at the end of the day. Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Tobias - Shiva: so and then and the Western actually came in to look at that. And then once the procurement team worked out that the loading was there and they could avoid it by purchasing, then they just purchased. And the and interestingly at the start of this year we launched a rental program, the pilot. So 10 machines, four barley barley only and because we wanted to see how it went. And same thing. People came in and there's a loading on there. So, you know, they could I can't remember the exact but it was sort of three and a half years you could have paid off a machine, three and a half years of rental. And when people did the did the maths, then they were like, we may as well just buy one. or people just said no. So so yeah it it's in and that's that also shows the psychological gap. Arjun Thomas: Hm. Tobias - Shiva: People are looking for the easiest, simplest, cheapest solutions always. and in Arjun Thomas: Right. Yeah. Tobias - Shiva: business I I think we are pushed towards efficiency probably too much. and short term isn't, like we said. And and those are great examples where we have large businesses that say, No, I don't have the money, I want to rent or I want to lease and then when you put the numbers in front of them and they realize that there's like a penalty for that, like you know, you cut it's not free money. you know, we're Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: not We're not a bank and even a big bank doesn't give you free money, right? So Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: so you know the the when they realize, hang on. actually no, we do have the money now. You know, we do have the priority now. because it it's it's the psychological gap. so so so yeah, so and then as far as ongoings, yes, we we do ongoing maintenance. So we have a a growing team now that go out and do proactive and preventative maintenance on every machine. So every two to four weeks we'll be at a machine and at a customers. And whether we're just giving it a clean up and checking some sensors and doing, you know, checking microbes or whatever. or we're doing training. so they might have new operators or they might have teams new teams upstream that we want to talk to about separation and the reason why and all of that. So and we do that. And it's you know, I think for the small machine that's about, it's about a thousand dollars a year. for the for two to f every two to four weeks we're on site and that includes you know making sure the machine's in tip top condition and doing training for about a thousand dollars a year. So it's it's pretty pretty cheap. It's it's you know it's it's cost for us, so it's loss making that initiative. But it means that we we have a much closer relationship with our customers and they therefore have a much closer relationship with our technology and the machines are in optimal condition and and we're getting the job done at a you know a at at a better scale and i in a better way. So so yeah, that's and that's non negotiable from us. You know, if if people don't want the that that way, then they can go and buy from a competitor. Arjun Thomas: That makes sense. I mean, you're investing in building those relationships. So it's customer experience, right? So i for you it's not just maintaining the machine, it's ensuring that it's used well. so they become the case study for the next purchase and the next purchase and the next purchase. So so I completely get that. But I'm curious about as you think about this business into the future as it scales, are you Or maybe it's too early to think about it. Are you thinking about changing the way you kind of service this? And the reason I asked the question is I actually dropped a podcast yesterday about someone doing cold rooms in the Philippines. Again, same kind of geographical complexity of of of Indonesia where it's disparate islands and transportation and c and and and transport between these locations is massively time consuming. So just to send an operator out into one particular location is a four hour drive sometimes. And as you scale this, and and when I ask them the question which is how are they th rethinking the way they're doing cold rooms versus the standard? Because the standard is a a fixed maintenance cadence, right? So once every three months, once every six months, they look they heavily invest in IoT sensors to kind of have a dynamic maintenance schedule to optimize costs. but for them they don't have the customer experience element as much as clearly you do have. So do you think about that, the that the tension between customer experience and you know what's the least amount of maintenance I should be able to kinda get away with running an efficient shop. Tobias - Shiva: I think look, I think is because what you're talking about is then hyperscale, right? So then you're talking starting to look at operational minutiae. and we're not there yet. now we're putting we're putting the groundwork in. So all machines are IoT enabled. So from our sensor network we we we can control machines remotely. but we we have a a dashboard at the factory. Which shows all of our machines and that gives us uptime, gives us sensor health, gives us microbial health. so we've designed something that we call the digestion arc. So, and that is weight over time in the machine, and and each machine has a specific arc. So if there is a deviation in the arc, then we will know that there's something wrong. Now that could be heat pad, that could be blower, that could be rotors, that could be Machines on an angle, we can we can check all of those things remotely. And but you know, it also could be microbial health. So so something's gone into the machine, it happens, right? somebody tips a mop bucket full of chemicals into the food waste bin for some reason, or it spills or Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: somebody thinks that 10 gallons of used cooking oil can go into the machine and which is out there, you know. Arjun Thomas: You talking about that. Tobias - Shiva: You know, i i it it ha shit happens, right? so so yeah, I mean it it's w we have the sensor network and we have the ability to do all of this remotely, but we're not at that point of tightening those operational screws and looking for that minutia, just yet. And in fact we're probably, you know, that we're over investing because we're we're building a category, to be honest. but we're but we're also building a brand. And it's it's not just about a dumb product. you know, like that's as you know, mate, like business it we're still largely human based as a as a as a business and business is predominantly done human to human still for a while. so you know we've got to bring some of that warmth and some of that love and and look in in in industrial B2B I won't say waste management, but you know, resource recovery machinery, it doesn't really exist, right? Arjun Thomas: Resource recovery, yeah. Tobias - Shiva: you know, we're flogging big old bits of steel and and off we go, you know. so it's something that that that my team and I are consciously focused on creating a a really great customer experience from the hardware into the software and and and and then into the the after sales service. So look, don't get me wrong, let's flash forward a few years and We're popping up in lots of other different markets and the unit economics of doing business in those markets are vastly different to what we're we're dealing with here. Of course, you know, I'll I'll pick Australia, right? we've got to pay I don't know if this is true, but I saw I saw the delivery drivers are just about to get 30 bucks an hour or something. you know, if we had to spend 30 bucks an hour, I don't know what the minimum wage. Is right now down there, but let's you know, let's call it 30 for the shits and giggles. But yeah, if we had to spend thirty bucks an hour to have people on the road and much longer commutes in Australia, you know, much more, you know, much Arjun Thomas: Distances, yeah. Tobias - Shiva: yeah. so yeah, that that would change the way we would have to do things. But we're not there yet. And and that that Arjun Thomas: Fair enough. Tobias - Shiva: that situation exists across, you know, the two hundred and ninety million people and across the seventeen thousand islands of Indonesia, we think the model is is it is built for Indonesia. So We'll tackle that when we get to it, but for now, it's it's worth it to to put that money into the building those relationships, building those happy customers, learning more about our people, learning more about our waste flows, learning more about our machines, and and putting that back into the cycle of of of growth and development. Arjun Thomas: Makes makes sense. I think every good early business or good early innovation requires constant connection with the market. 'cause it is a two-way conversation, right? So when I talk to great founders, they they they all understand that it's it's a tension with the market and you and your customers evolve, the market evolves, and unless you have this bi-directional conversation all the time, you can't off you can't off outsource that to a digital medium, right? Sometimes it requires a conversation over a table, over a coffee, a one hour conversation. Like this to kind of unpack what is just you know the the Arabic bacteria that sits upon the landfill, right? There's a lot that's happening below. one one or two last questions, because I I'm conscious of time and you know I've already taken up quite a bit of yours. the the the value proposition to the hotel owners, you said you know, at the end of the day they look at it as a balance sheet. The output, which is this resource that you're creating, or resource recovery, How is that used today? Or is it used today? Tobias - Shiva: So the West Ind, 'cause they're they're you know, they're they're two years next week it'll be two years. They've replaced chemical fertilizers on the on the property. And so they just use our digestate and they use that two ways. They use that both as a fertilizer or a fertilizer replacement, because we're not a certified fertilizer, as a fertilizer replacement. And but also when they do renovations, they they use it as as a soil, you know, it's a rebuild living soil. So where they've had diggers or construction or whatever, they use Shiva to rebuild that soil. And they're able to put grass straight back on top of it. So then mix it with dirt and then and then get stra grass straight back on top of it. And the interesting part part there, and and we've we've done a bit of content on this, it's on our Instagram. it's they had some oil palms then, which were decorative and out the front of the convention center. And Was it was a public holiday, it might have been gulling gun or something like that, and they were redoing the area, and so they needed some some soil for that area around the day the oil pumps. And so they they had a heap of Shiva lying there, and so they used that, and they thought nothing of it, right? And and then a month later, these oil palms started fruiting and flowering for the first time ever. Right? So 20 years, Arjun Thomas: Wow, right. Wow. Tobias - Shiva: and this is the first time they've come to life, you know, they've been sitting there. dormant and so and plants will do that right now plants will sit there forever Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: and they need that extra bit of energy to be Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: able to turn that into a flower which obviously then is pollinated and gets turned into fruit. So and if they don't have that energy they won't use it. They'll prioritize survival. So so that was awesome. But then you know a number of weeks later they had the international palm oil growers convention there and Pak Dika who's their head of landscaping came out And it was like, what the hell? And there was like fifty people around these oil palms. These are oil palm plantation owners, right? These are the experts. Arjun Thomas: Right. Right. Tobias - Shiva: and they were taking photos going, This is wild, you know, like we haven't seen a tree this healthy. So Arjun Thomas: See this twenty years, yeah. Wow. Tobias - Shiva: yeah, yeah. Look, great story. could we replicate it? I don't know. but you know, we're talking about a flourishing tree, not a not a not a dying one. So the the product is used now by all of our customers. They use it or they have contra deals with organic farmers and they swap produce for it. we're talking to a couple of people Aston Kara and things like that. So working on, you know, if the machine gets into a certain hotel then it's in a decent proximity to them. They can collect the digest aid, etc. We're also working on a number of different formulas to buffer the digest aid. And turn it into something standardized. We're about 12, 14 months actually into that, into that process. It's, you know, pretty secretive. So I you know, I can't go into huge details, but we've had scientists and agronomists, et cetera, working full-time for 14 months, working on two specific permutations of what that could look like. and I'm pretty excited about what that could potentially mean for us moving forward. The only other competitor that I know of that does anything with their digest aid is Harp out of Europe. so I and it's a granulated product. I'm not I'm not sure of the the you know the the commercial success or anything like that of that product. But the rest of the digester companies, the ones that are doing aerobic digestion, because you c obviously can't rec recover anything from a a dehydrator, but the yeah, they're the only ones that I know globally that are doing something. So that would be interesting for us to be the first to really push that angle outside of what they're doing with, you know, their pelletized granulator. Arjun Thomas: Very cool. And given that you're creating essentially d value as an output where before it was a cost to take the problem away, for a lot of these you know, schools, hospitals, hotels, do they Do they view this as a net value, net positive to the balance sheet? Because essentially you can recover costs. So you know, with the Western they reduced the amount of fertilizer they were used to purchase before. does that have any material impact on the commercials of of of this investment? Or is it still too early to kind of plug that in? Okay. Tobias - Shiva: No no of course I mean the Western are ecstatic, right? and and and you know, because they backed us so early, I mean we still had a bit of warts and the you know, we had a few few niggles in the system and stuff like that. And so, you know, we've we've certainly had to rally around those guys and make sure that you know we we were we were on top of it and and supporting them. But no, they're ecstatic. so the yeah, i it's it's honestly I I think Once people realize that in the the the New World Order is in the formalized waste sector, they have with their organic, they have to separate their organics, okay? And and even as households we need to. All right. So the whole world is moving this way. You know, you've got South Korea leading the way, you've got New York doing really well, you've got Australia pushing FOGO in certain areas and stuff. Like we've we've I think we're we're definitely pushing that way. Globally, consumers are starting to realise, shit. organics need to be sorted and they don't necessarily know why and I think that's up to us to do better better education and and and better messaging around that better communication. But so they have to separate organics they and then they have to have those organics dealt with responsibly. And that means they can either compost they can black solder fly larvae they can vermicompost or they can digest. That's it. So that's it globally those those are the four options. Okay. so yes, okay, animal feeds, but as we know, animal feeds highly regulated and pigs and chickens do not eat everything, much to you know, Arjun Thomas: Mm-hmm. Tobias - Shiva: much going against what you probably heard. So and there's an interesting case study from Potato Head here that did that. So so yeah, they're there they they are the options for our food waste. So and you know they're all they're more expensive than what we were doing. But what we were doing previously, Mother Nature was paying the bill, you know, so Arjun Thomas: Mm. Tobias - Shiva: and she can't pay it anymore. She you know, she she physically cannot. so we have to, you know, act responsibly with our waste, whether it's a household or a or a business. and and you know, the the limits, the the the options are are pretty pretty clear. so you know, and and honestly, you know, we we moved into a house about four months ago. And I was playing around with this concept of an in-ground compost up and made from terracotta. It's about 90 centimeters high, it's about 40 centimeters wide. And it's got holes in it because I didn't want to have to to harvest, right? I wanted the worms to do the work, I wanted nature to do the work, and it was a concept. Interestingly, that prototype has handled we're a family of five. and we entertain probably once every two weeks or something, have a barbecue or friends around or whatever. yeah, that pot has never been emptied and it is still all of Arjun Thomas: Wow. Tobias - Shiva: our food waste goes into that. our bones go to our dogs, okay. So, you know, but everything else goes into that into that terracotta pot. you know, it's it's You don't have to go and spend money on technology and machines. And I say this all the time, you know, the best tech is no tech. You know, it's it's remembering, you know, before Arjun Thomas: Right. Tobias - Shiva: we it's amazing what convenience can make you forget. that, you know, food waste is actually the easiest thing to deal with. it's just once again, Arjun Thomas: We've forgotten how I guess. Tobias - Shiva: it's just thinking and then acting. If we can connect the thinking to acting, that's that's what that's where the change lies. Arjun Thomas: Well, I think on that positive note, one last thing I'd like to end with, Tobias, is that there is clearly no shortage of hard things you've had to do, to kind of get the business to this point, figuring out all the levers and I probably think that's another five hour conversation. But is there one thing that surprised you by being really, really easy? Tobias - Shiva: One thing that has surprised me as being Arjun Thomas: by being very easy. That that was just just just happened so naturally, that happened so easy. Tobias - Shiva: No. no and and look, I I don't know if if if I did explain it well enough, but it was I I you know, leaving behind a twenty year career in a very, very different field, in a different market. And coming to a market where, you know, I I'm still learning the language, but back then I, you know, my barsa was terrible. Changing and pivoting and and all of that, all of the complexity and all the difficulty, all that. But it was it was made very easy in general. You know, it w it was interesting that when I needed to learn something or know something or meet someone. It kind of it kind of happened, you know, and and Arjun Thomas: Mm. Tobias - Shiva: you know, we make our own luck, sure. and and you know, it's I was working hard at it. but it it was surprisingly frictionless, let's say, to to do this 180. you know, and And I feel, you know, I feel really grateful for that. Now, maybe it's my experience and I knew not to go down certain paths and maybe it's that. I don't know. but overall it it it has just felt a bit serendipitous and it's happened quite organically, right? and yes, look, but business is hard. Like I said, it's not just hard for the hotels, etc., it's hard for everybody. And my wife and I were discussing this last night, you know, like it's that that extra five percent, three percent, two percent, one percent, whatever it is, when you think when you're at the wall, you know, and that can be that could be from a product perspective, that can be from a market marketing, could be a commercial thing, you know, like I don't know any of the entrepreneurs, successful entrepreneurs that I know, in fact any entrepreneur that hasn't gone to the wall, you know, and and it's what you do at that point. that makes the difference. And the good ones that I know, that's when they they push off the wall and they they go. and sadly, you know, they're the minority. so yeah, look, there has been plenty of war moments across all parts of all parts of Shiva. and personally, you know, getting into this thing, none of it has been super easy at all. But that maybe that's a perspective thing, I don't know. But in general, it it it has has felt quite guided. and maybe that's experience, maybe that's no divine intervention, I don't know. I got an got an angel on my shoulder, mate. I don't know. Arjun Thomas: Yeah, it was organic. yeah, but on that on that high note again, as as this conversation was super easy, thank you for making it so. I really appreciate the generosity of your time and the openness in which you kind of unpacked the journey to get Shiva to where it is today. I'd love to buy you a beer whenever I'm in Bali next and if you're on the island. and Tobias - Shiva: Perfect, mate. Come come and check out the factory. Arjun Thomas: done, done and done. thanks again, Tobias, and have a wonderful day. Tobias - Shiva: Thanks, Alvin. Cheers, man. Thank you.