Latest / The Vegan Report / Our Plant-Based Ancestors. With Dr. Hadar Ahituv | Ep. 68
Transcript
- 0:00My name is Ryan and you are listening to The
- 0:03Vegan Report. For decades, we've held a clear
- 0:07and widely accepted picture of what prehistoric
- 0:11humans were like. Central to that narrative is
- 0:15the belief that they followed a so -called Paleo
- 0:20diet, a diet consisting of whole foods heavily
- 0:23focused on animal proteins while avoiding grains
- 0:27and legumes. However, a groundbreaking study
- 0:32published this very year challenges that claim,
- 0:37according to this research, our ancestors' diets
- 0:40were predominantly plant -based, including grains
- 0:45and legumes. This revelation suggests that early
- 0:50humans might have been more accurately described
- 0:53as gatherer -hunters rather than hunter -gatherers.
- 0:58How? How did such a misconception about prehistoric
- 1:03humans arise? And what does this new discovery
- 1:07tell us about our identity as a species? To answer
- 1:14those questions, I am joined by Dr. Hadar Ahidouf,
- 1:18the lead researcher behind this study. Dr. Ahid
- 1:23Roof is based at the Laboratory for Ancient Food
- 1:26Processing Technologies at Haifa University's
- 1:30Zinman Institute of Archaeology. So Hadar, your
- 1:35paper is titled, Starch -Rich Plant Foods, 780
- 1:41,000 Years Ago, Evidence from Aeculian Percussive
- 1:46Stone Tools. Now, I thought about my knowledge
- 1:52of history. And I think I can pretty much go
- 1:56back to 3000 years before Christ. And that's
- 2:00the extent of my historical knowledge. So for
- 2:05me, 780 ,000 years means absolutely nothing.
- 2:10I have no conceptual historical context framework
- 2:15to understand that number. So I guess my first
- 2:20question for you is, can you give me some context
- 2:23about what was, you know, being human like 700
- 2:28,000 years ago? And what was life like? What
- 2:33was, you know, the what did the earth look like?
- 2:36Yeah, so Actually, it's a really big question.
- 2:42I can tell that our ancestors, there were few
- 2:49ancestors through the prehistory of life until
- 2:53we know that we are the homo sapiens ourselves.
- 2:58There are a few types of hominins, if you would
- 3:03like to call it like this, but also before them,
- 3:06there were the kind of types that were more similar
- 3:09to other species that we know. So if I'll just
- 3:14mention them for you in the podcast, there were
- 3:18Australopithecus, and there are also different
- 3:21kinds of Australophorensis, for example, and
- 3:24the source of them, we can talk about Africa
- 3:27as kind of the source of human, if you would
- 3:33like to call it like this. For example, Lucy,
- 3:36she's the most famous one. She dated for 3 .2
- 3:41million years ago, and she was the host of Pitechus
- 3:44of Forensics. And she's one of the oldest species
- 3:49of human that we can call them like this. And
- 3:56when we are talking here about 780 ,000 years
- 4:03ago, we can talk about hominins. So hominins
- 4:12are the ancestors that went out from Africa and
- 4:21spread all over the world. And the hominins,
- 4:24if you would ask which type of person that went
- 4:29out from Africa, I can tell you that it's...
- 4:32homo erectus, although there are few opinions
- 4:37for here and there, but it's kind of the mainstream
- 4:43think that the homo erectus is the type of human
- 4:51that went out of Africa. And if we're talking
- 4:54about the surrounding, so the surrounding was
- 4:59Like we can imagine from movies. So it was kind
- 5:03of savannahs and Forests with high and big trees
- 5:08and big mamas and also small animals But all
- 5:13was really wild and big and massive and dramatic
- 5:17When we are traveling today, you know in the
- 5:20cities or even in villages It's so so so different.
- 5:25So if you go back to 3 ,000 years from now, as
- 5:30you mentioned, we can say that the surrounding
- 5:35was quite similar. Not, of course, not with the
- 5:40towers and the big cities as we know them, but
- 5:43communities of people that live together. And
- 5:46all of this kind of lead us to what we are now
- 5:50today, just in big, just in large, the technology
- 5:54and what's came on us. on it and if we want to
- 5:59connect it to some kind of period that we can
- 6:02divide it to the old world and then to the new
- 6:07world we probably must point out on the agricultural
- 6:11revolution that happened around 10k before present
- 6:19around it of course it's depend who you're asking,
- 6:24but at the end of the Upper Paleolithic and when
- 6:31the Neolithic period started. And the agricultural
- 6:35revolution actually brought us to what we know
- 6:37today about villages, about settlements, about
- 6:41sit in one place and become to be a farmer instead
- 6:46of hunter -gatherers. So actually what is earlier
- 6:50than 10K from present that we can talk about
- 6:58is the hunter -gatherers that we know them. And
- 7:01these hunter -gatherers went around, searched
- 7:05for foods, searched for any kind of resources
- 7:09that they can use, and they traveled. There are
- 7:14even research that talks about over 20 kilometers
- 7:20per day. around to search food and return to
- 7:23the camp. So most of the sites that they were
- 7:26lived in are either caves or open sites under
- 7:32the sky. And they collect, whether it's animals,
- 7:38whether it's plants, what is my research brought
- 7:42to the new field to see and look for. So also
- 7:49plants. And they brought them to the side and
- 7:51also other resources like unorganic resources
- 7:54like plants and all kinds of other tools. For
- 8:00example, if they will process skins and create
- 8:07ropes and those kind of stuff. So they needed
- 8:11to collect them around in the surrounding and
- 8:14bring them to the camp and then use them. Yeah,
- 8:20I think this is it. If I can summarize all of
- 8:24the things into a small section here in the podcast,
- 8:30but of course it's a huge data that must be more
- 8:38increased. Yes, definitely. I mean, it's a long
- 8:44stretch of time. Let me go back to what you said
- 8:47about the hominids, because I think it's one
- 8:51of the most fascinating chapter of the existence
- 8:56of humanity. So basically, there were other human
- 9:03species around. And I guess my question is, are
- 9:10we the product of you know, reproduction between
- 9:14those human species? Or are we something completely
- 9:19separate from them? How much can we relate to
- 9:23those other human species? It's a really interesting
- 9:29question. Again, it's huge, huge data in the
- 9:33research that, you know, there are even groups
- 9:36in the research that talks about different ways
- 9:40but what came from the latest researches in the
- 9:46recent research talks about that there were some
- 9:51combinations between the species, the human species,
- 9:57and actually it was not as much as dichotomic
- 10:02as much as it has been thought before. So there
- 10:06are some kind of, you know, combinations between
- 10:11as much as they can be seen in the DNA research.
- 10:16For example, if we are talking about the Neanderthals
- 10:19and the Homo sapiens, you know, way after the
- 10:24hominids that we talked about in GBY and Geshov
- 10:26-Notiakov, so you can see that there are also
- 10:29evidence of Neanderthals also in our DNA, in
- 10:32the DNA of the Homo sapiens. It's small percentages,
- 10:36of course, and Homo sapiens now became the controller
- 10:40of the whole species and occupied all the globes
- 10:46and also before the agricultural revolution if
- 10:51I mention it also. But definitely we carry on
- 10:56us some fractions of DNA from other species as
- 11:01well. And if you want to differentiate between
- 11:05the old, you know, the really ancient species,
- 11:08as I mentioned before, between the Australopithecus
- 11:10suffrensis, Australopithecus bozi, for example,
- 11:14and for the Homo erectus, so you can see similarities,
- 11:19but I'm not sure about the DNA that is really
- 11:23in this stage to answer about those questions.
- 11:27So what I can say from the research itself is
- 11:30that There are differentiations. And when we
- 11:34talk about homo erectus, this is the first homo,
- 11:38this is the first species of human that create
- 11:42tools. And he used tools. So he create tools
- 11:46that he can use them for other tools. To create
- 11:50another tool. So if, for example, I'll give you
- 11:52an example. He create some indexes that he can
- 11:56chop. uh woods you can chop skins uh little and
- 12:02produce other stuff from them to use with or
- 12:06to process for example if it's meat or if it's
- 12:09plant as i also plant as i mentioned in my research
- 12:14so this is kind of the differentiation and this
- 12:18person the the abel the the homo habilis this
- 12:23is the first You know, homo habilis, it's considered
- 12:26as homo erectus. This is the species that went
- 12:31out of Africa in the first out, the big first
- 12:36out of Africa, and then spread it all over, you
- 12:40know, into Asia and Europe. And then, yeah. Then,
- 12:46you know, if we haven't mixed that much with
- 12:51them, where have they gone? Why are they extinct
- 12:56right now? And I'm asking that, having in mind
- 13:02the hypothesis then, we're the ones who have
- 13:07destroyed them. So can you confirm that? I can
- 13:11refer to this. But again, these are the big question
- 13:14of actually in prehistory and I don't want to
- 13:17be risked with other colleagues. But I'll try
- 13:21to answer, I think, on the right answer. And
- 13:29I want to mention that the suitable species were
- 13:35survived. Those who were adjustable enough to
- 13:39the changes, also in environment, also in the
- 13:42surroundings. You know, climate change. Also,
- 13:46there may be the change of amount of animals
- 13:48around them, the predators that maybe attack
- 13:51them. And there is a huge discussion about the
- 13:56production of tools. For example, the differentiation
- 14:00between the Australopithecus, as I mentioned
- 14:04them, to the Homo habilis. So when you succeed
- 14:08to create some tools, so maybe you can defend
- 14:11yourself better than other species. Further,
- 14:16if you went to the Homo erectus in the Geisha
- 14:22B 'not Yaakov, 780 ,000 years from now, these
- 14:28hominids, they will control on fire. So this
- 14:32is the first evidence out of Africa of human
- 14:37species that control on fire. So this control
- 14:41brings with itself, you know, maybe can stand
- 14:45by its own, the control of fire that can lead
- 14:48for other options, maybe survival options, maybe
- 14:53you can extinct other species, I guess, with
- 15:01these abilities. So it's adaptions that human
- 15:05species, specific human species, as we know,
- 15:08maybe the Homo sapiens further, but if we talk
- 15:10now about Homo erectus, they made those adaptations
- 15:13to the surroundings that helped them to survive
- 15:16upon the others. Okay, let's go back to your
- 15:20study. So now we have, you know, defined and
- 15:28given context around the years. But what about
- 15:34the location? How did you select the location?
- 15:39How did you make the decision to start digging,
- 15:44you know, at the banks of the South Jordan River,
- 15:50I think. So I'll just mention that this excavations
- 15:54were happened way before me as a student, even.
- 15:59And I have a PhD, of course, and the research,
- 16:02but the the leader of the excavation, and she's
- 16:08also signed on this research as well, with her
- 16:11help. and she was excavated in a she was excavator
- 16:22in the 80s and the 90s of the last century and
- 16:25she she actually made a really great job about
- 16:31preserving the the finds that she take out of
- 16:35the the ground out of the soils so actually when
- 16:38you excavate you reduce layers from the soil
- 16:42Sorry, most of the layers, most of the sediments
- 16:46were thrown away after the excavation, wild excavation
- 16:49itself. And sorry, Nahama Goren in Bar, Professor
- 16:55Goren in Bar, kept a lot of the sediments and
- 16:59kept a lot of the finds also in a way that allowed
- 17:05it to preserve better. for me to come and check
- 17:10this. So I came into this after the second degree
- 17:14when I talked with my supervisor. And my supervisor
- 17:20mentioned me that her supervisor, Nahamah Goremin
- 17:23-Bah, Professor Nahamah Goremin -Bah, have a
- 17:26lot of material sits and wait for people to investigate
- 17:31it for microremains. So actually there are a
- 17:35lot of microremains that I can do in actually
- 17:39any archaeological site. I can use in any kind
- 17:44of find to extract and resell starches if we
- 17:48talk about starches or maybe other microremains
- 17:51like pollen and like other phytoliths. And my
- 17:58specialty, actually I'll just mention it, I'm
- 18:01a specialist with starch. And what I decided
- 18:05to do is to take some kind of case study that
- 18:09will be strong enough and maybe will fade much
- 18:13light about plant processing and production of
- 18:21foods out of plants. And when she suggested this
- 18:26as a quite good sampling site, I jumped. almost
- 18:33right away and decided to test these stones because
- 18:38they thought these actually percussive tools,
- 18:41not just a stone. And it was fantastic to test
- 18:47them. And of course, again, I'll repeat, there
- 18:52are a lot of options here in Israel and a lot
- 18:55of corporations to do, but this is kind of unique
- 18:59material to work on and prehistory. that, for
- 19:03me, is most interesting than other periods, for
- 19:08example. So this is what led me to investigate
- 19:12this site and take these samples out of this
- 19:15site. So it's a combination between great taking
- 19:21care about the stuff, the great checking and
- 19:25analyzing of the material, and great context.
- 19:30of material and its combination of all. Yeah.
- 19:34And I think this is what brought me to this.
- 19:39And I guess we could get to the conclusion of
- 19:44that study. And maybe a way to sum it up is,
- 19:53yes, we were hunter -gatherers, but maybe we
- 19:56were more gatherers than hunters. So would you
- 20:00agree with that? You know, summary? So I'm, I'm,
- 20:06I must agree with this summary, because, and
- 20:08maybe I'll say something for, you know, in the
- 20:12beginning of this, well, most of the archaeological
- 20:15sites that were excavated, they're excavated,
- 20:19and the finds and the tools kept right away,
- 20:25they kept right away after the excavation and
- 20:28they classified and when you're excavating by
- 20:31hands so a lot of the sediments that around the
- 20:35finds are thrown away so all the macro remains
- 20:41actually I wish I wish that I think that this
- 20:45is what the archaeologists done of course they're
- 20:47keeping all of the macro remains that what they
- 20:50can see but a lot of the material conclude also
- 20:55micro -remains that can't be seen unless you're
- 21:00taking them to the lab and test them under the
- 21:03microscope. So what you can find in most cases
- 21:07in archaeological sites, especially in prehistoric
- 21:10sites, is that you can find bones close to plants
- 21:15or other stone tools, net stone tools. and maybe,
- 21:21maybe, maybe a little bit of charcoals, or even
- 21:26that, not that much. Sometimes you can see if
- 21:30it's further in prehistory, like from the Epipaleolithic
- 21:34through the Neolithic period, and of course,
- 21:39go through to the Roman period, you can see also
- 21:42the structures, the buildings, and if it's in
- 21:46prehistory, you maybe will see three stages of
- 21:49stones that may be served as the base of the
- 21:52wood or something. So this is what you mostly
- 21:57see when you're excavating. And when decided
- 22:01to take the research of microremains into the,
- 22:05you know, to take the samples and take them into
- 22:07the microscope and observe them, it's a new world
- 22:12for the archaeologists. in large but also for
- 22:16the micro remains researchers, because you can
- 22:20reveal much more out of the excavation. And if
- 22:25you, if we as archaeologists want to reconstruct
- 22:28the real picture about how people in this case,
- 22:34how our ancestors live or manage their lives,
- 22:42and what activities they've done, you must check
- 22:45in all directions. And I'm not blaming, of course,
- 22:51the archaeologists in large, and of course it's
- 22:53not. This is the process of research. Well, now
- 22:56we are in a period that those micro -remains
- 23:01researchers are able to be done. So we have the
- 23:04microscope, we have other chemicals we can use.
- 23:10And it's great how the... you know how the technology
- 23:13is improved in all aspects so it's allowed us
- 23:17to do this but most of the archaeological excavations
- 23:20up to kind of the 20 years from now ago most
- 23:24of them they excavate you know bare hands just
- 23:27collect the pints and this is what the archaeologists
- 23:31done so i can't blame them but this what caused
- 23:37the bias of not seeing any plant remains because
- 23:40plant remains are organic they are more affected
- 23:43by the surroundings, they are more affected by
- 23:47other insects or microorganisms. Also, the purpose
- 23:54of this research is to investigate an archaeological
- 23:58site, a prehistoric archaeological site, is that
- 24:01this specific site was waterlogged. The waterlogged
- 24:05is surrounded without oxygen. the possible of
- 24:12microorganisms that needs oxygen to live and
- 24:16to eat the starches, the starch remains from
- 24:19the staples decreased, increasingly decreased.
- 24:25So it's great, great, you know, to check there.
- 24:29So this is what we need inside and I hope for
- 24:31that. And the starches were preserved, but it's
- 24:35not the case in all other, you know, archaeological
- 24:38sites. It's also dependent on preservation. So
- 24:42if you, as you mentioned, the three thousand
- 24:46years from the Christian, from the Bible, for
- 24:50example. So in those archaeological sites, there
- 24:56are high percentages of preservation of organic
- 24:59materials. And by the way, these organic materials
- 25:02are from charcoals. Most of them were burnt.
- 25:09and then they preserved because when you burn
- 25:12something, you transform it to charcoal, and
- 25:17then it became unorganic in some way. And then
- 25:21it's less breakable, less damaged. Of course,
- 25:25it's damaged and there are economic processes
- 25:28on archaeological sites in large, but most of
- 25:32them are preserved. And here, in this unique
- 25:36site, the macro -remains, the plant macro -remains
- 25:39were preserved also because they were they were,
- 25:45you know, soaked with water under the water in
- 25:51soil sediments. So it was soil sediment that
- 25:54was a swamp and it was a lake shore before this,
- 25:59like 780 ,000 years ago. And this is what afford
- 26:05the preservation. So we assume that because there
- 26:08is macro botanical remains of plants, we assume
- 26:11that we have here a potential to reverse starches.
- 26:17And this is it. Also, it's a unique site because
- 26:22of the macro botanical remains of fruits, different
- 26:28kinds of fruits, almonds, and a lot of other,
- 26:32like acorns. others that probably consume and
- 26:35as we mentioned here they they probably consume
- 26:40and I think what is if you if you will ask me
- 26:44and probably will you you want to ask but I think
- 26:47I'm I'm jumping over maybe I'll continue the
- 26:51uniqueness of these riches the uniqueness the
- 26:55uniqueness of this research is that we examine
- 27:00starches we examine plant residues out of tools.
- 27:05Most of the archaeological remains excavating
- 27:09the archaeological site, they are found close
- 27:12to tools, close to other remains of humans. So
- 27:17it's indirect evidence that macro botanical remains.
- 27:24But they are in the site, so we can talk about
- 27:27them. that maybe they can use with, you know,
- 27:31plant processing, maybe they brought for specific
- 27:35reasons, and probably it is. But when you discovered
- 27:38and when you reveal touches or plant proxies
- 27:44out of tools, so it's like you, you know, picking
- 27:48out in your plate, in your plate at home. So
- 27:52it definitely came from what you processed and...
- 27:56probably consumed. And it's more direct evidence
- 28:01for the process of plants. And it's probably
- 28:05the earliest evidence of plant processing and
- 28:11consumption of plants. That's absolutely fascinating
- 28:22to think that archaeologists would look at you
- 28:26know, the, those macro, um, clues of what early
- 28:32people ate, um, and, and, and just have that,
- 28:37you know, bias of, you know, not, uh, looking
- 28:40at the micro stuff, um, which yes, like you said,
- 28:44um, is more rich in, in, in clues on what exactly
- 28:51they, they, they were eating, what was their
- 28:53their diet about. So you talked about instruments.
- 29:00Are we talking here about, and you mentioned
- 29:04plates, like some sorts of plates. Are we talking
- 29:10about cooking here? Were those people, you know,
- 29:16that advance in their manipulation of food? So
- 29:21it's a great question, and I think you touched
- 29:23the point exactly. Well, as I mentioned before,
- 29:28the site was known by the oldest evidence of
- 29:32controlling the fire outside of Africa. So fire
- 29:37was there, and we can see also evidence of charcoals
- 29:40that were brought intensifically over the site.
- 29:45And also we can see, of course, other remains
- 29:50of animals, of mammals, from different kinds
- 29:54of mammals, and also fish. But here in these
- 29:58reaches, we find out also starches that were
- 30:04damaged in a way that's really similar to cooking
- 30:08or, if you would like, fire processing of plants.
- 30:14I'm trying to be careful with my words, but...
- 30:17The evidence well, it's it's look like this and
- 30:21we present it also in the research we gave also
- 30:24a figure for this and we present the statues
- 30:26and we suggest that those touches went over a
- 30:32processing on grindstone tools and Grindstone
- 30:36tools is kind of large terms for percussive tools
- 30:41for processing tools. So these plans brought
- 30:46brought to these tools, the stone tools, basalt
- 30:50stone tools, and they were processed. This is
- 30:53what we extract, this is what we take out from.
- 30:56So not the plates, actually not the ancient plates,
- 31:01but the processing tools. So if you want, it's
- 31:03like the food processor today on the, you know,
- 31:08that sits in our kitchen. So this was the ancient
- 31:11food processor, and they use this and process
- 31:15it. and maybe after this or maybe before that
- 31:18they brought this production this you know maybe
- 31:24it was a flower or something like that and they
- 31:29process it or create it at some point and put
- 31:33it through the fire and then consume it. We guessed
- 31:37that they consume it so yeah I'm choosing my
- 31:41words here because this kind of stuff that are
- 31:44a little bit kind Kind of jump over, but we can
- 31:47talk about it, I guess. So I'll just say that
- 31:54the evidence came out of these processing tools,
- 31:57they call them percussive tools, and it was specific
- 32:02plant parts. And they didn't mention it before
- 32:05and they think it's worth to mention that the
- 32:08starchy parts in plants are really specific because
- 32:12the starch not... and all of the plants. So you
- 32:17need to pick specific parts of plants that contain
- 32:22the starch. And these kinds of plant parts came
- 32:26from different kinds of plants. So for example,
- 32:29from acorns, we found evidence for acorns. We
- 32:33found evidence of species. It's a starch formation
- 32:38that is correlated with barley. Wild grass and
- 32:43also rate so it's a similar formation. So actually
- 32:47it's it could be that all of these four were
- 32:51processed but Probably some of them like two
- 32:54of them three of them. Maybe all of them were
- 32:56processed. So we talked about acorns about wheat
- 33:00or barley or the two others and also chestnuts
- 33:04that these are nuts also roots of water lily
- 33:09yellow water lily and we mentioned chestnut and
- 33:14maybe also lily bulbs. So it's kind of big, you
- 33:20know, big, big kind of range of species that
- 33:27came from different kinds of plant parts. So
- 33:29we talked about bulbs, nuts and grains and seeds
- 33:35also. And it's unique also because we found it
- 33:39on these tools, but these kind of plants came
- 33:43from different seasons. So you can find them
- 33:47in different seasons. So you can yield like the
- 33:49yield, when you need to go out and harvest them,
- 33:54you can find them in different kinds of seasons.
- 33:57For example, the chestnuts and the water yellow
- 34:01lily, they are actually harvested in the winter,
- 34:07mostly in the winter, autumn. And if we talked
- 34:11about wheat or barley, or also oat, they found
- 34:16around the spring into the summer, and acorns
- 34:21somewhere in between, also close to the winter.
- 34:25So it's kind of range of seasonality. And we
- 34:28can talk here about seasonality preferences,
- 34:31or maybe depending on the seasons. So it means
- 34:35that this ancient hominid, Ancient hominins,
- 34:41they knew the surroundings, they knew the year
- 34:43-round seasonality, they knew, of course, well,
- 34:47without doubt, they knew the cycles of climate,
- 34:53the cycles of plant production, next -generation
- 35:00season production of the plant. And it's, I think,
- 35:07it's extreme. extremely interesting to know that
- 35:11they have these develops and if we combine it
- 35:15also to the processing that maybe they take the
- 35:18plants and after the process put them also in
- 35:21fire and you combine all the things you can talk
- 35:24here about really developed cognitive of those
- 35:27kind of species the hominids and if you would
- 35:31say Homo erectus if you want Homo erectus back
- 35:35then back to around 800 ,000 years from now.
- 35:40800 ,000 years. So it's, I think it's really
- 35:46interesting and need saying. Quick follow -up
- 35:49question. Do you think there were more plants
- 35:53that they consumed and that maybe, you know,
- 35:57because of the limitation of the sites, you did
- 36:00not get to discover? Because, you know, it's
- 36:04It feels like it's really wide ranging the kinds
- 36:08of plants they were eating. So I'm thinking maybe
- 36:11it was not limited to that. Great question. Definitely
- 36:16they consume more. Definitely. Because, as I
- 36:21mentioned, starches found in specific plant parts.
- 36:26And the starches are not familiar with all kinds
- 36:29of plants. There are plants, for example, the
- 36:32mole leafy. with leaves, plants with leaves,
- 36:38that you consume the leaves, so leaves not produce
- 36:42starches for storage. The starch that I'm talking
- 36:47about is starch for storage, not starch for energy
- 36:51that every plant produce for its energy. So starch
- 36:56is a storage source, not all of the plants create
- 37:00it. So they create sometimes oils and fats, and
- 37:03sometimes also allium, the different kind of
- 37:05sugar. So, and we can find on the site different
- 37:11kinds of plants in the macro remain now. We're
- 37:15talking about plants that live after the seeds
- 37:20and grains, but those kinds of remains are, well...
- 37:27Let us know about huge range of plants and huge
- 37:30range of other plant parts. For example, the
- 37:33fruits, as I mentioned, and other kinds of seeds
- 37:36and grains that mostly go through fire. So we
- 37:42can talk also about your example that I didn't
- 37:44found in the starch. They have starches, but
- 37:49I didn't found the starch of them in the percussive
- 37:52tools, but they are called how they call, I just
- 37:58forget the name for now, but they are kind of
- 38:02small popcorn that they are being sold now even
- 38:06today in India. And this is a species that extinct
- 38:09in Israel and all of the surrounding of, you
- 38:13know, the Eastern Mediterranean, but it's now
- 38:15lives only in India. And ancient remains of it
- 38:19discovered in Geshub not Yaakov. Again, seven
- 38:24780 ,000 years from now. So, yeah, fascinating,
- 38:30I guess. Yeah. Truly. And something else that
- 38:35strikes me about this is, like you said, there
- 38:39are many plants, the eight that are now extinct.
- 38:45And then there are others that we don't see as
- 38:48food. So basically 780 ,000 years ago, they had
- 38:53a more diverse, um, um, you know, plant food,
- 38:59um, um, cuisine than, than we do, because we're
- 39:03really limited on the kinds of legumes and, um,
- 39:08plant foods that we eat. Great. Definitely a
- 39:13great notice, I must confess. And also deals
- 39:18with, as probably you noticed already, with the
- 39:23agricultural revolution. And as also researchers
- 39:29in this period, I can say that we limited our
- 39:35plate. kind of eight founder crops. So these
- 39:42eight founder crops are the wheat, the barley,
- 39:45chickpea, lentils, baba bean, and the flax, and
- 39:50maybe I forgot someone in between, pea also,
- 39:54and chickpea. And these kind of species, those
- 39:58are the most common today to the region of the
- 40:00eastern Mediterranean. We can add them the maize,
- 40:06and also tomato and potato that came from the
- 40:10Americas, and we can add also mash bean and others,
- 40:20and rice of course from Asia. So it's a small
- 40:26group of plants, but these small groups of plants
- 40:30that were picked and create our small bag of
- 40:35plants that we are mostly consumed today, it's
- 40:38not what has happened back then. And maybe if
- 40:45you want, if we try to summarize it differently,
- 40:49maybe I can say that we reduced our preferable
- 40:55species of plants out of something that was big
- 40:59and huge And we domesticate those specific plants.
- 41:03It's not came from out of nowhere. It came from
- 41:05somewhere. The somewhere was, you know, back
- 41:08then that our ancestors knew all the surroundings,
- 41:12knew all the plants, all the, you know, the resources
- 41:16in large. And from them, they picked and, you
- 41:19know, reduced what we're using today. When I
- 41:24think about hunter -gatherers or gatherers, hunters,
- 41:29I always thought, you know, how can they find
- 41:33what they eat in the wild? And I realized now
- 41:38that I was thinking, how can they find bell peppers
- 41:41and potatoes and, you know, what we usually cultivate?
- 41:46But actually, you know, they were eating more
- 41:50different species and more diverse species than
- 41:54that. So of course they would find, you know,
- 41:59other things, other sources of food. If you don't
- 42:04widen your window of, you know, food available,
- 42:10plant food available, of course you would think,
- 42:14you know, they would never survive in the wild.
- 42:18Yeah, what we know today, just selective, you
- 42:22know, selectivity from what they knew. If I go
- 42:25back, so I always thought if I go back to those
- 42:30early people, I would find some bloodthirsty
- 42:34groups who had a really hard time surviving and
- 42:41Basically hunting all the time something like
- 42:45that cartoon. I don't know if you know it primal
- 42:48I think it won some awards but you know that
- 42:54Early human is just obsessed with hunting and
- 42:58it's all very bloody and violent But you know
- 43:03what you're describing is more of a community
- 43:07Just eating plants and cooking them together.
- 43:14I don't know, I get the feel of togetherness
- 43:18and peace from our ancestors that I did not get
- 43:24from mainstream culture, pop culture, our, you
- 43:30know, mainstream view of those ancestors of ours.
- 43:37Yeah, and this is connect for something else
- 43:39that I don't want to go inside, but actually
- 43:42this is what we have been, you know, weighed
- 43:46on like road to be looked to. And if we're, there
- 43:53is sentence that my lecturer used to say in our
- 43:57lectures every time almost and that we talked
- 43:59about the prehistory against our modern times.
- 44:03And he mentioned that if we can imagine clock,
- 44:07the picture of clock and Two seconds close to
- 44:1312 are the end of the life that we are know today
- 44:16about getting rich, achieve supplies, and living
- 44:22in buildings, wanting to buy a car or using a
- 44:26phone call. All of this that brought us to the
- 44:31agricultural revolution and from there to settle
- 44:35and to be more hunter. and to build the big houses
- 44:40and to be, to achieve to be, you know, more and
- 44:44more and more from all different kinds. And then
- 44:46I do not say that it's not good or good. I just
- 44:49mention it. So it's only to like in the time
- 44:53scale on the, you know, on the, on the timeline
- 44:56of all human species. When you took this, When
- 45:02you took us, where we are now in the modern life,
- 45:05it's only two seconds from all the clock. Like
- 45:09it's promissed from all the prehistory of the
- 45:13human species and what it's going through. And
- 45:18all the others, as you mentioned, it's the hunter
- 45:21-gatherer, or if you like, gatherer -hunters,
- 45:23yes, definitely. And these were communities that
- 45:27took each other, you know, to care about each
- 45:29other and treat each other and if I'll just throw
- 45:32here an anecdote, 30 ,000 years from now in a
- 45:40cave in Shanidar in Iraq, for example, there
- 45:43is an evidence for medicine treatment for people
- 45:48inside the cave. So you can see actually a bone
- 45:51that arrowhead embedded inside it. And then you
- 45:57can see this bone healed. someone needed to treat
- 46:02this person, to treat this species, to treat
- 46:06this individual. So these were communities that
- 46:12needed to take care of each other, needed to
- 46:16bring food to the ancient table together, no
- 46:22matter who went to collect, no matter who went
- 46:24to hunt, no matter... who bring, you know, other
- 46:28unorganic stuff like the tools that I told you
- 46:31when someone needs to produce tools. So it was
- 46:33kind of communities that work together. It's
- 46:36not just as we know from today that every individual
- 46:40is for itself. And I must add for this is that
- 46:45it was also diverse and the group was really
- 46:53much the center and not the individual. This
- 46:59is one thing, and then the second thing that
- 47:02I think it must be mentioned. Actually, I wonder
- 47:13how to say this, but you know what? Everyone
- 47:21needs to to take care to each other and to notice
- 47:25to see each other but yeah never mind it's not
- 47:30fixed in my mind right now and it seemed important
- 47:35yeah yeah well it's so important maybe we'll
- 47:40need to edit it after this but yeah never mind
- 47:46i just okay maybe that's talk about it off recording,
- 47:51if you want, because I'm curious. Let me ask
- 47:56you this about those people. And you alluded
- 48:01to it when you talked about how it's more collective
- 48:06and less about one individual. I always thought
- 48:09that if we were hunter societies, then, of course,
- 48:14we became very hierarchical and patriarchal because
- 48:19there are only a few of us who have the athletic
- 48:22abilities to hunt or, you know, to go after praise.
- 48:31And so if we depend on them to get our food,
- 48:36then they gain socially more power. I always,
- 48:41you know, thought of it that way. But if we depended
- 48:46not on hunters for our for sustaining ourselves,
- 48:50but actually on plants, and finding those plants,
- 48:54and then cooking those plants, the way society
- 49:00was built was much more equitable, and the distribution
- 49:06of responsibilities was much more fair, and I
- 49:11guess, because of that, maybe it was less hierarchical.
- 49:16Is that a good way of looking at things? A good
- 49:20analysis of social structures in prehistoric
- 49:25time? I think it's hard. I understand where you're
- 49:30going to, but I think it's hard to answer this
- 49:33in analytic, you know, tools or maybe in such
- 49:38a research. I think we should be more careful
- 49:41because, and I'll say while I'm saying this,
- 49:47so from what we can know from, you know, from
- 49:51ethnographical research, all of the kind of those
- 49:57activities will happen in those ancient sites
- 50:01if we, you know, throw it to the ancient times.
- 50:05all of the activities happened there were some
- 50:07groups so if you want well it's not that true
- 50:11to say you know that females were collected and
- 50:16the males were went out to hunter to hunt so
- 50:21it's not it's not true as we can see it also
- 50:23from ethnographical evidence but i'm not going
- 50:27there for you know for for that but i'm mentioning
- 50:33that some were specialized with Flint napping,
- 50:37some were specialized with wood making, some
- 50:40were specialized with creating, some were specialized
- 50:45with hunting, and some were specialized with
- 50:48gathering. And all of that needs to be done in
- 50:52a community, like in a complete community. You
- 50:55need all of these kinds of resources, activities,
- 50:59you need all of these kinds of persons to be
- 51:02able to live. and live properly. At some point,
- 51:07at some point, and this is also why I mentioned
- 51:10the two seconds theory in the clock, at some
- 51:14point this arrangement was disturbed. And there
- 51:20are a few, or maybe more than few, hypothesis
- 51:23in archaeology that combines also history and
- 51:28combined also A climate change and animal moving
- 51:33and all different kind of you know different
- 51:35kind of what is it. Why this arrangement was
- 51:41the why this you know all of this yeah you want
- 51:45the net of how things work all of the field.
- 51:50Since three point two million years from now
- 51:52since lucy the start of the crisis and up to
- 51:56the. 10 ,000 years from now for the agricultural
- 52:01revolution. So things will change. And I think
- 52:07that if we want to talk about kind of, if you
- 52:15would say, you know, something to wish for is
- 52:20the communities that we used to live like them.
- 52:24you know, the range of years from 3 .2 until,
- 52:28you know, 10 ,000 years from now. That it was
- 52:32a community that everyone took care about each
- 52:35other. And there is someone, and this is kind
- 52:39of, you know, this is cross -wide, all of the
- 52:42archaeologists and other hypothesis people, that
- 52:46something happened and disturbed this. And I
- 52:50think this is the thing that we need to take.
- 52:54If it's rather it's good or not, or trying to
- 52:57judge it, you know, it's not in our hands. This
- 53:01is what this is. I think the point that they
- 53:04want to bring. Yes, definitely. I am of the opinion
- 53:11that. it's not very interesting or useful to
- 53:17moralize everything. Let's just study it as it
- 53:21is and try to understand it instead of judging
- 53:24it. But yeah, it's interesting how you describe
- 53:30it and how there was this turning point in our
- 53:34history or prehistory that changed us as societies.
- 53:41Okay, I need to ask this before we stop the recording.
- 53:49What do you make of people who would say they
- 53:54could not be that relying on plants because plants
- 54:00do not offer enough nutrients for sustaining
- 54:05themselves. They need that animal protein. What
- 54:12do you make of that? So you kind of remind me
- 54:16what I wanted to say before. So it's great. Because
- 54:20as we're learning, as we're studying ancient
- 54:24societies, also today and also in archaeology.
- 54:28So you can see that there's a kind of percentages
- 54:34of how much we consume. how much they consume,
- 54:41plants or animals, or the combinations in between.
- 54:48And the research that I just read, and I think
- 54:55that it also became a consensus that there are
- 54:58some kind of periods around the year that are
- 55:02needed to be, that you need to eat a little bit
- 55:06more fat. and periods that you need to eat less.
- 55:10For example, the summer that you need to eat
- 55:12less, and the winter that you need a little bit
- 55:15more. But again, this research is specifically
- 55:18a research that I'm really interested with, and
- 55:22I like the claims there, is that they talk about
- 55:2670 % for plants and 30 % for meat and flushes
- 55:35and fatties. This is in the winter and 80 % and
- 55:3920 % in the summer. So I think you can understand
- 55:46from this the main bottom. So most of what we
- 55:54eat, I think is based on plants and all of other
- 55:58kinds of types and less of what I can say about,
- 56:03you know, probably you are not, but... others
- 56:06that less consume the other fatties and what
- 56:10needs to be for creating the body and to stay
- 56:18alive. But this, of course, in ethnographical
- 56:23societies, the research was on them. So I think
- 56:29we kind of have an answer. And of course, plant
- 56:34-rich. rich, really rich in proteins and don't
- 56:41conclude the carbohydrate unless I don't know
- 56:44if someone emphasized them. I don't know. Yes,
- 56:47I mean, as a vegan, I know that, you know, we
- 56:50can sustain ourselves with plants only. But it
- 56:54is beautiful to think that I could be invited
- 56:56by our prehistoric people to a meal and You know,
- 57:01again, as a vegan, I would be able to eat what
- 57:04they had because, you know, they had most of
- 57:09their cooking was plant based, which is incredible.
- 57:15And what do you make of the fact that, you know,
- 57:17because I think of my grandparents and their
- 57:21generation before mine, and they were also, you
- 57:26know, relying mostly on plant food. for them,
- 57:32you know meat was a plus something for special
- 57:37events or luxury and It's the case for many cultures
- 57:43and I'm finding out that you know, there was
- 57:47this reliance on plants mostly and animal proteins
- 57:52were just you know a plus Can we draw something
- 57:58like? a link from, you know, our prehistoric
- 58:02people to to our more recent ancestors, like
- 58:08some kind of not tradition. I'm also losing my
- 58:14word now. Let me let me try to help you. And
- 58:19there is one. Of course, we know this from historical
- 58:22documents about feasting about, you know, meat.
- 58:28made food or meals, you know, great meals for
- 58:31the king of this and the other king, or nevermind.
- 58:36But I can just bring an example from Epipoleolithic
- 58:41period site. It's called the Chilazon, Chilazon
- 58:45cave. It's also in Israel, the north of Israel.
- 58:49And in this site, what the excavator, Professor
- 58:53Leo Grossman found, with the excavators of course
- 58:58is that this cave was served as a shaman cave
- 59:02and shaman a burial cave for the shaman shaman
- 59:08i'm not going inside this it's worth to read
- 59:11about this about this rituals i think i think
- 59:15you will find it and all the audience also will
- 59:18find it interesting and they explain why why
- 59:21it's interpreted as shaman and I think it really
- 59:24is, although we are not like to combine between,
- 59:26you know, kind of modern thoughts and throw it
- 59:32to the ancient things, but it's worth to read.
- 59:35And then she found evidence about feasting. So
- 59:41it's really high cave that it's really hard to
- 59:46climb to there. And inside the cave, there were
- 59:50three Three cattles. Three cows inside it that
- 59:58they were butchered and they were consumed. And
- 1:00:03it was one level of, you know, one level size.
- 1:00:08So it means that probably that some kind of butchering,
- 1:00:12the butchering is of course, but maybe also the
- 1:00:14feasting. Maybe they consume the meat that they,
- 1:00:17you know, the cattle that they butchered. And
- 1:00:20it's around the ceremonial thing around the burial
- 1:00:33of the shaman. So you can see evidence, I guess
- 1:00:38you can use it as an evidence for eating meat
- 1:00:42in special events, also in prehistory, although
- 1:00:46it's really in the edge between you know, the
- 1:00:49prehistory and actually before the agricultural
- 1:00:52revolution and after the agricultural revolution.
- 1:00:55It's really, you can point it as the dot. And
- 1:01:00I think it's pretty interesting. And again, it's
- 1:01:03an evidence. I want to also to mention something
- 1:01:07about the, you mentioned before, you know, really
- 1:01:09fast, you said those primitive, you know, ancient
- 1:01:14mans. But I think it's worth to, to open it a
- 1:01:18little bit and they think from what we discussed
- 1:01:21all of the conversation that we have now today
- 1:01:25is that we can learn that maybe we are the primitive.
- 1:01:29Maybe we are the primitive that think that what
- 1:01:33we have in our plate and when we go to the grocery
- 1:01:36shop and buy what we need. Maybe this is primitive
- 1:01:41and not to go out and maybe not to involve with
- 1:01:44other activities, not to participate in gathering
- 1:01:47if you want or other resources that we want to
- 1:01:50bring outside and not open our eyes to the surroundings
- 1:01:54and to understand what we have, how much material
- 1:01:58we have and we can have in our hands. And I think
- 1:02:02maybe we are the primitive and not them. And
- 1:02:06I must, yeah. I think those are great parting
- 1:02:12words. I really loved this conversation. Such
- 1:02:18a treat. And my vision of our early ancestors
- 1:02:23has really changed because of you. They're less
- 1:02:27scary now. And life during prehistoric time sounds
- 1:02:34less awful. You know, they had those hospital
- 1:02:38caves and, you know, churches caves and they
- 1:02:44ate water lily for breakfast. So it seems cool.
- 1:02:49I mean, that's, that's a life. Definitely, I
- 1:02:55must, you know, just to be more specific, they
- 1:02:58used any kind of resources. Everything that they
- 1:03:02could use, so they say why not. Of course, they
- 1:03:09did not have the luxury of like us, you know,
- 1:03:12to... to yeah if they had to eat animals of course
- 1:03:17they would um it's uh it's understandable and
- 1:03:22uh you know i'm not trying to say that our early
- 1:03:25ancestors were vegans or something like that
- 1:03:28of course not but the fact that they relied that
- 1:03:32much on on plant based you know goes against
- 1:03:36most of what i was taught and what I watched
- 1:03:41on TV and read about, any work of fiction too.
- 1:03:47It's not the, but you have shown that it's not
- 1:03:51the reality, it's not the truth. So yes, very,
- 1:03:56very interesting and very grateful for that conversation.
- 1:04:03Hadar, thank you so much. Did you want to add
- 1:04:05something? Thank you everyone for listening.
- 1:04:15I kindly invite you to share this podcast with
- 1:04:17the vegans you know. Let's encourage more people
- 1:04:20to take action. Again, thank you so much for
- 1:04:24caring and I will see you next Tuesday for a
- 1:04:27new episode.