Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Why AppLovin Crashed Despite 84% Margins?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today is Wednesday, February
- 0:0311th, 2026 and I have to be honest with you, if you have
- 0:07been glued to your portfolio tracking app for the last 48
- 0:11hours, you are probably nursing a bit of a headache.
- 0:15Yeah, a headache is putting it mildly.
- 0:17The market is, well, confused. Feels like an understatement.
- 0:22It feels a bit like we're all watching a movie where the sound
- 0:24is out of sync with the picture. You see one thing, but you hear
- 0:27something totally different. That's a very good way of
- 0:30putting it. It's a strange morning.
- 0:32We are seeing a disconnect that, you know, usually only happens
- 0:35once or twice a cycle. A real dislocation.
- 0:37Right. I mean, usually the math is
- 0:38simple. Good news, equal stock goes up.
- 0:41Bad news, Equal stock goes down, but today we are looking at a
- 0:44company that just reported what I can only describe as God tier
- 0:48numbers. Not an exaggeration.
- 0:50I'm talking about the kind of earnings report that usually
- 0:52results in champagne corks popping on the trading floor and
- 0:55analysts tripping over themselves to upgrade their
- 0:56price targets. But if you look at the chart, it
- 0:59looks like a crime scene. It really does.
- 1:01It is a classic violent collision between fundamental
- 1:05brilliance, what the business is actually doing, and technical
- 1:09breakdown, what the traders are feeling.
- 1:12And right now, the feeling is fear.
- 1:14Exactly. So today we are putting on our
- 1:17detective hats. We are diving deep into a love
- 1:20incorporation ticker symbol AP, and I can already hear some of
- 1:25you groaning. I can hear the collective sigh
- 1:28through the headphones because you're thinking, wait, isn't
- 1:30that the mobile gaming company? The guys who make those little
- 1:33puzzle games my aunt plays for six hours a day.
- 1:35And if you are thinking that you are already walking into the
- 1:38trap, that is mistake #1 As of right now, February 2026, if you
- 1:43still classify Aplavin as a gaming studio, you are looking
- 1:46at a ghost. A ghost.
- 1:47That company functionally doesn't exist anymore.
- 1:50They perform surgery on themselves.
- 1:52That is the first layer of the onion we have to peel back.
- 1:54This isn't a gaming company. It hasn't been one for a while,
- 1:57really. This is a pureplay AI money
- 1:59machine. But here is the hook, and here's
- 2:02why this matters to your wallet. Right now.
- 2:05The stock is trading somewhere in this volatile range of what,
- 2:08$456 to $472? It has been an absolute rocket
- 2:14ship for the last two years. I mean vertical, but recently.
- 2:18It cracked. It didn't just crack, it
- 2:20shattered. It crashed right through its 200
- 2:23day moving average. It triggered the dreaded death
- 2:25cross. Which is a phrase that sounds
- 2:26like heavy metal lyrics, but for those who don't spend their days
- 2:29staring at Candlestick charts, it is actually quite
- 2:31significant. It's a.
- 2:32Big deal. It's usually the bell tolling
- 2:34that the party is over. It signifies a long term shift
- 2:38in momentum from bullish, which is, you know, greed, to bearish,
- 2:42which is fear. So that is the tension we are
- 2:44living in today. On one hand, we have a company
- 2:46printing cash with 84% EBITDA margins, which by the way sounds
- 2:51completely fake and I want to fight you on that number later.
- 2:54We could definitely fight about it.
- 2:55It's a fun number to argue about.
- 2:57And on the other hand, the market is treating it like it's
- 2:59radioactive. The central question for this
- 3:02hour is simple. Is this a clearance sale on a
- 3:05Ferrari engine or are we looking at a value trap?
- 3:10Is the market waking up to a fatal flaw that the dazzling
- 3:13numbers are hiding? It is the ultimate bull versus
- 3:16bear debate. Is it a toll bridge that prints
- 3:19money just by existing, or is it a treadmill where they have to
- 3:22Sprint at Olympic speeds just to stay in the same place?
- 3:25We are going to unpack all of that.
- 3:27We have a mountain of sources today, Deep value intelligence
- 3:30reports, financial research requests and the Q 4/20/25
- 3:34earnings transcript, which just dropped yesterday.
- 3:36Fresh off the presses. But before we get into the weeds
- 3:39of Apaloven, we need to adjust the broader context, because you
- 3:42cannot analyze a stock in a vacuum, right?
- 3:45When you see volatility like this, when you see a stock with
- 3:47perfect numbers getting hammered, you need to know which
- 3:49way the wind is blowing and the water market.
- 3:51Context is everything. If the whole house is burning
- 3:55down, it doesn't matter how nice your furniture is.
- 3:57You need to know if the temperature of the entire market
- 4:00is rising. Is it a fire or is it just your
- 4:02toaster that's smoking? Precisely and Speaking of
- 4:05temperature, for those of you trying to figure out if we are
- 4:08in a bubble or a bust to track total market temperature,
- 4:12welcome to search and download iOS app Buffett Indicator from
- 4:17Apple App Store. It is a crucial tool for days
- 4:20like today. It really is.
- 4:21It helps you see if the overall market is overheated, which
- 4:25gives you a clue as to whether a sell off is specific to the
- 4:29company. Meaning, you know, app lovin did
- 4:31something wrong. We're just part of a broader
- 4:33correction where the baby is getting thrown, thrown out with
- 4:35the bathwater. Right, so let's start with the
- 4:38mission statement. For this deep dive, we're going
- 4:41to take this confusing mess of data and run it through three
- 4:43specific filters to see if we can find the truth.
- 4:46I like this approach. We are going to look at it
- 4:47through the Warren Buffett value framework, we're going to look
- 4:51at it through the Peter Lynch growth lens, and we're going to
- 4:54look at it through the Stanley Druckenmiller macro perspective.
- 4:57The Holy Trinity of investing styles.
- 5:00You have the patient accumulator, the grow hunter,
- 5:02and the macro shark. Three totally different ways of
- 5:04looking at the same problem. Exactly.
- 5:07And by the end of this hour, we want to answer one question.
- 5:09Is Applevin a buy, a sell or a watch?
- 5:13But we have to start with the identity crisis because you said
- 5:16earlier that thinking of them as a gaming company is looking at a
- 5:18ghost. Walk us through that.
- 5:20How do you go from making match 3D to being an AI infrastructure
- 5:25play? OK, so to understand the numbers
- 5:27we saw yesterday, you have to rewind the tape to mid 2025.
- 5:32That was the pivot point, the critical moment, the inflection.
- 5:36Historically, Apple oven was this strange hybrid.
- 5:38There were a 2 headed monster. On one side they had this ad
- 5:41tech software, the boring plumbing stuff.
- 5:44From the other side, they owned a massive portfolio of mobile
- 5:47games. Right, I remember that they were
- 5:49spending huge amounts of money developing content, marketing
- 5:51games, hiring artists, trying to get you to download Wordscapes.
- 5:55Exactly. And that is a really, really
- 5:57hard business. It's capital intensive.
- 5:59It is. I mean, making games is hard.
- 6:01It's like making movies. You have hits, you have misses.
- 6:04You spend $10 million on a game and nobody downloads it.
- 6:08Precisely. It is a hit driven business.
- 6:11You could have a great quarter and then a terrible one.
- 6:14And the market hated the inconsistency.
- 6:16It dragged down their valuation for years.
- 6:19They were being valued like a gaming company, not a software
- 6:22company. Which is a much lower multiple.
- 6:24A much, much lower multiple. But in 2025 they made a massive
- 6:28surgical strategic move. They decided to amputate the
- 6:32limb. A bit dramatic, but I like it.
- 6:34Well, it was. They divested their apps
- 6:36segment, the entire gaming studio to a company called
- 6:39Triple dot Studios. They sold it for $400 million
- 6:43and took an equity stake. Oh, on $400 million?
- 6:45That seems low considering how much revenue those games
- 6:49generate. That feels like they sold it for
- 6:50pennies on the dollar. It might seem low if you just
- 6:53look at the top line revenue, but remember revenue and gaming
- 6:56is low quality if it costs you a fortune to generate it.
- 6:59OK. It's about the margin.
- 7:01It's all about the margin. They basically cut off their
- 7:03right arm, but it was the heavy, expensive arm that was weighing
- 7:06them down in the water. They shifted from being a
- 7:09content creator, which is hard, to a pureplay software platform.
- 7:13They kept the brain, which is their AI engine, and they sold
- 7:17the body. So they went from being Netflix
- 7:19spending billions on shows to being the Internet provider that
- 7:22Netflix runs. On that is a very, very good
- 7:25analogy, yes. And that brings us to yesterday,
- 7:28February 11th, 2026, the Q 4/20/25 numbers.
- 7:32I was reading the earnings transcript and the CEO, Adam
- 7:35Forrey, he didn't just sound happy, he sounded vindicated.
- 7:38Vindicated. I like that.
- 7:39Like a guy who told everyone the world was round when they all
- 7:42said it was flat and he just watched the ship sail back into
- 7:45the harbor. Well, let's look at the proof,
- 7:46the numbers that made him so happy.
- 7:48Revenue came in at $1.66 billion for the quarter. 1.66 billion.
- 7:53That is up 66% year over year. That's massive of growth for a
- 7:57company this size. But revenue is just the top line
- 8:00vanity metric, right? Revenue is vanity.
- 8:02Profit is sanity. Cash is king.
- 8:03It's an old saying because it's true.
- 8:05OK, well, the net income is what caught my high initially, $1.1
- 8:10billion, up 84% year over year, which is also incredible.
- 8:14But the number that made me spill my coffee, the number I
- 8:17actually circled in red ink on the report, is the Adjusted
- 8:20EBITDA margin, 84 percent. 80, Yeah. 4.
- 8:25Percent stop right there. Can we just sit with that for a
- 8:27second? 84% margin?
- 8:29That sounds like a scam. That sounds like a Ponzi scheme.
- 8:31How does a legitimate business keep 84 cents of every dollar
- 8:35before interest and taxes? It's a fair question.
- 8:37It feels like a typo. It does.
- 8:39Apple doesn't do that. Microsoft doesn't do that.
- 8:41Visa, which is basically a digital tollbooth, doesn't do
- 8:44that. How is this possible?
- 8:45It is startling, isn't it? But it's not a typo.
- 8:47And this is where the divestiture comes into play.
- 8:49When they sold the gaming studio, they flushed all the low
- 8:52margin revenue out of the system, all that expensive hit
- 8:55or miss stuff. What is left is the software
- 8:58platform, and software specifically this kind of AI
- 9:01driven ad tech has incredible unit economics.
- 9:04But 84% help me visualize that, give me some context.
- 9:07OK, think about the rule of 40 in sauce.
- 9:10In the software as a service world, investors use this little
- 9:13heuristic, this rule of thumb. Right, I've heard this.
- 9:15If your annual revenue growth rate plus your profit margin
- 9:18equals 40, you're considered an elite company.
- 9:22So if you grow 20% and have 20% margins, you are a star.
- 9:27The venture capitalists love you.
- 9:29OK, so 20 + 20 is 40 simple enough?
- 9:32So what's Applevins number? Well, Applevins is growing at
- 9:3666% and their EBITDA margin is 84%.
- 9:40So 66 + 84, that's a 150. They are operating at the rule
- 9:44of 150 in a completely different stratosphere.
- 9:47This is what we call software royalty territory.
- 9:49It means their costs are almost entirely fixed.
- 9:51Fixed costs, so they built the machine and now it just runs.
- 9:54They have the servers, they have the algorithms, they have the
- 9:56engineers, but it doesn't cost them an extra dime to process
- 10:00the next billion ad requests. So for every extra dollar they
- 10:02bring in, almost all of it drops straight to the bottom line.
- 10:05The report mentions operating leverage.
- 10:08That's the fancy term for it, right?
- 10:10Exactly. Operating leverage is when your
- 10:12revenue grows much faster than your expenses.
- 10:15App lavens revenue is skyrocketing, but their expenses
- 10:18are flat. That gap between them is pure,
- 10:22beautiful profit. And it's not just accounting
- 10:24profit, it's real cash. The report says there's a 95%
- 10:28flow through from EBITDA to free cash flow.
- 10:31What does that mean in plain English?
- 10:33That is the magic number. A lot of companies show profit
- 10:35on paper, but they have to spend it all on new factories or
- 10:38inventory or whatever. Right, capital expenditures.
- 10:41Applavin doesn't need factories. They don't have inventory
- 10:43rotting in a warehouse. They just run the code.
- 10:46So out of that, call it $1.4 billion in EBITDA, $1.31 billion
- 10:51of it became actual spendable cash in just one quarter. 1.3
- 10:56and 1 billion in cash in 90 days.
- 10:59Staggering isn't. It that is staggering.
- 11:01That is a lot of dry powder. But let's move from the what to
- 11:04the how, because you can't just wave a magic wand and get 84%
- 11:07margins. There has to be a machine doing
- 11:09the work. And the sources keep mentioning
- 11:11the thing called a Exxon. Yes, a Exxon, specifically a
- 11:15exon 2 point O, and now we're hearing about the evolution to
- 11:18three-point O. This is the engine under the
- 11:20hood. This is the brain.
- 11:22The notes describe it as the Google Ads for the app economy,
- 11:27but that feels a bit abstract. What does it actually do?
- 11:29Is it just matching keywords like old school search ads?
- 11:32No, no. It's much more sophisticated
- 11:34than keywords. It's prediction.
- 11:36It's behavioral prediction on a massive scale.
- 11:39OK, unpack that. Think about the ecosystem.
- 11:41You have millions of apps, games, utilities, shopping apps.
- 11:46You have millions of advertisers who want to reach customers, and
- 11:49you have billions of users. The advertisers have a huge
- 11:52problem. They don't just want downloads.
- 11:53Right, because I download stuff all the time, play it for 5
- 11:55minutes and delete it. I am a worthless user to them.
- 11:58Exactly, you are a churn statistic, a waste of their
- 12:01marketing budget. They want the whales.
- 12:04They want the person who downloads Clash of Clans and
- 12:06spends $500 on gems, or the person who downloaded a shopping
- 12:09app and actually buys the shoes. They want the spenders.
- 12:12They want the spenders, and finding those people is like
- 12:14finding a needle in a global haystack.
- 12:16So Axon is the metal detector. Axon is a magnet.
- 12:20It uses machine learning to predict with extreme accuracy
- 12:25not just who will click an ad, but who will transact, who will
- 12:29spend money. It analyzes thousands of data
- 12:32points, your device type, what other games you play, how long
- 12:36you play them, your battery level, your location.
- 12:38A battery level serially. Everything.
- 12:41Maybe people with low battery are more likely to make
- 12:43impulsive purchases because they want to finish the level before
- 12:45the phone dies. Who knows, The AI knows.
- 12:48The point is, it builds a profile of a spender and then
- 12:51finds other people who look just like that.
- 12:53And because App Levin owns the mediation platform, which we
- 12:56need to discuss, they have a massive amount of data to train
- 12:59this brain. That's the key.
- 13:01That's the secret sauce. This is the flywheel concept
- 13:04mentioned in the outline. Talk about that.
- 13:05What's the flywheel? Is the classic data flywheel a
- 13:08self reinforcing loop? It works like this.
- 13:10More developers use their mediation platform, which is
- 13:13called MSO, to sell their ad space.
- 13:15This gives Applavin more data on what ads perform well and who
- 13:19clicks them. That fire hose of data makes
- 13:22Axon smarter and better at predicting.
- 13:24So more data, smarter brain, right?
- 13:26And because Axon gets smarter, the advertisers who use it get a
- 13:30better return on ad spend, or ROAS.
- 13:33For every dollar they put in, they get more back.
- 13:35They spend more money. They pour their budgets into the
- 13:38system that works. And because advertisers are
- 13:40spending more, developers make more money, which attracts even
- 13:44more developers to the Max platform.
- 13:46And the whole thing just spins faster and faster.
- 13:48More developers, more data, smarter AI, better results, more
- 13:52ad spend. Wow.
- 13:54It is a beautiful, powerful perpetual motion machine.
- 13:58And look at these revenue numbers.
- 13:59It's clear it is working. The advertisers are voting with
- 14:02their wallets. It feels like they have built a
- 14:04perfect money printing machine but and there is always a but on
- 14:07this show otherwise it would just be a fan.
- 14:09Club there is always a but if it were this easy, everyone will be
- 14:12doing it. The story would be too good to
- 14:14be true. If everything is so perfect, if
- 14:16the numbers are this good, why is the stock chart screaming
- 14:19emergency? Why is the price crashing?
- 14:22Why are the technicals broken? This brings us to the core
- 14:25debate, the Moat. The Moat.
- 14:28Is this thing a toll bridge or is it a treadmill?
- 14:30This is where the bull and the bear analysts in our reports
- 14:34start throwing punches. This is the heart of the
- 14:37argument. Let's start at the bull
- 14:38argument, the data monopoly. We mentioned they own a thing
- 14:42called Max. Explain Max to me like I'm 5 or
- 14:46maybe like I'm a slightly slow 12 year old.
- 14:48OK, imagine an auction house. Let's say you are a game
- 14:52developer. You made a cool puzzle game.
- 14:54You have a blank space in your game where you want to show an
- 14:57ad to make money. My in game billboard.
- 14:59Your in game billboard. Exactly.
- 15:01That blank space is valuable real estate.
- 15:03You want to sell that billboard space to the highest bidder for
- 15:07every single person who sees it. OK.
- 15:09I want top dollar. Right.
- 15:10In the old days you use something called a waterfall.
- 15:13It was really dumb. You would call up Google and say
- 15:16will you pay $5 for this ad impression?
- 15:19If they said no, you'd call Facebook and ask will you pay
- 15:21$4.00? It was slow, inefficient, and
- 15:24you left a ton of money on the table.
- 15:25MMX changes that. Max is what we call unified
- 15:29bidding. It's a real time auction where
- 15:31everyone yells their price at the exact same millisecond.
- 15:35Google Meta, Unity and critically, Aploven's own ad
- 15:38network Max is the auctioneer. It sees all the bids instantly
- 15:43and picks the winner. The highest bidder gets to show
- 15:46their ad. And Applevan owns the
- 15:47auctioneer. They own the auctioneer.
- 15:49And here is the kicker. Here is the part that should
- 15:51make you sit up straight. Applevan also has its own bidder
- 15:54in the room. Wait, pause.
- 15:55If I own the auction house and I'm also bidding on the items,
- 15:58can I see what everyone else is bidding?
- 16:00Bingo, you've got it is a massive, massive competitive
- 16:03advantage. The technical term is
- 16:04information asymmetry. That feels almost unfair.
- 16:08Because they run the auction through Macs, they see everyone
- 16:11else's cards. They see what Google is willing
- 16:13to pay for you specifically. They see what Unity thinks you
- 16:16are worth. They see the entire data flow of
- 16:19the mobile advertising world. And they use that privilege
- 16:22information to train Axon. So they are playing poker, but
- 16:26they have mirrors behind everyone else's chairs.
- 16:29That's a great way to think about it.
- 16:31In business, unfair advantage is just another word for Mote, and
- 16:36the bull argument is that Max has over 60% market share.
- 16:40It's the dominant platform. So most of the data flows
- 16:42through them. And once a developer installs
- 16:44the Max Software Development Kit, the SDK, into their game,
- 16:48it is very, very hard to RIP it out.
- 16:50It's like the plumbing in your house.
- 16:51It controls their revenue. You don't mess with your revenue
- 16:54stream unless you have a really, really good reason to.
- 16:57That creates incredibly high switching costs.
- 17:00OK, I see the bull case. It's strong.
- 17:02It sounds like a toll bridge. A toll bridge is the best
- 17:04business in the world. You build it once and then
- 17:07everyone has to pay you to cross it forever.
- 17:09You just sit there and collect the cash.
- 17:11That is the bull case in a nutshell, a digital toll bridge
- 17:15on the app economy highway. But the bear case, and this is
- 17:18from the SAFE analyst in our notes, disagrees fundamentally.
- 17:21OK, let's hear it. They argue this isn't a toll
- 17:24bridge, it's a treadmill, and it's a treadmill located on
- 17:27someone else's property. The rented land theory.
- 17:29Exactly. The toll bridge, like the BNSF
- 17:31Railway that Warren Buffett owns, makes money because it
- 17:35owns the land of the tracks. It's a physical monopoly.
- 17:38Nobody can build another railroad next to it.
- 17:40It's durable. Applavan, however, operates
- 17:42entirely inside the Apple iOS and Google Android ecosystems.
- 17:46They are a tenant, not a landlord.
- 17:49They are a tenant and the landlords, Apple and Google are
- 17:53not friendly landlords. They are powerful and they are
- 17:56capricious. They can change the locks
- 17:58whenever they want. In fact, they have done it
- 18:00before. You're talking about the
- 18:01apocalypse a few years ago. IDFA.
- 18:03IDFA, the identifier for advertisers.
- 18:07We have to remember the trauma of 2021 and 2022.
- 18:10It sent shockwaves through this whole industry.
- 18:12Remind me what happened exactly? Apple basically flipped a switch
- 18:15and said apps can no longer track users across other apps
- 18:19unless the user explicitly agrees.
- 18:21And of course, when given the choice, most users said no
- 18:24thanks. I remember that pop up ask app
- 18:26not to track. I clicked it every single time
- 18:29without thinking. Everyone did, and it decimated
- 18:32the ad tech industry. It was like someone turned off
- 18:34the lights. Facebook lost $10 billion in
- 18:36revenue, they said. Snap Pinterest Unity stock
- 18:40collapsed. The signal went dark.
- 18:42The advertisers were flying blind.
- 18:44But Apple and survived. In fact, they thrived after an
- 18:47initial dip. Why?
- 18:49How did they manage? That because they were ahead of
- 18:51the curve, they had already been building a Exxon 2 point O,
- 18:54which use what's called probabilistic modeling instead
- 18:56of deterministic tracking. They were guessing who you were
- 18:59instead of knowing for sure, and their guesses were better than
- 19:01anyone else's so. They adapted.
- 19:03They adapted brilliantly, but the bear argument is the risk
- 19:07didn't go away. Apple could introduce Private
- 19:09Relay for everyone. Google's rolling out their
- 19:12Privacy Sandbox on Android, which is their version of the
- 19:15same thing. The landlords are always
- 19:17renovating. So if Apple decides tomorrow
- 19:20that probabilistic modeling is against the rules, if they find
- 19:24a way to block that too. Then Akon's key stops working,
- 19:28the lock changes, and Apple then has to scramble to invent a new
- 19:32key that is the treadmill. So the treadmill analogy means
- 19:36you have to keep running just to survive.
- 19:38You can never rest. Yes, because you don't control
- 19:41the platform. You have to constantly out
- 19:43innovate the restrictions. You have to be smarter than
- 19:46thousands of Apples privacy engineers.
- 19:48You have to be faster than Google's policy changes.
- 19:50You are sprinting at full speed just to stay in the same place.
- 19:54And the bear argument, to quote the report, is we are betting
- 19:57that management can outpace the global tech ecosystem
- 20:00indefinitely. That sounds exhausting.
- 20:03That is a venture capital bet. That is not a value investment.
- 20:07A value investor wants a business that works even if the
- 20:09management team goes on vacation for a year.
- 20:12A business with adorable Moat. If Appleman's management stops
- 20:15innovating for six months, or if they miss one critical policy
- 20:18update from Apple, the algorithm degrades and the entire business
- 20:22could be in jeopardy. That is a terrifying thought.
- 20:25When you put it that way, you are betting on the jockey, not
- 20:28the horse, because the track owner hates the horse and keeps
- 20:32changing the rules of the race. You are betting on the jockey
- 20:35winning the Kentucky Derby every single day forever, while the
- 20:39track owner is out there at night digging potholes in your
- 20:42lane. OK, well, Speaking of the
- 20:43jockey, let's talk about the man in the saddle, because if the
- 20:47bet is on the leadership, we need to know who they are.
- 20:50This brings us to the segment I like to call the cannibal.
- 20:54The cannibal. It sounds sinister, doesn't it?
- 20:57Like a horror movie villain. It does, but in finance, it's
- 21:00actually a term of endearment, at least for some.
- 21:03It refers to a company that eats its own shares, a company that
- 21:06aggressively buys back its own stock.
- 21:08And Applevin is practically feasting on itself.
- 21:11They certainly are. And the pilot here is Adam
- 21:13Forgey. He's the CEO and Co founder and
- 21:16we have to give credit where it's due.
- 21:18This guy is not a hired gun. He's not a suit who came in from
- 21:21another company. He's a founder.
- 21:22He's a founder. He has serious skin in the game.
- 21:25He owns about 10.9% of the company.
- 21:28At current prices, that's worth roughly $15 million.
- 21:30That is a lot of skin and interestingly I was looking at
- 21:33his compensation package. It's 96% stock and performance
- 21:37bonuses. He isn't taking a massive cash
- 21:40salary. He only gets rich if the
- 21:42shareholders get rich. That is usually the gold
- 21:44standard for alignment. We want CEO's who think like
- 21:48owners because they are owners. Their incentives are our
- 21:51incentives. So let's look at what he's doing
- 21:52with that $1.31 billion in cash. We talked about that quarterly
- 21:56gusher of cash. He isn't sitting on it.
- 21:58In 2025, they repurchased $2.58 billion worth of stock. 2 1/2
- 22:03billion dollars. It's a massive amount of capital
- 22:06return to shareholders. And they have authorization to
- 22:09buy another $3.3 billion. So the bull view is this is
- 22:12genius. They generate so much cash they
- 22:14don't need it for operations. Remember, no factories to build.
- 22:18So they are increasing our slice of the pie with every share they
- 22:21buy. It shows massive confidence.
- 22:23It's the classic Henry Singleton playbook from Teledyne back in
- 22:26the day. Explain that.
- 22:27Teledyne is the classic example of a cannibal stock.
- 22:30The CEO, Singleton realized his stock was chronically
- 22:34undervalued by the market, so he used all the company's cash flow
- 22:38to just buy back shares. He bought back 90% of the
- 22:41company over time and the remaining shareholders became
- 22:44fabulously wealthy. That is the bull view.
- 22:48We believe in our future so much we are buying ourselves.
- 22:52But the bear view? Well, let's bring in Warren
- 22:54Buffett again. Buffett loves buybacks, but only
- 22:57under one very specific, very important condition.
- 23:00Price. It always, always comes back to
- 23:02price. Buybacks are only accretive to
- 23:04shareholder value if you are buying the stock for less than
- 23:07it's intrinsically worth. If you were buying a dollar for
- 23:10$0.50. And if you're not?
- 23:11If you're buying a dollar for $2.00, you are destroying value.
- 23:14You are literally taking cash out of the company's bank
- 23:16account and setting it on fire. And Appluvin has been buying
- 23:20back stock while it was trading at all time highs.
- 23:22We are talking about buying back stock AT506070 times earnings at
- 23:27over 100 times book value. This is where the reckless label
- 23:30comes in, from the Bayer analysts.
- 23:32Think about it this way, If the stock is actually worth say
- 23:35$195, which is what some of the more conservative discounted
- 23:38cash flow models suggest, and Adam Forrey is buying it back at
- 23:43$472 using our shareholder cash. He is lighting our money on
- 23:47fire. He is incinerating it.
- 23:49He is permanently destroying shareholder capital.
- 23:52For every share he buys, he takes $472 of cash in the
- 23:57company bank account, buys one share and rips it up.
- 24:01If that share was really only worth $195, the company just
- 24:04lost $277 on the transaction. It's like buying a house for $1
- 24:09million that is really worth $400,000 and patting yourself on
- 24:12the back for owning more real estate.
- 24:14That's a perfect analogy. It doesn't make any sense.
- 24:16But why would he do that? He owns 10% of the company.
- 24:19If he incinerates cash, he burns his own money too.
- 24:22He's not stupid. What's the counter argument?
- 24:24That is the counter argument. He must believe the stock is
- 24:26worth significantly more than $472.
- 24:29He must believe the growth is going to continue at such a pace
- 24:32that today's rice will look cheap in hindsight.
- 24:35He's making a statement Or and is it the cynical view he's
- 24:38caught U in the momentum? It's hard to be disciplined when
- 24:41everyone tells you you're a genius and your stock is up 300%
- 24:44in a year. Hubris is a real risk for any
- 24:46successful CEO. And buybacks also do what to the
- 24:49stock price? They support it.
- 24:51They create a constant bid in the market.
- 24:53There's always a buyer. Some bears argue it's a form of
- 24:55financial engineering to keep the momentum going.
- 24:57If that bid disappears. If they stop buying, the floor
- 25:01might drop out. So we have a cannibal strategy
- 25:04that is either the sign of a supreme compounder with
- 25:07incredible foresight or a sign of a reckless top ticking
- 25:11management team. We need to figure out which one
- 25:13it is. And that leads us directly to
- 25:15the valuation. Is this Ferrari too expensive?
- 25:18Let's look at the sticker price. As of this morning, the market
- 25:20cap is around $154.5 billion. The PE ratio is hovering around
- 25:2553 point 7X or 60X trailing 12 months depending on how you
- 25:29slice it. That is rich.
- 25:31The S&P 500 average is usually around 2025 X.
- 25:34It is a premium valuation, no doubt about it, but the bulls
- 25:38will tell you you have to pay a premium for this kind of growth,
- 25:42which brings us to the PEG ratio.
- 25:44Price to earnings growth, it's sitting at 1.34.
- 25:47Now for our listeners, usually a peg under one point O is
- 25:50considered cheap. One point O is fair value.
- 25:53So 1.34 is a little on the pricey side but not insane.
- 25:57Exactly, 1.34 is actually quite attractive for a company growing
- 26:01this fast if you compare it to other high Flyers like a
- 26:03palantir or a snowflake or NVIDIA at their peaks. 1.34
- 26:07isn't astronomical if and it is a massive capitalized bold faced
- 26:12if you believe the growth holds. Let's run it through our three
- 26:14filters. First, the Buffett filter.
- 26:17Would the Oracle of Omaha buy this?
- 26:19Buffett would likely pass, and he'd probably pass in about 5
- 26:21minutes. 1st circle of confidence AD tech is
- 26:25notoriously unpredictable and complex.
- 26:27It's a black box of algorithms. Buffett like simple businesses
- 26:30he can understand by looking at. Them railroads, insurance,
- 26:33candy, furniture, not AI algorithms that are totally
- 26:35dependent on iOS privacy settings.
- 26:37Exactly 2nd and this is the big one, margin of safety.
- 26:41Buffett wants to buy a dollar for $0.50 at 53 times earnings.
- 26:44Aplavin is priced for perfection.
- 26:47What does that mean? Priced for perfection.
- 26:49It means the market is assuming nothing will ever go wrong.
- 26:53It's assuming growth continues at this breakneck pace.
- 26:55Margin stayed 84% and Apple never changes the rules again.
- 26:59There is no safety net built into the price.
- 27:01So if earnings missed by a penny or if growth slows from 66% to
- 27:05say 40%, which is still amazing growth by any standard, the
- 27:09stock gets crushed. Gets annihilated correct when
- 27:12you are priced for perfection. Anything less than perfection is
- 27:15a disaster. The discounted cash flow models
- 27:18in our report, even the optimistic ones, suggest a fair
- 27:21value closer to 227 to 340 dollars.
- 27:24So we are trading at, let's call it $460.
- 27:27The fair value is maybe $280 on a good day.
- 27:30That is a big gap that is a long way down.
- 27:31It is a massive premium. You are paying for the AI
- 27:34euphoria and the story, not just the current cash flows.
- 27:37OK, so Buffett is out. He's not even looking at it.
- 27:39What about Peter Lynch, the invest in what you know guy but
- 27:43also the JRPAC guy growth at a reasonable price?
- 27:45Lynch might actually be intrigued by this.
- 27:47He'll have the fast grower category.
- 27:49These are the companies that could be 10 baggers.
- 27:52And if you look at the forward-looking PEG ratio using
- 27:54next year's estimated earnings, it drops to around .54.
- 27:58Whoa, 0.54 That is deep value territory for Peter Lynch.
- 28:03A peg that low implies the earnings are going to
- 28:05practically double next year. It does.
- 28:07It implies massive acceleration is still ahead.
- 28:10Lynch would say, look, they're growing at 66%.
- 28:13Paying 50X earnings is fine if they can keep it up.
- 28:15He famously said he'd rather buy a company with a high PE and
- 28:18high growth than a low PE and no growth.
- 28:21So Lynch might be nibbling here. OK.
- 28:24And our third filter, Stanley Druckenmiller, A macro guy.
- 28:27Druckenmiller focuses on the inflection.
- 28:30He wants to catch a company when the business model fundamentally
- 28:32changes for the better. He doesn't care about the past
- 28:35five years. He cares about the next 18
- 28:37months. And selling the gaming studio to
- 28:39become a high margin capital light software platform that is
- 28:43a textbook inflection point. It's the definition of an
- 28:46inflection. Margins jump from 30% to 84%.
- 28:50That is a structural change, not a blip.
- 28:52It changes the DNA of the stock. Druckenmiller would likely be
- 28:57very interested in the story, but he would be watching the
- 28:59macro environment and the chart like a hawk.
- 29:01And the macro environment brings us back to the chart.
- 29:04The technical warning, we mentioned the death cross
- 29:06earlier. Let's dig into that.
- 29:07Yes. So the price, which is around
- 29:09$472 today, has fallen below the 200 day simple moving average
- 29:14which is sitting up at 502 dollars.
- 29:16Why does that matter? It's just a line on a chart.
- 29:19Fundamental investors usually laugh at technical analysis.
- 29:21They call it astrology for men. It matters because of who owns
- 29:25the stock. It's not just you and me.
- 29:27It's massive institutional funds, pension funds,
- 29:29algorithmic trading pods. And these massive entities have
- 29:33strict risk management rules. Rules that are programmed into
- 29:36computer code. Exactly when the price breaks
- 29:39the 200 day moving average, it is a big red flag for many of
- 29:42them. It triggers automatic sell
- 29:44orders. It's a psychological line in the
- 29:45fan. It signals that the long term
- 29:48trend, which has been powerfully up, is now potentially down.
- 29:51So the momentum traders are leaving the building, the hot
- 29:54money is getting out. They are rushing for the exits.
- 29:58They don't care about the 84% margin.
- 29:59They don't care about the PEG ratio.
- 30:01They care that the line on their screen is pointing down.
- 30:05And this is where the danger lies for the dip buyer.
- 30:08Go on. You see the stock drop from a
- 30:10high of say 730 to $470 and you think, wow, it's on sale, time
- 30:15to buy the dip. But if the momentum is broken,
- 30:18it could go much much lower before it finds a bottom.
- 30:21Our expert note here says value investors catch falling knives
- 30:25only when the floor is concrete. I love that line.
- 30:28It's a great line because it's true.
- 30:30If you buy a real estate company and the stock crashes, you can
- 30:33look at balance sheet and say well the buildings are worth X,
- 30:35we can liquidate the buildings. There's a concrete floor of
- 30:38asset value. Apple ovens floor is algorithms
- 30:41and platform permissions. Those are intangible.
- 30:44If the sentiment shifts, if people stop believing the story,
- 30:47there is no hard asset to stop the fall.
- 30:50Exactly, If people stop believing in the AI story, the
- 30:53floor isn't at $400.00. It isn't at $300.
- 30:56It might be all the way down to $100.
- 30:58It's a story stock. And when the story breaks, look
- 31:01out below. So we have a broken chart, a
- 31:03dazzling income statement and a valuation that requires you to
- 31:06believe in miracles. But companies don't stand still.
- 31:10They have to grow. Where does this go from here?
- 31:12What is the future? That's the billion dollar
- 31:15question. They can't rely on mobile games
- 31:17forever. The mobile gaming market is
- 31:18huge, over $100 billion, but it's maturing.
- 31:22It's not growing at 50% a year anymore.
- 31:24They need new frontiers to conquer.
- 31:26And there are two big growth levers mentioned in the reports,
- 31:29e-commerce and connected TV. Let's start with e-commerce.
- 31:33E-commerce is the logical next step.
- 31:34It's about using the Akon engine to sell physical products, not
- 31:38just app installs. So moving beyond the App Store.
- 31:40Right. Imagine you are scrolling
- 31:43through a news app and Axon knows you just looked at running
- 31:46shoes on a different site an hour ago.
- 31:49It shows you a highly targeted, compelling ad for those shoes.
- 31:53You like this game? You'll love these sneakers.
- 31:56It's applying their prediction engine to the entire world of
- 31:59online shopping. That seems like a massive
- 32:01market, but the one that really seems to excite the bulls is
- 32:05connected TV, or CTV. They acquired a company called
- 32:08World to get into the space. CTV is the Holy Grail of
- 32:12advertising right now. Think about it, we all stream
- 32:14TV, Netflix, Disney Plus, Hulu, YouTube TV.
- 32:18But the ads on TV are they're dumb.
- 32:20They are terrible. I see the same car insurance ad
- 32:2310 times in a row during a football game.
- 32:25It's annoying and I already have car insurance.
- 32:27It's annoying and it's incredibly wasteful.
- 32:29It's the old spray and pray method from the 1960s.
- 32:32Advertisers pay to show the ad to everyone, hoping that someone
- 32:35watching actually needs a car. Apple Oven wants to bring the
- 32:38precision of mobile performance marketing to the biggest screen
- 32:41in your house. So Agathon would predict what TV
- 32:44show I want to watch and serve me a targeted ad based on my
- 32:47interest, just like on my phone. Not just that, this is the key
- 32:50part. They want to close the loop on
- 32:52attribution, meaning they want to prove the ad worked.
- 32:55The dream is you see an ad for a pizza on your TV during the
- 32:59show, AQR code pops up, you scan it with your phone and you buy
- 33:03the pizza right there. Applivin can then go to Domino's
- 33:06and say, see our ad on that TV show directly caused this sale.
- 33:11If they can solve that, if they can prove that the TV ad caused
- 33:15the sale, the total addressable market, the Tam, absolutely
- 33:18explodes. But right now is world making
- 33:21money? Is this a real business yet?
- 33:23It's a rounding error. Compared to the mobile business,
- 33:26it's tiny. It's a venture bet inside a
- 33:27giant company. If it works, the stock is
- 33:29probably cheap even at today's prices.
- 33:32If it fails, then the core business better keep growing
- 33:34like a weed because the stock is expensive.
- 33:36And remember, tracking on TV is hard.
- 33:38There are no cookies on ATV. So after all this digging, all
- 33:42this debate and we have to land the plane, we have to come to a
- 33:44conclusion. What is the verdict?
- 33:45The report has a status of Watch.
- 33:48I agree with the watch rating. I think it is the only
- 33:50responsible rating right now. Explain that why not sell if the
- 33:54chart is broken and the valuation is sky high, why not
- 33:57just dump it and run away? Because the business quality is
- 34:00undeniable. You can't ignore it. 80 4%
- 34:02margins are so rare they're unicorns.
- 34:04You do not short a company with 84% margins and a founder LED
- 34:07team that executes this well, you will get your face ripped
- 34:10off. The earnings powers is just too
- 34:12strong. OK, so too good to bet against
- 34:14but you don't BUY? Not here, Not a $470.
- 34:18The price is hostile. There is simply no margin of
- 34:21safety. If you buy at $472, you are
- 34:24paying full retail price for a car that might have a serious
- 34:27systemic recall. You are betting that nothing
- 34:30goes wrong in a business where things can go wrong very, very
- 34:33quickly. So we wait.
- 34:34We sit on our hands. What are we waiting for?
- 34:37We are waiting for the fat pitch.
- 34:38The report suggests a target entry price of somewhere in the
- 34:41range of 280 and 80 dollars, 320.
- 34:43Dollars. That seems far away.
- 34:45That's another 3040% drop from where we are now.
- 34:47That requires some serious patience.
- 34:49The stock might never get there. It might not, and if it doesn't,
- 34:52we miss it. And that's OK.
- 34:54That's the discipline of value investing at $280.
- 34:57The hype is gone, the momentum traders are gone, the AI
- 35:01tourists have left, and you are paying a reasonable multiple for
- 35:04the incredible cash flow. You are avoiding what I like to
- 35:07call the stupidity tax. The stupidity tax.
- 35:10I love that buying the top because of FOMO, fear of missing
- 35:14out is the ultimate stupidity tax.
- 35:16So while we watch, what do we monitor?
- 35:18What are the signposts that would make us change our minds?
- 35:21Three things for me. One, does the software platform
- 35:24revenue keep growing above 30%? If that slows down
- 35:27significantly, the growth thesis breaks.
- 35:30OK #2. Two, do they keep buying back
- 35:32stock? If the price drops to $400.00
- 35:35and they suddenly stop buying, it tells you they were just
- 35:37propping up the price before. If they buy more aggressively as
- 35:40it drops, that is a powerful sign.
- 35:42It shows true conviction in their own valuation and degree.
- 35:45The CTV experiment, we need to see proof that Axon works
- 35:49outside of the walled garden of mobile games.
- 35:51We need to see world revenue start to actually matter on the
- 35:54income statement. We need to see that growth liver
- 35:56start to fire. OK, so let's wrap this up.
- 35:58We have Appleoven. It's a Ferrari engine, an
- 36:01incredible piece of technology, but it's inside a chassis.
- 36:05They don't own the Apple and Google ecosystem.
- 36:08It's an incredible machine. It generates a massive, almost
- 36:11unbelievable amount of cash, but it is trading at a price that
- 36:15demands perfection in a world that is very, very imperfect.
- 36:19The risky analyst in our notes mocks waiting.
- 36:21They say you'll miss the boat. The train is leaving the
- 36:24station, but the SAFE analyst says I'd rather miss the boat
- 36:28than sink on it. Investing is a no called strike
- 36:31game. That's the beauty of it.
- 36:32That's Buffett's great insight. You can stand at the plate with
- 36:34the bat on your shoulder for years.
- 36:36The pitch at the market can throw pitches AT470460450
- 36:40dollars. You don't have to swing.
- 36:41You can wait for your pitch. You can wait for 280.
- 36:43Dollars. Here's a final thought for you
- 36:44to Mull over as we close out. We talked about the cannibal, we
- 36:47talked about the buybacks. If Ablavin is generating so much
- 36:50cash, $1.3 billion a quarter and growing, and they can't deploy
- 36:56it into R&D because the business is so efficient, and if the
- 36:59stock price stays too high to buy back effectively, what do
- 37:03they do with all that money? That is the ultimate dilemma of
- 37:06success, the problem of too much cash.
- 37:09Do they have to become a dividend payer?
- 37:11It's a real possibility. And if a high growth AI company
- 37:14starts paying a dividend, does that kill the growth narrative?
- 37:18Does it signal to the market that the hyper growth phase is
- 37:21over? That is the question.
- 37:23When you win the game, what do you do with the prize money?
- 37:26If they start paying a dividend, the growth investors might flee
- 37:30and the value investors might finally enter.
- 37:33It would be a complete changing of the guard for their
- 37:35shareholder base. Something to think about while
- 37:37you stare at that confusing chart.
- 37:39Before we go, a reminder that full Deep Value Research reports
- 37:43can be found in the description links.
- 37:44Absolutely dig into the numbers yourself.
- 37:46Don't take our word for it, form your own opinion.
- 37:49All analysis is based on publicly available sources and
- 37:52may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 37:55The content is for educational purposes only and does not
- 37:59constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 38:02before making investment decisions.
- 38:05If you want to access more advanced contents, welcome to
- 38:08subscribe on Deepvalues dot AI. We will share our latest
- 38:11researches and the most advanced AI agent tools for our
- 38:14contrarian friends. Don't forget to like this video.
- 38:17Much appreciated. Thanks for listening everyone.
- 38:19See you on the next deep dive.