Latest / Kentucky Tonight / General Assembly Policy Priorities and the State Budget
Transcript
- 0:09Kentucky. Tonight I'm Renee
- 0:10Shaw. We thank you so much for
- 0:12joining us this evening. We
- 0:13continue our coverage of the
- 0:152026 Kentucky General Assembly
- 0:16in regular session. The session
- 0:18began last Tuesday. It's a 60
- 0:20day session that will include
- 0:22work on Kentucky's two year
- 0:24budget. But there is so much
- 0:25more. Powell lawmakers address
- 0:27child care in the state, and
- 0:28what are the chances lawmakers
- 0:29will take up Governor Andy
- 0:31Beshear? Perennial call for
- 0:33universal pre-K for four year
- 0:34olds. Will Kentucky take
- 0:36another stab at redrawing
- 0:37congressional boundaries, as
- 0:38other states have done, looking
- 0:40to do or have rejected? And
- 0:42what about the big concerns
- 0:43around K through 12? Education?
- 0:45Banning DEI addressing funding
- 0:47disparities, splitting up the
- 0:48state's largest school district,
- 0:50and even handling violent
- 0:51students in the classroom. With
- 0:53close to 500 bills already
- 0:54filed at the end of day five of
- 0:56the 60 day session. What are
- 0:58legislative leaders top items
- 1:00on their to do list? We'll ask
- 1:02them. We've got four
- 1:03legislative leaders in our
- 1:04Lexington studio tonight. State
- 1:06Senator Robert Stivers, a
- 1:07Republican from Manchester and
- 1:09Senate president, state Senator
- 1:12Cassie Chambers Armstrong, a
- 1:13Democrat from Louisville and
- 1:14Senate minority whip, state
- 1:17Representative David Osborne, a
- 1:18Republican from prospect and
- 1:19House speaker. And state
- 1:22Representative Lindsay Burke, a
- 1:23Democrat from Lexington and
- 1:24House Minority Caucus chair. We
- 1:26certainly want to hear from you
- 1:27tonight. You can send your
- 1:28questions and comments by X.
- 1:30Formerly known as Twitter, at
- 1:32Pub Affairs KET. You can send
- 1:33an email to KY Tonight at
- 1:35Keturah or use the web form at
- 1:38Keturah KY Tonight. Or you can
- 1:41give us a call the good old
- 1:43fashioned way at one
- 1:45(800) 494-7605. Well welcome
- 1:46everyone, ladies and gentlemen.
- 1:48Feeling pretty good on day
- 1:49going on day six. Feel great.
- 1:51Feel great game day. Yeah. So
- 1:54far so good. Things are good.
- 1:55Well let's just talk about I
- 1:57asked the group last week about
- 1:58the new chambers and how that's
- 2:00affecting things. And of course
- 2:01that was the eve before you got
- 2:02in there. So, speaker Osborne,
- 2:04how are you feeling about the
- 2:05new chambers? And do you think
- 2:07it's going to help with
- 2:08expediting the flow of
- 2:10legislation and conversation
- 2:11this session at all?
- 2:12>> You know, it's different.
- 2:13And I guess there's certainly
- 2:16it's nice to have heat that
- 2:17comes on and and off when you
- 2:20ask it to. It's nice to have
- 2:21good lighting. It's nice to
- 2:22have internet access. All those
- 2:25things are, are are nice. But
- 2:28it's it's just not the same.
- 2:30And because there is something
- 2:33about walking into the halls of
- 2:34the Capitol building that that
- 2:37inspires you and, and I think
- 2:39it, it, it drives home to, to
- 2:43everybody of, of all political
- 2:45persuasions, the importance of
- 2:48the work that we do. It's
- 2:50really difficult to find that
- 2:52inspiration in the halls of the
- 2:53new chamber. It really is. So
- 2:55as I continue to tell our
- 2:56members, you know, find your
- 2:58inspiration from from outside
- 2:59because you're not going to
- 3:01find them in that room. But the
- 3:02work that we will do is every
- 3:04bit as important. And we have
- 3:07to we have to take it that way.
- 3:09But it's it's just a building.
- 3:11>> Yeah. Thank you. President.
- 3:13What do you agree with that.
- 3:15>> Yeah. It's pretty dull and
- 3:18ours is smaller. So it it's
- 3:20created a little bit of
- 3:22logistical problems. Probably
- 3:24the one positive is it's not as
- 3:27far as a walk from our main
- 3:29offices to our temporary
- 3:32chambers. But I agree, when you
- 3:34walked in in the rotunda, past
- 3:37the governor's office, the
- 3:38attorney general's office, up
- 3:40the second floor where the
- 3:42Supreme Court is, and then to
- 3:44the third floor where the
- 3:45respective chambers are. If you
- 3:47didn't get a certain sense of
- 3:50awe about man, we're here. This
- 3:52is this is a big deal. Because
- 3:54it is. So it's it just doesn't
- 3:59have that aura about it that
- 4:03the Capitol has.
- 4:04>> And for many lawmakers, they
- 4:06may never return to the Capitol.
- 4:08Now we're going to call it the
- 4:09new old Capitol, since we have
- 4:11an old state capitol.
- 4:13>> Jimmy Higdon will finish his
- 4:15career. That's right. There
- 4:17will probably be other people
- 4:18who will finish their careers,
- 4:19never going back to the old
- 4:22Capitol.
- 4:22>> And their capacity that
- 4:23they're in now. That's correct.
- 4:24So how do you all view it? Does
- 4:26it feel different to you and is
- 4:28different bad?
- 4:29>> So I'll say I miss the
- 4:30people. For me, it's not so
- 4:32much about the building, but I
- 4:33miss when you walk into the
- 4:35Capitol. The Capitol belongs to
- 4:36the people. And whether it's a
- 4:38school group that's there
- 4:39getting a tour, whether it's
- 4:40just people milling about, just
- 4:41sort of taking care of their
- 4:43business. I miss seeing the
- 4:44people because now we can go
- 4:45from the annex to the chambers
- 4:47without seeing anyone other
- 4:48than staff and other elected
- 4:49officials. And I understand
- 4:50there are logistical reasons,
- 4:51and it's a smaller chambers and
- 4:53sort of dealing with all the
- 4:54realities that we have to deal
- 4:56with, but it makes you feel a
- 4:57little more siloed, makes you
- 4:59have to work more to continue
- 5:00to feel connected to the people
- 5:02that we represent and the
- 5:03people that we serve.
- 5:04>> Yeah. Do you see it that way,
- 5:06Representative Burke?
- 5:06>> I do, I think I agree with
- 5:08everyone who has weighed in so
- 5:10far, because it's true that
- 5:11this new space has lots of
- 5:13bells and whistles that are a
- 5:14pleasant addition, but it lacks
- 5:16the gravitas of the Capitol
- 5:19we're used to. And I hope as
- 5:21session goes on and more people
- 5:22start showing up for different
- 5:24lobby days and things like that,
- 5:25that will get some of that
- 5:27hustle and bustle that makes
- 5:28being in the Capitol such a
- 5:30pleasure.
- 5:31>> Well, and perhaps when the
- 5:32committee schedule picks up a
- 5:33little bit more earnestly, and
- 5:35we know that from looking at
- 5:36the calendar on both the House
- 5:38and Senate, there's an hour
- 5:40scheduled for committee
- 5:41hearings as opposed to two
- 5:43hours in the past. So I want to
- 5:45ask, what is the intention
- 5:47behind kind of abbreviating
- 5:49that committee hearing time,
- 5:51and do you think it will
- 5:52expedite action?
- 5:54>> I don't know what the House
- 5:55committee hearings are. We we
- 5:57tried to pick and choose based
- 5:59on prior history, which
- 6:01committees took longer and and
- 6:03looked at giving them better
- 6:06positions, better timing. You
- 6:07know, naturally, in a budget
- 6:09session, the appropriations and
- 6:10revenue and the transportation
- 6:12chair are going to have a lot
- 6:14longer type of hearings and
- 6:15more access to committee rooms.
- 6:16But that's it's nothing in
- 6:20particular. It's just that we
- 6:21wanted to try to make sure
- 6:23there was ample time, but not
- 6:25wasted time.
- 6:25>> So is it a way to kind of
- 6:27take we've got 500 bills and
- 6:29counting and it's going on day
- 6:30six. Is it a way to kind of say,
- 6:32these are going to be where
- 6:34we're going to spend our time
- 6:35on these priority measures.
- 6:37>> And actually think, if you
- 6:38look back at our previous
- 6:39calendars, we've always had two
- 6:40hour blocks that we've tried to
- 6:42narrow it down to to one hour
- 6:44meeting times. We are still on
- 6:45two hour blocks for for
- 6:47committee assignments. We meet
- 6:48at eight, ten and 12 on Tuesday,
- 6:51Wednesday and Thursday. That is
- 6:54so since we are in kind of a
- 6:58state of of change a little bit,
- 7:01it's so everybody knows from
- 7:02from 8:00 until 9:00 they're
- 7:04going to be in there. It may
- 7:07spill over from time to time.
- 7:08And certainly there's the
- 7:10ability to do that. But it's
- 7:11trying to to focus. Our bodies
- 7:13work more than anything.
- 7:15>> So I mentioned and you want
- 7:16to comment on that real quick.
- 7:17>> I was just going to say one
- 7:19thing that I like to keep in
- 7:21mind and remind folks is
- 7:22efficiency is not always the
- 7:23most important value when we're
- 7:25legislating. So whenever we're
- 7:26legislating, it's not just
- 7:27about how quickly can we get
- 7:28things done, how quickly can we
- 7:30move things along? Legislation
- 7:32by design is supposed to be a
- 7:33little clunky, because you're
- 7:34supposed to have people with
- 7:35different opinions and ideas,
- 7:37and really everyone having the
- 7:38opportunity to come in and feel
- 7:39heard and be heard and express
- 7:41their opposition. And so that's
- 7:42something that I hope as we
- 7:44shift schedules and our in new
- 7:46chambers and all of that, that
- 7:47yes, efficiency is important,
- 7:49but it's not always the most
- 7:50important thing. The most
- 7:51important thing is making sure
- 7:52that people really are
- 7:54represented and feel
- 7:55represented. And so I hope we
- 7:56can keep that in mind as the
- 7:58session moves forward as well.
- 7:59>> So one of the issues that
- 8:01we've heard about and in other
- 8:03states is about redistricting.
- 8:03Representative Burke and I know
- 8:05that there is a plan and by
- 8:06House Democrats to address this,
- 8:08or a couple of them have filed
- 8:09legislation to deal with this,
- 8:11we know that Texas has gone
- 8:14ahead with this. Florida is
- 8:15considering it, possibly in
- 8:16this regular session or in a
- 8:17special session that the
- 8:19governor calls. Indiana has
- 8:21rejected the idea, but
- 8:22California went ahead. And this
- 8:23is all about maybe the push to
- 8:25shore up some of those seats in
- 8:27the midterm elections and
- 8:29prospects for GOP. So tell us
- 8:31about the idea that has come
- 8:33across from your caucus to deal
- 8:35with the whole debacle over
- 8:37mid-decade redistricting.
- 8:39>> Yes. Well, Representative
- 8:41Anne Dunworth of Lexington has
- 8:42filed a bill that is modeled
- 8:44after how Lexington City
- 8:46Council's redistricting process
- 8:49occurs involves creating a
- 8:52nonpartisan commission and
- 8:54utilizing commission
- 8:56recommendations so that this
- 8:57redistricting process is not
- 8:59politicized and seized upon by
- 9:02either party. I think you can
- 9:04look to states like Michigan
- 9:05for a similar model. There are
- 9:08places all over the country
- 9:09that utilize these nonpartisan
- 9:12commissions, and I think that
- 9:13that's really what our our
- 9:15constituents would want us to
- 9:16do. They expect us to meet
- 9:19their needs. And when we're
- 9:21fighting over things like how
- 9:23many congressmen, sorry, how
- 9:27many districts where the
- 9:28districts are, those are not
- 9:29the things that our
- 9:31constituents are asking of us.
- 9:32They're not what we need. And
- 9:34so I hope that we won't be
- 9:35focused on that during this
- 9:36session when we have so many
- 9:38other important things like the
- 9:39budget to deal with.
- 9:40>> Is there an appetite in
- 9:42either Senate or House
- 9:43leadership to do mid district
- 9:45mid decade redistricting?
- 9:50>> Oh, you want to start. You
- 9:51want.
- 9:52>> Me to look? We've had no
- 9:53conversation about it quite
- 9:54frankly. You know, I will point
- 9:56out that, you know, there's
- 9:59been exactly one redistricting
- 10:01plan in the last 40 years. It
- 10:03was found to be
- 10:04unconstitutional. I mean, to be
- 10:05constitutional. Excuse me. And
- 10:06that was the one we passed this
- 10:08past in 2022. I guess it was.
- 10:13And, you know, we're proud of
- 10:14that. We're proud of the fact
- 10:16that we did it right. And the
- 10:19courts affirmed that we have,
- 10:22frankly, had the only place
- 10:25that I have heard the concept
- 10:27of redistricting has come from
- 10:29outside sources. Quite frankly,
- 10:30I haven't heard it from
- 10:32majority, minority, Senate,
- 10:34House. You know, there's
- 10:35speculation because it has been
- 10:36a national news item. But but
- 10:39as far as our conversations
- 10:40have gone, it's just it's not
- 10:42been an issue.
- 10:44>> Nothing. Burger in the
- 10:45Senate.
- 10:46>> No. And I came just after
- 10:48the redistricting. I was a
- 10:49product of redistricting. And I
- 10:51go back and I've given people
- 10:53the history lessons. They like
- 10:55to talk about how the
- 10:56Republicans created the first
- 10:58congressional district. But if
- 10:59you look at 92, that district
- 11:01was created by the Democrats to
- 11:03look like that, and the second
- 11:05district was created to look
- 11:06like that because they were
- 11:08trying to beat Hal Rogers in
- 11:09the fifth district. So they
- 11:11moved a lot of his constituents
- 11:13out to try to beat him, putting
- 11:15him into Old Seventh. Well,
- 11:17when it came back, they moved
- 11:19enough Republicans into
- 11:20district one to district two
- 11:22that then it allowed Ron Lewis
- 11:23and Ed Whitfield to get elected,
- 11:25and they didn't beat
- 11:27Congressman Rogers. So instead
- 11:29of sweeping the board, they
- 11:31split the board. And so I think
- 11:33the same type of thing from a
- 11:35history lesson, you got to be
- 11:36careful what you do. If you're
- 11:38being political. From that
- 11:39perspective, you take the most
- 11:41heavily Democratic district in
- 11:42the area and start diluting it
- 11:44in an effort to to to take it
- 11:46out. You may wind up losing a
- 11:48couple of your seats because
- 11:49you then made a base. And I'm
- 11:52talking pure politics. You made
- 11:54a base mad. That will come out
- 11:56and, you know, vote to elect
- 11:59their person. So there's not
- 12:00been any discussion among my
- 12:02group, nor have I had any calls
- 12:04from anybody. But actually, I
- 12:06did have a call with some
- 12:08people out of the white House.
- 12:09I told them, I don't think this
- 12:11is a good idea, and they've
- 12:12never heard from them at any
- 12:14time since.
- 12:14>> Push on that. Not at all.
- 12:16Resistance. All right. Let's
- 12:17talk about pre-K. I think we're
- 12:19all on one accord on pre-K,
- 12:20right. So last week we carried
- 12:24the governor's state of the
- 12:25Commonwealth and Budget address,
- 12:26and he again made the push for
- 12:28this time $40.5 million in the
- 12:31fiscal year beginning July 2027
- 12:33for the initial phase of pre-K
- 12:34for all program, which would be
- 12:36implemented over the course of
- 12:37of several years. And then we
- 12:39heard the governor at the
- 12:40Kentucky Chamber dinner where
- 12:42you all attended, and you two
- 12:43spoke, where he reminded
- 12:45lawmakers that back in the year
- 12:472016, when then Governor Matt
- 12:48Bevin, a Republican, was
- 12:50governor, there was he had
- 12:52vetoed a measure that would
- 12:53have expanded preschool
- 12:55eligibility to kids up to 200%
- 12:57of the federal poverty level,
- 12:59up from 160%. The Senate voted
- 13:03for that. Then. Senator Stivers,
- 13:06what was your position back in
- 13:082016, and how does that look
- 13:10similar or different than your
- 13:11position now?
- 13:12>> Well, I've never been a big
- 13:13supporter of universal pre-K,
- 13:15and I don't remember that in
- 13:172016. But to me, it is the
- 13:22agreement on daycare. The need
- 13:23for quality daycare is not the
- 13:26issue, it is what quality
- 13:27daycare looks like. And we know
- 13:29it's an impediment to some
- 13:32people getting back into the
- 13:34workforce. But when you start
- 13:36thinking about placing this
- 13:39universal pre-K with the K
- 13:42through 12 system, then it has
- 13:44a lot of logistical problems.
- 13:47And I heard from
- 13:49superintendents and other
- 13:50people just recently when we
- 13:51had snow days. Who makes the
- 13:53decision for that school board
- 13:55employee to come in and work?
- 13:57Well, they've got to work. If
- 13:59that hospital worker is going
- 14:00to go or the person at the
- 14:02grocery store is going to go to
- 14:04work, they have to be there.
- 14:05They can't take off those days.
- 14:07And those are the examples that
- 14:08people call me back and say, we
- 14:10don't know how this works
- 14:12logistically. If you make it a
- 14:14school function and it's
- 14:16different. In Clay County or
- 14:20Owsley County than it is in
- 14:22Louisville, as to what a
- 14:23daycare model should look like.
- 14:26>> What what would it look like
- 14:27in Louisville? And do you see
- 14:29some credence in what President
- 14:30Stivers is saying in opposition?
- 14:31>> Well, we're finding out
- 14:33because Louisville is under the
- 14:35leadership of our mayor. We now
- 14:37have five by five, which is
- 14:39expanding opportunities for
- 14:40early learning to every child.
- 14:41And I will say, I agree that
- 14:44daycare access is important,
- 14:45but I actually don't like the
- 14:46term daycare because I think it
- 14:48minimizes what we're talking
- 14:49about. What we're really
- 14:50talking about are early
- 14:51learning opportunities for
- 14:52children, for our littlest
- 14:53learners. As a parent of a
- 14:55preschooler, I see every day
- 14:57the way that it impacts him and
- 14:59the things that he learns and
- 15:00the way he came home the other
- 15:02day and explained surface
- 15:03tension to me. He is four years
- 15:05old and came home and explained
- 15:06surface tension to me. And we
- 15:09know when we look at the data
- 15:10that those early learning
- 15:12opportunities, whether we're
- 15:12talking about two year olds,
- 15:13three year olds, four year olds,
- 15:16we get back whatever we invest
- 15:17into it. And sure, are there
- 15:19logistics we have to work out.
- 15:21Absolutely. That's why the
- 15:22governor's pre-K for all
- 15:23advisory board has a whole
- 15:25bunch of members with a whole
- 15:26bunch of expertise to solve
- 15:28them. We can solve big things.
- 15:29I believe government can solve
- 15:30big things. We've done big
- 15:32things before, and investing in
- 15:34pre-K for all would be a game
- 15:35changer for Kentucky kids. We
- 15:37know that it impacts every
- 15:39outcome that we could care
- 15:40about. From crime rates to
- 15:42lifetime career earnings. We
- 15:43have a broad coalition of
- 15:45support, from businesses to
- 15:47parents to early childhood
- 15:49educators. I can't understand
- 15:50why we're not doing something
- 15:51about it.
- 15:52>> Well, Caleb Brown, who is
- 15:53CEO of the conservative group
- 15:55Bluegrass Institute for Public
- 15:56Policy Solutions, wrote a piece
- 15:58back in the fall that got
- 16:00printed in November, and he
- 16:02talked about this being an
- 16:04expensive experiment. And he
- 16:06said researchers from
- 16:07Vanderbilt University followed
- 16:083000 low income children
- 16:09through sixth grade with
- 16:11alarming results. Children who
- 16:12attended Tennessee's voluntary
- 16:14pre-K program fared worse on a
- 16:16range of metrics compared with
- 16:17children who didn't. The
- 16:19academic gains were that they
- 16:21observed in pre-K faded by the
- 16:23end of kindergarten. Even the
- 16:24worst negative effects grew
- 16:26larger over time. Children who
- 16:27were in pre-K program scored
- 16:29lower on achievement tests in
- 16:30both third and sixth grade
- 16:31compared to their peers who did
- 16:33not attend. And by the sixth
- 16:34grade, he said, pre-K attendees
- 16:36were more likely to be in
- 16:37special education. So when you
- 16:39hear those dire outcomes, what
- 16:42gives you confidence that
- 16:44Kentucky should proceed in a
- 16:45similar direction as Tennessee?
- 16:47>> Well, without looking at
- 16:48that specific research, I can't
- 16:51comment on the quality of the
- 16:53research that was used. What I
- 16:55do know is that there are many
- 16:57other studies that underscore
- 16:58the success that comes along
- 17:00with the investment and
- 17:02universal pre-K for all, and we
- 17:04can look at other states. So if
- 17:06we treat the idea as something
- 17:08that can be shopped in the
- 17:10laboratory of states, we can
- 17:11find successful examples all
- 17:13over the country where
- 17:15different state governments
- 17:16have cracked this nut. And are
- 17:18any of them perfect? No,
- 17:19they're probably not. But each
- 17:21one of them has created a
- 17:23structure. They've all been
- 17:24able to figure it out. They've
- 17:26each done it in their own way.
- 17:28And so Kentucky has the
- 17:29opportunity now to do it our
- 17:31own way. I think the governor's
- 17:33proposal of phasing it in
- 17:34slowly over time makes a lot of
- 17:36sense, because if we are
- 17:37looking at public school
- 17:39infrastructure, no, we can't go
- 17:41pre-K for all overnight. My two
- 17:43sons are both in a position
- 17:46where they could benefit if we
- 17:47would do this. Right now, my
- 17:49family pays as much for daycare
- 17:50as we do for our mortgage, and
- 17:53families just can't sustain
- 17:54that. I'm working two jobs. My
- 17:57husband's working another job.
- 17:58If we want families to go out
- 17:59and work 3 or 4 jobs, then they
- 18:01might be able to afford child
- 18:03care. But this program allows
- 18:05families to get back to work.
- 18:07It allows caring parents to
- 18:09know that their children are in
- 18:10a good place, that they're
- 18:12getting high quality. Education,
- 18:16and that they're being well
- 18:18cared for so that parents don't
- 18:20worry when they're at work.
- 18:22>> And school readiness has
- 18:23been one of the arguments for
- 18:24early pre-K, but you certainly
- 18:26don't want the kind of results
- 18:27that Tennessee is experiencing,
- 18:28because it doesn't seem like
- 18:29those kids are kindergarten or
- 18:31school ready. So quality is
- 18:34important.
- 18:34>> Quality is very important. I
- 18:35wonder about that study
- 18:37specifically. The thing that
- 18:38comes to mind for me is that,
- 18:41unfortunately, the social
- 18:42determinants of educational
- 18:43success that are set from the
- 18:45very beginning for most
- 18:47families, those are going to
- 18:48continue through life. So if
- 18:49you're born to a parent who has
- 18:52low educational attainment and
- 18:53just came out of the
- 18:55correctional facility when you
- 18:57were born, that's going to be
- 18:58true for the rest of your life.
- 19:01What we can do is try and
- 19:02monitor, use all the data
- 19:04sources, and do what we can to
- 19:05support families so that
- 19:06students have the best set of
- 19:08opportunities in front of them.
- 19:09>> Speaker Osborne what could
- 19:10be a possible solution to the
- 19:12childcare crisis in Kentucky if
- 19:13it's not universal pre-K?
- 19:15>> You know, as far as the
- 19:17universal pre-K conversation
- 19:19goes, I still haven't had a
- 19:20conversation with the governor
- 19:21on it. And I think that based
- 19:24on this last proposal, that
- 19:25really is not pre-K for all,
- 19:27it's pre-K for a few more. But
- 19:31I will well, I agree with the
- 19:33sentiment. I will disagree with
- 19:35with Senator Cassidy Armstrong.
- 19:38Chambers Armstrong, excuse me
- 19:40just a little bit. I think that
- 19:41there is a very distinct
- 19:43difference between early
- 19:44childhood education and
- 19:46childcare, and I think that
- 19:48each equally important, each
- 19:50vitally important to families
- 19:52across the Commonwealth. But,
- 19:54but but different. I mean,
- 19:56there are some incredible
- 19:57things going on in the early
- 19:58childhood education space that
- 20:01are showing phenomenal results.
- 20:03You look at the. The parents
- 20:08first teacher program that
- 20:11Arkansas has. It's making
- 20:13generational strides for for
- 20:15impoverished kids down there
- 20:16and impoverished families down
- 20:18there that we haven't even
- 20:19gotten to talk about here yet.
- 20:22But and then you look at some
- 20:24of the public private
- 20:26partnerships in, in childcare
- 20:28that Samara Heavrin has worked
- 20:29on continuing to work on, she's
- 20:31getting ready to to introduce a
- 20:33new measure regarding childcare
- 20:36and how the the public and
- 20:38private sectors can work
- 20:39together on that. I think that
- 20:40there's some some things that
- 20:41we can do. I think there are
- 20:43things we must do, but I don't
- 20:45believe that there's a
- 20:46tremendous amount of support
- 20:47for the the universal pre-K
- 20:50model.
- 20:51>> And if I could just respond,
- 20:52well, I would say that daycare
- 20:54is not the only form of early
- 20:56childhood education. It should
- 20:58always be early childhood
- 21:00education. When we talk about
- 21:01access to childcare, we've got,
- 21:02as you were pointing out, Renee,
- 21:04talk about access to high
- 21:05quality childcare. That means
- 21:08when that child is in that care
- 21:09setting, that child is being
- 21:11engaged, that child is learning,
- 21:12that child is benefiting.
- 21:13Because what we know, and I'm
- 21:15talking as a mom, parents
- 21:16aren't going to leave their
- 21:17kids in settings that they
- 21:18don't feel like are a good fit
- 21:20for their family, that they
- 21:21don't feel like are benefiting
- 21:22their child. And so we can
- 21:24really have a win win here. We
- 21:26can provide that care for those
- 21:27parents to go to work, to earn
- 21:29that income, to contribute to
- 21:30their communities. But we can
- 21:31also make sure that that child
- 21:33is learning things because it
- 21:34does take a village. It takes
- 21:36all of us contributing, helping
- 21:37our kids learn and grow. And so
- 21:40we really can't have a solution
- 21:41that benefits everyone in this
- 21:43situation.
- 21:43>> How much does the state pony
- 21:44up for such quality early
- 21:46learning experiences?
- 21:48>> Well, the question you know
- 21:49here, and I'm going to kind of
- 21:52digress to who did this study.
- 21:55Vanderbilt isn't Podunk
- 21:57University. It's got a
- 21:59tremendously good academic
- 22:01reputation. In fact, I believe
- 22:03that's the governor's alma
- 22:05mater, if I'm not mistaken. But
- 22:09to this and I'm going to back
- 22:12I'm a parent. I have four
- 22:13children. Thinking about what
- 22:17we did for our children. We had
- 22:20daycare of various sorts, but
- 22:21not universal pre-K. We didn't
- 22:24go to special classes and Clay
- 22:27County Manchester they've done
- 22:29all right. Master's level
- 22:32biomedical engineer, you know,
- 22:34marketing degree, you know,
- 22:36take take your choice. But I
- 22:39think when you look at that
- 22:40study, that study will tell you,
- 22:43because that studies a few
- 22:44years old, that study will tell
- 22:46you where the better emphasis
- 22:48is, is in that first, second,
- 22:50third and fourth grade year to
- 22:51make sure that they're on level
- 22:53at third and fourth grade, not
- 22:56pre first through four. And
- 22:58that's what that study reflects
- 23:00that kids be kids.
- 23:03>> So if I can just say I feel
- 23:05like someone needs to defend
- 23:06all the data supporting pre-K
- 23:07briefly. And I promise I won't
- 23:09run through all the studies.
- 23:11But there are places you can
- 23:12find them. There have been a
- 23:14lot of studies that have shown
- 23:15if kids have access to pre-K,
- 23:17they're less likely to become
- 23:18justice involved. If kids have
- 23:19access to pre-K, they have
- 23:20higher educational scores in
- 23:23third grade and in fifth grade.
- 23:25On reading and math. There have
- 23:26been studies that have shown
- 23:27that kids that have access to
- 23:29pre-K are more likely to
- 23:30graduate and more likely to
- 23:31have higher earnings throughout
- 23:32their careers. So there's a
- 23:33whole bunch of data. I haven't
- 23:35seen this particular study.
- 23:36I'll go read this particular
- 23:37study. It's going to take a
- 23:39whole lot of evidence to
- 23:41convince me that from what I
- 23:42have seen, that pre-K is not
- 23:44the best thing that we can do
- 23:46to invest in our children and
- 23:47in making sure that all of our
- 23:49children are ready to learn the
- 23:51first day they enter
- 23:52kindergarten. I will just
- 23:53whenever I showed up on
- 23:54Louisville Metro Council, we
- 23:55had this office for youth
- 23:57development, and as a young mom,
- 23:58I was like, great, let's talk
- 23:59about developing our youth. Are
- 24:01we talking about, you know,
- 24:02three year olds, four year olds,
- 24:03what are we doing? And all of
- 24:05the programs were focused on
- 24:06kids 16 to 25, which is a
- 24:08really important group to focus
- 24:10on. We should absolutely be
- 24:11investing in our young people
- 24:12that need those investments
- 24:14when they reach that age. But
- 24:15it kind of struck me, why
- 24:17aren't we focusing on families
- 24:18at the beginning? Why aren't we
- 24:19passing policies that help
- 24:22families and kids get that
- 24:23running start? Why aren't we
- 24:24doing things? Whether it's
- 24:25daycare, whether it's pre-K,
- 24:28whether it's making diapers
- 24:30affordable, why aren't we
- 24:31really taking our resources and
- 24:33and investing in families early?
- 24:34Because in my mind, that's what
- 24:36makes sense.
- 24:37>> So what are the early
- 24:39investments in families from
- 24:40this side of the table? What
- 24:41are you doing to help the type
- 24:43of situations that Senator
- 24:45Cassie Armstrong come? Chambers
- 24:47is talking about chambers.
- 24:49>> Armstrong. I answered.
- 24:50>> We both messed that up. Yeah.
- 24:54>> Cassie K we'll get it right.
- 24:56>> I'm going to go back to
- 24:58where to my premise about
- 25:01having students ready by third
- 25:04and fourth grade levels. And if
- 25:07I'm not badly mistaken, some of
- 25:09the first bills that were ever
- 25:12introduced were introduced by
- 25:13Jack Westwood to make sure that
- 25:16we had reading programs.
- 25:19>> And he's a Republican.
- 25:20>> Senator, a Republican
- 25:21senator that came in in 1997
- 25:23with me, that that was one of
- 25:25the first bills he got passed.
- 25:28And it was kind of unusual for
- 25:30a minority party member to
- 25:32actually pass a bill. Right.
- 25:35But those were some of the
- 25:37things that we have focused on
- 25:40consistently is how you have
- 25:43those one through four grades,
- 25:46one through four, to make sure l
- 25:51and reading level, because
- 25:53that's in virtually every study
- 25:55that I've seen that if they're
- 25:57on that level at grade, grade 3
- 26:00or 4, their likelihood of
- 26:02success is greatly enhanced.
- 26:05And that's where we focused our
- 26:07efforts.
- 26:07>> But if they were behind by
- 26:09the time they get to the third
- 26:10grade, it's too late for many
- 26:12of them.
- 26:12>> By the time they get to the
- 26:14third or fourth grade level. So
- 26:16that's where you have to make
- 26:17sure when they're at first,
- 26:18second, third and fourth. And
- 26:20it is you know, there are
- 26:21studies. I'm aware of this
- 26:22study. That's how I knew it was
- 26:24several years old. I've seen
- 26:25the studies. There are studies
- 26:27that contradict each other, but
- 26:29you can see this one, which
- 26:31again, Vanderbilt did. And they
- 26:34understand research protocol as
- 26:35well as anybody about what you
- 26:38do to make sure you get the
- 26:41appropriate results based on
- 26:43blind type of circumstances.
- 26:46And so we followed that for a
- 26:48long time because Tennessee
- 26:50attempted to do that. And, you
- 26:52know, I've heard some past
- 26:53governors, why do we always
- 26:54want to be like Tennessee? I
- 26:56think that was Steve Beshear's
- 26:58comment. So, you know, we
- 27:00watched what Tennessee did.
- 27:02They didn't they tried to do it
- 27:04and they backed away from it.
- 27:05>> Well, Renee, if I could just
- 27:07jump in because I think you
- 27:09asked a really important
- 27:10question, I'm not sure we got a
- 27:11full answer to it. I think what
- 27:13what we're hearing here is that
- 27:15we all agree we should be
- 27:16investing in families. And, you
- 27:17know, I have a post-it note
- 27:19that I keep in my bathroom on
- 27:21the mirror that says one out of
- 27:22every five Kentucky kids lives
- 27:24in poverty. And I ask myself
- 27:25every single day when I look at
- 27:27that post-it note, what did I
- 27:28do today about that? Because
- 27:30those are all of our kids.
- 27:31That's all of our
- 27:32responsibility to do things to
- 27:33help those children. And I was
- 27:35thinking about last session and
- 27:36I started thinking about the
- 27:38bills we passed, and I'm not
- 27:39sure I can think of a single
- 27:41bill that was dedicated to
- 27:43child poverty measures that was
- 27:45not, you know, we're going to
- 27:46help everyone and help kids in
- 27:47the process. But we are
- 27:49tackling that problem of child
- 27:50poverty. One out of five kids
- 27:51in our communities living in
- 27:53poverty, and something we
- 27:54should all do something about
- 27:55every day. We all own that
- 27:56problem. And so I would like to
- 27:58work with anyone of any
- 27:59political party, in any chamber,
- 28:01on legislation to help our
- 28:04families that are living in
- 28:05poverty. That's why I filed
- 28:06legislation around refundable
- 28:08child tax credit. I've been
- 28:10championing diaper
- 28:12affordability, lots of programs
- 28:13to to help these kids. And so I
- 28:15would like to hear from the
- 28:16other side of the aisle, what
- 28:18are the initiatives that
- 28:19they're excited about in that
- 28:20space?
- 28:20>> I'll yield to you all.
- 28:22>> Well, again, Cassie, 1 in 5
- 28:26kids in Kentucky don't live in
- 28:28a vacuum. And so I don't think
- 28:30you can attack it in one level.
- 28:32You know, you've got to attack
- 28:33it in a multifaceted then
- 28:34you've got to attack it from
- 28:36from an opioid addiction
- 28:37standpoint. You've got to
- 28:38attack it, attack it from a
- 28:39workforce preparedness
- 28:42standpoint. We've invested
- 28:43record numbers of dollars in in
- 28:45public education. We've
- 28:47invested dramatically in opioid
- 28:49and and drug addiction. You
- 28:52know, we we have the largest
- 28:54single public private
- 28:56partnership on childcare that
- 28:57we've ever had. And it will be
- 28:59eclipsed dramatically this year.
- 29:01So you can't look at it in a
- 29:03vacuum. And that's that's the
- 29:05problem with an individual
- 29:06program. An individual program
- 29:07will not solve vast problems.
- 29:11It's got to be done on a
- 29:12holistic basis, and we attack
- 29:13it from every facet.
- 29:14>> Well, I'm looking forward to
- 29:16attacking it with you because I
- 29:17will say, what worries me
- 29:19sometimes is that we pass a lot
- 29:22of programs, we pass a lot of
- 29:25legislation, but people out
- 29:26there are hurting. It's a scary
- 29:27time for a lot of people right
- 29:29now. When we look at these
- 29:31pressure points in legislation
- 29:32and in policies, those are pain
- 29:34points for people out in our
- 29:35communities right now. And so I
- 29:36do think that what people want
- 29:38from us is for us to to come
- 29:40together and really deliver
- 29:42policies that are going to help
- 29:43make people's lives better.
- 29:45>> So this is a drastic
- 29:47departure from what we've been
- 29:48talking about. But this
- 29:49question comes from Janice
- 29:50Taylor from Jefferson County.
- 29:52What is the chance Kentucky
- 29:53State retirees will receive a
- 29:55cost of living increase? It's
- 29:56been 14 years.
- 29:59>> You know. Well, I'll I'll
- 30:01start with that. Even though
- 30:03the budget will start in the
- 30:04House, there's no way to answer
- 30:06a budget question right now
- 30:08because we've talked about some
- 30:10issues here that may have
- 30:12budgetary implications. So when
- 30:14you look at this to try to silo
- 30:16and say, this one issue is
- 30:17going to be done or this one
- 30:19issue is going to be done, you
- 30:20have to look at it. And I've
- 30:22always used this term, you have
- 30:24to budget in the context of the
- 30:25whole. And so you have to look
- 30:27at all the priorities and what
- 30:29is needed. And with that, you
- 30:31know, will we or won't we? It's
- 30:33hard to say where everything
- 30:34will finish up. You just can't
- 30:36do that at this point time. But
- 30:40as the. Session goes through
- 30:44and the House, the governor's
- 30:46budget is reviewed, what
- 30:47they're going to do, and then
- 30:48we'll get it in the Senate,
- 30:50then those things will come to
- 30:51light as to what we're going to,
- 30:53what type of whichever, how
- 30:55much we're going to put in K
- 30:56through 12, how much we're
- 30:57going to put in post-secondary,
- 30:59what we're going to do in the
- 31:00retirements.
- 31:01>> Yeah. Has Chairman Petrie
- 31:02already finished the state
- 31:03budget plan?
- 31:03>> It is not finished. It is
- 31:05well in progress.
- 31:06>> When will it be delivered or
- 31:08do you anticipate when it will
- 31:09be delivered?
- 31:10>> I would expect within the
- 31:11next week.
- 31:12>> Within the next week.
- 31:13>> To ten days. Yes.
- 31:14>> Okay. You care to give us
- 31:17any kind of spoilers on what to
- 31:18expect as some top priorities?
- 31:20Do you know.
- 31:21>> I would say to stay tuned. I
- 31:23mean, look, we're going to take
- 31:24the same approach to, to the
- 31:26budget as, as we have for the
- 31:27last several years. And that is,
- 31:29you know, to be very, very
- 31:31pragmatic about about how we
- 31:32utilize taxpayer dollars. We
- 31:35will we will spend based on our,
- 31:37our needs and not our wants,
- 31:38you know, and those two things
- 31:40are dramatically different.
- 31:41>> Do you anticipate cuts to
- 31:42any kind of state programs,
- 31:44agencies or services.
- 31:46>> Constantly trying to
- 31:47evaluate every program that we
- 31:50spend dollars on? Because I
- 31:51think clearly there are some
- 31:52that work extremely well. And
- 31:55and we may want to increase
- 31:56those programs. There are some
- 31:57that may not be delivering the
- 31:59results that we would like, and
- 32:00we may need to take some
- 32:01dollars away from those. So
- 32:03it's a constant evaluation of
- 32:04how we best utilize those,
- 32:05those state dollars. And I
- 32:08think that, you know, there's
- 32:09nothing to suggest that we
- 32:11won't approach it the same way.
- 32:12I do believe that we will
- 32:14continue. You will continue to
- 32:15see us. Utilize the route of
- 32:19two separate budget bills, one
- 32:21that will be the the normal
- 32:23operating budget of the
- 32:25Commonwealth that addresses
- 32:27ongoing operations and another
- 32:29that will address one time
- 32:31spending measures, one time
- 32:33investments that we will make
- 32:35with with some of our excess
- 32:36reserves.
- 32:37>> Representative Burke, what's
- 32:38your optimism or pessimism
- 32:40about the budget process and
- 32:41the outcome?
- 32:43>> Well, as the newest member
- 32:46of this panel, I will tell you
- 32:47that I've only had the
- 32:49privilege of being involved in
- 32:50one budget session so far. And
- 32:52so coming into this next budget
- 32:54session, I'm hopeful that we
- 32:55will take advantage of the
- 32:57opportunities that are before
- 32:58us, especially as it comes to
- 33:01this budget reserve trust fund.
- 33:03That's at a level where we can
- 33:05safely borrow from those
- 33:08dollars and still maintain
- 33:09enough of a surplus there so
- 33:11that we are secure, and no
- 33:13matter what kind of disaster
- 33:15might come, we still have the
- 33:16dollars we need in place. So
- 33:19I'm cautiously optimistic, but
- 33:21hopeful.
- 33:22>> What's the prospects for
- 33:24borrowing or taking money from
- 33:25the budget reserve trust fund
- 33:26or Rainy Day fund, as it's
- 33:28sometimes called.
- 33:30>> Redirecting that.
- 33:30>> Well, both of you.
- 33:32>> Well, I'll say this, and I
- 33:33think David and I are both on
- 33:35the same page. We're going to
- 33:37we're not going to take money
- 33:38from the budget reserve trust
- 33:39fund, to which are one time
- 33:42dollars to fund recurring
- 33:45expenditures. You know, I think
- 33:46the governor I'm not sure. So I
- 33:48don't want to say with
- 33:50Definitiveness made some
- 33:51recommendations like that.
- 33:53That's what got us into trouble.
- 33:55That's what we started digging
- 33:56out from in 2016. That's what
- 33:59got us such bad bond ratings.
- 34:01That and a pension system that
- 34:04was, you know, on the verge of
- 34:05just total bankruptcy. So
- 34:08that's something that will not
- 34:10happen. I just can't see it
- 34:12happening in any way. Because
- 34:14when you look at this and this
- 34:15is wonky, you know, the first
- 34:17thing you hear from the bond
- 34:18rating agencies, which are
- 34:20neutral, they're not political.
- 34:21They sit there and look and say,
- 34:22you're using one time dollars
- 34:24to pay recurring expenses. Why
- 34:25are you going to pay for those
- 34:27recurring expenses next year
- 34:28when you don't have those one
- 34:29time dollars? And that's how
- 34:30your bond ratings and your
- 34:32operating ratings get
- 34:34downgraded? So from my
- 34:35perspective, and I won't speak
- 34:36for the speaker, that won't
- 34:38happen in the Senate.
- 34:39>> I would agree. I think that,
- 34:41you know, for for several years,
- 34:43some of our surrounding states
- 34:44have been held out as, as kind
- 34:46of an ideal of, you know, a
- 34:48growing Midwestern or southern
- 34:50economy. And, and they have
- 34:52they've had tremendous success
- 34:54in some of those states. And we
- 34:55are behind on some level. But I
- 34:57also think they got very
- 34:58comfortable in spending money
- 35:00that we never had. And so when
- 35:03you see some of our states,
- 35:05both our north and our south,
- 35:06that are are making dramatic
- 35:08budget cuts, having real budget
- 35:10shortfalls, it's because they
- 35:12weren't as as practical about
- 35:14spending their one time dollars
- 35:16as, as maybe we were. And while
- 35:18that sure, it made us maybe a
- 35:20little bit envious from time to
- 35:21time when we looked at the
- 35:22things they were spending money
- 35:24on right now, it makes us it
- 35:25makes us very comfortable and
- 35:27and where we are with the
- 35:29budget and our reserves and our
- 35:30ability to to fund government
- 35:31as it should be.
- 35:32>> So the $156 million
- 35:34shortfall doesn't scare you any,
- 35:35right.
- 35:36>> It doesn't.
- 35:36>> It's not.
- 35:37>> A shortfall.
- 35:38>> And you know, it's you know.
- 35:40>> What is.
- 35:40>> It then. If it's not a
- 35:42shortfall.
- 35:42>> It's not a shortfall. A
- 35:44shortfall is where your
- 35:45revenues aren't enough to cover
- 35:46your expenses. We did not
- 35:50budget. If let's say you make
- 35:52$50,000, do you spend your
- 35:54$50,000 every year? No you
- 35:55don't. We didn't spend the full
- 35:58revenues we were to receive. So
- 36:01it's not a shortfall.
- 36:02>> What is it then?
- 36:03>> It's we just didn't make as
- 36:05much money. But we have more
- 36:07than enough money to cover the
- 36:08recurring expenses. And then if
- 36:09you want to take a two year
- 36:11budget, all we did, we finished
- 36:13last year's budget $131 million
- 36:16above this year. They're saying
- 36:18maybe 150 below receipts, not
- 36:23below the expenditures that we
- 36:24put in there. So it's not a
- 36:26shortfall.
- 36:27>> You understand it that way,
- 36:28Senator?
- 36:29>> Yeah. Well, I was just about
- 36:30to say I'm glad my friends on
- 36:32the other side of the aisle are
- 36:33feeling so confident, because
- 36:34when I look at the budget
- 36:36numbers, I am not feeling
- 36:37confident at all. And
- 36:38specifically when I look at
- 36:39what's happening in Washington,
- 36:40DC, I want to be very clear. I
- 36:42believe it's going to be
- 36:44devastating for the state of
- 36:45Kentucky. We are looking at
- 36:46projections showing 200,000
- 36:47Kentuckians possibly losing
- 36:48their health insurance, as many
- 36:50as 34 rural hospitals closing.
- 36:52And sometimes I say these
- 36:53numbers and folks are like,
- 36:54well, those projections, those
- 36:55are, you know, down the road we
- 36:57have time to do things about
- 36:58them. There's a hospital in
- 37:00Louisville that decided not to
- 37:01move forward with its birthing
- 37:02center because of changes to
- 37:04Medicaid out of the federal,
- 37:06the federal legislation that's
- 37:08happening right now. That was
- 37:09going to be the first place
- 37:10West of 65 that women in
- 37:12Louisville could give birth the
- 37:14only place. And that was going
- 37:15to be a big deal. And that's
- 37:17not happening because of what
- 37:18happened in Washington, DC. And
- 37:20so I believe you look at these
- 37:22projections. What's happening
- 37:23in Washington, DC is going to
- 37:24be very impactful. And what
- 37:27worries me is I don't hear
- 37:28folks standing up and saying,
- 37:31this is going to hurt our
- 37:32communities. This is something
- 37:33that is not good for
- 37:35Kentuckians. This is going to
- 37:36hurt the people that I
- 37:37represent. This is going to
- 37:38hurt our state. And I believe
- 37:40that we have that obligation
- 37:41when we feel like things are
- 37:43going to be bad for Kentucky to
- 37:44stand up and to say.
- 37:46>> That, well, Jeff Sims from
- 37:47Caldwell County is saying that
- 37:48he says he's asking what are
- 37:50the biggest financial concerns
- 37:51from federal funding cuts to
- 37:53this biennial budget? So he's
- 37:54kind of echoing your sentiment.
- 37:56How do you feel about it,
- 37:57Representative Burke?
- 38:01>> The budget cuts when it
- 38:02relates to Medicaid are the
- 38:04most troubling. And I'm really
- 38:06grateful that the legislature
- 38:07brought back the Medicaid
- 38:08Oversight Advisory Board to
- 38:10take a look at that and see
- 38:11what we can do.
- 38:12>> To finalize their
- 38:13recommendations today.
- 38:14>> Yes. And the bad news is, we
- 38:18don't have enough money to fix
- 38:20all of that. And I don't think
- 38:21that we have the political will
- 38:23to do it either. So I am very
- 38:27concerned about how those kinds
- 38:28of cuts are going to play out
- 38:30across the state and what it is
- 38:32that we'll do to try and shore
- 38:33up Kentucky families so that a
- 38:36health disaster doesn't become
- 38:37a financial disaster.
- 38:38>> How do you mitigate that
- 38:40concern?
- 38:40>> You know, it always
- 38:42intrigues me about how, oh,
- 38:44this is going to happen or
- 38:45that's going to happen. But
- 38:46then when you actually see the
- 38:47proof of what happens, it
- 38:49contradicts what people are
- 38:50saying. I know the hospitals
- 38:53that were listed, I know the
- 38:54phone calls that were made to
- 38:56hospital administrators to say,
- 38:57would you sign a letter that
- 38:58your hospital is going to close?
- 39:00And they said, no, we're not.
- 39:01One of them is in my hometown.
- 39:03They got the call and they said,
- 39:05we're not going to close.
- 39:07Whoever put us on that list was
- 39:08wrong. So I think it's really
- 39:12seriously inappropriate to
- 39:14create this type of angst and
- 39:17anxiety for the purpose of a
- 39:19political argument. Then here's
- 39:21the other thing. All I've heard
- 39:23is, wait a minute, you're
- 39:24cutting the income tax. You're
- 39:26cutting the income tax. You're
- 39:28ruining ruining our base. Well,
- 39:30let's talk about cutting the
- 39:31income tax. Does anybody here
- 39:33on the other side know how much
- 39:35our income tax grew the first
- 39:38six months of the year? Close
- 39:40to 8%. Wait a minute. We've
- 39:43been cutting the taxes, but
- 39:45it's growing. I don't hear
- 39:47anybody talking about that
- 39:48because they don't want to
- 39:49carry that political narrative
- 39:51because it's wrong.
- 39:52>> How is it growing? Explain
- 39:53that to us.
- 39:54>> Because when you do this, we
- 39:56become a growth state. People
- 39:58move here. It's just like what
- 40:00happened in the bourbon
- 40:01industry. We cut taxes, but
- 40:03when we cut the taxes, the base
- 40:06expanded. And so it's not five
- 40:08of us paying taxes, it's 20 of
- 40:10us paying taxes. We don't risk
- 40:14putting an individual at any
- 40:15greater tax liability because
- 40:17we bring more people into work.
- 40:19And if you want to address a
- 40:21lot of the social ills and woes,
- 40:23give people economic
- 40:26opportunity, they're less
- 40:27likely to get into drugs.
- 40:28They're less likely to do
- 40:30something wrong. They're more
- 40:31likely to take care of their
- 40:33families. That's the way you
- 40:35cure a lot of these things.
- 40:36>> I want to go back to what
- 40:38President Stivers was saying
- 40:39about health care. I do think
- 40:41it's connected to economic
- 40:42growth, because I think people
- 40:43can't access health care and
- 40:44can't be healthy. You're not
- 40:45going to have an economy that
- 40:47grows. But I believe that those
- 40:48numbers about hospitals came
- 40:50out of the Trump administration.
- 40:51Those were from the federal
- 40:52government controlled by his
- 40:54political party. Many of the
- 40:56projections about the specific
- 40:57hospitals and what I'll say is,
- 41:00I have not heard any hospitals
- 41:02saying, yeah, we're about to
- 41:03close today.
- 41:04>> You just said 34. We're
- 41:05going to close.
- 41:06>> What I not today. What I
- 41:07have heard people saying is
- 41:09that we are already beginning
- 41:11to change the services that we
- 41:13offer and the care that we
- 41:15provide because of the changes
- 41:16to the Medicaid program and our
- 41:18ability to make ends meet. And
- 41:20so when we're talking about
- 41:21places, you know, this
- 41:22President Stivers, rural
- 41:23Kentucky, we already have a lot
- 41:25of health care deserts. And
- 41:26when we have hospitals that
- 41:27have to start walking back, the
- 41:29care that they're providing,
- 41:30it's going to be that care.
- 41:31That's sort of the the low
- 41:33dollar, low value, and that's
- 41:34going to make it harder for
- 41:36people to drive and get the
- 41:37care they need.
- 41:38>> You know, now you've changed
- 41:40your argument. You've changed
- 41:41from closing to rolling back
- 41:42certain areas of health care,
- 41:43to different terms.
- 41:44>> Well, I, I believe the I
- 41:46hope I'm wrong. I never root
- 41:48against Kentucky. I never root
- 41:50against Kentucky families. I
- 41:51never root against Kentucky
- 41:52outcomes. I'm not going to root
- 41:53against Kentucky health care. I
- 41:55hope I'm wrong. What I'm saying
- 41:56is that that's what the
- 41:57projections are, the
- 41:58projections that we have seen,
- 41:59say, 34 hospitals, up to 34
- 42:02hospitals will close.
- 42:03>> And you don't think phone
- 42:04calls were made to ask people
- 42:05to sign letters saying, yeah,
- 42:06we're going to close.
- 42:08>> Well, I would love to see
- 42:10those letters. And again, I.
- 42:11>> Hope I didn't sign them, but
- 42:12they were asked to.
- 42:14>> Well, so I think what I am
- 42:16saying is I don't think anyone
- 42:18can disagree that there have
- 42:20been changes to the Medicaid
- 42:21program that are going to make
- 42:22it a lot more financially
- 42:24difficult for health care
- 42:25providers in the state to make
- 42:26ends meet and provide care.
- 42:27>> Hasn't the Kentucky Hospital
- 42:29Association come out and said
- 42:30that this could put something
- 42:3130 something odd? Hospitals at
- 42:34risk, particularly rural
- 42:36hospitals?
- 42:37>> I have yet to see a single
- 42:39hospital come out and say that
- 42:41they will close.
- 42:43>> All right. We're going to
- 42:44put a pin in that, and I'm sure
- 42:46we'll have further discussion
- 42:47on that as we go down the road.
- 42:49>> Sure, sure.
- 42:50>> Let's talk about the changes
- 42:51in Medicaid. I mean, obviously,
- 42:53uncertainty is always the enemy
- 42:54of good budgeting, and we do
- 42:55have some degree of uncertainty
- 42:57out there. But one of the
- 42:58certainties we do know is that
- 43:00the report revealed $800
- 43:01million was was inappropriately
- 43:02spent out of the Medicaid
- 43:04program this past year. So
- 43:07there are efficiencies that
- 43:08we're going to find what degree
- 43:10those efficiencies will close
- 43:12the gaps that we have. But we
- 43:13know that that in one audit
- 43:16report, we found over $800
- 43:17million that was paid to people
- 43:19that were not eligible. These
- 43:20were people that were claiming
- 43:22benefits in multiple states.
- 43:24You know, that alone is an
- 43:26enormous hole. And then you you
- 43:30think that that is just one
- 43:32tiny little, little silo of the
- 43:35enormity of the Medicaid
- 43:36program. And I believe that
- 43:38that the the recommendations
- 43:41that are coming out of Medicaid
- 43:43Oversight and Advisory Board
- 43:44this this year bill that will
- 43:46be introduced probably next
- 43:48week will be transformational.
- 43:51I think that the the the
- 43:55positive things that we will be
- 43:56able to do in the Medicaid
- 43:59space are going to be dramatic.
- 44:00>> Yeah. And we'll make space
- 44:02to make sure that we talk about
- 44:03that. So speaking of
- 44:04uncertainty, there is
- 44:05uncertainty around the future
- 44:06of Blue Oval SK, the Hardin
- 44:08County plant, after Ford Motor
- 44:09and Escalon ended their EV
- 44:10battery partnership, Ford says
- 44:13it will retool the facility to
- 44:15make data center battery
- 44:16systems more than 300, or close
- 44:18to $300 million in tax
- 44:20incentives was given toward
- 44:21this project. Is this another
- 44:22Brady Industries? And can the
- 44:25legislature recover those tax
- 44:27incentives from that project?
- 44:29And and how do you avoid a
- 44:31Brady industry circa Matt.
- 44:32>> Bevin you you make me laugh
- 44:36because the only thing that was
- 44:37at risk from the state at that
- 44:39time was $15 million. And we
- 44:41got the $15 million back.
- 44:44>> Now you're talking 300
- 44:46million.
- 44:46>> Now you're talking 300
- 44:47million, but you're also
- 44:48talking about a lot more than
- 44:50that. You're talking about what
- 44:51was there 1600 people working
- 44:53now that are laid off? Well,
- 44:55let's talk about all the other
- 44:56money we had to invest down
- 44:59there for. I think there was a
- 45:00couple of fire departments and
- 45:02some. Water and sewer that were.
- 45:03Yeah, the educational CTCs had
- 45:07to upgrade its facility and
- 45:09they're losing money because of
- 45:11this. This is about the biggest.
- 45:15Well, no, it's about it is the
- 45:17biggest economic boondoggle
- 45:19we've been in. And and so now
- 45:23we've got all this money
- 45:24invested. They advised us
- 45:25they're going to be a year
- 45:27before they retool, which to me
- 45:29means they can't meet the
- 45:33metrics for the incentives that
- 45:35were given for the upfront
- 45:38money. Totally different. This
- 45:40is what the governor wanted to
- 45:41do. He wanted to front the
- 45:42money instead of having it over
- 45:44a 20 year period. He wanted to
- 45:46bring it back and do a present
- 45:48value. We supported that. I
- 45:50don't know if we'll do it again
- 45:52because this has become really
- 45:53a mess.
- 45:55>> Can you recover some of that
- 45:57upfront money?
- 45:58>> Oh, we have clawback
- 45:59provisions within within the
- 46:01statute and within the
- 46:03agreements.
- 46:04>> And so that can just be
- 46:06exercised. Is that a vote that
- 46:07has to happen? How does that
- 46:09happen?
- 46:09>> No, I think there's a couple
- 46:11different ways that can happen.
- 46:12I think the economic
- 46:13development cabinet can say,
- 46:14hey, look, you haven't done
- 46:15this and if they don't want to
- 46:17do it, then you get into
- 46:18litigation.
- 46:19>> Speaker Osborne.
- 46:20>> Contractual obligation, just
- 46:21like just like any other loan.
- 46:23You know, I think that
- 46:25everybody is certainly going to
- 46:27going to hope that that this
- 46:30this retooling is going to be
- 46:32effective. And, you know,
- 46:33they're going to spend another
- 46:34billion dollars on top of what
- 46:36they've already spent down
- 46:37there, which, you know, that
- 46:38will do great things for our,
- 46:40our our sales tax numbers. But
- 46:41it's not going to do anything
- 46:43as far as putting jobs on the
- 46:44line. But you would you would
- 46:46expect that, you know, if
- 46:47they're going to invest another
- 46:48billion dollars down there,
- 46:49that there would be some
- 46:51reasonable expectation of
- 46:52employment, but they're going
- 46:53to be in default of the of the
- 46:55contract. And I think just as,
- 46:56as with any other contract, you
- 46:59know, there are enforceable
- 47:01provisions in there.
- 47:03>> And we do want to look last
- 47:05thing we want to do is see it
- 47:07collapse. Right. We do not want
- 47:08to see that. But we have to
- 47:10also understand it's our job to
- 47:12protect the tax dollars that
- 47:14were invested in that community.
- 47:16And it's beyond those which
- 47:17were just incentives.
- 47:19>> This side. Have a comment
- 47:20about this?
- 47:21>> Yeah, I think President
- 47:22Stivers probably knows that I'm
- 47:24a bit of an optimist, but I
- 47:26will say I agree with the
- 47:27speaker I am and and the
- 47:29president. I am rooting for
- 47:31this project even where we are
- 47:33today. I think it's okay to be
- 47:35disappointed about where we are
- 47:36today, but even where we are
- 47:38today, it is still the largest
- 47:39single economic investment in
- 47:40the history of Kentucky. It is
- 47:42still a big deal, and we all
- 47:44want it to thrive and to
- 47:45succeed because we're all
- 47:46rooting for Team Kentucky. This
- 47:49isn't happening in a vacuum.
- 47:50We've seen changes with the
- 47:51Trump administration targeting
- 47:53the the EV facilities. And so
- 47:54and I think we have to be
- 47:56honest about how those changes
- 47:58impacted this program and this
- 48:00investment. But I am rooting
- 48:03for it, and I am hopeful that
- 48:04we will still be able to turn
- 48:06this into something that is
- 48:07good for our people.
- 48:08>> Any further comment there?
- 48:10>> Completely agree. I do think
- 48:11that the retooling is going to
- 48:13be a success, and that we're
- 48:14going to see those jobs bounce
- 48:16back, and not only will that be
- 48:17a great success for Western
- 48:19Kentucky, it's going to be
- 48:20something that we look back on
- 48:21in the future and say, even
- 48:23though it was a bumpy ride, I'm
- 48:25glad we went on it.
- 48:26>> Yeah. So a couple of
- 48:27lightning round questions here
- 48:28from viewers. This question
- 48:29from Louisville. Does the
- 48:30legislature plan to pass
- 48:31legislation to build an
- 48:33educational facility for
- 48:34inmates in Boyle County?
- 48:38>> I'm unaware of any
- 48:40initiative in Boyle County.
- 48:42>> Boyle County. B.o.y Lee a
- 48:45viewer from Louisville which.
- 48:48>> Unaware of that type of.
- 48:50>> Request that might be.
- 48:51>> Yeah.
- 48:51>> Haven't gotten an email
- 48:52about.
- 48:53>> That one.
- 48:53>> Okay. Yeah. Do you know this
- 48:55could be a viewer from your
- 48:57your area?
- 48:57>> Okay.
- 48:58>> I will tell you that
- 48:59Representative Decker is
- 49:00working on a bill with Ryan
- 49:01Quarles at KTC, right, for some
- 49:04reentry education programs. I
- 49:06don't know if that may be what
- 49:08they're referring to, but. But
- 49:09that bill will be filed
- 49:11probably within the next couple
- 49:13of days.
- 49:14>> Yeah.
- 49:14>> Do you think positively that
- 49:16kind of measure?
- 49:16>> Yeah. There's several things
- 49:18that have been bounced around.
- 49:19It's even up at KCC in West
- 49:21Liberty. They talked about the
- 49:22Marion Adjustment Center
- 49:23possibly being a location, but
- 49:25I know that they have been
- 49:27looking at that, and it's
- 49:28probably a good investment to
- 49:29give people who are going to
- 49:31get back into the system, out
- 49:33of the corrections system, to
- 49:35have some type of job skills or
- 49:37training.
- 49:38>> So this question, I'm going
- 49:39to kind of paraphrase and
- 49:40clarify. So they ask please
- 49:42explain the House bill
- 49:43regarding local police given
- 49:45Ice authority and did it or did
- 49:46not pass? Well, it was just
- 49:47filed. I'm assuming that you're
- 49:50talking about this bill by
- 49:51representative TJ Roberts would
- 49:52require all Kentucky police
- 49:54agencies, including KSP, to
- 49:55enter federal agreements with
- 49:56Ice under a certain program.
- 49:59And, of course, Beshear has
- 50:00authority over the Kentucky
- 50:01State Police. So tell us more
- 50:03about this if you have more to
- 50:05say about it.
- 50:06>> Speaker Osborne, I.
- 50:07>> Can't tell you much more
- 50:08about it. I know that the bill
- 50:10is filed and I've seen some
- 50:12some reports on it, but we
- 50:13haven't we haven't had any
- 50:14conversations as a caucus or
- 50:16anything like that. So I can't
- 50:17really tell you any of the
- 50:19specific details as to to what
- 50:21it may entail at this point.
- 50:23>> Yeah. There's another
- 50:24immigration measure related
- 50:25measure. This one, there's two
- 50:28House Bill eight 186 and House
- 50:29Bill 259. This is about banning
- 50:34immigrant citizens from holding
- 50:35local and state elected offices.
- 50:39Naturalized citizenship. Your
- 50:40thoughts on this,
- 50:41Representative Burke?
- 50:42>> To just be blunt, it's
- 50:44un-American. That's an
- 50:46un-American measure, and it's
- 50:48unconstitutional. We need to
- 50:50get our heads straight and
- 50:52focus on the things that our
- 50:54constituents need, and
- 50:56legislating about preventing
- 50:58U.S. citizens from holding
- 50:59office, is not it?
- 51:01>> I think that Bill's got some
- 51:0314th Amendment problems.
- 51:04>> Okay. And that's coming from
- 51:06the speaker of the House on a
- 51:07House measure. So we'll see if
- 51:09that moves anywhere. Let's talk
- 51:10a little bit about governor's
- 51:12powers. And five minutes or so
- 51:13that we have remaining. Will
- 51:15there be efforts to either
- 51:17shift or limit more executive
- 51:20powers? And if we think their
- 51:22support for checks and balances,
- 51:23how does this square with the
- 51:25perception of President Donald
- 51:26Trump's expansion of executive
- 51:28power? Is there any kind of
- 51:30conflict, in your view, about,
- 51:32regardless of the level of
- 51:33government, what what executive
- 51:36power should be?
- 51:38>> Well, there always should be
- 51:41checks and balances. That's the
- 51:43way our framers and drafters of
- 51:47our constitutions put these
- 51:49things together. And I say
- 51:51these the federal Constitution,
- 51:53the state constitution. Now,
- 51:54you have to look at it totally
- 51:56different at the federal level,
- 51:57because we don't have the
- 51:59dealings with foreign entities.
- 52:02And if you want to go back to
- 52:04the 13 colonies and you want to
- 52:05go back and look at all the
- 52:07letters between Madison and
- 52:08Jefferson and Washington, and
- 52:10when we were basically a
- 52:12confederacy to a democracy in
- 52:14the Constitution that was
- 52:16drafted. This is why we went to
- 52:18a centralized government to
- 52:19deal with foreign affairs. And
- 52:21so I think a lot of the things
- 52:23you're seeing is how a
- 52:24president deals with foreign
- 52:25affairs. We don't deal with
- 52:27foreign affairs. Never will.
- 52:28It's not perceived to be. But
- 52:31there should always be checks
- 52:32and balances. And the Kentucky
- 52:36Constitution is such that the
- 52:39governor has certain enumerated
- 52:40powers within the Constitution,
- 52:42or that which is prescribed by
- 52:44law. There is not a
- 52:48Transportation Secretary in the
- 52:51Constitution. We defined it. We
- 52:53can redefine it. But, you know,
- 52:55so it's there. It's our it's
- 52:57our prerogative. But there's
- 52:59not a lot of discussion about
- 53:01that. You know, the budget's
- 53:02the ultimate policy document.
- 53:04And I think that's what we're
- 53:05going to be focused on.
- 53:06>> Any concerns about what's
- 53:08been done in the past as
- 53:10prelude to future.
- 53:11>> No. I when we talk about
- 53:13changing the balance of power,
- 53:14that's a really weighty thing.
- 53:16President Stivers was just
- 53:17talking about the history of
- 53:18democracy. It's really weighty
- 53:19when you start messing with
- 53:20that balance of power. I
- 53:22remember a few years ago when
- 53:23we had a fight about who got to
- 53:25assign the parking spaces in
- 53:27the Capitol parking lot,
- 53:28whether it was the executive or
- 53:29the legislative branch. And I
- 53:31just remember thinking, this is
- 53:33what people are sending us here
- 53:35for. You know, it was one of
- 53:36those moments where I don't
- 53:38believe that that's what the
- 53:39people sitting at home want us
- 53:40to be, to be talking about.
- 53:42They want us to be solving
- 53:43their problems. And so I say
- 53:45that just by way of balance, of
- 53:47power is really weighty thing.
- 53:48I don't like it when we have
- 53:50these skirmishes around the
- 53:51edges. I like it when we can
- 53:52come together and really focus
- 53:54on what matters to people when
- 53:55they're sitting down on the
- 53:56tables in the evening. And I
- 53:58think for the most part, our
- 53:59balance of powers is doing just
- 54:01fine.
- 54:01>> Any other comment on that?
- 54:03>> No.
- 54:03>> And I'll say, you know,
- 54:05balance of power, because I
- 54:06have been around here a long
- 54:07time. And if you want to look
- 54:09at the governor's Office of AG
- 54:11Policy that was created by Paul
- 54:12Paton because he didn't like
- 54:13Billy Ray Smith, who is the
- 54:15current Democrat AG
- 54:17commissioner, and he wanted
- 54:18control of the tobacco
- 54:19settlement proceeds. So they
- 54:21took it away from him. And that
- 54:22was actually Democrats against
- 54:24Democrats. So that's kind of a
- 54:27repetitive thing, a redundant
- 54:28thing where it's kind of
- 54:29wasteful spending to where you
- 54:31have a constitutionally
- 54:32prescribed office with certain
- 54:34powers, but they're taken away
- 54:35by the governor's Office of ag
- 54:37Policy because he could do it.
- 54:39So that's not a good use of
- 54:40balance, of power. And you will
- 54:42see that throughout the history
- 54:43of Kentucky. And some things
- 54:45need to be rebalanced. Some
- 54:46things just need to be redone
- 54:49because it's a wasteful use of
- 54:51money.
- 54:52>> So this is we got one minute
- 54:54and 35 seconds. Education Jake,
- 54:57split the district. Keep it
- 54:59whole.
- 55:00>> You have a new
- 55:02superintendent. It is my
- 55:03opinion that you should let
- 55:05that superintendent have time
- 55:06to create a record before you
- 55:08do anything else.
- 55:09>> Speaker Osborne is a member
- 55:10in your caucus that's filed a
- 55:12bill that would split CSI.
- 55:14These really underperforming
- 55:16schools, split the district.
- 55:18>> You know, Jefferson County
- 55:20Public Schools is going to
- 55:21continue to be a dominant point
- 55:24of conversation, probably for
- 55:26the next several years, quite
- 55:28frankly. Not only are they
- 55:30educating, you know, a sixth of
- 55:32our kids in the state, but they
- 55:34also have the largest majority
- 55:36of failing schools in the state.
- 55:38And the fact of the matter is,
- 55:41it is it is such magnitude that
- 55:43we don't have a choice but to
- 55:44pay attention to it. I think
- 55:46that there are a lot of smart
- 55:48people that have come up with a
- 55:49lot of smart ideas about how to
- 55:51tackle JCPS. The fact of the
- 55:53matter is, I don't know that
- 55:54any of those smart people are
- 55:56experts in how to restructure
- 55:57Jefferson County public schools.
- 55:59I do believe it deserves a
- 56:01heady conversation. I do
- 56:02believe that it will continue
- 56:04to get an unbelievable amount
- 56:07of attention. I have great
- 56:09hopes for the new
- 56:10superintendent. I am
- 56:14unbelievably concerned about
- 56:14the reports I heard from the
- 56:16Chief Financial officer of
- 56:18Jefferson County Public Schools.
- 56:19That goes to leave it there
- 56:20saying he withheld information.
- 56:22>> All right, we'll have to
- 56:23leave it there. We'll pick that
- 56:24up a little later, perhaps on
- 56:26Kentucky edition, which you can
- 56:27join us for tomorrow night at
- 56:29630. Take good care.