Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Grand Illusion (1937)
Transcript
- 0:13Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. I really thought, will I
- 0:23do a French accent? Should I do a French accent?
- 0:26And then I was like, eh, I'm not really French.
- 0:30I don't have that in me. You know, it was like,
- 0:31I can get away with the Colombian, I think. On
- 0:35paper, at least. I don't know. When people look
- 0:36at me, they're probably like, what are you doing?
- 0:38But this is the plight of American. I think.
- 0:42Right. Well, we're like, man, it'd be really
- 0:44cool to do an accent right now. And everyone's
- 0:45like, you sure you want to do that? Right. It's
- 0:48like, no, no, no. My grandfather, he hails from
- 0:52that nation. You know what's so funny? Sure.
- 0:54I've learned that what doesn't matter, like the
- 0:56accent that doesn't matter, where it's like,
- 0:57hey, you can't do that. Australian, funny. And
- 1:01then this just helps me out. Like Scottish or
- 1:03Irish? Yeah. I mean, with Scottish, and this
- 1:06is, again, as a fellow Scot, like this is...
- 1:09That is something where people can't really get
- 1:11mad at you because they don't fully know you're
- 1:13doing a Scottish impression because you could
- 1:14just be like, I'm just making noises. Yeah, you're
- 1:17so bad at a Scottish accent that people are like,
- 1:20I don't know. I've told this story recently,
- 1:22but not on here. But my great grandmother was
- 1:26what I have called criminally Scottish. Where
- 1:29like she is like obscenely Scottish. That sounds
- 1:31more problematic than the accent. And I remember
- 1:35every time that my parents were, like we went
- 1:38over to her house, my parents were playing cards
- 1:40with her. And they would always, I forget what
- 1:43it was, but it was one that has like an ante,
- 1:45right? Like you would have to bet. And every
- 1:47time she would win, she would then knock on the
- 1:50table and she would say a phrase that means put
- 1:55your money in. Okay. But what she said was, decorate
- 1:58the mahogany. That's a long phrase. And she would
- 2:01say it in like that, decorate the mahogany. And
- 2:03she'd tap the table. Yeah. That then became like
- 2:06a sleeper cell covert phrase for me that every
- 2:09time I heard it, I was like, it's time to watch
- 2:11Murder, She Wrote. Or like something where I
- 2:14was like, I need a Werther's Original right now.
- 2:17Man. What were the strawberry ones? It was Werther's
- 2:20Original Strawberry? It was like strawberries
- 2:23and cream, wasn't it? Yes. Was there cream? Oh,
- 2:25yeah. The strawberries and cream. Was that Werther's
- 2:30original? I don't know. I didn't have the same
- 2:33grandmother. Cream Savers? My grandmother was
- 2:35like, you want a cakey? And give me a zebra cake.
- 2:39And then if I said, well, I'm hungry, she'd say,
- 2:42you have fried eggy. And that's what she would
- 2:44say. So you would have either a zebra cake or
- 2:47a fried egg. That's it. Dude, invite me over
- 2:50next time. Well, I'm aware. Yeah, she's not doing
- 2:53that anymore. I'm aware that that's probably
- 2:56not on the invite anymore. It's been a while
- 2:58since I've had a fried eggy. Yeah. Well, I mean,
- 3:02I can make you a fried eggy. And I know where
- 3:04to get a zebra cake. No, you can't. No, you can't,
- 3:06Ryan. You can make me a fried egg. Nobody can
- 3:09make a fried eggy. You're so right. My bad. I
- 3:11don't mean to replace your great grandmother.
- 3:13Just my grandmother. Just your grandmother. Yeah.
- 3:15But she was great. Yeah, she was. She was awesome.
- 3:19What a terrible thing to have to do where you're
- 3:21like, hey, my great grandmother. And your grandmother's
- 3:22like. Well, what's so good about her? Yeah, yeah.
- 3:25Wasn't great when I was growing up. I'm right
- 3:28here. And speaking of growing up. Yeah. In a
- 3:32way. Go ahead. Yeah. We're talking about the
- 3:34Grand Illusion today. Grand Illusion is something
- 3:39that I've been really excited to get into because
- 3:41whenever I'm looking at the best picture list
- 3:44of Criterion releases. This cover has always
- 3:47been so interesting to me. Have you seen this?
- 3:50I have, yes. For the longest time, I would look
- 3:52at it, and I would just be so infatuated with
- 3:55it. Man, I can't find this anywhere. It's so
- 3:57hard to find. And I really like this cover because
- 3:59I don't know what's going on here, but clearly
- 4:01it's set in medieval times because this man has
- 4:03a crown on it. And I was like, oh, what's the
- 4:06grand illusion? This man has a crown. The other
- 4:08man's beneath him. I wonder if this is a royalty
- 4:10thing. So I say that to say that... Jean Gavin,
- 4:16I believe is his name, the actor. His hair is
- 4:20so good in this movie that I thought it was a
- 4:23crown. Do you see what I'm talking about? Yes,
- 4:24I see. I'm looking at the poster now. 100 % accurate.
- 4:28Looks like a crown. Great hair. That's not a
- 4:30knock on him at all. No, it's very David Lynch.
- 4:34It is. Honestly. It is, yeah. It's like the perfectly
- 4:37coiffed but also perfectly messy. Hello and welcome
- 4:40to the Grand Illusion. God, something he would
- 4:43be born to say. So, Grand Illusion, I'm really
- 4:46excited to talk about this one, but we want to
- 4:48go ahead. There's a lot to talk about, so I'm
- 4:50going to get started with not very much to talk
- 4:53about in terms of nominations, because guess
- 4:54what? This is only one nomination, but boy, what
- 4:58a story behind the nomination. Outstanding production,
- 5:01since here we are talking about Best Picture
- 5:03nominees, and this is on behalf of Realization
- 5:06to Art Cinematography, well, Cinematographic?
- 5:10Graphic? Graphic. I'm not going to do the accent
- 5:14because, you know, canceled. But Realization
- 5:16to Art Cinematographic. And this is RAC for short.
- 5:21RAC. And correct me if I'm wrong, Ryan. That's
- 5:25a French production company. That is a French
- 5:27production company. And not only that, but this
- 5:30is the first foreign film, first international
- 5:33film to be nominated for Best Picture. Now, when
- 5:37we say that, are we excluding... Okay, that makes
- 5:41sense. Yeah. I was going to say. Because there's
- 5:43been London, like, Cavalcade and all that. Private
- 5:45Life of Henry VIII was, yeah, an English film.
- 5:48Right. So it's not necessarily the first film
- 5:51from another country. It's just the first film
- 5:53from another language. Yes. And, man, was that
- 5:57surprising to you when we started this? You know,
- 6:01obviously we know now, 90 years in, that it is
- 6:05not 90 plus years in. This is not the first and
- 6:09only. Sorry, this is not the only by any means.
- 6:12But I didn't expect it this early. Me neither.
- 6:15I thought that America was going to be gatekeeping
- 6:18the Academy Awards. And, you know, because we
- 6:22don't do like a super deep dive into all of the
- 6:24other categories, I'm not sure how frequently
- 6:28foreign language shows up in the smaller categories.
- 6:31But as far as best picture, it does seem like
- 6:34at the time we were like, Hollywood, Hollywood,
- 6:36Hollywood. This is kind of cool. This is exciting.
- 6:39I rock with it. I'm really interested in what
- 6:42this means moving forward. And like in the coming
- 6:44years, we know that the Academy is very reactive.
- 6:48So I'm always interested whenever we see like
- 6:51a different kind of movie. Okay, are we going
- 6:52to see kind of not copycats, but doors that have
- 6:55been opened because of this? And I wonder what
- 6:58this is going to do for international films moving
- 7:00forward with this being nominated. But again,
- 7:04of note. Where other areas it should have been
- 7:07nominated, it wasn't. So I wonder, we'll talk
- 7:11about that when we get to cast and everything.
- 7:13But I wonder if maybe this was more of a, hey,
- 7:17just as an introduction to see how this goes,
- 7:19we are going to do Best Picture, Outstanding
- 7:21Production, but we'll see in the future. This
- 7:23is one of the highest rated movies of the year
- 7:26on Letterboxd. So I think it's interesting that
- 7:29it wasn't nominated in other categories. Because
- 7:33there are so many names that like even we've
- 7:35become familiar with, with like Douglas Shearer
- 7:37and Cedric Gibbons and like Dolly Tree, who I
- 7:40don't think was ever nominated. But I see her
- 7:43name all the time. I don't even know if her is
- 7:46appropriate. But anyway, we see all these names
- 7:48like constantly. And the Academy Awards really
- 7:52do feel like a celebration of certain people
- 7:56in their craft because you're seeing those names
- 7:58show up so frequently. And here it's like. You
- 8:01know, they don't know the costume designers over
- 8:04in France or the production. What is it? Art
- 8:09production, art designers, like even the actors.
- 8:12These are names that we're not really familiar
- 8:15with other than one name. We'll see if you at
- 8:18home recognize. But we have Jean Gabin as Lieutenant
- 8:21Mikaiko? Marichal is kind of what I picked up
- 8:26from what they were saying. Thank you. My C's
- 8:29are R's. I can't do the French accent because
- 8:39I can't even write the English words. Nailed
- 8:46it. And then Eric von Stroheim is the name that
- 8:49you might recognize. We did talk about him. Was
- 8:52it Shanghai Express? Yes. I believe he was in
- 8:55that. Yeah. He plays Captain von Raufenstein.
- 8:58And this was directed by Jean Reno. Renoir. Renoir.
- 9:02How do you pronounce it? Renoir. I believe it's
- 9:06Renoir. Renoir. We're doing so good. So it's
- 9:09interesting. No, you're doing good. We're getting
- 9:11through it. So with this one, when I'm writing
- 9:15down everything on IMDb, because this is a foreign
- 9:19language film, the names are like, you know.
- 9:23La Lieutenant, uh, Marshal, uh, the Capitaine
- 9:26del Baldo. So there, there is like, it doesn't
- 9:29just say like Captain Baldo. It doesn't just
- 9:31say, you know, Lieutenant Marshal. It's, you
- 9:33know, La, Li. And this already kind of took me
- 9:37by surprise because when I started this, I wasn't
- 9:39sure that it was, uh, foreign language. Let's
- 9:43start here. This was so hard to watch. It was
- 9:45very hard to find. Sorry, hard to find is what
- 9:47I mean to say. Correct. This is hard to find.
- 9:50Now, this is the first ever, I don't know if
- 9:52you know this, this is the first Criterion disc
- 9:54that was made. I did know that. So that's really
- 9:57interesting. But that also means that it's very
- 9:59hard to find. So when it comes to physical media,
- 10:02tough. Right. I've been looking, but very tough.
- 10:06It's not available on demand. It's not available
- 10:09streaming. There is an option for our fellow.
- 10:12First off, if you're listening to this podcast,
- 10:13you really should be a member of this community.
- 10:15But our fellow card -carrying library members.
- 10:19Yeah. You probably should have a library card,
- 10:23whether you're listening to this podcast or not.
- 10:25But Canopy is a huge thing for that as well,
- 10:28where you can stream some of the movies available
- 10:29through the library. And while Grand Illusion
- 10:33is there sometimes in this region. It was unavailable
- 10:37to us. Right. So very tough to find this one.
- 10:40We had to reach out to our friend Bryce to get
- 10:42some help. And he helped us out to find that,
- 10:45which was really nice of him. But this was difficult.
- 10:48And I'd love to see it available more often,
- 10:50maybe in libraries, just because it is the first
- 10:52foreign language film to be nominated for Best
- 10:54Picture. And it should be more accessible. I
- 10:57wish that I would have gone to the library and
- 11:00looked for a physical copy. To see if maybe they
- 11:03had one. I can back you up on this. They don't.
- 11:05They don't? Okay. Well, I should have went to
- 11:07Videodrome, then. Because I can almost guarantee
- 11:10they would have a copy. Oh, they should. Yeah,
- 11:12you're right. I didn't think about that. I went
- 11:14to my library. Taylor goes, like, maybe every
- 11:17three weeks. Yeah. And she goes to pick up, like,
- 11:19a new set of books. And every time I go, I'm
- 11:21always like, okay, let me look two years ahead.
- 11:23And be like, what movies are here that I can
- 11:25pick up now and hold on to? A couple. But Grand
- 11:29Illusion was never one of them. And some Criterions,
- 11:31too. But not Grand Illusion. Again, first one,
- 11:34it's pretty difficult to find. Right. So that
- 11:37made it kind of difficult to access. But then
- 11:41once we can access it, that's when I found out,
- 11:43oh, this is a foreign language film. Right. I
- 11:46didn't anticipate that. Did you know going into
- 11:47this? No. I didn't know anything about this movie.
- 11:50Neither did I. I didn't know the crown thing
- 11:53either. I was so out of the loop. All I knew
- 11:56is that it was the first spine number on the
- 11:58criterion list. That was pretty much it. So there's
- 12:03always been some prestige behind this. Right
- 12:05here in front of me, I have Roger Ebert's The
- 12:09Great Movies that he puts out, like, all of his
- 12:13five -star reviews, basically. And he compiles
- 12:16them in a book. Or he did. Excuse me. But I've
- 12:20had this book for a while, and Grand Illusion
- 12:22was always one that was listed in that book.
- 12:26I also have the 1001 movies to see before you
- 12:30die. That's listed there as well. So there's
- 12:32always been this prestige surrounding this movie.
- 12:34I had no idea what it was about, but I knew that
- 12:37it was going to be very, very impactful because
- 12:39it's been so well received by like everybody.
- 12:43Yeah, I was a little intimidated when I looked
- 12:46at the score and everything. concerned that again
- 12:49with like misreading the cover of this i i was
- 12:52concerned this was going to be kind of a private
- 12:54lives of henry the eighth kind of thing or at
- 12:56least you know some royalty in like the 1700s
- 12:59and i was going to be very interested or well
- 13:02yeah interested um it's not true at all This
- 13:06was fascinating to watch. I'll give just a brief
- 13:09synopsis here. A group of French soldiers, including
- 13:12the patrician Captain de Beldeau and the working
- 13:15class Lieutenant Marshal, grapple with their
- 13:18own class differences after being captured and
- 13:20held in a World War I German prison camp. So
- 13:24what did you think about this one? So, like,
- 13:27to dive a little deeper into the themes here,
- 13:30I think it's a movie about class, right? Totally.
- 13:35I don't know what I expected from it, even after
- 13:38it started. And I almost feel like I was looking
- 13:42for a really deep meaning just because of the
- 13:47way it was set up and the way that there was
- 13:49so much prestige around it. I didn't think it
- 13:50was going to be like a straightforward cut -and
- 13:52-dry story. I feel like I was looking for that
- 13:57deep theme the entire runtime of the movie, and
- 14:01I never really found it. I mean, I could... I
- 14:04could shine a little light on that for you if
- 14:05you want. I mean, at least my understanding of
- 14:07what it was. So in the movie, they're talking
- 14:10a lot about, like, the wars and everything. And
- 14:12granted, this is happening, you know, just a
- 14:15few years shy of Pearl Harbor and everything.
- 14:17So, like, war is on everyone's mind. But specifically,
- 14:21World War I is something that is referenced a
- 14:24lot in this movie. And in France, World War I
- 14:27was referred to as La Derre de Derre. Butchering
- 14:30that, I'm sure. But that's referred to as the
- 14:34last one of all. Okay. So, like, the last war
- 14:36of all. And that, I think, is what is being referred
- 14:40to as the grand illusion. Like, the grand illusion
- 14:43is that, like, war will cease and, like, war
- 14:45will stop. And this is a movie that, like, continues
- 14:48that idea of, like, there will always continue
- 14:50to be war. And it's interesting because this
- 14:53movie has such, like, an amicable spirit to it.
- 14:58Where this is a prison break movie. Yeah. And
- 15:00we will continue to see prison break movies.
- 15:03We've seen prison break movies here with The
- 15:05Big House. And I'm a Future from a Chain Gang.
- 15:08We will continue to do that. But in this, on
- 15:11top of that, we're so used to things like Shawshank
- 15:14Redemption and movies where people are tortured
- 15:17in these prison camps. That in this, it's almost
- 15:22like a Canadian production. Because... Even Rothenstein,
- 15:27when he meets everyone, everyone's just kind
- 15:30of like, how are you doing? Was your travel okay?
- 15:32Can I get you anything? Maybe a seltzer? Everyone
- 15:35is so cordial and amicable. And it's like, hey,
- 15:38we understand that we just captured you. Do you
- 15:41want a steak dinner? What can we do for you?
- 15:43People are looking out for each other. I mean,
- 15:46not everyone, but some are. And I think that
- 15:49is the idea in the movie where there is this...
- 15:54And we're just thinking, hey, we're just going
- 15:56through the motions, like war is war, it's okay,
- 15:58things will end, and things will get better at
- 16:00some point, and we won't have to be captured
- 16:02or prosecuted for who we are. And that is the
- 16:05illusion of this will continue to happen forever
- 16:08and ever. And that's why the end is the way that
- 16:12it ends. I was about to get into it, I'm not
- 16:14going to get into it right now. To me, it was
- 16:17just one big metaphor of... what life is in war
- 16:22and that being the grand illusion i don't know
- 16:26if it's like a perfect metaphor but that's the
- 16:28the grand theme to it that i missed yeah i almost
- 16:32took it because it deals so much with class because
- 16:34i i think the reason these prisoners are treated
- 16:37so kindly is because of their rank true uh and
- 16:43then their um heritage comes into play and that's
- 16:47when they're treated differently yeah i think
- 16:49when they first walk through the door when they
- 16:51say oh we we shot down some planes we have some
- 16:53officers here it's very important to mention
- 16:55that they're officers um that's when they bring
- 16:59them in they're like oh okay officers we're also
- 17:01officers like we're all high ranking officials
- 17:02in our respective armies uh or militaries rather
- 17:06and i i think that opening scene was kind of
- 17:10the most impactful in the entire movie for me
- 17:12which is kind of a bummer to you know have the
- 17:16high be at the very beginning but i thought it
- 17:18was it was fascinating like they walk in and
- 17:21one of their arms is injured uh because the soldier
- 17:25that went to go collect them after they'd been
- 17:27shot down was like hey i took him to the hospital
- 17:29he was injured and they bring them in and they're
- 17:31like hey sorry about that uh but we're having
- 17:33dinner if you want to hang out and to me their
- 17:38whole internment felt like the grand illusion
- 17:41where they're like yeah we're being kept here
- 17:45as prisoners but like it's not so bad like they
- 17:48treat us pretty decently like we're being fed
- 17:51not great but not awful either you know and i
- 17:55don't know beyond that every time they were looking
- 17:57for a reason to escape it it almost felt like
- 18:00satirical because the reasons for escape were
- 18:03never displayed on screen well the conditions
- 18:08To drive them to escape. Yeah. And the conditions
- 18:10there are like, you know, they're not eating
- 18:11as well as they want to. They don't have as much
- 18:14freedom. They're in these rooms together. We
- 18:17do see a moment of isolation for Marshall to
- 18:20where he's contained from everyone else. And
- 18:23we see him go a little mad in that. But otherwise,
- 18:26every time that there is a prison break attempt
- 18:29or a prison break, it again, this is just what
- 18:33kind of baffled me a little bit, too, is it's
- 18:36almost like a sitcom. And this all sounds negative.
- 18:39We'll get back to how it's not, at least for
- 18:41me. It feels like a sitcom to where they're digging
- 18:45a hole, but then when someone sees them in the
- 18:47hole, it's that sitcom intro moment where the
- 18:50person shakes their head and looks at the camera
- 18:52and just kind of is like, can you believe this
- 18:54guy? And they're like, ha ha, you like to escape
- 18:58prisons, do you? Well, I guess we're just going
- 19:00to send you to a prison where it's more difficult
- 19:02to do that. And it's never like, you know, a
- 19:06punishment. I mean, I guess that's a punishment
- 19:08in itself, but there's never like any severity
- 19:10to it. It's just more so like, oh, you better
- 19:13not escape from this prison. Yeah. And the tone
- 19:16of that had me so confused as to why this was.
- 19:19And I think it is like you said, that class difference
- 19:23of. If they weren't officers, if they were just
- 19:26like people that they picked up off the street,
- 19:28there'd be a difference to it. But they're treating
- 19:30them a certain way. And it's not until they get
- 19:33to this impenetrable fortress of a prison, which
- 19:36is ran by Rothenstein, as you mentioned, Erich
- 19:40von Strahan. And it's here where he kind of has
- 19:44the same mentality. He greets them all very cordially.
- 19:48And it's not until he recognizes Bordeaux. and
- 19:51begins talking with him that we start seeing
- 19:53his difference in um interest in terms of class
- 19:56of like yes you're all captains but you're french
- 20:00or you're not correct me if i'm wrong here was
- 20:02it like you're not like like them like i view
- 20:05them differently than i view you and i'm trying
- 20:07to remember why that was isn't it because they
- 20:10they met Oh, previously they met previously,
- 20:13but also, uh, Baldo is not, uh, Jewish like Rosenthal.
- 20:18Right. Um, so he, he treated them differently.
- 20:20And of course, German officer, like that was
- 20:23obviously a very trying time. Um, so that just
- 20:26a clear division, uh, on their side. So that,
- 20:30that was one that to me, it was interesting because
- 20:32you start seeing some duality to a character
- 20:35and specifically in Rothenstein. And this is
- 20:38interesting to me. I'm interested in your thoughts
- 20:40on it because Raffenstein, I really like this
- 20:43character and I really like Straheim in that
- 20:45role. Yeah. But this is a movie that to me at
- 20:49times it was hard to kind of like for me to piece
- 20:51together the tone of it. Is it a satire? Is it
- 20:55like, you know, kind of a comedy? Is it just
- 20:57a drama that's like right down the line? And
- 21:00part of that, I think, is the fact that like
- 21:02the director, Jean Renoir. And Stroheim actually
- 21:07collaborated on the character of Raufenstein
- 21:10and merged two separate characters together into
- 21:16Raufenstein. So there was a German commander
- 21:20who was relentless and then someone who was like
- 21:24a little more compassionate towards Bordeaux
- 21:26and decided to merge that into one person. So
- 21:29instead of just making Raufenstein like this,
- 21:31like relentless, you know, head of the prison.
- 21:35They decided to give him like some heart to him.
- 21:37And I think that makes him extremely likable
- 21:39in this. But at the same time, he's not supposed
- 21:41to be a likable character. Right. So how did
- 21:44you feel about Ruffenstein? I mean, I think he's
- 21:48like a memorable character. I think is like the
- 21:51most accurate way to put it. I don't know if
- 21:54I liked him or disliked him at any one point.
- 21:56But I think like just his on -screen presence
- 21:58is really impactful. His look is really interesting
- 22:02because he's in his whole military garb and everything.
- 22:06But then he also has this, like, neck brace on
- 22:08underneath his outfit. And it's funny, when I
- 22:11was reading Letterboxd reviews and things, everybody
- 22:14mentions that. Like, oh, it's so iconic. I've
- 22:16seen this for years. And I'm like, man, I've
- 22:19never seen this outside of this movie, but I
- 22:21understand, like, why it is iconic. And even
- 22:25that look, like, he's very stiff and... Constantly
- 22:30standing upright, mostly because of his neck
- 22:32brace, but it deals with his personality as well,
- 22:36where he is an officer. He is very stern, but
- 22:39also softer than you would expect him to be,
- 22:41like you were just saying. But I think it made
- 22:44not only his character, but the entire movie
- 22:47a little confusing for me, just tonally, like
- 22:50you said. I kept thinking about Dr. Strangelove
- 22:54when I was watching this movie. Have you ever
- 22:56seen that? Oh, yeah. Okay. Like, that's very,
- 22:59very, like, you know you're watching satire when
- 23:02you watch that movie. And in this, you're kind
- 23:05of constantly thinking, like, well, is that what
- 23:07this is? Is it comedy or is it straight drama?
- 23:10Just sprinkled with a little bit of teehee, ha
- 23:13-ha, you know? And by the end of it, I was like,
- 23:17I think this really leans more towards Dr. Strangelove
- 23:20for me. Because in what world do prisoners get
- 23:24treated this way, this kindly? And I think that...
- 23:28Eric von Stroheim's character is such a big component
- 23:33to that, because you expect certain things from
- 23:35him, and that's not the character he is at all.
- 23:39Yeah, I don't fully understand, but I will say
- 23:42that I really did enjoy my time with The Grand
- 23:45Illusion. That'll come out in my rating. But
- 23:48I had a really good time with it, and I think
- 23:50it's because I did just give myself over to the
- 23:53tone of it. And the tone is variable. Like there
- 23:57is a lot going on. And just in terms of like,
- 24:01I mean, I guess the best word for it is like
- 24:04the pacing, the subject matter, the tone of the
- 24:09overall movie. I just gave myself over to it
- 24:12and I just kind of let it happen. And I ended
- 24:15up enjoying that a good bit. And I agree with
- 24:18you. I don't fully understand. And I do think
- 24:20that that's it's less a issue of the movie and
- 24:23it's more. You know, one thing that we don't
- 24:26talk a lot about in this series is that these
- 24:30movies were made roughly 90 years ago. Right.
- 24:34Right. And so much has changed in that time.
- 24:38And not just in, you know, themes. And not just
- 24:42in the way movies are made. And not how things
- 24:44are communicated. Dialect has changed. Like,
- 24:47political parties have changed. Like, so much
- 24:50is different from now than it was then. Yeah.
- 24:52That contextually. We are so lost whenever we
- 24:56talk about some of these things. You add on top
- 24:58of that the foreign language element of this
- 25:01and a completely different place nationally,
- 25:04like a different nation. And I think there's
- 25:07so much context that I'm missing that this doesn't
- 25:11fully land for me the way that it landed for
- 25:13everyone else back then. And I'm sure that we're
- 25:15missing some of that context. Yeah. So I want
- 25:18to put an asterisk on like anytime we talk about
- 25:20like confusing because that's just confusing
- 25:22for me. right and me i'm with you yeah i wasn't
- 25:26gonna throw you under the bus but yeah for us
- 25:28no drag me it's it's so confusing for us because
- 25:32we're missing that context so it's more of an
- 25:34issue on our side than it is the movies but the
- 25:37movie never comes across as like hey that's lazy
- 25:39or hey this doesn't make sense why you're doing
- 25:41that it's more i don't know if i fully have the
- 25:43pieces that i need to solve this just yet yeah
- 25:46does that sound right for what you experienced
- 25:48yeah yeah i think it and not even like just this
- 25:53movie. Because I feel like it doesn't speak so
- 25:58specifically about this prison camp or what war
- 26:03is going on or anything like that. You don't
- 26:06really have to know the political climate in
- 26:10the real world. It does help to know why it was
- 26:12made. But if you're just sitting in the movie,
- 26:15there aren't specifics that I think are necessary
- 26:18to know about the real world. I think the movie
- 26:21is trying to make a broader statement about just
- 26:24war in general and the world in general and class
- 26:28in general. So yes, I agree with you because
- 26:31there are so many of these movies where I'm just
- 26:33like, I don't know history well enough to be
- 26:36able to follow one -to -one. But with this movie,
- 26:39for me at least, it's almost just that the themes
- 26:43and the topics and the style in which they are
- 26:47presented themselves were not interesting to
- 26:51me. And I don't know if that is a deeper evaluation
- 26:57of how I feel about French cinema. Because I've
- 27:01watched more modern French as well, and I always
- 27:04kind of struggle just a little bit. And it might
- 27:06just be culturally, the storytelling there. So
- 27:10I think that's kind of an interesting thing to
- 27:12look at, where there are some Letterboxd reviews
- 27:15that say, oh, Jean Renoir? I don't get it, you
- 27:19know? I've seen a lot of reviews like that, and
- 27:21I think maybe I might be that guy, which sucks.
- 27:25It sucks to, like, see a movie get such a high
- 27:27rating and then be like, why is everybody clapping?
- 27:31What did I miss? I'm the problem, you know? But
- 27:35I couldn't figure this movie out. I really couldn't.
- 27:37And I think that if we, you know, not go beat
- 27:40by beat for the movie, but you have that introduction
- 27:43where the officers show up and they're treated
- 27:46very kindly and, like, friendships almost blossom.
- 27:49There's a really great moment, too, where as
- 27:51they're sitting down enjoying dinner, they bring
- 27:53in the it's almost like a coffin, right, of another
- 27:57soldier that has died. And they're just like,
- 27:59yeah, we're going to take care of them. And the
- 28:02officers of the German army are like, sorry about
- 28:05that. You know, it was it was before we knew
- 28:07you were coming over to dinner. We wouldn't have
- 28:10done it otherwise. It's like so silly to me.
- 28:14Not silly. Silly in a satirical way. Like, that
- 28:17feels like satire. Yeah. Like, it's supposed
- 28:19to be such dark satire that it's not something
- 28:23you're going to laugh at. You're just going to
- 28:24be like, wow, geez. Like, you're supposed to
- 28:27react just a little bit to it. That's throughout
- 28:31the movie. That humor that you're talking about
- 28:33is throughout the movie where they are mentioning,
- 28:35you know, hey, well, you understand why we had
- 28:38to shoot down that plane, right? And they're
- 28:39like, oh, yes, of course. That's our bad for
- 28:42being over here. And again, like... In the name
- 28:45of satire, it does come across as just so cordial.
- 28:50And everyone is so kind to each other at certain
- 28:53times. And then obviously, you know, not other
- 28:55times. And Ruffenstein is a perfect example of
- 28:59that. Speaking of Ruffenstein, I wanted to bring
- 29:02up, you mentioned the neck brace that he wears.
- 29:05But the thing for anyone who has not seen this
- 29:07movie or seen a cover for this. uh, Rothenstein
- 29:10is wearing this neck brace that's made of like
- 29:13steel or metal. Yeah. And it is, it runs under
- 29:17his jaw and it like just comes to the edge of
- 29:20his chin and it encompasses his entire jaw and
- 29:23then goes up to his chin. And he is a Bond villain.
- 29:27Like that is, that is a perfect Bond villain
- 29:30look. And the way that Straheim plays him is
- 29:33that where it's kind of, it reminds me of, um,
- 29:36I forgot who he played in, um, Skyfall, but Javier
- 29:40Bardem? Yes. I don't remember his character.
- 29:43That sounds familiar. I think it's Silva. I think
- 29:45he nailed it. The way that he plays Silva in
- 29:48that movie is similar to how Straheim plays Raufenstein
- 29:53in this, where it's kind of like, you know, I
- 29:56mean, sure, I could kill you right now, but what's
- 29:57the fun in that? Like, you know, this is my system,
- 30:01and I'm so proud of this, like, fortress, you
- 30:02can never escape. This is one comment that I
- 30:05had on the movie, and this isn't the movie's
- 30:07fault. It's just more 90 years of cinema that's
- 30:10been inspired by this and other movies like it
- 30:12and how this has resulted. There is something
- 30:16really funny to me about whenever prisons are
- 30:18like, how did they break out? You're like, yeah,
- 30:20that is crazy. What kind of insane system do
- 30:22they have? And they're like, well, they had a
- 30:24spoon. It's always the spoon. And they dug out,
- 30:27and we didn't expect it. And I kind of let that
- 30:30go. But when they're like, all right. You rascals,
- 30:33we're going to have to send you somewhere else
- 30:34because you keep trying to break out of this
- 30:36prison. We're going to send you to a prison that
- 30:38you can't break out of. And they're like, okay,
- 30:40let's see how this goes. And they get there.
- 30:43And ultimately, spoilers for The Grand Illusion,
- 30:46they escape because they caused a distraction,
- 30:50made rope out of multiple clothing materials,
- 30:53and then climbed out a window and ran. I feel
- 30:58like there shouldn't be a window that can open.
- 31:01That they can then get out? You know, these two
- 31:06tactics, the spoon tactic and the sheet tactic,
- 31:10these have been done so many times in real life,
- 31:14too. Like, what is it? Escape from Alcatraz?
- 31:18Like, that's how they got out with the spoons,
- 31:20right? Or at least that's how they started to
- 31:23get out. Right. Yeah. But do you think that in
- 31:26modern prisons, they're like, we don't do spoons,
- 31:29we don't do sheets? Everything else is fine.
- 31:32You can have whatever. You can have cell phones.
- 31:35Like, they don't collect any contraband brought
- 31:40in by anybody except for spoons and sheets. I
- 31:43just don't know who's making their prisons out
- 31:45of red clay. I'm going to be so honest with you.
- 31:46Like, who's making prisons out of red clay? Who
- 31:49is building, like, giant crate and barrel windows?
- 31:55And, I mean, the sheets are just going to be
- 31:57natural. That's sure. But, like, bars. And I'm
- 32:01not trying to, trust me, one thing I'm not interested
- 32:03in doing is telling the American prison system
- 32:06how to run their system and how to make things
- 32:09more difficult for people to break out of. That's
- 32:12not something I'm interested in doing. But what
- 32:14I am interested in is how prisons back then were
- 32:18expecting, I mean, maybe that's part of the whole,
- 32:20like, everyone is so cordial and nice to each
- 32:22other. You guys don't want to leave here, right?
- 32:24We're having a good time. Right. I don't know
- 32:26if that's... Stockholm Syndrome kind of thing?
- 32:27Exactly, yeah. But not even Stockholm Syndrome.
- 32:30They're just straight up like, yeah, I mean,
- 32:31so Parcheesi Night is like tomorrow. What are
- 32:33you guys doing? Lumiere comes out. He's like,
- 32:35B. Prisoner. Yeah. I do want to talk a bit about
- 32:43Jean Gabin as Marshall. He, first off, handsome.
- 32:50Handsome. That hair. I don't know if Christopher
- 32:54Nolan is taking any kind of inspiration from
- 32:55here, but with the hair and everything, I'm getting
- 32:58a little bit of a gab in from him. Yeah? Of Nolan?
- 33:01Well, just because Nolan has the perfectly coiled
- 33:03English hair and everything. I don't know if
- 33:05it's a European thing. But anyways, outside of
- 33:08that, I thought he was fantastic in this movie.
- 33:11I really, really liked Jean -Gabin's performance.
- 33:15And it's almost like one that in the first 30
- 33:17minutes, you're kind of like, who's the lead
- 33:20in this movie? Yeah. And it's hard to kind of
- 33:22read what's going on. But he is so good. And
- 33:26I think he's just like, to me, he's so impressive
- 33:29because he comes out of nowhere. And to me, he
- 33:32kind of like also runs the screen similar to
- 33:35how Cary Grant does, similar to how Spencer Tracy
- 33:38does. And he has such an idea of like how to
- 33:40then take the movie and put it on his shoulders.
- 33:42Yeah. I thought he was fantastic. Yeah. Uh -oh.
- 33:46No, no, no. He really was good. Man. This is
- 33:50just one of those movies where, like, I struggled
- 33:52with it overall. So a lot of the minor, not minor,
- 33:55but a lot of the details were lost on me. Yes,
- 33:58he is very good. And it's exciting to see, like,
- 34:02a name pop up that we're so unfamiliar with because
- 34:05it is a French actor. But, like, I can't think
- 34:10of a memorable moment where I was like, wow,
- 34:13he was so good in that particular scene. And,
- 34:15like, I'm going to think about that moving on.
- 34:17Like, is that... thing for you well i i think
- 34:20specifically the scene where he's given the most
- 34:22to do in that exact moment outside of like you
- 34:24know elsa later on is uh when he's put in containment
- 34:28and he's slowly losing his mind and he's rejecting
- 34:31like food and everything and even in that it
- 34:34feels like such like a a cordial like the guard
- 34:37sits next to him is like hey man i got some dinner
- 34:39for you if you're interested like you know you
- 34:41can't see your friends or anything but here you
- 34:43go The tone of it overall, and I can't name a
- 34:47specific line or anything, but I believe there's
- 34:49one monologue from him that I really liked. And
- 34:51it's more seeing him kind of losing his mind
- 34:53over time and become comfortable with the idea
- 34:56of what this looks like. But also just him running
- 35:00in the very end. I love that final scene. It's
- 35:03not like he did specific great running. It's
- 35:05just there's many moments of him that I enjoy
- 35:07that I can't really recall right now. it's funny
- 35:10when you're going through the list here of all
- 35:12the characters and you're writing down like the
- 35:13actors and everything, because the second name
- 35:16that I had listed here was, uh, Dita Parlo as
- 35:19Elsa. Yeah. And we got like an hour and 40 minutes
- 35:21in this movie. And I was like, is there a woman?
- 35:24Right. Like I have not seen an Elsa or a Dita
- 35:27Parlo, Paul, uh, show up at all in this. Yeah.
- 35:31Um, and it's not until later on that obviously
- 35:33we meet her because it's when, uh, Marshall and
- 35:37was it Rosenthal? Because Baldo sacrificed himself.
- 35:41Yeah. So it should be those two. When they escape.
- 35:44And, oh, that was a scene that I loved. I'll
- 35:47get back to that. They escape from the prison
- 35:49because Baldo has sacrificed himself, which is
- 35:51a great scene of Baldo kind of like calling Rothenstein's
- 35:55bluff of, hey, you're not going to shoot because
- 35:58you appreciate me too much. I will say, while
- 36:01I did like that scene, I thought there was a
- 36:03little too much, like, a little too much. like
- 36:07goofiness in that yeah where he's like hey you
- 36:09better not run he's like well i'm gonna and he
- 36:11starts running he's like hey and then he stops
- 36:14and he's like i'm telling you i probably you
- 36:15probably shouldn't run he's like but i'm gonna
- 36:17and then he runs again and he's like hey one
- 36:20more time and he stops and looks i'm like just
- 36:22run like right at this point just run uh and
- 36:26that's ultimately what where he meets his fate
- 36:28i would like a pullout shot from that like maybe
- 36:31a pan out where we can see how far rofenstein
- 36:34was from bordeaux because i just don't know if
- 36:36i believe that his aim is that good at that distance
- 36:40to have like a fatal blow but because he's got
- 36:42like a little like mauser right like a little
- 36:45german pistol right and at this point they're
- 36:47not just like hey um don't go They're like shouting
- 36:50to each other. So I'm like, you're far away.
- 36:52And he's higher up on like the rocks. So it's
- 36:54hard for you to see him. But anyways, that's
- 36:57a distraction that Marichal and Rosenthal need
- 37:00to escape. They escape and then they start turning
- 37:03on each other. And there's some tension between
- 37:07them. But then they end up in a farmhouse. And
- 37:09this is where they meet Elsa. And Elsa is someone
- 37:12that they attach themselves to, specifically
- 37:15Marichal, who becomes romantically involved.
- 37:18with Elsa. And he kind of has to tell her later
- 37:22on, this isn't going to work out between us because
- 37:24I'm going to have continued to be on the run
- 37:26for the rest of my life. Yeah. Until I can at
- 37:28least get somewhere to where this, you know,
- 37:30isn't a problem anymore and we can get there
- 37:32too. But Elsa was one when I saw that list, I
- 37:35was just like, I don't know where she's going
- 37:36to fit into this. Is she going to be like an
- 37:38attendant in the prisoner camp? Is she going
- 37:41to be someone who's writing in or something?
- 37:43She was just kind of at the end. So I don't know
- 37:45why she was listed, especially above like Baldo,
- 37:47Ruffenstein, and Rosenthal for me, who are way
- 37:51more present. I think it's every movie has to
- 37:53have a romance. So you've got to list the romantic
- 37:56interest pretty high on the billing. even if
- 38:00it means sitting through an hour and 40 minutes
- 38:02of a movie to be like, oh, there she is. I'm
- 38:05going to be honest. If there's a romance in this
- 38:06movie, it's Ruffenstein and Boldo. Yeah. Which
- 38:09I ship. I'm very happy to ship that. Yeah. But
- 38:13that's the romance that I looked at in this movie.
- 38:16Can we go back to that scene where he runs and
- 38:19gets shot? Boldo and Ruffenstein? Yeah. I think
- 38:21that's a big reason this movie didn't land for
- 38:24me, because that should be the scene that showcases
- 38:28the, like, grand illusion the hey we're friends
- 38:32you know like you have led me to believe that
- 38:34you guys are like care about us enough to not
- 38:38be cruel to not uh extract uh exert any type
- 38:42of like actual punishment other than confinement
- 38:45you know so he goes to run but then that back
- 38:49and forth you were talking about makes it feel
- 38:51like a farce and it just doesn't land for me
- 38:55it feels not even satirical just And it, I don't
- 39:01know, I feel like I was trying to be on board
- 39:04for most of the movie, but the tone was like
- 39:06kind of dragging me all over the place. And then
- 39:08getting to that point, the movie kind of lost
- 39:11my respect in what it was trying to do. Does
- 39:15that make sense? It makes sense. It's just funny
- 39:17because the way that I watched it. It's funny
- 39:20for me because the way that I watched it, I felt
- 39:22that same way about that scene, but it was less
- 39:25like, I can't take you seriously. And it's more
- 39:26like, what am I missing in this? Yeah. Because
- 39:29I can tell like it's, it's shot so well. It is
- 39:32a beautiful looking movie. The acting is great.
- 39:34It's just the decisions in the screenplay to
- 39:36make this such a easygoing effort for everyone
- 39:41involved seems intentional. And I'm trying to
- 39:43understand why that is. Like, I understand what
- 39:46theme you're going for. I just I'm trying to
- 39:48decide this or I'm trying to figure out this
- 39:50decision to do that. Because, again, the way
- 39:53that we describe this is, you know, he could
- 39:56shoot at any time and we understand what he doesn't
- 39:58initially. Right. Like, that's his friend. But
- 40:00it's just there's one, maybe two times too many
- 40:03that they stop each other. Yeah. We're like,
- 40:05OK, what are we doing? What is this? One thing
- 40:08that I think may hurt this is that the audience
- 40:10or not the audience, the background cast. isn't
- 40:15really interacting with the leads this way. I
- 40:18think in that scene, if, if Rothenstein was like,
- 40:23Hey, just come on, please don't leave. Don't
- 40:27run. We're having such a great time. What's going
- 40:28on? And then he runs again and he stops. We're
- 40:32having a good time. He stops him. If one of his
- 40:36soldiers behind him was like, uh sir he's getting
- 40:39away shoot him like something where like clearly
- 40:41the prison is run one way and then ruffenstein
- 40:45is now breaking the rules for his friendship
- 40:47with him if there's something communicated like
- 40:50that even small like one little line interaction
- 40:53or something and like ruffenstein like shoves
- 40:55him away or something sure that communicates
- 40:58it but they're kind of just like waiting along
- 41:00with him like waiting for him to take a shot
- 41:02so there i think there needed to be something
- 41:05like that where there's Group communication saying,
- 41:09hey, this is how things normally go and this
- 41:10is how things have differed versus like, you
- 41:13know, please rate us five stars on your way out
- 41:16of the escape. Like, yeah, there's just something
- 41:19missing from that. Yeah, yeah. And unfortunately,
- 41:22I think that scene was enough to just completely
- 41:24tailspin the movie for me. Interesting. Because
- 41:27there's another 30, 40 minutes after that. Yeah.
- 41:29And there's a big shift in the movie itself as
- 41:33soon as the two escape. Because then you're not
- 41:37dealing with Rothenstein anymore. You're just
- 41:39kind of dealing with this. It's not like a love
- 41:42triangle, but the three adults like living together
- 41:45in this farmhouse. Do you think that the movie
- 41:48loses some power there as well? I think so. I
- 41:53think that. Honestly, you could have taken out
- 41:55the whole section with Elsa, and I really wouldn't
- 41:57have had much of an issue at all. Because I think
- 42:00the interest is more in the brotherhood of these
- 42:03three individuals and some others when the first
- 42:06prisoner or two. But the chemistry in these three,
- 42:11and specifically Rothenstein, I think that once
- 42:14he exits the movie, there really isn't much...
- 42:19or much to keep the pace alive. Yeah, I just
- 42:22don't know what they were trying to express in
- 42:26the farmhouse section. Well, that to me does
- 42:29make sense. I understand what they were doing
- 42:31because they're trying to say like, well, hey,
- 42:32that's all over. Like, that's all over and now
- 42:35this is life. Like, you can now live with Elsa
- 42:37and everything is going to be okay. And that
- 42:40is, again, the illusion that they're trying to
- 42:43shake. That like, you can escape war. Right.
- 42:46So and I understand that, like, you can escape
- 42:49war in some senses, like at the very end of the
- 42:51movie, but that's more a technicality than it
- 42:53is like the idea of war, it's just going to continue
- 42:55to happen somewhere else. So I do understand
- 42:58what they're doing with that. I don't think it's
- 42:59as successful as they want it to be. Yeah. But
- 43:02I read it as like, you know, the idea is that
- 43:04you can get past the trials and tribulations
- 43:09of your life, and you can move on and things
- 43:11are okay. Yeah, you got out of the prison, but
- 43:13now they're just going to chase after you. So
- 43:16they're going to find you at some point. Now
- 43:17you have to live with that like dread of, are
- 43:19they going to show up? Are they going to find
- 43:21me? Am I really safe? So that is the illusion
- 43:24ultimately. So I understand that. I just don't
- 43:27think it's successful. And your interpretation
- 43:30of what grand illusion in this movie is, is not
- 43:34the same as mine. So I think that that doesn't
- 43:37like that logic and reason doesn't. work for
- 43:41me because i'm like well well that's not what
- 43:43i got from like the war part of it i almost feel
- 43:46like the grand illusion like you could say we're
- 43:50being treated kindly and stuff so it's like the
- 43:52illusion of friendliness and and like camaraderie
- 43:56amongst enemies even is the grand illusion but
- 44:00i think it's almost interesting to look at it
- 44:02from the flip side and say like war itself is
- 44:07the grand illusion because look at how well everybody
- 44:09can get along together right like i'm a mechanic
- 44:13you're a mechanic there's so much we have in
- 44:16common but if you try to escape i am required
- 44:20to shoot you you know and i think that the war
- 44:24itself becomes the illusion where it's just like
- 44:27yeah we do this thing every few years or whatever
- 44:30where we turn on Our brothers and our sisters,
- 44:34you know, and we just decide, yeah, well, we're
- 44:37going to kill them for whatever reason. Doesn't
- 44:40matter. I think that that's almost the illusion,
- 44:44you know? And it could be both. One thing I want
- 44:48to say is that sometimes when we're doing these
- 44:50episodes, there isn't so much content to the
- 44:53movie to where we can actually have a conversation
- 44:55like this. It's more just, hey, this was done
- 44:57really well. I like this. This is why it was
- 44:59nominated. It's almost kind of a relief that
- 45:02this movie was nominated for just one thing because
- 45:04now we have the opportunity to talk about so
- 45:06many other things like the meaning of this movie.
- 45:09And I don't think that either of us are wrong.
- 45:11Well... We could be. But I don't think that we're
- 45:14wrong for seeing different things in it because,
- 45:16again, that's what happens when movies like this
- 45:18are a little more open and they aren't fully
- 45:21direct. And sometimes that's really good. And
- 45:23sometimes that makes for a great movie. And sometimes
- 45:25it makes for better conversation than it does
- 45:29for a movie. So I'm really enjoying this kind
- 45:32of episode for us to just talk through what this
- 45:35could mean. And I don't think that either is
- 45:37necessarily an incorrect way to read it. Because
- 45:40the satire of it, whether it's intended to be
- 45:43satire or not, is so present. Right. And that
- 45:48has to be the idea of what the illusion can be.
- 45:51I like the idea of both. I don't think either
- 45:53are there because it's so into the script. It's
- 45:56so in the screenplay and the way these interactions
- 45:57happen. That mechanic thing you mentioned is
- 46:00in the very beginning. That is like, oh, hey,
- 46:02this guy's a mechanic, too. We should talk about
- 46:04this. And it's not played for laughs. It's just
- 46:07more of a surreal thing. Isn't this like, and
- 46:12this makes it more difficult as like, you know,
- 46:13an American that doesn't speak French watching
- 46:15this movie where you're like, I mean, did I miss
- 46:18something? Like I looked away for five seconds
- 46:20and like, these guys are kind of like playing
- 46:22volleyball together. Like, are they, are they
- 46:24okay? Are they prisoners? I don't fully understand
- 46:26what's going on here. And it almost seems like
- 46:28an experiment sometimes of like, you're waiting
- 46:32for the other shoe to drop. You're waiting for
- 46:33the inglorious bastard scene where like someone
- 46:35holds up three the wrong way and they're like,
- 46:37time to turn on this person. And that doesn't
- 46:41really come unless they just try to escape or
- 46:43try some like, you know, foolish mistake. The
- 46:47funny thing to me is when they first get to the
- 46:51prison for Raufenstein and Raufenstein greets
- 46:53them, they're like, well, hey, you know, we're
- 46:56just going to try and get out of this, right?
- 46:57He's like, yeah, I know. It's just not possible
- 46:59here. So that's what makes it really fun. Like,
- 47:02you know, you guys can try, but there really
- 47:04isn't anything there. So he's not even saying
- 47:05like, don't do it. He's like, yeah, I mean, go
- 47:07for it. Yeah. Which again, makes him almost sound
- 47:09like a Bond villain, like you mentioned earlier,
- 47:11because it is just almost like he's toying with
- 47:15them in a way. Yeah. Yeah. I don't know. I've
- 47:18seen so many people describe this as like the
- 47:20greatest anti -war film of all time. Sure. So
- 47:24if that's the way it's presented to me, I feel
- 47:27like I'm digging through every scene in the movie
- 47:30to figure out like, well, how is this preaching?
- 47:34anti -war or war is bad bad because we watch
- 47:37all quiet on the western front right and that
- 47:39is a very very much like an anti -war film but
- 47:41it's presented in a way of look at how brutal
- 47:45war is look at like what people have to go through
- 47:49and and just how terrible it is and in this you
- 47:52don't see any of the terrible so for it to be
- 47:56an anti -war movie i think that's that's why
- 47:58i cling to the idea of like war war isn't a brutal
- 48:03terrible thing in this movie war is just a silly
- 48:07stupid thing of like why why are we doing this
- 48:12look at how we can just get along but we have
- 48:17to put on this act of okay well you're my prisoner
- 48:20and this is what's going to happen if you do
- 48:22wrong but have a great time buddy see i wouldn't
- 48:26say that it's the greatest anti -war movie A,
- 48:28a fall time. B, that we've watched for this pod.
- 48:31I wouldn't say that either. Right. So I think
- 48:34that that's a, that's a tough thing to read up
- 48:37front because I think that that's, you know,
- 48:39we read that sometimes and we'll be like, oh,
- 48:41okay, cool. That's the gospel. I'm going to be
- 48:43like thinking about that, watching this. Or now
- 48:46that I watched the movie, I'm going to see that.
- 48:47And now I'm going to like warp, not warp, but
- 48:49I'm going to be thinking about that and how my
- 48:52idea of it can fit into it. Right. The other
- 48:54thing too, is that this is just a very subjective
- 48:57movie. Because, not just in its open themes and
- 49:00even the way we're discussing it, but also, this
- 49:03film was banned in Germany and France. Right.
- 49:07And this was during World War II, obviously.
- 49:10And this is what I find so funny about this.
- 49:13The Germans believed that it was too anti -German.
- 49:17Yeah. While France claimed it was too anti -war.
- 49:21Okay. So, and both of these things could be true.
- 49:25Maybe it is anti -German and anti -war, but it's
- 49:28just that, like, that is proof that, like, two
- 49:30opposite sides of this are, like, well, not opposite
- 49:34sides, but two different countries are viewing
- 49:36this differently. Right, right. And that's so
- 49:40interesting to me. And I think that's when what
- 49:42you mentioned earlier, like, having an understanding
- 49:44of, like, the political climate of the era kind
- 49:48of shapes the way the movie is presented and
- 49:51kind of interpreted. I think that's what's interesting
- 49:54is that we look at this in two different ways.
- 49:56And when we watch these movies, we just want
- 49:59the movie to be telling us something and we want
- 50:01a story and we want visual storytelling. We want
- 50:04like good storytelling in the script and performances
- 50:06that are fantastic. And I think this movie is
- 50:10one of those. You ever saw Mallrats? I have not
- 50:14seen Mallrats. There's a scene in Mallrats where
- 50:16one of the characters is looking at one of those
- 50:18visual puzzles. We're supposed to look at this
- 50:20jumbled mess, and you're supposed to see the
- 50:22sailboat. I forget what it's called. It's like
- 50:24an optical illusion. Yeah. I'm going to get to...
- 50:26Wow, I'm going to circle... Dude, I'm going to
- 50:28thread the needle so well on this. Watch me.
- 50:31Optical illusion. And he's looking at it, and
- 50:34you have to look at it hard enough until you
- 50:36can see the sailboat. And you can differentiate
- 50:38everything else and just see the sailboat in
- 50:40it. And the whole movie, so many other things
- 50:42are happening, but this side character is just
- 50:44constantly looking. And he's just waiting for
- 50:47the sailboat to show up because he can't see
- 50:48it. And at the end, when he's about to see it,
- 50:51something gets knocked over and he gets so mad.
- 50:53I think that this movie is an optical illusion.
- 50:57Interesting. And this movie is where you're supposed
- 50:59to be looking at it. And if you look long enough,
- 51:01you might be able to find the thing that the
- 51:03movie is really trying to say to you. But it's
- 51:05not saying one specific thing. It is giving you
- 51:07multiple things. I'm not trying to be cheeky
- 51:11and be like, maybe the grand illusion is the
- 51:13grand illusion. I'm not saying that, but I think
- 51:16that this movie is less of a, hey, here is like,
- 51:20I'm telling you how to feel. And it's more, I'm
- 51:22putting it all in there. And whatever you decide
- 51:24to see, that's correct. And that's your way to
- 51:27see it. But ultimately there is, there are multiple
- 51:30things you can find in this, but I feel like
- 51:32there has to be a source code. I feel that there
- 51:35is a source code in this. I just haven't fully
- 51:37deciphered it. So that's why for me, I enjoyed
- 51:39this more because I gave myself into the optical
- 51:42illusion of it and didn't try to like label it.
- 51:46If that makes sense. Yeah. Yeah. No, that does
- 51:48make sense. I think that seeing this is the greatest
- 51:51anti -war movie of all time. Oh, God. At the
- 51:53start. Yeah. Really kind of skewed like how I
- 51:56was watching the movie. Of course. Which is a
- 51:58bummer. Because ultimately, you can probably
- 52:02tell based on the way I've been talking about
- 52:03the movie the whole time, I gave this movie two
- 52:05stars. Okay. And that's the lowest of anybody
- 52:09I follow on Letterboxd. And I think the lowest
- 52:11of any of the Letterboxd reviews that I saw,
- 52:15scrolling for like 10 minutes, you know? And
- 52:18that's one of those moments where I'm like, uh
- 52:21-oh. I'm going to have to retire as podcast host
- 52:24now. Because I messed up somehow. Like, I don't
- 52:27know what happened. But what did you give the
- 52:29movie? Four stars. Yeah, see? And I'm not saying
- 52:34four stars. I understood everything perfect.
- 52:38I'm just saying four stars. I enjoyed my time
- 52:40with this. And I'm eager to figure out more in
- 52:43the future. Yeah. And I think sometimes movies
- 52:46can be so obtuse that it's frustrating. And this,
- 52:50while it is a little obtuse at times, is not
- 52:53intentionally doing that. There is more going
- 52:55on. It's more, hey, I can't crack the code to
- 52:58this. Sometimes I think it's more upsetting to
- 53:00be, I mean, this isn't like a rare opinion. I
- 53:04compare it to like, there's a safe in front of
- 53:06me and I don't have the lock combination versus
- 53:09I have a safe in front of me and it's broken,
- 53:12right? Like there is something to get in. There
- 53:15is a way to get into this. I have to figure it
- 53:18out. This is the Dark Souls in me. I play Dark
- 53:20Souls, like Bloodborne and all the FromSoft games.
- 53:23So this is the like, hey, let me be patient.
- 53:26Let me try and figure it out. There's probably
- 53:28a way through this. Versus I'm going to use my
- 53:31controller to beat through the television and
- 53:33grab this villain and shake him by the neck.
- 53:36Like that's two very different reactions. And
- 53:39that's not the reaction you're having here. But
- 53:40I think sometimes that is what movies can do.
- 53:43They can be obtuse. We didn't think this through.
- 53:45It doesn't matter. It's a movie. Here, damn.
- 53:47Right? Yeah. This isn't that. This is a movie
- 53:50that is trying to say multiple things, maybe
- 53:54intentionally. And there is something there.
- 53:56I just, context is so absent for me in this.
- 54:00I don't think I have it all. But I really enjoyed
- 54:02my time with it. I thought the acting was great.
- 54:04I thought the visual storytelling was fantastic.
- 54:07Love Raufenstein. Straheim is, you know, we didn't
- 54:10necessarily say it, but on something in this
- 54:12movie. And there's just such a great... To me,
- 54:16it could have been very easy for them to make
- 54:17this movie Marshall versus Rothenstein. But instead,
- 54:21they complicate things in a delicious way by
- 54:24adding Baldot and Rosenthal. And there's a really
- 54:27nice mixture of characters and interactions between
- 54:30those. So I had a great time. And I'm going to
- 54:34have to rewatch it one day. I'm interested in
- 54:36what that looks like for you, because I don't
- 54:38think the way you've seen the movie here is wrong.
- 54:40I think that's right. It's just, there are, I
- 54:43think it's a different kind of movie than we've
- 54:45experienced so far. Yeah. And I wonder how much
- 54:48of that is the movie itself and how much of that
- 54:51is the French. Totally. And again, like you said,
- 54:55culture wise, so much has changed, not just with
- 54:57America and not just with France, but with both
- 55:00and the way that we communicate to each other.
- 55:02So context is just like, you almost need like
- 55:05a history degree to like fully understand everything
- 55:07and then review this movie properly. yeah which
- 55:10is don't get me wrong this could happen again
- 55:13and i'm gonna be like bump this movie but this
- 55:17time i was like yeah i'm ready to accept this
- 55:19right now yeah yeah i'm just curious to know
- 55:22what more international films will look like
- 55:24true from you know decades past years past yeah
- 55:28we'll see how that goes um So My Double Feature
- 55:32is a movie that is not nearly as intellectual
- 55:35or interesting as Grand Illusion. But in terms
- 55:39of prison break movies, I was avoiding Best Picture
- 55:43nominees. So it was kind of limited. I picked
- 55:46a movie that to me is the, not the quintessential,
- 55:50but this type of movie is the quintessential
- 55:52TNT Sunday afternoon movie. It is the Paul Haggis
- 55:57Russell Crowe film The Next Three Days from 2010.
- 56:01This is a movie in which Russell Crowe's wife,
- 56:03Elizabeth Banks, is convicted of a murder that
- 56:06she didn't do. And she's in prison. And years
- 56:09and years go by. And this system is not allowing
- 56:12her an opportunity to get out. And she actually
- 56:15tries to take her own life. And it's at this
- 56:17point when Russell Crowe believes that the only
- 56:19way to save his wife's life is to break her out
- 56:22of prison. And he plans a prison break for her.
- 56:26I thought the idea of like what prison can do
- 56:28to you and how corrupt the system can be is so
- 56:33present in this. Obviously, one's a very American
- 56:36way to look at it. And the other one is the French
- 56:38way. So I think it's a nice dichotomy of sweet
- 56:41and savory of the two kind of differences of
- 56:44storytelling. But again, just a fun like, hey,
- 56:48it's raining on a Sunday and TNT is playing this
- 56:50Russell Crowe movie. Let me watch it. Zero issues.
- 56:53I've never heard of this movie. Never even heard
- 56:55the title. uttered and i had tnt growing up hey
- 56:59i'm not saying that it's played on tnt i'm just
- 57:01saying it should oh okay i see um but i did see
- 57:04in theaters i think i screened this one through
- 57:06shake fire when i worked there wow or interned
- 57:09there rather okay i'll have to look into it this
- 57:11is a fun one um that's like the era of russell
- 57:14crowe that you really like russell crowe brother
- 57:16who are you telling like this was body of lies
- 57:19state of play i think he was in that um next
- 57:22three days pretty good But what I'm really excited
- 57:26about is Unhinged. I've told you about Unhinged,
- 57:28right? Yeah. When he's like, hey, I'm having
- 57:31a good day. And then someone cuts him off. He's
- 57:32like, actually, I think it's time to murder.
- 57:35Yeah. And it is hysterical. Russell Crowe should
- 57:39not be. What's his name? Maximus in Gladiator?
- 57:43Maximus should not be driving a Toyota and getting
- 57:46mad at a Subaru for cutting him off. Well, you
- 57:49know. But at the same time. If someone's like,
- 57:51oh, so that movie shouldn't exist, I'm like,
- 57:52don't do that. Husband to a murdered wife. Father
- 57:56to a murdered son. Driver to a Subaru. I will
- 58:00have my vengeance. What was your double feature?
- 58:02A little uninspired because the movie, the tone,
- 58:06like, was so all over the place for me. The first
- 58:09thing that I thought of, like I said, was Dr.
- 58:11Strangelove, but that's been nominated for Best
- 58:13Picture, so we'll be watching it. So I went with
- 58:16something that this movie ended up inspiring,
- 58:18which is The Great Escape. The old Tom, Dick
- 58:21and Harry digging holes, trying to break out
- 58:24of a POW camp. So I wish I had something like
- 58:29more exciting to say, but that's probably the
- 58:32least like. thematic and more of just the straight
- 58:36like hey they use spoons to dig holes in these
- 58:38movies so check it out well they're the same
- 58:41kind of genre of movie although one a little
- 58:43more and anti -war than the other sure or at
- 58:46least common commentating on war um they probably
- 58:49play that on tnt as well you know what i should
- 58:51have said when we were talking about the whole
- 58:52gladiator unhinged thing is the are you not going
- 58:55to merge are you not going to merge um I just
- 59:02kind of want to do that now. Just gladiator themed.
- 59:05Quotes. With the characters wearing gladiator.
- 59:07Sorry. If the characters in gladiator were in
- 59:08unhinged, that's kind of what I want. Yeah. No,
- 59:12I like that. I will have my vengeance in this
- 59:15lane or the next. Pretty good. Pretty good. It's
- 59:19a good idea. So that's been The Grand Illusion.
- 59:22Thank you guys for listening. We have a ton of
- 59:26episodes that you can go and listen to on the
- 59:27Patreon if you are looking forward to financially
- 59:32contributing to the pod. We have our Horror of
- 59:35the Overlooked episodes we drop on the 13th of
- 59:37every month. We have our episodes that we drop
- 59:40early for you, including exclusive. access to
- 59:45our Discord. You can contact us at OUTAOPodcast
- 59:49at gmail .com. Have you seen Grand Illusion?
- 59:53Did you understand it? Do you fully know what
- 59:55the movie is about? And did we misread it completely?
- 59:58We did. But let us know how. And feel free to
- 1:00:01contact us. Again, that is OUTAOPodcast at gmail
- 1:00:04.com. Yeah, and you can comment on the episodes
- 1:00:07themselves on Spotify or your other podcast players.
- 1:00:10And we can read some of those on the show notes.
- 1:00:12Just, I guess, let me know if you want them read.
- 1:00:14Sometimes people comment and they're just like,
- 1:00:16this was a good episode. I assume you don't want
- 1:00:19that read on the episode, but I will. I'm going
- 1:00:21to do it. I'll do it. I'm going to do it. But
- 1:00:24yeah, thanks so much for listening. Next episode,
- 1:00:27what do we have for the people, Ryan? You know
- 1:00:32what? I'll tell you this. It's either Jezebel
- 1:00:35or Test Pilot. Yes. Okay. So look forward to
- 1:00:39either one of those. We're not sure when this
- 1:00:41episode drops. We had difficulties with it. You
- 1:00:44sure did. But. stay tuned for that as always
- 1:00:47I'm Kyle I'm Ryan and we'll see you at the movies