Latest / Elon Musk Podcast / Elon Musks X (Twitter) Will Start Charging For Access

Transcript

Elon Musks X (Twitter) Will Start Charging For Access · Elon Musk Podcast

• 0:01
  Hi everybody and welcome back to another episode of the Elon Musk
• 0:04
  Podcast. Today's episode we explore a
• 0:06
  topic that has sparked wide-ranging conversations
• 0:09
  across social media and tech circles.
• 0:12
  The notion of implementing a subscription fee for accessing
• 0:15
  social media platforms, specifically a network
• 0:19
  previously known as Twitter, now labeled as X Elon Musk, the
• 0:23
  owner of X, dropped his bombshell during a live
• 0:26
  streaming conversation with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin
• 0:29
  Nyahu amid declining ad revenues and increasing scrutiny from
• 0:33
  civil rights groups. Could a paywall be the game
• 0:37
  changing maneuver to win back advertiser trust and deal with
• 0:40
  the growing menace of bots? Now let's get into this.
• 0:44
  So here's the backdrop. During a discussion
• 0:46
  predominantly centered around a I units regulation, Prime
• 0:49
  Minister Netanyahu brought up the issue of managing hate
• 0:52
  speech amplified by bots on social media.
• 0:56
  And in response, Musk offered a solution.
• 0:58
  Charge a small monthly fee for using X, and According to him,
• 1:04
  doing so would significantly raise the bar for bots to create
• 1:07
  accounts. Each bot would require a new
• 1:10
  payment method, making it cost prohibitive for bot operations.
• 1:15
  Now, before, the proposition must have revealed that the
• 1:18
  platform's US ad revenue had plummeted by 60% in a prime
• 1:23
  driver, pressure from civil rights and consumer
• 1:26
  organizations influencing major brands.
• 1:30
  And while X has been trying to funnel its user base towards its
• 1:33
  paid service, X premium adoption rates have been anything but
• 1:37
  stellar. Some estimates pegged a
• 1:39
  subscriber count for X Premium in the ballpark range of just
• 1:43
  over 800,000 users, and it's not uncommon to hear must make
• 1:48
  ambitious announcements only to modify his approach later.
• 1:51
  But if we take his statement at face value, this could be a
• 1:54
  tectonic shift in the way social media operates.
• 1:58
  Not many platforms have ditched at revenue in favor of
• 2:02
  subscriptions, although a few are dabbling in it, especially
• 2:06
  given the soft ad market. The proposition to implement a
• 2:10
  subscription fee for acts brings to light a key conundrum that's
• 2:14
  polarizing tech aficionados and casual social media users alike.
• 2:18
  On the one hand, a subscription based model could be a panacea
• 2:22
  for the platform's revenue woes. Providing a steady income stream
• 2:26
  does not beholden to the whims of advertisers or pressure from
• 2:29
  advocacy groups. After all, the subscription
• 2:32
  model has worked effectively in other digital spheres.
• 2:35
  Think streaming services like Netflix or Paramount Plus or any
• 2:40
  other streaming network out there, or specialized news
• 2:43
  outlets. However, the other side of the
• 2:46
  coin reveals concerns about the democratization of information.
• 2:50
  One of the essential charms of social media has always been its
• 2:53
  accessibility. It's a platform where anyone can
• 2:56
  voice their opinions, seek information, or engage in
• 3:00
  discourse without a paywall acting as a gatekeeper.
• 3:05
  Implementing a monthly fee, even a nominal 1, risks creating an
• 3:09
  information hierarchy. Those who can afford it will
• 3:12
  have a voice, while others might be effectively silenced, or at
• 3:16
  the very least severely limited in their access to a platform
• 3:20
  that's become integral to modern communication.
• 3:24
  Then there's the question of user adoption.
• 3:26
  While Musk's figure of 550 million monthly users may or may
• 3:30
  not include bots, let's not forget that X Premium service,
• 3:35
  priced at around $8 a month, has garnered A relatively meager
• 3:39
  uptake, only around 800,000 users according to some
• 3:42
  estimates. And this raises questions about
• 3:44
  how willing the general user base would be to shift to a paid
• 3:48
  model, especially when the perks of X premium like fewer ads and
• 3:52
  the ability to edit posts haven't been persuasive enough
• 3:56
  to convert the majority. Now, beyond the financials in
• 4:00
  the bot problem, there's the societal angle.
• 4:03
  Both Musk and Netanyahu discussed the need to balance
• 4:06
  free speech with curbing hate speech and antisemitism.
• 4:09
  Netanyahu urged Musk to find a middle ground and undertaking
• 4:13
  that, while tricky, cannot be avoided given the platform's
• 4:17
  reach and its impact. And while Musk did not confirm a
• 4:20
  specific timeline or cost for the proposed monthly fee, the
• 4:24
  plan, if implemented, would alter the dynamics of the entire
• 4:28
  social media industry. It also remains to be seen how
• 4:31
  this move will align with X's existing problems, especially
• 4:34
  those tied to hate speeds and misinformation.
• 4:38
  And the backdrop to Musk's dramatic announcement is the
• 4:41
  revenue landscape that's seen better days for X in the
• 4:45
  revelation that X has made ad revenue that has drastically
• 4:50
  declined 60%. This drop is particularly
• 4:53
  significant considering that advertising has traditionally
• 4:56
  been the lifeblood of social media platforms.
• 5:00
  And while the reasons for this are multifaceted, a significant
• 5:04
  contributing factor, according to Musk, is the rights group,
• 5:08
  and they are steering brands away from the platform.
• 5:11
  It's important to remember that advertising is not just a source
• 5:15
  of revenue, it's a barometer of a platform societal acceptance.
• 5:19
  Advertisers are cautious about the platforms they associate
• 5:23
  with, and the retreat from X indicates A deeper problem than
• 5:27
  just financial figures. The platform is facing a crisis
• 5:31
  of trust, and that extends to both the users and the
• 5:34
  advertisers. Consequently, a decline in the
• 5:37
  advertiser trust can set off a chain reaction.
• 5:40
  Fewer ads lead to reduced revenues, which in turn limits
• 5:43
  the platform's ability to innovate or even maintain
• 5:46
  current service levels. It's a slippery slope that can
• 5:50
  jeopardize the platform standing in the highly competitive social
• 5:53
  media arena. Now that said, X has been
• 5:56
  attempting to work around to this issue by promoting its
• 5:59
  premium subscription service X Premium, which comes at a price
• 6:03
  tag of $8 per month and despite its feature rich offerings,
• 6:07
  there aren't that many people using it.
• 6:10
  Estimates show that 800,000 people have signed up and that's
• 6:14
  just a drop in the ocean considering Musk's claim of 550
• 6:18
  million monthly users. And this is an uphill battle for
• 6:22
  X and Elon Musk. They're going to have to lure
• 6:26
  subscribers to X Premium, and they have to highlight the good
• 6:30
  things about X Premium and shift it from an ad based model to a
• 6:34
  subscription based one in the future.
• 6:36
  So that wraps up the topic for today.
• 6:39
  If Musk actually moves forward with the plan to charge a small
• 6:42
  fee for using X, the ramifications could be far
• 6:45
  reaching, not just for X, but for social media as a whole.
• 6:49
  Whether it will resolve issues like declining advertiser trust
• 6:52
  or the proliferation of bots, only time will tell.
• 6:56
  Thank you for tuning into the Elon Musk Podcast today.
• 6:59
  If you found this discussion insightful, do us a favor, hit
• 7:02
  the subscribe or follow button on the platform you're listening
• 7:04
  to right now. It's completely free.
• 7:07
  It takes just a second, so I'll see you in the next one.
• 7:10
  Take care of yourselves and each other.