Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Legal Due Diligence in M&A Transactions
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Legal Due Diligence in M &A Transactions.
- 0:07I'm Belinda McCauley, Executive Director of the
- 0:09Beverly Hills Bar Association, and I'm very happy
- 0:12to be here today to introduce our speakers, Justin
- 0:14A. Goldberg and Stephen Yoon. Justin is a partner
- 0:18in the Corporate and Securities Practice at Aaron
- 0:21Fox Schiff. in Los Angeles and co -leader of
- 0:24the firm's cannabis industry group. Justin represents
- 0:26clients across a wide range of commercial transactions,
- 0:30including mergers and acquisitions, joint ventures,
- 0:32corporate structuring, finance, and corporate
- 0:34compliance. His M &A experience spans industries,
- 0:38including food and beverage, insurance and reinsurance,
- 0:41cannabis, sports, and automotive, where he has
- 0:44led and advised on numerous domestic and cross
- 0:46-border acquisitions, asset purchases, and joint
- 0:49venture transactions. recognized by best lawyers,
- 0:52One to Watch 2024 and 2025, and has received
- 0:56multiple certificates of congressional recognition
- 0:58in connection with his pro bono work for the
- 1:00Veterans Legal Institute, where he serves as
- 1:02a board member. Stephen Sung Soo Yoon is a senior
- 1:06associate in the corporate and securities practice
- 1:08at Aaron Fox Schiff in LA. Stephen advises clients
- 1:11on a broad range of corporate transactions, including
- 1:14mergers and acquisitions, joint ventures, corporate
- 1:16structuring, finance, and corporate compliance
- 1:18across industries, including music, food and
- 1:21beverage, sports, and cannabis. His transactional
- 1:23experience includes advising on domestic and
- 1:26cross -border acquisitions, asset purchase transactions,
- 1:29corporate reorganizations, and post -closing
- 1:31integration matters. Steven is a Leadership Counsel
- 1:35on Legal Diversity Pathfinder 2023. Prior to
- 1:39joining the firm, he served as a law clerk at
- 1:42the Veterans Legal Institute, where he assisted
- 1:44veterans in obtaining discharge upgrades. And
- 1:47now let's get started. Everyone, thank you for
- 1:50joining us today. Stephen and I are going to
- 1:52go through the legal diligence process for M
- 1:55&A transactions. Thank you very much for the
- 1:58kind introduction. And we ask that you can put
- 2:01questions and answers in the chat, but we're
- 2:03going to do our best to answer them at the end.
- 2:07So let's jump in right now. So we're going to
- 2:13give you an overview today kind of about all
- 2:15the steps in the legal due diligence in M &A
- 2:19transactions, both asset purchases and stock
- 2:21purchases. Please go to the next slide and then
- 2:25I'll review the agenda. So first we're going
- 2:29to cover what is due diligence, just kind of
- 2:31a broad overview. Then we're going to get into
- 2:34how the type of M &A transaction impacts due
- 2:38diligence. So there is a distinct difference
- 2:41between due diligence in an asset purchase and
- 2:44due diligence in a due diligence in a stock purchase.
- 2:48And we're going to go through those nuances and
- 2:50differences. And then we're going to talk about
- 2:52coordination due diligence among the business
- 2:55and legal teams, both outside counsel, inside
- 2:58counsel, and then also with the business units.
- 3:01Then we're going to discuss how to identify issues
- 3:04when conducting due diligence, basically issue
- 3:06spotting and things different practitioners will
- 3:09look into in the M &A process and what they're
- 3:12hoping to gain out of it. And then Stephen's
- 3:15going to go over the scope of due diligence,
- 3:17basically how broad and deep you're going and
- 3:21how many things you're looking into. And next
- 3:23we'll get into how due diligence relates to the
- 3:27purchase agreement, basically tying it all together.
- 3:29So why you're doing due diligence and how that's
- 3:32going to impact the stock purchase agreement
- 3:34or asset purchase agreement that you are drafting.
- 3:37Then we'll get into disclosure schedules because
- 3:39due diligence kind of is the backbone of the
- 3:42disclosure schedules to any purchase agreement.
- 3:44The legal due diligence memorandum, which is
- 3:46usually the deliverable from the outside counsel.
- 3:48Any normal alliance letters for sharing such
- 3:51due diligence. And then just some key M &A due
- 3:55diligence topics. Next slide, please. So first,
- 4:01what is due diligence? At a fundamental level,
- 4:04due diligence is the buyer's investigation of
- 4:07the target. So the buyer is making an offer,
- 4:10and they make an offer based on certain assumptions
- 4:13that they may gain. based on a non -disclosure
- 4:17agreement, based on a review of financials, based
- 4:19on a review of a pitch deck. It could be materials
- 4:22from an investment banker. This is the buyer's
- 4:26investigation to confirm those. So if they're
- 4:28making an offer for $100 million based on 6 .5
- 4:32times EBITDA, they need to confirm that EBITDA.
- 4:35They need to confirm that the business has the
- 4:38revenue and the profits that it says it does,
- 4:40and that if there's any risks associated with
- 4:42it. So the process is facilitated by the seller.
- 4:46It allows the buyer to assess the legal, financial,
- 4:49and operational risks and confirm the deal's
- 4:52assumptions. And these will usually be baked
- 4:54in to the letter of intent or term sheet if there
- 4:57is one. The letter of intent and term sheet usually
- 4:59lays out the parameters for due diligence, how
- 5:02long it is, 30 days, 60 days, 90 days, any ability
- 5:06for extensions, and usually the areas that are
- 5:10covered. The main areas that are covered in most
- 5:13due diligence for M &A transactions are legal.
- 5:16So you're looking at litigation, you're looking
- 5:18at labor employment, you're looking at environmental.
- 5:21And then financial, you're looking at the financial
- 5:23statements, making sure those are accurate. If
- 5:26it's a bigger company, those are in compliance
- 5:28with GAAP. You're also doing due diligence on
- 5:32tax, making sure there's any kind of unknown
- 5:34kind of tax issues. And it could be if it's a
- 5:38company that has a lot of intellectual property,
- 5:40you're going over intellectual property issues
- 5:43and their kind of portfolio. And by nature of
- 5:47this process, it's very multidisciplinary. So
- 5:50you're involving tons of specialists. So you
- 5:53obviously have your core corporate M &A team.
- 5:56That's kind of quarterbacking the process, but
- 5:58then you're dealing with accountants who are
- 6:00doing their own financial diligence who may have
- 6:02their own separate requests and different business
- 6:05units they're dealing with. you're looking at
- 6:07their insurance, or you could be doing an insurance
- 6:09due diligence with their broker or with their
- 6:12general counsel. Then you're doing environmental
- 6:14due diligence, especially if you're buying real
- 6:16estate, that can involve site visits, that can
- 6:19involve phase ones, phase twos, different service
- 6:22providers that provide those things. And then
- 6:24other specialist advisors that you may bring
- 6:26in, you could bring in someone for cyber, you
- 6:29can bring in someone for insurance, or you could...
- 6:32bringing someone to do IP due diligence. So there's
- 6:35a number of kind of specialty providers in specific
- 6:38areas that the main firm either may not be the
- 6:42best at or they may want a second set of hands
- 6:44or a second opinion or they're conflicted for
- 6:46some reason on a certain part. So it just spans
- 6:50a lot of areas. And then a supposed to support
- 6:53this process by reviewing the materials, identifying
- 6:57all the issues and escalating questions to the
- 7:00senior due diligence, to the senior team members
- 7:02to ensure that risks are identified for the client.
- 7:05So basically the way this works is you would
- 7:07create a data room, you have a due diligence
- 7:10request list, those requests are responded to
- 7:13by the client, the first year, second year, third
- 7:16year associate reviews, the responses. Finds
- 7:19out what's there find out what's missing starts
- 7:21reviewing the materials and they start raising
- 7:23this to the middle of a senior associate who's
- 7:27Like you're running the deal and then that's
- 7:28raised to a partner to relate to the client either
- 7:31in the form of an email a phone call or due diligence
- 7:34memorandum and That's kind of how the process
- 7:37plays out Justin if I may the ultimate goal of
- 7:41due diligence basically is to give your client
- 7:42whether it's the buyer the seller sufficient
- 7:44information to make like an informed decision
- 7:46on whether to proceed with the transaction. So
- 7:48if you're representing buyer, that's the goal
- 7:51of the due diligence. And so everything that
- 7:52Justin laid out, our job as the associates or
- 7:56whoever's leading the deal, that is our goal,
- 7:58right? To raise the questions and recognize patterns
- 8:01so that our client can make an important decision.
- 8:05Yes, so you're basically empowering your client
- 8:08and giving them the tools that they need to have
- 8:11an informed business discussion with their counterpart,
- 8:15who is usually either the general counsel or
- 8:18it might be a deal person on the other side.
- 8:20It might be the investment banker. There's different
- 8:23liaisons and touch points as an M &A deal is
- 8:26negotiated. And this is basically the ammunition
- 8:29they need for the negotiation, good or bad. So
- 8:32if they discover that there's an environmental
- 8:35liability, then you need to figure out whether
- 8:38you're gonna do a phase one or phase two, how
- 8:40long that's gonna take, if that's gonna delay
- 8:41closing, if you're gonna specifically exclude
- 8:44that, you may be getting reps and warranty insurance.
- 8:47So usually known liabilities are carved out of
- 8:50the reps and warranty insurance. So how are you
- 8:52dealing with this? It's basically a burden shifting
- 8:55between the buyer and the seller. And this is
- 8:56kind of determining the burdens to be shifted.
- 9:00Next slide, please. So how the type of M &A transaction
- 9:10impacts to diligence, this is huge. So an asset
- 9:14purchase agreement by its nature, you're purchasing
- 9:17assets. The assets may be a going concern business,
- 9:21they usually are. Like if you're purchasing a
- 9:23Krispy Kreme store, you're purchasing the store.
- 9:25It's an operation that's going, it has employees
- 9:27that are sales. It has marketing. It's obviously
- 9:31making doughnuts, selling doughnuts. But that
- 9:34still is a asset to be sold. And the key fundamental
- 9:39difference is when you buy equity, you get all
- 9:42the liabilities through the end of time. So if
- 9:45you buy stock from someone else, you get those
- 9:49liabilities and it could be an environmental
- 9:51liability that goes back 30 years. It doesn't
- 9:54matter. It's yours now. If it's an asset deal,
- 9:57you're only buying the assets and you're only
- 10:00assuming the liabilities that you agree to be
- 10:02assumed. So if you're a buyer, you would kind
- 10:05of almost always, perhaps in certain regulatory
- 10:08circumstances where you need to own the equity
- 10:09to like get a license, you would always rather
- 10:12do an asset deal. Because you could exclude whatever
- 10:15liabilities you want. It's creature of contract
- 10:17You can name the assets you're buying You can
- 10:19use due diligence to kind of refine and cherry
- 10:22pick exactly what you want to buy and Exactly
- 10:24what you don't want to buy and exactly the liabilities
- 10:26that you want exactly the liabilities that you
- 10:28don't want or if you want no liabilities So an
- 10:31asset purchase agreement gives you a lot of flexibility,
- 10:33but it also will limit the pool of due diligence
- 10:36in a way Like you don't need to be as thorough
- 10:41on like tax liability if you're not assuming
- 10:44any tax liability. So that's how they kind of
- 10:49interact and it's a huge kind of risk allocation
- 10:53because in an equity deal you really need to
- 10:57negotiate your indemnities, your reps and warranties
- 10:59because this liability goes at the end of the
- 11:01time, all liability basically. So you need to
- 11:05at least to the statute of limitations, you need
- 11:07to kind of figure out how that risk sharing is
- 11:09gonna work and who's handling and who's responsible
- 11:12for what liabilities. And then in an equity deal,
- 11:16it's just completely different. Because as I
- 11:18noted, you inherit everything, so your due diligence
- 11:20is gonna be incredibly thorough. You wanna be
- 11:23as thorough as possible. You wanna take as long
- 11:25as you need. You wanna run down every single
- 11:28question. You wanna... review their operations,
- 11:32their contracts, their compliance, their litigation,
- 11:34their labor and employment, their environmental,
- 11:36their tax, their financial statements. Basically
- 11:39anything you can get your hands on and the due
- 11:42diligence request is maybe like 130 requests
- 11:45long and some of those requests are nuanced.
- 11:49So you kind of want to do a full scope of the
- 11:53company, figure out how they do business, what
- 11:56Do they have a robust in -house council? Do they
- 11:59use outside council lots? Do they have a form
- 12:01template for their contracts that are all their
- 12:02employee, that all their vendors sign? Or is
- 12:05every one a different one? Is it new? Do they
- 12:08have misclassification risk for their employees,
- 12:10especially in California? Do they have a lot
- 12:12of independent contractors, which could raise
- 12:14red flags? Do they own a lot of real estate,
- 12:17which has landlord tenant issues, which has different
- 12:21kind of... nuances in kind of do they own the
- 12:26exact lands, you may need to do surveys, do they
- 12:29have any kind of underground storage tanks, which
- 12:32if you're buying kind of like a gas station or
- 12:34an automotive dealership or kind of any outside
- 12:36plot of land may be important from an environmental
- 12:39standpoint. So the due diligence when you're
- 12:43doing an equity transaction is just way more
- 12:46thorough. and then just leads to a lot more questions
- 12:50and a lot more follow -ups. You may go through
- 12:52three or four rounds of follow -ups and usually
- 12:55what happens is you'll give them your due diligence
- 12:58list. It'll take them a couple of weeks to respond
- 13:00because it's not as easy to do. In some cases
- 13:04you have an investment banker or a broker on
- 13:06the other side who's pre -packaged a lot of the
- 13:08information based on kind of a form. list on
- 13:11their side to kind of organize their data room,
- 13:14which in some ways makes things easier. But a
- 13:16lot of times it's just easier to kind of build
- 13:18it around your request list so that you can make
- 13:21sure your questions are getting answered. But
- 13:23then you have Follow -up calls, follow -up emails,
- 13:27responses to the various follow -ups, calls between
- 13:30the clients, calls between the legal teams, different
- 13:33memorandums on the buyer side to kind of inform
- 13:36the client, maybe an interim due diligence memorandum,
- 13:38maybe a red flag due diligence memorandum, and
- 13:40a final due diligence memorandum before closing
- 13:42as you bring down your rep. So it's just usually
- 13:45a much more robust process. Next slide, please.
- 13:52So the coordination of due diligence is really
- 13:54important. It's really important to know who
- 13:58is running the due diligence process and who
- 14:00is running the various aspects of the due diligence
- 14:03process. Because there's usually two due diligence
- 14:05processes and people don't think of it like this.
- 14:07There's a financial due diligence process, which
- 14:09is usually an accounting or investment banking
- 14:11function, and they have their own list. So you
- 14:14may have a Moss Adams or a PWC. or a EY that
- 14:19has their own checklist of things that they need
- 14:21to see from an auditing and financial standpoint,
- 14:23which has absolutely almost nothing to do with
- 14:26the legal due diligence. That's kind of operating
- 14:28in a separate vacuum to either do a quality of
- 14:31earnings analysis or to verify that the financials
- 14:35are in accordance with GAAP or that the financials
- 14:37are fairly presented. So there's just a number.
- 14:43of aspects of that, which you kind of as the
- 14:46lawyer need to keep track of, but that's not
- 14:48really your process. And then you have your own
- 14:51due diligence process, which could be run by
- 14:53counsel. It could be run by the investment bank.
- 14:55The investment bank has a due diligence list.
- 14:58Like you see this in an auction where it's like
- 15:00they have a form. purchase agreement. They have
- 15:03all the due diligence presented and they're just
- 15:05looking basically for the highest bidder. And
- 15:06then everyone signs an NDA and does the exact
- 15:09same due diligence on the exact same pool of
- 15:12documents and materials. So it's really important
- 15:17at the beginning to figure out how that process
- 15:19is going to work and to coordinate on your side
- 15:22between the client. Usually the client will have
- 15:24a point person that's negotiating the deal. It
- 15:26could be the general counsel. It could be a business
- 15:28person. Then also between the service providers
- 15:32between the lawyers between the accountants between
- 15:34the brokers between the bankers like brokers
- 15:36Package things really nicely because they want
- 15:38to get to a finished deal So a lot of times when
- 15:41you work with brokers it can make things easier
- 15:44but you definitely want to make sure you key
- 15:47thing to do early on is to build out like a contact
- 15:49list and Like who are the key points on each?
- 15:53like when you start a deal, like who are the
- 15:55key points of the client, key points on the opposing
- 15:57counsel, key points on our side, key points on
- 16:00the accounting teams, like kind of have that
- 16:02information so that everyone knows like who to
- 16:05put on each email. And then the next thing you'll
- 16:08do is kind of build out your data room. So you'll
- 16:11have this Excel spreadsheet or smart sheet. um
- 16:15which is software that's kind of like excel or
- 16:17in word that'll have all these requests and all
- 16:21these boxes to fill in that here this match request
- 16:24oh we have nothing please confirm that nothing
- 16:26exists this is not applicable and then you'll
- 16:29so you'll build your data room out that way it'll
- 16:32be it could be in various categories like a to
- 16:35c or a to like e or d or yeah i've seen it you
- 16:39can go like sometimes 15 categories like a all
- 16:43the way to like m for the various classifications
- 16:46between the legal, environmental, L &E, intellectual
- 16:48property, et cetera, whatever the verticals are.
- 16:51And then you might have 10 folders under that,
- 16:53because there's 10 specific different requests.
- 16:57But then you also, if you're doing a publicly
- 16:59traded company, you have... you have EGR documents,
- 17:03you have 10Ks, you have 8Ks, you have annual
- 17:07filings they need to make. So you can gain a
- 17:09lot from those public filings that they put in.
- 17:12So you also kind of need to inventory those because
- 17:14they also might be like, hey, this was attached
- 17:16to exhibit for a filing that we did like earlier
- 17:20this year, just go pull it from there, that type
- 17:23of thing, instead of providing it. So that's
- 17:26important if you're dealing with a public company.
- 17:28and usually a public company has gone through
- 17:29a lot more kind of water scrutiny or financial
- 17:32statement scrutiny because they have a lot of
- 17:35Sarbanes -Oxley requirements. So that's kind
- 17:37of a different type of deal in a lot of ways,
- 17:41but it's just something to keep in mind. If I
- 17:44may speak from an associate's perspective, I
- 17:47think one of the keywords that Justin used out
- 17:49of all that from a diligence perspective is the
- 17:52word inventory. So especially as you're in your
- 17:55younger years or as you move up to become a mid
- 17:57-level or senior associate, you're going to be
- 17:59asked to kind of be the master of the data room
- 18:01and to kind of know what's in there and what's
- 18:04missing and whether or not the documents that
- 18:05have been provided are responsive. Like a partner,
- 18:08like if Justin's on a deal and I'm on a deal
- 18:09with him, Justin's not going to be in the nitty
- 18:11gritty of the data room to know, hey, we got
- 18:14everything we need for this question or for this
- 18:16specific area of law. That's going to fall on
- 18:19me or one of my juniors, right? And so being
- 18:22the master of what documents are in there, having
- 18:24a coordinated person, whether it's an associate
- 18:27or maybe a paralegal who's just doing a daily
- 18:29check every day, that is really helpful from
- 18:31a streamlined perspective of understanding what's
- 18:35being provided and whether or not that's necessary
- 18:37or needed for whatever advice that you want to
- 18:41be giving to your clients. And so I would say
- 18:43getting organized internally within your team
- 18:46as well at your firm. is really important as
- 18:48far as making this process smooth. Because sometimes
- 18:51you'll get great data rooms from the other side
- 18:54where it's super organized and neat. And you're
- 18:57like, this is beautiful. We don't really have
- 18:59many comments. We could just look at what's in
- 19:01there. And that's sufficient for producing whatever
- 19:03work product that we're being asked to produce.
- 19:06And then other times, it's just like a drop box
- 19:08where they just dumped everything in there. And
- 19:10you kind of have to make heads or tails out of
- 19:12it, which can be challenging. But that's why
- 19:15I'm saying it's very important to kind of like
- 19:16what we used to do is have a list, right? So
- 19:20here are the asks, here are the outstanding asks,
- 19:24and you go back and forth with the opposing counsel
- 19:25like, hey, you didn't respond to this yet. That's
- 19:28what Justin was talking about earlier, going
- 19:29back and forth with the opposing counsel, or
- 19:32maybe it's their general counsel, where you go
- 19:34back and forth with, hey, this hasn't been responded.
- 19:36Here's our follow ups. And so you can only do
- 19:39that if you're organized with what's being provided.
- 19:42And sometimes you got to go through the investment
- 19:45banker who's running the coordination of the
- 19:47diligence of whomever. It might not be you directly,
- 19:50but that's where it's important to be on the
- 19:52same page with your client and that other advisor
- 19:55as far as who's asking and how they're asking.
- 19:58Yeah, and I think it's really important because
- 19:59from a partner perspective, like a lot of times
- 20:02I won't even have access to the data room. I
- 20:04just like. or I may have access, but I've never
- 20:07gone into it, because if I ever need something,
- 20:10I'll just email Stephen and be like, hey, can
- 20:12you pull this document? Or hey, I have a question
- 20:15about this specific agreement. Can you get it
- 20:17for me? And then I'll review the substance of
- 20:20it, but I'm not reviewing the degree of each
- 20:23upload. But it is kind of important in a way
- 20:26of what software you use to know and get alerts
- 20:28on what's being uploaded and when it was uploaded.
- 20:31So there's a lot of digital tracking of when
- 20:34certain things. So when you're adding follow
- 20:36up requests and you're like, there's been nothing
- 20:39responded in these folders and then you get an
- 20:41order that they put them in the folders and they
- 20:43upload it on this date. So I think that's very
- 20:45important. That's so key, Justin, having that
- 20:48alert. Oftentimes, or all of them, you can send
- 20:52notifications, hey, send me an email when something's
- 20:54uploaded. As a junior, especially, I remember
- 20:57when I was coming up, I had them on for all my
- 20:59matters. So I would be inundated with a bunch
- 21:01of emails, but at least I knew what was being
- 21:03uploaded. Even if I couldn't check it, I knew
- 21:05later, hey, I remember some things were uploaded.
- 21:08What was that? So it's just to stay organized.
- 21:11Yeah. And you could set like, I run my email,
- 21:14I run my outlook through like tasks. So I could,
- 21:17to exactly what Stephen said, I would put those
- 21:19as a task and get to them all at the end of the
- 21:21day. And then I would potentially update my due
- 21:23diligence tracker of like this, and then you
- 21:25could just like know that you, okay, this is
- 21:27everything that was uploaded today. And you go
- 21:30in and you kind of mark that. And I think it
- 21:32is important in this process, there's a lot of
- 21:34questions you may ask that may not have answers.
- 21:37And it's really important to drill down and be
- 21:40like, Do you not have this? Please confirm that
- 21:42this does not exist. So at least you have an
- 21:44answer from the other side that there's nothing
- 21:46hanging out there. They affirmatively have told
- 21:49you either on a call or in writing, this doesn't
- 21:51exist. So when you remember randomly, you could
- 21:52say that this seller told us that this is not
- 21:56an issue. So it's really easy from a risk sharing
- 22:00and allocation perspective to be like, well,
- 22:03it's not our responsibility because they said
- 22:04this doesn't exist. So if anything pops up, it's
- 22:07completely on them because they said it didn't
- 22:09exist. No, no, yeah, you go. Well, I was gonna
- 22:15say one of the things that like, specifically
- 22:17to what Justin was saying, like, one of the last
- 22:19lines is calls with target company, like, I would
- 22:21just like, in the beginning, just like, get on
- 22:23the same page with the other side, like, hey,
- 22:25if we are buyer, right, I don't want you seller
- 22:28council to be closing out anything, I will close
- 22:32it out, I will take when it's closed, don't just
- 22:34close it, because things can get missed that
- 22:36way, right? Like if they're like, we respond
- 22:38to this close, but then upon their response,
- 22:41we as buyer have follow ups, then I have to reopen
- 22:44that and find and targeting that or pointing
- 22:47that out to the other side can be very difficult.
- 22:49So like, just getting on the same page with Hey,
- 22:51like when you respond, put it as partial, and
- 22:54then I will close it out. Even setting that framework
- 22:57in the beginning can go a long way as far as
- 22:59organization, and not missing things. So that's
- 23:03something that I would I try to do in all my
- 23:06deals with uh yeah and like steven and I represent
- 23:10a large client where we've done a number of deals
- 23:12and they use smartsheet and we just very upfront
- 23:15we like right after we send out the term sheet
- 23:17or the initial asset purchase agreement we're
- 23:18like this is how we're going to run our process
- 23:21yeah like This is the form we're going to use.
- 23:25This is the provider. This is how you upload
- 23:27things. This is what we expect. This is the tempo
- 23:30of when we'll have follow -up calls. This is
- 23:32how we're going to ask for certain responses
- 23:35or to close out various items. So it's really
- 23:38smart and good best practice to get aligned early
- 23:41with the other side, because they've probably
- 23:43never been through this before, especially if
- 23:44they're selling. Like they've had a business
- 23:46for maybe 10, 15, 20 years, and this is the first
- 23:49time they're going through it. And we've done
- 23:50it a handful of times or many, many times. So
- 23:53that that's why you want to kind of level set
- 23:57expectations and then get everyone on the same
- 23:59page. And that also involves coordinating with
- 24:02your practice area specialists like. If you know
- 24:05your risk a person is super busy and she needs
- 24:07to review these executive comp arrangements or
- 24:10these Certain DLL rules like you need to get
- 24:14her that stuff earlier. You need to make the
- 24:16expectation That's going to take two weeks for
- 24:17her review. So you're the kind of quarterback
- 24:20from a corporate standpoint of getting involved
- 24:23all of your specialists Usually internally in
- 24:27the firm, sometimes there's consultants or outside
- 24:29people, but you need to make sure that everyone
- 24:32gets their materials, that everyone reviews their
- 24:34materials, that everyone knows their deadlines,
- 24:36that everyone knows when you have to draft your
- 24:37mentor and when they need their analysis by so
- 24:39you have time to review. So it is a huge organizational
- 24:43and logistical challenge, but that is kind of
- 24:47the bread and butter of being an M &A attorney.
- 24:49Having good organization and project management
- 24:52is core to the job. Like you cannot be good at
- 24:55being an M &A attorney unless you're a good project
- 24:57manager and you're organized. Like this process
- 25:00is all about organization and the train's running
- 25:04on time and you kind of need to trigger it that
- 25:06way. And that involves the next topic. Like your
- 25:09UCC searches, environmental searches, library
- 25:13searches, reports. Like a phase two is gonna
- 25:16take 60 days usually. So. If you know that you
- 25:19need a phase two because there's environmental
- 25:21liability, you're not going to close out due
- 25:22diligence until that's complete because the environmental
- 25:24liability may be massive and you need to review
- 25:26the report. So it's an important judgment call
- 25:29for the client on those certain things. A phase
- 25:32one may be much quicker. Your UCC searches can
- 25:36take three days, five days. your library searchers
- 25:40could take a day. So knowing the cadence and
- 25:42when you're going to get your UC series searchers,
- 25:45when you're going to get your lean searchers,
- 25:46when you're going to get your litigation searchers,
- 25:48it's really good to have a service provider that
- 25:51you really like. Like we use Telos and they're
- 25:54really reliable and they're very efficient and
- 25:57fast and kind of they meet, like they say it's
- 26:00going to take five days, it usually takes five
- 26:01days. But then we have other service providers
- 26:04that like especially on the real estate side,
- 26:06maybe not as good or maybe not as good at meeting
- 26:08deadlines. And you just kind of have to use them
- 26:10for title insurance and other reasons. But you
- 26:12need to know going in that, hey, if I need this
- 26:15survey or I need my abstracts back for the title
- 26:19insurance, I may not get them for a week or two.
- 26:22So the real estate person may get jammed. That's
- 26:26so true. As the quarterback, as the corporate
- 26:28associate, you don't want to be in a position
- 26:30where you're saying, I'm so sorry, but can you
- 26:32get this to me by tomorrow? like, and you just
- 26:34give them like, you just gave them like a 60
- 26:35page PDF, like, they're not gonna want to work
- 26:38with you, you look unorganized, unlikely that
- 26:40they can even do that. So you want to put yourself
- 26:43in the best position to succeed. And you do that
- 26:45by staying organized. So if you know you have
- 26:47to do these searches, that's priority number
- 26:50one, right? Before you start reading into where
- 26:52the proper consent in there and all that, all
- 26:55that corporate stuff, like I would do UCC searches.
- 26:58ordering things with other vendors, things that
- 27:00are outside your control, right? You can control
- 27:02how quickly you read through material contracts,
- 27:05or is there a change of control provision in
- 27:07these things? You can control that, but you can't
- 27:09control when a vendor sends you back search results.
- 27:12And so to the extent that you can get ahead of
- 27:17that stuff, that is highly advisable and best
- 27:19practice. Yeah, because you could work a 16 hour
- 27:22day until you need to. You can work till four
- 27:23in the morning to get it done. But you can't
- 27:26control whether you're going to get your UCC
- 27:27search back or your phase one. You can just be
- 27:30stuck. So it is very important to be cognizant
- 27:33of that and know that. And then in addition to
- 27:37have like a defined schedule from where you're
- 27:39working from, you know, you never want legal
- 27:42to be the hole up in a deal. So So business people
- 27:46have different motivations for doing certain
- 27:48things and maybe a quarter closing and maybe
- 27:50a month end and maybe, hey, we need to close
- 27:52backstay because we want to open this store or
- 27:54whatever. So you want to make sure that you're
- 27:56working backwards and meeting those deadlines
- 27:58and structuring your due diligence process in
- 28:01a way that accomplishes the end goal. It's not
- 28:03just doing due diligence, it's getting the deal
- 28:05done. So it's all for a secondary purpose. It's
- 28:10not just for doing it itself to learn more about
- 28:13the company. And if I may add one more thing
- 28:15regarding these searches, Justin, there's also
- 28:18a difference between domestic searches and an
- 28:21international search. So if you have a bunch
- 28:23of parties that you know you need to run searches
- 28:26on and they are foreign entities or they're overseas,
- 28:30for whatever reason, they're not domestic, those
- 28:32searches typically take our vendors a little
- 28:34bit longer over time. And so you want to bake
- 28:36that into your timing as well, because it's very
- 28:40likely that they'll say, oh, these will come
- 28:41in a week or two. And you can't be like, oh,
- 28:44shoot, my memo's due on Friday. What do I do?
- 28:47So you don't want to be in that position. So
- 28:49a lot of that is, again, most firms or most people
- 28:53have a relationship with the vendor that they've
- 28:55used before. So if that's the case, you want
- 28:58to get on the same page with them. Hey, we're
- 29:00expecting these searches. Will you be ready?
- 29:03I always send an email like, hey, I'm about to
- 29:04send you some search results. Are you guys ready?
- 29:07And then I always know, hey, there's going to
- 29:10be some foreign stuff. And then they'll be like,
- 29:11okay, well, they'll take us two, three extra
- 29:13days or something like that. And that way, I
- 29:15can make it into my timeline. Yeah, and you could
- 29:17also bifurcate it. You could be like, I'm going
- 29:19to get you the domestic stuff now. And then we'll
- 29:21get you the foreign stuff in a week when it comes
- 29:22in. But this also speaks to kind of the trust
- 29:25and coordinating with like having a team that
- 29:27you use. Like, this is the like, you might have
- 29:30the best tax person in the world. But if they're
- 29:32not a tax M &A person, and they don't know the
- 29:34tempo of how M &A works, then they're not going
- 29:38to be the right person to do to handle your taps
- 29:41to diligence. So you need to have people you
- 29:43trust and that are used to the speed and tempo
- 29:45of an M &A deal and that preferably work with
- 29:47before it just makes everything run a lot easier.
- 29:50Next slide please. So in this area we're going
- 29:59to go over how to identify issues when conducting
- 30:02due diligence. This is probably the hardest thing
- 30:04because you're like how am I reviewing so many
- 30:06documents and so many different areas and figuring
- 30:09out what issues need to be spotted. It's a very
- 30:13kind of judgment -driven experience laid in exercise
- 30:17and usually relies on a lot of years of in -depth
- 30:24experience kind of in the trenches of whatever
- 30:26industry you're doing the M &A deal on. It's
- 30:30always better to not close something out and
- 30:33flag it. and be over inclusive and run it down,
- 30:36then just kind of glossing something over and
- 30:39potentially missing a material risk. So everything
- 30:41is going to be different. So if you're looking
- 30:44at a litigation search and you see like 10 pieces
- 30:47of litigation, it may just be in an industry
- 30:50that gets a lot of litigation and they all may
- 30:53be small and they may have a firm that they use
- 30:55or an insurance carrier and they're all handled
- 30:57by insurance and it's not a big deal. Or maybe
- 30:59they just get sued a lot and you need to know
- 31:01that and you need to dig in to everything that
- 31:05they're doing and figure out why they keep getting
- 31:08sued or what area they keep getting sued in.
- 31:10If labor and employment, they keep getting nailed
- 31:13on misclassification issues, they may have a
- 31:15misclassification risk and they may be doing
- 31:17things wrong when it comes to classifying people
- 31:21between employees or independent contractors.
- 31:24Or if they constantly get hit with class actions,
- 31:26they may be like... bigger things at play that
- 31:29you need to dig deeper. So I think if you kind
- 31:33of smell a rat, then usually that's kind of a
- 31:36good way. Like if something looks wrong, it may
- 31:39be wrong. I'm not saying 100 % of the time it
- 31:42will be, but there's no reason not to kind of
- 31:44go to the second level and kind of ask the question
- 31:47and follow up and get you yourself, your client,
- 31:50your partner, comfort in that specific area.
- 31:53And everything is going to be different. Like
- 31:55looking at a contract and looking at termination
- 31:58provisions or consent provisions or non -compete
- 32:01provisions. Like there may be a contract that
- 32:04says you can't assign the deal and then have
- 32:08a change of control. And that'll be a breach
- 32:12of contract, but it might be a $30 ,000 contract
- 32:14and a $50 million deal. And they may just write
- 32:16whatever. but it could be a Mesa contract that
- 32:20impacts the P &L or impacts the EBITDA financial
- 32:23statements and that's really important like that
- 32:26happened in one of the deals we did there was
- 32:28a something that was baked into the revenue that
- 32:31they and then The seller didn't tell the buyer
- 32:35that that client was terminating So that portion
- 32:39of the EBITDA that they projected out and paid
- 32:41whatever seven ten times for was Vaporating so
- 32:46it's not It's not a 1x damage, it's a 7 to 10x
- 32:49damage. So that's the type of thing you need
- 32:53to be on the lookout for. You wanna be uber cautious
- 32:56here. No one's ever gonna get mad at their lawyer
- 33:00for being overly cautious. I mean, that's why
- 33:02you're there and that's why they're paying you
- 33:04what they're paying you. And that's why you're
- 33:07kind of the boots on the ground and the foot
- 33:09soldiers to make sure that nothing gets missed.
- 33:12I would also say I would apply that as an associate
- 33:14as well. So like, especially if you're more junior
- 33:16and this is like just that this is a judgment
- 33:18driven exercise. And inherently, when you have
- 33:21less experience, that's harder to do. So you
- 33:23might think everything's a red flag, or you might
- 33:24think nothing's a red flag. But when you're early
- 33:27on in your career, I would ask the question early
- 33:30before, you know, before you have like a 27 bullet
- 33:35point question. So like, if I'm seeing something,
- 33:37I'm like, this looks weird, I would just ping
- 33:40or email or call or walk into the office of your
- 33:42supervising attorney and be like, Hey, does this
- 33:44look right to you? Is this the red flag? And
- 33:46then, Oh, no, don't worry about that. That's
- 33:48not a red flag because of X, Y, and Z. Or they
- 33:49might be like, Huh, that's interesting. Why don't
- 33:51you dig in and let me know what you find in an
- 33:53hour. That way you're not, you're being efficient
- 33:55with your time and you're not potentially holding
- 33:57onto something that could be a bomb because you
- 34:00were like, I just didn't think this was important
- 34:02when it actually was. So being communicative
- 34:04and being on the same page with your team internally
- 34:07before you even go to the client to can save
- 34:10you a lot of time and a lot of headache as well
- 34:12with regards to the workflow. Absolutely and
- 34:17there's so many instances where you're going
- 34:19to go to someone more senior that's not an issue
- 34:21at all. Like I know why that is, don't worry
- 34:24about it. I've had a discussion with the GC about
- 34:26this or oh that just happens all the time, it's
- 34:29not a big deal or they may be like wow okay let's
- 34:31dig further. So I think it is really important.
- 34:35to be out in front and be communicative and not.
- 34:39You don't also want a major issue to get buried
- 34:41in 27 other things. You want to raise it and
- 34:46let it stand on its own legs. So I think it's
- 34:49really important when you're doing this type
- 34:51of issue spotting, focus on inconsistencies.
- 34:53If things look wrong, they're usually wrong.
- 34:55So it may not be malice, it may not be bad intent,
- 34:59it may just be sloppiness, it may be a family
- 35:01business, and maybe they didn't do things right,
- 35:03or maybe someone forgot to sign here or put the
- 35:05wrong name here. Some of it can be easily explained,
- 35:08other times it can't, and that needs to be dealt
- 35:11with. Unusual terms are probably just unusual.
- 35:14And you gotta ask the business people to explain
- 35:17them and figure out like a lot of times you weren't
- 35:19there, the GC may not have been there, the CEO
- 35:21may not have even been there, but they, someone
- 35:24probably was that you could ask and run that
- 35:26down. So flag those things, make sure that you
- 35:31can set up a call with the relevant business
- 35:32people, get the question answered that you need
- 35:34to get answered. Looking for missing approvals
- 35:38and other things like if you're expecting consents
- 35:41for certain actions or you're expecting different
- 35:44kind of corporate formalities to be filed and
- 35:46they haven't been followed, then that's a red
- 35:48flag and you need to kind of run that down and
- 35:50figure out what happened and ask the people in
- 35:54charge of why this doesn't exist because it may
- 35:56be the type of thing where they didn't know to
- 35:58do it and you need to kind of do a ratification
- 36:00of past actions to kind of button that up before
- 36:03closing and then shift that liability onto the
- 36:05seller. And then contingent liabilities are a
- 36:08massive focus. Anything that can kind of blow
- 36:10up after the deal closes, that's open -ended,
- 36:15you're usually gonna want a contract around that
- 36:17because you don't want your client to be the
- 36:20one that's caught with that contingent liability.
- 36:22You want to be like, we know it's a liability,
- 36:24we don't know the value of it, but it's not our
- 36:27problem regardless. Like it's gonna be like whatever
- 36:31it is it'll be and then they're gonna pay it.
- 36:33either at a indemnity, a hold back, an escrow.
- 36:37There's so many modalities you can contract around,
- 36:40but it's important to focus on those so they
- 36:42can be specifically carved out. And then one
- 36:46of the main focuses of due diligence, and Stephen
- 36:48will get to this in further slides, is consents.
- 36:51I mean, at a fundamental level, all of your agreements
- 36:55that get uploaded, like the material contracts
- 36:59section of a purchase agreement, might have 25
- 37:03subparts and you're going to need to review all
- 37:06of those material contracts to make sure that
- 37:09they can be assigned or who can block the deal.
- 37:13Like it could be a major customer that there's
- 37:15no assignment provision in a change of control
- 37:18and you need that customer. So you may need to
- 37:22get into a separate negotiation with that customer
- 37:24over how to get this consent. or it may be a
- 37:27lease that you need for a store and you don't
- 37:29want to immediately close the deal and then get
- 37:31booted out of your property. Yeah, so it's really
- 37:35important and that's a lot of what associates
- 37:37are doing is a lot of contractual review. So
- 37:41looking at lease consents is kind of like the
- 37:43most fundamentally due diligence thing because
- 37:45one of the reps that you're gonna be making the
- 37:47purchase agreement, at least the seller will
- 37:49be, is that there's no consent that's gonna block
- 37:52the deal. or they need to schedule out every
- 37:54single consent they have. So it's a really important
- 37:58exercise to make sure that that list is right.
- 38:01And if I can tie that into one of the specific
- 38:04experts that you would be probably bringing on,
- 38:08would be like, sometimes there's like acceleration
- 38:10clauses and like employees, like grants, right?
- 38:13So like, oh, if the company sells, then like
- 38:15they vest immediately or something like that.
- 38:18And your client's gonna want to know the buyer.
- 38:21to be like, oh, well, we expected that there
- 38:24was going to be this number on the cap table.
- 38:26But now it's going to be another number because
- 38:28everyone's best. So all these acceleration clouds,
- 38:31anything that changes from what the status quo
- 38:34is because of your transaction, you want to be
- 38:36flagging. Change control stuff, assignment stuff,
- 38:38acceleration stuff, liabilities that can blow
- 38:40up like Justin said after the fact. These are
- 38:42things that you want to be identifying as an
- 38:44associate so that you can flag it for the appropriate
- 38:46people to either contract around it or maybe
- 38:50we negotiate against it. Yeah, and those are
- 38:52key business issues because if everyone's accelerating,
- 38:55they don't have golden handcuffs anymore. They
- 38:58can sell or they can cash out and you may need
- 39:02to give them a new grant. They may be key team
- 39:04members that you want for the next four years.
- 39:06You may want to ask them to roll over their equity
- 39:08into a new vehicle to further incentivize them
- 39:11to stay on board and hit their targets. It's
- 39:16important to be flagging those things so the
- 39:17business people can contract around them. Next
- 39:20slide, please. And Stephen will kind of take
- 39:21over from there. Yeah. So the thing I want to
- 39:25talk about now is the scope of the due diligence.
- 39:27And I think Justin kind of touched on it earlier
- 39:29with regard to the LOI or the term sheet, to
- 39:32the extent that there is one. But generally,
- 39:35that's listed or laid out, or there's an understanding
- 39:38between the parties at the outset. So it's typically
- 39:41client -driven. And it depends on the size of
- 39:43the transaction or the risk tolerance that your
- 39:45client is comfortable with. So it could either
- 39:48be an issues list. Sometimes it's very simple
- 39:50like, hey, give me an email bullet list. It could
- 39:52be as simple as that. Or it could be just give
- 39:54me a summary of the top things that you've been
- 39:56finding. Or it could be a full -on diligence
- 39:58memo where it's like, 20 pages long, and we go
- 40:02in depth and really analyze each aspect and talk
- 40:05about like every litigation matter or every real
- 40:07estate lease and, you know, the risks associated
- 40:10with each one. You're going to see the full scope
- 40:14of things probably throughout the duration of
- 40:16a career. And it's important to kind of get that
- 40:20understanding down at the beginning, because
- 40:22it can kind of help you frame how you're reviewing
- 40:25things as well. Right. So like, if you know,
- 40:27you're just doing a red flag, you probably don't
- 40:29need to go crazy into the nitty gritty, you do.
- 40:32You need to learn everything and know everything
- 40:33so that you know what to advise your client against.
- 40:36But at the same time, understanding that it's
- 40:40just going to be a red flags memo, you probably
- 40:42don't need to flush it out as in depth to your
- 40:45supervisor, for example, before it gets to the
- 40:47client. and so those are kind of again if you're
- 40:51not sure the supervisor will let you know hey
- 40:54we have a red flags memo due on Thursday or we
- 40:56have a we're going to do a you know full -on
- 40:58due diligence memorandum by next Friday or something
- 41:00like that so it'll be clear but you should know
- 41:04especially as a junior as you go and then cross
- 41:08-functional coverage is like it's a critical
- 41:10element we've been talking about it all day today
- 41:12But you want to bring on your specialist, you
- 41:14know, labor and employment, intellectual property,
- 41:17tax, data privacy, environmental litigation.
- 41:19All these folks are going to help you identify
- 41:22the risks that you want to be highlighting for
- 41:24your client. And so we've mentioned this, but
- 41:27as they conduct their own review within their
- 41:29respective like domains or whatever, you're responsible
- 41:32for making sure that everything is covered and
- 41:34that nothing falls through the cracks. And so
- 41:36sometimes that entails you in the memo, right.
- 41:42Bringing on their analysis, but like making it
- 41:44slow within the, you know, the four corners of
- 41:47your document, but also making sure that, you
- 41:49know, if something is, if there are interlapping
- 41:52stuff that are touching like labor and employment
- 41:54touches like material contracts because of the
- 41:57acceleration provisions that I was talking about,
- 41:59you don't want that memo to the client to be
- 42:01disjointed, right? You want there to be some
- 42:03kind of connective tissue between those two.
- 42:05um sections of the memo and so that's kind of
- 42:08like where you're massaging it and also making
- 42:10sure that if they are flag they your experts
- 42:13are flagging things that you are appropriately
- 42:15making those asks in the follow -up and the additional
- 42:20due diligence requests that you are sending out
- 42:21to the other side so um keeping track of those
- 42:25things and for your experts is i would say like
- 42:28an integral part of what you're doing because
- 42:31Even though I'm not a labor employment lawyer,
- 42:32and I'm not a tax lawyer, I'm not an IP lawyer,
- 42:34I know enough to be like, okay, this looked weird.
- 42:38I'm going to flag it for, you know, my Jeff,
- 42:40Jeff, my labor employment partner, like, I could
- 42:42just be like, Hey, does this look right? Or what
- 42:43is this? And then if he says, No, I need you
- 42:45to ask this follow up question. It's going to
- 42:49be on me to make sure that information, whatever
- 42:51the other side tells me gets to Jeff properly,
- 42:54right? He's not going to be in the in the weeds
- 42:56of like making following up on on on our clients
- 42:59behalf that's going to fall on me as the corporate
- 43:01associate and so being able to um coordinate
- 43:04with the specialist in this way is very very
- 43:06important as far as you know what work product
- 43:09you're going to be producing and then if you
- 43:12have questions oh yeah go ahead just no no i
- 43:15was going to say um we'll move on to the next
- 43:16slide in a minute but It's really important to
- 43:19understand what the client and what they're looking
- 43:21for and the cadence and what they expect. Do
- 43:24they expect a full -blown memorandum? Do they
- 43:26expect an interim memorandum and then a final?
- 43:28Do they expect only a red flag? Do they expect
- 43:30an email bullet point list? Just kind of level
- 43:32setting those expectations. And then you'll also,
- 43:34as you work with clients further and they do,
- 43:37especially ones that do more and more M &A, you'll
- 43:39understand what they're looking for and how to
- 43:42structure your process to get them what they
- 43:43need. And then I think this kind of like brings
- 43:48it all together as far as like, what is, okay,
- 43:50so what is due diligence and what's the impact
- 43:52that it has? Well, it basically, it's the connective
- 43:54tissue to the entire buy -sell process with regards
- 43:58to the purchase agreement, right? Everything
- 44:00we've discussed so far, the investigating, the
- 44:02coordinating issues spotting, the scope of whatever
- 44:04product you're gonna be producing, it ultimately
- 44:06feeds into the negotiation and the drafting of
- 44:08the definitive agreement, the purchase agreement,
- 44:11whether asset or stock. And so it's going to
- 44:14inform a lot of the sections, like specifically,
- 44:16I think Justin said this earlier, but the reps
- 44:18and warranties, right? So like if you identified
- 44:20like a regulatory issue or an unusual contract
- 44:24that like your client doesn't want to bring on,
- 44:27you're going to want to tailor a representation
- 44:29or you're going to want to qualify the language
- 44:31appropriately to carve out those things, probably
- 44:33in a disclosure schedule or you're going to have
- 44:36baskets or limits to the indemnity, right? you
- 44:40can call them fundamental reps. These are very
- 44:42important reps and they'll last a little bit
- 44:44longer because we really, we, the client really
- 44:46cares about these things versus, you know, the
- 44:48general reps and warranties who were okay if
- 44:51they, you know, expire, the survival term expires
- 44:54in like 12 months or 18 months or whatever. So,
- 44:57and it's all that like the client can only make
- 44:59that judgment call if they know basically how
- 45:05the other party is operating in an M &A transaction
- 45:08and they can only do that with your help. And
- 45:11so in the context of an asset deal, like I said,
- 45:14diligence is an important role because it guides
- 45:16that identification process. If you want to exclude
- 45:19a liability, you put that on a schedule. If you
- 45:23want a specific contract to not be brought on
- 45:28or you definitely want to make sure that it is,
- 45:31these are things that you are able to identify.
- 45:33And the diligence will reveal these things for
- 45:36your clients so that they can make that judgment
- 45:39call. And then it can even impact like covenants,
- 45:44right? So like if there's an issue that needs
- 45:46to be remedied either maybe before or maybe like
- 45:48immediately after closing, that kind of language
- 45:51like, hey, you seller are gonna stay on and do
- 45:53this after closing, that needs to be in the agreement,
- 45:56right? And so that can only, you only know that
- 46:01they have to do something after closing because
- 46:02you found it in the diligence. So you might negotiate
- 46:05a specific covenant. as a clothing condition,
- 46:09for example. It's the foundation based on the
- 46:14risk allocation that Justin was talking about
- 46:16earlier. It's the main risk protection you have.
- 46:21The whole purpose of having a stock purchase
- 46:23agreement or asset purchase agreement is to shift
- 46:25risks in various ways. The reps are what you're
- 46:29buying in addition to your assets. You're buying
- 46:32them on the assumption that all these things
- 46:34are true. And there's no point in including a
- 46:36rep if you know it's untrue based on the diligence.
- 46:38You need to figure out how you kind of contract
- 46:42around that. So that will inform your drafting
- 46:44and really inform kind of your indemnity package
- 46:47at the end of the day. Yep. Absolutely. I think
- 46:51we can go to the next slide. And I feel like
- 46:59this next thing could be like its own hour long.
- 47:02presentation, but with regards to disclosure
- 47:04schedules, like that like that is going to be,
- 47:07especially for like an early M &A lawyer, like
- 47:09that's, you're going to be working with disclosure
- 47:10schedules quite a bit, whether you're on the
- 47:12buy side or the sell side. And so this is the
- 47:15basic, for a little bit of context, disclosure
- 47:18schedule is basically the document that describes
- 47:21the exceptions to, you know, the reps and warranties
- 47:25of the purchase agreement. So like, it's going
- 47:27to say something to the effect of you know except
- 47:30that set forth on schedule one right there are
- 47:33no litigation matters so we as the council right
- 47:37who did the diligence we want to make sure that
- 47:39schedule one lists all of the litigation matters
- 47:41that that we identified in the diligence process
- 47:45right and so in that diligence process we can
- 47:47say like this is a huge risk because it's the
- 47:49big litigation matter or this is a small one,
- 47:51like that's its own separate thing. But the document
- 47:54that is being produced as a result of your efforts
- 47:57and your research and your diligencing is going
- 48:00to be reflected in the purchase agreement through
- 48:02the disclosure schedules. And so you want to
- 48:06be on top of that. It's a process that you go
- 48:13through with your client, with the other side.
- 48:16And if you're a buyer, you want it to be, you
- 48:19know, super broad. You want, you want to be,
- 48:21you want it to be very, um, done to, uh, have
- 48:24very specific disclosure schedules. If you're
- 48:26a seller, you want to just put everything on
- 48:28there and be like, Hey, we disclose it to you.
- 48:29We, uh, we don't, we let you know about it. Right.
- 48:33Yeah. And this is a point it's like, uh, we've
- 48:36had this demon of going through. This is like,
- 48:40if we're the buyer and we're drafting the schedules
- 48:42for their review and they review it and they
- 48:44don't list something. That's on them. I'm not
- 48:46going to do that job for them. Like this is an
- 48:49exception to a rep and warranty that they're
- 48:51making. So if they don't want to make an exception,
- 48:53it's not my job to make it for them. Like I'm
- 48:56going to be informative and I'm not going to
- 48:58like make it look dumb when I know something,
- 49:01but it also is like that's their job. And like,
- 49:05so it's important to know which side you're drafting
- 49:07from. And then the next part is the legal due
- 49:11diligence memo that we kind of touched upon.
- 49:13It's going to be per your client's request and
- 49:15the form and the scope will vary. But it's definitely
- 49:18that work product is the high level summary,
- 49:22the detailed topic by topic analysis, whatever
- 49:24format that they asked for, get on the same page
- 49:27with your client at the outset so that there
- 49:30are no surprises. I just mentioned this earlier
- 49:33too, but a non -reliance letter basically is
- 49:35it's agreement that it's a letter that says,
- 49:38our work product, the due diligence memo or whatever
- 49:41it was, it's a work product prepared for the
- 49:44benefit of the client and not to be used for
- 49:46the reliance by any third party. So it's a letter
- 49:48that you send to like a lender or an insurer
- 49:52that is reviewing this for purposes of assisting
- 49:55your client with the transaction as well. And
- 49:57they say insurance calls here. So like sometimes,
- 50:00I feel like this has become less of a thing where
- 50:02you're actually on the call. In my experience,
- 50:04we've done it more with emails, but like when
- 50:07you send it to an RWI insurance company, they're
- 50:10gonna review your memo, right? Because they're
- 50:14gonna carve out known liabilities, right? So
- 50:16like if they know there's a litigation, they're
- 50:17not gonna be like, yeah, we'll cover it during
- 50:19insurance. They're gonna wanna carve it out.
- 50:20And so they're gonna have very specific questions
- 50:22with your work product. And so, as you do your
- 50:26diligence, be kind of drafted with that in mind
- 50:29as well. If there is an RWI insurance mechanism
- 50:32in your purchase agreement, and you know that,
- 50:34and it's not just going to the client, kind of
- 50:37be as descriptive or as detailed as possible
- 50:40so that the insurer, you limit the back and forth
- 50:42with the insurers. If they're not like, what
- 50:44does this mean? or run this down for us. Because
- 50:47it just creates more work. The more you can do
- 50:50at the outset with the memo and gearing it towards
- 50:53the RWI insurer, it's just going to make your
- 50:55life easier. You don't need to hammer the reps
- 50:59if you know that they're going to be insured.
- 51:01Just go with the package that your insurer wants,
- 51:04get the things that you need, and then your diligence
- 51:06will reveal anything that will be outside the
- 51:08scope because it's going to be outside the scope
- 51:09of the policy anyway. The last slide I think
- 51:15we have is, it's just like due diligence topics
- 51:18that we kind of touched on throughout the course
- 51:20of our presentation today. But these are kind
- 51:23of the big ones that I, you know, we would probably
- 51:25be on the lookout for just that like if you were
- 51:27just asked me to name off the top of my head.
- 51:30So like consent requirements, right? So like
- 51:31we talked about that. Identifying the consent
- 51:34provisions in the contracts, the leases, whatever.
- 51:37It's very important, right? So like that's something
- 51:39you definitely want to be making sure that you're
- 51:42diligent seeing. changing control is kind of
- 51:44like an offshoot of that, right? Sometimes we
- 51:46talked about the employment stuff, employment
- 51:48agreements, whether you have like a single trigger,
- 51:51it's like if you have a change of control or
- 51:53a double provision, a double trigger provision
- 51:55where it's like you require changing control
- 51:57and a subsequent event such as a termination,
- 51:59right? So like depending on what trigger is activated,
- 52:03it's gonna have an impact on your client as the
- 52:07buyer or as the seller. 280G, that's an IRS code
- 52:13I believe and it has to do with like parachute
- 52:15payments to like executives and whatnot. So things
- 52:19that you want to be on the lookout for. 280G
- 52:22is very important if you're doing a rollover
- 52:25transaction or you're buying a business and then
- 52:28like let's say a PE firm is buying it. or a kind
- 52:31of large institutional investor and they're going
- 52:33to employ the current leadership team on big
- 52:36comp packages with big equity grants, like that
- 52:40could trigger a massive 280G liability and usually
- 52:42needs to be cured by a shareholder vote. and
- 52:45you can't not do the transaction. If the vote
- 52:47fails, it just basically knocks down the comp.
- 52:50So there are a lot of rules around it and very
- 52:51specific specials. So if you see a deal where
- 52:55the selling team is getting a lot of equity packages
- 52:58and big salary raises and employment agreements,
- 53:01just think to ADG. That's just a thing you need
- 53:03to check off and have a specialist review. Yep,
- 53:06kind of to that too, like multi employer pension
- 53:08plans, the FLSA compliance, like all those kind
- 53:12of things that related to like employee or employee
- 53:14benefits, they can all trigger like massive withdrawal
- 53:17liabilities or exposures based on like history
- 53:20of audits or disputes. So like you want to be
- 53:24Bringing on your experts to review these things
- 53:27Yeah for always look out for 401k get your risk
- 53:29of person review again Make sure if you need
- 53:31to go to a frozen plan or they to assume the
- 53:33plan there's like you're not gonna know how to
- 53:35do that But they will yeah exactly And we touched
- 53:38on this earlier too, just even with regard to
- 53:40timing, environmental liabilities, depending
- 53:42on the scope of what you'll need, phase one or
- 53:45phase two, you want to get your real estate person
- 53:47in there, kind of like in the data room or reviewing
- 53:50the things immediately so that they can help
- 53:53assess the given risks. Tax, same thing. IP,
- 53:58so it depends on sometimes. a deal might not
- 54:01have any IP. But if there is IP, you want to
- 54:04have the proper searches done by your IP team.
- 54:07You want to check for infringement claims or
- 54:09anyone who's claiming that they have a right
- 54:12to use a critical IP that your client is potentially
- 54:15buying. So you want to make sure that there are
- 54:17no pending or threatened infringement claims
- 54:18as well. Letters to auditors, they may reveal
- 54:22contingent liabilities. Target company memorandums,
- 54:25to the extent that they exist, might have Am
- 54:30I talking about useful baseline for comparing
- 54:31representations to potential buyers against like
- 54:34the record of the history? You want to know like
- 54:37the corporate governance documents to see what
- 54:40their practices are. How do they approve things?
- 54:42What's the historical decision -making? Were
- 54:45there any previously understood matters in some
- 54:47of the consents? And then I think lastly would
- 54:51be like the anti -trust filings and restricted
- 54:54governance. So like anti -trust filings, SR yeah
- 55:00exactly um like in my trigger antitrust filing
- 55:05that it's like a big enough deal right like if
- 55:07you don't want any monopolies and so um that
- 55:09that's going to be a whole other analysis that
- 55:11that needs to be that's going to be flushed out
- 55:13probably in the in the beginning in the uh the
- 55:16LOI or the the term sheet stage, but that's definitely
- 55:21something that it's like, it's like a huge red
- 55:23flag item because it could, it's a gated item.
- 55:25So there's a 30 day waiting period. So if you're
- 55:28making the file and it takes some time to prepare
- 55:30the file and they need to wait 30 days to see
- 55:32if the FTC or DOJ is going to intervene. So that
- 55:34that's an important thing to know. Yeah. Even
- 55:38applies to like specific industries. Like if
- 55:40you're doing a healthcare deal, like every state
- 55:43has like its own unique rules with that too.
- 55:47So like you want to be you know, flagging it
- 55:49for the appropriate team. Yeah, I would say like
- 55:52each of these topics, they're like, they represent
- 55:54an area where diligence findings can basically
- 55:57materially affect the deal terms, right, whether
- 56:00the pricing or maybe even a decision to proceed
- 56:02with the deal or not. So as you gain experience,
- 56:05you're going to gain like a deeper understanding
- 56:07of how to, number one, review them, how to flag
- 56:10them. And so, yeah. Yeah, I was going to say
- 56:14one thing, Stephen, before we get to the Q &A
- 56:16very briefly, due diligence reveals the payoffs
- 56:20you need to make. So your lien searches, you're
- 56:22going to want to get your debts paid off, your
- 56:25liens terminated. You don't want to buy a business
- 56:27that has an all asset lien on it. Like you don't
- 56:30want to inherit lenders that you don't need.
- 56:32So you want to kind of have a schedule identifying
- 56:34exactly what needs to be paid off and then working
- 56:35through the process to get those liens clear
- 56:37either at closing or after closing. Right, right.
- 56:41And oftentimes that involves like work, like
- 56:42a payoff letter with like the lender or something.
- 56:44And you're going to be tasked with coordinating
- 56:46all that stuff, right? Making sure that the UCC
- 56:47three amendment determination filing is filed,
- 56:50like all these things that you will be keeping
- 56:52track of. You got to keep, you have to stay on
- 56:55top of it as the quarterback, as someone who's
- 56:57running the deal. And oftentimes if, if it's
- 57:00you and a partner, like that's going to fall
- 57:01on you, right? The Justins of the world, they're
- 57:04not gonna, he's not gonna know every single nitty
- 57:06-gritty thing for every deal he's on. This is
- 57:08not realistic for him. Although Justin does a
- 57:10good job of somehow doing, you know, he does
- 57:14a great job of that. But it's definitely gonna
- 57:16fall on the associate to kind of stay on top
- 57:18of it and to drive the deal. And Justin said
- 57:20it in the beginning, but like, if you're like,
- 57:24the bread and butter of this is staying organized,
- 57:26is being clear with your instruction, clear with
- 57:29the delivery of your findings. It's not helpful
- 57:32to copy paste like a provision. You need to show
- 57:36how that applies to your transaction. Oh, this
- 57:39assignment provision in this contract said this.
- 57:42Okay, how does that apply to my client? If you
- 57:44just copy and paste it, that's not helpful for
- 57:46them. You got to digest it for them and present
- 57:50it in a manner that they can see, oh, because
- 57:52of this, we might lose, I'm just gonna use an
- 57:55example, a Walmart. So that's a huge vendor of
- 57:58ours, they're huge. a contract that we really
- 58:00care about, we don't want to lose this, that's
- 58:02a red flag. So being able to do that is really
- 58:06key. And I think hopefully after this presentation,
- 58:10you guys can have a better understanding and
- 58:11feel more comfortable doing so. Yeah, you're
- 58:14not a secretary. You're not just verbatim spitting
- 58:17out things like you use your brain, speak in
- 58:20English, inform the client. It's kind of at a
- 58:24basic level. You want to make sure that your
- 58:26points getting cross So if you're speaking too
- 58:28much legally is it's just not gonna get there
- 58:30I do see a question in the chat kind of a bad
- 58:34drop box Yes, this gets back to organization.
- 58:38No matter what provider you're using, could be
- 58:40Dropbox, could be Google Drive. I don't prefer
- 58:42Google Drive. I don't prefer Dropbox. But as
- 58:45long as it's organized, it doesn't matter. You
- 58:47need to be able to track when things are uploaded.
- 58:49You need to be able to figure out how it matches
- 58:52to your due diligence list. You need to be able
- 58:54to check off your list. So that, in my opinion,
- 59:01is really important. it's kind of fundamental
- 59:05to kind of the whole process. So we hope that
- 59:08this was informative. If you guys have any further
- 59:10questions, we'll stay on for another kind of
- 59:1415, 30 seconds to see, and we're happy to answer
- 59:16them live. And if you think of anything afterwards,
- 59:19you could feel free to reach out to us or email
- 59:21us. We're kind of an open book. A lot of this
- 59:24is not in any way deal specific. This is just
- 59:26kind of general knowledge for any type of, I
- 59:29would say, M &A deal that's over like $5 million.
- 59:31Like once you get into the small mid -market
- 59:33or kind of large market deals, you're going to
- 59:37see this all the time. So and if you're doing
- 59:39M &A at a mid -size or big M1 100, M1 200 firm,
- 59:44this is going to be the process you're primarily
- 59:45using. So thank you everyone for your time today.
- 59:51We really appreciate the opportunity and we hope
- 59:54that you learned a lot. This concludes today's
- 59:58presentation. Thank you so much Justin and Stephen
- 1:00:01for an excellent presentation and thank you so
- 1:00:03much to our audience. Have a great day everybody.
- 1:00:06Thank you.