Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Advent Calendar-Dec 9th-Scythe
Transcript
- 0:13From the kitchen of the cabin, we look the best games of all time
- 0:17according to board game Geek in Ben and Steve's advent calendar. So this one's
- 0:28the seventeenth best board game ever Maid's Day, it says, who bgg I
- 0:33mean, fucking tasteless. Why do we even use the top twenty five list
- 0:36from this because it is the center of the board gaming hobby, Steve,
- 0:40we should do our own top twenty five. Like, let's talk about some
- 0:43games we actually like and know. Well, shit in a box voice blotter,
- 0:47I'd rather play that than fucking Side. So all right, now we're
- 0:51gonna get to it. So this is the seventeenth best board game ever made,
- 0:53my little Side, as I like to call it. If you look
- 0:57over on my shelf, Thirsty, you'll notice that I have Side and the
- 1:00expansions you have not yet relieved yourself. The no shipping auction, I see
- 1:06no, and I've painted all the men is nice. Yeah, because what
- 1:08you convinced yourself at the time that you liked it? All right, So
- 1:11and then it's a good game. So I'm gonna give you that the fucking
- 1:15most disappointing board game ever produced. I'm gonna give you the most disappointing board
- 1:19game designer. I'm gonna nip off to the kitchen in the Christmas Market and
- 1:26get a glass of water, and I'm gonna give you unadulterated while I'm going
- 1:32to get a glass of water just because I'm on the main feed. Yeah,
- 1:36I'm sure you are you sure you want me to be I don't want
- 1:38I don't want to watch virtually, I don't want to interrupt you. So
- 1:41I'm gonna give you a full minute to vent on side. And what's great
- 1:45Because I'm gonna go get a glass of water, I'm gonna miss the thing
- 1:49and it's only when I come to edit it that I'm gonna be able to
- 1:52hear it. It's gonna be very cool. So let's talk about side.
- 1:56Right. You sit down to play a game of scythe and what do you
- 1:59see? You see the it's like weird cyberpunk futuristic setting and a bunch of
- 2:05minis and mechs, and you think that they're gonna fight each other and it's
- 2:07gonna be this post apocalyptic battle to like somehow rescue civilization or bring it back
- 2:15from the edge. And it's not that it's just like it's so fucking typical,
- 2:22I don't know, boring, tedious, Like why these mechs, you
- 2:25don't need them. They don't do anything, they mean nothing. They are
- 2:29just fat, And Jamie Stegmeier seems to like to design games that are just
- 2:32fat and that like reward the players for no reason, like you did the
- 2:38same thing in Charterstone, where like your final score when you're done with the
- 2:40game is thirty five thousand points just for writing your name on the map.
- 2:45And then we played Expeditions recently, which I guess is like scythe the sequel,
- 2:49and you get like, you know, bonus points if it's like a
- 2:52Tuesday, like these games that just like they're not finished. They're they're like
- 2:57a sort of concept thrown in a box with some fucking minis and some beautiful
- 3:04art, and fucking people buy it, like people sign up to be subscribers
- 3:08to this shit, like it's like a subscriber sucker list. I want to
- 3:13sit down at if I see a board ben that has mechs on it,
- 3:19I want those mechs to fight. I want it to mean something. I
- 3:22don't want them to just be tokens that you move around that represent nothing whatsoever.
- 3:27Yeah, you can sit around painting them. Is that the excitement that
- 3:30size provides the buyer once they've parted with their well earned like fucking one hundred
- 3:36and fifty euros or whatever it costs that you get to paint the minis.
- 3:38You get to paint the minis. You get to paint the minies and then
- 3:40do nothing with them except stare at them and wonder why they're in the box,
- 3:45why it was necessary to make this game at such exorbitant expense, and
- 3:50then disappoint everyone who sits down to play it. Oh, except I'm wrong.
- 3:53People aren't disappointed. People are like suffering size false consciousness because people actually
- 4:00game seventeen Best Game of a Maid. You know what, I must be
- 4:03wrong because I've you must be loads of people who think this game is brilliant
- 4:06seventeen first game, love it. Oh, you gotta play it with the
- 4:09expansion. Yeah, I've heard that before. So you shouldn't have to fucking
- 4:12play the game with the expansion. Mechs should do something. The setting lies
- 4:16the content. And I'm not fucking standing for Scott Side than any yore,
- 4:20so I quite like Side. I don't mind the game. I think it
- 4:26is not the seventeenth best board game of the maid. I think it's a
- 4:30little baggy, but I enjoy the game. I think the Airship's expansion is
- 4:34rubbish because so often I played with the Airship's expansion. They don't do anything.
- 4:41They don't do anything, So you just have more minis on the board.
- 4:44You just have more minis on them, Like, I mean, I
- 4:46guess your children can play with them. Maybe it's like a it's like not
- 4:47a board game. It's like it's some kind of like, you know,
- 4:49a preteen playset, so you can I would actually have more fun as a
- 4:55twelve year old if I took the airships in the Mets, then I fucking
- 4:58just fought with Like, ah, did you? That would be a more
- 5:01fun game than the game that comes in that box. So the fundamental issue
- 5:05I have with Stone my Engen is is like, is what you said,
- 5:13the games aren't finished? When you buy a new Stonemare game, you're almost
- 5:16virtually guaranteed to have to buy an expansion to fix I feel good business strategy
- 5:24ogain. I mean it's a great so I like Viticulture, but it's unplayable
- 5:29without Tuscany expansion unforgivable, right, I agree with you and scythe Just so
- 5:36I have up there a game we haven't played with End this Winter all right,
- 5:42which we should play it so that No, it has minis and I
- 5:46think it's scythe esque, but we'll see if it fixes side sides biggest problem.
- 5:53So so people have told me, people who have chosen it for the
- 5:57podcast, it doesn't do what it says in the tin. So this is
- 6:00the problem people have. It's probably it's probably at the vanguard of this,
- 6:02like avalanche of minis fueled games. Right. So for me, the problem
- 6:09with the Stigma bray is that it is a good central idea that isn't worked
- 6:16hard. So if you look at one of the best game designers, I
- 6:24oh, our partner exactly. So he will have an idea for a game,
- 6:29then he will work it and work it and work it until every aspect
- 6:33of that game works together like a beautifully made machine. He designs games that
- 6:39like game like activities. So with decorations, yeah, so so side I
- 6:45think is okay. And when you put some of the expansions in it,
- 6:47so I only think it's okay. I did convince myself why I did convince
- 6:54myself because I backed up with kind Star, so when it ended initially came,
- 6:57I that it was better than it was. But it's it's not a
- 7:00bad game. It's certainly not the seventeenth best game. But I am not
- 7:03a fan, but it's not a bad game. But I think I think,
- 7:08broadly speaking, maybe Jamie Stegmai isn't at the vanguard of the minis games
- 7:15because I don't think actually, if you look at his outlay, he's really
- 7:19a minis game producer. Right, how do you feel about those mechs in
- 7:24that expeditions? Absolutely points, But what he is at that, what he
- 7:30is at the vanguard is the bagging euro style of game, right. I
- 7:35mean this is just like feels like around twenty thirteen twenty fourteen that eurogames were
- 7:44coming out that had lost the essential design aesthetic of eurogames, which is to
- 7:49make them absolutely only as complex as they need. There is clearly a niche
- 7:56in the board game market for like play play and forget games. Right,
- 8:01you buy the game, you play it once, you never played it again,
- 8:03you forget about it because everybody's collection is ballooning. And sure, maybe
- 8:09there's not a lot of value to capture in investing into designs the way the
- 8:13classic designers, they're done right. They put a lot of time and attention
- 8:16and care into making their their board game designs completely air tight, and people
- 8:22like us appreciate that. But the market, I don't know how much the
- 8:26market cares. If the market is attracted by shiny, glossy theme minis,
- 8:31then you don't really have to finish the game. You just do like you
- 8:33get, you get close enough, throw in a box, sell it.
- 8:37Fucking one hundred thousand people will buy it. They'll play it, they'll they'll
- 8:41or they'll convince themselves they like it because they paid so much money for it.
- 8:43But then it goes on the shelf and then onto the next thing,
- 8:46and you can serve that market. And that's a business, true fucking game
- 8:50production lines like a it's a fucking b movie studio. Right, you're right.
- 8:54So what's fascinating is the I spoke to chef and feldwork and he said
- 9:01he didn't like doing expansions, but he didn't he considered his job to make
- 9:05a game. That's a hole thinks that you name drop a designer that you've
- 9:09that you've met in every episode you do. Well, I just happened to
- 9:11have met a lot of these people, right, And I think it's relevant
- 9:13to the conversation I met Christopher Walkins, did you yeah with him? How
- 9:18was it he was not that happy to see him? No or not?
- 9:22I mean, I think he just wanted to, like, get the fuck
- 9:24out of there. Your your man. I want to see him in a
- 9:26play based on James Joyce's The Dead, Okay, And he came out and
- 9:30I asked him for a photo, and he seemed like he really wanted to
- 9:33leave, And I got a photo and I and I and I tried to
- 9:35banter with him. Didn't work. I don't know whether he's a banterrific guy.
- 9:39I mean, he wasn't anything with that man anyway. So the thing
- 9:43is, it's it's it's it's an interesting point that stefan Feld likes to design
- 9:50sort of games that are self contained things that is not the current model of
- 9:56gate design, right if you look, dare I say, I tend to
- 10:01blame everything on the Americans, But again, you sure do, especially in
- 10:05the eurogame space. When Americans started to make euro games round about the time
- 10:11I got into gaming, they really started to make you play you find that
- 10:16games are not games, but they are a business plans. Right, Americans
- 10:26are always looking for like the angle their business plans. You released the base
- 10:31game here, the expansion here, the next expansion here, the next expansion
- 10:33here. Right. What you want every game to be an empire is predictable
- 10:37revenue, exactly. And also with Stegmyer, if you notice his sort of
- 10:41business, his business policies to just cram as much shit into a box as
- 10:46possible, regardless of whether it's spin play testing. I mean he might be,
- 10:52you know, as much as I'm crapping on his games, he might
- 10:54be one of the shrewdest business man in games. Yeah maybe, I mean,
- 10:58but that's not what I admire. And games as oh we're not.
- 11:01We're not here to be apologists for like the business for publishers. I'm here
- 11:03to talk about. I mean, more power these quad games. Yeah exactly,
- 11:07I mean more power to you if you if you're making money. But
- 11:11so so the point is, I mean expeditions which is hopefully never gonna get
- 11:16anyway nia to being in the top twenty. Folk call, well, today's
- 11:18my birthday. I get to draw a bonus card. So bad that game
- 11:22is so indicative of I need an extra forty cards in this game because I
- 11:30need to perpetrate the myth of value, so I'll just have them a stupid
- 11:37fucking ideas. And yet, and yet ob Rosenberg can come out with deck
- 11:39after deck for a bricola with whoever it's sing is decks and like they all
- 11:43work right, because this is like a game to stay on the test of
- 11:46time, and these games are not right and so, and the thing is,
- 11:52I used to be a Stegma fan because I was bewitched by it.
- 11:56But there are some great games by Stone. I think Viticulture is great.
- 12:01I think Between Two Cities is great. I mean, it's not a James
- 12:03stake By game, but still I think I think he messed up with Libertalia
- 12:07read for Hims unfortunately. I think Wingspan's cool. Yeah, I mean,
- 12:13I think wings Fan is fine, but Tapestry. Tapestry is truly deplorably patent,
- 12:20and I don't think it's acceptable. I honestly don't think it's accept to
- 12:24break to publish a game and have fifty different factions and then have to publish
- 12:31in a rata three months later, wildly changing the rules for the factions because
- 12:37they're completely unbalanced. That should be done during playtest. Just not necessary for
- 12:41these games to be so big and expensive. I'm not saying there is no
- 12:46place for a large, expensive games, but these are not big games.
- 12:48These are like little games and a big part. Do you know how much
- 12:52I paid for my copy of Through the Ages at Essen from CG. It's
- 13:01not cheap, you're not. Well, it wasn't thirty years, but it
- 13:03was fifty yuros, right, fifty is cheap these days? Fifty euros for
- 13:07Through the Ages, which is the most game you'll ever get, the fifty
- 13:09quick. That's a big email in a box, and so and so.
- 13:13You can see the approach between someone like Jamie Stegmar and someone like glaudshevatte Vladaschi.
- 13:18Battle waits twenty years to publish Through the Ages expansion, which is essentially
- 13:24a deca cards, and he waits until he gets thousands of iterations and play
- 13:28tests, so he tweaks everything to perfection, whereas Jamie Stegmyer publishes a game
- 13:33and I'm still I'm still surprised by what he said to me in the interview.
- 13:39I didn't work and he doesn't even played lasting after the ins release.
- 13:43No, no, no, did he say to people shouldn't played greatly reviews
- 13:46or something? Yeah, so he said. He said he didn't mind the
- 13:48criticism when the game was in playtesting, but after it's been published. I
- 13:52think it's very unfair that you should have negative criticism, which blows my fucking
- 13:56mind. I mean I don't even have any like Cogon criticism. I just
- 13:58have like an emotional reaction, an emotional overreaction. You know what, maybe
- 14:03we should play side again with whatever Rise of Fenris expansion over the Holidays battle
- 14:09report, you know what, I will give it a fair chance. So
- 14:11we after that? What are we doing? What are we doing? So
- 14:16we're doing tickets a Ride Legacy yep, Clank Legacy yep, and now scythe
- 14:20Rise of Fenris over Christmas and Googan with the expansion. What. Yeah.
- 14:31Thank you for listening. You can support the show at Patreon dot com,
- 14:35forward slash five g f D and join the discord by going to five g
- 14:37f D dot com. Have a very merry Christmas