Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Rule of Law Under Pressure: Procedural Justice in Crisis Response with Lyndsey Olson
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to the rule of law under pressure, procedural
- 0:06justice, and crisis response. I'm Nia Wall, secretary
- 0:10of the Beverly Hills Bar Association's barrister
- 0:12section, and I'm delighted to introduce today's
- 0:15speaker, Lindsay Olson. Lindsay Olson has been
- 0:18appointed as the St. Paul City Attorney since
- 0:202018, appointed by Mayor Melvin Carter. She leads
- 0:24a team of nearly 100 legal professionals in Minnesota's
- 0:27second largest municipal law office, guiding
- 0:30all legal operations for the city of St. Paul
- 0:32with a focus on equity, innovation, and access
- 0:35to justice. Lindsay has also been an adjunct
- 0:38professor at the University of Minnesota Law
- 0:41School. From 2013 to 2018, she was the first
- 0:44woman to serve as general counsel for the Minnesota
- 0:47National Guard and Department of Military Affairs.
- 0:50A colonel in the Minnesota National Guard Jag
- 0:53Corps, She is the first female staff judge advocate
- 0:56of the 34th Infantry Division, a combat veteran
- 1:00of Operation Iraqi Freedom, and a Bronze Star
- 1:03recipient. She is also a 2020 graduate of the
- 1:06U .S. Army War College. And now let's get started.
- 1:13Good afternoon, everyone. Thanks for joining
- 1:16us. I want to start out by just giving you a
- 1:22little bit of background. I appreciate that great
- 1:24introduction by Nia. I do have a military background
- 1:29and the reason I mention it here so heavily is
- 1:34because it helped to frame my thinking and the
- 1:39way that I approached my work with our police
- 1:41department in the days following the murder of
- 1:44George Floyd. In our community, so St. Paul,
- 1:48Minnesota, If you're not familiar with Minnesota
- 1:51is what's called the Twin Cities area. And we
- 1:54are right across the river from Minneapolis.
- 1:56So we are not Minneapolis. We are a different
- 1:58city, but we are the state capital. And our metro
- 2:02area is several million people between Minneapolis
- 2:06and St. Paul. And so we have two different police
- 2:10forces and our two different municipalities.
- 2:15So, but certainly what I'm about to relate to
- 2:17you is a lot of the effects that we felt and
- 2:21everything that we dealt with in in the wake
- 2:23of that George Floyd's murder that happened in
- 2:27our community and that we immediately felt the
- 2:29effects of both with our neighboring city and
- 2:31our own city as well. So my background as you
- 2:35heard is in the Jag Corps. I spent 15 years on
- 2:38active duty and then I retired this year after
- 2:4224 years of service from the Minnesota National
- 2:44Guard. And one of the things that I think is
- 2:49really important, maybe there are some military
- 2:53folks on this call. If so, thank you for your
- 2:55service. And you may or may not be familiar with
- 2:58what judge advocates do. But a couple of things
- 3:02to understand about my training and my experience
- 3:06that I brought to my role as a city attorney
- 3:08is. We in the JAG Corps, like all lawyers and
- 3:14our public lawyers in specific, pledge to the
- 3:18Constitution, to uphold the Constitution. And
- 3:21you can see here, the first statement is about
- 3:24being the moral conscience, the institutional
- 3:26conscience of the armed forces. We perform that
- 3:29in a lot of different types of roles, including
- 3:31in operations. And we look at you know, values
- 3:37of how we are doing operations under international
- 3:41law as well as domestic law, specifically for
- 3:43the Guard. And Judge Advocates are considered
- 3:48rule of law practitioners. We train in that.
- 3:51We work in that. We worked in that both while
- 3:54I was in Iraq as well as several domestic operations
- 3:58with the National Guard. So thinking about how
- 4:07law intersects with community is something that
- 4:09the military does. Military doesn't always do
- 4:13it very well and neither do police. Lawyers,
- 4:17I think, always can play a really pivotal role
- 4:20in working with their operators, their police,
- 4:25and in the case of the military, the military
- 4:28as well. So I'm sure that everyone on this call
- 4:34is familiar with the murder of George Floyd and
- 4:37what occurred on the street in Minneapolis that
- 4:41day in May. And immediately I will say, like
- 4:46you're seeing some pictures here in this slide
- 4:50that are the ones on fire. That is the precinct
- 4:55in Minneapolis. The rest of the slides here,
- 4:59the pictures are St. Paul. We had a lot of devastation
- 5:03here in the city that started right away that
- 5:08evening and lasting several days. We had 1 ,500
- 5:14businesses damaged between the two cities, more
- 5:17than 170 fires damaged and looting just within
- 5:23our city alone. The bulk of that was concentrated
- 5:27in Minneapolis, but a large swath of our community
- 5:30was just completely destroyed as you can see.
- 5:33That brought myself, our mayor, everyone to our
- 5:38emergency operation center. We had tons of people
- 5:45in the streets right away. We had, of course,
- 5:48people creating destruction, and we also had
- 5:50people that were peacefully protesting. out in
- 5:55the streets and at the Capitol as well. So all
- 5:58simultaneously. Those first several days, like
- 6:02many cities, we were overwhelmed. Our police
- 6:05were overwhelmed. We didn't have the sheer number
- 6:08of people to contain what was happening. And
- 6:11our fire department was overwhelmed as well.
- 6:16I think the second largest in the state so they
- 6:19have a lot of ladders but they were to the point
- 6:21where firemen were getting pelted with bricks
- 6:26and rocks and things bottles and the police were
- 6:30protecting the firemen to try to put out fires
- 6:32and we just simply couldn't get to all the fires
- 6:34those first several nights so that was a really
- 6:39difficult time in our community and Being in
- 6:44the emergency operation center, we were working
- 6:47very closely with the police. There was also
- 6:51a state operation center as well that we were
- 6:54in communication with. But I started working
- 6:57with the incident commander who was running all
- 7:00of the police activity throughout the city. That's
- 7:04how the way that we started working on this evolved.
- 7:12to get to know each other professionally and
- 7:14work together, you know, he was also the commander
- 7:20of the unit that we have in the St. Paul police
- 7:22that responds to protests. And so right away,
- 7:26you know, we were looking at some things like
- 7:29you're seeing here where police are showing up.
- 7:32The picture on the far left is Target, a target
- 7:36that got destroyed. Several targets got looted
- 7:40and just completely destroyed. This is outside
- 7:43the target in St. Paul where they were trying
- 7:45to secure it. You can see folks in gas masks,
- 7:48full kind of riot gear here with the helmets
- 7:51and all of that. Excuse me. There were also a
- 7:56lot of different situations happening throughout
- 8:00the city where tear gas was being thrown, we
- 8:04had crowds interacting, objects being thrown
- 8:08at police, and so things were violent, and we
- 8:13were looking at how do we ramp that down, what
- 8:16do we use as our, you know, I think police minds
- 8:21turn to their what they call non -lethal weapons,
- 8:25and right away we had a conversation with the
- 8:28mayor about not what non -lethal weapons we were
- 8:33going to use and how that was going to work.
- 8:38And so we were very conservative about our use
- 8:42of non -lethals and that includes tear gas. So
- 8:47we did use tear gas. We did not through the whole
- 8:51course of the rioting and then into several protests
- 8:57that lasted about 425 days over the course of
- 9:00about a year and a half, up until the prosecutions
- 9:05that occurred in our federal courthouse in St.
- 9:07Paul. We did not use non -lethals like rubber
- 9:12bullets, bean bags, other things like that that
- 9:16a lot of other agencies were using on folks,
- 9:18and we'll talk a little bit more about that.
- 9:28So we were kind of advancing on this ramp up
- 9:33of violence. And one of the things that our mayor
- 9:38and I think a lot of mayors were very concerned
- 9:40about is how do we ramp down the violence? How
- 9:42do we take it back down? We were activating the
- 9:45guard. So presence did matter. You know, just
- 9:48people on the street from from a government perspective
- 9:52to sort of create a safe environment for people
- 9:56who want to peacefully protest. So we were working
- 10:00on that as well. But this you may have seen it
- 10:03was in the national news and it's actually discussed
- 10:08in a few of your materials. This is St. Paul
- 10:11police officers kneeling down which with also
- 10:16a couple of our sheriffs that were there and
- 10:19they were at a protest. So these folks showed
- 10:24up and you can see a very different uniform here.
- 10:27So June 1st, now this is when we had moved into,
- 10:32we had National Guard out, the fires were out,
- 10:38we had violence that was leveling out, but we
- 10:42had a lot of protests happening all over the
- 10:45city. Massive protests. hundreds of thousands
- 10:48of people gathering, and that happened daily
- 10:52in multiple spaces all over the city for the
- 10:54next year and a half. Some of our protests were
- 10:57armed at times, some of our protesters. So still
- 11:01high stakes protesting happening where a lot
- 11:04of different types of protests happening, pro
- 11:08-police, anti -police, and of course we have
- 11:11police feeling. a lot of pressure and fear about
- 11:17their legitimacy, how they're perceived by the
- 11:20community and the backlash from the murder of
- 11:23George Floyd and the policing of BIPOC and particularly
- 11:27Black men, Black folks, you know, for decades
- 11:32and decades and decades. And so all of that is
- 11:36converging. The folks that I worked with from
- 11:40the St. Paul Police Department I went to a lot
- 11:45of shift changes. I spoke with street officers
- 11:52as well as leadership. I kept working with the
- 11:55individual who was what I felt was, and this
- 11:58is a military term, but it's one that I really
- 12:00like and I think translates to a lot of circumstances.
- 12:03It's called center of gravity. In the military
- 12:06context, we talk about what is an objective,
- 12:08a center of gravity that's extremely strategic,
- 12:11that can change the course of how things go.
- 12:16And I think it's important, and one of the things
- 12:19that I stressed was finding the people in my
- 12:23police organization who were centers of gravity
- 12:25for that team, because those mid -level leaders
- 12:30or high -level leaders, or it could even be like
- 12:34a street boss officer, those folks are the ones
- 12:38that are going to directly impact the way that
- 12:42folks on the street are interacting with the
- 12:47public and impacting how they show up. That was
- 12:54one thing that we were doing here. We had started
- 12:58having conversations about how we show up. in
- 13:03protests. You can see the stark contrast of how
- 13:08these folks showed up to this protest versus
- 13:15what you first saw outside of that target. And
- 13:19this is where we started shifting how police
- 13:22were showing up and changing the tenor of how
- 13:26we were working with these organizations that
- 13:29were coming out to protest. And there's a lot
- 13:32more to that. And I want to get to that. But
- 13:34this was an important moment. And it was unscripted.
- 13:38It happened just very organically. And it was,
- 13:46I think, a turning point, at least locally for
- 13:50us, where people saw that and felt, hey, it's
- 13:57a recognition that the police officers really
- 14:04have an empathy and they are part of the community
- 14:07and they want to recognize what people are expressing
- 14:13and respect it. So police response models, first
- 14:23of all, police aren't very good planners and
- 14:26that's not to disparage police at all, but they're
- 14:29not trained necessarily, some agencies do a really
- 14:33good job at it and they realize that and they
- 14:35do a good job. Other agencies, a lot of police
- 14:38agencies are response, they're training response.
- 14:40Police is a response model, right? You respond
- 14:43to an emergency and you're trained in different
- 14:47types of response. And these are types of response
- 14:50that are generally used. Now all of them have
- 14:53some good aspects to them. So Ronald surface
- 15:00I want to mention something that he said in an
- 15:02NPR interview he is. He headed several agencies,
- 15:06including the New Orleans Police Department for
- 15:08a time, but he is a leading expert nationwide
- 15:13on the police side for protest response. And
- 15:16he was mentioning some of these models, the negotiated
- 15:19management model is one that he has used with
- 15:22success and that he mentioned. And one of the
- 15:25things that he talked about was police know how
- 15:28to... respond when things are peaceful. They
- 15:31also know how to respond when things are violent
- 15:33and the place where this gets really complicated
- 15:36and what we see more and more is it's sort of
- 15:38there's this gray area or there's some intelligence
- 15:41that maybe there's going to be some agitators
- 15:44or some groups that are coming in to do violence
- 15:47in the community that aren't even from the community
- 15:49and we had that happen and so did several communities
- 15:52across the country. and versus folks that are
- 15:56coming out to exercise our First Amendment rights.
- 16:00And we want to protect those people. And it becomes
- 16:02a very, very complex set of circumstances for
- 16:06police to navigate and understand how are we
- 16:09successfully navigating interaction with the
- 16:12community? How are we protecting people that
- 16:14are peaceful? How are we discovering people that
- 16:19are violent and how are we keeping a safe space
- 16:26as these things move forward. Aspects of all
- 16:31of these types of response were things that we
- 16:35used in St. Paul along with restorative justice.
- 16:47Restorative justice, I'm going to talk about
- 16:49in a minute here a little bit more deeply. And
- 16:53I think that it's, restorative justice is, I'm
- 16:57sorry, procedural justice. Procedural justice
- 17:00is something that flows throughout people's experience
- 17:04of the justice system. It's how they feel about
- 17:07what they are experiencing and it impacts how
- 17:10they... how they perceive the legitimacy of the
- 17:15rule of law systems, of courts, of cops, of prosecutors,
- 17:21of the corrections system. And we'll go over
- 17:26the aspects of that. I think it's the reason
- 17:29that it impacts so much with protesting is because
- 17:34we're talking about the intersection of constitutional
- 17:39rights. that you can see here, there's a couple
- 17:44of quotes, one from a law review article that
- 17:46I've included for you on the Fourth Amendment
- 17:50and how to look at the Fourth Amendment in protest
- 17:55situations and making sure that we are honoring
- 18:03First Amendment constitutional rights in the
- 18:07proper balance with whatever level of unrest
- 18:13is happening and Fourth Amendment rights and
- 18:18how police are responding within the Fourth Amendment
- 18:21as well. And so all that is to say that the aspects
- 18:25of procedural justice really collide very importantly
- 18:30in these situations at a level where I think
- 18:34people's experience of protesting because it's
- 18:39something that is foundational to our democracy
- 18:41really can have an impact on how they feel about
- 18:48the legitimacy of government, how they perceive
- 18:53the fairness of the whole justice system from
- 18:58their interaction with police to if they're picked
- 19:03up and prosecuted and treated by the court and
- 19:06all of those things. So that is another thing
- 19:09that I brought into the conversation with our
- 19:12police and talk to them about thinking about
- 19:15how that can help protect them. And I think it's
- 19:21really important and this is something that I
- 19:23brought in from my military training, particularly
- 19:27in Iraq, which is a very different situation
- 19:30in a lot of ways from anything that we would
- 19:32see domestically. But one of the things that
- 19:35we were doing in Iraq is winning hearts and minds.
- 19:40We were protecting the local populations there
- 19:43and we certainly want to keep our own troops
- 19:47safe and identify anybody who is trying to harm
- 19:50us but also we want to protect civilian populations.
- 19:54We want to respect them. We want them to know
- 19:56we're there to assist them in rebuilding and
- 20:00that mission is very complicated with you know
- 20:03working with a lot of younger men who are also
- 20:06scared to be out there with some people who are
- 20:09trying to kill them. And you know, I think there
- 20:14were a lot of mindsets in the police department.
- 20:18Not only do you have some former military folks
- 20:20that are in there, but you've got a situation
- 20:24where at this time in specific, I think more
- 20:27than I've seen in the past. And I don't know,
- 20:32you know, any time in the past, but certainly
- 20:34I think for the first time in a lot of those
- 20:36officers careers, they really felt unsafe in
- 20:39their community. They felt that they didn't know
- 20:43how to respond in more kind of normal situations
- 20:47that they would have, you know, not had a problem
- 20:49responding in before because they felt that people
- 20:53were always angry at them and wanted to harm
- 20:55them. And that was something that was really
- 20:59important to talk about. And I think that attorneys
- 21:02can play a role in that, an important role. And
- 21:05again, identifying, being able to talk with those
- 21:09officers, those street officers, and also relying
- 21:12on those folks that are very influential in their
- 21:17own department. Now, you know, every police department,
- 21:20I think every workplace probably has its own
- 21:24issues right and so I you know I think our our
- 21:27police department in St. Paul has run um really
- 21:29very well of course we have um you know a lot
- 21:33of the same issues that all the departments have
- 21:36um we are very very different department than
- 21:38Minneapolis for instance um and so you know turning
- 21:42around a police department um in terms of the
- 21:45culture is a very different conversation than
- 21:47the one I'm having with you all today about what
- 21:48we did um And so we came into this with a set
- 21:56of escalation of force rules and continuum of
- 22:02force that was based on 21st century policing.
- 22:06I think we were very cutting edge coming into.
- 22:10uh this circumstance and that also really helped
- 22:13out my ability to work with um our our officers
- 22:18and um and their understanding of what their
- 22:21response to violence was and their use of force
- 22:24and response and so um you know nothing i'm saying
- 22:29is is to say that this was easier uncomplicated
- 22:32and recognizing that all cities have and and
- 22:35all police departments have different cultures
- 22:38and and struggles and aspects. So one of the
- 22:48things that we know about police response. And
- 22:55there's a lot of research out there. I've sent
- 22:58you in the documents I made available a couple
- 23:03of articles that include some research in a couple
- 23:08of big cities. But it's been going on for a long
- 23:11time. There are several good uh articles out
- 23:16there uh where protesters have been interviewed
- 23:19and they're asked about their experiences which
- 23:22is basically their um you know how their their
- 23:27uh view of the procedural justice that occurred
- 23:29in their um in their experience during a protest
- 23:33um and so What is clear is that disproportionate
- 23:39police force is one of the things that can make
- 23:41peaceful protests not peaceful. And I think that's
- 23:44a really important takeaway that how we show
- 23:48up, which is why we changed the uniforms along
- 23:50with some other things that we did and didn't
- 23:53do, is a really important first step because
- 23:56it's something that the city that the police
- 23:59can actually control. You can start um this off
- 24:03you know it's like starting a negotiation right
- 24:06with a party you're not sure where they're at
- 24:08um but you can start off in a in a hostile way
- 24:12or you can start off in in a way that encourages
- 24:15um you know a respectful discourse and a back
- 24:20and forth and and and so it's the same you know
- 24:23when when police show up right if you show up
- 24:25in uh riot gear ready to rumble if you're saying
- 24:28things to people um like if you do x y we're
- 24:31going to start beating on you um you know people
- 24:35respond to that in a way that is more violent
- 24:37and then they also move towards people that are
- 24:40acting in violence when violence is being done
- 24:41to them even if they had no intention of coming
- 24:43there to do violence um and along with um with
- 24:49this, you know, employing methods like what Ronald
- 24:54Serpus had, the Chief Ronald Serpus had mentioned,
- 24:58which is reaching out to groups that are known.
- 25:02I would say in many of these circumstances, there
- 25:07are organizers, leaders of all of these protest
- 25:11groups, many of them come out time and time again.
- 25:15And When I speak to police about it, they say,
- 25:18well, I don't want them to think that we're friends
- 25:19because then they're going to take advantage
- 25:21of us. And I think that that's a real fear, right?
- 25:26But that's not the purpose of the reach out.
- 25:28The purpose of the reach out is more to establish
- 25:33a respectful dialogue to help understand who
- 25:37the group is and what they want to accomplish
- 25:39and to let the group know that you're there to
- 25:42help them to assert their First Amendment rights.
- 25:47And the leaders of the group can do a lot to
- 25:50work with the people that are showing up. If
- 25:53they have things they want to accomplish in their
- 25:55protest, unless it's violence, but let's say
- 25:59they're doing lawful things. So they want to
- 26:00show up, they want to have a protest, they want
- 26:02their issues known. They don't want agitators
- 26:05there any more than the police do. Because those
- 26:08folks are going to take that often to a different
- 26:11direction. They're not going to be able to accomplish
- 26:14what they set out for the group. So we can find
- 26:18common ground with these groups often, and that
- 26:21happened a lot with several groups. You know,
- 26:24groups that didn't like police, we even had people
- 26:26say to us, like, we don't like you, but we know
- 26:29that you're here to help us to achieve what we're
- 26:33trying to achieve, and we appreciate that. And
- 26:35sometimes that's all the common ground you're
- 26:37going to get, right? But that really helps achieve
- 26:41a successful First Amendment experience for people.
- 26:46It helps achieve a very peaceful environment
- 26:49for the community. And so that's the blend of
- 26:55understanding and response methods that we started
- 26:59to use. Some of the things that a lot of agencies
- 27:04do that can lead to this bad cycle is is just
- 27:10responding and not training, not planning. I
- 27:13was on a call today where that very thing did
- 27:17get brought up and someone said, well, we tried
- 27:20to plan and it was just, it didn't work at all.
- 27:23And it was terrible. And so I think it's better
- 27:24to just respond because otherwise you're wasting
- 27:26time. And my response to that would be, that's
- 27:30a terrible idea. And what a failure to plan well
- 27:35means is that you... you've got to bring in people
- 27:38who can help get you there, not that planning
- 27:40is a bad idea. And so that would include running
- 27:44scenarios, doing what's called a tabletop or
- 27:46an exercise where you have a scenario, bringing
- 27:49together different groups and walking through
- 27:52how you would respond and what partners you need
- 27:58there, for instance. And you can see a lot of
- 28:04these other mindsets are also things that can
- 28:09derail you. And I've already mentioned the disconnect
- 28:12between the rank and file and the executive leadership.
- 28:15And that's why I started with recognizing who
- 28:19is open to receiving my counsel and who do I
- 28:24need to identify that. is influential in the
- 28:28organization, both for working with rank and
- 28:32file, the folks that are beyond the street, as
- 28:34well as the executive leadership and bridging
- 28:37that and affecting the way that people show up.
- 28:42So a lot of these things can start a bad cycle.
- 28:53So procedural justice. I pulled this definition
- 28:55from Yale Law School. If you're interested more
- 28:58in procedural justice, they're a good place to
- 29:00start. They have a justice collaboratory that
- 29:02does a lot of work around procedural justice.
- 29:05But it has basically four pieces to it that I
- 29:09think lawyers will, if you're not familiar with
- 29:13procedural justice, you'll see this and think,
- 29:14well, a lot of that is really, you know, Like,
- 29:18yeah, I know that, right? But we don't talk about
- 29:20it often in these ways. That people are treated
- 29:23with dignity and respect, that they have a voice,
- 29:27that they can be heard, and that they have a
- 29:30neutral decision maker and a transparent process,
- 29:34and that the decision maker is conveying trustworthy
- 29:38motives. And those four pieces really place people
- 29:43in situations where no matter what's going on
- 29:47for them. So let's say we've got someone in court
- 29:49in front of a judge and a prosecutor and a defense
- 29:53counsel there that if they have a situation where
- 29:57they're being prosecuted for a crime, this is
- 30:02probably one of the worst moments of their life.
- 30:04And they're scared. They don't often understand
- 30:06what's happening. And even when we're working
- 30:10with them, trying to help them to understand,
- 30:13which should be the goal of both. of all parties
- 30:15in that courtroom, sometimes they don't get treated
- 30:20with dignity and respect. And sometimes they're
- 30:23not treating others with dignity and respect.
- 30:25But I think as system partners and as a prosecutor,
- 30:31our role is as a minister of justice. And so
- 30:35in that role, we're stepping up to help somebody
- 30:41to feel that they are getting justice through
- 30:46this process, even if they don't agree with the
- 30:49outcome. And that can start with just treating
- 30:51someone in a way of basic human dignity and respecting
- 30:59them. giving someone a voice. I mean, the courtroom
- 31:03is a good way to think about, you know, that
- 31:07voice aspect because people aren't always given
- 31:09a voice when they're arrested, right? And often
- 31:12we as lawyers tell people, don't say anything.
- 31:14So maybe that's not your place to have a voice.
- 31:17But when we're looking at the entire process,
- 31:20people tend to think like, how was I treated
- 31:22by police? And, you know, moving into the the
- 31:29process working with prosecutors and into the
- 31:33courtroom. What was my experience? And even if
- 31:39I don't like that I got convicted of this crime,
- 31:42I don't want to spend time in jail or I don't
- 31:44want to do these consequences that if they feel
- 31:48like the process was run fairly, they will come
- 31:53out with a neutral or even a positive feeling
- 31:58about what they experienced. So procedural justice
- 32:08in protest, you can start to see how this would
- 32:12be a really helpful model to add in to how police
- 32:18are showing up and thinking about, you know,
- 32:24aspects of allowing people to use their voice
- 32:27in a protest, right? Thinking about having those
- 32:33interactions where, you know, you might not like
- 32:35police, but you over time build a level of trust
- 32:41when you see police over and over again. I think
- 32:44now after the experiences that we've had coming
- 32:47out of the protest after the murder of George
- 32:50Floyd, we've continued to interact with community
- 32:55in that way. And so when people come and protest
- 32:59in the city of St. Paul, the people that have
- 33:01come multiple times and have some history with
- 33:04interacting with our police department, if they
- 33:06are arrested, they have some history with my
- 33:09office, they have some history with our court
- 33:11system, and they have that level of trust in
- 33:16saying like, I might not like what's happening.
- 33:19I have my goals for coming out and exercising
- 33:21my First Amendment rights, which might be civil
- 33:24disobedience. But I'm treated in a way that I
- 33:30feel is proportional and just, and my rights
- 33:34are respected. I'm able to use my voice. I'm
- 33:36able to be protected if I want my constitutional
- 33:41First Amendment right. The other thing we looked
- 33:50at is who's in the space and why are they in
- 33:52the space, which is always a really important
- 33:54aspect of this. And you can see here, you're
- 34:01probably all familiar with the siege of the third
- 34:02precinct and. When that happened, it really ramped
- 34:07up the violence because people who were involved
- 34:09in that plan and carried out that plan over in
- 34:13Minneapolis were emboldened by their ability
- 34:17to burn that police building down and their ability
- 34:21to take over that space and do some lawless things
- 34:25there. Thecrimethink .com there is an actual
- 34:33account of the plan that they had to burn down
- 34:39the building. There was an anarchist group that
- 34:47came in. We had a lot of groups coming in either
- 34:50from out state Minnesota, but also from around
- 34:53the country. You can see on the far right, the
- 34:57Boogaloo Boys had a conspiracy. They came to
- 35:00Minnesota with the intention of harming a lot
- 35:04of people harming the community, harming officers,
- 35:06harming community members, burning down buildings,
- 35:09creating chaos. And many of them were arrested
- 35:13and faced federal charges. You can see in the
- 35:15middle, that's our governor, Governor Walz. On
- 35:20the back end of our, of the damages of the riots,
- 35:27what we found and what police found in both federal
- 35:30and state is that and local is that the damages,
- 35:36a lot of the people who did violence in our community
- 35:39were not members of the community. They were
- 35:42not from the Twin Cities area. They came into
- 35:46our community to create unrest and violence.
- 35:51And so we had a small minority of folks that
- 35:55were intent on creating violence and how officials
- 36:00approach interacting with a protest can really
- 36:05affect how much influence and how much violence
- 36:09they're able to inflict. And so if we're looking
- 36:15back at that research, it's how police are showing
- 36:18up. are police able to identify and pull out
- 36:22folks who are there to do violence instead of
- 36:28affecting mass arrests with all people that are
- 36:31present. So we worked a lot on things like that
- 36:35of identifying individuals who were there doing
- 36:39violence and pull them out. And I was in the
- 36:43EOC talking with all of our law enforcement on
- 36:48site um letting them know um you know about how
- 36:53to approach these things in ways that um could
- 36:57you know maximize the uh the peacefulness on
- 37:02the ground and also what we're thinking about
- 37:05as prosecutors on the back end of this um was
- 37:09something like a sit -in for um peaceful protest
- 37:13where there's a curfew and they break the curfew.
- 37:16We had that happen. There was a massive group
- 37:17that sat on our Capitol lawn that we knew ahead
- 37:20of time. They said when they came, they're like,
- 37:22we're going to be here and we're going to sit
- 37:23here. And that's all they did. And they kind
- 37:28of forced the police there to pick them up and
- 37:31remove them. But often police have this feeling
- 37:35like these people have to be prosecuted because
- 37:38they have to know that you know doing that um
- 37:43you know is against the law it's against the
- 37:45curfew and um I'll talk a little bit more about
- 37:49what I did on the back end in a in a little bit
- 37:52but um one of the things I told them up front
- 37:54too to manage expectations with everyone was
- 37:57I will you know you are you need to do what what
- 38:00you're doing in the moment right you you're as
- 38:04police on the ground you're making those decisions
- 38:07um that discretion of are we doing a mass arrest?
- 38:11Like how do we clear the space? They're responsible
- 38:14for enforcing the court, the curfew, and that's
- 38:16what they have to do. So if they arrest 100 people,
- 38:19you know, for just sitting on the lawn at a time
- 38:22that's past the curfew, because really the point
- 38:25of the curfew is to make sure that other people
- 38:27who are out to do violence in the community can
- 38:30be identified. And the error, the time late at
- 38:33night a lot of times is the most violent time.
- 38:37um up until about you know two maybe sometimes
- 38:40three in the morning um that time tends to ramp
- 38:43up violence when it's dark when there are you
- 38:45know less people and so the curfew can be something
- 38:48that helps um to get folks who might normally
- 38:52just be enjoying things out in the community
- 38:53that might not know what's going on um to get
- 38:56out of a space that's unsafe and also to be able
- 38:59to identify people who are um breaking curfew
- 39:03on purpose and might be doing that for a reason
- 39:05that is here to harm our community and cause
- 39:07violence. versus this group that was doing civil
- 39:13disobedience in a peaceful way. And so in my
- 39:16mind as a prosecutor and someone who is looking
- 39:19at our office approach, that was an important
- 39:21aspect to me in terms of figuring out how are
- 39:23we handling different people. But we looked at
- 39:27everybody individually, regardless. We didn't
- 39:30want anyone to think that they were getting out
- 39:33of something on the front end and at like a batch
- 39:35dismissal. So we did not do that. But managing
- 39:40the expectations is important. This is a little
- 39:45bit on some research that underpins what I've
- 39:51just explained here. And this was a research
- 39:58that happened from the Occupy Wall Street protests
- 40:01in New York and DC. There is an article out there
- 40:05about this research as well. I didn't attach
- 40:07it for you. But I believe the author is the same
- 40:11author as one of the other articles. And so if
- 40:13you want to read deeper about it, it's an easy
- 40:17search on finding that article. But this also,
- 40:21again, says interviews of those folks showed
- 40:25that they were likely to shift their attitude
- 40:27in favor of violence and to engage in violence
- 40:30themselves, even if they didn't come there to
- 40:32do that, when they observed officers using what
- 40:35disproportionate force or coming at folks who
- 40:39were there to be peaceful, to do violence on
- 40:43others. So again, there's a lot of research out
- 40:48there showing how we show what matters. There's
- 40:57an article, there are two articles actually,
- 40:59and I attach both of them for folks if they want
- 41:01to look at them. This is important for several
- 41:05reasons. They're actually like opinions of lists
- 41:09of doctors who treated people after the. the
- 41:12protests after George Floyd's murder. One group
- 41:15was from Minneapolis, and that's what you see
- 41:17here. That's where this quote is from. And that
- 41:20was about brain injuries. That was about different
- 41:22types of projectiles. And then there's also one
- 41:24on beanbags that is from Denver, maybe. I can't
- 41:28remember the city. But both of these show what
- 41:39officers are doing to people with these less
- 41:42than lethal weapons are very harmful to them
- 41:44physically and really can create a lot of tissue
- 41:48damage. They're not necessarily, they're supposed
- 41:53to be not harmful, but they are. And a lot of
- 41:56times the way that police officers employ them,
- 42:01if they aim at people's heads or they aim at
- 42:03people's groins and there's, you know, body worn
- 42:07camera footage of them doing those types of things
- 42:09where it's like more of the intent to harm someone.
- 42:12And people have experienced very horrible injuries
- 42:17coming into the hospitals after that. And the
- 42:21opinion of this group of doctors who treated
- 42:24folks coming off of that police response where
- 42:27they received injuries in these two cities, but
- 42:31it happened in a lot of cities across the nation
- 42:34was that these non -lethal weapons, including
- 42:41rubber bullets and bean bags, bean bag rounds,
- 42:44things like that, are not appropriate for crowd
- 42:47control. And so not only did organizations, police
- 42:55organizations across the country receive a lot
- 42:58of civil rights litigation after this on these
- 43:03types of actions, These findings I think are
- 43:09important and are damaging to a city's ability
- 43:14to be able to defend that. Because here we have
- 43:17doctors saying the injuries that these cause
- 43:21make these weapons different than what is intended
- 43:28or understood and it's not proportional. That
- 43:35is not a dispositive thing in a case, but I think
- 43:39it's definitely something that can influence
- 43:41a jury. When people hear, hey, there's doctors
- 43:45that treat people, and we know that these types
- 43:51of projectiles can really harm people and are
- 43:54recommended not to be used in this way, that
- 43:58I think can really. influence a group of folks
- 44:01to think about what the legality and the appropriateness
- 44:04of a situation and a context is as an attorney
- 44:08that defends cities. So this was significant
- 44:12from my view for thinking about how our police
- 44:17agency Would use these in the future because
- 44:21again, we didn't we made a conscious decision
- 44:23because of things like this even before seeing
- 44:25this That we weren't going to use those things
- 44:28because we were going to look at Proportional
- 44:30response and and think about how we were showing
- 44:32up in order to work proactively to decrease violence
- 44:35and we were very successful in that and so we
- 44:39were able to minimize our use of non -lethal
- 44:41weapons instead of showing up that way and I
- 44:45want to give you a a taste here of what was happening
- 44:49around the U .S., because certainly St. Paul
- 44:51is different than L .A. and Chicago and all other
- 44:54places. All cities are unique and have unique
- 44:56aspects in their communities, in their police
- 44:59departments, in their local governments. And
- 45:02so to just show you, you can see here on the
- 45:06chart on the left, you know, where these protest
- 45:10events were happening. There was a total of 8
- 45:11,700 that happened, and they just looked at um
- 45:17this is from a chiefs a national chiefs association
- 45:19by the way they they did a huge report um on
- 45:22their members which were um i think like 21 major
- 45:25cities uh and um so of these major cities all
- 45:30the major cities that you could think of that
- 45:32had the the the most um protests and the most
- 45:35violent ones um this was from may 25th um which
- 45:38was uh when george floyd was murdered and then
- 45:42up until july 31st so um We had protests that
- 45:46were spanning out, and I know several cities
- 45:48did after that date, but I think they just did
- 45:49a cutoff. I'm not sure why they chose that date.
- 45:52But in that time, you can see 8 ,700 protests,
- 45:55events, and 3 ,692 involved unlawful acts of
- 46:01civil disobedience. But those think civil disobedience
- 46:06different from violence. The report that the
- 46:10Chiefs Association found was that only 574 of
- 46:14the protest study involved violence and one city
- 46:17accounted for 100 of those 574 and so percentage
- 46:22wise in terms of. where violence happened versus
- 46:27protests that were happening, mass protests that
- 46:30were happening, you can see there's a huge span
- 46:32between that. So rhetoric talking about all of
- 46:35these protests are violent, and the numbers show
- 46:40that's just not true, and that in the vast majority
- 46:45of cases, violence can be avoided and that isn't
- 46:49why people are protesting. And so I think this
- 46:52really important information and it comes from
- 46:56police and you know across the nation. On the
- 47:04back end of this, this is an article from The
- 47:08Guardian from 2023, so it's like a couple years
- 47:12old, but I couldn't find anything that was 2025.
- 47:15um to find out where where these cities were
- 47:18at with payouts but in 2023 they already had
- 47:22paid out 80 million dollars in um 1983 cases
- 47:27and other civil rights cases, settlements to
- 47:30protesters for actions by police people that
- 47:33were injured or had violent encounters with police.
- 47:37And you can see this Howard University professor
- 47:39says I've never seen a wave of settlements for
- 47:41police brutality like this in American history
- 47:43was quite significant. It's been quite vast and
- 47:46is still ongoing. So you know, several cities,
- 47:49folks that I know, colleagues and counterparts
- 47:53are facing still hundreds of lawsuits, massive
- 47:57lawsuits. So that will be happening for years
- 48:00to come. It's very expensive for taxpayers, very
- 48:02expensive for communities. And of course, you
- 48:05know, just jabs that legitimacy right in his
- 48:12heart. So here's St. Paul's results. So we had
- 48:16450 days of multiple sustained protests from
- 48:192020 to 2022. That was the day that we had the
- 48:26trials of the officers held at the federal courthouse
- 48:29in St. Paul. So that's why I chose that date.
- 48:31But we had multiple protests each day during
- 48:33that whole sustained time period. We had thousands
- 48:36of people. Several of our groups were armed,
- 48:38as I mentioned before. And we did facilitate
- 48:40hundreds of arrests during that time. our city
- 48:43has had zero 1983 cases. So 14 USC 1983, that's
- 48:48civil action for deprivation of rights. And that's
- 48:53the basis on which most people sue for police
- 48:56brutality actions, police violence that they
- 49:01suffer. And so I... I'm obviously thrilled with
- 49:07this result. It is unprecedented in my opinion.
- 49:10I don't know any other city that's achieved that.
- 49:14I certainly didn't go into the partnership with
- 49:18our police thinking that we would achieve this,
- 49:23but showing that this is possible I think is
- 49:27also really heartening because you know, we achieved
- 49:33peace for our community. Our police, you know,
- 49:37were able to arrest people, were able to uphold
- 49:41the rule of law, we were able to increase legitimacy
- 49:44from its low point in our city, and we were able
- 49:47to do it in a way that did not necessitate violent
- 49:51interactions with protesters. And I'm almost
- 49:56wrapping up here. I want to have some time for
- 49:58questions. So Just a few lessons learned and
- 50:03some information about how I handled arrests.
- 50:12I thought a lot about how we had some... protests
- 50:17in the past and some mass arrests in the past
- 50:19where protesters aim was to disrupt the court
- 50:23process. And they were able to do that in a couple
- 50:26of cases. And I wanted to make sure that we were
- 50:30providing procedural justice for people that
- 50:33were ticketed and picked up. And so The process
- 50:39that I worked on with my team was to announce
- 50:41ahead that both we were looking at that we were
- 50:45prioritizing any violent crimes and that we would
- 50:49be looking at peaceful crimes, but I wasn't batch
- 50:53dismissing anything. But we were going to look
- 50:56at dismissing or moving into alternatives to
- 51:01traditional prosecution. So diversion, those
- 51:06cases that were peaceful. And so that people
- 51:10could understand that we were looking at outcomes
- 51:14and processes that were proportional to what
- 51:17their ticket was for and what they were picked
- 51:20up for and what their actions were. And so with
- 51:22my team, with my prosecutors, we looked at everybody
- 51:25individually. Individual justice is how we do
- 51:28our work. So we always look at everyone's individual
- 51:31situation and work towards what is justice in
- 51:34that situation. and we did that here as well
- 51:37even though we had hundreds of cases. We weren't
- 51:40going to press the easy button on on moving any
- 51:43of them out. We moved a lot of people into a
- 51:46program that we have here called Ethos, which
- 51:47is a restorative justice program. It has a recidivism
- 51:51rate after almost seven years of under 9 % versus
- 51:56about 42 % around our state for traditional prosecution.
- 52:02And as you guys probably know, but I'll say it
- 52:04anyway, recidivism is a re -offense rate. So
- 52:07it's a circle process that people engage in that
- 52:11talks about why they did what they did. They
- 52:15have to admit that they did the thing in order
- 52:17to go into the process. It's a type of diversion
- 52:19and they repair harm in the community with a
- 52:22circle of community members. And I think that
- 52:26really mesh well with a lot of the tickets that
- 52:29we saw here. where people got to feel heard.
- 52:33They also got to talk with community members
- 52:34who maybe were affected by some of their actions
- 52:36in ways that they can acknowledge that there's
- 52:39a reason why something is illegal because it
- 52:41does create a type of harm to the community.
- 52:45All those things are ways that we wanted to simultaneously
- 52:49hold people accountable in ways that made sense
- 52:52and also ensure that we're upholding the rule
- 52:55of law, but also treating people in a way that
- 52:58helps them to feel that they're heard, they're
- 53:02listened to, they're treated with respect, and
- 53:04coming out of that feeling like this is a place
- 53:07where I can receive justice. I also think it
- 53:11was really important to have city attorneys in
- 53:15our operations center with police, alongside
- 53:18police, and for any municipal folks on this,
- 53:23I would highly recommend that you're doing that
- 53:25if you can. And these are some of the flyers
- 53:33and online things that were happening with the
- 53:35arrests. There were these mass meetings of folks
- 53:39that had been arrested or detained and then lawyers
- 53:42that were stepping up to do pro bono for them.
- 53:44So we knew that we were ramping up for people
- 53:48that were, you know, some people wanted to create,
- 53:51you know, distrust and you know disruption in
- 53:58the courts and so we took that into consideration
- 54:02just understanding why people were there. And
- 54:05so that is that's what I have for you today and
- 54:10I'm happy to take questions at this time. I know
- 54:12we have a few minutes left here and I hope you've
- 54:16enjoyed things. If you want to reach out to me
- 54:20On the back end, I can leave my contact information
- 54:24with the Beverly Hills Bar Association. You can
- 54:25also find me on LinkedIn as well as online. My
- 54:30contact information is available publicly as
- 54:32a city attorney. I'd be happy to take questions.
- 54:38About this time, I don't see any questions, so
- 54:41maybe we give the attendees a minute or two.
- 54:44Do you have any additional parting thoughts for
- 54:46the audience today? Yeah, well, I would, I would,
- 54:53you know, there's a lot here I think that is
- 54:57relevant to circumstances that we're seeing now.
- 55:03We have a couple of cities where federal troops
- 55:05have been deployed and we're seeing a lot of
- 55:12federal agents in our cities, a lot of protests
- 55:15in our cities. I think a lot of the lessons here
- 55:20can be really helpful in what a lot of cities
- 55:25are facing now. I think lawyers have a unique
- 55:31ability to impact their communities. I think
- 55:35it's incredibly important for whatever kind of
- 55:38law you practice to be able to even have conversations
- 55:43about the Constitution, about our rights with
- 55:49people that you know and helping people to understand
- 55:53what our Constitution is. If you do nothing else,
- 56:02I think that if you're looking to make an impact
- 56:05where you live and where you are, that impact
- 56:10right there, I think can just can spread, right?
- 56:13We have a responsibility within the profession
- 56:17to uphold the Constitution. and a lot of people
- 56:22don't remember civics, or I think even some lawyers
- 56:27don't remember constitutional law if they don't
- 56:29practice it. And so I think having those conversations
- 56:32is just really, really important to be able to
- 56:37have someone take something away that they can
- 56:39then talk to someone else about and just help
- 56:42share education with folks. All right. I don't
- 56:52see any questions. I just want to take a moment
- 56:55to thank you for your time today. We really appreciate
- 56:57you speaking to our members on this topic. And
- 57:00I hope our attendees enjoy the rest of their
- 57:01day. Thanks.