Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #19: Historical Party Divisions of Congress
Transcript
- 0:00It's that time again.
- 0:02Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast with your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:07Today, we're gonna talk about everybody's favorite political institution, Congress.
- 0:15Now both chambers of congress, the US House and the US Senate tend to be hotly contested as to
- 0:21which party is going to take majority control, but it wasn't always like this.
- 0:26When you look back at the partisan history of congress, you find several streaks where either
- 0:32the Democratic party or the Republican party consistently won one or either chamber,
- 0:39sometimes dominantly so.
- 0:41So today's episode of the podcast will be an overview overview, excuse me, of said history
- 0:47and how the upcoming congress, the 119th congress, compares to said history in terms of
- 0:53majority party control of either chamber.
- 0:56So let's dive in.
- 0:58Now a few caveats of this analysis here is it's gonna be predominantly focused on Democrats
- 1:05versus Republicans because those are the current parties after all.
- 1:09We will take a short look, however, at the party systems in America prior to the birth of
- 1:15the Republican Party in the 18 fifties.
- 1:17The Democratic Party has been around since basically the beginning.
- 1:22I'm also not counting potential changes to majority control within a congress unless
- 1:27otherwise noted because it just gets a little too convoluted.
- 1:32So I'm not focusing on special elections or vacancies unless, again, unless I otherwise say
- 1:39so.
- 1:40Comparisons of net gains or losses of seats for a party are gonna be based on post election day
- 1:46numbers.
- 1:46So for example, the change in seats, if I say a specific change in seats for Republican or
- 1:52Democratic parties from the 18/92 to 18/94 election.
- 1:57It's just those post election day numbers.
- 2:01And once again, disregarding vacancies unless otherwise noted.
- 2:05So let's go into the party systems in party systems in US Congress pre Republican party.
- 2:14Now at the beginning, there were no parties.
- 2:17There were simply pro administration and anti administration.
- 2:21The founding fathers didn't envision parties, but they gravitated towards them fairly
- 2:27quickly.
- 2:28So while it was pro administration and anti administration, the first few congresses
- 2:34towards the end of Washington's presidency, George Washington, there were they led to the
- 2:40emergence of the federalist and democratic republican parties.
- 2:44The democratic republican party is the democratic party of today.
- 2:48And in the US house, democratic republicans took the majority in 1794, and when they were
- 2:55just anti administration, they had it in 1792, and the US senate pro administration slash
- 3:02federalist had majorities already.
- 3:05Federalists took the majority in the US house in 1796 and 1798, but then they lost it in 1800
- 3:13and never got it back.
- 3:14Never even came close to doing so in either chamber, and then the Federalist party would
- 3:19die out in the early 18 twenties.
- 3:22And for a short time, America became a one party system of just the Democratic
- 3:27Republicans.
- 3:27And that party, eventually, a divide emerged between the democratic republic Democratic
- 3:34Republicans allied with John Quincy Adams and Henry Clay, and those allied with or Andrew
- 3:41Jackson.
- 3:42So Andrew Jackson eventually become president, and Jacksonians would eventually become the
- 3:48dominant faction.
- 3:50US House Jacksonians took the majority in 18/26, and then they heavily expanded it in
- 3:5518/28.
- 3:56And in the US Senate, the Jacksonian majority well, they had a there was a Jacksonian
- 4:02majority from 18/22 to 18/34, except for 18/32.
- 4:06So for a brief period, Jacksonians were not the majority in the US senate.
- 4:13Now, eventually, there comes a point where those who were against Jack Andrew Jackson
- 4:20decided, look.
- 4:21I just make another party because we hate Andrew Jackson that much.
- 4:24So in the late 18 thirties, the Whig Party forms, and Jacksonian Democrats simply become
- 4:31Democrats.
- 4:31Now the Whig Party is just a is a very disparate group of interests all over the
- 4:38country.
- 4:38They were united simply in their hate for Andrew Jackson.
- 4:44Now say for a few instances, it was mostly Democrats taking or holding majorities in
- 4:49either chamber of congress.
- 4:50In a in fact, in 18/40, that was the only time Whigs took majorities in both chambers at the
- 4:56same time in elect in an election.
- 4:59So that leads us to this era of the very beginning of the Democrats versus Republicans
- 5:05and eventually leading into the civil war and the Reconstruction era.
- 5:09The slavery issue rips apart the Whigs who cease to exist in the early 18 fifties, but
- 5:16Republicans come in fairly quickly to fill in the vacuum.
- 5:20So in short, in this time period from 1856 to 18 77, Republicans dominate both chambers of
- 5:29congress, and partly because the democratic base in the south, the southern states secede.
- 5:35Democrats only win a majority in the US house in 1856 and 1874, and in the US senate from in
- 5:431856 and 1858.
- 5:45So the Republican party is founded at 1854 in Ripon, Wisconsin, and they start competing for
- 5:51congress and become a very viable contender.
- 5:56Originally, they were formed to combat slavery and its expansion.
- 6:00They would take the majority in in the US house in 1858, and in US senate, they would take it
- 6:05in 18 60, the year before the civil war.
- 6:11Even though the southern states would secede and then obviously get readmitted into the
- 6:17union, there were still Democrats in the US Congress, just significantly fewer of them
- 6:22since the base was in the South.
- 6:25The civil war ends at 18/65, and the Reconstruction era begins, and that's
- 6:30predominantly led by Republican policies.
- 6:33And this Reconstruction era ends with the compromise of 1877 where Republican Rutherford
- 6:41b Hayes is elected president, but the Republican Party agrees to end Reconstruction.
- 6:46And by this time, Democrats are already gaining steam in congress again.
- 6:50So in the US house, they gained the majority in the 18/74 election going from 88 members in
- 6:57post 18/72 election to a 182 members post 18 74 election and then gained the majority with 42
- 7:07seats in the 18/78 election.
- 7:11So it went from 19 to 28 to 35 to 42 seats in those successive elections from 18 72 to 18 78.
- 7:23And then that leads us into the gilded age, and the gilded age refers to the post
- 7:29Reconstruction era through the rest of 19th century.
- 7:33Yielded because on the surface, everything looks super pretty and and and nice and all
- 7:39gold and everything's all peachy.
- 7:41But below the surface, even though the economy is booming, below the surface, there's a lot,
- 7:47and I mean, a lot of corporate and political corruption.
- 7:50You had a lot of wealth inequality as well.
- 7:54And here is just a it was really a tale of 2 chambers from the oh, cut it off at the 18/76
- 8:02to 18/92 elections.
- 8:04So the US house in this time period is dominated by Democrats.
- 8:10They won or kept control in 7 out of 9 elections.
- 8:14The exceptions being 18/80/18/88.
- 8:19In 18/90, they even went as high as 238 Democrats compared to 86 Republicans and then 8
- 8:27that were third party or independent representatives.
- 8:32And in 18/92, they went down a bit, but they still had 218 Democrats, 124 Republicans, and
- 8:3914 third party slash independent representatives.
- 8:44Now on the other side, however, the US senate was dominated by Republicans.
- 8:49They won or kept control in 7 out of 9 elections, the exceptions being the 1878 and
- 8:561892 elections.
- 8:59Though they had a couple instances of tight control where Democrats almost took the
- 9:03majority back from them.
- 9:07That leads us into the turn of the century and the progressive era and the roaring twenties.
- 9:12So the 18 nineties to 1929 right before the great depression.
- 9:17The 18 94 election is what some scholars and historians and so on.
- 9:22It's all a realignment, and a realignment election is an election where we see long term
- 9:28durable changes in what demographics tend to side with which party.
- 9:32Now whether it's a realignment or not, it ushers in an era of Republican supremacy.
- 9:40They would, in the 18/94 election, gain 4 seats in the US senate and a 130 seats in the US
- 9:49house from what they had 2 years prior.
- 9:55And you had all these progressive era reforms to voting, business, and so on in response to
- 10:01the rapid or rampant, excuse me, corporate and political corruption of that day and of the
- 10:08preceding gilded age.
- 10:10And so Republicans become the dominant force of congress to start off the progressive era.
- 10:16They were the majority party from 18 95 to 1911 in the US house and in the US senate from 18 95
- 10:23to 19 13.
- 10:24So almost complete overlap in the 2 chambers.
- 10:28And then the largest majority they had at the time was 254 of the 357 seats in the US house
- 10:36or 71.1% of the seats, in the 18/94 election.
- 10:42And in the 19 06 election, they ended up with 61 of 92 seats of the US senate.
- 10:50But then you saw towards the end of the progressive era, partisan control decidedly
- 10:55shifted to the Democrats.
- 10:56So in the 19 tens, US house majority belong to Democrats for 1911 to 1919, including 291 of
- 11:06the 435 seats or 66.9% following the 1912 election, and they had a US senate majority
- 11:15from 19 13 to 1919, including 56 of 96 seats following the 1914 election, 58.3 percent of
- 11:24the US Senate.
- 11:27Though that shift was also short lived, and Republicans would take back majorities in both
- 11:32chambers following the 1918 election.
- 11:35And then that's when we get into the roaring twenties, which saw a huge economic boom for
- 11:41the country and voters rewarded Republicans for it.
- 11:45Now whether you believe Republicans were responsible for for it or not, that's not the
- 11:50point.
- 11:51But for voters, they reported Republicans for it.
- 11:54And in the 1920 election, Republicans had 302 of the 435 seats or 69.4 percent in the US
- 12:02house, and then they had 59 of the 96 seats, 61 a half percent in the US senate.
- 12:09So things were rolling along fine and dandy until the Great Depression hits in 1929, and it
- 12:19impacts the whole world.
- 12:20And voters' fury was felt immediately.
- 12:23In the 1930 election, Democrats make huge gains in congress.
- 12:27And then 1932, they'd also elect Franklin Roosevelt for president and democrats.
- 12:34Now in the 1930 election, republicans had initially kept their majority in the US house
- 12:40and still lost about 50 or so seats, but 14 representatives elect died between election day
- 12:50and the inauguration day of congress, so they had to have special elections for those seats,
- 12:56and that actually led to democrats taking the majority of the US house in 1930.
- 13:01And, also, in 1930, democrats gained 8 seats in the US senate.
- 13:07And then in the 19 32 election, democrats really cemented their supremacy by gaining
- 13:13another 12 seats in the US senate.
- 13:15So they went from 47 to 59, and then they gained another 97 seats in the US house.
- 13:22So Democrats throughout the Great Depression and for post Great Depression, but during World
- 13:33War 2, they are mostly dominant.
- 13:36They have they had as many as 334 of the 435 seats or 76.8% following the 1936 election.
- 13:46And in the US senate, they had as many as 76 of 96 seats or 79.2% following the 1936 election.
- 13:55Now Republicans finally broke through a couple times post World War 2, though it was very
- 14:00short lived success in congress.
- 14:02They won the majority in the US house and the US senate in 1946 and 1952, but would lose it
- 14:10the next election for in each in each of those cases, while Republican Dwight Eisenhower was
- 14:18still quite popular at the end of his tenure in office, democrats would expand their majorities
- 14:25in that time.
- 14:25So from the 1956 to 1958 elections, they went from 232 to 282 seats in the US house and then
- 14:3449 to 65 seats in the US senate.
- 14:39And then after that period, you see a the beginning of what some political scientists
- 14:46called a great sorting out in the 19 sixties.
- 14:49So the seeds of partisan change are sown in large part due to the civil rights movement,
- 14:55but it is a slow burn that's called the great sorting out that some people say is still going
- 15:01on today.
- 15:02But, basically, people start moving toward their true party affiliation.
- 15:07At the time, the parties weren't considerably different on their self identified ideology.
- 15:13There were many conservatives conservatives still in the Democratic party and many liberals
- 15:18liberals, excuse me, still in the Republican party.
- 15:23Now there were several major impetuses for this big sort catalyst, like we said, to a moment
- 15:29ago, the civil rights era's reforms.
- 15:31Southern Democrats start to lose influence in their party.
- 15:35You saw the abolition of poll taxes through the 24th amendment, and and that that that that
- 15:42amendment's ratification in 1964, poll taxes being a way to try to prevent black voters from
- 15:50from voting.
- 15:51They would have to pay a fee to be able to use the polls or to be able to go out to vote, and
- 15:58a lot of them were too poor to pay those.
- 16:01And in the case of poorly whites, they found a way to get around.
- 16:05They found several southern states found several ways to try to get around that by
- 16:09giving them grandfather clauses where, you know, if if their grandfather had the right to
- 16:14vote, they didn't have to pay poll taxes.
- 16:16They found all these sorts of nefarious ways to try to keep black voters from being able to
- 16:22vote, poll taxes being one of them.
- 16:24And then you also had desegregation and integration in the 19th starting in the 19
- 16:27sixties, and the Voting Rights Act of 19 sixties and the Voting Rights Act of 1965.
- 16:33So southern Democrats really started to lose their power in that regard.
- 16:39And then you also had Barry Goldwater's 1964 presidential campaign.
- 16:44And he really put his identification as a conservative at the forefront of his campaign,
- 16:50and you started to see in public opinion polling, people started to think a lot more
- 16:57about what their political ideology is.
- 17:00It was it was something that didn't have a whole lot of salience for a lot of voters at
- 17:04the time, but it started to gain salience over time.
- 17:08Now Goldwater lost by a landslide against Lyndon b Johnson, but he would continue to have
- 17:16an impact on the conservative movement afterwards, such as with the religious right
- 17:21later on becoming a major player in politics and then Republican Ronald Reagan when he
- 17:27became president.
- 17:29He was also influenced by Barry Goldwater as well.
- 17:33Looking at congress' partisan divide, though, you wouldn't necessarily see this change.
- 17:38They were still quite dominant for the sixties seventies even when Republican Richard Nixon
- 17:45became president, and he was fairly popular at the beginning before for the Watergate scandal.
- 17:51But Republicans would finally end the Democrats' majority streak they had in the US
- 17:56Senate from 1955 to 1981.
- 18:00In the 1980 election, they would gain 12 seats in that chamber.
- 18:05They had 41 seats following the 1978 election and then went up to 53 following the 1980
- 18:11election.
- 18:12They would lose the majority in the US Senate again in the 1986 election.
- 18:17So Ronald Reagan and Republicans, they had the US Senate for the first three, or before his
- 18:25whole first term and then for the first part of his second term, but then his last 2 years in
- 18:31office, they the Republican party would lose the US senate.
- 18:34And that during that whole time, the US house was still democratic.
- 18:39In fact, democrats had a US house majority for 40 years from 1955 to 1995 until the 1994
- 18:51election, which was another watershed for the Republican Party as they rested partisan
- 18:56control for both chambers of congress.
- 18:59They would gain 9 seats in the US senate, 54 seats in the US house from what they had in the
- 19:061982 election, and this was the first time they had won control of both chambers since the 1952
- 19:12election.
- 19:14Then you saw the growth in the south for the Republican party finally coming to fruition.
- 19:19According to the CQ Almanac, the Democrats only won one US senate race, and they also in in
- 19:26that region, in the southern region, and lost 21 US house seats in that region.
- 19:32So a lot of big gains for the Republican Party in that era, and that's where you really saw
- 19:39this era of closely divided politics that we see today.
- 19:42That's what a lot of people would argue was the beginning of this era, was that 1994 election,
- 19:50where since then, majorities haven't usually been huge, and there's usually a fair chance
- 19:56for 1 or both chambers of congress to flip majority control.
- 19:59Not necessarily that they often do, but that there is a reasonable chance for it.
- 20:05Now the biggest exception here is the 2008 election when Barack Obama won his 1st
- 20:10presidential election.
- 20:12US house, there was as many as 257 Democrats compared to a 178 Republicans.
- 20:18So 59.1% of the seats in the US house were democratic.
- 20:23And in the US senate, 57 Democrats to 41 Republicans, including 2 independence backed
- 20:28caucus with Democrats.
- 20:31And so for the most part, there has been a fair amount of competition.
- 20:36But from 1984 to 2024, they the Republicans have won or kept the majority in 12 of the last
- 20:4516 congressional elections, so that's including 2024.
- 20:49Their biggest majority being 247 Republicans to a 188 Democrats following the 2014 election.
- 20:57And for the US Senate, they kept the major Republicans kept the majority or won it in 11
- 21:03of the last 16th congressional elections.
- 21:05Their biggest majority being having 55 Republicans on several occasions in the years,
- 21:11that Clinton or Bush were president.
- 21:15So looking at the overall results for Democrats for versus Republicans, again, keep in mind the
- 21:24caveats from the beginning of the episode.
- 21:27I'm not counting changes in seats from within a congress unless I say otherwise.
- 21:31Just to change from post election day 1 year to post election day 2 years later.
- 21:36So if you look at other analyses, the number of seats that they say change might sound might be
- 21:42a slight bit different than the ones I give because there might be also counting seats that
- 21:47changed due to a special election.
- 21:51So the 35th congress, which was 18 57 to 18 59, was the first time that Republicans were the
- 21:59main opposition to Democrats.
- 22:01So counting the 2024 elections, we've had 84 regularly scheduled federal elections for
- 22:10congress featuring Democrats versus republicans.
- 22:12This upcoming congress of the is the 119th congress.
- 22:18So looking at US house majorities, democrats have won or kept the majority 47 times, and
- 22:27this is mostly due to that streak from 1954 to 1994 where they won the majority or kept it 20
- 22:35straight times.
- 22:37Next longest streak, though, was the 8 straight elections they won from 1930 to 1944, which was
- 22:44mostly the time that FDR was president, FDR being a very popular president of at the time.
- 22:52Democrats for congress enjoyed basically the association of the party name with, that the
- 23:01party name's association with FDR, and that helped out a lot of those Democrats in
- 23:07congress.
- 23:08Remember, though, for for that 1930 election, 14 representatives elect had died before
- 23:14inauguration, and then Democrats wants enough special elections to take that majority.
- 23:21Republicans have won or kept the majority 37 times compared to democrats 47 times, and that
- 23:28includes 2024.
- 23:30Initially, the party or initially, when it started to become democrats versus republicans,
- 23:37it was actually initially republicans that won the chamber more frequently.
- 23:43Their longest streak, they had 8 straight elections from 1858 to 1872 that they won or
- 23:50kept the US house majority, but that was partly due to the secession of southern states during
- 23:56the civil war and then the process of readmitting them post war.
- 24:00And then also 8 straight elections from 1894 to 19 0 8 with the turn of the century, and
- 24:08William McKinley and and Teddy Roosevelt, being president for most of that time.
- 24:14And majority control has changed 19 times in the US house between Democrats and Republicans.
- 24:21So that most frequently happened in the late 19 forties and early 19 fifties where the majority
- 24:27change in the US house 4 out of 5 elections in that period.
- 24:33Though changes in control were also pretty frequent in the 18 eighties and early 18
- 24:38nineties when control changed in 5 out of 8 of those elections.
- 24:45Now looking at US senate majorities, it's basically the opposite story.
- 24:50Whereas for the US house, Democrats have usually won or kept the majority.
- 24:55For the US senate, it's actually been Republicans who have mostly won or kept the
- 25:00majority.
- 25:01So in this case, Democrats have won the majority 38 times in the US senate.
- 25:07Longest streak there being 13 elections from 1954 to 1978, and they also won and kept the
- 25:15majority in 7 straight elections from 1932 to 1944, again, largely helped by FDR's
- 25:22popularity.
- 25:24Meanwhile, Republicans have won the majority 46 times in the US senate, and they were
- 25:29particularly successful successful from 18 60 to 1910 when they won or kept the majority in
- 25:3724 out of those 26 elections, and the exceptions at that time frame being 1878, 1892.
- 25:45So like with the US house, majority control has changed 19 times.
- 25:51And, also, like the US house, the US senate control changed in 4 out of the 5 elections
- 25:57from 1946 to 1954.
- 25:59And then in these last two elections we've had, 2022 and 2024, majority control for the US
- 26:06senate has changed in those years as well.
- 26:10Now looking at the upcoming congress and how it compares to the past, in the US house,
- 26:17Republicans kept control, but they had fewer wins this year than they had in 2022.
- 26:23They won or kept 222 seats in 2022, but in 2024, it was only it's only 220.
- 26:33And then you've also got 2 current or soon to be resignations due to nominations by Donald
- 26:39Trump.
- 26:40Now Donald Trump return soon to be returning to the presidency.
- 26:44The Republicans still have the majority.
- 26:47Matt Gaetz resigned when he was nominated nominated to be attorney general, but withdrew
- 26:53his name.
- 26:54So he's he had already resigned at that point.
- 26:56And then Mike Waltz, both of these guys being Florida US House reps.
- 27:02Mike Waltz is still in office as of this recording, but he will resign soon because he
- 27:07was named national security adviser.
- 27:10And for the US House, this this upcoming congress, it's one of the closest divides we've
- 27:15ever had in this chamber.
- 27:17And 2024 seems to have carried on the trend of the previous two presidential elections where
- 27:23the winning presidential candidate's party actually lost seats.
- 27:26So when Trump won in 2016, Republicans lost 6 US house seats.
- 27:32And when Biden won in 2020, Democrats lost 13 seats.
- 27:37And now Trump looks to have lost a couple of seats this year as well.
- 27:44Now for the US senate, Republicans took a majority with 53 seats, and they flipped 3
- 27:50democratic seats and 1 democrat turned independent seat, somewhat of a chance to flip
- 27:57control again in 2026, though it's too early to tell how much of of a chance there is.
- 28:02But this is the 2nd presidential election in a row where the winning presidential candidate's
- 28:07party gained seats in 2020.
- 28:11Biden's Democrats gained 3 seats.
- 28:13And then in 2024, Trump's Republicans have gained 4 seats in the US Senate.
- 28:20But you gotta keep in mind, though, that for the US Senate, only a third of the seats are up
- 28:25for election.
- 28:26So some seats may be more given to a democratic lean or some or some might be more given to a
- 28:32republican lean.
- 28:33So that also affects the the numbers there.
- 28:37Whereas for the US house, all the seats are up every 2 years.
- 28:43So that is going to do it for today's episode of the podcast.
- 28:47As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 28:50Let's get to the random question of the day.
- 28:52And today's random question is, do you wish you could play every instrument in the world or
- 28:59speak every language in the world?
- 29:01Now I used to be very much in the latter camp speaking every language in the world because I
- 29:06thought felt that had much more utility.
- 29:08And, also, several there are several languages that just seem like so much fun to speak, and I
- 29:14wish I could speak them fluently.
- 29:16But started to get more and more into the you know, I really wish I could jam on a on a
- 29:22guitar and be able to drum at the same time.
- 29:26Well, I mean, not at the same time.
- 29:27Can't do that, but be able to do all those.
- 29:31Definitely not sing though because singing is one of my, one of the worst skills I have, if
- 29:38if that makes sense.
- 29:39It's it's not a it's one of the things I'm absolutely the worst at.
- 29:44I definitely cannot sing.
- 29:45Doesn't stop me from from from trying to sing just because it's it's fun to do, but I
- 29:49definitely don't think I'm I'm any good.
- 29:53I would if this was early days of American Idol, I would be plastered as one of those get
- 29:57a lot of this guy who thinks he can sing and, of course, then I could be, like, one of those.
- 30:03Oh, it's been my dream to be on American Idol.
- 30:05I love American Idol.
- 30:06It's my favorite show.
- 30:07And then when I get rejected, I say, man, f American Idol and and just curse them out and
- 30:12act like I never said that I like the show.
- 30:15You know, that that that that was funny at the beginning when I was younger, but, you know,
- 30:19looking back on that, some of that was just kinda mean spirited to highlight those people,
- 30:25but still kinda funny to look back on.
- 30:27But, anyways, thank you so much for listening to the podcast as as always.
- 30:33Links in the show notes for Facebook, LinkedIn, my matchmaker FM, profile if you wanna be on my
- 30:42podcast or if you want me on yours.
- 30:45Email at Paul Raider Writes atgmail.com, and, my writing's on Beam.com.
- 30:52So I will talk to you next time, and until then, take care.