Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Could The Buckeyes Land Their Best Defensive Line Class Ever?
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdeman
- 0:05here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going, Tony. I've
- 0:11spent the last several days baking in the sun and eating fair food at the
- 0:16big Fourth of July community fair, so I am feeling fantastic and the absolute
- 0:21healthiest I do all year long after I've got several days worth of fried food
- 0:26and sun poisoning. So yeah, it's I'm doing great, Tony. More
- 0:30importantly, how are you doing all right? Doing all right? What is
- 0:34your favorite fair food? I am? I'm usually good for, you know,
- 0:39some kind of a fried oreo or fried something like that. I have
- 0:44been spoiled with funnel cakes. I work with a guy who runs a funnel
- 0:47cakestand or ran a funnel cake stand, and like will make funnel cakes occasionally
- 0:51for work functions. So I don't usually bother getting funnel cakes at fair foods,
- 0:55but at like a fair because I have access to those during non fair
- 0:58times. But very very that's that's always a good one. You don't ever
- 1:03feel great after a funnel cake or if an elephant here, but you feel
- 1:07really good while you're eating them. And then afterwards kind of like, oh
- 1:10boy, um, I need seven glasses of water. What is you do?
- 1:12You have a favorite growing up? It was the elephant here and it
- 1:19was and I obviously I haven't had one in over thirty years, so I
- 1:23don't know if they've maintained their quality. Back back at the Henry County Fair
- 1:27utmost quality. Also back when I was a kid, they seemed pretty gigantic.
- 1:33I'm guessing now they're probably about the size of a street taco tortilla and
- 1:38it would be very underwhelming. But I was always always an elephant here person.
- 1:44You mentioned the deep fried oreo, and I remember where I was the
- 1:47first time I ever had a deep fried oreo, and it was not at
- 1:49a fair. It was at the media party for the twenty sixteen game against
- 1:57Clemson, and so you know, there's always the past bowl game we went
- 2:01to was a very disappointing spread of food, but the one in Arizona that
- 2:07year was spectacular, And so I had deep fried oreo for the first time,
- 2:10and it was one of those things that affected me so much. I
- 2:15just wanted to tell everybody about it, like, and yes, I had
- 2:19been drinking, but you're like everywhere. You know, you're you're at the
- 2:23table, and I'm just going and getting people these deep fridoris, Like have
- 2:27you have you heard about deep fried oreos? Let me, let me spread
- 2:30the word about deep fried oreos. And they were spectacular, and I have
- 2:35not I don't know that I've had any sense just because they were so good.
- 2:38But they're not really. I don't think they're they're good for you time.
- 2:44I don't think they are. I like the idea of you being this
- 2:46evangelist, like the Great Commission for trans Fats. I like that a lot
- 2:50with you were just running around. Can I tell you some good news about
- 2:53fried oreos? Yeah? I I'm usually good for like one of those,
- 2:58and it's like I'm gonna have one and it's to be tasty and that's it,
- 3:00and I'm still going to feel kind of crappy after that. But if
- 3:02I eat like three, you just you get this like exponential curve of how
- 3:08bad you feel after you eat each individual one after that. So yeah,
- 3:14I have I have learned to learn my limits and just just one and don't
- 3:19don't fall into the just one more trap with the deep freight oreos. Just
- 3:23just have one and then we'll see you next year at the fair. And
- 3:28I know people are wondering, how does this topic get into what we're going
- 3:31to talk about, But as you're mentioning it, I think it flows perfectly
- 3:36into following recruiting because it can make you feel really, really good at the
- 3:40time, but then also after you've consumed some following of recruiting, it can
- 3:45make you think, I don't I don't feel so great. And that has
- 3:50kind of been the situation at Ohio State following the defensive line recruiting over the
- 3:53past week. You you get the high of landing ed accused but rather um
- 4:00Justin Scott the defensive tackle on Sunday and like, oh, this is fantastic,
- 4:06and your consume, consume, consume, and then you're ready for more
- 4:10on Monday. But Marquis's life when the defensive end chooses Miami, like I
- 4:15just I don't feel so good, and that that's that is following recruiting.
- 4:19It's that's the highs and it's the lows and then after while like I'm ready
- 4:26for another deep fried Oreo. Deep fried orias are also where interior defensive linemen
- 4:31come from. That is how defense. Interior defensive linemen are built, So
- 4:35how do you get a high school kid to weigh three hundred and ten pounds?
- 4:39Deep fried Oreo's friends, there's a reason that a lot of the interior
- 4:43defensive linemen come from the Deep South and or what I call the Sweet Tea
- 4:46Belt. A lot of the same principles at work there. So, yeah,
- 4:49this is this was a kind of too surprising outcomes for Ohio State.
- 4:55I think Justin Scott was one of the more out of nowhere commitments for Ohio
- 4:59State. Not that I mean, we did a show with Mark Giveler last
- 5:01week talking about, you know, potential, here are some guys who could
- 5:04be committing, and Justin Scott was, you know, he was on the
- 5:08list of guys how many five stars is O High State going to get?
- 5:11And he was on the list, but he wasn't necessarily O High State was
- 5:13a favorite. Necessarily, it didn't seem like anything was imminent. And then
- 5:16all of a sudden boom on what Sunday, It was all of a sudden,
- 5:19No, hey, they got Justin Scott, Like what when? Where?
- 5:23Oo? So that was that was a very big surprise. And then
- 5:27Marcus Lightfoot Ohio State, the industry consensus and everything everyone that we had been
- 5:31around had been hearing, and everyone around college football had seemably be hearing was
- 5:35a Marquis Lightfoot was all Ohio State. And then just the last day or
- 5:40so before his commitment, you started hearing rumblings that Miami was maybe making an
- 5:45nil play and maybe you know, and then all of a sudden boom,
- 5:48he is one of the more surprising, sort of out of nowhere, last
- 5:54twenty four hour flips that you've seen in a while. So, I mean,
- 6:00it's a It is recruiting and good news, Tony. They still don't
- 6:02put pen to paper until December, so there is still plenty more time for
- 6:06everyone to change their minds. Again, do you think, tom, let
- 6:10me ask you this, Losing Marquis light Foot to Miami, losing Mark Fletcher,
- 6:15the running back the year before to Miami, does this make things even
- 6:20between Ohio State and Miami for Ohio State destroying the Hurricanes football program over twenty
- 6:27years ago? Now are things now as this evened things up? It's not
- 6:31even until What's his Name makes a documentary for the thirty for thirty series about
- 6:35Miami's two incredible recruiting triumphs over Ohio State. Um, it's Billy Corgan Corbyn,
- 6:43Billy Corby, yes, yea, until Billy Corbyn makes you know cocaine
- 6:48Cowboys three. This time it's a defensive lineman. Uh yeah. I think
- 6:55this is one of these things where I mean, you have long held a
- 6:57position that you know, a player leaving and going to play for Miami is
- 7:01fine because you will never hear from them again. And you know, I
- 7:05think I'm sure any Miami person right now hearing that will say, ah,
- 7:09that is sour grapes. And then someone on our board talked about, you
- 7:13know who, you know, who's the biggest loss at Ohio States. You
- 7:15know, boys, Ohio State lost Sean Charles Henderson to to Miami and that's
- 7:19the biggest loss they've had to Miami and recruiting and you go and look at
- 7:21my Sean Charle Henderson's recruiting or his career at Miami and it was like two
- 7:27hundred and seventy eighth overall pick and suspensions and you know, miss missed time
- 7:33and all sorts of stuff. And it's just over the last twenty years,
- 7:38if a guy goes to Miami, it's like falling into the Springfield mystery spot,
- 7:41you know, you're just like, oh, well, he went,
- 7:44he went to Miami. What happened to him? I don't know. Once
- 7:46once they go in the tent, you don't never see them again. And
- 7:48you know, I mean every once in a while you'll turn on a Pinstripe
- 7:50Bowl or something and it's like, oh, yeah, that guy. But
- 7:55you don't you know that if you if you were to flip these and Justin
- 7:59Scott had announced for one of his other finalists, Notre Dame or Michigan,
- 8:03and Markis Lightfoot had chosen Ohio State, that's probably worse for Ohio State because
- 8:07if if Justin Scott plays at Michigan, you're going to see Justin Scott every
- 8:11year. If Marquis Lightfoot goes to Miami, You're never going to see Murky's
- 8:16Lightfoot again, unless Ohio State ends up in a Pinstripe Bowl or something dramatically
- 8:20changes about the course of Miami football history, which has that change has been
- 8:26just right around the corner for the last twenty years. But maybe some change
- 8:31coming with Miami applying for admission into the AAU and if they can get that
- 8:37done within the next three to five years, perhaps Marquis Lightfoot will be in
- 8:41the Big Ten and perhaps be on Ohio State schedule. But yeah, Miami
- 8:48is and I should have verified this, but I did see somebody on the
- 8:52board mentioned that one of the interviews Lightfoot gave about why he chose Miami is
- 8:58because after all of the work and after the practices, it's a relaxing place
- 9:03to be. And how many times so you heard Marvin Harrison talking about how
- 9:11relaxing it is in Columbus constantly just I mean, he won't stop. He's
- 9:15like I heard him talking about the Hammock District down in the Short North.
- 9:18I mean, it's just it's just constant. Just put your feet up.
- 9:22Ohio State football, put your feet up and relax. That's why Tony Ohio
- 9:26State has not been to as many pinstripe balls as Miami. And I want
- 9:30to be super super clear, Markie's Lightfoot is a hell of a football.
- 9:33Markie's lightfoot is a fantastic pass rusher, incredibly well rounded player. It's just
- 9:39when you go to Miami, you generally see your talents wasted. And that's
- 9:41just sort of been the track record for the last twenty years and you know,
- 9:46change is always right around the corner, and oh, uncle Luke is
- 9:48gonna get Uncle Luke is going to fix this up. And then there they
- 9:52are seven and five again, and so you know it's just it's a little
- 9:56bit of all that's that's too bad. That was a poor choice. Like
- 10:00you would rather see someone like that from a from his personal interest standpoint.
- 10:05You would rather see someone like that go to in Alabama or a Georgia or
- 10:07somewhere where you're actually going to play and get developed and not just have a
- 10:11relaxing time and then get to go to May you know, maybe you get
- 10:16to dump Mao on your coach after a Bowl games. That is something that
- 10:18you cannot offer. They can Ohio State promise you that. No, no,
- 10:22they cannot. And if it sounds like we're bagging on Miami, believe
- 10:26me. Later in the show, we're going to talk about the lack of
- 10:28development of Ohio State defensive linemen. That might sound like we're bagging on Ohio
- 10:33State because there's some significant names there that maybe we're I don't want to say
- 10:39insignificant, but anyway, so the Marquis Lightfoot thing took some wind out of
- 10:46the sales for what was shaping up and what is still possibly shaping up to
- 10:54to possibly be the best defensive line hall in Ohio State history if things were
- 10:58to main as they are. And we've probably said the exact same thing about
- 11:03the Ohio State defensive line class last year, let's just go ahead and get
- 11:05that out of the way, with all of the guys that Ohio State was
- 11:09leading for that maybe that didn't end up choosing last state. In fact,
- 11:13I don't know that any of them ended up choosing Ohio State at this point
- 11:16in the year. But so you've got already Justin Scott they are now they
- 11:22are the considerable favorites for Edric Houston, who is the the the number four
- 11:28defensive lineman actually the number number four defensive linement and the class actually number six
- 11:35overall twenty four seven. Their composite combines edges and tackles, and so just
- 11:41in terms of defensive linemen overall, he's the number six. Dylan Stewart out
- 11:45of Washington, DC is the number four overall defensive lineman, the number two
- 11:50edge in the class. And after Justin Scott committed, then you had cut
- 11:54crystal balls coming in for Dylan Stewart, and so then there's all of this
- 11:58excitement. You could at the four or the five and the sixth ranked defensive
- 12:03linemen in the class. Marquis Lightfoot is like fifteenth overall in terms of this
- 12:11list of defensive linemen. So it will be a heck of a four man
- 12:15class. And you throw in somebody later on down the line, maybe like
- 12:18a Jaden Jackson from IMG, and it's shaping up to be a really incredible
- 12:22class. And then Lightfoot commits to Miami and it's like, oh gosh,
- 12:26now where are they going to get the numbers? And and one of the
- 12:31reasons why I say it's following away, and I've said this for years.
- 12:33Following my high State recruiting is a lot like eating a bunch of deep fried
- 12:37oreos. You could end up with Justin Scott, Edric Houston, and Dylan
- 12:43Stewart and there'll still be people going, oh, I wish, but I
- 12:48really wish I would have had Marquis Lightfoot as well. And you know,
- 12:52you just get you want more, you want more, you want more,
- 12:54and it's like, well, can't you just be happy if if if it's
- 12:56just those three five star players, would that be Okay, Well, Ohio
- 13:01State right now is they have more five start commits for twenty twenty four than
- 13:05any other program. They have four. Georgia and Alabama both have three.
- 13:09I think there might be one more team with three. Ohio State number one
- 13:13overall right now in terms of average player ranking in the class, their number
- 13:16two in the class overall, with I think five fewer commits than Georgia,
- 13:20the ranked ahead of Michigan, even though Michigan has eight eight more players committed
- 13:26right now. I mean this is they're the number two program in the nation
- 13:30right now in the two four seven composite team rankings and they only have I
- 13:33think eighteen players committed something like that. So it is, it's there's a
- 13:39long, long, long way to go. This is going to be assuming
- 13:43assuming there are not massive defections from this class or you don't have a ton
- 13:48of players just plummeting down the rankings for some reason this fall. This is
- 13:50going to be one of, if not the best classes in Ohio State history.
- 13:54This is going to be one of, if not the best defensive line
- 13:56classes in Ohio State history. And you're kind of seeing people already kind of
- 14:01going, well, what what happened. I thought this was supposed to be
- 14:03this incredible July. It's like, well, they've already gotten one five star,
- 14:07and they have another commitment potentially coming on Thursday, and then they have
- 14:09another potentially commitment coming on the third, twenty third, and another potential commitment
- 14:13coming on the thirtieth, and another potential commitment coming on the August fifth,
- 14:16then then another potential commitment coming on August twenty second, And like, all
- 14:20of these guys are Top one hundred caliber players, so most of them are
- 14:24top fifty players, a few of them are five stars. I mean there's
- 14:28just and you know, the hay is not in the barn yet on any
- 14:31of this. They have not Not only are these guys are not signed,
- 14:33some of them, you know, all these guys that we're talking about now
- 14:35are not even verbally committed, but they are right now in a spot where
- 14:39they have a fantastic foundation for this class, a fantastic foundation for this class,
- 14:43and you have a bunch more guys where even if they don't get all
- 14:46of them, and they just get some to most of them, this is
- 14:50going to be one of, if not the best classes in all high state
- 14:52history. So you know they have. It feels like they have solved many
- 14:58of the NIL related issues they have had in the past and they have found
- 15:01ways to overcome it. And the NIL world continues to change, and well,
- 15:05you know, there will probably be more n all losses at some time
- 15:09in the future. But there were people who couldn't wait to tell you that,
- 15:11you know, Ohio State football was basically dead because they weren't going to
- 15:13ever finish figure this out. It was going to be terrible. And you
- 15:16know, Pet's heads falling on off on all that kind of stuff. And
- 15:20then here they are in their number two in the class, despite having what
- 15:22seventeen or eighteen commits and a bunch more potentially on the way very soon.
- 15:26Like it feels like Pet's heads are probably just fine right now. Maybe later
- 15:31on this summer we can do a show, is is this the best Ohio
- 15:37State running back class of all time? You know, and look back at
- 15:39the running back class history, because it's rare for them to bring in three
- 15:43guys like they're shaping up to do this year. But tom, if they
- 15:48do get those three, if they do end up with Justin Scott, Dylan
- 15:52Stewart and Edric Houston, and we would assume at least one more similar down
- 15:58down the line. Where could this rank among Ohio State's defensive class history?
- 16:06And and what is what is the top class in defense and top defensive line
- 16:12class in Ohio State in I don't want to say history, but we've got
- 16:19a list here. I've got a list all the way going back to nineteen
- 16:22ninety and I'm wondering where this class would rank among this list. And we
- 16:27don't have it ranked or anything, but there are as I put this list
- 16:33together, one of the things that stood out to me is that the defensive
- 16:37line picks up when urban Meyer arrives, and defensive line recruiting picks up when
- 16:44urban Meyer arrives. And not that it was stagnant before then, but the
- 16:51it was, it was kind of stagnant before then. You know, you
- 16:52got guys Doug Worthington and you know, like Lawrence Wilson, you get some
- 16:59of these guys out of state. But Urban Meyer arrived, and you get
- 17:02those guys out of state every single year, and you get multiple guys out
- 17:04of state. And so as you perused this list that I sent, you
- 17:10do you what is I guess, is there a top class, What do
- 17:14you think is the top lass? And we don't have any ranking systems or
- 17:17anything, but what sticks out to you? Yeah, I think you just
- 17:21looking through the list, and the list that you put together goes all the
- 17:22wack to nineteen ninety And the first thing that I thought was, Wow,
- 17:26there were a lot of misses on defensive line recruiting in the nineteen nineties and
- 17:30early two thousands. And the second thing that was what you brought up,
- 17:33which is, boy, the defensive line recruiting got us so much better when
- 17:37urban Meyer arrived, and then potentially even better than that when Larry Johnson arrived.
- 17:41These two things are probably not a coincidence. When you think about how
- 17:45Florida beat Ohio State in the two thousand and seven BCS National Championship Game.
- 17:51How did they do it well? They had Ohio States tackles basically looking like
- 17:55turnstiles for much of the night and beat it with pass Russian for a Smith
- 17:59had no ends to do anything. And so urban Meyer knows the value of
- 18:03a good pass rush. So then that became a much much bigger focus.
- 18:06And you know, even the guys who you're talking about being out of state
- 18:08guys before Urban got there. You know, Doug Worthington was from upstate in
- 18:15New York. Lawrence Wilson was from Michigan, I believe. And you know,
- 18:18now then all of a sudden, then you're getting the Bossas out of
- 18:21Florida, and you're getting h you know, JT. Or Chase Young out
- 18:26of out of Maryland, and you know, guys, guys out of all
- 18:30all over the country. Because you had that became a draw to come play
- 18:33for Urban Meyer, to come play for Larry Johnson. So you know,
- 18:37when you look through the classes, it's impossible to put the twenty twenty four
- 18:41class, which is still a theoretical class, and you know, we haven't
- 18:44seen any kind of college production there yet, so it's kind of hard to
- 18:48put them on that list, just going through in terms of classes where the
- 18:52full class was really contributors the whole time. I think twenty twenty one,
- 18:56JT. Twemlow, Jack Sawyer, Mike call Tyleik Williams, that one is
- 19:00going to be up there. There's still you know, they're still graded incomplete
- 19:03right now. We'll see how this year ends up. I think that one
- 19:07is ultimately going to be very high on the list. Twenty eighteen was just
- 19:11that was an incredibly deep class. It took seven guys, six of them
- 19:14ended up being at least contributors through on Vincent tyreech Smith, Tyler Friday,
- 19:18Tommy Togi, i Antoine Jackson, Jafronte, John Baptiste, Alex Williams ended
- 19:22up transferring to Vanderbilt and never never really played at Ohio State. Those are
- 19:26you know, those are really really good classes. But you know, when
- 19:33you probably twenty thirteen, Joey Bosa, Michael Hill, Billy Price, Taekwon
- 19:37Lewis, Donovanmonger, Tacy Sprinkle, I mean, Bosa and Taekwon Lewis were
- 19:41huge, huge players on some really really good Ohio State teams. And then
- 19:47so was Billy Price, but he just had to change change a different position.
- 19:51Noah Spence at Alphas Washington, Tommy Shutt, Savon Pittman, and Jamal
- 19:55Marcus in twenty twelve. You know, Spence, you know, was an
- 19:59incredible play and then had to leave Ohio State under some off field circumstances.
- 20:03But an alf of Washington was a really important player and some of those big
- 20:06Ohio State teams. It just there are just so many teams where you've got
- 20:11like one really you know, there's there's like the one guy who is this
- 20:15incredible impact player and some other guys who were contributors or good depth players.
- 20:19I still think when all is said and done, I still kind of think
- 20:23twenty twenty one is potentially going to be the best of all of those in
- 20:29terms of not just Nick Bosa was there, and you know, like Nick
- 20:33Bosa, Jonathan Cooper, Malique Barrow were a class and Cooper was obviously a
- 20:37long term captain, BLOCKO Jersey recipient, all that kind of stuff, you
- 20:42know, but they didn't have like three, four or five guys who were
- 20:45really long term contributors in that class. I still think twenty twenty one is
- 20:51potentially going to end up up there with pretty much anyone. That's where I
- 20:56am as well. I think you're going to see four NFL guys of the
- 21:03four that were in the class, and that's that's a fair hit rate.
- 21:07That's a pretty decent hit rate. It's probably the best among any of these
- 21:11classes. I think it probably should end up going with some sort of a
- 21:15scoring system, like the class gets a point for you know, every start,
- 21:21and then maybe like two points for every all Big ten person you know
- 21:23season, then the three points for every All American season, and then another
- 21:27four like an award or something, and then you see where it all shakes
- 21:30out and then you can have it. It's you know, definitive. But
- 21:33of course, the twenty eighteen class with toront Vincent, Tyree Smith, Tyler
- 21:37Friday, Time, Joe Gay, Antoine Jackson, Javant Day, John Baptiste
- 21:41like all four, all six, six of those guys started at least a
- 21:45few games they were around. But that class may be at the top of
- 21:51the list. Like if you're voting for Heisman and the same guy gets every
- 21:56fourth place vote, he ends up third place or second place. You know
- 21:59that sort of thing where it's it's it's maybe quantity more than quality that would
- 22:04get them up there. I feel bad for Malik Barrow, part of that
- 22:08twenty sixteen class with Nick Boss and Jonathan Cooper, because Barrow was obviously got
- 22:15injured, but he was the best player at IMG's team and he was incredible
- 22:18in high school and imagine what those three could have done. I do like
- 22:23the fact that twenty thirteen class with Joey Bose and Tyquan Lewis had a stretch
- 22:30of three years where that class produced a big ten defensive Lineman of the Year.
- 22:36And then I think that maybe the year or two after that also the
- 22:38Remington Trophy Award winner. So that's that's gonna be hard to beat. But
- 22:44of course Billy Price, he was impactful on the offensive side, Michael Hill
- 22:48was a starter for an entire year. Tracy Sprinkle was a starter. So
- 22:52you get basically five starters out of that class, even though one of them
- 22:55is on offense. Twenty twelve, Urban Meyer's first class probably the only Ohio
- 23:02state class in history with three fire star defensive lineman even though like Timmy Shott
- 23:06was a five star on Scout, which no longer exists, and I'm not
- 23:10sure that even their records exists anymore. I believe there's a fire and they
- 23:14were all just it was all paper, so they were never digitized. So
- 23:18that and then Timy Schett never produced like a five star guy. Some of
- 23:23these others, the Robert Rose and Thaddius Gibson class of two thousand and six,
- 23:32like what could have been Robert Rose from Glenville Army All America. Thatius
- 23:36Gibson ends up being pretty good. But those two to me, could have
- 23:40been by themselves, could have been something special, just a bunch of names
- 23:45that I'm with you though through through all of this. At twenty twenty one
- 23:51class as very much the potential, and it's already realizing some of that potential.
- 23:56Do you look at the two classes below them to twenty twenty and twenty
- 23:59nineteen, and there's only one player remaining from the twenty twenty class and only
- 24:04one from the twenty nineteen class. And when we talked about the low numbers
- 24:07that Ohio State has on a defensive line and the need to add more this
- 24:11year, you can look back to that twenty twenty class of Jacolby Cowen,
- 24:17Darry and Henry and Thie Hamilton and see like there's there's I mean, Ti
- 24:22Hamilton is a lone senior. I believe what Jade McKenzie, but there's there's
- 24:26not a senior laden situation up there, right. And that's I think sort
- 24:32of if you went and did like safety recruiting over the same period of time,
- 24:36you'd be looking at sort of a very similar situation where you took all
- 24:40these guys and then so many of them have washed out and at other programs
- 24:44you know, Darry and Henry Young is at Kentucky and Noah Potter from the
- 24:48twenty twenty nineteen class, I think he's at Cincinnati now, Kobe Cowen at
- 24:52UNC. And what's so interesting is these are kind of, I think vaguely
- 24:57in order of star ranking or you know, going down the class for class
- 25:03ranking. Tie Hamilton von Hamilton both at the very far right of their classes,
- 25:07meaning they were the lowest rated player in their classes. And boy,
- 25:12the Hamilton's out of Lovely Pickerington in Ohio shurt have turned out to be two
- 25:17really productive underrated players for Ohio State. I think maybe the market inefficiency is
- 25:22are there any more Hamilton brothers out there? Because they've both turned into really
- 25:26productive players for Ohio State in a way that guys ranked way ahead of them
- 25:30have not. And you know, Zach Harrison was at the top of that
- 25:33twenty nineteen CLASSI obviously had a very good career and is off to the NFL
- 25:37now. But now that's this is why we always talk about the importance of
- 25:41building depth, and you have to have a certain number of guys in these
- 25:45classes to keep the pipeline flowing, because they're not all going to pan out.
- 25:48You go through this list and even the classes, you know there are
- 25:52guys who were ranked very very highly who either injuries or just didn't pan out
- 25:56on the field or off field whatever. You're not going to have a one
- 26:00hundred percent hit rate. Even if you were Larry Johnson and you've been doing
- 26:03this for a long time and you know how to develop and you know how
- 26:06to identify talent, You're still not gonna have one hundred percent develop, one
- 26:08hundred percent hit rate on these guys. So that's why it's so important to
- 26:11keep stacking all these classes on top of each other. And why when you
- 26:15have a year when you had only one defensive end in the twenty twenty three
- 26:19class and Joshua Mickens, why that position is such a significant position for Ohio
- 26:23State this year and why we're gonna keep We're gonna be keeping talking about defensive
- 26:29and defensive line recruiting a bunch this year because that is going to be a
- 26:33position where they really really need to be strong in the twenty four class to
- 26:36make up the fact that they missed on a couple of their top targets in
- 26:38twenty three. I could point at the twenty seventeen class, Jase Young,
- 26:44Haskill, Garrett two All Americans, John Cage a six year guy, nineteen
- 26:49ninety three class, Mike Grabel and Matt Fagas not too bad looking at the
- 26:56best Jim Trussell class, I think it's probably two thousand and two with Quinn
- 27:02Pitcock and Mike Kudla. Joel pent was part of that, Tim Shaefer,
- 27:04Jay Richardson played years in the NFL. But you go through the rest of
- 27:11that, well, you know you Doug Worthington, Lawrence Wilson, Todd Denlinger,
- 27:15they all were starters. Dexter, Larry Moore in two thousand and six
- 27:19with Daddius Gibbson, they were starters. You got a big play out of
- 27:23Solomon Thomas and from the two thousand and seven class with Cameron Heyward. But
- 27:29as you look at this, is there a clear number one for the Jim
- 27:32Trestle recruiting because I might go with two thousand and two. Yeah, two
- 27:37thousand and two probably has the best depth of a quality depth of a gym
- 27:41Trestle class because they're just a lot of years with two and three guys under
- 27:45Trestle and sort of late Cooper era as well. And if you're bringing in
- 27:49two defensive linemen in a class, three defensive linemen in a class boy,
- 27:52you need your hit rate to be good because that is not a spot where
- 27:56guys typically walk on the field and just dominate from day one, so you're
- 27:59going to development time. So it is really important to have a good deep
- 28:03class. Just from that perspective. Yeah, I'm probably gonna go with two
- 28:07thousand and two just because he got five names. Tim Schaefer ended up moving
- 28:11to offensive line and never I don't think he ever ended up starting at Ohio
- 28:14State. But Richardson, Kudla, and Pitcock were all multi year contributors at
- 28:19Ohio State. Really good players at Ohio State. Joel Penton won was it
- 28:23the worful award I think at Ohio State. You know, so he was
- 28:27up and they took down the individual awards from the wall inside the practice is
- 28:30a little bit. Joel Penton's face was up a smart you know, Joel
- 28:33penton smiling face was up on the wall for some of his off field work
- 28:37while he was at Ohio State. I mean, that's that's a really good
- 28:40class overall. I think that has to be the best fressel Er class.
- 28:44What was interesting to me was, you look at some of these names from
- 28:47the past. It doesn't feel like guys flip flop sides of the ball.
- 28:49That feels like that's really a desperate move at this point. If you if
- 28:52you see someone, you know, a defensive lineman flip flopping too the offensive
- 28:56side of the ball or vice versa. When you go back through the list,
- 28:59it's like, boy, that used to happen all the time. You
- 29:00know, Tim Schaefer did that. You know, Billy Price was on here
- 29:04as a defensive lineman ended up going to the offensive line. They were a
- 29:08bunch of guys who ended up switching sides of the ball. It just it
- 29:11feels like that doesn't happen anymore. But apparently it used to happen a lot
- 29:15more than you know, I guess, at least I thought it did back,
- 29:18you know, back back a decade or two ago. Well, even
- 29:22in twenty and eleven class, you had two of them, Chase Ferris and
- 29:25Joel Hale, both of their five man class, two of them end up
- 29:29on the offensive line. The last two times they've signed six six defensive lineman
- 29:33two. You know, there's been one guy from each class to end up
- 29:37on the offensive side. In twenty fifteen it was Josh Allaby, and in
- 29:41twenty thirteen Billy Price, and really over the last you know, since since
- 29:45nineteen ninety they've only signed more than five guys three times. And we've talked
- 29:51about that. Twenty eighteen with seven, and in fifteen and thirteen with six,
- 29:56and so the last three years they've signed war which you know, seems
- 30:03to be like it gives them decent numbers moving forward, other than the fact
- 30:08that that twenty twenty one class might hit so well that they could be on
- 30:12their way out before you know, you even know it. And so I
- 30:18wonder how many is not enough in in twenty twenty four? Is you know,
- 30:25is free enough? Is four enough? Can they go get five?
- 30:27And one thing they'll always tell you, the coaches always tell you we're not
- 30:30going to reach And Ohio has had some guys you know in this year's class
- 30:36at Ohio State didn't really like, you know, Brian Robinson being one,
- 30:40and um, another guy name is escaping me that recently committed to Michigan from
- 30:47from Ohio. Where these guys are tweeters like not big enough for one position
- 30:52too big for the other that sort of thing where Ohio State's like, yeah,
- 30:56I think and under trestle. Probably those guys are guys at this point
- 31:00you're you know, you're you're getting so specialized where it's like, well,
- 31:04no, we feel good about these guys, and we're not sure where you're
- 31:10going to end up. So they when when you just let the out of
- 31:15state guys go or when you let the in state guys go, that makes
- 31:21it even more important to hit And I thank you that the guys were talking
- 31:23about then you know, as we know, recruiting rankings are infallible, so
- 31:29that would be huge. Yeah, extremely scientific, very precise, always never
- 31:33end out. Yes, recruiting rankings. It does feel like you probably need
- 31:37to be taking minimally four maybe five every class at this point, just because
- 31:42you go back through these lists and there's a bunch of guys who were at
- 31:45Ohio State four years and years and never panned out. But they were at
- 31:49Ohio State for four or five years. Now, if you're a guy who's
- 31:52not going to pan out or who's not even close to sniffing the field,
- 31:56you're going after a year or two and then you get that turnover, you
- 31:59get a churn in that room. And with a place, you know,
- 32:01with a position group where it takes a little while to be physically ready to
- 32:05get on the field, you need to have some veteran depth at this you
- 32:09know, at this spot, you need to have some veteran depth. And
- 32:12at the on the offensive line. It feels to me like whatever X was
- 32:16for you know, how many players, how many players in this position group
- 32:20did you need to take five years ago? It feels like it's kind of
- 32:22like X plus one. Now you got to just take You got to take
- 32:25an extra guy, find an extra guy, and you're not reaching You're not
- 32:28going to take the you know, the two star guy and you're going to
- 32:30steal them away from Western Michigan or something. But you've got to find guys
- 32:35who are the kind of guys who might go to Kentucky or the guys kind
- 32:38of guys who might have gone to Michigan State under Mark D'Antonio. And if
- 32:43they're may be good enough, you might have to you might have to look
- 32:46at taking another guy because just because of the way roster churn works right now
- 32:50with the transfer portal and guys, Ohio State has not had nearly as much
- 32:53turnover it as other programs have. But right now, I don't think you
- 32:59can feel super confident that you're going to have, um, you know,
- 33:02you're going to have four of your five guys or three of your four guys
- 33:07for three four years in any given class, in any given position group.
- 33:12You have to kind of assume look at look at the you know, the
- 33:15cornerbacks, look at the safeties they've had. They've had a ton of guys
- 33:17churn in and out over the last few years. They've already lost a couple
- 33:22of receivers from the class of twenty twenty two, and and you know those
- 33:24guys basically played one season and boom there out. So it is just it
- 33:29is very It's getting harder and harder to keep guys on campus. So you've
- 33:32got to have You've got to make sure, you know, keep stock in
- 33:35that pond, because other other teams are going to be fishing in your pond,
- 33:38uh, you know, legally, legally or you know, like a
- 33:43little you know, maybe maybe the season hasn't really opened yet, but they're
- 33:45out there in their boats anyway. So you're going to have people fishing in
- 33:49your pond. So you got to make sure you keep it stocked so you
- 33:52don't run out of fish. It is interesting because the last three years they've
- 33:55taken four each year, and four of the previous five years they'd only taken
- 34:00three each year, except for that twenty eighteen outlier where they took seven,
- 34:05because they'd only taken six the previous two years. And it's just there's too
- 34:09much up and down there. I think if you can get into the solid
- 34:12four and five every single year, that keeps things a little bit more even
- 34:15keel and you're not you know, the boat is only rocking a little when
- 34:20somebody steps off and jumps onto another boat. Whereas you know if you've got
- 34:23well, we've got seven on the spider of the boat and two on this
- 34:27part of the boat. Tom, that's how boats sink. And let's uh,
- 34:30I'm I am a sailor anything else before we go, No, I
- 34:35think I think the idea of you in a sailor suit in with a little
- 34:37hat is probably exactly the thought we want to leave everyone with. So I
- 34:40think we need to wrap it up right now and not a moment later.
- 34:45All right, then, want to thank you all for joining us. As
- 34:47always, please find us at buckeyehuddle dot com, become a member, sailo
- 34:52to us there on the forum. We are there right now talking about the
- 34:55biggest surprises in Ohio state recruiting history, and a bunch of old names from
- 35:00way back when, popping up and right chipping back into the memory banks.
- 35:05Of course, you can find us on YouTube dot com slash bucket huddle if
- 35:07you're watching this there, watching us there right now, I'm go ahead and
- 35:10at the like button, thumbs up, at the subscribe button, at the
- 35:14bill to be notified all that good stuff. And of course you can find
- 35:16us at Facebook dot com slash bucket huddle as well. So thank you all
- 35:20for tuning in and we'll talk to you guys later