Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / When Bankruptcy Is Filed During Divorce: What Happens Next?
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to when bankruptcy is filed during divorce.
- 0:07What happens next? I'm Ryan Wedeking, an incoming
- 0:12co -chair of the Beverly Hills Bar Association's
- 0:15Family Law Section. Our section is sponsored
- 0:17by White, Suckerman, Orzowski, Lunet, and Hunt
- 0:20LLP. White, Suckerman provides a wide variety
- 0:26of resources to complete almost any project,
- 0:28large or small. They also provide traditional
- 0:31accounting and tax practice services. We invite
- 0:34you to contact them to discuss your specific
- 0:36accounting needs and learn how they can be of
- 0:38service to you. We have so many great programs
- 0:42coming up over the next month or so, so please
- 0:44mark your calendars and register now if you haven't
- 0:48already for the following. On October 14th, we
- 0:51have a fireside chat with Judge Kaufman and new
- 0:54family law judges. On October 23rd, also with
- 0:58Judge Kaufman, we have Parenting Plan Assessments,
- 1:02the LA County Practice Overview. On November
- 1:051st, we have our annual Family Law Symposium.
- 1:08This year is, this symposium is called Order
- 1:12in the Court, Tactics for Addressing Bad Faith
- 1:15and Incivility. That is going to be a fantastic
- 1:19program dealing with a number of troublesome
- 1:22issues at the Family Law Bar and Bench. On November
- 1:265th, we have the State of Department 2, one of
- 1:28our annual in -person flagship events. And on
- 1:32November 15th, we have Spotting and Managing
- 1:35SLAP Issues in Family Law. And that is SLAP,
- 1:39S -L -A -P -P, of course, not a domestic violence
- 1:43topic. Other exciting programs are on the calendar
- 1:49and in the works, and you are also... Welcome
- 1:52at our Family Law Section meetings on the third
- 1:55Wednesday of the month at 4 .30 p .m. We plan
- 2:00events, hear directly from Judge Kaufman and
- 2:03other bench officers, brainstorm new ideas on
- 2:06cases, and sometimes even have fun. Now, let's
- 2:11get to the program. I'm delighted to introduce
- 2:14today's speaker, James P. Menton Jr. James is
- 2:18a partner and chair of the corporate restructuring
- 2:21and bankruptcy group at Robbins Kaplan LLP. He
- 2:25represents clients in fiduciary disputes, creditors'
- 2:28rights, and remedies actions, corporate bankruptcies,
- 2:32and complex commercial litigation. He has decades
- 2:35of experience resolving high -stakes matters
- 2:38involving multimillion dollar claims. Drawing
- 2:41on his extensive network and litigation experience,
- 2:44He provides strategic counsel to debtors, creditors,
- 2:48fiduciaries, trustees, and other parties in distressed
- 2:51corporate situations, asset recovery, and restructuring.
- 2:55And crucially for today's audience, he also assists
- 2:59family law attorneys in addressing bankruptcy
- 3:05claims where a party has filed a bankruptcy petition
- 3:08while a dissolution action is pending. Thank
- 3:13you, James, for joining us today. And with that,
- 3:16I will let you take it away. Thank you, Ryan.
- 3:20Appreciate the opportunity to speak today to
- 3:21all of you. Why don't we get started? First slide,
- 3:26please. So I just thought I'd start with a quote
- 3:31in my world bankruptcy. sometimes happens quickly
- 3:37and sometimes it's long attenuated. This is a
- 3:40quote from The Sun Also Rises by Ernest Hemingway.
- 3:44There are two characters that were chatting in
- 3:46the book and one of them asked, how did you go
- 3:49bankrupt? And the response was two ways, gradually
- 3:52and then suddenly. And that's been my experience.
- 3:55In my practice, I'm not sure if you've run into
- 3:58that in your practice, but I thought it might
- 3:59be apropos for today, where I think sometimes
- 4:02bankruptcy happens quicker than we had anticipated.
- 4:06Next slide, please. So with the filing of the
- 4:14bankruptcy petition, there's what's called the
- 4:17automatic stay and it's automatic. It's an injunction
- 4:20issued by the bankruptcy court, but as I said,
- 4:22it's automatic. And what that does is it's fairly
- 4:26broad based and it does a number of things to
- 4:29kind of put a stay or a hold on things that happened
- 4:32prior to the bankruptcy. Among other things that
- 4:36it does is that you're prevented from starting
- 4:39or continuing lawsuits or collection efforts
- 4:41against the debtor. You're also prohibited from
- 4:45enforcing judgments or trying to create or perfect
- 4:49liens against the debtor or property of the estate.
- 4:55You're also prohibited from taking or controlling
- 4:58property of the bankruptcy estate. And you're
- 5:03also prohibited from collecting on pre -petition
- 5:07bankruptcy debts as well as offsetting those
- 5:11debts against the debtor from before the case.
- 5:13Again, the concept is it's automatic and it's
- 5:16trying to put a hold on things so you don't have
- 5:18a rush to the courthouse or otherwise in order
- 5:21to take a hold of assets of the debtor or property
- 5:26of the state before those kinds of matters are
- 5:29addressed in the bankruptcy. Fortunately, for
- 5:37many of us, including in the family law space,
- 5:40there are certain exceptions to the automatic
- 5:43stay for domestic matters. Importantly, those
- 5:47include paternity actions that are ongoing. It
- 5:51also deals with domestic support orders. Either
- 5:54the commencement or modification of those domestic
- 5:57support orders are not stayed by the automatic
- 6:00stay. the child custody and visitation matters
- 6:04are not stayed by the automatic stay and then
- 6:08the divorce itself is not but with one exception
- 6:12the idea that if you're dividing what's considered
- 6:16property of the bankruptcy estate, then that
- 6:19is state. In other words, the bankruptcy court
- 6:21has an interest, as do the creditors in the bankruptcy,
- 6:24for making sure that property of the estate is
- 6:28divided as appropriate as the bankruptcy court
- 6:31determines. And so the idea you can go forward
- 6:33with divorce, and we'll get into this in a bit,
- 6:36but you'll need to get relief from stay in order
- 6:38to do... dealing with issues of dividing via
- 6:43state property. And also what is accepted from
- 6:47the bankruptcy state is domestic violence proceedings.
- 6:52So those can move forward. There are other exceptions.
- 7:00to help enforce the domestic support obligations.
- 7:03And those include collecting support obligations
- 7:07that are not part of the bankruptcy estate. So
- 7:09if the debtor has separate property, you can
- 7:12pursue that. There's also the possibility of
- 7:16moving or seeking. wages to kind of garnish or
- 7:22attach wages to satisfy a domestic support obligation
- 7:26under a court order or perhaps government agency
- 7:30orders. You also have the ability in order to
- 7:33bring pressure to bear, if you will, on having
- 7:37licenses suspended, professional licenses, recreational
- 7:40licenses, things of that nature. You also have
- 7:45the ability to report the overdue support to
- 7:51credit agencies. So you're able to do that as
- 7:54well as essentially intercepting tax refunds
- 7:57with the concept of obviously domestic support
- 8:00obligations are very important and they need
- 8:03to be paid. And so the Bankruptcy Code provides
- 8:07these opportunities to kind of enhance rights
- 8:12in terms of trying to get those paid irrespective
- 8:16of the bankruptcy having been filed. Next slide,
- 8:22please. So here's the Gruntz case, which was
- 8:27a case in the Ninth Circuit. What was interesting
- 8:30about that case, because it did deal with the
- 8:33automatic stay. And this was a case where a woman
- 8:35was domestic or support obligations were owed.
- 8:41They were not being paid. And so the spouse,
- 8:44the ex -spouse pursued or. went to the authorities
- 8:48and started criminal proceedings were started
- 8:51and there was a conviction and that happened
- 8:56twice. And what the debtor did is the debtor
- 8:58tried to suggest that it was in violation of
- 9:00the automatic stay because what the ex -spouse
- 9:05was trying to do was to collect on a debt. The
- 9:08court didn't buy that, if you will. The court
- 9:12basically said that under the under the bankruptcy
- 9:16code, criminal proceedings are also accepted
- 9:19from the automatic stay. And it said that whatever
- 9:22the motive is for those proceedings to go forward,
- 9:26even if the ex -spouse did have that motive,
- 9:30that that was not relevant based on a plain language
- 9:33meaning of the statute. And then it was really
- 9:37the authorities, in this case, the state authorities
- 9:40that were going forward with that. So the court
- 9:43found that it was not a violation of the automatic
- 9:45stay. What's also important here is that this
- 9:48was a state court that found that the automatic
- 9:51stay did not apply. And so the concept here is
- 9:55that family courts can't modify or lift the automatic
- 9:58stay. but they can decide whether it applies
- 10:01or not. And in this case, they decided that it
- 10:04did not apply. So if the family law court were
- 10:07to do that on a matter before it, that certainly
- 10:11would be subject to review by the bankruptcy
- 10:13court. I just caution you, however, that If if
- 10:18you go forward and in the family law court and
- 10:21it's ultimately decided that it was in violation
- 10:23of the automatic stay Or a lifting of the automatic
- 10:26stay or modification If they've taken up by the
- 10:31bankruptcy court upon review that could be considered
- 10:34for if it's if it is that Then that would be
- 10:37considered void and so that creates some complications
- 10:41there. So as a practical tip or point You may
- 10:47want to consider if you have these issues out
- 10:50there as to whether the automatic stay applies
- 10:52or it doesn't apply or whether it's accepted.
- 10:56One thing you can do is go in front of the bankruptcy
- 10:59court and seek clarification whether the stay
- 11:04applies or not or in the alternative to provide
- 11:08relief from stay in order to proceed with the
- 11:10matters that you're interested in. So, when I
- 11:21mentioned before the idea that the divorce proceeding
- 11:24can go forward, but what estate is the notion
- 11:29of the division of property of the bankruptcy
- 11:33estate. And so, what you need to do in that regard
- 11:36is you need to seek relief from stay under 362D
- 11:39of the Bankruptcy Code. And you can seek relief
- 11:43from stay for cause. which is not defined in
- 11:46the bankruptcy code and so it's decided on a
- 11:47case by case basis. Courts, bankruptcy courts,
- 11:51when considering relief from stay matters tend
- 11:54to focus on matters such as judicial economy,
- 11:58the state court expertise, and the estate's interests
- 12:01in whether to grant relief from stay or to modify
- 12:04the stay to allow the family law proceeding to
- 12:08go forward with respect to division. property
- 12:12of the estate. In my experience, bankruptcy courts
- 12:16are interested in and generally defer to bankruptcy
- 12:19courts on such matters, given their expertise.
- 12:23McDonald is a case that is cited in some other
- 12:28materials that you'll be getting after the program
- 12:30that makes that clear. And then in Sandoval,
- 12:34that was an interesting case here in the Central
- 12:36District of California. The bankruptcy court
- 12:40said basically, from its perspective, there were
- 12:44two methods to deal with this notion of division
- 12:47or determination of the property of the estate
- 12:50and how it's to be divided. One was for the bankruptcy
- 12:53court to do that. And the second option was to
- 12:56have that go forward in the family law case.
- 12:59but with certain protections in place. And in
- 13:03this case, the bankruptcy court was concerned
- 13:05about collusion. This was a case where there
- 13:11was property that the house that was owned by
- 13:13the debtor's parents and they had title was taken
- 13:19by the debtor and her ex -husband. And it was
- 13:24unclear as to who owned the property, who owned
- 13:28equitable and legal title to the property anyway,
- 13:30so went into bankruptcy. The spouse who had not
- 13:33filed bankruptcy filed a proof of claim in the
- 13:36bankruptcy saying that he was entitled to $70
- 13:38,000 of that house. Basically, what they did
- 13:42is they ended up settling that matter. What the
- 13:45bankruptcy court allowed them to do was to go
- 13:48to the bankruptcy court to deal with issues concerning
- 13:51the characterization and division of that property.
- 13:54the bankruptcy court would treat that as a proposed
- 13:57settlement. Then you'd have to go back to the
- 14:00bankruptcy court and get approval of that. So
- 14:02to go back, what happened in this case is the,
- 14:05as I said, the ex -husband had filed a proof
- 14:08of claim saying that he was entitled to at least
- 14:09$70 ,000 of the equity in that house. And they
- 14:14entered into a settlement agreement in a family
- 14:16law arena where Basically, he got money, the
- 14:23house went to the parents, was transferred to
- 14:27the parents, and the bankruptcy estate got zero.
- 14:32And then a motion was brought in the bankruptcy
- 14:34court to approve that, and the court did not
- 14:36approve that. The bankruptcy court decided there
- 14:38was collusion going on, that it didn't make any
- 14:40sense that the... that the husband or ex -husband
- 14:43was getting $70 ,000 and the estate was getting
- 14:47nothing at a minimum, the bankruptcy court opined
- 14:51that the estate should be getting something and
- 14:53certainly perhaps not less than $70 ,000 if the
- 14:57husband was entitled to $70 ,000. So that is
- 15:00kind of a situation where how one bankruptcy
- 15:03court kind of dealt with the issue about how
- 15:05to deal with the division of property, the estate,
- 15:09its characterization, and its division. Next
- 15:13slide, please. In another case, the Betelmenti
- 15:19case out of South Carolina, the court did it
- 15:23a little bit differently. Didn't seem to be so
- 15:25concerned about the collusive aspect of things,
- 15:28but certainly wanted to protect the bankruptcy
- 15:33estate and its creditors. And so what it did
- 15:34in this case, It allowed the family law court
- 15:39to go forward with its determination of the apportionment
- 15:42of the marital assets, but then it prohibited
- 15:45basically any further action to collect, recover,
- 15:48transfer, encumber, or liquidate that estate
- 15:50property without further bankruptcy court order,
- 15:55and it retained the ability to review the family
- 15:58law court's determination as it related to estate
- 16:01property. What's going on here is this this balancing
- 16:05act of understanding the expertise of family
- 16:08law courts to deal with these kinds of issues,
- 16:11among other issues in the family law arena, but
- 16:15then being very mindful of the bankruptcy itself
- 16:19and creditors and what makes sense from a bankruptcy
- 16:24perspective. And so courts grapple with how to
- 16:26deal with that. And these are examples of two
- 16:28courts and how they've addressed it. So when
- 16:33you're thinking about this stuff, think about
- 16:34what makes sense from your perspective in terms
- 16:38of that division and rest assured you're going
- 16:43to probably have some bankruptcy oversight. in
- 16:45one form or fashion. So that's not surprising
- 16:48and is to be expected. In terms of relief from
- 16:52stay practice, there are forms that one needs
- 16:55to fill out. You want to support that with a
- 16:57declaration for relief from stay for cause. And
- 17:03in connection with that, typically these orders
- 17:06have a 14 -day stay, if you will, of the effectiveness
- 17:10of that order. So what I've done in the past
- 17:15is request a waiver of that so that it becomes
- 17:18effective immediately. And then also, as I've
- 17:22mentioned previously, you may want to consider
- 17:25seeking relief from the bankruptcy court to get
- 17:29clarification on whether the automatic stay applies
- 17:31or a comfort order to say that it, again, doesn't
- 17:34apply or to get relief from stay in the event
- 17:37that it does apply. That's a potentially prudent
- 17:40course of action to take if there's some confusion.
- 17:42or you don't want to want to want to run a foul
- 17:45with a bankruptcy estate because running a foul
- 17:47of the bankruptcy estate as I said before can
- 17:50impact what happens in the family law court in
- 17:53terms of it being avoid avoid judgment or whatever
- 17:57but also there are there potential sanctions
- 18:01and whatnot that can be that could be requested
- 18:05anyway if there's kind of a willful violation
- 18:07of the automatic stay so you will obviously want
- 18:10to try to avoid that. Next slide, please. So
- 18:18we talked about or alluded to bankruptcy, the
- 18:22property of the bankruptcy estate and kind of
- 18:24what is that. It's fairly, fairly broad based
- 18:27under 541A of the bankruptcy code. It includes
- 18:31all of the debtor's legal and equitable property
- 18:33interests as of the petition date. It includes
- 18:36community property basically under the debtor's
- 18:39sole or joint control and also community property
- 18:43that's liable for the debts of the spouse and
- 18:46the non -filing spouse. It includes property
- 18:50recovered from avoided transfers, also property
- 18:54acquired within 180 days of the bankruptcy by
- 18:57inheritance, divorce or death, also includes
- 19:02rents, profits, proceeds from estate property,
- 19:05and then property of the estate. required after
- 19:09the petition date. So it's fairly broad -based
- 19:12in terms of the expansiveness of what is property
- 19:16of the estate. As a further amplification or
- 19:24just as a supplement to that, in individual Chapter
- 19:2711 and Chapter 13 cases, the estate includes
- 19:30post -petition property and income earned before
- 19:33the case is closed, dismissed, or converted.
- 19:36and then there are certain exceptions to what's
- 19:40property of the estate and or exceptions or not
- 19:44considered not property of the estate and that
- 19:46excludes if you have a power that you're working
- 19:49for the benefit of from someone else vis -a -vis
- 19:52valid spendthrift trusts that's not property
- 19:55of the state or is excluded from it and then
- 19:59in terms of property of the estate and how that's
- 20:02determined what law applies it's state law determines
- 20:06those issues rather than federal law. And the
- 20:12notion is that, let's say the bankruptcy, you
- 20:15know, you've got the family law case going forward,
- 20:17then bankruptcy is filed. If there hasn't been
- 20:18a court determination, a family law court determination,
- 20:21as to the division of that community property,
- 20:24then it's all considered, upon the filing, it's
- 20:27all considered community property. So that'd
- 20:31be something to be mindful of. And that was basically
- 20:37what the mantle case was talking about. So the
- 20:42bankruptcy code provides for certain exceptions
- 20:45or exemptions, if you will. And there's the bankruptcy
- 20:50exemptions, and then California has its own exemptions.
- 20:55In California, we've opted out of the federal
- 20:57bankruptcy code. exemptions and so what you focus
- 21:02on here in California is California residents
- 21:03you focus on the state law exceptions under CCP
- 21:07section 703 and 704 and debtors can avoid judicial
- 21:14liens that impair and we'll get we'll talk about
- 21:17judicial liens a bit later in the program debtors
- 21:20can avoid judicial liens that impair the exemptions
- 21:23the the one exception to that is for domestic
- 21:26support obligations And then there may be other
- 21:30laws out there, California or in other states
- 21:33that somehow prohibit going after exempt assets,
- 21:39but those are kind of excluded, if you will,
- 21:45under the bankruptcy code. So those wouldn't
- 21:46prohibit you from going after exempt assets if
- 21:50you're a support creditor. So domestic support
- 21:59obligations, a key concept in the family law
- 22:02context in the bankruptcy world. A domestic support
- 22:07obligation is a debt, including interest in the
- 22:11nature of alimony, maintenance or support owed
- 22:14to a spouse, former spouse or a child of the
- 22:17debtor. And it can arise before, during or after
- 22:22bankruptcy and must be based on a based on a
- 22:25court order, a separation agreement, divorce
- 22:27decree, marital settlement agreement, or government
- 22:31determination, and it can't be assigned to a
- 22:34non -governmental entity except for collection
- 22:36purposes. So the question is what is the domestic
- 22:49support obligation and how is that determined?
- 22:51And really the focus is not so much on the on
- 22:54the language per se, but it's focusing on the
- 22:59intent and what's the substance of the obligation.
- 23:05So in other words, not just the language or the
- 23:08payee. And what's important here is those, you
- 23:13know, so for instance, in my experience and the
- 23:16case law provides that domestic Support obligations
- 23:20may include debts of the ex -spouse, the non
- 23:25-filing spouse's attorney's fees, and we'll talk
- 23:27more about that later. Mortgage payments for
- 23:31the ex -spouse, the residence of the ex -spouse,
- 23:34or educational expenses. The idea is it's for
- 23:39the welfare and benefit of the ex -spouse or
- 23:44children, for example. What's important here
- 23:48is that domestic support obligations are non
- 23:50-dischargeable under the bankruptcy code under
- 23:53523A5. And what I mean by that is that typically
- 23:56when you file a bankruptcy, the individual will
- 23:59get a discharge in the bankruptcy if things go
- 24:03as they typically go. And what that means is
- 24:05that the debtor no longer has personal liability
- 24:09on those pre -petition debts. When we say non
- 24:14-dischargeable, what that means is that carries
- 24:16through. In other words, for domestic support
- 24:19obligation, that means that those obligations
- 24:22prior to the bankruptcy, during the bankruptcy,
- 24:24and after the bankruptcy are not dischargeable,
- 24:28meaning that it's a personal liability that continues
- 24:31on even though there's been this bankruptcy.
- 24:36critically important here and why you want to
- 24:39have domestic support obligations, particularly
- 24:42for you if you're an attorney representing the
- 24:45spouse who didn't file bankruptcy and you want
- 24:46your attorney's fees paid, it's important. One
- 24:49vehicle for getting paid is to have that characterized
- 24:52and considered as a domestic support obligation
- 24:57because as I said that rides through Through
- 25:01the bankruptcy and it's also important in the
- 25:03sense that it's given kind of a super priority
- 25:05If you will in the bankruptcy within the bankruptcy,
- 25:08there is a kind of a waterfall of who gets paid
- 25:11and when and this is the Domestic support obligation
- 25:16is a higher priority So get paid out before other
- 25:20unsecured creditors. So that's that's another
- 25:23important aspect of domestic support obligations
- 25:26and why and how it's played out in the bankruptcy
- 25:29and why it's important to be sure that you have
- 25:32a domestic support obligation, not only if you
- 25:34can for your attorney's fees, but also for your
- 25:37client who you're representing in the family
- 25:42law context. As I mentioned before, the debtor
- 25:51receives a bankruptcy discharge that eliminates
- 25:52the personal liability, as we mentioned. There
- 25:57are, in addition to 523A5 that I talked about,
- 26:01and I'll talk about 523A15 in the next slide
- 26:05or two, but there are other non -dischargeable
- 26:08obligations that I'd suggest one keep in mind.
- 26:14And those include for the for money, property
- 26:19or services that were obtained by fraud or false
- 26:23pretenses, 523A2, fiduciary fraud or embezzlement,
- 26:30523A4, and will for a malicious injury under
- 26:32523A6. So in this particular context, in the
- 26:38family law context, suppose you're representing
- 26:40someone in your clients in family law and suppose
- 26:44the other, the spouse, during the marriage has
- 26:50committed, you know, what you perceive to be
- 26:52fiduciary fraud or embezzlement of community
- 26:55funds or even of separate property or engaged
- 26:59in kind of willful or malicious injury to your
- 27:02client or to your client's property. One way
- 27:05to address that aside from this 523A5 matter,
- 27:10which that's a domestic support obligation, but
- 27:12this is something different. This is basically
- 27:15your client having been injured by these kinds
- 27:17of activities. And so what you can do is you
- 27:22can file in the bankruptcy court a complaint
- 27:26arguing that the debt for let's say fiduciary
- 27:30fraud or embezzlement or for malicious, willful
- 27:34or malicious injury. should be accepted from
- 27:39the discharge as well. And that typically is
- 27:43a complaint that you file as an adversary proceeding,
- 27:45and then you actually go to trial in the bankruptcy
- 27:50court on those issues. And if you are successful,
- 27:53that debt would also be accepted from discharge.
- 27:57It'd be a non -dischargeable debt, meaning that
- 28:00the debtor would still have personal liability
- 28:02for those for those damages as well. It's important
- 28:09to keep in mind for these particular debts that
- 28:13are non -dischargeable under 523A2, A4, or A6,
- 28:18that there's a timeline, there's a time frame,
- 28:20if you will, for bringing those in the bankruptcy
- 28:23court. So in other words, you just can't bring
- 28:25it at any time. And that deadline is, in the
- 28:29bankruptcy world, after the bankruptcy is filed,
- 28:32there's typically what's called a 341A meeting
- 28:35of creditors that is scheduled. And what that
- 28:38means is that the U .S. trustee's office will
- 28:40schedule a meeting with the debtor where creditors
- 28:43can show up. And during that time, the debtor
- 28:46is under oath and they answer questions about
- 28:49their bankruptcy schedules and a whole variety
- 28:51of things, basically about the bankruptcy case
- 28:53and their assets, liabilities, documents, things
- 28:57of that nature. Once that's scheduled, you'd
- 29:02need to file the 523A2, A4, or A6 complaint within
- 29:0660 days of that initial scheduling of the 341A
- 29:12meeting. In my experience, that 341A meeting
- 29:15of creditors tends to get continued for a variety
- 29:18of reasons, scheduling, or it happens, and then
- 29:22it gets continued to another date in order for
- 29:25the debtor to provide more information or documents.
- 29:28for the trustee to maybe do some more investigation.
- 29:32But the continuation of that 3401A meeting doesn't
- 29:36change the timeline or the timeframe by which
- 29:40you need to file the 523A2A4 or A6 complaints.
- 29:46So consider once the bankruptcy is filed, whether
- 29:48you have these type of debts that potentially
- 29:52are non -dischargeable and then strategize and
- 29:54think about whether you want to bring that complaint
- 29:57and be be mindful of the deadline for doing so.
- 30:08So we talked about non -dischargeable debts under
- 30:10523A5. Debt that are non -DSO debts, that are
- 30:17property division debts, basically like equalization
- 30:20of property and whatnot in the bankruptcy case,
- 30:24that can be non -dischargeable. under 523A5 or
- 30:32523A15. Those debts in Chapter 7 and 11 are completely
- 30:40non -dischargeable, but in a Chapter 13 case,
- 30:45523A15 for those non -DSO debts, property division
- 30:49debts. Those can be dischargeable. They could
- 30:53be provided for in a Chapter 11 plan, and so
- 30:55long as that plan is consummated, where, in other
- 30:58words, the debtor satisfies its obligations under
- 31:02the plan, then those would be kind of discharged,
- 31:06if you will. So it's mindful here. Here it's
- 31:12important to when you have a Chapter 13 case
- 31:15to understand what debts are being characterized
- 31:19and how they're being characterized and whether
- 31:22they are, suppose it's a domestic support obligation
- 31:26under 523A5, but it's being characterized as
- 31:28a 523A15 debt, then you want to be proactive
- 31:32on that and reach out to the debtor to try to
- 31:35get clarification there or to get things modified.
- 31:39And if that doesn't work, then the concept would
- 31:43be to seek relief in the bankruptcy court to
- 31:48make sure that things are not mischaracterized
- 31:50or mistreated because the downside in Chapter
- 31:5313 case is that it could be considered, assuming
- 31:56it gets consummated, it would be dischargable
- 31:59under the Chapter 13 plan. That's not the case
- 32:02in Chapter 7 or Chapter 11. It's helpful to understand
- 32:07how debts are being characterized in the bankruptcy
- 32:10by the debtor and whether that comports with
- 32:13your sense or understanding about what those
- 32:16debts are and to be proactive in seeking relief
- 32:19to protect your client's interest in the bankruptcy.
- 32:30So I've seen some commentary among the case law
- 32:34about state and federal courts share jurisdiction
- 32:36over determining debt subject to or accepted
- 32:38from the debtor's discharge, except for 523A2A4A6
- 32:43applying bankruptcy law. If in doubt, I would
- 32:48suggest go to the bankruptcy court to get clarification
- 32:50there. So there's no confusion in that regard.
- 32:54We've talked about debts that are non -dischargeable.
- 33:00There's also, under the bankruptcy code, and
- 33:03we talked about getting discharged from personal
- 33:05liability, there's also the opportunity to seek
- 33:08to have the debtor not get a discharge generally
- 33:11for all obligations. And that's under 727. And
- 33:17that's for basically bad acts, if you will, under
- 33:20the statute. And it can be considered such things
- 33:23like... The property disposition was fraudulent
- 33:28or failure to preserve records or withholding
- 33:30of information or providing false testimony,
- 33:34not disclosing assets on the schedules, basically
- 33:39defrauding the bankruptcy court and creditors
- 33:41and disobeying court orders. So there is a vehicle
- 33:44to seek to deny the discharge of the debtor.
- 33:48Generally, that is by filing a complaint. So
- 33:51that's another potential resource or leverage
- 33:55point that one can use in the bankruptcy, not
- 33:58only to have this non -dischargeable debt aspect
- 34:01of things, but also to basically request the
- 34:04court deny the debtor a discharge. That's the
- 34:08filing of a complaint in the bankruptcy. So let's
- 34:16go turn it a little bit to litigation and avoiding
- 34:19powers. under the bankruptcy code. So what I
- 34:24often run into is preferences. The notion of
- 34:29a preference that is typically the debtor has,
- 34:32the trustee in bankruptcy says within 90 days
- 34:38prior to the bankruptcy that the debtor provided
- 34:41money to the client or to others on it. for antecedent
- 34:47debt or within a year for an outsider and that
- 34:50the person who received the money got more than
- 34:51they would in a chapter seven liquidation. There
- 34:55are certain defenses to preferences in terms
- 34:59of contemporaries. providing new value and an
- 35:03ordinary course of business transactions and
- 35:06transfers. The good news here in the family law
- 35:10space is that domestic support audits are exempt
- 35:14from avoidances as a preference. So that's good
- 35:18news. So the bad news is that potentially payments
- 35:22on non -DSO debts within that period maybe challenges
- 35:25preferences. Typically what happens in my experience
- 35:28is that the Chapter 7 trustee will send out a
- 35:33letter in advance saying, look, asserting that
- 35:37certain payments were considered preferences.
- 35:42And then there's an opportunity, well in advance
- 35:45of the deadline for filing those preference actions,
- 35:48which is two years after the bankruptcy is filed.
- 35:50And so there's an opportunity to educate the
- 35:53trustee and to try to work something out, to
- 35:56reach resolution on that. And I've done that.
- 35:59Sometimes that works, sometimes that doesn't.
- 36:01If it doesn't work out, then potentially, and
- 36:04the lawsuit is filed and maybe pre that filing,
- 36:07you've been able to reduce the amount of issue.
- 36:12for purposes of litigation or if you can't reach
- 36:15a resolution and the complaint is filed in the
- 36:19bankruptcy court and you kind of litigate that
- 36:22like you would other matters. So that's kind
- 36:32of preferences. There's also fraudulent transfers.
- 36:35fraudulent transfers under the bankruptcy code
- 36:38under 548 there are there's certainly there's
- 36:41actual fraud fraudulent transfers under under
- 36:44548 and also constructive fraudulent transfers
- 36:47those are brought within two years of the bankruptcy
- 36:49so sometimes you will get a letter in advance
- 36:52from the from the the trustees saying i believe
- 36:54you've also received a fraudulent transfer or
- 36:58we believe you received a preference but if it's
- 37:01not that it's a fraudulent transfer or vice versa
- 37:04In terms of actual fraud, it can be shown by
- 37:08direct or circumstantial evidence. A lot of times
- 37:10you don't have someone actually saying, yes,
- 37:13I affirmatively wanted to commit fraud here.
- 37:16And so you look at various factors, including
- 37:18when these transfers were happening, was there's
- 37:21pending litigation? Were you transferring most
- 37:24of the property? Was the debtor insolvent at
- 37:26the time? Was there a special relationship? Was
- 37:29the debtor transferring all the assets to his
- 37:34spouse to siblings, relatives, whatever. Was
- 37:40there a transfer that actually happened or it
- 37:43looks like it happened, but it really didn't
- 37:45because the debtor kept, essentially retained
- 37:47the property. Those are the facts and circumstances
- 37:51that you want to look at to see. If you know
- 37:56support the notion of an actual fraudulent transfer
- 37:58or that's what they will look to And then obviously
- 38:01if you're on the defensive side You'll want to
- 38:02try to push back on on those factors and argue
- 38:05that it wasn't fraudulent transfer Yeah, we talked
- 38:14about kind of within two years of the bankruptcy
- 38:17and recently On the constructive fraudulent transfer
- 38:21side of things, it's did you really not receive,
- 38:24did the debtor not receive originally equivalent
- 38:26value for the transfer or an obligation incurred
- 38:29while the debtor was insolvent or another test
- 38:33is being undercapitalized or believed or recently
- 38:39should have believed that paying debts was going
- 38:42to be incurring debts beyond his or her ability
- 38:45to pay. that that's kind of the constructive
- 38:49fraudulent transfer scenario. And then the ninth
- 38:52circuit, as I indicate here, equates reasonable
- 38:55value with fair market value. Assess from the
- 38:57creditor's perspective based on all of the circumstances.
- 39:06And then 548 deals with self -subtle trust that
- 39:11have been common in various jurisdictions and
- 39:14that the bankruptcy codes provides the opportunity
- 39:17to go back 10 years to look at those self -settled
- 39:21trusts to see whether those were set up and operated
- 39:25essentially to defraud creditors. James, it actually
- 39:32looks like we have one question if we do have
- 39:34the time for that. I have a Mr. Jack Russo is
- 39:37asking. Can non -married Marvin v. Marvin partners
- 39:42get DSO relief or is that only for married folks?
- 39:45What about civil partners? I haven't dealt with
- 39:49that issue before, but I think an argument can
- 39:52be made in that regard. But as I said, I'd have
- 39:55to research that further. I haven't dealt with
- 39:57that, but I think arguments should be made in
- 40:00support of that. Thank you. And then one is kind
- 40:10of the avoiding of the transfer itself as a fraudulent
- 40:12transfer. And then there's also from whom you
- 40:14can recover. And you can certainly recover from
- 40:18the person who received the funds and also for
- 40:21someone for whose benefit it was received. If
- 40:25you are a subsequent transferee that provided
- 40:28good value. in good faith and for value without
- 40:34the notion of the avoidability of the transfer,
- 40:37then that can be a safe harbor, if you will,
- 40:40to get to not have that liability, that exposure
- 40:44as a transferee. And then 544B really, really,
- 40:53what it allows you to do is use state law, fraudulent
- 40:57transfer law, in order to to avoid fraudulent
- 41:03transfers. So in this case, under California
- 41:06law, same kind of concept apply in terms of actual
- 41:08fraud and constructive fraud. So those are general,
- 41:16we're running a little short on time, so I want
- 41:17to kind of speed up a little bit. So why don't
- 41:19we go to the next slide, please. Next slide.
- 41:32And the Magia case, that's just to say that marital
- 41:36settlement agreements, they are subject to fraudulent
- 41:39transfer statutes here in California, certainly.
- 41:43And so you want to be mindful of that. Next slide.
- 41:53So I want to get to attorney's liens for practitioners
- 41:57out there. The notion is The state law applies
- 42:02to the gun of the creation and the validity and
- 42:06perfection of liens and bankruptcy. The point
- 42:10here is that upon the filing of the bankruptcy,
- 42:14the trustee is considered a hypothetical judicial
- 42:17lien creditor, as well as a bona fide purchaser
- 42:20with authority to avoid unperfected liens. So
- 42:23the notion is if you don't have from your client
- 42:26or from your perspective for attorney, your attorney
- 42:29lien, if it's not perfected prior to the bankruptcy,
- 42:32then you run into the prospect of the bankruptcy
- 42:35trustee seeking to blow that lien off, if you
- 42:38will, or to say that to avoid that lien, which
- 42:42then renders you kind of just a general unsecured
- 42:45creditor. An example of this case of that is
- 42:48Inri Bush, 356 BR 28. In that case, it involved
- 42:54someone who was representing the debtor in family
- 42:57law proceedings, and then the debtor went bankrupt.
- 43:01And the family law lawyer was claiming not only
- 43:04a charging lien, but a fee stipulation lien,
- 43:10considered a fee stipulation as a judicial lien,
- 43:13and also had a family law. real property lien.
- 43:18And that all was contested by the chapter seven
- 43:21trustee. And so the highlight there is that there
- 43:24was a fee stipulation that basically said that
- 43:26this attorney's fees would be taken out of the
- 43:28proceeds from the sale of property. But unfortunately
- 43:34for the attorney in that case, the fee stipulation
- 43:36was not recorded. So in other words, even though
- 43:39it was entered in the family law case, it was
- 43:42not recorded and therefore the court said that
- 43:45the Chapter 7 trustee as a hypothetical judicial
- 43:47lien creditor and as a bona fide purchaser with
- 43:50authority to avoid unperfected liens did not
- 43:52have constructive notice of that unrecorded fee
- 43:54stipulation and therefore that was not considered
- 43:59a lien under the bankruptcy, well, for purposes
- 44:03of the bankruptcy case. So that was not a vehicle
- 44:05that the attorney could use to claim a lien on
- 44:09the proceeds of the property. Next slide please.
- 44:15So in terms of family law attorney real property
- 44:18liens, you all know the statutory basis for that
- 44:22under 2033. And in this Bush, the same case that
- 44:27we're talking about, in that case, the attorney
- 44:29also asserted a real property lien as well. And
- 44:36in that aspect of the case, the court agreed,
- 44:39even though this notice of lien had not been
- 44:43done under 2033B. The attorney had recorded an
- 44:49all -inclusive deed of trust, and the court said
- 44:52that provided constructive notice. Therefore,
- 44:56the attorney did have a lien on the proceeds
- 44:59based on the perfection and the recording of
- 45:05that all -inclusive deed of trust. The Henry
- 45:08Scott case talk talks about the idea that the
- 45:12family law real property lien is not a judicial
- 45:16lien and therefore it can't be kind of avoided
- 45:19under 522 F1 that talks about avoiding of judicial
- 45:22liens or avoiding liens that impair exemptions.
- 45:27And so that's critical to know. And then in this
- 45:31case, The argument also was that when you have
- 45:34your real property lien, it's against your client's
- 45:38community property interest and not against the
- 45:41debtor. And so therefore, that was also, in the
- 45:44Scott case, a basis for why did not find an issue
- 45:48or problem with the real property lien or why
- 45:52couldn't be avoided. But also in the judicial
- 46:04lien, we've got the real property lien. We also
- 46:07have charging liens. I don't know how many of
- 46:09you have that as part of your practice as well.
- 46:12A charging lien, as you know, is made pursuant
- 46:15to contract. they remain enforceable in bankruptcy,
- 46:20even if the judgment is entered after the petition
- 46:22date. So for instance, if you have a charging
- 46:24lien and you're entitled to the proceeds resulting
- 46:28from property that's obtained in the context
- 46:32of that dissolution, then even if that ends up
- 46:36getting consummated after the bankruptcy, you're
- 46:39arguably, if you have that lien, you're still
- 46:41entitled to the proceeds of that. In that case,
- 46:44the Pacific Far East Lines case was was exactly
- 46:48what happened there where the, um, the, and it
- 46:51wasn't in the family law context, but it was
- 46:53in kind of the charging lien general context.
- 46:55And there was a contingent, uh, fee arrangement
- 46:58and then the bankruptcy was filed. Um, and then
- 47:00the, the, the, uh, retainer agreement was, was,
- 47:06was not re it was rejected in the bankruptcy
- 47:09and we don't have really time to go through that
- 47:10today. But anyway, so not withstanding that the
- 47:13attorney was allowed the reasonable value of
- 47:15its services, and even though that deal was consummated
- 47:18after the bankruptcy, the court found that the
- 47:23lien did flow through, if you will, that the
- 47:24attorney did have the right to recover its contingency
- 47:30fee, consider the reasonable amount of its services
- 47:34in that case, notwithstanding the bankruptcy.
- 47:38So that's important to know. So in the charging
- 47:42lien context, In order to have a valid one, obviously
- 47:47you need to need to comply with California law.
- 47:52I cite the Fletcher case there. In other words,
- 47:55you've got to give the right for them to seek
- 47:58independent counsel, advise them of their ability
- 47:59to do that. I've seen cases where when that was
- 48:02not done, you didn't have a charging lien. And
- 48:07then this Tri Valley case, this was a case where
- 48:11a charging lien was claimed, but the The complaint
- 48:16itself did not plead that the compliance with
- 48:21Rule 3 -300. The attorney argued that it wasn't
- 48:25necessary to plead that compliance with Rule
- 48:293 -300. The court found otherwise. The court
- 48:32gave leave to amend for them to try to figure
- 48:35all of that out to give them another opportunity
- 48:38to see if that was the case. So be mindful of
- 48:42that if you are. um, pursuing charging liens,
- 48:45um, in terms of compliance with rule three, 300,
- 48:48uh, and then be sure you're pleading it, um,
- 48:51correctly. Um, and then in, in the Henry Bush
- 48:56case again, um, the debtors attorney, um, in
- 49:01the pre -petition dissolution proceedings was
- 49:03entitled to summary judgment confirming that
- 49:05the attorney's lien chargingly attached the proceeds
- 49:07of the debtors real property. The issue there
- 49:09was whether the charging lien, um, whether the
- 49:13language in the underlying agreement provided
- 49:17for charging lien against the real property and
- 49:22an equity interest in the real property and the
- 49:25proceeds and the court found that was the case.
- 49:27The court found that the California law provided
- 49:31for the ability to have such a lien outside of
- 49:34those family law statutes that we just talked
- 49:38about and the court ultimately decided that The
- 49:42court also looked at some of the circumstances,
- 49:46looking at the intent of the parties as to whether
- 49:49the real estate and the proceeds were subject
- 49:53to the charging lien. The court found that all
- 49:55of that came together, if you will, to support
- 49:59what the attorney was saying. So to support,
- 50:04the court found that the attorney's charging
- 50:07lien attached to the proceeds of the debtor's
- 50:09real property, as I indicated. So it's a practical
- 50:17tip in that regard in terms of charging liens.
- 50:19One, you want to be sure that you're creating
- 50:23one validly under your attorney agreement. And
- 50:27we know that perfection typically the charging
- 50:32lien is perfected upon the execution of that
- 50:35agreement. If real property is in play, in connection
- 50:43with the dissolution proceedings and your representation
- 50:45of the client, consider making sure that the
- 50:50real property is specifically identified in that.
- 50:56Otherwise, you get into issues, as they did in
- 50:59Bush, about the characterization of the looking
- 51:02at the language itself and what the intent of
- 51:04the parties was. So it may circumvent that kind
- 51:08of discussion by explicitly covering that real
- 51:11property. And then this concern about, in Bush
- 51:15and obviously in other cases, about having constructive
- 51:19notice. And so even though your attorney lien,
- 51:24the charging lien is perfected upon having been
- 51:29executing the retainer agreement, consider actually
- 51:34recording that in the county where the real property
- 51:38is to protect to provide that constructive notice.
- 51:43And so that would be something to do in anticipation
- 51:48potentially if there is a bankruptcy later that
- 51:51the trustee will try to say, no, there wasn't
- 51:54constructive notice. It wasn't recorded. And
- 51:56therefore you have an unrecorded lien as a result
- 52:01of which you have an unsecured claim in the bankruptcy
- 52:04case rather than a secured claim. And I might
- 52:06add here that The reason why it's important to
- 52:10have a lien is that a lien flows through the
- 52:12bankruptcy. In other words, even if the debtor
- 52:14is discharged from personal liability, if you
- 52:17have a lien on property, then that is not discharge
- 52:21and bankruptcy and that can become a source of
- 52:24recovery. So that's why it's important to, yeah,
- 52:27and that's why the trustees in these cases try
- 52:29to avoid these liens. So that's why it's important
- 52:36to think about ways in which you can have various
- 52:40liens and have them secured prior to the bankruptcy
- 52:44so that that can be a source of recovery for
- 52:48you potentially in the bankruptcy case as opposed
- 52:53to having an unsecured claim and if you're an
- 52:58unsecured creditor then you're sharing pro rata
- 53:01with other unsecured creditors. something worth
- 53:08keeping in mind in terms of attorneys and trying
- 53:12to get paid in the event of a bankruptcy, whether
- 53:14that is by, you know, as a result of the other
- 53:18party or your own party. If it's your own party,
- 53:22then obviously the liens become very important
- 53:26as a secured claim. And if you're not, then you
- 53:30want to focus on other ways in order to get paid.
- 53:34And we talked about having it characterized perhaps
- 53:37as a domestic support obligation or having it
- 53:42characterized as a 523A15, a non -DSO debt obligation.
- 53:49And I have seen cases where the attorney is successful
- 53:54in going into the bankruptcy court and arguing
- 53:57that that it's non -dischargeable under 523A,
- 54:02that the attorney's fees are non -dischargeable
- 54:05under 523A5 and A15. So we're almost out of time
- 54:10here. I wanted to open it up to see if there's
- 54:13any additional, well, in terms of a wrap -up.
- 54:18So the notion... And now I'll get very briefly
- 54:21to questions, if there are any. Assess, look,
- 54:24be careful about the automatic stay. Assess its
- 54:27applicability and exceptions and take appropriate
- 54:29action. That may mean going to the bankruptcy
- 54:31court and getting a comfort order, if you will.
- 54:34Or if it's for equalization of metal assets,
- 54:37then you certainly want to get relief from stay.
- 54:40Understanding that there's going to be some oversight
- 54:41in one way or another from the bankruptcy court.
- 54:44Certainly want to keep informed on bankruptcy
- 54:46proceedings and what's going on there and whether
- 54:49debts or property. characterized and treated,
- 54:51and if not, take prophylactic action to make
- 54:55that happen. And then also we've talked about
- 54:57if you've got some potentially non -dischargeable
- 55:01debts for, you know, for fraud and breach of
- 55:04fiduciary duty and that indesiliment and whatnot
- 55:07and willful malicious injury want to potentially
- 55:11pursue that recovery in bankruptcy and be mindful
- 55:14of the timing there. Certainly be mindful of
- 55:17domestic support obligations and property division
- 55:20claims and their treatment in the bankruptcy
- 55:24case and act as necessary there and state current
- 55:29illegal legal developments obviously and then
- 55:34plan ahead bankruptcy as we started that sometimes
- 55:37bankruptcy happens suddenly and so while you're
- 55:40in your family law cases it may you may want
- 55:44to consider even if bankruptcy doesn't seem likely
- 55:47or even possible things can happen quickly and
- 55:50so you may want to kind of plan ahead or think
- 55:54about that in advance and put things in place
- 55:57so that if that bankruptcy happens, you're well
- 56:01situated to navigate the bankruptcy and the family
- 56:04law context. If there's any kind of last minute
- 56:10questions, I'm happy to answer questions now.
- 56:15If there aren't any, by all means, there's my
- 56:17contact information. You can certainly contact
- 56:20me. at any time at your convenience and happy
- 56:24to chat with you about that. Also, it's not part
- 56:27of the materials that you'll be getting, but
- 56:28I've also written an article on marital property
- 56:32agreements. I mentioned the notion of them being
- 56:35subject to fraudulent transfer statutes. And
- 56:38I've written kind of an article about that. I
- 56:40had an experience in a case where that came up
- 56:42and how to address that. Chapter seven trustee
- 56:46filed an adversary. proceeding against my client
- 56:50from Missouri, trying to essentially blow up
- 56:53the whole dissolution resolution and divorce
- 56:59decree in the bankruptcy or in the family law
- 57:02case in Missouri, brought it out here in California,
- 57:05trying to unwind everything. And so we had to
- 57:08kind of deal with all of that and we did. So
- 57:11happy to chat with you about that. It's a matter
- 57:14of public record. We ended up resolving that
- 57:16matter. pursuant to court authority, but I wrote
- 57:20an article on that. So, if you're interested
- 57:21in that, certainly email me and I'll be happy
- 57:24to send you a copy of that article. All right,
- 57:28James. So, it actually looks like we have quite
- 57:30a few questions if you'd like to take the time
- 57:33to answer those. All right. So, Martha Warner
- 57:37asks, is the portion of a family law judgment
- 57:39that awards back wages to a spouse non -dischargeable
- 57:44under Section 523A -15? It could be potentially
- 57:52under A -15 or I'm wondering if it could be a
- 57:56domestic support obligation in some form or fashion.
- 58:02Right. And then let's see. Jack Russo is asking
- 58:06again, can an attorney lien be perfected by filing
- 58:09against the litigation file? How? I'm not sure
- 58:16if it could be perfect. There's issues. The charging
- 58:18lien is turned in terms of the litigation itself.
- 58:21I don't know that maybe if the property is subject
- 58:24to that litigation itself, I think in the Bush
- 58:26case or in another some other cases I was looking
- 58:29at not clear about the interplay between what
- 58:33you can record vis -a -vis the action itself,
- 58:35or I think it's on causes of action or. So I'm
- 58:42not really sure about that, to be honest with
- 58:43you. OK. And then Jack asks again, can a consulting
- 58:48attorney file a lien even if you're not or the
- 58:52consulting attorney is not of record in the case?
- 58:56I would argue, well, I think you can try to go
- 59:01down that road or you can potentially, in terms
- 59:05of being a consultant, maybe have it considered
- 59:08as a domestic support obligation. Suppose in
- 59:16a Chapter 7 case, only one spouse is filing.
- 59:20The non -filing spouse bought a property after
- 59:23the marriage, and the filing spouse signed an
- 59:27interspousal transfer deed at the time, giving
- 59:29up any ownership interest and simply residing
- 59:32there. In that scenario, does the property still
- 59:34need to be listed in the filing spouse's schedules,
- 59:37and how would it be treated in the bankruptcy?
- 59:42Well, the Chapter 7 trustee would probably look
- 59:44at that underlying trend. You'd want to, in terms
- 59:47of that transaction, you'd want to document it
- 59:49and you'd want to be clear, I suppose, in terms
- 59:52of giving up any interest. It sounds like it
- 59:55was separate property and so that sounds like
- 59:57it might be outside the bankruptcy context, but
- 1:00:00think about whether the trustee may try to argue
- 1:00:04that the non - the spouse that ended up in bankruptcy,
- 1:00:09whether there was some kind of contribution to
- 1:00:11that particular asset. So for instance, suppose
- 1:00:14his or her wages were then used to pay down the
- 1:00:18mortgage or something like that, or improvements
- 1:00:20to the property. Consider whether the... there's
- 1:00:24the possibility of gaining some kind of equitable
- 1:00:26interest in the property, which then potentially
- 1:00:29could be subject that the trustee may want to
- 1:00:32look at or claim an interest in. But in the absence
- 1:00:35of that, I mean, if you've got separate property
- 1:00:37and you're really clear about that, then you'd
- 1:00:38want to be, in the bankruptcy context, you'd
- 1:00:40want to make the argument or be clear as to the
- 1:00:44schedules and whether it's considered, whether
- 1:00:47they're characterizing it as somehow a community
- 1:00:49property asset. and then, in a sense, dialogue
- 1:00:55with the trustee or maybe need to seek relief
- 1:00:57in the bankruptcy case in order to get some declaratory
- 1:01:01relief or some kind of resolution of that issue
- 1:01:04if that comes up. All right. Thank you. And let's
- 1:01:10see. Can the prevailing party's legal fees be
- 1:01:15added to the lien claimed or are all these added
- 1:01:18fees? Or all these other fees get cut off as
- 1:01:22of the BKY filing date Like I guess it depends
- 1:01:32in part that may depend on Your attorney for
- 1:01:36whom I mean, I would argue if you have a lien
- 1:01:38if you have a lien that it could cover pre and
- 1:01:44Pre and post petition fees. In the Bush case,
- 1:01:48for instance, they found that the charging lien
- 1:01:51applied not only to pre -petition, but post -petition
- 1:01:54fees. The other side tried to argue that it didn't
- 1:01:58apply to post -petition fees, but the bankruptcy
- 1:02:01court in that case anyway, in dealing with the
- 1:02:04real property and it being in a exempted real
- 1:02:07property felt that it didn't impact the bankruptcy
- 1:02:09at all because it was, it was a lien on exempt
- 1:02:12property. Um, a little bit more fact intent,
- 1:02:15you know, it's really kind of depends on the
- 1:02:17facts, but I certainly would argue if you have
- 1:02:19a lien that goes through, it does. If you are,
- 1:02:21if you're representing, um, um, your client who
- 1:02:25then files bankruptcy, you, you, there's a pre
- 1:02:28-petition stuff, but you may want to work out
- 1:02:32an alternative agreement, like in the context
- 1:02:34of the bankruptcy, maybe to be employed by the
- 1:02:36bankruptcy estate in order to be sure of getting
- 1:02:41your fees paid post -petition. I'd want to look
- 1:02:45at that and not rely on a pre -petition fee agreement
- 1:02:48because I have seen situations where there is
- 1:02:51some talk, as I alluded to, about whether that's
- 1:02:54an executive contract, meaning duties and obligations
- 1:02:57on both sides and in the bankruptcy context,
- 1:03:00whether that can be kind of assumed, if you will,
- 1:03:03meaning kind of taking on the responsibilities
- 1:03:05or it ends up being kind of rejected. So those
- 1:03:09are some things to think about, I would suggest.
- 1:03:14So we have some more questions. One from John
- 1:03:18asks, if not a divorce and one person files,
- 1:03:22is the entire community a state subject to trustee
- 1:03:25action? If there's not a divorce and there's
- 1:03:30community property, then community property is
- 1:03:33considered a part of the bankruptcy estate. That
- 1:03:36will be adjudicated in the bankruptcy if there's
- 1:03:40not a pending divorce. Another is the withdrawal
- 1:03:47from an individual retirement account subject
- 1:03:50to automatic stay. Short answers, I don't know,
- 1:03:58but I think retirement funds are maybe exempt.
- 1:04:03Except from property of the estate. I'm not sure
- 1:04:08the question for anyone that I'm not, you know,
- 1:04:11if you have follow up questions to those who
- 1:04:13have asked questions and you want to have more
- 1:04:16fulsome discussion, happy to have that offline.
- 1:04:19All right, so it looks like we just have a couple
- 1:04:21more. Are there any state bar rules that bar
- 1:04:24these recorded lien rights? Well, certainly one
- 1:04:33could do a deeper dive on that. I think I only
- 1:04:35more aware of the charging lien and the charging
- 1:04:37lien has certain. Under the fee agreement, there
- 1:04:41are certain requirements in order to have a charging
- 1:04:44lien. And certainly we've talked about the family
- 1:04:47law provisions, which is under California law
- 1:04:49as well. There may be other obligations, but
- 1:04:52those are the ones that I'm most aware of. And
- 1:04:56what is the sentence or paragraph you recommend
- 1:04:59in a fee agreement and must an independent counsel
- 1:05:02review and bless it? I'm happy to talk offline
- 1:05:07about that, but yeah. Okay, so it looks like
- 1:05:13that's just about it for questions. If you do
- 1:05:16have any more questions, feel free to reach out
- 1:05:17to Mr. Menton at his email address provided on
- 1:05:21the slide. Thank you so much, Mr. Menton, for
- 1:05:23your time today and thank you so much for our
- 1:05:25audience for joining us. Have a good afternoon,
- 1:05:27everybody. Thank you.