Latest / Crime Stories with Nancy Grace / YOUNG GIRL SADE ROBINSON 'EXCITED' ABOUT DATE WITH SPOILED BRAT KILLER

Transcript

YOUNG GIRL SADE ROBINSON 'EXCITED' ABOUT DATE WITH SPOILED BRAT KILLER · Crime Stories with Nancy Grace

0:00
Speaker 1: Study.
0:01
Speaker 2: It is beautiful, beautiful soul.
0:04
Speaker 3: Date turned murder, date to homicide, to dismemberment to scattering
0:11
Speaker 3: human remains.
0:12
Speaker 4: Park goer reports finding a severed human leg.
0:15
Speaker 5: Then there's another finding, Then there's another one. Four total
0:19
Speaker 5: parts human remains.
0:20
Speaker 6: Tonight into the mind of a human butcher.
0:30
Speaker 4: Five point thirty pm, April second cuta Hey Police respond
0:33
Speaker 4: to a call along Lake Michigan at Warnamont Park, a
0:36
Speaker 4: popular recreation area. A park goer reports finding a severed
0:40
Speaker 4: human leg.
0:41
Speaker 7: Three days after the Warnamont Park discovery, another call to
0:44
Speaker 7: police about a severed body part. Eleven miles away from
0:48
Speaker 7: the shores of Lake Michigan, in a Milwaukee West Side neighborhood,
0:51
Speaker 7: a body part is found at a playground. Within twenty
0:55
Speaker 7: four hours, police respond to another call about the discovery
0:58
Speaker 7: of human remains.
1:01
Speaker 6: After a car is found on fire, paired with a
1:08
Speaker 6: pet tribute blanket found near some of the human remains,
1:16
Speaker 6: Police begin to focus on a beautiful young teen girl,
1:23
Speaker 6: shaw day Listen.
1:26
Speaker 8: Shade Robinson graduates with honors a semester early from Riverside
1:30
Speaker 8: High School. She continues her education at Milwaukee Area Technical College,
1:34
Speaker 8: working towards her associate's degree in criminal justice. In fact,
1:38
Speaker 8: she's only a month away from graduating. But Robinson hasn't
1:41
Speaker 8: been spending all her times in the books. She works
1:43
Speaker 8: through high school and college at the Pizza Shuttle on
1:46
Speaker 8: Milwaukee's Lower East Side. She makes such a difference at
1:48
Speaker 8: work that her coworkers say Robinson is considered the heart
1:51
Speaker 8: of Pizza Shuttle. Former owner Mark Gold says she is
1:54
Speaker 8: the type of employee who never calls out and is
1:57
Speaker 8: loved by customers and our coworkers.
1:59
Speaker 6: In a I just she's everything you want your child
2:08
Speaker 6: to be. She's this fantastic student, she is working while
2:16
Speaker 6: she's going to school, very close family, tons of relatives
2:23
Speaker 6: in the military, and she is inspired to consider the
2:30
Speaker 6: US Air Force. I mean, this is the girl we
2:36
Speaker 6: all want to have. And just look at her. I
2:42
Speaker 6: remember my grandmother. I would give her my school picture
2:45
Speaker 6: every year and she could say, I can just see
2:48
Speaker 6: see the mischief coming out of your eyes. Look at
2:52
Speaker 6: this girl. Can't you just see the joy, just the
2:57
Speaker 6: love of life, crackling, smart, just beaming out of her.
3:06
Speaker 6: How in the world did she collide cross paths with
3:12
Speaker 6: an alleged spoiled brat killer The son of a Milwaukee millionaire,
3:20
Speaker 6: a former ex high school football star now a thirty
3:26
Speaker 6: something meter bartender. You know what I want to get
3:32
Speaker 6: off him and back to shah Day. Let me see
3:35
Speaker 6: that beautiful face again, Liz. I want to see that
3:40
Speaker 6: picture of shah Day in her. Look at her. I
3:46
Speaker 6: like the one of her in her. She's at home.
3:49
Speaker 6: There's a big cross on the wall behind her, and
3:51
Speaker 6: she's got on her she's getting ready for captain their
3:55
Speaker 6: Oh my goodness, joining me is a very special guest
4:01
Speaker 6: along with an all star panel. This is Shawde's mother,
4:07
Speaker 6: Miss Gina Scarborough. I didn't know you were going to
4:20
Speaker 6: hold that up and just showing that says it all.
4:27
Speaker 6: It just says it all, you know, miss miss Scarborough.
4:31
Speaker 6: Whenever I have to travel for work, my backpack is
4:36
Speaker 6: so heavy because I have all these mementos of the
4:40
Speaker 6: twins I carry with me and set up wherever I am.
4:44
Speaker 2: No I heard you talking about it. It's just told
4:49
Speaker 2: me to think that you have this picture instead of
4:52
Speaker 2: your girl.
4:54
Speaker 6: First of all, tell me about shaw Day Shady.
4:58
Speaker 2: This is beautiful, beautiful soul. I know that my kids
5:04
Speaker 2: were very special and different. They my parents raised me.
5:11
Speaker 2: They raised us. We are light workers. We put out
5:16
Speaker 2: positive energy, we exert we help others. I'm a community
5:21
Speaker 2: advocate as a personal way of my life, the way
5:26
Speaker 2: I live, I've worked for others. I help others my
5:30
Speaker 2: whole life. I've raised my daughters that way. My daughters
5:33
Speaker 2: have excelled. I have two daughters. This has called so much.
5:38
Speaker 9: Emotional effect to my family or her, my parents who
5:43
Speaker 9: love my baby so much, her grandparents, her uncles, her aunties,
5:48
Speaker 9: the community, everyone has pulled up. This has affected many
5:52
Speaker 9: people in Milwaukee. I'm come here today. This is the
5:57
Speaker 9: hardest thing I would ever have to do life to
6:00
Speaker 9: speak Shaddai's voice.
6:02
Speaker 2: Shadai was a beautiful soul. She was an amazing girl. Nancy,
6:07
Speaker 2: everything he spoke is exactly what my daughter exerted. I
6:11
Speaker 2: couldn't have asked for any better daughter. There was things
6:16
Speaker 2: my daughter did that many adults were not even able
6:21
Speaker 2: to accomplished in their lifetimes. And I'll be forty three
6:26
Speaker 2: in a week. My birthday's life twenty seven Shoty's birthdays
6:31
Speaker 2: on May the tenth. I had her on Mother's Day.
6:35
Speaker 2: The son of a I'm gonna watch my language on
6:39
Speaker 2: this platform. The son of a took my darter from
6:44
Speaker 2: me a month before. She's graduating with her Associate of
6:49
Speaker 2: Artist degree. She works so hard. She's a full time student,
6:53
Speaker 2: she has two full time jobs. She has her own
6:56
Speaker 2: little bachelor red apartment. She doesn't stay in a college
7:00
Speaker 2: on campus. She has her own bacherette department. She has
7:03
Speaker 2: her own car. She pays all of her own pills.
7:06
Speaker 9: This is trauma sizing, Nancy. I never expect this is
7:12
Speaker 9: the pull up on my front door.
7:15
Speaker 2: This is a normal This is a twenty twenty four
7:18
Speaker 2: Jeffrey Dahmer. I need him held accountable. I need justice
7:23
Speaker 2: for Shada Hey. There has been a lot of in
7:27
Speaker 2: the many black and brown girls that I've been called
7:30
Speaker 2: missing in Milwaukee for a moment, and all of them
7:35
Speaker 2: are gonna be held accountable now because they put they
7:39
Speaker 2: mess with the wrong family, they mess with the wrong family.
7:42
Speaker 2: Because we're not gonna stick wide and we're not gonna
7:45
Speaker 2: sit still, and we're gonna call all of them out
7:47
Speaker 2: and we're gonna speak for the whole community because I'm
7:50
Speaker 2: not about to sit down and I'm not about to
7:51
Speaker 2: sit still on this one. It's justice for Shade, Nancy.
7:56
Speaker 6: It's justice missus Scarborough. I feel like anything anything I
8:08
Speaker 6: or anybody on this panel could say right now, it
8:14
Speaker 6: pales compared to what you just said. And believe me,
8:20
Speaker 6: miss Scarborough, this story of shah Day has not just
8:26
Speaker 6: touched people in Milwaukee. It has touched people around the world.
8:32
Speaker 6: And when you say you're not going to sit back,
8:36
Speaker 6: neither are we until there is justice for your girl
8:41
Speaker 6: and the other missing and murdered girls across Milwaukee. They're
8:48
Speaker 6: not all just missing, they're dead. Many exactly are dead.
8:58
Speaker 6: Guys with me is shy Day's mother who this is
9:04
Speaker 6: so much pain, but she is joining us tonight to
9:09
Speaker 6: speak out for shah Day. What happened? What led up
9:17
Speaker 6: to this night?
9:22
Speaker 2: Yes, Nancy, this is yes Nancy. The last time I
9:27
Speaker 2: spoke to my daughter was on Easter Sunday. Okay, we've
9:31
Speaker 2: seen her. She came by my parents' home. We spent
9:35
Speaker 2: the Sunday together. This was Easter Sunday.
9:39
Speaker 10: Okay.
9:41
Speaker 2: I cooked for them, both of my daughters. We all
9:44
Speaker 2: met by my parents' house where I'm currying the at
9:47
Speaker 2: We all commute here. All my girls are busy. They're
9:51
Speaker 2: my youngest is sixteen. They have a lot of activities.
9:54
Speaker 2: They're working, they go to school. I have very successful
9:57
Speaker 2: and independent, self sufficient ar We harm her nobody. We
10:02
Speaker 2: just put out and help others into the universe. Okay,
10:06
Speaker 2: So I seem like she it's just very It's like
10:11
Speaker 2: she's a nineteen twenty year old young lady. Okay, we
10:15
Speaker 2: all at this age. We have a lot of friends.
10:18
Speaker 2: She's not in a relationship. She didn't have a boyfriend.
10:21
Speaker 2: She wasn't tied down to anyone. She's single and she's dating.
10:24
Speaker 2: I knew she hung out with her coworkers at Pizza Shuttle.
10:29
Speaker 2: They went out to little bars and hung out sometimes.
10:32
Speaker 2: I'm a very concerned mother. I'm very overperspective. I always
10:36
Speaker 2: would put in Shota's ear and be careful. I don't
10:39
Speaker 2: trust these people around Milwaukee. I'm just that extra type
10:43
Speaker 2: of mom, and my daughter's always mom. Just sit back.
10:46
Speaker 2: I try to give them space, let them be independent.
10:49
Speaker 2: But I just been having this vibe and intuition and
10:53
Speaker 2: I have been wanting her just to like not hang
10:55
Speaker 2: out and go out to places for some reason. And
10:59
Speaker 2: I don't know exactly, and I'm still trying to find
11:01
Speaker 2: out the facts, but I know that this type of
11:06
Speaker 2: this individual, and I want to make clarity because there's
11:09
Speaker 2: been a lot of trolls. There's been a lot of media.
11:12
Speaker 2: I can't interact and deal with. I'm grieving my daughter
11:15
Speaker 2: right now. I want respects. I need time. They're claiming
11:20
Speaker 2: this was a first day, like you know, it's just
11:23
Speaker 2: a first date. I don't this. Dude never she never
11:26
Speaker 2: mentioned as dude says, and I'm learning.
11:30
Speaker 6: A little bit about that. We're learning a little bit
11:33
Speaker 6: about that. Take a listen to Dave Matt crime o Coon.
11:37
Speaker 4: A month away from turning twenty, Shade Robinson tells a
11:40
Speaker 4: maintenance worker at her building that she's excited about her
11:43
Speaker 4: first date with thirty three year old Maxwell Anderson. Robinson
11:46
Speaker 4: texts Anderson about where to eat and tells him she's
11:50
Speaker 4: feeling seafood. Anderson takes Shaw day to a place he
11:53
Speaker 4: used to work, the Twisted Fishermen. After dinner, they spend
11:56
Speaker 4: some more time together, having drinks at Duke's on Water.
12:00
Speaker 4: Believes dukes together around nine pm.
12:04
Speaker 6: Straight out to Alexis Tereschug joining us Crime online dot
12:07
Speaker 6: Com investigative reporter, how do we know that they were
12:10
Speaker 6: together that night?
12:13
Speaker 5: They met there? There are multiple surveillance cameras outside these restaurants,
12:17
Speaker 5: both of them that show her arriving walking through the
12:22
Speaker 5: east side of the restaurant. He arrived on the west
12:24
Speaker 5: side of There's such good video footage of this. This
12:27
Speaker 5: is just such a good helpful part of the case.
12:30
Speaker 5: They go there together. He used to work there at
12:33
Speaker 5: the Twisted Fishermen. So the bartender there spoke with police
12:37
Speaker 5: and said they came in. They sat at the bar together,
12:40
Speaker 5: they had a drink. It seemed friendly and casual, nothing
12:45
Speaker 5: that would alert the bartender to anything that was wrong.
12:48
Speaker 5: He said, they just had a few drinks and they
12:50
Speaker 5: left within an hour.
12:51
Speaker 6: To miss Scarborough. This is shaw Dai's mother. When did
12:56
Speaker 6: somebody realize they needed to call you and ask we
13:00
Speaker 6: are a shaw Dah.
13:02
Speaker 2: Yeah, So it was Wednesday, Nancy. I was at my job.
13:06
Speaker 2: I went to work that morning.
13:08
Speaker 10: I got off.
13:09
Speaker 2: As soon as I got home from work, I was
13:12
Speaker 2: receiving calls from like my.
13:15
Speaker 10: My my mother, and my brother.
13:16
Speaker 2: We were all concerned because we all have the three
13:20
Speaker 2: sixty location app. Okay, we all share it as the family.
13:23
Speaker 2: So I have the app shared with me, my mom,
13:26
Speaker 2: both of my daughters. Then my daughter also shares shade.
13:30
Speaker 2: My oldest daughter also shares the app with additional friends.
13:34
Speaker 2: Monday morning, I've seen her getting ready for work. She
13:37
Speaker 2: facetimed me. Then she that evening around three forty five,
13:41
Speaker 2: four o'clock, I got a text message from her asking
13:44
Speaker 2: a cash app for fifteen dollars. My daughters does not
13:47
Speaker 2: ask me for money like she has. My daughter makes
13:50
Speaker 2: more money to me. Literally she's that was that bass? Okay?
13:55
Speaker 2: So like those in a big deal, I'm just that
13:58
Speaker 2: type of mom. You need something, I'm going cash happy.
14:01
Speaker 6: So you get this test asking for fifteen dollars and
14:04
Speaker 6: Shawdey would never have done that. I mean she needed
14:09
Speaker 6: she could a charge Apple, pay you name it. So
14:12
Speaker 6: you knew right then something was wrong. And then this
14:17
Speaker 6: take a listen to Chief Jeffrey Norman.
14:21
Speaker 11: On Saturday, April six, MPD continued the search of in
14:26
Speaker 11: the area and located additional human remains on the railroad tracks.
14:31
Speaker 11: Lead you know. Saturday April six, MPD returned to the
14:34
Speaker 11: area when Miss Robinson's family located her blanket. At this time,
14:40
Speaker 11: do you take us located additional human remains.
14:43
Speaker 12: According to court documents, the remains found Saturday included human
14:47
Speaker 12: flesh and a foot. The foot had pink nail polish,
14:50
Speaker 12: possibly mounting the polish on the leg found days earlier.
14:55
Speaker 6: Joseph Scott Morgan, renowned professor of forensics, Jacksonville State Universe.
15:00
Speaker 6: We're talking about a severed leg and a severed arm,
15:06
Speaker 6: and somebody at the medical examiners went, look the fingernail
15:10
Speaker 6: polished matches. I don't need DNA. A jury's not gonna
15:14
Speaker 6: need DNA, but they're gonna have it.
15:16
Speaker 13: Why because every contact, as you mentioned, does in fact
15:22
Speaker 13: leave a trace. We've known that for over one hundred
15:24
Speaker 13: years now, and it's coming to fruition here in the
15:27
Speaker 13: world in which we inhabit. DNA is going to play
15:30
Speaker 13: a big role in this, and we're talking about proximity Nancy.
15:35
Speaker 13: With the alleged perpetrator here, he will have had a
15:39
Speaker 13: very intimate contact. Unfortunately with Shade, just this idea of
15:45
Speaker 13: dismemberment alone is going to leave a trace behind. And
15:49
Speaker 13: it's not necessarily his trace on her as much as
15:53
Speaker 13: it will be her trace on him potentially, and ultimately
15:58
Speaker 13: it could be her shaw Day that actually brings him
16:05
Speaker 13: to justice. Her DNA will be found on him, and
16:09
Speaker 13: it will be pointing a big, accusing finger back at him.
16:17
Speaker 14: On Wednesday, April the fourth, our investigation led to a
16:22
Speaker 14: person of interest, Maxwell Stephen Anderson, who lives in the
16:27
Speaker 14: thirty one hundred block of South thirty ninth Street, where
16:31
Speaker 14: he was arrested after a traffic stop near the home.
16:37
Speaker 14: A search warrant was conducted.
16:40
Speaker 6: Not only did blood evidence emerge in his home, this guy,
16:47
Speaker 6: this idiot technical legal term, left a phone trail a
16:53
Speaker 6: mile white. You know, when you look at his home,
16:56
Speaker 6: you think, wow, beautiful yard and acculately kept. You know,
17:01
Speaker 6: why not because of him? Thirty three year old former
17:06
Speaker 6: high school football star. He's a nepo baby, nepotism baby.
17:12
Speaker 6: This thirty three year old guy, Maxwell Anderson has a
17:17
Speaker 6: millionaire dad who ran a Milwaukee insurance brokerage firm. Now
17:24
Speaker 6: what do we know about him?
17:26
Speaker 5: Alexis Tereschuk, He has a rap sheet. He has been
17:32
Speaker 5: arrested for domestic I'm sorry, not just arrested, convicted for
17:36
Speaker 5: domestic abuse, for disorderly conduct, and for drunk driving. This
17:41
Speaker 5: guy has a rap sheet a mile long. He is
17:45
Speaker 5: not an upstanding citizen of the community. And as I said,
17:47
Speaker 5: these are not just arrests we're waiting to hear from.
17:50
Speaker 5: He has been convicted of all three of these things.
17:53
Speaker 6: Let me talk about this guy. Police find a foot
18:01
Speaker 6: apparent apparently human flesh at a playground, pink nail posh
18:07
Speaker 6: matching up. In the home, they find blood, gasoline containers,
18:15
Speaker 6: packages addressed to the defendant, very important, blood on a comforter,
18:21
Speaker 6: blood scattered throughout the home. Let me tell you this,
18:25
Speaker 6: and I'm going to go to you. Fattus with me,
18:27
Speaker 6: high profile trial lawyer, TV legal analysts, founding partner of
18:32
Speaker 6: the Warner Fattus elite legal group. Eric, this isn't his
18:37
Speaker 6: first time at the rodeo. You don't go from zero
18:43
Speaker 6: to one twenty mph in two seconds. There has to
18:48
Speaker 6: be something some revving up up to not only a murderer,
18:54
Speaker 6: but a luring, luring her onto a day. How many
18:58
Speaker 6: times do you think he watched her come in, have
19:01
Speaker 6: a drink, have dinner, anything like that, before he gets
19:05
Speaker 6: the guts up and say hey, would you like to
19:07
Speaker 6: go to dinner? He planned this? What about it? Eric?
19:12
Speaker 3: Yeah, Nancy, It's chilling to think about what was going
19:15
Speaker 3: through Maxwell Anderson's mind allegedly as he appears to have
19:19
Speaker 3: been preparing for this. You know, the details give rise
19:22
Speaker 3: to a predatory nature. Here there's a huge age gap, right,
19:27
Speaker 3: and then there's also a friend who says that Maxwell
19:29
Speaker 3: Anderson had a five foot by six foot deep hole
19:32
Speaker 3: dug in his backyard. And then we look at the rapidity,
19:36
Speaker 3: how quickly this turning from a murder to dismemberment in
19:41
Speaker 3: a like Overnight.
19:43
Speaker 8: A neighbor's security camera shows two figures entering Anderson's backyard
19:47
Speaker 8: at nine twenty four pm. At twelve forty seven am,
19:50
Speaker 8: a street camera shows Robinson's card departing Anderson's home. A
19:55
Speaker 8: camera at Cutahey High School shows a car drive toward
19:58
Speaker 8: the pumphouse at Warnamont Park at two fifty three am,
20:02
Speaker 8: a figure is seen walking from the road and climbing
20:05
Speaker 8: down the bluff to the beach several times. At four
20:09
Speaker 8: thirty one am, the car leaves the park. Three hours later,
20:13
Speaker 8: bus surveillance catches a man carrying a tan backpack walking
20:17
Speaker 8: away from a fire at thirtieth and Lisbon. At eight
20:21
Speaker 8: twelve am, Anderson, carrying a tan backpack, is seen boarding
20:25
Speaker 8: a bus heading toward his home. Anderson gets off at
20:29
Speaker 8: eight thirty five am and enters his backyard eight minutes later.
20:35
Speaker 6: Miss Scarborough, you haven't even been able to have a
20:39
Speaker 6: funeral yet.
20:41
Speaker 2: Why, yes, that's correct, Nancy. This is probably the hardest
20:47
Speaker 2: part that we're struggling with right now. I'm trying to
20:51
Speaker 2: find peace playing my daughter to arrests Yick salizh.
20:57
Speaker 1: Just give her her transition she deserves because she was
21:01
Speaker 1: taken to soon. My baby was only she didn't even
21:06
Speaker 1: make twenty. She was twenty in a few weeks. I
21:08
Speaker 1: made its tenth Nancy. They don't. They can't even provide
21:12
Speaker 1: us with a death certificate right now. They don't even
21:16
Speaker 1: know the cause of my Darter's death. They don't know
21:19
Speaker 1: when they're not giving me enough information, Nancy, this is
21:24
Speaker 1: so frustrating. There is no closure right now for me
21:29
Speaker 1: and my family.
21:33
Speaker 15: As volunteer searchers try to locate all of teen girl
21:36
Speaker 15: shot A Robinson's remains a fourth set of body parts,
21:40
Speaker 15: this time at a remote tree line stretch of beach
21:42
Speaker 15: along South Michigan. Just after seven am, someone walking along
21:46
Speaker 15: a South Milwaukee waterline discovered and arm and torso the
21:51
Speaker 15: remains washed ashore about a quarter of a mile from
21:53
Speaker 15: a nearby apartment complex.
21:57
Speaker 6: This is the fourth set of remains time a torso.
22:02
Speaker 6: What else is missing? How to Aaron Maybin, investigative reporter
22:06
Speaker 6: and anchor for Fox six in Milwaukee, erin thank you
22:10
Speaker 6: for being with us. There's so much happening and so
22:13
Speaker 6: quickly in the Shade Robinson case. But first I want
22:17
Speaker 6: to go to the torso. We have a torso, a
22:22
Speaker 6: female torso that has washed up, so to speak. We
22:27
Speaker 6: have unidentified blood, Aaron Maybin, this is blood on betting
22:34
Speaker 6: going up the wall from the basement. And we know
22:39
Speaker 6: that the basement now uncovered was a sex dungeon, and
22:45
Speaker 6: blood elsewhere in the whole blood where it shouldn't be
22:49
Speaker 6: in the normal course of one's routine. So with all
22:53
Speaker 6: of this happening, I can't help but wonder are there
22:57
Speaker 6: more victims? Since that blood does not match shah Day
23:01
Speaker 6: and we have reason to believe it doesn't match the defendant,
23:05
Speaker 6: the suspect. But back to the torso. Tell me everything.
23:09
Speaker 16: Well, you know, this all began with a severed leg
23:12
Speaker 16: at a parking Kutahy and it just sparked so much mystery,
23:16
Speaker 16: and that's what this case has been, Nancy, A ton
23:19
Speaker 16: of mystery. Where are these body parts first off coming
23:23
Speaker 16: from and then we later learned that it is Shade
23:25
Speaker 16: Robinson who's been a missing girl. The latest was that
23:29
Speaker 16: arm in Torso that washed up on shore. Someone was
23:33
Speaker 16: walking along the beach Nancy and they found this arm
23:37
Speaker 16: in Torso. Now let's go back to that separate leg
23:39
Speaker 16: because these places where they were found really not close
23:43
Speaker 16: to each other. They're a few miles away, about a
23:46
Speaker 16: ten minute drive from each other. And police were quickly
23:49
Speaker 16: able to identify that this arm and Torso were that
23:53
Speaker 16: of Shade Robinson's.
23:54
Speaker 6: There's a very strong possibility that there are other victims.
23:58
Speaker 6: And you know where I'm going with this, Aaron Mabon.
24:01
Speaker 6: If you don't know a horse, look at his track record.
24:05
Speaker 6: Has he put other victims? Specifically? Who was that grave
24:10
Speaker 6: Doug for in his backyard? Whose blood is that on
24:13
Speaker 6: his wall? Who else had been in that sex torture
24:17
Speaker 6: chamber that he had in his basement? So if he
24:20
Speaker 6: put part of shah Day in the water, ergo has
24:26
Speaker 6: he put other victims in the water? See where I'm
24:28
Speaker 6: going with this.
24:29
Speaker 16: We know that right now police are just searching for
24:31
Speaker 16: Shady Robinson in connection to Maxwell Anderson. They swabbed betting.
24:36
Speaker 16: They swabbed a wall in the basement. We know that
24:40
Speaker 16: that blood was not shaw De Robinson's DNA.
24:45
Speaker 6: Speaking of searching the home, listen to this.
24:49
Speaker 12: Maxwell Anderson had a sex dungeon in the basement of
24:53
Speaker 12: his West Milwaukee home. According to a law enforcement source,
24:56
Speaker 12: cops found a sex sling restraints in handcoff Us, A
25:00
Speaker 12: close friend of Anderson said that on a visit to
25:03
Speaker 12: Anderson's home last year, he noticed a large hole in
25:05
Speaker 12: the ground that was about five feet long by six
25:07
Speaker 12: foot deep. Anderson said he was working on an underground basement,
25:11
Speaker 12: despite having a large basement in the home already. Neighbors
25:14
Speaker 12: say the basement in the home had small windows that
25:16
Speaker 12: were always covered so you could not see inside.
25:20
Speaker 6: Joining us right now, Crime online dot Com investigative reporter
25:23
Speaker 6: Sidney Sumner, Sidney, thank you for being with us. Sidney,
25:28
Speaker 6: what can you tell me about gas cans being found
25:31
Speaker 6: in the suspects home? And I want to just ask
25:35
Speaker 6: one more time about the blood, the location of the blood.
25:41
Speaker 17: Nancy, they found those gas cans and the blood stains
25:44
Speaker 17: on that search warrant from April fourth. Gas cans were
25:47
Speaker 17: found in the garage and that just further corroborates that
25:51
Speaker 17: Anderson is responsible for that car fire. We remember he
25:55
Speaker 17: was seen entering a bus just after the fire started,
26:00
Speaker 17: a ten backpack matching multiple witness descriptions, and that blood
26:05
Speaker 17: again was found on betting, on a comforter, and on
26:09
Speaker 17: the wall of a stairwell leading down to the basement
26:12
Speaker 17: where that sex dungeon apparently is.
26:17
Speaker 6: I mean, I guess I need to shrink on this one,
26:20
Speaker 6: Attorney Eric Faddis. But who digs a grave in the
26:24
Speaker 6: backyard and doesn't use it? What is that? What's that exactly?
26:33
Speaker 3: I mean, you don't need a PhD to find out
26:35
Speaker 3: kind of what a person's intention was. It's a five
26:38
Speaker 3: feet by six feet grave. It's a human body size.
26:44
Speaker 4: Footage from inside the unfinished basement the police have called
26:47
Speaker 4: a sex dungeon shows it's in disarray. A large hole
26:51
Speaker 4: has been dug in the concrete floor, A drain in
26:53
Speaker 4: the floor is stuff with towels. The drink cover marked
26:56
Speaker 4: with evidence numbers. A door without a handle leads to
26:59
Speaker 4: a dark closet, and there are several tables that chair
27:02
Speaker 4: and exercise equipment. The mattress of a queen bed frame
27:05
Speaker 4: is flipped on its side and betting is tossed over
27:07
Speaker 4: a table in the corner of the room.
27:12
Speaker 6: You are seeing footage that we have managed to obtain
27:16
Speaker 6: of the underground torture chamber as it has been described.
27:22
Speaker 6: But there is more more than what you are seeing.
27:28
Speaker 6: From a hack saw to a circular saw, to a
27:31
Speaker 6: power drill, a grave dug in the backyard, various sex
27:39
Speaker 6: paraphernalia all found, and this underground bunker belonging to the
27:45
Speaker 6: son of a Milwaukee millionaire. We also learned that he
27:50
Speaker 6: was in fact digging another underground layer. What if anything
27:58
Speaker 6: will this reveal? And joining us now is Shadet's father,
28:03
Speaker 6: mister Carlos Robinson. Mister Robinson, thank you for being with us.
28:10
Speaker 6: Thank you, mister Robinson. When did you learn that Shahdat
28:18
Speaker 6: had been killed?
28:21
Speaker 18: H for sure when the DNA came back as a
28:26
Speaker 18: match to mine. When she was missing, I was hopefully
28:35
Speaker 18: she was still here.
28:37
Speaker 6: Up until that point. Did you believe that she was
28:40
Speaker 6: just missing, that she would be found.
28:43
Speaker 19: That's what I was praying for her.
28:45
Speaker 18: She would be found, that the body parts wasn't hers,
28:49
Speaker 18: and that she is going to be found.
28:52
Speaker 6: Mister Robinson, there was a moment where a volunteer, not police,
28:58
Speaker 6: but a volunteer discover, as it's being called, a pet
29:02
Speaker 6: tribute blanket and it was found wet and dirty and
29:06
Speaker 6: filthy in a park area, a part for children area,
29:13
Speaker 6: and nearby were human body parts. When you heard her blanket,
29:21
Speaker 6: her little pet tribute blanket had been found, what went
29:25
Speaker 6: through your mind?
29:27
Speaker 18: All of this is en comprehensible, you know, I don't
29:31
Speaker 18: understand how the community, and I appreciate everything.
29:33
Speaker 19: That they're doing, how they can find a blanket that
29:36
Speaker 19: was already searched by an area that was already searched
29:40
Speaker 19: by the the authorities.
29:44
Speaker 6: Was it, mister Robinson. Had that area been thoroughly searched
29:49
Speaker 6: by authorities, because it's my understanding volunteers found body parts
29:56
Speaker 6: as well.
29:58
Speaker 11: Yeah.
29:59
Speaker 18: I talked to the police after they the blanket was found,
30:05
Speaker 18: and I asked them why they didn't find it, because
30:09
Speaker 18: they told me they searched that area previously. I've been
30:12
Speaker 18: here since eleven o'clock last night. I haven't been asleep.
30:19
Speaker 18: I've been to the parts, I've been all over the flashlights,
30:24
Speaker 18: a binoculars, and I just don't feel like I can sleep.
30:29
Speaker 19: I just need to I just want to find it.
30:31
Speaker 18: You know, there's only two body parts left that we
30:36
Speaker 18: have found, and I just want to put her the
30:40
Speaker 18: rest properly. I keep having dreams about it. I just
30:45
Speaker 18: want her to at least rest in peace. Oh huh,
30:49
Speaker 18: and uh I can't. I can't do that until I
30:53
Speaker 18: have her a together. H They won't even let me
30:59
Speaker 18: see the body as they have because you said it's evidence.
31:05
Speaker 18: So uh, I'm just trying to do what I can
31:09
Speaker 18: do to find hope that she leads me to her.
31:15
Speaker 6: Mister Robinson, Oh, just thank you so much for speaking
31:22
Speaker 6: with us today because I know your heart is breaking
31:26
Speaker 6: and you have been looking through the night out with
31:29
Speaker 6: a flashlight trying to find your daughter her body parts.
31:36
Speaker 6: Tell me about Shade in life.
31:42
Speaker 19: My baby girl was an amazing person. She was.
31:50
Speaker 20: She was full of love. She was a giver. She
31:55
Speaker 20: would give it a shirt off for me. She had
32:00
Speaker 20: a very good heart.
32:01
Speaker 19: She was intelligent, mister Robinson.
32:04
Speaker 6: What did she want to be when she got out
32:06
Speaker 6: of college? What did she want to do?
32:09
Speaker 19: Her goal was to be a lawyer.
32:11
Speaker 18: Ultimately she was graduating from criminal justice, all right, but
32:20
Speaker 18: she was she was torn between military and being a lawyer.
32:25
Speaker 18: But she always wanted to be a lawyer.
32:27
Speaker 6: How proud of her? Were you? Going to college? Paying
32:33
Speaker 6: her way? Working? I mean, this girl did it all?
32:40
Speaker 19: Yeah, she did. She did. She was a very independent
32:47
Speaker 19: minded person. She would call me and tell me, you
32:56
Speaker 19: know that I'm doing this or I'm doing that.
32:59
Speaker 6: You stated that two body parts have not been found.
33:03
Speaker 6: What part of shah Day has not been found?
33:09
Speaker 19: Her head and one of her arms?
33:15
Speaker 6: Sir? When you learned that she was quote excited about
33:22
Speaker 6: her date with this Milwaukee millionaire son, what goes through
33:28
Speaker 6: your mind?
33:32
Speaker 18: None of it makes sense to me. She did not
33:39
Speaker 18: seem this guy was not her type at all. I
33:44
Speaker 18: don't know how he got her to come to his house,
33:48
Speaker 18: but that's not something I could see my daughter doing,
33:53
Speaker 18: especially with somebody she didn't know.
33:55
Speaker 6: Mister Robinson, we are learning about this guy underground torture chamber.
34:07
Speaker 6: What goes through your mind when you hear about that?
34:13
Speaker 6: I think my father would just lay down on the
34:15
Speaker 6: ground and cry.
34:18
Speaker 19: It takes a different kind of evil to do something
34:20
Speaker 19: like this.
34:24
Speaker 6: Joining me right now is a very special guest, a
34:27
Speaker 6: woman I now consider a friend, Sena Scarborough. This is
34:32
Speaker 6: Shawde's mother. How do you keep putting one foot in
34:40
Speaker 6: front of the other.
34:42
Speaker 2: Oh yes, Nancy, this is so challenging daily I don't
34:51
Speaker 2: know how I'm doing it. I'm walking and shuddy spirit
34:54
Speaker 2: and in her grace. I am her voice. I have
34:59
Speaker 2: to speak an advocate through her for others.
35:04
Speaker 10: This is not something that just like pulled up and happened.
35:13
Speaker 10: I don't know.
35:14
Speaker 2: This is a waking nightmare, Bailey. Every day I wake up,
35:17
Speaker 2: I can't believe what is taking place. I am Shaddy
35:22
Speaker 2: Robinson's mother. This is very ongoing, the tragic. My baby
35:28
Speaker 2: was my everything. She's my light, She's my star. She
35:33
Speaker 2: was so independent, so sufficient, She had her whole life
35:36
Speaker 2: ahead of her.
35:37
Speaker 10: She worked two jobs. She was dedicated, she was strong.
35:43
Speaker 2: The Maxwell Anderson that hardn't hurt my baby. I want
35:54
Speaker 2: that individual and this family held fully accountable.
35:58
Speaker 10: This is unacceptable behavior. My daughter is not Miss Garborough.
36:03
Speaker 6: I just wanted to tell you that in the last days,
36:06
Speaker 6: his lawyer has demanded that he have a laptop behind bars.
36:14
Speaker 6: He can kiss my rear end if he's going to
36:16
Speaker 6: get a private laptop behind bars. Miss Garborough, I'm seeing
36:21
Speaker 6: you and you have definitely you're wasting away. You just
36:28
Speaker 6: I can look at you and you have lost so
36:32
Speaker 6: much weight. You're wasting away. How are you managing to
36:37
Speaker 6: go forward?
36:40
Speaker 10: I can't sleep, Nancy, I can't eat.
36:44
Speaker 2: I'm doing ongoing, you know, therapy along with my youngest daughter.
36:54
Speaker 1: I have.
36:56
Speaker 10: Symptoms, physical symptoms.
36:58
Speaker 2: I don't mean to get in death, but I don't
37:01
Speaker 2: share this a lot. But since this has happened, I'm
37:05
Speaker 2: very empathic, and I've always.
37:08
Speaker 10: Been like this.
37:10
Speaker 2: I can literally fill the symptoms of what this person
37:21
Speaker 2: did to my daughter. I literally feel moved the same
37:25
Speaker 2: way physically. It's a lot of different layers of things
37:29
Speaker 2: going on with my physical wealth. I can't describe it,
37:34
Speaker 2: but I don't know. Nancy is through the grace. It's
37:38
Speaker 2: very challenging.
37:40
Speaker 6: We are still on the search for parts of Shade's body,
37:44
Speaker 6: but we are learning in the last days that police
37:48
Speaker 6: are focusing now on various dating apps as to how
37:54
Speaker 6: this team girl met up with a much much older man.
38:00
Speaker 6: I don't know what he said to her on this
38:02
Speaker 6: dating app to make her think that it was okay
38:04
Speaker 6: to go with him. But we're not only learning about
38:08
Speaker 6: a potential dating app connection, but we're also learning about
38:13
Speaker 6: an alleged ci A confidential informant that claims this guy,
38:21
Speaker 6: Maxwell Anderson, told him the SI that he was going
38:25
Speaker 6: to lure shah Dat, take her to the basement, shit
38:29
Speaker 6: her and dismember her. Now, who the hey knows something
38:33
Speaker 6: like that and does nothing but Regarding these newly released warrants, listen.
38:43
Speaker 21: Eight unsealed warrants are giving new insights into the investigation
38:46
Speaker 21: of Shade Robinson's murder. Newly released surveillance images show Shade
38:50
Speaker 21: meeting Anderson at the Twisted Fishermen for their date. The
38:53
Speaker 21: warrants also reveal police are reviewing employment records and surveillance
38:57
Speaker 21: from Victor's nightclub. Anderson reported worked at Victor's, a club
39:01
Speaker 21: that one of Shade's co workers has they frequented. Investigators
39:05
Speaker 21: are trying to determine how shaw Dee met Anderson.
39:08
Speaker 6: With me as Shawde's mother, Sheena Scarborough, I don't know
39:13
Speaker 6: if you have seen the footage of that basement. It's filthy,
39:21
Speaker 6: it's dug up, it's covered in debris. And this defendant
39:30
Speaker 6: picked shawd out of all the women in the area
39:35
Speaker 6: to lure her down to that filthy basement to murder her.
39:42
Speaker 6: I just don't understand why her have you seen that basement.
39:48
Speaker 2: It discusses me, Nancy, my daughter to not deserve this.
39:53
Speaker 10: This is unsurrell.
39:55
Speaker 2: This is freaking unsurrell Like, I don't know how we
39:59
Speaker 2: were this nightmare.
40:02
Speaker 22: By this demon. Why would you harm my baby? She
40:06
Speaker 22: hurt nobody. She was angelic, She put out good energy,
40:11
Speaker 22: She helped others. She was there for the community, She
40:15
Speaker 22: was there for the elders, the young people, her peers.
40:18
Speaker 22: She was constantly giving back. There is something deeper into this,
40:24
Speaker 22: but the truth is going.
40:25
Speaker 6: To be told, missus Scarborough. Before we sign off, I
40:30
Speaker 6: just want you to know how much we are praying
40:34
Speaker 6: for you and thinking about you and your whole family,
40:39
Speaker 6: and we will not rest until her killer gets the
40:44
Speaker 6: maximum sentence in that jurisdiction, which is life without prawl.
40:53
Speaker 6: Thank you please.
40:55
Speaker 2: Family.
41:00
Speaker 1: These are her earrings that came in the middle yesterday. Nancy.
41:03
Speaker 1: I don't know if you can see. You to go
41:06
Speaker 1: to the baby place for the first time, and these
41:10
Speaker 1: came for her. These are her earrings, and I have
41:15
Speaker 1: her earrings. These are my baby series. This is so.
41:21
Speaker 6: You know, what's so funny. Look what I've got my
41:25
Speaker 6: dad's shirt, my dad that passed away. I don't know why.
41:30
Speaker 6: I just feel better having it with me. Like your earrings. Guys,
41:37
Speaker 6: let's just stop for one moment and remember an American
41:40
Speaker 6: hero police officer, Michael Jensen. Just twenty nine years old.
41:48
Speaker 6: Jensen's shot in the line of duty Syracuse, New York,
41:52
Speaker 6: leaving behind his loving parents and sweet sister. American hero
41:58
Speaker 6: police officer Michael Jensen. I want to thank all of
42:04
Speaker 6: our guests for being with us, specifically Hiday's mother, Missus Scarborough,
42:10
Speaker 6: who suffered greatly to get shad Day's story out, and
42:15
Speaker 6: to all our other guests, but especially to you for
42:19
Speaker 6: being with us tonight and every night. Nancy Gray signing off,
42:23
Speaker 6: I'll see you tomorrow night, and until then, good night friend,