Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use 10b5-1 Insider Trading Plans
Transcript
- Lucas: Palantir is trading just above 122 dollars today. That's more than triple where it landed in its 2020 direct listing. And if you're an early employee or a venture investor, that kind of run-up creates a very real tension: you want to realize some of that gain, but if you sell right before a big contract announcement, you could land in SEC crosshairs. Luna: Right, the classic insider-trading trap. So how do these folks sell without looking like they had inside info? Lucas: They use something called a 10b5-1 trading plan. The name comes from Rule 10b5-1 under the Securities Exchange Act. The basic idea: an insider enters into a binding contract to sell shares at predetermined times or prices, months in advance. The SEC's position is that as long as the plan was adopted when the insider had no material non-public information, any trades that happen later are not considered insider trading. Luna: So it's like an automatic sell order that's set way ahead. But we've seen stories where executives seemed to get lucky timing even with those plans, right? Lucas: Exactly. The old rule had a loophole: an insider could adopt a plan one day, and start trading the next, while still having recent knowledge of upcoming news. The SEC closed that in 2022 with new amendments. Now, for most insiders, there's a mandatory cooling-off period — 90 days for directors and officers, and 30 days for other plan adopters. And they have to certify that they're not aware of any material non-public information at the time of adoption. Luna: That actually made a big difference. I remember a study from the SEC after the change — improper trading patterns dropped significantly. Lucas: It did. And for a company like Palantir, which doesn't give quarterly guidance and has that unique direct listing structure, 10b5-1 plans have become a go-to tool. We've seen multiple filings this year from Palantir insiders — co-founder Peter Thiel and others — adopting or amending plans. It's not a signal to panic; in fact, many institutional investors view a newly adopted 10b5-1 plan as a sign that management is being deliberate and compliant. Luna: Yeah, I think a lot of retail investors misread those insider-sale filings. They see 'insider sold shares' and hit sell. Lucas: That's part of why we're doing this episode. So, let me ask you something. If today's breakdown helped you understand 10b5-1 plans a bit better, or if it made you think differently about insider trading rules, honestly, if it was worth a coffee to you, that's the link — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No perks, no nothing. Just a way to keep the show ad-free and independent. Luna: Absolutely. A small gesture goes a long way. And as Lucas said, it's just buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Now, back to the mechanics. How does a company like Coinbase handle its 10b5-1 plans? Lucas: Coinbase is a great case. When it went public via direct listing in 2021, a huge chunk of employee shares became tradable immediately. The company actually adopted an insider trading policy that strongly encourages the use of 10b5-1 plans for any officer or director who wants to sell. And because crypto markets are so volatile, having that pre-set schedule helps avoid the optics of 'he sold right before a crash.' Luna: Right. Coinbase insiders have filed many 10b5-1 adoptions over the years. But I think one nuance is that these plans are required to include either a price limit or a specific date. So it's not like the insider can just sell at any time — they have to commit to a formula. Lucas: Exactly. The two main structures are a fixed plan — 'sell 10,000 shares on the first trading day of each month' — or a formula plan — 'sell 5,000 shares whenever the stock's 20-day average crosses above 150.' Some even include a limit price, so the shares only execute if the stock is above a certain level. That way, the insider isn't leaving money on the table. Luna: And the SEC requires companies to disclose these plan adoptions in their 10-Q and 10-K filings or via 8-K, right? So it's public record. Lucas: Since the 2022 amendments, yes. Public companies must disclose the adoption, modification, or termination of a 10b5-1 plan by their directors and officers. Before, it was often buried. Now you can track it in filings. For example, Palantir's 2025 annual report mentioned that a majority of their officers were using 10b5-1 plans. Luna: What about companies that aren't tech? Do we see this at more mature firms? Lucas: Absolutely. Microsoft has had insider trading plans for decades. But interestingly, Microsoft doesn't require its executives to use 10b5-1 plans — they just strongly recommend. Other firms like Coca-Cola make it mandatory for any insider trades. The post ipo world is where it's most visible because early investors are looking for an exit ramp. Luna: So when a company like Rivian or Airbnb — both trading at 141 and not much above their IPO prices — when insiders file a 10b5-1 plan, should we read anything into it? Lucas: Not necessarily. For Rivian, which is at 15.84, an insider might adopt a plan simply because they want to diversify. The market often overreacts. Studies show that companies announcing new 10b5-1 plans see no significant abnormal stock returns afterward. It's portfolio management, not a vote of no confidence. Luna: That's a good point. But there's always the danger of a plan being abused. Remember the case of the CEO who adopted a 10b5-1 plan and then secretly received material non-public information? They tried to cancel the plan but the trades still happened. Lucas: That's why the 2022 amendments also made it harder to modify or cancel a plan. Insiders can't just cancel after bad news. There's a cooling-off period for cancellations too — 30 days for plan adoptions and modifications. It effectively forces the insider to stick to the plan or wait. Luna: So the key takeaway: 10b5-1 plans are a compliance tool, not a market signal. They let insiders sell without triggering insider-trading allegations. Lucas: Exactly. And for post ipo companies, where the float is often tight and insider ownership is high, these plans provide liquidity and confidence to both the company and the market. If you're ever reading a Form 4 filing and see '10b5-1 plan' in the notes, now you know what it means. Luna: And if you want more episodes like this, you know where to find the coffee link. Lucas: Exactly. We'll be back next time with another deep dive into the mechanics of public company finance.