Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 110: On the French pension reform and ongoing strikes
Transcript
- 0:08You're listening to the New Paris, I'm your host Victor
- 0:11muta. If you were to walk the streets
- 0:14of Paris today you'd see about 7,000 tons of garbage piling up
- 0:20on sidewalks the stench after a week of no garbage collection is
- 0:25you might say ungodly some residents have seen an uptick in
- 0:29Rat socializing and according to reports this could go on until
- 0:33at least next Monday March 20th. This trash assault is the result
- 0:38of strikes in response to the macron, government's pension
- 0:41reform plans which lawmakers are debating and voting on this very
- 0:45week. Here's the thing, nearly 70
- 0:48percent of the French population is against the proposed
- 0:52retirement reform, which would raise the retirement age from 62
- 0:56to 64 by 2030. As of 2027, people will need to
- 1:01work for 43 years instead of 42 years to receive their full,
- 1:05pension the government insists, these changes are crucial for
- 1:09protecting the country's share out pension system and are quick
- 1:13to point to their neighbors, Italy, Germany.
- 1:16Spain who already have a higher retirement age.
- 1:21In Germany and Spain. For example, the legal minimum,
- 1:23age is 65. And in Italy, it is 67 years old
- 1:27but opponents insist that comparison isn't really fair.
- 1:30As it distracts from a uniquely French social system, that is
- 1:34being put at risk and the fact that those foreign systems
- 1:37incorporate more parameters than the French one, Here's what
- 1:42else, the critics of the reforms say 41, the pension system isn't
- 1:47in a deficit yet, the government really should be looking to
- 1:50alternatives to fill its coffers without forcing people, to work
- 1:53longer. Namely going after the 1%
- 1:57economists. Also say that it may not even
- 1:59have the desired effect because if more people are working, that
- 2:02means more public spending The second key point is that the
- 2:06most impacted by the reform will be The Usual Suspects.
- 2:10The underprivileged physical laborers, and women.
- 2:13These are people who tend to start work earlier in life, so
- 2:16have normally earned the right to a full pension, by the age of
- 2:1962. Now, they'll have to work two
- 2:21extra years, for no added benefit for women, particularly
- 2:26those who take breaks to raise children.
- 2:28It will take longer to reach the minimum contributions for a full
- 2:31pension pushing the retirement age, Words of 67 by some
- 2:37accounts women's pensions are as much as 40 percent lower than
- 2:40those of men and therefore this reform amplifies existing
- 2:44inequalities it's worth also looking to the French Economist
- 2:48Thomas Piketty, who puts it this way.
- 2:51And I quote repeating over and over again that the wealth tax
- 2:55called the ESF brought in less than 5 billion euros is
- 3:00tantamount to taking citizens for fools.
- 3:02This low yield reflects The choice of successive governments
- 3:06to exempt billionaires and to rely on bogus self declarations
- 3:11and it is precisely this choice that must be called into
- 3:14question. It is by tackling the issue of
- 3:17justice that we will get out of the current crisis.
- 3:20However, with the pension reform, the government is
- 3:22preparing to do, just the opposite.
- 3:25The stated objective is to make 20 billion dollars, poor 20
- 3:29billion euros in savings per year by 2030 in order to finance
- 3:33the government's Other priorities.
- 3:36The problem is that these 20 billion will fall entirely on
- 3:40the shoulders of the most modest.
- 3:43So the government can try to disguise things.
- 3:45But the reality is that it is invented a regressive tax that
- 3:49will be imposed exclusively on the least qualified and that's
- 3:53the end of his thinking. So in other words, why aren't we
- 3:57going after the 500 largest Fortunes in France that have
- 4:00expanded in a decade from 200 billion euros to 1000 billion
- 4:05euros, according to Piketty, taxing them, could bring in 400
- 4:09billion euros, that could go even further.
- 4:12If the government actually made an effort to tax the wealthiest
- 4:15500,000 people in its country, the one percent.
- 4:19But let's be honest, we know why that hasn't happened and why
- 4:23it's unlikely to happen. I'm all for some adjustments.
- 4:27As I don't think social systems are immutable, but if nothing is
- 4:30being done in Earnest to rein in the mushrooming billionaire
- 4:34class, you better believe, the working and middle class are
- 4:37going to show up for a fight. Mac homes reform is a political
- 4:42choice, not an obligation. According to some handy online
- 4:47calculators, I've used to determine what age.
- 4:49I will be able to retire here. It won't be before 67.
- 4:53And while that sounds late, I also figure it is what it is.
- 4:57Maybe that's the American in me. This is the way things are going
- 5:01for me. But there are certain
- 5:03individuals, including those with physically demanding jobs
- 5:06Who start working in their teens.
- 5:07And we know there are many of them who have to take time off
- 5:10to rear children for whom this is simply unjust.
- 5:14So, where do I Personally, stand, I'm against the reform in
- 5:18its current state and sympathetic to the people who
- 5:21will be the most penalized by the changes.
- 5:22The reform will bring about, but I'm also a bit frustrated with
- 5:26our local government for not having found some short-term
- 5:29Solutions, at least for the trash issue.
- 5:32And more about that about half of paris's, Alan d.
- 5:35Small have Municipal trash collectors and sanitation
- 5:38workers, the other half, which includes my neighborhood much to
- 5:41my surprise is managed by private providers.
- 5:45Private sector providers are still working and cleaning up
- 5:48the streets but three garbage incinerator plants.
- 5:51Outside of Paris are also on strike, meaning the trash gets
- 5:54collected and then I guess Fester's in a heap in front of
- 5:57closed facilities. When it becomes a sanitary issue
- 6:01for residents, I think the city needs to figure out a way
- 6:03forward, that still allows the sanitation workers to make their
- 6:06voices heard. So, here we are.
- 6:09Spring is upon us, complete with all of the horrific allergens
- 6:13that will lead me to start popping pills.
- 6:15Quite imminently tensions, are high streets are filthy but the
- 6:20city has devoted more media coverage to the upcoming
- 6:23Olympics in 2024 than what is actually what it is actually
- 6:26doing to mitigate the effects of this strike.
- 6:29Yeah. On the bright side, I guess you
- 6:32could say there's never a dull moment to living in Paris for
- 6:36more background on this issue. I've included a few links in the
- 6:38show notes, and I'm covering Citywide and National issues on
- 6:42my newsletter each month on the New Paris dispatch.
- 6:45Which you can find at bonjour that Lindsay trim you de.com
- 6:50until next time a bientot. On the bright side, I guess you
- 6:32could say there's never a dull moment to living in Paris for
- 6:36more background on this issue. I've included a few links in the
- 6:38show notes, and I'm covering Citywide and National issues on
- 6:42my newsletter each month on the New Paris dispatch.
- 6:45Which you can find at bonjour that Lindsay trim you de.com
- 6:50until next time a bientot.