Latest / Talking Michigan Transportation / Mackinac Bridge Authority Vice Chairman Bill Milliken Jr. shares memories
Transcript
- 0:07Jeff Cranson: Hello, welcome to the Talking Michigan Transportation Podcast.
- 0:10Jeff Cranson: I'm Jeff Cranson.
- 0:11Jeff Cranson: This is, in fact, the 200th episode of the podcast.
- 0:19Jeff Cranson: I certainly want to acknowledge everybody who listens regularly and appreciate it.
- 0:24Jeff Cranson: I'm hopeful that you find something here of interest each week.
- 0:28Jeff Cranson: I should also thank Randy Dubler, who engineers and produces the podcast and was a driving force in its creation and still is very helpful in tightening it and making it better each week.
- 0:41Jeff Cranson: Today, I'm speaking with Bill Milliken, who is vice chairman of the Mackinac Bridge Authority, lifelong Michigan resident, deep roots in northern Michigan, son of a Governor by the same name, Michigan's longest serving governor, as a matter of fact, and Bill has some great insights and thoughts about what it means to serve on the authority that oversees and protects our state's probably signature icon, the Mackinac Bridge.
- 1:08Jeff Cranson: So, I hope you enjoy the conversation.
- 1:10Jeff Cranson: So, bill Milliken, thank you again for coming on the Talking Michigan Transportation Podcast.
- 1:17Jeff Cranson: I think it's your first time talking with us.
- 1:20Jeff Cranson: I wanted to talk with you because of your role as vice chairman of the Mackinac Bridge Authority.
- 1:25Jeff Cranson: Any given year it can be somewhat light duty and then other times it can be very challenging, but I know you take very seriously the responsibility to oversee and protect what is really our state's signature icon.
- 1:38Jeff Cranson: So welcome and tell me what it means to you to serve on the MBA.
- 1:44Bill Milliken Jr.: Well, it's great to be invited to talk with you about it, and I'm certainly very proud of being appointed by the governor to be a member of the seven-member authority.
- 1:54Bill Milliken Jr.: My family and I have spent a lot of time on the bridge.
- 1:59Bill Milliken Jr.: The Labor Day Bridge Walk was something that I joined my parents for many times during Dad's 14-year term in office, so I feel like I've got a good sense of the bridge and the magnificence of it.
- 2:15Bill Milliken Jr.: One of the things that I missed recently is the fact that occasionally, when it was just a two-lane crossing, you used to occasionally see a Great Lakes freighter go underneath you and if you're on the grid looking through, you can look down on the deck of the freighter as it went through, and it was a magnificent vantage point on some of these thousand-foot vessels flying the Great Lakes.
- 2:41Jeff Cranson: Yeah, I hadn't thought about that.
- 2:43Jeff Cranson: But in my first years walking, yeah, marine traffic was still allowed to navigate, so I saw that same thing and now, for obvious reasons, the Department of Homeland Security and Michigan State Police have advised against allowing that.
- 2:57Jeff Cranson: While you know, anywhere from 25,000 to 30,000 people are walking on the bridge.
- 3:01Jeff Cranson: So, yeah, that's a miss.
- 3:04Jeff Cranson: Talk about those early days.
- 3:06Jeff Cranson: I think when your father was elected governor, you probably would have still been a student.
- 3:13Jeff Cranson: Did you bring friends along?
- 3:15Jeff Cranson: Was that like a real treat to go up and do that?
- 3:18Bill Milliken Jr.: It was a family affair.
- 3:19Bill Milliken Jr.: I never invited friends of mine to join me.
- 3:22Bill Milliken Jr.: I guess I might have been able to arrange that, but it was me and my father, and sometimes my mother would be the Millican bridge walking delegation.
- 3:36Jeff Cranson: Did you have trouble keeping up, because your dad was always determined to set a record.
- 3:41Jeff Cranson: In fact, I think he broke the previous record and once walked it in 47 minutes.
- 3:48Bill Milliken Jr.: I think that he wanted the best Governor Romney, and apparently has.
- 3:53Bill Milliken Jr.: Historically, I managed to keep up with him, but you knew you'd done something by the time you got to the finish line over there in Mackinac City.
- 4:02Jeff Cranson: Yeah, well.
- 4:02Jeff Cranson: Well, you recently mentioned your family.
- 4:05Jeff Cranson: History actually goes back deeper than your father serving as governor and walking it, probably each of those 14 years.
- 4:12Jeff Cranson: He was Michigan's longest serving governor, so he probably walked the bridge more than any other governor too.
- 4:17Jeff Cranson: But talk about going back a decade or so before the bridge was even built.
- 4:24Bill Milliken Jr.: Yeah, there's a family legacy there that I wasn't aware of for years.
- 4:28Bill Milliken Jr.: But Chase Osborne was an early governor of Michigan and he, as a matter of fact, he for four years he was the postmaster in Sault Ste Marie and prior to becoming governor, so it may account for some of his advocacy for a UP interest and a bridge to be built between the two peninsulas.
- 4:51Bill Milliken Jr.: My grandfather, james T Milliken, was serving in the Michigan Senate in the 40s and he and Governor Osborne established a relationship over the prospect of a bridge and advocacy for the construction of a bridge advocacy for the construction of a bridge, and it's one of the earliest records that I'm aware of of elected officials in government saying that, boy, we ought to do this bridge, and so I sometimes would love my grandfather to know that I've been appointed to a position on the bridge authority.
- 5:27Bill Milliken Jr.: He'd be very proud.
- 5:28Bill Milliken Jr.: Yeah, that's really cool, but it also says that you guys have a real legacy of public service in the family.
- 5:37Bill Milliken Jr.: We do, and I grew up with it and I'm doing my best to carry it on.
- 5:42Bill Milliken Jr.: People have asked me, well, when are you going to run for elected office?
- 5:46Bill Milliken Jr.: And to which I reply that I already hold an elected position as a trustee of Washtenaw Community College in Ann Arbor.
- 5:56Bill Milliken Jr.: I have no aspirations for higher office.
- 5:58Bill Milliken Jr.: I've been exposed to a lot of it but I think I'm comfortable with my station.
- 6:17Jeff Cranson: Well, you know, you and I have talked about this, and I think community colleges are more important than they've ever been in terms of the gap that they fill between traditional four-year universities and the skills and training that the modern workforce needs.
- 6:25Jeff Cranson: So how does that, does that fit?
- 6:26Bill Milliken Jr.: at all with your interest in infrastructure and being involved in a bridge like this, in a bridge like this.
- 6:31Bill Milliken Jr.: I don't know how closely the two are tied, but on the community college side there is no shortage of gratification sitting at the trustee meetings, listening to the reports of students whose lives have changed and opportunities have opened for them based on the training we've been able to give them at the college.
- 6:45Bill Milliken Jr.: There are mothers who are able to get a home with their children for the first time.
- 6:52Bill Milliken Jr.: There are employment opportunities.
- 6:55Bill Milliken Jr.: The welding and nursing programs at Washtenaw Community College are on a waiting list Heavy demand for those, and the people who come out of those programs have ready employment opportunities in Michigan and widely.
- 7:09Bill Milliken Jr.: So that's been gratifying.
- 7:13Jeff Cranson: Yeah, I can see where that would be.
- 7:14Jeff Cranson: Well, let's talk about your role as vice chair on the MBA and chairman of the Finance Committee.
- 7:21Jeff Cranson: Is that right?
- 7:22Bill Milliken Jr.: That's correct.
- 7:23Jeff Cranson: yes, and finance is about the most important issue that there is when it comes to the bridge and its long term.
- 7:30Jeff Cranson: We're self-supporting.
- 7:32Bill Milliken Jr.: yes, we manage the bridge and we run it on toll revenues that we collect from vehicles crossing the bridge.
- 7:39Jeff Cranson: Yes, and one would argue that user fees are the best way to fund transportation infrastructure infrastructure.
- 7:51Jeff Cranson: So talk about that balance you have to strike between looking down the road at you know five years, 10 years, 20 years what the bridge needs and not raising tolls at a rate that you know really shocks people that have to use the bridge frequently.
- 8:05Jeff Cranson: It's a lot you have to wrestle with.
- 8:07Bill Milliken Jr.: Well, and it's evolving.
- 8:09Bill Milliken Jr.: Pre-covid, crossing the bridge was a cash affair, but with the onset of COVID, for three or four years credit cards were mandatory because nobody wanted to handle currency.
- 8:22Bill Milliken Jr.: So people crossing the bridge can now either pay cash or they can pay us with a credit card, and so what used to be an all-cash business has now gotten more intricate.
- 8:37Bill Milliken Jr.: There are a lot of other bridges like ours that are credit card payments as well, so we're not alone in that.
- 8:48Bill Milliken Jr.: The long-term planning for the bridge is something that requires budgeting and engineering expertise, and we just finished painting the bridge a couple of years ago, and it took us about, as I remember, about seven years.
- 9:04Bill Milliken Jr.: That's a lot of steel.
- 9:05Bill Milliken Jr.: Interestingly, 90% of the Mackinac Bridge is underwater, so when you're looking at it from a distance and you're marveling at that span, you've got to remind yourself that that's just 10% of the work that went into this bridge when it was constructed in 1950, beginning in 1954.
- 9:23Bill Milliken Jr.: So there's a lot to it.
- 9:25Jeff Cranson: Yeah, I think when you see those photos of when the bridge was built and the cofferdams and the things that they had to do in that era, with the technology of the time, you know, in the mid 50s, in order to work underwater and go so deep into the bedrock so that the bridge could last as long as it has, it's amazing, it's truly a feat it has.
- 9:50Jeff Cranson: It's amazing, it's truly a feat.
- 9:51Jeff Cranson: You've probably learned some things without being a civil engineer about bridges and infrastructure and just the need to paint.
- 9:55Jeff Cranson: I mean, was that a question of yours?
- 9:57Jeff Cranson: When you first came out on the board and they said, hey, we've got this painting project going on.
- 10:01Jeff Cranson: It's going to take seven years, were you thinking why do you need to paint the bridge?
- 10:05Bill Milliken Jr.: Well, I'm glad nobody asked me how long it should take, because I never would have guessed seven years.
- 10:09Bill Milliken Jr.: One of the pieces of inspiration that I had when I joined the Bridge Authority I got David McCullough's book on the Brooklyn Bridge.
- 10:21Bill Milliken Jr.: It's a great book.
- 10:24Bill Milliken Jr.: And the Brooklyn Bridge actually paved the way for a lot of the engineering and technique of the construction.
- 10:31Bill Milliken Jr.: It was a suspension bridge.
- 10:33Bill Milliken Jr.: Brooklyn Bridge is only a mile long and they have oh what 40 million cars a year crossing the Brooklyn Bridge, so they're about 10 times what we do on the Mackinac Bridge.
- 10:46Bill Milliken Jr.: But the cables the suspension cables on the Brooklyn Bridge are the same technique, the same cables that we used on the construction of the Mackinac Bridge.
- 10:58Bill Milliken Jr.: So there's a lot of linkage between the two and it's been interesting to realize how some of those engineering principles are consistent.
- 11:05Jeff Cranson: Yeah, those guys that conceived and built the Brooklyn Bridge in the mid-19th century were incredible visionaries and incredible geniuses and it's really.
- 11:16Jeff Cranson: I mean, just as I can't fathom what it was like to build the Mackinac Bridge in the mid-50s, I can't imagine what it was like to build the Brooklyn Bridge then.
- 11:23Jeff Cranson: But McCullough's book I've read it also and it's very good, pretty much like everything David McCullough does.
- 11:34Bill Milliken Jr.: One of the interesting aspects of that book I thought was they're dealing with the bends for the first time and how medically.
- 11:39Bill Milliken Jr.: What was required for decompression when people came down off the river bottom and there was one of the laborers in the Brooklyn Bridge had a severe case of the bends and was hospitalized and it was a critical situation and so they relocated him to another hospital where they felt they could better address it.
- 11:59Bill Milliken Jr.: You may remember this that it was Walter Reed who was the physician, as in Walter Reed Army Hospital that treated this case of kind of a freak accident at the time, and his son actually had to take it over and finish it.
- 12:37Jeff Cranson: Yes, stay with us.
- 12:39Jeff Cranson: We'll have more on the other side of this important message.
- 12:43Safety Message: In Michigan.
- 12:43Safety Message: Safety comes first on the roads.
- 12:45Safety Message: To combat distracted driving, Michigan passed the Hands-Free Law.
- 12:49Safety Message: The law makes holding or manually using a cell phone or other mobile electronic device while operating a vehicle a primary offense.
- 12:57Safety Message: This means an officer can stop and ticket you for violating the law.
- 13:01Safety Message: This can include, but not limited to, sending or receiving a call.
- 13:05Safety Message: Sending, receiving or reading a text or email, accessing, reading or posting to social media sites or entering locations into the phone GPS.
- 13:16Jeff Cranson: With this law in place, drivers are encouraged to stay focused, keeping their hands on the wheel and their attention on the road.
- 13:22Jeff Cranson: Drive smart, drive safe, drive hands-free.
- 13:26Safety Message: Michigan's hands-free law making the road safer for everyone.
- 13:32Jeff Cranson: So tell me, looking forward, I guess, beyond what we talked about in terms of weighing, you know tolls what do you see as some of the things you'll have to work through in the coming years with both the finance committee and the full board?
- 13:50Bill Milliken Jr.: One of the issues that the bridge authority is going to address is whether or not credit card fees that we pay when a driver comes through and pays the toll, whether those fees should be paid by the drivers or whether the bridge authority should continue to fund those themselves, and so that could affect tolls.
- 14:16Bill Milliken Jr.: The economics of that, the big picture, need to be examined and see what's a fair way to address that.
- 14:24Jeff Cranson: And you're talking probably as much as what two and a half three percent.
- 14:28Bill Milliken Jr.: Yes, I think the Secretary of State's office in Michigan has a two and a half percent fee.
- 14:33Bill Milliken Jr.: If I go to get a title or registration for a vehicle and I use a credit card, that's what I'll be asked to pay as well.
- 14:41Jeff Cranson: Yeah, talk about a fee.
- 14:43Jeff Cranson: You don't see?
- 14:44Jeff Cranson: I mean, we think we carry this piece of plastic and that's all there is to it, right?
- 14:48Bill Milliken Jr.: Yep, not so.
- 14:50Jeff Cranson: Yeah.
- 14:50Jeff Cranson: So what else do you think?
- 14:53Jeff Cranson: I mean, that's certainly a big one.
- 14:55Jeff Cranson: What else, I guess, what piques your interest?
- 14:59Jeff Cranson: When you're at these board meetings and you're hearing these discussions and you're hearing bridge engineers talk about all they do, you see a lot of presentations, a lot of slideshows.
- 15:07Jeff Cranson: What really I mean?
- 15:11Jeff Cranson: The fact that you read McCullough's book shows that you've got some knowledge coming into this.
- 15:17Bill Milliken Jr.: But what piques your interest?
- 15:18Bill Milliken Jr.: Well, let me dip into another piece of history for a minute.
- 15:20Bill Milliken Jr.: When the legislature created the Mackinac Bridge Authority in the 50s, 1953, the Mackinac Bridge Authority in the 50s, 1953, the Bridge Authority was directed to begin interviewing engineers for the construction of a Mackinac Bridge and several engineering firms around the country were selected and Dr David Steinman, who ended up as the chief engineer for the Mackinac Bridge, went before the Bridge Authority and somebody asked him the Bridge went before the bridge authority and somebody asked him the question Dr Steinman, if somebody, one of these Great Lakes freighters, hits your bridge, what's going to happen?
- 15:55Bill Milliken Jr.: And without hesitation he said, the freighter will break into and sink.
- 15:59Bill Milliken Jr.: And that sort of characterizes the well, my word the overbuilt nature of the Mackinac Bridge.
- 16:07Bill Milliken Jr.: It has sustained several hits since by freighters and various craft and they come away the worst for wear and the bridge stands tall.
- 16:16Bill Milliken Jr.: So Dr Steinman was absolutely correct in his assessment of the strength of the bridge that he was going to design and the one that was built there.
- 16:25Jeff Cranson: Yeah, he didn't suffer for hubris, that's for sure.
- 16:27Jeff Cranson: I remember in the book about the bridge he was also quoted talking about testing the depths into the bedrock, and you know for how deep they'd have to go to support the towers, and saying that they tested I think what was it to a thousand years, and then he was convinced that they could last to infinity.
- 16:46Bill Milliken Jr.: a thousand years and then he's convinced that they could last to infinity.
- 16:49Bill Milliken Jr.: And the wind tunnel tests?
- 16:51Bill Milliken Jr.: The bridge is inspected biannually by national engineering firms and they did a wind tunnel test several years ago on a model of the bridge and deemed it capable of withstanding up to 150 mile an hour winds.
- 17:09Bill Milliken Jr.: And we've had some pretty strong winds in the Strait of Mackinac but none have reached that level.
- 17:16Bill Milliken Jr.: But it's good to know that it's secure from that point of view as well.
- 17:19Jeff Cranson: Well, one of the things and my goodness, if your dad was around now and I know you're every bit as committed to sustainability and the environment as he was Nobody envisioned the warm the cycle being what it used to be in that part of the state.
- 17:37Jeff Cranson: It got cold in November and stayed cold until April, and now it doesn't, and increasingly we have these thaws in January and February and huge chunks of ice are falling off the bridge and it has to be closed because of that, because obviously that's a safety concern and you know that's another expense.
- 17:55Jeff Cranson: I'm sure you've been involved in some of the discussions about that.
- 18:00Bill Milliken Jr.: And it's an effort to adequately explain to motorists and truckers why they can't cross the bridge.
- 18:08Bill Milliken Jr.: They think it's a nuisance, but some of those sheets of ice are pretty heavy and there are windshields and body damage and all kinds of harm that could result if they actually got under one on its way down.
- 18:20Bill Milliken Jr.: So it's a changing environment but it's important that it's policed.
- 18:24Bill Milliken Jr.: The bridge has got surveillance cameras positioned all along the stretch so from the St Ignace Mackinac Bridge Authority office they've got a good ability to visually monitor what the conditions are out there.
- 18:37Bill Milliken Jr.: And it's carefully managed and there's nothing careless about it.
- 18:42Bill Milliken Jr.: It's all executed with precision executed with precision.
- 18:54Jeff Cranson: Yeah, there's no shortage of incredible commitment by both Kim Nowak and everybody on her staff the people that really take their role, working on again what I call the state's signature icon.
- 19:00Jeff Cranson: They take it very seriously and obviously everybody in Michigan cares about that bridge.
- 19:06Jeff Cranson: I mean we stamp it on our license plates.
- 19:08Jeff Cranson: That's how big a deal it is right.
- 19:11Bill Milliken Jr.: You know, jeff, there's another aspect of global warming, too, tangential at any rate, which is the Straits of Mackinac don't freeze the way they used to, and, much to the dismay of our friends who winter over on Mackinac Island, they don't have as much access, or access that's as safe as it has been in the past to hop on their snowmobile and go over to St Agnes for shopping or dinner or whatever it is.
- 19:36Bill Milliken Jr.: So it's affecting lives all the way around.
- 19:42Jeff Cranson: Yeah, no, that's a huge factor and that's an area of the state and the country that you're going to see those kinds of impacts going forward, just like extreme weather events you know, more floods, you mentioned wind, certainly MDOT's wrestling with high water events all over the state and in an environment where we already can't fund what we need to in terms of roads and bridges, in an environment where we already can't fund what we need to in terms of roads and bridges, trying to build for a more sustainable network is just a greater funding challenge.
- 20:18Jeff Cranson: Well, bill, what else would you want people to know about you and your work with the authority, or really just anything about your commitment to the state where you were born and raised and obviously care a great deal about?
- 20:32Bill Milliken Jr.: One of the things that I've been able to do several times is in conjunction with the Detroit Regional Chamber of Commerce Policy Conference.
- 20:40Bill Milliken Jr.: On the island, the Bridge Authority always invites members of the Senate House, elected members of the legislature, to come over to the office for a briefing on what we do and then invite them to go out and take a tower tour.
- 20:57Bill Milliken Jr.: And those that are interested and those that are willing, we'll take them up to the top of the South Tower to let them see from 650 feet in the air what Michigan's two peninsulas look like in one glance.
- 21:12Bill Milliken Jr.: And the procedure for doing so isn't it's not like climbing in an elevator to go to the top of the Empire State Building.
- 21:22Bill Milliken Jr.: It's a tiny elevator, it's dark and involves climbing some ladders when you get there.
- 21:29Bill Milliken Jr.: So it's not for the faint of heart, but it's been very meaningful to be a part of that tour and to get to know our legislators better, to make sure they understand what we are dealing with and we're trying to manage this state's largest asset dealing with when we're trying to manage this state's largest asset.
- 21:51Jeff Cranson: Yeah, I think it's a great idea to get them that up close and personal with the bridge and understand what it's all about, and that education has gone a long way for our relationships and their understanding.
- 22:01Jeff Cranson: So, yeah, that's a really, really good point.
- 22:03Bill Milliken Jr.: When I was in grade school, my father, who was I believe he was in the he may not even have been in the Michigan State Senate yet but he invited me to drive to Mackinac Island, to Mackinac City, and take a boat over to the island for the day.
- 22:19Bill Milliken Jr.: He was going to meet Sophie Williams at the Grand Hotel and we got off on the dock in Mackinac Island and we boarded one of the wicker taxis.
- 22:31Bill Milliken Jr.: Many of our listeners may not remember what a wicker taxi is, but it was a bicycle with a wicker seat on the front for two people and an energetic bicycler in the back who rode you around the island wherever you wanted to go.
- 22:46Bill Milliken Jr.: And we took a Wicker taxi up to the Grand Hotel and had a meeting with Sophie Williams and then back down to the dock and back to Traverse City.
- 22:56Bill Milliken Jr.: And one of those Wicker taxis is still on display in the lower lobby at the Grand Hotel and I have to smile every time I walk by it.
- 23:03Bill Milliken Jr.: It brings back memories.
- 23:05Jeff Cranson: That's a great story.
- 23:06Jeff Cranson: So that was a precursor to the pedicab that you see now in so many cities.
- 23:11Jeff Cranson: Yeah, that's a great story.
- 23:14Jeff Cranson: Now I appreciate talking to you and I appreciate that history.
- 23:18Jeff Cranson: I know how much the bridge meant to your father and the family and I had wondered I wanted to ask you before, but I forgot about whether you had done any of those walks when he was governor, and I thought you probably did.
- 23:32Jeff Cranson: So it must be pretty cool now to walk the bridge on Labor Day with another governor.
- 23:38Bill Milliken Jr.: Well, the bridge walk has evolved a great deal since George Romney and Bill Milliken walked it back in the day and, among other things, the considerations from Homeland Security and the Michigan State Police and new measures that we have for managing it and executing it safely.
- 23:56Bill Milliken Jr.: But the walk goes on.
- 23:57Bill Milliken Jr.: And what?
- 23:58Bill Milliken Jr.: 35,000 people last year.
- 24:01Bill Milliken Jr.: So we've got a success story on our hands.
- 24:05Jeff Cranson: Yeah, no, I think that there's a lot of gnashing of teeth about the changes, letting people start from each end and turn around if they want to, because of the timing, and it's worked out really well and, like you said, you know, it's allowed the tradition to continue.
- 24:19Jeff Cranson: Things change, that's OK, but overall it's still working out really well.
- 24:25Jeff Cranson: So well, thank you, bill.
- 24:27Jeff Cranson: I appreciate you taking the time to talk with us.
- 24:28Jeff Cranson: I'd like to thank you once more for tuning in to Talking Michigan Transportation.
- 24:33Jeff Cranson: You can find show notes and more on Apple Podcasts or Buzzsprout.
- 24:37Jeff Cranson: I also want to acknowledge the talented people who help make this a reality each week, starting with Randy Debler, who skillfully edits the audio, Jesse Ball, who proofs the content, Courtney Bates, who posts the podcast to various platforms, and Jacke Salinas, who transcribes the audio to make it accessible to all.