Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Hertz Sells on Amazon, VinFast Expands Dealer Network, Atlas Robot Gets Handsy
Transcript
- 0:00[funky music] Good morning. It is Thursday, Aug- August 21st. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. And everyone on this podcast is lucky today because we have Steve Greenfield as the co-host.
- 0:10Kyle, Kyle's on a plane somewhere right now. [laughs] Everywhere I go. The people really don't know. Good morning, Steve. Who I is and who I be. Oh, how are you? You're not on a plane. Good to be back.
- 0:20Y- you're not on a plane- Talking about-... but you're in a hotel. [laughs] Hotel in Orlando. Yes, I am. Orlando. Yes. Yes. Orlando. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Oh, that's nice this time of year. That's fantastic.
- 0:28I'm gonna be in Orlando, uh, next week. The end of next week. Ah, I missed you by a week. Yeah, I know. Oh, that'll be fun. Have... We, we could've, we could've went on some roller coasters together- Yeah. [laughs]...
- 0:36with some Mickey ears. Like, that, that would've been the content the internet really wants. Right. [laughs] Uh, so, uh, how has the summer been for you?
- 0:43We had, we've, we've had you on the show, but, you know, we're kinda getting the tail end of the summer now. How would you sum it up- Yeah... for yourself?
- 0:48L- luckily enough I've had a, sort of a, a, a lapse in travel, but you gotta hear this. Like, between now and the end of the year, and we're, here we are August 21st, I've got two separate trips to Ireland.
- 0:58[laughs] I've got a, a trip to Berlin. I've got a trip to Vietnam. Gosh. And I've got a trip t- a trip to China. So- Oh, my goodness... I'm, I'm gonna, I'm gonna be e- earning those Delta miles. Here we go.
- 1:07Oh, my G- Oh, oh, oh, and I've got a separate trip to Finland as well. So it's l- hard to even track all this stuff, but I've got a, a bunch of international travel coming up. But it's all exciting, all good.
- 1:15Some combination of conferences, investors, and then, um, you know, fi- finding startups. So- It's a new show. Steve- I, I think- Steve Goes Global. Exactly right. Exactly right. Oh, my goodness.
- 1:25I thought it was hard to keep track of you n- then. Yeah. Like, we're really gonna need to build a tracker website. It's like the Santa Claus tracker. We will. Yeah.
- 1:30I mean, maybe you need, maybe, I feel like, do you need, like, a London HQ now? Right? Like- Ooh, that, that would be good. Yeah. Like a little home base. I could do, I could do that, Paris, and Istanbul. Maybe Dubai.
- 1:40I'd be set. Yeah. Oh, very interesting. Very interesting. All right. Well, good. It's gonna be a rip-roaring, uh, Q3 and Q4 for Steve's travel. It, it will be.
- 1:47It's gonna be so much fun to, to hear back on all the things you learn and you find. And, uh, you always are so nice to bring them back to us, so. Yeah. We should do a couple international segments. Done. For sure.
- 1:56There you go. There you go. Count it. Nathan's writing down notes already. Um- All right... hey, everybody.
- 1:59I just wanna make sure you know that we did have an amazing webinar yesterday, one of our a Soto Edge's, uh, webinars. It was the 2025 Halftime Report with our friends at Wide Whale.
- 2:07We looked at the state of dealer reputation first six months of the year. The data is, uh, very surprising in some areas.
- 2:13Talk about how brands are comparing to other brands, what dealers can do now to make some mid-game adjustments so that the rest of the year the reputation scores get better. There's some good news in that report, too.
- 2:23So you should check it out. You can go to asotu.com and just fill in the form. We'll send you the recording right away. You'll get all the data, all the things, um, and it's a lot of fun.
- 2:31So just wanna make sure you don't miss that. All right. We have some fun news to talk about. And the summer's kinda weird with automotive news.
- 2:36Sometimes it's dry, some, you know, people are busy selling cars and on vacations. But I'm starting to feel the, the uptick back of the motion, that September motion that everybody, uh, always looks forward to.
- 2:46Big announcement this week. Hertz partnered with Amazon to list its vehicles on the retail giant's platform, giving customers a new way to shop for former rentals online.
- 2:55It's building on the roughly one-third of Hertz vehicle sales that already go directly to consumers.
- 3:01Basically, shoppers can now browse and buy Hertz vehicles on Amazon, then pick them up in Dallas, Houston, LA, or Seattle. Uh, they have plans to expand that to 45 US locations.
- 3:12Uh, basically, retail sales at about 1,000 to $1,500 per vehicle for Hertz compared to their wholesale channels.
- 3:20They're also expanding its, quote, "Try Before You Buy" program to 100 cities and enhancing digital sales through platforms like Carvana and Autotrader.
- 3:29H- Hertz CEO Gil West said, quote, "It's really important as well that we get more net out of what we're selling." So, um, Amazon, Hertz. I mean, Amazon's the real story here, right?
- 3:40Not Hertz selling vehicles to consumers. What do you think? Well, I think, I think a bit of each. You know, when I was at Manheim 20 years ago, Hertz was one of our customers.
- 3:47And 100% of all their cars, uh, that came out of fleet went through Manheim locations, were sent down the auction lanes and sold to dealers. Mm-hmm.
- 3:56And, uh, s- since then they've diversified, as you just said, quite considerably. They have their own retail brand at Hertz stores. They've, they've, they've had relationships in the past with Carvana. Mm.
- 4:05And now this Amazon news. I think the big news here, here, it's easy to dismiss this, right? It's like, oh, this is like, you know, not, not news. But, but it is news.
- 4:11One is that, you know, Amazon has only been selling for Hyundai dealers so far. And new cars. So that... Yeah. And new cars. Well, they announced used a couple weeks ago, but n- now you've got a separate seller.
- 4:21And, you know, the, the auction should be, uh, t- take- taking notes here. If, if consigners like Hertz, if sellers- Right... like Hertz can sell directly to consumers, which is what they want.
- 4:30Like you just said, they wanna have hi- higher pricing. Then it's, it is a threat to the auctions. O- other sellers, if, if Amazon's successful, will bypass the auctions- Mm...
- 4:40and sell directly to consumers through either Amazon or Carvana or whatever you might, might have. And, um, it changes the dynamics because a lot of dealers rely on these two-year-old vehicles- Yes...
- 4:51whether they're off lease or coming out of rental. You know, think of CarMax, for example, right?
- 4:55I don't know what percentage of the cars that they sell o- o- uh, at their sites that are off lease or off rental cars, but it's not insignificant. Yeah.
- 5:03And if th- and if those dry up because they sell directly to consumers in the future- Right...
- 5:06then dealers in general, whether I'm a franchise dealer or whether I'm an independent dealer, there's gonna be fewer cars for you to stock on your lots. Yeah.
- 5:13So in some ways, you know, these commercial sellers trying to find efficiency, i.e. getting closer to re- retail pricing and bypassing wholesale- Mm-hmm...
- 5:22it is, is problematic because dealers might, you know, in a couple years say, "Wait, hold on a second. You know, what happened to the two or three-year-old car?"
- 5:29Imagine if off lease cars start selling directly to consumers. Which would be an- all- another much clearer pipeline.
- 5:36I think, um, taking those used cars out of deal- out of the dealer's market is going to be impactful if it really catches on. I think there's still a few hurdles that they need to jump.
- 5:45One, in my mind, just 'cause I come from a reconditioning background, is the reconditioning. How do you- Yep... disclose, like Carvana does a great job of disclosing vehicle condition on their site.
- 5:54But they, they're the ones that have the cars in their, their hands. They have the technology. They have the, the ability to shoot it. They have their framework. And they've built the trust of people- Yeah...
- 6:03to say, "That is how I'm going to get the car, and if not, Carvana will make it right."
- 6:07I think there is some opportunity for, um, a-You know, companies like ACV and people to give a third-party condition report that validate its, you know, physical condition in the same way that, you know, Carfax does.
- 6:18I'm sure they have this try before you buy program, or they have this, you know, money back guarantee. But no one ever really wants to deal with that, right? That's a very complicated thing.
- 6:25What do they do with the trades? Um, are there trades, right? How are they gonna take the car in? Hertz doesn't wanna trade, that's for sure. No, no. Yeah, I mean, you, you, you're definitely right.
- 6:35The, the consumer who's buying on Amazon is gonna want Amazon stamp of approval around the condition of the car. Mm-hmm.
- 6:40And, and full disclosure, you know, if it was in an accident, obviously, if any damage to the car whatsoever. Yeah, the Carfax stuff, yes. Yeah. So I mean, but it, it begs the question, right?
- 6:48So if there is gonna be a third party, you mentioned ACV, that puts their stamp of approval on it, you could have an Amazon condition report powered by who? Kelley Blue Book? Yeah. AC- ACV? Right. Carfa- Carfax? Yeah.
- 6:59What's gonna resonate most with, with consumers? Probably one of these consumer facing brands. Yep. I don't, I don't know.
- 7:04With all, with all due respect to the ACV guys, they have an awesome brand, awesome company, but the average consumer- For sure. It's not a retail facing brand. Right.
- 7:10But a KBB or Carfax powered Amazon condition report- Yep...
- 7:14could really resonate and imbue a lot of trust for the consumer, and they may be more likely to click the buy button knowing that somebody's standing behind the, the, the, the condition of the vehicle.
- 7:23I also think of, um, companies like UVI, who now has partnered with Hertz to do the vehicle scanning and the condition scanning, where you can actually disclose, give good imagery, and have a history on it r- as well.
- 7:34So just like everything, right? Something changes, means there's opportunity for somebody, and there's a challenge for somebody else. So, um, well, it'll be interesting to see how this one plays out.
- 7:42I'm also thinking like, when does Amazon start offering financing? Right. You know? Yeah. I mean, they know- Yeah... your purchase history.
- 7:48They know probably more about every consumer than just about any other platform out there. Well, it's a great point. So, so I think the contemplation so far has been having dealer friendly financing.
- 7:57The dealer can effectively surface their, their financing sources through amazon.com. Right. But when H- when Hertz sells a car on, on Amazon, to your point, who's gonna offer the financing? Yeah.
- 8:06I don't think Hertz really wants to be married to that car anymore. They wanna say goodbye and get on with their- Right... rental business. Exactly right.
- 8:11So- A- and Amazon could offer an Amazon branded financing source, which probably would not include a dealership in that transaction. Probably not. Talking about dealerships, though. [upbeat music] New one. Segway time.
- 8:23You said you were going to Vietnam. I don't know. Does it have something to do with VinFast? Maybe.
- 8:27But VinFast US dealership network is taking shape in the grand opening of its very first California franchise location in San Diego. The new store is operated by Sun Road Automotive Group.
- 8:37They offer sales service, test drives of the VF8, the VF9, uh, which are electric SUVs.
- 8:42The automaker is planning to replace all 15 of its former company-owned California stores and now operates nearly 30 authorized dealerships across 14 states with the company, quote, "Recognizing the distinct advantages of this distribution channel," to which everyone over here applauds.
- 8:58California remains a key focus for the brand, which calls the state a top priority for EV growth, also making sense. The new location has full support for warranty repair, maintenance using genuine VinFast parts.
- 9:09Here's a quote from Mike Nolte, VinFast US VP of sales and marketing. He said, "This event marks a pivotal moment in our strategy." So VinFast, uh, leaning into the dealer network and opening in California.
- 9:21Yeah, and juxtapose that against when they launched here and they brought the first, you know, thousand vehicles into the country.
- 9:26Their, their, their intent was to sell directly to the consumer, build a consumer brand, not, not have, uh, deal- dealers, et cetera. So they flipped entirely, which is good, which is great.
- 9:35I mean, I, I, I think that they, they, they struggled and failed with the average consumer not knowing what this brand is. Mm-hmm.
- 9:41Um, so ha- having local dealers in their local markets that know the consumers, that can market to the consumers and bring them in makes, makes total sense to me.
- 9:49I don't think they would've succeeded trying to build a consumer brand. True. I mean, we've seen the billions of dollars that the parent company, VinFast, has lost at home trying to fund this thing- Mm-hmm...
- 9:58to get the, the economic engine. I mean, they're selling a lot of these back in the Vietnamese market, but not internationally yet. Yep.
- 10:04I think that the, the cars so far, with all due respect, have been challenged for the spec that we need here in the US. Yeah. The, the range hasn't been long. Range, for sure. Yeah. They've had quality issues.
- 10:13So, but, you know, with, with the first iteration, I, I think of the first iteration of the Hyundais that came into the market. That's great. They were horri- horrible. Yeah. Horrible cars. Subarus, too.
- 10:21Look, look, Subarus, too. Right. [laughs] Look, look... Exactly. They, they were rust buckets. Yeah, they were. So look where we are now, and I think that, um, you know, ha- have some patience.
- 10:29But a good signal that they've embraced the dealer network. They understand that that's the path that really unlock growth, and we'll see how this, this, this, this brand, uh, emerges in the US. Yeah. And you know what?
- 10:40Really needing, needing a headstart for when Chinese vehicles will eventually make their way to US lots.
- 10:47I know a lot of, a lot of folks predicting that that's gonna happen sometime, or we're gonna hear more about that in the next 12 months about some major Chinese investment in US state. Um, I can't remember who it was.
- 10:57The, the, one of the gentlemen you had at your, uh, s- China summit, he wrote a piece, and he made a prediction that, um, he predicts that within the next- By, by, by Q4. Yeah. By Q4. Yes.
- 11:07Mike, Mike, Michael Dunne from Dunne Insight. Michael Dunne. That's what it is. Anyone who doesn't subscribe to Michael Dunne, D-U-N-N-E, highly recommended. Ve- ve- very smart.
- 11:14Probably the, the foremost expert globally on the Chinese brands.
- 11:18And yeah, he, he recently, as of last week, said that he's, he's, um, kind of betting that by Q4, Donald Trump will, will ink some sort of deal with Chinese automakers, and they'll start, you know, producing cars here in the US.
- 11:30By, by, by Q4, that'll be announced, and we'll see. I mean, interesting- I mean, he s- It was so specific, right? Yeah. Like, the, the, the prediction was so specific. It's one of those, like- Michael's an insider.
- 11:39Michael's an insider... he knows something. Michael's an insider. And I believe he said- Yeah, yeah... it, the, it'll be b- a multibillion dollar investment in a southern state to make the vehicles here. Um- Yep...
- 11:48and so I mean, so it's good that VinFast has their headstart. I mean, they've had a headstart. Now let's see if they can get it to ground.
- 11:54But, um, well, I mean, [laughs] this is all just one big rollercoaster that you are, you are paying attention to probably more than anybody else and aggregating, uh, some information and connecting the right people, right?
- 12:04Michael Dunne- Yeah... is now part of the conversation. There we go. All right. Good old Mike. Last but not least, let's talk about, uh, something that's a little more in the future, but not maybe so much.
- 12:13It's a combination of AI and robotics and automotive. All right, let's roll the video.
- 12:19I'm gonna let this video roll, and this is a video of a humanoid robotFrom Boston Dynamics is I'm gonna read the information so we can watch the video, and we're gonna see this robot, uh, just moving things from bin to bin, parts, while they're trying to mess him up.
- 12:30Basically, Boston Dynamics and Toyota Research Institute are working to make humanoid robots useful in real life by teaching them complex, adaptable behaviors through massive AI models.
- 12:40So, um, a lot of people are familiar with Boston Dynamics, but Toyota Research Institute, which is a Toyota subsidiary, focus on human-centered AI innovations in automated driving, energy, and materials to do what they say improve the human condition.
- 12:55So this Atlas robot, if you're watching you can see, is being trained with a large behavioral model to handle all these tasks. And, uh, we see it squatting, bending over, putting parts from one bin into another.
- 13:07It's gonna be arranging them on shelves in a moment.
- 13:09Um, a single policy now enables Atlas to complete multi-step manipulation tasks like packing, sorting, and handling large objects with the team saying, quote, "If you can demonstrate it, the robot can learn it."
- 13:22So it learns by watching. What do you think of this robot we're watching, [laughs] Steve? I think we shouldn't be tormenting our robot overlords. [laughs] They are... So [laughs] that's a good point.
- 13:35So there's this very, very patient robot who's moving parts from one bin to another while there's somebody with a hockey stick, very Canadian, coming in and closing the bin, dragging the bin away from the robot, and the robot, like...
- 13:48It does feel like when the robot sees that something's changed, there's a min- there's, like, a minute thought in there where he says- [laughs]... "Will you please stop doing that? I'm trying to get something done."
- 13:57It won't be long before he neutralizes the threat. [laughs] And he says, the robot says, "If you do that one more time-" There you go... "I'm gonna, I'm gonna put you- "Stop, stop"... I'm gonna put you in this bin."
- 14:07[laughs] In the bin. In the bin, yeah. But hey, look, I mean, if you, if you look at where, where Elon's going with Tesla, like he's betting less on the adoption of EVs and more on two things, you know, AI and robotics.
- 14:19Mm-hmm. He says with his Optimus, um, uh, robots, you know, there, there's a market for a million of these things a year. Mm-hmm. And he believes that at volume the price will come down to 30 grand each.
- 14:29And, uh, there, there should be a humanoid robot in everybody's home, right? To do all those tasks like we're seeing here, repetitive tasks that we want- we, we don't wanna do. L- load the dishwasher- Mm...
- 14:39unload the dishwasher. [laughs] Do la- do laundry for us, mow the lawn. Yeah.
- 14:43You know, a- anything around the house that takes up your time that's of low value that you don't wanna do, these robotic, you know, sort of humanoid should be able to do. Whether we get there, I don't know.
- 14:52But I can tell you there's a whole bunch of these companies emerging also in China. You guys covered, like recently there's been like these, these Chinese Olympics over there- Mm-hmm...
- 15:00uh, to, to prove out just the limits of, of these robots, these humanoid ro- robots.
- 15:04And this technology's all coming, and, and you layer that into like the AI brain that we're all experimenting through with like ChatGPT, et cetera, and, uh, it can be, you know, equal amounts of like exhilarating and exciting, but also pretty, pretty scary.
- 15:16If these things do get smart, um, there's all kinds of app- ba- bad applications. For example, you, you deploy them on the battlefield, and they go house to house, they clean out the humans, right? Yeah.
- 15:26That we don't want, and eradicate the humans. Mm-hmm. So there's a lot of, uh, debate right now about sort of like the ethics around AI. Mm-hmm.
- 15:32And, uh, bo- both in the workplace, but also, like, you know, wi- with, with, um, o- other countries around the world that might not hold themselves to the same sort of ethical compass that the US would.
- 15:42Yeah, I mean, that... Geez, if I wasn't terrified enough when we started the show. Yeah. [laughs] Like the thought of that little robot dog going house to house with that gun turret on its top, like knock, knock, knock.
- 15:51I mean, but that, that isn't science fiction actually, it's reality. No longer. There are things- There are things.
- 15:56I was watching this video this morning, uh, I was still home, and, um, and I, I saw this video for the first time, and I just kind of like started to think, like, "Would I ever have a robot in my house?" Right?
- 16:08And you start to think like, oh, well, it could be like the, the euphoric part of it is like, I come, I wake up, and the house is clean, right? It wasn't when I went to sleep, but it was when I woke up.
- 16:17And then the next thought was like, I've also seen videos of what happens, like when the robot freaks out, right? Right.
- 16:23It falls over, and it just starts violently swinging and dri- [laughs] And can you imagine being asleep, and then just hear this massive commotion, right?
- 16:29And then there's this big hole in, in the, the back glass patio door, and the robot just ran- Right... out the back door, [laughs] jumped over the deck or something. [laughs] I was like, uh, you know what?
- 16:37I, I don't think I'm ready for that. [laughs] Yeah. Well, I think it's coming.
- 16:41I mean, we start, started maybe with the Roomba, but yeah, yeah- [laughs] I think it's inevitable that we'll, we'll have a lot of robots in our lives. Yeah. And they'll make life easier.
- 16:47But like you said, we've gotta like be very cautious around how quickly we adopt these things. Yeah.
- 16:52I'm just excited that, you know, when you and I, decades from now, uh, we're gonna be able to have our, like, strap on exoskeletons. Right.
- 16:59We're gonna be able to get around and get in our self-driving car and have all the mobility we ever wanted. So they're the parts I'm excited about.
- 17:04We'll, we'll leave the rest to other people to try to figure out and defend. [laughs] Well- Sorry about that... we'll be getting on ro- ro- roller coasters in Disney when we're 100. Yes. There you go.
- 17:14Together, you and me, Mickey Mouse ears. [laughs] Let's do it. Steve Greenfield, thank you so much for joining us today. Enjoy some sunshine in Orlando. Everyone else, get out there.
- 17:22Take care of the humans in your life, right? The humans are gonna be the one that are really worth it. [laughs] We'll see you here tomorrow.
- 17:31[upbeat music]