Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise Without a Performance Review
Transcript
- Lucas: Listener question today, and it's a good one: 'My company doesn't do formal performance reviews. How do I ask for a raise when there's no review cycle to anchor it to?' Luna: Oh, that's a common situation, especially at smaller companies or startups where reviews are ad hoc or non-existent. Lucas: Exactly. And the default move for a lot of people is to just wait and hope their boss brings it up. But that can leave you underpaid for years. Luna: Right. So if we've helped you think through a career move like this, or if you're listening and thinking 'I need to have this conversation,' just a quick note: the reason this show stays ad-free is listener support. If today was useful, you can keep it going at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: It really does make a difference. And it means we never have to interrupt the actual advice with a commercial break. Luna: Exactly. So let's get into the strategy. Lucas: Alright. So first thing: if there's no review cycle, you have to create your own trigger. The worst time to ask is out of the blue — 'Hey boss, can we talk about my salary?' with no context. Luna: That puts them on the defensive immediately. They don't have data in front of them, they don't know what you're going to ask, and the natural response is 'Let's talk about it at the next review' — which doesn't exist. Lucas: Right. So you need to frame it around a specific achievement or milestone. Maybe you just finished a big project, hit a quarterly goal, or took on new responsibilities. That's your opening. Luna: And you need market data. Websites like Levels.fyi or Glassdoor can give you a range for your role and location. Without that, you're just guessing. Lucas: I'd go a step further: get at least three data points. One from a salary survey, one from a job posting for a similar role, and one from a recruiter or peer if you can. Then you have a credible anchor. Luna: And you want to be specific about your contributions. Not 'I work hard,' but 'I led the migration to a new CRM that saved the team 20 hours a week.' Quantify it. Lucas: Exactly. So now you have a trigger event, you have market data, and you have your own metrics. The next step is the ask itself. Here's a three-sentence script I like. Luna: Let's hear it. Lucas: Sentence one: 'I wanted to set aside some time to talk about my compensation, given the impact I've had on this quarter.' That frames it around performance, not entitlement. Luna: And it gives the boss context. They know what's coming, but it's not an ambush. Lucas: Sentence two: 'Based on my research, the market range for my role is between X and Y, and I'm currently at Z.' You're showing you did your homework, not just asking for a number out of nowhere. Luna: That's key. You're not demanding; you're informing. And it invites a discussion rather than a rejection. Lucas: Sentence three: 'I'd like to discuss what it would take to bring my compensation in line with that market range, given my contributions.' This keeps it collaborative — you're asking for a conversation, not a decision on the spot. Luna: And then you shut up and let them respond. Don't fill the silence with nervous chatter. Lucas: Right. Now, the boss might say 'We don't have budget for a raise right now.' That's a common objection. Your response: 'I understand. What would need to happen for a raise to be possible in the next quarter? Can we set a check-in on that?' Luna: That pushes them to define a path. If they say 'We just don't do off-cycle raises,' then you have a different problem — you may need to look externally. Lucas: And that's a legitimate outcome. Sometimes the company's structure just doesn't allow it. But at least you've tried, and you've put yourself on their radar if they do get budget later. Luna: One thing to add: timing matters. Don't ask right after a layoff or during a company-wide cost-cutting initiative. That's tone-deaf. Lucas: Good point. Also, don't ask when your boss is clearly stressed or about to go on vacation. Pick a calm moment, maybe after a win. Luna: And if they say yes? Great. But if they say 'We'll look into it,' follow up. Send a brief email summarizing the conversation and the next steps. Keep it professional. Lucas: I'd send that email within 24 hours. Something like: 'Thanks for the conversation earlier. As discussed, I'll be looking forward to revisiting this in Q3 after the budget cycle.' That creates a paper trail. Luna: Exactly. And if they say no definitively, ask for feedback. 'What would I need to achieve to be considered for a raise in the future?' That sets a clear goal. Lucas: Now, there's another angle here. If your company truly has no review cycle, you might want to propose one. Suggest a quarterly check-in focused on goals and compensation. Luna: That's a proactive move. It helps not just you, but your whole team. And it positions you as someone who thinks about process improvement. Lucas: Exactly. So to summarize: create your own trigger, gather market data, quantify your impact, use the three-sentence script, and handle objections gracefully. Luna: And if all else fails, you've at least practiced the conversation for when you interview elsewhere. That practice is valuable on its own. Lucas: Great point. Alright, we'll take that listener question and turn it into action. Next episode, we're talking about how to ask for a raise when you've only been at the company six months — which is a whole different challenge. Luna: That's a good one. See you then.