Latest / Film And Whiskey / Joker / Benromach 10-Year Single Malt Scotch
Transcript
- 0:00In 2019, director Todd Phillips and star Joaquin Phoenix gave
- 0:05the world the darkest film we have ever watched.
- 0:10In 2025 we take a return trip to Scotland for the first time in
- 0:15weeks. The I like the way you put that,
- 0:19Like we just, yeah, we just hang out in Scotland pretty often.
- 0:21It's been too long, Brad. Too long.
- 0:24The film is Joker. The whiskey is Ben Romack, 10
- 0:28year. And we'll review them both.
- 0:30This is the film. And Whiskey podcast.
- 0:53Welcome to the Film and Whiskey podcast, where each week we
- 0:55review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 0:58I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 1:01And this week we are throwing it back about five years here,
- 1:04Brad. Well, a little more than five
- 1:06years I guess, which is crazy to think about.
- 1:08I remember when Joker came out, obviously, but it was pre COVID
- 1:14and those COVID years, we've said it many times on this
- 1:17podcast, just really screwed with my perception of time.
- 1:20It's weird to think that this movie's already been out for
- 1:22five years because it feels like it was, you know, maybe two
- 1:25years ago. I don't know, maybe it's just
- 1:27me. Yeah, I mean, according to
- 1:29Tarantino, 2019 was the last year that cinema existed.
- 1:34So that like this just feels like an epoch ago.
- 1:39Which is crazy because Tarantino also happened to just release a
- 1:43movie in 2019. He got his movie in just under
- 1:46the wire before cinema night. Yeah.
- 1:48Funny how that happened. What what a coincidence.
- 1:51All right, so today we're looking at Joker and folks, I'm
- 1:54going to lay all my cards out on the table right after this
- 1:57little teaser. Welcome into film in Whiskey.
- 2:00If this is your first time listening to us, we talk about
- 2:03movies, we talk about whiskey this season, we're looking at
- 2:06movies from the last 20 years and we're asking the question,
- 2:09does this movie deserve to be considered a modern masterpiece?
- 2:14Joker is a really interesting document, Brad, of, I guess the
- 2:18late twenty 10s, early twenty 20s.
- 2:22It's, you know, obviously still really relevant to our times.
- 2:25They just came out with the sequel this past year that was
- 2:27pretty universally panned and flopped hard at the box office.
- 2:31So Joker is still somewhat top of mind for people.
- 2:36But I wanted to lay my cards out on the table by saying this,
- 2:39Brad, I watched this movie. I think it's a pretty well made
- 2:44movie. I don't have quite the visceral
- 2:47hate for it that it seems like a lot of movie critics have, but I
- 2:51will say that I don't know if I've ever been less excited to
- 2:55start watching a movie for our show.
- 2:58I definitely at multiple points this week could have started
- 3:01this movie and just decided against it 'cause you really
- 3:05gotta get yourself in a specific frame of mind to take in this
- 3:09movie. Yeah, I watched this film maybe
- 3:14a year ago and was impressed with a lot of the craft of the
- 3:20film and highly unimpressed with the message.
- 3:23So coming into this time, I was really curious where I would be.
- 3:27I I don't know if I quite had the trepidation to get into it
- 3:31that you did. It's definitely a hard movie to
- 3:35make yourself watch. Yeah.
- 3:38And it's not filmed with the sort of like, hatred for
- 3:42humanity that someone like a David Fincher has.
- 3:45But it definitely reminds me of watching a movie like 7, where
- 3:48you just come out of that movie and you feel real icky, and you
- 3:51feel like you need a shower. And there's not a lot of rays of
- 3:55hope happening at the end of this movie.
- 3:58So we're going to dive into it. We're going to talk about it a
- 4:01lot. But Brad, I, I'm really curious
- 4:03to hear what you think of Joker. So maybe for the earliest time
- 4:08this season, we're at the four minute mark.
- 4:09I think. Let's just jump right in and
- 4:11let's get into, Brad explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 4:14movie plots with only 60 seconds sticking on the clock, so let's
- 4:18go ahead and do your take with this little segment that we
- 4:21call, Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 4:24show where Brad breaks down the plot of the film that he has
- 4:27just seen often for the first time.
- 4:30Now, this is of course, Brad's second time watching this film.
- 4:33It's not really a super complicated plot, Brad, and we
- 4:36will discuss how it seems to be a plot that's reused a lot, but
- 4:41it should be something that you can handle in 60 seconds, no?
- 4:45I I think I have this Bob. By the way, nice sultry voice
- 4:50you have there today, Brad. That's what happens when you get
- 4:53sick, Bob. Dude, I I have never gotten sick
- 4:57with the frequency that I do now after having children.
- 5:00It's like, and I thought that it worked that such that like kids
- 5:04get sick a lot because their immune systems haven't built up
- 5:07the tolerance, but I as an adult should have the talt.
- 5:10Like why am I getting sick all the time?
- 5:12Yeah, I It's because kids are dirty, and not only do they fray
- 5:17your last nerve, they also fray your bodily health.
- 5:21It's wild. And that's our endorsement for
- 5:24parenthood, folks. Dude, if anybody's, if anybody's
- 5:27out there listening, have kids. It's the absolute best thing in
- 5:31the world. Yeah, you get to sound like
- 5:33this, Bob. You gave such a glowing
- 5:34endorsement that I'm sure that really rings true with most
- 5:37people now. All right, Brad, let's dive into
- 5:39Joker. So you have 60 seconds on the
- 5:42clock, folks. We are going to spoil this whole
- 5:43movie. So if you haven't gotten around
- 5:45to seeing the Best Picture nominee Joker, hit pause, go
- 5:49watch the film, and then come back and rejoin us for the rest
- 5:51of the episode. Brad, one minute and go.
- 5:55Joker is a film about an evil society that tramples a poor man
- 6:01into absolute terror. The end.
- 6:06The end. Boom.
- 6:08Bad society, Bad society. OK.
- 6:13How do we want to frame today, Brad?
- 6:15I've been kind of sending you little tiny fragments of
- 6:18thoughts I have on this movie throughout the day.
- 6:20And I have so many thoughts, but I don't really know how to
- 6:22construct an episode out of them.
- 6:25It feels weird to just jump into like performances because
- 6:28there's really only one performance we need to talk
- 6:30about in the movie. And obviously Joaquin wins best
- 6:34actor for this movie. I think we would both agree that
- 6:36he does a pretty phenomenal job, right?
- 6:38Like I I don't have any complaints about his
- 6:41performance. I have lots of complaints, lots
- 6:45of thoughts about the movie that he is in so.
- 6:50Personally, I I think we need to spend at least 10 minutes
- 6:54talking about Sam Morel and his role in the film.
- 6:57Who is that? He's the You've never heard Sam
- 7:02Morel. No.
- 7:04Oh bro, I thought you were in a stand up.
- 7:06He's the comedian that's on stage right before Arthur
- 7:12Joaquin goes up and he's he's talking about, you know, how men
- 7:17and women view sex. You know what, there's also a
- 7:19comedian or before him, Gary Goldman, who's like a long time
- 7:23working comedian. That's that was in the movie.
- 7:24So I was like, oh, I recognize him.
- 7:26OK, so there you go. Let's talk about stand up comics
- 7:29who make brief cameos, but not, crucially, Joaquin Phoenix.
- 7:33So here's the thing. Here's the thing with Joaquin,
- 7:38like he reflects the absolute I, I mean, obviously he sets the
- 7:43tone, but in a lot of ways, I feel like the this whole movie
- 7:49is an overindulgence and his performance is just that.
- 7:54Now am I saying it's a bad performance?
- 7:56Like not in any stretch of the imagination.
- 7:59I think Joaquin does incredible things.
- 8:03I I think his ability to have like 3 different laughs for the
- 8:09joker based on like what's going on around him is incredible.
- 8:15The scene where he kills Randall and then is helping the the
- 8:23dwarf that is also a clown get out of the apartment.
- 8:26It like I think Joaquin just freaking knocks it out of the
- 8:30park, dude. But I once again, I, I think my
- 8:34struggle with this film will never be I, I don't know if I
- 8:38can separate the darkness of this film and the message that I
- 8:43think is so wrong and terrible from Joaquin's performance.
- 8:47Well, then maybe let's just go ahead and start diving into
- 8:49messaging in this movie because I've been really struggling with
- 8:54why the movie doesn't totally click for me.
- 8:57Why doesn't it work? And why do I feel like this
- 9:00movie is irresponsible in the way that it handles its themes?
- 9:05Because, you know, I was, I was saying earlier that it kind of
- 9:08lifts plot elements. And the thing that it was most
- 9:10accused of copying off was early Scorsese, especially a movie
- 9:14called The King of Comedy. And then prior to that, Taxi
- 9:18Driver. And the movie really does follow
- 9:19the structure of Taxi Driver. And so I understand that people
- 9:25accuse it of ripping those movies off.
- 9:26I don't necessarily think it does that.
- 9:28I I didn't think so on this viewing at least.
- 9:32But when I compare it to a movie like Taxi Driver, the reason
- 9:36Taxi Driver works is because from the very beginning of the
- 9:39movie, not only do you understand that Travis Bickle is
- 9:43an unstable person, but you never view him or anything he
- 9:48does in terms of like, heroic framing.
- 9:52They never use the language of film to establish his actions as
- 9:57heroic. And so even at the end of the
- 10:00movie, when you have that kind of like, darkly humorous
- 10:03epilogue where it turns out Travis didn't die, and not only
- 10:08did he not die, but he's getting like letters of commendation and
- 10:10being viewed as a hero by the public, it's like, oof, that
- 10:14hits even harder because there are people like this among us.
- 10:18That's kind of what they're trying to go for with Joker.
- 10:21But I think that Todd Phillips uses cinematic techniques that
- 10:28set the Joker up in such a way that the audience is
- 10:31sympathizing with and rooting for him, even as you watch him
- 10:35do, like, horrific stuff. It's not that you want to be
- 10:39rooting for him, but I feel like this movie is framing itself
- 10:43almost as like a good triumphing over evil or a guy overcoming
- 10:48the obstacles, but the obstacles are like innocent people that he
- 10:53shoots to death. It's just it's a very confused
- 10:57messaging. Well, I, for me, I walked away
- 11:00this second time watching it and I was just kind of like, I feel
- 11:04like this is like a very radical socialists fever dream.
- 11:12Like the idea that rich young stockbrokers that are in their
- 11:18like late 20s, like just because they are mean to a lower class
- 11:26citizen, if you will, on the subway, we can assume that they
- 11:32are just terrible people in their entire lives and they
- 11:34deserve to die. And, and it just, you know,
- 11:38continues to spiral from there. And I really, really struggle
- 11:43with this viewpoint that the world is just this inherently
- 11:49nihilistically dark place that pretty much everybody is evil or
- 11:55broken in their own ways and deserve death.
- 11:59And they deserve death because of these supposed sins that they
- 12:05have committed. Yeah, man, it's, it's a struggle
- 12:09for sure. And I I will also say on the
- 12:11stockbroker front, the three guys that he murders on the
- 12:14subway, surprisingly very adept at musical theatre.
- 12:19I would not have expected those three finance Bros to know
- 12:22Stephen Sondheim to the extent that.
- 12:24They I, I agree with that and I think that's like a very, it's a
- 12:31good call out Bob because it's, to me, it points out the
- 12:35weirdness of this movie and how it doesn't feel like he can
- 12:39really stick to a tone or like an identity for the people in
- 12:45the movie. It just feels like he's kind of
- 12:47throwing a lot of stuff in there that he wants to see.
- 12:49Yeah. And well, and I feel like
- 12:51getting back to the theme thing, like I say that it's confused
- 12:54because I feel like, and again, it, I'm not trying to say that I
- 12:58know Todd Phillips's mind, but it almost feels like the things
- 13:02that he wants us to be kind of chewing and marinating on are
- 13:06really underdeveloped. And the things that he doesn't
- 13:09intend to be poking through are the things that actually do poke
- 13:12through. And I mean that like
- 13:14thematically. So I think it's pretty clear.
- 13:16And you kind of called this out when you're talking about it as
- 13:18like a socialist fever dream. I think that this movie wants to
- 13:23kind of toe the line of being political and being like what it
- 13:28perceives to be timely. Obviously this comes out during
- 13:30the first Trump administration and you have at the beginning of
- 13:33the movie a a lower class man whose mom only watches the news,
- 13:40doesn't have friends, but watches the news all day and and
- 13:44says this billionaire is such a good guy.
- 13:47He's going to save us all. He's he should be in government.
- 13:50Like it feels like Todd Phillips is trying to hint at like a
- 13:54Trumpian figure. No, Rob, definitely, definitely
- 13:59not. But then they also do the thing
- 14:01of like, but we're going to set it in 1980.
- 14:04So it's not current times. And it feels like they're
- 14:06hedging. Like if you're going to make a
- 14:09movie that is intending to be some kind of either social
- 14:11satire or just like a social commentary, you got to give it
- 14:16some teeth, dude. Like make it a little more
- 14:18biting than this, whether or not the audience ends up eating that
- 14:20up. Like you have to go whole hog on
- 14:24that. And it feels like at every step
- 14:27they want to be controversial, but then they want to make him
- 14:30an empathetic figure. They want to be bold, but then
- 14:32they want to soften it with, you know, traditional filmmaking
- 14:35techniques. They want it to be timely, but
- 14:37we're going to set it in the past so that it can't be a one
- 14:39to one. And it just constantly feels
- 14:42like a guy that wants to, like he wants to muddy up the waters
- 14:46a little bit, but he's too afraid to do so.
- 14:48I also think that this movie works way better if in in
- 14:54pairing with what you just said, like make it more direct.
- 14:58If that's what you're trying to say.
- 15:00Get rid of the DC of it all, yeah?
- 15:03Let's talk about that. Like don't make this a movie
- 15:06about Joker like 100% you could make this movie 100% the same,
- 15:13including all the clown stuff. Like he can be a clown on the
- 15:17streets of 1980s New York totally fine.
- 15:21But like why in the world did this have to be a comic book
- 15:26movie? It literally makes continues to
- 15:30make zero sense to me. Well OK, so this might be a good
- 15:33place to touch on the sequel a little bit.
- 15:35And I know you haven't seen the sequel.
- 15:37I might be like one of the five people that don't absolutely
- 15:41hate the sequel. It is at least 1/2 hour too
- 15:43long. It is very boring, but it is a
- 15:46much more direct and coherent like Vision from Todd Phillips,
- 15:52because I think he basically, he basically thought like people
- 15:55misinterpreted what I was trying to do with my first movie.
- 15:58So I'm going to use the entirety of the second movie to under
- 16:01score that this man is not a hero.
- 16:03And in fact, he's like the biggest loser on earth.
- 16:06And that's like like the the second movie is punishing
- 16:09towards towards Arthur. Oh, that's honestly Bob, that's
- 16:12partially fascinating to me because I, I feel like you
- 16:15walked into that movie theater like a wolf into a sheep pen,
- 16:20like you were just salivating at the opportunity to hate on that
- 16:24movie. So I'm impressed First off that
- 16:26you, you gave it its due process if you will.
- 16:30Secondly, I, I don't know about you, Bob, I walked away from
- 16:34watching Joker thinking, man, not only is Arthur Fleck a
- 16:38loser, he is a sociopathic murderer.
- 16:43That is not a hero, correct? Should not be lionized.
- 16:49Well, and that's getting back to your whole thing about the DC of
- 16:51it all. So it feels like they're trying
- 16:54to shoehorn in these references to Bruce Wayne to, you know,
- 16:58Thomas Wayne. So like all these people.
- 17:01And it doesn't really work because even at the as the movie
- 17:05comes out, Todd Phillips is saying like, we're leaving it
- 17:08ambiguous as to whether this guy really is the Joker that you
- 17:11know, or whether he's just going to inspire the Joker.
- 17:15And it's like, so this isn't even ADC character.
- 17:17He's just a guy. And again, not trying to spoil
- 17:20the whole second movie for you, Brad.
- 17:22It's made very clear in the second movie, this guy's not the
- 17:25Joker. So what are we doing here?
- 17:27I don't know if you know this but it's like next on my list.
- 17:30There's no way I can go another day in my life without.
- 17:33Seeing Joker fully idea, it would only be better if it was
- 17:39directed by Denny Villeneuve. Only better is a correct
- 17:45phrasing if it was directed by Denny.
- 17:48So yes, the DC of it all kind of pisses me off a little bit too,
- 17:52because the movie definitely works better without the DC
- 17:55references. However, I think we have to be
- 17:58honest and say like, this movie also doesn't gross a billion
- 18:00dollars without the DC connection.
- 18:04So yeah, I don't, I don't know. Yeah.
- 18:06If if you want to make money, you know make a comic book movie
- 18:09in the 20 teens. If you don't want to make money,
- 18:12make a comic book movie in the twenty 20s.
- 18:15Yeah, that's that's true. They once again, they got it in
- 18:18right under the wire right before cinema ended.
- 18:21All right, So Brad, we've we've kind of set up some of our
- 18:25trepidations with the movie. Our our peccadillo's with the
- 18:28movie. I don't know man, where do you
- 18:30want to go from here? Like Joaquin's very good.
- 18:33This movie is very confused. Should we jump into things we
- 18:37liked? Should we keep trying to explore
- 18:39what it is that makes this movie not work?
- 18:41I'm not sure. Yeah, I mean, I'm curious how
- 18:43you feel about De Niro. Like he's the only other actor,
- 18:47like really in the movie. His mom is in it a little bit.
- 18:53I'm very curious where you're at on De Niro on Late Night Show
- 18:57host De Niro. Well, let's talk about the De
- 19:00Niro performance and let's talk about the character of Murray
- 19:03Franklin. So as De Niro's gotten older,
- 19:07he's obviously, I think leaned into the fact that like he
- 19:09doesn't have to memorize his line so much anymore.
- 19:12He improvises a lot. This really felt like he showed
- 19:16up on set and it was his first time reading any of his lines.
- 19:20Like there were some really awkward line readings from him
- 19:22in this movie. So I think it's a bad
- 19:24performance. I also think that he doesn't
- 19:27have late night host vibes at all.
- 19:29He's not a charismatic guy. And why is Murray Franklin such
- 19:36a Dick? Why is his show like set up to
- 19:39be mean to regular people? That's not how late night TV
- 19:42works. Exactly that.
- 19:44That to me was the biggest, like, bizarre decision of the
- 19:49writing team where I'm like, yeah, IA 100% believe that
- 19:54Joaquin Phoenix and Francis Conroy are like watching late
- 19:59night TV host together and falling asleep to it.
- 20:02That is very believable. I don't know, man.
- 20:05Maybe the 80s were just a lot meaner than we know about.
- 20:09Like maybe, you know, all these late night show hosts were just
- 20:13being absolute DS to their guests.
- 20:17It seems to me, though, based on clips that I've seen from late
- 20:21night television of this, you know, 60s, seventies, 80s, that
- 20:25these are some of the most congenial, charismatic, like fun
- 20:30to be around guys in the world. And De Niro is basically like if
- 20:35Travis Bickle got about two steps more charismatic.
- 20:40Well, and they're obviously getting De Niro to be in the
- 20:42movie to have something to kind of volley against the
- 20:47accusations of them ripping off Taxi Driver in King of Comedy.
- 20:50It's like, oh, well, now he gets to be the late night host
- 20:52instead of the comedian. And it's like, OK, cool, you
- 20:55made a little meta joke. But I just don't think he's the
- 20:58right guy for this role, man. Did you see that they tried to
- 21:01get Leo to play Arthur Fleck opposite of De Niro?
- 21:06I don't know if that would have worked as well.
- 21:09I actually, I, I really think Phoenix is good for what they're
- 21:12trying to do with this character.
- 21:14Like, I, yeah, even that very first shot of him putting his
- 21:17make up on in the mirror and forcing his fingers into his
- 21:20mouth to make himself smile and you get the teardrop.
- 21:22It's like, oh, I know everything I need to know about this guy.
- 21:25Yeah, that that scene was apparently just completely like,
- 21:30there's nothing in the script about him crying.
- 21:33Joaquin just, like, walked on the stat, pulled his face up
- 21:36into a smile and a tear fell out of his eye.
- 21:39And Todd Phillips is like, all right, next scene.
- 21:41Moving on. We, we got it, dude.
- 21:45Brad. OK, so here's where I want us to
- 21:48go today. I think that I still have more
- 21:50complaints. As always, I want to center them
- 21:54around the ending of the movie and why the ending of the movie
- 21:57is what makes this movie so problematic.
- 21:59And I'm not even talking about the climactic gunshot.
- 22:02I'm talking about what happens after that.
- 22:04But in order to do that, I think this is a good time to go ahead
- 22:07and press pause and drink some whiskey.
- 22:08We're a little bit early, but if I'm going to talk any more about
- 22:11this movie, I need a drink, dude.
- 22:13I'm with you man, Let's do it. All right, so today we are
- 22:21checking out Ben Romach space side single malt Scotch whiskey.
- 22:26Ben, I almost called you Ben because I'm talking about Ben
- 22:29Romach. Brad.
- 22:30I looked up a video of how to properly pronounce it just to
- 22:33make sure I wasn't going to stick my foot in my mouth here.
- 22:36And they, they have the the chapter at the end of Ben Romach
- 22:41is like aspirated. It's not quite as, it's not
- 22:44quite as throaty as like a Hoff in Hebrew, but it's, you got to
- 22:50say Ben Romack. So I've been.
- 22:52Practicing. No man, I like drinking my Ben
- 22:54Romack. Ben rematch 10 years.
- 22:57So this is a space side whiskey Brad, it's been a minute since
- 22:59we've had a space side. I am very excited for this
- 23:02because we've always said space side tends to be kind of like
- 23:05the most like delicate of the scotches that we've tried.
- 23:08At least Highland packs a little bit more of a punch.
- 23:11And then obviously you've got your Isla, you know, among the
- 23:14other couple regions. But it's been a minute and we've
- 23:18never tried Ben Romack. This is their entry level 10
- 23:22year version. They also have, I see on their
- 23:24website a 15 year and then they've got super premium ones
- 23:27that are in the 20s. Brad, what can you remember
- 23:30about the space side scotches that we've tried to this point?
- 23:34Man, I, I mean, I really don't remember much about our space
- 23:39sides. Is is Abrilower a space side?
- 23:43Yeah, so I, I do remember really enjoying the Abirlowers.
- 23:48For me, they had a lot of like Berry notes and like a very
- 23:58beautiful floral delicacy to them.
- 24:02Yeah, I'm with you, dude. That's exactly what I pick up on
- 24:04space sides as well. And it's funny because as we
- 24:06transition into the nose on this one, I actually get a little bit
- 24:10more like a peat smoke on this one than I think I've ever
- 24:13gotten on a space side before. Brad, I think you've tried it
- 24:16already. I'm drinking it live so I've
- 24:18given one nosing note, but I'm going to go ahead and stick my
- 24:21nose in this class while you give your notes.
- 24:24Bob, I am going to give you one of the best nosing notes of all
- 24:27time. This reminds me of Honey Smacks.
- 24:32Oh wow. Right.
- 24:36Like they're so good but they like even when I ate them I felt
- 24:39like it was the poorest I ever felt as a kid.
- 24:42Yes exactly. This seems like poor people
- 24:45food. Like Great Depression era
- 24:47cereal. Yeah, so honey smacks quite,
- 24:52quite the endorsing opinion there, Bob.
- 24:57There is a bunch of vanilla here.
- 24:59It's got like a really nice thick cherry, syrupy vibe on the
- 25:02nose. There's some cranberry, there's
- 25:05some plum. I overall, it's a really
- 25:09pleasant nose that has me intrigued.
- 25:12I'm going to give it a 7 1/2 out of 10.
- 25:14Yeah. I'm going to be just a little
- 25:15bit lower than you. I meant just a 7 out of 10.
- 25:18When I first poured it out, I got like really bright orange
- 25:21and and cinnamon notes that definitely had the Pete smoke to
- 25:24it as well. And then it kind of like it
- 25:27started to get a couple funky notes on it.
- 25:28I get some almost raw, like yeasty dough on it.
- 25:32I get some, there's some kind of wood that I can't like put my
- 25:34finger on, but it smells like a wet, almost like balsa wood and
- 25:38like it. It was a really weird note for
- 25:40me to get. I like it.
- 25:43I wish that it was a little more in that kind of delicate fruity
- 25:46realm that we like. So I'm just in A7 and hoping
- 25:49that it gets better on the taste.
- 25:51I think the palette is incredible.
- 25:55There is plum. There's like a really nice cacao
- 25:58note kicking through the entire experience.
- 26:01It reminds me a little bit of like a Rice Krispie treat, like
- 26:05a like a sugary, grainy vibe there.
- 26:09There is a lot of really nice flavors.
- 26:11It's not overwhelmingly complex, so somewhat simple in its
- 26:15presentation, but I'm going to give it an 8 out of 10 Bob.
- 26:19Wow, this is way smokier than I would have expected just looking
- 26:22at the bottle and seeing the word space side.
- 26:24If you had told me that this was like a more lightly peated Isla
- 26:29Scotch, I believe you. But this doesn't remind me of
- 26:32any of the space eyes we've had to this point.
- 26:34Which is fine. Like you don't have to mimic
- 26:37other distilleries with the product you're creating.
- 26:39It's just kind of throwing off my mental expectations here, so
- 26:43I'm trying to readjust a little bit.
- 26:46I definitely get a much more vegetable, much more medicinal
- 26:50note towards the back end. It's got like that kind of woody
- 26:52grass type note to it, not quite Piney, but in that realm it has
- 26:58that almost like ashy cigarette kind of taste towards the back
- 27:01as well. But I will say it's got a layer
- 27:04of sweetness that helps to offset that a little bit so it
- 27:07doesn't tip fully bitter at the end.
- 27:09I like this quite a bit. I think I'm just still resetting
- 27:13what I was expecting it to be. I'm going to come up to a 7.5 on
- 27:16the pallet. I think the finish is really
- 27:19nice. I think that there's a little
- 27:23bit of oakiness to it. It gets kind of spicy at the
- 27:26end. There is that for me it turned
- 27:29into that vegetal note almost almost into a dilly type of
- 27:36region. Overall pretty good finish,
- 27:39drops off a little bit from the nose and the taste.
- 27:41I'm going to give it a 7 out of 10.
- 27:43Yeah, I like the finish. I don't really have a lot of
- 27:45notes on this one. It doesn't feel like a super
- 27:47complex whiskey to me. It does get bitter and it does
- 27:51get kind of overly like it's, it's so smoky that it almost
- 27:57comes back around into sourness. I don't quite know how to
- 28:00explain that. But like the flavors that are
- 28:01left a minute after on the back of my palate are turning sour.
- 28:06And so I think that this is kind of like if this was an Isla
- 28:10Scotch, I would think it's an underwhelming experience as a
- 28:12space side Scotch. I kind of think it's a little
- 28:14bit of an underwhelming experience and it's so far out
- 28:17of the wheelhouse of what we've come to identify space side as
- 28:21that it feels kind of like a bottle floating on its own out
- 28:25in between Space Side and the I Love region.
- 28:28I have no idea what to make of this.
- 28:30I'm going to give it a 6.5 on the finish.
- 28:33I'm going to give it just a 7 out of 10 on the balance.
- 28:36Brad, did you give a balance score?
- 28:38I didn't. I'll I'll give it a 7 1/2 on the
- 28:40balance. I think there's good flavors
- 28:42that all work together really well and I like, I'm a fan.
- 28:47I I like this Bob, I found this. It seems like you can get it for
- 28:52around $50.00 in the States, which is, I think an eminently
- 28:59reasonable price for this whiskey.
- 29:01Yeah, I'm going to, man. I'm going to purposely fudge my
- 29:06numbers, Brad. I'm going to ruin the integrity
- 29:08of my scoring structure here because right now I'm at a 28
- 29:12out of 40 and I think that the price on this is extremely fair.
- 29:17Like I was going to give it a 7 out of 10.
- 29:18It's only A7 because I don't really like it that much.
- 29:21But if we're just talking like if you had to buy this blind
- 29:25without ever tasting it, it's like a nine or a 10 out of 10 on
- 29:29value. However, if I do give it a
- 29:31seven, I would be at a 35 out of 50, which is where we start
- 29:34recommending a product and I, I don't think I recommend this
- 29:37one, Brad. So I'm I'm going to give it a
- 29:39six, keeping me at a 34 out of 50.
- 29:43You just said this could be a nine out of 10 value.
- 29:46Yeah, it could be. And then you gave it a six.
- 29:48Yeah, that. That's the brakes, dude.
- 29:51Dude this is like. As the Joker would say, that's
- 29:54life. That, that is life Bob.
- 29:58It didn't have to be that way. You could have chosen otherwise.
- 30:02This is an 8 1/2 out of 10 on value I like for 50 bucks.
- 30:07This is a really great single malt experience, regardless of
- 30:12if you are Snooty about a regional flavour tasting like
- 30:16what you expect a regional flavour to taste like.
- 30:18Not that I know anybody who's like that.
- 30:20Sure, sure. And in my entire life, Bob, I am
- 30:24coming to a 38.5 out of 50 here. All right, I'm going to, I'm
- 30:29going to 34 out of 50, which is bringing us to an average of a
- 30:3236.25. So we still landed in the soft
- 30:36recommend range anyway. I will say folks like just the
- 30:40value of it. It really is like A9 or A10.
- 30:43I just think that this was kind of a subpar drinking experience,
- 30:46and it's probably the first one that I wouldn't recommend that
- 30:50we've had in a long, long time. Brad.
- 30:52Just not my cup of tea this week.
- 30:54I. Sure, man.
- 30:57Whatever you say, Bob. I, I, I, I have seized.
- 31:01You know how you don't always know what movies I'm going to
- 31:03vibe with? Yeah, you, you throw me
- 31:05curveballs with our whiskey sometimes where I'm like, yeah,
- 31:08Bob's like, yeah, sure. This is this is pretty solid
- 31:11whiskey at a good value. Nah, don't recommend though.
- 31:14I don't think it's that solid. That's the thing.
- 31:16Like it's OK, I just think that like if you could get a bottle
- 31:20of like Talisker 10 for like 60 bucks instead of this Talisker
- 31:24is world's better than this bro. I dude I think the price on
- 31:28Talisker has gone up. I think it's like a $7580 bottle
- 31:32now. And I would agree with you.
- 31:34Talisker, 10, is world's better than this.
- 31:36Well yeah, but if it's 80 bucks then I get it man.
- 31:39So it sounds like you definitely recommend though.
- 31:41Would you try? Would you recommend trying it or
- 31:43buying it? Yeah, yeah.
- 31:45Try and buy great great great whiskey.
- 31:48Try followed by it by All right, man, I love it.
- 31:51Let's get back into talking about Joker.
- 31:53What do you say? I would say that Talisker Single
- 31:56Malt 10 Year Old will set you back $75.00 in the state of
- 31:59Ohio. It's all these, it's all these
- 32:02darn tariffs. They just didn't put it on Ben
- 32:04Roma because they don't think it's that good.
- 32:06That's what it was. Tariffs.
- 32:09All right, man, let's get back into talking about Joker.
- 32:11Let's get to it. All right, everybody, that was
- 32:20Ben Romack, 10. An unmitigated success at that
- 32:25$50 price point, don't you think, Bob?
- 32:28Whatever you say, man. Also, I'm, I'm just going to
- 32:31take a second and tell you, I can't trill my Rs.
- 32:36That was a good, that might have been the absolute best I have
- 32:39ever done in my life. I'm very proud of myself, right?
- 32:41That was a really good rolled R Man you you still missed the Ch
- 32:45sound but well, I was I. Literally was.
- 32:49I was so impressed with the rolled R that I just was like,
- 32:52I'm not even going to try. No, I know I can do that.
- 32:55It's like you got to quit while you're ahead and you quit mid
- 32:57word I. Sure did, Bob.
- 32:59I sure did. Speaking of things where I quit
- 33:03when I'm ahead, let's talk about two facts and a falsehood, Brad.
- 33:08Is going to try to stumpy ball 2 all right and what is wrong 2
- 33:15facts and a. Falsehood 2 Facts and a
- 33:18Falsehood is the part of the show where Brad presents me with
- 33:20three items as fact about the making of this movie, one of
- 33:24which is a complete lie. Brad, I'm still riding high off
- 33:27last week's victory in Everything Everywhere All At
- 33:30Once, where I did not enlist our guests help and still got it
- 33:34right. I'm not riding coattails this
- 33:36season, man. I'm doing pretty well.
- 33:38Lee Diaz, What a guy. Great guy.
- 33:40Truly what a guy. Go back and listen to that
- 33:43episode if you haven't heard it yet.
- 33:44If you've not ever purchased a bottle on Reserve Bar, I highly
- 33:49recommend that program. Lee, you know heads up the
- 33:52Single Barrel program as well. They pick absolute bangers on
- 33:56Reserve Bar. Dude, excellent whiskey.
- 33:59We're not being paid to say this not.
- 34:01Yet at least like unasked for plug Lee, you're welcome.
- 34:05You do great work and we think you're the best.
- 34:08Also, this is our pilot for advertising for you next season,
- 34:12so you know, send that money bro.
- 34:14There's more where this came from, Lee.
- 34:16Let's get into two facts and a falsehood.
- 34:19Fact #1 Early in production, director and writer Todd
- 34:22Phillips wanted Willem Dafoe to narrate the film as a unreliable
- 34:27older Joker, with his takes on the scenes growing more manic as
- 34:31the film neared its conclusion. Fact #2 Early footage shows
- 34:36Arthur walking by a sign for amusement mile Gotham City's
- 34:40version of Coney Island, which features prominently in the
- 34:43original Killing Joke graphic novel.
- 34:47Joker Co creator Bill Finger was partially inspired by a sign for
- 34:50Steeplechase Park in the real Coney Island, which featured a
- 34:53grotesque grinning face. Fact #3 the Super Rats segment
- 34:59on Murray Franklin's show and in the news references Ratcatcher,
- 35:04an obscure D List villain who could mind control rats.
- 35:08The character eventually made an appearance in James Gunn's The
- 35:12Suicide Squad. OK, 2 sounds the most factual,
- 35:18so I'm going to say 2 is a fact. Is it one or is it 3?
- 35:23I don't know anything about comic books. 3 sounds absolutely
- 35:27preposterous, but I can't tell if it's preposterous because you
- 35:30wrote it or because comic books are just dumb.
- 35:33Brad, That's that's where I'm at on that one.
- 35:36I think both of those things are probably true.
- 35:39So you're admitting to three being a falsehood.
- 35:42I, I mean, I, I would never ever admit to a falsehood, Bob.
- 35:46Number one also sounds fictional because people have been making
- 35:52like fan art of Willem Dafoe as the Joker for such a long time
- 35:56that it almost seems like it would be kind of like when they
- 35:59had the Juggernaut in that one X-Men Movie and they made him
- 36:03say the I'm the Juggernaut bitch.
- 36:05Like it feels like it would be more of a joke than a real thing
- 36:08at this point if Willem Dafoe was the Joker.
- 36:12Does that does that feel like something Ryan Reynolds would do
- 36:14or Todd Phillips though? That's what I'm saying I'm going
- 36:18to say #1 is the falsehood. But I'm really going to kick
- 36:22myself. If you admitted on air to
- 36:24writing #3 and I didn't pick it, but I'm still doing it, man.
- 36:29I'm going to go with number. One Bob.
- 36:31I have never once in my life seen a fan art of Willem Dafoe
- 36:37really as the Joker. Oh yeah, like all over the
- 36:40place, dude. It makes a lot of sense.
- 36:43He would be an incredible joke. Dude you know how they made
- 36:47Logan about like old Wolverine? They they could make Arthur
- 36:53about old Arthur Fleck and have Willem Dafoe play him.
- 36:57Well, they can't, if you saw what happens to Arthur Fleck at
- 37:00the end of the second movie. But aside from that, yeah.
- 37:03We Ultimate Universe Multiverse, Bob, they're all the rage.
- 37:09Fact number one is the falsehood.
- 37:11You got it correct. Yes.
- 37:14Do you know why Willem Dafoe works so well as the Joker Brad?
- 37:17Why is that? Bomb he has a gigantic mouth.
- 37:21He like just a huge mouth that like it makes so much sense.
- 37:24As the Joker that is. If that's the only qualification
- 37:28to be Joker, then Cameron Diaz would be an incredible Joker.
- 37:34Well, that's just not kind. Come on man.
- 37:37Dude, I she's a beautiful woman. Yeah.
- 37:40Also huge mouth. We could just like, have a Mick
- 37:44Jagger Joker. We could do a Steven Tyler from
- 37:47Aerosmith Joker. Just assemble a team of people
- 37:50with big mouths to be Joker. I have just a bunch of different
- 37:54like it's a multiverse Joker movie.
- 37:58This sounds terrible. We need to stop talking or
- 38:00Disney's going to actually make it.
- 38:02Or Warner Brothers. Or whoever the hell it is they
- 38:04they need. Content.
- 38:05Yeah, they they do need content. Where do you think life is at
- 38:10for superhero films? Because it just feels like they
- 38:14have had their last gasp, for the time being at least.
- 38:18Yeah, I still think there's probably a couple billion dollar
- 38:21movies waiting to be rung out of that.
- 38:23The whole thing, like Deadpool this last year, just made a
- 38:25billion dollars plus. Did it?
- 38:28Yeah, dude. And it's like it wasn't a good
- 38:29movie like. Yeah.
- 38:32Most of these are not good movies.
- 38:34And I think the thing about superhero movies is, like, we
- 38:37used to have superhero movies that we all understood would be
- 38:40bad, and then we just had fun with how bad they were.
- 38:43And now we're expected to take them all as, like, serious works
- 38:46of cinema, and they're still bad.
- 38:48So it's like, cool, I just watched an unenjoyably bad
- 38:51movie. And I think that's kind of where
- 38:54I'm at with it. I don't want to follow your
- 38:56stupid TV shows. I don't want to go into this
- 38:59Grim Dauer experience and have it be bad like we're we have run
- 39:04our course. That's where I'm at with
- 39:06superhero movies. I I think that's my problem with
- 39:09Joker in a lot of ways, is that I think they actually like the
- 39:15craft of this movie is really well done, Bob that there are so
- 39:20many pieces of this film. I I really truly like, it's just
- 39:24that the entire narrative force of this movie is like completely
- 39:29antithetical to how I see and understand the world.
- 39:34And I also think that it's like truly a harmful viewpoint for
- 39:40people to think this way about the world.
- 39:42I like, I think it's bad for society.
- 39:44Well, so let's let's hone in on that a little bit because I've
- 39:47also been thinking of like words like harmful and dangerous.
- 39:50And that's kind of why I brought up my taxi driver parallel in
- 39:54the first half, because this is not the first movie that tries
- 39:58to kind of gut punch you with the unhinged guy who has killed
- 40:03people is actually hailed as a hero.
- 40:06Taxi Driver does that Clock Rick Orange does that.
- 40:09But I think going back to again what I said in the first half,
- 40:12those movies never pretend like their main characters are heroic
- 40:17and they don't use the language of cinema.
- 40:20To paint them as heroic. And I think this movie does.
- 40:23And what I can't tell is if Todd Phillips intended that or if
- 40:27like he accidentally made a movie that was like a really
- 40:31good rags to riches story, but then still made that movie go
- 40:35where it does at the end of this.
- 40:37And I texted you at one point and I said maybe it's just
- 40:41because we just reviewed Creed, but this feels like a really
- 40:44effed up version of Rocky. Like it, you know, the it's set
- 40:48around the same time as the original Rocky.
- 40:50There's that level of grime and poverty.
- 40:53But it definite like, here, let me pull up the text I sent you
- 40:56because I phrased it so much better earlier.
- 41:01Yeah. And so I don't know if it's just
- 41:02like the guy on the stairs thing that you get in both Rocky or
- 41:06Joker, but I feel like it's presented structurally really
- 41:11similarly to Rocky. It's a rags to riches story.
- 41:15It's about a guy that overcomes the odds.
- 41:18And no matter how much they want you to see it as a descent into
- 41:22madness, the way they filmed the movie is like you're watching
- 41:27the training montage in Rocky. And so when Rocky goes and
- 41:32fights Apollo Creed at the end of the movie, even though he
- 41:34loses, you cheer for him. And in this movie, yes, you
- 41:39recognize, like, on its surface that what Arthur is doing is
- 41:42horrific, but it's almost like they've set you up to kind of be
- 41:47like, well, those maybe those people did deserve it.
- 41:49Those people really sucked. And that's a really, really
- 41:53tricky and dangerous tightrope to be walking.
- 41:56And I don't think it does it with much grace.
- 41:59Yeah, you don't know my favorite character in the movie, Thomas
- 42:02freaking Wayne when he punches him in the face in the bathroom.
- 42:07Like, tell me that's not the most John Wayne moment of a
- 42:11modern film you've seen in a while, Bob.
- 42:13Yeah, and The thing is, Thomas Wayne absolutely seemed like a a
- 42:17huge Dick and probably a bad person.
- 42:19You know what though? I didn't see him murdering
- 42:21innocent people. So like, sure, didn't you know?
- 42:24That's where we're at with this movie.
- 42:26If you put hands on my like 8 year old son as well, I'd
- 42:29probably punch you right in the nose too.
- 42:31Yep. And so that's why I wanted to
- 42:34talk about the ending of this movie.
- 42:35So Joker goes on the Murray Franklin program after Murray
- 42:39indicates that he wants to basically bring him on just to
- 42:41make fun of him. He has completely lost touch
- 42:44with reality. He's murdered at least five
- 42:45people at this point and admits to murdering people on air and
- 42:49then shoots Robert De Niro in the head, which apparently they
- 42:53do not broadcast that on tape delay.
- 42:55It went out live to millions of people and happened during the
- 42:59middle of a riot, which he also inadvertently sparked.
- 43:02And when they saw him kill this famous celebrity, it was the the
- 43:06spark that lit the flame that caused the revolution in Gotham.
- 43:11And he is now a hero amongst the disenfranchised in Gotham,
- 43:15leading to a maybe reign of terror.
- 43:20And that's where this movie gets really weird for me, man,
- 43:22because I don't know how you interpret the ending of this
- 43:25movie as anything more than a valorization of what he has
- 43:30done. Dude, he, he's pulled out of the
- 43:34car like Christ, like he's laid on the hood of an ambulance or a
- 43:40police car. And like the mob gathers around
- 43:43him like, like he is their salvation.
- 43:47And I like, it's that scene that makes me go, man, I don't care
- 43:52what Todd Phillips says. He knew what he was doing.
- 43:55Like you, you can't film that scene and not have the audience
- 44:01see Arthur Fleck as the hero of the film.
- 44:04Well, and I think it also opens up a whole bunch of unintended
- 44:07secondary questions of like, OK, let's just say that he's
- 44:12presenting him as as a hero for these people who are already
- 44:16angry. And he's not necessarily
- 44:18condoning the violence, but he's trying to portray this is how it
- 44:21gets when people are beat down for too long.
- 44:23This is what you can come to expect.
- 44:26I can. If you if you want to do that,
- 44:27Bob, go watch Do the right thing.
- 44:28Well, and I yeah, I was just saying I can almost, almost
- 44:32understand that point of view. The problem is that you're also
- 44:35folding in these issues of mental health, which are done
- 44:39really poorly and really sloppily.
- 44:41And you're making this person who admits to being mentally ill
- 44:45and we know probably schizophrenic and has breaks
- 44:47from reality, be the leader of this crusade.
- 44:52And so then the secondary question becomes, what is Todd
- 44:55Phillips trying to say, not about the Joker, but about the
- 44:57people who are worshipping him? Are you saying like, are you,
- 45:01are you ultimately saying that all of the poor disenfranchised
- 45:04people who are pissed off are also mentally ill?
- 45:08Because that offense? Like it just seems like there's
- 45:11no good way to interpret this where characters or or even Todd
- 45:15Phillips comes out clean at the end of it because he wrote, he
- 45:19writes himself such a convoluted ending that it, it reflects
- 45:24poorly on him and all the characters.
- 45:27I, I, you know, I don't know if I'm expressing it exactly how I
- 45:30want to, but do you know what I'm saying?
- 45:32Yeah 100% dude. The the reality is you can't
- 45:37walk away from this movie feeling clean.
- 45:40Like there is no non dirty way to walk away from this movie.
- 45:45Todd Phillips, for better or for worse, Like I I read AI read a
- 45:50quote from him saying that for him the through line of the film
- 45:54is kindness and how it's like if he had had just one person show
- 46:01him true kindness, maybe this wouldn't have happened.
- 46:04And I'm like, dude, I'm sorry, but like, that's not the message
- 46:08of this movie. Like, you created a grenade.
- 46:13You pulled the pin out and you put it in the hands of the
- 46:17American public. And when it exploded, it's kind
- 46:20of like oopsies. Yeah.
- 46:21I wanted to give them a flower, and instead I handed them a
- 46:24grenade. Right.
- 46:26Well, in the, the metaphor I was going to use was almost like,
- 46:28you know, it's like they they drilled a hole into a wall that
- 46:31you need to stick a piece of dynamite into and it has to be
- 46:33placed with precision to blow the whole thing up to collapse
- 46:36it. And I feel like to your point
- 46:38earlier, it is OK to make a movie where everyone in the
- 46:42movie is awful and you're supposed to, as a viewer, come
- 46:44out of it questioning how can humanity be so terrible to each
- 46:49other. There are movies that do that
- 46:51quite well and they're good movies.
- 46:54This movie I it just wants to have its cake and eat it too.
- 46:57It wants to make you think, like, man, the world is such a
- 47:00mean, horrible place. But then it also wants to make
- 47:03you feel not just empathy for the Arthur character as the
- 47:07person who's beat upon, but to root for him as he gets one over
- 47:11on these people through extremely violent and horrific
- 47:14means. And then it's like, well, OK, is
- 47:17your intent to just implicate all of us in how horrible human
- 47:21nature is? Because I think even that could
- 47:23have been done better. It just, it's not done with
- 47:25tact. And in movies like a taxi
- 47:27Driver, like A Clockwork Orange, you take that stick of dynamite
- 47:31and you get it put exactly where it needs to be.
- 47:33And it feels like, you know, you use the grenade metaphor, I'll
- 47:35use dynamite. It feels like he's just kind of
- 47:38been juggling the stick of dynamite that he knows is going
- 47:40to explode. And he kind of like, lobs it up
- 47:42against the wall. And he's like, that's close
- 47:44enough. And he walks away and he lets
- 47:46the wall get some damage done to it, but he doesn't do it with
- 47:50precision. And I feel like if you're going
- 47:53to juggle themes like this, you have to do it so much more
- 47:57tactfully than what we have here.
- 47:59Absolutely. And I, I'm curious, I, I, I
- 48:02don't know if you're OK with me moving us into to let's make it
- 48:06a double. Yep.
- 48:07But I I think for me, well. Hold on, let's play the theme
- 48:10song, Brad. Hold on.
- 48:11We're going to do. Let's make it a double.
- 48:13Presented by Blackwood Distilling Company.
- 48:15We're. Near the end of the episode.
- 48:17So thanks listening to the film and whiskey show.
- 48:20Let's have another film with this one.
- 48:22Even if it's struggling. It's the final segment of the
- 48:24dinner. Let's make it a double.
- 48:25Let's Make It a double Is the part of the show where we pick a
- 48:28movie to Paris up with this one to make the perfect double
- 48:31feature. Brad, you were on a roll.
- 48:33I, I didn't mean to interrupt you there, but you go ahead and
- 48:36share your double feature with us.
- 48:38I I'm going to pair it with a movie that I think does what
- 48:42Todd Phillips is trying to do. Maybe not in the same like vein.
- 48:46They're not. The two movies are not trying to
- 48:48say the same thing, but I think they both have a slightly
- 48:52nihilistic view of the world. I'm going to pair this with
- 48:56American Beauty. Interesting.
- 49:00I I I think both films have artistic merit.
- 49:04The story that they are trying to tell can be interesting at
- 49:08points. I just think that American
- 49:10Beauty does the whole examination of like the thin
- 49:17veneer of the American suburban dream way better than Joker does
- 49:24the harshness of modern society, if you could say that that's
- 49:31what he's fighting against. I think they're both trying to
- 49:32get at like the rot that is at the core of America as they see
- 49:36it. But you're right, I think that
- 49:38American Beauty does it better. And this movie if if what you're
- 49:41looking at is the quote UN quote rot, this movie starts with them
- 49:45in like 1970s New York City basically where it's like the
- 49:49dirtiest a city has ever been. You're already in the rot.
- 49:52And so it doesn't really feel like they have to work that hard
- 49:55to convince you of like, everyone's on edge, everyone's
- 49:58crazy, you know. So I'm, I'm with you, man.
- 50:00Now that you've explained it, I like that pairing for mine.
- 50:04I'm going to go ahead and pair it with a movie that I also
- 50:07don't think accomplishes what it wants to in terms of its social
- 50:10critique, and also a movie that's been misinterpreted by
- 50:14Bros and brought into the fold among them and and kind of
- 50:18worshipped among them. And that is a movie called Fight
- 50:20Club Bob. You you know the number one
- 50:22rule. You don't talk about Fight Club
- 50:25I, I will talk about it 'cause I think it's not that good of a
- 50:28movie and. I think I think you're
- 50:30ridiculous. If I've ever given an opinion
- 50:32that most people disagree on, it is it's my Fight Club opinion.
- 50:35But I feel pretty similar about both these movies where it's
- 50:38like you're really playing with fire here.
- 50:41And sometimes it's fun and gleeful to play with fire and
- 50:44not care about the consequences. But sometimes it's like you can
- 50:48see the angry men of America wanting to hold on to this thing
- 50:55and misinterpret it. And that can be very dangerous
- 50:58sometimes. And so this this reminds me of
- 51:00Fight Club in a lot of ways. I will say, Brad, as we Segway
- 51:04out of Let's Make It a Double and closer to final scores, I
- 51:09think this is a better movie than Fight Club.
- 51:10And for all the complaining I've done, I think this is like a
- 51:15pretty good movie. Would you agree?
- 51:18I would agree. I like the first time I saw this
- 51:22I probably was at like A7 7 1/2 out of 10.
- 51:26I think I've come down a little bit because I just have a hard
- 51:29time assigning value to artistic merit when I think the message
- 51:36itself is just, yeah, gross. Yeah.
- 51:41You know, so I think I'm going to come down a little bit.
- 51:44I do think that there are a lot of parts of this movie that are
- 51:47incredibly well done. I I think that the color palette
- 51:52for the film is actually like, great.
- 51:54Like, I, I think whoever designed the sets and the
- 51:56costumes, they really had a good eye for what Todd Phillips was
- 52:01looking for. I do think Joaquin Phoenix is
- 52:04incredible. I do too.
- 52:05I think he's really good man. That I, I looked at the other
- 52:09best actor candidates from this year and that like there are a
- 52:14few other performances that I think are incredible and maybe
- 52:18deserving of it, but it makes a lot of sense that he received
- 52:21this this year. All right, so before you give a
- 52:24final score, let's say goodbye to Let's Make it a Double, which
- 52:28as always, has been brought to you by Blackwood Distilling
- 52:31Company. No matter what movie you paired
- 52:32this up with, you can always make it a double with Blackwood.
- 52:36And as always, if you go to bourbonoutfitter.com/film
- 52:40Whiskey and use our code Film WHISKEY at checkout, you'll
- 52:43receive 5% off a bottle of Blackwood.
- 52:46I just had lunch with good friend of shows Zach Johnston
- 52:50who is one of the the main guys at Blackwood.
- 52:54He has given us a few more bottles and guys I have to tell
- 52:59you coming down the Pike they have some really awesome stuff
- 53:02coming. So if you haven't had Blackwood
- 53:05yet, make sure you try it because they are putting out
- 53:09incredible toasted products. We're going to get into final
- 53:13scores here. I just want to remind you, Brad,
- 53:15that this year, 2019, the year cinema died, apparently,
- 53:18according to Tarantino. What a freaking lineup.
- 53:21Here's the Best picture lineup from the 2019 squad.
- 53:25Parasite wins the Oscar Ford versus Ferrari, The Irishman,
- 53:31JoJo Rabbit, Joker, Little Women, Marriage Story 1917 and
- 53:38Once Upon a Time in Hollywood unbelievable lineup of movies I
- 53:44I forgot about marriage story, one of my favorite movies of all
- 53:47time and then I saw it here and I was like, Oh my.
- 53:49Gosh, dude, do you think Adam Driver because he was also
- 53:54nominated, do you think he deserves it over Joaquin?
- 53:57No, see, that's a question of head or heart.
- 53:59I would say yes, just because I love that movie so much.
- 54:02But I like, I really do. I have no qualms with Joaquin
- 54:05winning this Oscar. Yeah, I I don't think I do
- 54:07either. He he really poured his heart
- 54:11and soul in and from what I've heard, he's like kind of a
- 54:15method actor, but also still like overall a really nice guy
- 54:19on set. So it seems like he kind of has
- 54:22the best of both worlds. There you go, just like us, with
- 54:26me and you as the hosts on Phil and Whiskey Brad.
- 54:28I'm going to give this movie A7 out of 10.
- 54:32I think I could go higher, like a 7.5 doesn't seem unreasonable
- 54:36to me, but I think it's so mishandles the really delicate
- 54:41balance you have to achieve with the themes they're working with
- 54:44that I give it a seven more on like ethical grounds than
- 54:47anything else. I don't think I can go any
- 54:49higher than that. Does that make sense?
- 54:52Yeah, 100%. The I think he's the lead guy at
- 54:55Ebert wrote a review on this and he said a phrase that I really
- 55:02liked. He said that this movie is
- 55:04unforgivably, opportunistically nihilistic.
- 55:09And I'm like, I I think that is a perfect summation of this
- 55:13movie. I can't get down with it.
- 55:15I think like artistically it's like an 8 out of 10 morality and
- 55:22like heroization of the main character is like a 2 out of 10.
- 55:27I'll land at a six Bob A. Six.
- 55:30OK, all right, well, we're putting ourselves in the
- 55:33crosshair of a bunch of Bros that really love this movie
- 55:36because we're coming out to a 6.5 on average, but we'd like to
- 55:40know what you think. Joker seems to be a beloved
- 55:43movie by a lot of people, and it seems to be accepted into comic
- 55:47book Canon even though it is not even remotely related to any
- 55:50comic books. So reach out to us.
- 55:53Tell us what you think. Is this a modern classic?
- 55:57Oh, you know, usually I I get upset when you cut me off mid
- 56:01sentence, but you've got a really good job of reminding me
- 56:04all the things I've forgotten today.
- 56:06I keep forgetting to ask the most important questions.
- 56:10No, it's not. I this is the closest I would
- 56:14come to saying yes on a movie I've scored this low, but I am
- 56:18going to say no more on principle than anything else.
- 56:22I I think tons of people would say yes.
- 56:24Yeah, I think principle is the thing that like, it's unfair for
- 56:27me to say no because if it's a classic, it's a classic even if
- 56:30I don't like it. But I will say, the goodwill
- 56:33towards this movie has dissipated a lot in the wake of
- 56:36how much people hated that second movie.
- 56:39I think over time people will like revisit the first one and
- 56:42be like, OK, it's not so bad after all.
- 56:44But even the people that love this movie hated the second one
- 56:47so much that I think we're in a real Joker rut right now.
- 56:51So for now, and to cover over the fact that this is just my
- 56:54own feelings, I'm going to say no.
- 56:56But once again folks, you can let us know what you think of
- 56:59Brad and my own scoring system for whether or not something
- 57:03could be a classic by reaching out to us on social media,
- 57:07Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Tiktok or YouTube at Film
- 57:11Whiskey. Or if you want to talk to us
- 57:13directly about it, you can join our Discord server where we are
- 57:17on every single day talking to you guys, fans of the Film and
- 57:20Whiskey podcast. So if you want to join us, you
- 57:23can find a link at the end of every single one of our show
- 57:25notes. Brad, we've had to reshuffle a
- 57:27little bit with our line up here and it looks like the next movie
- 57:30on our list is supposed to be The Wolf of Wall Street, which
- 57:33we will get to in time. I think I need a palate cleanser
- 57:36after Joker, so I'm going to call Wolf.
- 57:38Of Wall Street. Isn't it?
- 57:41I mean, if we were, if we were cleansing our palates with
- 57:43copious amounts of cocaine, then sure, Yeah.
- 57:46But I'm going to say let's slot back in Inside Out for next
- 57:50week. We'll do a Pixar week, and then
- 57:52we will return to the world of debauchery for The Wolf of Wall
- 57:55Street. What do you say?
- 57:57Pour inside out man, it is just like squashed between two
- 58:02hookers right now. You, dude, you're telling me,
- 58:05man. All right, so next week we're
- 58:08going to do some Pixar. We're going to cleanse our
- 58:09palates. We're going to come up for air a
- 58:11little bit before diving back in the cesspool.
- 58:13So we will see you next week for Inside Out, but until then, I'm
- 58:16Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 58:19And we'll see you next time.