Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / The Origins Of Preoccupied Attachment
Transcript
- 0:18So welcome everybody. This is I love you.
- 0:20Keep going. It's Thursday, December 5th,
- 0:222024 at 7:35 PM Pacific Time. And tonight what I thought I'd
- 0:28do is talk about the, the origins of preoccupied
- 0:33attachment and, and how that manifests in a way of beginning
- 0:39to make sense of these, the effects of early conditioning.
- 0:43Why that would matter to a meditation community, of course,
- 0:47is that we want to be able to see clearly the obstacles or the
- 0:53obscurations that keep us from from a path of liberation.
- 0:57And often because what we're really talking about in terms of
- 1:04enlightenment is understanding what the enlightened view is and
- 1:07being able to hold that view and how often the attachment views
- 1:12get in, in the way of that. And we we're we're confined to
- 1:16that view that arises in early conditioning, which changes the
- 1:22appearance of self and world. We do also live in this human
- 1:27human body, which means or subject to the nature of the
- 1:35biology of the body. Then because attachment
- 1:39conditioning happens early and it affects actually the way that
- 1:42the the brain forms. Human beings are one of these of
- 1:48a few species on the planet that largely develops outside of the
- 1:54womb. So we're born, we have an intact
- 1:58brain stem, a partially formed bright hemisphere, not much in
- 2:01the way of the left hemisphere. And so the actual physical
- 2:04structure of the brain that we have is affected by the
- 2:09environment that we grow up in. And it grows in reaction to the
- 2:12environment. So that the way in which your
- 2:16care was delivered to you when you were an infant and in in
- 2:20early childhood actually shapes the that basic structure of the
- 2:24brain. And so secure people have one
- 2:27sort of structure preoccupied another dismissing people,
- 2:32another, disorganized people another.
- 2:41So talking about how that all comes into play.
- 2:48And then the, the path out of that into a, into a way of, of
- 2:58being able to attract that more more clearly.
- 3:02The thing about preoccupation is also related to the, the, the
- 3:09way in which mentalizing and emotional regulation forms.
- 3:13We all basically are born as auto regulators, which means
- 3:17we're involved in ourselves. We don't really have much
- 3:20awareness of the people around us, and we developed strategies
- 3:25that are regulating within that confined system.
- 3:28So for the first few months of life, and then if a caregiver
- 3:32comes to us reliably enough that we reorient from auto regulation
- 3:37to depending on the emotional regulation care of someone else,
- 3:42we reorient toward external regulation.
- 3:46If the regulators come to us reliably enough and, and we can
- 3:51see and recognize clearly the the way in which they help us
- 3:59regulate, we can begin to learn these strategies for ourselves
- 4:04and develop the capacity to to regulate ourselves.
- 4:10Once we have a broad enough range of skills in order to be
- 4:14able to regulate ourselves, we say that we have self mastery
- 4:18and be able to emotionally regulate and but understand that
- 4:24insecure functioning collaborative relational
- 4:27dynamics. The understanding is always that
- 4:31if you can't regulate yourself, you can depend on your
- 4:35regulators to bring you back into emotional balance.
- 4:39So it's this capacity to be really brilliant at regulating
- 4:43it yourself and at the same time this deep understanding that
- 4:46it's easy to get dysregulated to the point that you can't
- 4:50regulate yourself. And so then you come back to the
- 4:54caregiver then who helps you to be regulate.
- 4:57And then once you're re regulated, it encourages you to
- 4:59go and to explore some more. So you learn this value of
- 5:05regulating with someone else and going off and exploring and then
- 5:08coming back and regulating with someone else.
- 5:11One of the other things that happens when you're encouraged
- 5:14to explore is the interest of the caregiver in what you find
- 5:21out. And this is something that's
- 5:23really vital to the development of the capacity to explore that
- 5:28you feel that the things that you discover that are important
- 5:32to you are of interest to the people that are central to your
- 5:37lives. And so that they're, they're
- 5:39curious about what you found out.
- 5:42Often that's because there's a synergy there where the things
- 5:45that you find out actually help them with their exploration.
- 5:48And then the things that they share with you about their
- 5:52exploration also help with that. But when you don't develop a
- 5:59secure attachment, the circumstances are different than
- 6:05that. And really what we're looking at
- 6:07from that earliest point of view of the causes is that the
- 6:13caregiver, while they come reliably enough to move you from
- 6:17auto regulating into a dependence on an external
- 6:21regulator, they're not reliable enough to carry you into
- 6:26developing the capacities to regulate yourself to the point
- 6:31of self mastery or that they're reliable enough for you to
- 6:37actually. Feel safe to leave them.
- 6:48That's really the thing that that is one of the primary
- 6:54causes that the the care that the caregiver provides to in the
- 7:01dynamic that develops preoccupation is unreliable.
- 7:05It's unpredictable in early mentalizing, you have
- 7:10spontaneity versus monitoring. So you learn to just allow
- 7:15everything to arise spontaneously, but you learn to
- 7:18monitor it continuously. And the way that that happens in
- 7:22early childhood, sorry, my voice is a little raspy.
- 7:31The way that that develops in early childhood is the the
- 7:37caregiver reflects back to the to you, their experience of you.
- 7:42We don't really have the capacity as human beings to
- 7:47reflect on ourselves in in any way that's accurate.
- 7:52What we do is rely on the reflections of other people to
- 7:55understand their experience of us and begin to evaluate and
- 8:01make sense out of the way that we're operating in the
- 8:04relationship. In that early dyadic experience
- 8:09with the the caregiver. The child, of course, doesn't
- 8:12have the cognitive capacity to form any of these expressions in
- 8:17a way that would produce an outcome that would be desirable.
- 8:22And in fact, they probably don't even know what that would be.
- 8:25Am I too hot? What do I do there?
- 8:27Am I too cold? What do I do there?
- 8:29Am I hungry or thirsty or I need to be cleaned up?
- 8:35What is it that's happening and how do I communicate it?
- 8:38What am I feeling and how do I regulate my emotions?
- 8:41All of this is not a cognitive conscious experience with the
- 8:44infant. It's an expression, a
- 8:47spontaneous, unmonitored expression, which is then
- 8:51hopefully attended to by the caregiver who's sensitively
- 8:54attunes and then reflects back to the child.
- 8:59So the child presents, the caregiver sensitively, attunes,
- 9:03empathetically connects, they reflect back to the child their
- 9:07experience. And in that reflection back, the
- 9:10child begins to understand what those sensations in the body
- 9:15mean in terms of the facial reflection of the caregiver.
- 9:21And then when the caregiver ties to that a caring response to the
- 9:26child's presentation, the child begins to understand that if I
- 9:29make this expression, the caregiver understands it in that
- 9:33way and that elicits a particular type of caring
- 9:36response from them. Is that all making sense?
- 9:40So what we begin to identify in the expression of the caregiver
- 9:45is our internal states. And what we begin to learn from
- 9:49the caregiver is how to manage those states.
- 9:56And in order to do that, the child's expressions need to be
- 9:59reflected back in a predictable way that's similar enough that
- 10:04the child can recognize those particular patterns.
- 10:08But when you have a caregiver who miss Attunes who doesn't
- 10:12understand accurately or accurately enough what the
- 10:15expressions of the child are and whose attention is distracted,
- 10:23the child doesn't learn of value in monitoring what the the
- 10:30caregiver is doing. When the child has to over and
- 10:36over again, present in a way that will elicit a response from
- 10:43the child, but they don't have any way of understanding what
- 10:47particular pattern to use. They don't monitor or they don't
- 10:52develop the capacity to monitor. What they develop is the
- 10:55capacity to spontaneously express themselves in the hope
- 11:00of getting the care that they want.
- 11:03That making sense. So they don't tie a particular
- 11:08meaning to a particular facial expression or physical response
- 11:13to the caregiver because there's no pattern that they can
- 11:16recognize. So that they could learn a
- 11:19collaborative form of communication with the
- 11:21caregiver. They become just constantly
- 11:25attending to expressions that might elicit the care that they
- 11:30want because they they don't monitor and they're constantly
- 11:38needing to present themselves in a way that gathers the attention
- 11:42of the caregiver. What begins to happen is that
- 11:46they begin to in mesh in the mind states of the others of the
- 11:51caregiver so they can understand what kind of presentation to
- 11:56make to elicit the care that they want.
- 11:58And in doing so, they lose track of their own internal state
- 12:06experience and become more oriented around the the internal
- 12:12states of the caregiver. So that gives them an an other
- 12:16orientation rather than a self orientation, and it gives them
- 12:21an orientation toward an external presentation on the
- 12:24part of the caregiver rather than touching deeply into their
- 12:28own internal state. And because they're dependent on
- 12:35the emotional regulation of the caregiver, they Orient around
- 12:40attempting to emotionally regulate themselves through the
- 12:44interaction with the caregiver and don't really develop much in
- 12:48the way of capacity to regulate themselves.
- 12:52And what that means is that they require proximity, constant
- 12:56proximity to the caregiver in order to feel emotionally
- 13:01regulated by them. So we we talk about these
- 13:07different modes, the attachment mode, the exploration mode and
- 13:13the collaborative relationship mode.
- 13:18And people who go grow up to be preoccupied, the attachment
- 13:23system is constantly activating because it's so difficult for
- 13:27them to get it to settle. What we understand about the
- 13:38attachment, the system being activated, it deactivates the
- 13:42exploration system so that the child can seek proximity to the
- 13:48caregiver for protection and reassurance and the re
- 13:51establishment of the sense of safety.
- 13:54But if the attachment system never deactivates because there
- 13:58isn't that sense of connection and safety with the caregiver,
- 14:02there's that sense of unpredictability and, and a
- 14:08sense of misattunement, the the exploration system doesn't turn
- 14:15on. And so the other aspect that's
- 14:18pronounced in preoccupied people is a, is a stunting of their
- 14:24capacity to explore. We talk about exploration in
- 14:29primary and secondary means. They are particularly stunted in
- 14:34the primary exploration, which is the pursuit of meaning that's
- 14:37unique to that child and often are more oriented around
- 14:45secondary exploration, particularly if somebody takes
- 14:48charge of what that exploration can be.
- 14:52If a caregiver directs the child's exploration, the child
- 14:56can perform very well for the caregiver and often appear to be
- 15:02doing quite well. But their own solo exploration
- 15:07where they're in charge of it and it's really oriented around
- 15:09their a sense of meaningfulness in life doesn't develop Mudit.
- 15:17George, the preoccupied adult. I think I know somebody like as
- 15:24a close friend. There's a wearable affirmation
- 15:28that, hey, you know, you're safe with me.
- 15:31Or like some, is there a way to make them feel safe when I'm
- 15:35with them as an adult? Not, not somebody who's a kid.
- 15:42Well, I think the the verbal affirmation is good.
- 15:48I think also there needs to be an invitation for an authentic
- 15:56presentation of what they're thinking and feeling.
- 16:01And because they're so used to pretending to be who it is that
- 16:06you want the, the invitation has to be presented in a way that
- 16:11they might actually try doing it rather than just inquiring what
- 16:16you mean by that and performing for you, if that makes sense.
- 16:21So. Where would you like to go for
- 16:30dinner? Oh, doesn't matter.
- 16:31We can go wherever you want. No, I'm quite interested in
- 16:35where you want to go. What?
- 16:37What do you want to have? Chinese or what are you?
- 16:39What are you thinking? No, really.
- 16:41You can tell me whatever you want in terms of what it is that
- 16:44you want to eat. You want to go for Chinese and
- 16:51you say, you tell me what you want, where you want to go eat,
- 16:55and we'll go eat there. So that you put them in a
- 17:00position where they would have to explore, they would have to
- 17:04come up with a, a solution. And then you go and you affirm
- 17:11that it was a good choice and that you're glad that they made
- 17:14it so that they have a sense that they can do that and it
- 17:18won't result in the usual bad stuff that they're expecting,
- 17:26which is abandonment, right? Usually they would say like no
- 17:30preference. I'm never sure if it's actually
- 17:32no preference for this, but that's the occupied state of
- 17:36mind. No, it's not.
- 17:38It's not accurate because they probably have a preference.
- 17:41I can give you an example. Well, that's more of a
- 17:48disorganized response. It it's, it's they're always
- 17:53willing to do whatever you want so that they they that you won't
- 17:56abandoned them and they're very reluctant to take any kind of
- 18:00authentic stands. And then if they don't like the
- 18:07restaurant that you choose, they feel free to pick at you because
- 18:10you picked the wrong place. That doesn't help them.
- 18:16What really helps them is not taking over the exploration from
- 18:22them and allowing them to do it. Even though you can see them
- 18:32struggling, you just have to have patience to let them
- 18:34struggle for just a while. They're struggling because they
- 18:38can't really do it and you, so you say it's not a big deal.
- 18:41Just take your time and figure it out.
- 18:43I, I have total confidence in you that you can figure this out
- 18:48and I'm, I'm happy to go with you.
- 18:50And then I'll choose the next one.
- 18:52So it's a shared experience. Thank.
- 19:00You so much. And then you do really have to
- 19:04have the patience to let them work through all of that
- 19:07internally. This is not a zoom background by
- 19:15the way, it's real. What time is it?
- 19:19What day is it? Noon on a beach like 24°.
- 19:26Nice in, Celsius in. Celtic.
- 19:32And it's Friday morning, Friday morning, Friday afternoon.
- 19:38Actually, I actually don't know what it is.
- 19:39Yeah, it's Friday morning. Yeah.
- 19:54So now preoccupied. The the, the, the problem with
- 20:03the exploration, with the preoccupation is that because
- 20:06they're dependent on somebody else to emotionally regulate
- 20:09them, they can't be separated from the person who emotionally
- 20:12regulates them. Or they face this regulation,
- 20:16which they can't really get themselves out of.
- 20:18And because that proximity to the regulator is paramount to
- 20:26them that they abandoned the exploration for that.
- 20:29This happens early in childhood. They don't venture away from
- 20:33that. The other thing that happens to
- 20:36preoccupied kids in or kids who grow up to be preoccupied adults
- 20:43in childhood is a kind of role reversing or involving the
- 20:48involving in the mind states of the caregiver.
- 20:52Now what I've described before was the involving aspect.
- 20:57The child becomes focused and enmeshed in the mind state of
- 21:02the caregiver because they need to know that information in
- 21:06order to be able to present the, the the request for care that
- 21:11they need in a way that's likely to be effective.
- 21:14But they there is also another aspect of that, which is we call
- 21:18role reversing, where the actual care of the caregiver is, is
- 21:24given to the child as a responsibility.
- 21:27So not only do they need to involve in the mindset of the
- 21:31caregiver, a mesh with the mindset of the caregiver, but
- 21:34they they are given the responsibility for the care of
- 21:38the caregiver. This doesn't happen until around
- 21:42six years of age because that's the youngest where the child's
- 21:48capacities are developed enough that they can do it.
- 21:52But you, you may have encountered children who are
- 21:56controlling. So what do you notice in the way
- 21:59that preoccupation takes hold in adults?
- 22:02That there's kind of two pathways. 1 is the helpless path
- 22:07pathway, where over and over again the the person in front of
- 22:12you who doesn't appear to be helpless presents themselves as
- 22:15helpless so that you'll engage in in helping them often.
- 22:21What do you find yourself? Is it a helpless loop where they
- 22:24present a problem for you to help them solve it, and you
- 22:30offer a solution which is rejected and the problem is
- 22:33represented and you offer another solution and it's
- 22:36rejected. And over the course of time,
- 22:40everything you can think of is rejected and and doesn't work
- 22:43and the the the person in front of you remains helpless.
- 22:48Or they've tried all of the options and they haven't worked
- 22:51and you begin to develop the sense of helplessness to help
- 22:55them. That's what I call being stuck
- 22:57in a helpless loop. But the other direction is
- 23:01controlling. And this is where they demand
- 23:06control of everything. And it, it, it, that
- 23:11helplessness is turned into a moral stance of demand that you
- 23:28need to help them or save them. And it's takes on all sorts of
- 23:42stuff, all sorts of presentations.
- 23:46I should say for a while in the meditation community there was a
- 23:54a strong demand that was given that everybody engage in send
- 23:58free products on retreats and, and, and it became an extremely
- 24:04rigid experience around the use of Sentry products in order to,
- 24:11to prevent people that were highly allergic to scents from
- 24:16having these severe reactions to it.
- 24:20But that always to me felt like the the aspect of controlling
- 24:25preoccupation, the the demand for help, which is presented as
- 24:31I'm allergic to scented products, becomes this
- 24:38controlling atmosphere where you're prohibited from a kind of
- 24:42expression that you might make it.
- 24:44It ceases to be voluntary Christian.
- 24:50I would have not bathed in protest.
- 25:00Yes, it did take out that quality in the zendo.
- 25:13It reminds you of a funny story when we we went to.
- 25:18Well, no, actually I did. I went to Miramar looking for a
- 25:22retreat center where we could go, and I went to Upendeet, not
- 25:30Upendeet, can't remember anyway. And it's a vast place, 700 acres
- 25:41or something like that, and it's divided in the middle with a
- 25:44wall. And one side is, is the female
- 25:46side and one side is the male side.
- 25:49And I went into the the meditation hall on the male
- 25:54side, which is a two-story building.
- 25:57And it really was like a putrid locker room in inside there.
- 26:01It was an absolutely blast of intense body odor.
- 26:11And then I went to the female side and the windows were open
- 26:16and it was light and breezy. And I immediately inquired it
- 26:23was OK if I meditated on the female side of the wall.
- 26:26But I was absolutely. So I was told no, I could not.
- 26:32I even threw in the I'm an old person, but that didn't help.
- 26:38George I I studied. Engineering.
- 26:40So engineering school was similarly enlightening.
- 26:56So in these two pathways, the helplessly preoccupied tends to
- 27:01be on the organized side, and the the controlling side of
- 27:06preoccupation tends to head over toward the disorganized side of
- 27:10it. One of the things about being
- 27:18dependent on external regulators in adults is often that you're
- 27:23in a constant state of emotional dysregulation because you don't
- 27:26have constant proximity to the regulator.
- 27:29And so you run around with this very high level of emotional
- 27:34dysregulation, sometime on the controlling side, easily into
- 27:39the tantrum mode of dysregulation.
- 27:44The then the dilemma is how do you interact with people who are
- 27:55empathetic and connect to you and feel empathetically what
- 27:59you're experiencing and what often happens?
- 28:03And this is kind of the way that the experience of people is
- 28:09organized into the the types of relationships that they have
- 28:13with adults to cure people who are empathetic and naturally
- 28:18pick up on that empathetic state of the other person will
- 28:23experience you as constantly in a state of dysregulation and
- 28:27helpless to re regulate, which will create for them a
- 28:31disharmony in terms of internal States and experiencing that two
- 28:38people that are highly emotionally dysregulated don't
- 28:41regulate each other very well. And so preoccupied people don't
- 28:45tend to align with other preoccupied people because the
- 28:50intensity of each other's dysregulation is more
- 28:53dysregulating. Dismissing people because they
- 28:57have the capacity to suppress emotional, the empathetic
- 29:03experience of other people because they suppress their own
- 29:07emotions, don't have an empathetic response to the
- 29:11dysregulation of preoccupied people because they don't
- 29:14experience it consciously, so it isn't something that drives them
- 29:18away. It's one of the things that sets
- 29:20up the dynamic of dismissing people and preoccupied people
- 29:24forming relationships because the dismissing person is not
- 29:31emotional and is very self oriented in the way that they
- 29:35operate in the world. They like to draw people to them
- 29:41to take care of them and they don't depend on an exchange of
- 29:47exploration with somebody else to remain interested in them so
- 29:55that the deficits that the preoccupied person has don't
- 29:59disqualify them from being in relationship to a dismissing
- 30:03person. So what you see most often in
- 30:07that kind of a coupling is a dismissing person with a
- 30:11preoccupied person. The preoccupied person is
- 30:14willing to abandon their personal exploration for
- 30:18physical proximity to somebody who's emotionally regulating for
- 30:21that. And because they're so oriented
- 30:25toward the other person and they enmesh to the other person,
- 30:29really what you'll notice is that the emotional experience of
- 30:35the dismissing person becomes the primary emotional experience
- 30:39of the preoccupied person. And then the preoccupied person
- 30:43attends to emotionally regulating the dismissing
- 30:47person. And when the dismissing person
- 30:50is regulated, the preoccupied person feels regulated because
- 30:55they've displaced the empathetic experience of the other with
- 30:59their own emotional experience. When they're separated from the
- 31:06dismissing person and the empathetic connection is broken,
- 31:10the preoccupied person often feels as an extreme distress of
- 31:16the separation because they're then forced to attend to their
- 31:20own emotional state, which is often highly dysregulated.
- 31:24Is that making sense in terms of how that dynamic works?
- 31:31So the preoccupied person is dependent on the exploration of
- 31:36the their regulator because they don't separate it in order to
- 31:40explore from them for themselves, and they often
- 31:45identify the relationship as the primary means of their own
- 31:49exploration. They think that the relationship
- 31:53or the connection to somebody else is what's supposed to
- 31:56provide the meaningfulness of their life.
- 31:59And because it doesn't really do that, they're often in a state
- 32:03of deprivation, which keeps them in a dysregulated state and in a
- 32:11state of dissatisfaction. That making sense.
- 32:17They don't have the capacity to separate and do solo exploration
- 32:22because they can't regulate themselves.
- 32:24So they can't solve the deprivation experience on their
- 32:28own, and they turn to their partner to do it for them.
- 32:32That's part of the helpless manifestation.
- 32:37All making sense the dilemma. So what really needs to happen
- 32:44in order for a preoccupied person to move out of
- 32:48preoccupation into a, a, a sense of more security so that they
- 32:56can begin to develop their capacity to explore.
- 33:01And this is really the turning the attention from the emeshment
- 33:06with the mind state of the other person and paying attention to
- 33:10their own mind state, beginning to understand what those
- 33:15internal states are that they're experiencing.
- 33:19And then to begin to develop emotional regulations strategies
- 33:23that they can use to regulate themselves.
- 33:28Once they begin the capacity to emotionally regulate themselves
- 33:32and not depend on an external regulator to do that, and they
- 33:38can regulate themselves well enough to separate from that
- 33:42caregiver, then they get into a place where they can actually
- 33:46begin to explore. And that actually is harder to
- 33:50do for most preoccupied people than the emotional regulation
- 33:54piece, which you can learn through the various meditation
- 33:59strategies that are part of our always cool, always kind of
- 34:04grouping. But the exploration requires you
- 34:09to understand what it is that's actually meaningful to you.
- 34:12And because nobody has ever really reflected back to you
- 34:16what your qualities are, this is the thing that we count on and
- 34:20other people reflecting back to us what our authentic interests
- 34:24are. Partly that's because we don't
- 34:27ever really express what our authentic interests are, because
- 34:30we are meshed in the mindset of somebody else in need to present
- 34:34something to them that they'll find responsive or that they'll
- 34:40respond to in a way that makes us feel connected to them.
- 34:45We need to begin to express ourselves authentically.
- 34:50There's a lot of conditioning around this that comes in
- 34:52childhood. And so that authentic expression
- 34:55is not simply a decision that you make, but it requires a lot
- 34:59of emotional regulation. You, you express, or the way
- 35:04that I like to describe it is you.
- 35:07If you're not so down, so far down the rabbit hole of
- 35:10inauthenticity that you even can recognize what's meaningful to
- 35:14you. When the authentic expression
- 35:17comes to mind in response to the present moment and it causes
- 35:21abandonment terror, immediately what arises is the mind.
- 35:24In the mind is the inauthentic thing that you could express.
- 35:28Instead, if you express the inauthentic thing, it
- 35:32immediately relieves the abandonment here, and the
- 35:34delusion is that that's actually supportive of the relationship.
- 35:38You're no longer frightened about being abandoned because
- 35:42you haven't expressed yourself authentically.
- 35:44You've expressed the thing that you think the other person would
- 35:47find acceptable, but a little while later you're going to be
- 35:53angry that you didn't express yourself authentically.
- 35:58Even if they did respond to the expression that you made because
- 36:01it wasn't authentic, it isn't your authentic needs that are
- 36:05being met. And you're back in that familiar
- 36:07state of deprivation in a relationship to somebody because
- 36:11of the fearfulness around expressing yourself
- 36:14authentically. So you begin this process of
- 36:17expressing yourself authentically, which activates
- 36:22the abandonment terror, which means you have to be able to
- 36:24hold that experience of abandonment terror and continue
- 36:29to express yourself authentically.
- 36:32And if you do that, the abandonment terror will subside
- 36:36and you'll be hit by the terrible sadness, which is the
- 36:39recognition that for so much of your life where you weren't
- 36:44willing to express yourself authentically, you didn't get
- 36:47the things you need and you didn't actually even make a
- 36:51valid attempt at getting them. That making sense.
- 36:54So that it, and as you express yourself authentically and, and
- 36:59people respond to you much in the same way that they did in
- 37:03the inauthentic expression, you begin to understand that all the
- 37:08way along, had you been able to express yourself authentic, you
- 37:12authentically, you had a much greater chance of getting your
- 37:14needs met. And that that is a terrible
- 37:18sadness. So I think of it as a
- 37:21bittersweetness, the bitterness. Of course, as you recognize for
- 37:25so long, you're the one who didn't ask and that's why you
- 37:28didn't get. The sweet part, of course, is
- 37:31that you've, in order to have that insight, you'll have to
- 37:35begin to ask authentically. And then you'll begin to see
- 37:39that actually you can receive from people the things that you
- 37:44need from them. The same way that you elicited
- 37:48attention from people by presenting a false self, you can
- 37:52elicit attention from people by presenting your authentic self.
- 37:57Except at this time, they're really interested in you.
- 38:00They, they want to know what's going on with you.
- 38:03They want to participate with you and so you begin to have the
- 38:09sense of being seen, being known, being valued.
- 38:13Whereas as long as you're hanging out in the pretend side
- 38:17of things, you never have that feeling really.
- 38:20In fact, you have the a constant anxiety that discovered what was
- 38:25really true about it, that you you would be abandoned.
- 38:28Is that making sense? So you begin to track your own
- 38:35eternal states. You begin to develop ways of
- 38:39emotionally regulating yourself that don't depend on somebody
- 38:42else helping me with it. And then you begin to explore
- 38:49what actually is meaningful and what isn't meaningful.
- 38:54Not back and forth. Then you move into a place where
- 39:02you're you can be in collaborative relationships.
- 39:07How's that sound? I I can see from your
- 39:15expressions that I'm totally unconvincing.
- 39:23You can do this. It, it, it isn't, you know, it
- 39:26isn't even your fault in the sense that you adapted to the
- 39:33experience of your family system and what was available to you in
- 39:39your family system. And to have survived this long
- 39:42and, and life means that you, you learned those lessons well,
- 39:46that they weren't ideal lessons to learn is something else.
- 39:52But the capacity to understand what's happening and to to adapt
- 39:57to them, you have all of those capacities.
- 40:01Really, the point is now can you learn a different set?
- 40:06And since you've already demonstrated that you can learn
- 40:09a set, it's highly likely that you can learn another set.
- 40:16There is the willingness to. Present authentically and that I
- 40:25think it's actually the the biggest challenge for
- 40:27preoccupied people. They're so used to getting
- 40:30everything that they need through pretending to be
- 40:34somebody else. And in their childhood
- 40:38experiences, the authentic presentation was a spectacular
- 40:43failure in terms of being able to get your needs met.
- 40:47And so we're really conditioned to think that I can't actually
- 40:52take those risks because my needs won't be met and I can't
- 40:55regulate myself emotionally, and I'm totally dependent on
- 40:59somebody else doing it for me. And I can't risk losing that
- 41:04connection and then being in a state of dysregulation that I
- 41:07can't get myself out of. And so you don't throw the baby
- 41:13out with the bathwater. You just move a little bit into
- 41:17authentic expressions with small things at the beginning and move
- 41:22further and further into authentic expression.
- 41:27The more you receive feedback that the authentic expression is
- 41:32acceptable. And I think really that's one of
- 41:35the hard things, that bitter part where I you, you discover
- 41:40that the authentic expression is it, is it as acceptable as the
- 41:44inauthentic expression was And there was there was no penalty
- 41:49in it makes sense. Yeah.
- 42:00I'm just thinking about how it sounds like there's some, you
- 42:04know, parallels or, you know, with kind of what we would call
- 42:07codependency. And just thinking about the
- 42:10conditioning that you described for the child that gets enmeshed
- 42:14in the mind states of the adult and how As for the adults to
- 42:20have, you know, if this is my strategy or patterning, I might
- 42:26have very little awareness of what is happening for me
- 42:30emotionally, but I might have an A lot of awareness of what's
- 42:34happening for my partner or the people around me.
- 42:37But does that? Is that a kind of accurate?
- 42:41I do think, I think that one of the things that you notice about
- 42:47dismissing people as there's a high level of addiction there.
- 42:50So 30% of dismissing people are addicts and in disorganized
- 42:56people, 70% of disorganized people on the avoidance side are
- 43:03addicts. The controlling side of
- 43:06disorganization is not so substance addicted, but they get
- 43:11involved in these controlling relationships with other
- 43:14disorganized people. So you often see, for instance,
- 43:17in Al Anon a room full of disorganized controlling
- 43:22preoccupied people who are talking about their
- 43:25relationships with disorganized avoidant people and and trying
- 43:30to demand or figure that out. On the organized side, it it is
- 43:35often more the helplessly preoccupied tied to the, the
- 43:42dismissing person. And we would describe that as
- 43:48codependent in the sense that one person in the relationship
- 43:52is having their needs met and the other person in the
- 43:56relationship is not having their needs met, but they're providing
- 44:00the care for the other. The, the, of course, neither
- 44:12side is volitional, right? The people on the attic or
- 44:17dismissing side think that that's how the world works.
- 44:21And the people on the preoccupied side also think that
- 44:25that's how the world works. And so you just want to be good
- 44:28at the way that the world works. And so you enter into those
- 44:32kinds of agreements, understand that often or one of the ways
- 44:41that I hear a codependency being described is that one person is
- 44:46taking from the other, whereas actually they're both in it and
- 44:50they're both getting out of that kind of dynamic what they both
- 44:54want. So it, it is in some sense and,
- 44:57and mutually agreed upon relationship rather than one
- 45:01person necessarily being exploited by another person,
- 45:05even though it, it can appear that way.
- 45:10And to come out of that, of course you have to address your
- 45:13own stuff and not necessarily the stuff in the other person.
- 45:19But they often show up in, in, in the work that we do as the,
- 45:24the poor dismissing person being dragged by the controlling
- 45:29preoccupied person, and then the controlling preoccupied person
- 45:33talking exclusively about what's wrong with the the dismissive
- 45:38person. And as soon as you ask them to
- 45:42make the adjustment to talk about themselves, they stop
- 45:45coming. The experience I have often is
- 45:51that making sense to you? Yeah, that makes sense.
- 45:54And I'm also wondering like, where does something like, you
- 45:59know, a borderline personality organization fit on kind of this
- 46:02spectrum of, you know, attachment strategies where
- 46:06there's a lot of emotional dysregulation, you know, fear of
- 46:09abandonment, so. The Masterson scale, which is
- 46:16the personality things Antisocial personality disorder
- 46:20at one end and borderline personality at the other end.
- 46:26One of the problems with these kinds of theories is that the
- 46:32way that you meet people is they're almost always a mix.
- 46:38And the way that it lays down on top of the attachment framework
- 46:48is the antisocial narcissistic personality tends to lay down
- 46:54more on top of the dismissing person and the the borderline
- 46:59personality tends to lay down more on the preoccupied side.
- 47:05But I would say that the piece that's often left out of that is
- 47:11that we're really talking about disorganized people when we're
- 47:15talking about personality disorders, not organized people.
- 47:19So you're really talking about a disorganization with a
- 47:24attachment conditioning. And when you're talking about
- 47:27complexly disorganized people, which is often who you're really
- 47:30talking about, they have the disorganization, they have
- 47:33dismissing strategies, they have preoccupied strategies, some of
- 47:36you have secure strategies. And so it would be, I mean, I
- 47:44think it trying to lay them in a in, in a way other than it's,
- 47:49it's a complex bridging that has to go on mostly that's what you
- 47:57see. And can a complexly disorganized
- 48:02person have a mix both of you know, secure, but also the
- 48:07disorganized, fearful, avoidant, fearfully preoccupied, you know,
- 48:12loop of everything? Yeah, they're the actually the
- 48:16hardest to to relate to because they're so unpredictable in the
- 48:21way that they respond. You know, secure functioning
- 48:24relationships really are about this is my experience, this is
- 48:28what I want to express of it. How do I translate it so that
- 48:31the person will understand what I am I'm trying to communicate
- 48:38to them? How do I understand what they've
- 48:41understood that I've tried to communicate?
- 48:42So we're actually communicating. And then how do I modify my
- 48:48understanding of the relationship?
- 48:49But if you can't predict how somebody is going to respond to
- 48:54information that you give them, then you can't formulate it in a
- 48:57way that might be communicating. And so then you're you, you,
- 49:03you're in some ways restricted in how you could express it.
- 49:08And then you have to be open to wildly varying responses.
- 49:15Whereas in secure functioning relationships or in organized
- 49:18communicating relationships, you have a good idea of how you need
- 49:23to present something to somebody so that you can gauge what their
- 49:26response is, so that you're you can be assured that they
- 49:29understand what you mean. And that's the part that's
- 49:33really lost on disorganized people or complexly disorganized
- 49:37people. There's no way to predict how
- 49:39they're going to respond. And so you can't predict how to
- 49:43say something to them. And so the, the, the failure
- 49:47rate in terms of communicating is quite high.
- 49:51And then you're operating with these skewed perspectives of
- 49:54what's happening. The main difference between
- 50:00antisocial personality disorder and narcissistic personality
- 50:04disorder is that antisocial people don't care what people
- 50:08think of them. And narcissistic people are are
- 50:12are obsessed with what people think of them.
- 50:16So that's also something that shows up in in in the attachment
- 50:24consolation. You might say that AD 1A
- 50:28hardcore flat, no attachment system, no emotional system
- 50:34tends to be more on the anti personal, anti social
- 50:39personality side and the, the, the DS3 the, the, the dismissing
- 50:47person who has restriction and attachment and restriction and
- 50:51emotion is much more sensitive to that.
- 50:58Thanks. Can I ask one more kind of
- 50:59follow up as this is? Yeah, so I'm thinking, and I
- 51:04don't know if this is also sort of diagnostic question of like
- 51:08something like DID or but where there's somebody who might
- 51:13normally, you know, most of the time they have an organized
- 51:17orientation, but then certain life circumstances or relational
- 51:23things, you know, they trigger them.
- 51:26And then this other fractured off part of their psyche comes
- 51:31into the comes into awareness and sort of takes over.
- 51:34And then they might act in a way that is more, you know, kind of
- 51:39carefully preoccupied or, you know, 1 so that it can't.
- 51:43Can that also be a phenomenon where sort of circumstantially a
- 51:49splintered off part or, you know, I'm not sure what kind of
- 51:52language to use, but that it's. So in structural dissociation,
- 51:59you have the apparently normal part and you have the emotional
- 52:04parts that are split off in in DIDA, dissociative identity
- 52:12disorder, you have more than one apparently normal part, and
- 52:15they're not linked. So if something happens in one
- 52:19apparently normal part, the other apparently normal parts
- 52:22don't know about it and there's no limit to the number of
- 52:27apparently normal parts. You have no limit to the number
- 52:30of split off parts within the apparently normal parts.
- 52:38So remember that we make up reality based on meaning that we
- 52:44assigned to it. We have the capacity to sense
- 52:46the object could be sensed when there's contact consciousness of
- 52:49that arises, it's evaluated for urgency.
- 52:53Urgent stuff gets more attention faster and then it's compared to
- 52:57the perceptual database and wherever the the match happens.
- 53:03That secluded data set is what creates the meaning of the
- 53:10moment. So depending on where you land,
- 53:16that small data set is what creates the experience of the
- 53:20present moment, which is why it appears differently.
- 53:23You're making up a self response in the present moment based on
- 53:27the data. And because the data is
- 53:30sequestered from each other, you have understandings and meanings
- 53:34that are are quite segmented. Then you make a meaning and then
- 53:39you act from that meaning and and then the reaction and the
- 53:44outcome is then remembered into that same sequestered part.
- 53:49So in the next moment, if you're, if the match is in a
- 53:51different part of the system, there's no awareness that that
- 53:55other part happened because it's not included in the data set
- 53:59that you create in the next moment of experience in, in
- 54:05people that don't have that, it's all one database.
- 54:08So the, the, the, the accumulated experiences are
- 54:12always available. Whereas in the parts where
- 54:15they're fragmented, it depends which fragment you're in what,
- 54:19what data there is to create the experience of the present
- 54:23moment. And so from the the side of not
- 54:28being in that situation where you have access to the other
- 54:32interactions that you had with them, it seems as if there's
- 54:36some manipulation or some lying going on or some problem going
- 54:41on because they're presenting that that didn't happen or they
- 54:47don't know what you're talking about, but they're not
- 54:50necessarily being manipulative. They for the most part don't
- 54:54have that experience because of where it's at, so that it does
- 55:01render them really unreliable in terms of being able to maintain
- 55:04a normal kind of discourse. So and, and understand that in
- 55:15adults who are disorganized, dissociation is the primary
- 55:19means of emotional regulation. So in order to be able to come
- 55:22out of dissociation as the primary means of emotional
- 55:25regulation, you have to develop alternative emotional regulation
- 55:31schemes that you can substitute for the dissociation.
- 55:36That's really the way out of it, to develop alternative emotional
- 55:40regulation strategies that are more efficient and dissociation,
- 55:44which is really not efficient good enough.
- 55:52Yeah, that's good. Thanks.
- 55:53And I'm thinking that you would also then want to swap out the
- 55:56control lane and the you know the the bad you know that the
- 56:02non functional ways for right. Right.
- 56:06The controlling strategies, while they were effective in
- 56:10childhood for controlling the caregiver so that the caregiver
- 56:15could step up and fulfill the adult roles in in adult
- 56:21relationships, most people are unwilling to be controlled in
- 56:27that way. So that what you're doing is
- 56:30self excluding from secure functioning relationships and
- 56:33self excluding from most functional relationships.
- 56:37Because the only people that are willing to acquiesce to that
- 56:40level of being controlled are people that can't function very
- 56:44well. So they're giving up the their
- 56:47freedom, their autonomy to be controlled by somebody else.
- 56:51But the the person who's in the controlling position is going to
- 56:55have to take on the whole care of the person in order for that
- 56:59really to work. And you'll notice in what the
- 57:05controlling person, of course, is getting out of it is constant
- 57:08proximity because to be in complete control, the person can
- 57:11never be away from you. And so you get the regular, the
- 57:14emotional regulation that you need from that.
- 57:17And then the other person gets the dependency that they need
- 57:22out of it. Is that making sense?
- 57:28So again, even though that dynamic looks often terrible on
- 57:34the outside, both people are getting out of it what they
- 57:37want, what they think that they need, but it's also not
- 57:43particularly satisfying in terms of intimacy.
- 57:46And so there's usually a a constant state of deprivation in
- 57:52in those relationships. They don't really ever settle.
- 57:57There's constant chaos and constant threat of abandonment.
- 58:06What do you say We do a little bit of meta meditation just to
- 58:10to wrap up. So go ahead and take your
- 58:15meditation postures. All right, Let go of the
- 58:20meditation. How's that?
- 58:23So on the 14th of December I'm giving a talk about my
- 58:26photography and we'll spend 3 hours going over it Now my mind
- 58:33planning anyway to actually talk some solid technique if that
- 58:40matters to you. We now have AI built into
- 58:45Photoshop and you can pretty much do whatever you want.
- 58:47And I, I think that's really fun.
- 58:51And I've been using different digital manipulation programs
- 58:57for 25 years. And so it's also nice in terms
- 59:00of the arc of that and also how the technology is reflected in
- 59:04different ways in the work. So if that's, it's interesting
- 59:07to you, that's on the 14th, which is a Saturday from 9:00 to
- 59:11noon, a Pacific. And then in January, starting on
- 59:18the fourth, we're going to do the Level 1 Series on four
- 59:22Saturday mornings and then in February start our level two
- 59:28classes again. So that's what's coming up.
- 59:31Really appreciate your practice. Nice to see you here.
- 59:36I will see you next week. I think one of these weeks
- 59:40coming up, it's going to be Christmas.
- 59:43Let me see what the calendar is going to tell me.
- 59:47So we probably won't do that. And then I think it's also New
- 59:50Year's, the way the calendar falls this year.
- 59:53So let's see. We will be here on the 12th and
- 1:00:04on the 19th, the day after Christmas.
- 1:00:09I play that by ear. And then, yeah, no, I guess we
- 1:00:13will be the 2nd of January. That gives everybody time to
- 1:00:17recover Boxing Day, All right? Thanks so much you later.