Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP293: Avoiding Platform Tribalism - Understanding Adobe's Market Fit & Value For Ecommerce Teams, With Gene Founder Matt Parkinson
Transcript
- 0:00What I have found in the in the platform space is it's becoming
- 0:03incredibly aggressive and incredibly tribal.
- 0:07Whoever whichever horseshoe back that's the winner and it can do
- 0:11no wrong. And it's it's developed a little
- 0:13bit of a cult or fanboys and process and I feel that's that's
- 0:16damaged some of the RFP nature. You listen to Inside Commerce, a
- 0:22weekly ecom strategy, technology and CX focus podcast hosted by
- 0:25experienced digital consultants and re platform specialist James
- 0:28Get a call Rogers. Get insights into ecom strategy,
- 0:30leading brands, hear from industry thought leaders and
- 0:33leading tech vendors with practical advice to help you
- 0:35improve your online CX. Hi everyone and welcome back to
- 0:40the Inside Commerce podcast sponsored by Shopify.
- 0:44It's just me today. James is, I'm not too sure where
- 0:47James is, but he couldn't make this episode unfortunately.
- 0:49But today we have a super experienced and interesting
- 0:53guest in Matt Parkinson from Jean.
- 0:56Matt's a long term Magento and econ specialist and he's been in
- 1:01this space for a long time. Or come on to some of the kind
- 1:04of innovations that have come out of Gene in the past in the
- 1:06Magento ecosystem and kind of how they maybe differ from some
- 1:10of the other partners out there. So today we're going to talk a
- 1:14bit about some of the newness in the Magento Adobe space and some
- 1:17of the things that came out of the Adobe Summit earlier this
- 1:20year. And also some of the things that
- 1:23Gene have recently invested in and kind of bought to market
- 1:27both around the Adobe and Magento space and also the
- 1:30affiliate space. We'll come on to that.
- 1:32But yeah, to start with, Matt, can you give us a bit of an
- 1:34intro to Jean yourself and kind of your background in this
- 1:37space? Thanks, Paul.
- 1:40Thanks for inviting me. It's first time you've invited
- 1:42me on your podcast. So we get, we get that I
- 1:44eventually we. Look lazy with her as a lot of
- 1:47people now. That's all right.
- 1:49I also heard long time and experience which found it.
- 1:53I just heard old when you were saying that, so we'll try, but
- 1:57thank you for that introduction. We've been in the magenta Adobe
- 2:01space since really the inception back in 2008.
- 2:05So whatever that is 17 years, so long time standing and we've
- 2:10broadly built our entire professional services business
- 2:13around that that platform and and have had to navigate the
- 2:16various ups and downs over that, that period.
- 2:20We're from AUK focus, but we, we work across the globe into with
- 2:25a lot of international brands best known I guess in, in, in
- 2:30the ecosystem for building various products that are are
- 2:36mass used. We work closely and have done
- 2:40for about 8 or 9 years with PayPal.
- 2:42So we build a lot of that. Braintree, their latest PPCP and
- 2:46Fast Lane technology would power about 10,000 merchants globally.
- 2:50With that going back a little bit now that we still dine out
- 2:54on it 10 years ago, eight years ago built the page builder
- 2:57technology which made a significant difference to how
- 3:02how Magenta at the time, just before Adobe acquired it, how it
- 3:06was perceived and used in in the marketplace.
- 3:09And most recently we we've built some tooling which hopefully
- 3:12we'll get onto which we branded under a new business called
- 3:16Bluefinch, which is trying to solve some of the, the
- 3:22challenges that the platform still has around total cost of
- 3:26ownership, time to market and and check out.
- 3:29And that's really, I guess our our ethos in the business trying
- 3:34to build elegant solutions that that solve real world problems.
- 3:40Great. Yeah, I think we'll we'll come
- 3:42on to that in a bit. I think that and kind of some of
- 3:44the stuff that's coming out of the community general is a
- 3:46really like important topic around Magenta and Adobe.
- 3:51But the first question I've obviously just started in as
- 3:53well. I think both you and I have had
- 3:57some fairly strong views over the platform space over where
- 4:00Magento sits, like how you know Magento should be deployed and
- 4:05kind of where it's it's relevant in the industry.
- 4:08Do you want to just give us a bit of a view of kind of the
- 4:10state of Magento and Adobe and yeah, kind of the platform
- 4:14ecosystem? We just had a really good
- 4:17conversation before we hit record.
- 4:19We should have recorded, recorded that it's, I think it's
- 4:25fair to say that Magento was a hugely dominant player 10 years
- 4:32ago. That landscape has massively
- 4:35changed I think in the last 4-5 years.
- 4:38You know, the, the new entrance into the market, there seems to
- 4:43be new platforms propping up, cropping up all the, all the
- 4:46time, various moves and frameworks and headless and PWA
- 4:54and composable and Mac and this platform's better.
- 4:57This platform is better. I do think in the last sort of
- 5:01six or nine months, it has settled down a little bit and
- 5:05there are some clear winners. Obviously your, your sponsor
- 5:08Joffe has, has sort of trounced the, the, the D2C market
- 5:14globally. It's undeniable.
- 5:18There's been, there's been some other enterprise plays in the,
- 5:21in, in the market. You know, the, the commerce
- 5:24tours, the spikers, the elastic pass, the frame, it goes on and
- 5:27on and on. And I think it became very
- 5:32noisy. And what was what was a clear
- 5:34strategy for a lot of other platforms was to bash Magento
- 5:37because of its dominance and what have you.
- 5:39And understandably Magento is not without its faults, which
- 5:43I'm sure will come on to them. What I have found in the in the
- 5:47platform space is it's becoming here incredibly aggressive and
- 5:51incredibly tribal. Whoever whichever horseshoe back
- 5:57that's that's the winner and it can do no wrong.
- 6:01And it's it's developed a little bit of a cult or fanboy ISM
- 6:05process. And I feel that's that's damaged
- 6:08some of the RFP nature and platform selection seems to be
- 6:19disproportionately weighted on populism rather than actually
- 6:24looking at fatal suitability. So I think it it has reduced
- 6:30people's desire to do proper due diligence and understand the
- 6:35real nuance of each platform and whether it it serves the
- 6:38business's purpose rather than taking a face value.
- 6:41What, what salesperson or marketing deck says this, this
- 6:44will solve all your problems. And I think that is starting to
- 6:47to feed through because people have obviously experienced the
- 6:51new platforms so last year or two and found various friction
- 6:55points. What do Mattel, Victoria
- 6:59Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier all have in common?
- 7:04They power their businesses with Shopify.
- 7:08Shopify is the most innovative and scaled commerce platform on
- 7:11the planet. It also happens to have the best
- 7:15converting check out on the planet Shopify Powering the
- 7:20future of enterprise commerce. Find out more at
- 7:23shopify.com/enterprise. Yeah.
- 7:27I think that I think that makes sense.
- 7:29And I think we, James and I have taught loads over the last kind
- 7:34of 6912 months around. I think there was a period where
- 7:38Mac became very dominant. And over maybe a two year period
- 7:43just after COVID, a lot of people bought solutions like
- 7:46commerce tools based solely on what was being put in front of
- 7:50them. And you know, a lot of CTOSCIOS
- 7:53and you know, sea level people generally were kind of read
- 7:56bought into that movement. And then I think there was a
- 7:59pretty significant backlash as a result of like mis selling.
- 8:03And I think a lot of those businesses and ended up moving
- 8:06more towards shop buyer maybe at the time big commerce as well.
- 8:09And I think that was definitely about this as well.
- 8:13But I do think, I mean, I think your point around, I think the,
- 8:16the platform space right now just feels very different to
- 8:20before where there was kind of like a bit more respect to the
- 8:22market. I completely agree.
- 8:24Like you see so much content on LinkedIn where you've got people
- 8:27in the Magento's face just actually bashing Shopify, but
- 8:30also, you know, the shot the five people as you share, I
- 8:33think Magento and Salesforce just absolutely killing them.
- 8:36And I think the conversation we just had before this annoyingly
- 8:41was aroused. Like I think what's what's been
- 8:45lost in the industry is people saying, right, how do I build
- 8:49something for around, you know, how we're currently operating,
- 8:52how our team wants to operate and the customer.
- 8:54And this doesn't apply to every business.
- 8:56I think small businesses, simple businesses, people with very
- 9:00little money or cash at the time.
- 9:03But if they want to move to Shopify because it's going to be
- 9:06cheaper to upgrade, but I do think there's that this whole
- 9:10piece where you're kind of building around or like building
- 9:12IP or building around a broader requirement has probably been
- 9:16lost. And now that is kind of, you
- 9:18know, we're going to move and operate as a platform like Shop
- 9:21Fire wants us to operate. And yeah, and I think in what's
- 9:25your view on like do you think that's where Magento's still
- 9:28kind of, you know, has that kind of position in the market where
- 9:31you do have flexibility around how orders are managed, like
- 9:34different kind of check out flows and yeah.
- 9:38Yeah. So the the what I've just to
- 9:42round off that, that last point, I would like to see much more
- 9:46objectivity rather than serving personal interests from from a
- 9:53consultant point of view or an agency point of view.
- 9:56And I think it would, it would result in better outcomes if we
- 10:02knew where the where the skeletons were buried across all
- 10:06platforms. So going back to Magenta, I
- 10:08think again, actually, I think it's probably one of the, the
- 10:11challenges that Shopify will face.
- 10:13Magenta was effectively positioning itself to be all
- 10:19things to all people from start up, mom and pop shops up to huge
- 10:25multinational multi store B2B enterprise platforms.
- 10:28And it's very difficult to build a, a platform that serves so
- 10:33much ICP. And I think this is broadly, you
- 10:35know, got 5 struggling with, with their playing to be to be
- 10:38an enterprise space when there's a perception around that because
- 10:42you can't, you can't focus, you can't channel the efforts into
- 10:45particular features of functionality.
- 10:47The Magento suffered from that for years.
- 10:50It suffered from poor implementation.
- 10:53It's suffered because it was such a high bar to get to get
- 10:59good at it. People could hack it, hack it
- 11:01around because it was very accessible.
- 11:06They had a a number of missteps when they launched the Magento
- 11:102, which did even more damage. And I think fair to say with,
- 11:15with the, the ownership over, you know, the 15 years from
- 11:19private to eBay, to private equity and now to mass tech with
- 11:23Adobe, despite all of those stakeholders and governance,
- 11:28it's really lacked A cohesive road map or strategy of where
- 11:32it's going to put it's innovation and investment.
- 11:35And I don't mind saying I, I, you know, I've been quite vocal
- 11:38about this. It's, it's, it's been a shame
- 11:43that there hasn't been the same cadence or focus to build out
- 11:50new feature sets and, and develop and then, and then hold
- 11:54some of the challenges in the stack.
- 11:57A lot of that innovation has come from the community.
- 12:01And despite all of the, you know, the disruption at the, the
- 12:06strategic or leadership level, the platform still endures.
- 12:10Yes, it's taken a hit over the last few years, but it's still
- 12:13got market share that aside from Woo Commerce and Shopify, all
- 12:18the other platforms would give their right arm for that type of
- 12:23tough dominance. And certainly with the advances
- 12:26that you know the front end team at Hoover have done over the
- 12:30last 18 months, two years, three years, it's reignited a lot of
- 12:34enthusiasm in the open source market.
- 12:36And there is, there is again that, that decline is certainly
- 12:41levelled off in the open source Magento space and starting to
- 12:44uptick because there is a resurgence in, in enthusiasm
- 12:48energy and people are now turning I think back to the fact
- 12:51that they would like some control over their platform.
- 12:54They don't like necessarily the vendor lock in around Stas where
- 12:59technology broadly dictates your, your, your decisions for
- 13:02the business. So I think there's a place for
- 13:05all of these platforms. I think it comes back down to,
- 13:07yeah, being open and honest with the fit for your, for your
- 13:10business and being clear on what you want to do.
- 13:13The biggest, the biggest difference now is, you know,
- 13:16there's Magento and then there's Adobe Commerce.
- 13:19And previously there's, there's been some conflation and
- 13:23confusion around where they they sit.
- 13:25I think with the announcements Adobe has made around Adobe
- 13:29Commerce Optimizer and their SAS platform, there is definitely a
- 13:33divergent now and a clear positioning and ICP that each
- 13:38platform sits in. And when they're going on, I
- 13:41think that that clarifies, clarifies it what I like to
- 13:45position it as is that one code base with a, with a menu option.
- 13:50So you can go with a the traditional open source
- 13:55platform, we have full control. You can that go with the
- 14:01commerce license with Adobe, but you still have the ability to to
- 14:06control that host it where you want.
- 14:08So you have the benefit of a big tech firm looking over, but you
- 14:13still have a lot of control or you if your business decides you
- 14:16want to abdicate a lot of the ownership of that, you can go
- 14:19out and sign up to their full SAS Manage program.
- 14:25So you've got a kind of menu of options, but broadly the code
- 14:28basis. It's similar.
- 14:30So I think that takes us quite nicely onto one of the
- 14:32questions. We'll probably end up moving
- 14:34around a little bit here, but I think all all of what you just
- 14:38said definitely resonates of me. I personally often cite some of
- 14:42this change that you just mentioned around Adobe as being
- 14:47a big contributed to the Shopify site, because I think a lot of
- 14:50people say Shopify is just, you know, this amazing product and
- 14:54they came in and changed everything.
- 14:55But I actually think a lot of the change in like Adobe maybe
- 14:58not managing some of those reputation issues, particularly
- 15:01wow. And maybe some of the stuff
- 15:03they're doing now is was a bit late.
- 15:06And I think that's probably been as big a contributor to Shopify
- 15:10kind of soaking up market share. And I'm sure we'll come on later
- 15:13on around kind of the Shopify industry now and some of the
- 15:18risks around that. But you just mentioned Magento
- 15:21SAS player. So one of the questions or kind
- 15:24of the newer SAS offering. Can you talk us through like how
- 15:28that works and how you see that being kind of a newer viable
- 15:35option for maybe where Magento maybe wouldn't have fit before?
- 15:40Yeah. So it's it's important to to
- 15:42again make that distinction between Dobie Commerce and
- 15:44Magento. So what Dobie are quite keen to
- 15:47do is Magento is the name given to the open source I from now
- 15:52Adobe, Adobe Commerce. So I think the strategically I
- 15:59think it makes a lot of sense for Adobe.
- 16:02They've got history in the space about Sassafire products done it
- 16:06with Creative Suite. It is a nod to addressing some
- 16:15of the known issues with the platform, such as the total cost
- 16:20of ownership around patching, upgrading.
- 16:25It's lining the platform much more with the DX suite from from
- 16:29Adobe. So that customer data platform,
- 16:34Journey optimizer, analytics platform and a lot more of their
- 16:38creative AI generated tools, which is the direction they're
- 16:42coming. So it's bringing it into the
- 16:43same stacks and that it's much more interoperable with with
- 16:48APIs and they can sit much more closely together.
- 16:52It allows it's, it's got built in under a brand name called app
- 16:58builder. This middleware, low code, low
- 17:01code ability to integrate third party tech and, and features of
- 17:07functionality much more in a, a modular managed process.
- 17:11So unlike Shopify where you, you know, variable, if you're an
- 17:15enterprise player, you need, you know, a #1020, you're better
- 17:20more experienced at this than I am of apps that are outside your
- 17:24control in a, in a distributed ecosystem.
- 17:27This is trying to bring it in. So there is some standardisation
- 17:31control that strategically all makes it makes a lot of sense.
- 17:35The the challenge is it's quite a, it's quite a structural
- 17:40change for people that are used to Adobe commerce.
- 17:44And one of the benefits, and my concern is one of the benefits
- 17:47of the platform is it's openness, extensibility and the
- 17:51fact that last 10 years, there's a lot of tech and a lot of
- 17:54engineering has been built. A lot of third party providers
- 17:57have spent a lot of effort resource in building
- 18:00integrations into the platform that now needs to be re
- 18:04engineered in this new world, which will take a lot of time.
- 18:09The the cost and speed of building those integrations is
- 18:13much reduced. So it's actually we've, we've
- 18:15done it for PayPal already. It's the the path is easier few
- 18:22restrictions, fewer effort, but it is still it's still early and
- 18:29again carrying back to that honesty around consulting the
- 18:33brands go, yeah, this is the direction they're going fast
- 18:37model take on what you know, but there is some there is some
- 18:41calorie burn initially to to make sure you you get in that.
- 18:45Space, yeah. And if you like, I, I know
- 18:48literally nothing about this product and I think the industry
- 18:51knows very little about the product actually.
- 18:54And I do think it's pretty big development and it does have
- 18:58potential that what's in terms of like costs, like is it a case
- 19:03of, you know, similar license model and then you have
- 19:07potentially some benefit from ATCO perspective, you don't have
- 19:10that same level of like maintenance and kind of upkeep?
- 19:15Correct. So the, I think broadly the
- 19:19licensing will be akin to what what they currently do with the,
- 19:23the commerce, but they're bundle bundling a lot of other features
- 19:27there. And I think the added value,
- 19:29certainly the, the feature that we're most aware of and I guess
- 19:36can see immediate benefit from is this app builder, which is a
- 19:41I'm, I'm not a fan of the name because as soon as you say app
- 19:45builder people are you building apps?
- 19:46It's not about that. Actually it's it's a federally A
- 19:50middleware, no code, low code from API to API mesh
- 19:55effectively. And the reason we like that is
- 19:57we can we can deploy technology and on there, whereas previously
- 20:05it would have to be baked into the core or you'd actually have
- 20:08to use an Ipass. Solution.
- 20:12So instantly that has allowed a lot of cost saving from people
- 20:16using things like ipass or, you know, Sligo or Tray or Hashworks
- 20:21or anything out there. You can actually have that in
- 20:23the code so there's instant added value in the stack.
- 20:28Then ultimately they're trying to remove that need for agencies
- 20:34or merchants to maintain the versions and the patches.
- 20:38So again, the cost of those upgrades, which is a clear
- 20:43obstacle, problem, friction point for many in the industry.
- 20:47Absolutely. And I think it's probably that
- 20:49kind of maybe bottom 50% by that has been one of the key issues
- 20:56or Adobe, this might be a bit of a naive question.
- 20:59How like far along is this product?
- 21:02So they, I think they announced it it at Adobe Summit.
- 21:05They're like live merchants using it.
- 21:07Like is it kind of something that you're kind of seeing more
- 21:10and more demand for? So the, the, this is their, this
- 21:18is their showcase strategy. So there's a lot of, a lot of
- 21:23focus on investment going into this.
- 21:26They're accelerating that integration, you know, already
- 21:29by the end of the year, hundreds, 200 integrations
- 21:32through the app builder networks and there is some pace going
- 21:35into that. They they have some early, early
- 21:41adopter merchants going on it. The response from the merchants
- 21:47has been we really like it conceptually and strategically
- 21:51it's really good. Our position is that's the
- 21:54direction of travel. You know, if that's the read you
- 21:56want to go, great. Just be mindful that early
- 22:00adopters require some, you know, early investment.
- 22:05Yeah, that makes sense. Yeah.
- 22:07And I think that's really interesting.
- 22:08That'll be interesting to see how that develops because it
- 22:10feels like it's probably more in line with where Magento 2 could
- 22:15have been, yeah. Yeah, but I think so.
- 22:18I think the the I mean we're going to come on to this.
- 22:21I think you asked him one of your questions that you sent
- 22:24through is this is this a direct play against something like a
- 22:29pure SAS Shopify? I don't, I don't see it.
- 22:32That is certainly in response to the market conditions and the
- 22:36field that you know, just read any Gartner or Forest report,
- 22:40you know, SAS, SAS, SAS, SAS. So I think it's certainly an
- 22:44answer to that. I think they they wouldn't see
- 22:48going after the typical ICP that makes up the 80 or 90% in store
- 22:55base for Shopify. That's not where Adobe plays.
- 22:58It is very much the the large multinational enterprise with
- 23:05with a level of complexity that's needed in in the
- 23:08platform. Yeah.
- 23:10It feels a bit more in line with maybe kind of the architecture
- 23:14around centre or potentially like a bit more of a kind of
- 23:19feature rich commerce tools, so kind of SAS based, but with the
- 23:24ability to like still kind of be build IP around it, but more
- 23:28flexibility on around the kind of core areas of the platform.
- 23:32I, I think so. I mean when, when we were, you
- 23:34know, the last couple of years the RFPs we've been in which are
- 23:37tend to be the, the large complex multinational B to BB to
- 23:43C mixed platforms. The platforms on on the table in
- 23:49the RFP tended to be the commerce tools, the sales force
- 23:53and the Adobe. We tended not to see the big
- 23:55commerce and the shop fries in those conversations.
- 23:59Historically, a lot going back a year or two, commerce tools
- 24:03certainly had the edge in terms of the narrative and the wind
- 24:08behind in terms of what they were doing.
- 24:10But I think I was incredibly critical of the Mac ideology.
- 24:13I felt it was it was it was a simplistic cult, Careful.
- 24:20It was a simplistic view that just added unnecessary
- 24:23perplexity over engineering for what you were doing.
- 24:25And I think that's, I think this is perhaps a response to go,
- 24:29yeah, the platform that has has a lot of robustness built into
- 24:34it, but now it's taking the next level in terms in terms of newer
- 24:37technology and architectural decisions.
- 24:41Great. Well, yeah, excited to see how
- 24:42that kind of plays out. And so one of the other things
- 24:45that was announced at the Adobe Summit was the Adobe Commerce
- 24:49Optimizer, which again feels pretty relevant to kind of a lot
- 24:54of the topics we've already covered.
- 24:56Can you talk us through how this works and like what the kind of
- 24:59benefits to brands or retailers are?
- 25:02Yeah. So the the optimizer is another
- 25:04I guess that's the front end layer.
- 25:07And the view is this is, you know, the the new front end
- 25:12technology that was called EDS, it's now rebased broadly the
- 25:16same sort of thing. So it's, it's a pathway, I think
- 25:19to full SAS because I think it's understanding that if you've
- 25:24invested heavily on the on an on Prem solution or even Adobe
- 25:28commerce, what are you just simply going to shift into a SAS
- 25:34product that is very early. This is a, this is a, a pathway
- 25:39that allows people to address some of the, again, one of the
- 25:43endemic problems about the speed and performance of Magento's
- 25:46front end. So it allows you to layer on the
- 25:50newer EDS technology app builder onto your existing stack with a
- 25:56precursor of eventually then that would then fold into a full
- 25:59SAS. It's marketed that all of that
- 26:01technology can sit on other back end platforms as well.
- 26:07I'm, I'm a little more sceptical of that because of, again, it's
- 26:11the same sort of Mac ideology that, yeah, it's all wonderful.
- 26:13It's just plug and play and we know that doesn't happen, but it
- 26:16doesn't, you can't just mash this stuff together.
- 26:20So I'm a little more nuanced on that as an approach.
- 26:23But yeah, it's, it's, it's a way of sort of start off decoupling
- 26:28some of the the front end and allow you to interface with the
- 26:32wider Adobe DX suite. Yeah.
- 26:35So I guess that feels like it's probably an alternative, a play
- 26:39approach to something that you've mentioned a couple of
- 26:42times, which is Hoover, which me as an outsider, you know, in the
- 26:48industry, it feels like a lot of the kind of excitement around
- 26:52Adobia Magento is coming from Hoover and a lot of the agencies
- 26:56that are. You know.
- 26:57Winning net Neo are really kind of going to market with them.
- 27:01What's your view on Hoover, what they're building?
- 27:06And I guess do you agree that, you know, this is a big part of
- 27:09the the play at the moment? I think what Hoover have done is
- 27:21sort of thrown a bit of a lifeline to what was becoming a
- 27:27very fairly disillusioned community.
- 27:31So it's a vast community of Magento developers.
- 27:35If we go back to the open source market.
- 27:37So it's less about Adobe now, it's more about the the Magento
- 27:39open source bit of a disillusionment.
- 27:42You know, where's it going? Where's the investment coming?
- 27:46All the noise and all the investments seems to be on the
- 27:48new shiny. And when I talked about the lack
- 27:54of innovation into the product, the front end was known as one
- 28:02of those areas that people got enormously frustrated was it was
- 28:05it was sluggish. It took a lot of effort.
- 28:07You can do it and we do it, but it does take a lot of effort and
- 28:11a lot of front end developers didn't really enjoy wading
- 28:15through that treacle. You know, years ago, probably
- 28:18going back 201718 Magenta. At the time, Magenta Adobe took
- 28:23the view that it was all about PWA and they vested heavily in
- 28:26the PWA stack again, another, another hype and chasing of
- 28:34buzzwords rather than actually going back and keeping it simple
- 28:38and inherently changing the framework of the front end.
- 28:41Had they done that, had, had Hoover been an internal product
- 28:45or had Hoover done it 5 or 6 years ago, I actually think the
- 28:48trajectory of Magenta would have been completely different, which
- 28:53is probably what we tried to do 10 years ago with the, the page
- 28:55builder technology. So they, they've, they've really
- 29:02excited the community and, and, and enhanced that innovation and
- 29:07enthusiasm and demonstrated that with the right focus and the
- 29:11right skills, the site can be incredibly performant and quick
- 29:16to build and deploy. So they, they've had a lot of
- 29:19success and now they're taking that and building out another
- 29:21road map of features and developments.
- 29:23They're bringing out their own CNS page builder technology.
- 29:28I'm taking a few beatings that page builders crap now, but I
- 29:32keep explaining it's 10 years old and no one's built anything.
- 29:35So they're, they're trying to do a lot around that a lot fix, fix
- 29:39a lot of the, the, the annoyances and friction in the
- 29:42platform. And they've got a lot of love in
- 29:44the community. People are really advocating for
- 29:46it. So they, they've done a
- 29:47tremendous, tremendous job doing really broadly what the, you
- 29:52know, the owner should, should, should do.
- 29:55Yeah. Yeah, absolutely.
- 29:57And do you, do you work with Hoover?
- 29:58Like how do your team feel about it?
- 30:01Yeah, we do. Again, we we're working closely
- 30:06with them with our new product Bluefinch, which again it's them
- 30:11a sort of mission and vision trying to solve and innovate,
- 30:14solve problems that that people use.
- 30:18Hoover is a is a really good quick framework to build on and
- 30:28we, we put that in our in our selection, whether it be the
- 30:34Adobe EDS platform, the Hoover platform still being incumbent
- 30:41Luma platform. So again, it comes down to cost
- 30:43fit rather than being polarized and just go.
- 30:47That's the, that's the route. Yeah, definitely.
- 30:50That makes sense. And then I guess the next
- 30:53question. So we have covered this a little
- 30:54bit and this question was maybe a little bit more focused around
- 30:58the future for Adobe and Magento, but I think we've
- 31:02covered a lot of that. So like how I guess my question
- 31:05is like Tam, the market for Magento, you know where people
- 31:09are actively want and need Magenta or Adobe, which to me
- 31:14feels at the moment fairly like complex B to C multi brand
- 31:19people that you know have IP that is very important within A
- 31:24build or B to B. How do you see that market?
- 31:28Do you think Magenta or Adobe's products will ever be mass
- 31:31market again or do you see them focusing more on that kind of
- 31:36enterprise and B to B category? Yeah, I think the days of of
- 31:40complete mass market Don, I think the Adobe is a you know
- 31:46they're they're traditional customers are huge global
- 31:51billion dollar businesses in terms of the DX suite and it's
- 31:55about building commerce capability into that.
- 31:58So I think there is there is a very clear certainly in our in
- 32:02our view is a very clear lane and fit for businesses that as
- 32:08you rightly point out, there is a level of complexity.
- 32:12There is a desire to have control, control over check out
- 32:19control over data, control over business logic because that does
- 32:24the risk. And I think there will be a
- 32:27there will be a push back on that that vendor lock in from
- 32:31shop fine. I think they will challenge to
- 32:34to nail that enterprise space data governance, data integrity
- 32:39for for one, the they've yet to you know, despite 3 years of
- 32:45saying yes, we do multi store yet to really nail that.
- 32:48I don't think markets, I think that's a marketing.
- 32:52I don't think that hits hits the right nail and B to B still, you
- 33:00know, there's some promise in terms of the feature set, but
- 33:01it's still not still not on parity.
- 33:08And whilst Adobe still has some holes in its B to B capability,
- 33:13the fact that it is an open architecture and it allows us to
- 33:16build whatever the business wants, that's still the for us.
- 33:19That's why we've we've resisted the urge of going to the Shopify
- 33:22world. And the type of businesses we we
- 33:25look for are the ones that we call it level 5 commerce.
- 33:28It's about differentiation. And you know, we've got a
- 33:32really, really powerful subscription based business
- 33:36we've looked after for seven years and they've invested so
- 33:39heavily in making sure that they're, their technology serves
- 33:44their customers and they're a unique customer set.
- 33:47It's in healthcare, adult healthcare as well.
- 33:51Really sensitive to how they, they want to operate and the,
- 33:56the work we've done around. Didn't you?
- 33:58Well, there you go. Thank you. 7-8 years ago, lazy
- 34:01still with us. The stuff they've done around
- 34:04lifetime value, turn rate, the the user journey is phenomenal.
- 34:12They're really on it. And there's no constraints.
- 34:17If you took, if you took an app off the, it's just wouldn't, you
- 34:20just wouldn't be able to do that with that ridiculous amount of
- 34:23API workarounds. So it's this, there's that
- 34:26there's that space for for businesses in that
- 34:28differentiation like. They're also multi brand as well
- 34:31for and. I don't know if it's still
- 34:33managed in the same way, but they have multiple brands
- 34:35operating from individual instances of Adobe or Magenta.
- 34:39I think that's it's another area that shot by and and a number of
- 34:44the other platforms aren't really and.
- 34:48And and international as well. And it allows us to do a level
- 34:51of orchestration on payments as well.
- 34:53It gives us our freedom to to make, to make the right decision
- 34:56for the business rather than going, OK, you want to do this
- 34:58his app. Does that fit?
- 35:01I think I think in terms of those shop fires, I think they I
- 35:04think markets gets better all the time.
- 35:06But I agree that there kind of thing anyone listening to this
- 35:09would agree that there's still areas that need to be invested
- 35:13in and worked on. And you know, also the
- 35:15compatibility of the ecosystem and maybe some of the more kind
- 35:19of trade in focused areas aren't there.
- 35:21That's it's a work in progress. I think they'll definitely get
- 35:24there. I think B to B, I think shop
- 35:27Fire have obviously got an incredible brand.
- 35:29They're very good at marketing. But I think I'm still to be
- 35:32convinced that, you know, that they have the plan to actually
- 35:38compete with the the proper B2B platforms than the Adobe's and
- 35:44some of the others that are, you know, actively serving B2B
- 35:48retailers doing billions and billions of dollars with the
- 35:52complexity. And I I feel like sometimes
- 35:55they'll come out and they will say that, you know, they're
- 35:58ready to go after that market, but it doesn't quite feel like
- 36:00they've got that same energy behind that one as they do some
- 36:05of the other categories that I think they're going after.
- 36:08So I think, yeah, agree on that one.
- 36:12It's a phenomenal, it's a phenomenal platform.
- 36:15It, you know, I said it makes the, IT makes the easy stuff
- 36:18really easy, but it makes the hard stuff really hard.
- 36:24Yeah, the mission, ultimately the mission for Shop Fire is
- 36:27there's no barrier to entry. I think Shop Fire becomes, you
- 36:31know, what Microsoft was or Windows was, and they want to
- 36:35be, yeah, a default operating system.
- 36:38And then they figure out how they maybe monetise it and also
- 36:42leverage the data. And I think, you know, the real
- 36:44vision for Shop Fire is to go head to head with some of the
- 36:47biggest companies in the world from a data perspective
- 36:50alongside the enterprise player, which I think has a bit of a
- 36:53different orientation. And, you know, they need to
- 36:57bring in volume on that side. But yeah, I think that's
- 37:02ultimately where it's heading. And I think, you know, it's
- 37:04going to definitely have an impact on their ecosystem, the
- 37:07service industry. But I feel like that vision
- 37:11doesn't necessarily tie into like, a business that's built a
- 37:15way of working from scratch from, yeah, you know, that does
- 37:20hundreds and hundreds of thousands of orders, the
- 37:24complexity. So yeah, I think it'd be
- 37:25interesting to see how that side progresses.
- 37:29Does it all? Does any of it matter though,
- 37:31Paul? Does any of it matter?
- 37:33Three years? He'll just be buying off
- 37:34strategy PT, weren't we? Well, that's, that's kind of,
- 37:37yeah. I mean, I've, yeah, I think
- 37:39there's obviously a lot of question marks over what econ's
- 37:42going to look like in two or three years anyway and what
- 37:45those yeah, kind of experiences look like.
- 37:47So yeah, I don't think anyone really fully knows the speed at
- 37:52which some of that stuff's going to affect us all.
- 37:56It's a next one. So Gene's always been at the
- 37:58forefront of innovation in the Magento or Adobe space.
- 38:01So I've seen various different products you've done from like
- 38:05VR related things to payments. Bluefurt was obviously the
- 38:09highest profile 1, so you've got 2 new products.
- 38:12So to start with, can you talk us through Bluefinch, like
- 38:15exactly what that is? Yeah.
- 38:17What the kind of strategy is, what the benefit is to a
- 38:22merchant and kind of yeah, how far you want to take that.
- 38:26So we were, we were, we were inspired broadly by what the
- 38:31guys at Whoville had done. So they demonstrated that there
- 38:34was still an appetite and still a market there.
- 38:37You know, despite the decline, there's still good 200,000 user
- 38:40base out there that we know of, that we don't know of.
- 38:45And I think it was a little bit of a response to, to the, the
- 38:50onslaught from Shopify, you know, the, the, the ammunition
- 38:56they had, rightly so, was total cost of ownership, right?
- 39:00The the cost of upkeep and the patching, the time to market it
- 39:05takes takes and the effort to to spin up a site.
- 39:09And also the check out, you know, the optimised check out
- 39:12and you know, the known challenges around the endemic
- 39:17product with, with magenta. So we thought, OK, well, whoever
- 39:20sold the front end, can we go about solving some of these
- 39:22other, other challenges? So if we took them in in
- 39:26isolation. So the total cost of ownership
- 39:27really comes down to the disproportionate amount of money
- 39:31you have to spend on patching and upgrading the platform and
- 39:35the, the challenge around that. And there's many reasons why it
- 39:38does cost that, but it didn't need to be that.
- 39:44So for the last three or four years, that's not a, that hasn't
- 39:47been a problem for us as an agency or our, our clients.
- 39:50So optimising the code. So we took the view as a let's
- 39:53package up some of that, that learning tooling, coding and
- 39:58putting it into a platform, a SAS platform that any merchant
- 40:02can now connect to. And it will validate, manage,
- 40:09interrogate your code and go through a load of checks and
- 40:13spit out compatible pull requests within about, you know,
- 40:172 minutes. And if if there are.
- 40:20Compatibility issues or problems with it, what it will do is
- 40:23highlight where those are what you need to do. 99% of the time
- 40:28they're to do with some third party module or extension.
- 40:32So it's the first time ever that we're going to be able to
- 40:35surface up and not not necessarily name Shane, but
- 40:38certainly shine a light on the culprits and take take the
- 40:43criticism away from the platform and the agency that has to do
- 40:46this. And it allows the business to go
- 40:49because often they're blind to why it costs this much.
- 40:52So suddenly when you run this report, the business or the
- 40:54merchant, you go, I got all green ticks.
- 40:57Surely it shouldn't cost anything.
- 40:59We can just, we can just go live similar to you do with, you
- 41:02know, shop file or WordPress sort of green and blue
- 41:05deployment. And the, I mean the real, the
- 41:11real test came back in beginning of April when Adobe released a
- 41:15load of updates and patches and upgrades usual, usual
- 41:19scheduling. And we, we passed that through
- 41:2230 sites within within two to three minutes.
- 41:27The only thing that slowed us down was actually the release
- 41:29from Adobe of those patches. Now that that effort, even if
- 41:34you had really good code and really good clean, simple sites
- 41:41would still take four or five hours, maybe even a day per
- 41:46site. So suddenly we've gone 30 days
- 41:49there in 2 minutes. You can go in and just pull
- 41:52request. So huge amount saving and huge
- 41:55amount of effort in that. So that's that's a really
- 41:58exciting, I think product in the market's been crying out for
- 42:01donkeys years. My only annoyance is that we
- 42:04didn't do it 5-5 years ago. Yeah.
- 42:07So I feel like, and I guess the the goal is if you get the
- 42:10volume, then you end up with a lot of data around this stuff
- 42:14and you can apply that AI to and everything else.
- 42:16Feels like kind of like Hoover have always had like a bit of a
- 42:20proposition around that. But it's obviously been meant
- 42:23that you need to use, you know, their hosting service and
- 42:26everything else. And and I guess like how
- 42:28accessible is it like from a cost perspective, like
- 42:30presumably you charge for this service.
- 42:33How does that sound back? We do, I think it works out
- 42:37about I think $50 per site just to run the process, the pull
- 42:41request. So if you, you know, if you say,
- 42:44look, best case scenario, it's going to take you 5 hours.
- 42:48It's, it's really affordable. And what we want to do is put it
- 42:53out there mass market to, to levy up the the community and
- 42:57take all that criticism away from it, encourage people to
- 43:00actually patch an upgrade because then that has a that has
- 43:03a bearing on the security aspect of the security holes that
- 43:09generally come about because people don't patch it because
- 43:11they can't afford it. So there's a lot of peripheral
- 43:14benefit of improving the standards of the coding.
- 43:18And every time you, every time you use the tool, it iterates
- 43:22and your platform gets better and better because you basically
- 43:24wash through any crap code, legacy code and you wash out
- 43:30any, any modules that are defunct or not keeping pace with
- 43:34it and it really cleans up the ecosystem.
- 43:37I guess the friction, it also removes friction, which I think
- 43:40has probably been one of the biggest issues as well around
- 43:42Adobe, like all of these kind of patches and everything else,
- 43:46says usually someone on the other hand getting frustrated or
- 43:49having an impact. Yeah, yeah.
- 43:52But it slows, it slows people's ability to move ahead with their
- 43:55road map because everything stops because a patch comes out
- 43:58and you have to divert resource and effort to do that.
- 44:01So that it's a, it's compounded impact.
- 44:04And I think what our our view, we did it as an agency, we
- 44:07wanted to remove that from consideration.
- 44:11So I don't see it, our merchants don't see it.
- 44:14It's just a line item in support.
- 44:16It just happens and that means they can carry on constraint on
- 44:19the CapEx road map, feature development.
- 44:22Makes sense. And then the other new product
- 44:24that you've developed, which I, when we last met, I was pretty
- 44:27surprised at like how far along you are with it and that some of
- 44:30the relationships you've built with global kind of publishers
- 44:34and media companies. Can you talk us through that?
- 44:38I've actually forgotten the name of it and I haven't written it
- 44:40down. So, yeah, could you talk us
- 44:42through that? Take note you will hear it a lot
- 44:44shop through. The shop through is a is a carve
- 44:49out business from Jean. So this is a this is a new start
- 44:52up. I say new.
- 44:53It's been just over 12 months now where we've been developing
- 44:56the platform, validating, doing a lot market fit.
- 45:01It came about, I guess probably, excuse me, 3 or 4 years ago with
- 45:05a vision that could see the way the world was going from a an
- 45:12e-commerce point of view in that for the last 20 years, nothing's
- 45:18really changed. We direct everybody to a
- 45:21website. Oh, is that you see even even
- 45:24even the screen thinks it's good, directs everyone to a
- 45:29website, redirects everyone to a website, irrespective of what
- 45:31channel you're on. And I, I the view that, you
- 45:34know, eventually it's going to be kind of a channel this world.
- 45:37And actually people will need to be buying wherever they are in
- 45:41context, wherever they discover a product.
- 45:43So they buy anything anywhere sort of concept.
- 45:46And that kind of got born around when I start thinking about the,
- 45:49the AR technology or the, the, the conversational commerce IoT.
- 45:55So all that seems quite old hat now, seeing as everyone's
- 45:58talking them just about chat AI. But broadly, that's kind of
- 46:02aligned with where a lot of the conversations now going with
- 46:05agents. And you know, the buzzword now,
- 46:07which is agentic commerce. And is that, that, that vision?
- 46:11So we set about how can this work?
- 46:13And it was really taking the idea of rather than directing
- 46:16someone to a retailer, why don't we bring the check out to the
- 46:20consumer wherever they are. So in sort of traditional terms
- 46:24is about an embedded buying experience wherever you are now
- 46:29that and then that has lots of benefits from a from a, a
- 46:33tracking cookie issue. So you don't have all that, that
- 46:36nonsense building convenience to the consumer speed fewer steps,
- 46:45all the friction addresses the, the checkout conversion
- 46:48abandonment rate. And that, that was really where
- 46:51we we honed on it. And we, we found in the last 12
- 46:54months that there is a natural fit into the affiliate marketing
- 46:56world at the moment. And when we started doing a lot
- 46:59of market research, like a lot of market research in in this
- 47:03world, we uncovered so really so many problems, so many
- 47:08challenges that that industry faces with quite a a legacy
- 47:14concept of redirection. And, you know, facing more and
- 47:21more increasing challenges with the advent of AI, with the
- 47:24advent of loads more ad tech. And one of the, the stand out,
- 47:30stand out data points we found was just how much, how much
- 47:40money is misappropriated to that last clip touch point with the
- 47:46main culprits being voucher code websites, cash back websites.
- 47:51When we started talking to the, the content creators and
- 47:54publishers, they were kind of aware that was happening, but to
- 47:58not to not the extent. And when we started looking into
- 48:01it, it's, it's huge. So these these guys, these
- 48:04publishers, big publishers, content creators put all that
- 48:06effort into curating, generating that content.
- 48:11And at the best or best guess, half of that half of that
- 48:15traffic is effectively high. I mean, you we use the
- 48:19provocative term hijacked at that last click, that last
- 48:23moment. And these guys that are doing
- 48:25the hard lifting aren't getting any benefit.
- 48:28So our solution by flipping this on its head puts the power back
- 48:32into the those guys and so you go, OK, you can now get proper
- 48:36recompense for the effort and work you put into generating
- 48:39that content and driving the intent for the sale rather than
- 48:43the closing of the sale. Yeah, Yeah, that makes sense I
- 48:46think. Yeah, I agree on the affiliates
- 48:48base and there's there's so much misattributed Commission in that
- 48:54world even Yeah, earlier on in the process as well.
- 48:58Feels very tropical as well, obviously with AI and Google and
- 49:04QBT both announcing a level of kind of in context check out.
- 49:10So I guess this would be the equivalent that via editorial
- 49:13size, because I think people will still consume editorial
- 49:15content. And I guess the same could apply
- 49:17to like, you know, video and whatever else.
- 49:21Yes, yeah. So how does a commercial model
- 49:23work? So it feels like at the moment
- 49:25you're probably working more with publishers and directly
- 49:29with brands and maybe networks. But how does it work?
- 49:33Yeah. So I think if you're if you're
- 49:36being cynical, you could argue that we are also in network
- 49:40putting, putting retailers in touch with publishers and
- 49:44content. Creators.
- 49:45Yeah. It's a good point, actually.
- 49:47Yeah. However, we are trying to solve
- 49:51the problem for the for the originators, the intent first
- 49:56and foremost, because they're the ones that are being I guess
- 50:01most acutely affected by the the attribution.
- 50:05And actually as an industry in a sector, I think they they are
- 50:11staring down the barrel of another seismic if over the next
- 50:16couple of years. I was fortunate enough last week
- 50:18to be at the PayPal C360 events is a sort of two or three day
- 50:25sort of leadership away day where you get a lot of access to
- 50:32to what they're doing internally and and some, you know, amazing
- 50:35speakers. So we had that class from ex
- 50:39open AI perplexity there because they announced their perplexity
- 50:43tie up and the work that's going into agentic agentic comets.
- 50:49So you can see where the world is moving and what we've done is
- 50:52built the rails that would enable not only that to happen,
- 50:56but actually still monetize it for the people that are
- 50:59generating the content. And I think there will be a
- 51:04there will be a desire for authenticity and that will come
- 51:11from content creators and and publishers.
- 51:14So we've been very fortunate that the engagement for the
- 51:17publishing network, the big newspapers, big, big magazines
- 51:21have seen this as a need and they've really jumped on board
- 51:25with solving the problem because the money exists on the table.
- 51:29We're just basically saying, well, it's now due to you.
- 51:33So you can change their bottom line overnight by implementing
- 51:36this technology. The retailers have been great,
- 51:39you know, because we we're solving that from publishers.
- 51:43They're therefore more likely to promote retailers in our
- 51:46network. So we've got about 150 Shopify
- 51:48merchants actually you'd be pleased to know they've already
- 51:51joined our, our network. So we've got quite a, we've
- 51:56accelerated that quite a lot. We're still early, but early,
- 51:59early signals have been amazing on the, on the conversion and
- 52:03the attribution. So really, you know, really
- 52:05pleased and quite, yeah, quite confident when this can go over
- 52:09the next 612 months. Great.
- 52:11Yeah, it's, it's super interesting.
- 52:12We'll have to at some point get you back to do an episode maybe
- 52:15on this specifically because I think, yeah, it feels like
- 52:19there's a lot of potential there and potential, I guess for you
- 52:22guys to work more with the other networks.
- 52:24And yeah, obviously kind of broaden it out and there's a lot
- 52:27of data available there that I'm sure we could talk about for
- 52:29ages. The benefit of I'd love to,
- 52:32we're going to release a white paper next week, which is a
- 52:34whole research piece of what we've done.
- 52:37The benefit for retailers is because we can now service up
- 52:39exclusive offers and deals in a closed environment.
- 52:43So often retailers are reluctant to pull out the the codes and
- 52:48because they're getting then widespread coverage over the
- 52:54aggregators online. Whereas now for the first time,
- 52:57retailers will know which publishers are promoting them
- 53:00and driving them the actual sale traffic and therefore can
- 53:03negotiate with them better deals because they know it's in that
- 53:06closed environment, the anonymized coupons basically.
- 53:10Great. Well, yeah, I look forward to
- 53:12reading the right paper. This has been a great
- 53:14discussion. Obviously we've covered a lot
- 53:17and yeah, a few, a few different kind of areas.
- 53:22If people want to get in touch around the Gene kind of Adobe
- 53:26Magento side or the Shot free side, how can they get in touch
- 53:30with you? Wow to mattmatt@gene.co.uk
- 53:37Laurel answer any questions, have a look on the LinkedIn
- 53:40Trophy. Perfect.
- 53:42And yeah, I really appreciate you coming on.
- 53:44Like I say, it's always interesting talking to you.
- 53:46I think the Magenta Adobe discussion would be really
- 53:49interesting to a lot of people and it feels quite topical again
- 53:53at the moment. And as always, thanks to
- 53:55everyone for listening. If you've got any questions,
- 53:58feel free to reach out to Matt or James or I and we can connect
- 54:01you. And as always, please follow or
- 54:05subscribe to Inside Commerce to help us keep going.
- 54:08James is a lot better at that kind of exit piece.
- 54:11Yeah, thanks. I'm Philly Slim.
- 54:14You're listening to the Inside Commerce podcast, hosted by
- 54:17experienced consultants James Gert and Paul Rogers, Inside
- 54:20Commerce is your fast track to digital knowledge, featuring
- 54:23interviews with leading e-commerce retailers, industry
- 54:25Thoughtleafs and the C-Suite, key tech companies to explore
- 54:28the latest digital strategy, customer experience and tech.
- 54:32Discover what the latest trends really mean and get practical
- 54:35advice based on experience to help fine tune your E com
- 54:37strategy and tech. Follow us on LinkedIn and reach
- 54:41out to James and Paul if you'd like to discuss an ecommerce
- 54:43project. We hope you enjoy the latest
- 54:45episode.