Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Denaturalization Demystified: A Practical Guide for Immigration Attorneys
Transcript
- 0:02Hello, everyone, and welcome to today's program,
- 0:06Denaturalization Demystified, a Practical Guide
- 0:09for Immigration Attorneys. I'm Alla Policastro,
- 0:13Director of Education and Professional Development
- 0:15at Beverly Hills Bar Association. And today I
- 0:17am absolutely delighted to introduce our speakers,
- 0:20Nancy Cantor and Lindsey Vick. Nancy is an experienced
- 0:23litigator and advisor at Gordon Reese, where
- 0:26she leverages her extensive career experience
- 0:29at the Department of Justice in Washington DC
- 0:31to guide clients through complex regulatory challenges,
- 0:35administrative law matters, constitutional claims,
- 0:37and all aspects of commercial contract disputes
- 0:40and civil litigation. Nancy is experienced in
- 0:43both employment -based and family -based immigration
- 0:45matters, as well as workplace compliance. She
- 0:48advises on governmental investigations relating
- 0:51to compliance with US immigration laws, including
- 0:54worksite enforcement actions and raids, immigration
- 0:57compliance audits, H -1B site visits, civil denaturalization,
- 1:01and responding to administrative and judicial
- 1:04warrants. Lindsay Vick is also a litigator at
- 1:07Gordon Reese, where her practice encompasses
- 1:09class action defense, administrative law, constitutional
- 1:12claims, and civil litigation. Her immigration
- 1:15expertise spans removal defense, habeas corpus
- 1:18petitions, citizenship, and civil denaturalization.
- 1:22Prior to joining Gordon Reese, Lindsay was a
- 1:24senior litigation counsel with the U .S. Department
- 1:26of Justice, where she focused on immigration
- 1:28-related federal civil litigation in federal
- 1:31district courts and circuit courts appeals nationwide.
- 1:34She advised senior leadership at the Department
- 1:36of Justice, Department of Homeland Security,
- 1:39Department of State, and Department of Health
- 1:40and Human Services on complex legal and policy
- 1:43matters. We're so excited to have these experienced
- 1:47speakers with us today, so I'm going to turn
- 1:48it over to them. Thanks, Al. It's good to be
- 1:53here. Let me get our screen share going. So we're
- 2:00here today to talk about civil denaturalization.
- 2:03I know it's been kind of a hot topic and an interesting
- 2:06topic because it's been in the news a lot. You
- 2:10know, one of the things that we're going to focus
- 2:12on is kind of not just the recent case trends
- 2:16and the recent rhetoric about ramping up civil
- 2:18denaturalization, but also kind of the nuts and
- 2:21bolts and the procedures for how the government
- 2:23initiates these types of actions and what we've
- 2:26seen traditionally in terms of how they're prosecuted.
- 2:35Great. And thank you, Nancy, for that introduction.
- 2:38I will preface this by saying that I am unfortunately
- 2:41not in sunny California. I am in sunny Atlanta,
- 2:45Georgia, but it is also high pollen season. And
- 2:49so if I'm coughing or sneezing, please excuse
- 2:52me. I'm not sick. I'm just suffering from allergies.
- 2:56OK, that out of the way. So, the profile of a
- 2:59typical civil denaturalization defendant. Who
- 3:02are we talking about? Who are we expecting to
- 3:05see the government ramp up resources and taxpayer
- 3:07dollars to denaturalize? These cases are not
- 3:11always what you'd expect from an action as severe
- 3:14and serious as stripping someone of their citizenship.
- 3:18Defendants in these cases are generally not the
- 3:21worst of the worst, although as with all things,
- 3:24there are exceptions. There have, of course,
- 3:27been denaturalizations of terrorists and child
- 3:30abusers, but thankfully those people are not
- 3:34all that common. Instead, the case of Norma Borgono,
- 3:39who you see pictured here, is fairly typical
- 3:41based on the cases that at least I have seen
- 3:44when I was at DOJ and since that time. Borgono
- 3:48was elderly, she was a grandmother, or is a grandmother.
- 3:53Presumably, she is still alive. I don't know
- 3:55where she is today, but speaking of her in the
- 3:58past tense, she was elderly, she is a grandmother,
- 4:01and she wasn't some well -known fraudster who
- 4:04famously made off with millions. She actually
- 4:07didn't even profit based on her criminal activity
- 4:11and did cooperate with the FBI during her criminal
- 4:15proceedings. However, she was still denaturalized.
- 4:19And so when the government says that it's going
- 4:21to be ramping up denaturalizations, it's important
- 4:25to understand that these, the majority of the
- 4:29time are going to be people who are older for
- 4:31several reasons. Naturalization is typically
- 4:34the end of a person's immigration journey. And
- 4:38that journey alone can take years. So those who
- 4:41naturalize are often older. And also the criminal
- 4:47activity forming the basis for denaturalization
- 4:50is necessarily discovered after naturalization
- 4:53or else the person likely would not have been
- 4:56naturalized in the first place. So then that
- 4:59depends on how far back the government goes in
- 5:01its investigations to find denaturalization defendants.
- 5:05And that will determine how much older these
- 5:08defendants are. So a lot of the time, you're
- 5:11dealing with people who have adult children,
- 5:15grandchildren, health issues, not a lot of money,
- 5:19fixed incomes, they're retired, but discretion
- 5:22and equities do not come into play in civil denaturalization.
- 5:27If most defendants are older and not wealthy,
- 5:30they don't have the money to litigate what can
- 5:33become quite expensive civil case for the average
- 5:36person. And moreover, The government is not necessarily
- 5:41exercising prosecutorial discretion, especially
- 5:44now under the current administration, based on
- 5:47sympathy or equities. These cases are driven
- 5:50by statutory compliance. And so if you don't
- 5:53manage to reach a pre -litigation settlement,
- 5:56then discretion and equities just don't come
- 5:59into play. And I'll hand it off to Nancy. So,
- 6:07you know, I think one of the reasons certainly
- 6:09that I've seen for this uptick in interest in
- 6:12denaturalization is, you know, the rhetoric both
- 6:16during the first Trump administration, but especially
- 6:18during this most recent new administration that,
- 6:22you know, they're going to have an annual or
- 6:24a monthly target of one to two hundred referrals.
- 6:27That's caused a significant amount of concern,
- 6:30not only among immigration practitioners, but
- 6:32also just friends. You know, I have a lot of
- 6:34friends and I myself am a naturalized U .S. citizen.
- 6:38So I have a lot of friends who are naturalized
- 6:39U .S. citizens or family members who are. And
- 6:41there's been a significant concern that, you
- 6:44know, when you start looking at numbers ranging
- 6:46in one to two hundred a month, who are they going
- 6:48after? What is happening historically between
- 6:511990 and 2017? the government filed about 11
- 6:55on average per year. That's 11 of these actions
- 6:58filed in federal courts. When the government
- 7:01is now saying that they have a monthly target
- 7:04of one to 200, you'll notice that number refers
- 7:07to referrals, not case filings. I think it was
- 7:12on an ex -tweet or some kind of press blurb that
- 7:16I saw a couple of weeks ago where... the Attorney
- 7:20General Bondi said that in the first year of
- 7:24the Trump administration, they filed 40, I believe,
- 7:27approximately 40 denaturalization lawsuits. That
- 7:30is a significant increase from what the government
- 7:32has historically done. If you're looking at 11
- 7:34average per year, obviously that's four times
- 7:38as many. However, that's still a far cry from
- 7:40the one to 200 referrals. And we'll get into
- 7:43kind of the difference between, you know, when
- 7:46a referral turns into an actual lawsuit. Um,
- 7:53So the government loves civil denaturalization
- 7:55for many reasons. Two of them are because it's
- 8:00a lower burden of proof. There is criminal denaturalization.
- 8:03We're not talking about that today. There's a
- 8:06slightly higher burden of proof for criminal
- 8:08denaturalization. And there's also a time limit.
- 8:10I believe it's 10 years. There is no time limit
- 8:13on civil denaturalization. You could have naturalized
- 8:18and become a US citizen. you know, 30 years ago,
- 8:21and the government cannot come and say they're
- 8:24going to denaturalize you now. The other reason
- 8:27is there is no right to legal representation.
- 8:30Unlike in criminal proceedings, you're on your
- 8:33own. You can represent yourself pro se, obviously.
- 8:36I don't recommend it. But there is no right to
- 8:39free counsel. So individuals are often left with
- 8:42a choice of, you know, kind of where and how
- 8:46are they going to get their resources and who
- 8:50are they going to have to defend them? Again,
- 8:53historically civil denaturalization is not a
- 8:55big thing. So there aren't that many folks in
- 8:58terms of immigration bar or just generally who
- 9:00are aware of how to defend these types of cases.
- 9:04So this prioritization that the department has
- 9:08kind of made one of the hallmarks of this administration
- 9:12is per June 11, 2025 memo to instruct attorneys
- 9:18to maximally pursue, that's the language she
- 9:20used, all cases permitted by law, specifically
- 9:24targeting organized crime and financial fraud.
- 9:27And I will say that, you know, what the big...
- 9:30The big examples of cases that I've seen so far
- 9:33that have been filed and the ones in which denaturalization
- 9:36has been successful have largely been cases involving
- 9:41some kind of financial fraud or criminal conviction.
- 9:44And we'll cover why those are kind of the easy
- 9:48ones for the government to come to their attention.
- 9:53This is statute -based and one of the reasons
- 9:56why I love civil denaturalization is because
- 9:58it's statute -based. It's actually in the code.
- 10:01It is not in the regs. It is not a policy. It
- 10:03is in the US code and denaturalization occurs
- 10:07when DOJ establishes that citizenship was procured
- 10:11by concealment of material fact or by willful
- 10:14misrepresentation. or was illegally procured.
- 10:18Concealment of material fact or willful misrepresentation.
- 10:23That's where you get into problems because failing
- 10:29to disclose a material fact that would have affected
- 10:32the government's decision to grant citizenship
- 10:34is a basis for denaturalization. for all the
- 10:38lawyers out there, you can see there's no signature
- 10:40requirement. There's no intent to deceit, intent
- 10:44to commit fraud, intent to deceive, intent to
- 10:47like omit. And we'll get into as we look at kind
- 10:51of various circumstances in which I've seen civil
- 10:55denaturalization referrals come into play. So
- 11:00when you are looking at a denaturalization, case,
- 11:07the very first thing that the government is going
- 11:10to look at is your Form N -400. And the N -400
- 11:13is your application for citizenship. It is not
- 11:19a particularly, I don't think it's a particularly
- 11:22complicated form, but I think that's because
- 11:24we're lawyers and we filled out the bar character.
- 11:28formed so many times in the course of our lives
- 11:30that we're used to it. But when you look at the
- 11:34N -400, it asks for very detailed information.
- 11:39And not only do they ask for resident history,
- 11:43but there are also many categories which can
- 11:47be more inclusive than an average normal person
- 11:50thinks or would necessarily. you know, come to
- 11:56mind when filling out this form. As I've been,
- 12:00you know, kind of working in the denaturalization
- 12:02space or, you know, I spent two years briefly
- 12:05at USCIS working with the affirmative litigation
- 12:07law department where we looked and where we reviewed
- 12:12referrals before they went to the Department
- 12:13of Justice. It really became kind of it was really
- 12:18kind of shocking the kinds of things that the
- 12:20application asks for and how little the average
- 12:25person understands in terms of what they need
- 12:27to disclose. So for instance, on the bottom right,
- 12:32omissions about marital status or residence can
- 12:35trigger fraud claims. Misrepresentations during
- 12:38the green card stage can impact your naturalization.
- 12:41So I definitely saw instances where an individual
- 12:45got married, got the marriage annulled, the N
- 12:49-400 asks, you know, disclose all your prior
- 12:51marriages, is that annulment a marriage that
- 12:53needs to be disclosed on the N -400? I would
- 12:56say yes, but I don't know that necessarily everyone
- 12:59would think that or that the average person would
- 13:02consider that something that needs to be disclosed.
- 13:05We also had many instances and probably in some
- 13:08cases the most tragic ones was the accuracy in
- 13:11disclosing prior removal orders. My favorite
- 13:15example of kind of just how unwittingly someone
- 13:19can find themselves in a civil denaturalization
- 13:22situation is the example of an individual who
- 13:26came to the United States in the 90s and applied
- 13:30for asylum in New York. A lot of people applied
- 13:33for asylum in New York. Nothing was digitized.
- 13:37At some point, this person moved from New York
- 13:41to California, and they applied for asylum again.
- 13:46They ultimately got asylum. They ultimately became
- 13:51an LPR. They ultimately became a US citizen many,
- 13:55many years later. Our records are now digitized,
- 13:58and the government has... discovered that actually
- 14:02when this individual applied for asylum in New
- 14:05York, they moved and did not update their address,
- 14:09and that an interview notice for the asylum application
- 14:17interview had gone out. They had failed to show,
- 14:20and an order to show cause had issued. As a result
- 14:24of that, he was issued an in absentia removal
- 14:27order. So he does have a outstanding removal
- 14:31order that's in absentia that this individual
- 14:33has never known about. He would have had no way
- 14:35of knowing about it. He never updated his address.
- 14:38USCIS has no duty to go find you and make sure
- 14:40you're aware of it. But when he applied for that,
- 14:45certainly when he applied for his M -400 and
- 14:48became a naturalized citizen, he was asked whether
- 14:53or not there were any outstanding removal orders.
- 14:56And when they said no, that was false. And that
- 15:00is a basis for the government to seek denaturalization.
- 15:02And I saw many, many cases during the course
- 15:05of my time at USCIS where that was essentially
- 15:08the fact pattern. So we're gonna go, you know,
- 15:13this is... One of the big questions, too, on
- 15:16the N -400, it asks, have you ever committed
- 15:20a crime for which you were not arrested? So I
- 15:24love this one because have you ever committed
- 15:27a crime for which you were not arrested? Well,
- 15:30I mean, I was four years old and I took a pack
- 15:32of gum at the store. Is that a crime? I wasn't
- 15:35arrested for it. I've given variations of this
- 15:40talk multiple times to many folks. And the question
- 15:44is, well, is that a crime within the US or is
- 15:48that a crime abroad? What if I got a speeding
- 15:50ticket when I was driving in Denmark? And I mean,
- 15:54there's just a lot of what ifs that nobody knows
- 15:57the answer to. Many reported denaturalizations
- 16:01are based on a false no answer to that question
- 16:05by naturalized citizens who committed these crimes
- 16:10or crimes that they were not arrested for. And
- 16:14you know, it's difficult because when you're
- 16:16filling out that form, you really have kind of
- 16:20no limits as to what you can or should disclose.
- 16:22And let's be honest, I'm not sure that everybody
- 16:25would even be able to pull these records. I played
- 16:28this game before myself where I thought, Well,
- 16:31I mean, is all my seating, is all the times I
- 16:34sped or maybe didn't fully stop, would that be
- 16:37considered a crime? We just don't know. I want
- 16:40to take an opportunity to pause here and ask
- 16:42Lindsay if you have anything to contribute or
- 16:45if you want to chime in. Oh, just that I agree.
- 16:49This is the question. It's the hook that I think
- 16:52gets everybody. And by surprise, because I think
- 16:57a lot of people, when they're filling out the
- 16:59N -400, they look at this question and they just
- 17:02think it's silly. And they're like, oh, silly
- 17:05government. Why did they put it there? It's just
- 17:09the government being the government and being
- 17:11bureaucratic and adding more words when it doesn't
- 17:13have to. But actually, that question is very,
- 17:17very important for the exact reasons that Nancy
- 17:20just stated. So the question is, when does denaturalization
- 17:32occur? So denaturalization is typically based
- 17:35on pre -naturalization activities, anything that
- 17:38you did before you became a naturalized U .S.
- 17:40citizen. But it's the failure to disclose that
- 17:44activity, that crime, that outstanding removal
- 17:47order, that prior marriage, all of that stuff,
- 17:49at the time of your N -400 that becomes an issue.
- 17:53I'm focusing here a lot on the N -400, because
- 17:56that is the most recent in time, so you'll have
- 18:00the most prior history to look at. But it can
- 18:02also be based on failure to disclose things on
- 18:06your I -485 application for a lawful permanent
- 18:09residence status. USCIS does have available to
- 18:14it your entire immigration file, we call it the
- 18:16A -file, and that A -file includes copies of
- 18:19all of the applications the individual has filed.
- 18:22and it can go as far back as misrepresentations
- 18:26on your initial I -9 form. You came in on an
- 18:29I -9 and you didn't disclose something, that
- 18:32could be a basis for material misrepresentation
- 18:36or omission. It could be on your I -4E5, your
- 18:41application for asylum, and your N -400. Typically
- 18:45crimes committed after naturalization do not
- 18:48serve as basis for denaturalization, so don't
- 18:51worry about that. And USCIS tracks criminal proceedings
- 18:57of naturalized citizens and compares fingerprints
- 19:00of convicted individuals with naturalized citizens.
- 19:03So one of the things that I learned when I was
- 19:05with USCIS was that DHS has a Office of Biometric
- 19:10Identity Management. I believe that's what it
- 19:13stands for. It's OBIM. And OBIM is basically
- 19:16the federal government's repository for all of
- 19:18your biometrics information and data. Fingerprints,
- 19:21eye scans, all that good stuff. They run the
- 19:27database that USCIS uses, TSA uses. They link
- 19:31up with the FBI and share resources and information.
- 19:35They are the entity behind, kind of how when
- 19:38you go through TSA and you have to show your
- 19:39fingerprints or have your face scanned, they
- 19:41are the entity behind those hits. And all, I
- 19:46mean, I have long since given up any hopes of
- 19:49committing any crimes because my fingerprints
- 19:51are everywhere. But, you know. But the government
- 19:56has your fingerprints. They are digitized. And
- 19:59depending on who is running those prints, the
- 20:01results can come almost immediately. Obviously,
- 20:04when you're entering at the border and you're
- 20:07trying to get through CBP or TSA, those hits
- 20:10are pretty fast. If you are going to an asylum
- 20:14interview at an asylum office and you have to
- 20:17go in for your biometrics, those hits are on
- 20:19a slower return. those hits are on a slower return
- 20:23time scale. But the fact is the government has
- 20:26your fingerprints. They can track them once they're
- 20:28in the system. They information share with local
- 20:31state entities and the FBI. So that's the easiest
- 20:35way to get a hit on someone who has a criminal
- 20:38activity and their citizenship. So trigger events
- 20:44for denaturalization are Some family petition
- 20:49or something that is filed that causes a manual
- 20:53audit I will just use myself as a example. I
- 20:59naturalized in the United States in some time
- 21:03in the 1990s, so for example if I were to Think
- 21:09of a quick way of saying this if I you know My
- 21:12file would technically, I guess, be closed, or
- 21:15let's use my parents as a better example. My
- 21:17parents would technically have a closed file.
- 21:20You know, their A file would be sealed somewhere
- 21:22at the USCIS cave where they store all the A
- 21:25files. If they are going to file to petition
- 21:28for someone to come to the United States by doing
- 21:31that, USCIS will pull their A -file and look
- 21:34at it and when they pull their A -file now in
- 21:36the year of 2025 they may look at things that
- 21:40were filed in the 1990s and previously and that
- 21:43may trigger an audit. We talked about criminal
- 21:46investigations. If you are prosecuted for state
- 21:52federal crimes, that could trigger a look at
- 21:55your naturalization eligibility. That's a pretty
- 21:57easy one too. It's just a simple fingerprint
- 22:00hit. And then it's a question of when you committed
- 22:03those crimes and when you became a naturalized
- 22:07citizen. And then there's database audits, the
- 22:12integration of biometric data across agencies.
- 22:16And, you know, we kind of live now in a state
- 22:18where we just are certainly, I just assume my
- 22:22information is out there. You know, there's all
- 22:25this talk about kind of AI and how you're scanned
- 22:28and, you know, process throughout these things,
- 22:30but. It wasn't always that way. And there have
- 22:33been periods in our history, and I've certainly
- 22:36seen it in the government's history, where the
- 22:39integration and biometric data has triggered
- 22:43these audits that have led to denaturalization.
- 22:47The big one is Operation Janus. So historically,
- 22:52when you applied for citizenship or asylum, whatever
- 22:55immigration benefit, you had to go and get your
- 22:57biometrics taken. It is fingerprints. There are,
- 23:03I've seen so many of these, but it's a historic
- 23:06fingerprint card. Anyone who's a lawyer has done
- 23:09it. You've gone to your local police department
- 23:11or done a FBI or Department of Justice background
- 23:16check where you've had to give your fingerprints
- 23:18with the four fingers and then your thumb. So
- 23:22those are paper cards historically, right? We
- 23:24didn't all have computers. We certainly didn't
- 23:26in the 1950s and the 60s and the 70s and 80s.
- 23:29So they were all printed manually on a card.
- 23:33And I remember going to the police department
- 23:35in the 90s when my family needed to be fingerprinted
- 23:39for our naturalization. Those fingerprint records
- 23:46were digitized at some point. There was actually
- 23:49an effort to scan in all of that biometric information
- 23:55that existed on paper fingerprint cards and load
- 24:00them into federal databases. That was what resulted,
- 24:06or I think that was Optianis, which was the effort
- 24:09to integrate and digitize all these fingerprint
- 24:11cards. What happened was that, well, you digitize
- 24:16all these fingerprints and you realize that...
- 24:19you were getting hits. You were getting somebody,
- 24:22in the example that I gave at the beginning,
- 24:25somebody who had applied for naturalization or
- 24:28applied for asylum in New York in the 90s, then
- 24:33eight years later applied in California, never
- 24:36disclosed that they had previously applied for
- 24:38asylum or that they had an outstanding removal
- 24:40order they were not aware of. That objeanness
- 24:45at the end of the at the end of the Obama administration,
- 24:50there was a inspector general report that basically
- 24:53directed the government to sort out kind of this
- 24:57apparent conflict, right? Like, why do we have
- 24:59all these paper identities that are matched hits
- 25:03with kind of our federal digital database? What
- 25:06is going on? Figure it out. So that really was,
- 25:10it was the end of the, Obama administration start
- 25:14of the first trump administration where op janice
- 25:18led to that inspector general directive to figure
- 25:21out you know what was going on so during the
- 25:25um first trump administration usdis and the department
- 25:30of justice actually stood up specific immigration
- 25:33naturalization or I should say affirmative litigation
- 25:37units to identify, investigate, and refer these
- 25:42cases for prosecution. What happens is that USCIS
- 25:47is responsible for doing the initial file review,
- 25:51so they will pull the A files, they will assess
- 25:55the prior application, the existing application,
- 25:58and you will literally have, USCIS will literally
- 26:00have an individual's a file under one application
- 26:04or identity and the individual's other a file
- 26:07under another application or identity. They will
- 26:10look for matches, they will look for conflicts,
- 26:11they will look for any kinds of issues. They
- 26:14will also, because our records are all digitized
- 26:17now, they can also actually look at this individual's
- 26:21entire travel history. They can also see kind
- 26:24of what has happened in terms of if there's been
- 26:26any state activity, federal activity. kind of,
- 26:31you know, your entire history is out there. We
- 26:33would get basically CBP travel reports from our
- 26:40DHS investigators that basically had every entry
- 26:43and exit in and out of the country, the dates
- 26:45and the times of those, and, you know, kind of
- 26:48the match, the fingerprint identification number
- 26:50that matched the applications. So we could in
- 26:55some instances have cases where An individual
- 26:58has a 1990 paper application. They have an early
- 27:052000 file under which they ultimately naturalize.
- 27:09And then I've had cases where I can look at this
- 27:12individual's entire travel history and kind of
- 27:15match when they may have traveled here or there.
- 27:18Again, there were so many instances where it
- 27:21was an unsuspecting individual who applied in
- 27:24New York, moved to California, never knew he
- 27:26had an outstanding removal order. But we also
- 27:29had cases where people were traveling under false
- 27:33identities. And it was very obvious when that
- 27:38was the case, right? Because you'd have one application
- 27:40where they had one named Bob, and then they had
- 27:42another application where they had another name,
- 27:44Joe. But you could have, at the same time, their
- 27:47entire travel history where their fingerprint
- 27:50identification numbers match. They're coming
- 27:52in and out. And certainly, as we get into the
- 27:5690s and the 2000s, you could then start having
- 27:58actual picture images of the snapshot that C
- 28:02&P captures when you're coming in and out of
- 28:05any port of entry. So it was kind of like putting
- 28:08together a puzzle. Once you put together that
- 28:11puzzle, or USCIS is responsible for putting together
- 28:14that puzzle, and that is what turns into the
- 28:18referral. So we mentioned earlier the one to
- 28:21200 cases for referral. That is the packet that
- 28:27USCIS, the agency sends to the Department of
- 28:31Justice saying, this case, we have the evidentiary
- 28:35support for you to proceed with denaturalizing
- 28:38this individual. Do you have anything? You want
- 28:42to chime in and add Lindsay? Um, not necessarily
- 28:46on this slide, but thanks All right Again there.
- 28:51Um, oh, all right. So I mean what happens is
- 28:55you know, a case is referred to the department
- 28:58of justice Um, it's interesting. I mentioned
- 29:01earlier. I love dnats because it's statute -based
- 29:03there is actually a procedure that the government
- 29:06must follow um in order to initiate these actions
- 29:09and It is the U .S. attorney's office. It is
- 29:16the U .S. attorney's office and the U .S. attorney
- 29:18who gives the final sign off and approval to
- 29:22file a civil denaturalization action in his district.
- 29:27During the first Trump administration, there
- 29:30was hesitation among many U .S. Attorney's offices
- 29:35to file and bring these actions. I remember having
- 29:39many discussions with U .S. Attorney's offices
- 29:43who were reluctant to bring these actions or
- 29:46who wanted to conduct their own investigation
- 29:48and not rely on USCIS's investigation before
- 29:52proceeding. So that is, you know, theoretically
- 29:56another check on another or another check or
- 30:00another stop pause before these cases are filed.
- 30:03They have to go through USCIS, they have to get
- 30:06sent to the Department of Justice Office of Immigration
- 30:08Litigation in Washington, and then the U .S.
- 30:12Attorney's Office for the district in which the
- 30:14individual resides also has to sign off on the
- 30:16decision to file that complaint. Individuals
- 30:20are by statute given 60 days personal notice
- 30:23to answer any petition. I find that that notice
- 30:27section is very interesting because it uses the
- 30:30word notice and not service. So is the personal
- 30:35notice the day the U .S. attorney reaches out
- 30:38to the unsuspecting grandmother and says we have
- 30:41evidence to believe you committed fraud in your
- 30:43naturalization application and 60 days from that
- 30:46email or letter she has defaulted? Or are we
- 30:50actually waiting for a time period? Are we actually
- 30:53commencing it upon the filing of a civil suit?
- 30:56That's not been litigated to my knowledge, but
- 30:58that is something that folks who do denaturalization
- 31:02should be worried about or concerned about. The
- 31:06burden of proof is that the government must present
- 31:09clear, unequivocal, and convincing evidence.
- 31:17It's, again, It's a high burden of proof, but
- 31:21not really when you consider the fact that no
- 31:24scientist or affirmative Attempted to see or
- 31:28defraud is required Typically these cases are
- 31:32in my experience Decided on MSJ many of them
- 31:37are decided at summary judgment because they're
- 31:40simply you know, there is It is very hard for
- 31:43an individual to say Now I, you know, especially
- 31:47in the case of the unsuspecting grandmother who
- 31:51applied in, you know, New York and moved to California,
- 31:54they can't say like the facts show you had an
- 31:57outstanding removal order. You didn't disclose
- 31:59it. We don't care that you didn't know about
- 32:01it. That's not our problem. The fact is that
- 32:05you have one and you did not disclose it. And
- 32:07that's a problem. Typically, I would say in these
- 32:12cases, you could expect to do some discovery
- 32:15and some depositions. And then, if and when an
- 32:19individual is denaturalized, the court will issue
- 32:21an order revoking citizenship and canceling the
- 32:24certificate. Now, I know, Lindsay, this one,
- 32:27you probably have something to add and contribute
- 32:29to, so I'll give you some opportunity to do so.
- 32:33Sure, yeah. I've seen cases where, I guess one
- 32:42anecdote, the U .S. Attorney's Office brought
- 32:44a case when I was at DOJ that I reviewed and,
- 32:50you know, the U .S. Attorney's Office told me
- 32:52that this person was a fraudster, clear evidence
- 32:56of fraud, and, you know, it was a slam dunk case
- 33:01and I needed to get on to filing it as soon as
- 33:05possible. However, when I was reviewing the record
- 33:07myself, I noticed that the person they were seeking
- 33:11to denaturalize was an older woman, not necessarily
- 33:14elderly, but I think she was in her 50s or so.
- 33:20And the person had actually a history before
- 33:24they came to this country. They were a victim
- 33:28of what I would call human trafficking. They
- 33:31were a minor underage and essentially forced
- 33:35into prostitution. And the government, I think
- 33:40at one point in her file was saying that she
- 33:44was subject to a prostitution bar, but luckily
- 33:47I think there was discussion and they walked
- 33:49that back. Either way, when I was reviewing her,
- 33:54I think it was an I -130, she was allegedly petitioned
- 33:57for by her um, husband, but this husband was
- 34:01about, was more than 40 years older than her.
- 34:04And, um, she was quite young at the time. She
- 34:07was over age, but, but still quite young. And
- 34:10so I, um, I think all that is to say some of
- 34:14these cases, I think the investigation can actually
- 34:17reveal, um, some other type of, um, I guess,
- 34:22action that the government should look into.
- 34:25And I think in this case, it was a potentially
- 34:27human trafficking. However, at that point in
- 34:30this person's life, it had been decades since
- 34:35she naturalized. She, I think, was having health
- 34:39issues. She was a widow. And so then you have
- 34:45to think, as the government, does this person
- 34:47really want to be involved in some type of...
- 34:51action against her traffickers, if they're even
- 34:55still alive, and certainly is this truly something
- 34:59that the government wants to pursue for denaturalization
- 35:02when the fraud may have been a result of human
- 35:05trafficking. So that was one of the first denaturalization
- 35:10cases I came into contact with. It was very interesting
- 35:16and eye -opening, I would say. All right. So
- 35:27moving on to where these cases are won or lost.
- 35:32We've kind of spoken about this. As we mentioned,
- 35:36the standard for civil denaturalization is lower
- 35:39than the criminal denaturalization standard,
- 35:42obviously. But the courts have set a higher bar
- 35:46for success than the typical civil burden of
- 35:48proof of preponderance of the evidence. I believe,
- 35:54and I meant to clarify this before the presentation,
- 35:56but so once the government meets its higher burden,
- 36:00I believe it's the defendant only has to show
- 36:04their case or rebut that evidence by a preponderance.
- 36:10But please correct me if I'm wrong, Nancy. I'm
- 36:12pretty sure I remembered that correctly. And
- 36:16so the government's success rate is thus closely
- 36:19tied to its ability to present the clear unequivocal
- 36:22convincing evidence and to comply, of course,
- 36:25with the statutory prerequisites. And their failures
- 36:30to meet the statutory prerequisites, even though
- 36:32they may seem just procedural, they are important
- 36:38and they can result in dismissal of the government's
- 36:40case. For example, they have to make an affidavit
- 36:43of good cause. And if they decide to forego that
- 36:47process or do it incorrectly, their case can
- 36:50be dismissed. And as we were mentioning in practice,
- 36:54these cases are usually resolved on dispositive
- 36:57motions because usually what it comes down to
- 37:01at the end of the day is legal arguments. Legal
- 37:05arguments about the various statutes involved,
- 37:08the denaturalization statute, if there's a statute
- 37:13of conviction relevant, the fraud statute. There
- 37:16are arguments that defense counsel can make.
- 37:21Actually, what has happened in a lot of these
- 37:24cases is we, so the defendant will file, well,
- 37:29there's a complaint. Defendant will file either
- 37:33an answer, often a motion to dismiss, and basically
- 37:38saying that government hasn't made a case. And
- 37:43then ruling on that motion to dismiss will happen
- 37:49hopefully before you get into discovery, but.
- 37:51maybe at the same time depending on your court
- 37:53and if the uh motion to dismiss is denied then
- 37:57obviously defendant files an answer then what
- 38:00the government has done in a lot of these cases
- 38:02recently is they file a rule 12c motion for judgment
- 38:05on the pleadings essentially the same um or very
- 38:10similar to a motion for summary judgment and
- 38:13basically just telling the judge look there's
- 38:15really no need for discovery here uh which can
- 38:18be beneficial to your defendant client if you're
- 38:21representing a defendant here. We don't need
- 38:24fact investigation. This is just legal issues
- 38:28and so rule in this substantive motion. And so
- 38:33defense counsel can argue materiality in the
- 38:38statute. They can try to argue mens rea. Sometimes
- 38:44these arguments can get really tricky, really
- 38:47nuanced and in the weeds. But there are some
- 38:51hooks for arguing that actions were not or statements
- 38:58were not knowing or willful. Again, the statute
- 39:02does make that very, very difficult. But there
- 39:06are ways you can try to make those arguments.
- 39:09And particularly if the criminal statute is at
- 39:14play, there can be cremigration arguments and
- 39:18that's immigration lawyers often refer to the
- 39:21intersection of criminal law and immigration
- 39:24law as cremigration and so you can make these
- 39:27arguments as well because the government will
- 39:30often first argue that if it's a fraud conviction
- 39:35or a fraud offense that the offense or conviction
- 39:38is a crime involving moral turpitude which is
- 39:41also a term of art in immigration law. And so
- 39:46if you have a crime involving moral turpitude,
- 39:50then you have illegally procured your naturalization
- 39:54because you could not have established good moral
- 39:56character as someone who has a crime involving
- 40:00moral turpitude. But then obviously even besides
- 40:07the CINT issue, The government can say that the
- 40:14person lacked good moral character because they
- 40:16committed unlawful acts. There are several unlawful
- 40:22acts defined by regulation that preclude good
- 40:26moral character and the government can point
- 40:28to these as well. Since different fraud statutes
- 40:34often have different elements or mens rea, this
- 40:37is where defense counsel can try to poke holes
- 40:40in the government's case. And so I don't know
- 40:45if we've talked about the good moral character
- 40:48period for naturalization, but that's, I think
- 40:53I referred to it. Basically what that means is
- 40:57to establish eligibility for naturalization.
- 41:00you have to establish you've had good moral character,
- 41:04which is defined by regulation and as a term
- 41:08of art, from five years before, from the time
- 41:13of your application for naturalization, five,
- 41:15looking five years back. So if you have committed
- 41:20a crime or criminal offense during that period,
- 41:23you would be barred from naturalization. And
- 41:26so if the government can essentially reconstruct
- 41:29a record, Say you have a post -naturalization
- 41:35conviction, but it's close in time to the person's
- 41:39naturalization. Well, then the government might
- 41:41say, let's do an investigation and see if we
- 41:44can find evidence of the criminal activity that
- 41:47formed the basis of that post -naturalization
- 41:49conviction prior to naturalization, but during
- 41:54that good moral character period. It can get
- 41:58a little complex, but those are also ways that
- 42:02defense counsel in these cases can try to pick
- 42:05apart the government's case because if there's
- 42:10arguments about when certain things happened
- 42:13and the credibility of the evidence, you know,
- 42:17you really want to look closely at that five
- 42:19-year period and how can you poke the holes or
- 42:22how can you say that the activity didn't occur
- 42:26then, or at least that the government hasn't
- 42:28shown clearly and unequivocally that the activity
- 42:31occurred during that five -year period. So that's
- 42:34what we mean when we say reconstructing a record,
- 42:37and often it can be a little difficult because,
- 42:41like we mentioned, these cases often involve
- 42:45people who naturalized potentially years, decades
- 42:48ago, and then the criminal activity and their
- 42:52good moral character period was even farther
- 42:55ago. So that can be difficult too, just finding
- 43:00the evidence to rebut the government's claims.
- 43:07And I'll move on to the next slide. Okay, so
- 43:13consequences of denaturalization. The consequences
- 43:17can be immediate and significant. You lose your
- 43:22citizenship rights and in many cases you are
- 43:26exposed to detention and in many cases now at
- 43:29least you are exposed to detention and removal.
- 43:34So obviously you lose your passport. The government
- 43:38I think often requires as part of the order that
- 43:42the person surrender their passport or any other
- 43:45documents showing citizenship to the government.
- 43:49You can't vote. It can impact job eligibility
- 43:53depending on where you work. And then the person
- 43:58reverts back to their status prior to naturalization,
- 44:01which in most cases is lawful permanent residence.
- 44:06And I think I never heard about cases, you know,
- 44:11prior to this administration, I never heard about
- 44:14cases where people were denaturalized and then.
- 44:17actually put into removal proceedings. And I
- 44:21definitely never heard of denaturalized people
- 44:24being put into detention. But that is certainly
- 44:28with the government's campaign to detain as many
- 44:34unlawfully present non -citizens as possible,
- 44:37as many non -citizens with potential criminal
- 44:41offenses as possible. That is now a very real
- 44:47consequence of denaturalization. It's also detention,
- 44:52that is, is a negotiation tool in the government's
- 44:56tool belt with these cases because the government
- 45:01does try to resolve the case or the parties often
- 45:06try to resolve the case before it moves into
- 45:08actual litigation or before the complaint is
- 45:11filed. And often agreements would be made under
- 45:17a settlement agreement, but now the government
- 45:21can more credibly threaten a potential denounced
- 45:26defendant that, look, when you're denaturalized,
- 45:30we will detain you, we will remove you. And that
- 45:34is because, again, we're seeing in the last year
- 45:37a significant extreme uptick in detentions and
- 45:42removals. And so now the likelihood of post -denaturalization
- 45:53removal proceedings is much, much higher, and
- 45:57especially given the government's very strict
- 46:00and unwavering positions that they have in immigration
- 46:03court. Immigration courts have been unfortunately
- 46:09very unforgiving to litigants in recent in recent
- 46:15months. And so it's very difficult once your
- 46:18case gets to immigration court to avoid detention
- 46:23and to avoid a very swift proceeding where they
- 46:27seek to remove you. And so another consequence
- 46:32of denaturalization, not necessarily of the denaturalization
- 46:36order itself, but just the investigation and
- 46:40litigation is that Because now the denaturalization
- 46:46defendant is back in the spotlight in front of
- 46:49the government, the government probably forgot
- 46:52about them for years. But now that they're back
- 46:55in the spotlight, the government may look and
- 46:58say, hey, this guy actually had a post -judgment
- 47:02restitution order. It's pretty substantial. He
- 47:06hasn't paid it. And we've let it slide for years.
- 47:10But now that we know about this person, we can
- 47:13go ahead and seek to collect on that restitution
- 47:18order. So for example, say that a defendant was
- 47:24convicted of fraud post -naturalization. The
- 47:27government argues the criminal activity leading
- 47:29to conviction occurred prior to naturalization.
- 47:33So during the five -year good moral character
- 47:35period before applying. And so the government's
- 47:39argument is naturalization was illegally procured.
- 47:44But now what the government can also say is,
- 47:48we're once again aware of your conviction that
- 47:50came with an order of restitution and there's
- 47:53nothing wrong with the order of restitution.
- 47:56So we're gonna file an application for writ of
- 47:58garnishment and seek to obtain all your property
- 48:02and your bank accounts and your assets to satisfy
- 48:06that what is often in a decades old restitution
- 48:10order. And obviously that garnishment can happen
- 48:14regardless of denaturalization. It was a valid
- 48:17post -judgment order, but it's likely that if
- 48:20it weren't for the denaturalization litigation,
- 48:22the government may have continued to deprioritize
- 48:27that person's restitution order. So overall,
- 48:34the most severe consequences, in my opinion,
- 48:37are of denaturalization are the high likelihood
- 48:40of immediate detention and very swift removal
- 48:45and because unlike garnishment the government
- 48:50cannot detain or seek removal prior to denaturalization
- 48:54and that's that's an important point because
- 48:58obviously that would mean detention and removal
- 49:01of the U .S. citizen which the government absolutely
- 49:03cannot do and so But you can imagine if most
- 49:08denaturalization defendants, again, if they're
- 49:11older, elderly, not wealthy on a fixed income,
- 49:14then the stakes of detention particularly and
- 49:18removal are extremely high. And I'll move on
- 49:23to the next slide. So here we've set forth some
- 49:30of the authorities for the denaturalization process.
- 49:35DOJ justice manual lays out the process for the
- 49:42litigation on the government side and obviously
- 49:45there are the statutes there that lay out all
- 49:49the requirements for this litigation. Can we
- 49:55move ahead? Okay. And another important note,
- 50:01this is also in the statute, is that children
- 50:05who derive citizenship automatically through
- 50:08a parent who naturalized will also be stripped
- 50:13of their citizenship. And in practice, I haven't
- 50:18seen this situation or heard about it, but I
- 50:21imagine the person, derivative child who may
- 50:25then be an adult. But I imagine that child may
- 50:29be able to seek naturalization again on their
- 50:33own as long as they satisfy the requirements
- 50:36and have no criminal activity. But that would
- 50:40certainly be tricky and obviously life changing
- 50:43for someone who believes that they were a citizen
- 50:45since childhood. Nancy, I don't know if you had
- 50:49anything to add. No, I think this is the big
- 50:52one for me because during the first Trump administration
- 50:55It was kind of understood that a couple of things
- 50:59that were understood when I came to do nuts and
- 51:02it turns out it was policy but We did not we
- 51:06did not take the government did not take the
- 51:08position then that if someone was denaturalized
- 51:10That you know their derivative children were
- 51:12also deemed to have lost citizenship uh we you
- 51:16know very clearly said our position is we denaturalize
- 51:19the individual who committed fraud or failed
- 51:21to disclose whatever information we could have
- 51:24but we're not going to go after derivatives um
- 51:27that apparently is a policy matter and if you
- 51:29look at the statute it is They are deemed to
- 51:32have lost and to lose citizenship. There is no
- 51:35requirement for the government to institute proceedings
- 51:37against that individual. So it's almost like
- 51:40operation by law, derivatives lose citizenship.
- 51:43That's a problem. It's concerning. I don't know
- 51:46to what extent the government intends to pursue
- 51:48this or if the government will ever pursue this,
- 51:51but it is something to be concerned about, especially
- 51:54when folks are presented with a civil denaturalization
- 51:58case. What do I do? It's not just, are you giving
- 52:01up your citizenship? It's what happens to your
- 52:04children, if any derived citizenship by virtue
- 52:06of that. Another concern too we don't think about
- 52:10is one of the spaces in which denaturalization
- 52:14has been a surprisingly hot topic is in the civil
- 52:17tax space. Because what is the effect of denaturalization
- 52:21on your taxes? People have done, there's obviously
- 52:25what happens when you relinquish status. uh really
- 52:28push LPR status um but you know there is a there
- 52:33is the question of kind of how far does it go
- 52:35and what kind of tax planning estate planning
- 52:39planning for your children and their status do
- 52:41you have to worry about and you know a lot of
- 52:44this is frankly just um stuff that we don't know
- 52:47and will need to be litigated uh but it's certainly
- 52:51not anything that you know i'm aware of ever
- 52:54having been pursued as just a matter of policy
- 52:57or law And so we've mostly touched on a lot of
- 53:05this, but you immediately revert to an LPR, lawful
- 53:10permanent resident, or a green card holder upon
- 53:12denaturalization. Detention and deportation are
- 53:17possible. You lose your rights and the removal
- 53:21risk. And so overall, what we're seeing is the
- 53:25government's shift. in position from denaturalization
- 53:30as a rare remedy to the government purporting
- 53:34to use it as a routine enforcement tool. And
- 53:37the emphasis there is on purporting to, because
- 53:42whether the government can actually or will actually
- 53:44prosecute as many cases as it claims it may remains
- 53:49an open question. because they are not only expensive
- 53:54for the defendant, but they do require a significant
- 53:57amount of taxpayer -funded litigation resources
- 54:00that DOJ could use for other litigation. And
- 54:06so that's it for that slide. Maybe what I was
- 54:12just saying is really the thing I see. I've had
- 54:14a lot of conversations with folks about denaturalization
- 54:17and whether or not we should really all be worried.
- 54:21And my answer, for the most part, is no. One,
- 54:26the government don't commit any crimes. If you
- 54:31are a naturalized citizen and you have concerns
- 54:35about the accuracy of your N -400 application
- 54:38or your prior immigration documents, just don't
- 54:41commit any crimes. I mean, some of that is easier
- 54:44said than done. But, you know, just try to stay
- 54:47under the radar. I certainly think that the government
- 54:50is going to go after kind of the low hanging
- 54:52fruit, the easy targets, folks who have financial
- 54:55crimes, other crimes, who they get the automatic
- 54:57hits on, or they're going to go after the op
- 55:00janus population. That's the I think at the end,
- 55:04by the time they had reconciled them with match
- 55:06fingerprints, there were probably, I think, 3
- 55:08,000 individuals in that Opjana's population
- 55:11that could be referred to the Department of Justice
- 55:14for civil de -actualization. So those are kind
- 55:17of the low -hanging fruits, the easy targets
- 55:19in terms of who and where the government can
- 55:23look at denaturalizing. I also, I mean, unfortunately,
- 55:29one of the concerns is, you know, we have a lot
- 55:31of We've seen a lot of stop and pause in visa
- 55:35processing and asylum processing and entry and
- 55:38admissions for certain national certain nationalities
- 55:42in certain countries So I do think that to the
- 55:46extent there are certain countries that are on
- 55:48this administration's target list individuals
- 55:51from those countries who have recently naturalized
- 55:54may be subject to you know, may be the subject
- 55:59of some kind of effort to investigate their naturalization
- 56:03applications and their immigration files in general.
- 56:08That said, like Lindsay mentioned, it takes a
- 56:11tremendous amount of resources and time to do
- 56:14these cases in our current situation and climate
- 56:18where the government is getting sued left and
- 56:21right. And if you are someone who follows kind
- 56:24of the legal news and buzz, Um, you know the
- 56:28the us attorney's offices are really struggling
- 56:30to kind of manage and handle their defensive
- 56:33docket So yes Denaturalization is a priority
- 56:39and the government is very proud of the fact
- 56:41that they have filed what 40? Denaturalization
- 56:44lawsuits in this year, which is four times as
- 56:47many as they filed in the past But they simply
- 56:49don't have the resources without some kind of
- 56:52significant additional push and dedication of
- 56:55resources to pursue 100 to 200 filings a month.
- 57:01There's just, I mean, there's just no way in
- 57:03which that amount of kind of initiation of lawsuits,
- 57:07civil denaturalization lawsuits is going to happen
- 57:10without some kind of significant increase in,
- 57:13you know, resources and hiring. I will say like,
- 57:18when you think about kind of the administration's
- 57:20priorities in terms of enforcing immigration,
- 57:24the low hanging fruit is really kind of the easy
- 57:27ways to go. And when you have process and procedure
- 57:31and laws that are in the US Code, it's going
- 57:34to be much harder for the government to perceive
- 57:36this than in situations where you're looking
- 57:38at immigrant populations with folks who are without
- 57:42status, who are already removable. They are entitled
- 57:45to some process, but certainly not the protections
- 57:47of the US Code in terms of all of the procedures
- 57:51and the steps that the government must follow
- 57:54when it comes to civil denaturalization. So I've
- 57:58gotten a lot. I think, you know, I spent some
- 58:03time talking to folks about civil denaturalization.
- 58:06And I think my big parting words are always,
- 58:11it's OK. I'm certainly not really worried right
- 58:14now. I have definitely been through all the permutations
- 58:21of concern, like what happens if someone wants
- 58:24to denaturalize my parents and then I'm automatically
- 58:27denaturalized by operation of law. Do I then
- 58:29have to file a deputory action to have it deemed
- 58:32that I am a U .S. citizen? What does this all
- 58:34mean? I've gone through those kind of legal permutations
- 58:38in my head. This is a fun exercise. But for most
- 58:42people, I say, look, you're either you're either
- 58:45living a very, you know, lawful, peaceful existence
- 58:48in the United States, don't commit any crimes,
- 58:50you shouldn't come to the attention of the government.
- 58:52And two, if you're not within that Ob -Giannus
- 58:55population, then you don't really have anything
- 58:57to worry about. Because again, The amount of
- 59:01resources and time that the government would
- 59:03have to put into finding and prosecuting each
- 59:07of these cases is just not something that I see
- 59:10it having the capacity to do at this time or
- 59:13any point in the near future. Yes. I don't know
- 59:18if we have any questions that we can offer before
- 59:21we conclude. Oh, I see some. Yeah, it looks like
- 59:24we have two. And I don't know, Nancy, I could
- 59:28read this first one for you. It's about manual
- 59:31file audits, which you may know more about. So
- 59:36they say, if I may ask a question regarding subsequent
- 59:39immigration filings that often trigger a manual
- 59:41file audit with submitting form I -846 as a financial
- 59:46joint sponsor, not the I -130 petitioner, type
- 59:50of filing, would that be the type of filing that
- 59:52triggers a manual file audit? It could. I've
- 59:57had somebody, I've actually had somebody ask
- 59:59me this question where they wanted to submit
- 1:00:01a joint financial sponsor for a relative who
- 1:00:03is looking to apply for residency status. And
- 1:00:06I said, yes, I mean, when you file these, the
- 1:00:10government holds your file. In the ordinary course
- 1:00:14of things, I would say it's not a problem, but
- 1:00:17you know, The very first thing that we did at
- 1:00:20USCIS when we got any kind of immigration application
- 1:00:24for any kind of immigration benefit was to pull
- 1:00:26the underlying A file. So that is going to be
- 1:00:30the first thing that any USCIS adjudicator does,
- 1:00:34immigration service officer does, is pull the
- 1:00:37A file for the applicant and the beneficiary
- 1:00:42and for the sponsor. I don't know, you know,
- 1:00:45kind of for the most part, for most folks, I
- 1:00:47would say probably not a risk, probably not something
- 1:00:50you have to worry about. I assume that most people
- 1:00:54disclose everything that they could. But I just
- 1:00:58don't know. I think one of the hard things, too,
- 1:01:01is the longer you've been in the US, the more,
- 1:01:06in some ways, the longer you've been in the US
- 1:01:08and the longer you were not naturalized before
- 1:01:10you became a naturalized citizen, obviously,
- 1:01:12the more opportunities the government is going
- 1:01:14to have for fraud. I tell folks who, like I believe,
- 1:01:19the one inquiry that I got was from a friend
- 1:01:21of mine who was a naturalized derivative citizen.
- 1:01:24So she naturalized by virtue of her parents.
- 1:01:28And I said, there's not going to be anything
- 1:01:29in your application. I said, your A file is basically
- 1:01:33going to be copies of your parents' file and
- 1:01:36then your certificate of citizenship. You wouldn't
- 1:01:38have made any affirmative statements. I just
- 1:01:40don't know that the government has the resources
- 1:01:42to let them pull your parents' file. Again, it's
- 1:01:46a resource question. But as a lawyer, I feel
- 1:01:50like I have to advise people that there is a
- 1:01:53risk and we just don't know kind of what the
- 1:01:56government is going to do and the extent to which
- 1:01:58they're gonna go back and investigate. Lindsay,
- 1:02:07it looks like you're muted. I got it. Okay. The
- 1:02:14next question is not denaturalization related.
- 1:02:17It's actually detention related. And I can actually
- 1:02:21answer that question. I don't know if Danny,
- 1:02:24if you want to email me offline, just because
- 1:02:27it's not on the topic of this presentation. I
- 1:02:31do have something to say about it. And I would
- 1:02:33actually have to look up some cases and some
- 1:02:37old emails to answer it. So you can email me.
- 1:02:45Well, I think that's all we have, unless there's
- 1:02:47any more questions. All right. Perfect. That
- 1:02:51looks like that's it for questions today. This
- 1:02:52concludes today's presentation. Thank you so
- 1:02:56much, Nancy and Lindsay, for an excellent presentation.
- 1:02:59And thank you so much to our audience. Have a
- 1:03:01great day, everybody. Thank you. Thank you.