Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Great Wealth Divide: Why Bitcoin & Gold Are Replacing Bonds
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of gutless 1974198792972000 and
- 0:18whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same thing
- 0:20over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I. Say when we sell.
- 0:26Hey, OK, I say when we sell. All right, we're back near all
- 0:34time highs. This week we sat down with Tyler
- 0:37Neville. We discussed a number of topics.
- 0:39It was an engaging conversation, enjoyed it quite a bit.
- 0:42We first started with the generational divide and the
- 0:45policy distortions that Tyler has lived through in his career
- 0:48post great financial crisis to the present day and the dynamic
- 0:52playing out between short volatility and long volatility
- 0:55and ultimately why you need to own scarce assets and be long
- 0:59volatility to preserve and grow your wealth.
- 1:02We also got into the topics of the AI productivity shock, what
- 1:05that could mean for labor markets and financial markets
- 1:08going forward. And then toward the end of the
- 1:10conversation got into Bitcoin treasury companies and
- 1:12institutional appetite for these companies as well as spot
- 1:16Bitcoin directly. And then at the end of the
- 1:18conversation, we had a little bit of an internal RIP Brian,
- 1:22Michael, myself, we had some interesting takes.
- 1:25I would say Brian and Michael came out swinging for the fences
- 1:28for the end of the year and into next year.
- 1:30So you want to stick around for that one to hear where they
- 1:32think this is all going and ultimately what the price might
- 1:35look like. And if you're bullish Bitcoin,
- 1:38if you're a long scarce assets, if you own Bitcoin, then you
- 1:41really need to have a plan for securing it for the long haul.
- 1:45And that's why you may want to speak with on ramp.
- 1:48We focus on multi institution custody.
- 1:50What that means is Peace of Mind for you, your family, seamless
- 1:54inheritance built in without your family needing to know how
- 1:57to manage devices and see phrases.
- 2:00You also have insurance, Bitcoin back loans, Bitcoin Iras quite a
- 2:04bit being built on this foundation of multi institution
- 2:07custody. So if you're not in touch with
- 2:09us already, reach out to on rampbitcoin.com.
- 2:12I would love to speak with you. All right, we are back.
- 2:15It's the last trade got Tyler Neville and we're joined by
- 2:19Brian and Michael from on ramp as well.
- 2:21Tyler, thank you for joining the last trade today.
- 2:23How's it going, man? Going well, man, it's getting
- 2:27less hot here in Austin, so enjoying the weather finally.
- 2:30Tyler Yeah. Excited to have excited to have
- 2:32you. We, we're curious about how you
- 2:35feel about Jacksons wall art, because it's been commented that
- 2:39he it looks like he he's in a cave.
- 2:40And so we just wanna, we're trying to work, you know, help
- 2:43him level up the podcast appearance.
- 2:45Curious if you have any recommendations.
- 2:47Yeah, you know, like I gotta roast you.
- 2:49Mike. Look, what do you, what do you
- 2:50got going back there? It's nothing special either.
- 2:53I know I I at least had something on the wall, so I felt
- 2:56good. I just got back to Texas.
- 2:58I'm in a office that we have here in Wimberley and it's going
- 3:01to be revamped. I got nice art, but I just got
- 3:03it put it together. I got back late last night, so
- 3:05it's been a little bit difficult.
- 3:06Jackson does not have that excuse.
- 3:08He just likes to to look like he's in a cave.
- 3:11Yeah, he's. Very loved one.
- 3:12I love when it blows up in Michael's face.
- 3:13It just happens. It happens every show.
- 3:15He'll never admit it, but it does.
- 3:17He makes Jackson makes up for it with it.
- 3:19Look at that. The gold golden locks, long
- 3:22flowing hair. No background needed.
- 3:24You don't need a background with that.
- 3:29You're a lot Tyler, man. This is going to be a fun one.
- 3:31You, you kept us waiting. We wanted to record with you a
- 3:34couple months back and life happened.
- 3:36So this is even more highly anticipated show than it, it
- 3:39originally was. And so been really enjoying your
- 3:42takes recently the past few months on X.
- 3:45That's where I follow most of your work, but then also your
- 3:47podcast with forward guidance at the Block Works team.
- 3:51But why don't we start? It's a really big topic and so
- 3:54take it however you'd like. But you write a lot about just
- 3:57the the policies and the macro forces that are really driven A
- 4:02generational divide, particularly in the United
- 4:04States. And would love to better
- 4:06understand just over your career, the policies that you've
- 4:09observed and the the forces at play in the markets that have
- 4:13ultimately led to this massive concentration of wealth with
- 4:17boomers, inability for, you know, millennials, Gen.
- 4:21Z to afford homes, to marry, to have children.
- 4:24I think this ultimately gets at a lot of the when you dig into
- 4:28the financial system, it really explains a lot of these trends.
- 4:30So I'd be curious to hear what you've observed in your career
- 4:33and how you ultimately categorize all this.
- 4:37Sure. Yeah, I, I guess the easiest way
- 4:39to start is I started in 2007 at this firm called KBW, which was,
- 4:45it was an investment bank that just covered other banks.
- 4:48So you figured out how the hell banks worked.
- 4:51This is only my first job out of college.
- 4:52And I was doing like financial modeling for all these, like
- 4:57regional banks right before the financial crisis hit.
- 4:59And you essentially see like as people stopped paying their
- 5:02mortgages, you saw non performing assets just go
- 5:05skyrocketing. So these banks were essentially
- 5:08like walking zombies. And I realized at that point,
- 5:11you know, KBW was one of the first banks to actually say
- 5:14like, this was a it's going to be a bad recession in 2008.
- 5:17And then I realized across the street, Wall Street, no one
- 5:21actually knew how the system was made.
- 5:23It was literally just a bunch of people pressing buttons and
- 5:26making shit tons of money, excuse my French, and they had
- 5:29no idea how the banking system worked.
- 5:31And so like, I don't know, I probably, I became a little too
- 5:33obsessed with it and read a bunch of books about how the
- 5:37monetary system was made, etcetera, historical books of
- 5:40like Fiat paper currency, you know, sovereign individual,
- 5:44those types of, of, of books, the ascent of money by Neil
- 5:47Ferguson. And I basically realized that
- 5:51like it's after 19, you know, 70 was it 79?
- 5:54Nixon got off the gold standards.
- 5:56It's just a money printing Ponzi scheme backed by debt.
- 6:01It's really hard to actually say that in an institutionalized
- 6:04setting like these investment banks, but that that whole
- 6:08premise of just like feeding debt and just debt fueled growth
- 6:13hit it today. Newmont in 2008.
- 6:15And then everyone I realized didn't know how the system was
- 6:17made. So that basically formed the the
- 6:19basis of of all this stuff. And after 2008, we've basically
- 6:23been in the same money printing scheme for the last, you know,
- 6:2617 years. It's fascinating to me that no
- 6:31one really realizes it. Like we've been diluting our
- 6:34currency at like an exponential rate.
- 6:37But if you, if you actually say that in an institutionalized
- 6:39setting, like they, they don't really want to hear it, but
- 6:43that, that's essentially the backbone.
- 6:45We can go anywhere from there. But where do you guys think we
- 6:48should go from there? But.
- 6:50You could, maybe you could just expand a bit on from 2008 to
- 6:54where we are today, like the, the proverbial can kicking that
- 6:58has occurred as you referenced, like we're, we've sort of just
- 7:02extended and pretended everything that we sort of
- 7:04instituted in 2008 in the wake of GFC.
- 7:08Maybe just a little bit more color and detail around like
- 7:10what those mechanisms have been, what they're sort of evolving
- 7:12into in the current age and kind of what you expect going
- 7:16forward. As you know, there's a ton of
- 7:18pressure on the Fed obviously to, to cut rates and cut rates
- 7:21into an environment where everything's at all time highs.
- 7:23So that seems a little bit counterintuitive, like curious
- 7:26just, you know, mapping from 2008 to now those mechanisms and
- 7:29and what you see today. Yeah, it's, it's just to
- 7:32simplify it. I think what it is, is it's the
- 7:34boomers don't want to take a haircut any out of their
- 7:37financial assets. And so they keep coming up with
- 7:39what I call the acronym FACTORY, where if you go for the past 15
- 7:43years, every single time there's a hiccup and credit markets to
- 7:46come up with some, oh, it's TARP, it's, you know, LARP, it's
- 7:50whatever the heck it is. They'll bail it out in 2 seconds
- 7:53and create some acronym to make sure the money markets are are
- 7:56functioning fine and there's no credit problem.
- 7:59And that's, that's been the backbone of of the whole thing
- 8:02for the past 20 years essentially.
- 8:04And it's all because boomers are heading into the late of their
- 8:07latter years and they do not want to take a haircut on their
- 8:10assets, especially homes. Housing prices need to stay
- 8:13higher because that's the majority of their retirements.
- 8:17100% there's something that caught my attention, Tyler, on
- 8:20your ex profile more recently. And it ties back into the
- 8:24original point that you made where if you're existing within
- 8:27the institutional finance world, it's either people are dishonest
- 8:33or they still don't recognize the inherent foundation of the
- 8:37financial system and how this ultimately drives asset prices.
- 8:40But you had quote tweeted, I guess, a podcast interview
- 8:45talking about how you know, people who are in this case,
- 8:48like a finance professor. But it really extends out until
- 8:50like what these people are taught in university, then
- 8:53they're taught early in their career, and then these, these
- 8:56umm, portfolio construction ideas and theories that we've
- 9:00pretty much agreed to in this industry to.
- 9:03And so now people operate under the false assumption that
- 9:06inflation is like 2 or 3%. If you're generating A7 or 8%
- 9:11nominal return in your portfolio, you're doing great.
- 9:14But there's very little acknowledgement within
- 9:16institutional portfolios of the true rate of inflation, the
- 9:21debasement of the currency. And if you were actually to
- 9:24start measuring returns against that benchmark, the returns
- 9:28would look far less attractive across the board.
- 9:31So I'm curious what thoughts you have there.
- 9:33Yeah, one of my favorite things is after 2008, playing not to
- 9:38lose in in hedge funds was the really cool thing to do.
- 9:43So you, you had a massive boom in beta neutral hedge funds,
- 9:46meaning like, you know, if you were long $100 or something, you
- 9:49were short $100.00 of something else.
- 9:50And if you could make 8% in that world, you are a genius.
- 9:55And you could charge 2 and 20 and maybe 3 and 30.
- 9:58And you know, if you, if you just made money from now in up
- 10:01markets and down markets, you were great.
- 10:03But the problem with the whole thing was it just ignores like
- 10:05history and debt bubbles in general.
- 10:08And so if you actually do the math, it's say it's an 8 Rau
- 10:12Palace is 8 to 10% dilution in Fiat currency per year.
- 10:16So that pretty much makes every single functional bond.
- 10:19You know you're losing money every year by investing in bonds
- 10:22like if the high yield bond is right now is yield to worst is
- 10:26like 6% to buy the riskiest credit debt, you would still
- 10:30lose 2% in real terms against the the dilution of the
- 10:33currency. So it really makes that right
- 10:36now does not make any sense because why the hell would any
- 10:40millennial and genzier buy a bond right now?
- 10:43It does not make any sense because they just continuously
- 10:47torch the currency. And if you were to, when you say
- 10:50this in an institutional setting, they're like, well, you
- 10:54know, if you risk adjust it and you it's been 17 years of this
- 10:57and these academics just still can't get their mind out of it.
- 11:01Meanwhile, you have the crypto Bros who just absolutely have
- 11:03crushed it continuously year after year after year.
- 11:06And it's like a difference of the mid, you know, they mid
- 11:09curve it all the intellectuals, but I think they're starting to
- 11:12realize, Oh my God, there's really only two trades.
- 11:15You stay ahead of the Fiat dilution through like, you know,
- 11:17fast growing tech stocks or frontier, I call them frontier
- 11:20stocks or space stocks or whatever they are.
- 11:22Or you go to stores, stores of value because there's no other
- 11:26way out of this thing. I call it the Ponzi scheme.
- 11:28You know, everyone makes fun of me for calling it a Ponzi
- 11:30scheme. There's pockets of real things
- 11:32happening obviously in the Ponzi scheme, but they continually see
- 11:35just never ending dilution of your currency at higher, you
- 11:39know, higher valuations. But it's like this deceptive
- 11:42game just to keep the boomer system going.
- 11:44And I think what they're really trying to do is just hand off
- 11:47the assets in a more. It's like a the great rotation
- 11:50they call, they almost called this the great rotation in 2008,
- 11:54except it never came. But it's a giant debt for equity
- 11:56swap. Like you slowly move out of the
- 11:58bonds. Boomers still will invest in
- 12:00bonds because they're mandated to and they just hold.
- 12:03The supply of the bonds is getting smaller and smaller as
- 12:06the boomers have more and more cash and then that money slowly
- 12:10seeps into equity markets because they're the ones keeping
- 12:12the yields down with constant reinvestment through pensions,
- 12:15etcetera. Yeah, it's a great take.
- 12:18I mean, it really ties back to the whole notion of sound money
- 12:21or Bitcoin is more of a common sense test.
- 12:23And I think maybe we talked a little bit about the existing
- 12:26status of the world in the market inertia.
- 12:28And we see this across just legacy infrastructure in
- 12:31general. There's the market sentiment.
- 12:33It's hard to go against it calling bonds impaired.
- 12:35We talk to people at Fidelity, it's very hard for them to even
- 12:37discuss that even though it's pretty straightforward or the
- 12:40math is the math more curious changing a little directions on
- 12:44this great rotation because we naturally see this happening.
- 12:47I think there's been a calls for the dollar demise for since the
- 12:51beginning in 71. I think what's different in
- 12:53where we potentially might be in a suddenly phase is really gold
- 12:56because gold is this thing has been suppressed for decades and
- 12:59it's making its move. It's close to $4000 a tryouts,
- 13:01which is just absolutely insane. We saw what happened was in
- 13:04Shanghai we could talk a little bit about and effectively
- 13:08different countries coming together that are going to start
- 13:10net settling oil on the commodity that underpins
- 13:12everything in different currencies, whether it's, you
- 13:15know, backed by gold or in gold. Just curious how you see this
- 13:19rotation playing out into particular sound assets with
- 13:21gold and a Bitcoin I. Don't know.
- 13:25It's like 40 years of breaking down institutionalization is
- 13:28like really hard to do. So I think it's just going to
- 13:30happen slowly and steady. We're getting into some sort of
- 13:34euphoria here in gold and Bitcoin starting to move as
- 13:37well. I don't know if this is going to
- 13:39be like, I think it's going to be slower because there's so
- 13:43many mandated things from the institutional world.
- 13:45It's like you get, you know, money from taxes goes up.
- 13:48These taxes go to pensions, pension, have to invest into
- 13:51these asset classes. So it's really hard to like
- 13:54rotate fast into all these things.
- 13:56It's just going to be this gradual, like slow default I
- 13:59think on a lot of the Fiat bonds is my read.
- 14:03But I don't think it's going to be like you wake up 1 morning
- 14:05and it's limit up and gold and Bitcoin every single day for
- 14:08like months and then the entire Fiat system kind of folds.
- 14:13I, I would, I would generally agree with that just in the
- 14:15sense that, you know, the, the 6040 is so ingrained, as you
- 14:20mentioned, particularly with, with boomers and older
- 14:23generations that they're just going to hot swap out of all
- 14:26their bonds. Like that's not what's going to
- 14:27happen. And I think you brought up a
- 14:28great point around the generational divide and the
- 14:32perception of debt markets, right?
- 14:33Because if you're someone younger, you're exactly right.
- 14:36Like, why would, why would I lend the US government money to
- 14:39receive a negative real return? Like it's completely nonsensical
- 14:43to someone who has grown up in a world where the, the general
- 14:48trust in institutions has eroded at, at a pretty remarkable clip.
- 14:52And so like, that's the big disconnect in my mind is like,
- 14:55it's this generational divide of, of people who have grown up
- 14:58in a world really post GFC where the trust in institutions, the
- 15:02trust in government is maybe not at an all time low, but it's
- 15:05it's on a steady decline, right? And so I think that that is sort
- 15:09of a pivotal component of why those younger generations will
- 15:14opt for, you know, they'll probably still buy equities, but
- 15:16they're not going to buy bonds and they're increasingly going
- 15:19to look to a Bitcoin as their digital gold portion of their
- 15:22portfolio. So I think it's, it's a very
- 15:24astute observation in terms of again, that generational divide
- 15:27in terms of, you know, just how you perceive stores of value,
- 15:30how you perceive of investments and, and it really all comes
- 15:33back down to institutional trust waning in my mind, like that's
- 15:36that's sort of the critical juncture.
- 15:39Yeah, As a side note, I used to trade at one of the largest 6040
- 15:43portfolios in the country. It's called the Franklin Income
- 15:46Fund. Is this $100 billion fund
- 15:50essentially what it was? It was just like the the boomer
- 15:52fund where everyone just plays not to lose.
- 15:55They just want their income every month.
- 15:57It's it it this guy that manages absolutely brilliant.
- 16:01What it what it really is is over time, he he shorts
- 16:05volatility, he sells overwrites call calls in the equity
- 16:09position. And what you really do is you're
- 16:11picking up nickels in front of a steamroller.
- 16:13And I think that synopsize my experience with that is over a
- 16:17generation when you're just looking to clip yield and you're
- 16:20not actually investing in new ideas that really that whole
- 16:24product. I call it the short volatility
- 16:26trade in general because like that mimics almost every baby
- 16:30boomer product, which is I want to clip yield instead of invest
- 16:34in something new because I don't want to the risk of investing
- 16:37something new. And herein lies the the irony is
- 16:39that over a generation, when you clip yields and you create more
- 16:43debt, you're just moving wealth from one part of the social
- 16:47class to another. So it's like you just
- 16:49annihilated the middle class through Fiat printing and
- 16:51clipping yield. And it's tell me if I'm going
- 16:53down a rabbit hole here. But it's the same premise of
- 16:55insurance where it's like Warren Buffett shorts volatility.
- 16:58He offers, you know, he takes premiums and he goes and buys
- 17:02bonds. And that whole mechanism that
- 17:04it's a similar to the 6040 is, is gone on for too long.
- 17:08And we're at the point where the secular stagnation is so bad
- 17:11because no one has invested in new things, how the government
- 17:14has to make up the gap for the nominal growth that we need to
- 17:18pay off the debt, which makes the risk reward of going out on
- 17:22in the risk spectrum like way better because otherwise the
- 17:27system doesn't exist. You just you'll have like social
- 17:29discord if you just keep doing this clipping yield short
- 17:32volatility trade. So now retails figured it out.
- 17:35It's like this is just, and this is what I meant by you go from a
- 17:38short volatility products to long volatility products is like
- 17:41an easier way to explain it is back like 40 years ago, you
- 17:46know, our grandparents had China like the plates and they would
- 17:49say, oh, you got to get a good piece of China.
- 17:51You're going to pass it down and like it's going to be a great
- 17:53store of values, this China. And then like you go in our
- 17:57generation, it's completely worthless.
- 17:59And that was not a store of value at all.
- 18:03It's the same thing as like bonds now for for us is like,
- 18:06that's ridiculous. Like what?
- 18:07Why would we ever own a bond? And so I when I mean from going
- 18:11from short volatility is like you created this whole risk
- 18:14adjusted return theory about how to invest in assets for 40
- 18:19years. All these institutionalized
- 18:21people did it, but then they forgot to pay.
- 18:23It's the most important thing, which is the dilution of the
- 18:25fucking Kurds, excuse my French. And So what now we're at this
- 18:29point where because of the way the system is set up, you need
- 18:33to force nominal growth higher through the dilution of the
- 18:36currency and fiscal spending. And so that money has to flee
- 18:41into the new frontier assets to create the growth for the next
- 18:44cycle. And so we perverted risk
- 18:47adjusted returns is sort of what I'm saying is like you've pushed
- 18:50it so far where the risk now lies in owning, you know, a home
- 18:55and your your wealth is generated in stocks in frontier
- 18:58stocks now because of the this generate generational gap.
- 19:02And I had a good chart on Twitter about that, which is
- 19:05like, we saw the blow off top and home values.
- 19:08And now there's just like anything that's been used as
- 19:11leverage and squeeze, the middle class is now an asset that will
- 19:14relatively underperform in this new like next 20 year cycle.
- 19:18Sorry, I just rambled there. You guys tell me to shut up if
- 19:21you want. No, that's, that's the point of
- 19:24the podcast, right? That's why you're here.
- 19:26It's funny because it was timely.
- 19:28I was over at my in laws a couple days ago and my wife just
- 19:33found these treasury bonds that were gifted to her when she was
- 19:37born. And so it's just it's funny
- 19:40because to your point, Tyler, China right, as a store of value
- 19:4440 or 50 years ago, it's the same idea as gifting, you know,
- 19:48a newborn baby Treasury bonds 30-40 years ago.
- 19:52And so now you go to redeem a bond and it's a nice gesture.
- 19:57And the person who gifted that thought that that would be worth
- 20:00something today. But then you go to redeem and
- 20:02it's like, well, this doesn't actually buy me anything.
- 20:05Yeah. And so it's interesting because
- 20:08a lot of this is generational investing and just.
- 20:13A lot of things, I guess in the markets are just human
- 20:15psychology, but in terms of how we perceive what a good
- 20:17investment is or what a good store of value is, a lot of it
- 20:20has to do with narratives, but then of course properties as
- 20:23well. So like Bitcoin is like
- 20:24partially A narrative, but also the objective monetary
- 20:27properties of it. And so I think like kind of ties
- 20:30into what you're saying that generationally both the macro
- 20:34and the micro as well as technology and narratives kind
- 20:37of inform what people perceive to be good stores of value.
- 20:41And so I am curious to kind of try to bridge this, how, how do
- 20:46you think about like the short volatility trade kind of coming
- 20:49to an end of the road where you have pretty much every asset
- 20:52class at all time highs? I mean some of the illiquid ones
- 20:55are starting to show impairment and pretty remarkable markdowns
- 20:59relative to what they were purchased like 5 or 10 years
- 21:01ago, say in commercial real estate.
- 21:03But still things are at all time highs.
- 21:05Yet you pointed out that money markets are there's a ton of
- 21:08cash and money markets. And so, like, how do you think
- 21:11about the fact that traditional assets are in all time highs,
- 21:14the fact that younger generations want to own
- 21:18different assets than what their parents or grandparents owned,
- 21:21and the fact that there's still much cash on the table still,
- 21:23you know, like, does everything go up?
- 21:25Or how do you think about markets in like the next handful
- 21:28of years? I think it's a relative game
- 21:31where the Weimar Republic I, I bring up a lot because it's,
- 21:35it's this extreme example of money printing where you know,
- 21:38your, your German currency was basically devaluing at an
- 21:41exponential rate and you'd have to go get your paycheck and
- 21:44wheelbarrow it over and pay for your eggs.
- 21:46And I call it why America now? Because I think we're in this
- 21:49relative game where the dilution is just going to keep happening
- 21:53at an exponential rate unless, you know, the caveat is unless
- 21:56AI is really massively productive and creates like a
- 22:00massive productivity boom, which is possible, very possible.
- 22:03But my point being is that in this world where you're
- 22:07constantly pushing fiscal spending, monetary spending,
- 22:10it's basically MMT is what we're doing.
- 22:12And in that world, there's going to be relative winners and
- 22:15relative losers. And commercial real estate is a
- 22:18perfect example. It was like, but we thought this
- 22:20was, you know, it was like a Thanksgiving Turkey right before
- 22:23Thanksgiving. He's like, oh, it's great, this
- 22:25big fat building. You can charge all these rents
- 22:27and then all of a sudden, like boom, generational change, no
- 22:30one wants to go in the office anymore.
- 22:31We realized, why are we paying? You know, why are corporations
- 22:35paying a 20% tax to the commercial real estate owners
- 22:38when we have all this technology where we can do our jobs
- 22:40anywhere just and then all of a sudden that Thanksgiving Turkey
- 22:44is, you know, toast. But a lot of the pension fund
- 22:47flows were were funneling into that for generation because it
- 22:51was risk adjusted yield. But like if you've all adjusted,
- 22:55it's great return over 30 years, but then all of a sudden bam,
- 22:57done. So like a lot of those types of
- 23:01assets where it's just a tax on someone else and if there's a
- 23:05technological disruption, it really can go to the wayside.
- 23:09You're better off like ironically, investing in new
- 23:13ideas now rather than the the, the stuff of the past.
- 23:17I mean, there's different. I would change my tune if the
- 23:20Fed all of a sudden decided to be like, you know, tighten
- 23:23rates, like then you have to, you know, adjust it or if credit
- 23:26spread starts widening and you need to get a little bit more
- 23:30conservative. But where we sit today, they're
- 23:33trying to delever the debt to GDP, which is, you know, 130%.
- 23:38They need to get that down so that our deficit isn't so huge
- 23:42and we can actually grow our way out of the debt.
- 23:44So that's like we're in basically war, wartime finance.
- 23:47They just can't actually say it. Yeah.
- 23:51It's so true. We have Luke Grubman on the
- 23:53podcast about a month ago and we're talking about the idea,
- 23:58his idea of you don't really like in wartime, you don't ask
- 24:02permission of the bond market to do something right.
- 24:04And so the idea kind of what you're describing as well is
- 24:08there's a fiscal constraint now in the treasury market is, as we
- 24:12all know, heavily manipulated. And the Federal Reserve controls
- 24:15interest rates and they're far below what the market would
- 24:17actually price them at. If you have a country that is
- 24:21120, a 130% federal debt to GDP in order to retain or in order
- 24:28to, I guess where I'm going with this is we're pretty much at the
- 24:33point now where there needs to be an acknowledgement that it is
- 24:35kind of like wartime. And you have to start
- 24:39intervening even more in the bond market, IE driving rates
- 24:42lower, purchasing more of the Treasury debt by whether
- 24:46mandating banks like the private sector or just doing it on the,
- 24:49the, the Federal Reserve's balance sheet.
- 24:51But ultimately there just needs to be more and more
- 24:53intervention, which to your point I guess will be more
- 24:56liquidity, faster dilution rate and ultimately play into the
- 25:00store of to your assets more favorably.
- 25:02Yeah, I think that's spot on of what's gonna happen.
- 25:05The Acronym FACTORY will do whatever I call them, the Valve
- 25:07controllers and the Acronym FACTORY.
- 25:09They will do whatever it takes to make sure the bond market
- 25:13stays calm and salubrious and and no one questions.
- 25:17It's like you ever see The Dark Knight where he's like, it's all
- 25:20part of the plan. You know, they blow up a truck
- 25:23full of soldiers. It's all part of the plan.
- 25:25But kill one innocent person, everyone freaks out so that that
- 25:29you can't you need to have it stay all part of the plan and
- 25:32the bond market needs to stay copacetic.
- 25:34As soon as you get volatility in the bond market, like just get
- 25:36the hell out because that ruins all the asset, the relative
- 25:40asset values. And that's that's the one thing
- 25:42I watch. Was that a good impression or?
- 25:47It was pretty good, actually. One thread I wanted to pull on
- 25:50that you referenced earlier was like, you know, this notion of
- 25:53the productivity miracle from AI.
- 25:56And I keep coming back to this because it's a nice story for
- 26:00people to tell themselves that like, Oh yeah, we're going to
- 26:02grow our way out of this productivity boom, etcetera.
- 26:05I think they're not. Handicapping is effectively what
- 26:07that forces the government and the Fed and the Treasury to do
- 26:11in response to something like that, which is actually print
- 26:14more money and dilute the currency even faster because
- 26:17they can't afford that type of deflationary boom when they have
- 26:21this much debt. And I think that's a big
- 26:23disconnect that people are overlooking today.
- 26:25And one example of it is another acronym like Ubi.
- 26:28Like if a ton of jobs are lost due to this AI productivity
- 26:31boom, there's probably going to be pretty, pretty loud screams
- 26:34for some form of Ubi and that dilutes the currency even
- 26:38further. So I think people are not
- 26:40handicapping this appropriately in terms of this theoretical
- 26:43productivity boom. There's a great paper by this
- 26:47guy named Leopold Ashbrenner. It's called situational
- 26:50awareness. I don't know if you guys have
- 26:52read it, but he basically says there's going to be as AI
- 26:56scales, there's going to be massive problems in the social
- 27:00contract because if you have massive productivity, something
- 27:05you've never seen before, 1002 thousand percent product
- 27:07productivity growth, a lot of the people that capture that
- 27:11productivity growth are wealthier.
- 27:13And you know, the lower in middle income, you might have
- 27:16inflation come down due to the productivity growth, but you
- 27:19know, you might lose your job, right, like you said, and you
- 27:22have Ubi or something. So this battle is just going to
- 27:25be getting worse and worse. And there's a great chart.
- 27:27Do you know infra? His name is Robert on Twitter.
- 27:30He put up this, he's awesome, by the way, does great, great macro
- 27:33work. But he put up this chart of like
- 27:35jobs jolts going down as the stock market goes up.
- 27:40And it's the first time they've disconnected the line of the
- 27:44line in the sand was when ChatGPT was actually created.
- 27:48And you saw like now people are getting more productive.
- 27:51One person can do a lot more things.
- 27:53So I think I'm a believer in the AI productivity boom.
- 27:57I think it's going to create massive imbalances and it's
- 28:00going to be there. It is right there.
- 28:01It's perfect. It's a good one.
- 28:03Like, right, you see, look at that right as ChatGPT is
- 28:05released, you know, jolts go down.
- 28:07And what's even scarier about this is if you're a college
- 28:11educated kid who just paid, you know, 200 grand in student loans
- 28:16and you have no real skill set. And I mean, I use Grok AI Chachi
- 28:21PT all the time. It's frightening how like they
- 28:24can do what I used to do in a week in 5 minutes.
- 28:29So like, this stuff is coming fast and it's frightening.
- 28:34I don't know whether to be like happy about it or sad about it,
- 28:37but it's going to cause major issues.
- 28:39And like, you have to protect yourself.
- 28:41And I mean, I think crypto is a way to protect yourself
- 28:45specifically. And you're going to the
- 28:47government, they're going to do some wacky stuff.
- 28:49The next 10 years is just going to be bizarro.
- 28:51But there's one thing that I think secularly works in that
- 28:55environment is the crypto ecosystem.
- 28:58Yeah, I think two things to call out.
- 29:01You're exactly right. Like things are to get insanely
- 29:02weird with AI, but the amount of energy required is just going to
- 29:05naturally be inflationary because it's going to cost so
- 29:07much more for energy across the globe, which is going to help in
- 29:11that case for like Ubi, because it's going to be very expensive
- 29:14just to like heat your home or like do anything productive.
- 29:17Where I end up coming back to, and I know this is jumping
- 29:20forward, but it comes back to what's the difference between
- 29:22savings and investing? Because I get like, there's
- 29:25going to be a time between here to 10 to 30 years, but the
- 29:29rational decision is to save, not to invest, especially one,
- 29:34because it's an order of operations.
- 29:35You can't really invest until you have savings.
- 29:37But also because in this situation we're talking about,
- 29:41it doesn't happen in a vacuum. So as the amount of monetary
- 29:44units come into the system and people go further out in the
- 29:46risk curve, that means more things are going to naturally
- 29:49not work out. More things will, you know,
- 29:51people are going to be left holding the bag effectively
- 29:53zeros, and then you're going to start to look at what is the
- 29:55risk free rate and that ends up going back to gold and Bitcoin.
- 29:59And with these breakouts, I think nobody wants to catch a
- 30:03fallen knife. But at the end of the day, like
- 30:05wealthy people do not want to see their money be debased.
- 30:08And at a certain point they naturally start to go in and out
- 30:10of the, you know, bonds and, and equities and say, well, like,
- 30:13look, you know, it's just self preservation game theory.
- 30:16So just curious like how you see that fitting in?
- 30:18Because I know that there's been a really nice story for the past
- 30:2030 years to kick the can down the road.
- 30:22But it feels like things are different specifically because
- 30:25depending on where gold goes in the amount of sovereign bid, it
- 30:28ends up being the treasury or the reserve asset.
- 30:30We've already seen amount of gold being held versus treasury.
- 30:33So these are just like different sentiments and different like
- 30:35inertia moving in a direction that we've never seen before
- 30:38that I think kind of adds a different like a wild card to a
- 30:41lot of the discussion that is just going to it's unknown
- 30:45unknowns effectively. Yeah, the whole premise of what
- 30:49is saving in this world is just, you know, you for for a brief
- 30:54snippet, when Trump was putting the tariffs on and they were
- 30:56being like, you know, they're they really wanted to shrink the
- 30:59spending and Doge happened. That was like, I might have to
- 31:03save my money again. The liquidity of the dollar
- 31:05system just like shrunk yeah, that, that was probably time to
- 31:09save your money, but now they, they didn't Now the now the
- 31:13charade is up and everyone knows that, oh, they can't stop this
- 31:16trade like they can't stop it. So our our idea of what saving
- 31:19is like here's a great there was a great chart was like median
- 31:23rents are going up higher than wages.
- 31:26You know, say it's like your, your rents are going up 5% a
- 31:28year. Your wages are going up 3% a
- 31:30year. So you're, you're becoming 2%,
- 31:32you know, less wealthy every year just by, you know, the rate
- 31:35of, of, you know, change in, in rent.
- 31:38And I think people are starting to catch on to that is like,
- 31:41God, my, my car insurance went up by 20% this year.
- 31:45How the hell do I stay ahead of that?
- 31:47And this is goes back to the why America, things like this is
- 31:50normal in history for governments to do this.
- 31:53There's no currency backed by government has ever lasted that
- 31:58long. And think, I think what's going
- 32:00to happen is the government's just going to place the dollar
- 32:02right alongside a Bitcoin. And that will just be the way
- 32:05it's, it can slowly devalue relatively.
- 32:08And then you'll have two different, you know, monetary
- 32:10worlds. You're going to have the China
- 32:11backed gold monetary world in Russia and India.
- 32:15And then you're going to have the the futuristic 21st century
- 32:17crypto backed dollar in the US and allied countries.
- 32:21And I think that's just that's probably the most likely outcome
- 32:24here. But yeah, the premise of saving
- 32:27is just ridiculous. Like the boomer boomers can't
- 32:30wrap their head around like, my wage not going up
- 32:34commensurately. It used to be like, oh, I make
- 32:365% more every year and it gets cheaper to live.
- 32:38Like, oh, this is fantastic. And like, it's the exact
- 32:41opposite now for pretty much millennials and Jen's ears.
- 32:44Like, that's why they're not having kids.
- 32:46Like, assets are too expensive and, you know, their debts are
- 32:49too large relative to their incomes.
- 32:51And that that'll all change here, I think where the, the
- 32:55supply of Labor will shrink. Everyone's going to start
- 32:58getting paid more. And you know who's going to
- 33:01actually pay for it is the boomers, because they're all
- 33:03sitting in bonds and they're getting going to get smoked all
- 33:06their pensions and, and all this stuff.
- 33:08It's just when we get into office and millennials, you
- 33:11know, Jen's ears get into office and younger, they're going to
- 33:14print money to the cows come home because they're like, well,
- 33:16you fed us all this debt, but no one thinks past five years
- 33:20anymore. We can already see Mitch
- 33:21McConnell's gone, the Pelosi's gone.
- 33:24All these old people, they're just, they're just going to be
- 33:26gone. And one of my favorite quotes is
- 33:28like, because of this generation of the villains of the next one.
- 33:32And we're just going to see these people are going to
- 33:34horrible. History is going to look upon
- 33:37them horrible when when you see like the fertility of the next
- 33:40generation has been decimated by all these policies.
- 33:44Yeah, the, the, the distinction between savings and investment I
- 33:47think is a very important one. And the reason it's not well
- 33:51understood today is a function of the past several decades
- 33:54where subconsciously, most likely, like most people are not
- 33:59conscious of, of this reality, but there's a subconscious
- 34:02notion that you can't save in dollars.
- 34:04Like if you just hold dollars in a bank account, even if the the
- 34:07individual doesn't exactly know why, they don't know the
- 34:10mechanisms or how CPI is calculated, they know that, you
- 34:14know, they can't just hold dollars in a bank account.
- 34:16So they're then forced to become speculators, effectively become
- 34:19an investment professional in addition to their day job.
- 34:22And frankly, because there was no alternative, you know, you
- 34:25could, you could think about gold, but then it's, it's, you
- 34:28know, hard to have a material amount of that in your
- 34:30possession or, or know that your, your counterparty has the
- 34:34gold, etcetera. There's, there's issues there.
- 34:36And so now that we do have Bitcoin as this opt out
- 34:39mechanism for savings, we're still very early and people
- 34:42recognizing it as such is, is the main rub, right?
- 34:44Because people still view Bitcoin as very speculative as
- 34:48an, as an investment, as a technology play.
- 34:50In some sense we view it as savings, but most people do not.
- 34:53But that is, I think going to be the important sort of
- 34:57educational education driven evolution that we observe over
- 35:01the next few years is people recognizing like this thing is,
- 35:05is actually not speculative. It's actually the opposite
- 35:07because it's the it's actually the only thing I can trust going
- 35:09forward in terms of credible monetary policy and a finite
- 35:12supply. Now how long that takes to
- 35:15actually, you know, pervade and manifest across society, I think
- 35:19is an open question. But that feels like the the
- 35:22journey that we're going on is, is people recognizing that maybe
- 35:26I don't have to be a speculator and move so far out the risk
- 35:29curve and and Yolo call options on Robin Hood.
- 35:31If I can just save in a superior form of money, I'll outpace all
- 35:35this other stuff that, you know, would take time out of my day to
- 35:38become an investor. And when I can just, you know,
- 35:40focus on my day job, focus on my life, my family, and just save
- 35:44money. We recently launched On Ramp
- 35:47Guardian. This is a feature designed to
- 35:49protect you and your Bitcoin against physical and digital
- 35:53threats. This is included on all on Ramp
- 35:56accounts. And so if you are thinking about
- 35:58social engineering attacks, $5 wrench attacks, people accessing
- 36:04your account through credentials to FA, etcetera.
- 36:07If you're just generally concerned about the security of
- 36:10your Bitcoin long term, whether it is a digital risk, a physical
- 36:14risk or it's both, get in touch. Like I said, this is included in
- 36:18all on Ramp accounts on Ramp Guardian.
- 36:21And there are a lot of different ways that this can protect you
- 36:24against the increasing sophisticated attacks that we
- 36:28are seeing every single day. So get in touch with us on Ramp
- 36:32bitcoin.com, book a consultation if you're interested, and I
- 36:35would be happy to share more about what on Ramp Guardian
- 36:38means for you. Thank you.
- 36:40On that point someone derivatives guy, one of the
- 36:46really interesting things is everything is usually just a
- 36:49relative derivatives relative value in terms of volatility.
- 36:54And what I mean by that is if you look at the volatility in
- 36:57the S&P, it's like 30 day Vols like it's like 8 or something.
- 37:03And that's come down historically because they keep
- 37:06trying to squeeze yields. You can, you can actually
- 37:09manufacture equities into bond like proxies with volatility by
- 37:13call overwriting or put underwriting, if that makes
- 37:17sense. I'm going down a rabbit hole,
- 37:19but you'll like where I'm going in terms of that.
- 37:21But and what's happened to Bitcoin over time is the
- 37:25volatility of Bitcoin has kept going down and down and down and
- 37:27down and down. In fact, it's getting in terms
- 37:30of store value. Everyone's like, oh, it's true
- 37:32volatile. It's actually getting less and
- 37:34less volatile and it's a yield like if you generate yield, now
- 37:37you have yield generation type products on Bitcoin, which to me
- 37:42is basically, oh, you're creating Bitcoin backed bonds,
- 37:45right? That's what you're doing as the
- 37:46volatility comes down and the holder base gets more, you know,
- 37:51wide enough to actually sell calls and sell puts and generate
- 37:55yield off your Bitcoin, you're creating a new financial system,
- 37:59if that makes sense, right? So relatively, would you rather
- 38:02buy a six like a 6% high yield bond or you know what, 11%
- 38:07yielding, you know, Bitcoin back to me, it's a no brainer, but
- 38:10it's all a volatility trade, right?
- 38:12So you smush volatility and boomer assets, but you have a
- 38:16little bit more to squeeze out from Bitcoin through through the
- 38:19ball. But overtime you can kind of see
- 38:20the volatility as the adoption cycle gains, you see the
- 38:23volatility drop in in Bitcoin, you know, a long term.
- 38:26So it's getting more secure is what I'm saying, in terms of
- 38:29that saving store value. Yeah, that for sure.
- 38:33Was that too far down the ribs rabbit hole there?
- 38:36No, not, not at all. I mean, it makes sense.
- 38:38It actually ties into something that I was curious to get your
- 38:41thoughts on. We have mixed opinions on the
- 38:44Bitcoin treasury companies in this group here.
- 38:47And one of the things I thought that was interesting about how
- 38:50you've categorized them was relative to the junk bonds of
- 38:55the knees in terms of new, like new creation of product in the
- 38:57financial markets. Curious if you could just like
- 39:00expand on that idea a little bit and share your thoughts.
- 39:04I think you already did a little bit if you want to share your
- 39:06thoughts in terms of how you perceive perceive these Bitcoin
- 39:09treasury companies in the space. So I'm not, I'm not a hater on
- 39:13them and I can tell you why. So one of my old bosses, this
- 39:17guy named Mark Hart and he's like, he's a macro OG.
- 39:20He shorted the subprime crisis in 2008.
- 39:23He bought credit fault default swaps on European debt in like
- 39:252010, right before the default. You know, the European sovereign
- 39:30debt crisis. He bought Bitcoin in like 2014.
- 39:33He's been on like every big macro trade of the past
- 39:36generation. And where his theology of
- 39:40investment is way different than like your PE ratios, your EVDBTA
- 39:44ratios. And he's like, how do people
- 39:46value art, right? Like how do you value art?
- 39:51And so you need to have access to the art, you need to have
- 39:54awareness of it. Like a Michelangelo piece is
- 39:56like, oh wow, that's awareness, right?
- 39:58That's part marketing. You need to have a custody and
- 40:01security, you need to be able to borrow against it.
- 40:03That is a huge one, right? You need to have patina, which
- 40:07is like it's got, you know, Hutzpah behind it.
- 40:10And then the potential for price appreciation.
- 40:12Those are 6 different attributes to any asset of why they hold
- 40:16value and. The one that really opened up
- 40:19for Bitcoin specifically was used as collateral.
- 40:22When you can borrow against something it really unlocks a
- 40:26whole new ability to for that asset to unlock value.
- 40:31Similarly, like the bad examples of it is when in the Tulip
- 40:35bubble, you could borrow against tulips and buy more tulips and
- 40:38lever up right? Like that was used as collateral
- 40:41that unlocked a huge price appreciation in tulips, but
- 40:44there was no utility behind it. But so my my point being is like
- 40:48what Michael Saylor did was he used his balance sheet, borrowed
- 40:53money against it to buy Bitcoin. He created a, you know, Bitcoin
- 40:56backed bond essentially, and that moment unlocked a massive
- 41:01and I could you could go back when I actually wrote about this
- 41:03specifically for block works like years ago, but that I was
- 41:06like the inception of what there are being what he's really are
- 41:10being is the boomer system to the next generation system.
- 41:14It's a time arbitrage. You're basically taking money
- 41:17from all these boomer pensions. They're buying your bonds and
- 41:19you're putting it into this new system.
- 41:21So I don't really have a problem with the treasury companies.
- 41:24In fact, as they you'll you'll see in this next if there is a
- 41:29next bull run the treasury companies can utilize lower cost
- 41:32of capital can issue a high yield bond at 6%.
- 41:35Go buy more Bitcoin. I mean, I would lever my company
- 41:38up, you know, 10 times over, especially if my my shitty
- 41:42software company is growing at 5%.
- 41:44I could use my balance sheet, borrow against it and buy
- 41:48Bitcoin. So like the treasury companies
- 41:50make a lot of sense. The only issue I have is if if
- 41:56the government all of a sudden becomes like they actually want
- 42:01to normalize things and raise rates and inflation becomes a
- 42:04problem, then watch out. Like obviously that's that's a
- 42:08big issue. But oil still at 60 bucks, like
- 42:10look at all, you know, they're, they're figuring out ways to
- 42:12keep, you know, the inflation at Bay in a lot of senses.
- 42:16So I don't know, I'm very flexible on these things right
- 42:19now. It makes a lot of sense when you
- 42:21can borrow at a really cheap rate and put it in Bitcoin.
- 42:24But maybe that's not true. If inflation actually takes off
- 42:27and they have to tighten, then these are all it's going to call
- 42:29cause a worse cascade. So like I can keep those two
- 42:32things in my mind at the same time.
- 42:35As a yeah, I mean, I, I think, I think that's an interesting way
- 42:38of putting it in terms of funneling in the dollars from
- 42:42the legacy system into the new system via credit markets or you
- 42:47know, in some cases preferred equity.
- 42:48I guess like where where I stand with this is there's in this
- 42:52space in particular, there's like a lot of copycats,
- 42:54especially in the past quarter or two.
- 42:56And there's this overarching narrative for the Bitcoin
- 42:59treasury space that the critical role that these companies play
- 43:02is that the narrative being is, oh, well, people can't access
- 43:06Bitcoin directly for XYZ reasons.
- 43:08So we need to have vehicles to allow people to access through
- 43:12the fixed income and equity markets to Bitcoin.
- 43:16And what I've seen, and this is specifically for institutional
- 43:19investors as part of this narrative.
- 43:21But what I've seen in practice and in reality is the fact that
- 43:25the equity for the copy, you know, for a lot of the small,
- 43:28let's say the smaller Bitcoin treasury companies are owned by
- 43:31retail investors. And on the margin, the only real
- 43:35places you see any sort of institutional adoption of these
- 43:39companies is the strategies play in it.
- 43:42Like probably the top five companies we actually see
- 43:44participation and it's on the equity side.
- 43:47But I think more importantly, to your point, Tyler, it's on the,
- 43:50you know, the fixed income side, right?
- 43:52Because there's, there's a lot of opportunity there.
- 43:55And that's kind of like where, you know where I'm at in terms
- 43:58of there's competing there. There's the narrative that I
- 44:00think they go to market with in terms of, oh, this is how you
- 44:02get $300 trillion of whatever fixed income or capital into
- 44:07Bitcoin. And in reality, it's still
- 44:09really a retail phenomenon. And on the margins, you're
- 44:12seeing a little bit of institutional interest.
- 44:16On the equity side, yeah, I, I kind of agree.
- 44:20I don't, I wouldn't particularly play in those pools, to be
- 44:23honest. Micro strategy, you know, I
- 44:25can't speak of, of single stocks.
- 44:30That's a big enough balance sheet where you can do a lot of
- 44:33different things now, like if your equity is undervalued, you
- 44:36could buy it. You know, if, if it's
- 44:38overvalued, you can sell it, you know, and there's so many
- 44:41mechanisms in the, the, the financial system, like I, I
- 44:44don't think it's a bubble. If Bitcoin goes up by 100%, like
- 44:48a lot of those treasury companies, they're going to do
- 44:50better than a lot of other companies out there.
- 44:53So, and the, the interesting thing is, is that as their
- 44:57equity goes up, they can issue more equity.
- 44:59And it's like this self reinforcing cycle into Bitcoin,
- 45:02if that makes sense. So I, I don't, I don't know.
- 45:05I all I know is that if the credit markets were to shut off
- 45:08somehow, those smaller balance sheet treasury companies are
- 45:12going to be really hurt, especially because the retail
- 45:15investors are so pervasive in them.
- 45:17But yeah, on the whole, here's one other macro thing.
- 45:21Last thing is there's $7.31 trillion in money market funds.
- 45:25What does that tell you? That tells you that there's $7
- 45:28trillion that's looking for yield, right?
- 45:31And so there is actually too much capital and not enough good
- 45:34ideas to put it in. When you think about that whole
- 45:38premise is like as rates come lower in that money, those money
- 45:41market dollars seep out and go into other assets.
- 45:46Like we might be at the beginning of a cycle rather than
- 45:50the end of a cycle. Like you don't see that many
- 45:52people saving at it's like a peak $7.31 trillion in cash.
- 45:58Like you don't see that in at the end of a bull market
- 46:01euphoria. I think you see the money
- 46:03markets, cash coming down and forced into equities and it's
- 46:08like, yeah, there we go. Which is just wild like that.
- 46:12I would think it would, it wouldn't be like that, but it's
- 46:18but think about how much this is how much money boomers have that
- 46:21are looking for yield. It's why rates aren't spiking,
- 46:24right? They keep reinvesting it in
- 46:26yield assets. And they don't even care about
- 46:29losing money because they're like, I don't care.
- 46:31I'm wealthy. I'll just going to.
- 46:32I just don't want to lose my money.
- 46:34Yeah. I think there's two, there's 2
- 46:36core aspects. They're really hard to discuss
- 46:39because we live in a world where we're talking about outcomes
- 46:42that maybe are sub not here, but before earlier in the caller sub
- 46:45optimal. But they're relative because of
- 46:48the situation we're in. That makes sense in a relative
- 46:51basis, you know, in real versus nominal returns and where the
- 46:54treasury trade gets a little trapped.
- 46:56And I agree, like we're still in the early stages and they're
- 46:59going to come back with a resurgence.
- 47:00And it's not because they're good products are needed in my
- 47:03view. It's because of the relative
- 47:05situation we're in coupled with everyone's effectively short
- 47:08Bitcoin. And if they understood that they
- 47:11were short Bitcoin, then they would be holding Bitcoin based
- 47:17on its kegger and opportunity to grow in a risk free like view
- 47:21versus taking additional execution risk with a treasury
- 47:24company. And the way to underpin it is if
- 47:27you said every treasury company from here for the next call it
- 47:3036 months will not go under and meaning whether it's custodial
- 47:34risk, their own custodial risk. You know, a lot of these are
- 47:36going to be generating are trying to generate additional
- 47:39yield outside of some of the examples you said with leverage.
- 47:42And if none of them went out, then I could see it persisting.
- 47:46But what is going to happen and I can promise you this is that
- 47:48some will blow up and they will blow up specifically because for
- 47:5115 years objectively no net new financial product has come into
- 47:55Bitcoin and just succeeded tremendously.
- 47:56The last one was 2022 and everyone seems to forget block
- 47:59by Celsius FTX. And then you can go back two
- 48:01years before that. You can go back two years before
- 48:03that. So this is just the next thing.
- 48:05And it's not to say it won't persist because yes, every
- 48:08company should hold a better form of money on their balance
- 48:11sheet that outperforms everything else.
- 48:12And then they can just take market opportunities by
- 48:15acquisitions. But the notion that like the
- 48:17companies are buying Bitcoin to take leverage, it's like, well,
- 48:20the individual can either just hold the Bitcoin and risk
- 48:23adjusted would outperform on a long enough time horizon.
- 48:26Some of these firms and it's going to become apparent when
- 48:30some blow up because most aren't wrecking, they don't even really
- 48:32recognize that custody is a thing in Bitcoin.
- 48:34So they don't even know that that's actually an issue and
- 48:37everyone you know forgets the past 15 years of all of it.
- 48:40So I think it's just basically if I had to encapsulate the
- 48:43treasury trade, it is effectively opportunistically, I
- 48:47don't want to say taking advantage, but it's it is taking
- 48:50advantage of the early stages we are and the rest of the markets
- 48:54understanding of crypto or Bitcoin.
- 48:56Let me ask you this question on that when you, I don't know if
- 49:00you own a house, but what's the, what's the loan you take out of
- 49:03your house generally? Like what?
- 49:05What do you put down? Well I got lucky.
- 49:07I have some property out here so it got in 21.
- 49:09It was like 2 and two and like 2.3%.
- 49:12Oh, you, you put, I mean like you put, you normally put.
- 49:14I guess you said the interest rate.
- 49:16Yeah, yeah, yeah. What do you put down to?
- 49:18So normally you're like 4X. 1120% Yeah, yeah.
- 49:21So like when you think about, I don't know, a lot of the
- 49:24treasury companies, idiosyncratic things, but like
- 49:28if you're levered on your house, you know, 4X and these these
- 49:33treasury companies are barely levered.
- 49:36I don't, I don't know, maybe, you know, I think they're over
- 49:38collateralized rather than under collateralized like relative to
- 49:41a house. When you think about that.
- 49:43And if they have to stifle rates to grow out of it, maybe this
- 49:46could go along a lot longer. My point is that like we take a
- 49:50lot of leverage out on our own houses in in terms of debt and
- 49:54then we criticize it when they do it on Bitcoin.
- 49:57Like I don't even think sailors that over lever relative, you
- 50:01know, compared to like my own leverage on my house.
- 50:06I think it makes sense in a vacuum if that's all that was
- 50:09happening. But the problem is that as we
- 50:11get further with more liquidity and interest rates going down,
- 50:15these products will go further on the risk curve.
- 50:17And again, if we go back to relative base, somebody had
- 50:20Bitcoin or gold as their savings.
- 50:21And I think this is the problem as we look at in the future of
- 50:23like where a lot of people have been and have benefited from
- 50:27just recognizing in bitcoins and gold are some of the best stores
- 50:30of value, if not the best that it makes sense for a little risk
- 50:33capital. Again, going back to investing,
- 50:35if you're going to park a sliver of your portfolio into something
- 50:38like this and to your point, could use some returns on BTC,
- 50:41but that's not what people are doing.
- 50:43People are put parking their Bitcoin sleeve in this and then
- 50:47it's insanely volatile and then they're going to get shaken out
- 50:50because withstanding Bitcoins volatility frequent is objective
- 50:54properties that give it value. These other things don't have
- 50:57objective properties, they're subjective properties.
- 51:00They're financial arbitrager machines.
- 51:03Yeah. You know, in a heavily financial
- 51:06arbitrage world that will be insanely, incredibly more
- 51:10chaotic and volatile and to expect that it's just going to
- 51:13work out and you're going to make more Bitcoin or higher real
- 51:15return than Bitcoin this early in Bitcoins monetization is the
- 51:18main point versus just holding spot.
- 51:20And the kicker is once institutions and individuals
- 51:23recognize that, that trade effectively compresses because
- 51:26it's just taking again advantage of the markets unsophisticated
- 51:29view of where we're at today. But that see, I agree, I agree
- 51:33with you and I'm like very cognizant that that could don't
- 51:38get me wrong, but I think it could also.
- 51:40But it's like gravity. It's just gravity.
- 51:42It has to unwind. A lot but does it though?
- 51:45What if the government's passed the point of, I mean, if this
- 51:47why, why am our America type backdrop where they're
- 51:51constantly devaluing like, I don't know, maybe, but over a
- 51:55year? But you see, that's, that's the
- 51:58big problem is this happens. That view is a similar view that
- 52:01a lot of people say, well, if Bitcoin like hyper, you know,
- 52:04just dollar hyper inflates, Bitcoin runs, nobody will spend
- 52:07their Bitcoin because everyone's going to hoard it.
- 52:09It's like that makes zero sense because it's the price is
- 52:11running. People are going to naturally
- 52:12want it for goods and services and they'll require people to
- 52:15spend it, among other reasons. In the same view.
- 52:17The cut, the cousin is what you said is if that world happens
- 52:21and we go to Whymar, that means that monetary units are getting
- 52:23pushed out at an exponential rate, meaning that capital is
- 52:26moving to ways that it shouldn't be and things are blowing up.
- 52:29And then people are recognizing what is the risk for your rating
- 52:31goes back to savings. So this is just like this is
- 52:34unwinding all the mental fucker of like the Fiat system back to
- 52:37like first principles. And we can't expect people not
- 52:39to do that. And that's where we build like
- 52:41the way we build because eventually people are waking up
- 52:43and they increasingly do and they're like, we'll wait.
- 52:46So I really want Metaplanet holding like my Bitcoin for
- 52:48additional, you know, 20%. Or do I just want to hold the
- 52:51underline and know that I can go to sleep and then I can just go
- 52:54back to being a doctor or dentist or doing whatever I was
- 52:56supposed to do. And that's basically the
- 52:57Renaissance we're on for the next 10 to 100 years.
- 53:00I totally agree with that premise, don't get me wrong.
- 53:03I was just like playing the mental game of like, I think a
- 53:06lot of this stuff is a pension thing where it's, you know, I'm
- 53:09CalPERS, I need to put my money in, you know, X number of
- 53:13convertible bond funds and that money goes there and then they
- 53:16buy some, you know, Bitcoin back convertible bond from a treasury
- 53:20company. It's that that.
- 53:22I agree. Yeah, I, I agree there.
- 53:26I agree there. The problem with that part is
- 53:28that's where a lot of the treasury companies are hiding
- 53:30behind. But the reality is my
- 53:32understanding only strategy and maybe meta planner at a scale to
- 53:36access those markets and so everyone else is just basically
- 53:40fleecing retail to sell them, you know, higher performing
- 53:43Bitcoin. That I agree with.
- 53:45I'm sure they're just doing ATMs and like annihilating their
- 53:48equity and stacking, you know, Bitcoin.
- 53:50But yeah, you make sure you do your due diligence there.
- 53:54I don't dabble in the the lower tier ones, which I think is,
- 53:57yeah, it's kind of a scheme, but more so like you can make up a
- 54:01lot of alpha if the underlying does go up.
- 54:04Is that was sort of my. I do.
- 54:08I do have a question on the institution institutional
- 54:12adoption of Bitcoin directly like Tyler.
- 54:15Do you have any thoughts on, do you have any thoughts on that?
- 54:18Because when I look at the and Brian actually had an
- 54:21interesting chart where Ibid is now, what was it the top 20 in
- 54:25terms of ETF assets? Yeah, But it's still like if you
- 54:29look at the 13 apps, it's still probably like 7580% retail owned
- 54:33and then you have a lot of hedge funds in there, not a lot of
- 54:36strategic asset allocations yet from institutional investors
- 54:39into Bitcoin. Do you think that that'll change
- 54:42in the next five years or is this going to be a, are we going
- 54:46to continue to run up against barriers just from like
- 54:48gatekeeping and mandates that'll keep Bitcoin out of spot,
- 54:51Bitcoin out of institutional portfolios for a while?
- 54:54I think, I think it's changing slowly.
- 54:57It's sort of like the demographic thing is all these
- 54:59mandates. Here's a great story.
- 55:01When I, when I worked at Franklin Templeton, we sat
- 55:04around this big, you know, it's like 50-60 person oak table and
- 55:10they were like a town hall meeting for the up and coming,
- 55:13you know, younger generation. I, I, this is like back in 2015
- 55:18or something. And I raised my hand.
- 55:19I was like, I think we should start a Bitcoin ETF and every
- 55:23old person there, you Jenny Johnson was the CEO.
- 55:26They all laughed in my face and we're like, you're an idiot and
- 55:29my my whole point is not I told you so, but they did the Bitcoin
- 55:33ETF years later. It's more that these things from
- 55:36the giant institutions perspective take so effing long
- 55:40to like undo mandates that I think we're probably on the cusp
- 55:46if we go on another bull run here.
- 55:48I think it the, the, the walls will come crashing down and
- 55:51they'll say, God, we got to let we got to do more of this stuff.
- 55:54And we've already seen it like Morgan Stanley has 0 hash like
- 55:57embedded. A lot of these legislative
- 55:59pieces are going to this institutional money to be kind
- 56:05of allocated to it. But I do strongly feel that like
- 56:08I don't love the ETFs in terms of the way the what they do to
- 56:12the market structure, like ibit being such a large piece of it.
- 56:16Like I really do love this decentralized nature where you
- 56:19hold your own Bitcoin and I at some point if everyone piles
- 56:23into Ibit, like I don't like that risk and I hope that
- 56:27naturally gets decentralized at some point.
- 56:29I. Mean, yeah, I mean, that's what
- 56:33we're. You guys got to scale faster.
- 56:35Preaching. Preaching to the choir.
- 56:36There still faster. So anyway to pump your tires a
- 56:39little bit? Brian, I was curious on your
- 56:42thoughts. I don't want to toot her own
- 56:44horn too much. So I want to Brian, get your
- 56:46thoughts on some of that information you did share ahead
- 56:48of the call though, because there's the two notable things
- 56:51there was the fact that I bit is in the top 20 ETFs.
- 56:54I mean, we, we spoke to a handful of analysts that have
- 56:58been covering this kind of from the start, Eric and James, to
- 57:01name two people from Bloomberg in particular.
- 57:04And everyone who's followed the Bitcoin ETFs, you know, pre
- 57:10approval, post approval, have really all been blown away in
- 57:13terms of their expectations on the success of this product.
- 57:16And Brian, I wanted to hear what you thought just on, I bet now
- 57:20being in the top 20, it's only been around for like 18 months.
- 57:24So insatiable demand there. And then the other piece of
- 57:27information that you had kind of married to this was the fact
- 57:30that Vanguard is talking about boomer institutions.
- 57:33Vanguard is now reconsidering offering Bitcoin Etps to their
- 57:38client base. There's a lot to unpack here.
- 57:41I mean, even just looking at the list we have on here, look at
- 57:44how many times Vanguard is. Above.
- 57:46I bet in in terms of these these the largest ETF, so the Vanguard
- 57:51news is, is one piece that is interesting in terms of them
- 57:54sort of, you know, signalling that they might be bending the
- 57:57knee. I haven't seen a ton of follow
- 57:59through on specifics or details there, but it seems like the
- 58:04underlying demand from their end clients likely sparked some
- 58:08movement here. And then also just observing the
- 58:10success of of these products, you know, a few months ago we
- 58:13had the headline that Blackrock's I bit now generates
- 58:17more revenue for them than their S&P ETF products, which is
- 58:20pretty remarkable. And the broader signal from all
- 58:23of this to me is like, they're the most successful product
- 58:26launches of all time, the Bitcoin ETFs.
- 58:29Despite that, however, the access and plumbing for people
- 58:34to get exposure to these is still very early days.
- 58:37So Teford Digital has a chart that that shows us very clearly
- 58:41in terms of sort of the broadening access to these spot
- 58:43ETFs. And it's still, you know,
- 58:45there's still a lot of restrictions in place.
- 58:47Even if they're approved on a platform, there might be
- 58:49stipulations around which which clients can actually get access.
- 58:53And there's typically sort of firewalls until in terms of
- 58:57direct solicitation to end clients around these things.
- 58:59So that that's the big signal to me is like it's still so early
- 59:04until in terms of the actual plumbing and people having the
- 59:06ability to get access to these things.
- 59:08But it's still, you know, 90 billion in assets and I bit and
- 59:12you know, the best performing sort of best product launches of
- 59:15all time really in terms of just ETFs generally speaking.
- 59:19So it's just pretty remarkable that that that you have that
- 59:21sort of dichotomy occurring here.
- 59:23All right, quick break. If you're enjoying the episode,
- 59:25please leave us a like a comment rate 5 stars subscribe depending
- 59:30on where you're listening. If you are on YouTube, a comment
- 59:33really helps. You could leave positive
- 59:35feedback on the show. You could leave constructive
- 59:37criticism. Any of that helps.
- 59:39So please, if you can just engage, take a few seconds, like
- 59:43subscribe, comment. It helps a bunch.
- 59:45We spend a lot of time to record, edit, distribute the
- 59:48podcast. So thank you very much in
- 59:51advance for doing so. I really appreciate it.
- 59:53Now on with the show. Looks like Tyler had to jump,
- 59:56but yeah, those are my thoughts. Yeah.
- 59:58I mean, I think it ties in a little bit what he was talking
- 1:00:02about. And to tie what you were saying,
- 1:00:03I think we just have we have so much room to run in this cycle.
- 1:00:08I think it just lasts so much longer than we expect to given
- 1:00:11that the amount of flows, whether it's Vanguard, we talked
- 1:00:13to Ras all day long, banks like everyone's still setting up
- 1:00:16infrastructure. And unless we expect some kind
- 1:00:19of weird blow off top and generally blow off tops, last
- 1:00:22you know, there's usually certain amounts of leverage in
- 1:00:24the system or. Certainty leveraging around
- 1:00:27counterparty risk, like I don't see any of that happening.
- 1:00:30I think the the leverage is pretty tame that we're going to
- 1:00:34let these flows come in, which is going to be recursive or
- 1:00:37reflexive because then more people and more companies are
- 1:00:39going to develop structure products, liquidity pools to get
- 1:00:42get their existing clientele into it.
- 1:00:44It just feels like this is going to last much longer than even
- 1:00:47next year, which is the injury. And then that's on the backs of
- 1:00:49what's happening with gold as well.
- 1:00:51So it really feels like just uncharted territory.
- 1:00:53And we kind of talked about this a few months ago about the
- 1:00:56notion of if there's a sovereign bid for BTC, that changes it.
- 1:00:59But I think like the Canary and the sovereign bid for BTC is
- 1:01:02just a sovereign bid for gold because I think it ends up
- 1:01:04rational if the largest sovereigns are already stacking
- 1:01:08gold. I think it gives even more of an
- 1:01:10incentive, whether it's the US or really challenger countries
- 1:01:14to just pick up the digital version of it that they can buy,
- 1:01:17you know, fraction all of the cost.
- 1:01:20And I think it came out this past week about like how I think
- 1:01:22gold's market cap moved. Is it 10 trillion?
- 1:01:26I think it's 10 trillion something, some crazy number.
- 1:01:29That's right. Yeah, in the past year, so to
- 1:01:32expect that if Bitcoin needed to move up to, you know, $1,000,000
- 1:01:37BTC, that would be a will that be a 10 extra here market cap.
- 1:01:43But that's only what is that in Cherlin. 2021 probably plus or
- 1:01:48minus. Yeah.
- 1:01:50So basically double to get to 1,000,000 and gold hadn't
- 1:01:53stopped. So point being is like that
- 1:01:55everything's kind of on the table when it comes to these
- 1:01:57growth, these assets growing. The other, the other factor too
- 1:01:59is Jackson. I put a chart in there from
- 1:02:03Catoosa Research on Twitter that shows the market cap of gold,
- 1:02:07but relative to global assets. This is one of them that shows
- 1:02:14if gold basically kept pace with money supply.
- 1:02:16So it's doing a ratio of you know M2 in 1980 and then 2011.
- 1:02:23But if you pull up the, I put a second one just under this that
- 1:02:27shows the market cap of gold relative to global assets in
- 1:02:321980 versus today. And this is just pretty stunning
- 1:02:36because like what we just discussed, golden ripping added
- 1:02:38ten trillion over the past year, yet it's still 1/4 of sort of
- 1:02:43where it was in 1980 in terms of its percentage of global assets.
- 1:02:47So like it sort of just speaks to what you were articulating,
- 1:02:51Michael, and that like we are in uncharted territories.
- 1:02:53There is a lot of room to run for both gold and Bitcoin in
- 1:02:57this context of, well, they're actually smaller than they were
- 1:03:0140 years ago in terms of, you know, their actual capture of
- 1:03:06global assets. Are we a gold podcast now?
- 1:03:10Yeah, I mean, I I don't, we need to almost all do a podcast group
- 1:03:17instead of a podcast club instead of a group of book club
- 1:03:20for this Groman Macro Voices pod because I didn't get to fully
- 1:03:23listen to it. I want to go re listen, but it
- 1:03:26ultimately was just describing all these different touch points
- 1:03:30relative to why we're just in uncharted territory.
- 1:03:33And like every mental model is fundamentally flawed because
- 1:03:36it's effectively the dollar dying in real time.
- 1:03:38And we're seeing this happen first hand with what what's
- 1:03:41happening with gold? What's happening the Shanghai
- 1:03:42markets. It's weird.
- 1:03:44I need to get off of Twitter because the algo doesn't even
- 1:03:46give you any relevant information.
- 1:03:47It's just rage bait because I missed I guess the past two
- 1:03:50weeks. I don't know if you saw, I guess
- 1:03:52Modi. It was Modi from India, G from
- 1:03:55China and Putin all meeting and then they were also meeting
- 1:03:58again. There was two different events
- 1:03:59and it was 1 like flexing kind of military capacity, but the
- 1:04:02other one aligning on the usage of different ways to settle oil.
- 1:04:07And these are happening like front and center, you know, to
- 1:04:10showcase the world like we're moving in this different
- 1:04:12direction. And then and so there's that
- 1:04:14example that they talked through.
- 1:04:15And then there was another one that was super interesting, it
- 1:04:18from a guy that was an anthropologist that broke down
- 1:04:21and I want to say 1976, the fall of communism effectively from a
- 1:04:25human capacity when you talk about birth rates and just the
- 1:04:29different factors that would go in and you know, communism fell
- 1:04:3212 years later. And then he broke down again.
- 1:04:34He had another paper, I want to say in 2014 or 20, like late
- 1:04:39either twenty 2000s, early 2000 and 10s, effectively breaking
- 1:04:42down how the US could not retain this, this like level of power,
- 1:04:48given the amount of capital that would be required to sustain it.
- 1:04:52And it had like 2021 as the time frame.
- 1:04:55And it's obviously gone a little bit further.
- 1:04:57And then he just recently posted another piece.
- 1:04:59He's only had three and he's older now.
- 1:05:01And it was just effectively explaining like where we're at
- 1:05:04from, whether it's demographics, capital and debt to military and
- 1:05:08industrial power, Like we're just in a completely different
- 1:05:11ball game. And I think that's why we see a
- 1:05:12lot of this volatility and, and almost because the way it was
- 1:05:16being described was while this was happening, something
- 1:05:19happened with like Sydney Sweeney and everybody was
- 1:05:21talking about that. It's like we're just like
- 1:05:22everyone's like being paying attention to these other things
- 1:05:25while all this stuff is happening in real time.
- 1:05:28And I think the main take away there is that if the dollar is
- 1:05:31in real time losing reserve status like everything's on the
- 1:05:34table when it comes to other assets and their price relative
- 1:05:37to dollars. Yeah, for sure.
- 1:05:39And what Michael was referencing was Emmanuel Todd, I believe it
- 1:05:43was Defeat of the West, published in 2024.
- 1:05:46But yeah, what I took away from that and what Luke has been spot
- 1:05:50on about for probably a decade at this point is the fact that
- 1:05:55you can't really decouple the United States from China and
- 1:05:58Russia, which are the biggest adversaries of the country
- 1:06:02because of the dependence that we have from an industrial
- 1:06:06capacity to the military. And so it's kind of like this
- 1:06:10odd situation where the tensions between these countries continue
- 1:06:14to grow, but we it's pretty much like a toxic relationship
- 1:06:18because like the tensions continue to grow.
- 1:06:20But the fact that we depend on these countries for raw
- 1:06:24materials, for creating a lot of the industry that we no longer
- 1:06:27have in the United States, we actually can't like initiate any
- 1:06:30sort of hot war with them or even just like to couple
- 1:06:33economies from them without collapsing our own.
- 1:06:35And so that's, I think like the, the, the left bell curve, the
- 1:06:39simplification of the thesis. And then the other thing that
- 1:06:42was interesting that I caught there was essentially Luke's
- 1:06:46thesis, if you play it out another two or three years, is
- 1:06:49that gold becomes gold overtakes the US Treasury market as the
- 1:06:54largest percent of sovereign reserve assets.
- 1:07:00And so at that point, you know, I'm sure too, or if that does
- 1:07:03happen two or three years from now, I'm sure the United States
- 1:07:05will still continue to think that the world resolves around
- 1:07:09revolves around the US Treasury market, but the market is
- 1:07:13actually decided otherwise. And so does that actually start
- 1:07:16a conversation around, well, it's gold actually now the
- 1:07:20neutral not even, yes, it's a neutral reserve asset, but is
- 1:07:23gold the reserve asset if it overtakes, if it overtakes?
- 1:07:26Yeah, in that like Brian, I'd love you to get your thoughts on
- 1:07:29this because this is, you know, we harp on it and I know it gets
- 1:07:32a little old, but I just can't help because it feels like we're
- 1:07:35the only some of the only people saying it or me is about the
- 1:07:37treasury stuff. The Bitcoin treasury is
- 1:07:42everything's the same until it isn't.
- 1:07:43And so if we're talking about treasuries taking reserve stat
- 1:07:47or goal taking reserve status from treasuries, and you know,
- 1:07:50very smart people have been talking about outside money for
- 1:07:52so long. If volatility and counterparty
- 1:07:55risk increase in this world, which I think we would all agree
- 1:07:58everyone would, then it makes 0 little to zero sense to hold a
- 1:08:02large percentage of wealth inside the system because you
- 1:08:05don't know where the risk lies across a number of different
- 1:08:08orders. So again, that's the angle of
- 1:08:10like you're taking this asset that is meant to be
- 1:08:12decentralized out of the system, you're parking it right back in
- 1:08:14the middle of the financial system and a bunch of weird
- 1:08:16things are going to happen and be prepared for them.
- 1:08:18And it's not to say you can't speculate, but it goes back to
- 1:08:21or what are you doing and what's your plan?
- 1:08:23Because if it's speculative asset, well, if you're all in
- 1:08:25Bitcoin, that's perfectly fine. But if you have no Bitcoin
- 1:08:28exposure or anything outside of the system, maybe you want to
- 1:08:30start with a core position before you start to bring it
- 1:08:34back in and be susceptible to whatever is going to happen over
- 1:08:36the next two to 10 years. 100% I mean, that's that's very well
- 1:08:40said that the other way I would describe it is like, you know,
- 1:08:44the treasury company wrapper or even just the ETF wrapper
- 1:08:48effectively nukes a a large portion of the value prop of
- 1:08:52owning Bitcoin. And that's sort of what you're
- 1:08:54getting at in terms of if there's a renaissance around,
- 1:08:58you know, what is money, what is a store value, what is a reserve
- 1:09:03asset, holding it in a structure where you don't have the same
- 1:09:10ownership guarantees or assurances is completely
- 1:09:13illogical. And so, you know, I think, you
- 1:09:17know, part of the disconnect in in the conversation earlier
- 1:09:19around treasury companies is like, you know, it's fine for
- 1:09:23risk capital, but but understand that they are trades
- 1:09:26necessarily. And you are fundamentally just
- 1:09:30getting a different, you know, you're getting some price
- 1:09:32exposure to Bitcoin, but you're not getting any of the other
- 1:09:35benefits that make it a a reserve asset.
- 1:09:38You know, it's price appreciation is not the reason
- 1:09:40that people are adopting it as a reserve asset.
- 1:09:43They're adopting it because you can hold it without counterparty
- 1:09:46risk. They're adopting it because it
- 1:09:47can't be diluted by a government.
- 1:09:51They are not holding it purely for the price appreciation.
- 1:09:53And I think that that is not well understood at all, just
- 1:09:57given the uptake in the narratives that and the hype
- 1:10:00around these treasury companies that we've seen.
- 1:10:02But it is, you know, if you just go back to first principles
- 1:10:05around the merits and the the core value prop of this asset,
- 1:10:10by putting it in these wrappers, whether it's ETFs or the
- 1:10:13treasury companies, you're stripping away a lot of that
- 1:10:16core value, the reasons why you would even want to own an asset
- 1:10:19like Bitcoin in a portfolio. Yeah.
- 1:10:22And I think like there's too big, I guess there's so much
- 1:10:26embedded in all of this when it comes to the asset price doesn't
- 1:10:31happen again in a vacuum as the price appreciates that nobody
- 1:10:36else is, other people are buying it, other people are recognizing
- 1:10:39what Brian just said. And then they will start to
- 1:10:41demand goods and service be paid in that.
- 1:10:44And so you may want the underlying as it appreciates
- 1:10:46because you may naturally want to spend it or you actually may
- 1:10:49be required to spend it, right. There's a lot of pretty like out
- 1:10:53there examples. But I remember back in the day,
- 1:10:55there was a client that came to us.
- 1:10:57They needed to set up like without it being publicly known
- 1:11:00large or a meaningful Bitcoin position from a business
- 1:11:02continuity perspective around cyber attacks, because naturally
- 1:11:06when cyber attacks happen and they like steal data and they
- 1:11:08ransom it, they they don't want, you know, bank trails and they
- 1:11:12want you to pay in BTC. Now, obviously that's very on
- 1:11:14the far end of the spectrum, but there will be increasingly
- 1:11:17reasons why people will want to accept Bitcoin as the price
- 1:11:20appreciates. And if you don't have any
- 1:11:22exposure and it goes back to well, why would you want the
- 1:11:25underline is there's a value prop in the censorship
- 1:11:28resistance, There's a value prop in, you know, the custody
- 1:11:30aspect. But there's real value in
- 1:11:33optionality. Like that's the purpose of money
- 1:11:35is to give you optionality on what you do with it in the
- 1:11:38future, but also how you do with it what you want.
- 1:11:41And you can't eat your equities. You can't do any of these.
- 1:11:43Like nobody's going to take your MSTR shares if you know you need
- 1:11:47to spend them on something. And so again, I think this is
- 1:11:49just, we're so early. There's so much education, but
- 1:11:52it's going to happen, I think faster than people recognize
- 1:11:54because once some risk happens inside the treasury company
- 1:11:58craze, people will start to understand that.
- 1:12:00And then also as counterparty risk and more merchants and
- 1:12:03people just naturally will accept it and incentivize people
- 1:12:06to give them their Bitcoin. They're going to be like, well,
- 1:12:07why am I not holding this? Or I should figure out actually
- 1:12:09how to have a small cornerstone position in a similar vein that
- 1:12:13this business had for their continuity purposes?
- 1:12:17Yeah, just be patient, Michael. It may be maybe a decade, but it
- 1:12:22was similar to that Luke Roman podcast where Eric, the host of
- 1:12:27Macro Voices, said what Luke would say on the podcast.
- 1:12:30Five years ago people thought he was like a nut job and now like
- 1:12:33all the same people are saying well shit, he's actually right.
- 1:12:37So if you just be patient, wait 5 to 10 years if you might be.
- 1:12:41Right. Just be patient, man.
- 1:12:42All right. Just did you, did you listen to
- 1:12:44the? Did you listen to the whole
- 1:12:45project or you listen? I didn't make it through.
- 1:12:47I listened to a bit this morning.
- 1:12:49It is probably one of the best I've listened to because not in
- 1:12:52a good way. It was just really breaking down
- 1:12:54in a very pragmatic, we're like headed to a very weird spot.
- 1:12:58And it seems to all kind of be like converging right now.
- 1:13:01And yeah, it's not. Yeah.
- 1:13:05Yeah. It'd be a lot weirder if we
- 1:13:08didn't have Bitcoin though. That's what I would say, yeah,
- 1:13:10we'd be cooked. It'd be big cooked.
- 1:13:12Yeah, I guess that's like that's the challenging thing is it
- 1:13:18really does tie into like wanting to have wealth outside
- 1:13:21of the financial system. And I that would even go beyond
- 1:13:25just like owning Bitcoin or gold, right?
- 1:13:26Like you probably would want to own, maybe some people want to
- 1:13:31actually raise their own food. But I think it's like kind of
- 1:13:33the, the broader theme, the really macro theme over the next
- 1:13:36like 20 years would probably be moving away from just measuring
- 1:13:40wealth from numbers on the screen because the numbers on
- 1:13:43the screen, they can go down in nominal value and then get
- 1:13:45destroyed in real value. They could be confiscated from
- 1:13:49you. And so that's where that
- 1:13:50probably goes longer term. And that's kind of like, I guess
- 1:13:53what you're saying about, you know, things get weird or things
- 1:13:55get scary. Yeah, and that's the main reason
- 1:13:57I brought it up so many times, and I'll bring it up again is
- 1:13:59like watch Cinderella Man, because it's a good flick, but
- 1:14:02it's really a documentary about the Great Depression because all
- 1:14:04these people lost all of their money.
- 1:14:07And it brings you to a real visceral place of like, Oh my
- 1:14:09God, what happens if all the numbers moved off a screen?
- 1:14:12Because it actually happened, albeit it was about 100 years
- 1:14:15ago. And so we're just so far removed
- 1:14:17to realizing that can happen. And we should post covet realize
- 1:14:21that anything can happen because everyone before that would have
- 1:14:23said nobody could get locked in their house and all the things
- 1:14:25that happened post that and and they did.
- 1:14:27And so I think it's just still discounted that volatility will
- 1:14:30only increase from here because basically the dollar is the
- 1:14:33world reserve currency is failing.
- 1:14:35And so you just have to be prepared for that.
- 1:14:37And being prepared for that isn't putting money into the
- 1:14:39financial system and having a gatekeeper.
- 1:14:44All right, well, what do you have to say?
- 1:14:47No, I was just thinking about when's the position time to take
- 1:14:50a little a little bit into gold just because I think I think you
- 1:14:53might need a little gold in the future.
- 1:14:55Jackson. Yeah, you, you missed the
- 1:14:57levered, the levered long back at 58 or 62 because we're
- 1:15:01sitting at like 120 right now. Yeah.
- 1:15:04Price dipped a little bit in Jackson and kind of had, do you
- 1:15:07say, on the terminal. Did you say 750 by the end of
- 1:15:10the year, Michael, I think I, if I'm remembering correctly, that
- 1:15:12was your price target six months ago.
- 1:15:14You know end of end of year is is hard.
- 1:15:21I think end of cycle whenever we kind of.
- 1:15:24Cycles are over. There's no more cycles.
- 1:15:26Come on. I think we're what I think is
- 1:15:28going to happen in the next few months is we're going to get a
- 1:15:30run up and people are going to think it's the top.
- 1:15:33People are going to think it's a blow up top at like 151, sixty,
- 1:15:39maybe even 170. Then there's going to be a head
- 1:15:42fake down, maybe back to like 125 and then into next year bull
- 1:15:47market continues. I like, I mean, I think.
- 1:15:51Most people are totally sidelined as a result of the
- 1:15:54head fake. I think most people are
- 1:15:56sidelined right now. Just that's true.
- 1:15:59What what, what I think is the most interesting is how Grauman
- 1:16:04said on the pod that he came to Bitcoin because he understood it
- 1:16:06as a currency problem. Because everyone talks about
- 1:16:09even earlier, we're talking about Whymar as being some like
- 1:16:11really ephemeral thing. But like when you look at gold
- 1:16:13for Bitcoin versus the dollar, it looks exactly like that.
- 1:16:16And so, and we're still in the early stages and there hasn't
- 1:16:19been this amount of devaluation in the dollar.
- 1:16:23So, yeah, I think, I think we end up even in your world, which
- 1:16:27you shared, Brian, I think it ends up at higher numbers
- 1:16:30because whether it's now or it feels like it's going to be now
- 1:16:34because there's just been this chop for the past, you know,
- 1:16:36nine months. There's too much capital pools
- 1:16:39sitting on the sidelines that we know want to come in, whether
- 1:16:42it's institutional capital, the Treasury stuff, the salt.
- 1:16:44The US government. Yeah, the US government and
- 1:16:47between gold doing what it's doing and this it's just I don't
- 1:16:50think we're prepared for like where I'll and it could be we
- 1:16:52could be wrong. Like there's the whole gradual
- 1:16:54suddenly and it could take much longer, but it doesn't feel like
- 1:16:57that right now like the amount of chaos being churned up in the
- 1:17:00traditional kind of news cycle and what's happening.
- 1:17:02We saw the only time we've seen this happen again was like post
- 1:17:0519, 2019 when the repo markets broke and we there's like all
- 1:17:08hell ensued in 2020. That's what this feels like,
- 1:17:11that the chaos is getting ratcheted up because the system
- 1:17:13is just starting to, like, crumble.
- 1:17:17Certainly feels like Weimar in many ways.
- 1:17:19Yeah, that's what, Yeah. You feel it when you go out,
- 1:17:21when you look at it's just crazy, like when you go interact
- 1:17:26with the normal world. I limit that, but when I do you
- 1:17:28kind of hear these. I just remember sitting the
- 1:17:29other day at the like pumpkin patch and they were like talking
- 1:17:31about concerts and and they were like, these weren't like hang.
- 1:17:34On I didn't. I didn't know you went to
- 1:17:36pumpkin patches, Michael. I don't, but I have to like, you
- 1:17:38know, once in a while kind of, you know, do the, do the patch,
- 1:17:42do the. Fire off a patch.
- 1:17:46Fire, fire up a patch. But they were just talking about
- 1:17:49like going to concerts and they're like, imagine the
- 1:17:51everyday person can't afford this.
- 1:17:53And these were like everyday people in my mind.
- 1:17:55They weren't like, so they're, they're just referencing like
- 1:17:58that people can't go to concerts and like they're like all and it
- 1:18:00wasn't even expensive, I guess relative, but it was like, if
- 1:18:02you go with your family, it's going to end up X dollars.
- 1:18:05So it's not really achievable. And you look at the groceries
- 1:18:08and you go buy any meat related product.
- 1:18:11It's it's not. And maybe the last thing is all
- 1:18:14those charts or like, I don't know, I can't help but feel the
- 1:18:18other version of Fed speak when you see post 21 and that like
- 1:18:23stock market, the chart we pulled up earlier where the
- 1:18:26stock market went vertical and then the jobs declining.
- 1:18:29Like I think that's a component of interest rates, not
- 1:18:33necessarily productivity, but interest rates being, you know,
- 1:18:38rising. So naturally, you know, people
- 1:18:40were laid off. But then also when you look at
- 1:18:43the job like recalculation of numbers and it goes back to GDP
- 1:18:47growth has been measured in the wrong underlying currency.
- 1:18:50So it looks like we're growing, but we're not.
- 1:18:52And we've. Basically, yeah.
- 1:18:53It's also wildly It's also been wildly manipulated by government
- 1:18:57spending and government jobs being a large bulk of any
- 1:19:00proverbial job growth. Exactly.
- 1:19:02So we're like at a true sense of like gross new product.
- 1:19:05You can make the case like post 71, we've been in effectively in
- 1:19:08a recession because there's been more monetary units than actual
- 1:19:11productivity that's been created.
- 1:19:13And that's why you see the world what it is today.
- 1:19:16It goes back to the whole tweet of like your clip or whatever.
- 1:19:20It's like we want to fly. We were promised flying cars and
- 1:19:22whatever. All we got was like 240
- 1:19:23characters. It's like that's why we're
- 1:19:25sitting here with the same shit, because there's no actual
- 1:19:27productivity happening. There's just people talking
- 1:19:29about treasury companies and all this other bullshit that
- 1:19:31produces no real value in the world.
- 1:19:33Like that's the crux of it. And everyone's incentivized to
- 1:19:35go deliver no new value because they can gain the system to
- 1:19:38extract more dollars. Once all these concepts get back
- 1:19:41and understood, that's when you got to get the real renaissance.
- 1:19:44But it's just going to take time.
- 1:19:46Pull this up on another pod. But there was also that tweet
- 1:19:48that was basically saying like 75% of stock market gains are
- 1:19:52from AI related stocks. A lot of that's probably NVIDIA.
- 1:19:55But like, that, I think is also an explanation for that chart
- 1:19:59that we had up that shows stocks going up despite, you know, the
- 1:20:02real economy suffering is it's being propped up by people just
- 1:20:06chasing this hype cycle. And you know what have we gotten
- 1:20:09out of it thus far? Like, you know, just this week
- 1:20:13open AI put out their Sora app, which is basically a tick tock
- 1:20:16competitor that is just purely AI slot videos, you know,
- 1:20:20benefits of society, probably negative, generally speaking.
- 1:20:23So like, you know, all of this money chasing, you know, this,
- 1:20:27this AI hype cycle remains to be seen what comes out on the other
- 1:20:31side of this. And so a lot of capital will be
- 1:20:33destroyed in this process. And so, yeah.
- 1:20:36Should. Get pretty weird.
- 1:20:38Maybe the one thing like to tie it all back to positive is this
- 1:20:42is really where it goes back to the whole, I think it was for
- 1:20:45earlier about savings. If you finally get it right, it
- 1:20:48doesn't even have to be Bitcoin. But if you end up in gold and
- 1:20:50you feel relatively good that you are going in real terms to
- 1:20:54maintain your purchasing power, then everything we talked about
- 1:20:57and we're focused to pay attention to out of because for
- 1:20:59sick, you know, ways either because we're interested in or
- 1:21:01because of the business and doing these podcasts, you don't
- 1:21:04actually have to pay attention to any of it.
- 1:21:06You can just go back to living your life.
- 1:21:07But if you don't decide to do that, then you're effectively on
- 1:21:10the hamster wheel of trying to make ends meet, whether it's
- 1:21:13with your job, not quitting, you know, not having wealth saved.
- 1:21:17That goes back to the optionality.
- 1:21:18But then also being glued to Twitter in these screens, trying
- 1:21:21to figure out what's the latest dat and the crypto and like
- 1:21:23whatever to get into versus just like opting out by protecting
- 1:21:27your wealth. And then you just get your head
- 1:21:29back because you don't have to pay attention to this.
- 1:21:31And if you decide to pay attention, it's because you're
- 1:21:33just a perverse individual versus, you know, like it's just
- 1:21:35there's a level to get back to normalcy and it just means you
- 1:21:38just protect your wealth. But until you realize what we're
- 1:21:41talking about, people just are going to end up playing the real
- 1:21:44versus nominal returns, and they're just going to get
- 1:21:46absolutely crushed because the risk lies everywhere in that
- 1:21:49world. Yeah.
- 1:21:50Well, I mean, it's, yeah, it's also what Tyler said too.
- 1:21:53Or it's like, it's what you're saying as well, where most
- 1:21:56people would rather just be in something they perceive to be
- 1:21:59comfortable and safe, even if they know they're still like not
- 1:22:03growing on a real basis. Like most people haven't
- 1:22:05actually came to that conclusion yet, but still, Michael, it
- 1:22:08might be your point where a lot of investors or savers are
- 1:22:12comfortable owning bonds that are not going to actually grow
- 1:22:16their wealth. It's actually going to lose
- 1:22:17wealth over time, then own something they perceive could
- 1:22:21just like blow up one day, right?
- 1:22:23So I think we still have a lot of work to do.
- 1:22:25We'll probably have to do the last trade at least for another
- 1:22:27decade or so, then we can see at least any of this plays out.
- 1:22:31Maybe Jack, he'll get a house by then.
- 1:22:32Maybe he'll get a house by in in a decade he'll get we'll get
- 1:22:35armed. I'm in a cave, but Tyler said
- 1:22:38The Cave was nicer than whatever Michael's got going on there.
- 1:22:41So if you like, if you like where I'm recording from in The
- 1:22:44Cave, like I'm like the Madam, just yeah, just like leave a,
- 1:22:47like leave a comment. We need to call out Jackson's
- 1:22:51paper hands because the price dipped a little bit and he just
- 1:22:53stopped with the terminal. This used to be his favorite
- 1:22:55chart. He'd pull it up and we had.
- 1:22:57Ripping boys. We had we had this little clip
- 1:23:00down here or maybe I don't even know.
- 1:23:02I guess this is. Yeah, it was probably like 2
- 1:23:03months ago at this point. I haven't done it.
- 1:23:05It was somewhere, somewhere down here where it just got
- 1:23:07depressing and and Jackson's like we're going to we're going
- 1:23:10to end the end the chart. But, you know, we're, we're,
- 1:23:12we're back. 120 All right I guess I do have paper hands I
- 1:23:20sold all my Bitcoin all right I guess we'll we'll call it I'll
- 1:23:23call it a week if you like the if you like the internal riff at
- 1:23:26the end of the episode. Maybe we can make this a
- 1:23:28standard, but we will have to hear feedback if people actually
- 1:23:31enjoy it and let us know. If you don't enjoy it, you can
- 1:23:35let us know as well because then you know, we'll save your time.
- 1:23:37We'll save our time. We won't do this anymore.
- 1:23:40So thanks for tuning in this week and we'll see you next week
- 1:23:42maybe. Thanks all this thanks for
- 1:23:45listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:23:47If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:23:49episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:23:52app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:23:54today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:23:57Before we finish, a quick reminder that Onramp Media is
- 1:23:59for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:24:02nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:24:05Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:24:08to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact
- 1:24:11to schedule a consultation with one of our private client
- 1:24:14advisors.