Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Dual-Class Structures
Transcript
- Lucas: So it's August 2026, and we're seeing some serious red on the screens. Apple's down 8.3 percent over the past five days, and Meta's off 6.3 percent. But that's not what I want to dig into today. I want to talk about why some of these companies were built the way they were, structurally, before they ever hit the public markets. Luna: You're talking about dual-class shares, right? That founder-control structure that's been a flashpoint for years. Lucas: Exactly. And it's a topic that feels especially relevant right now, because even as the market is punishing some of these mega-cap tech names, the governance questions are still simmering underneath. So let's unpack why a company would go public with one class of shares for the public and a different class for the founders, and whether that's actually good for long-term shareholders. Luna: And for the listener who's not a governance nerd, can you set the baseline? What does dual-class actually mean in practice? Lucas: Sure. In a typical IPO, a company sells shares that all carry one vote each. But in a dual-class structure, the founders and early insiders get shares with, say, ten votes per share, while the public gets one vote per share. That means the founders can own a relatively small slice of the economic pie but still control the board and major decisions. Think Google's founders, Larry Page and Sergey Brin, or Meta's Mark Zuckerberg. Luna: So it's a way to keep the vision intact, but it also means public shareholders are essentially along for the ride without much say. That's a hard trade-off. Lucas: It is, and it's the crux of the debate. Proponents argue that it shields founders from short-term Wall Street pressure, letting them invest in moonshots like self-driving cars or the metaverse without worrying about a quarterly earnings miss tanking the stock. And there's research that shows some dual-class companies outperform in the first few years after going public. Luna: But then that outperformance fades, right? I remember a study that showed after about five years, the performance gap narrows, and sometimes the governance discount starts to show. Lucas: Right, and that's where the critics come in. They point to cases where a founder's missteps have destroyed value, and the public shareholders had no real way to push back. Think of WeWork — Adam Neumann had a dual-class structure that gave him outsized control, and we all saw how that story played out. Luna: That's a textbook example. And it's not just the old guard — some of the recent high-profile IPOs, like Rivian and Palantir, have also used dual-class structures. Rivian's actually down 7.6 percent over the last five days, so investors are clearly not rewarding it right now. Lucas: Yeah, and it's worth noting that the market is also paying attention to governance when it prices these stocks. So, the immediate stock moves we're seeing in Apple and Meta — they're probably tied to earnings and macro, but governance is a slow-burn factor that can show up in the multiple investors are willing to pay. Luna: Let's talk about the mechanisms. Some companies have started to adopt sunset clauses — provisions that automatically convert dual-class shares to single-class after a certain period or after the founder leaves. That's been a compromise to address investor concerns. Lucas: Yes, and it's a trend that's been gaining traction. A few years ago, when Lyft and Pinterest went public, they included sunset clauses. And more recently, some companies have offered time-based sunsets — say, ten years after the IPO. The idea is to give founders a runway to execute their vision, but also to reassure shareholders that the structure isn't permanent. Luna: But not every founder is on board. There's a camp that says sunset clauses undermine the whole point of dual-class, which is to give long-term thinkers the freedom to think in decades, not just in election cycles. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the philosophical divide. On one side, you have the 'founder knows best' school, and on the other, you have the 'no taxation without representation' school of shareholder rights. It's not a black and white issue, and the data is mixed, so it's a fascinating tension to watch. Luna: And in practice, how are institutional investors responding? I know BlackRock and Vanguard have said they're not automatically against dual-class, but they want to see accountability measures. Lucas: Right, they're engaging. Index funds are in a tricky position because they have to hold these stocks, but they can vote their shares in a way that signals their preferences. We've seen proxy advisory firms like ISS and Glass Lewis recommend against directors who don't support sunset provisions. It's not a revolution, but it's a quiet pressure campaign. Luna: So, for the post ipo company listening — and I imagine some founders might be tuning in — what's the practical takeaway? If you're thinking about going public, how do you decide whether to use a dual-class structure? Lucas: First, look at your long-term capital needs. If you're in a capital-intensive business, like autonomous vehicles or biotech, you might need to raise a lot of money over time, and dual-class can help you maintain control despite dilution. Second, think about your investor base. If you're targeting growth investors who are used to founder-led companies, they might be more accepting. But if you want to attract more traditional institutional money, you might need to offer some protections. Luna: That's a good framework. And it's not just about control — it's also about signaling. A company that adopts dual-class is saying, 'We believe in this vision, and we're willing to bet that you'll trust us.' But it cuts both ways. Lucas: Absolutely. And we should also mention that some companies have chosen to do a sunset provision from day one, which can be a smarter play. It gives you the benefits of dual-class in the early years, but it also gives investors an exit ramp if things go south. That's a balanced approach that might be the best of both worlds. Luna: We've been talking a lot about governance structures, and it reminds me of how much goes into these decisions behind the scenes. I know our listeners are often founders and operators, and I think a lot of them appreciate that we can have these candid conversations without a paywall or ads. It's something we're able to do because of listener support. Lucas: Yeah, that's a good point. A handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's literally what funds making this many of these shows. It keeps us independent and able to dive into topics like this without worrying about advertiser pressure. Luna: And we're grateful for that. It means we can keep bringing you these deep dives. Alright, back to dual-class — one more angle I want to bring up: the SEC's stance on all of this. Any recent developments there? Lucas: The SEC has been fairly hands-off on dual-class structures, but there's been talk about requiring more disclosure around these structures in IPO prospectuses. And there's also been discussion about whether stock exchanges should tighten their listing standards. The NYSE and NASDAQ both allow dual-class, but they've faced pressure to adopt rules that would limit their use, especially for companies that are already public. Luna: I remember that a few years ago there was a movement to create a new stock exchange that would list only companies with one-share-one-vote structures. That never really took off, but it shows the level of concern. Lucas: Right, that was the Long-Term Stock Exchange, and it did end up listing some companies, but it hasn't become a major venue. Still, the conversation is alive. And as more tech companies go public, especially in areas like AI and fintech, the governance question is only going to get more attention. Luna: So, wrap it up for us — what's the one thing you want our listeners to remember about dual-class structures? Lucas: I think it's that dual-class isn't inherently good or bad — it's a tool. The key is alignment. When founders use it to pursue a genuine long-term vision, it can create enormous value. But when it's used to entrench underperformance, it can destroy shareholder value and erode trust. The best companies are the ones that think carefully about that balance and are willing to adapt over time. Luna: And that adaptability might be the real test — whether founders are willing to evolve their governance as their company matures. It's a conversation that's not going away, especially as the market keeps shifting under our feet. Lucas: Well said. For now, that's our take on dual-class structures. We'll be back soon with more on the business and technology stories that matter. Until then, keep building.