Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL X Expro: The potential of Geothermal
Transcript
- 0:05Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, a very special
- 0:09edition brought to you live from the show floor of Women in New
- 0:12Energy, in which Expo has been a sponsor.
- 0:16And I'm joined by James from that very company.
- 0:20How are you doing today, James? I'm good.
- 0:21Thanks, Ryan. How are you?
- 0:23I'm not too bad, I'm not too bad.
- 0:24The show's been been great. I don't I don't like being part
- 0:28of the team that helped pull it together and then saying, oh,
- 0:30it's a great success because that sounds like I'm patting
- 0:32myself on the back. But if you want to pass in the
- 0:34back, that'd be. Great, absolutely.
- 0:36Do you know what it's actually the first time I've attended
- 0:39Expert has supported in the past, but but there's a great
- 0:42energy around the room today. And you know, you were you were
- 0:44on one of the panel sessions first like this morning.
- 0:47And there was an interest. It was an interesting talk
- 0:50because we were speaking about diversity, but not about gender
- 0:54diversity or social diversity in any in that way.
- 0:58Except that did obviously crop up because it is the theme of
- 1:01the conference. But instead we were speaking
- 1:03about how different technologies are going to clump together to
- 1:07form our journey to Net 0. Now Expo had a really
- 1:11interesting announcement just this morning, the day of the
- 1:14event. We, we found out that you're
- 1:16working with the Northern Endurance Partnership, probably
- 1:20EU KS furthest along CCS project, I think it's fair to
- 1:23say. Can you tell me a little bit
- 1:25about the well intervention testing that you're doing there?
- 1:27Yeah. So, so NEP is going to be a huge
- 1:29project in the UK. It's, it's one of the first two
- 1:32projects that's actually reached FID, which is funded partly
- 1:36through the government, £22 billion that was pledged to CCOS
- 1:40in the UK. There's going to be a big scope
- 1:42of work starting probably next year whereby wells will be
- 1:46drilled and they will be tested to understand the properties of
- 1:50the reservoir and to see whether it's actually going to be
- 1:54physically practically possible to inject CO2 at scale into that
- 1:58reservoir. If if those tests pass, which we
- 2:01hope they do, then it's going to move on to a field development
- 2:04to actually drill the CO2 injector wells.
- 2:06So you're testing 2 wells that are currently on the endurance
- 2:09field, correct? That that's correct.
- 2:11So we're, we're going to be mobilizing with an integrated
- 2:14well testing service, including surface well testing packages,
- 2:18fluid sampling analysis, download tools and data Yeah, to
- 2:22help support that operation. And are you planning to to head
- 2:25back out once the Noble Innovator has done its thing
- 2:28next year and drilled those six wells?
- 2:30I, I believe so. I think we we're certainly
- 2:32speaking with our partners and the operators to see how we can
- 2:35support that operation. Too Now today CCUS got brought
- 2:39up. We've just had a little bit of
- 2:40background on some of the work Expo does in CCS.
- 2:44It's been doing work for quite some time.
- 2:46You've already been working with Ecuador, which is one of the
- 2:49three firms on NEP in Northern Lights.
- 2:52You've done that a good few years ago.
- 2:54But CCUS got brought up today and we were speaking about
- 2:58emissions reduction, speaking about how it interacts with
- 3:01other technologies. And you, you describe the
- 3:04hierarchy of carbon emissions as avoid, reduce, replace,
- 3:10mitigate. And then you added one reverse,
- 3:13which I guess we've applied to CCUS.
- 3:16Do you mind just describing that that whole hierarchy?
- 3:19I think, yeah, I think when we put this into the context of net
- 3:22zero, we sometimes get lost along the way in, in terms of
- 3:27what we're actually trying to achieve.
- 3:28So, so net zero is essentially net zero CO2 or CO2 equivalent
- 3:33emissions entering the atmosphere.
- 3:35And we've set a date, a provisional date of 2050 to
- 3:37achieve as of course, if we do it quicker.
- 3:39Fantastic. Now there are so many ways you
- 3:42could manage emissions. Generally speaking, the the 1st
- 3:46and most obvious way and, and the lowest cost and simplest way
- 3:49actually is, is to don't, don't emit in the 1st place.
- 3:52Now a large part of that comes through behavioural changes or
- 3:56simple procedural changes. So the way we do things and the
- 3:58way we, we go about life. So I don't know how you go ahead
- 4:01today. You may have driven, you may
- 4:03have gotten on the bus or you may have car shed.
- 4:05Each of those options has a different, I guess it's a, it's
- 4:08a different social choice, which leads to a different emissions
- 4:11output. So it's the first thing we can
- 4:13do as a society is, is look at what we do on an individual
- 4:16local basis and look at that, that that's free, that's cheap,
- 4:18that's easy, that's accessible. That should be done.
- 4:22The next one is improve efficiency of existing things.
- 4:26So existing machinery, processors, operations, we, we
- 4:30can do that. And that's a great way to, to
- 4:32reduce carbon emissions. Of course we need to be looking
- 4:34at replacing fossil fuels with electricity.
- 4:38So that brings in renewable solar, wind, solar, hydro, and
- 4:43of course GF thermal is part of that equation in terms of base
- 4:45load power and nuclear has a part to play as well.
- 4:48So that that's kind of the top of the triangle and that's where
- 4:50the most impact could be made. Of course, probably should be
- 4:53made. I think the IEA indicates that
- 4:56around about 80% of emissions reductions will come from that,
- 5:00that top part of the triangle. So it's, it's super important,
- 5:03but if we go past there that there is an acceptance and an
- 5:06understanding for society really that we are going to continue to
- 5:10emit emissions into the future, CO2 emissions, let's say from
- 5:14from power or from heavy industry.
- 5:16Now if we're going to do that, which we are going to have to do
- 5:19because we need to support industries such as steel,
- 5:23cements, Petro chemicals which are going to continue to produce
- 5:27CO2, we need to mitigate that CO2 before it enters the
- 5:30atmosphere. And that's where CCUS or CCS
- 5:32comes into play. That's the process of capturing
- 5:34CO2 at the point source, processing it and storing it in
- 5:38the subsurface permanently underground.
- 5:41And the interesting thing you put there was the reversal.
- 5:44So CO2 abatement is going to have a huge part to play
- 5:49probably from now until 2050. And it's going to be part of the
- 5:52the climate management toolbox. I think it's quite a nice way to
- 5:56put it. But there's, there's also a
- 5:58concept called the carbon budget, which is the total
- 6:01amount of CO2 society can emit into the atmosphere to keep with
- 6:06this 1.5 warming scenario. And I read a report just this
- 6:09morning actually that we're going to blow that in three
- 6:12years. So we're going to exceed that
- 6:13budget, which means anything beyond that we need to be
- 6:18thinking about removing the CO2 to kind of keep within the
- 6:21budget and ultimately draw it down to get to kind of net 0.
- 6:26So I think up up until 2050, CCS is going to be used for carbon
- 6:30abatement. When we look from 2050 to 2100,
- 6:33it's going about going to be about carbon dioxide removals
- 6:36from the atmosphere. So that's the concept of direct
- 6:38air capture. So literally sucking CO2 out of
- 6:41the air with big fans or big hoovers, which sounds a bit
- 6:44crazy, but but it's something that probably will be needed at
- 6:47scale again. And also bioenergy with CCS,
- 6:50which is it's quite a neat concept where you, you trees
- 6:55sequester CO2 and you turn them into pellets.
- 6:58The pellets feed the power station, which generates energy.
- 7:01If you capture that CO2 and store it, that's actually a, a
- 7:05net negative cycle of Co of carbon.
- 7:08So that's a carbon dioxide removal technique.
- 7:09Too. That's that's really
- 7:11interesting. So it's just how how you sort of
- 7:13square that circle and you how you just described direct air
- 7:17capture as a Hoover and you described the idea of CCS as the
- 7:21net in net 0 during your talk this morning.
- 7:25And I thought that was a really apartment analogy.
- 7:27You know, if you think of it like fishing, you know, you sort
- 7:30of catch up. All those.
- 7:32All those CO2 fish and you take them away, right?
- 7:35That's, that's the idea. It was, it was quite an
- 7:37interesting way to put it, 'cause I think sometimes when
- 7:40you share news about CCS, like sometimes people are a bit like,
- 7:45what is it? Yeah, No, it's not, I wouldn't
- 7:47say smoke and mirrors, but I'd say we, we've got to, we've got
- 7:49to bring the public along in the understanding.
- 7:52And it's a journey. And I think to to some, to most
- 7:55probably it seems like a science experiment and a very expensive
- 7:58one at that. But I think you've got to put it
- 8:00into the context of the energy transition and, and we need to
- 8:02explain better what part CCS plays.
- 8:05And it's just, it's not understood enough.
- 8:07But essentially it's two parts, it's carbon abatement and carbon
- 8:10removals. The initial focus has to be
- 8:14carbon abatement and that's going to continue to the future.
- 8:16That's not a a stop gap because like I say that the Heavy
- 8:19Industries are going to continue to manufacture and live into the
- 8:23future and that's going to support economic growth, jobs,
- 8:27manufacturing, trade. I mean the whole thing comes
- 8:29along with it. It's bigger than just one thing,
- 8:31but we need to start thinking about CO2 capture as a tool for
- 8:35energy management or sorry, climate management.
- 8:38But it's just one of many things where they all need to fit
- 8:41together and it's fitting together bit that it's difficult
- 8:43because, well, there are so many things we can say about that.
- 8:47But, but finance is 1, policy is 1 and working on a global scale
- 8:51is another. I mean, it's, it's a big, big
- 8:53challenge. I think one of the, one of the
- 8:54problems we face in the panel actually was we had this, this
- 8:57big question of what new technologies are going to be
- 9:02best to manage net 0 or something like that.
- 9:05And it went off on many, many tangents because it was such a
- 9:07big question, which is great, but but it, it requires this
- 9:12kind of top level helicopter view of, of energy systems
- 9:15thinking to, to weave it all together.
- 9:17And that I think is going to be the bigger challenge.
- 9:19The the technologies of course are are difficult and we need
- 9:22money to to evolve them and to get to get them to a commercial
- 9:25state. But I really think it's how they
- 9:28interconnect with each other that's going to be the key to
- 9:30solving this, this challenge of society.
- 9:32But investment is a big part of the energy transition.
- 9:36It's a big question mark right now.
- 9:38There's a lot of private capital investment that's, you know,
- 9:42ready to go into sectors like CCS like hydrogen, geothermal,
- 9:47wind, so on and so forth, particularly CCS because as you
- 9:52say, it's, it's sort of unproven.
- 9:53It still feels like a bit of a science experiment to some.
- 9:57There was a talk on the panel about sort of push, you know,
- 10:01for government initiatives and government policy to provide
- 10:05that investor confidence because otherwise these these
- 10:08opportunities are going to slip through our fingers, right?
- 10:11I'll just stop you there for a second.
- 10:13CCS isn't unproven, it's just not proven at industrial scales.
- 10:18So, So currently we capture globally about 50 in the, in the
- 10:22region, 50 million tons of CO2 per year.
- 10:25We need to go from megatons to gigatons.
- 10:27So, so millions to billions. That's what I'm trying to say.
- 10:31But but it is proven. I mean the technology is all
- 10:33there discreetly. So we can capture CO2, we can
- 10:35separate CO2, we can compress it and transport it and store it.
- 10:38But it's connecting it together in terms of a chain.
- 10:41That's the challenge. And it's kind of that that cross
- 10:43chain risk and how to get everyone working together and
- 10:45thinking together and getting separate industries to talk to
- 10:48each other, which in in itself is a challenge.
- 10:50Coming on to your investment point, I think the government
- 10:55and public money does have a big part to play.
- 10:59And that's what we're seeing here in the UK.
- 11:01And the government have pledged £22 billion to CCS for these
- 11:05track one projects, predominantly to get things off
- 11:08the ground. And there's a, there's an
- 11:09acceptance here that the market, whilst it should be
- 11:12self-sustaining the future, isn't going to start that way
- 11:14and it can't start that way. And private investment simply
- 11:17can't take that risk. They can't have that capital
- 11:21exposure because at the moment it's a, it's a loss making
- 11:23market. If you think about CO2, how we
- 11:26see it today, that there's no intrinsic value to it.
- 11:28So we've got to stimulate a market so we can trade it.
- 11:31But until that point, until the market's strong enough that the
- 11:35position we're in right now and we probably will be in for a few
- 11:37years, is that the cost of capture is high and the price of
- 11:41carbon is low and there's a gap. And that that doesn't make good
- 11:44business sense to big companies investing in this space.
- 11:47So what the government are doing are are pledging money to
- 11:49support the growth of the industry in the initial stages
- 11:52and to close that gap to give revenue assurance and and
- 11:56assurance of returns to the investors who are who are
- 11:58supporting the industry and the growth of it.
- 12:01That the UK government in particular have done a good job.
- 12:04They've done a good job with putting down some pretty solid
- 12:07foundations in terms of regulations and policy on how
- 12:11we're going to manage the system moving forwards.
- 12:13And they've got a view of simulating market upfront and
- 12:16then between now and 2035. So in the next 10 years
- 12:20transitioning to a fully self supporting self-sustaining
- 12:24carbon market, which is fantastic.
- 12:26And, and I think something really interesting happened a
- 12:29couple of weeks back was that we saw Black Rock invest in the Eni
- 12:34high net projects. And I think they they took about
- 12:38a 50% share or maybe just under a 50% share, which is a great
- 12:41sign to the market that actually this is an investable long term
- 12:46market or industry that people can actually profit from.
- 12:50And I think when you're talking in the investment sphere or two
- 12:54private companies, I mean, it comes down to the business case.
- 12:57You have to be able to craft a commercial model to make it
- 13:01investable. And, and this is the challenge.
- 13:03We're dealing with a waste product with no intrinsic value
- 13:06and we're trying to craft it as a business that's profitable in
- 13:09the future. And there's a disconnect.
- 13:10But I think, I think the signs are looking good.
- 13:13The not only the UK, but in Europe, certain other places
- 13:17around the world too. But those two, these, these two
- 13:20places where we are in, in Northern Europe seem to be the,
- 13:22the leading light and it's backed by kind of a compliance
- 13:25market as opposed to a incentive based market, which is the
- 13:28difference between the UK and the US.
- 13:30But but yeah, I, I think we're moving in the right direction
- 13:33and, and the private investment from BlackRock and High Net is
- 13:36it's a very good scientific market and, and hopefully others
- 13:39will follow suit. You know, I, I want to touch on
- 13:42something else that you spoke on spoke on.
- 13:44I was trying to come up with a clever segue and I've just given
- 13:46up. I'm just not not going to try.
- 13:48Maybe I'll try. Let's see, so you talk about
- 13:51geothermal and you know, the, the use case for in, in Europe
- 13:56and specifically the UK is, is geothermal facing a similar, a
- 14:01similar situation? Because we, you know, we don't
- 14:03have much of A market for that, especially in the UK.
- 14:06There's maybe one or two, you know, test cases, but there's
- 14:09not a lot, right? It's an interesting point.
- 14:11I think you're right. Currently there is no geothermal
- 14:14market in the UK. What what we do have is very,
- 14:17very small scale. So there's a district heating
- 14:19system in Southampton that not many people know about.
- 14:21But but it does exist. It's existed for for many years,
- 14:24I think probably 20 years plus. I think it's made in the 80s.
- 14:27But it demonstrates what could be done with geothermal.
- 14:29I think geothermal possibly is misunderstood as an industry and
- 14:34it's been around for forever. I mean, if you think about what
- 14:36it is, it's, it's generating heat or power from hot rocks.
- 14:39Now the world is hot, there's heat within the earth.
- 14:43So it's it's been a natural resource for for as long as
- 14:45time. I think it's been misunderstood
- 14:47in what we can do with it as society.
- 14:49And it's based largely on the geology.
- 14:51So people think of geothermal as power production, so they think
- 14:55of big plants and electricity generation.
- 14:57But geothermal could mean many different things.
- 14:59So you could have shallow geothermal for district heating.
- 15:02So you combine relatively warm water, but not super warm water,
- 15:06like 20 to 30° C with heat pumps, ground source heat pumps.
- 15:11And that can generate local heating and hot water.
- 15:14And if you think about one of the challenges with getting to
- 15:17net zero, the the things that are going to stop the UK, as I
- 15:21read in a different report, I've been reading a lot of reports,
- 15:24really, yeah. Is that the two things that are
- 15:26going to challenge us are transportation and buildings.
- 15:30Now with the building side of things, geothermal district
- 15:33heating and local heat networks could actually solve that
- 15:35problem. And the great thing is you don't
- 15:37need to go deep, you need to go shallow and just have a heat
- 15:40differential. So the heat pump works.
- 15:42And this is something that could, I think work at scale.
- 15:44Now how to get that off the ground is again, a challenge
- 15:47because to me, in my mind, it works on public buildings.
- 15:51So universities, hospitals, MOD schools, council buildings, that
- 15:57that's where it would work. And that would require, of
- 15:59course, public funding. I think when you look at the
- 16:03kind of the commercial market behind it you, you're basically
- 16:06competing against wholesale gas prices for heating.
- 16:09So I'm not sure how that would work.
- 16:10But but I was in an event the other week where this was all
- 16:14being discussed and there were banks in the rooms in, in the
- 16:19room on a panel and they were saying, look, guys, we want to
- 16:22invest in geothermal. We we want the projects to be
- 16:24presented to us. But we're not going to take that
- 16:26that initial upfront capital risk of drilling a well in case
- 16:30it doesn't work that that's not our business.
- 16:31First of all, the value is too small and also that's, that's
- 16:35not our risk profile. We're looking at big projects,
- 16:37long term investment for long term returns.
- 16:40So it's it's a question of who, who funds that initial
- 16:43development. Some of the room actually that
- 16:46the government folk in the room suggested it might have been
- 16:48industry because it fits with the oil and gas risk profile for
- 16:51exploration wells and industry thought it might have been a job
- 16:56for the government. So there isn't quite a way
- 16:58forwards, but I think we're we're, again, you spoke about
- 17:01the European market earlier that that is about, as I understand,
- 17:04at least 15 to 20 years ahead of us in terms of district heating.
- 17:07And there's a big movement now from the likes of Germany and
- 17:10Holland and Denmark and France to kick on with this.
- 17:13But the reason the Netherlands has a geothermal market more
- 17:17advanced than ours isn't because of the geology.
- 17:19The rocks are pretty much the same.
- 17:20They're not super hot rocks, but they're great for district
- 17:22heating. They have to heat the
- 17:24greenhouses so they can produce the crops.
- 17:28They were doing that by using gas to produce heat, which of
- 17:31course wasn't very efficient. It didn't make any sense.
- 17:33And actually they were using CO2 and they still do to actually
- 17:36pump CO2 and heat that way too. So it's kind of a, a use of use
- 17:40of CO2 in that sense. But it's it's a kind of an
- 17:44adjacent almost unconnected industry in agriculture.
- 17:47Stimulated the geothermal district heating market in
- 17:49Holland. And that's the reason they're
- 17:50further ahead than us as opposed to the geology.
- 17:53And because of that, the governments, they have then
- 17:56incentivise investment in geothermal projects, which is
- 17:58then move the market forward. So it's a little bit convoluted,
- 18:01but there's no reason I guess on paper technically or we couldn't
- 18:04have a similar system or set up in the UK.
- 18:06Sounds like it's a, it's a question of support and demand.
- 18:09In that case, you know, you've got to have the support from
- 18:12either industry or government, but also the the key, the use
- 18:17case in the form of greenhouses in Denmark and in the UK it
- 18:21could be, yeah, hospitals or, you know, council buildings,
- 18:25whatever it may be. You spot on.
- 18:26It's, it's the use case, it's people first understanding the
- 18:29industry, what the industry can bring to the market and then
- 18:32having a use case and then having that, that, that, that
- 18:34first mover buy into it and then you see the success and then you
- 18:38can build on that. We I don't report that much on
- 18:41geothermal, mainly because my focus is on the UK so there's
- 18:44not much I can speak about. So forgive me if I'm wrong, but
- 18:48you know, the UK has an expertise in drilling wells, in
- 18:53servicing wells. Well, we were just speaking
- 18:55about the Northern Endurance Partnership and the work you're,
- 18:57you're doing to, to test wells. And yeah, we've, we've got firms
- 19:01like Expo and your competitors. We've got a wealth of knowledge
- 19:05on, on drilling and maintaining wells.
- 19:07So surely like you know, we have, we have the expertise
- 19:09ready to go on that. No, you're right.
- 19:12I mean, we, we as a service, as the service sector, as part of
- 19:14the service sector, we, we are ready to support that that
- 19:17industry as a service company, we don't drive the market.
- 19:22We react to the market and respond to the market.
- 19:24So, so I think it's a service sector we are ready to go the
- 19:27drilling, the testing, the completions, the operations.
- 19:31I don't think that's so much of a challenge.
- 19:33I think it's the market stimulation that's the challenge
- 19:36in this case. And do you see, do you see that,
- 19:38that response from places like, you know, the NHS, the, the, you
- 19:44know, local councils? Do you do you see them seeing a
- 19:48a use case for this? Do you see that that?
- 19:50Engagement, yeah, I mean, personally, I don't know, that's
- 19:53kind of outside of my expertise. But I, I wonder if the
- 19:57conversation has been had with them, as in we're having this
- 20:00conversation now and I've had it with a few people today and it's
- 20:04kind of a light bulb moment. It's like, oh wait, we we've got
- 20:07free heating, so that means we're not going to get cold in
- 20:09the winter and it's not going to cost us anything.
- 20:12That sounds like a great plan. Why aren't we all doing it?
- 20:14And, and that conversation I think needs to be had probably
- 20:17at a, a very senior level in government.
- 20:19Then it needs to filter down. And actually there was an MP
- 20:21there last week at this geothermal event and he was the
- 20:25the advocate, the, the MP advocate, the political advocate
- 20:28for geothermal. So hopefully he continues to
- 20:31gain traction. Hopefully that trickles back to
- 20:34to Westminster. Well, I think that that wraps up
- 20:37all the talking points we had on on the show floor from Expo
- 20:40today. We had carbon capture, hoovers
- 20:43and hot rocks for heating. And that I think I think that
- 20:46wraps up the the conversations. Thank you very much, James, for
- 20:49joining me and thank you very much for listening.
- 20:52If you'd like to stay up to date with all the comings and goings
- 20:55from the show floor right here at Women in New Energy 2025,
- 20:59stay tuned to Energy Voice Out Loud.