Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use the Spotlight Effect to Build Influence at Work
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's a moment in every career where you get offered something that looks like a trap. A project everyone else has quietly stepped away from. Maybe it's an underfunded initiative, maybe it's a client relationship that's gone sour, maybe it's a product launch with no budget. Luna: The thing nobody wants to touch. Lucas: Exactly. And conventional wisdom says: avoid it. Don't touch the hot potato. But there's a really interesting argument — backed by some actual psychology — that sometimes the smartest political move you can make is to voluntarily take that assignment. To step into the spotlight when everyone else is stepping back. Luna: Let me guess — this is where the 'spotlight effect' comes in. Lucas: It is. And I want to ground this in a real example. There's a mid-sized tech company — we'll call it Nexus Software, not its real name — and back in early 2025 they had a product called Nexus Sync. It was a file-sharing tool aimed at enterprise clients. And it was failing. Lucas: The beta metrics were terrible. The engineering team kept missing milestones. The product manager who had been leading it quit in frustration. And for about six weeks, nobody internal wanted to touch it. It was seen as a career graveyard. Luna: Right, because if you take it on and it fails, that failure is visible. It's attached to your name. Lucas: Exactly. But here's where it gets interesting. A mid-level product manager named Sarah — not her real name either — volunteered to take it over. And when I heard about this, I thought, that's either incredibly brave or incredibly naive. So I dug into what happened. Luna: What was her logic? Lucas: She told me she saw the project as a platform, not a poison pill. Her thinking was: everyone is watching this project. It's the thing the CEO brings up in every all-hands. It's the thing the board asks about. So if I can make even modest progress — not a home run, just credible improvement — that visibility becomes an asset. Luna: So she's betting that the attention itself is valuable, even if the outcome is messy. Lucas: That's exactly it. Psychologists call this the spotlight effect — it's the tendency to overestimate how much others notice us. But Sarah flipped it: she deliberately put herself in a high-visibility situation, knowing that people would notice her performance, good or bad. And she was betting on the upside. Luna: Did it work? Lucas: It did. She didn't turn Nexus Sync into a billion-dollar product. But she stabilized it. She got the engineering team to hit two consecutive milestones. She renegotiated with the biggest beta client and kept them on board. And within six months, she was promoted to director of product. Lucas: Her boss told me later: 'We promoted her because she was willing to take on the thing nobody else would. That's the signal we needed.' Luna: So the signal is courage. But also competence — she actually delivered. Lucas: Right. And that's the key nuance. The spotlight effect only works if you have a reasonable shot at making things better. If the project is truly doomed — if the market has moved on, if the technology is obsolete, if the political support isn't there — then stepping into the spotlight just means failing in public. So you have to do a ruthless assessment first. Luna: What's the assessment question you'd ask? Lucas: I'd ask: is there a plausible path to a win, even if it's not a grand slam? Can I define a smaller win that still looks credible? In Sarah's case, she didn't need to make Nexus Sync the market leader. She just needed to stop the bleeding and show forward momentum. That was a win her bosses could see. Luna: So it's about redefining success for yourself within the project. Lucas: Yes. And that's a political move in itself. Because if you can set a reasonable yardstick — and then meet it — you've demonstrated judgment as well as execution. The people above you see that you understand the difference between a real turnaround and a salvage operation. Luna: I'm thinking about the flip side though. What about people who are already in the spotlight too much? Like, the person who always volunteers for every visible task. Doesn't that start to look desperate? Lucas: It can. The spotlight effect works best when you're selective. If you say yes to every high-profile assignment, two things happen. One, you stretch yourself thin and your performance slips. Two, you signal that you're hungry for visibility in a way that can come across as needy. The key is to pick the one or two projects where the spotlight is already bright, and where you have a genuine angle. Luna: So it's scarcity. You want to be the person who steps up when it matters, not the person who's always in the frame. Lucas: Exactly. And there's research on this. A 2021 study in the Journal of Applied Psychology looked at what they called 'voluntary task assignment' and found that employees who selectively took on high-visibility, high-risk tasks were rated higher in leadership potential by their supervisors — but only if they also had a track record of delivering on their core responsibilities. Luna: So you can't just be the person who volunteers. You have to also be the person who does their day job well. Lucas: Right. The spotlight project is a supplement, not a substitute. If your core work is slipping, taking on a visible project just exposes that more. Luna: Let me ask about another angle. What if you're in a workplace where the culture doesn't reward visibility? Like, a more collaborative or consensus-driven environment? Lucas: That's a sharp question. And it matters a lot. In some organizations — particularly in parts of Europe or in very flat startups — taking a visible solo role can actually be seen as grandstanding. You have to read the culture first. Lucas: But even in those environments, there's usually a version of this that works. Maybe it's taking on a visible role in a cross-functional team. Maybe it's volunteering to present the team's findings to leadership. The spotlight doesn't have to be a solo spotlight. It can be a shared one. Luna: So you're still getting the visibility, but you're framing it as service to the team. Lucas: Exactly. You become the person who steps up to represent the group, not the person who steps over the group. That's a subtler political move, but it's powerful. Because now you're seen as both competent and collaborative. Luna: I want to go back to something you said earlier — about the spotlight effect being a psychological bias. How do you keep yourself from overestimating how much people will notice your success? Because if you take on a visible project and do great work, but people are distracted, you might not get the payoff. Lucas: That's a real risk. The spotlight effect cuts both ways. People overestimate how much others notice them, but they also overestimate how much others will remember. So you can't just do the work and hope people see it. You have to be intentional about making the work visible. Lucas: That means regular updates. It means sharing progress in meetings. It means finding ways to let your boss and your boss's boss know what's happening — without being obnoxious about it. There's a line between keeping people informed and self-promotion, and you have to walk it carefully. Luna: So it's not just about doing the assignment. It's about managing the narrative around it. Lucas: Exactly right. And that's where a lot of people stumble. They do the hard work, they deliver results, but they assume the results speak for themselves. In a busy organization, results rarely speak for themselves. You have to amplify them. Luna: I think that's actually a good point to pause on, because a few listeners have written in asking how we keep this show going without ads or sponsors. And I think it's a similar kind of thing — we do the work, but we also have to be intentional about making it sustainable. Lucas: Yeah, that's a fair connection. And look, a handful of listeners already chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's literally what funds making this many episodes. It's not a big ask — just that if the show's helped you think through a career move or a workplace decision, that link is there. Luna: And it keeps the show completely independent. No sponsors to satisfy, no algorithm to chase. Just us and the topic. Lucas: Exactly. So if that resonates, you know where to find it. But back to the spotlight effect — because I want to leave listeners with a practical framework. Luna: Good. Because the theory is interesting, but the application is what matters. Lucas: So here's a simple three-question test before you volunteer for that high-visibility project. Question one: Is this project genuinely important to the people who make decisions about my career? If the answer is no, the spotlight is wasted. Luna: Second question? Lucas: Question two: Do I have a realistic path to a visible win — even a modest one? If the project is so broken that no amount of effort can produce progress, you're just setting yourself up for a public failure. Luna: And the third? Lucas: Question three: Can I afford the time and energy without letting my core responsibilities slip? Because if your day job suffers, the spotlight will just expose that. Luna: So important, important, important. All three have to be yes. Lucas: All three. And if they are, you might just have found the kind of assignment that builds real political capital. Not by avoiding risk, but by stepping into it — deliberately, selectively, and with a plan. Luna: That's the kind of move that gets noticed. And remembered. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the whole point.