Latest / Killer Destinations / 201. MASTER MANIPULATOR OR VICTIM? Aaron Friar - Medford, OR 2017
Transcript
- 0:00[SPEAKER_00]: I'm Kathy with a C and I'm Kathy with a K and this is Killer Destinations.
- 0:09[SPEAKER_00]: Today's destination is Medford, Oregon.
- 0:12[SPEAKER_00]: Located in southern Oregon just twenty seven miles north of the California border, the city was established in eighteen eighty three to coincide with the arrival of the railroad.
- 0:23[SPEAKER_00]: Medford is the largest city in southern Oregon and is located in the rogue river valley known for its natural beauty and recreational opportunities.
- 0:33[SPEAKER_00]: It is also known for its pairs.
- 0:36[SPEAKER_00]: That's where Harry and David is located.
- 0:39[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, favorite.
- 0:40[SPEAKER_00]: I'm always pumped up when I get something from Harry and David.
- 0:42[SPEAKER_00]: It's also known for being the gateway to the Rogue Valley wine region, where it's surrounded by numerous wineries and vineyards to explore.
- 0:51[SPEAKER_00]: The city is also notable for being just an hour and a half drive from crater lake, a volcanic crater that is the deepest lake in the United States at one thousand nine hundred and forty nine feet.
- 1:04[SPEAKER_00]: Its proximity to this national park makes Medford a sought after destination for adventures and nature enthusiasts.
- 1:13[SPEAKER_00]: and maybe the biggest claim to fame, and I love this one, is that it's rumored that Bigfoot has been there.
- 1:19[SPEAKER_00]: In fact, the world's only known Bigfoot trap lies in our very own Rogue Valley, a local minor claim to have found human-like tracks in his garden that were over foot and a half long.
- 1:33[SPEAKER_00]: So in nineteen seventy four, the now defunct North American wildlife research team built the big foot trap and kept it baited with carcasses for six years.
- 1:45[SPEAKER_01]: I hope they were animals they found in the forest.
- 1:48[SPEAKER_01]: Or like roadkill.
- 1:49[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I hope the same thing.
- 1:51[SPEAKER_00]: But not surprisingly, the trap never caught big foot.
- 1:54[SPEAKER_00]: In two thousand six, the US Forest Service repaired the dilapidated trap.
- 2:00[SPEAKER_00]: and it has become a popular tourist attraction for the last thirty years.
- 2:05[SPEAKER_00]: Do they say if they stock it with carcasses too?
- 2:07[SPEAKER_00]: They no longer stock with carcasses.
- 2:09[SPEAKER_00]: But couldn't you see rogue residents stocking it with carcasses?
- 2:12[SPEAKER_00]: Absolutely.
- 2:13[SPEAKER_00]: Just because, yeah, especially teenage boys on the weekend, totally.
- 2:16[SPEAKER_00]: But in two thousand seventeen, one of Medford's residents went missing.
- 2:22[SPEAKER_00]: And one thing the police knew for sure was that the perpetrator was not big foot.
- 2:32[SPEAKER_01]: It was Monday night in mid-October of two thousand seventeen, when Sierra Freyer, who was eleven, and her younger sister Olivia, who was eight, were spending the night at their dad's house along with their older sister Ellie, who was fifteen.
- 2:46[SPEAKER_01]: Now, the girls' father and mother were divorced, and so they kind of switched back and forth between the parents, and this was the night that they were staying with their father, Erin.
- 2:56[SPEAKER_01]: In the middle of the night, the middle child Sierra, the eleven year old, was startled from sleep.
- 3:02[SPEAKER_01]: And you know how you do sometimes where you wake up and you don't know why and so you just kind of sit there and listen.
- 3:08[SPEAKER_01]: So that's what she was doing but she heard her dad swear and then she heard a glass break and so she assumed something like that had woken her up earlier and no harm no foul.
- 3:16[SPEAKER_01]: But she still laid a wake for about an hour because she was just listening to the sounds of the house, right?
- 3:22[SPEAKER_01]: Because you do, you get that like scared startle and it's hard to settle down.
- 3:25[SPEAKER_01]: Like, what is this?
- 3:27[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.
- 3:27[SPEAKER_01]: But once she didn't hear anything, she was like, okay, time for me to go to sleep again.
- 3:31[SPEAKER_01]: But she wasn't able to.
- 3:33[SPEAKER_01]: So at about six, fifteen, she got up and went to go find her dad and her sister, because her sister wasn't in the room with them.
- 3:38[SPEAKER_01]: So when she walked out into the living room and went over to the couch, she noticed that there was something that was splattered on the walls.
- 3:46[SPEAKER_01]: and on the couch.
- 3:48[SPEAKER_01]: So she put her hand down on the couch to kind of figure out what it was, maybe that was the glass that broke.
- 3:52[SPEAKER_01]: But when she drew her hand back, it was blood.
- 3:56[SPEAKER_01]: And then she realized what was on the wall and on the floor was also blood.
- 4:02[SPEAKER_01]: So she ran into her dad's room and he wasn't there and neither was her sister Ellie.
- 4:07[SPEAKER_01]: This is the fifteen-year-old older sister.
- 4:09[SPEAKER_01]: So she's kind of freaking out at this point, understandably.
- 4:11[SPEAKER_01]: All she has with her now is an eight-year-old.
- 4:13[SPEAKER_01]: So the first thing she did was she called her dad's girlfriend, a woman named Michelle, and said, my dad and Ellie are missing.
- 4:20[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know what to do.
- 4:21[SPEAKER_01]: Michelle said, it's okay.
- 4:22[SPEAKER_01]: I'm gonna come over.
- 4:23[SPEAKER_01]: Let's just figure out what's going on.
- 4:25[SPEAKER_01]: And so she did.
- 4:26[SPEAKER_01]: Michelle was over there.
- 4:27[SPEAKER_01]: And when she saw the scene and the copious amounts of blood, Michelle took Sierra and eight-year-old Olivia, and they went over to the mom's house.
- 4:38[SPEAKER_00]: who was just a couple blocks away.
- 4:39[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 4:40[SPEAKER_01]: And so this is the mom of all three girls, Ellie and Sierra and Olivia.
- 4:44[SPEAKER_01]: So they go over there, they tell the mom what happened and the first thing the mom did was she called nine one one.
- 4:50[SPEAKER_01]: And she said, okay, something's going on.
- 4:52[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know what happened, but my ex has been and my oldest daughter are missing.
- 4:57[SPEAKER_01]: So they sent police out to do a welfare check at the same time that they sent out a missing person's alert for fifty year old Aaron Freyer and his fifteen year old daughter, Ellie.
- 5:07[SPEAKER_01]: So when police arrived for the welfare check cath, they showed body cam on several of the different things that I watched.
- 5:13[SPEAKER_01]: And what it showed was the police officers walking into the front door.
- 5:17[SPEAKER_01]: And there was significant blood spatter on everything.
- 5:22[SPEAKER_01]: It was all over the walls.
- 5:23[SPEAKER_01]: It was all over the floor.
- 5:25[SPEAKER_01]: There was a lot of blood on the couch.
- 5:27[SPEAKER_01]: It was actually there was a big puddle next to it.
- 5:29[SPEAKER_01]: And the couch seemed to have a lot of blood already in it.
- 5:31[SPEAKER_01]: And then you hear one of the officers say to the other, is that brain matter?
- 5:36[SPEAKER_01]: And the guy looked and said, yep, it's brain matter.
- 5:38[SPEAKER_01]: And the only reason I knew it was is because in the video, they blocked it out.
- 5:41[SPEAKER_01]: So you can see exactly.
- 5:43[SPEAKER_01]: So they knew that somebody had been significantly injured in the house.
- 5:46[SPEAKER_01]: They just didn't know who or if it was both Ellie and Erin.
- 5:51[SPEAKER_01]: Starting from the couch, they saw a blood trail that went from the couch out the front door onto a sidewalk.
- 5:57[SPEAKER_01]: And then from the sidewalk, it went back through a gate into kind of a dirt area, which is where a car is usually parked.
- 6:04[SPEAKER_01]: And they saw that's where the blood stopped.
- 6:07[SPEAKER_01]: And that's where the fresh tire tracks were because Erin's silver mercury marquee was missing.
- 6:18[SPEAKER_00]: So at seven, forty in the morning, the med for police dispatch the major assault and death investigation unit to come to the home, start their forensic investigation and just get moving on things.
- 6:30[SPEAKER_00]: Officers immediately realized that the father's phone and the fifteen-year-old girl's phone, Ellie's phone, were at the house, so they couldn't track them.
- 6:40[SPEAKER_00]: As the scene is being processed, the investigators go to the mom's house where we have eleven-year-old Sarah.
- 6:48[SPEAKER_00]: Detectives began interviewing her and she starts telling them about how she heard these sounds.
- 6:54[SPEAKER_00]: She was afraid, she stayed in her bed, she listened, but at some point she looked out the window.
- 7:01[SPEAKER_01]: Well, she had seen shadows going by it, you know, like when somebody's breaking up the light that's outside and that's what had made her go look.
- 7:07[SPEAKER_00]: As she's looking out the window, she sees two boys.
- 7:11[SPEAKER_00]: One is her older sister's boyfriend and his name is Gavin, and another is a blonde boy that she doesn't recognize, but she gives a description to detectives as she's being interviewed.
- 7:22[SPEAKER_00]: Now that detectives know that Ellie is with her boyfriend, Gavin, they start tracking his phone.
- 7:29[SPEAKER_00]: and they immediately started getting hits in East Medford.
- 7:32[SPEAKER_00]: So detectives are going that way, but there's another group of detectives still looking for everything else.
- 7:37[SPEAKER_00]: Everything else attended to this missing person.
- 7:40[SPEAKER_00]: They find Aaron's vehicle about an hour later.
- 7:42[SPEAKER_00]: This is the mercury mark he that had been taken from the house.
- 7:45[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 7:46[SPEAKER_00]: Now this is where they suspect the bleeding person was placed.
- 7:50[SPEAKER_00]: But no one is inside the car.
- 7:54[SPEAKER_00]: There is blood, however, on the outside, on the bumper of the car.
- 7:57[SPEAKER_00]: So they know that something's out.
- 7:59[SPEAKER_00]: When you hate to be the one to open that trunk.
- 8:01[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, totally.
- 8:03[SPEAKER_00]: They're like, they know what they're going to find.
- 8:05[SPEAKER_00]: So they open the trunk and there's nothing there.
- 8:09[SPEAKER_00]: Just a heck of a lot more blood.
- 8:11[SPEAKER_00]: Lots of blood.
- 8:12[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 8:12[SPEAKER_00]: And lots of blood soaked into the carpet.
- 8:14[SPEAKER_00]: And the car was still warm.
- 8:16[SPEAKER_00]: So they knew that they were probably close.
- 8:20[SPEAKER_00]: Where was the car found?
- 8:21[SPEAKER_01]: It was just found off of a kind of rural road on the outskirts of Madford that looked like it had just been stashed somewhere among trees.
- 8:30[SPEAKER_00]: About an hour after finding the car and this was four hours after the missing persons report goes out, patrol officers see Gavin walking down the street, but he isn't alone.
- 8:42[SPEAKER_00]: He's with Ellie, and he's with the blonde boy that Sierra had described to a T. Since Ellie was safe, detectives obviously knew that the blood in the house and in the car belonged to her father, Erin, which obviously meant that if he were still alive, they were running out of time to find him.
- 9:01[SPEAKER_00]: So detectives take these three to the police station and they put them all in separate rooms as one does.
- 9:08[SPEAKER_00]: They actually put them in separate patrol cars too.
- 9:10[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, that makes sense.
- 9:11[SPEAKER_01]: They separated all three initially, detained them.
- 9:13[SPEAKER_01]: They weren't arrested.
- 9:14[SPEAKER_01]: They were detained, put in separate cars and then taken down into separate rooms.
- 9:18[SPEAKER_00]: Although sometimes they want people in the same car because it's, you know, being recorded.
- 9:22[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, just leave them there to sit for a minute while you go talk to somebody else.
- 9:25[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.
- 9:26[SPEAKER_01]: That's what I do.
- 9:29[SPEAKER_00]: So the first person police spoke to was the blonde boy that Sierra recognized as being with her sister's boyfriend as they walked past her window in the wee hours of the morning.
- 9:40[SPEAKER_00]: He told police his name was Mike, but the police knew it wasn't Mike because they had responded to a burglary call a few weeks prior.
- 9:50[SPEAKER_00]: And it was a burglary that had supposedly taken place at his grandparents' house
- 9:56[SPEAKER_00]: And the grandparents told police that they thought their grandson was stealing jewelry.
- 10:01[SPEAKER_00]: So police already knew that his name wasn't Mike.
- 10:05[SPEAKER_00]: His name was Russell Jones the second.
- 10:08[SPEAKER_00]: And Russell had spent the better part of his life in foster care.
- 10:12[SPEAKER_01]: Is that right?
- 10:13[SPEAKER_01]: He had and I didn't find any explanation for it where his parents were, why the grandparents didn't have custody, whatnot.
- 10:19[SPEAKER_01]: But he had spent the majority of his life in foster care.
- 10:22[SPEAKER_01]: When they put Russell the second into this interrogation room, they actually didn't stay and talk to him.
- 10:26[SPEAKER_01]: They left him where he was.
- 10:28[SPEAKER_01]: My guess is to think about his life choices.
- 10:30[SPEAKER_01]: I think they just wanted to see what he was going to do.
- 10:32[SPEAKER_01]: He knew there was a camera that was on.
- 10:34[SPEAKER_01]: He knew there was a microphone that was on and they just kind of left him there and they went to go look at the monitor in the bullpen of the detectives room.
- 10:41[SPEAKER_00]: He was bizarre because when the detectives were not in the room, he would look at the camera and say bizarre things.
- 10:50[SPEAKER_00]: He said it strangely.
- 10:53[SPEAKER_01]: At one point, he said something with a British accent.
- 10:55[SPEAKER_00]: But the tone of his voice was strange.
- 11:00[SPEAKER_00]: At one moment, it might be a little bit passive.
- 11:02[SPEAKER_00]: The next, it's very aggressive.
- 11:03[SPEAKER_00]: His facial expressions.
- 11:05[SPEAKER_01]: We changed from calm to like his face screwed up in anger.
- 11:09[SPEAKER_00]: It was almost like you were watching a play where somebody was overacting.
- 11:13[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, absolutely.
- 11:14[SPEAKER_00]: And it was disconcerting to watch this guy.
- 11:17[SPEAKER_00]: And he would say things like, I know everything I'm saying is being recorded and I'm saying these things on purpose.
- 11:23[SPEAKER_00]: So one of the things he said is we can do this the nice way and we can negotiate.
- 11:28[SPEAKER_00]: or we can do it the hard way and I could release my bipolar, which actually you don't want that.
- 11:33[SPEAKER_00]: Make a deal or I let out my bipolar, your choice.
- 11:37[SPEAKER_00]: I wish I could do justice to the way he was saying it.
- 11:40[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 11:41[SPEAKER_00]: Just the way it came out was so aggressive.
- 11:43[SPEAKER_01]: And creepy.
- 11:44[SPEAKER_01]: Like, you kind of felt like if somebody else was there with him, he would have unleashed his bipolar.
- 11:50[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, like it would be like, we can do this a nice way and negotiate.
- 11:55[SPEAKER_01]: Or we can do it the hard way and I'll let out my bipolar.
- 11:58[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 11:59[SPEAKER_01]: But he did it much creepier because I can't do that.
- 12:00[SPEAKER_00]: But you, you, you all put you in your bed.
- 12:03[SPEAKER_00]: You could if you tried.
- 12:04[SPEAKER_01]: I better have.
- 12:09[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, but it's like you're listening to him when you're like, is he acting or is this real?
- 12:13[SPEAKER_00]: Like so it was one of those funky situations.
- 12:15[SPEAKER_00]: But he did say too funny things.
- 12:17[SPEAKER_00]: Oh my god, yes, he did.
- 12:18[SPEAKER_01]: So one of them was looking at the camera again, like he's just having this conversation.
- 12:22[SPEAKER_01]: He said, Hey, I'm not the one with the donut fetish.
- 12:25[SPEAKER_01]: And I know you need coffee with your donuts, but I don't have that fetish.
- 12:29[SPEAKER_01]: And then I know I shouldn't laugh at this, especially dad's LAPD.
- 12:33[SPEAKER_00]: Your husband.
- 12:35[SPEAKER_01]: This is what it is.
- 12:36[SPEAKER_01]: He told a joke.
- 12:37[SPEAKER_01]: Someone's like a non-tax joke, but it wasn't.
- 12:38[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 12:39[SPEAKER_01]: What do you call it when a police car is being towed by a tow truck?
- 12:44[SPEAKER_00]: Pulled pork.
- 12:47[SPEAKER_00]: It was funny.
- 12:49[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 12:49[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 12:50[SPEAKER_00]: And it kind of came out of nowhere.
- 12:52[SPEAKER_00]: And it turns out that Russell, who was twenty-two years old at the time this all went down, actually did have bipolar disorder.
- 13:00[SPEAKER_01]: And wait, seven years older than Ellie too.
- 13:02[SPEAKER_01]: He was significantly older than she was.
- 13:04[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, just at that point.
- 13:05[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 13:06[SPEAKER_00]: And he was also autistic, but very high functioning anyway.
- 13:10[SPEAKER_00]: So he's waiting to have a conversation with the detectives.
- 13:14[SPEAKER_01]: And in the meantime, a female detective was in an interrogation room with Ellie Freyer.
- 13:20[SPEAKER_01]: This in some ways was even more bizarre than the one-sided conversation that Russell was having with the camera.
- 13:27[SPEAKER_01]: The female detective walked into the room and I'd love to call her by name, but in three different things that I watched or read, she had a different last name.
- 13:36[SPEAKER_01]: And we've actually seen this before, where on TV sometimes the detectives give a false name because obviously you don't want people tracking you down or whatnot, but I couldn't tell you what her name was, so it's just the female detective.
- 13:48[SPEAKER_00]: And a lot of times, the show's also give different names for like moms and dads, family members.
- 13:53[SPEAKER_00]: They just, they make up new names.
- 13:55[SPEAKER_01]: Right, even though if you read the newspaper, she'll find it.
- 13:57[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 13:57[SPEAKER_01]: That's actually how I found it that one time we did an episode on Karinot out of San Diego.
- 14:02[SPEAKER_01]: Amazing episode if you haven't seen it.
- 14:04[SPEAKER_01]: But the reason I found out that detective's name is that it was in the court records.
- 14:07[SPEAKER_01]: And so that kind of gave it away.
- 14:09[SPEAKER_00]: And you see other, like some other podcast, we'll take the actual wrong name.
- 14:13[SPEAKER_00]: And they're using it.
- 14:16[SPEAKER_00]: I don't think they realize it's not real.
- 14:17[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 14:17[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 14:18[SPEAKER_00]: They've got to cross reference those things.
- 14:19[SPEAKER_01]: But anyway, the records take side note.
- 14:21[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 14:21[SPEAKER_01]: They're the, they are the arbitrary standard for sure court records.
- 14:26[SPEAKER_01]: So when detective What's her name goes in to talk to Ellie.
- 14:30[SPEAKER_01]: She walked in and in a very kind voice.
- 14:32[SPEAKER_01]: You could tell she was trying to be a friend.
- 14:34[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, totally.
- 14:34[SPEAKER_01]: And we're going to do a dramatic re-enactment for you.
- 14:40[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, I'm ready.
- 14:41[SPEAKER_00]: She's Ellie, I'm Detective What's her name.
- 14:43[SPEAKER_00]: And you're gonna be shocked by this, but I've never had acting lessons.
- 14:46[SPEAKER_01]: You're gonna be shocked by this.
- 14:49[SPEAKER_01]: I have.
- 14:49[SPEAKER_01]: I'm just kidding.
- 14:51[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, so this is what happened.
- 14:53[SPEAKER_01]: Well, hello.
- 14:54[SPEAKER_01]: I'm Detective What's her name?
- 14:56[SPEAKER_01]: Can you tell me your name?
- 14:58[SPEAKER_01]: I have the right to remain silent.
- 15:00[SPEAKER_01]: Well, yes, in fact, you do, but I do need to know your name for legal reasons.
- 15:05[SPEAKER_00]: My name's Rain and I'm eighteen.
- 15:08[SPEAKER_00]: That's it.
- 15:08[SPEAKER_00]: That's all we're doing.
- 15:10[SPEAKER_00]: but that's what it was like in this the girl had a soft voice and she was looking directly in the detectives eyes and just and just like here I remember a little teeth yes exact for a little fifteen year old teeth well and that's what I thought was hysterical that at some point she hadn't caught on that they knew who she was and it took a little while
- 15:25[SPEAKER_00]: Well, because the detective was like letting her.
- 15:27[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 15:28[SPEAKER_00]: Well, letting her lie.
- 15:29[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
- 15:29[SPEAKER_01]: She's talking to Raine and she says to Raine.
- 15:32[SPEAKER_01]: She said, yeah, I won't call her Raine anymore.
- 15:35[SPEAKER_01]: But she said to Ellie, well, you know, you're here because this morning, your sisters told their mom about something that worried them.
- 15:44[SPEAKER_01]: And you know, when police went to your dad's house, they saw an awful lot of blood.
- 15:48[SPEAKER_01]: Do you know anything about this?
- 15:50[SPEAKER_01]: And Ellie said, it's my dad.
- 15:52[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 15:52[SPEAKER_01]: Talking and it's like, yeah, it's like trying to be just like a
- 15:56[SPEAKER_01]: And trying to sound innocent and babyish almost.
- 15:59[SPEAKER_01]: But the whole time, like being sincere and direct and loving.
- 16:04[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 16:05[SPEAKER_01]: So she's like, I don't have a clue.
- 16:07[SPEAKER_01]: Is everyone okay?
- 16:08[SPEAKER_01]: And then the detective was like, well, where were you last night?
- 16:11[SPEAKER_01]: And she said, I was staying with my mom.
- 16:13[SPEAKER_01]: And the detective was like, okay, look, we know that's not true because we talked to your mom.
- 16:18[SPEAKER_01]: So quit the effing lies, which is I think a quote.
- 16:22[SPEAKER_01]: And we need to know what's really happening.
- 16:24[SPEAKER_01]: And she said, okay, well, my mom and dad are divorced.
- 16:27[SPEAKER_01]: So typically I go back and forth between my mom and dad's house, but I try and stay with my mom a little bit more because my dad can be kind of abusive.
- 16:34[SPEAKER_01]: So the detective was like, tell me more.
- 16:37[SPEAKER_01]: And she said that she felt misunderstood by her father and that he treated her poorly.
- 16:41[SPEAKER_01]: So the Detective Astelli, this is actually one of my favorite parts.
- 16:45[SPEAKER_01]: The Detective Astelli, where were you today?
- 16:47[SPEAKER_01]: And Ellie replied out, and the Detective said, where out, out and about?
- 16:52[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 16:52[SPEAKER_01]: I was like, well, thank you for clarifying that.
- 16:54[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 16:55[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 16:55[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 16:55[SPEAKER_01]: Now that you've told me where you were, let's go on.
- 16:58[SPEAKER_01]: Then Ellie was asked, well, who were you with?
- 17:00[SPEAKER_01]: And again, she refused to give the name.
- 17:01[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, she was like, I don't want to say their names.
- 17:03[SPEAKER_01]: And didn't she say I don't have to say their names?
- 17:05[SPEAKER_01]: Or I don't have to tell you their name?
- 17:06[SPEAKER_00]: I don't remember if it was, I don't have to, or I don't want.
- 17:08[SPEAKER_00]: But here's the thing when I was watching the interview like I only saw like bits and pieces of the things that you saw, but I'm watching the interview and I'm thinking of myself what fifteen year old does an answer a detective's questions?
- 17:21[SPEAKER_01]: Who isn't scared in that office and in that room?
- 17:24[SPEAKER_00]: Ellie did not appear to be frightened.
- 17:27[SPEAKER_00]: You know, telling a detective that you have the right to remain silent.
- 17:30[SPEAKER_00]: You're not going to tell her where you were.
- 17:31[SPEAKER_00]: You're not going to tell her who you're with.
- 17:32[SPEAKER_00]: And she was, I'm telling you, she was looking her dead in the eye and making these deliveries.
- 17:37[SPEAKER_00]: And I was like, what fifteen year old behaves like that?
- 17:40[SPEAKER_01]: We'll see, and I can see at the beginning, it being kind of hutspa, right?
- 17:43[SPEAKER_01]: You're like, you're a sassy, fifteen year old.
- 17:44[SPEAKER_01]: You know better than adults, adults are stupid, whatnot.
- 17:47[SPEAKER_01]: But you don't look them in the eye and lie to them about everything for that long.
- 17:50[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 17:50[SPEAKER_00]: So like that's so confident.
- 17:51[SPEAKER_00]: I don't have to tell you.
- 17:52[SPEAKER_01]: I have to tell you.
- 17:53[SPEAKER_01]: I have to make sense.
- 17:54[SPEAKER_01]: That I could see.
- 17:55[SPEAKER_00]: Because she'd go in.
- 17:56[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 17:57[SPEAKER_00]: So the detective was like, okay, the jig is up, as you were saying, that was well.
- 18:01[SPEAKER_00]: Like, they had been in the interrogation room a long time before the detective really was like, okay, here's the deal.
- 18:09[SPEAKER_00]: But so I was, I'm not gonna say impressed, impressed isn't the right word.
- 18:13[SPEAKER_00]: Like, horrified, slash, impressed, slash, shocked.
- 18:18[SPEAKER_01]: I don't like impressed, but I know what you're trying to say.
- 18:20[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 18:20[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, just like, dang.
- 18:22[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 18:23[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know if I'd have that, you know, if I was going to see one, you know, not a fifteen.
- 18:26[SPEAKER_00]: No, but as an attorney, no.
- 18:28[SPEAKER_00]: Obviously, you're totally doing it.
- 18:29[SPEAKER_00]: But actually, there's a lot of adults who aren't attorneys who would not do that.
- 18:32[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 18:32[SPEAKER_00]: Like, you feel like you have an obligation to answer questions and all this kind of stuff.
- 18:36[SPEAKER_01]: Which you do not.
- 18:37[SPEAKER_00]: And that's why people line getting troubled.
- 18:39[SPEAKER_01]: But well, and it's why people say things they shouldn't, obviously, because they don't know that they can just say, I want to turn you.
- 18:44[SPEAKER_01]: I'm not talking to you.
- 18:45[SPEAKER_01]: And they just sit there and just, you know, after Diet Coke, right, and try and try and cigarettes.
- 18:50[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe some chocolate.
- 18:51[SPEAKER_01]: Not that I've done that.
- 18:52[SPEAKER_00]: Anyway, we like Japanese seas candy here.
- 18:55[SPEAKER_00]: We'll answer questions for food.
- 19:00[SPEAKER_01]: So then the detective asked Ellie about her boyfriend Gavin and said, hey, what does your dad think about Gavin?
- 19:06[SPEAKER_01]: And she said, oh, he doesn't like him.
- 19:09[SPEAKER_01]: And he told me I have to break up with him.
- 19:11[SPEAKER_01]: Why?
- 19:11[SPEAKER_01]: Ellie at fifteen was dating Gavin.
- 19:14[SPEAKER_01]: Who was nineteen years old?
- 19:18[SPEAKER_01]: Which go dad?
- 19:20[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, the dad was like having none of it.
- 19:22[SPEAKER_01]: So the detective was like, well, tell me more.
- 19:25[SPEAKER_01]: And she said, well, you know, like I said, my dad, I didn't like him.
- 19:28[SPEAKER_01]: Both my parents were really controlling, which I think means they were parents of a teenager.
- 19:32[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 19:32[SPEAKER_01]: And she said her dad was verbally and physically abusive.
- 19:35[SPEAKER_01]: And she actually said Kath that a few times when her dad got mad at her, he would grab her by the throat and push her up against the wall.
- 19:43[SPEAKER_01]: During this time, Ellie was talking in a very high-pitched kind of baby like, wow, what happened to him?
- 19:49[SPEAKER_01]: Type voice, which is just annoying.
- 19:52[SPEAKER_01]: But the detective then started to get real with her and tell her what they knew.
- 19:56[SPEAKER_01]: and Ellie's voice changed.
- 19:58[SPEAKER_01]: And it went from this to what do you want to know?
- 20:02[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, it wasn't that big a distinction, but it became much flatter.
- 20:05[SPEAKER_01]: She wasn't trying to fool her anymore.
- 20:07[SPEAKER_01]: She wasn't trying to put on the, like, I'm a little innocent baby doll.
- 20:10[SPEAKER_01]: It was, okay, things are real.
- 20:17[SPEAKER_00]: So the detective started telling Ellie, look, here's what we know.
- 20:22[SPEAKER_00]: We know that you were trying to move out with your boyfriend.
- 20:26[SPEAKER_00]: We know that you were taking clothes out of your house.
- 20:30[SPEAKER_00]: And so what they would do is they would pack a bunch of Ellie stuff into a bag and she would hand it to her boyfriend out of her bedroom window.
- 20:38[SPEAKER_00]: And they just did this slowly over the course of time.
- 20:41[SPEAKER_01]: And so it's been about a week I think that they had been doing that.
- 20:44[SPEAKER_00]: Was she weak?
- 20:44[SPEAKER_00]: I thought it was short, but it was not a day.
- 20:48[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 20:48[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, it would definitely not.
- 20:49[SPEAKER_00]: So basically, Ellie says, look, the situation with my dad has gotten worse and I'm looking for a way out.
- 20:56[SPEAKER_00]: So I started to plan to run away.
- 20:59[SPEAKER_00]: And that's, that's what you're saying.
- 21:01[SPEAKER_00]: So she tells the detective that morning they were taking sort of the last of her clothing and things to her boyfriend's house.
- 21:08[SPEAKER_00]: I have to assume he didn't live with his parents because you think like if you had a nineteen year old son who brought home a fifteen year old daughter would you allow that okay I agree with you but I don't I don't know I didn't see anything I wonder the same thing yeah like do his parents think she's eighteen
- 21:25[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, that's true.
- 21:26[SPEAKER_01]: He could have lied.
- 21:26[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know.
- 21:27[SPEAKER_00]: But she was in high school band.
- 21:29[SPEAKER_00]: Did she look like an eighteen year old?
- 21:30[SPEAKER_01]: She's the petunia.
- 21:31[SPEAKER_00]: She was little.
- 21:32[SPEAKER_01]: She's petite.
- 21:33[SPEAKER_00]: And so the detective's like, what were you doing out walking around with Gavin and Russell?
- 21:38[SPEAKER_01]: And she had like five thirty in the morning.
- 21:40[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, she's like, we had just taken the clothes out of my house and we were out and about getting food.
- 21:45[SPEAKER_00]: So after hours of talking and hours and hours.
- 21:48[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, the detective basically says to Ellie the blood all over the house is your father's and we know you know that and so Ellie basically comes clean.
- 22:01[SPEAKER_00]: And she tells the detective that Russell, the blonde guy, attacked her father with a machete.
- 22:08[SPEAKER_00]: And then she tells them where the machete could be found.
- 22:11[SPEAKER_00]: It could be found near the northern Walmart.
- 22:14[SPEAKER_00]: Ellie is telling the detective, look, it was all Russell.
- 22:18[SPEAKER_00]: And then the detective was like, were you in the room at the time?
- 22:20[SPEAKER_00]: And she says, no, I wasn't in the room at the time.
- 22:23[SPEAKER_00]: Well, where was Gavin?
- 22:24[SPEAKER_00]: Where was your boyfriend?
- 22:26[SPEAKER_00]: My boyfriend was outside putting clothes in the car.
- 22:30[SPEAKER_00]: So she basically said, but I heard screaming and I ran and she said, I have no idea if Gavin, my boyfriend, is in on it.
- 22:40[SPEAKER_00]: I was just trying to get out of the house.
- 22:43[SPEAKER_01]: So now that we know that Russell is perpetrator according to Ellie, the detectives are still listening in the bullpen to his ramblings and just thoughts.
- 22:53[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, exactly.
- 22:55[SPEAKER_00]: His jokes.
- 22:56[SPEAKER_01]: Actually, like we had talked about, do we play some of it on here so that people can listen to it?
- 23:01[SPEAKER_01]: But the problem is is that if it's not in context, if you can't see him, it's actually kind of hard to understand.
- 23:06[SPEAKER_01]: It's just like, why are they playing this?
- 23:08[SPEAKER_01]: But it was funny in a sad kind of way.
- 23:10[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, totally.
- 23:10[SPEAKER_01]: As the detectives are listening, Russell stops from talking about their donut fetish and telling police jokes to talking about what might have happened to Aaron.
- 23:20[SPEAKER_01]: And so the detectives are like, all right, you know what, maybe he's been in there long enough now.
- 23:24[SPEAKER_01]: Let's go see if he wants to talk.
- 23:25[SPEAKER_01]: So the investigators went into the room and Russell said, hey, I've got nothing to hide, but you know, I'll talk much easier if you may cigarette first.
- 23:34[SPEAKER_01]: The detective who called it smoking and joking, which I guess is something they try and do in terms.
- 23:40[SPEAKER_01]: I had no idea.
- 23:41[SPEAKER_00]: I don't say it probably really co-bosses that now that nobody could smoke anymore.
- 23:45[SPEAKER_01]: It's really a good point.
- 23:47[SPEAKER_01]: So the detective takes Russell out to where the detectives all go to have a smoke break.
- 23:53[SPEAKER_01]: And there are cameras out there, but there's no recording equipment.
- 23:55[SPEAKER_01]: So they're just talking, you can see them out there.
- 23:58[SPEAKER_01]: They go outside, the detective gives him a sige.
- 24:00[SPEAKER_01]: And that was pretty much all it took her rustled to open up and spill everything.
- 24:04[SPEAKER_01]: Totally.
- 24:05[SPEAKER_01]: It's kind of a cheap day.
- 24:06[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 24:06[SPEAKER_01]: They actually also got him McDonald's for lunch and he was trying to outside him now.
- 24:11[SPEAKER_01]: But you can't be excited at that point because how cold were those fries?
- 24:15[SPEAKER_00]: That's true.
- 24:16[SPEAKER_01]: That is an important part.
- 24:17[SPEAKER_00]: French fries are not good unless they are piping hot.
- 24:19[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 24:20[SPEAKER_01]: So what Russell told the detectives was that he and Gavin went over to Aaron Fryer's house.
- 24:24[SPEAKER_01]: This was about midnight.
- 24:25[SPEAKER_01]: So at about four a.m.
- 24:27[SPEAKER_01]: Ellie and Gavin were in her room and the dad caught him.
- 24:31[SPEAKER_00]: Where was Russell?
- 24:32[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know.
- 24:32[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 24:33[SPEAKER_01]: It was almost like he was telling this as a narrator.
- 24:35[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 24:35[SPEAKER_01]: My guess is he was there.
- 24:37[SPEAKER_01]: Anyway, so he said that he, and maybe he was in the room too, because I didn't get the impression that Aaron caught them doing anything.
- 24:43[SPEAKER_01]: More that like Gavin was in the room.
- 24:45[SPEAKER_01]: Like we had talked in the last episode, like boys weren't allowed upstairs.
- 24:48[SPEAKER_01]: Boys weren't allowed back where your bedrooms were.
- 24:50[SPEAKER_01]: So maybe that was just the thing.
- 24:51[SPEAKER_01]: Is it like, I don't care who you are.
- 24:52[SPEAKER_01]: You're a boy in my girl's bedroom and she's fifteen.
- 24:54[SPEAKER_00]: At four am, a nineteen year old and a fifteen year old girls bedroom is never good.
- 24:58[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.
- 24:59[SPEAKER_01]: So he said that Aaron comes in, sees Gavin and Ellie in there, probably Russell too.
- 25:04[SPEAKER_01]: So I guess Gavin starts fighting with him and is able to get the gun away at which point Ellie and Russell ran out of the room.
- 25:10[SPEAKER_01]: And Russell said, I don't know what happened after the gun went off.
- 25:13[SPEAKER_01]: I just ran.
- 25:15[SPEAKER_01]: The detective said, okay, look, if a gum went off, probably means Erin might not still be with us.
- 25:20[SPEAKER_01]: You gotta tell us where you dumped the body because I don't want some kid to be out there like playing or hiking or looking for their dog and to run across such a grizzly sight.
- 25:30[SPEAKER_01]: Can you take us to the body?
- 25:33[SPEAKER_01]: and Russell said, yep, happy to do it.
- 25:35[SPEAKER_01]: And he did, just like that.
- 25:37[SPEAKER_01]: So they drive a little ways out of town to where he had jumped the body.
- 25:40[SPEAKER_01]: It was down an embankment on kind of, it was a two lane highway in each direction, but there were trees on each side of it.
- 25:46[SPEAKER_01]: So it wasn't like a thick forest, but it was definitely a more rural area.
- 25:50[SPEAKER_01]: They get to the spot.
- 25:51[SPEAKER_01]: Russell says, stop, stop, pull over here.
- 25:53[SPEAKER_01]: This is where we dumped him.
- 25:54[SPEAKER_01]: The detective gets out of the car with Russell and they look over this embankment and down the embankment about twenty feet.
- 26:00[SPEAKER_01]: All the detective saw was a tarp.
- 26:02[SPEAKER_01]: It was a green tarp and he asked Russell, is that Aaron's body?
- 26:08[SPEAKER_01]: And he said, it is.
- 26:09[SPEAKER_01]: So they walked down, they pulled the tart back, and pulled a tinkerbell fleece blanket back, which I have to imagine belonged to one of the two little girls, probably the eight-year-old, and inside of it was Aaron Freyer.
- 26:21[SPEAKER_01]: He had clearly been beaten to death.
- 26:23[SPEAKER_01]: His face and body were a mess, but the worst part was his head, because it had clearly been hit so hard so many times, it was caved in.
- 26:34[SPEAKER_01]: And then up in the tree above it, about eight feet above it, was a bat.
- 26:38[SPEAKER_01]: Six hours after starting their search for Aaron Freyer, tragically his body was found, and there were no bullet wounds.
- 26:50[SPEAKER_00]: So Aaron Freyer was described as somebody who would do anything for you and share anything with you even though he didn't have a lot.
- 26:59[SPEAKER_00]: Do you know who that reminds me of your younger brother?
- 27:02[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, totally.
- 27:03[SPEAKER_01]: He is the kind of guy where if you needed a soda and he it was the very last soda he had.
- 27:09[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 27:10[SPEAKER_01]: He wouldn't he wouldn't even think about not giving it to you.
- 27:13[SPEAKER_00]: He's a super super generous person.
- 27:15[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, he absolutely is.
- 27:17[SPEAKER_00]: According to friends, Aaron, if you needed something fixed around your house, he was super handy and he would totally do it for you.
- 27:25[SPEAKER_00]: That is my younger brother.
- 27:26[SPEAKER_00]: He can do anything.
- 27:27[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.
- 27:27[SPEAKER_00]: He can, he could literally do anything.
- 27:30[SPEAKER_00]: Anything handy.
- 27:30[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, you need me to put in a cement patio.
- 27:32[SPEAKER_00]: Got it.
- 27:33[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, you want to rock wall?
- 27:35[SPEAKER_00]: Got it.
- 27:35[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 27:36[SPEAKER_00]: You need a new breaker box.
- 27:37[SPEAKER_00]: Got it.
- 27:38[SPEAKER_00]: And then my older brother can't do it.
- 27:41[SPEAKER_00]: He can't.
- 27:42[SPEAKER_00]: He can litigate the heck out of anything.
- 27:43[SPEAKER_00]: He's smart.
- 27:46[SPEAKER_00]: He's funny.
- 27:46[SPEAKER_00]: He's loyal as hell, but not handy.
- 27:49[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, not handy.
- 27:50[SPEAKER_01]: That's okay.
- 27:50[SPEAKER_01]: He doesn't need to be.
- 27:51[SPEAKER_00]: That's not my dad.
- 27:52[SPEAKER_00]: My dad's not handy.
- 27:53[SPEAKER_00]: Once Russell showed the detectives where Aaron's body was, they took him back to the station and they started saying, we need more information.
- 28:03[SPEAKER_00]: And he basically said, look,
- 28:06[SPEAKER_00]: None of this was my idea.
- 28:07[SPEAKER_00]: This was Ellie's idea.
- 28:10[SPEAKER_00]: And, by the way, I was lying about the gunfight.
- 28:13[SPEAKER_00]: I was lying about Gavin taking the gun from the dad, and, et cetera, et cetera.
- 28:17[SPEAKER_01]: Which they would have figured out anyway, once he was autopsy.
- 28:19[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, exactly.
- 28:21[SPEAKER_00]: So here's the crazy thing.
- 28:22[SPEAKER_00]: Russell tells the detectives that their plan was actually not to kill Erin.
- 28:30[SPEAKER_00]: The plan was to get chloroform, knock him out, tie him up, try to be.
- 28:36[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, put him in an RV, drive him to was it California?
- 28:39[SPEAKER_01]: California.
- 28:39[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, as we said, that today's destination meant for it was twenty seven miles north of the California state line.
- 28:44[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and so they were gonna take him to California, time to a tree, basically tell him he's been a bad dad for being abusive to his daughter, right?
- 28:52[SPEAKER_00]: And then they were gonna leave and then we're gonna go on their merry way.
- 28:55[SPEAKER_01]: Leave him to the elements.
- 28:56[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 28:56[SPEAKER_00]: But the animals.
- 28:57[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.
- 28:57[SPEAKER_00]: But the reason Russell and the gang, you know what?
- 29:01[SPEAKER_00]: Like Scooby and the gang.
- 29:02[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 29:02[SPEAKER_00]: Couldn't go through with this version of the plan is because you can't buy chloroform online anymore.
- 29:10[SPEAKER_00]: Dang it.
- 29:10[SPEAKER_00]: And this is how he said it.
- 29:12[SPEAKER_00]: He's like, well, we couldn't do that because you can't buy chloroform online anymore.
- 29:16[SPEAKER_00]: Like it was sort of like, oh, shucks.
- 29:17[SPEAKER_00]: And just like in the past, I don't know.
- 29:19[SPEAKER_00]: I could have gone all the chloroform online.
- 29:21[SPEAKER_00]: I know and I was like, oh my god, that's so crazy.
- 29:24[SPEAKER_00]: It's a little scary.
- 29:25[SPEAKER_00]: If that's in your Google search history, yeah, stay away from me.
- 29:29[SPEAKER_01]: Anyway, okay, well maybe you shouldn't be here.
- 29:34[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, but I wasn't going to use it for bad things.
- 29:37[SPEAKER_00]: So the detectives asked Russell why this had to happen.
- 29:42[SPEAKER_00]: Why did this happen?
- 29:43[SPEAKER_00]: Aaron seemed like a good guy, even though he was supposedly abusing Ellie.
- 29:49[SPEAKER_00]: And Russell said, we had to do this to protect Ellie.
- 29:53[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, he totally saw himself as like that was his role was to protect Ellie.
- 29:57[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 29:57[SPEAKER_01]: So now after Ellie and Russell, it is Gavin's turn.
- 30:01[SPEAKER_01]: And the detectives, though, they weren't kind of pussy footing around with him.
- 30:05[SPEAKER_01]: They walked in and they said, look, Russell took us to Aaron's body.
- 30:09[SPEAKER_01]: We have people out there recovering him and we know that he's deceased.
- 30:12[SPEAKER_01]: And they said, look, we know you went over to the house to get Elliot of a bad situation.
- 30:16[SPEAKER_01]: This is no longer a matter of when it happened, where it happened, or even who was involved.
- 30:23[SPEAKER_01]: It was now a matter of why did this happen.
- 30:26[SPEAKER_01]: Gavin told detectives that a couple of weeks prior
- 30:30[SPEAKER_01]: He and Ellie had been at Gavin's residence when Aaron showed up.
- 30:34[SPEAKER_01]: And he was banging on the door and telling him to open the door because he wanted to kill him all these types of things.
- 30:39[SPEAKER_01]: He may have found out, by the way, because this was something that we also discovered around this time.
- 30:44[SPEAKER_01]: Aaron had actually reported Gavin to the police for statutory rate.
- 30:49[SPEAKER_01]: Again, he was nineteen.
- 30:51[SPEAKER_01]: His girlfriend was fifteen.
- 30:53[SPEAKER_00]: Gavin, that's a father who means business.
- 30:55[SPEAKER_01]: It's a father who's very protective of his diet.
- 30:58[SPEAKER_00]: I actually appreciate that.
- 30:59[SPEAKER_00]: Absolutely.
- 31:00[SPEAKER_01]: Gavin said, you know, when all this happened, I called police to report it.
- 31:04[SPEAKER_01]: And so the police looked into see whether or not what Gavin was saying was true.
- 31:09[SPEAKER_01]: Did Aaron show up at Gavin's house and at any point threatened to kill him.
- 31:14[SPEAKER_01]: So Gavin didn't have a ring doorbell.
- 31:17[SPEAKER_01]: You know, that wasn't any help to them, but they looked at ring doorbells around Gavin's house to see if Aaron's car, this mercury marquee,
- 31:24[SPEAKER_01]: or Marquis, depending on who you are, to see if that car was seen in any of the doorbells around, any of the surveillance videos of businesses that were nearby, what not, there was nothing to substantiate that Aaron had actually been at Gavin's house.
- 31:37[SPEAKER_01]: Does it mean it didn't happen?
- 31:39[SPEAKER_01]: They just weren't able to find anything.
- 31:41[SPEAKER_01]: Gavin then starts telling the detectives what he knows about this verbal and physical abuse that was happening by Ellie's dad.
- 31:48[SPEAKER_01]: He said that when he and Ellie started dating, which was about four or five months prior, Ellie had told him that her dad was physically and verbally abusing her.
- 31:56[SPEAKER_01]: but it was just a couple days prior to this that Ellie had told him her dad was actually sexually abusing her.
- 32:04[SPEAKER_01]: That wasn't something that had come out.
- 32:06[SPEAKER_01]: And I guess at one point in the prior days, she had said that she was lying in bed and her dad came in to lay down next to her and basically didn't touch her but laid next to her and touched himself.
- 32:18[SPEAKER_01]: That's what he said and he said, you know, that's what really sent me off.
- 32:22[SPEAKER_01]: And on the night that Erin was killed, Gavin said that he had received a text from Ellie that said, my dad's been really creepy and touchy feeling today.
- 32:31[SPEAKER_01]: Like this is bad.
- 32:32[SPEAKER_01]: I need to get out of here.
- 32:34[SPEAKER_01]: So they decided that night they were going to go pick up Ellie and her stuff and just get her out of there and move her to his place so she didn't have to deal with her dad anymore.
- 32:43[SPEAKER_01]: The detectives don't stop, right?
- 32:44[SPEAKER_01]: They keep interrogating him and what about this and what about that and double checking what's going on and what not?
- 32:49[SPEAKER_01]: It again took a few more hours like it had with Russell and Ellie, where Gavin said, okay, let me finally tell you what happened.
- 32:56[SPEAKER_01]: And he said that they went over there to get Ellie and it's because of these reasons, right?
- 33:00[SPEAKER_01]: It's because her dad was not only now physically and verbally abusing her.
- 33:04[SPEAKER_01]: He was sexually abusing her.
- 33:05[SPEAKER_01]: Gavin said he went into the house, Russell waited outside, saw Aaron, Ellie's dad, sleeping on the couch, and so Gavin went into Ellie's bedroom.
- 33:14[SPEAKER_01]: And while he was in there, the dad woke up and went into the bedroom to talk to Ellie, and so Gavin hid behind the door, because he said he didn't want to get the crap beat out of him like you thought was going to happen.
- 33:23[SPEAKER_01]: And the dad was like, Ellie, where are you awake?
- 33:25[SPEAKER_01]: What are you doing?
- 33:26[SPEAKER_01]: And she said, oh, I just got up to pee.
- 33:28[SPEAKER_01]: And he said, okay, you're fine.
- 33:29[SPEAKER_01]: I'm going back to bed.
- 33:30[SPEAKER_01]: And he was went back to sleep on the couch.
- 33:32[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know why he was sleeping on the couch because there was a second bedroom there.
- 33:35[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe that was where Ellie stayed.
- 33:36[SPEAKER_00]: He was probably just there on the couch because he was afraid Gavin would sneak in.
- 33:40[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that was my thought.
- 33:41[SPEAKER_00]: He was probably like standing watch for the nineteen year old.
- 33:43[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 33:44[SPEAKER_01]: So while Gavin and Ellie waited for Aaron to go back to sleep, Gavin told detectives that Ellie handed him a bat, and they just hung out in her bedroom waiting.
- 33:53[SPEAKER_01]: And so when Aaron finally fell asleep again, Ellie and Russell took her stuff out to the car.
- 33:58[SPEAKER_01]: And so Russell said to detectives, well, my plan was I was just gonna walk straight out of there.
- 34:02[SPEAKER_01]: He's gonna go through the living room, walk out the front door, do nothing.
- 34:05[SPEAKER_01]: But as he started walking out of there, he heard Aaron begin to stir.
- 34:09[SPEAKER_01]: And he said, and I just acted on instinct.
- 34:12[SPEAKER_01]: and had the bat that Ellie had handed him and swung it at Aaron's body that was lying on the couch.
- 34:19[SPEAKER_01]: He said it was dark, he couldn't really see, but once he swung the bat he kept swinging it.
- 34:24[SPEAKER_01]: He said the first swing was over his shoulder and after that first swing he then took the bat above his head and was swinging it.
- 34:31[SPEAKER_01]: And said he did it about five or six times and he stopped and said he heard Aaron say what the F and so he just kept swinging the bat again again and again and again and again.
- 34:41[SPEAKER_00]: He didn't stop until he heard gurgling.
- 34:44[SPEAKER_01]: That's exactly it.
- 34:44[SPEAKER_01]: Did not stop until he heard gurgling.
- 34:47[SPEAKER_01]: Now, according to Gavin, neither Russell nor Ellie were in the room when this happened.
- 34:52[SPEAKER_01]: And, you know, he said, I didn't want to kill him and started crying.
- 34:57[SPEAKER_01]: No, he was crying.
- 34:58[SPEAKER_01]: He was crying.
- 34:59[SPEAKER_00]: He was crying.
- 35:00[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know.
- 35:00[SPEAKER_00]: He was crying.
- 35:01[SPEAKER_00]: I saw like a was he forcing some of it.
- 35:04[SPEAKER_00]: No, I think he was crying.
- 35:06[SPEAKER_00]: And he said, this is a nineteen year old.
- 35:09[SPEAKER_00]: He said, I want my mom.
- 35:11[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 35:11[SPEAKER_01]: He did.
- 35:11[SPEAKER_01]: I forgot about that.
- 35:12[SPEAKER_00]: And the detective's later said that he was the only one who had a suitable response for the situation.
- 35:18[SPEAKER_01]: You know, because you have a sociopath and potentially a psychopath.
- 35:22[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I mean, in Ellie, we're just self diagnosing, by the way.
- 35:25[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, not self diagnosing, but we're diagnosing.
- 35:28[SPEAKER_01]: If I'm so diagnosing, I'm fabulous.
- 35:32[SPEAKER_00]: A wonderful.
- 35:33[SPEAKER_00]: I think he was really torn up.
- 35:34[SPEAKER_01]: I forgot about the mom comment.
- 35:36[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and he kept saying, I never intended to kill her dad.
- 35:40[SPEAKER_00]: I never intended to kill Aaron.
- 35:41[SPEAKER_00]: I never intended.
- 35:42[SPEAKER_00]: Like, you know, just that was sort of his thing.
- 35:44[SPEAKER_00]: You know, and then afterwards, Aaron is dead on the couch or gurgling.
- 35:49[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 35:49[SPEAKER_00]: And then Russell took money out of his wallet and then they wrapped him up, put him in the trunk.
- 35:55[SPEAKER_00]: his own car of his own car exactly and then went and dumped his body exactly where Russell showed them it would be.
- 36:02[SPEAKER_00]: But watching Gavin's interview is interesting because it was like you're watching somebody realize the magnitude of
- 36:12[SPEAKER_00]: what happened.
- 36:12[SPEAKER_00]: That's that's how I saw it.
- 36:14[SPEAKER_00]: I saw it.
- 36:14[SPEAKER_00]: He was like, you know, fairly normal for a nineteen year old boy, except that he's dating a fifteen year old and it's like he's telling them the story.
- 36:22[SPEAKER_00]: It was like it was dawning on him.
- 36:24[SPEAKER_00]: Like, oh my god, there's no take backs.
- 36:26[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 36:26[SPEAKER_00]: And he's like, there's no take back.
- 36:28[SPEAKER_00]: I'm going to prison.
- 36:29[SPEAKER_00]: Aren't I?
- 36:29[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 36:30[SPEAKER_00]: That's what he said.
- 36:30[SPEAKER_01]: And the detective was like, it depends on what your intent was.
- 36:33[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, which I thought was a strange response.
- 36:35[SPEAKER_00]: Well, that's the response that's designed to get somebody to talk more.
- 36:39[SPEAKER_00]: Listen to this information, right?
- 36:40[SPEAKER_00]: You know, there's no way that detective has any authority to like say whether someone's going to jail or not, but right.
- 36:46[SPEAKER_01]: But that's when Gavin dropped a bombshell because he said to the detective, I was just trying to protect Ellie and our possible child.
- 36:59[SPEAKER_01]: And then detective was like like records for a couple of weeks that she was pregnant.
- 37:08[SPEAKER_01]: And sure enough, when detectives actually pulled videos surveillance from the Walmart, not only were they buying every snack known to man for their road trip, they also bought a pregnancy test.
- 37:18[SPEAKER_01]: Here's the interesting thing, Kath, that I thought is that all three of them had a different villain in their story.
- 37:22[SPEAKER_01]: It was a similar story, just different.
- 37:24[SPEAKER_01]: So of course, Ellie said Russell did it.
- 37:26[SPEAKER_01]: Russell said Gavin did it, but it was in self defense so that Aaron was the villain and then Gavin said his underage girlfriend was the villain.
- 37:34[SPEAKER_01]: She was the mastermind behind it all.
- 37:39[SPEAKER_00]: So even though the three of them were pointing their fingers at each other, Gavin showed detectives messages from Ellie to kind of boost his statement.
- 37:48[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 37:49[SPEAKER_00]: Like, sorry, Ellie was the ringleader.
- 37:51[SPEAKER_00]: I really didn't want to kill her dad.
- 37:53[SPEAKER_00]: And he would say every so often, Aaron was a nice guy.
- 37:55[SPEAKER_00]: He was a good guy.
- 37:57[SPEAKER_00]: Obviously, they didn't get along because Aaron couldn't stand the fact that Gavin was seeing his minor daughter.
- 38:02[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, exactly.
- 38:03[SPEAKER_00]: But it was like again, the magnitude of the situation hitting him, but he pulls out his phone and he shows detectives a text message from Ellie and one of them says, we need to make sure he's dead by the time we leave the house.
- 38:17[SPEAKER_00]: And another one, she said, you want to kill him now.
- 38:19[SPEAKER_00]: Don't you?
- 38:21[SPEAKER_00]: You can kill him in less than a minute, right?
- 38:23[SPEAKER_00]: That kind of thing.
- 38:24[SPEAKER_00]: So detectives searched Gavin's home and they found a drawing that was in Ellie's hand.
- 38:32[SPEAKER_00]: It was a diagram of the house.
- 38:35[SPEAKER_00]: And there was indications on where the cameras were located because Ellie's dad lived in a house behind a house, essentially.
- 38:43[SPEAKER_00]: And his home sort of abutted the back alley.
- 38:45[SPEAKER_00]: And Ellie was saying, OK, the front house has cameras and they're here in here.
- 38:49[SPEAKER_00]: So you got to be careful, blah, blah, blah.
- 38:50[SPEAKER_01]: And here's where you enter my dad's house, here's where all the different rooms are, where he's gonna be, where the bedrooms are, well, yeah.
- 38:56[SPEAKER_00]: There was a full schematic of the house layout.
- 38:59[SPEAKER_00]: So not only did they find this drawing by Ellie, but they also found a piece of paper written in Russell's handwriting, the blonde, okay?
- 39:10[SPEAKER_00]: And it says, is that why you're pointing at me?
- 39:11[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, exactly.
- 39:13[SPEAKER_00]: And it says murder plan B. And it has all of these sort of elaborate
- 39:19[SPEAKER_00]: Plants, delusional almost.
- 39:21[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, so one of them was, lease the front house, something like that, like beer renter in the front house.
- 39:27[SPEAKER_00]: Get the RV put in your name, repair the RV.
- 39:31[SPEAKER_00]: Right, gas it up, put new wheels on it, like very specific plans about the RV because again, they were supposed to be driving Ellie's dad to California to time to a tree.
- 39:41[SPEAKER_01]: But before that, if you'll recall, it also said, go to Mr. Fryer's house.
- 39:46[SPEAKER_01]: Kill him quickly.
- 39:47[SPEAKER_01]: Do you remember that?
- 39:48[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 39:48[SPEAKER_01]: So I don't it kind of calls BS on his plan to drive to California.
- 39:52[SPEAKER_01]: I think they did plan to do it.
- 39:53[SPEAKER_01]: Well, there was a lot.
- 39:54[SPEAKER_00]: I just for both points about an RV.
- 39:56[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 39:57[SPEAKER_01]: But it was underneath killing Mr. Fryer and it's our air and fryer, but I do think that was where the BS came is that I think they fully intended to flee to California or dip to California, but I think they plan to do it without Mr. Fryer and toe.
- 40:10[SPEAKER_00]: Well, I mean, just because it was written in that fashion, doesn't mean that's why he was organized.
- 40:17[SPEAKER_01]: Do you not think that's not true?
- 40:19[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, my God.
- 40:24[SPEAKER_00]: So anyway, what they didn't find was anything written by Gavin, the boyfriend who actually admitted to being the one who killed the dad with the bat.
- 40:36[SPEAKER_00]: So all three of them are charged with murder and conspiracy to commit murder.
- 40:42[SPEAKER_01]: And the detectives to this day believe that Ellie really was the mastermind behind everything.
- 40:49[SPEAKER_01]: Fifteen year old Ellie.
- 40:51[SPEAKER_01]: And by the way, she really wasn't pregnant.
- 40:53[SPEAKER_01]: It doesn't mean that they didn't think she was pregnant.
- 40:55[SPEAKER_00]: But she wasn't pregnant.
- 40:56[SPEAKER_01]: She wasn't.
- 40:57[SPEAKER_01]: And what the detectives believed is she used that as another way to manipulate Gavin into doing her bidding because, of course, if she was pregnant with his child, he would do anything he could to protect her.
- 41:06[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 41:07[SPEAKER_00]: Blond Russell, who as we said had autism, but was very high functioning.
- 41:13[SPEAKER_00]: And bipolar disorder was deemed unfit to stand trial.
- 41:17[SPEAKER_00]: He was not competent.
- 41:19[SPEAKER_00]: But I am certain that his lawyer in order to show his lack of competency and his appreciation of right and wrong showed the interrogation tapes to the judge.
- 41:30[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, I'm sure.
- 41:31[SPEAKER_00]: I'm sure the judge is like, OK.
- 41:34[SPEAKER_00]: Ultimately, given time, the judge did rule that Russell understood the difference between right and wrong at the time of the murder.
- 41:48[SPEAKER_01]: So, in October of twenty-eighteen, this is just a year after the murders.
- 41:52[SPEAKER_01]: Now, twenty-year-old Gavin pleaded guilty to murder and was sentenced to twenty-five years to life for murder and conspiracy.
- 42:00[SPEAKER_01]: He will first be eligible for parole in twenty-four-three when he will be forty-five years old.
- 42:05[SPEAKER_01]: Next up, just three months later, in January of twenty nineteen, now seventeen-year-old Ellie, also pleaded guilty to an adult charge of conspiracy to commit murder.
- 42:16[SPEAKER_01]: Remember she was just fifteen at the time that this happened.
- 42:19[SPEAKER_01]: She was sentenced to twenty-five years in prison, but she will stay in juvenile detention until she's twenty-five years old so that she can get access to programs and counseling and things like that, at which point she will then be transferred to an adult prison.
- 42:33[SPEAKER_00]: And she's supposedly going to college when she was sentenced.
- 42:36[SPEAKER_00]: She started going to college.
- 42:38[SPEAKER_01]: She will be eligible for parole in twenty forty one at the age of thirty nine.
- 42:42[SPEAKER_01]: Now, in August of twenty twenty one, now twenty six year old Russell pleaded no contest to conspiracy to commit murder because his Kathy said he was deemed fit to stand trial and he was sentenced to fifteen years in prison.
- 42:56[SPEAKER_01]: Ultimately, they decided that he knew what was supposed to happen.
- 43:00[SPEAKER_01]: Ellie had told detectives that Russell had killed her father with machete.
- 43:04[SPEAKER_01]: Sure.
- 43:04[SPEAKER_01]: That's what we said.
- 43:05[SPEAKER_01]: But apparently, that wasn't just out of thin air, they actually had a backup plan to use a machete to kill him if Gavin wasn't successful.
- 43:13[SPEAKER_01]: So there was no plan C, but that was apparently the plan C. Exactly.
- 43:18[SPEAKER_01]: He is scheduled to be released in twenty thirty one, scarily just six years from now when he will be thirty five years old.
- 43:25[SPEAKER_00]: And one of the things that I think is important to point out, so at Ellie's sentencing hearing, the family was very divided as you can imagine.
- 43:32[SPEAKER_00]: Her mother's side on one side of the courtroom, her father's side on the other side of the courtroom, because of her allegations of abuse, which, by the way, detective said there was no evidence of, but as you can imagine, it divided the family.
- 43:46[SPEAKER_00]: It's such a horrible, horrible, horrible thing to alleged against somebody.
- 43:51[SPEAKER_00]: you know, but I generally have a tendency to believe young kids when they say this kind of thing happened.
- 43:57[SPEAKER_00]: And there was no indication of anything other than what Kathy described earlier.
- 44:03[SPEAKER_00]: And so again, detective said, this man did not abuse his daughter, but we do not know.
- 44:08[SPEAKER_00]: And one of the things we tried hard to find and couldn't find is how did Ellie grow up?
- 44:13[SPEAKER_00]: Like we
- 44:14[SPEAKER_00]: No, her parents were divorced.
- 44:16[SPEAKER_00]: We know she was overly mature for a fifteen year old, but we really couldn't find any solid information on why she presented the way she presented.
- 44:27[SPEAKER_00]: That disappointed me that we couldn't find that, but because it's always interesting.
- 44:31[SPEAKER_01]: with the family split so mom and grandma were on one side the dad's family was on the rest after sentencing the grandmother said so this is my her maternal grandmother said that it was excessive to give her twenty five years because even though she did need to be punished she thought that was just too long sentence considering what she'd gone through now Michelle Robinson who was the dad's girlfriend at the time Erin was killed said simply justice has been served
- 45:03[SPEAKER_00]: And thanks for listening.
- 45:04[SPEAKER_01]: And tell your friends and subscribe.
- 45:08[SPEAKER_01]: The end.
- 45:08[SPEAKER_01]: And watch us on TikTok.
- 45:09[SPEAKER_01]: And follow us on Instagram and TikTok.
- 45:13[SPEAKER_01]: And tell us your cases.
- 45:14[SPEAKER_01]: If you have any cases, let us know.
- 45:15[SPEAKER_01]: And done.