Latest / Shades of Jade Podcast / Dr. Zafra Lerman on Science, Art, and Global Collaboration
Transcript
- 0:07Hey everyone, my guest today is Doctor Zafra Lehrman, a world
- 0:10renowned chemist, educator and peace builder who has pioneered
- 0:13the use of science diplomacy to foster dialogue and
- 0:16collaboration in the world's most volatile regions.
- 0:20As founder and President of the Malta Conferences Foundation,
- 0:23she brings together scientists from countries in conflict,
- 0:26including Israel, Palestine, Iran, Iraq and others across the
- 0:30Middle East, to work side by side on scientific challenges
- 0:33that transcend borders, from water scarcity to nuclear
- 0:36proliferation. Beyond diplomacy, Dr. Lehrman
- 0:39has spent decades fighting for human rights, advocating for
- 0:42persecuted scientists in the Soviet Union and China,
- 0:45including risking her own safety by venturing after midnight
- 0:48through dark alleys in Moscow to meet dissidents.
- 0:51She also developed groundbreaking methods to teach
- 0:54science through the arts, reaching underprivileged
- 0:56students, including homeless youth and incarcerated
- 0:59individuals by making chemistry accessible through music, dance
- 1:02and visual storytelling. Her work has been recognized
- 1:05globally, including multiple Nobel Peace Prize nominations,
- 1:09the US Presidential Award for Mentoring minorities in Science
- 1:12presented by President Bill Clinton, and the prestigious
- 1:15Andrei Sakharov Award for Human Rights from the American
- 1:18Physical Society. She has also been honored by
- 1:20UNESCO, the US State Department, and leading peace and science
- 1:24organizations worldwide. Welcome, Doctor Lehrmann, would
- 1:27you be able to tell us a little bit more about yourself?
- 1:30As you heard, my name is Saffa Lehrmann.
- 1:35I'm a scientist. I have a PhD, so I'm Doctor
- 1:39Saffa Lehrmann or Professor Saffa Lehrmann if you want.
- 1:45My PhD is in chemistry, but I used my science to make the
- 1:52planet a better place for everybody.
- 1:56So my book that is titled Human Rights and Peace, A Personal
- 2:02Odyssey, and it's now in paperback in on Amazon.
- 2:07It's on paperback so you can see the title and it's really a book
- 2:13written for everybody. It described my growing up in a
- 2:18developing country without hot shower, without a lot of things
- 2:26that people in the US take for granted.
- 2:30But I was a high society. I grew up in Israel and my
- 2:37father was a pioneer. And we had, I had probably the
- 2:44happiest childhood somebody can have because I did not have my
- 2:49mother waiting with an SUV when I came out from school to Take
- 2:54Me Home and drive me for the next program.
- 2:57She signed me on because we didn't have SUVs, we didn't have
- 3:01any cars, and we didn't have any organized programs.
- 3:06So we children developed our programs, we developed our
- 3:11imagination, we developed our creativity, we developed our
- 3:16innovation. Nobody prepared everything for
- 3:20us and I think it was the greatest way to grow up.
- 3:26Even I I felt sorry. I have a school next to me and
- 3:30when I walk at 3:00 and I see all the mother, every child, the
- 3:36mother with an SUV and an engine running in summer for the air
- 3:42conditioning and in winter for the heat, and the child runs
- 3:45into the SUV, Banks goes away till the next program the SUV
- 3:51will drive. And I remember that the biggest
- 3:54fun for us was to take the longest way you could find
- 3:59between school and home. So we can spend a lot of time
- 4:03together. And I'll continue.
- 4:07I knew I will be a scientist by the age of 2 already.
- 4:12I described a lot of things and a lot of question.
- 4:16So this was not news to me. I knew this will be the pass I
- 4:21will take. I describe it in my book and
- 4:28then I went and got my bachelor master PhD.
- 4:35But I had it. I was already married and a
- 4:38child so my son already attended all my 3 ceremonies.
- 4:44What was not easy to get the bachelor, master, PhD with a
- 4:50child, but possible in a message for all the women that have
- 4:55children that you can achieve everything you want.
- 5:00All what you need is to want it. I was for a period a single mom
- 5:06and this is when I came to the States as a single mom with a
- 5:10child and no relatives, no money, nothing.
- 5:17But we make it. They made it.
- 5:20It's true that a PhD is a big help, but even without PhD, if a
- 5:26woman wants, you can make it as a single mom.
- 5:30And all these stories about single mom cannot achieve.
- 5:36And all these stories are just nonsense.
- 5:40And in case you don't detect, I have a phone accent and it means
- 5:47by American terms, I was an immigrant.
- 5:53But there is a lot of pressure against.
- 5:58So I wanted to say that I'm an immigrant that contributed a lot
- 6:04to the country and the book is a result of pressure to write
- 6:12really three books during my life, but I never had time to do
- 6:16it because I was too busy in one of them.
- 6:23I after doing research for many years in fancy universities like
- 6:30Cornell, Northwestern in the US, the Swiss Polytechnic Room in
- 6:35Switzerland. I by myself have a PhD from the
- 6:39Weitzman Institute of Science in Israel that is considered for
- 6:45many years one of the best 10 research institutes in the
- 6:50world. Doesn't have undergraduate, it's
- 6:53only a Graduate School. So after doing research in all
- 6:58this fancy places, I decided to change direction because I
- 7:05believe that science education is a human rights that belongs
- 7:10to all. And I feel that we are leaving a
- 7:13lot of people out of understanding science and
- 7:18technology, of developing the critical thinking that science
- 7:24courses teach you. And then they are behind in the
- 7:29community. And my worry always is that we
- 7:34will form two class societies that are not divided by royalty
- 7:40but divided by knowledge of science and technology.
- 7:45So I decided to teach people that would never come close to
- 7:53science. And I got an offer that I could
- 7:57not refused from a College in Chicago called Columbia College
- 8:05and it was a wonderful place till it was destroyed few years
- 8:14ago. But before that, it was a
- 8:17college with vision, because the president that really built this
- 8:25college, his name was Mike Alexandroff, was a real, real
- 8:30visionary, a very progressive man, believed in equality for
- 8:38everybody. The school was open admission so
- 8:43it was a school for art and communication, but he believed
- 8:49that students that could not afford a beautiful portfolio in
- 8:53the art to go to a fancy old school should still pursue their
- 8:57dreams and talent. And he attracted to teach there
- 9:05the best and the brightest because it was people that were
- 9:09not only outstanding in the field, they were outstanding in
- 9:15their contribution to society. And their purpose was to really
- 9:24give the students all what you they can in order to make them
- 9:31successful. And it was very successful.
- 9:36I built a science institute from scratch that became very famous.
- 9:43We even got, in 2004, the world is the best undergraduate
- 9:49program in all the independent universities and colleges.
- 9:55And it was a school for health and communication.
- 9:59And what I did, I developed a method to teach science
- 10:03throughout music, dance, drama, poetry, rap, animation, anything
- 10:13a student wanted to use. And I assessed my students like
- 10:18that. My students did not write
- 10:21multiple choice tests. They could show me their
- 10:24knowledge if they wanted by singing a song that they did on
- 10:29the subject or a play that they did on the subject.
- 10:34Like a group of theatre students did a love story between sodium
- 10:38and chlorine to form table salt and they followed Romeo and
- 10:43Juliet and one music student or beautiful words about the
- 10:52depletion of the ozone layer and he sang it.
- 10:56I have plenty of ozone to the music of I have plenty of
- 11:01nothing. And wonderful projects came out
- 11:08and my students are extremely successful in every field they
- 11:12had chosen in Hollywood. I was invited to an Emmy Award
- 11:17when one of my students got it. But he said that his success is
- 11:22all the science classes that he took in the critical thinking
- 11:27that he learned in the way of thinking that got him ahead in
- 11:32animation. And therefore we got the Emmy
- 11:36Award. So this is one part where the
- 11:39book this discussed, as a matter of fact, it was adopted all over
- 11:44the world, then posed miracles with underprivileged students.
- 11:50I taught homeless students that went to college to even got a
- 11:56PhD in biochemistry. I taught prisoners.
- 12:00That became very successful. So it was a very successful
- 12:06method that brought me probably more than 40 international
- 12:10awards. In addition to all that, as I
- 12:15said, I believe that science education is a human rights.
- 12:19I believe in human rights. So I chaired for 26 years the
- 12:26Subcommittee on Scientific Freedom and Human Rights for the
- 12:30American Chemical Society. And with this committee I went
- 12:35to the Soviet Analyst Committee, I went to the Soviet Union.
- 12:42I met after midnight with dissidents.
- 12:47I took a crash course of Russian, so I did not need a
- 12:52translator that could be a KGB agent.
- 12:57And after midnight, I meet with I met with dissidents in dark
- 13:01alleys. I bought, This was illegal in
- 13:07the Soviet Union. I bought scientific material.
- 13:10It was illegal. And at 2:00 in the morning, I
- 13:14delivered a seminar to like 50 dissidents in a dark attic.
- 13:21Illegal. And I took all their CVS back to
- 13:25work on their release. They were represented a family
- 13:30of people that were in prison or in hard labour in Speria.
- 13:36And then I worked very hard on the release and it's a great
- 13:42pleasure to see people that have their freedom because you risk
- 13:47your own life for them. Oh, I was under pressure for
- 13:52many years to write the book on the education.
- 13:54Then I was under pressure to write the book on human rights
- 13:59because after Tiananmen Square in China, I worked in China, I
- 14:03worked in Cuba, I worked in Peru, Guatemala.
- 14:08I worked in a lot of countries on human rights while being the
- 14:13head of the science institute and running an extremely
- 14:17successful creative institute with a lot of grant money.
- 14:23Because we did things that nobody even dreamed on doing.
- 14:28We were really ahead of our time.
- 14:31And then after September 11, I suggested to my subcommittee on
- 14:40Scientific Freedom and Human Rights that we should
- 14:44concentrate in the Middle East. And I brought a proposal to the
- 14:49board of the American Chemical Society that I think the time
- 14:55came to organize a conference where scientists from all over
- 15:00the Middle East, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Israel, the
- 15:04Palestinian, all of them with no exception, will participate.
- 15:09It was several Nobel laureate for five days and give them a
- 15:14form to see what unites them instead of what separates them.
- 15:21To give them a form to stop demonizing the unknown other and
- 15:27to give them a form to develop collaboration on issues that one
- 15:32country cannot solve alone, like air pollution, like the water
- 15:38issue. Water is the big issue in the
- 15:40Middle East. They had land and the echo docs
- 15:44are going through a lot of boulders.
- 15:48They don't know the boulders. The nature and the environment
- 15:51don't see boulders. The astronauts don't see the
- 15:55boulders too. They see the the planet is one
- 16:00thing. And in 2003, it was the height
- 16:08of the intifada. The intifada was the uprising of
- 16:12the Palestinian. And they used a lot of suicide
- 16:17bombing in Israel. So every day in restaurants with
- 16:23buses, people were killed. And we ran our first conference
- 16:31and all the people that we invited came and the the
- 16:36conference was held on the island of Malta because I
- 16:40believe that an island is safer than the mainland.
- 16:45So this was my idea and therefore it got the name the
- 16:49Malta Conferences because the first two conferences were in
- 16:54Malta and then we came back every time back to Malta.
- 16:58So this is how these conferences started and we had already 10
- 17:06conferences and now will be the 11/1.
- 17:11And there are a lot of obstacles in organizing a conference like
- 17:18that. First, we have to raise all the
- 17:21money to support all the people. And raising money for peace
- 17:27purposes is very hard. There is billions of dollars for
- 17:31weapon of destruction. Only a small, small portion of
- 17:37that would go a long way to achieve peace.
- 17:40But to raise the money is a very, very hard task.
- 17:45The other tough main challenge is to get a country that will be
- 17:52willing to issue a visa to all the participants.
- 17:57This is not an easy task either because there is almost no
- 18:02country like that in the world that is ready to issue a visa to
- 18:07this all this group and to facilitate the the collaboration
- 18:16across borders that are being formed.
- 18:19The visa is one of the toughest, toughest issues because Malta,
- 18:32the first two conferences happened before Malta joined the
- 18:36European Union. So it was very easy to get a
- 18:40visa for everybody upon landing, but then they use, they join the
- 18:45European Union and then you need what is called the Schengen visa
- 18:50and this is held to get. So there is a huge chapter in my
- 18:58book that I titled for Mission Possible, mission input, for
- 19:05Mission Impossible to mission possible.
- 19:08And it shows how in every Malta all the obstacles of getting the
- 19:14visa and how till the last day the country said no we cannot
- 19:20issue and how in the last minute everybody gets a visa.
- 19:27But it shows all the methods in the ingenuity and almost like
- 19:35double O 7 working in order to be able to get a visa for the
- 19:41whole group. And people put fascia on me to
- 19:47write a book about that what was very interested to interesting
- 19:53to a lot of people. So at the end I got the ghost
- 19:58writer and. I dictated the whole book and I
- 20:05wanted to make sure that the book is not more than 200 pages
- 20:09because people don't have patience to read these days.
- 20:13But meanwhile a lot of people read it.
- 20:18You can see the reviews on Amazon's and people said they
- 20:22could not put it down after starting reading it.
- 20:28And we, I would like as many people to be as possible to be
- 20:37able to read it because there is a message that everybody can
- 20:40relate, relate to. In addition with that you are
- 20:48contributing to peace in the Middle East because all the
- 20:51proceeds are going towards the mount of conferences.
- 20:57So this is in a nutshell my activities.
- 21:02Each subject I can talk for several hours.
- 21:07I gave thousands of lecture around the world's only on
- 21:11education. The one of the things you were
- 21:14talking about was the different way of learning.
- 21:19I, I went to, to school for science and I, I was terrible at
- 21:26chemistry, fine with biology, fine with the earth sciences.
- 21:31And, and I, you were making me think about some of my favorite
- 21:37memories and projects that I had worked on.
- 21:40And we had a class, my favorite biology class was discussion
- 21:45based and we did have to present once or twice a semester.
- 21:49There was no exam. Everything was based off of
- 21:53participation. And I took more from that class
- 21:59than I did on any of the other classes I took because I was
- 22:04more actively engaged in the material instead of, OK, let's
- 22:07just study to pass this test. And then it and then it leaves
- 22:11your head when you're when you're learning the material
- 22:13that way. And then it made me think of my
- 22:17my chemistry classes. I'm like, you know, we had no
- 22:20fun. We had nothing unique in those
- 22:23classes. And I do wonder if we had
- 22:26introduced different ways of learning into those courses, if
- 22:30I would have done better. And then.
- 22:32No doubts, no doubt that you will be Iberman Styles did not
- 22:39like chemistry in high school because I didn't have a good
- 22:43teacher and I didn't like it. Which school did you go to?
- 22:48I took chemistry at University of Northern Iowa here in.
- 22:52Iowa. And I did not like it either.
- 22:58And you know, I the the members of my sub committee on
- 23:04scientific freedom and human rights where Professor Tom
- 23:10Spiel, that was the chair of chemistry at Princeton and
- 23:14Professor Jack Seidel that was the chair of chemistry at
- 23:19Indiana University. 1 is a fantasy Ivy League private
- 23:24school and 1 is a Big 10 state school and my idea was in
- 23:33Princeton for non science majors by that period they could take
- 23:41psychology as they require their requirement for science and with
- 23:49all my respect to psychology I did not feel it's a hard science
- 23:54that they really should be taking.
- 23:58So I suggested to my 2 colleagues that where in my
- 24:04committee on Scientific Freedom and Human rights that we should
- 24:09develop a course, the same course in the three institution,
- 24:15Princeton IN University and Columbia College that was open
- 24:19admission art and communication school.
- 24:25And we will develop it with my methods of teaching for non
- 24:30science majors. In this way, we will attract non
- 24:35science majors to take a chemistry class and we titled
- 24:40the class from Ozone to oil spill chemistry, the environment
- 24:45in you and I came and did workshop.
- 24:51So they will know to use my methods in their classes.
- 24:57And in order to prove that it's the same class all over.
- 25:05First, we applied to the National Science Foundation for
- 25:09a grant and the National Science Foundation was so impressed with
- 25:14their project that they gave us a grant and they called our
- 25:18project the flagship project of NSF.
- 25:22And since then they started having money for big consortium
- 25:28because they thought that variety of institution working
- 25:33together is a great idea. So we started this trend and
- 25:37they called it the flagship project.
- 25:40But in order to prove that my inner city open envision school
- 25:51students that never was on a plane before can fly to be with
- 25:58Princeton students all day in a joint symposium.
- 26:03So every year my class flew to Princeton and we spend a whole
- 26:10day symposium for the students from both sides showed their
- 26:15knowledge through different projects.
- 26:19The media covered it, the whole media from the neighborhood was
- 26:23coming and they called it a meeting of two cultures and they
- 26:28they really covered it heavily because it was a phenomenon to
- 26:34bring 2 schools like that together.
- 26:37And it was proven unbelievable. My students really second to
- 26:45none. And it gave them suddenly a new
- 26:50perspective. They went to look if they can go
- 26:53for Graduate School to Princeton and it became.
- 26:58But as I told you that we are the special president by the
- 27:02name of Mike Alexandroff, Mike said to me, you are taking your
- 27:08student to Princeton, you're going Sunday, the symposium is
- 27:15Monday. I want them to have more
- 27:19experiences that they never had before.
- 27:23So I want you to take the class and I'll pay for that to a
- 27:29Broadway Martinez. So they will see what is
- 27:33Broadway that they hear about. And many of them are theatre
- 27:38students, so they will enjoy that and then take them to a
- 27:43nice restaurant for dinner in Manhattan before you continue to
- 27:48Princeton. This is when you have a
- 27:51president with a vision that could bring up a school.
- 27:58But sadly, nobody lives forever and all that.
- 28:06This appeared now, but it was unbelievable to have such a
- 28:11visionary president. And I remember that one of the
- 28:16classes, the play we saw on Broadway was five men named
- 28:23Moore, and it was their last performance.
- 28:28And then they said if there is anybody in the audience that
- 28:33would love to come on stage to sing with us and dance with us,
- 28:38we will be very happy to incorporate them.
- 28:41So enough my students around the stage dancing and singing with
- 28:47this group and what an experience to be with the five
- 28:53men named MO and they are performing together with them.
- 28:58So those are the experiences that their students got in
- 29:03addition to have an experience to be in a symposium together
- 29:08with Princeton students and and this was a model of a College of
- 29:16the future, but sadly it's not there anymore.
- 29:23The scientific dude was closed, other institutes that were very
- 29:30creative and closed and it changed.
- 29:34Yeah, I I bet that was an amazing experience.
- 29:37Oh, it was, it was wonderful, Wonderful.
- 29:41And the people that he managed to surround himself that were
- 29:46teaching there, Gwendoline Brooks taught there.
- 29:49She's a very famous poet. She taught there poetry.
- 29:54They are very famous people from television and journalism taught
- 30:01there. It's it was a very, very
- 30:05creative way that he built this college.
- 30:11Sorry to interrupt, I just wanted to tell you about one of
- 30:13my sponsors real quick. Are you looking for a gift for a
- 30:18music lover? Or maybe some apparel to show?
- 30:20Off your quirky side, old. Glory has you covered.
- 30:23With over 300,000 officially licensed items covering music,
- 30:27sports, entertainment and pop culture, you're guaranteed to
- 30:30find the perfect item. They even have seasonal gear.
- 30:33My husband enjoys The Beatles and Led Zeppelin apparel and I
- 30:36love the Billy Idol apparel. I even found items for my fellow
- 30:40plant enthusiasts. This family owned superstore is
- 30:43known for their quality and customer service.
- 30:45Offers Free standard shipping on all orders and orders are
- 30:48shipped the same day you purchase.
- 30:50My discount code gives you 15% off your entire order and it's
- 30:53currently the best deal available.
- 30:55Just visit oldglory.com and enter in my promo code JADE.
- 30:59That's JADE at checkout. Yeah.
- 31:04All right. I do have some questions.
- 31:07I'm going to try and pick something that is similar to
- 31:10what we've been talking about. Well, actually, so I do have a
- 31:16question. What is it like getting
- 31:18scientists from conflicting countries to sit at the same
- 31:22table, which you did mention a little bit.
- 31:25Just getting the people there physically is quite the
- 31:29challenge. Do you do you see that most of
- 31:33the time people are willing to talk or or?
- 31:36Let me tell you you you're talking about people, but these
- 31:40people have something in common. They are scientists.
- 31:45And science is very international.
- 31:49We call it science diplomacy what we are doing.
- 31:53So science diplomacy doesn't see culture, doesn't see religion,
- 31:59doesn't see language. It's international.
- 32:03I always love to say that The chemist from Bethlehem, PA and a
- 32:09chemist from Battle of Them in the West Bank could communicate
- 32:13their chemistry research to each other without having to to
- 32:18speak, even if they don't have a language to speak to each other.
- 32:23So it's not just people, it's people that already have
- 32:29something in common that is international.
- 32:33In addition, scientists have very different status in most
- 32:39countries than any other profession.
- 32:43Only in the US they are not respected, but they're in any
- 32:47other country they are extremely respected and a lot of
- 32:52governments can really not do things that they want to do
- 32:57without scientists, sadly enough.
- 33:01Even building weapon mass destruction, you need
- 33:04scientists. So science is something that can
- 33:09prolong life, but science is something that can cut life very
- 33:14short and therefore scientists have the responsibility to walk
- 33:23towards peace. So fails, they have something
- 33:28already in common before they see.
- 33:31Yes, the fails day in 2003 was very interesting.
- 33:37Every group from every country was standing separate.
- 33:42We have 15 separate groups standing.
- 33:45And then we had dinner. Everybody said separately and I
- 33:50walked around and talked to the people and tried to to tell them
- 33:57that they should mingle that they are very important
- 33:59scientists and for sure the Nobel laureates are very big
- 34:03attraction to every scientist. So scientists wanted to sit with
- 34:10their Nobel lawyers. So they had to move from their
- 34:14table. Then everybody's equal in the
- 34:16multi conferences. So even the Graduate School
- 34:20student we want young people. So it will continue.
- 34:23They can sit next to a Nobel lawyer at lunch.
- 34:28So at the end of the conference that is five days you, I have a
- 34:36feeling that a family reunion ended.
- 34:41People hugged out there. People have tears saying
- 34:45goodbye. You don't see even who belongs
- 34:49to which country. Everybody says goodbye with
- 34:53hugging to each other. I even was afraid last time that
- 34:58I'll get covered because I'm still afraid of being too close
- 35:02to people. And here's something to people
- 35:05hug you and kiss you, but it's like a family reunion ended.
- 35:12But for sure the first day was very, very strange.
- 35:17But I managed to break the ice very, very fast with few jokes
- 35:25and few that and putting my arm around people from different
- 35:33countries. So the ice breaks soon and then
- 35:38everybody has the same interest in science and and we have
- 35:44social events that are very important because this is where
- 35:48friendships that overcome cosmos of distrust and intolerance can
- 35:53be formed. So people that were there like
- 36:00reporters from Nature magazine that is one of the IT is the
- 36:07most famous magazine inside. They just cannot believe that
- 36:13they they said you can hear and hear and hear about it, but till
- 36:18you see it with your eyes, it's completely different experience.
- 36:24Yeah, you can only imagine. Completely different experience.
- 36:31And the scientists, the Palestinian scientists come both
- 36:35from the West Bank and Gaza. This is a little bit unrelated,
- 36:41but earlier you were talking about scientists and working
- 36:44with with weapons and it it made me think of the bombing of Iran.
- 36:50And the goal was to to take out the scientists that were that
- 36:56were building the nuclear weapons and.
- 36:59This was not the goal. The goal was to take out the
- 37:02nuclear weapons that threatens the world.
- 37:05The goal was not to take. Yeah, to.
- 37:09That to destroy the facilities and build Yeah, no.
- 37:17It's I I don't think people realize though, that there there
- 37:21is a danger in science too to almost having that that
- 37:26knowledge with, you know, with what you're talking about about
- 37:30earlier and in the military uses uses science.
- 37:35Everybody uses science. Right, right.
- 37:37I I don't think that people. Always realize that about
- 37:40science. We couldn't be on Zoom without
- 37:44science. Everything is based on science
- 37:47and technology. Science is the research that
- 37:51brings to the technology that everybody can use.
- 37:57Yeah, you know, the the nuclear bomb, the atom bomb really was
- 38:04built on a principle that Albert Einstein wrote in 19 O 5A very
- 38:12simple equation equivalency square and all the fission
- 38:19reaction that is causing the atom bomb when the uranium atom
- 38:27is broken, there is vision. It's all based on E equal MC
- 38:33square. So he everything you see, all
- 38:39our technology, everything is based on the research in
- 38:46science. You wouldn't have an iPhone
- 38:49without all the research in science, right?
- 38:53Right. How do you stay hopeful in the
- 38:57face of conflict and setbacks? I must stay hopeful because if
- 39:02you don't stay hopeful, you, you give the world to fall apart and
- 39:10disappear. You must stay hopeful.
- 39:13You must do what you can in order to bring peace.
- 39:19I don't think that harassment in demonstrations on campuses will
- 39:29bring peace any part of the world between Russia and Ukraine
- 39:33or Israel and Gaza. I think it's just pushing
- 39:39violent to the people that are looking for outlet to be
- 39:43violent. This doesn't work.
- 39:45Bring peace, bringing people together, this will bring peace
- 39:50to the world. And the point is, as I said, we
- 39:55have to raise the money. If one of the multi billionaires
- 40:01that are around and they probably don't listen to your
- 40:05podcast but if any of them by mistake would have listened to
- 40:10your podcast for them to support the multi conference would be
- 40:16changed money. And if they could sponsor it and
- 40:22give more money, we could have it more often.
- 40:26Then more people will be in the in the network.
- 40:31And the same as in order to have an atom bomb, you need what is
- 40:36called critical math of uranium to start a chain reaction.
- 40:41What does it mean critical math? It's amount of metal uranium
- 40:50sent certain ounces of uranium that can start the reaction.
- 40:58If it's below deck, you cannot start it.
- 41:01So the amount that you need to start it, it's called critical
- 41:05math. I want to form a critical math
- 41:09of scientists that will be able to start a chain reaction for
- 41:15peace and for one person it's change money.
- 41:21What it cost change money. I'm sure they spend in in one
- 41:27week more than in restaurants, more than the conference like
- 41:33that cost. But if they would donate to
- 41:38peace, then we could involve many, many more people.
- 41:44And there is nothing. More important is for people to
- 41:49realize that they are not enemies for each other.
- 41:53They are friends. They are not enemies.
- 41:56They have a lot more in common than separate.
- 42:00It's the government that start all these wars.
- 42:03And therefore I'm very disappointed that instead for
- 42:09the universities to try to have symposiums, conferences,
- 42:19workshops, bringing people with different ideas together.
- 42:26They suppose this crazy demonstration that just show how
- 42:32badly they teach. Because when you ask those
- 42:36students at Columbia University, you say from the river to the
- 42:42sea, what sea? And so many answer the Black Sea
- 42:47and the river is the Gaza River. From what do parents pay
- 42:52$80,000, right? I always told my students that
- 42:59first in my class you will learn critical thinking.
- 43:03I don't want you ever to be a follower, so you will have
- 43:08critical thinking that you will know what somebody tells you.
- 43:12And then I don't care which side of demonstration you will take
- 43:18all the time. It will be for men,
- 43:21knowledgeable, intelligent point of view, and not that you stand
- 43:27there and scream from the river to the sea and you don't have
- 43:31any idea what river and what sea, right?
- 43:34It's embarrassing. It's embarrassing for a
- 43:37university like Columbia that their students lack critical
- 43:43thinking, that before they scream something, they don't
- 43:47even ask what they are going to sleep.
- 43:50It's a very, very poor testimony to the teaching.
- 43:56It could not happen to a student of mine, I can promise you,
- 44:02because I told them I I took students to demonstration, but
- 44:08they knew why they go to demonstration.
- 44:10You could ask them questions. They would answer in a very
- 44:13intelligent way. Yes, and that that is what I
- 44:18have noticed if you do go to some of these demonstrations on
- 44:21campus, the you ask them what are you here for?
- 44:26What is your message? And they really can't tell you
- 44:30anything aside from the the lines that they're screaming.
- 44:34And not only as you said, are they are they making themselves
- 44:38look stupid, they're also making victims out of innocent people.
- 44:42They're making it a a dangerous or uncomfortable area for other
- 44:48students that have nothing to do with what they're screaming
- 44:51about in the first place. Exactly, they are American
- 44:55citizens that go to an American University.
- 44:58What would they have to do with conflict that is far away from
- 45:02them? Right.
- 45:03They're making no change. And if, if the change is, if
- 45:07there is change, it's a negative change on campus and that's all
- 45:10it is. This is why these universities
- 45:13have to pay now a huge fine to the government and why the
- 45:18presidents have to resign. Yeah.
- 45:22And it's a good thing that they resigned.
- 45:25Maybe there will be a president that will tag tell the faculty
- 45:31please, please teach these to think to critical thing and to
- 45:38so if they don't want to open a book, damn it, Google and find
- 45:44out the name of the sea and the name of the river.
- 45:49Even that they don't did not tell their students and that the
- 45:54administration was involved in all that at Columbia and they
- 45:59didn't tell the student what river and what sea.
- 46:03And shows you the lack of curiosity of the students that
- 46:07the person they produced that they did not have the curiosity
- 46:12to know what they are screaming. This is a horrible testimony for
- 46:19one of the best and most expensive universities in the
- 46:24US. Yeah, I that when to open
- 46:30admission would never be caught in a situation like that.
- 46:34Right. Well, it, so I feel that the
- 46:38shift started happening while I was in college from 2017 to
- 46:442020. It, it seemed to change very
- 46:47quickly and I it's, it's giving universities a bad name.
- 46:54And now it's almost like people don't don't respect.
- 46:58Those who are seeking. A higher education because
- 47:02college isn't the way it used to be.
- 47:05So I really hope that something happens to turn it back to more
- 47:10of like what you spoke about where.
- 47:14You know, give knowledge and give logic and critical
- 47:22thinking. For that the parents pay you
- 47:24$90,000 a year, but don't at least hundreds of students that
- 47:32scream without understanding what they say.
- 47:40I talked to one student, it was NYU really and that participated
- 47:48and I said to her there is a demonstration calling for
- 47:55destruction of the state of Israel, are you joining this
- 47:58demonstration? And she said to me for sure, no.
- 48:03And I said what do you mean for sure no, but every day you use
- 48:09join one like that. She said no, I never joined.
- 48:13I said what do you think? From the river to the Seamians.
- 48:16This means destruction of Israel.
- 48:19Israel is from the river to the sea.
- 48:22You want them out of there. This is she was in a stage of
- 48:28shock. I can't imagine that's yeah.
- 48:34They did not even connect with what they are saying.
- 48:40Right. It makes you wonder why I don't.
- 48:45I don't know why they're doing it in the first place, I guess.
- 48:49Somebody initiates it, and badly, as I used to tell my my
- 48:57student never be for loyals. But nobody invested so much time
- 49:02in order to tell their students and teach them not just to
- 49:06follow. Human being are like sheep.
- 49:12They will follow. They are followed.
- 49:15There is no much difference. It's like like sheep and it's in
- 49:21fashion. Oh, I'm joining.
- 49:23It's great. We got tent.
- 49:26We have encampments. Yeah.
- 49:29How come that all the tent all over the US from the East Coast
- 49:33to the West Coast have the same? Yeah.
- 49:37This means that students bought tents or somebody that wants to
- 49:44see the encampment bought all the tents and walked to the
- 49:48university. It shows you it's not a smart
- 49:51person or organization because at least they should have the
- 49:56brain not to send the same kind of all over the country that
- 50:03took a minute for for everybody to figure out that it's
- 50:07abundant, but. Right, right.
- 50:10Sentent in Berkeley and at Columbia, exactly the same tent.
- 50:16Oh my goodness, They're very sad that the students don't use
- 50:23their brain at all. Right.
- 50:26They don't understand it, you know, with if parents send their
- 50:30students to Columbia, they are they cannot fold a big amount of
- 50:35money. This student probably before
- 50:38that spend their time from 11 sport game to the other
- 50:45organized organized by the mother in the SUV till they went
- 50:50to college and never had a chance to to think ever had a
- 50:58chance. The thinking was done by
- 51:00somebody else. I was sick oldest.
- 51:05How do you think we can bring change to that?
- 51:10To ingrained in the US, we can bring change only if we really,
- 51:16really pay attention to our education.
- 51:19From K to 12, OK, If we can improve education.
- 51:27Like it was many, many years ago that the great people had chosen
- 51:33to be teachers and they knew how to teach and they were
- 51:37intelligent and they taught students to think and they
- 51:42taught student geography. Students in the US don't study
- 51:46geography. They don't have any idea about
- 51:50geography. So this is where the problem and
- 51:56it's going on like that for too many years.
- 52:00And I don't see anybody coming and say education is important.
- 52:07And this will like in Switzerland that education is #1
- 52:13because everybody understands their own children.
- 52:17So the the rich pick up private schools and then kids are not in
- 52:24the public schools but all the rest of the population.
- 52:30Even where I live you cannot teach in high school without a
- 52:37master degree or a PhD. At least the master but prefers
- 52:43PhD. But I got money from the
- 52:47National Science Foundation to work with teachers in the
- 52:52Chicago Public School and there were teachers that teach taught
- 52:58science that all what they by themself have had is two classes
- 53:04of science as undergraduate and they had only a bachelor degree
- 53:09with a major in music and they could have been science.
- 53:12Teachers. Now this is the problem if I
- 53:17call science education a human rights.
- 53:22Do you think that if the Department of Education is
- 53:26abolished or they take education back to the states, a lot of
- 53:31states are doing school choice? Do you think any of those are
- 53:34good moves? The education never was taken
- 53:38out of the states. Education always was at the
- 53:42hands of the state, so the Department of Education could
- 53:47not really influence much. No, education is not only states
- 53:53this, it's even more locally than states.
- 53:57Every city has their own curriculum.
- 54:01There is nothing. Other countries have national
- 54:05curriculum. the US doesn't have something like that.
- 54:10So to be honest, President Carter started the Department of
- 54:16Education, but I never understood the function if
- 54:22education is in the hands of the states.
- 54:25So I don't think there will be much change by eliminating the
- 54:30Department of Education. I think cutting money from the
- 54:35National Science Foundation or NIH, the National Institute of
- 54:40Health, is a disaster and this will affect science in the US
- 54:48for many years. If somebody will not wake up
- 54:52very fast and will install all this monies back.
- 54:57I think this is the disaster, but not the elimination of the
- 55:00Department of Education. Yeah, that makes sense that I'm
- 55:09surprised we don't have a national curriculum, but.
- 55:13You know, country still works very separately by states, and
- 55:19the curriculum is so, so different.
- 55:23Things that can be taught in a blue state cannot be taught in a
- 55:28red state. I remember how much we thought
- 55:32that evolution should be taught in older states.
- 55:39It's it's will be very hard to the division is too strong the
- 55:47US to be able to to do a national curriculum.
- 55:53But if you have any safe National Science Foundation that
- 55:57they're responsible of the grants for education, like they
- 56:02help a lot to raise the education.
- 56:05NIH is all our health depends on that.
- 56:09That they cut the money for Cancer Research, for vaccines.
- 56:15It's our life. What are we going to be like
- 56:20Africa? I cannot understand the
- 56:25rationale behind that. Right.
- 56:30Yeah, I I'm not sure. Some of it I understand.
- 56:35And might lose our best scientists because.
- 56:38Right make. Money to do a science and a lot
- 56:42of other countries pour a fortune into research.
- 56:47Right, right. And that's where you're, that's
- 56:49where you're going to go where you're able to to.
- 56:51Do the things that. You're wanting to do?
- 56:53Yeah. Would you like to show us your
- 56:56book again? Here is the book and the book is
- 57:01now in paperback. Yeah, in on Amazon, I'm sure on
- 57:06everything. A Barnes and Noble online and
- 57:10paperback is much cheaper. And if you read the reviews on
- 57:15Amazon, you will see why it's important for everybody to read
- 57:21this book. A lot of messages and you can
- 57:25see what one woman can make changes in the world and you can
- 57:29be the same, especially young people.
- 57:32It doesn't have to be a a woman, a man can make a change too and
- 57:37to the better. So this is the book.
- 57:41And if people want to see, for example, videos about how to use
- 57:50a theatre or dance to teach science, my personal website
- 57:56iszafferlammen.com. OK.
- 57:59If you want to know more about the Malta Conference, the
- 58:04website ismaltaconferencesfoundation.org.
- 58:12OK. All right.
- 58:14Is there anything else you'd like people to to check out or
- 58:17maybe look into as far as science education and keeping
- 58:22that alive? We have a YouTube that has all
- 58:26the videos that the student produced both in music and art
- 58:33and dance and and animation. And this is Lehman Institute
- 58:40YouTube. OK, you can look for that too.
- 58:45All right, I will post those links so that everyone can just
- 58:48click on them, so. All right.
- 58:50Sounds very nice talking to you. You too.
- 58:53Good luck. Yes, thank you.