Latest / 501(c)-Wheee! / S1E2: Great Expectations (Illusions and disillusionment of working in nonprofits)
Transcript
- Katrina: Welcome! let me start again. Welcome to 501C Wii! Still good. Still got it. I'm Katrina, a toddler mom, wholesale Pandasal Baker, Native New Yorker, and nonprofit executive coach. And I'm Nina, a mom of two, yogi, aspiring SoCal soccer mom, and comms consultant. We're two friends who met working at a charitable foundation on Fifth Avenue, surrounded by ambitious people and missions to save the world. It's been Over a decade since then, the world has not been saved, and we've dropped our rose-colored glasses. Instead, we picked up many new opinions, stories, and friends along the way. And somehow we discovered our commitment to the nonprofit sector only grew. So now we're here to chat, ask, learn, and laugh with you all as we try to make sense of a sector that the world desperately needs, but sometimes makes zero sense. Whatever you happen to be doing right now, changing your baby's diaper or commuting to Work. We're so happy you're here. Let's get started. What's on today's agenda, Katrina? Well, today's episode is about great expectations, the illusions and disillusionment of working in nonprofits. So really thinking about why, when, and how it happens for us, for other professionals, for our friends, people within our network. But I think before we get started, as with the last episode and all other episodes, we'll start off with an icebreaker. Mm-hmm. So I think we decided that our icebreaker is just to talk about what is happening right now. Okay, so describe where we are. We're overlooking, I think that's downtown Brooklyn. Because I am in New York after three years, like three years ago almost to the month. my gosh. Sam and I moved away. To the month. Yeah, in our that's crazy. Well we left September twenty-first, which is like almost the first day of yeah, and that was when I was pregnant with first kid. Mm-hmm. And it's been three years already. Mm-hmm. it's been it's been really I don't know, just kind of surreal people at each other face to face. With our big old eyes. Yeah. I mean I am within arm's reach of Nina right now. So it's just kind of crazy. It is really crazy. But yeah. Yeah. Well. Incredible being back. Yeah. So it just is like, I don't know, layering and layering of meaning. Yeah. On top of these places. Yeah. I mean New York holds a special place in your heart for sure. Well, I realize that I've lived here longer than I've lived any other place. Including wild. Including, yeah, where we were in Hermosa. California. Yeah. Eight and a half years longer. Yeah. So See Katrina again later this week. Yeah. All the catching up. And then we'll bring our children together. It's yeah, there will be no catching up. No. There will be catching babies. Literally catching babies. Physically catching babies. Yeah, catching our running away babies. Yeah. but it's gonna be great. I'm really looking forward to the next hang with with the kiddos. Okay, well, thank you all for joining us for the second episode and a little bit of reminiscing. Should we get into it? Yeah, let's do it. so we're going to be talking about the illusions that we came with as we entered the sector. Yeah. I also thought we could start with things that we expected or things that we didn't expect, like think about it in that way too. Okay, I was thinking about this topic well, last night really. and I think one thing that probably proved to be true 'cause I think in episode one I talked a little bit about my hesitations around the sector. But one thing that proved to be true is the potential for self-righteousness. I'm just gonna go for the jugular. And how many people really actually literally like I'm quoting here, thought they were doing capital G God's work. Regardless of it, it wasn't a religious non organization where I heard these words exactly, but people just really walking around and being like, I'm doing God's work. Yeah. This is the holy of holiest work. And it kind of allowed for a lot of, I don't know, misbehavior, maybe disrespect. Yeah. I also heard the words, we're the adults in the room. So I think there's a lot of yeah, there's a lot of moral superiority that goes on and I think it can be weird because it's sort of religious in its fervor. Mm-hmm. Even if it's not in a religious institution at all. Again, it's just moral superiority. And when people are really steeped in that, I think it just justifies a lot of really gross mismanagement, mistreatment of colleagues, of people that work under you. Even weirdly like hostility toward the communities that people are supporting. One of our voice notes will get into this. Yeah. Very viscerally, actually. Yeah, maybe that was part of my disillusionment, even though I might have seen it coming. Yeah. As I said back in college, I was like, a lot of people are also just here to like feel really powerful. And yeah, and then the last thing I'll say on that is that I think it's really I recognize that in people because I also have that impulse in me. And I it's really ugly. in retrospect, you know, I look back on myself ten years ago and I know I had that that moral high ground thing where I just would be like this I mean, this is really embarrassing to admit, but when we worked at foundations. And we'd be working with so many subject matter experts and be learning so much from, you know, the other disciplines. Yeah. It's kind of like when people like have their a lot of people have a religious conversion moment. And the first year or two is them being an absolute a-hole about it to everyone else because they're basically immature about it. And I had that experience and I look back and I'm just I cringe at the things that I said or did. And of course I cringe now when other people treat me in a certain way because they're in that place or like new religious energy, or they're like a new convert. And I think I see that in the nonprofit field too. And then, you know, in ten years from now I'm sure I'm I'm gonna look back on myself now and see myself in that same judgmental place. But hopefully I'm just evolving out of that. But yeah, I think that that's kind of what can lead to disillusionment because, you know, if you're made to feel shitty all the time and look down on because you're not savvy enough about this topic or you're not up and up on the latest lingo. Yeah. Yeah. That kind of stuff is really it's hard to work. No, there's definitely a certain level of martyrdom yeah that comes with working. with professionals in the nonprofit sector. Which in some ways I can understand how that complex develops, right? you're addressing an issue, a really important issue. And when you're at the forefront and you see the change that you are making, yeah, of course you're going to get a little gassed from it. Yeah. Because you're seeing the impact of all the hard work that you've been putting into into this specific area of focus. How much you've sacrificed. Exactly. Probably. And when you are Sacrificing so much, you can't help but you know, feel a little bit of resentment towards the rest of the world that isn't doing enough for not caring enough, for not sacrificing enough like you are. yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. I can understand how that happens. That doesn't excuse it, right? That's that's an explanation, it's not an excuse. but I think we see that across the board. I think we're probably just a little bit more conscious about it because everything is just so public. The rise of social media, the rise of just information out there, right? So, you would hope, that more people are a little bit more conscious about how they're showing up in these spaces. so I will say that my illusionment about the nonprofit sector is that everyone just held fabulous galas. Yeah. I think that is really where I thought all nonprofits have these black tie events and are raising a shit ton of money and you have cocktails and you have beautiful food and you are mingling and everyone is donating thousands of dollars just to sit at a table. Yeah, that's right. and that wasn't even the space that I was in when I first entered in the sector because I was working in medical academia. So but there were doctors that were doing that level. Of I guess fundraising and schmoozing. And I'm saying, like, I'm talking about doctors that raised millions of dollars for the institution to not only fund their research, but also fund a professorship or you know, some of their infrastructure to build out a lab or to fund new research spaces. Yeah. Right? And I've been to some of those events that doctors would hold. And I just remember that being a whole hoopla. Yeah. And I'm like, my gosh, now he's gonna get so much money. And he's gonna have another fabulous party, right? And this was really the illusion that I think after leaving medical academia, something that stayed with me until I entered the foundation. But to your experience, was that turnoff or was it repulsive at all like repelling you from consciously entering more into the nonprofit field or was it just something you were like it was an understanding that you had I think for me it was kind of a turn on at the moment. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay. And I was also young. Yeah. And I It was glam. It was glam. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, when you're in your early to mid, even to late twenties, living in New York City. You want the ballgowns. You want the ballgowns. You wanna, you know, this is this is the the age group that came up on the gossip girl era, right? Yes. You wanna live the glam. Was I making money to live a glam life? No. But I was using the environment around me, yeah, to support that glam life. but when you're around it, you're kind of like, ooh, yeah, I wanna I wanna rub shoulders with these people because they seem like they're doing excellent work while also. Having a good time. Good time. I don't want us to come off as like it's a bad thing. It's just it's good to be intentional about it because if that's where dollars are going or energy is going, it just is part of the world to know and be aware about as opposed to assuming It's like that for everybody or it should be that way. Right. And listen, I'm not opposed to having a good time. No, no, exactly. You know, like let's bring the energy, let's bring the love in these spaces. Yeah. Yeah. But I think it was also what, as you said, what was the intention behind it? Yeah. Was it really to create community? Not so much. At least not in those galas that I was attending. You can definitely feel in some galas whether the community is real. Yeah. I mean I've we've been to the galas like that. Right. and and it's fun and we dress up yeah we have a good time yeah and it is wonderful but then there are the other gallas where people are just showing up to be seen. Exactly saving the world. Right doing really, really good stuff. This reminds me actually I totally forgot about this but I think before I enter the foundation world I definitely thought that foundations were like Leonardo DiCaprio Foundation or XYZ Celebrity Founder. Like I didn't that. Ryan's Diamond Ball. I thought that's what it was. I hated that. I completely forgot that that's what I thought foundations were celebrity PR schemes. Yeah. No, I agree. That's how that's what I also believed and imagined that all galas would be these really huge events. They would generate so much revenue for the organization. I think when I was at the foundations, that's when things started to shift. I wouldn't say that was the pivotal moment where I started to better understand the work ahead in the sector, but that was definitely an opportunity to get more explosion. exposure to how organizations were operating were rallying in the reality of it yeah Yeah. I think a good place to mention that disillusionment is an important step. Yeah. I think in any relationship actually. yeah. Just to remove illusion. I yeah, any even in marriage and friendship with kids, like all aspects of life. Just coming out of a place of realism as opposed to living under this delusion, you know, that somebody or something is I don't know, some dreamy some dreamy thing. I think illusions though in all of this are important. Like thinking about the rose colored glasses, being starry-eyed. It's important to come in with expectations. We also need to come into the field or the field needs people who go in expecting a lot. Cause that is how we raise the bar. Yes. That is how we move anything from from just a a it's the status quo to something that could be better. And I think it's just sad that along the way, you know, we lose out on really talented people who are like, I don't need to deal with this hypocrisy. I don't need to deal with this pe being lorded over. superiority complexes and everything. So we yeah, we I think that's the loss. But when you have people who come in and they're like, Wait, I actually thought this would be better and I'm gonna fight for it to be better, then that's when we get philanthropic reform. Or changes to how boards work. So they're more maybe community oriented or less top down and less tyrannical. Or like when foundations started paying for more general support. Yeah, like the overhead that nonprofits need I think there's a long time where you just assumed it was just a waste of money. Yeah. Well, I think I think what you were saying but didn't name explicitly is that on top of coming in with high expectations, which is important, as you said, to raise the bar of the work that we're doing, I think it's equally important to be adaptable to change. Right? Yeah. You can come with with the high expectations and I'm all for that. But as we talk about reform, as we talk about, you know, shifting the ways we work. I think being nimble in addition to having these high expectations is key. If you're unable to pivot, if you're unable to shift with the tides of what's happening, that's where we find ourselves in a pickle. Yeah. I think we've both worked at places where, well, especially when people are in positions of power. And They know how they got there. Right. I mean, I have specific people in mind who were at their organizations for like decades. Yeah. And if that's how they got to their place of expertise and respect in their field, It's gonna be hard for them to be nimble. Yeah. No totally open to new energy coming in and changing it. I mean, we see that a lot. I saw that a lot, and I'm imagine that you saw that a lot. with founder syndrome. yeah. There are definitely founders who are ready to let go. Yeah. Right. And allow the new leader to just step in and do what they find is best for the organization for the game. Allow for an evolution that is outside of them. Exactly. There are others that because they've been in the game for so long They have zero trust in the transition from one leader to another, which is really challenging. And I've seen that happen, right? Where the the founder is still there in a quote unquote advisory role or like some type of board role where they are quote unquote emeritus. Exactly, yes. But they can't help themselves but to impose their processes, yeah, their leadership style, or even really fight change to programming. Yeah. Which is really hard for the leaders to come in and change and do what they're seeing needs to be done in the sector. I think this is present in family foundations as well. yeah. Family foundations are so fascinating. I This is something that I've been thinking about also as I think about my my shift. I would love to get into family philanthropy. man. Yeah, you tell me about it because I don't ever want to step into one of those. Family foundations seem like such an interesting beast to navigate. Right? Because you have a living board and you have living board. You ha you have people sharing their thoughts, rightfully so. But it's also it's their money. Right. Yeah, obviously they're gonna have a say in work but then you wonder, wait, how closely have you actually worked in this community that you're hoping to support? You can't help but pass judgment on it. Well not only that, but the the bar for accountability is much higher. Like the responsibility with all that money. There needs to be more presidential. There needs to be yeah, there needs to be. Is there actual accountability for them? No. Right? The it the level of accountability is much lower. Well and because they hold so much of the wealth of the of the country. Well, and I think that's kind of the inherent difficulty with philanthropy in general. Like one of the challenges that you have to step into, or like, I don't know, fancy word, problematic, of the whole philanthropic field is how to steward that power responsibly. Yeah. well in a way that power actually just still you know, what is it goes down. when I was in grad school, one of my instructors said that people do not give just to get the tax rate off. Mm-hmm. They don't. They are motivated by other things. Which I think broadly speaking is true. Yeah. But let's not forget that there are tax benefits. There are major yes. So many for the ultra wealthy to give. And for them it's probably a d a drop in the bucket. Yeah. Quite honestly. but I think that's something that, you know, I think a lot of people assume too, that, well, you know, give for the tax write off. And some are motivated by that level of financial incentive and some are genuinely motivated by their hope to create change. Or i or have a lived experience that they want to wrap out of. Exactly. But that I think that's something that a lot of people also think, the nonprofit sector, you can use it as a financial tool. I think there are a lot of icky tax. There are a lot of icky loopholes that people can really to protect wealth, basically. yeah. I mean, there are really smart ways to do it. Right. For sure. Mm-hmm. Not against smart financial planning. Yeah. But it's the use of a social good mechanism for personal gain, I think that's where we get kind of yeah weirded out. Right. Because they're they're basically manipulating the system in such a way that they benefit from things that wasn't necessarily intended to be used in that way. But because it's that loophole. Yeah, well I I don't even know if it's a loophole, it's like they're just using they're just holes they're just holes in the system. Yeah, I guess. Yeah. It's just a way yeah, different motivations can play a part in sector and it makes the sector really complicated. Right. Like the whole structure is like really complicated because there are these motivations involved in it. Right, exactly. Which I think plays into this other level of complexity around the sector is that all nonprofits have to be poor. Yes. If you enter into the nonprofit sector, traditionally speaking, I think the generalization is that if you work in the sector, you're supposed to be poor. Yeah. Just like your nonprofit organization is supposed to be poor or strained of resources. This reminds me of the whole misconception of all artists are serving. The whole starving artist thing of like you have to be in such dire straits to be doing your best work and that's not the case. people are making livelihood out of nonprofit work. I mean it's an it's a job too that supports families. Right. People need living wages. People want to be in dignified workplaces. and sometimes it just does get really, really extreme. Let's talk about the ways that working in in our fields has exceeded our expectations in really incredible ways. Because there has there's so much of that. I have met so many incredible, incredible people. working in some capacity in nonprofits. the passion for a very particular population or this one neighborhood in their city or they had a really traumatic experience and are trying to make sure no one else has the experience they did. I mean, I just can't believe how inspired I've been for the last ten year ten fifteen years of my career. it just is remarkable. I I think that kind of thing is priceless. And has kept me in the field because I don't wanna stop being around those kinds of people. Like really incredible human beings. I agree. And I think I've also been exposed to people who have sacrificed a lot but never get to that martyrdom feel because they know that there's always more work to be done. And I think when you always see the goal far, far away you know, and you overcome feelings of hopelessness what is more hopeful than that. Mm-hmm. It's incredibly hopeful just to keep doing the work. just getting up day after day and and doing the thing. what you make me think of are the leaders who Have the foresight anticipate the necessary changes with that level of intentionality for the betterment of their communities. Right? You can have leaders with foresight, but it's really thinking about what is their North Star. that is driving them to think ahead and anticipate and then make the shifts they need to make for their communities. Yeah. I think that's really where you c see that difference between those working in the sector and those that aren't. Right? We're really thinking about it holistically. How does this impact not only our immediate organization, but how does it impact the rest of the communities that we're in, that we're serving, the leaders we're also supporting. So I think the the idea for the most part, or at least in my experiences, I similar to you, the people we've met and the intentionality they come with, I think is super meaningful. It's so beautiful. It is really a beautiful thing to see that they're using their skills, their intelligence, their resources to generate that level of impact. Yeah. That we're all hoping to see in the sector. Yeah. From a communications perspective, I feel like I've been in just countless rooms where I'm listening to someone you know, speak about what they did last year, the work that they've seen over the last ten years, the changes in their in their hometowns, their communities, wherever they're working in, and I'm like, wow, no one knows about this except for their funders and their direct beneficiaries. Yeah. There's no New York Times article about this. There's no publicity. Ideally there is because maybe, you know, some other community half around the world can benefit from the same exact solution. Or innovation. But I just I just think, wow, this is not for glory. This is not for fame. It's just real raw passion. And dedication. It's it's so stunning and that that's just constantly happening. I think at social impact agencies where you're taking on a lot of clients, I think what I hear a lot from colleagues and my own experience has been sometimes the work in the agency is really mind numbing. Or you know, you're doing your time sheets or You're in all these meetings, but it's when you get the chance to be on the ground and interviewing, I don't know, teachers at a school in Colombia, rural Colombia, and they're talking about like a I don't know, community health workers coming all the way out to see them. And it's funded through some complicated international consortium or whatever. And it just all that is really complicated. Once once you actually talk to the students and the teachers and the parents, you're like, my gosh, this is what this is for. Yeah. And that's that's what you get in in this in this field. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Constantly. Right. it's it's really special. Well, I think another thing that has been really beautiful to see, And that I've really appreciated seeing in the nonprofit sector is that there are so many people that are just constantly looking to learn. Mm-hmm. Right? They constantly want to hear what's happening in the field. They want to be on the pulse of the types of changes that we need and understanding how can I be part of that change. They're really keeping an ear to the ground around what is it that these communities need. need what is it in my area of focus that is coming up as you know the hope for change and how can I be part of it or how if I can't be part of it who do I know that can also create that change right and I think that's something that I really appreciated is that there's been this change I would say specifically in Philanthropy too. That I think when I started it, you kind of came in with this idea that foundations are the ones that are kind of leading the charge around what change looks like. And therefore, they're picking the types of organizations and grantees that will create that change. When really over time Foundations are more so the vessels. that support that change because the leaders on the ground are really those nonprofit leaders. Yes. Right. The grantees that are creating the programs, right? And they're seeing, well, this is actually what needs to happen. Who are the partners we can bring along to support that? Yeah right. So I think there's been kind of this shift where philanthropy has no longer taken well I'm not talking across the board. No. There are definitely some foundations there so like, no, we are the experts in the room. We hold the purse string So it's our agenda. Exactly. is that my style? No. It's not my style either. No, and I think we bonded over that before. Yeah. But there are definitely some foundations that feel that way. But for those that they're the thought leaders, they are the ones with the vision. for those that have really leaned into the idea that we need to take a grante-centered approach and really listen to our partners and genuinely see them as partners and as the leaders and we are here to support that work. I think those are the ones that are really getting it right. And I've seen that type of relationship blossom and bloom really beautifully between program officers, foundation partners, and organizations because then they can have really meaningful conversations with each other. Yeah, really constructive. Yeah, constructive, transparent. I think it's actually quite apparent when people talk about the work that they're funding or the work that they're doing that is getting funded, you can kind of tell. a certain point you can read between the lines and see, is this a is this relationship that's symbiotic and constructive and people are staying in their lanes, or is it one where it's sort of, I don't know, top down dictatorial, people are trying to like make sure they check off the boxes of their grant requirements. Yeah. Yeah. Right. So when we think about, you know, philanthropy as a place of privilege. Yes. As you said, those types of spaces can also be really humbling. Yeah. And when with the right leadership exactly. The right leadership. And when leaders are willing to act with a level of humility and to say, do I have experience? Yeah. Yes. Am I the smartest person in the room? Probably not. I know. I know. That I think really can be a challenge, but when done well is pretty amusing. It's a whole approach. Yeah. I've taken the most from those kinds of leaders when I've been in when I've been in the room with them. Yeah, same. It's and I'm just like especially in this day and age where the incentive with media and press and everything is to come out as the number one expert. Mm-hmm. Yeah. When the incentives are so high for that and you know, thought leadership, X, Y, Z, everything. people who would like kind of, you know, yeah side sidestep and like make room for somebody else. Right. And also the types of funders that don't need to be the voice on behalf of the sector. And rather invite other voices to the table to be able to share their stories. What are our takeaways? I think the takeaway so Carly Ray Jepson's latest album. What? She has a new album? I feel like she's one of the most underrated pop stars ever, and I've been following her music for the last, I don't know, last four albums or something. I'm not the only person I know that says that actually. Yeah. Okay, since Call Me Maybe, I feel like people are like, okay, she did song. But her pop just feels so sophisticated. I highly recommend go listen to I think it's called Night and Day or Day and Night. I've been listening to it on the key. The whole album. Yeah. It was about a month ago, I think. Okay. Very, very good for anyone who's interested in pop. Okay. Yeah. I've been listening to her and Bad Bunny. Bad Bonnie. and Shakira. Yeah. But anyway, Carly Rejepson's latest album. Yeah, go check it out. That's a plug-in for Carly Rach. Carly Rachel, if you hear this podcast, I'm her unexpected ambassador. Send Nina some free tickets because she just made a plug for you. I'd love to go. Yeah, I heard this really good quote on the radio as I was driving here. I love that. I know I Listening to the radio is also underrated. Yes, I love the radio. I mean you can you can defer to your Spotify so easily because you know what you like, but when you listen to the radio, it's a different experience for sure. I love my Kiss FM. Yeah SoCal. I listened to I think it was on Power One five one. I can't remember. Whoever Charlemagne the god is. Fucking hate that dude. But I think today on the radio today he was saying that he follows this page on Instagram and it was I think it's a page of indigenous hip hop and rap artists. And one of the one of the posts said that Calm is a flex. And the way it ended is that in a world full of noise, being able to stay silent and reflective is a strength. Wow. And takes a lot of work. So don't underestimate the ability to be calm and silent. Alright, well on that note stay calm out there, people. Stay calm and carry on. Thanks for listening. hope you enjoy this episode. Tune in for the next one, and we'll continue to bring you all of the same and fun goodies that we have been. Bye. Bye. Wh we can talk.