Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / Inside the World of Defense Lobbying with Gene Moran
Transcript
- 0:26The Welcome to this very special edition of the KJ Master Class
- 0:30Live the show which ensures that you profit from your time spent
- 0:34here with experts, either through the industry, insights,
- 0:37information or simply. Learning from them.
- 0:41And today we have Gene Moran joining us Live Straightway from
- 0:45Florida, USA. And he is an award-winning a top
- 0:49defense lobbyist and and consultant, and also the
- 0:54president of Capital Integration.
- 0:56Welcome to the show. Jade.
- 0:59AJ, thanks for having me. Good to be here.
- 1:02Good to have you on the show and I am sure.
- 1:05You know a. Lot of people.
- 1:07Who would be? Wanting to understand more about
- 1:10the about the world of defense lobbying.
- 1:13This is a very. Different sort of world for
- 1:16different people. For some it is about ARM, for
- 1:20some it is about a lot of money and for some who want to also
- 1:24understand how. This defense lobbing.
- 1:27Works. What do middle men do?
- 1:29I don't see you as a middleman, more of a who explains an open
- 1:33doors for people. So this is what you know and in.
- 1:36India, Several deals. Have come under different sort
- 1:39of questions under different government, so a lot of people
- 1:42do want to. Understand all these things but.
- 1:451st to understand from you Jane, is that you are an
- 1:48award-winning. Defense lobbyist.
- 1:51Who gives awards? To a defense lobbyist.
- 1:55Well, that is a great question. There are industry associations
- 1:59who who pay attention to how effective a company or an
- 2:05organization might be in shaping or influencing a government
- 2:11outcome. There are lobbying associations.
- 2:15There are defense industry associations, each of which
- 2:19bestow awards On a On a broader level, there are consulting
- 2:25organizations that bestow recognition to those who achieve
- 2:31high success. In the US, Bloomberg Government
- 2:35is a is a well recognized name. They track who is influencing
- 2:41outcomes. The National Institute of
- 2:43Lobbying and Ethics is another big name within the lobbying
- 2:47industry that that tracks how things are are moving and who
- 2:52who has achieved success on behalf of their clients.
- 2:56Those are just a couple. Right, right.
- 3:00Help us understand this. You know this?
- 3:03Lobbying business How? Does this work?
- 3:07What does? A lobbyist do.
- 3:09Earlier you were in corporate lobbying, before that you were,
- 3:13if I understand and you are a very educated man, you have got
- 3:16a PhD in public policy. You have been into army and
- 3:20army, Navy, Navy captain. So all these things make you the
- 3:25right person. You know both from the from the
- 3:29educated people side, both from the understanding of a general
- 3:33person side you know and also also from the business side.
- 3:38And in this backdrop, help us also understand about the
- 3:41military industrial complex, whether it is a good word or a.
- 3:45Bad word. Help us understand this this
- 3:48whole business. Of arms lobbying.
- 3:51Yeah lobbying can be a charged word particularly in the US that
- 3:55where the the misdeeds of a very few made some made some big
- 4:00headlines. And you know typically when when
- 4:04bad things happen and people you know are execute misconduct they
- 4:10are they are charged in and they go to jail and there have been a
- 4:13few that have been charged and gone to jail.
- 4:16But on the on the on the in a larger sense lobbying is about
- 4:21helping to shape and influence outcomes and outcomes can be
- 4:26funding or policy and the way our government works.
- 4:32The executive branch makes a proposal to Congress, our
- 4:36legislative branch of how they think that spending should
- 4:41unfold. Congress gets to put its imprint
- 4:45on that request and industry has a say with the executive branch
- 4:51and with Congress. So I say that there are three
- 4:54rings of the circus of federal sales industry agency in
- 4:57Congress and there are opportunities to participate in
- 5:03the process in any of those three rings or all of those
- 5:07three rings typically not at the same time.
- 5:09There's there's usually some sequence but communicating and
- 5:15informing, and educating decision makers throughout that
- 5:19process is what lobbying and advocacy is all about.
- 5:24And and there are, you know, very clear rules of how it can
- 5:28be conducted at what level of government one is allowed to
- 5:32communicate, how it's reported that there's communication
- 5:35happening. So it it's actually quite
- 5:38transparent, much more so than many other aspects of our lives.
- 5:44But it but the the very high profile misdeeds of the few seem
- 5:48to get more attention and so there's a generally negative
- 5:52perception of what lobbying is about.
- 5:55As a result very very few companies participate in it.
- 6:01My research for my PhD focused on defense companies and the
- 6:07executives understanding of Congress, and I documented that
- 6:12the levels of awareness of how the process really works are
- 6:17quite low and less than 1% of defense companies participate in
- 6:24lobbying. So you would think it being the
- 6:28largest part of our federal government budget that there
- 6:31would be many, many more, but but there just aren't.
- 6:35Right, right. So who?
- 6:37Are the you say a? Lot of companies get dissuaded
- 6:40by. Whatever controversy that
- 6:43happens in some instances, what happened in the past?
- 6:47Then who are the major? Participants.
- 6:49Is it only about the big players?
- 6:52Is it? Is it that there is?
- 6:54Room for smaller players. How does that work?
- 6:57And you say that you know. You open doors for access of.
- 7:02Access for companies. Selling in Washington, DC So who
- 7:06do you open doors for? Is it about?
- 7:08Big companies. Is it also about?
- 7:11Smaller companies and Is it only that U.S. companies can sell to
- 7:17the US government or is it for, say, companies from outside they
- 7:21can? Be a part a bidder into this
- 7:23process. You know the the interesting
- 7:26thing AJ is that the same process applies whether the
- 7:30company is small, medium or large.
- 7:33They're all selling into the same process.
- 7:37The larger companies have the ability to put more people and
- 7:42resources on different parts of the government apparatus.
- 7:46So they might assign people specifically to agencies in our
- 7:50executive branch. They might assign people to
- 7:53specific members of Congress or committees of Congress to pay
- 7:58attention to. They may have professional
- 8:01communicators on staff who help write op-ed pieces and articles
- 8:07and professional commentary. So those larger companies do
- 8:11have some advantages, but the process is the same for small,
- 8:15medium or large. And you know we might want to
- 8:18define what is a large company. I I typically use a break point
- 8:23of about a billion in revenue or more is a is a large company in
- 8:28in by US standards a small company is somebody with less
- 8:31than 50 million in revenue and a few 100 people on on staff.
- 8:37But this this process is the same.
- 8:40What happens in in lobbying is that the very large companies
- 8:45tend to spend more on it because they're able to.
- 8:49And the the numbers definitely show that large very large
- 8:55companies, the big big 10 primes have significant advantages of
- 9:00size. So half of acquisition dollars
- 9:03go to fewer than 50 companies. Yet in our US defense industrial
- 9:09base, there are nearly 1,000,000 companies.
- 9:13And so if if half go to just 50 companies, you can see where
- 9:18there's a, there's a challenge. We have some other policies that
- 9:22allow smaller businesses to get some advantage, but there's a
- 9:26big group in the middle, several 100,000 companies who don't have
- 9:30any of those advantages. And so they can really benefit
- 9:33from somebody helping guide them through the process.
- 9:35And that's that's what I try to do.
- 9:38Companies from around the world can participate in this U.S.
- 9:42market, and they do. There are some restrictions.
- 9:47Our Congress tends to support policies that are about Buy
- 9:53America. We want to preserve our
- 9:56industrial base. We want to make sure that our
- 9:58supply chains are secure in the event of some international
- 10:02calamity. But companies from around the
- 10:06world do participate in in the US defense market.
- 10:12Right, right. Could you explain that?
- 10:15And you know, and it's interesting that. 50 main
- 10:19companies versus there are millions of other companies and
- 10:24these fifty companies control more than 50% of the defense
- 10:29business. Am I if I'm understood?
- 10:30It correct. That is that is correct.
- 10:32Now the numbers are very big. You know, a ship, for example,
- 10:36costs, you know, $3 billion for a smaller ship and over $10
- 10:41billion for an aircraft carrier. So.
- 10:44So those dollar values are large for what those large companies
- 10:47can produce. But you know, the, the the fact
- 10:51is that if you're a small company trying to break in you,
- 10:55you really do need some help to understand where to plug into
- 11:01the process. And lobbyists like me typically
- 11:06come with some experience. You mentioned some of my
- 11:08background. You know, I was in the Navy.
- 11:10I was a ship captain ashore. I worked in Washington.
- 11:14DCI represented the Navy to our Congress.
- 11:18I've been around this from multiple perspectives.
- 11:22My time as a corporate defense lobbyist exposed me to industry.
- 11:27You mentioned the military industrial complex.
- 11:30That is something. You know it.
- 11:32It is a, it is a term that's been with us for decades.
- 11:37But there are these interrelationships of I call it
- 11:41the three rings of the circus industry agency in Congress that
- 11:44they have to work together for the process to unfold properly.
- 11:49It's it's how our government is designed.
- 11:51It's how our capital system is designed to to interact with
- 11:55that federal market. But it's not something that's
- 11:59it's learned quickly or easily. It is learnable, but it but it
- 12:04takes time and it's it's easiest to bring people in who have that
- 12:09those experiences rather than try to learn it on your own.
- 12:14Right. And if somebody says.
- 12:17Gene you. Are one of the persons.
- 12:19Who is helping? These 50.
- 12:21Companies control more. Than 50%.
- 12:23Of the business, what would you say, which side are you on?
- 12:26Are you on the side of this 50? Percent Or are you on the side?
- 12:29Of the millions who do not get any business.
- 12:32Yeah. So I I wouldn't say that I take
- 12:34a side I provide the most value to companies that have either a
- 12:38limited Washington presence or no Washington presence.
- 12:42And so those very large companies they have full time
- 12:46offices, you know large offices in Washington DC that are that
- 12:50are focused on this. I I don't provide any unique
- 12:54value to them. Where I can help is companies
- 12:57that need somebody to help them set their strategy, find the
- 13:02opportunity, develop an engagement plan of how to
- 13:06approach the government, and then work with them as as the
- 13:10process unfolds. And over time we're able to
- 13:14influence policy outcomes. Sometimes they're very big
- 13:18policies that affect the national and international
- 13:20issues, even for a small company.
- 13:23Sometimes it's about funding, positioning, funding before a
- 13:27contract comes about. And many, many companies, large
- 13:31and small, miss that government sales in the US is fundamentally
- 13:37about funding. If you don't understand how the
- 13:40money flows, you can chase a contract that won't have money
- 13:45the the right type of money applied to it such that it helps
- 13:48you. Right, right.
- 13:52Gene, help us understand you have.
- 13:53Been a corporate lobbyist also, and now you are a defense
- 13:57lobbyist. How different are these two
- 14:00things? Or is.
- 14:00It only about. Different sectors.
- 14:03Because even defense itself is a IS is a corporate in itself so.
- 14:07How? But still there might be some
- 14:09difference or or there is not much.
- 14:11Difference. Except for that, it's about
- 14:13arms. Well, it's it's unused.
- 14:16It's there's some interesting facts here that I'll share.
- 14:18The the defense industry, although it's the largest part
- 14:22of the federal budget in the US, as an industry defense lobbying
- 14:29does not rank even in the top 20 of industries that lobby at the
- 14:35federal level. There are much bigger industries
- 14:38like pharmaceuticals, financial services, real real estate in
- 14:48the US, the AARP, the American Association of Retired Persons.
- 14:52There there are very large organizations that that lobby
- 14:55that that dwarf or that over shadow defense in terms of how
- 15:01many are, how much influence is being applied.
- 15:06My corporate role, I was in a Washington office of a a large
- 15:11defense company, not not one of the top 50, but just just
- 15:15outside of that. And we oversaw multiple programs
- 15:20that the executive branch was trying to fund and we would try
- 15:24to help achieve outcomes, either funding outcomes most typically
- 15:30or policy outcomes that would affect funding.
- 15:33And when you're in a corporate setting, your full time focus is
- 15:37just on those few programs. The same could apply in other
- 15:42industries where a policy may be under examination.
- 15:47Could be tax, could be something affecting revenue, something
- 15:51affecting sales, where a a company would want to
- 15:55communicate with the relevant congressional committees of
- 16:00oversight to try to shape outcomes.
- 16:03What I do now with the the companies that don't have a
- 16:07Washington presence is, I feel, more roles.
- 16:10So I'm a strategist, I'm a an advisor, I'm a Sherpa, and then
- 16:17I can orchestrate meetings and open doors and guide people
- 16:21through the appropriate type of meeting that will generate an
- 16:25outcome. A lot of people have meetings
- 16:27and they they don't know how to command the meeting, they don't
- 16:29meet with the right people, they meet at the wrong place in time
- 16:32and as a result they don't get an outcome.
- 16:35This this is about helping shape outcomes that lead to good
- 16:39government decisions. Right, right.
- 16:43And. Let me ask you here 2 two
- 16:45things. One is who are these defense?
- 16:49Middle Men. And second parties.
- 16:51A lot of people say that corporate America and the
- 16:55military industrial complex. Also shape a lot of this foreign
- 17:01affairs or foreign issues related to either.
- 17:06It is related to any difficult situation anywhere in the world
- 17:11related to, you know, sales of much more arms and creation of
- 17:16conflicts. How?
- 17:18How does? That happen, is it?
- 17:20Is it like how does the foreign sales of arms happened and where
- 17:24do you people come in? Do you come into the picture at
- 17:28all in terms of sales to different governments from
- 17:31American companies? How does this work and where do
- 17:35that middle men come in in terms of this?
- 17:38Whole process? Is it all?
- 17:40Are they also part of lobbying or are they separate, sort of?
- 17:44People. Yeah.
- 17:47There are actually a couple of questions in there AJ and I'll
- 17:49try to try to break it up a little bit.
- 17:52The term middle men can mean different things to different
- 17:55industries. I would suspect that most
- 17:58industries have some version of of a middle person who does
- 18:04business development before a sale takes place.
- 18:08Speaking in the in the US that is that is that is fairly common
- 18:13in the executive branch and and in most industries we certainly
- 18:17see it in defense. There comes a time when
- 18:20communication with Congress or with very senior levels of
- 18:24government may be required and at that point it becomes
- 18:28lobbying. It is it is no longer just
- 18:30business development and and sales preparation it it is
- 18:33officially lobbying and those those laws are clearly defined
- 18:38with respect to what we call foreign military sales.
- 18:43The US uses these programs where we might sell arms, either
- 18:53articles that are that are no longer used by the US or new
- 18:57product that that may be desired by an international partner or
- 19:02ally. Those can be tools of foreign
- 19:07policy influence and and those are those exchanges are
- 19:13coordinated at the very highest levels of government.
- 19:16There are defense companies who have agents legally registered
- 19:23working with a an allied country or a partner country where they
- 19:30they help coordinate that sort of a sale.
- 19:33But there are other parts of the government involved in that
- 19:36sale. Excuse me, that that must
- 19:40participate. So our State Department our
- 19:44White House staff the the the industry company partner the
- 19:50congressional committee of oversight it could it could be
- 19:53the Foreign Relations Committee could be the Armed Services
- 19:55Committee. There's a there's a decision
- 19:58making apparatus that that is specific to foreign military
- 20:03sales. The a company or I'm I'm sorry,
- 20:08a country could have access to that Channel of sales but it's
- 20:13usually part of a broader. Relationship between 2:00 or
- 20:20more countries. Right, right.
- 20:25I wanted to understand when you are such you have a.
- 20:29Great understanding of this whole defense lobby.
- 20:33You have been a Navy captain, a retired Navy captain now.
- 20:39When you are in that part of the job, sometimes you know you
- 20:43always. Have questions about things
- 20:46happening at at at the political level.
- 20:50I don't want to talk too much of politics in this.
- 20:52But when you look at it from a point of view, all.
- 20:57This lobbying all the. Sales have you, you must be also
- 21:01coming across equipments which are not up to that.
- 21:06Level. And sometimes they use.
- 21:10The services or. Different sort of.
- 21:13People to get through for their sales, you know.
- 21:17How do you? See this as a.
- 21:20As a. Former soldier which might
- 21:23impact the lives of people. How does it does it?
- 21:27Work or. Low quality arms never get
- 21:31through. How does it work?
- 21:33Yeah, for for my situation, my my military background is a is a
- 21:39a bonus. It helps me speak with authority
- 21:44within the executive branch. I understand how our military
- 21:48communicates and how it makes decisions.
- 21:51I've been a participant in that one of my roles.
- 21:55I had a couple of jobs in the Navy where I was in Washington,
- 21:57DC, coordinating with Congress on behalf of the Navy.
- 22:03I ran international delegations for the likes of Senator John
- 22:08McCain, Senator Richard Lugar, Lindsey Graham, Senator
- 22:14Lieberman, just just some examples.
- 22:16People who operate at the very highest levels of government
- 22:19internationally to be able to help educate companies about how
- 22:26some of these communications take place and where a company
- 22:30needs to engage in the process. I I can come forward with with
- 22:36great credibility and put them on target quickly.
- 22:40There are what I call plenty of empty suits in this town and
- 22:45those are those are people who who present themselves as though
- 22:49they might have some particular skill set.
- 22:52But you know, the results bear out over time.
- 22:54My, my work, just as an independent lobbyist for the
- 22:58last 10 years has generated over $5 billion in upside sales for
- 23:03for my clients. Those are those are you know
- 23:07facts on the ground and when one develops A reputation for how
- 23:12they can help a company generate those sort of results that that
- 23:20tends to perpetuate in the form of referral activity.
- 23:24And and hey you need to work with Gene for those that can't
- 23:29deliver. They tend to fade out and you
- 23:32they might be on the scene for a couple of years and and then
- 23:35they they fade away It. I'm I'm confident that the the
- 23:41companies I work with the projects that we work on these
- 23:44are these are things that the government fundamentally wants.
- 23:48We're not trying to fit a square peg into a round hole.
- 23:52We're trying to help the process move more quickly.
- 23:55And so I companies that work with me see results 12 to 18
- 24:00months faster than if they just followed the entire process from
- 24:04start to finish. Right.
- 24:06You have written several. Books, Jimmy, if I understand.
- 24:10And, you know, help us understand what what books?
- 24:13You have written and who is the that book for?
- 24:17If you had told me 10 years ago that I would be a best selling
- 24:21author, I would have laughed and and the same for the the PhD
- 24:25dissertation and I'm now a university professor on the side
- 24:29teaching public policy. These are things that I
- 24:32recognized it my my positioning allowed me to speak with
- 24:36authority on on some things that many people don't know a lot
- 24:39about. So I've written about the three
- 24:42ring circus of federal sales and pitching the big Top.
- 24:45I've written about influence with my co-author Alan Weiss
- 24:48$1,000,000 Influence. I developed a program called
- 24:52Capital Currency. It's an online immersive program
- 24:56with videos and and A and a guidebook and downloadable
- 24:59templates to help teach people how this process works.
- 25:03That's called Capital Currency. I have another book coming out
- 25:06in November, a commercially published book called Government
- 25:09Deals Are Funded, not Sold, and it's to help companies better
- 25:14recognize that in Washington, if it's not funded, it's not real.
- 25:19And there are plenty of people who who chase opportunities that
- 25:23don't have funding behind them, and I know how to find the
- 25:26funding. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 25:30There is much to learn about this.
- 25:33Whole whole thing. That happens.
- 25:36In terms of lobbying, defense. And and these are.
- 25:39Curious matters for all. People.
- 25:41Across the world, including those in India and you know.
- 25:45Normally when I when I do my show for, if it's a business
- 25:49person or a consultant, I generally ask them you know,
- 25:53please tell us more. So that part you can tell that
- 25:56where can people learn more about you?
- 25:58And then I also tell them that how is it that people can, you
- 26:02know, connect with you and and connect with you for?
- 26:05Professionally in this. Case I don't know if I can tell
- 26:08them because defense lobbing is such.
- 26:10A thing and very. Few people would.
- 26:13Actually be able. To talk about a professional
- 26:16relationship with you. But be that as it may, I will
- 26:20still. Ask you how?
- 26:21Can people learn more from from you, about you?
- 26:25And how can people who would want to access make you help,
- 26:29help take your help open some good doors for them, whatever
- 26:33they are producing, how can they do that?
- 26:36Well, the the interesting thing about our our method of
- 26:40government and how federal sales work is that if you can sell in
- 26:44the defense environment of our federal government, you can sell
- 26:48within any agency. It is fundamentally the same.
- 26:51The defense industry is the most highly sophisticated and and
- 26:57well organized of any of the agencies in terms of how federal
- 27:00sales unfold. So if somebody had a had a
- 27:03product or service they were trying to present to anywhere in
- 27:06our federal government, I can help with that.
- 27:10My website genemoran.com has a host of resources access to my
- 27:16books. There are, there are videos I do
- 27:18public speaking. There are case studies of of how
- 27:23things have unfolded. And my hope is that when
- 27:27somebody visits my website that they can see some image of
- 27:31themselves. It may not be the exact product
- 27:34that that that they're trying to sell, but they can understand
- 27:37that there's a process and and when you understand the process
- 27:41and you have a guide to take you through the process, you can
- 27:44achieve wildly spectacular outcomes.
- 27:48Absolutely with this. It's a wrap on this very special
- 27:52edition. Of the KJ master class live.
- 27:55Thank you so much indeed. For joining us.
- 27:57Thanks, AJ.