Latest / The Vegan Report / The Buddha For Veganism. With Bob Isaacson & Ardjani Puig | Ep. 50
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan, and for this episode we will explore the link between Buddhism
- 0:15and veganism.
- 0:16A few months ago I had an incredible conversation with Bhikkhu Sonu, a vegan Buddhist monk,
- 0:23and during the episode we talked about Dharma voices for animals.
- 0:28What is Dharma voices for animals?
- 0:30It's a non-profit organization committed to speaking out when the actions of those
- 0:35in the Buddhist community and the policies of Buddhist centers lead to animal suffering.
- 0:42Since that conversation I knew I had to get this organization on the podcast, and today
- 0:47at last we will be speaking with Bob Isaacson, founder and president of Dharma voices for
- 0:53animals, and Ajani Puik, project director of Dharma voices for animals.
- 0:59So both of you, I'm so happy to have you on, welcome to the show.
- 1:04Thank you, thank you for having us, it's a pleasure to be here and to have this conversation
- 1:08on this important, passionate subject for all of us on the call.
- 1:12Yeah, I'm happy to be here and share whatever I can, whatever you're interested in and your
- 1:18listeners are interested in about Dharma voices for animals.
- 1:22Amazing.
- 1:23So my first question for you has to do with being strategic in making an impact for the
- 1:31vegan cause.
- 1:33And this is how I introduced my conversation, my former conversation with Biko Sonu.
- 1:39I asked him, how come there aren't more initiatives out there that target leaders in our communities,
- 1:49like business leaders or religious leaders, who will then implement greater change in
- 1:56their own community?
- 1:58They have that power, they already have that much influence on a greater number of people.
- 2:05Yeah, so Bob Isaacson here, so I started this organization Dharma voices for animals with
- 2:12three friends in California in 2011.
- 2:16And the reason we did it was all four of us had experienced frustration in attending retreats
- 2:25at places that were sometimes not even vegetarian, let alone vegan.
- 2:33There seemed to be such a disconnect between the Buddhist message of compassion for all
- 2:37sentient beings and the actual practice of serving animal flesh and or animal products,
- 2:44milk, eggs, etc.
- 2:47So we started it because we realized I tried individual advocacy along with two friends,
- 2:53we actually did this work independently, then we met each other, and we decided we needed
- 2:57an organization.
- 2:58So we started.
- 2:59So you make a really good point.
- 3:01If we're just talking one on one, it's important to talk one on one with people for sure.
- 3:07But we don't change that many hearts and minds if we do that.
- 3:11But instead, if we talk to institutions, leaders, as you put it, that's the vision of DVA, as
- 3:17you mentioned.
- 3:18So in each country, so I just should mention to your listeners, we have important projects
- 3:24in four countries.
- 3:26First of all, our US project, we call it our US Centers Project, and our Johnny Plyg is
- 3:30here to talk about there to share other information and understandings insights that she has.
- 3:38We also have a project in three countries, three Asian countries, and that's Thailand,
- 3:44Sri Lanka, and Vietnam.
- 3:46Those three countries have a combined Buddhist population of about 141 million Buddhists.
- 3:55So the reason for DVA is the reason we're in those three countries, that Buddhism is
- 4:01the religion or spiritual path.
- 4:06Other people would call it a religion of choice of the majority of the people.
- 4:12In Thailand, 65 million people identify as Buddhists have a population of 70 million.
- 4:18And there we talk to the monks, we talk to the monks, there's about 300,000, not a lot
- 4:23of nuns in Thailand.
- 4:26Most of the monastics are monks or men, and they eat everything.
- 4:32The way they interpret their precepts, they have to accept whatever is offered.
- 4:36People understand that the monks like to eat, they like the taste of animal flesh, eggs.
- 4:42Some monks are eating seven or eight eggs a day in Thailand, but they suffer, scientific
- 4:48studies have been done there, they suffer from the worst kinds of disease, cancer, heart
- 4:53disease, high blood pressure, obesity, and, did I say cancer?
- 4:59Yeah, all the big ones that you can think of.
- 5:01So we talk to the monks there, and we're not even talking about compassion.
- 5:05They don't want to hear from a guy from California about compassion.
- 5:08They want to hear, and I'm from California.
- 5:10They want to hear from, they want to, they are concerned about their health, which is
- 5:14why we talk to them about their health.
- 5:17And slowly this compassion emerges so that they can see another reason.
- 5:23And what we're starting to also talk to them about the environment to give them three really
- 5:28good reasons to be vegan.
- 5:29So similar stories in the other countries.
- 5:32Vietnam is Mahayana, Buddhist country, and there they believe that the Buddha was vegetarian,
- 5:38and he wanted his followers to be.
- 5:41So we're starting at a much higher place in Vietnam, but so few of the Vietnamese folks
- 5:46are vegetarian, let alone vegan.
- 5:49So we teach cooking at the pagodas or the temples in Vietnam.
- 5:54People say, we don't know how to cook vegan.
- 5:57What is this?
- 5:58Well, of course you can leave out the animal flesh and you got something often that's vegan.
- 6:02We give them some more recipes, give them more interesting things to do than that.
- 6:09And so we're teaching.
- 6:10Sometimes we get 5,000 people at one of our presentations.
- 6:13They come, they get free food, and they also learn about vegan cooking.
- 6:18And Sri Lanka, it's just, it's a conglomeration of many different things we're doing.
- 6:22But the monks there, although there aren't many that are vegetarian or vegan, maybe 15%,
- 6:26just roughly your estimate by myself.
- 6:31In Sri Lanka, the monks are surprisingly open to our vegan message, surprisingly open.
- 6:37And they allow us to talk to their congregation, to their Sunday schools that are run out of
- 6:42the temples.
- 6:43So this is what we're doing.
- 6:44And our Jani, of course, can address and should address what we're doing in the US.
- 6:52So the message, I want to conclude by saying the message of the Buddha could not be stronger.
- 6:58The message, I'm certainly not an expert on world religion and other religions, but the
- 7:06message of the Buddha could not be any stronger.
- 7:09All sentient beings are entitled to our compassion and not to be harmed.
- 7:14It's the first precept by the Buddha.
- 7:20It's chanted all the time.
- 7:22Right now, people, millions of people around the world are chanting that.
- 7:26And yet people are supporting the suffering of animals by eating them and eating their
- 7:31products.
- 7:32So since it's such a strong message by the Buddha, since there are so many Buddhists
- 7:36in the world, somewhere between 500 million, which I think is a very low estimate, and
- 7:411 billion Buddhists in the world, and because there are so few Buddhists that are following
- 7:46these teachings, we decided to start DDA in 2011.
- 7:51Amazing, Bob.
- 7:54We'll get back to the teachings part.
- 7:57Arjani, do you believe that the religious argument for animal protection is of greater
- 8:02impact than the secular argument for animal protection?
- 8:08Or do you believe that activism targeted towards religious groups, leaders, has the potential
- 8:14of making a greater impact?
- 8:16I guess another way of phrasing that question.
- 8:18Yeah, I think especially if we look at Buddhism, the difference really is that there is already
- 8:24a supposed commitment towards compassion and towards non-harm.
- 8:29And it is very central in the Buddhist path.
- 8:34And if we're presupposing that commitment, then we have a lot of space and, so to say,
- 8:42to speak of this commitment and to encourage and exhort people to follow that commitment
- 8:53into action and not just stay in the realm of prayer, let's say.
- 9:00And this is so common in the Buddhist path on so many levels.
- 9:03I mean, the entire path is a path.
- 9:06It's a training path.
- 9:07We are honored to train our minds to perfect certain qualities of mind, to really practice
- 9:18mindfulness, to be vigilant of the content of our thoughts, of our speech, of the actions
- 9:24of our body.
- 9:25So always this body, mind, and speech view on the effects of our action and how we are
- 9:32in the world and how we influence others and whether we are bringing benefit to beings
- 9:40or not.
- 9:41And especially in Mahayana Buddhism, there's the entire path of the Bodhisattva vow and
- 9:47the Bodhisattva concept.
- 9:49So there we are aiming to attain enlightenment, that liberation, not just for our own sake,
- 9:57but in order to bring all countless, endless sentient beings to that same liberation, to
- 10:05that same enlightenment.
- 10:07So that is part of the Bodhisattva vow.
- 10:10It is also called Bodhicitta, the aspiration to benefit beings and bring them towards enlightenment.
- 10:17And so it is just a very easy entry point for the vegan message when it is understood,
- 10:23when it is understood what the amount of suffering is that we are causing with our consumption
- 10:29of animal products.
- 10:30And yeah, Mahayana Buddhism is a special kind of Buddhism and it has kind of a strong link
- 10:37with veganism.
- 10:39And I'm thinking of Bodhisattva Guanyin and the stories related to one particular story
- 10:48where she appears in a fishing village and she discourages the villagers from eating
- 10:55and fishing, fishes, and she just implements a new model of how to sustain yourself through
- 11:06agriculture instead of fishing.
- 11:08And you think, oh my gosh, this has been written like centuries ago.
- 11:14And then you think of Emperor Ashoka and the spread of Buddhism from India and how he was
- 11:22the first one to implement animal welfare laws in history, in all of history.
- 11:30It came from a Buddhist leader.
- 11:34And I think of that long legacy and that strong relationship between Buddhism and animal welfare
- 11:44and veganism, vegetarianism, I guess.
- 11:48And I think, how come, like Bob described, how come there are so few vegans in some of
- 11:57those countries among monastics?
- 12:01Why is there such a contrast and disconnect between the Buddhist teachings, the Buddhist
- 12:08history and legacy and the reality of Buddhism on the ground?
- 12:16Bob, I see that you're looking for answering this question.
- 12:21Go ahead.
- 12:22Yes.
- 12:23So this is it.
- 12:24And so many people, we just got a very nice donation from a woman in Oakland.
- 12:29And she said, gee, I was surprised.
- 12:31I found your website and I saw it and I thought to myself, what?
- 12:36I thought, we're vegan.
- 12:39She's a vegan herself.
- 12:40But then I find out, so actually I started, I wrote an article published in the Lion's
- 12:45Words, a Buddhist publication, both online and there's a journal, a physical journal
- 12:52that's published.
- 12:53And that's how I start out the article.
- 12:57One could stop someone on the streets in London or New York and ask them, are Buddhists vegan
- 13:05or at least vegetarian?
- 13:07And most people would say, of course.
- 13:10That's the common understanding.
- 13:12But as you point out, there are very few vegans and more, but not so many vegetarians.
- 13:19So I would say one thing in favor of vegan monastics, we work in Vietnam, as I mentioned,
- 13:27there are approximately 50,000 monastics.
- 13:29And I should say a lot of women monastics who run temples, it's really neat to call
- 13:34the abbesses, the abbots are the men.
- 13:37And the monastics, 50,000 of them, they're all vegan.
- 13:43And that's because they understand the Chinese monastics and the Vietnamese monastics are
- 13:47vegan because they understand the word in their cultures, Vietnamese or Chinese, that
- 13:54we can interpret as vegetarian, that it actually means vegan, it means completely vegetarian.
- 13:59We could say pure vegetarian, it's a way of saying it.
- 14:02And so we have like an automatic volunteer army in Vietnam, which we try to use to our
- 14:09advantage to manage animals that are vegan, they completely understand.
- 14:14But then when they ask their sanghas to be vegan, they'll say either it's not healthy,
- 14:20because we know that's not true, but they think it is, that's what's important.
- 14:24Or they say, I don't know how to cook vegan.
- 14:28So what we've been doing for the last three years or so in Vietnam, we started our project
- 14:33there in 2018 at a big animal rights conference in Hanoi.
- 14:39We teach them how to cook vegan.
- 14:41And it's interesting, and it's fun, and it's easy, and it's inexpensive compared to the
- 14:46other food they're eating.
- 14:48And so I think we're converting lots of people.
- 14:50We have, we'll work with three chefs in, they're all based in Hanoi, but eventually we'll get
- 14:56out to the rest of the country, Hanoi is the capital, of course, of Vietnam.
- 15:00So that's our challenge.
- 15:06But that's also the reason we have DVA.
- 15:08You know, if all Buddhists were vegan in the perfect world, we wouldn't have any work to
- 15:13do.
- 15:14So this is why we started the organization, the message is so strong.
- 15:17There's so many Buddhists in the world, hundreds of millions, wherever we draw the line and
- 15:22think it's a billion or 800 million, whatever it is.
- 15:25There are lots of them and very little compliance with compassionate eating, which is clearly
- 15:32required by the Buddha, whether it's Mayan Buddhism or Theravada Buddhism.
- 15:37Yeah, I think I would add that the reasons that not more Buddhists are vegetarian or
- 15:44vegan are the same that why other people aren't, you know, it is not so different.
- 15:52There is like Bob already mentioned, there's misinformation, like a lack of education around
- 15:57how to be healthy on a plant based vegan diet, or even a vegetarian one.
- 16:03So, and, and really like the animal industries have worked really hard to sow a lot of that,
- 16:10you know, misinformation into into society, right, by promoting really with like huge
- 16:15budgets for for decades and decades, the message that you need the animal protein to be strong,
- 16:22you need milk for your bones, you know, all these things to raise your children well.
- 16:27So I mean, these these kind of things, I mean, for one, they're their cultural legacies.
- 16:33I mean, it's, it's, we've been eating, we've been omnivorous society, you know.
- 16:39But on another, there's also the element of, there's powerful industries behind it that
- 16:43that keep sowing that kind of information for for their, you know, profit benefits.
- 16:49And so, yeah, that's sort of the information piece.
- 16:52And then the other piece is like just attachment, attachment to taste, you know, not knowing
- 17:00the realities of the industries, not knowing how the animals actually live.
- 17:05That goes hand in hand again with misinformation because of the sort of humane washing, green
- 17:09washing that happens a lot, or, you know, a lot of people really just think that the
- 17:14dairy cars have a fine life.
- 17:17And many people don't even stop to contemplate that by humans drinking milk, we're taking
- 17:22it away from, you know, a calf for whom that that milk was intended.
- 17:26And and just just really that that lack of education of the realities of the industries
- 17:34and the amount of harm they cause to not only the animals themselves, but then the planet,
- 17:40right.
- 17:41And this is where the environmental impact and climate impact comes in, also biodiversity
- 17:46loss.
- 17:47So we're inflicting, like influencing so many more animals beyond, you know, just just the
- 17:53animals, the farmed animals.
- 17:57And yeah, a lot of bias, like it's just a lot of cognitive dissonance, a lot of excuses
- 18:02that are found, you know, another thing to mention is the hierarchical structure of,
- 18:08you know, but as some Buddhist communities, at least, there's still a lot of simply like
- 18:14following the teacher.
- 18:15And if the teacher's example is someone who consumes animal products, then a lot of students
- 18:22will simply not question it.
- 18:23Like they will simply be like, oh, but he he's eating it.
- 18:26So she, you know, they're eating it.
- 18:28And so I can, so I guess that's the way to interpret the text, right.
- 18:32So they, they kind of stop at that interpretation by the model of someone else, right.
- 18:39Who is their teacher who's teaching them the Dharma, right.
- 18:41So it's, it's super tricky that that hierarchical thing.
- 18:46And the example of teachers is a whole like big, tricky subject in itself, I think that
- 18:51is worth contemplating.
- 18:54Going a bit deeper here, I understand, and you explained very well, you know, the vegan
- 19:02dimension, but what about the speciesism?
- 19:06When I look at people in the West who display more of a speciesist outlook on life, I always
- 19:18think, you know, oh, it's because of their Judeo-Christian background, you know, they
- 19:23have learned that humans are, you know, perfect creations, you know, this perfect creation
- 19:30at the top of the world and everything was made for them.
- 19:34And you know, they were also taught that animals do not have a soul.
- 19:40So I understand that.
- 19:42Now have you noticed if there was speciesism in among Buddhists?
- 19:50Like it's not just the fact that they're not vegan, it's the fact that they don't see
- 19:57animals as being sentient or they see themselves as being superior to other form of life out
- 20:08there.
- 20:11Have you noticed that in people, in Buddhists?
- 20:16And are you also addressing that part of the problem?
- 20:21Yeah, so, I mean, make a good point.
- 20:25The just, Arjani just mentioned desire, one of the classes.
- 20:34And also it's a version.
- 20:36So people, my way into veganism, first I was vegetarian for many years and then vegan for
- 20:43the last 20 years was through the suffering.
- 20:47Look at the films, Meet Your Meat, PETA film, Earthlings, another film, just, it's really
- 20:54hard for me to watch these films.
- 20:57But when I kind of look away, I realize that this is going on all the time, that millions
- 21:04and millions of animals are getting killed every day to feed us.
- 21:08I like to ask the question, how many animals die each year to feed Buddhists around the
- 21:14world?
- 21:15And the number is extraordinary, astronomical.
- 21:19So it's a version to seeing the suffering.
- 21:23The suffering, it's terrible what happens.
- 21:24I mean, you know this, the three of us know this, but people don't want to see it.
- 21:30They avert their eyes, they don't, they'd say, I'd rather not see that.
- 21:34So it's a version to the suffering that the animals experience on the one hand, and it's
- 21:40the attachment or the desire for the taste of the food, which is reinforced.
- 21:47We're on holidays and people in all cultures have holiday meals with family and friends
- 21:52and they're used to a certain type of food.
- 21:56It's mostly animal flesh and animal products and all.
- 22:00It's hard to break that habit.
- 22:03And here in a country like Vietnam, my goodness, the monastics couldn't be better examples.
- 22:08There's 50,000, at least in the Vietnamese Buddhist Sangha.
- 22:12By the way, our director of the Vietnam Project is one of the three top monks in the country
- 22:18of Vietnam.
- 22:19He stayed here in my house for almost a couple of weeks in 2017, which is where we forged
- 22:24the relationship and he's since been our director.
- 22:28And so he talks about this all the time in his Dharma talks.
- 22:31He's got a group, a vegetarian group, I think it's 100 people in his Sangha.
- 22:36But he said one of the most famous, about the most famous Sangha temples, they call
- 22:41pagodas in Vietnam, called Ba Phan.
- 22:44And so they have thousands of people frequent that temple and only 100 people are even vegetarian.
- 22:50People just don't want to hear the message either because of a desire or aversion.
- 22:56So what are you?
- 22:57Or ignorance, the one, right?
- 22:58And we have all three, attachment, aversion and ignorance.
- 23:02Yeah, and ignorance is the third.
- 23:03And ignorance, as we know, is the basis for both the for desire and for aversion.
- 23:10It's central to all that.
- 23:11Moha is, yeah.
- 23:12So it's the same thing.
- 23:15It's the same point why people are not vegan out there in the rest of the world that are
- 23:23not Buddhist and people that are not vegan, that self identify as Buddhist.
- 23:30So it's a big job.
- 23:31But we know we've got the basis, the foundation of this house for DVA is the Dharma and the
- 23:39direct teachings of the Buddha.
- 23:40In the Dhammapada, which is a Pali canon text, it said not only that the one should not harm,
- 23:49but one should not cause harm.
- 23:52So people, everyone, all beings experience the fear and they shy away from danger.
- 24:00And one realizes this, she does not cause, does not harm or cause to be harmed.
- 24:07That phrase is repeated something like 24 times in the Dhammapada.
- 24:11It's a central text for Theravada Buddhism, but also for Mayan Buddhism.
- 24:15They accept, I think all the traditions except the Pali canon.
- 24:19I mean, what could be stronger?
- 24:21Not people are looking away or wanting, wanting, wanting, wanting this taste that they're so
- 24:26addicted to.
- 24:27Ajani?
- 24:28Yeah, I want to add to the speciesism question because I do believe Buddhism has a potential
- 24:37and in it, it is actually quite anti-speciesist and not anthropocentric in its worldview because
- 24:45we have the different realms of beings, right?
- 24:48And we are all on one way in the same category, which is sentient being, you know, wandering
- 24:53being in samsara.
- 24:55And we like from the Buddhist teachings, we are, we can be reborn in any of those six
- 25:00realms.
- 25:01Right?
- 25:02So that means any of us have, have probably been animals before and might be animals again,
- 25:09as well as the other realms of beings, you know, so there is a complete equality of,
- 25:16of the, of the, of the consciousness, like of what is described as a sentient being.
- 25:21Like we, we can, we just take on these different forms.
- 25:24Right?
- 25:25But so from that perspective, it should be even more relevant to us what happens to all
- 25:32the kinds of other beings, because it might, might be, you know, it might be us one day.
- 25:37And, and a lot of Tibetan teachers also teach from that perspective.
- 25:42I mean, they call it a mother sentient being.
- 25:46So they always in their Dharma talks, they talk about, you know, imagining that all other
- 25:51sentient beings, because we've been transmigrating so long in samsara, you know, countless and
- 25:57countless of lives.
- 25:59The belief is that therefore every single one has at some point had some degree of relationship
- 26:04to you, whether it's been your mother, your father, your sibling, your friend, whoever.
- 26:10And so they, they use that to say like, yeah, do not really do not harm any one of them.
- 26:16It is the same as harming your own mother.
- 26:19So those, those teachings are right, right.
- 26:23Like there, there's plenty of them out there.
- 26:25And that's a very anti-speciesist view in my opinion.
- 26:30Since the conversation is pulling more and more towards the, you know, the teaching part.
- 26:36So let's dive into that topic.
- 26:40And I guess a question I have around that is, you know, one of the most surprising teaching
- 26:48of the Buddha is the fact that, you know, he selected the list of how do you say, you
- 26:55know, like jobs, like forbidden jobs, like bad jobs that you should not have.
- 27:02How does he call that life, not lifestyle, livelihoods exactly.
- 27:09It's the word that slipped my mind, but yeah, livelihoods.
- 27:13And he called them, you know, wrong livelihoods.
- 27:17And among them is what he calls business in meat.
- 27:24And he forbids his not he forbids, but he recommends his followers not to make a livelihood
- 27:33in the business of meat.
- 27:36And he was telling his followers that about 3000 years ago when farming was not the kind
- 27:46of factory farming we have right now, you know, it was, I guess, much more humane in
- 27:52the way that many of the public like to imagine where their food, their meat and animal products
- 28:02are coming from.
- 28:04And yet he looked at that and still condemn that practice.
- 28:11And I want to start with that.
- 28:13What is so wrong with, you know, humane farming in the sense of what the Buddha witnessed
- 28:21and how do you explain that even 3000 years ago, there was this understanding of how harmful
- 28:32it was, you know, bring us a bit in the historical context of that time.
- 28:38And who wants to take the Bob?
- 28:40Yeah, I mean, so this is a great point.
- 28:43I must say, I really like your question.
- 28:46And I must say that very few people who I've talked to have engaged with in the last, I
- 28:53was doing this advocacy 10 years before we started DVA 2011 ever talk about wise livelihood.
- 28:59It's really important.
- 29:01And as you said, the Buddhist said that it's not wise livelihood, it's unwise livelihood,
- 29:09your unskillful livelihood to engage in the raising of animals for slaughter.
- 29:16And you think about that.
- 29:17So why do Buddhists or how do Buddhists justify eating animals?
- 29:23Well, they often, not always, but often say, I didn't kill the animal, someone else killed
- 29:30the animal.
- 29:31So several things to say about that.
- 29:33The first is wise livelihood.
- 29:35To clear the Buddha did not draw the line between killing the animal yourself and eating
- 29:41an animal that was killed for others, because he forbade, not forbid, you use that word,
- 29:47and actually, it's just he strongly recommended against working in raising animals for slaughter.
- 29:55It's specifically mentioned in the Noble Eightfold Path, specifically mentioned there.
- 30:02So that to me is kind of the end of the story.
- 30:06If you say, well, someone else killed the animal, all I'm doing is eating it, then you
- 30:13are not understanding where the Buddha drew the line.
- 30:16And when we are eating animals, we are forcing others to kill the animal.
- 30:23And what about the slaughterhouse workers?
- 30:25I don't know about Canada, but in the US, most of the slaughterhouse workers are poor,
- 30:31don't have a lot of other opportunities.
- 30:34It's the most dangerous occupation, factory occupation in the United States.
- 30:42It's totally harmful.
- 30:43You have to kill so many animals during the day, and they have to go home and perhaps
- 30:48hug and hold their children after having done this.
- 30:53If we're eating animals, we're forcing slaughterhouse workers to kill the animals.
- 30:59It's a huge human rights issue in the United States that we're starting to bring attention
- 31:03to.
- 31:05So there really is no good excuse for Buddhists to be eating animals as there is not for anyone,
- 31:16but especially for Buddhists.
- 31:18The mindfulness is the key to the Buddhist teachings, just to know what your experience
- 31:23is in the present moment.
- 31:24If we're paying attention to that, there's a contemplation that goes with it.
- 31:30How did the animal come to be on my plate?
- 31:34People should take a look at these films.
- 31:36If you're going to eat animals, just take a look at the film.
- 31:39See how it is that the animal went from its life to your plate.
- 31:47It's not easy to look at, but it's important to look at because whenever you change your
- 31:51diet, it's good to do it.
- 31:57I was in my 20s, mid-20s when I became vegetarian, but I was in my 40s when I became vegan.
- 32:04So I thought, gee, how come I didn't know this before?
- 32:06Why didn't I notice it?
- 32:07Well, okay, but all we can really control is the present moment.
- 32:11It's never too late to stop adding to the suffering.
- 32:15Yeah, I could add, back to the question specifically of right livelihood versus wrong livelihood.
- 32:24The other, I just looked it up again, so the other five, one, two, three, four, five, livelihoods
- 32:30that are not recommended are also related to causing harm.
- 32:34So it is really in its essence about not subsisting on causing harm to whatever kind of other
- 32:42being.
- 32:43So another one that's not recommended is dealing in weapons, any kind of business related to
- 32:49weapons, war, et cetera, trading human beings for slavery, business in intoxicants, businesses
- 32:59in poison, and then meat production and butchery.
- 33:05So it's really all of them are about that we should not forward, like forward is one
- 33:13of the right words, we should just not subsist on the suffering of others.
- 33:17We should not gain benefit for ourselves through causing harm to others.
- 33:26So that it's just so, such a central tenet all the time in Buddhism is not to cause harm,
- 33:33not to cause harm.
- 33:35Whether that's an insect, a human being, an animal, and they go further.
- 33:40I mean, even like unseen beings, like, you know, in many Buddhist traditions, even those
- 33:45there is instructions how not to harm them.
- 33:49So it's very vast.
- 33:52It's a very vast amount of teachings that are all exalting us not to cause harm and
- 33:58suffering to others and instead to protect them, to benefit them, to teach them Dharma,
- 34:05to bring them relative and ultimate benefit.
- 34:08There's also that like the ultimate would be teaching them the Dharma and helping them
- 34:12to gain ultimate liberation, but benefit like the relative benefit is any kind of benefit
- 34:17in the present moment.
- 34:18So material benefit, psychological benefit, anything.
- 34:25I'm, I'm truly interested in knowing what kind of reaction Buddhists have when you confront
- 34:35them with those teachings, when you present the proof, when you say, look, this is like
- 34:41you said, Arjani, it's in the, you know, the hard, the core of Buddhism, like not harming.
- 34:50How do they react?
- 34:52You know, are they in denial or do they feel offended?
- 34:58And not just, you know, and is there, you know, like a different reaction from the monastic
- 35:03community to the lay community?
- 35:09Are they less receptive?
- 35:11Because I guess they feel like they're the teachers and they don't want to hear lay followers,
- 35:18you know, correct them maybe in their practices or point out to something they could be doing
- 35:26better.
- 35:27So I wonder, you know, how do Buddhists react to your act?
- 35:35It's so interesting because sometimes it can be quite aggressive, even like it can be really
- 35:41like don't come to me with pointing the moral finger, like don't be moralistic.
- 35:46And I mean, but you don't tell me what to do.
- 35:50Like I have my own way of interpreting Buddhism or I guess the difficult thing is that they
- 35:56feel attacked in their practice.
- 35:59And if they do take their practice seriously to a degree, you know, then it is a difficult
- 36:05thing to come in and say, hey, you're not doing it right.
- 36:08Or you're like, you're misinterpreting something here.
- 36:10Or so I understand that defensiveness from within, you know, from within to some degree.
- 36:18And what I hear, one of the most common responses that also many teachers I've seen give is
- 36:28that that we cause harm all the time, no matter what.
- 36:33Right.
- 36:34So this kind of that's a very common answer is I don't like we cannot avoid harm, even
- 36:39if you eat vegetables, and even if you're vegan, you know, all the insects and we know
- 36:43these arguments as vegans, right, all the insects and all the rodents killed in agriculture
- 36:47also, you know, killed for your sake because you were asking for the crop.
- 36:52Right.
- 36:53So the only thing about that, the only problem with that issue is with that argument is that
- 37:01we know, of course, when we're informed that the numbers are far greater when we're consuming
- 37:06animal products.
- 37:07The numbers of insects and rodents, etc. killed on agricultural land is greater because we're
- 37:13using like 70% of that 80% of that to feed livestock to then feed humans.
- 37:19And so the animal protein equation versus a plant direct plant protein, you know, ingestion
- 37:26and the lives harmed.
- 37:27I mean, the stack is just, I don't know, I don't know the number right now, but it's
- 37:33like a lot more like so.
- 37:36So from whichever angle you can say, okay, then, but, you know, it's causing less harm.
- 37:42So let's choose the less harm approach whenever we can.
- 37:47And I think it's important when we're debating or speaking with people to also admit that
- 37:52part, right, to say like, yeah, I know my life, the way I'm living it through so many
- 37:57other ways is causing harm and is causing the killing of beings and be it, you know,
- 38:01this laptop that we're speaking on right now or phones, you know, like driving a car, all
- 38:06those, you know, so many just walking outside in the yard, you know, we crush insects without
- 38:12our knowledge.
- 38:13And, and so I think it's important to always say to be humble in that moment and say, yes,
- 38:18it is true.
- 38:19We are all causing the death of other sentient beings simply by existing.
- 38:24And there's really no way to avoid that completely.
- 38:27But there are very accessible nowadays ways where we can reduce that amount greatly, right?
- 38:36Very greatly, especially if we take into account, like I mentioned before, you know, the effects
- 38:41of animal agriculture nowadays on the entire planet on biodiversity loss, on water pollution,
- 38:48land use, you know, all these things that influence again, so many more animals and
- 38:53insects, et cetera.
- 38:55Yeah, so it's a reduction approach.
- 38:59It's not, it's not, yeah, it's not perfection.
- 39:01It's not like, oh, we're now saints that don't cause any harm anymore, right?
- 39:06Once we're vegan Buddhists, no, we acknowledge the harm that is still being caused, but we're
- 39:11trying to reduce it.
- 39:12Yeah.
- 39:13So DBA has been around, I want to add to that, 13 years now.
- 39:18And I was doing this, you know, eight or 10 years before that, talking to all, pretty
- 39:23much all of the major, best known, well-known Western teachers, one-on-one, most of the
- 39:30time, sometimes it'd be through emails or texts and all.
- 39:35People don't want to talk about it.
- 39:36So what I like to say, they don't want to talk about it.
- 39:40They don't want to debate it.
- 39:41They don't want to talk publicly about it.
- 39:43They just want to be left alone to eat whatever they want to eat.
- 39:47The problem, of course, is that the average American eating somewhere between 10 and 20,000
- 39:56animals in a lifetime, that's a lot of suffering.
- 40:02And so, but it's tricky to engage in the debate.
- 40:06You can't force people to talk about it.
- 40:08Just once we're talking about it, we're like 80% of the way there, just to talk about it.
- 40:15So if you're reading our mission, part of our mission, and it's getting people to talk
- 40:23about it.
- 40:24There's two parts.
- 40:25One is the education, talking about it.
- 40:27So let's have a quick, I like to say, can we have a conversation about this?
- 40:31Let's see what happens.
- 40:32Remaining humble, not self-righteous, it's hard.
- 40:35It's really hard to do.
- 40:36I talked to my sangha about it.
- 40:37I have a weekly sangha for years and years, and I only bring it up maybe once a year.
- 40:42So some people even miss it, because it's hard for people.
- 40:45But I've come around to what I think is as non-judgmental as I've ever been about it.
- 40:52Because you know, one time I was doing the stuff that everyone is doing, that other people
- 40:56are doing now, eating animals and then eating animal products until 20 years ago.
- 40:59So you have to come at it from that point.
- 41:02I'd like to recommend our film.
- 41:05Our film was produced by Keegan Kuhn, who most of your many, let's say, listeners would
- 41:12know, Cowspiracy, What the Health, They're Trying to Kill Us are three of his films.
- 41:17He produced some, at least two of those films, that we and I wrote a cabrio.
- 41:22So he produced our film.
- 41:23I helped write the script and also did some of the editing.
- 41:26He has another member of our original DVA team.
- 41:31And it talks about all this except for Wise Livelihood.
- 41:34It wasn't, the understanding of that wasn't so clear back about 10 or 12 years ago.
- 41:39But now, so everything else that we're talking about today is in the film.
- 41:42And we talked to and interviewed some of the top teachers, both Western and Eastern teachers.
- 41:49Men and women, different religions, different races, Mahayana, Theravada, everything is
- 41:55in there.
- 41:56It's, I think, a really good film.
- 41:58And Keegan's an award-winning documentary filmmaker.
- 42:01So this is a good place to go.
- 42:03By the way, the film has been translated into 12 languages, including Chinese and Spanish.
- 42:09And we have a translation of all the major Asian languages, where 98.5% of the Buddhists
- 42:16live, except for Japanese.
- 42:18If anybody wants to do a translation in Japanese, it's actually not that much, only four pages
- 42:24when you put it in a transcript.
- 42:27We love it.
- 42:28Cannot find for this time.
- 42:31We will have a Japanese translation.
- 42:33All the other major languages are in there.
- 42:35So please watch our film.
- 42:38Amazing.
- 42:39And of course, you will find the link in the description below for the movie.
- 42:44And yes, I absolutely recommend it.
- 42:47And Animals in the Buddha, it's the name of it.
- 42:49Go to our website.
- 42:50It's there.
- 42:51You can click on it or just go to YouTube.
- 42:52Animals in the Buddha.
- 42:53It's there.
- 42:54In fact, I should add it in the audio file of this podcast, just to give a sample to
- 43:00people.
- 43:06Are these animals being killed for you?
- 43:10Normally, people have no idea what animals go through.
- 43:24It will only be realized when you get to see what actually happens in the slaughterhouses.
- 43:36Until then, you wouldn't realize.
- 43:37And then when you see that, actually, you will feel if that is really appropriate to
- 43:47eat them.
- 43:49It's really horrifying.
- 43:53Even slaughterhouses have the entire animal that they are supposed to slaughter for the
- 44:02day are standing in a corner out there and then the one by another being slaughtered
- 44:10in front of the rest of the animal.
- 44:12And then you can imagine how terrifying that experience would be.
- 44:22Just imagine yourself being out there and all your friends and colleagues are being
- 44:29slaughtered and you are in the line.
- 44:32Just a step away from that terrifying thing.
- 44:38According to most religions, talk about hell, like most horrifying suffering realm, but
- 44:46I can't imagine there is something more horrifying and painful so-called hell than those horrifying
- 44:56experience when you are lined up in the slaughterhouse.
- 45:01Just heartbreaking.
- 45:02So, we need to actually see those things so that how we humans are actually causing so
- 45:13much trouble to other sentient beings.
- 45:18Let me continue on this lane of teachings and how people practice Buddhism while not
- 45:27being vegan and all of that.
- 45:30I want to turn this time to the vegans and to the vegan community at large.
- 45:37I think that if you look at any report or poll done studying the vegan world and its
- 45:48population, you would find that most vegans are not religious.
- 45:53And I interpret that in two ways.
- 45:56First of all, as a failure to reach out to religious communities and advocate for veganism
- 46:03in those communities, but also I find that among vegans, there is this nihilism, this
- 46:16difficulty to confront the large scale of animal suffering out there.
- 46:26I would even talk about an existential crisis of just realizing the scale and horror of
- 46:35just factory farming.
- 46:40I wanted to ask you as a Buddhist and as a vegan Buddhist, how do you square your veganism
- 46:49with your Buddhism?
- 46:52How do we make place for, because Buddhism is all about happiness and self actualization.
- 47:03But how can you seek and find that while living in a world where you have billions of creatures
- 47:10just being tortured and killed mercilessly?
- 47:17It's a tough question.
- 47:18I know, but it has to do with how the sense you give your veganism and if you find any
- 47:27spiritual meaning to your veganism.
- 47:31Yeah, so I'll let you answer.
- 47:34Buddhist teachers are not, at least in present time, are not Buddhist.
- 47:40The last Buddha, the historical Buddha, about 2600 years ago is best we could tell, and
- 47:48he did a pretty good job of avoiding harm when he was alive, as you point out, before
- 47:55huge amounts of factory farming.
- 47:59And it's too easy, it's too lazy, in my opinion, to cop out, to see the suffering and
- 48:10to see the, let's say, non-compliance by Buddhists with Buddhist institutions and Buddhists around
- 48:19the world, to not get involved in that.
- 48:22I mean, it's easy to say, this is terrible.
- 48:28They don't understand suffering.
- 48:30They're not mindful, so I'm not going to practice this.
- 48:34The Buddha wasn't a Buddhist, it was the Buddha gave us great teachings.
- 48:38The teachings fully support non-harming of animals and a compassionate diet, which today
- 48:45means vegan diet, to limit the harm and eliminate all the harm because of all the factors that
- 48:55we discussed before.
- 48:57So I choose not to hang out and get involved and aversive to the teachers, both here in
- 49:10the US, Western teachers, and teachers that I come across in the three countries, Sri
- 49:16Lanka, Thailand, and Vietnam.
- 49:18Vietnam's pretty good.
- 49:20The teachers are vegan, as I pointed out before.
- 49:25So the animals need us.
- 49:28It's not about me, my ego.
- 49:33I can't believe this dissent to reserving animal products or animal flesh.
- 49:39Let's have a conversation about this.
- 49:42I mean, that's the challenge of being a Buddha.
- 49:45The Buddha also expressed a strong suggestion and a hope that his followers would not only
- 49:55refrain from harm, but actually be adding something positive to rectify the wrongs that
- 50:03are being committed to help those that need our help.
- 50:06There's like an affirmative duty on responsible Buddhists, so we can either choose to accept
- 50:12that or not.
- 50:13People don't have to start an organization.
- 50:16Just talk to some people.
- 50:17Ask the question.
- 50:19When a teacher is talking, I can't tell you how many times I've heard teachers at Spirit
- 50:23Rock or IMS or Forest Refuge where I practiced for years and years, and they'll say, I just
- 50:28had a wonderful sushi dinner.
- 50:31And at the dinner that I had, and there's no suggestion it's vegan or vegetarian sushi,
- 50:36and then I noticed this or that, or I had fish and chips in England.
- 50:42An English teacher talks, a teacher in England talks about that.
- 50:46And it's so amazing without any thought that maybe that would be taken in a heartfelt way
- 50:53by somebody like myself that doesn't think it's okay to eat animals as a Buddhist.
- 50:59So we have to do something.
- 51:02It's right there in our face.
- 51:03So say something.
- 51:04You don't have to start an organization if you want to.
- 51:06Great.
- 51:07We're the only international Buddhist animal advocacy organization in the whole world.
- 51:13We're the only one.
- 51:14We've been out there for 13 years and haven't seen any other.
- 51:18There aren't any.
- 51:19There are organizations that are doing good work, but they're not devoted to animal advocacy
- 51:24like we are.
- 51:26So that's the calling.
- 51:29It's our calling, and I'm sure all of our people's calling of our people.
- 51:33We want to do something about this.
- 51:35Arjani, if you want to add something.
- 51:37Yeah, I mean, the only thing that comes to mind, I'm still a little bit on the philosophical
- 51:42how to deal with the suffering in the world.
- 51:46So the Buddha, his very first teaching was on the Four Noble Truths.
- 51:51That's the first thing he spoke about was suffering.
- 51:54So contrary to perhaps what you mentioned like as the nihilistic or maybe like the very
- 52:01intellectual Western materialistic or scientific point of view, it went straight to suffering.
- 52:09It went straight to what is it that causes suffering, be it physical, mental, anguish,
- 52:16discomfort, the whole spectrum of suffering.
- 52:19The word dukkha is a very, it's actually worth looking into because it can be translated
- 52:24with like 20 different words.
- 52:26So many degrees of suffering that he's talking about, and he taught sort of how we get into
- 52:34that entrapment and how to get out of it.
- 52:37And so that is really what we're turning towards on the Buddhist path.
- 52:42There isn't a shying away from it or denying it or even being crushed by it.
- 52:49So the message isn't, oh my God, there's so much suffering.
- 52:52Yeah, let's just call it a day because this is terrible, we should go in bed and cry.
- 52:58It's too much to handle.
- 52:59It's like, okay, there's so much suffering, what can we do to alleviate it in ourselves
- 53:03and then for others as well?
- 53:06So yeah, the entire path deals with it really, like constantly.
- 53:10All mind training, everything we do really revolves around that question of the truth
- 53:18of suffering, the mechanisms of it and how to unwind those and find liberation.
- 53:28And yeah, that's what comes to mind with that question.
- 53:32Those are great answers.
- 53:34I mean, I tried to ask the daring questions and the questions that nobody is asking, but
- 53:41actually that everyone is asking inside, but are not hard to ask out loud.
- 53:50Let me ask another question with a more philosophical dimension.
- 53:56And it has to do with evil.
- 53:58And that's the same question I asked a Catholic priest.
- 54:03If we look at those workers or even executives of the farm industry or all the people that
- 54:11are actually abusing animals out there, and we've seen the footage, are those people evil?
- 54:21Is there such a thing as evil from a Buddhist perspective?
- 54:27The way I understand this is it's not evil people.
- 54:33We do unskillful acts.
- 54:36And so there's always a possibility of redemption in the next moment.
- 54:42So it's that bad person, terrible for doing this, that's not so helpful for that person
- 54:49or for the person saying it.
- 54:51Instead, it's just recognizing there are a lot of acts that cause suffering.
- 54:55I mean, in subtle ways, we cause suffering almost all the time to ourselves and to others.
- 55:01But this is kind of off the charts suffering when you see what happens to animals.
- 55:06So it's quantitatively different, qualitatively different, quantitatively and qualitatively.
- 55:13It is.
- 55:16So this is something we can do something about.
- 55:22And it's something we should do something about if we can.
- 55:29And to practice Buddhism, to see that universal suffering is the first noble truth, there's
- 55:37suffering everywhere, then to see how it is that we add to suffering.
- 55:41So if someone, the practice might go, I'm just putting this out there, it might go something
- 55:45like this.
- 55:46So someone is eating animals, maybe that person takes a look at a video, because it's that
- 55:50common knowledge what happens to animals.
- 55:53And what I like to say is that if you haven't seen a video and you haven't been one of the
- 55:57few people that can get into slaughterhouses or factory farms, it's a thousand times worse
- 56:02than you can imagine.
- 56:04So wherever you imagine, multiply that by a thousand.
- 56:07And that's where it is.
- 56:08So you might take a look at that just to fill in the blanks of a place we don't have any
- 56:16experience.
- 56:17You take a look at that and then just pay attention to what arises when you go into
- 56:22a store or sit down in a restaurant and order your favorite hamburger or chicken or dairy
- 56:30dessert or something and pay attention to it.
- 56:33What is it?
- 56:34I mean, I notice craving, I notice wanting for foods.
- 56:39Now my universe of foods that I eat are all plant-based, but I really like frozen soy.
- 56:46I really like it.
- 56:47I just had some for lunch.
- 56:49It was an ice cream, quote unquote, it's a soy cream sandwich with chocolate outside
- 56:57and vanilla inside.
- 56:58And I really like this.
- 56:59I thought I don't have time to have one of these sandwiches about yay big, just like
- 57:05regular ice cream sandwiches, but they're vegan.
- 57:07They're delicious.
- 57:08Clear craving.
- 57:10And I was aware of that.
- 57:12I mean, I could have this later on.
- 57:14I don't have it now.
- 57:15We're going to start in five minutes.
- 57:17But I noticed their craving as I put the delicious soy ice cream sandwich in my mouth and chopped
- 57:23that.
- 57:24I even walked upstairs because I didn't have enough time to finish it downstairs.
- 57:27So to notice that and also to notice aversion.
- 57:30When I'm sitting at a table and people I know or maybe not know so well are ordering steaks
- 57:37and chicken and everything they're eating there.
- 57:40I have to see that.
- 57:41I'm of course thinking, I notice my aversion.
- 57:43Why are they eating that?
- 57:44This is on and on and on.
- 57:47That's aversion.
- 57:48That's what it is.
- 57:49I can practice mindfulness around my vegan practice.
- 57:51And I suggest to our listeners that everyone can practice mindfulness around their eating.
- 57:57And as the Buddha said in the Foundations of Mindfulness, Majjhima, Nakaya, number 10,
- 58:03very important teaching in the Pali Canon, that we can be mindful internally, what we're
- 58:10experienced as I just described, but also externally.
- 58:13All right, Jenny.
- 58:14Yeah, I would add, just contemplating on the question of evil, I think from a Buddhist
- 58:21perspective, it is confused mind.
- 58:25So confused mind is able to be bewildered mind, bewildered by intense emotions usually.
- 58:35The mind experiences so much intensity of these patterns, of habitual patterns of emotions
- 58:45of, again, all born from ignorance, attachment and aversion, right?
- 58:49As those three first, as that ground where everything springs from.
- 58:54And so much of it is about reifying the self and protecting the self and defending the
- 58:58self.
- 59:00And that self can look like that small moment when we're like offended by something, someone
- 59:05says, and it can look like I'm trying to survive and feed my family and I need this job or
- 59:11I want to eat this hamburger because I think it's healthy for me or whatever kind of self
- 59:17protection is happening.
- 59:20But it is always like the reifying of self versus the Buddhist path moving us a bit more
- 59:27towards selflessness, right?
- 59:29Or a more altruistic point of view where those lines of dualistic mind get blurred a bit
- 59:36more and self and other isn't seen as separate.
- 59:40And I know like Tichanand Han and others teach it with words like interbeing, right?
- 59:45There's so many teachings on the interconnection of all of us, right?
- 59:50Dependent arising, like none of us are a separate entity per se, right?
- 59:54And so even studying like more philosophical aspects of Buddhism, studying them can infuse
- 1:00:02this question as well, that it is all interconnected and that also like sort of kind of brought
- 1:00:08the evil thing.
- 1:00:09But yeah, so much harm is caused just by bewildered, confused, bewildered beings that are fighting
- 1:00:16for their survival.
- 1:00:18And from that comes hatred, all kinds of actions, right?
- 1:00:24Thank you.
- 1:00:26I want to now turn to the activism part of the organization.
- 1:00:33And I want to ask you, you know, what has been the impact of Dharma Voices for Animals?
- 1:00:41And we touched on that.
- 1:00:44And like you said, Bob, this organization has been doing great work for 13 years.
- 1:00:52And so I want to inspire our listeners and talk about the impact the organization has
- 1:00:58done in the last decade.
- 1:01:01Okay, so let's start right here in the US.
- 1:01:06As I mentioned, my own retreat center has been Spirit Rock since about 1996.
- 1:01:14They built the retreat center and completed it in 1998.
- 1:01:17I started going on retreats there maybe, probably three years, we put all the retreats together.
- 1:01:23When I first started going on retreat, and I was actually at the first retreat July of
- 1:01:281998, the food was all vegetarian, but every single main meal, every single meal had dairy.
- 1:01:39So there were no vegan meals and no vegan alternatives, no options.
- 1:01:44So we started working.
- 1:01:45We started posting messages, donating breakfasts and lunches, and then you get to post a message
- 1:01:52on the bulletin board.
- 1:01:55And we did that, some of our supporters gave us money to do that.
- 1:02:02And slowly but surely, it took a long time with Spirit Rock, it took 10, 12 years.
- 1:02:08Eventually their meals are now, I would say, 97, 98% vegan.
- 1:02:16Now there's alternative milks offered, all of the dressings are vegan dressing, all of
- 1:02:23the soups are vegan soups and on and on and on.
- 1:02:26And similarly things that happened with IMS and Berry and Forest Refuge and BCBS center
- 1:02:33out there.
- 1:02:34And there's some other centers that are there.
- 1:02:36So we've affected enormous change at these centers, but we have so much work to do.
- 1:02:43So now our Johnnie's caseload is the centers in the United States.
- 1:02:48And she's going to need help from maybe from your listeners, anybody can help people that
- 1:02:52actually go to Dharma centers.
- 1:02:54And if it's in Canada, if it's a big center, we could probably include that in our list
- 1:03:00of centers we're going to engage with.
- 1:03:03And each center requires a different thing.
- 1:03:06We try to connect with decision makers at the centers and start conversations with them
- 1:03:13and support them.
- 1:03:14Maybe we can financially support vegan alternatives, things like that.
- 1:03:21We're exploring all kinds of possibilities.
- 1:03:23In a country like Sri Lanka, I tell you, there's 16 million Buddhists in Sri Lanka.
- 1:03:29It's right off the southeast coast of India.
- 1:03:33In Sri Lanka, we've had a television show on prime time that teaches vegan cooking.
- 1:03:39We've had a radio show for five years that goes on every Friday morning in Sri Lanka.
- 1:03:46We have a staff of 17 regional coordinators in Sri Lanka.
- 1:03:52They go to women's groups.
- 1:03:55They go to factories.
- 1:03:57They go to temples, talk to the kids in the Dharma schools or the Sunday schools, talk
- 1:04:03to the parents in the sagas in the temple.
- 1:04:08And we are now, every single month for the last 18 months, we have made over 100 presentations,
- 1:04:16sometimes as many as 140 presentations, separate presentations.
- 1:04:20We're reaching, on the average now, 10,000 people one on one every single month.
- 1:04:25I don't know how many people change.
- 1:04:27We have the anecdotal evidence.
- 1:04:28Some of the temples have changed in Sri Lanka.
- 1:04:31We have the anecdotal evidence that there's one temple in particular there, one to vegan,
- 1:04:35it was a vegetarian temple.
- 1:04:37But we know we're affecting lots of people because of the anecdotal evidence.
- 1:04:42Maybe someday we'll do a study there.
- 1:04:45We now have MOUs, memorandums of understanding, where specific WATs, W-A-T-WATs are the term
- 1:04:56for temples in Thailand.
- 1:05:00A WAT commits to one day a week, they will only accept vegan or plant-based food from
- 1:05:07the followers.
- 1:05:08Now, what effect does that have?
- 1:05:10Not only are the monks eating vegan for one day a week, it's a good start, it's not enough,
- 1:05:18but it's a really good start.
- 1:05:20But now we're educating the followers.
- 1:05:22And again, there's 65 million of them.
- 1:05:25Before we started in Thailand, which is next to China, the largest Buddhist population
- 1:05:32in the entire world, before we started there, the Thai monks didn't even have the word vegan
- 1:05:39or plant-based in their vocabulary.
- 1:05:41They weren't thinking about it.
- 1:05:43And so if you're a model, if you're a devoted Buddhist, and a monk says, it doesn't matter
- 1:05:50if you're eating animal flesh, it doesn't matter if you're eating animal products, it's
- 1:05:55all the same.
- 1:05:56Just take whatever's offered.
- 1:05:57But now we're changing that narrative.
- 1:06:00So it does matter.
- 1:06:01I know it's only one day a week at these temples, but a lot of the monks are responding to this
- 1:06:07and we're working with the major temples.
- 1:06:09We've been to 150 of them in the last four years.
- 1:06:12We also teach vegan cooking.
- 1:06:14And then in Vietnam, we're sponsoring these large-scale cooking classes and cooking shows.
- 1:06:23And some of our events get as many as five or 6,000 people.
- 1:06:27So we're not counting them with the counter, but we're estimating that during the course
- 1:06:33of a weekend, actually showing people, 5,000 to 6,000 people how to cook vegan.
- 1:06:39And at the same time, talking to them about the nutritional benefits to lower your risk
- 1:06:46of getting cancer and heart disease and obesity and high blood pressure, et cetera, et cetera.
- 1:06:52So we know we're having an enormous effect.
- 1:06:54We've gotten major grants from Open Philanthropy, from ACE, Animal Charity Evaluators.
- 1:06:58We just got one a couple of days ago from ACE, from the World Foundation of Animals.
- 1:07:13So we're definitely a major factor out there and we are the only voice for animals in the
- 1:07:20Buddhist community, the only organization that's a voice for animals internationally.
- 1:07:24Thank you, Bob.
- 1:07:25Arjani, would you like to add something to this long, beautiful list?
- 1:07:30Yeah, I'd love to just present a little bit what the US strategy will be going forward
- 1:07:36because I'm new in my position at DVA.
- 1:07:39So I'm coming in and having to come up with a whole approach of how I'm going to try to
- 1:07:47raise awareness of animal suffering and influence Buddhists in the States.
- 1:07:53So that's my role.
- 1:07:56So it's a three-tiered strategy that we're planning at DVA.
- 1:08:00So the first being direct Dharma center engagement.
- 1:08:04So really reaching out to Dharma centers, consulting them thoroughly on how to change
- 1:08:11their menus, what to buy, how to go towards more and more meals being fully plant-based.
- 1:08:21And in that, we're building right now this program called the Climate and Compassion
- 1:08:27Awards.
- 1:08:28So we plan to award and honor Buddhist centers that have animal and climate-friendly food
- 1:08:35policies.
- 1:08:36So it's really wanting to push institutional food policies to be better for climate and
- 1:08:44animal impact.
- 1:08:46And with those awards, we hope to raise the profile of those centers and encourage other
- 1:08:51centers to join and to go through our consulting and hopefully adapt their food policies more
- 1:08:59and more.
- 1:09:00And then the second tier would be community engagement, community outreach.
- 1:09:04I'm very excited about that one because we will have two cohorts per year.
- 1:09:10So compassion leadership cohorts running twice a year, around four to five months each, where
- 1:09:17individuals from sanghas or just individual practitioners, individual Buddhists, even
- 1:09:22individual Buddhist curious people, even if they're not fully practicing yet, or just
- 1:09:27you know, like, yeah, just practicing a little bit.
- 1:09:32They can partake in this learning cohort with us and we will be training them in all aspects
- 1:09:38of, first of all, like all the in-depth, like what the Buddha taught, like what does Buddhism
- 1:09:43teach about animal rights, ethics, veganism, vegetarianism.
- 1:09:49Then also, like the environmental impact, truly like a full deep dive also on animal
- 1:09:54suffering and the realities of the animal industries and what common practices are so
- 1:10:00that they're really equipped with that knowledge in depth and then environmental impact and
- 1:10:05health impact and then a bit of strategy about, you know, how to engage conversations, how
- 1:10:10to lead good conversations.
- 1:10:14And then encouraging them to go out into their individual communities and bringing animal
- 1:10:21advocacy programming into those communities.
- 1:10:24So that can be in the form of running a book club, a discussion group, you know, showing
- 1:10:30movies on the subject, documentaries, having a potluck, some kind of like vegan bakeout
- 1:10:36or something.
- 1:10:38So it will be very creative.
- 1:10:39It could be arts programs, whatever they want, but we will be sort of training them, incubating
- 1:10:44them.
- 1:10:45It's like it's the incubating changemakers approach.
- 1:10:47So you bring people in, you incubate them to know how to do advocacy work and then you
- 1:10:53send them out to advocate for animals we have in Buddhist communities.
- 1:10:58So that will be that tier.
- 1:11:00And then the last one, just public education, right?
- 1:11:03So there's direct center outreach, community outreach, and then public education, where
- 1:11:07we just hope to do more on our website, you know, just get like a better blog running
- 1:11:14again, have more interviews, you know, just really raise awareness of animal suffering
- 1:11:19and the Buddhist sphere in the United States in the public way, just kind of in conversation,
- 1:11:26in the narrative, in the discourse area.
- 1:11:29Yeah.
- 1:11:30Thank you, Arjani.
- 1:11:32And I have to confess to the listeners that I am a member of Dharma Voices for Animals
- 1:11:39and I decided to be a donor and I encourage listeners to also donate.
- 1:11:45After listening to the impact of the organization, this is what you're contributing to, an organization
- 1:11:53that is smart and is strategic, that is making a difference.
- 1:11:58And there's this concept in Buddhism of getting joy, getting happiness from the good and wholesome
- 1:12:05actions and great things that happen to people.
- 1:12:10And I get lots of joy from just reading or listening to you, but also reading about all
- 1:12:20the great things that Dharma Voices for Animals do.
- 1:12:24So I try to be objective in this interview, but really, I truly believe in this organization.
- 1:12:33Arjani, Bob, did you have anything more to add before we stop the recording?
- 1:12:40Well, thank you for that comment and your appreciation of the work.
- 1:12:45I'm also very excited to begin this journey with DBA and to really expand and bring whatever
- 1:12:51skills I have and ideas to the table.
- 1:12:55And I'm excited and I really hope people reach out, they can volunteer, they can participate
- 1:13:02in the cohort, they can tell us of Dharma centers that they think should participate
- 1:13:07in the awards.
- 1:13:08There's so many ways to help us out or to be engaged.
- 1:13:14So I look forward to hearing from folks out there.
- 1:13:18Also thank you for kind words and for being a member and for donations.
- 1:13:25It's wonderful.
- 1:13:26It can really help us.
- 1:13:27So all these projects that I mentioned in Asia are three countries and in the US and
- 1:13:34that we're doing lots of other stuff.
- 1:13:35And we don't mention like in Brazil, Germany, we do work in all these places, but we concentrate
- 1:13:42on our four projects that we picked those out because of the impact on the number of
- 1:13:46Buddhists and impact that we can have.
- 1:13:49So people can join, go to our website and become a member, drop down and just sign up
- 1:13:56and make a donation if you like.
- 1:13:59I mean, if you don't have the means to do that, it's okay, just join and then you'll
- 1:14:02get our newsletter.
- 1:14:03So there's something you can do.
- 1:14:05We have a Sangha that meets the last Sunday of every month.
- 1:14:13So it's either one hour, we call that Sangha or three hour retreat.
- 1:14:18And I'm either teaching, so we teach meditation and also it's kind of a time where you can
- 1:14:25just share your joys and your frustrations with practicing at Buddhist centers or practicing
- 1:14:34in Sanghas.
- 1:14:37And so it's kind of a support group for Buddhists.
- 1:14:41Some people are activists, some are vegan, some are vegetarian, some are none of the
- 1:14:45above, but do that.
- 1:14:46I teach it and I also teach with our board member, Bhante Sati, who's a Sri Lankan American
- 1:14:52Theravadan Buddhist monk.
- 1:14:54He's one of the few Theravadan monks in the world that's vegan and he has been for many
- 1:14:59years.
- 1:15:00He's been living in the US since 1999 and just send an email or a web form to us if
- 1:15:09you haven't already signed up for one of our Sunday meetings.
- 1:15:14So that's another way you can get involved, support your Dharma practice or if you're
- 1:15:18curious about meditation or whatever, very much appreciated.
- 1:15:22The other thing is to help us out with these centers.
- 1:15:25If you go to a center, so maybe you're going to go on a retreat or maybe it's just you
- 1:15:31go to listen to a Dharma talk or maybe just go for a meal.
- 1:15:35Let us know.
- 1:15:36Just send an email to friends at dharmavoicesforanimals.org and one of us will be answering your email
- 1:15:45if you want to tell us about a center.
- 1:15:47You got this center and maybe on a certain day of the week they're serving hamburgers
- 1:15:52there and you're curious about that or you're upset by that.
- 1:15:57Let us know.
- 1:15:58If you're going to the center, they'll listen to you.
- 1:16:01They'll give you the time to talk to them about that.
- 1:16:07You might just ask a question.
- 1:16:09I'm confused.
- 1:16:10Maybe it goes on like this.
- 1:16:11I'm confused.
- 1:16:12Why are we eating hamburgers?
- 1:16:15Because I understand how hamburgers are produced.
- 1:16:19Or maybe you just contact us and let us do the work for you and that's fine.
- 1:16:23We just need information on these centers.
- 1:16:26So I think that's a way to answer your question.
- 1:16:28Thanks.
- 1:16:29Yeah.
- 1:16:30And I would love to leave one last message too just for listeners, especially if there's
- 1:16:34any Buddhist listening.
- 1:16:37If compassion, I think it's important to contemplate like if compassion, the teachings of compassion
- 1:16:44is what drew us to Buddhism.
- 1:16:47But that is the case and if we care deeply about compassion as a practice, then we have
- 1:16:54that opportunity three times a day to put those teachings into practice and into action.
- 1:17:00And really in the spirit of engaged Buddhism, of really letting our practice come alive,
- 1:17:05of letting it infuse all aspects of our lives, like our relationships, our consumption, our
- 1:17:10mind, our thoughts, our, like I said, like body, speech and mind.
- 1:17:15It's a wonderful opportunity to consider the animals and the impact we have.
- 1:17:19And yeah, I want to leave with that.
- 1:17:22Yeah, if I may, just one more thing I'd like to share.
- 1:17:27So animals cannot speak for themselves.
- 1:17:29They don't speak in a way.
- 1:17:31I mean, if we have a cat or a dog, we kind of know what they want and that's, but most
- 1:17:36animals, farmed animals really can't go to a center and say, why are you eating my children?
- 1:17:42I mean, they can't do that.
- 1:17:44So they didn't vote for us.
- 1:17:47They didn't select us, but we represent them.
- 1:17:50And we, as I mentioned, are the only international Buddhist animal advocacy organization in the
- 1:17:56entire world.
- 1:17:57So when you help us, you're helping the animals.
- 1:17:59We're speaking for them.
- 1:18:00We're trying to do the best job we can.
- 1:18:03And this is your opportunity to help us, to support us so that we can be a voice for animals,
- 1:18:13a sound of voice for animals.
- 1:18:16Thanks for having us, by the way.
- 1:18:17Of course.
- 1:18:19And those are great parting words.
- 1:18:21Yes, this is your opportunity.
- 1:18:23And yes, you have the chance to be compassionate three times a day.
- 1:18:31Yes, to all of that.
- 1:18:33And of course, again, more details in the description below.
- 1:18:37So Ajani, Bob, thank you so much for all of your work, for your dedication to this organization.
- 1:18:46And thank you so much for having accepted my invitation.
- 1:18:50Thank you.
- 1:18:51Thank you.
- 1:18:52Thank you, everyone, for listening.
- 1:18:54I kindly invite you to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 1:18:58Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 1:19:01Again, thank you so much for caring.
- 1:19:04And I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.
- 1:19:08May all beings be happy, Whatever living beings there may be,
- 1:19:18Whether they are weak or strong, Omitting none,
- 1:19:25The great or the mighty, Medium, short or small,
- 1:19:33The seen and the unseen, Those living near and far away,
- 1:19:43Those born and to be born, May all beings be happy.