Latest / First Trust ROI Podcast / Ep 80 | Gibson Smith | Why are Interest Rates Climbing Again…and What are the Implications for Bond Investors? | ROI Podcast
Transcript
- 0:12Ryan: Well, as we head into fall, there is a lot of change in foot.
- 0:16Ryan: We've got a new Fed chair, we've got midterm elections right around the corner, we've got a shift to debt financing for artificial intelligence, some populist pushback against that, and we've got a changing geopolitical background.
- 0:31Ryan: A lot to talk about in markets.
- 0:33Ryan: Joining me today on the First Trust ROI podcast is Gibson Smith, the founder and CEO of Smith Capital, who serves as a subadvisor for several First Trust ETFs.
- 0:43Ryan: Gibson and I will discuss all of these issues and more on this episode of the First Trust ROI Podcast.
- 0:49Ryan: Can you believe it's fall?
- 0:51Ryan: I guess is my opening question for you.
- 0:53Ryan: I don't know where the summer went, but um it seems like the year is flying by.
- 0:58Ryan: Um it's football season is upon us.
- 1:03Ryan: Um there's a lot of exciting things happening in college sports in NFL uh football, uh at least you know, expected for the year.
- 1:13Ryan: But uh here we are at fall.
- 1:14Ryan: So thanks for uh joining us on the podcast again, Gibson.
- 1:20Gibson: Always happy to be happy to be with you, Ryan.
- 1:22Gibson: This is a lot of fun.
- 1:24Ryan: Okay, so given that we are um not quite three-quarters of the way through the year, uh, but but closing in on that, um, last time we spoke, I think, was towards the end of winter, early spring.
- 1:38Ryan: And I guess I'm wondering um as this year has progressed, has it played out as you have uh expected it to?
- 1:46Ryan: Is is are we at this point in 2026?
- 1:49Ryan: Um are we seeing what you expected to see back in March when we spoke last?
- 1:54Gibson: Yeah, I mean a lot, a lot has changed.
- 1:56Gibson: Um, you know, one thing, one of our themes for the year was you know, don't fight the administration.
- 2:04Gibson: And when we think about the agenda of the administration, that's still one of our key themes uh throughout, not this year, it'll probably leak into next year, but the administration is issuing an enormous amount of change, and with that change comes volatility and uncertainty.
- 2:22Gibson: So I think it would have been, you know, almost impossible to predict with high level of probabilities how things were going to play out this year in light of all the things we've experienced.
- 2:32Gibson: I mean, clearly the situation in the Middle East is uh kind of raising some concerns around the durability of inflation, and that's changed our view a little bit.
- 2:41Gibson: Um but yeah, it's a it's a different world.
- 2:43Gibson: There's a lot of variables, um, there's a lot of volatility, there's a lot of uncertainty, and you know, plays into some of our other themes that we've been focusing on in terms of markets.
- 2:53Ryan: Yeah.
- 2:54Ryan: Um I want to dig into uh some of those themes as we as we have our conversation today.
- 3:00Ryan: But before we do, I would just point out that as an active manager of funds, uh Smith Capital, you know, with all these changing conditions, you are able to adjust and to manage risks that appear that weren't on the horizon before and to exploit or take advantage of opportunities as they present themselves.
- 3:21Ryan: So I guess it's no surprise to me to see in the ETF industry one of the dynamics that we've seen over the last couple of years is really the resurgence of active managers like yourself because you're able to address some of those risks and to take advantage of some of those opportunities.
- 3:40Gibson: Yeah, it's you know, it's a very dynamic period of time, and I'm sure we'll we'll touch on this in some of your questions, and I'll kind of share my thoughts.
- 3:49Gibson: But active management is so critical on the fixed income side, and it's going to become even more important as time passes.
- 3:59Gibson: And just a little preview of our thoughts.
- 4:02Gibson: Um, when we see what's happening in the hyperscaly scalar or the AI issuance that we're seeing in the corporate bond market, there's just this insatiable need for capital and an abundant desire to borrow money and to make investments in the AI movement.
- 4:22Gibson: What that's doing is it's changing the construct of the credit indices that we're measured against.
- 4:27Gibson: And if we think about the Mag 7 as it relates to the equity market being a very dominant source of returns both on earnings and on performance of the equity indices, 12 months from now, the credit indices are gonna have those same influences where the Mag 7 are that are many of them are hyperscalers in terms of the AI build-out.
- 4:51Gibson: And for active asset allocators, they're gonna have to consider the correlations that exist between the equity market and the bond market even more so.
- 5:01Gibson: And I think that's going to not only bring more money into the active fixed income space, but it's gonna force the indexers and closet indexers, you know, to really consider that there are correlated risks between equity and fixed income right now that are very, very high, and it may not serve the end investor.
- 5:22Ryan: Yeah, that's really interesting.
- 5:23Ryan: And I want to I definitely want to dig into some of those um some of those specifics related to credit and the opportunities and the risks that are related to AI.
- 5:32Ryan: And um you you're right, this is a multi-trillion dollar uh project of investing and building out um data centers and building out AI, and and it's gonna be amazing to see how it continues to play out.
- 5:47Ryan: So I I'm uh I'm keen to get your thoughts on that and how it impacts your world.
- 5:53Ryan: Um I'm also curious from a high level, I want to start off a little bit.
- 5:58Ryan: Um, you know, we we talk about some of the unexpected uh risks and opportunities, and one of the things that we talked about in March, because it was just happening, was that there was, you know, in the geopolitical uh sphere, we were seeing an outbreak of war in the Middle East with Iran.
- 6:17Ryan: None of us were really sure where that was going.
- 6:20Ryan: Still not quite sure where it's going, uh, but it certainly has lasted longer than than I think some people had expected it to when we last spoke.
- 6:29Ryan: Um and so I'm curious the that feeds through to a lot of different parts of the economy, but I'm curious where uh or how that has impacted the bond market throughout this year and what your outlook is going forward as we think about high oil prices and inflation and all the tie-ins to that.
- 6:48Ryan: Um how is that impacting your world?
- 6:51Gibson: Well, I think if if we step back and we go back to the March period of time, one of our views, which is still playing out, was that we were entering a normalization process on inflation.
- 7:02Gibson: If we go back to what the massive stimulus that was part of, you know, the kind of the COVID period of time, that had started to work its way through the system.
- 7:12Gibson: Even some of the tariffs that were issued by the current administration, those had kind of started to work their way through.
- 7:19Gibson: We were seeing an adjustment in the rents component as an input into the inflation data.
- 7:25Gibson: All of this was happening.
- 7:27Gibson: Um and then obviously we entered the Middle East, and you saw this spike in energy prices, which has proven to be a little more durable than I think most of us thought.
- 7:38Gibson: I remind my team all the time when Russia invaded Ukraine.
- 7:42Gibson: I think many of us thought, well, this will be over in two weeks, and here we are almost three years later, still dealing with that situation.
- 7:48Gibson: The situation with Iran is taking longer than most had hoped.
- 7:53Gibson: And that elevated energy price is now starting to work its way through the inflation data and is holding the inflation data up more than I think most would like, particularly bond investors like myself.
- 8:05Gibson: Is it permanent?
- 8:07Gibson: Is it going to be with us for a long time?
- 8:10Gibson: Are we going to see energy prices decline?
- 8:12Gibson: The true answer is nobody knows for sure.
- 8:16Gibson: But the reality is if you look at supply and demand in the energy market, our domestic production, so on and so forth, there's probably a bias towards energy coming down in terms of price in the future.
- 8:29Gibson: But in the near term, uh the bond market's really focused on that elevated energy price and what it means for our average consumers and ultimately what it means for the inflation data.
- 8:39Gibson: We're going to get a series of inflation data this week on Thursday and Friday with PPI and CPI, and we'll get a first glance into how this is working its way through the system.
- 8:48Gibson: But you know, everyone's paying attention to it right now, and I think it is one of the most critical factors for fixed income investors and ultimately probably all investors, in that if we don't get some reprieve on the inflation front, we probably are in an environment where yields will remain elevated.
- 9:08Gibson: And if yields end up going significantly higher, I think that poses a pretty significant threat to risk assets.
- 9:15Gibson: I mean, the underlying fundamentals are good, but you know, higher discount rate, higher rates in the economy actually will start to feel the impact.
- 9:24Gibson: Um watching that very, very closely, Ryan.
- 9:26Gibson: And I think you know the problem with you know any situation like Iran is it's day-to-day headlines and day-to-day changes in sentiment, and you know, we uh we pay very close attention, but I I really want to stress the point that supply and demand is gonna be the ultimate determinant over time, and we'll see how this plays out in the near term.
- 9:47Ryan: So you can't talk about inflation and um sort of expectations of inflation without also talking about the Fed.
- 9:55Ryan: And there's been some change at the Fed as well, with Kevin Warsh uh coming in as as the new Fed chair.
- 10:01Ryan: Um he seems like he's a bit different than Jerome Powell.
- 10:05Ryan: Uh of course, Jerome Powell has stuck around at the Fed, and so our our economic team at First Trust has said uh you know that that Walsh is kind of the chairman and name only because of the influence of Jerome Powell.
- 10:17Ryan: I'm just curious to get your thoughts on that.
- 10:18Ryan: But um so maybe maybe you could let us know what you think about that.
- 10:23Ryan: But also I'm curious um what sort of changes you're seeing a new Fed chair, Kevin Walsh, try to implement at the Fed and what impact is he having?
- 10:36Gibson: Well, we we uh think that the change at the Fed with Walsh taking the helm is actually quite significant.
- 10:43Gibson: And I agree with you know Jerome Powell kind of lurking around, uh maybe having some influence on this.
- 10:49Gibson: But if you take Kevin Walsh at his word, he is restructuring the Fed and getting the Fed back and focused on the monetary policy business and transferring some of the policy tools used during COVID and you know post-the-great financial crisis back in the hands of the Treasury.
- 11:08Gibson: We've written about this um in our piece, Don't Fight the Treasury, which was playing off of the kind of you know common phrase of don't fight the Fed as you're as it relates to investing.
- 11:19Gibson: We think that the Treasury is more empowered and is going to be a higher influence on markets than the Fed has been for a while.
- 11:26Gibson: But we do think that this change at the Fed is significant.
- 11:30Gibson: Um I have talked a lot about this publicly about Walsh being more like Greenspan and much less like Bernanke and Yellen.
- 11:38Gibson: I think that's significant.
- 11:40Gibson: I think it's important.
- 11:41Gibson: Uh we're going to get less guidance, we're going to get less forecasting.
- 11:45Gibson: And he's formed a bunch of task force that are going to go in and review a lot of things at the Fed and hopefully come with new positions.
- 11:53Gibson: One of them is obviously the balance sheet.
- 11:55Gibson: The balance sheet expanded to $9 trillion plus dollars during the COVID period of time, and he has been a big um critic of the use of the balance sheet and the overuse of the balance sheet, ultimately fueling some inflation in the economy.
- 12:10Gibson: And I think there's going to be some interesting data that comes out of that.
- 12:14Gibson: At the same time, he's also going in with the task force and reviewing all of the data that the Fed uses and produces and making sure that there's high integrity in the data and it's used in a higher level forecasting than it has been in the past.
- 12:28Gibson: I think these are all positives.
- 12:30Gibson: Um I think the market is going to have to adapt, though.
- 12:33Gibson: The market's going to have to adjust to this view that the Fed is always going to be there to help facilitate stable and upward trending markets.
- 12:42Gibson: And I think Warsh, in particular, again, more like Greenspan, is going to let markets set clearing prices and really be a, shall we say, a diagnosis of where risk is in the system.
- 12:54Gibson: And I think that's actually very healthy, but there's going to be an adjustment process that comes from it.
- 13:00Ryan: So as a portfolio manager, does it make the the reduce forward guidance, does that make your life, your job easier or more difficult, or does it not matter?
- 13:12Gibson: Uh to be determined.
- 13:13Gibson: You know, it's hard to say right now.
- 13:15Gibson: We don't know exactly what this is going to look like.
- 13:17Gibson: Um we've gotten a little foreshadowing from Warsh, particularly at Jackson Hole, but we don't know exactly what it's going to look like yet.
- 13:24Gibson: Um I I don't view it as actually hindering us in any way.
- 13:29Gibson: Um, you know, we're not trading off of you know the data as aggressively like many hedge funds would be or other, you know, really active investors.
- 13:38Gibson: We look at it as the data setting a trend and building a kind of thesis around the market.
- 13:45Gibson: So I don't think it's going to change what we do very much in terms of what you know Warsh does at the Fed.
- 13:50Gibson: It's just a different chairman.
- 13:51Gibson: It's kind of like when you look at a CEO.
- 13:54Gibson: Uh new CEO takes over a company, he or she comes with their biases and their vision and their idea of what the company should be doing and focused on.
- 14:04Gibson: This is the same thing at the Fed.
- 14:05Gibson: We have a new chairman, he's gonna guide us on what the Fed's gonna look like, what they're gonna do, and then we will respond if we need to in the way that we manage money.
- 14:13Gibson: But I don't think it's gonna be as extreme as the market is is kind of forecasting.
- 14:17Gibson: I just think it's gonna be, again, getting the Fed back into the monetary policy business and letting the treasury deal with the fiscal policy business and market dynamics, more capital markets than uh than they have in the past.
- 14:32Ryan: So, in the lead up to um to Kevin Walsh becoming the Fed chair, one of the narratives that I would hear sometimes was that you know, this is this is Trump's guy.
- 14:40Ryan: Trump wants rates to come down, therefore the risk is that, you know, when Walsh becomes chair, he's gonna push really hard and they're gonna end up cutting rates.
- 14:49Ryan: And um we've seen kind of the opposite.
- 14:52Ryan: As we speak right now, I think the market is pricing in something like 60% chance that uh the Fed raises by 25 basis points uh in September.
- 15:01Ryan: Um so I'm curious, is that surprising to you that that um that first off that Kevin Walsh hasn't been as pressured by the president?
- 15:12Ryan: And secondly, the market is now kind of expect expecting that the the Fed's gonna raise rates um at least once, if not twice this year.
- 15:21Gibson: Yeah, knowing Kevin Walsh and uh listening to him and understanding his view of the Federal Reserve, I think the first word that comes to mind is credibility.
- 15:31Gibson: And Walsh is not gonna do anything to destroy the credibility of the Fed and its focus on maintaining price stability and ultimately fueling full employment.
- 15:41Gibson: He's made that very clear.
- 15:43Gibson: He has repeated that line over and over and over again.
- 15:46Gibson: And, you know, the questioning of Fed independence is obviously on front and center for him.
- 15:52Gibson: And I think he will be not only allowed to by appointment, but he will exhibit independence from what the president wants.
- 16:00Gibson: I you know, the whole confirmation process where he was accused of being the hand puppet of Trump and everything else was just noise.
- 16:07Gibson: It was just absolute noise.
- 16:09Gibson: Uh Kevin Walsh is a very, very smart individual, he's a very high character individual, and I think he is going to be very disciplined and diligent about the credibility of the Fed and making sure that that credibility is maintained through their actions.
- 16:24Gibson: So I don't worry much about that.
- 16:26Gibson: But you bring up a wonderful point in that the market was absolutely obsessed with the Fed easing rates, and now the market is absolutely obsessed with the Fed raising rates.
- 16:37Gibson: And I always raise this question with investors: what if the Fed does nothing?
- 16:41Gibson: What if they just sit pat and let the data kind of work through the system, let the Iran situation work through the system and ultimately see what happens?
- 16:51Gibson: I think the one thing that's very, very clear in Warsh's comments is they're not 100% comfortable with the data as it exists right now.
- 16:59Gibson: So they're going to clean it up, and as they clean it up, they'll have a better idea of what's going to play out.
- 17:04Gibson: We have so much at play right now in markets, particularly, we all talk about AI, but the productivity gains from artificial intelligence are significant.
- 17:15Gibson: The promises of productivity gains are even more significant.
- 17:19Gibson: So there's a lot of dynamics that are going to play out, and they're playing out quickly.
- 17:22Gibson: And I think, you know, Kevin Warsh doesn't want to do anything extreme here, particularly in the early innings of his term.
- 17:29Gibson: And I think we should expect that he's going to be patient and he's going to watch and learn and see if there's anything that the Fed needs to do.
- 17:37Ryan: Yeah.
- 17:38Ryan: That that seems like a reasonable position to me that that um you can allow markets to work a bit before being too interventionalist.
- 17:47Ryan: Um so I I think that's a probably a good thing.
- 17:51Ryan: Um, you know, one of the things you mentioned um was the sort of the role of the Treasury and the role of the Fed kind of uh getting getting aligned properly.
- 18:01Ryan: I I think I'm not sure how you put it, but that was the gist.
- 18:04Ryan: Um and there has been some um interesting developments at the Treasury with uh Treasury Secretary Bissent um earlier this summer announcing what seemed for people like me to be a new version of quantitative easing that's not really called quantitative easing and it's different from quantitative easing, but I'm not fully sure exactly why.
- 18:26Ryan: Um so with that as a really confusing question.
- 18:29Ryan: Uh maybe you can explain it for us.
- 18:31Ryan: What's going on with uh quantitative easing that's not quantitative easing?
- 18:36Gibson: Well, I I kind of view it more as yield curve control or yield curve dynamics.
- 18:43Gibson: And if we recall, the Fed was actively engaged in quantitative easing, which was in essence taking securities out of the market, predominantly treasuries and mortgages, to put liquidity into the system, which ultimately works its way through as stimulus in the economy.
- 19:01Gibson: What Warsh and I think Bessent have a handshake agreement on is that as it relates to capital market management and yield curve management, some of that is gonna transfer to the Treasury.
- 19:14Gibson: Bessent came out a couple weeks ago and talked about the buybacks.
- 19:18Gibson: We're gonna get the first round this week.
- 19:20Gibson: The buybacks have historically been used to manage liquidity risk on the yield curve.
- 19:27Gibson: It now sounds as though buybacks could be used to contain interest rates so that the Treasury can continue to come in and finance the deficit through the Treasury issuance.
- 19:38Gibson: So this is a whole new frontier, and it's a new realm of what I would call somewhat market manipulation to be very candid.
- 19:46Gibson: I mean, the Fed during COVID and during the great financial crisis was manipulating long rates to keep them down so that we could finance the deficit.
- 19:55Gibson: It feels as though that has been turned over to the Treasury now, and Warsh is less interested in the Fed having a large balance sheet and being responsible for that yield curve management.
- 20:06Gibson: To me, this makes logical sense.
- 20:08Gibson: Um the $64,000 question for most market participants is you know, can the Treasury basically battle the bond vigilantes and keep interest rates contained or artificially set at levels so that they can issue securities?
- 20:23Gibson: And that's be it that's to be determined.
- 20:25Gibson: Um the analogy I've used uh with clients is that if you're in an alley and you're in a fight and you're carrying a knife and the other person has a bazooka pointed at you, that's not a good fight to be in.
- 20:36Gibson: So it's gonna be interesting to see how this plays out.
- 20:39Gibson: There's gonna be a lot of dynamics, there will be an enormous amount of criticism.
- 20:42Gibson: Um the one the one theme that is very, very important to watch is not just the absolute level on rates, but what does the shape of the yield curve look like as we work through some of these things?
- 20:54Ryan: So I was reading, um, your your team puts out some wonderful commentary and and comments, um, and I was reading through some of it earlier, um, and you were talking about wages in one of the blogs, and you wrote, wages are the durability test for the near-term macroeconomic framework.
- 21:12Ryan: And I thought that was a really interesting way to think about it, and I was wondering if you could maybe expand on that a little bit.
- 21:19Gibson: So we go back to uh you know a model, you know, if we think about a Keynesian model where consumption is obviously an important driver of economic growth.
- 21:28Gibson: I mean, the estimates are the consumer in the economy is somewhere between 70 and 80 percent of overall economic growth.
- 21:37Gibson: If you don't have wages growing at a rate above the rate of inflation, that obviously hinders consumption.
- 21:46Gibson: And in today's environment, if we think about consumption plus investment plus government spending, exports minus imports, the investment side of it is very, very strong with all of the AI investment.
- 21:59Gibson: Investment and all the investment associated with reshoring of our industrial base here in the United States.
- 22:06Gibson: That's going to add somewhere between 1 and 1.2 percent to economic growth.
- 22:10Gibson: But if we don't have wage growth at a time when we have low unemployment, that consumption number gets challenged.
- 22:17Gibson: And that's what we talk about in terms of the durability of growth is very contingent on wage and wage growth being greater than that of the inflation rate.
- 22:26Gibson: This can last for a little bit of time, but ultimately there is a call it reconciliation process that if wages don't don't start growing, we're going to have a problem as it relates to economic growth.
- 22:40Ryan: There's probably also some political implications of that as well.
- 22:45Ryan: I think as people see inflation and they they recognize that their wages are maybe not keeping up with that inflation, that can cause some uh some headwinds for well the incumbents especially because people start wanting change.
- 22:59Ryan: And of course we have the midterm elections right around the corner.
- 23:03Ryan: Um and so uh I'm curious where you think uh we're going from the midterms, and and then we can talk about the implications of that.
- 23:12Ryan: But um where are we headed uh for the midterms from from your team's perspective?
- 23:17Gibson: Yeah, and we've highlighted this in some of our writing.
- 23:19Gibson: Thank you for for bringing that up.
- 23:21Gibson: Um we highlighted uh what we called the six W's, which were market themes that we were focusing on, and one of them was Washington, and that was related obviously to the midterms.
- 23:32Gibson: You know the Trump administration has had the benefit of controlling both the House and the Senate, and when you control Congress, you can move policy through.
- 23:41Gibson: We think about the the big beautiful bill that went through and the impact that has had on not just the tax code, but the overall stimulus in the economy and again the the reshoring and the reindustrialization of the United States, along with some other policy tools associated with you know consolidation and and you know, MA, so on and so forth.
- 24:01Gibson: But you know, as we go into the midterms, right now it looks as though the Democrats have a chance of taking the House and the Republicans should keep the Senate.
- 24:08Gibson: These things can change on a dime.
- 24:10Gibson: So we have to be really careful in the forecasting and even more careful in the polls.
- 24:15Gibson: The polls have proven to be, you know, largely ineffective as it relates to predicting outcomes, even if you go to the betting sites and you use those as your source of information.
- 24:24Gibson: So the midterms are really, really important.
- 24:26Gibson: And Ryan, what you highlighted, I think, is critically important in that the dispersion of opportunity in our society or the dispersion of wealth is obviously weighted towards the higher end, and that gets reinforced by many of the liberals andor those that look at this through a lens of Trump facilitating this kind of big dispersion between the wealthy and those just getting by.
- 24:53Gibson: And I can tell you wholeheartedly, in an inflationary environment like we're in right now, whether it's transitory or it's more durable, you know, the average consumer is feeling the pain.
- 25:02Gibson: And when the average consumer is feeling the pain, they react, and they usually react through their vote.
- 25:08Gibson: And at this midterm period of time where this midterm elections is going to be very, very interesting.
- 25:13Gibson: We've seen an emergence of the Democratic social, you know, socialists.
- 25:19Gibson: Um obviously Mundami in New York is the one that gets the most attention, but they're popping up all over the nation in states that used to be particularly red, they now have, you know, kind of nominations and or people coming into the movement that are getting a lot of attention.
- 25:35Gibson: And I I don't I don't want to, you know, kind of forecast that this is gonna be a major problem.
- 25:42Gibson: I think it's just something we need to keep an eye on as it relates to socialism versus capitalism and this movement of trying to facilitate greater opportunity for the general public.
- 25:52Gibson: It's it's gonna be a big theme in the midterms.
- 25:55Gibson: Um I can't predict with any level of uh confidence what's gonna play out here because we just don't go into that level of detail.
- 26:05Gibson: And even if we did, I'm not sure we'd necessarily know how this is all gonna play out.
- 26:09Gibson: But it's gonna be very interesting to see if the administration maintains control of Congress.
- 26:14Gibson: If they don't, it means probably a little bit slower policy change.
- 26:19Gibson: It means that things slow down a little bit.
- 26:21Gibson: That might be really pretty good for markets.
- 26:23Gibson: Generally, when you have a divided Congress, markets do better.
- 26:26Gibson: Um so we'll we'll we'll be paying very close attention.
- 26:29Gibson: We'll watch and see how this plays out.
- 26:31Gibson: But um I'd say it's gonna be one of the market-moving events here over the next two months as we move into the uh into the midterms.
- 26:39Gibson: You know, unfortunately, we're not gonna be able to turn on TV without the garbage ads and being told how bad people are on the other side and everything else.
- 26:47Gibson: It's uh in Colorado we've got a very fierce race going on here, and it's just shameful what's uh what's playing out on TV.
- 26:54Gibson: I'm almost embarrassed.
- 26:56Ryan: There are always, I think, surges of rhetoric and populism, and you know, both parties and maybe you know, third parties, fourth parties uh trying to figure out what's the best way to really engage people to get them activated, especially in midterms where you know these populist messages start um trying to gather steam.
- 27:21Ryan: And it it's interesting because earlier we were talking a little bit about the investments in AI and and the move to uh to finance those with debt and the implications.
- 27:32Ryan: But one of the things that we've noticed in the last couple of months in particular is that the messaging surrounding AI and data centers has really um pivoted, I think, towards well, um kind of anti-data center and anti-AI and questioning whether or not these are good investments and questioning whether or not they're good for the communities, and um you've seen moratoriums and you know, my home state of New York, you've seen um you know pauses put on by by different uh governments and um kind of surprisingly in Texas with Governor Governor Abbott, which has been a little bit more free market, and um and and so I I'm I'm curious what your thought is there.
- 28:14Ryan: Is this like a a sh just sort of a my take is that it's a lot to do with midterms and and sort of that populist urge.
- 28:21Ryan: But um do you do you think that I'm right with that, or is this something that is longer term where we're gonna have some pushback against the development of AI and data centers or any any thoughts there?
- 28:33Gibson: Yeah, I'll start I'll start with a statement.
- 28:34Gibson: I I sure hope not.
- 28:35Gibson: Um I I really do believe that the you know the AI race, um, which is largely between the United States and China is the real deal.
- 28:45Gibson: And I I mean I can expand on this.
- 28:47Gibson: We could talk for for you know one or two hours on this issue.
- 28:51Gibson: We have a piece coming out this Wednesday on, we've titled it as one of the W's WOW, which is a 12-page write-up on AI, and it's it's very extensive and it goes into a lot of detail.
- 29:03Gibson: And so maybe we can follow up with a conversation on that point.
- 29:06Gibson: But no, I do think it's important.
- 29:08Gibson: What I find really interesting, and if we go back and we think about a timeline of, you know, call it China entering the WTO, and the narrative that's been with us for the last 15 to 20 years, is the gutting of America and the gutting of the industrial base and the loss of jobs and kind of the impact this is having on a lot of the regional communities or the middle of the of the country.
- 29:36Gibson: And now we have this opportunity to kind of rebuild and reindustrialize a lot of these areas that have suffered from that, and it's kind of met with battle cry of this is all bad.
- 29:50Gibson: Um, my view on this is that you know, states in particular were very quick to recruit capital to come and address some of these long-standing issues of underemployment or unemployment or stagnant wage growth or you know, all the issues that have come with these changes.
- 30:08Gibson: And it it's almost fascinating that you can't win either side.
- 30:15Gibson: You you you lose for creating global free trade that lowers inflation, and you lose by bringing in jobs back through the development of these centers.
- 30:24Gibson: So I think they are largely related to the midterms.
- 30:28Gibson: I think that the uh money that's gone into marketing against this to try and create villains is is is high.
- 30:36Gibson: And in the end, I think where we're gonna settle out is probably slowing down just a little bit and really allowing states to look at this through a lens of it's not just about jobs, it's about the community, it's about the health of the environment, it's all this as a package deal.
- 30:53Gibson: And I think they're gonna force some of the data center builders and the hyperscalers to really look at this through a broader lens of how they're gonna impact the communities and kind of why this is good.
- 31:04Gibson: So they've done a, I think, a poor job of marketing themselves and kind of talking about the job creation and kind of wage growth and all the things that we just talked about.
- 31:13Gibson: But it it's a it's a focal issue right now.
- 31:16Gibson: Um I I say this not not to not to be critical, but you know, when I was watching a show and Aaron Brockovich was being interviewed, I had kind of a 25-year flashback to when I was younger and dealing with some of these other issues.
- 31:30Gibson: And it's a it's a big it's a big campaign right now.
- 31:33Gibson: Um some of it's probably right and some of it's probably wrong, and the truth will come out over time.
- 31:38Gibson: And bottom line, though, is I hope we don't slow this down.
- 31:42Gibson: I I think AI and the uh technological advancements that we are seeing are so critically important to our country.
- 31:49Gibson: They're so important to the the health and the well-being of the United States from a competitive standpoint.
- 31:54Gibson: And I think when all is said and done, we're gonna look back at this period as not only dynamic, but fueling not just the future growth of the country, but doing it in a non-inflationary way.
- 32:06Gibson: I am in Warsh's camp that these are these are disinflationary uh elements of society and our economy, and I I think it's gonna be very, very positive.
- 32:15Gibson: But you know, we're it's new.
- 32:18Gibson: It's the first inning, second inning.
- 32:20Gibson: So there's gonna be these these issues we're gonna have to work through.
- 32:24Ryan: I really do think that your your point about marketing and the PR that um has has been lacking for data centers and AI is just so important.
- 32:33Ryan: And I think it it has a lot to do with the fact that these are sound, it's it's difficult to make the case in a soundbite, and that's what elections have become.
- 32:43Ryan: People's attention span is very short, and so you need to really package a what seems to be a more complex argument into a soundbite, and it's difficult to do.
- 32:53Ryan: But um again, to your to your point, I I think the advantages are broad.
- 33:00Ryan: It's not just advantages for enterprises that AI is going to bring and efficiency and productivity for enterprises, but even the way that internet brought information to everybody, you can now have a conversation with a PhD level person with endless patience and learn about any topic you want if you're on anywhere on the economic spectrum.
- 33:21Ryan: It doesn't matter.
- 33:22Ryan: Um it's no longer just the really um you know the really wealthy that can that can have a conversation with this, but but it's it's it's anyone.
- 33:30Ryan: And you can um you can just imagine some of the broad applications and how this can benefit society.
- 33:36Ryan: So I'm I'm more of an optimist as well as uh some of the benefits that this could have.
- 33:41Ryan: Um on profits for enterprises, absolutely, but I think you know the populism is misplaced.
- 33:48Ryan: It I think this should be something that a um that you know the population could get behind because it's beneficial.
- 33:54Gibson: Yeah, the part of society should probably be most concerned about AI is is higher education.
- 33:59Gibson: I mean, we are democratizing you know intelligence and wisdom at a very, very brisk pace.
- 34:05Gibson: And you know, I I think it it's gonna be interesting to see how higher education responds uh to the AI, and I think it is a threat, but you're exactly right.
- 34:16Gibson: And the the positives of this development and again giving people the ability to you know garner intelligence and wisdom and advance themselves in the way that they can process data and information is so positive.
- 34:32Gibson: Um, obviously it will be abused and there will be things that play out that are negative, but the reality is this is a massive, massive shift.
- 34:40Gibson: And it is, in my eyes, very, very positive for society.
- 34:44Gibson: Um, it is going to really, I think, change some of the barriers that have existed with the you know the higher education part of our society and really create new opportunities.
- 34:54Gibson: I mean, I was asked last week what am I most bullish on, and I said entrepreneurialism.
- 34:59Gibson: I mean, I think AI will open up new opportunities for people, uh, for our society.
- 35:05Gibson: Um, we're going to be doing things that we haven't done in the past that you know kind of relate to economic growth as well as kind of how we are a citizen in the global uh society.
- 35:14Gibson: And it's, I think it's just it's dynamic, it's exciting.
- 35:18Gibson: I can't wait to see how this plays out.
- 35:20Gibson: Um now at the same time, we we have a kind of a battle cry here.
- 35:25Gibson: Um our society really has to embrace the fact that this is happening.
- 35:29Gibson: It's not a yes or no decision, it's happening.
- 35:32Gibson: And as I say to all of the people who work for me, you have to become very proficient in how you're using the LLMs and how you're adapting to this kind of new opportunity.
- 35:44Gibson: And if you don't, you will be left behind.
- 35:46Gibson: Um so it's it's exciting.
- 35:48Gibson: It's a very exciting time.
- 35:50Ryan: So we're at a relatively early stage of the the hyperscalers sort of transitioning towards uh towards debt financing some of these data centers.
- 36:03Ryan: Um and um one of the questions I hear sometimes is what's what level of capacity is the market willing to bear for those companies to really finance this with debt?
- 36:12Ryan: Um and to your point earlier about the correlations between the the bond indices as they have more of that uh exposure and and stock indices, I think that's an issue.
- 36:24Ryan: But I'm curious, what's and any sense of the capacity for uh bond investors to to finance these sorts of uh data centers, especially for the hyperscalers?
- 36:34Gibson: Well, the one thing I know for sure is it's not unlimited.
- 36:36Gibson: I mean, there are caps, there are limits.
- 36:38Gibson: Um we haven't reached them yet.
- 36:41Gibson: It feels like um every deal is met with a new round of financing needs.
- 36:47Gibson: Um the positive is that the companies that are issuing the debt are the highest quality companies in our economy, and they are companies that are critical to the success of the economy.
- 37:01Gibson: So we're we're starting at a very, very good position where these companies can take on the additional leverage and not have it impair their financial position.
- 37:12Gibson: So that's that's one positive.
- 37:14Gibson: On the negative side, though, there there are limits, there are capacity constraints, and there ultimately has to be some return on this capital investment.
- 37:23Gibson: And right now it's kind of vague.
- 37:26Gibson: We hear stories that the returns are there, but they're not exactly showing up in the earnings yet, or if they are showing up in the earnings at a slower pace than we would like to see.
- 37:37Gibson: So the the bit the big question is is still outstanding of are there going to be returns on this invested capital that make sense, that support the investment, and or are accretive to the company's earnings in a way that makes this investment look really, really smart.
- 37:54Gibson: We won't know the answer for that, in my opinion, for probably another 18 months to two years.
- 37:59Gibson: We'll start to get glimmers and more insight and so on and so forth.
- 38:03Gibson: But that's the real question.
- 38:05Gibson: Um what the the good thing is, if we go back to kind of the dot-com financing period of time, that was all done in the high-yield market.
- 38:13Gibson: And we were financing hope.
- 38:16Gibson: In this environment, it's coming out of the highest quality companies, and we're financing the development of the newest next wave technology that has an enormous amount of promise.
- 38:27Gibson: In dot com, we didn't have ubiquitous broadband or Wi-Fi in the system.
- 38:32Gibson: Today, um, we do, and that is actually a big differential between dot-com and this AI financing.
- 38:39Gibson: So, Ryan, it's it's gonna be um, I mean, I say this with with no joke.
- 38:46Gibson: The hyperscalers will take as much capital as the market is willing to give them, and they will keep pursuing capital until the market says no more.
- 38:55Gibson: And that's the environment we're gonna be in.
- 38:57Gibson: Um so it's gonna be up to us as active managers to say, we know you want the capital, but you're not paying us enough for that capital, or the risk associated with that is not appropriate.
- 39:10Gibson: You know, one factor that I think every everyone should be aware of, and this is not transparent in markets, and I haven't seen any really reporting on this.
- 39:19Gibson: Um, we went back and looked at all of the issuance associated with AI development and the hyperscalers and the data center build-out and everything else over the last 18 months, from where it was issued on spread to where it is today, and about 80% of that debt issued is underwater.
- 39:37Gibson: Either spreads are wider or yields are higher.
- 39:40Gibson: So the experience of the fixed income investor or the persons providing that capital has not been positive, which tells me that the next round of financing or next round of capital needs are gonna be even more expensive.
- 39:54Gibson: It's gonna come at wider spreads, obviously higher yields based on what's happened in the treasury market.
- 40:00Gibson: So there's a point where that cost of debt capital starts to work its way into the most important question, which I just said is what are the returns gonna be?
- 40:09Gibson: If the returns are 34, you know, 30 to 40 percent and you're financing at 5 or 6 or 7%, you don't care.
- 40:16Gibson: But if the returns are 15% and you're financing at 7%, that's a lot more risk.
- 40:21Gibson: So these are the questions that we're gonna work through.
- 40:23Gibson: Um, I do think the next round of financing is gonna have higher yields and wider spreads.
- 40:28Gibson: Um, we may have some interest.
- 40:30Gibson: We'll have to wait and see how it plays out.
- 40:31Gibson: But as of right now, we're fairly, you know, significantly underweight the hyperscaler debt and the issuance that we've seen.
- 40:38Gibson: Uh, we've been concerned about the kind of you know the need for more capital and the valuations that the capital has been priced at, and we're gonna continue to be very disciplined around that.
- 40:49Ryan: So that's uh that's a good uh segue to my next question for you.
- 40:52Ryan: And that is as an active manager, kind of at a high level, um, you know, you you've got certain levers that you can that you can adjust uh from a risk-adjusted standpoint.
- 41:02Ryan: So where are you with respect to taking credit risk and looking at the opportunity just in general, and you can get as detailed as you like, but um and also from a duration standpoint, are you um you know, relative to benchmarks, are you are you longer duration, shorter duration?
- 41:18Gibson: Sure.
- 41:19Gibson: Let's talk about credit first, uh, because I think they're two independent um kind of issues for fixed income investors, particularly active investors.
- 41:27Gibson: Um when we look at spreads or the premium that we're paid to lend money to a company, spreads are historically very, very tight right now.
- 41:37Gibson: And that is validated by the earnings outlook and the fundamentals of corporate America, which are very, very, very positive.
- 41:44Gibson: I mean, I think we had earnings growth in excess of 20% last quarter.
- 41:48Gibson: So companies are doing really well, they're very profitable, they're generating free cash flow, and that warrants some of the tight spreads or valuations that we're seeing in the credit markets.
- 42:00Gibson: But when you look at the math behind the market, it doesn't make sense to loan money out for long terms or longer duration because your breakeven are very, very tight.
- 42:11Gibson: In other words, if you are wrong and spreads don't continue to tighten, you're gonna be handed some fairly significant losses.
- 42:18Gibson: Basis points times duration equals percentage change in price.
- 42:21Gibson: So we've been very, very positive on front-end credit and lower quality credit in the front end.
- 42:29Gibson: Five years and in, where we can earn a lot of yield or carry in our portfolios without a lot of risk.
- 42:35Gibson: And a lot of our exposure in the high yield market in our portfolios is in companies that have very pristine balance sheets.
- 42:43Gibson: In some cases, they have cash on the balance sheet that covers the next couple debt maturities.
- 42:48Gibson: In most cases, the bonds we own are inside of the revolver, which means we've taken out the refinancing risk.
- 42:54Gibson: So that's where we are on the credit markets.
- 42:55Gibson: Now, we will take 10 and 20-year and 30-year exposure on the credits where we have high conviction.
- 43:02Gibson: We see the management team as focused on delevering, they have the ability to generate free cash flow and use that free cash flow to pay down debt.
- 43:10Gibson: We really want to have those high confidence total return opportunities weighted high in our portfolios, and we are doing that across all of our strategies.
- 43:19Gibson: On the overall duration front, our view has been and continues to be that we want to take duration in the treasury market where you have very high real yields, between 1.5% and 2.5%.
- 43:32Gibson: And we're in the camp that the treasury market still offers a sense of insurance against market volatility.
- 43:40Gibson: There are many commentators out there today that say the bond market does not offer any protection or any insurance or any coverage against things going wrong.
- 43:48Gibson: I completely disagree with that.
- 43:51Gibson: And so we want to have a little more duration from the treasury market.
- 43:54Gibson: It provides us excess liquidity, plus it provides us the upside when rates turn and ultimately.
- 43:59Gibson: If something were to go wrong and we were going to a corrective period of time, I do think the bond market will see a lot of flows coming back into the market, and the bond market will react really well to a slowing growth environment or perception of slowing growth environment and also a declining inflation environment.
- 44:16Gibson: So that's how we're positioned right now.
- 44:18Gibson: I will tell you, as active managers, we have had long duration on and then long duration off throughout the last couple quarters.
- 44:26Gibson: We've been overweight 30s at one point and then underweight 30s.
- 44:31Gibson: We just we have to actively manage this, you know, interest rate risk and the risk of the yield curve in our portfolios.
- 44:38Gibson: It's what we do as part of our sector rotation.
- 44:40Gibson: So we're not a manager that has a view 12 months out and just sets the view and lets it kind of play out, and whether we're right or wrong will be determined 12 months from now.
- 44:50Gibson: We look at the market, we take in as much information as we can, and then we adjust the portfolio based on what we think is appropriate for our investors in terms of generating risk-adjusted returns and protecting the capital.
- 45:03Ryan: All right, my final question for you today, Gibson.
- 45:06Ryan: Um, looking out on the horizon, what are the wild cards that we're not thinking about?
- 45:12Ryan: What's what's coming that that no one's expecting?
- 45:15Ryan: And that's kind of an unfair question, but I love unfair questions at the end of a discussion.
- 45:20Ryan: So what are the wild cards that uh that you think uh could could materialize in the next three or four months?
- 45:28Gibson: Let me let me give you a couple.
- 45:29Gibson: And you know, we we as part of our process try and highlight, again, the themes that we see.
- 45:36Gibson: We try and relate them into our portfolios, for example, our participate and protect and heighten levels of liquidity, don't fight the administration, the central bank shift.
- 45:47Gibson: Those those are themes that run across our portfolios.
- 45:50Gibson: But we also come together and we try and highlight where we could be wrong or what could happen in market that could create some unwarranted or maybe unwelcome volatility.
- 46:00Gibson: The one that is most kind of present to me or the most obvious to me is that as we go through the change in global trade, we go through this resetting of not just free trade but fair trade and how we're gonna deal with different countries, that ultimately is a policy shift that has significant implications, both as it relates to the growth trajectories of different countries, but it all flows through the currency markets.
- 46:32Gibson: In today's environment, everyone's focused on the yen, the what's happening in Japan versus the United States.
- 46:38Gibson: Japan has historically been one of our largest creditors in terms of using the dollars that they receive from trade to invest in U.S.
- 46:46Gibson: treasuries and help us finance our deficit.
- 46:49Gibson: Number two, or in some cases number one, has been China.
- 46:52Gibson: And we all know the administration is aggressively going after the trade position with China.
- 46:59Gibson: So this flows through the currency markets.
- 47:01Gibson: And while the markets focused on the yen-dollar relationship and what that means, I'm focusing on the RB.
- 47:09Gibson: The RB has been the Chinese currency, has been largely manipulated and supported by China in terms of its valuation versus the dollar, enabling them to export cheaper goods to the United States.
- 47:23Gibson: Again, handshake agreement in exchange for financing our deficits.
- 47:27Gibson: That handshake is no longer the case.
- 47:29Gibson: That agreement is broken, and it's going to be very interesting to see how this plays out over time.
- 47:35Gibson: There are estimates that the RMB could be, you know, shall we say, um, misvalued to the tune of 20 to 50 percent.
- 47:43Gibson: And if we go through a process of truly valuing that currency versus the dollar, or probably as importantly the euro, that has massive implications for inflation, for growth, for trade.
- 47:55Gibson: So that's one wild card that I'll put out there that doesn't seem to be getting much attention.
- 48:02Gibson: Um I threw out another one a little bit earlier in terms of the, I'll call it the borrowing experience.
- 48:09Gibson: As a fixed income investor, when we participate in a new issue or we lend money to a company, if we're met with losses right out of the gate because of changes in market conditions or a repricing of spreads, we become a little more cautious in our next round and we make sure that we're really compensating or getting overcompensated for the risks.
- 48:29Gibson: And I do think that at some point on the horizon, particularly in the near term, there could be a fairly significant shift in the cost of capital on the debt side, wider spreads, higher yields, uh, that makes companies kind of pause a second and step back and think, are we necessarily doing the right thing here?
- 48:48Gibson: And those two are the kind of the biggest, you know, big wild cards.
- 48:51Gibson: There's plenty, I mean, there's plenty of things that could go wrong here, right?
- 48:54Gibson: The Iran situation could get worse, the situation in Ukraine could get worse, there's obviously the noise between the United States and Canada, the reshuffling of trade.
- 49:04Gibson: I mean, there's so many things.
- 49:06Gibson: The midterms, I mean, all these things are are on the horizon, and we just have to manage through them in the most disciplined fashion, make sure we have as much, many facts as possible and as much information as possible, and just make the decisions.
- 49:19Gibson: And sometimes the decision is we don't need to own it.
- 49:23Gibson: We don't need to be invested in it.
- 49:24Gibson: We don't need to take on that risk because it doesn't serve our investors.
- 49:30Gibson: It's not in our best interest of our our return.
- 49:32Gibson: So that's a long-winded answer to your question, Ryan.
- 49:36Gibson: But I think the currency markets demand an enormous amount of attention right now.
- 49:40Gibson: They're the ultimate kind of arbiter of change, and I think everyone should be paying very, very close attention.
- 49:47Ryan: All right.
- 49:47Ryan: That's uh great advice, and uh appreciate the insight and the wisdom you've provided us today.
- 49:53Ryan: A lot to think about uh as we head into the fall and then into the winter.
- 49:57Ryan: Uh, hope everyone had a wonderful summer.
- 50:00Ryan: Uh I know it's been uh you know kind of too short, ended too quickly, but um as as Gibson, you and I were talking uh as we started our conversation, maybe before we were, I don't know if we were uh recording or not, we we have football season to look forward to.
- 50:16Ryan: Um and uh you know those of us who are football fans uh are very excited about that.
- 50:21Ryan: So uh that's that's what you know, losing summer moving into fall means for me in upstate New York, even as I see the cold coming, the the leaves beginning to change.
- 50:30Ryan: So, anyways, Gibson.
- 50:32Ryan: Thanks for uh thanks for joining us again on the podcast.
- 50:36Ryan: We'll do this again sometime soon.
- 50:38Ryan: Um maybe maybe I can come out to to Denver and uh sometime early next year and we can uh have another conversation.
- 50:45Gibson: I would love that.
- 50:46Gibson: Thank you again for having me.
- 50:47Gibson: It's an honor and uh look forward to seeing you soon.
- 50:50Ryan: All right, sounds good.
- 50:51Ryan: And thanks to all of you as well for joining us on this episode of the First Trust ROI podcast.
- 50:55Ryan: We'll see you next time.