Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 243:1-5. Respecting Torah scholars: Tax Exemptions

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 243:1-5. Respecting Torah scholars: Tax Exemptions · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:00
  Good morning, we are in Simon Reshma Gimmel in Shah Ham Las
• 0:13
  ois Binion Tamika Khameim did not, did not would not go out
• 0:21
  themselves with the rest of the rest of the nation.
• 0:23
  Lots of opinion over Kafira E Sahir, whether to do to to build
• 0:30
  or to build the big trenches or the ditches, things like that.
• 0:35
  Shilohi's basil thing of ours because it's natural bizion, but
• 0:41
  in front of the army it's natural bizion.
• 0:43
  The Kiwan Shaheim, the Pyturium, and since their palter, I feel
• 0:48
  like hearing claim on ain't safe since they bet from a palter.
• 0:53
  Then then they don't have to hire pay for the hiring of any
• 0:57
  other people to build stuff for the city.
• 1:01
  Again, you know, construction, you know, a couple of name
• 1:04
  things, whatever. They don't have to go ahead and
• 1:08
  you know, pay for the construct, pay for the construction of
• 1:11
  these things because it's bad so and bizarre.
• 1:13
  So, and if it's any time that going out into the you know, to
• 1:17
  work physical work or things like that, which is not the you
• 1:22
  know, cover for tomahawk, you know, you can imagine that, you
• 1:25
  know, let's say, you know, you know, row Shiva, you know going
• 1:29
  out and you know, putting on work clothing and you know
• 1:33
  things like that, anything like that.
• 1:35
  That would be that's a part of babe the bedroom memoriam
• 1:42
  because she call Adam, you'd say the asshole.
• 1:44
  He is only talking about the case where everyone's going out
• 1:48
  to do, they're all going out physically themselves to do the
• 1:51
  job. Although if they're not doing it
• 1:54
  themselves, everyone is hiring a company to go ahead and to and
• 2:00
  to do the building or to do the the other the other types of,
• 2:06
  you know, other types of work or whatever.
• 2:08
  A grazing moment. I hear that say sorry or they're
• 2:12
  making a collection in Dover going the if it's something
• 2:18
  which is not get a high of the like the if he hates it by him
• 2:23
  like basic, you know, basic life, water, Plano, plumbing,
• 2:29
  electricity, all these types of things, garbage collection,
• 2:34
  whatever everyone lost his welcome.
• 2:35
  They are here to go ahead and to pay for these thing, you know,
• 2:39
  to pay part of you know, to pay part of this as well.
• 2:44
  The in between the House of the if everyone went out the you
• 2:48
  know, the you know, the people in the the town or whatever went
• 2:52
  out to try to fix it themselves or to build something
• 2:55
  themselves. They should say name the police
• 2:59
  they they decided to hire to hire out and to hire people.
• 3:03
  Then from the column Khayovim meeting Falcon, you don't say a
• 3:08
  freshman that since you know, since they went out there in a
• 3:12
  batsman and therefore when the work started there was a tour of
• 3:17
  the Tahmacl because of the Zion that even if the everyone
• 3:20
  decides to hire that they'd be putter as well.
• 3:23
  You don't say that, but since people are doing it themselves
• 3:27
  with Tahmaclom is part of the field.
• 3:30
  I mean, the difference is, is that the the the the first case
• 3:33
  in the Mohabbar is that they hire.
• 3:36
  It's the case. The case since evolve is
• 3:38
  everyone's going out to go ahead and do and do the work.
• 3:41
  So the question is, is it Hong Kong hive to go ahead and hire
• 3:45
  some other some guy to go ahead and and and to pitch in there
• 3:49
  with the all the other people of the town?
• 3:51
  But if no one in the town is going out, then the and it's
• 3:54
  something which is the gay had to stay high of, you know, you
• 3:58
  know, basic living. So then he'll be high and then
• 4:01
  he'll be high to to to pay for part of it, you know, to put his
• 4:05
  put his, his share, pay for his share.
• 4:09
  No, the town public, public works, public taxes, you know,
• 4:15
  it's, you know, different types of municipal services, things
• 4:19
  like that. That's what we're talking about
• 4:21
  over here. So or let's say, let's say in
• 4:26
  here in this country, you're living in a building and they
• 4:30
  have to buy it. All right.
• 4:31
  And I know, you know, everyone from the vibe is going out and
• 4:34
  cleaning the sewage drain, you know, you know, outside digging
• 4:38
  out clean and fixing the sewage drain.
• 4:40
  And you know, in the building. He wouldn't be, you know, he'd
• 4:43
  be, you know, he'd be parked there from from doing that or to
• 4:46
  hiring some other worker to do it.
• 4:48
  They hire a company he'd be have to put in for it.
• 4:51
  That's for, you know, for a building or for, again, for a
• 4:53
  town for, you know, you know, whatever whatever groups of
• 4:58
  people there are of Aldova should talk to Shreya Sayer
• 5:01
  something which is needed for guarding the city to go in
• 5:05
  Columbus a year, Amigulus said. How like the walls of the city
• 5:09
  or the towers or star Shymree more to pay for the police force
• 5:15
  or to pay, you know, militias or, you know, security, security
• 5:21
  camera armies, things like that. Low Hayabi lost Islam club.
• 5:26
  He doesn't he's not hired to go ahead and the not hired to give
• 5:30
  them to to give anything towards that.
• 5:33
  She ain't swift in Shira. They don't need Shira.
• 5:37
  It's very interesting. Chiffonar, it sounds like puts a
• 5:40
  bit of a muna in over here that the Adsense, you know, the the
• 5:44
  common, the Torres eschmira. So therefore the part of Adsense
• 5:47
  are paying for any sort of security, any sort of security,
• 5:52
  let's say a security company or or or or any other, you know,
• 5:58
  defense, defense systems, I don't know.
• 6:01
  And then they wouldn't have to pay for the Iron Dome.
• 6:03
  I have no idea. OK, so OK, so so maybe Mihalik,
• 6:11
  well, Shamir is also higher Adam, but but there's a
• 6:15
  difference between the part. There's a difference between
• 6:19
  immediate, immediate danger and and just hiring guards.
• 6:26
  There's a, there is a, there will be a difference between
• 6:28
  some sort of immediate danger. Like for example, there she was
• 6:31
  a restraining move. If there was a plague in the
• 6:33
  city, they, you know, they, they ran away or the people attacking
• 6:36
  the city, they also ran away. You're not talking about, they
• 6:38
  would sit there and go like this.
• 6:40
  You know, I told her it was showing, you know, it was
• 6:42
  showing me. You're talking about the
• 6:45
  preventative measures active, you know, active safety.
• 6:49
  That could be, that's not what we're talking about over here.
• 6:52
  You know. Uncle Ponteville, OK, how you
• 6:54
  perturiated? Call me in a meeting, therefore
• 6:57
  telling to call her poultry for all sorts of taxes.
• 7:00
  Bay me see Matsui Macobeni. I hear whether there are taxes
• 7:04
  which are placed upon the whole city Bay Mas who cuts of Al
• 7:09
  Koish Levada or any it's a personal tax bank Vui and Ben
• 7:13
  Shanam Kabui and whether they're, you know, whether it's
• 7:16
  a, you know, a sudden tax or it's a general, you know, a
• 7:20
  general tax, income tax, maybe I don't know the people in the
• 7:27
  city are higher as part of to go ahead and to pay their taxes.
• 7:34
  I feel even if it's not even if it's not a general fund, even if
• 7:42
  they have each person's individual name is listed.
• 7:44
  And so you know the guy you know some.
• 7:46
  So the arsenal we showed him was saved.
• 7:48
  It's individual name the clouds putter, but the shakhan Baskins
• 7:53
  that the cloud is hive to pay for Tony Collins taxes.
• 7:58
  It's gets it. I'm not going to yeah, I'm
• 8:00
  trying to avoid any politics when it comes to this whole
• 8:02
  sift. But this is one of the
• 8:05
  discussions or reasons you know that here when you know, when
• 8:08
  the let's say, you know, we're paying taxes and things and
• 8:12
  people not paying taxes or do they have to or they don't is
• 8:16
  some part of the question is also we'll see what defines.
• 8:20
  But the you know, whether you know that that's him yet they're
• 8:25
  not are not P Shukanara. They're not supposed to impose
• 8:27
  any any sort of taxes besides basic, you know, living taxes on
• 8:31
  the And therefore, if they're going against the Shukanara,
• 8:36
  what do you do? That's you know, that's you
• 8:39
  know, that's that's the question.
• 8:41
  Again, I'm not an expert in taxes.
• 8:42
  I don't know where all the taxes go to right.
• 8:45
  Yeah, But for stuff, stuff which isn't can they hire?
• 8:48
  He doesn't have to pay the other people have to shoulder it.
• 8:51
  That's what it says. That's the one which is the
• 8:53
  personal feeding people is stuck.
• 8:56
  He gets stuck. But as a as a tax on the then
• 9:01
  they they wouldn't have to go ahead.
• 9:03
  And I understand it doesn't understand these the the these
• 9:07
  taxes and things can go to, you know, many different things say
• 9:11
  in America, right, taxes will go to upkeep the army.
• 9:14
  And I don't know real crowd knows about the whole all those
• 9:18
  in services. But unless you're talking about
• 9:21
  Pasha's basic, you know, like I said, you know, basic, it's not
• 9:25
  like, you know, medical care, garbage collecting plum, you
• 9:28
  know, water services, things like that basic then then that's
• 9:32
  and it's multiple on the rest of the on the returns called
• 9:36
  Tabuhakam. It is on the rest of the people
• 9:38
  to go ahead and to and to and to and to shoulder his taxes so he
• 9:42
  can learn, He can learn and he can be around.
• 9:44
  If they do it themselves. It's so cream up favorite for
• 9:48
  those things. That's for building.
• 9:53
  Oh, and and with me. So the meets in here.
• 9:56
  Listen, honestly, the meets in here we're talking about is
• 9:58
  again, we're talking about general.
• 10:00
  You know, the melef put a head tax on people.
• 10:03
  The melef used to put stuff on. Now I don't know that if that
• 10:06
  those taxes used to just go Konami, if they would just go to
• 10:10
  the to the King's coffers. So you're right.
• 10:13
  That's the poshness of it. How far do we do we take?
• 10:17
  That's the thing. I guess that's beyond the share.
• 10:19
  How far do you take the different the different
• 10:22
  discussions? But I brought a thing about
• 10:23
  taxes now that I just brought up that this is one of the rise.
• 10:26
  I'm not getting into sock. I'm not getting into, you know,
• 10:28
  I'm just giving you, I guess, bringing up ideas.
• 10:30
  I've got feeling in Amar her hegmoine shatamah hakam adsman
• 10:35
  yitnu yitnu. Even if the Hagman themselves
• 10:39
  said the rabbi asked to pay, I have a Sieber law says Baldom.
• 10:43
  The Sieber will have to put the money out for him, even creamy
• 10:46
  with Sieber Altawa Hakam detained.
• 10:48
  And if the seaboard decided that they had that they got to force
• 10:52
  the time of Hakam to give. And this is, you know, aim the
• 10:56
  same Shalam clone that seaboard cannot force the time of Hakam
• 11:00
  to pay money no matter what, even if they say he has to.
• 11:03
  It's not fair. It doesn't make a difference.
• 11:05
  And that it's it's not binding. It's all Hakam Hakram Lahakhri
• 11:13
  or the Shame's hatsi burshi nubato dahab and he can go back
• 11:20
  and put a hair around the community or things like that.
• 11:23
  So they should pay the Angel of being all share on it.
• 11:27
  It makes a difference if he's the wealthiest person in the
• 11:29
  city or not. It's this is a didn't cover and
• 11:33
  this is this is what Khazal said the Dafko tobacco.
• 11:38
  Now what is the we're talking about is Toraso Umanosa.
• 11:42
  If they're you know, if they're it sounds like it by rash people
• 11:47
  that they're always the career is Torah about ain't Toraso
• 11:51
  Umanosa. But if the career is not
• 11:53
  learning, is not learning Torah, then they are if this he does a
• 12:05
  little bit of work or he does a bit of business.
• 12:08
  He trades in stock, some stocks and I, I don't know, whatever.
• 12:13
  At least finest boy today Hayev, right?
• 12:16
  If he has just just enough, he makes just enough to pay his
• 12:19
  bills and nothing, nothing more than that.
• 12:22
  Not to, you know, well, at least Usher and not to, you know, have
• 12:26
  a put, you know, renovate his house or have a nice kitchen or,
• 12:30
  you know, things like that. The whole Shah.
• 12:33
  She she she'll pull me a sock of Taser Aldevitor.
• 12:37
  And every time he has free time, he goes back to learning.
• 12:41
  The learning, mate. Tell their Nico.
• 12:42
  Terrazo Nosoi. It's still called Terrazo Nosoi.
• 12:46
  So it's not so it's not. So.
• 12:48
  Yeah. Nowadays, you know, it's again,
• 12:56
  vacations. I mean, this girl used to go to
• 12:58
  used to go to Switzerland if it's for health.
• 13:00
  And I saw someone say not to like they stomm Muttayel, they
• 13:03
  stomm, you know, go for the strolls and you know, and they
• 13:07
  again, it's a different door. It's a different door in the
• 13:09
  what was so you know, but Uncle Punnim, but that this is the
• 13:16
  definition. I got the Angel of Bain Bain
• 13:18
  shoe take this Shiva makes a difference.
• 13:20
  If he's a Shiva, a lawyer Rakshi who moves up the tomahawk on the
• 13:23
  doyroid. He should be Mosa to be a
• 13:26
  tomahawk on his door. Not that he's the tomahawk on
• 13:29
  the door don't really rock better on the first time he's
• 13:32
  moves up to be called tomahawk. I'm in his door.
• 13:34
  That's what that's the definition Shia de Lisa Vilite
• 13:37
  Bataro door in his door as because it's the rise from
• 13:44
  that's that's that's the McCord is that even if even if, you
• 13:47
  know, 200 years ago, they will laugh this guy's they will laugh
• 13:50
  at it. But in his door he's they know
• 13:53
  how to go ahead and to and to and to learn and talk and
• 14:01
  learning and things. So maybe and he understand you
• 14:06
  know, he has a good they have a good understanding and chaste
• 14:11
  going in to Russell and also the action is buyer.
• 14:15
  I guess this is a Sebastian. But the main thing is is that is
• 14:18
  that the the people who will be putter from taxes is the dire
• 14:22
  like I said, the riots from it says schmoozer, schmoozer.
• 14:28
  I mean you stop wasn't known as the so for PK and he said he's
• 14:33
  you know he is it's according to the door.
• 14:36
  Nava got the aim of the rain and she even though there's double C
• 14:41
  and then later sift that the if you're a person's LP, LP DNA
• 14:48
  Khazal, he has to he has to pay literally the we don't have
• 14:55
  anyone on that level in Vaishary.
• 14:58
  They come out going the Indian the patrum in mass, but this did
• 15:02
  a patriming from paying taxes aim at that.
• 15:06
  We're not so you know, we don't go.
• 15:09
  So he should be known as the he's the rabbi.
• 15:16
  He's the rabbi for Alpha Pecan. The remote says, even though
• 15:26
  that's medium, but still there's since things are unclear,
• 15:29
  there's some places where the time of is time to go ahead and
• 15:34
  to and to pay and to pay anyway. Now they they do bring, you
• 15:42
  know, there's for example, it's interesting.
• 15:45
  So the pescatua brings the Dominican and they everybody and
• 15:50
  they started was never to put any mass on any on any time of
• 15:53
  Hong Kong there. You should started a certain I
• 15:58
  think I see more than asking out there a certain idea of cover
• 16:01
  the terror, which I don't think which they ravished Mohabbat the
• 16:06
  Rabbani and and and and people learning things like that.
• 16:10
  They, they, you know, they, you know, even even ones who aren't
• 16:13
  so necessarily so religious, they, they, you know, they,
• 16:17
  they, they're having them a lot. The question is what what is
• 16:21
  next shove? So there is a discussion in the
• 16:24
  place of what is next shove that what would be next shove.
• 16:27
  It's someone who who have it doesn't need someone who has a
• 16:30
  position. So, so the post can I'm safe to
• 16:33
  understand the sources of Gomara in Belvastor, which says those
• 16:37
  who go from city to city, breaking their legs, go from
• 16:40
  city to city trying to learn more and trying to understand
• 16:44
  more, going from yeshiva to yeshiva, things like that.
• 16:46
  The grub rings and straight out that it doesn't only mean
• 16:50
  someone with a position anyone who is he said the way the
• 16:55
  Arkansas Chauhan rights and so on and so other people are
• 16:57
  supporting him for him to be able to learn even if his wife's
• 17:00
  supporting him able to learn will be will be part of this
• 17:03
  category. So the Arkansas Chauhan Passkins
• 17:09
  and the one of them, the CUDA is that Oh, wait, I just again, any
• 17:20
  of these again, any of these things, you know, practically, I
• 17:25
  don't know what what practically is what positive for mecha is
• 17:28
  people that I don't know. I don't know how the how this
• 17:30
  thing practically goes. But the question is, is what is
• 17:33
  also to Russell and also very interesting thing to point out.
• 17:36
  And oh, and the rush says they're interested to rush which
• 17:40
  the which the place can bring that that he says, I I looked it
• 17:48
  up inside. He says that he says the punter
• 17:52
  from mass, he says he, he, he says even even in the time of,
• 17:57
  of of Hazal time, in time of, you know that there, I'll say,
• 18:01
  I'll say to medium, right. And so he's like, who's going to
• 18:04
  pay? Like who said who's going to pay
• 18:05
  the taxes? Well, that's what everyone's
• 18:06
  learning. Who's your everyone but a lot of
• 18:08
  people, good pretenders of people were learning.
• 18:10
  He said, he said, even there, I'll say alpha to medium, it
• 18:13
  doesn't make a difference. It's called chicane nowadays.
• 18:16
  In his time there was only a few or whatever Sarah Kushner works
• 18:20
  it out. He was basically Kumar and with
• 18:23
  with Rebbe and said there was a mass which was put on the the
• 18:26
  city of Terraria and and and the leaders of the Almayyar.
• 18:30
  It's came to him and said, OK, you got to pay.
• 18:33
  You have to pay off. And he said no, so it's your
• 18:35
  fault. And so he didn't pay.
• 18:38
  And so the half of them ran away and they still get put the mass
• 18:40
  on them. And then, and then the other
• 18:43
  half ran away except for one person.
• 18:45
  And then they put the tax on, on this one person.
• 18:47
  He ran away. And then they and they and they
• 18:50
  and the, and the Xero went away. This is the, the McClure of
• 18:55
  these things anyway, Gilmo and Azazo, the mitzvahs Azazo, the
• 19:01
  mitzvahs Azazo, the mitzvahs Azazo.
• 19:06
  And he's he's worse than a regular person.
• 19:10
  It's Mama Shamu, or if it's is is Mama, it's a kill.
• 19:14
  Cool. It's it's he's the worst of the
• 19:16
  worst. It's whatever.
• 19:20
  You can't learn to hear from him.
• 19:23
  Whatever. I know there was there was a
• 19:24
  mice to hear some someone who's called whatever.
• 19:29
  He ended up found out he was doing things he shouldn't be
• 19:33
  doing. And whenever Shyla came up to
• 19:36
  around here, he used to give a sheer and everyone liked the
• 19:38
  sheer. But he was like, how can you go
• 19:40
  to a cheer with someone who's over a virus anyway?
• 19:43
  Dalit, limpor, Aloha who has to sell?
• 19:57
  Should not, They should not. They would not let someone else
• 20:00
  sell first. Until this until until they sell
• 20:03
  like people that he sells his stuff first, the dafka de leka
• 20:07
  of the Kohave de Mazabe. It's only what there's all going
• 20:09
  by. But EE Koh de Mazabe love the
• 20:12
  the Leslie Rebecca that's Superman Rabbanon.
• 20:16
  He's not going to get a lot of profit of Sudehi Lahana if he's
• 20:21
  not going to make a lot of revox from it.
• 20:25
  And so we're not going to amass it everyone else to make it to
• 20:27
  make them wait just because, you know, just just cover the Torah
• 20:31
  stand there. You know, it comes to that.
• 20:35
  Then we would let everyone just just sell at the same time.
• 20:37
  That's obviously is going to make a a big windfall.
• 20:40
  That's something else. Hey, Thomas, the army of this
• 20:46
  name is Diane and he stands before the Diane, the Asian
• 20:50
  Ballydini Maharim. She called me the fun of and
• 20:54
  there are other people waiting in line that they came like even
• 21:00
  they mocked in I don't think the supplies nowadays, but they
• 21:03
  didn't but they would usher her name and give him VIP status
• 21:09
  whatever and do his case first.