Latest / Surrounded / Andrew Yang vs 20 AI Optimists | Surrounded
Transcript
- 0:00Americans' data is being sold and resold commercially for $300
- 0:04billion plus a year and no one sees a dime.
- 0:07But I just told the AI chatbot like,
- 0:08hey man,
- 0:09get me a person or I'm gonna kill myself.
- 0:11I think it's so dramatic.
- 0:12I did not use AI to prepare for this and that wasn't deliberate.
- 0:14I've written two books on this topic.
- 0:16I just like reread my own books.
- 0:18People have different viewpoint and different sentiment and
- 0:20they're actually feeling very optimistic of the future
- 0:23because of artificial intelligence.
- 0:24One third
- 0:25of working age Americans.
- 0:27Men is no longer in the workforce.
- 0:34Hey,
- 0:35what's up guys?
- 0:36Will AI democratize opportunity
- 0:38or accelerate inequality beyond anything we've seen before?
- 0:41I'm Paris Rose from Jubilee Media,
- 0:43and this is Surrounded,
- 0:44where one brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 0:47Today we're exploring how AI is reshaping the workforce,
- 0:50whether universal basic income is necessary
- 0:52in an AI driven economy,
- 0:54and what.
- 0:54Happens to human dignity when the market values productivity and profit
- 0:57above all else.
- 0:59I'm here with our featured guest,
- 1:00entrepreneur,
- 1:01bestselling author,
- 1:02and CEO
- 1:03Andrew Yang.
- 1:04I'm so happy to see you.
- 1:05How are you feeling today?
- 1:06I'm feeling great.
- 1:07Uh,
- 1:08it's awesome to be surrounded.
- 1:10Uh,
- 1:10I'm sure we're gonna have a wonderful discussion.
- 1:13All right,
- 1:13debaters,
- 1:13are you guys ready?
- 1:18Hi,
- 1:18I'm Andrew Yang,
- 1:20serial entrepreneur,
- 1:21co-founder of the Forward Party,
- 1:22and CEO of Noble Mobile.
- 1:24And today I'm surrounded by AI optimists.
- 1:31My first surrounded claim is AI will not democratize opportunity,
- 1:36it will accelerate inequality on a scale we have never seen before.
- 1:40If you'd like to be the first debater,
- 1:42please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:49Wow,
- 1:50very nice to meet you.
- 1:52Oh,
- 1:52it's nice to meet you as well.
- 1:53Well,
- 1:53thank you.
- 1:54My name is Christina.
- 1:55Um,
- 1:56I've been in the AI safety space for about 3 years now.
- 1:58Um,
- 1:58I got my master's in public policy from Carnegie Mellon.
- 2:01Fantastic.
- 2:02Where do you live?
- 2:02I live in Westwood.
- 2:03Cool.
- 2:04I can open with this is the way I see
- 2:06the situation
- 2:07is that you have.
- 2:09Capital,
- 2:11AI,
- 2:12data,
- 2:13and processing power and all four of these elements are now converging.
- 2:17In a multi-trillion dollar vortex that's going to hoover up
- 2:22tons and tons of value
- 2:24that's going to come from a lot of
- 2:26uh
- 2:27office parks,
- 2:28corporations,
- 2:29businesses,
- 2:30big and small.
- 2:31So the value is gonna head up,
- 2:32uh,
- 2:33and they're gonna be some winners for sure.
- 2:35Those winners are gonna be
- 2:36the
- 2:37shareholders and employees of the AI firms,
- 2:40the investors,
- 2:42folks who actually have enough capital to be in.
- 2:45Positions where they benefit from these efficiencies,
- 2:48but this number of people is going to be relatively small in the scheme of things
- 2:52compared to the folks that are going to be left wondering
- 2:55what happened to their call center job,
- 2:57what happened to their Uber
- 2:58job,
- 2:59etc.
- 2:59etc.
- 2:59I think it's a lot more complicated than that.
- 3:01I think there are two things that are happening simultaneously.
- 3:04I think that AI is democratizing
- 3:06um capability and opportunity for consumers.
- 3:09So for example,
- 3:09like,
- 3:10There are so many different things that we can do with AI now.
- 3:12Like you can start your own business.
- 3:14If you haven't programmed before,
- 3:15you can build an app,
- 3:16you can build a website,
- 3:17and I use AI as a tutor,
- 3:19as a therapist,
- 3:20and there's so many things that you can do with it.
- 3:22So it is democratizing opportunity.
- 3:24But on the other hand,
- 3:26um,
- 3:27I do think it is concentrating power
- 3:29very,
- 3:29very
- 3:30heavily and on an unprecedented level.
- 3:32I think those two things can happen simultaneously.
- 3:35Interesting.
- 3:35So you actually will concede on the power side,
- 3:38um,
- 3:39but you think the economic opportunity will actually be broadly
- 3:43distributed.
- 3:44So first I want to say that AI will
- 3:46of course create myriad new jobs and opportunities,
- 3:50um,
- 3:50and certain individuals are going to benefit.
- 3:53I just think that the individuals that benefit are going to be vastly outnumbered
- 3:57by the by the people
- 3:58that are on the outside.
- 4:00Uh,
- 4:00looking in,
- 4:01and the example I would use,
- 4:03um,
- 4:03would be a lot of the,
- 4:04uh,
- 4:05technological innovations of the past.
- 4:08I mean,
- 4:08like,
- 4:08if you look at something
- 4:10like e-commerce,
- 4:11where there was a point when we were all like,
- 4:13hey,
- 4:13we're all gonna sell
- 4:14our stuff,
- 4:15whatever it is,
- 4:16and I can't sew.
- 4:18But,
- 4:18you know,
- 4:19you'd like sell something.
- 4:20And then you fast forward
- 4:22and uh Amazon's a $3 trillion company,
- 4:25like trying to compete with them is is kind
- 4:27of silly because you have like a winner take all
- 4:30um uh dynamic that happened with e-commerce,
- 4:33and I think that the same is going to be true
- 4:35with AI that if I spun off,
- 4:37let's say I were to vibe code an app
- 4:39and then put it out on the App Store,
- 4:41there's nothing stopping me from doing that,
- 4:43and AI is gonna make that easier.
- 4:45But the odds of millions of people finding my app very,
- 4:48very low,
- 4:48they're going to be a couple of outlier winners where that does happen to them.
- 4:52But,
- 4:52but you're gonna have an explosion of apps that no one really sees or appreciates.
- 4:56Right?
- 4:56So I pause,
- 4:57we're gonna pause here.
- 4:58You've been voted out by the majority.
- 5:00Please return to your
- 5:01seat.
- 5:01Such a pleasure.
- 5:02Thank you.
- 5:03If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 5:05please get to the chair in 321.
- 5:11Oh hey there Andrew
- 5:13Drago
- 5:14holy crap like a Rocky,
- 5:15yeah,
- 5:16yeah,
- 5:16no,
- 5:16Ivan Drago
- 5:17love that character
- 5:19love that movie.
- 5:20Well,
- 5:20I,
- 5:20I,
- 5:20I appreciate it,
- 5:21you know,
- 5:21before I ask you your definition of inequality,
- 5:23I wanna look at how our country was founded by the small business spirit
- 5:27where we left
- 5:28the grips of bigger structures to carve out our own way,
- 5:31go after our.
- 5:32Own land
- 5:32and in the last 100 years the corporatization of America
- 5:36has
- 5:36flattened the distributions now we have the on the low end we have the earners
- 5:40and we have the corporations those who to do that so we have inequality today
- 5:43I think with AI
- 5:45we're pushing some of that lower end
- 5:46back creating a renaissance for small businesses
- 5:49because the output gap
- 5:50and the effort required to achieve an expert level output.
- 5:53Lets the small businesses compete with some of the bigger entities.
- 5:56I'm an entrepreneur.
- 5:57I can do something with a team of 5,
- 5:59get a team of 100.
- 6:00Tell me more about yourself and your work and what kind of work you do.
- 6:02So I have a spiritual growth app that,
- 6:04you know,
- 6:04facilitates it's direct to consumer play.
- 6:06What?
- 6:07Yeah,
- 6:07using AI
- 6:08way because I think we really need spiritual growth.
- 6:10I appreciate.
- 6:11I think that's,
- 6:11I don't know if we're allowed to do this,
- 6:13but what's it called?
- 6:13Holy habits.
- 6:14Holy habits.
- 6:15Yeah,
- 6:16yeah.
- 6:16So let's go.
- 6:16Do you have a spiritual background yourself?
- 6:18I'm a Catholic,
- 6:19so that that's the tradition I have.
- 6:21Yeah,
- 6:21man.
- 6:21So
- 6:23first,
- 6:23it seems like we agree on,
- 6:25uh,
- 6:25two things that are very important.
- 6:27So number one,
- 6:28the American economy is vastly unequal today.
- 6:31You know,
- 6:31the top.
- 6:3310% of Americans,
- 6:35uh,
- 6:36uh,
- 6:37control about 67% of the wealth and 90% of the stock market
- 6:41holdings.
- 6:42So you start with a very,
- 6:44very unequal,
- 6:45um,
- 6:45you know,
- 6:45playing field right now.
- 6:47So we agree on that.
- 6:48Number 2,
- 6:49I also love the spirit of small business.
- 6:51Love it.
- 6:52I came up as
- 6:53a serial entrepreneur.
- 6:55The
- 6:55owner of a
- 6:57private company,
- 6:58and I still look back incredibly
- 6:59fondly on that time because everything made sense.
- 7:02It's like you do the right thing for your business and it actually
- 7:04grows and give people jobs.
- 7:06Yeah,
- 7:06like you have 5 people.
- 7:08I will even agree with you that there are
- 7:10going to be myriad small businesses that wind up
- 7:13succeeding in part because of AI.
- 7:17I think though that the primary beneficiaries are going to be
- 7:21the holders of the data sets and the major models um that have now
- 7:25$1 trillion valuations
- 7:27have
- 7:28benefited from
- 7:29hundreds of billions of dollars
- 7:31in data infrastructure and that even as you're building holy habits,
- 7:34you probably have to license
- 7:36data
- 7:37from one of the major providers
- 7:40and then pay them.
- 7:41So,
- 7:42and I'm not gonna make the open source argument even though it.
- 7:44Can be made.
- 7:45Let's say I accept that anthropic open AI are gonna
- 7:48find they're gonna go farther ahead,
- 7:50fair enough,
- 7:50but all the other
- 7:51Fortune 500 companies that aren't AI companies,
- 7:54they can be completely displaced by the up and coming
- 7:56middle tier as people realize that they can solve what they're doing
- 8:00at a fraction of the effort.
- 8:01Yeah,
- 8:01you know,
- 8:02I'm really enjoying this conversation,
- 8:03Jago.
- 8:03So on board with the fact that a lot of major Fortune 500 companies
- 8:07are going to,
- 8:08uh,
- 8:09get lighter weight.
- 8:10They're going to eliminate a lot of workers.
- 8:11It's gonna be very sad for a lot of people and that
- 8:14various upstart insurgents are going to be able to compete with them.
- 8:17I
- 8:17do believe though
- 8:19that the major beneficiaries of the AI revolution
- 8:23are going to be the folks that already have
- 8:25massive brands,
- 8:27rents,
- 8:28capital structures,
- 8:29and the rest of it.
- 8:29So if you were to take,
- 8:31uh,
- 8:31you know,
- 8:31as,
- 8:31as an example,
- 8:32Verizon.
- 8:34So Verizon has the spectrum,
- 8:36like,
- 8:36I don't,
- 8:36don't even say,
- 8:38don't.
- 8:41No,
- 8:41no,
- 8:41no,
- 8:42it's like an anti-plug,
- 8:43at least it's trying to be
- 8:44because they're,
- 8:44they're paying 11 billion a year in dividends,
- 8:48and
- 8:49they
- 8:49just laid off
- 8:5115,000 workers,
- 8:53uh,
- 8:53relatively recently and announced
- 8:55that
- 8:56according to them,
- 8:57AI can do customer service better than a human,
- 9:00which I think I think we all know what that's going to mean for Verizon
- 9:03employees.
- 9:04So my argument is that Verizon is going to
- 9:06be in a position to benefit from these AI efficiencies
- 9:09to a higher degree
- 9:11than like even like a successful upstart.
- 9:14Well,
- 9:14certain provinces pause here.
- 9:16You've been voted out by the majority.
- 9:17Thank you so much.
- 9:18Drago,
- 9:18it's a real pleasure.
- 9:19That's really smart.
- 9:20Holy habits.
- 9:21Holy habits,
- 9:23we could all use them.
- 9:24Yeah,
- 9:25amen.
- 9:27321.
- 9:31Hey there.
- 9:31Hi,
- 9:32I'm Essie Magic.
- 9:33Hey,
- 9:33Essie,
- 9:34is your last name Magic?
- 9:35No,
- 9:35it's my nickname.
- 9:36Oh,
- 9:36it's still cool as heck.
- 9:38So I'm a small business owner.
- 9:40Oh,
- 9:40what kind of small business?
- 9:41Yeah,
- 9:41I have a jewelry brand that's an all empowering jewelry for women.
- 9:44What's it called?
- 9:45It's called Zam Jewelry,
- 9:47Z A M
- 9:48Z AM jewelry.
- 9:49So I'm gonna build on what the gentleman before said
- 9:51because there is actually data that shows that since,
- 9:55uh,
- 9:55Chat GBT was launched in 2022.
- 9:58We've seen an influx of business registrations,
- 10:01um,
- 10:01along with websites like uh Product Hunt as well.
- 10:04We've seen a lot more registrations,
- 10:06uh,
- 10:07or sorry,
- 10:07product launches on that site,
- 10:09uh,
- 10:09especially for solo entrepreneurs.
- 10:11So
- 10:11we are actually seeing data that shows that entrepreneurship is growing.
- 10:16It shows that more people have access from AI as opposed to
- 10:21not having
- 10:22access
- 10:23and whether it be things like education as Well,
- 10:25we have a lot more access to things we would have to pay for.
- 10:28If you
- 10:29wanted to get legal advice,
- 10:30you would have to
- 10:31spend thousands of dollars on a lawyer or,
- 10:34you know,
- 10:35accounting advice,
- 10:35tax advice.
- 10:37You can now go on
- 10:38Cloud or chat GBT and get help.
- 10:41So
- 10:41it's creating more access for people because
- 10:44of the financial cost that it's eliminated.
- 10:46Like,
- 10:47first,
- 10:47love it,
- 10:48love what
- 10:49you do
- 10:50and the fact that,
- 10:51I mean,
- 10:52I'm a small.
- 10:52Business owner
- 10:53myself,
- 10:54um,
- 10:54and agree with you that as
- 10:56the head of a small business you can save money
- 10:59on accounting,
- 11:01legal,
- 11:02marketing,
- 11:03um,
- 11:03human resources like a lot of that stuff's now subscription.
- 11:06The first thing I want to point out is that all of those things used to be
- 11:10something you would either hire a person for or a firm for and so
- 11:13you're not having to do that,
- 11:15which is good for you,
- 11:16but it's also a negative for
- 11:19the.
- 11:20You know,
- 11:20accounting firm you were,
- 11:21you would have hired in a past era or
- 11:24like the small bit,
- 11:24you know what I mean?
- 11:25So it's like zero sum.
- 11:26What,
- 11:26what's happening is you've extracted value and it's helping you,
- 11:29but it's gonna,
- 11:30you know,
- 11:30be less money for like the um lawyer you would have paid otherwise.
- 11:34The second thing
- 11:35is that
- 11:36as you try and grow,
- 11:39you're gonna be able to do it with fewer people.
- 11:41And I can say this from experience where my company
- 11:44uh took down a job posting for
- 11:47a junior engineer and a junior data analyst because
- 11:49I made them less necessary and less relevant.
- 11:52So it's going to be good for me
- 11:54in terms of growing the business,
- 11:57but it's going to be bad for the people that I
- 11:58otherwise would have had to hire who like otherwise would have had
- 12:03the ability to benefit from the opportunities that I'm creating.
- 12:06So what I,
- 12:06so what I'm suggesting,
- 12:08both of these things can be true where
- 12:10you can help a small business become competitive,
- 12:12but that's not necessarily going to mean like broader
- 12:16opportunity for
- 12:17like different groups of people.
- 12:18I'm gonna.
- 12:19Disagree on your first point because
- 12:22it was mainly the people who had high income
- 12:24that could afford those services in the first place.
- 12:26Lower income people could not afford
- 12:28to pay for a lawyer for tax help
- 12:30to get a certificate from.
- 12:32They couldn't afford it.
- 12:33So it's bridging the gap of the average Joe,
- 12:36the average Joe
- 12:37that now they're that wealth gap that we see
- 12:39is closing because they have access to these things
- 12:42that they can use to grow their career,
- 12:43not just entrepreneurship too,
- 12:45because even if you have a job.
- 12:47You shouldn't be having just one stream of
- 12:49income if you're depending on just one company
- 12:52for your income,
- 12:53you know,
- 12:53they can lay you off like that.
- 12:55So that's not smart for multiple streams of income.
- 12:58It can even help you
- 12:59start side businesses,
- 13:00side hustles,
- 13:01invest as well.
- 13:03So I,
- 13:03I disagree on your first point there.
- 13:06All right,
- 13:06I,
- 13:06I just want to say on the data side,
- 13:08which you,
- 13:09you cited coming in,
- 13:10I too have seen that there's a surge
- 13:12of
- 13:13uh business in corporation.
- 13:15Um,
- 13:15happening right now and that I agree that AI may be a part of that.
- 13:19And so sometimes people ask me,
- 13:20it's like,
- 13:20hey,
- 13:21Andrew,
- 13:21like you love entrepreneurship,
- 13:22I do.
- 13:23So why could you be sad if this is happening?
- 13:25And I,
- 13:26I think there are two things.
- 13:27Number one,
- 13:28there are a lot of people who are losing their jobs at tech firms,
- 13:32uh,
- 13:32and other places,
- 13:33and you know,
- 13:34that one of the first things they do is they,
- 13:36they set up like,
- 13:37essentially,
- 13:38like,
- 13:38you know,
- 13:39um,
- 13:39Jane,
- 13:40uh,
- 13:40Jane Smith or John Doe Consulting.
- 13:42And so it shows up as like,
- 13:43uh,
- 13:43hey,
- 13:43a business got started.
- 13:45To me,
- 13:45the key data point
- 13:46is what happens with that business after it gets formed and doesn't have to hire
- 13:51a full-time employee that's not the founder.
- 13:53And right now that second step is not being taken by
- 13:56the vast majority of the small businesses that are being started.
- 13:59So you're gonna have a lot of businesses that,
- 14:00to your point,
- 14:01might be able to generate a little bit of income
- 14:04for the founder.
- 14:05They might not be a full-time job even for the founder,
- 14:08and they're not necessarily going to get to a point where they have to hire someone.
- 14:10I think the statistics are gonna be like very,
- 14:12very,
- 14:13um,
- 14:13rosy in terms of business.
- 14:14Business formation,
- 14:15but like not so great in terms of the way the value gets distributed.
- 14:18That sounds like you're doubting people
- 14:20voted up in the majority.
- 14:22Thank you so much.
- 14:22I'm more of an optimist.
- 14:24And,
- 14:24and by the way,
- 14:25I also want to say if you can take a seat
- 14:27for a second,
- 14:28small business owners have to be optimists by nature.
- 14:31Like it's the only way we can do anything.
- 14:34I'm an optimist.
- 14:34I don't know if you guys can sense it.
- 14:36To me,
- 14:36like the landscape and the numbers and then there's like our attitude,
- 14:40and we have to wake up every day thinking we can make it happen.
- 14:44Uh,
- 14:44you know,
- 14:44like grow the business,
- 14:45shake up the world,
- 14:46and I think you can do that while also
- 14:49having a sense of,
- 14:50uh,
- 14:50like the backdrop in the numbers.
- 14:53Thank you.
- 14:54Thank you,
- 14:54Essie.
- 14:54I really appreciate it.
- 14:55All right,
- 14:56if you'd like to be the next debater,
- 14:57please get to the chair in 321.
- 15:03Oh hey there.
- 15:04Hi,
- 15:04I'm Val.
- 15:04Nice to meet you,
- 15:05Val.
- 15:06Andrew,
- 15:06how are you?
- 15:07I'm good.
- 15:08I'd like to go back to the original statement,
- 15:10and I do think that AI will completely democratize intellectual
- 15:15um ideas,
- 15:16so.
- 15:16Previously,
- 15:17um,
- 15:18legal
- 15:19advice like health advice,
- 15:20as well as like
- 15:21having a tutor in your pocket wasn't previously possible.
- 15:25And now I think it's really easy for anyone who has access to like
- 15:29even the basic AI models and an internet connection
- 15:33to be able to
- 15:34use that new
- 15:36intellect and it's like going to help elevate everyone
- 15:38as a whole.
- 15:39Um,
- 15:39first,
- 15:39can you tell me a little bit about yourself,
- 15:40Al?
- 15:41I'm a beauty and makeup and fashion content creator.
- 15:44Wow,
- 15:45so cool.
- 15:46I'm with you that we all can get expert advice now via AI
- 15:49and
- 15:50Makes a lot of us an expert
- 15:51at various things.
- 15:52And I also think that's going to be helpful to certain entrepreneurs like yourself.
- 15:57Two things I want to express.
- 15:58Number one is that I'm old enough where I remember the time before Waze,
- 16:02and I had something called a sense of direction.
- 16:04I don't know if you guys
- 16:06know what this is.
- 16:07So you used to bust out a map and then be like,
- 16:09OK,
- 16:09like you,
- 16:09you go down this road and then this.
- 16:11Obviously none of that exists anymore because of Waze.
- 16:14What we've done is we've outsourced.
- 16:15That part of our thinking,
- 16:17um,
- 16:17to the apps.
- 16:19There's some early evidence that right now we're starting to outsource part of,
- 16:23uh,
- 16:23our
- 16:24structured thinking to AI.
- 16:26Like young people are having a harder time writing a first draft
- 16:29as an example.
- 16:29And I went to Brown University,
- 16:31uh,
- 16:32and apparently a majority of economic students recently
- 16:36their scores
- 16:37go from a 96% with AI to 48% without.
- 16:41I feel like that can be also like used,
- 16:43like,
- 16:44like the calculator,
- 16:45like back in the day,
- 16:46people were like,
- 16:46oh,
- 16:46with the calculator,
- 16:47we're not going to do math anymore.
- 16:48But
- 16:49clearly,
- 16:49like the calculator,
- 16:51the internet has actually
- 16:52helped us as a society as a whole,
- 16:54like it will help progress.
- 16:56So the thing I want to say here is that
- 16:59I think AI is going to lower barriers,
- 17:01and I think there are going to be some people that win as a result of that.
- 17:04Um
- 17:05simultaneously.
- 17:06So,
- 17:07uh,
- 17:07I think that there are going to be some side
- 17:09effects to the outsourcing of our cognitive processing that we're,
- 17:13we're,
- 17:13that's going to impact young people a bit worse than,
- 17:16than some others,
- 17:17uh,
- 17:17that there's,
- 17:18um,
- 17:19going to be
- 17:20like some highly visible winners that we can all point to,
- 17:22like probably you because you seem awesome and talented.
- 17:25Um,
- 17:25but then for every vow,
- 17:27um,
- 17:28there are going to be a host of people
- 17:30that
- 17:31aren't able to,
- 17:31to.
- 17:32Breakthrough just like statistically.
- 17:34Do you have an example of someone
- 17:36like a case who wouldn't be able to break through?
- 17:39Oh,
- 17:39so one thing,
- 17:40and it's just recent,
- 17:41is that I was reading a sub stack piece because I like sub stack and I'm there,
- 17:46and a sub stack author was complaining that
- 17:48they've essentially reached like zero sum in terms of paid subscribers,
- 17:52like people,
- 17:53and so then it's like if I subscribe to you,
- 17:55I'm just going to stop subscribing to that person.
- 17:57So there's something about that to our attention
- 18:00around different fields where you can't have like a limitless number of
- 18:03influencers because we only have a certain number of hours in the day
- 18:08and,
- 18:08and some of that attention is going to get occupied by AI influencers increasingly.
- 18:14So if I look at someone like you and like they're going to be some
- 18:17Human influencers and brands that breakthrough because there always are.
- 18:21Generally speaking,
- 18:22there's going to be more and more of like a winner take all dynamic
- 18:25in the human space,
- 18:26and AI is going to end up diminishing the human space.
- 18:29I actually disagree because nowadays,
- 18:31like,
- 18:32everything is super niche,
- 18:33like now you can like go on book talk or
- 18:35go on makeup talk and everything is like very hyper individualized.
- 18:38There's even niches for like K Beauty and stuff,
- 18:40which
- 18:41I,
- 18:41I'm interested in.
- 18:42But back in the day,
- 18:43there were only like 3 celebrities that you would know,
- 18:45like just the most famous actors.
- 18:47So I actually do think it will help
- 18:49really
- 18:50make everything more niche and like
- 18:52actually democrat
- 18:54uh democratize everything.
- 18:55OK,
- 18:55pause here.
- 18:56You've been voted out by the majority.
- 18:57Val,
- 18:58it's such a pleasure.
- 18:59If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 19:00please get to the chair in 321.
- 19:07Hey there.
- 19:08Hey,
- 19:08nice to meet you.
- 19:09What's your name?
- 19:10Nikil.
- 19:10Nikil,
- 19:11uh,
- 19:11what do you do?
- 19:12I'm a software engineer.
- 19:13Where at
- 19:13Facebook.
- 19:14So I think going back to the original point,
- 19:16I think AI will
- 19:17democratize everyone,
- 19:18and it already has,
- 19:20and we've seen it.
- 19:20If everyone
- 19:22uses like anthropic models,
- 19:23everyone doesn't have to use that.
- 19:24Anthropic models or open AI models.
- 19:26There's a lot of
- 19:27open source models.
- 19:28There's a lot of stuff you can self-host and you control your own data.
- 19:32You control what you do with them.
- 19:33We all have phones in our hands.
- 19:35They all can run local models on them.
- 19:37Sure,
- 19:38they might not be the most frontier,
- 19:39but they work.
- 19:40Everyone has access to them
- 19:42and everyone can use them.
- 19:44Personally,
- 19:44myself at my home,
- 19:45I have
- 19:46a few GPUs that I use to run
- 19:48a few local models for voice assistant for coding.
- 19:52All kinds of tasks,
- 19:53etc.
- 19:54Yes,
- 19:54there are open source
- 19:55source of information that you don't have to pay the,
- 19:58the,
- 19:58the,
- 19:58the big guys.
- 19:59Yes,
- 20:00you can,
- 20:00um,
- 20:01create your own bot to solve some household task for you.
- 20:04So I'm,
- 20:04I'm totally
- 20:05with you on,
- 20:06on those fronts.
- 20:07And I'm curious about what you're seeing in your field because from what I've seen,
- 20:10the wages for entry level coders have gone off a cliff
- 20:13and the placement rates for computer science graduates have also gone off a cliff.
- 20:17Where if you look back at like,
- 20:19uh,
- 20:19You know,
- 20:20learned to code like 8 years ago.
- 20:22It was like fail-safe
- 20:23or foolproof
- 20:25career advice,
- 20:26and now those people are scrambling
- 20:28where their
- 20:29job placement rate has inverted,
- 20:31where if it used to be 88%,
- 20:33now it's 12%.
- 20:34So those folks,
- 20:35like that hard skill now is not commercially valued
- 20:39the way that it was.
- 20:39Is that accurate?
- 20:40I,
- 20:41sure,
- 20:41that's what the media says and that's what the public opinion wants.
- 20:43To think,
- 20:44but I don't think that's accurate at all.
- 20:46No.
- 20:46Well,
- 20:46I mean,
- 20:47the stuff I just said is fairly like objective and documented,
- 20:50um,
- 20:51you know,
- 20:51a Stanford study,
- 20:52various like BLS statistics,
- 20:54or actually I talked to a
- 20:56career placement officer at a university and
- 20:58that's what they told me was happening.
- 20:59So I don't think they are
- 21:01fronting.
- 21:01This is actually to me one of like the big
- 21:04themes around AI is that
- 21:06for a lot of the stuff I'm saying.
- 21:08I totally wish I was wrong.
- 21:10I do not believe I am wrong.
- 21:11Like one of the things I do is I try and hunt,
- 21:14uh,
- 21:14facts and figures.
- 21:15And if there's a fact that is like,
- 21:18you know,
- 21:18contrary to my
- 21:19point of view,
- 21:20I'm actually kind of glad.
- 21:24Because
- 21:25I think it's gonna get gnarly and nasty and be terrible for a lot of people.
- 21:28Now,
- 21:29a talented engineer like you can 100% use open source models to
- 21:32like solve some of your problems and save yourself some time.
- 21:35The thing I will say that is categorically wrong and meta is like,
- 21:38not to put anything on this,
- 21:40but meta is a culprit in this,
- 21:41is that we are not being paid for our data at all.
- 21:44Americans' data is being sold and resold commercially
- 21:47for $300 billion plus a year and.
- 21:49One sees a dime.
- 21:51I agree.
- 21:51And you know,
- 21:51one of the main beneficiaries of that
- 21:54is meta,
- 21:55because Meta is one of the main sellers of the data,
- 21:57the compilers of the data,
- 21:59they have more access to more of this data than just about anyone else.
- 22:01And one of the things I said,
- 22:03data is the new oil,
- 22:04and Meta is now one of the primary oil geysers.
- 22:07I believe that
- 22:08your employer is actually one of the main beneficiaries of this dynamic,
- 22:12but if you were to just grab an American on the street
- 22:14in Seattle or in LA and be like,
- 22:16hey,
- 22:17have you been paid for your data?
- 22:18they will say no.
- 22:19I can definitely see where you're coming from,
- 22:21and I agree this is a concerning point,
- 22:23but I would like to know what your solution to this whole data people for their data,
- 22:27pay people for their data,
- 22:28pay people for their data.
- 22:29I think that while
- 22:30that's a
- 22:31cool problem here,
- 22:32I'll suggest another solution.
- 22:33I think that all these big AI companies,
- 22:36frontier models,
- 22:37they're all trying to create restrictions on
- 22:40people that are trying to train new models,
- 22:41right?
- 22:42They're trying to like open source models or
- 22:44trying to train models they're trying to create roadblocks,
- 22:46restrictions and all that
- 22:48so instead of
- 22:49focusing on like something like
- 22:51reduction the use of AI or
- 22:53slowing down the technology,
- 22:54why don't we focus on opening the technology and let more players come in.
- 22:58Therefore we can have more open source models.
- 23:00I truly think open source
- 23:01is the best solution that we have to democratize this.
- 23:04We've seen this in Linux.
- 23:05We've seen this with PostGress.
- 23:06We've seen this with databases and everything.
- 23:08I mean,
- 23:08if you and I are arguing about whether some of these
- 23:11models that are proprietary right now should be open source,
- 23:13very different conversation.
- 23:15I'm not saying the same thing.
- 23:16I'm not saying the same thing.
- 23:17What I'm saying is
- 23:19these models should be
- 23:21easier to train,
- 23:22and they should not have,
- 23:24uh,
- 23:24the restrictions that anthropic and open AI,
- 23:26these companies,
- 23:27frontier companies,
- 23:28we're gonna lobby
- 23:29here.
- 23:29You're out of time for this claim.
- 23:30Thank you.
- 23:31Thank you.
- 23:31Nice to meet you.
- 23:32Nice to meet you too.
- 23:33Appreciate it.
- 23:34My next surrounded claim is AI is going to eliminate
- 23:37millions of jobs faster than new ones can be created.
- 23:40If you would like to be the next debater,
- 23:42please get to that chair in 321.
- 23:49Oh hey there,
- 23:49my name's Theo.
- 23:51Hey Theo,
- 23:51how are you?
- 23:52Tell me about yourself.
- 23:52Yeah,
- 23:53I'm a co-founder and host of a media startup based out
- 23:55of San Francisco called MTS stands for Monitoring the Situation,
- 23:59and we help people understand what's going on
- 24:01with artificial general intelligence in the future.
- 24:03Oh wow,
- 24:03great.
- 24:04So first,
- 24:05uh,
- 24:06about 36% of Americans graduate from college.
- 24:09Uh,
- 24:1064% do not.
- 24:11If you look at the American workforce,
- 24:13the most common job categories
- 24:16are.
- 24:17Clerical and administrative,
- 24:18uh,
- 24:18retail,
- 24:19food service and food prep,
- 24:21truck driving and transportation,
- 24:22which includes Uber drivers and manufacturing.
- 24:25Each of those job categories is going to contract
- 24:28in part because of AI and automation.
- 24:29This is just my opinion.
- 24:30I'm just,
- 24:31uh,
- 24:31throwing this out,
- 24:32but a couple of numbers to,
- 24:34uh,
- 24:34scaffold the convo.
- 24:36There are 2.9 million Americans who work in customer service call centers,
- 24:39uh,
- 24:39right now,
- 24:40and I'm an investor in.
- 24:42Uh,
- 24:43an AI call center,
- 24:45um,
- 24:46uh,
- 24:46solution
- 24:47that is,
- 24:48in my view,
- 24:49going to
- 24:50reduce that number sharply.
- 24:51Not,
- 24:52not the company I'm invested in,
- 24:53but like the category generally.
- 24:55Customers now
- 24:56are finding.
- 24:57Um,
- 24:58AI bots actually to be fine in terms of the experience.
- 25:01I don't know if people who are calling in now.
- 25:03It used to be like,
- 25:04like operator,
- 25:05operator,
- 25:05person,
- 25:06person,
- 25:06person,
- 25:06but like now the bot can address
- 25:09um 60% of your issues or so and then you don't have to deal with a,
- 25:12a,
- 25:12a person.
- 25:13Uh,
- 25:132 million Americans drive an Uber for other part-time or full-time,
- 25:17uh,
- 25:17jobs,
- 25:18and some of you here in LA have taken away.
- 25:202.5 million Americans work in the insurance industry,
- 25:23and the insurance industry is largely about passing information back and forth
- 25:28around systems.
- 25:29You can imagine AI doing a number on that.
- 25:3170 million Americans work at,
- 25:33uh,
- 25:33white collar jobs.
- 25:35Um,
- 25:35and so I think AI is going to,
- 25:36to crush this number.
- 25:38Well,
- 25:38just looking at the past 200 years or so of automation,
- 25:40you know,
- 25:41this claim has been made over and over again.
- 25:43And it doesn't stand because automating jobs is really hard.
- 25:46You know,
- 25:47jobs are bundles of tasks,
- 25:48right?
- 25:49And in order to automate a job,
- 25:50you have to do every single task the human does
- 25:53on some parade of uh curve of better and cheaper than the human.
- 25:57Like every single one.
- 25:57If there's one task and a job remaining for humans to do,
- 26:00humans are still employable.
- 26:01All right,
- 26:02so,
- 26:02um,
- 26:03historical referent number 1 is going to
- 26:06be what happened to the manufacturing workers
- 26:09in the Midwest and the South,
- 26:10uh,
- 26:10when robot arms came into the factory.
- 26:12So the number of,
- 26:14uh,
- 26:15workers went down by about 4 million
- 26:17and blew to smithereens,
- 26:18the regional economies of those towns in Ohio,
- 26:21Michigan,
- 26:22Pennsylvania,
- 26:23Wisconsin.
- 26:24Uh,
- 26:24North Carolina and,
- 26:25uh,
- 26:25uh,
- 26:25other places,
- 26:26the
- 26:27fallacy with what you just said
- 26:29is that
- 26:30often in corporations there are 100 people in a department doing a job,
- 26:35and if you can reduce
- 26:3760% of the tasks,
- 26:39they don't,
- 26:40what happens is you fire 60 of the 100 and then the remaining 40,
- 26:43you say,
- 26:44hey guys,
- 26:44like your job's just changed
- 26:46where you're now doing the thing
- 26:48that,
- 26:48uh,
- 26:48you know.
- 26:49Only humans can do,
- 26:50but then you just systematically reduce that number.
- 26:52And that's what's happening in organizations big and small around the country.
- 26:56Um,
- 26:57well,
- 26:57going back to the manufacturing point,
- 26:59like,
- 26:59it is true that automation can locally displace a lot of workers,
- 27:03but the other thing that you see is like huge job growth in other industries.
- 27:07Like for example,
- 27:08automating
- 27:09subsistence farming,
- 27:09which almost every human
- 27:11for all of history until the industrial revolution used to do.
- 27:14Has created a tremendous amount of new industries like
- 27:16this whole thing of like Jubilee videos would just not exist if we didn't have like
- 27:19a
- 27:20huge amount of the tasks that we previously did
- 27:22automated.
- 27:23There's huge job growth in other industries.
- 27:24People move to cities,
- 27:25for example.
- 27:25So concession that
- 27:27only 1% of Americans now working in agriculture and
- 27:30that number used to be 40 times higher,
- 27:32and we can still grow food.
- 27:33So that's a fact.
- 27:35The thing that I,
- 27:35I'm going to suggest is that AI is different than anything that has gone before.
- 27:39We've never had thinking machines that can.
- 27:42Solve cognitive problems as quickly
- 27:45as
- 27:46it can and faster than any human.
- 27:48Um,
- 27:49can do PhD level work,
- 27:50uh,
- 27:51can do billable lawyer work
- 27:52in
- 27:53seconds or minutes,
- 27:54and this is going to affect
- 27:55more industries
- 27:57more quickly
- 27:58than anything we've ever seen before,
- 28:00and people are not
- 28:01infinitely adjustable as we've seen when there's been a past
- 28:05transition.
- 28:05Even if you were to rewind to the industrial revolution,
- 28:07which people often cite in this conversation,
- 28:09which I'm gonna suggest is a bad fact pattern because it's,
- 28:12you know,
- 28:12200 years ago and,
- 28:13and,
- 28:14uh,
- 28:14a different situation,
- 28:15even in that situation.
- 28:18There were mass riots that killed dozens of people and
- 28:20caused the equivalent of $2 billion worth of damage,
- 28:23which is why we had something called Labor Day
- 28:25that got inaugurated in 1894 in response to the violence.
- 28:28And today's economy is much more complex
- 28:31with many more people and larger,
- 28:33and you have many more educated people who are not going to take getting
- 28:37kicked to the curb and pushed down a class
- 28:39gently,
- 28:40nor will the truckers,
- 28:41nor will a lot of other people.
- 28:42Even if you were to actually inspect history,
- 28:44you would expect very bad things to happen.
- 28:47Um,
- 28:47during this era of displacement.
- 28:49This happens every.
- 28:50You've been voted out by the majority.
- 28:52Thank you so much.
- 28:52Thank you so much.
- 28:53Of course,
- 28:53great seeing you.
- 28:54Oh,
- 28:55thank you,
- 28:55brother.
- 28:55Appreciate it.
- 28:57321.
- 29:01Thank you.
- 29:01Hello,
- 29:02I'm Sophia Du.
- 29:02It's such a pleasure to meet you.
- 29:04Sophia.
- 29:05I'm so excited to.
- 29:06I'm a media tech host on also a show MTS similar to Theo.
- 29:11So we are co-hosts together
- 29:12and help people
- 29:13understand AI.
- 29:14I was like MTS this seems so like,
- 29:16I think,
- 29:16uh,
- 29:17you know,
- 29:17I just heard this a minute ago.
- 29:18Congratulations.
- 29:19You guys have like a good team.
- 29:21Thank you.
- 29:21No,
- 29:21it's a really fun team and I'm really excited.
- 29:23To talk to you
- 29:24about AI because I am an optimist because
- 29:27of all of your fears that you say I definitely agree with a lot of them.
- 29:30There are certain things that we should do
- 29:32to mitigate all the harms that AI will cause
- 29:34and at the same time
- 29:35being an optimist
- 29:37and understanding what are the positive benefits that come
- 29:39out of AI is how we transform through this
- 29:42difficult period of time.
- 29:44And so
- 29:44what I wanna do is encourage more people to.
- 29:46Understand the benefits that happen and for specifically with the job loss claim,
- 29:50most people think,
- 29:51OK,
- 29:52one day it's just robots are gonna come in and all the jobs are going to leave,
- 29:55but really what actually ends up happening is it's a slow transition where
- 29:59AI gets introduced and then the jobs transform and re-augment and specifically
- 30:03they re-augment in ways where the human has to do more human
- 30:07type of work like radiology.
- 30:09AA got introduced and everyone thought that would ban
- 30:11and get rid of all the radiologists and there's still radiology.
- 30:14There's more demand for radiology,
- 30:15but the job of a radiologist now
- 30:17is way more human.
- 30:18They care way more about patient care
- 30:20and things that they could uniquely do
- 30:22and all that brunt work and that task that they didn't want,
- 30:25didn't want to do
- 30:25is now getting automated away to AI.
- 30:28But I don't think this is necessarily
- 30:29super negative,
- 30:30and I agree that we should reduce the harms as much.
- 30:33As we possibly can with policy with decisions.
- 30:35I study a lot of what that,
- 30:36what you do and what you believe in,
- 30:38and I align with so much of it and I love your policy work
- 30:41and I want to see your policy work
- 30:43be a highlight of this next decade that we get into.
- 30:46Oh,
- 30:46thank you.
- 30:47That's just so kind.
- 30:48I,
- 30:48I really appreciate it.
- 30:49All right,
- 30:50so what you're describing with a radiologist is called uh Gvon's paradox,
- 30:54um,
- 30:54which is if I technologically,
- 30:57um,
- 30:57make something inexpensive
- 30:59or even
- 31:00replace it,
- 31:00like people want more of it.
- 31:02Um,
- 31:02and
- 31:03that is true
- 31:04in certain situations.
- 31:06It is one thing I want to return to,
- 31:08um,
- 31:08you talked about,
- 31:09look,
- 31:10job replacement as a transitional period actually
- 31:12will take a little bit of time,
- 31:14and,
- 31:15um,
- 31:15that,
- 31:16that's something I think
- 31:17is changing even as we're having this conversation.
- 31:20So if you look at AI models
- 31:2212 months ago or 24 months ago,
- 31:24they're
- 31:25completely different today.
- 31:26And if you fast forward another 12 or 24 months,
- 31:29they'll be different again.
- 31:31I have a joke where I'm now 50 years old,
- 31:33which means if I don't get dumber in a given month,
- 31:35it was a good month.
- 31:36Meanwhile,
- 31:37the models will get twice as smart that month.
- 31:39And so saying that I'm somehow going to keep up with them,
- 31:42if I just,
- 31:43uh,
- 31:43you know,
- 31:44uh,
- 31:44do this program or
- 31:46um get this certificate,
- 31:48like it is not going to work for
- 31:50like a whole legion of people.
- 31:52And I think this transition is going to be much,
- 31:54much faster,
- 31:54unfortunately,
- 31:55than a lot of people wish.
- 31:56And as one
- 31:57piece of evidence,
- 31:58a
- 31:59A company called Block
- 32:00um set a new record for percentage of workers they'd laid off um in S&P 500 history
- 32:06a number of months ago where they fired about 40% of their,
- 32:09their staff.
- 32:10It was
- 32:114000 out of 10,000,
- 32:13and they just said,
- 32:13look,
- 32:14AI intelligence tools are gonna make it so that this is
- 32:17something that we're gonna have to do.
- 32:19Um,
- 32:20and,
- 32:20uh,
- 32:21that's happening now in real time.
- 32:23Oracle laid off 30,000 workers and said we're doing it to invest in AI.
- 32:28Um,
- 32:28Meta,
- 32:28which,
- 32:29uh,
- 32:29you know,
- 32:29Nikil worked for,
- 32:30said 8000,
- 32:31also cited AI,
- 32:32and I think this stuff is speeding up
- 32:34and going faster.
- 32:36So this is not like a multi-year transition.
- 32:38This is like a,
- 32:39hey,
- 32:39sorry,
- 32:40uh,
- 32:41like we don't need you anymore type of situation.
- 32:43So you brought up Gvon's paradox,
- 32:44and that's a great one because that's a big thing
- 32:46that economics say and specifically with Gvon's paradox as AI.
- 32:49Productivity increases productivity there also increases more demand and you
- 32:53brought up the speed and I'm glad you brought up
- 32:54the speed because this is a different technology and different
- 32:58from other types of technology that got introduced in the past
- 33:00but you're also seeing a rise in demand for new types of things and one
- 33:04of the biggest areas where we're seeing rise
- 33:05in demand are things that are uniquely human
- 33:07and that AI cannot replace things like taste.
- 33:10Like judgment,
- 33:11uh,
- 33:12things that
- 33:13the AI can't do in intelligence,
- 33:14there is more demand for it,
- 33:15creating more scarcity
- 33:17for it,
- 33:17and then creating new types of markets that are going
- 33:19to want to incentivize that type of stuff as well,
- 33:22creating new jobs in those fields.
- 33:23All right,
- 33:24like,
- 33:24I'm with you on new jobs.
- 33:26I'm with you on,
- 33:28uh,
- 33:28even taste and judgment-ish.
- 33:30Something like graphic design used to be considered a creative task,
- 33:33and now that's getting pounded out by AI.
- 33:35Um,
- 33:36video making,
- 33:37um,
- 33:37no offense,
- 33:37Jubilee,
- 33:38used to be considered a highly creative human task,
- 33:41and that's,
- 33:41uh,
- 33:41getting mulched by,
- 33:42by AI,
- 33:43um,
- 33:44and so a lot of high level cognitive and creative work,
- 33:48musician,
- 33:49um,
- 33:49you know,
- 33:49it can get taken up by AI.
- 33:52So you have
- 33:53like increasing need for
- 33:55human relationships and judgment,
- 33:56but it's only being enjoyed
- 33:58by folks who can
- 33:59afford to pay a premium.
- 34:01So what's happening is that you have,
- 34:03you have something called a K-shaped.
- 34:04Economy
- 34:05where the top 20%
- 34:07are capital holders and benefiting from a lot of
- 34:09the trends we're describing and so if I'm rich
- 34:12and I want someone to tell me what painting I should hang in in my living room,
- 34:16I will pay a human to do it,
- 34:18um,
- 34:18and so you could be like,
- 34:19oh,
- 34:19there's a new job,
- 34:20it's like,
- 34:21you know,
- 34:21home art decorator that didn't exist,
- 34:24um,
- 34:24and that is.
- 34:25True statement.
- 34:27But,
- 34:28but
- 34:28that's only because,
- 34:30like the ultra winners are going to,
- 34:33like,
- 34:33you know,
- 34:34want
- 34:34people's taste
- 34:35and we should do all we can to prevent a case
- 34:37you've been voted out by the majority.
- 34:39Thank you.
- 34:39Thank you very much.
- 34:40Such a pleasure.
- 34:41I'd love to.
- 34:42Oh,
- 34:42thank you.
- 34:42I enjoy that.
- 34:43Thank you.
- 34:43321.
- 34:49My gosh,
- 34:50I'm Skip Rizzo.
- 34:51Good to meet you.
- 34:51Hey Skip,
- 34:52you look so familiar to me.
- 34:53Yeah,
- 34:54I've been on TV or movies.
- 34:55I'm a professor at USC at the Institute for Creative Technologies,
- 34:59and I've been studying this area for 30 years.
- 35:02I'm also,
- 35:02I also have a startup sidekick platform
- 35:05which
- 35:06in the last week
- 35:08has
- 35:09Gotten the VA
- 35:11to distribute
- 35:12and endorse an AI
- 35:14conversational AI agent for veterans.
- 35:17I love it.
- 35:18And,
- 35:18and you know why,
- 35:18Skip,
- 35:19I love it
- 35:19is because studies have shown that military veterans,
- 35:22um,
- 35:22sometimes prefer
- 35:24the AI
- 35:25conversationalist
- 35:26because then they feel like they can actually share and vent and
- 35:29then if you put them in front of a human therapist,
- 35:30they'll just clam up.
- 35:31This is what our work has been doing over the years,
- 35:33so saving lives.
- 35:35Love it.
- 35:35Sidekick plus,
- 35:36yeah,
- 35:37yeah.
- 35:38But you know,
- 35:39going back to the industrial,
- 35:40isn't that gonna eliminate human therapists?
- 35:43We can do that.
- 35:45Wait,
- 35:45you're agreeing with it?
- 35:46I thought you were on the other side of this.
- 35:47No,
- 35:48I agree with a lot of what you're saying.
- 35:49In fact,
- 35:49I'm not sure you're
- 35:51necessarily the realist.
- 35:52I think you're,
- 35:53I think we're all realists when it comes to AI,
- 35:56you know.
- 35:57Maybe you're a little bit more cautious because
- 35:59you understand the financial elements and that becomes
- 36:02a political
- 36:04uh
- 36:04discussion
- 36:06going back,
- 36:06you know,
- 36:07the whole thing with industrial revolution,
- 36:08you know,
- 36:09all transformations lead to certain types of job loss,
- 36:13you know,
- 36:131900 you could say lamplighters or ice carriers.
- 36:19Telegraph operators,
- 36:21they're gone
- 36:22computer revolution,
- 36:23uh,
- 36:24typesetters,
- 36:25typists,
- 36:26switchboard operators,
- 36:28but
- 36:28we've replaced those jobs with better jobs or
- 36:32different jobs that leverage the technology we have today.
- 36:35Now
- 36:36I
- 36:37am taking a position and
- 36:39I want to cite the World Economic Forum
- 36:41stat that is commonly bandied about
- 36:44uh 90 million jobs will be.
- 36:46Loss by
- 36:472030,
- 36:48but
- 36:49people forget
- 36:51they forget that there's another part of that 170 million jobs will be created
- 36:57due to AI,
- 36:59so we have a net gain.
- 37:00And what I'm saying,
- 37:01like with the veteran app,
- 37:02we're not replacing jobs,
- 37:04we're filling in a gap where there isn't enough people
- 37:09to provide that service
- 37:11for veterans,
- 37:12so.
- 37:13You know,
- 37:14what do you think on this?
- 37:15All right,
- 37:16so this is one reason why it gets confusing in my opinion
- 37:18is that like I actually agree that many jobs will be created.
- 37:22I just think that the ratio is going to be like way out of whack
- 37:24and economists have something,
- 37:26there's a phenomenon for this called job polarization.
- 37:29Which is you're gonna have a handful of high-end jobs and a lot
- 37:32of low-end jobs and all the middle tier jobs are gonna get decimated.
- 37:35And so the middle tier jobs are like a
- 37:37lot of the white collar professionals that right now
- 37:40can make a good living as a lawyer,
- 37:42consultant,
- 37:42accountant,
- 37:43banker,
- 37:44marketing pro.
- 37:45AI is gonna just get rid of a lot of those jobs and I say this because I've sat with uh
- 37:50a public company CEO who said to me,
- 37:52um,
- 37:53hey Andrew.
- 37:54I'm gonna fire 20% of my workers this year.
- 37:57I'm gonna fire another 20% 2 years from now.
- 37:59I'm gonna fire another 20% 2 years from now.
- 38:01Every time it happens,
- 38:02I'm going to get a bonus.
- 38:03By the way,
- 38:04if I don't do this,
- 38:05they're going to fire me and replace me with someone else.
- 38:07And multiple big company CEOs recently raised their hand and said,
- 38:10I'm out
- 38:11because I don't want to undergo the AI transformation
- 38:15and then the board
- 38:16will then like grab someone.
- 38:17Who will?
- 38:18So if you look at all of those corporations scrubbing jobs,
- 38:22I think that's going to be
- 38:24a huge,
- 38:24huge reduction in the 70 million white collar workers,
- 38:29and I'm gonna give you a data point that I think cuts in this direction.
- 38:32We now spend as a society more money on data centers than on office buildings.
- 38:36I want everyone to think about that.
- 38:37Like we spend more money on data centers and office buildings,
- 38:40so the server is the new human.
- 38:42Anyone who's like,
- 38:42hey,
- 38:43we're gonna spend $3 trillion
- 38:45on AI,
- 38:46but it's not going to affect millions of workers,
- 38:48I think does not understand the way any of these CEOs' incentives are,
- 38:52doesn't understand the way the stock market's gonna cudgel
- 38:54them if they don't get with the program.
- 38:56If you employ a lot of people in the AI age,
- 38:58it means you're behind the times,
- 38:59a dinosaur,
- 39:00we should replace you with someone else.
- 39:02So you're gonna see a massive contraction of every very significant,
- 39:06um,
- 39:06sized company,
- 39:08or you're gonna see a new CEO who's gonna take the hatchet very quickly.
- 39:11See,
- 39:11that's why I say you're an AI pessimist because you're not talking
- 39:15about the jobs that AI will create to replace those jobs.
- 39:19All right,
- 39:19Skip,
- 39:20we do have to pause here.
- 39:21Good
- 39:21luck in 2028.
- 39:22Thank you,
- 39:22Skip.
- 39:23Real pleasure.
- 39:23Sidekick plus.
- 39:25If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 39:26please get to the chair in +321.
- 39:32Oh,
- 39:34Andrew,
- 39:35nice to meet you.
- 39:35I'm Vern.
- 39:36Vern,
- 39:37yeah,
- 39:37my second name is Andrew also,
- 39:39actually.
- 39:40So you're like Vern Andrew and Andrew is my first name.
- 39:42Cool.
- 39:43I wanna kind of
- 39:44just check where you're at on your claim because you're saying millions of jobs
- 39:48or the rate
- 39:48of new jobs will just be outweighed,
- 39:51right?
- 39:52Where,
- 39:52where,
- 39:52like where is that coming from though,
- 39:54because let's use some.
- 39:56Metric to measure it,
- 39:57right?
- 39:57Let's talk about unemployment,
- 39:58for example.
- 39:58What is it currently?
- 39:59It's around 3 to 4,
- 40:015%,
- 40:02right?
- 40:03So
- 40:04in
- 40:05the past,
- 40:06right,
- 40:06how bad has unemployment gone?
- 40:08I mean,
- 40:09obviously you
- 40:10said
- 40:10like 25%,
- 40:1125%,
- 40:12right?
- 40:12And that's kind of like a ceiling that has happened,
- 40:14but something crazy happened,
- 40:16right?
- 40:16Something crazy happened at that.
- 40:17You mean the Great Depression or no?
- 40:19Yeah,
- 40:19no,
- 40:19the Great Depression.
- 40:20Even then,
- 40:21since then,
- 40:21it's never exceeded 25%,
- 40:23right?
- 40:23Oh yeah,
- 40:24I just want to dig into this number because it's super important.
- 40:26So the unemployment rate
- 40:28measures
- 40:29who's in the workforce actively looking and can't find a job.
- 40:32Right now it seems like a very low,
- 40:35reasonable,
- 40:35like 3 to 4%.
- 40:37It doesn't measure
- 40:38underemployment,
- 40:39so it's like,
- 40:40hey,
- 40:40I'm a college grad who like then took a job as a barista.
- 40:43An Uber driver
- 40:44in the unemployment rate that counts as fully employed.
- 40:46There's something called the U6,
- 40:48which is you're underemployed,
- 40:49and it's about twice the,
- 40:51the U3 unemployment rate.
- 40:52So instead of 3 to 4%,
- 40:54it might read as like 67,
- 40:558%,
- 40:56which seems worse.
- 40:57So then you say,
- 40:58OK,
- 40:58even if I accept 67,
- 40:598%,
- 41:00maybe.
- 41:00And then you have an underemployment rate of recent college graduates,
- 41:03which right now is 42% heading up to 50%.
- 41:06And that's
- 41:07like a very,
- 41:08very bad thing for the future.
- 41:10So you're saying
- 41:11you're saying 1 in 2 college grads can't get a job?
- 41:14No,
- 41:14no,
- 41:14they're underemployed according to,
- 41:16to,
- 41:16to the stats.
- 41:16But here's like the major,
- 41:17major
- 41:18like hair on fire fact that we need to actually
- 41:22get our arms around
- 41:23is that the labor force participation rate in the United States
- 41:27has been declining and declining and declining over the last number of years,
- 41:31whereas we're together right now,
- 41:32it's at a 20-year low
- 41:34of around 61.5%.
- 41:36Which includes the fact that 1/3
- 41:39of working age American men is no longer in the workforce.
- 41:43And you guys all know dudes who resemble this.
- 41:46All know dudes who resemble this.
- 41:48So that person,
- 41:49that guy who went home and said,
- 41:51I'm out,
- 41:52no longer gets factored into the headline unemployment.
- 41:54I mean,
- 41:54that's fine,
- 41:55but OK,
- 41:55let's,
- 41:56let's use that ceiling of 25%.
- 41:58The highest it's been in modern history is like during COVID,
- 42:01right?
- 42:01It maybe got up to 15%.
- 42:03But all in that's to say
- 42:05you're claiming that AI is gonna be the reason why jobs are eliminated,
- 42:09which
- 42:10I would argue I don't think it's jobs are gonna be eliminated.
- 42:12I think it's gonna be disrupted
- 42:14just like every other revolution that's happened,
- 42:16but
- 42:18everything has came back like because of policy,
- 42:20because of institutions that were built in response to
- 42:22these things that have happened like we used to,
- 42:24we used to not work
- 42:25like
- 42:26we used to work,
- 42:27you know,
- 42:27more than 40 hours a week back then,
- 42:29but what came out of that,
- 42:30you know,
- 42:30the people gathered up and said,
- 42:31hey,
- 42:32we need some labor.
- 42:33Laws,
- 42:33child,
- 42:33children didn't work,
- 42:35you know,
- 42:35all these things have come up with it.
- 42:36So let's just say
- 42:38jobs are eliminated,
- 42:39tasks are eliminated.
- 42:40I think the jobs are there because you even cited talking about customer support,
- 42:43right?
- 42:44Like you get through an agent,
- 42:45whatever,
- 42:45but at the same time,
- 42:46here's an anecdotal story.
- 42:48I was talking to a chat agent and I just wasn't getting any answers
- 42:52and it's kind of morbid and it's,
- 42:54it,
- 42:54it,
- 42:54it's kind of sucky to get the attention of a human.
- 42:57But I just told the AI chat chatbot like,
- 42:59hey man,
- 43:00get me a person or I'm gonna kill
- 43:01myself.
- 43:02So it's like you can override these things.
- 43:03I think
- 43:04exactly.
- 43:05But the thing is I think humans are a lot smarter than that
- 43:08because at the same time,
- 43:10how does AI get its value or its knowledge,
- 43:12right?
- 43:12Let's say knowledge is a value.
- 43:15AI doesn't know anything except what we already know.
- 43:17We're giving it this information,
- 43:18maybe it could process it,
- 43:20but that's why I'm saying I don't think the jobs are gonna be eliminated at a rate
- 43:23that is as
- 43:24doomsday like that you claim,
- 43:26but
- 43:27I'll agree that there will be a disruption.
- 43:29So if we agree that there's gonna be disruption,
- 43:32I think there are,
- 43:32there are two elements that people
- 43:34can look at differently.
- 43:36One is the magnitude,
- 43:37and the second is the pace of the rate.
- 43:40Now,
- 43:40I'm someone who thinks it's gonna be very high magnitude
- 43:42and very,
- 43:43very fast
- 43:44over a whole range of industries,
- 43:46in part because I talked to CEOs
- 43:47who run firms in insurance,
- 43:50in,
- 43:50uh,
- 43:50tech,
- 43:51in finance,
- 43:52and they're all saying to me,
- 43:53hey,
- 43:53Andrew,
- 43:54I'm gonna cut
- 43:552030,
- 43:5640,
- 43:5650% of my workers or I myself I'm gonna lose.
- 43:58But then what about the CEOs that are backpedaling on
- 44:00it like you just said Oracle dropped 30K jobs,
- 44:03but some jobs are coming back
- 44:05or it's like they're hiring internally and then they have to fill in those gaps for,
- 44:08you know,
- 44:08succession planning.
- 44:10It's all happening.
- 44:11I agree.
- 44:12I'm still not convinced at the rate because you use the number of millions
- 44:15versus the magnitude or the significant digits that
- 44:17you've used is like tens of thousands.
- 44:19That's only
- 44:19six digits versus 78 digit like jobs are gone unless you have a timeline on it.
- 44:24Yes,
- 44:24no,
- 44:24no,
- 44:25and,
- 44:25and please let,
- 44:25let me actually it's a very important point to make.
- 44:27And this is something that every CEO knows.
- 44:30The easiest people to fire
- 44:32are the people you have not hired yet.
- 44:34As someone who runs a company,
- 44:36the single biggest move I can make is to just be like,
- 44:38hey guys,
- 44:39we're not gonna be hiring
- 44:40junior whippersnappers.
- 44:42And then where does that show up in the numbers?
- 44:44It shows up in the underemployment rate
- 44:47of recent level of recent college graduates,
- 44:49uh,
- 44:49and that number is going up like that,
- 44:51that's objective fact.
- 44:52So you take my small company
- 44:54and we've probably replaced,
- 44:56let's call it,
- 44:57you know,
- 44:585 jobs,
- 44:59uh,
- 44:59with AI.
- 45:00It's not enormous.
- 45:01But then you multiply
- 45:02my small firm
- 45:04times like the millions of small firms around the country.
- 45:07And so I think you're going to be able to discern
- 45:09easily like 6 figures of layoffs due to AI directly.
- 45:13And then they're going to be all these other layoffs that don't make the headlines
- 45:16because
- 45:17like Noble Mobile,
- 45:18my company,
- 45:18not hiring 5 people is not a headline.
- 45:20But then you multiply that times all the.
- 45:22Small businesses,
- 45:23like,
- 45:24I think it gets into the millions.
- 45:25Yeah,
- 45:25you're saying six figures,
- 45:26but then it's like at the magnitude of multiple companies are doing that
- 45:28at the end of the day,
- 45:29like maybe there won't be employees left and they'll have to rehire anyway,
- 45:32just like the stock market,
- 45:33it goes up and down.
- 45:34Maybe this rate will go up and down,
- 45:36but you're arguing at a rampantcy rate of just like
- 45:39non-convergence.
- 45:39I definitely think it's non-convergent.
- 45:41I think we're in for a secular reduction.
- 45:44In the number of people who show up to an office and look at a computer screen,
- 45:48and that includes people who do it remotely.
- 45:50And the comparison I'd make
- 45:51is that imagine when the first robot arms started
- 45:54showing up on the factory floors in like 1990,
- 45:56and then the,
- 45:57like people in the factory like,
- 45:58oh no,
- 45:59like what's going on there?
- 46:00And then some of them,
- 46:01100% said,
- 46:02this will not threaten my job
- 46:04because no one can turn that.
- 46:06Screw the way I can
- 46:07because like no one can do it
- 46:09now.
- 46:10We are in that moment right now.
- 46:11It's just it's less visible because it's not a robot arm,
- 46:14but $3 trillion being spent on intelligent machines that are doubling in power
- 46:18every number of weeks,
- 46:19they're 100% going to replace millions of workers
- 46:21in my opinion,
- 46:23and we will all see who's right in terms of this claim over the next number of months.
- 46:27I dearly hope
- 46:28that I.
- 46:28Incorrect,
- 46:29but I've seen nothing
- 46:31to persuade me that I am.
- 46:32If you're incorrect,
- 46:32we're gonna pause here because we're out of time with this claim.
- 46:35Hey,
- 46:35pleasure.
- 46:35Great to see you,
- 46:36man.
- 46:36It's great to meet you.
- 46:37Yeah,
- 46:38brother,
- 46:38thank you.
- 46:39My next surrounded claim is that universal basic income will
- 46:42become necessary as AI reduces the need for human labor.
- 46:46If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 46:47please get to the chair in 321.
- 46:54Hello.
- 46:55Well done.
- 46:56How are you?
- 46:56How are you?
- 46:57What's your name,
- 46:57Sophia?
- 46:58I mean,
- 46:58it's great to talk to you because you were the
- 46:59person who first introduced me to the concept of UBI
- 47:02in the first place.
- 47:03So a lot of your ideas like have been
- 47:05floating around in my consciousness for a long time.
- 47:07So I guess the main points I want to make here
- 47:09is just to Raise awareness because a lot of
- 47:11people presumably are going to be watching this video
- 47:13to the different types of UBI
- 47:15that we have like available or have been proposed.
- 47:17So for example,
- 47:17we have a sovereign wealth fund which is like
- 47:19akin to what Norway has.
- 47:21Alaska has more of like a public wealth fund,
- 47:23petroleum dividend,
- 47:24yeah,
- 47:24yeah,
- 47:24yeah,
- 47:24for everyone.
- 47:26A
- 47:26universal basic dividend would basically like
- 47:29distribute wealth to Americans based on like a
- 47:31weighted index of say the top AI companies
- 47:34um and how you actually define what the top
- 47:37AI companies are and whether they go into like
- 47:39infrastructure frontier models,
- 47:41uh,
- 47:41etc.
- 47:42etc.
- 47:42etc.
- 47:43that's the that's really.
- 47:44I think the core topic of contention,
- 47:45it's like,
- 47:46what would we even
- 47:47categorize as
- 47:48are you accepting the need for universal basic income generally and
- 47:52just want to figure out the flavor or the mechanism?
- 47:55I'm most interested in the flavor and the
- 47:56mechanism because I think that there hasn't been
- 47:58like rigorous enough work done in this.
- 48:00I generally am of the viewpoint that
- 48:02We need to put more research and resources
- 48:05into measuring,
- 48:06uh,
- 48:06unemployment and tracing it back to AI,
- 48:08right?
- 48:08I don't know what sort of indices there are available right now that we can,
- 48:12uh,
- 48:12sort of
- 48:13straightforwardly point to and be like this is because of AI,
- 48:16this is displacement.
- 48:17Once we have more insight from these sort of metrics,
- 48:20then I think we can come to a conclusion
- 48:22on when UBI should start to be instated,
- 48:24and I do think that there are sort of like incrementalist policies,
- 48:27right?
- 48:28Um,
- 48:28you could do things like wage insurance,
- 48:31right?
- 48:31So if somebody loses their job,
- 48:32they made 80K a year,
- 48:34and they have to go get another job because their job was displaced by AI
- 48:38and they have to get a job that's like 50K a year,
- 48:40then you could,
- 48:40you know,
- 48:41compensate,
- 48:42like the government could compensate,
- 48:43uh.
- 48:44Those people for like the amount that they lost,
- 48:46right?
- 48:46Um,
- 48:47so you are you actually agreeing that universal
- 48:48basic income will become necessary as they think
- 48:51labor because I'm,
- 48:52I'm with you then,
- 48:53yeah,
- 48:53yeah,
- 48:53yeah,
- 48:54I,
- 48:54I think so.
- 48:54I think right now,
- 48:55no.
- 48:56So maybe you,
- 48:56you and I disagree on the time frame,
- 48:58right?
- 48:58So you would you say that you agree that right now
- 49:00is the time?
- 49:01I would say yes.
- 49:02And here's,
- 49:02here's one of the arguments I would make.
- 49:04Our data was used to create these models.
- 49:06Our data is currently being sold and resold for several $100 billion.
- 49:10a year.
- 49:11And one fun thing is that,
- 49:13you know,
- 49:13I asked like,
- 49:13hey,
- 49:14which American has gotten paid for their data?
- 49:16And most Americans have not gotten paid anything for their data.
- 49:19I am probably the only person in the circle
- 49:21who actually did get paid for their data,
- 49:23kind of,
- 49:24um,
- 49:25in,
- 49:25in that I got a note from the publisher of one of my books saying,
- 49:28hey,
- 49:29AI wants to eat your book and,
- 49:31and,
- 49:31uh,
- 49:32ingest its
- 49:33ideas and it will pay you.
- 49:36Um,
- 49:36$2500 for the privilege.
- 49:38Now,
- 49:38imagine if every American got a message like that,
- 49:40being like,
- 49:41hey,
- 49:41your data got used to form these $1 trillion
- 49:45models and companies,
- 49:46and you are now going to get a certain amount of money back,
- 49:49um,
- 49:50for that.
- 49:50I think that would go over great with the American.
- 49:52People,
- 49:53the majority of Americans are for it,
- 49:54but I also think it's going to become increasingly common sense and necessary
- 49:58because more and more Americans are going to get kicked to the curb.
- 50:01Yeah,
- 50:01do you think the frontier models should be voted out with the majority?
- 50:04Thank you so much.
- 50:05Thank you.
- 50:05It's great to meet you.
- 50:06Great to meet you too.
- 50:07321.
- 50:12How are you?
- 50:12Hello.
- 50:13Good.
- 50:13I like your shirt.
- 50:14Thank you.
- 50:14My name's Jason.
- 50:15I am a serial entrepreneurial failure,
- 50:18but I haven't given up yet,
- 50:20so.
- 50:21I can come up with technical differentiators in my sleep,
- 50:24but I'm,
- 50:24I suck at market research and execute and go to market.
- 50:28So my two cents for you,
- 50:30um,
- 50:30would be to find a co-founder or teammate,
- 50:33um,
- 50:33who has the,
- 50:34the strengths that would complement you because virtually none of us
- 50:38can
- 50:39is great at everything.
- 50:40I certainly would include myself in that and I'm applying.
- 50:43Accelerate is largely to find a co-founder.
- 50:45So,
- 50:47OK,
- 50:47cool.
- 50:47Uh,
- 50:48confirming side from the universe.
- 50:49I was like
- 50:50thank you.
- 50:50And I even have a conversational AI chatbot
- 50:52that lets you talk to historical figures and build
- 50:54relationships with them like Marcus Aurelius or von
- 50:57Rumi or Long Champa or whoever you want.
- 50:59So yes,
- 51:00what's it called,
- 51:00the chatbot?
- 51:01It's called Arovi.
- 51:03A I A R O V I.
- 51:05Made up words have better trademarks.
- 51:07I'm not a diametrically opposed to this claim.
- 51:09I hope we have UBI.
- 51:11And the main reason for that is work has a bad reputation for many reasons.
- 51:16People are doing soul sucking,
- 51:18menial tasks that don't enrich them,
- 51:20what David Graber calls bullshit jobs.
- 51:22Yeah,
- 51:23yeah.
- 51:24And
- 51:25a lot of the jobs that AI can automate are the jobs that nobody wants to do.
- 51:30People dress up in hazmat suits and go to toxic
- 51:33waste dumps.
- 51:34It's a legal risk.
- 51:35Nobody wants to do it.
- 51:36AI can,
- 51:37you can have that robot in there,
- 51:38yeah,
- 51:39yeah,
- 51:39get that drone in there.
- 51:40The other thing kind of related to other,
- 51:42I mean,
- 51:43all your four points are kind of related,
- 51:44but
- 51:45productivity gains come later.
- 51:47We don't know what those productivity gains are going to be.
- 51:50So the new jobs that come through,
- 51:52we don't know what those are going to look like yet.
- 51:55You know,
- 51:55the,
- 51:55the End of Work is a book you're familiar with,
- 51:58right?
- 51:58But there was more office work that was created
- 52:01through automation and internet that had existed before.
- 52:04And the last point,
- 52:04and then I'm just interested in your thoughts,
- 52:06I would really like it if we stopped focusing on growth,
- 52:09you know,
- 52:09focus more on growth happiness products like Bhutan does.
- 52:13And if you look at pictures of John Rockefeller and Um,
- 52:17Gy and even Elon Musk,
- 52:19they don't look like happy individuals.
- 52:21So if our basic survival needs are taken care of,
- 52:24we can focus on work that is meaningful,
- 52:26and they'll probably be more productive for the economy as well.
- 52:29Jason,
- 52:29um,
- 52:30I love where you're going with this,
- 52:31so check it out.
- 52:32American GDP as we're sitting together
- 52:34is around $84,000 per person.
- 52:38And AI,
- 52:39no matter what anyone thinks,
- 52:40is going to,
- 52:41uh,
- 52:41have that number go up
- 52:43substantially over the coming seasons.
- 52:45I don't think anyone here disagrees with that.
- 52:46I mean,
- 52:46you guys are all AI optimists.
- 52:48So,
- 52:49so let's say that number goes to,
- 52:51um,
- 52:51100,000 a head.
- 52:53Heck,
- 52:53you could even go.
- 52:54Further,
- 52:54like $120,000 a head.
- 52:56At what point
- 52:57do you start looking around and saying,
- 52:59you know what,
- 52:59we should distribute some of that value to
- 53:02like the,
- 53:02the mom,
- 53:03the,
- 53:03uh,
- 53:04displaced worker,
- 53:05or the non-displaced worker,
- 53:06like the guy who's in the
- 53:08one third of the
- 53:10men in America who aren't attached to the workforce in any way.
- 53:14Uh,
- 53:14and in my opinion,
- 53:16the sooner we do this,
- 53:17the better.
- 53:18Uh,
- 53:18and I compare civilization
- 53:21to toothpaste in a tube
- 53:23where like after you squeeze it out of the tube,
- 53:25you can't get it back in.
- 53:27There's something called trust
- 53:29and as trust,
- 53:30uh,
- 53:31corrodes and deteriorates,
- 53:33um,
- 53:33we start to,
- 53:35um,
- 53:35turn on each other,
- 53:36uh,
- 53:37and get nasty,
- 53:38uh,
- 53:38and more scarcity-minded.
- 53:39So the,
- 53:40the,
- 53:40the two.
- 53:41Um,
- 53:42sides of the,
- 53:43uh,
- 53:43human psyche
- 53:45are scarcity and abundance,
- 53:47and right now scarcity is increasingly winning in a country where 57% of Americans
- 53:52are paycheck to paycheck and they don't have $200 or $500 in savings.
- 53:55So the only
- 53:57silver lining in this era,
- 53:58in my opinion,
- 53:59is that AI is going to generate enough value where you can actually try and,
- 54:02um,
- 54:02spread the value and push us to abundance.
- 54:04So my question is,
- 54:05in this
- 54:07voted out for the majority.
- 54:08Such a pleasure.
- 54:10Arovi.
- 54:11AI.
- 54:12If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 54:14please get to the chair in 321.
- 54:20Look at that,
- 54:20Damien,
- 54:20you won that one easily.
- 54:21Yeah.
- 54:22So basically with universal basic income,
- 54:24take after Damian Lillard,
- 54:26yeah,
- 54:26yeah.
- 54:28First thing with universal basic income that I would say is
- 54:31it doesn't seem mathematically feasible
- 54:33if you were to give,
- 54:34let's say 200 million Americans $1000 each,
- 54:37uh,
- 54:37that would be,
- 54:38uh,
- 54:39if you do that every 12,
- 54:40every month,
- 54:41that would be $2 trillion out of our $4 trillion federal tax revenue,
- 54:45so.
- 54:46Using that
- 54:47just roughly that would take away from things like Social Security,
- 54:50that would take away from
- 54:51uh spending in places that we really need
- 54:54and it's
- 54:55just not mathematically feasible and not only that,
- 54:58but I believe more in a
- 55:00universal basic services model where
- 55:02instead of an income that's directly given to people,
- 55:05it's
- 55:06put into things like infrastructure,
- 55:08high-speed rail,
- 55:09um.
- 55:10You know,
- 55:10climate crisis prediction for the government and
- 55:12sovereign wealth funds even can also contribute to those things.
- 55:15I'd say that's why,
- 55:16you know,
- 55:17universal basic income doesn't seem feasible
- 55:19to me.
- 55:19Damien,
- 55:20I,
- 55:20I appreciate both of these points a great deal.
- 55:23So first,
- 55:24when someone says universal basic services,
- 55:27I'm not opposed to it at all.
- 55:28Like if someone's like,
- 55:29hey,
- 55:30we're going to invest in,
- 55:32uh,
- 55:32you know,
- 55:33education,
- 55:34housing,
- 55:35healthcare,
- 55:35transportation,
- 55:36like all those things,
- 55:38sounds great to me.
- 55:39One issue though in America is we're really bad
- 55:41at actually delivering value along any of those dimensions,
- 55:44and it's often not a monetary thing.
- 55:46I live in New York City
- 55:48and
- 55:49as a community,
- 55:50New York City is spending
- 55:52something like $40,000 per student in the school system,
- 55:55which means if you had 30 students,
- 55:56you're spending $1.2 million
- 55:58which must mean that our kids are getting a great education,
- 56:00right?
- 56:00Like,
- 56:01no,
- 56:01they're not.
- 56:01Like their results are terrible.
- 56:02So,
- 56:03so,
- 56:04so one of the things that's happening.
- 56:05Is that if someone says universal basic services,
- 56:08what,
- 56:08what that often is
- 56:10um interposing between the value and the people
- 56:13is these dysfunctional institutions that then say like,
- 56:15no,
- 56:16no,
- 56:16we'll distribute the goods
- 56:17and then the goods get stuck.
- 56:19So that,
- 56:19that's one thing like I'm not against universal basic services if we were good at it.
- 56:23Um,
- 56:24but like I,
- 56:24I don't think we're great at it.
- 56:25The other point I want to address is like the mathematical objection.
- 56:29Um,
- 56:29to UBI,
- 56:30so GDP per head is 84,000 a head.
- 56:33It's gonna go to 100,000 a head.
- 56:34Like,
- 56:35so at some point you have to look around and say,
- 56:36OK,
- 56:36where's the value going
- 56:38now?
- 56:38You are 100% correct about the,
- 56:40the scope and the magnitude of the current federal budget,
- 56:42and there's a,
- 56:43a deficit,
- 56:43and I'm not unmindful of these things.
- 56:45Elon Musk has said that a combination of AI and robotics are going to produce so much.
- 56:49Growth
- 56:50and so much value that some of the concerns we're talking about
- 56:54um are going to become less important in the coming years
- 56:57um and I think directionally he's correct in that
- 57:00if you have AI and robots doing enough work
- 57:03there's gonna be enough top line value to go around.
- 57:05The question is how does the top line value actually
- 57:07filter to the average person.
- 57:10But if you were to want to try and address this,
- 57:12so in terms of like the,
- 57:13the cost of the UBI,
- 57:14I just want to make a few points.
- 57:16Number 1 is
- 57:17about half of Americans are currently receiving government benefits in some form,
- 57:20so it's not dollar for dollar necessarily that
- 57:22all of the money you're talking about is,
- 57:24is new spend.
- 57:25Number 2,
- 57:26you get a lot of the value back
- 57:28in better health outcomes,
- 57:30education outcomes,
- 57:31homelessness,
- 57:32uh,
- 57:33incarceration.
- 57:34Like if someone hits our institutions,
- 57:36it's extraordinarily costly,
- 57:38and I think everyone knows what I'm talking about.
- 57:40So if you invest it in people,
- 57:42you end up getting a lot of the money back and you know,
- 57:44one of the biggest returns would be entrepreneurship
- 57:46because folks who are getting a certain amount of money into their hands
- 57:50would then say,
- 57:50OK,
- 57:51like maybe I can actually take a risk and have uh something
- 57:54of a cushion.
- 57:55Um,
- 57:56absolutely,
- 57:56absolutely,
- 57:57and I,
- 57:57and I certainly agree with you,
- 57:58and I think the core of the issue that we're getting to is really
- 58:01we're having less of a discussion about universal basic income and
- 58:05more about how do we regulate wealth distribution throughout the country.
- 58:09And there's more options than universal basic income,
- 58:12and I think that
- 58:13it's oftentimes it's used as a scapegoat.
- 58:15There's like the cultural hegemony,
- 58:17hegemony,
- 58:18whatever,
- 58:18however you pronounce it.
- 58:19Um,
- 58:20where
- 58:20that's part of like
- 58:22what keeps us frustrated and distracted and unable to address these issues is
- 58:26throwing up.
- 58:27Well,
- 58:27we need,
- 58:27um,
- 58:27you know,
- 58:28it's a false dichotomy like the universal basic income versus,
- 58:31uh,
- 58:31you know,
- 58:32something else.
- 58:33There are many options.
- 58:34Yeah,
- 58:34so I,
- 58:35I just want
- 58:36that by the majority,
- 58:37but I'll let you finish your,
- 58:38yeah,
- 58:38yeah,
- 58:38let's say,
- 58:38say two things.
- 58:39So if this money were to come into the hands of the average American household,
- 58:43virtually all of it would get spent.
- 58:45And circulated at local businesses,
- 58:48uh,
- 58:48throughout their community.
- 58:49And so the Roosevelt Institute did a study as to
- 58:52what universal basic income of approximately $1000 a month a head
- 58:56would do,
- 58:56and it would
- 58:57increase the size of the economy
- 58:59in perpetuity
- 59:01by about 12%,
- 59:02uh,
- 59:02and create,
- 59:04um,
- 59:04hundreds of thousands,
- 59:05even millions of new jobs because again,
- 59:07like every local restaurant,
- 59:08every local garage,
- 59:09every local like,
- 59:10uh,
- 59:11Um,
- 59:11you know,
- 59:12tutoring service,
- 59:13like all I would have
- 59:14more
- 59:15value
- 59:16and so the money doesn't disappear,
- 59:18it,
- 59:18it stays in the community.
- 59:20The second thing is that America is the only
- 59:22major industrialized economy and one of the only.
- 59:25Uh,
- 59:25countries in the world that doesn't have something called a value added tax
- 59:28in large part because our companies are expert at
- 59:30making sure they don't pay a lot of taxes,
- 59:33so the,
- 59:33the major problem we're having in American life
- 59:35is that all this value is getting generated
- 59:37and,
- 59:38uh,
- 59:38the big winners can,
- 59:39uh,
- 59:40essentially just gain their way out of it.
- 59:42And so if you solve for that,
- 59:44then all of a sudden the false scarcity in my opinion is false because.
- 59:47We are the richest,
- 59:48most advanced society in the history of the world,
- 59:50economy of $31 trillion a year.
- 59:52So if someone pleads poverty
- 59:54in terms of our ability to,
- 59:56to do something like a UBI that would again
- 59:58grow the economy,
- 59:59uh,
- 59:59in perpetuity and it would be in our hands,
- 1:00:02I'd look at it and be like,
- 1:00:03look,
- 1:00:03like mathematically you're wrong,
- 1:00:05but also,
- 1:00:06uh,
- 1:00:06we spent $4 trillion on the financial bailout.
- 1:00:08We spent $4 trillion.
- 1:00:10On COVID,
- 1:00:11like when,
- 1:00:12whenever there's like,
- 1:00:13frankly,
- 1:00:13like a corporate need,
- 1:00:15we find the money.
- 1:00:17You know what I mean?
- 1:00:17And,
- 1:00:18and,
- 1:00:18and I would say that
- 1:00:19at this point,
- 1:00:20uh,
- 1:00:20the human need is just as clear.
- 1:00:23I,
- 1:00:24I agree.
- 1:00:24We do have to stop here.
- 1:00:25Thank you.
- 1:00:26Thank you.
- 1:00:27Appreciate it.
- 1:00:28321.
- 1:00:32Hey there.
- 1:00:33Hello,
- 1:00:33how are you?
- 1:00:34How are you?
- 1:00:34It's great to meet you.
- 1:00:35Good.
- 1:00:36I'm doing good.
- 1:00:36I'll tell you a little bit about myself.
- 1:00:38Please do.
- 1:00:38My name's Sean.
- 1:00:39I'm 41 year old single father.
- 1:00:41I was in an industry that you touched on before,
- 1:00:43such as insurance,
- 1:00:44so I was an underwriting analyst for,
- 1:00:45uh,
- 1:00:45an insurance company.
- 1:00:46I'm starting a little startup,
- 1:00:48um,
- 1:00:48and I also run a video game community for dads who play video games.
- 1:00:51It's kind of what I do.
- 1:00:52I'm a gamer,
- 1:00:53but.
- 1:00:53Touching on UBI,
- 1:00:54your statement assumes that
- 1:00:56America doesn't already need UBI,
- 1:00:59which I would assume you agree that we do need UBI
- 1:01:02already.
- 1:01:02I mean,
- 1:01:03I,
- 1:01:03I did campaign on UBI now,
- 1:01:05um,
- 1:01:066 years ago,
- 1:01:06so I thought we needed it then,
- 1:01:08and I wish we had implemented it.
- 1:01:10I wish that I had
- 1:01:12won and gotten my way,
- 1:01:13and then,
- 1:01:14uh,
- 1:01:14you know.
- 1:01:15We could be doing this from the White House.
- 1:01:16Yeah,
- 1:01:16no,
- 1:01:17of course,
- 1:01:17and I flew into LA and the first thing,
- 1:01:19and you could see it on the streets,
- 1:01:20no offense to LA,
- 1:01:21but you can see it on the streets that
- 1:01:23UBI is needed.
- 1:01:24Well before AI people were losing their jobs or
- 1:01:27even
- 1:01:28people who were working full time weren't able to afford their rent
- 1:01:30and were going homeless,
- 1:01:31and it's just,
- 1:01:32it's prominent everywhere.
- 1:01:34Sean,
- 1:01:34I love this so much.
- 1:01:35You're like,
- 1:01:36hey.
- 1:01:36It's not universal basic income will become necessary.
- 1:01:39It's that it is necessary and it was necessary.
- 1:01:42Yeah,
- 1:01:42it's already necessary and yes,
- 1:01:46yeah,
- 1:01:47I agree.
- 1:01:49And I also don't agree with some of the
- 1:01:51other statements that we can't find funding for it because
- 1:01:54because we did with the stimulus checks in 2020,
- 1:01:57we did with the stimulus checks in 2021.
- 1:01:58So we can put
- 1:02:00the money,
- 1:02:00the money.
- 1:02:01The money's there,
- 1:02:03but
- 1:02:05we should be able to do this.
- 1:02:06We should be able to do
- 1:02:07it.
- 1:02:07Yeah,
- 1:02:07we should be able to do it.
- 1:02:08We're gonna,
- 1:02:09I think I
- 1:02:09already converted somebody.
- 1:02:12I am,
- 1:02:13I,
- 1:02:13I am on your side.
- 1:02:15Thank you.
- 1:02:15It's even a round of applause.
- 1:02:16I'm with it.
- 1:02:18I'm with it,
- 1:02:18man.
- 1:02:19I see the need every day on the street too,
- 1:02:21not just here in LA but everywhere,
- 1:02:22honestly,
- 1:02:23it's like you go around.
- 1:02:24If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:02:25please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:02:31Hey
- 1:02:31back.
- 1:02:32So I want to go back to the statistic that the gentleman raised before
- 1:02:37about the World Economic Forum report,
- 1:02:40um,
- 1:02:40that said we were gonna have,
- 1:02:42uh,
- 1:02:42170 million
- 1:02:44jobs created by 2030.
- 1:02:47So that,
- 1:02:48uh,
- 1:02:49report,
- 1:02:49uh,
- 1:02:50mentioned all industries.
- 1:02:51So it was across technology,
- 1:02:54it was across healthcare,
- 1:02:55it was across education.
- 1:02:58So based on that,
- 1:02:59it's that disproportion of certain industries
- 1:03:03not having enough jobs
- 1:03:05are actually included in that report,
- 1:03:07so they will have enough jobs based on that report.
- 1:03:11Another thing I want to point out is that there's a study,
- 1:03:13and I believe it's from PWC,
- 1:03:16and they're seeing that when it comes to job postings,
- 1:03:20AI jobs are being reported 4 times higher
- 1:03:24postings than traditional jobs,
- 1:03:26so the jobs are there,
- 1:03:29it's just that.
- 1:03:30There's a resistance to
- 1:03:32adapting to them,
- 1:03:33so we're seeing more AI type jobs.
- 1:03:35There isn't necessarily going to be a decrease in jobs,
- 1:03:39right,
- 1:03:39which will eliminate the need for the universal basic income.
- 1:03:42It's just that transition of the new types of jobs that are there,
- 1:03:46which happens in every single,
- 1:03:48you know,
- 1:03:49We talked about the industrial revolution,
- 1:03:51even when tractors were created,
- 1:03:52that replaced a whole bunch of agricultural
- 1:03:54workers and those workers had to retrain,
- 1:03:56learn how to drive tractors.
- 1:03:58So
- 1:03:59that I don't believe that universal basic income
- 1:04:01is going to be something that happens,
- 1:04:02um,
- 1:04:03because it's also been talked about in history and it's never happened.
- 1:04:06Wow,
- 1:04:06so there are a couple of different pieces there.
- 1:04:11I was itching to say it all this time.
- 1:04:13So one is the need based on jobs.
- 1:04:15The other is,
- 1:04:16uh,
- 1:04:16whether it will happen or not.
- 1:04:17So I actually attended that World Economic Forum event,
- 1:04:20and when they said like,
- 1:04:22hey,
- 1:04:22we're gonna automate away,
- 1:04:23um,
- 1:04:2390 million jobs like over over this period,
- 1:04:26it,
- 1:04:26it seemed like it was a red alert.
- 1:04:28Like there was like a freak out.
- 1:04:29They're like,
- 1:04:29what are we gonna do?
- 1:04:30And by the way,
- 1:04:30if you look at the global statistics,
- 1:04:32America is somewhere in the middle in terms of the
- 1:04:34proportion of jobs they think are subject to automation.
- 1:04:36But one reason why our jobs will be much more.
- 1:04:39automated is that we're more expensive.
- 1:04:41Like if you have an American in a in a role and you
- 1:04:44factor in healthcare costs and payroll tax and all the rest of it,
- 1:04:47the incentive to get rid of us is higher than
- 1:04:49if you go to some other countries where those expenses,
- 1:04:52like,
- 1:04:52you know,
- 1:04:52your hourly rates lower and the rest of it.
- 1:04:54So I certainly
- 1:04:56was there,
- 1:04:57read that report and the rest of it,
- 1:04:59and it did not say like,
- 1:05:00hey,
- 1:05:00it's going to be fine.
- 1:05:01The AI jobs are going to save us.
- 1:05:02Like that was not the
- 1:05:03message.
- 1:05:04There's a transition.
- 1:05:06I agree with that part.
- 1:05:07OK.
- 1:05:08The second thing is that even though.
- 1:05:09There are of course going to be new jobs you've created.
- 1:05:11I think they're going to be inappropriate for a lot of the people that need them.
- 1:05:15Uh,
- 1:05:15they're going to be some winners.
- 1:05:16They're going to be people that managed to fill
- 1:05:18AI roles.
- 1:05:19In my view,
- 1:05:19it's going to be like a relatively modest number,
- 1:05:21um,
- 1:05:22compared to the displaced,
- 1:05:24um,
- 1:05:24and so I think both of those things can be true that there are going to be these,
- 1:05:27these postings.
- 1:05:28And if you look at some of these postings,
- 1:05:29I'm gonna say something really nasty and mean to everyone.
- 1:05:32Sometimes the jobs that get posted aren't real jobs.
- 1:05:34I don't know if you all know that.
- 1:05:36Sometimes companies I came from corporate.
- 1:05:37I actually came from corporate.
- 1:05:40Sometimes companies post jobs
- 1:05:42for data collection purposes.
- 1:05:44Sometimes they post jobs to seem like they're healthy.
- 1:05:47Like there are a lot of reasons why companies
- 1:05:49post jobs.
- 1:05:50And so when,
- 1:05:50when you
- 1:05:51apply to jobs,
- 1:05:52a lot of the time there's not gonna be a human that reads your resume.
- 1:05:54I think people have figured all this out.
- 1:05:56Now,
- 1:05:56in terms of the need for a universal basic income,
- 1:05:59um,
- 1:05:59one of the things that gets me revved up
- 1:06:02is the fact that so many Americans are struggling,
- 1:06:04uh,
- 1:06:05day to day and,
- 1:06:06and when
- 1:06:07you travel,
- 1:06:08um,
- 1:06:08this country.
- 1:06:09Uh,
- 1:06:09you kind of,
- 1:06:10uh,
- 1:06:10like,
- 1:06:11it's really clear that,
- 1:06:12um,
- 1:06:13the majority of Americans feel like
- 1:06:15they're on the outside looking in of whatever the heck is going on,
- 1:06:18um,
- 1:06:18in AI as evidenced by the,
- 1:06:20the,
- 1:06:21um,
- 1:06:21disapproval of AI being something like 74%.
- 1:06:25It's something like 26% approved,
- 1:06:2674% disapprove,
- 1:06:28and that's something that
- 1:06:30uh the AI optimists I'm surrounded by
- 1:06:32might hear that number and say,
- 1:06:33OK,
- 1:06:34like we should do something about that,
- 1:06:35you know,
- 1:06:36it's like we have to make people feel like they're gonna benefit from AI,
- 1:06:39but most Americans do not feel like they're gonna benefit.
- 1:06:41From AI and I believe that they're correct.
- 1:06:43I think Americans are actually smart and savvy,
- 1:06:45and they're like,
- 1:06:46Yo,
- 1:06:46this does not include me.
- 1:06:47And so until that changes,
- 1:06:49I think the hostilities,
- 1:06:50uh,
- 1:06:51is,
- 1:06:51um,
- 1:06:52going to be there.
- 1:06:52But you can't have you're gonna pause here.
- 1:06:54You've been voted out.
- 1:06:55Thank you so much.
- 1:06:55I had such a good point.
- 1:06:59If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:07:00please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:07:07Hey there again.
- 1:07:09My name's Jay.
- 1:07:10I am a media personality and I also am a game creator
- 1:07:14slash model for The Sims 4.
- 1:07:17And yesterday we just hit 67,000 Patreon subscribers.
- 1:07:20Oh my gosh,
- 1:07:20congratulations.
- 1:07:21Thank you.
- 1:07:22That's a really significant number.
- 1:07:23Thank you.
- 1:07:24I wanted to ask,
- 1:07:26I'm not really a big terminology guy and I definitely don't have
- 1:07:29all the stats and I am not somebody who cannot be educated.
- 1:07:33But I wanted to
- 1:07:34talk about where the statistics are that we would specifically be needing the,
- 1:07:40the universal basic income
- 1:07:42due to AI.
- 1:07:43I wanna go back to when COVID happened.
- 1:07:46That was
- 1:07:48very stats based.
- 1:07:50We,
- 1:07:50uh,
- 1:07:50a lot of people were out of work.
- 1:07:51Nobody could do things.
- 1:07:52And that was very easy to keep up with,
- 1:07:54like,
- 1:07:54hey,
- 1:07:55nobody's going to work.
- 1:07:56So it
- 1:07:57makes more sense statistically
- 1:07:59that we all got that.
- 1:08:00However,
- 1:08:01I don't want to act like everybody in the world loves.
- 1:08:03AI.
- 1:08:04We have a lot of companies who,
- 1:08:05if they even do an AI flyer,
- 1:08:06you're either getting canceled or they're rearranging their whole team.
- 1:08:10And there are a lot of companies who are also
- 1:08:13building up their brands to compete with the AI brands because they know
- 1:08:16that there is also a big majority of the people who hate it.
- 1:08:20So I feel like the statistics that you're saying,
- 1:08:23Unless I'm not understanding,
- 1:08:25you're basing every single company under the same guideline as
- 1:08:28if they're all using AI and that will be the same
- 1:08:31case.
- 1:08:31Am I misunderstanding that?
- 1:08:33Maybe just like a tweak.
- 1:08:35Um,
- 1:08:35so there's broad disapproval of AI
- 1:08:37and you're obviously,
- 1:08:39you know,
- 1:08:39perceiving that,
- 1:08:40and then companies are going to use AI in different ways.
- 1:08:43All the CEOs I've talked to have suggested that
- 1:08:46um it's going to lead to a reduction in work workers
- 1:08:49and some of the reduction in workers is not AI based um
- 1:08:52there is something called AI washing which is like hey I overhired
- 1:08:56like uh you know I I um
- 1:08:58managed my company poorly
- 1:09:00so I'm now gonna fire a bunch of people and I'm gonna blame AI.
- 1:09:03That that has totally happened.
- 1:09:04There's also,
- 1:09:05uh,
- 1:09:06like,
- 1:09:06hey,
- 1:09:07the reality is I am gonna replace like 500 customer service workers with 50 in AI.
- 1:09:11That's also very real and it's happening.
- 1:09:13And a real company told me that they were gonna do that.
- 1:09:15I am
- 1:09:16of the opinion that universal basic income
- 1:09:18is necessary,
- 1:09:19was necessary,
- 1:09:20will be necessary,
- 1:09:21and the sooner we implement it,
- 1:09:22the better.
- 1:09:22I believed in this years ago.
- 1:09:24I believe in it now,
- 1:09:25and I think it's going to become more and more apparent to people as
- 1:09:28the college grads are
- 1:09:30shunted
- 1:09:32into,
- 1:09:33uh,
- 1:09:33jobs that do not require a college degree because the knowledge premium
- 1:09:36that has benefited generations of college graduates is about to get
- 1:09:40uh eviscerated.
- 1:09:41If you have that population
- 1:09:43coming home,
- 1:09:44I think there's gonna be a lot of uh
- 1:09:46discontent,
- 1:09:48um,
- 1:09:48and I'm not going to pretend that universal basic income solves every problem,
- 1:09:52um,
- 1:09:53but it provides a foundation and a transition
- 1:09:55mechanism and fuel for people to be able to
- 1:09:58uh start businesses,
- 1:09:59create opportunities,
- 1:10:01uh,
- 1:10:01pursue
- 1:10:02initiatives and passions,
- 1:10:04uh,
- 1:10:04and maybe
- 1:10:05like make a transition
- 1:10:07both professionally and regionally.
- 1:10:09Yes,
- 1:10:09um,
- 1:10:09I also want to we're gonna pause here.
- 1:10:11We're out of time for this claim.
- 1:10:13Congratulations
- 1:10:14on the community and business.
- 1:10:16My final surrounding claim is the market will optimize
- 1:10:19for productivity and profit,
- 1:10:21not human dignity.
- 1:10:22If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:10:23get to that chair in 321.
- 1:10:29Hey,
- 1:10:29how are you?
- 1:10:29Nice to meet you.
- 1:10:30Nice to meet
- 1:10:31the best dressed man here.
- 1:10:33So tell me about yourself.
- 1:10:34Yeah,
- 1:10:34so I work at a nonprofit and I'm their head of emerging technology policy.
- 1:10:37So basically I read,
- 1:10:38write,
- 1:10:39talk about AI and how it's impacting consumers every single day.
- 1:10:42What kind of nonprofit?
- 1:10:43I'm at the Consumer Choice Center.
- 1:10:44Uh,
- 1:10:44we're,
- 1:10:45we're based in Arlington,
- 1:10:46uh,
- 1:10:46rather Washington DC,
- 1:10:47but we're all over the world,
- 1:10:48right?
- 1:10:49So
- 1:10:49we kind of go in and meet people where they're at,
- 1:10:51whether that's here in United States.
- 1:10:52States or overseas in Europe or Canada,
- 1:10:54what are you finding?
- 1:10:55I wanna hear more.
- 1:10:56Yeah,
- 1:10:56so I,
- 1:10:56I,
- 1:10:57I think when it's all said and done,
- 1:10:58when we're looking at this particular question around human dignity and and AI,
- 1:11:01I think that it's important to go and ground it in terms of who
- 1:11:04is going to set like what the parameters of that human dignity looks like.
- 1:11:07I think right now the marketplace,
- 1:11:09it's not,
- 1:11:09they're not mutually exclusive goals in terms of going and
- 1:11:11and maximizing for productivity and profit as well as and,
- 1:11:14and counting for human dignity in of itself.
- 1:11:17These companies are competing for consumer dollars,
- 1:11:19they're competing for their attention,
- 1:11:21their patronage,
- 1:11:21right?
- 1:11:22And
- 1:11:22basically,
- 1:11:23I think that consumers vote with their feet very effectively on these,
- 1:11:25on these companies and
- 1:11:26I think that whether it's on the degree of safety or restrictions that
- 1:11:30these companies are willing to go and put on their models versus maybe
- 1:11:33very few as as Grok will go and show perhaps
- 1:11:36these are the kinds of things that I think consumers go in and show
- 1:11:39and demonstrate and then that doesn't even account for the open source community.
- 1:11:42I think when we're talking about human dignity,
- 1:11:44certainly with this particular conversation,
- 1:11:46we have to keep in mind
- 1:11:47as again who is.
- 1:11:48Going and setting that parameter if we're asking the government to go and do that,
- 1:11:51I think that that is a very dangerous kind of course because
- 1:11:54I think that there is a wide variety of opinions in
- 1:11:56terms of the current administration that's in the White House.
- 1:11:58Uh,
- 1:11:58there was certainly a fair share of opinions about
- 1:12:00the previous administration that was in the White House,
- 1:12:02and I'm not sure if I want to go and trust those politicians to go and set
- 1:12:06what that human dignity standard might be
- 1:12:08because it's different for each individual person.
- 1:12:10So I think there's that side of the equation.
- 1:12:12Well,
- 1:12:12so you,
- 1:12:13you made two points just now that I want to press on.
- 1:12:15So number 1,
- 1:12:16you said,
- 1:12:16look,
- 1:12:16the market will actually
- 1:12:18optimize for human dignity because consumers will
- 1:12:21spend their money accordingly.
- 1:12:22And then number 2 is,
- 1:12:23even if you accept that the market will not optimize for human dignity,
- 1:12:27you don't want the government to do it because they,
- 1:12:29they,
- 1:12:29you know,
- 1:12:29aren't very
- 1:12:30like
- 1:12:31aren't very whatever the heck,
- 1:12:32liked,
- 1:12:32competent,
- 1:12:33whatever it is.
- 1:12:33I think I'll push back on that.
- 1:12:34I'm not saying that they won't go and,
- 1:12:36and it's not that they won't optimize for human dignity.
- 1:12:38It's just.
- 1:12:39That
- 1:12:39I think that it's a Pareto improvement,
- 1:12:41right?
- 1:12:41It's constantly an iterative process because what people
- 1:12:43are expecting from these companies is constantly changing.
- 1:12:45What we thought about for the social media company conversation just a
- 1:12:48decade ago relative to where we are today is two different things,
- 1:12:50and companies are constantly changing for that.
- 1:12:52I remember
- 1:12:53in the woebegone days when a company called Walmart came around to various,
- 1:12:58uh,
- 1:12:59communities,
- 1:12:59and then people would be like,
- 1:13:00no one is gonna shop at Walmart.
- 1:13:02They're gonna shop at their local hardware store and
- 1:13:04their mom and pop because they love those shops.
- 1:13:07Keepers
- 1:13:07and they're gonna want to shop local.
- 1:13:09And then that lasted for about 10 seconds.
- 1:13:12Everyone went to Walmart,
- 1:13:13um,
- 1:13:14and the local mom and pop's,
- 1:13:16uh,
- 1:13:16disappeared.
- 1:13:17You now have American Express is,
- 1:13:18in my opinion,
- 1:13:19sort of like
- 1:13:20pulling on the heartstrings like shop small
- 1:13:23Saturday,
- 1:13:23and then that's like the one day people are like,
- 1:13:25oh snap,
- 1:13:26maybe I will
- 1:13:27shop in,
- 1:13:27in the,
- 1:13:28the mom and pop.
- 1:13:29The marketplace,
- 1:13:29in my opinion,
- 1:13:31does not reward the folks
- 1:13:32who say like,
- 1:13:33hey,
- 1:13:34you should support.
- 1:13:35me even though I'm going to be a little more expensive,
- 1:13:37like a little further away,
- 1:13:38a little bit like,
- 1:13:39no,
- 1:13:39no,
- 1:13:39no,
- 1:13:39like Americans are just like,
- 1:13:40like hard pass.
- 1:13:42I would actually go and push back on that a little bit.
- 1:13:44I'd go and push back on that a little bit,
- 1:13:45right?
- 1:13:45Because if you think about platforms like Etsy,
- 1:13:47for example,
- 1:13:48that algorithm that is powered by AI is connecting lots of Americans to
- 1:13:52small businesses all around the world in ways that were not previously possible.
- 1:13:55And that is,
- 1:13:55I think that's like
- 1:13:57that's like a,
- 1:13:58again,
- 1:13:58to me,
- 1:13:59like a different claim that you're making.
- 1:14:01So to the um.
- 1:14:02Like,
- 1:14:03hey,
- 1:14:03because of consumer choice,
- 1:14:05the market will actually like reward like good values,
- 1:14:08good practices,
- 1:14:09etc.
- 1:14:10Like I,
- 1:14:10I would just say anyone who looks at
- 1:14:12the record of American consumer behavior,
- 1:14:15um,
- 1:14:15if you look at the facts,
- 1:14:16like I don't think that's borne out.
- 1:14:17The second thing is like,
- 1:14:18look,
- 1:14:19um,
- 1:14:20different folks can have different points of view on like the role of government.
- 1:14:23One of the arguments I'm making is that I prefer
- 1:14:26human agency to rest with people,
- 1:14:29um,
- 1:14:29and entrepreneurship to be.
- 1:14:31Like the,
- 1:14:31uh,
- 1:14:31a huge driver of what people do because I think that's more than dignity,
- 1:14:35that's like activation,
- 1:14:36actualization,
- 1:14:37like,
- 1:14:38you know,
- 1:14:38being able to,
- 1:14:39um,
- 1:14:40build something,
- 1:14:41create something,
- 1:14:41live your dreams.
- 1:14:42Like I,
- 1:14:43I have actually had a career that resembles that
- 1:14:45and like I want that for as many people as possible.
- 1:14:47I think that is the definition of human dignity that we should be striving for.
- 1:14:51And I think that these platforms,
- 1:14:53whether it's anthropic and the closed source proprietary models or open source
- 1:14:56ones are giving Americans plenty of opportunities to go and do that.
- 1:14:59And again,
- 1:14:59I think that it is,
- 1:15:00no,
- 1:15:00no,
- 1:15:00no,
- 1:15:00no,
- 1:15:00I'm gonna push back on this for just a second.
- 1:15:02There's like,
- 1:15:03hey,
- 1:15:03you can use my stuff if you pay the license and this is gonna be good for your dignity,
- 1:15:08or
- 1:15:08there's
- 1:15:09We are now a $1 trillion company built on your
- 1:15:11data and we're gonna share that value with you.
- 1:15:13I'm gonna suggest that the latter version actually respects,
- 1:15:17uh,
- 1:15:17dignity at a higher level than you can use my stuff.
- 1:15:20Yeah,
- 1:15:20again,
- 1:15:21I don't think it's about that.
- 1:15:21I think that even when I was talking about before with like the use cases,
- 1:15:25that's not,
- 1:15:25we'll go and take it away from the model level for using my stuff.
- 1:15:28We're talking about the use cases where we have,
- 1:15:30again,
- 1:15:30the technology getting utilized whether it's for
- 1:15:31AI powered trousers or we're looking at again
- 1:15:33in the healthcare industry where nurses are,
- 1:15:34are,
- 1:15:35there's a real shortage for nurses,
- 1:15:36right?
- 1:15:37And AI is gonna go and automate,
- 1:15:38let's say the,
- 1:15:39uh,
- 1:15:39the paperwork that nurses have to go and do.
- 1:15:41And that was actually one of the number one causes.
- 1:15:42That nurses were leaving the workforces that they were just
- 1:15:44suffering so much burnout from going and dealing with that,
- 1:15:47that they weren't doing the thing that they cared about anymore and AI
- 1:15:50going and automating that away lets them focus on the thing that they want
- 1:15:52to go and do that brought them into that career to begin with.
- 1:15:54So that's actually giving them a sense of purpose and
- 1:15:56human dignity in a way that was not previously possible.
- 1:15:58This is like a whole new claim,
- 1:16:00James,
- 1:16:00I'm actually enjoying,
- 1:16:01which is like AI is gonna get rid of the
- 1:16:02bureaucracy and allow people to do what they wanna do.
- 1:16:05People,
- 1:16:06we're gonna have to pause here.
- 1:16:08You've been voted out with the majority.
- 1:16:09And in some cases that's true,
- 1:16:10yeah.
- 1:16:11That was fascinating.
- 1:16:14If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:16:15please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:16:22Hey,
- 1:16:22how are you?
- 1:16:23Hi,
- 1:16:23Megna,
- 1:16:23I'm a software engineer at Google.
- 1:16:25I've
- 1:16:26been a software engineer for 10 years.
- 1:16:27And where are you physically located?
- 1:16:29Uh,
- 1:16:29Bao.
- 1:16:30Oh,
- 1:16:30great,
- 1:16:30thanks for making the trip.
- 1:16:31Just a show of hands,
- 1:16:32how many of you used any of the Gen AI platforms to prepare for this debate?
- 1:16:37OK.
- 1:16:39So
- 1:16:39pre AI pre-internet,
- 1:16:41unless you had access,
- 1:16:43if you,
- 1:16:43if you're poor,
- 1:16:44you wouldn't have been able to
- 1:16:45like have access to information in order to prepare and be equally
- 1:16:49competent as anyone else.
- 1:16:50So you would have to use your network network through your parents or
- 1:16:54you wouldn't need access to education or books,
- 1:16:56etc.
- 1:16:57to be able to.
- 1:16:58You know,
- 1:16:58have
- 1:16:59the dignity or knowledge to come and present,
- 1:17:01uh,
- 1:17:01in,
- 1:17:02in a space like this.
- 1:17:03But now I think all of these platforms provide similar answers.
- 1:17:05If I were to,
- 1:17:06irrespective of what my prompt is,
- 1:17:07you're gonna get fairly
- 1:17:09a good amount of equal information and all of us would be equally prepared,
- 1:17:12and that wouldn't have been possible before.
- 1:17:14First,
- 1:17:14let,
- 1:17:14let me say.
- 1:17:15I did not use AI to prepare for this and that wasn't deliberate.
- 1:17:18I maybe I,
- 1:17:19I could have or should have.
- 1:17:20Maybe I even intended to.
- 1:17:21I've written two books on this topic.
- 1:17:25So what I,
- 1:17:25what I actually did in real life,
- 1:17:27you guys get to judges,
- 1:17:29I just like reread my own books
- 1:17:32because
- 1:17:33what you're saying about AI preparing people for
- 1:17:36this kind of debate,
- 1:17:37I would 100% concede and agree with because like you're,
- 1:17:40you're smart to do it.
- 1:17:41I think that's.
- 1:17:41It's a very different statement than that the
- 1:17:43market will optimize for productivity and profit,
- 1:17:45not human dignity.
- 1:17:46If you say,
- 1:17:46look,
- 1:17:46if you're showing up to a debate event,
- 1:17:48you're gonna be better prepared because of AI
- 1:17:51like wouldn't even touch that.
- 1:17:52I'd be like,
- 1:17:53yes.
- 1:17:53What I'm saying is that the market
- 1:17:55is going to reward
- 1:17:56the capital holders,
- 1:17:58the controllers of the AI,
- 1:17:59the repositories of data,
- 1:18:01and the users of processing power.
- 1:18:03That's going to accelerate inequality,
- 1:18:06inequities.
- 1:18:07Uh,
- 1:18:07in our society,
- 1:18:08and they're going to be a lot of people experiencing very,
- 1:18:11very undignified circumstances as a result.
- 1:18:13The focus is being taken away from the fact that we live in a capitalistic society.
- 1:18:17So there is no free lunch.
- 1:18:19These companies would have to in some way charge like users
- 1:18:22in order to make these products.
- 1:18:24So that could be
- 1:18:25either providing ads or a subscription,
- 1:18:28but they have to get users to use these products.
- 1:18:30And,
- 1:18:30and because of that,
- 1:18:31they have to focus on
- 1:18:33getting.
- 1:18:33Users
- 1:18:34the answers that they need and so they are focused
- 1:18:36more on profit because of the society we live in.
- 1:18:38So I agree with you there.
- 1:18:39But,
- 1:18:40but generally,
- 1:18:40uh,
- 1:18:41these products have been
- 1:18:42extremely useful for pretty much anyone from any background in
- 1:18:46giving access to,
- 1:18:47to these large language models are trained on every
- 1:18:49possible knowledge and pilot data on the internet.
- 1:18:52So anyone has access to that.
- 1:18:53OK,
- 1:18:53just a simple conversation right now.
- 1:18:55Yes,
- 1:18:56again,
- 1:18:56I would not
- 1:18:57try and counter an argument saying that these tools are broadly useful.
- 1:19:01For
- 1:19:01lots of people in like lots of different circumstances.
- 1:19:04The question to me is,
- 1:19:05where does the value go?
- 1:19:06And so if I use this AI tool,
- 1:19:08it might allow me to accomplish my tasks a little bit more effectively,
- 1:19:12but
- 1:19:12there are going to be $1 trillion firms,
- 1:19:15uh,
- 1:19:15that are the primary beneficiaries,
- 1:19:18and the main way that anthropic is going
- 1:19:19to generate $100 billion in revenue this year
- 1:19:23is that corporations are going to pay anthropic
- 1:19:26that money.
- 1:19:27And swap out
- 1:19:28coders and marketers and call center workers and
- 1:19:31researchers and data analysts and like all,
- 1:19:34all the folks who used to do that job.
- 1:19:36And so you're going to have Anthropic and its investors is a very,
- 1:19:39very big winner.
- 1:19:40Google's gonna be a very big winner.
- 1:19:41Amazon's gonna be a very big winner,
- 1:19:43but the,
- 1:19:43the average person is gonna be like,
- 1:19:45wait a minute,
- 1:19:46what happened to my job?
- 1:19:47Wait a minute,
- 1:19:47why is my kid at home uh on the sofa instead of having a job?
- 1:19:51So the big thing here is like the market.
- 1:19:53In my opinion,
- 1:19:54it is not designed to optimize for human dignity.
- 1:19:56It's just not.
- 1:19:57It's like,
- 1:19:57you know,
- 1:19:57if,
- 1:19:58if I replace,
- 1:19:59um,
- 1:19:59Uber drivers with way more drivers and that,
- 1:20:02that income source disappears for those people,
- 1:20:04like the market is thrilled.
- 1:20:06Uber is like,
- 1:20:06yes,
- 1:20:07like,
- 1:20:07you know,
- 1:20:07we,
- 1:20:08we did it and,
- 1:20:08and because that's the purpose of Uber.
- 1:20:10The purpose of Uber is not to employ 2 million people.
- 1:20:12The purpose of Uber is to get me from point A to point B,
- 1:20:14and that's the market.
- 1:20:15Like if Uber could magically do this,
- 1:20:17the market would reward Uber is my point.
- 1:20:20Uh,
- 1:20:20pause.
- 1:20:21You've been voted out.
- 1:20:22Thank you.
- 1:20:22Thank you.
- 1:20:24Thank you.
- 1:20:24Great talking to you too.
- 1:20:25321.
- 1:20:29Hey there,
- 1:20:30how are you?
- 1:20:30Good.
- 1:20:30How are you?
- 1:20:31I'm Nathan.
- 1:20:31I wanna start with the
- 1:20:33idea that
- 1:20:34do you agree that we're not at AGI yet but we're on the path to AGI,
- 1:20:37which is why companies are
- 1:20:38kind of doing this corporate restructurings in order to invest more
- 1:20:42in that path.
- 1:20:42And I generally agree with that,
- 1:20:44yeah,
- 1:20:44OK.
- 1:20:44And if you agree with that,
- 1:20:46then I think there's a lot of industry and research partnerships going on.
- 1:20:49That as we get to the path of AGI as these new models get released,
- 1:20:53they're not at the point of AGI yet,
- 1:20:55they're being used for
- 1:20:56purposes of human dignity
- 1:20:58if that makes sense,
- 1:20:59and I think that's why they can coexist at the same time
- 1:21:02when you
- 1:21:03optimize for profit,
- 1:21:04but when you
- 1:21:05release those same models for general use to academia,
- 1:21:08for example,
- 1:21:09that.
- 1:21:10They can
- 1:21:10do it for general purposes like in biology,
- 1:21:13for example.
- 1:21:13Wow,
- 1:21:14this is a very nuanced argument you're making,
- 1:21:16Nathan,
- 1:21:17which I enjoy,
- 1:21:17which is you're like,
- 1:21:18look,
- 1:21:19there are a lot of
- 1:21:20positive prosocial institutions like
- 1:21:23universities
- 1:21:24that are going to use this AI
- 1:21:26to do great things.
- 1:21:28thing,
- 1:21:28you know,
- 1:21:28maybe some,
- 1:21:29uh,
- 1:21:30drugs and some other things,
- 1:21:31advanced solutions,
- 1:21:32they're gonna use AI to do so,
- 1:21:33so that AI and human well-being will actually be kind of
- 1:21:36tied together and the market will optimize and like that,
- 1:21:39that is like a very smart argument in part because
- 1:21:43I don't disagree with you that that will happen.
- 1:21:46Like I think that there are gonna be some good people
- 1:21:48in academia and in other precincts that use these AI tools to do great things.
- 1:21:53I do think that you're gonna have advances in life sciences,
- 1:21:56advances in,
- 1:21:57um,
- 1:21:57drug discovery and bioinformatics,
- 1:21:59uh,
- 1:21:59and we're gonna have material,
- 1:22:01uh,
- 1:22:01cures
- 1:22:02to some intractable,
- 1:22:04you know,
- 1:22:04it's like diseases that we haven't been able to solve for before,
- 1:22:06and on that level,
- 1:22:08it's.
- 1:22:09Phenomenal.
- 1:22:09The thing I'm going to say is that
- 1:22:11what you're saying is to me like uh kind of uh off at an angle
- 1:22:16for the market will optimize for productivity and profit,
- 1:22:18not human dignity.
- 1:22:19If you were to
- 1:22:21say,
- 1:22:21hey,
- 1:22:22Andrew,
- 1:22:22AI will be used to make some awesome things
- 1:22:24happen and that'll be good for the human condition,
- 1:22:26I would actually concede and agree.
- 1:22:28You say,
- 1:22:28hey,
- 1:22:28the market will reward
- 1:22:30human dignity over.
- 1:22:32Productivity and profit,
- 1:22:32then I would sharply disagree.
- 1:22:34I think like the vast majority
- 1:22:35of the instances and use cases and the beneficiaries
- 1:22:38are going to be,
- 1:22:39um,
- 1:22:40very,
- 1:22:40very much like,
- 1:22:41uh,
- 1:22:42profit oriented and that what what's gonna happen is
- 1:22:45like the rich are gonna get richer,
- 1:22:46um,
- 1:22:47and the rich in this instance,
- 1:22:49uh,
- 1:22:49are,
- 1:22:49it could be obviously like,
- 1:22:51you know,
- 1:22:51you're wealthy,
- 1:22:52um,
- 1:22:53but it's also like you're wealthy.
- 1:22:54Access to data,
- 1:22:55you're wealthy and like,
- 1:22:57uh,
- 1:22:57you know,
- 1:22:58having
- 1:22:58like a giant franchise the way that like uh Verizon
- 1:23:01or Coca-Cola has like the market's gonna reward that and
- 1:23:04the market's gonna reward corporations' ability to do more with
- 1:23:07less and less in this instance is gonna mean human beings
- 1:23:10and it's gonna be very bad for people broadly.
- 1:23:12I think that's something to debate on whether how,
- 1:23:15how,
- 1:23:15how,
- 1:23:15how close we're getting to that yet because.
- 1:23:18You know,
- 1:23:18I think with the current architecture,
- 1:23:20even there's
- 1:23:21thoughts of like,
- 1:23:22hey,
- 1:23:22when you start running super long tasks,
- 1:23:24your performance starts to degrade and things like that.
- 1:23:27I,
- 1:23:27I just feel like,
- 1:23:28do you think there's a way
- 1:23:29since,
- 1:23:30you know,
- 1:23:30you implement UBI,
- 1:23:31you,
- 1:23:32you thought about it before AI was even in the mainstream,
- 1:23:34right?
- 1:23:35Is it
- 1:23:36right,
- 1:23:36obvious,
- 1:23:37um,
- 1:23:37but Nathan,
- 1:23:38I want to make a pitch to everyone.
- 1:23:39This is important to me,
- 1:23:40very,
- 1:23:40very important to me.
- 1:23:41The proposal is the market will optimize for productivity and profit.
- 1:23:44But not human dignity.
- 1:23:45I want everyone to imagine what a market would
- 1:23:47look like if it was optimized for human dignity,
- 1:23:50um,
- 1:23:50because that to me is actually the project of this age
- 1:23:53to put it in terms that I think most people can understand,
- 1:23:56and this is one of the biggest misconceptions about me is
- 1:23:58that I think that universal basic income is the solve.
- 1:24:01I do not.
- 1:24:02I think universal basic income is the foundation,
- 1:24:04uh,
- 1:24:05or the floor,
- 1:24:05and then you need to build the house.
- 1:24:07So the house is how do people get.
- 1:24:10Purpose,
- 1:24:11structure,
- 1:24:11joy,
- 1:24:12fulfillment,
- 1:24:13community values,
- 1:24:14a place to go
- 1:24:15in an era when AI and machines are gonna do more and more of the work.
- 1:24:19And to me,
- 1:24:19the way you get there is you actually try and optimize for and reward
- 1:24:23human flourishing
- 1:24:25via
- 1:24:26measuring and benefiting health and wellness.
- 1:24:29And my,
- 1:24:29uh,
- 1:24:29and my joke here is that at this point we should be getting paid to go to the gym.
- 1:24:33I want everyone to think about that.
- 1:24:34We should be getting paid to go to the gym
- 1:24:36and the personal trainer who's there whipping us into shape should,
- 1:24:38should get paid too.
- 1:24:39Not,
- 1:24:40yeah,
- 1:24:40not necessarily by me,
- 1:24:41but like if you think about it societally,
- 1:24:42that like that would actually be a win.
- 1:24:44And so you would build a health and wellness economy and in my view,
- 1:24:47you'd actually have a new currency for that.
- 1:24:49Then you have,
- 1:24:50you'd have an arts and creativity economy and have a new currency for that.
- 1:24:53And then you'd have
- 1:24:55uh an education and nurturing and caretaking economy,
- 1:24:57you'd have a currency for that.
- 1:24:59That is what
- 1:25:00a market that's actually designed to optimize for us
- 1:25:03would look like.
- 1:25:04In the absence of any of those things.
- 1:25:06This market will optimize for is capital efficiency.
- 1:25:10How can I get the work done as quickly
- 1:25:12and cheaply as possible?
- 1:25:14And the answer to that is going to be AI.
- 1:25:15I just wonder.
- 1:25:17Thank you so much.
- 1:25:18Thank you,
- 1:25:18Nathan.
- 1:25:19It's great.
- 1:25:20I thought that might be true.
- 1:25:21321.
- 1:25:26Hey there.
- 1:25:27Hey,
- 1:25:27nice to meet you.
- 1:25:28Nice to meet you too.
- 1:25:29Welcome.
- 1:25:29I actually want to
- 1:25:31refer back to some of your other claims
- 1:25:34to contend
- 1:25:35with your current claim.
- 1:25:37Ultimately,
- 1:25:37I think
- 1:25:38there are different levels
- 1:25:39of uh tolerance that people have
- 1:25:42for their circumstances,
- 1:25:44and if the market only optimizes for
- 1:25:47productivity
- 1:25:48and
- 1:25:49um efficiency.
- 1:25:51There's going to be a threshold that it passes
- 1:25:54where
- 1:25:55human dignity being negatively affected
- 1:25:57has a reverse effect.
- 1:25:59You've
- 1:25:59referred to malady,
- 1:26:00I mean some of your other arguments,
- 1:26:02and I agree with that.
- 1:26:03People are going to riot,
- 1:26:05uh,
- 1:26:05people are going to
- 1:26:07just go into complete discord.
- 1:26:09That's going to completely disrupt any of the
- 1:26:12market efficiencies that we would see from AI.
- 1:26:14I'm enjoying this conversation a lot,
- 1:26:16Donnie.
- 1:26:16So,
- 1:26:17so what you're saying is like,
- 1:26:18look,
- 1:26:19If
- 1:26:19AI stampedes
- 1:26:21human dignity
- 1:26:22super badly,
- 1:26:23then there's gonna be a backlash and then you're gonna wind up in a different place,
- 1:26:26so it will not stampede human dignity.
- 1:26:28Yes,
- 1:26:28I think there's going to be um
- 1:26:30an inflection point
- 1:26:32where
- 1:26:32it might,
- 1:26:33the original goal will be.
- 1:26:35Productivity and profit,
- 1:26:36of course,
- 1:26:37yeah,
- 1:26:37has always been the case,
- 1:26:38but because the scales are so radically different,
- 1:26:41we're not going to see,
- 1:26:42um,
- 1:26:42the complacency that we see now where
- 1:26:44enough people are satisfied with their living conditions.
- 1:26:48I love this argument so much because it's literally
- 1:26:50how I spend most of my waking hours.
- 1:26:53No,
- 1:26:53genuinely,
- 1:26:54so check it out.
- 1:26:54Check it out.
- 1:26:55Um,
- 1:26:55what Donnie's saying is,
- 1:26:56look,
- 1:26:57like if AI continues to optimize for,
- 1:27:00uh,
- 1:27:00the almighty dollar,
- 1:27:01then more and more people are going to get pissed off and ticked off,
- 1:27:03and then they're gonna
- 1:27:04say like,
- 1:27:05hey,
- 1:27:05we need to change it and make it,
- 1:27:06make it,
- 1:27:07make it so that things are different.
- 1:27:08I ran for president on that case,
- 1:27:11more or less.
- 1:27:11One of my great learnings.
- 1:27:13From both that experience and the past number of years
- 1:27:16has been that the American political system is not really designed to solve
- 1:27:20our problems or optimize for human dignity in the way that you're describing.
- 1:27:24It's actually designed to kind of divide us and pit us against each other
- 1:27:28and refract our problems and just uh and
- 1:27:31and continue to let the mega corps
- 1:27:33have their way.
- 1:27:35So what you're suggesting is.
- 1:27:37One thing that I would love for you to be right about,
- 1:27:38which is that look,
- 1:27:40people are going to rise up and demand real change this time,
- 1:27:43and that's going to have to come from some
- 1:27:44kind of modernization or change to the political system,
- 1:27:46in my opinion,
- 1:27:47because I do not think that the current American political system actually
- 1:27:50can solve this problem.
- 1:27:51So you need a different,
- 1:27:52better version.
- 1:27:53So if you agree with that,
- 1:27:54then you and I are totally,
- 1:27:55so there's a slight deviation in our agreement.
- 1:27:57So,
- 1:27:58yeah,
- 1:27:58so I think
- 1:27:59it's not going.
- 1:28:00To be about demanding change,
- 1:28:02it's going to be forcing change.
- 1:28:03That's like ultimately where we're going to end.
- 1:28:05No,
- 1:28:05I'm,
- 1:28:05I'm with you there too,
- 1:28:06man.
- 1:28:07I love you.
- 1:28:07We love you and
- 1:28:08Johnny,
- 1:28:08I knew you were a smart man before you sat down.
- 1:28:11Then after you introduced yourself,
- 1:28:12I was like,
- 1:28:12jeez man,
- 1:28:13neuroscience from Johns Hopkins.
- 1:28:14I better not disagree with this guy.
- 1:28:16And it turns out I don't.
- 1:28:18Yeah,
- 1:28:19I
- 1:28:19have to pause here.
- 1:28:21You've been voted out,
- 1:28:22OK,
- 1:28:22dude,
- 1:28:24I hope you're right.
- 1:28:26I literally spent all my time trying to make you right.
- 1:28:29If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:28:31please get to that chair in 321.
- 1:28:37Hi,
- 1:28:37I'm Jeremiah.
- 1:28:38Hey Jeremiah,
- 1:28:39Andrew,
- 1:28:39nice to meet you.
- 1:28:40I'd love to hear a little bit about you.
- 1:28:41Yeah,
- 1:28:42so I'm a psychotherapist,
- 1:28:44and I think before we go into the topic,
- 1:28:46can I address a couple of things that you said about,
- 1:28:48um,
- 1:28:49psychotherapy?
- 1:28:50Yeah,
- 1:28:51so I would.
- 1:28:52that
- 1:28:53my profession,
- 1:28:54we are probably going to be the last to be replaced just because of all the human
- 1:28:58interactions that's required.
- 1:29:00But you mentioned before that the reason why
- 1:29:02they felt more comfortable with the AI was because
- 1:29:05they just felt more comfortable talking to an AI than a human.
- 1:29:08The reason being is because
- 1:29:10the um the military,
- 1:29:11I might be telling military secrets,
- 1:29:13the military contracts out
- 1:29:16to therapists to talk with their uh military personnel,
- 1:29:19but what people don't know is that even
- 1:29:21though we're sworn to privacy and confidentiality,
- 1:29:24not when it comes to the military,
- 1:29:26we have to send our notes to.
- 1:29:28Their superiors and then
- 1:29:30and guess what,
- 1:29:31right,
- 1:29:32and the,
- 1:29:32the vets,
- 1:29:33if they get depression,
- 1:29:35anxiety,
- 1:29:35PTSD on the job,
- 1:29:36they're discharged.
- 1:29:37So that's that.
- 1:29:38OK,
- 1:29:38so now what thank you for sharing that Jeremiah.
- 1:29:40Yeah,
- 1:29:40of course.
- 1:29:41Also,
- 1:29:41I just want to say quickly,
- 1:29:42my brother,
- 1:29:43um,
- 1:29:43was trained as a clinical psychologist,
- 1:29:45so I have like huge,
- 1:29:46uh,
- 1:29:47regard and respect for the work you do.
- 1:29:48Thank you.
- 1:29:49Um,
- 1:29:49so,
- 1:29:50what I wanna say is,
- 1:29:51I think we're looking at dignity in the wrong way.
- 1:29:54So the thing is,
- 1:29:55most people are not working in a job that they really want to be in,
- 1:29:58and I'll say most because I'm not gonna use absolutes like you did.
- 1:30:01I'm gonna say all,
- 1:30:02cause I mean,
- 1:30:03that's a cognitive distortion.
- 1:30:05The world is not black and white,
- 1:30:06it's 50 shades of gray.
- 1:30:07I don't know if you guys,
- 1:30:08OK,
- 1:30:08there we go.
- 1:30:09So the thing is,
- 1:30:10the dignity,
- 1:30:11so if,
- 1:30:11if people are not in jobs that they really want to be doing,
- 1:30:14Then they're not gonna be really dignified or
- 1:30:17having a sense of self-worth in it,
- 1:30:18right?
- 1:30:19So
- 1:30:19we need to shift that to make people have dignity and worth
- 1:30:23in roles other than that,
- 1:30:24right?
- 1:30:24A good father,
- 1:30:25a good husband,
- 1:30:26good wife,
- 1:30:27good friend.
- 1:30:28So what I will bring this whole thing together is
- 1:30:30I actually believe that AI with the displacement of jobs,
- 1:30:34so I use Waymo,
- 1:30:35not Uber and Lyft.
- 1:30:37So let's say an Uber and Lyft driver,
- 1:30:38right?
- 1:30:39They might not have a lot of dignity and worth transporting people,
- 1:30:42but Because there are professions right now,
- 1:30:44like health care,
- 1:30:46mental health,
- 1:30:47elder care,
- 1:30:48we need that stuff now.
- 1:30:50We need to be filled now.
- 1:30:51So when people get displaced,
- 1:30:53right,
- 1:30:53and they're unemployed,
- 1:30:54which they're not gonna be very dignified
- 1:30:56being unemployed,
- 1:30:57they can assume these positions.
- 1:30:59Helping fields have proven,
- 1:31:01fact check me,
- 1:31:02people that work in helping fields feel the purpose that you were talking about.
- 1:31:05They're gonna feel more self-dignity and higher self-worth
- 1:31:08working and filling these positions.
- 1:31:10That we need,
- 1:31:10right?
- 1:31:11Teachers,
- 1:31:11I think are still teaching
- 1:31:13one teacher to 30 students.
- 1:31:14It should be like one teacher to 15 students,
- 1:31:17right?
- 1:31:17So if we spend money to create more schools,
- 1:31:20more,
- 1:31:21um,
- 1:31:21elderly care,
- 1:31:22more,
- 1:31:22um,
- 1:31:22skilled nursing facilities,
- 1:31:23all these things,
- 1:31:24then these displaced workers
- 1:31:26will have jobs and their dignity and self-worth will improve
- 1:31:30just from their job alone,
- 1:31:31besides what I said before of them trying to find different
- 1:31:34roles to make them their self-esteem improve.
- 1:31:36I love the direction.
- 1:31:38Agree
- 1:31:39that more of us should be spending our time making people
- 1:31:43healthier,
- 1:31:44connected,
- 1:31:45better educated,
- 1:31:46etc.
- 1:31:46etc.
- 1:31:47I'm going to argue that you just made
- 1:31:49my case for me.
- 1:31:51Um,
- 1:31:51which is that the market will optimize for productivity and growth,
- 1:31:54not human dignity.
- 1:31:56Um,
- 1:31:56so all of the helping professions that you're describing,
- 1:31:59one could argue,
- 1:32:00are under-resourced in part because the market
- 1:32:04does not
- 1:32:04recognize
- 1:32:06the well-being that is being brought through them.
- 1:32:09Um,
- 1:32:09adequately or appropriately,
- 1:32:11and the,
- 1:32:11and the example I could use
- 1:32:13is that if you're an excellent teacher,
- 1:32:15studies have shown that you produce
- 1:32:17a ton of value
- 1:32:19for your students and,
- 1:32:20uh,
- 1:32:21um,
- 1:32:21over their lifetime,
- 1:32:22but that teacher does not get rewarded.
- 1:32:24My wife,
- 1:32:25who is,
- 1:32:25um,
- 1:32:26at home very often with our autistic son,
- 1:32:28the market values her work at zero.
- 1:32:31So I think you and I are completely
- 1:32:33aligned.
- 1:32:34In that the market does not reward
- 1:32:36human dignity in the way that it should.
- 1:32:38Yeah,
- 1:32:38and I,
- 1:32:39but what I'm saying is,
- 1:32:39I mean,
- 1:32:40that,
- 1:32:40that is sort of obvious,
- 1:32:41but what I'm saying is that people need to
- 1:32:44get their dignity and worth outside of work,
- 1:32:47right?
- 1:32:47So,
- 1:32:48they,
- 1:32:48you said AI is displacing them with,
- 1:32:50I,
- 1:32:50we already talked about it,
- 1:32:51AI,
- 1:32:51um,
- 1:32:52Uber,
- 1:32:53all that stuff.
- 1:32:54So what I'm saying is that they can
- 1:32:55reclaim their dignity and worth
- 1:32:57and
- 1:32:58Improve it by going in these fields that are already
- 1:33:01kind of short staffed.
- 1:33:03Um,
- 1:33:03pause here.
- 1:33:04We're out of time for this claim
- 1:33:06so much.
- 1:33:06I,
- 1:33:06I'm,
- 1:33:07I'm pretty much on board.
- 1:33:10In the sense of like,
- 1:33:11you know,
- 1:33:12I would love to fuel human
- 1:33:13performance.
- 1:33:14All right,
- 1:33:14so now it is time for the final.
- 1:33:16debate,
- 1:33:16great debate so far.
- 1:33:17It's been like a friendly conversation.
- 1:33:20If you're enjoying it.
- 1:33:20You know,
- 1:33:21I have boxing gloves strapped to the underside of this table,
- 1:33:25but didn't need them.
- 1:33:26Don't need them.
- 1:33:26I don't think so.
- 1:33:27Maybe because now it's time for the final debate.
- 1:33:29use them for defense.
- 1:33:30You get 10 minutes now uninterrupted.
- 1:33:33So take your time and look around the circle.
- 1:33:36And check for anyone you wanna continue the conversation with,
- 1:33:39someone who impressed you.
- 1:33:40You know what?
- 1:33:40I enjoyed my conversation with the hosts of uh MTS,
- 1:33:45um,
- 1:33:46but I,
- 1:33:46I feel like I didn't have enough time with,
- 1:33:47um,
- 1:33:48Sophia,
- 1:33:49come on up.
- 1:33:49Yeah,
- 1:33:50let's give her a round of applause,
- 1:33:51yay.
- 1:33:52Pleasure.
- 1:33:53It's great to see you again.
- 1:33:54OK,
- 1:33:55Andrew,
- 1:33:55why did you choose Sophia?
- 1:33:57I felt like we were having a good conversation that was cut short.
- 1:34:00She had nuanced and smart viewpoints,
- 1:34:02and I,
- 1:34:03I wanted to be able to explore them further.
- 1:34:05My surrounded claim is that being an AI optimist is necessary
- 1:34:09to get through this next period of immense technological transformation.
- 1:34:13I'm not sure I entirely disagree.
- 1:34:14With you,
- 1:34:15um,
- 1:34:15being honest,
- 1:34:16because I think being optimistic is a very good thing,
- 1:34:18uh,
- 1:34:19in our own lives,
- 1:34:19certainly if you're an entrepreneur or the head of an organization,
- 1:34:22if you come in with
- 1:34:23doom and gloom and pessimism and like woe is me,
- 1:34:26then
- 1:34:26no one wants to be around you,
- 1:34:27no one wants to listen to you,
- 1:34:28you're probably not gonna get a whole lot done.
- 1:34:30So I,
- 1:34:30I think being optimistic
- 1:34:32in that sense is
- 1:34:33the right approach.
- 1:34:34What frustrates me.
- 1:34:36Is when folks adopt
- 1:34:39uh attitudes about AI that strike me as overly optimistic
- 1:34:43um or not grounded in empirical fact and reality.
- 1:34:46Uh,
- 1:34:47there's one
- 1:34:48statement um from a journalist named Upton Sinclair
- 1:34:51that I think some of you guys remember.
- 1:34:52It's like it's hard to convince a man of a fact
- 1:34:55when his living depends upon him not believing it.
- 1:34:59Like,
- 1:34:59like that,
- 1:35:00I think that's actually a pretty good summary of some of the
- 1:35:03frustration I feel with some folks in the space.
- 1:35:05Yeah,
- 1:35:06I definitely understand that,
- 1:35:07and I would say one of the misconceptions about being an AI optimist
- 1:35:11is that you're blindly accepting everything that everyone says is going to happen,
- 1:35:15and it actually means how do we amplify our own agency?
- 1:35:19How do we actually act on that agency?
- 1:35:21And I think technology,
- 1:35:22especially AI,
- 1:35:23is one of the Best tools to empower ourselves to act on our agency,
- 1:35:27and I would urge everyone in this room,
- 1:35:30everyone watching,
- 1:35:30every single person in this world,
- 1:35:32they do have an important role to play in shaping the future,
- 1:35:35and pessimism is what keeps them powerless.
- 1:35:38Pessimism and fear mongering is a a tactic
- 1:35:41from governments,
- 1:35:42authoritarian governments,
- 1:35:43to
- 1:35:44get us to not want
- 1:35:45to act.
- 1:35:46All right,
- 1:35:46check it out.
- 1:35:46Check it out.
- 1:35:47I'm,
- 1:35:47I'm going to like try and
- 1:35:48layer layer this a little bit.
- 1:35:50So I think it's possible,
- 1:35:52possible to be personally optimistic
- 1:35:54and then also clear-eyed about the magnitude of the challenges,
- 1:35:57uh,
- 1:35:58and the disruption and the changes.
- 1:35:59And so I think most people know
- 1:36:01that,
- 1:36:02um,
- 1:36:02I ran for office,
- 1:36:03and I think if you run for office,
- 1:36:05what you do is you expand your lens
- 1:36:07to include
- 1:36:08people
- 1:36:09that are going to get kicked to the curb or on the outside looking in or like,
- 1:36:12you know,
- 1:36:13didn't graduate from college and aren't realistically going to
- 1:36:15be a beneficiary of this change or that change.
- 1:36:17Um,
- 1:36:18so on a micro level,
- 1:36:20being optimistic,
- 1:36:21I think is a plus.
- 1:36:22On a macro level,
- 1:36:23if your job,
- 1:36:24and in my case,
- 1:36:25you know,
- 1:36:25it's like a job I kind of took on for myself,
- 1:36:28but if your job is to
- 1:36:29look out for people,
- 1:36:31then I,
- 1:36:31I think,
- 1:36:32um,
- 1:36:33being
- 1:36:34clear-eyed or realistic or even slightly pessimistic
- 1:36:37because one of the things that I've sensed in American life,
- 1:36:39I just wanna throw this out to people,
- 1:36:41is that there's actually a bias
- 1:36:43towards.
- 1:36:44Kind of like ad it'll be all right,
- 1:36:46like,
- 1:36:46like da da da,
- 1:36:47it'll figure itself out like the market knows all and the rest of it that pervades a
- 1:36:51lot of our thinking and institutions in part
- 1:36:54because we're all brainwashed into being like you,
- 1:36:57you,
- 1:36:57you,
- 1:36:57you,
- 1:36:57you,
- 1:36:58wherever you are,
- 1:36:59you must be
- 1:37:00market optimized.
- 1:37:02And so,
- 1:37:02you know,
- 1:37:03and then I,
- 1:37:04I'm gonna say realistically,
- 1:37:05like a lot of people are gonna fail that test,
- 1:37:08um,
- 1:37:08because the bar to be market optimized is gonna go up.
- 1:37:11Up,
- 1:37:11up,
- 1:37:11up,
- 1:37:11up,
- 1:37:12um,
- 1:37:13and so if you go to an individual entrepreneur and they're like,
- 1:37:16hey,
- 1:37:16I'm gonna be optimistic,
- 1:37:17I'm like,
- 1:37:17yeah,
- 1:37:18yeah,
- 1:37:18go for it.
- 1:37:19But then if you want to try and account for the whole of society,
- 1:37:22then you'd have to look and be like,
- 1:37:24OK,
- 1:37:24like what do I really think is happening here?
- 1:37:26Yeah,
- 1:37:26definitely.
- 1:37:27So
- 1:37:27what I'm hearing is that we agree that at
- 1:37:29the individual level it's helpful to be optimistic,
- 1:37:31but at the macro level,
- 1:37:33that's hurtful.
- 1:37:33Is that correct?
- 1:37:34Do I understand your claim correct?
- 1:37:35Um,
- 1:37:36so,
- 1:37:36and even at the macro level.
- 1:37:37Someone says to me like,
- 1:37:38hey,
- 1:37:39AI will grow the,
- 1:37:40the top line of value creation.
- 1:37:41AI is gonna solve
- 1:37:43meaningful scientific problems.
- 1:37:45Like,
- 1:37:45I'm actually like
- 1:37:46down for all of that.
- 1:37:47I agree with all that.
- 1:37:48Yeah,
- 1:37:48I will say though,
- 1:37:49at the macro level,
- 1:37:50if you look at what's what's actually happening in
- 1:37:52media and resources that are going into research,
- 1:37:54all of it is to double down on what can go wrong,
- 1:37:57and that's important.
- 1:37:58We should understand that.
- 1:37:59But what there's less information for is actual resources
- 1:38:02and research on what exactly we could do right.
- 1:38:04I love what you say about UBI and I
- 1:38:06guarantee that you were the first person to introduce
- 1:38:08most people at a mainstream level to UBI and other opportunities
- 1:38:13and other frameworks around solvent wealth funds or what could possibly do
- 1:38:16people don't know about.
- 1:38:17You know why?
- 1:38:18Because the media isn't putting attention on what we can do correctly.
- 1:38:20The media is putting so much attention on everything that is going wrong.
- 1:38:23I was a TV commentator for a little while and they
- 1:38:25pitched me a show called The Future of with Andrew Yang.
- 1:38:28It was like the future of healthcare,
- 1:38:29the future of transportation.
- 1:38:31They did a focus group and they said,
- 1:38:33hey,
- 1:38:33bad news,
- 1:38:33Andrew.
- 1:38:34People don't like the future.
- 1:38:36What
- 1:38:36to think about now,
- 1:38:37now that is not you.
- 1:38:38You're all like super
- 1:38:39gung ho about the future because you're an entrepreneur.
- 1:38:41I think you can make it happen.
- 1:38:43But for the average American,
- 1:38:44they see the future
- 1:38:45and it makes them sad.
- 1:38:47It makes them anxious,
- 1:38:48and I'm gonna suggest that
- 1:38:50a lot of them
- 1:38:51are correct.
- 1:38:52A lot of them are onto something.
- 1:38:54Because the holders of the AI
- 1:38:56and the holders of the Capitol and the controllers
- 1:38:58of the data centers do not give a shit
- 1:39:01about what happens to that person and their family.
- 1:39:04And if that person gets upset,
- 1:39:05they'll be like,
- 1:39:06uh,
- 1:39:06we're just gonna ignore you,
- 1:39:07you're like,
- 1:39:07you know,
- 1:39:08blank you out,
- 1:39:09loser,
- 1:39:09like refract everything through a dysfunctional
- 1:39:12political system that's gonna say,
- 1:39:13you know why you're upset?
- 1:39:14It's because of those people over there.
- 1:39:16People over there who have like a,
- 1:39:17you know,
- 1:39:18like a different value set than you do or terminology than you,
- 1:39:20like they're the problem.
- 1:39:21More and more of us,
- 1:39:22my hope is that more and more of us wise up to that,
- 1:39:25um,
- 1:39:25and then raise our hands and say,
- 1:39:26look,
- 1:39:27there are going to be some winners and losers.
- 1:39:28In my opinion,
- 1:39:28the losers are going to vastly outnumber the winners.
- 1:39:32And that
- 1:39:33um let's
- 1:39:34actually manage this process,
- 1:39:36share the wealth,
- 1:39:36make it so the average person feels like they're gonna benefit.
- 1:39:39And I would say is that most people right now are looking for
- 1:39:42a framework on what exactly we can do to come out of this,
- 1:39:45even within
- 1:39:45all of the AI optimist community,
- 1:39:47all of the entrepreneurs in Silicon Valley,
- 1:39:49there's constant debate
- 1:39:50on what we can do to mitigate the concentrations of power.
- 1:39:53And so specifically the plans in there are really important,
- 1:39:57but the sentiment and the negative sentiment.
- 1:39:59It is more
- 1:40:00around the in the United States
- 1:40:02in poorer countries people love AI.
- 1:40:04The sentiment around AI is larger.
- 1:40:06They believe it's an opportunity for growth,
- 1:40:08for education,
- 1:40:09for prosperity,
- 1:40:10and they see it differently.
- 1:40:11So if we expand our conversation beyond just America
- 1:40:14and we talk about what's happening globally,
- 1:40:16people have a different viewpoint and different sentiment,
- 1:40:18and they're actually feeling very optimistic of
- 1:40:20the future because of artificial intelligence.
- 1:40:22I
- 1:40:23like your expanding the lens.
- 1:40:25I can imagine that people in very.
- 1:40:27Other countries are
- 1:40:28amazed that they can just like,
- 1:40:30you know,
- 1:40:30access,
- 1:40:30uh,
- 1:40:31AI and like do it,
- 1:40:32you know,
- 1:40:32relatively inexpensively for now.
- 1:40:34Like I,
- 1:40:35I will say that
- 1:40:36the folks who are in charge of the institutions that a lot of these other countries
- 1:40:39are saying,
- 1:40:40oh,
- 1:40:40snap,
- 1:40:41we're going to end up paying either the Americans
- 1:40:43or the Chinese to use their AI tools because
- 1:40:45we certainly are not going to come up with our Swedish AI.
- 1:40:49I mean,
- 1:40:49maybe it'll be in Swedish,
- 1:40:51but they'll be licensing the models from either us or China.
- 1:40:54I'm going to tell a.
- 1:40:55AI joke because I think people will enjoy it.
- 1:40:57How far behind
- 1:40:58the US is China and AI?
- 1:41:00And the answer is 12 hours because they wake up and see whatever we did,
- 1:41:04uh,
- 1:41:04the previous day.
- 1:41:06So you have,
- 1:41:06you have like these two great
- 1:41:08powers in AI and then the rest of the world is going to end up paying one of us the other.
- 1:41:12And that's going to be one of the,
- 1:41:13the great global competitions.
- 1:41:15But I can imagine like the average person being excited about the tools.
- 1:41:18Yeah,
- 1:41:18and I would say the other opportunity and the reason
- 1:41:20to be optimistic is that pessimism and often People think,
- 1:41:23OK,
- 1:41:23it's going really bad.
- 1:41:24Let's shut everything down.
- 1:41:25But I am an AI optimist because I don't like the problems in our world.
- 1:41:29I want cures to diseases.
- 1:41:30I want a better planet.
- 1:41:32I,
- 1:41:32I don't want eco economic inequality and global poverty
- 1:41:36as well.
- 1:41:36And
- 1:41:37AI right now,
- 1:41:38when it comes to diseases,
- 1:41:39it's doing so much to do drug discovery.
- 1:41:41They're in finding new solutions to cancers.
- 1:41:44It's creating new market for clean energy we've never had at this scale before.
- 1:41:47And so it's creating demand in new areas,
- 1:41:49and I agree.
- 1:41:50So much consideration we need to do,
- 1:41:52and I want to talk to you even further about what do we actually do.
- 1:41:55What's a tangible step forward that we can actually,
- 1:41:57yeah,
- 1:41:58yeah,
- 1:41:58no,
- 1:41:58Sophia,
- 1:41:59to close on this,
- 1:42:00I am
- 1:42:01pro-innovation,
- 1:42:03pro progress.
- 1:42:04I am not a shut it all down guy.
- 1:42:06I believe that they're going to be very
- 1:42:08negative effects for a lot of people,
- 1:42:10um,
- 1:42:11over this coming period,
- 1:42:13and yet I'm still not a shut it down guy
- 1:42:15because
- 1:42:15I think the opportunity in front of us.
- 1:42:18It is clear to,
- 1:42:20to grow the value creation to solve really,
- 1:42:23really long-standing problems.
- 1:42:25The major challenge in my view,
- 1:42:27is to get the winners of this era to say,
- 1:42:30look,
- 1:42:30it's better outside the bunker,
- 1:42:32it's better above ground than below ground.
- 1:42:34It's better without a bulletproof car and private security for myself.
- 1:42:37It's better not living in fear.
- 1:42:39Let me make it so that
- 1:42:40the average person.
- 1:42:41And
- 1:42:42is sharing in the incredible benefits of this technology in this era,
- 1:42:46and that is the opportunity.
- 1:42:48That is the pursuit.
- 1:42:49The scarcity mindset will turn us against each other and say like,
- 1:42:52hey,
- 1:42:53stop everything.
- 1:42:54I'm not a stop everything guy.
- 1:42:55I'm a come together guy.
- 1:42:57I'm like a,
- 1:42:58like,
- 1:42:58like,
- 1:42:58let's figure it out guy.
- 1:43:00I think that is to me,
- 1:43:02the opportunity of this age to go from scarcity.
- 1:43:04Which has plagued
- 1:43:06human society for,
- 1:43:07you know,
- 1:43:07since,
- 1:43:07uh,
- 1:43:08like our,
- 1:43:08our beginnings
- 1:43:09to actually a world of abundance.
- 1:43:11That is the
- 1:43:12biggest opportunity of this time,
- 1:43:13and I hope that we pursue it.
- 1:43:14I completely agree,
- 1:43:15and I think there's so much we agree on,
- 1:43:16and I look forward to talking more about what are
- 1:43:18their tangible solutions to actually get to that world.
- 1:43:20I love it,
- 1:43:20Sofia.
- 1:43:21Yes,
- 1:43:22appreciate you.
- 1:43:23We're gonna pause here because we are out of time.
- 1:43:25Thank you both so much.
- 1:43:26Give them a round of applause.
- 1:43:28It was
- 1:43:28awesome.
- 1:43:28Like I wanna talk to you more about.
- 1:43:31This was a great conversation.
- 1:43:34So everyone also give yourselves a round of applause.
- 1:43:36Thank you,
- 1:43:37debaters.
- 1:43:41I know.
- 1:43:42And
- 1:43:42Andrew,
- 1:43:43thank you so much for your time.
- 1:43:44It was a great conversation.
- 1:43:46I've got a lot,
- 1:43:47a lot on my mind,
- 1:43:48a lot to say.
- 1:43:49I know,
- 1:43:49I love to hear it.
- 1:43:50So much positivity in the room.
- 1:43:52I feel the positivity.
- 1:43:53This is probably the friendliest debate we've ever had.
- 1:43:55All right.
- 1:43:55And of course,
- 1:43:56thank you all for watching at home.
- 1:43:58This is your time to sound off in the comments.
- 1:44:01Let me know,
- 1:44:01did they change your mind?
- 1:44:02Are you now an AI enthusiast
- 1:44:04or are you still a pessimist?
- 1:44:06Let me know in the comments
- 1:44:07and we'll see you next time.
- 1:44:08Bye.
- 1:44:14They were optimistic.
- 1:44:15Uh,
- 1:44:15I enjoy talking to them,
- 1:44:17really smart.
- 1:44:19Open-minded for the most part.
- 1:44:21We were
- 1:44:22forging a human connection and having a genuine conversation,
- 1:44:24which is what I was going for.
- 1:44:26And I think they were too.
- 1:44:27So I enjoyed the heck out of it.
- 1:44:28Andrew did amazing.
- 1:44:30He is such a good speaker,
- 1:44:32and you can tell that he's really informed.
- 1:44:34Not only is he really informed,
- 1:44:35he's very earnest.
- 1:44:36I think a lot of his perspectives and his point of view comes
- 1:44:39from a place of genuinely wanting to do what's best for humanity,
- 1:44:42trying to do what's best for people.
- 1:44:44And so I really
- 1:44:45enjoyed my conversation.
- 1:44:46Andrew today.
- 1:44:47I actually do think he was
- 1:44:49more of an optimist than
- 1:44:51he let on.
- 1:44:53I was expecting someone very against AI,
- 1:44:55like gonna be very,
- 1:44:56very
- 1:44:56negative,
- 1:44:57but he's actually very optimistic about AI.
- 1:44:59I feel.
- 1:44:59Andrew's great,
- 1:45:00you know,
- 1:45:01it's a breath of fresh air compared to the
- 1:45:03traditional dividing lines in politics,
- 1:45:05so it's exciting to hear his perspective.
- 1:45:06I think that there's a balanced approach that most people
- 1:45:10know we could be,
- 1:45:11um,
- 1:45:12adopting that would be better.