Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / BRK Q3 Earnings Analysis: Berkshire‘s $381 Billion Cash Dilemma: Why the Q3 Profit Surge
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to The Deep Dive today.
- 0:02Well, we've got a big one. We're going to dig into the
- 0:04latest financials and the strategic picture for Berkshire
- 0:09Hathaway. We're using their Q32025 report
- 0:12as our guide here. Yeah, and it's, you know,
- 0:14analyzing Berkshire is always a unique challenge, isn't it?
- 0:17Definitely. It's not your standard company.
- 0:19It's this huge conglomerate, insurance, railroads, energy,
- 0:24you name it. A real behemoth.
- 0:26And the headline, I mean, you can't avoid it.
- 0:28They're cash pile. It just hit another absolutely
- 0:30staggering record. That's really the heart of the
- 0:33matter for this quarter. I think everything we're
- 0:35discussing today, it's drawn from AQ32025 financial research
- 0:39report we looked at and the sort of immediate take away, it's a
- 0:43bit contradictory actually. How so?
- 0:45Well. Profits are way up, right,
- 0:47especially from insurance, which we'll get into, but at the same
- 0:49time zero share buybacks and that massive growing cash hoard
- 0:54you mentioned. OK, so strong performance, but
- 0:56holding back on spending. Interesting.
- 0:58Exactly. And you know, just a quick
- 1:00reminder for everyone listening, this whole discussion is based
- 1:03on summarizing public research. It's purely for informational
- 1:06purposes, definitely not investment advice.
- 1:11Berkshires Complex. Right.
- 1:12You got to do your own homework, your own due diligence.
- 1:14Think of this as maybe a jumping off point.
- 1:16Precisely. OK.
- 1:18So let's get into that scorecard then.
- 1:20Q3 earnings, you said they were strong.
- 1:22Very strong. If you look at the standard
- 1:25number, the gap net earnings, the ones attributable to
- 1:28shareholders, yeah, that number climbed to almost $30.8 billion.
- 1:32Wow. OK.
- 1:33And how does that compare? That's up quite a bit from about
- 1:36$26.3 billion this time last year, so a healthy jump.
- 1:39But hang on, with Berkshire, we always talk about operating
- 1:42earnings, right, not just gap. Why is that the key metric here?
- 1:45It's absolutely crucial because gap earnings include all the
- 1:48swings, you know, the ups and downs from their massive stock
- 1:51portfolio. The investment gains and losses.
- 1:54Exactly, and those can be huge but they don't really tell you
- 1:57how the actual businesses are doing day-to-day.
- 2:00Like are the trains running on time?
- 2:02Is cry ICO writing profitable policies?
- 2:05Got it. So operating earnings strips out
- 2:07that market noise? That's the idea.
- 2:09Gives you a clearer view of the core business health and that
- 2:13number, operating earnings also looked really good.
- 2:16OK, what was it? It climbed to $13.5 billion.
- 2:19That's a really big increase from $10.1 billion in Q3 last
- 2:23year. 13.5 billion in operating earnings for the quarter.
- 2:26That's huge. What drove that surge?
- 2:29Primarily insurance, no questions.
- 2:31Specifically, the underwriting income, OK, it basically
- 2:34exploded, went from about $750 million a year ago to nearly
- 2:37$2.4 billion this quarter. 2.4 billion just from underwriting
- 2:41profit. Just from the underwriting side,
- 2:43yeah, it suggests, you know, better pricing, maybe tighter
- 2:46underwriting standards, perhaps fewer large catastrophes during
- 2:49the quarter. Whatever the reason, the core
- 2:52insurance operations were firing on all cylinders.
- 2:54Which leads us back to that cash pile.
- 2:57Because if the businesses are making so much money, where's it
- 3:00going? Well, it's piling up.
- 3:02The total Cash, Cash equivalents and short term treasury bills
- 3:06hit, wait for it, $381.7 billion. 381 billion.
- 3:12It's just it's hard to even picture that amount of money.
- 3:15It's astronomical, larger than the entire value of many major
- 3:19corporations. And connecting that back to what
- 3:21you said earlier, zero share repurchases in the quarter.
- 3:24That's right, they had almost $400 billion effectively ready
- 3:28to deploy, and they chose not to buy back a single share of their
- 3:32own stock. So what's the interpretation
- 3:34there? What is the research suggests?
- 3:36The simple line from the source is that management is quote
- 3:39waiting for better bargains. OK.
- 3:41So they think their stock and maybe everything else is just
- 3:43too, too expensive right now. That seems to be the signal,
- 3:46yes, but it's probably more nuanced than just stock prices
- 3:49being high. This huge cash pile, it kind of
- 3:52rips in two things at once, which are extreme discipline on
- 3:55capital allocation #1 they have a very high bar for investing
- 3:59that money. Right.
- 4:00They won't just spend it for the sake of spending it.
- 4:02Definitely not if they can't find an acquisition or even
- 4:06their own stock trading at a price that promises a better
- 4:10return than just holding super safe short term treasury notes.
- 4:15They'll just hold the cash. They'll just hold the cash.
- 4:17But the second thing it represents is, well, a massive
- 4:20opportunity cost potentially. Because that cash isn't really
- 4:24earning much, especially after inflation.
- 4:26Pretty much. So seeing $381 billion parked
- 4:29mostly in Treasuries, it sends a powerful message.
- 4:32It signals, I think, an extreme level of caution from management
- 4:36about current market valuations, not just in the US, but maybe
- 4:39globally. They're essentially saying
- 4:41nothing looks cheap enough to meet their standards.
- 4:43That seems to be the take away. The price of almost everything
- 4:46is just too rich for them right now.
- 4:48So incredible profit generation, but this reluctance to deploy
- 4:52the resulting cash. Let's maybe unpack the engine
- 4:55itself. How does Berkshire actually make
- 4:58all this money? What are the main parts of the
- 4:59empire? Right.
- 5:00It's important to remember the structure.
- 5:02It's a holding company, a conglomerate.
- 5:05You've got these massive wholly owned subsidiaries.
- 5:08Like GEICO? GEICO, BNA, NSF Railway,
- 5:12Berkshire Hathaway, Energy, Precision Cast parts, dozens and
- 5:15dozens of others, big and small, from sees candies to net jets.
- 5:18And that diversity must provide some stability.
- 5:20Absolutely. If you look at the revenue
- 5:22breakdown, say from 2023 figures, manufacturing and
- 5:26industry is actually the biggest chunk by sales volume.
- 5:29Really. But.
- 5:31Revenue, yeah, it was around 35%, something like $127
- 5:34billion. But insurance, while maybe
- 5:38slightly smaller in revenue, about a quarter $95 billion or
- 5:41so, is arguably more important strategically.
- 5:43Why is that? Because of the float.
- 5:45Right float. Let's quickly explain that for
- 5:48anyone maybe hearing it for the first time.
- 5:49It's basically the insurance premiums they collect upfront.
- 5:52Exactly. It's money they hold
- 5:53temporarily, the premiums collected before they have to
- 5:56pay out any claims later on. And they get to invest that
- 5:59money for their own benefit in the meantime.
- 6:01That's the magic, Buffett calls it the core of Berkshire's
- 6:05well-being and growth. It's like getting paid to hold
- 6:08billions of dollars that technically belong to
- 6:10policyholders, but you get to invest it.
- 6:13It's a massive low cost funding source.
- 6:15And that float combined with just the sheer size of their
- 6:19operations, that creates their famous economic Moat, right?
- 6:23For sure. Think about the scale.
- 6:25Ji ICO insures over 20 million vehicles.
- 6:28Wow. BNSF Railway operates in a
- 6:31sector with incredibly high barriers to entry, essentially a
- 6:34duopoly in US rail freight in many corridors.
- 6:37That scale gives them pricing power efficiency advantages
- 6:40competitors just can't replicate easily.
- 6:42Plus Long live brands discipline management.
- 6:45All contribute to the Moat, yes, but that scale it's a double
- 6:48edged sword now. How so?
- 6:50Well, management's been quite open about it.
- 6:52The company is just so enormous now.
- 6:54Rapid growth is basically off the table.
- 6:56They can't double the company every five years like they used
- 6:58to. Not even close, Buffett himself
- 7:00said doubling it in five years is effectively impossible.
- 7:03They're just too big. Which means only huge
- 7:06multibillion dollar acquisitions could even move the needle
- 7:09significantly, right? And finding those opportunities
- 7:12at prices they deem attractive, well, that brings us back to the
- 7:15$381 billion cash pile. The universe of potential deals
- 7:19is shrinking relative to their firepower.
- 7:22OK, That makes sense. Now shifting gears a bit, let's
- 7:24talk risks beyond market valuations.
- 7:27What are the big headwinds? The report highlights one very
- 7:30immediate 1 succession. Yes, that's definitely top of
- 7:34mind for many observers. The report confirms Warren
- 7:37Buffett plans to step down as CEO by the end of 2025.
- 7:40And Greg Abel, the vice chairman, is set to take over
- 7:43CEO duties. That's the plan.
- 7:45It's been signaled for a while. Abel's the designated successor.
- 7:49But still replacing an icon like Buffett that has to create some
- 7:52market jitters, right? Is the so-called Buffett premium
- 7:56on the stock at risk? That's the $1,000,000 question
- 7:58isn't or maybe the $100 billion question.
- 8:01Abel is incredibly well respected, knows the operations
- 8:03inside out, particularly the non insurance side.
- 8:06But he's not Warren Buffett. He's not Warren Buffett.
- 8:09He doesn't have that singular investing track record or
- 8:13frankly that unique connection with shareholders and the
- 8:15public. So yes, there's definitely short
- 8:18term uncertainty around the transition.
- 8:20How the market digests it remains to be seen.
- 8:22And beyond the succession, what about longer term, more
- 8:26structural risks? The research points to several
- 8:29Climate change is a big one. How does that impact Berkshire
- 8:32directly? Primarily through their
- 8:34insurance and reinsurance businesses.
- 8:36More frequent, more severe weather events mean higher
- 8:39insured losses. It makes modeling risk much,
- 8:42much harder and potentially more costly.
- 8:44OK, that's a big one. What else?
- 8:46Regulatory changes are always a risk for sectors like utilities,
- 8:49energy and rail. And then there's disruptive
- 8:51technology. Like what?
- 8:53Think about insert tech companies trying to chip away at
- 8:55the traditional insurance model. Or maybe more fundamentally down
- 8:59the road, what happens to auto insurance guy Geico's bread and
- 9:03butter when self driving cars become widespread?
- 9:06Yeah, that could completely change the game for auto
- 9:09insurers. It really could.
- 9:11So those are some significant long term challenges to
- 9:13navigate. And internally thinking about
- 9:16managing the current behemoth. The report mentions their cost
- 9:19structure. It's described as largely
- 9:22capital intensive and semi fixed.
- 9:24What does that mean in practice? It means they have massive
- 9:27ongoing costs just to maintain the assets they own.
- 9:31Think about the depreciation on BNSFS, railroad tracks and
- 9:34locomotives, or BH, ES power plants and transmission lines.
- 9:38Plus they carry a lot of debt, so interest payments are
- 9:41significant fixed costs. So big predictable expenses
- 9:45baked into the case. Pretty much, but that doesn't
- 9:47mean they aren't focused on costs they can control.
- 9:49Like at JICO recently, the report mentioned a big
- 9:52improvement in their combined ratio.
- 9:54Yeah, that was partly driven by some aggressive cost cutting.
- 9:56They slashed marketing and overhead spending pretty
- 9:58sharply. And cut head Kel significantly
- 10:00too right? Didn't they drop like 8000
- 10:02employees? That's right.
- 10:04The headcount went from over 38,000 down to about 30,520,
- 10:082023. It's a substantial reduction.
- 10:11Shows that can be tough on costs, but is there a risk
- 10:14there? I mean cutting that Dee
- 10:15esecially in areas like marketing or maybe claims
- 10:18handling, could that hurt the brand or service quality long
- 10:21term? That's always the balancing act,
- 10:23isn't it? You gain short term efficiency,
- 10:25but you might risk long term franchise value or flexibility.
- 10:29The report suggests maybe this was seen internally as trimming
- 10:32fat built up during, say, the pandemic hiring boom.
- 10:35OK. But yeah, it demonstrates A
- 10:37willingness to make tough operational calls.
- 10:39Still, the biggest costs remain those largely unavoidable ones
- 10:43paying out insurance claims and the massive capital needed for
- 10:45the railroad and utilities. Let's loop back to that capital
- 10:48discipline, especially regarding the buybacks or lack thereof 0
- 10:53in Q3. Right.
- 10:54And their policy has always been described as opportunistic.
- 10:57It's not like some companies that just announce a fixed
- 11:00buyback program every quarter. They only buy when they think
- 11:03the price is genuinely attractive.
- 11:04Exactly. There was that sort of informal
- 11:06threshold mentioned back in 2018, buying back stock when it
- 11:10traded at or below maybe 1.2 times book value.
- 11:13And they certainly acted on that in the past.
- 11:15Didn't they buy back a ton of stock in 2020 20?
- 11:17One Oh yeah, huge amounts. Something like $28.7 billion
- 11:22worth in 2021 alone. Which makes the 0 buybacks now
- 11:26in Q32025 even more significant. It really underscores the point.
- 11:31Even with nearly $400 billion burning a hole in their pocket,
- 11:34management looked at their own stock price in Q3 and
- 11:37effectively said Nope, too expensive.
- 11:39That level of discipline, it really speaks to the alignment
- 11:42between management and shareholders, doesn't.
- 11:44It I think it does. And that alignment is baked into
- 11:46the structure. You look, Buffett himself, his
- 11:49personal stake in Bircher stock is what, over $100 billion?
- 11:52Something like that. Yeah, and his salary, it's
- 11:54famously fixed at just $100,000 a year.
- 11:57Yeah, his financial incentives are almost perfectly aligned
- 12:00with long term shareholder value creation, not short term bumps
- 12:04or empire building. And the track record reflects
- 12:06that alignment. Decades of compounding book
- 12:08value per share at, you know, mid teens rates annually.
- 12:12Undeniably, and you even see this alignment play out in
- 12:15shareholder votes sometime. Well, when proposed come up for
- 12:18things management opposes, like certain enhanced climate risk
- 12:21disclosures or specific diversity metrics, they tend to
- 12:24fail, often by wide margins. Even with pressure from ESG
- 12:28groups. Yeah, for instance, a climate
- 12:30reporting proposal in 2021 only got something like 28% support.
- 12:34It shows that the major institutional holders, the
- 12:36vanguards and black rocks of the world, are generally voting with
- 12:39management's more traditional approach.
- 12:41Interesting. SO management long term holders,
- 12:45they seem pretty much on the same page regarding strategy and
- 12:47risk focus. Largely, yes.
- 12:50It creates a very stable long term oriented shareholder base.
- 12:53And looking back, say, over the last decade, 2015 to 2024, the
- 12:57growth story is just relentless, even if the rate is slowing.
- 13:00Absolutely. Total assets roughly doubled in
- 13:02that period. Revenue grew from around $210
- 13:05billion to over $424 billion by 2024.
- 13:09And crucially for today's discussion, that cash balance
- 13:11just kept climbing. It crossed $150 billion back in
- 13:1420 24. And now it's soared past $380
- 13:17billion to become a defining feature.
- 13:19So fundamentally, Berkshire still looks like a classic value
- 13:24investment in many ways, right? Trading at reasonable multiples.
- 13:27Yeah, based on the report, things like the price to
- 13:29earnings ratio were around 16 or 17 times estimated 2025 earnings
- 13:34price to book around 1.5 X recently.
- 13:37Pretty reasonable for a company of its quality and stability.
- 13:40OK. So wrapping things up, if you
- 13:43had to synthesize the core identity, right?
- 13:45Now I'd say it's this incredibly profitable, diverse, capital
- 13:49intensive machine still powerfully fueled by that
- 13:52insurance float, but but it's facing this major internal
- 13:56conflict, generating enormous profits while simultaneously
- 14:00hoarding a record amount of cash because management can't find
- 14:03opportunities, buybacks or acquisitions that meet their
- 14:05strict value criteria or are large enough to matter.
- 14:08The engines running incredibly hot, churning out cash.
- 14:11But the deployment pipeline, the way they usually reinvest that
- 14:13cash, seems almost completely blocked at current market
- 14:17levels. Which leads perfectly into our
- 14:18final thought for the listeners. Right.
- 14:21So here's somebody to chew on you.
- 14:22This company, Berkshire Hathaway, renowned for its
- 14:24discipline, its history of smart, often counter cyclical
- 14:28capital allocation. Now they're sitting on $381.7
- 14:32billion in cash and didn't buy back any stock last quarter.
- 14:36Does that signal extreme caution?
- 14:39Are they essentially telling you that they think market
- 14:41valuations, broadly speaking, are dangerously high and they're
- 14:44waiting for a significant correction?
- 14:46Or is there another possibility? Or is this unprecedented cash
- 14:50hoard simply becoming an unavoidable side effect of
- 14:53Berkshire's sheer size? Have they grown so large that
- 14:56even legendary capital allocators like Buffett and his
- 14:59team are finding it structurally difficult, maybe almost
- 15:01impossible, to deploy capital effectively regardless of market
- 15:05conditions? What is that massive cash pile
- 15:08and the decision not to deploy it tell you about the state of
- 15:10the markets and maybe even the broader economy right now?
- 15:13Something to think about.