Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Industry Strength Heading into 2026 — ACEC Q1 Business Sentiment
Transcript
- 0:32Welcome to the Engineering Influence Podcast from the American Council of Engineering Companies.
- 0:37And today we're talking with Joe Bates, Senior Researcher with the ACEC Research
- 0:41Institute on the new Q1 2026 Engineering Business Sentiment Report,
- 0:49which newly released from the ACEC Research Institute, of course.
- 0:55Q1 2026 coming as the latest on a very long series of quarterly Business Sentiment Reports,
- 1:03where the Institute goes out and interviews CEOs from firms across the country, ACC members,
- 1:12on the current and future expectations they have for the business and the macroeconomy.
- 1:18Joe, thanks again for joining us and to go over this report's results.
- 1:24It's always a pleasure to be here, Jeff. Thanks for having me back.
- 1:28Absolutely. I would love having you. So let's dig in to what we're seeing right now.
- 1:33Right now we're seeing really the takeaway is the industry is coming at 2026,
- 1:40the beginning of the year from a position of strength.
- 1:43Where are you seeing that resiliency coming from?
- 1:47Yeah. So first of all, the top line number is the sentiment regarding the U.S. economy.
- 1:53And that has increased by 11 points, which honestly, I was a little bit surprised.
- 1:59We're at a plus 45 now, and we have only exceeded that last year in the first
- 2:06quarter when there was a lot of optimism around the potentially pro-business
- 2:11administration coming into office.
- 2:13So we are at a level that we really haven't seen since early last year.
- 2:19And it's pretty broad based, but really what's underpinning that are firm finances
- 2:26and their continued resiliency.
- 2:28Even though we've seen perceptions of the economy going up and down really crazy
- 2:34over the last year, firm finances have been very steady.
- 2:38Industry sentiment has been pretty steady as well. And they're both extremely high.
- 2:44So that's really what's underpinning the strength of our industry right now.
- 2:49And the U.S. economy numbers, the reason those went up as much as they did was
- 2:55largely because of the small businesses. and to some degree,
- 2:59medium-sized firms as well.
- 3:01So there's, and that's what I, you know, I always talk about those firms being
- 3:05the canaries in the coal mine. And when they are feeling better,
- 3:09then we really feel more optimistic overall.
- 3:11Yeah, you know, it's interesting because you hear a lot of different reports in the news.
- 3:17You know, you'll turn one channel and the economy is doing gangbusters. We're doing fantastic.
- 3:23You turn another and it's another story. People talk about, you know,
- 3:28wage growth or they talk about just the issue related to tariffs on small businesses.
- 3:34I mean, what are you seeing is really the driver there for the macroeconomic sense?
- 3:39I mean, the jobs numbers that came out were pretty good for the beginning of the year.
- 3:46What's really driving the confidence
- 3:48in the economy and where do you see that going in the near term?
- 3:52I think the confidence in the overall economy, it has gone up and down.
- 3:58And it's very much followed a lot of the political discussions,
- 4:02the political policies that we have.
- 4:05And that is what's driving the top line numbers on the U.S. economy.
- 4:11So it's concern about the U.S.
- 4:14Political environment and general economic concerns are still weighing on the
- 4:21minds of our firm leaders.
- 4:24But I think the other piece of that is that we're getting used to,
- 4:30and I'm not sure this is good or bad, but I'm just saying I feel like we're
- 4:33getting used to a bit more of ups and downs. Yeah, yeah.
- 4:42This, I guess, is just human nature, right? I mean, if you have a bit of uncertainty
- 4:47or you're kind of, it seems like we're riding a roller coaster to an extent.
- 4:52I mean, we haven't had a lot of dips, significant, but a lot of short,
- 4:57you know, bumps in the process here where you see some numbers come up, come down.
- 5:03You see the impact of tariffs and
- 5:05how they're going to be absorbed in the economy. You see the labor rate.
- 5:09You see all these different things. The affordability issue,
- 5:12of course, is becoming really a front burner issue politically leading into
- 5:17the midterms. All that together.
- 5:20We've seen this in the past, though. I mean, from our industry,
- 5:23when things are outside of our industry, there,
- 5:28you know, going at different rates, kind of sputtering, stopping.
- 5:33There's concerns with the recession.
- 5:34There's, you know, whether or not there's going to be, you know,
- 5:38rate hikes at the Fed or is the Fed going to act to, you know, cut rates.
- 5:41There's a lot of instability out there, but our industry seems to have.
- 5:45Has shown over time to weather these external events very well,
- 5:50and it's almost like they're buffered from.
- 5:52Yeah, I think that's a really good takeaway from the entirety of our series,
- 5:57which we've been doing now for almost five years, is that we have seen a lot
- 6:02of different external factors that are affecting the overall U.S. economy.
- 6:07But when we look at our concerns about, or rather optimism about the industry
- 6:13itself, it's always been very strong.
- 6:16And when we ask about how is your firm itself doing, very, very strong numbers.
- 6:21So I think when we look at the future sentiment, that's really colored by these outside influences.
- 6:29But as you know, we have now for four and a half years been concerned about
- 6:35the future. But every time the future comes, we're feeling fine.
- 6:40So we are, I think, in a uniquely stable and growing industry.
- 6:48And part of that is in the data we collect that we don't have enough people
- 6:55to fill all the jobs, honestly.
- 6:57And so we have very healthy backlog.
- 7:00It's not too much, right? I mean, firms are managing their backlogs appropriately.
- 7:05If anything, they're not taking on projects that they know we just can't do
- 7:09it right now. But if we had more workforce, and we see that in this study, firms are still hiring.
- 7:19They're still expecting to hire more people in the future.
- 7:23There seems to be no end in sight to a labor need within our industry.
- 7:30Yeah, that has always been a constant throughout the last few quarters,
- 7:37has been the labor issue.
- 7:39Do you see any signs of easing? Has there been any noticeable change in the
- 7:45amount of open seats and kind of how firms are expected to fill or look for
- 7:54additional labor to do these projects?
- 7:57Yeah, you know, we have not really seen any change in the number of open positions.
- 8:02Very little, I should say. So still nine out of 10 firms have open positions.
- 8:08We've seen the total number of vacancies come down a little bit,
- 8:14but we still have more vacancies than we can fill. and people perceive that
- 8:21that will continue to change.
- 8:22But there is some good news, I think, in this quarter for firms.
- 8:27And that is that the wages that they are paying to keep their employees as well
- 8:33as to hire new employees, the increase year-over-year has come down just a little bit.
- 8:41So you remember when we first started tracking this about four years ago,
- 8:4510% year-over-year increases in wages, and that was pretty hard for firms.
- 8:51We're now down to about 7% for existing staff and 6% for new hires.
- 8:58I mean, it's not as great as it could be.
- 9:01We're still seeing pretty strong advances and increases there,
- 9:06but it's definitely better than those double-digit increases that we were seeing.
- 9:11Which is a good signal. I mean, deflationary pressure on wages is good for firm leaders, of course.
- 9:19I mean, I remember post-pandemic, it was really astronomically high.
- 9:26And seeing that will alleviate some pressure, definitely.
- 9:30Is there a larger concern on just the direction of federal policy and,
- 9:36you know, how that might have an impact on,
- 9:41you know, not looking long term, but like the next quarter, you know,
- 9:45Q2 and what, you know, we're doing right now in Washington related to,
- 9:50you know, any number of things really.
- 9:52But, I mean, it's become an issue where, you know, we're going from shutdown
- 9:57to shutdown. We're looking at doing a surface bill this year.
- 10:00That could definitely benefit the industry.
- 10:02I mean, that has a timestamp on it.
- 10:06The programs will expire if they're not extended or if we don't have a new bill
- 10:10in place by a date certain.
- 10:12You know, what's happening from a federal policy standpoint that could impact
- 10:16the industry? Yeah, you know, that's, I think, really interesting point here
- 10:20that we ask at the beginning of each year.
- 10:23So in Q1, what are your big concerns about the year ahead?
- 10:27And of course, we're still seeing wage concerns, which we just talked about.
- 10:31Although those concerns have definitely lessened, but they're still the top concerns.
- 10:35But after that, it's disruptions due to funding lapses or, you know, government shutdowns.
- 10:44And that's, you know, we haven't asked that in the past because it wasn't an
- 10:48issue in the past, but it's near the top of the list.
- 10:52And I think it's a real concern for firms that, especially firms that are working
- 10:58with public sector clients.
- 11:00Are these continued shutdowns, the uncertainty about whether we're going to
- 11:05have shutdowns, the uncertainty about what's happening with government funding,
- 11:09that seems to be bubbling up a little bit more to the surface.
- 11:13It's, again, not the number one issue, but it is definitely a concern for a
- 11:17lot of firm leaders right now.
- 11:19It would be interesting to see in
- 11:21future surveys and to ask that question because it seems that, you know,
- 11:27the time between, you know, when this survey went in to the field and as we
- 11:33started gathering, I mean,
- 11:34the results, I mean, we're seeing, if not full government shutdowns,
- 11:39we're seeing departmental shutdowns as we speak right now, DHS,
- 11:43aspects of DHS are now, you know, under a shutdown. Yeah.
- 11:47Whether or not that volatility and willingness, it seems, by policymakers,
- 11:53lawmakers on both sides ends of Pennsylvania Avenue to allow a shutdown to happen,
- 11:58how is that going to have an impact on how the firms look at the macroeconomy
- 12:05moving forward? It'll be an interesting question to ask.
- 12:08Yeah, and I think it is more of an issue of that perception of what's happening
- 12:12with the economy overall.
- 12:14I think firms, by and large, understand that the shutdowns will be temporary,
- 12:20that funding will be there,
- 12:22but it causes a lot of disruption and it does concern firm leaders and understandably so.
- 12:29Well, one area that you've asked about beforehand in previous surveys and something
- 12:34that the Institute's working on,
- 12:36on a more broader strategic mission with part of the Firm of the Future program
- 12:42that you're working on, is, of course, AI adoption.
- 12:44And this is something which, of course, has been a hot topic for the industry for a while now.
- 12:50But I think that this survey kind of showed a pivot point maybe or a high watermark
- 12:57in firm adoption and implementation of AI. Could you go into that a little bit?
- 13:03Yeah, this has been really interesting. I was pretty surprised,
- 13:06Jeff, but I think we have hit an inflection point, at least with firms realizing they need a strategy.
- 13:14And that's the first place you have to start, right? You have to create a strategy.
- 13:18You have to map out how you're going to address AI, how you want to implement,
- 13:24how you want to think about implementing.
- 13:27So this is a really, it's nuanced, right?
- 13:30So what we saw in this quarter is that almost a majority of firms now have an AI strategy in place,
- 13:38and that's up 20 points from when we first started conducting the research on
- 13:44that question a couple of years ago.
- 13:46So that is really, really good news. And the percentage of firms that haven't
- 13:50even started is really low now.
- 13:53It's a minority, and it's a smaller and smaller minority. So I think our messaging,
- 13:59as well as just the reality of AI and the effect it's having on businesses, is working.
- 14:06Firms are realizing, OK, we've got to at least have a strategy in place.
- 14:10But the nuance is that in the fourth quarter of last year, we asked about implementation
- 14:15and still the vast majority of firms are testing the waters.
- 14:22There are only a small percentage of firms who are really moving full force
- 14:27into widespread implementation.
- 14:29And that makes sense. I mean, again, first you have to have your strategy in place.
- 14:34Then you have to start figuring out where you're going to test,
- 14:36where you're going to have your pilot projects. You have to have those things
- 14:40actually go get in place and see how they work out.
- 14:43And then you start to spread, you know, implementation farther.
- 14:47So the good news is we're seeing movement. And that is very,
- 14:52very encouraging compared to where we were one and two years ago.
- 14:56Yeah, it's been interesting to see how this has developed because at the beginning,
- 14:59it was kind of the shadow looming over all industries.
- 15:03You know, what AI is and how it could disrupt things. that has kind of crystallized
- 15:10into firms, you know, some of them getting out of the gate early and putting
- 15:15in the strategy to deal with it.
- 15:17Now we're seeing a plurality of firms actually putting in a strategy,
- 15:22you know, 47% in this survey, having a strategy, and then, you know, you have,
- 15:3082% of firms over 500 FTEs who have an AI policy in place.
- 15:36And then another interesting statistic was the average workforce adaptability
- 15:41of 58%. Now, explain that a little bit more.
- 15:46Yeah, this was a really interesting question that, you know,
- 15:50one of our members actually suggested we ask.
- 15:52And I thought it was a great question. So one of our members said,
- 15:56hey, we'd love to know how well prepared our staff.
- 16:00So we asked the question, and I'm paraphrasing, but how well do you think your
- 16:05staff are adapted or what percentage of your staff do you feel have the necessary
- 16:12capabilities to adapt to these coming changes?
- 16:17And so to see at least, you know, almost 60% of staff being ready to adapt to
- 16:24changes, I thought that was encouraging.
- 16:26I mean, we would love to be at 100%, but, you know, having more than half of
- 16:32staff being ready, I think that's really good.
- 16:35So I was very happy to see that. But one point I want to go back to is that
- 16:40we are still seeing small firms, the smallest firms with fewer than 25 FTE,
- 16:45they're still lagging a bit in creating strategies, figuring out how to address AI going forward.
- 16:52And so I think we have to continue to place emphasis in helping smaller firms
- 16:57prepare for the AI revolution that we see coming.
- 17:02Yeah, that's an interesting point. I think that there's a lot that's happening
- 17:05on the ACEC side of things.
- 17:07The technology committee doing work, trying to get that, really that broad-based
- 17:12level of support throughout the industry for AI adoption and implementation,
- 17:17especially with the smaller firms.
- 17:18I think that, you know, there's a very low barrier of entry when it comes to AI.
- 17:24The problem is implementing it correctly, and that's where we need to come in and help.
- 17:30Yeah, I think so. You know, we talk about the firm of the future and all the
- 17:34work we're doing on the firm of the future initiatives.
- 17:37And we're doing a lot of interviews right now with some of the leading firms
- 17:42as well as the leading suppliers about how AI is going to come together with
- 17:47the workforce challenges of the future and the needs of the workforce.
- 17:52What does that mean? And what I'm hearing in these interviews consistently.
- 17:58Time and time again, is that small firms are not at a disadvantage,
- 18:03that there are tools that can be used to help democratize the playing field.
- 18:11And it really is a matter of having the time because obviously a small firm
- 18:16doesn't have as many people,
- 18:17but having the time, taking the time and dedicating some resources to figuring
- 18:23out how to utilize AI to benefit the firm because it can make a big difference.
- 18:28I've heard, you know, experts talk about the fact that they see a future where
- 18:33a 10-person firm can compete with a 200-person firm if they're properly utilizing AI.
- 18:40So that really, that's a game changer in my book.
- 18:43It is, and there is research that the Institute's put out there about AI and
- 18:47its impact on firms and how firms are approaching it, which is available up on the website.
- 18:53And then, of course, from the future, new AI study and a new workforce study,
- 18:57and then working on the synthesis of those two studies and seeing how those
- 19:02two items are interacting and impacting the industry. That's a project that's ongoing.
- 19:09You know, Joe, give us a little bit more about that and kind of what else the
- 19:13Institute's working on.
- 19:15Yeah, so that study that you're talking about, we are working on in conjunction
- 19:19with Mike Walsh, who is a futurist.
- 19:21He will be compiling a report on that. We'll be releasing that at Spring Convention in May.
- 19:27He'll also be doing a short intro video for us. So if you're there at Spring
- 19:32Convention, you'll see that on the main stage.
- 19:34And then I'll be talking about a few of the highlights from that finding or
- 19:38the findings from that study, rather.
- 19:40And we're going to have a breakout session at convention about that study.
- 19:44And this is really meant to take the ideas, what could be, and provide a more
- 19:52concrete set of initiatives or roadmap that any firm can take.
- 19:59And maybe it will be different for smaller firms versus midsize and large firms.
- 20:04But the idea is to create a resource document that will help firms to start
- 20:09to implement, not just create strategies now, but start implementing AI.
- 20:14So that's a big thing we're working on this spring.
- 20:16We're also working on a value-based pricing study because obviously AI changes
- 20:23the nature of the work that an engineering firm is going to do.
- 20:27And you can't really build by the hour anymore.
- 20:30You're investing in this technology that is a force multiplier.
- 20:33And you have to start to figure out how can you capture the value of your services?
- 20:39And are there other services you can provide with AI that you couldn't provide before?
- 20:44So that's going to be coming over the summer. And then we're also looking at what's the risk of AI?
- 20:50Where do you need to be looking within your firm in all different areas,
- 20:55you know, legal, HR, engineering itself?
- 20:58You know, what are the risks associated with AI and how can you mitigate those risks?
- 21:04How can you adapt to those risks?
- 21:07So we've got a lot going on this year, Jeff, and that's just the first half.
- 21:12It's going to be a very busy year for the Institute.
- 21:16So, Joe, I appreciate you taking the time out to go into depth on some of the results.
- 21:23Encourage everyone to click on the link in the show notes that will take you to Q1.
- 21:29Also on the Institute website, you can, to Joe's point, you know,
- 21:32we've been doing years of these, multiple quarters.
- 21:36You can take a look at some historical data, all available on the Institute's
- 21:41website. Joe, thanks again.