Latest / The So What? / US, China, South Africa: Quo Vadis?
Transcript
- 0:05Hello and welcome to the So What Podcast, in
- 0:08which political economic analyst J .P. Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of
- 0:13South Africans. You can find a written version
- 0:16of this content on J .P.'s website, jpluntman
- 0:19.co .za. I am Ruda Landman, and I am your host.
- 0:25The So What Podcast goes with J .P.'s newsletter,
- 0:30which you can find on his website. This one is
- 0:33dated the 20th of March, 2026. And the title
- 0:37is US, China, South Africa, Corvadas. With the
- 0:42whole world focused on the Middle East, what
- 0:45draws your attention to this discussion? Indeed,
- 0:49and two things happened. The one was, which was
- 0:52very well covered in the media, the comments
- 0:54that the new US ambassador to South Africa, Mr.
- 0:58Boesel, made, which, as I said, enjoyed a lot
- 1:00of media coverage. And then a statement which
- 1:03was made by President Xi Jinping in Beijing,
- 1:06which attracted a lot less coverage. And so...
- 1:11Those are the two things that spurred me on to
- 1:13focus on this topic. Now, to discuss this topic,
- 1:16I think we must first take a step back and go
- 1:1914 years back in history to 2012 when the National
- 1:24Development Plan was released. by the then National
- 1:28Planning Commission, chaired by then Minister
- 1:31Trevor Manuel. And essentially what the National
- 1:35Development Plan postulated in 2012 was that
- 1:39power is shifting from the West to the East and
- 1:42that South Africa must position itself accordingly.
- 1:45Now, you may well ask, what does that mean? And
- 1:48I think the meaning is that you've got to maintain
- 1:50relations with the old, but also develop relations
- 1:53with the new. So you've got friends in the West.
- 1:56maintain those relations, but there are new powers
- 1:59coming up in the East and develop new relations
- 2:02with them. That was long before it was anything
- 2:06near as clear as it is now. No, absolutely. Almost
- 2:09a decade and a half ago. And what has happened
- 2:12over this decade and a half is that South Africa's
- 2:16trade, South Africa's exports have followed that
- 2:19trajectory. Today, as in 2025, 35 % of our exports
- 2:24go to Asia. Now, Asia includes China, of course,
- 2:27India, but also other countries. 25 % of our
- 2:30exports go to the European Union, 25 % goes into
- 2:34Africa, and the remainder, 8%, goes to North
- 2:38America, 4 % to the Middle East, and 3 % to South
- 2:41America and Australasia. So you can see that
- 2:44our trade has already shifted along the lines
- 2:47that a national development plan postulated 14,
- 2:51almost 15 years ago. Now, I think what is important
- 2:54to do is to appreciate that. When we say South
- 2:58Africa exports to China or South Africa exports
- 3:00to the EU, in a sense it's nonsense because it
- 3:04is not the countries of Africa that are exporting.
- 3:06It's not the government. It's not a central agency
- 3:08that collects all the exports and takes them
- 3:11out. It is hundreds if not thousands of individual
- 3:14businesses, some of them small craft makers,
- 3:17some of them big mines, some of them big factories.
- 3:20It's a range of individual businesses and enterprises
- 3:23that take these export decisions. And their decisions
- 3:27over time has added up to the numbers that I
- 3:30quote. And I think that's a very important point.
- 3:32It's individual businesses taking decisions.
- 3:35What was President Xi Jinping's announcement?
- 3:39It's a very interesting announcement. On the
- 3:4112th of February, he announced that in future,
- 3:44from the 1st of May, 2026, all tariffs on all
- 3:49products from all African countries are scrapped,
- 3:52made null. The only exception is Eswatini because
- 3:57Eswatini recognizes Taiwan. But all other countries
- 4:01in Africa can now export tariff -free into China.
- 4:05What are we paying at the moment? It varies.
- 4:07On some products, it's null. But in general,
- 4:10the tariffs that South Africa pay on exports
- 4:13into China is between 10 % and 25%. So it's a
- 4:17big change that is being made. At the moment,
- 4:21the estimate is that about 8 ,940 product lines
- 4:26will go into China data -free. It's a huge announcement
- 4:30for the exporters of this country. Are you seeing
- 4:33other indications on the ground of the rising
- 4:37importance of China? Oh yes, absolutely, particularly
- 4:39in the motor industry. You would have seen that
- 4:42Nissan, it's been in South Africa for many years,
- 4:45is closing its factory that it has in Tswane,
- 4:48but the factory and the staff. will be taken
- 4:51over by Chedi, the Chinese company. So you're
- 4:54just replacing one manufacturer with another
- 4:56and production carries on with of course different
- 4:59products. The other announcement was subsequent
- 5:02to that was the Great Wall Motor Company, GWM.
- 5:06they revealed that they are talking to Mercedes
- 5:08-Benz to use the Mercedes -Benz factory in East
- 5:11London for the production of GWM products. Now,
- 5:15they haven't made a deal yet. They made that
- 5:18clear. And they're also talking to other parties.
- 5:21But it is possible that a deal may, kind of a
- 5:23sharing deal may be concluded. Now, what is interesting
- 5:27here is that an old hand in the motor industry
- 5:29told me that when he bought his first car many
- 5:32years ago, it was an Alfa. And the Alfa was manufactured
- 5:35in that Mercedes -Benz factory in East London.
- 5:38So sharing is not a new idea. And it looks as
- 5:41if the Great Wall Motor Company is looking at
- 5:44that. And what about exports to America? What's
- 5:48happening there in the meantime? Well, as you
- 5:50know, America has levied a 25 % tariff on automotive
- 5:54exports. That's this week. It might be different
- 5:57next week. Indeed. 25 % duty on exports into
- 6:02America. Now, that, of course, must hit the Mercedes
- 6:05-Benz factory in East London really hard because
- 6:08they produce the C180 Mercedes for export into
- 6:12the US. And one can only assume that those exports
- 6:15are taking a knock. And for them, therefore,
- 6:18it will make sense to share the factory with
- 6:20the great Walmart company. So our trade with
- 6:24China is very definitely on an upward trajectory.
- 6:28What's happening with the US? I think you've
- 6:30just started to indicate that that's going down.
- 6:35No, indeed. We don't have the latest numbers
- 6:38yet. We'll only get it in due course. But look,
- 6:40the trend, I think, is clear. First of all, President
- 6:44Trump believes in tariffs. He has believed in
- 6:47them for many, many years, and it's a fundamental
- 6:49part of his thinking. So he has imposed tariffs
- 6:52on the whole world, friend and foe. Whether you
- 6:55were a friend of the United States or an enemy
- 6:57of the United States, you got tariffs. In fact,
- 7:00it looks as if some enemies like the USSR or
- 7:04Russia, rather, and China were treated more benignly
- 7:08than some of his friends. some of the loyal friends
- 7:13over many years. But be that as it may, he levied
- 7:16tariffs on all of them. Even countries that have
- 7:19succeeded in negotiating a trade agreement with
- 7:22the US. are levied with tariffs. They had to
- 7:25agree to tariffs in order to get the agreement
- 7:27with the US. So I think we must accept that US
- 7:32tariffs on exports or imports from the world,
- 7:36exports from the rest of the world into the US,
- 7:39will remain under tariffs in one way or another,
- 7:43certainly as long as Trump is around, and I think
- 7:46even after him. And the reason I say that is
- 7:49we know from history that tariffs are very sticky.
- 7:53Once you've put them into place, it's very, very
- 7:55difficult to get rid of them. Because tariffs
- 7:57create beneficiaries and they create advantages
- 7:59for some classes of people. And those people
- 8:02will fight like hell to retain them. So tariffs
- 8:05are sticky. And I think we can accept that they
- 8:07will stay with us. Some of our exports are exempt
- 8:12from the tariffs, though. About half are exempt
- 8:14from tariffs. You're quite right. It's mainly
- 8:16minerals as well as citrus. So clearly, Mr. Trump
- 8:20would like to have those products at a cheaper
- 8:21price and not a price plus tariff. That's how
- 8:25it is in the moment. So South Africa has tabled
- 8:27a draft agreement, trade agreement with the US.
- 8:31We're keen to negotiate one. That agreement was
- 8:36tabled last May already. So it's almost a year
- 8:38ago. And since then, there's been no public progress.
- 8:42Maybe there has been progress in private, but
- 8:44it doesn't look like it. In January this year,
- 8:47when he was in Davos, our trade minister, Park
- 8:50Stau. revealed that we're still waiting for the
- 8:53Americans to give us dates for meetings to take
- 8:56place. Now, apparently, I understand that recently,
- 8:59in the last week or 10 days, meetings have been
- 9:02arranged, but whether anything will come of it,
- 9:05we'll have to wait and see. I'm very doubtful.
- 9:07I will not hold my breath, simply because the
- 9:11Americans have now introduced five preconditions,
- 9:14which are non -trade conditions that must go
- 9:17into a trade agreement. And this was clearly
- 9:20spelled out by Ambassador Boesel in his speech
- 9:23in South Africa. And they relate to expropriation,
- 9:27farm murders, B .E., kill the Boer chant, as
- 9:31well as geopolitical alignment. The ambassadors
- 9:33made it clear that the U .S. is not going to
- 9:36look at anything if it doesn't accommodate these
- 9:39five demands. On the other hand, it's quite clear
- 9:42that the five demands are politically impossible
- 9:44and they really are an attack on the sovereignty
- 9:47of South Africa. So I don't see much room here
- 9:51for a trade agreement, unless the Americans give
- 9:54way, which is not impossible. But I don't think
- 9:58there's a chance for an agreement to come into
- 9:59existence. So we will have to live with whatever
- 10:02tariffs the U .S. wants to impose. What about
- 10:06AGOA? AGOA is dead. People constantly refer back
- 10:10to it. The reality is simple. AGOA expired in
- 10:13September last year. In February, it was renewed,
- 10:17but it's only renewed until the end of 2026.
- 10:19It's now already March, so you only have about
- 10:22nine months left. In any case, the tariffs that
- 10:27Trump has levied... overtake or override AGOA.
- 10:31So, for example, the general 10 % tariff on air
- 10:35exports, that overrides AGOA. The 25 % tariff
- 10:38on automotives and automotive products, that
- 10:41overrides AGOA. So AGOA, for all practical purposes,
- 10:45is dead. And certainly after 2026, it will be
- 10:49completely dead. So I don't pay any attention
- 10:53to AGOA as a means of regulating trade. But then
- 10:57you say, in the meantime, as you put it, life
- 11:00carries on. What do you mean? Life carries on
- 11:03in the sense that there are currently more than
- 11:04500, some estimates say 600, US companies operating
- 11:09in South Africa. That's a large number of companies.
- 11:12And presumably they won't operate here if they
- 11:15don't make money, if it's not to their benefit.
- 11:17So they carry on. They make money. They're happy.
- 11:20They comply with BE legislation and so on. And
- 11:23they live with whatever the problems and constraints
- 11:26are in South Africa. And it looks as if more
- 11:29companies keep on coming. I mean, just in the
- 11:31last week. The big IT company, IT servicing company,
- 11:36Spinnaker, announced that they are operating,
- 11:38opening an office in South Africa in partnership
- 11:41with Patrice Motsepi's ARC, African Rainbow Capital.
- 11:46It's a middle -sized company, but it's taking
- 11:49on other people operating in the South African
- 11:52market, bringing competition. Secondly, there's
- 11:55a U .S. company called Rainbow Minerals, not
- 11:58to be confused with Mozepe's Rainbow Minerals,
- 12:01and they are testing it at the laboratories at
- 12:05Mintec in Randberg to extract rare earths from
- 12:09the soda ash at Palaborba. That's quite an important
- 12:13project, rare earths for the U .S. And lastly,
- 12:16Amazon, in direct competition with Starlink,
- 12:19is preparing to launch its own low -Earth orbit
- 12:22satellites with South African partners that are
- 12:25locally licensed. So Starlink is not the only
- 12:29low -Earth orbit satellite provider. Others are
- 12:33there too, and they're making their services
- 12:35available. So it is the same as with exports.
- 12:38Individual companies take decisions and they
- 12:40carry on with their business. They want to export
- 12:42to a country, they will do that. They want to
- 12:45open business, they will do that. And that's
- 12:46what we're seeing here. What's happening between
- 12:49us and the EU and the UK? Well, very interesting.
- 12:54It's beyond the scope of this note, but I think
- 12:57one should just note that, as I've said, the
- 12:59EU takes 25 % of our exports. We've now, in the
- 13:04last year, in 2025, towards the end of the year,
- 13:07we've signed three agreements with them. One
- 13:10is a clean energy and investment agreement. A
- 13:13second one is on rare earth minerals. and how
- 13:17one has to deal with that. And the third one
- 13:20is a comprehensive package of project totaling
- 13:24about 12 billion euros, which is a lot of money.
- 13:27So these three agreements were signed in the
- 13:29latter half of last year, and our trade with
- 13:32the EU will just carry on. There are at the moment
- 13:35about 1 ,000. EU and UK companies operating in
- 13:39South Africa. Compare that to the 600, 500 to
- 13:42600 from the US. And it gives you an indication
- 13:44of how strong our trade relations with the EU
- 13:47are. And it will probably expand. I think that's
- 13:50the way it's going. So what? Well, I think the
- 13:55first so what is that the question I ask in the
- 13:57topic, in the title of this piece, South Africa,
- 14:01US, China, Quo Vadis, where to? I think the answer
- 14:05to the Kuwaitis question is that there's a big
- 14:08repositioning taking place. And this repositioning
- 14:11was predicted as long ago already as in 2012.
- 14:14So in that sense, it's not new. And we've seen
- 14:17how our trade has changed to accommodate that.
- 14:21So it is not a new development, but I think it's
- 14:24a very decisive development. I think the other
- 14:26so what is that the contrast between the way
- 14:29that China approaches South Africa. and the whole
- 14:32of Africa, for that matter, and the way that
- 14:33China and the way that the U .S. approaches South
- 14:36Africa is very, very different. And you can only
- 14:41draw your own conclusions as to how that will
- 14:44affect trade going forward. Likewise, the EU
- 14:48and South Africa are moving closer together,
- 14:50and the trade and investment on that front will
- 14:52probably also increase. I think the other so
- 14:56-what -to -do is that The United States and its
- 15:01Margo supporters here in South Africa will have
- 15:04to accept that the problems in this country,
- 15:06whether it's expropriation or crime or whatever,
- 15:10will be solved by the people of this country.
- 15:13It will be solved through executive action, through
- 15:16political negotiations and through the courts.
- 15:18It is not going to be solved by outside diktat.
- 15:22Trump is not going to rush in on Air Force One.
- 15:25and tell the country what to do. That's not going
- 15:27to happen. So those problems must be sorted out
- 15:30here. And people will have to accept that. I
- 15:35think it's very sad that the US policy towards
- 15:37South Africa has been captured by the Afrikaner
- 15:41genocide narrative. That brings distortions which
- 15:44are not good for the relationship. And they will
- 15:47have to work through that. So many people say...
- 15:51We were at fault in our relationship with the
- 15:54US and that's why they are so nasty towards us,
- 15:57President Trump specifically. I don't buy that
- 16:01at all. I think it is true that South Africa
- 16:03has neglected the relationship. We haven't had
- 16:06good, efficient ambassadors there. The last one
- 16:10was Ibrahim Rasool in his first term, which ended
- 16:12in 2014, I think. You'll recall when we were
- 16:15in the US in 2013 -14, Rasul was regarded as
- 16:19one of the most effective ambassadors. His second
- 16:22term, of course, didn't work out like that. But
- 16:24after Rasul, we haven't again had effective diplomacy
- 16:28in the US. So in that sense, it's true. But no,
- 16:31I don't think it's our fault. Trump made it clear
- 16:33that very good, loyal friends like Japan, like
- 16:36South Korea, like Canada, they all got a kick
- 16:39in the butt or a kick in the face, should I rather
- 16:42say. That is what Trump, that's his style. That's
- 16:45what he's doing with tariffs. So, no, I don't
- 16:47think it's our fault. We have the right to decide
- 16:49how we run our affairs here inside the country,
- 16:52just as the Americans have got the right to decide
- 16:55theirs. We don't criticize their domestic policies
- 16:58or, for that matter, their foreign policies,
- 17:00like the current war in Iran, for example. So,
- 17:04no, I don't buy the argument it's our fault.
- 17:07The furthest I would go is to say that we've
- 17:09neglected the relationship and we've got to rebuild
- 17:11it. Whether you can rebuild it with this kind
- 17:14of attitude remains to be seen. My late father
- 17:16always said, you can only do business with a
- 17:18man who wants to do business. And we'll have
- 17:21to see whether the US wants to do business. A
- 17:24last comment on the impact of the war, the Middle
- 17:27East war? Well, I think it's extremely serious
- 17:29and it's quite clear what it's doing to the world.
- 17:32It'll be bad for everybody, also for South Africa.
- 17:36And I think what the war also underscores is
- 17:40the fact that power is shifting. Who would have
- 17:43thought that a country like Iran, which is really
- 17:46a middle size to small power, can exert the influence
- 17:50that it does. So power is shifting and it's important
- 17:54that we stay abreast of that. Thank you very
- 17:57much. Thank you. And to our listeners, go well
- 18:00until the next time. Thank you for listening
- 18:05to the So What Podcast. If you enjoy this content,
- 18:08please don't forget to leave a review and a rating,
- 18:11and please consider subscribing so you don't
- 18:14miss any future episodes. Also, tell your friends.
- 18:17Remember, you can find a written version of all
- 18:20JP's content at jplandman .co .za.