Latest / Word Balloon Comics Podcast / Matt Singer Talks Movies TV and his Siskel Ebert Book
Transcript
- 0:01Hi, everybody, Welcome back to Word Below, the Comic Conversation show.
- 0:06John Centris. Here, my buddy, Matt Singer, the movie critic is
- 0:08here. Opposable Thumbs is a brand new book that he has clever title.
- 0:14And if you're thinking movies and thumbs, you're probably thinking of Gene Siskel and
- 0:19Roger Ebert, the battling movie critics of Chicago that made a big splash nationally
- 0:25and as Matt points out in his book, really changed the way we think
- 0:29about movie criticism. They were stars. There were big movie critics before their
- 0:35time and certainly since their time, but Gene and Roger arguing about movies as
- 0:40they did on television and in their respective columns Ebert at the Chicago Sun Times
- 0:47Ciscle at the Chicago Tribune, really made a mark on film criticism. I
- 0:51absolutely encourage you to go on YouTube and look at their critiques of some great
- 0:58movies and even little movies. And really I can attest for myself as a
- 1:03Chicago in all my life followed these guys in print and on TV, and
- 1:07their words meant a lot. If there was a little movie that I became
- 1:11aware of and through their columns, I would end up going to see them
- 1:17at my dinner with Andre Diner come to mind as little movies I would have
- 1:21blown off if not reading the right criticism and hearing the right criticism on their
- 1:26TV reviews. So this is a great book. Matt is also here because
- 1:30he does a great job at Screen Crush. I say Indy Wire and he
- 1:34was there, but now at screen Crush game on me. You'll hear my
- 1:38embarrassment when I identify him as a Indy Wire guy. But he is the
- 1:44main guy at screen Crush and does a great job there. Not only is
- 1:48Matt writing and blogging about films, he did a great book about Spider Man
- 1:52a couple of years ago. And also I just want to get his opinion
- 1:56of what's going on with DC and Marvel as far as the TV in film
- 2:00business, are we at an oversaturation point? I don't think, you know.
- 2:06Again, I just think it's a lack of creativity and it's something we
- 2:08discuss in the final part of our discussion. But regardless of great talk with
- 2:14Matt Singer about Ciskell Ebert and Nerd film and television culture. On today's Word
- 2:20Balloon, Wordvillain is also brought to you by my league, the League of
- 2:23word Balloon Listeners, the loyal listeners of word Balloon who also subscribe to word
- 2:29Balloon via Patreon, Patreon dot com slash word Balloon. Wordvallain is free,
- 2:35It'll always be free. I always say that, and I mean it.
- 2:37But if you appreciate what I do here and if word Balloon is worth I
- 2:40don't know the price of a comic book to you a month, I hope
- 2:44you think so. I like to present not only what I'm doing today,
- 2:47but in all my episodes, the great in depth conversations with pop culture creatives
- 2:53and really get insight and find out what makes them tick beyond whatever book they're
- 2:58selling or property they're selling at the moment. It's always great to learn about
- 3:00these people beyond their work, and that's what I try to do with every
- 3:05episode of word Balloon. So if you can do it, if you can
- 3:07spare the money. Patreon dot com slash word Balloon, thank you as always
- 3:13for your support, League of word Balloon Listeners. Word Balloon is brought to
- 3:17you by Alex Ross Art alex rossart dot com. That's the website for the
- 3:23iconic artist that gives us incredible images that are indelible and a lot of times
- 3:29historic. Alex has been doing this for a long time and doing nothing but
- 3:34excellent A grade work. I know. I remember when Alex was just getting
- 3:38started years ago doing things like Terminator, the Burning Earth and even the Green
- 3:44Hornet covers. That was a long time ago. Since then, he has
- 3:47established incredible relationships with DC, Marvel, all the big publishers, all the
- 3:52big characters. Not only that, but incredible art as well of images like
- 3:59the Beatles, the Monkeys, David Bowie, Money, Python, you name
- 4:02it. And the great thing is, if you go to Alex ross art
- 4:04dot com you will find fantastic art that is affordable to high scale covers,
- 4:11process pages, interior pages, all of that at wonderful prices. But literally
- 4:18if you can only afford a poster Alex as you covered. If you're a
- 4:21high end art person that appreciates lithographs and original art, Alex as you covered
- 4:30Alex Rossart dot com. Welcome back, everybody. It's time again for word
- 4:34Balloon, the Comic Book Conversation Show. John Stuntriss here happy to welcome my
- 4:40buddy Matt Singer back to word Balloon. Movie critic The Man at Oh,
- 4:45I hope I get this right, Indie wire right, Matt, motherfucker,
- 4:48goddamn it, Matt, I'm sorry, hold on half the second. I
- 4:54haven't been on you are in like a decade, all right, Shame on,
- 4:58ladies and gentlemen. From the Cargo American Journal, one of William Randolph's
- 5:01finest papers. It's Matt Singer. I'm sorry, Matt. Where where where
- 5:05is your greenrush screen crush? God damn it. I've always said what I
- 5:11love about you, John, is you do your research, You prepared,
- 5:14you know on the p Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, Well I
- 5:20will do my damn this not to make more mistakes. Uh, Matt,
- 5:24you've written this incredible book, opposable thumbs. Uh. It's all about Cisco
- 5:30and Ebert, and I completely agree with your subtitle. These men changed how
- 5:35people watch movies and really elevated the art of movie movie criticism. And it's
- 5:41not like they started in this vast wasteland of a film criticism that reached a
- 5:47national literate audience. I mean we did have. We did have. Certainly,
- 5:51Rex Read was around. Pauline Kale was another great name at both East
- 5:57Coast names and stuff. But there was a common Man touch my perspective and
- 6:01probably yours when it came to Jean and Roger. Yeah, I think that's
- 6:06right. I mean, there was wonderful film critics before Jeene Siskel and Roger
- 6:11Ebert, and there are you know, wonderful critics today at Indy Wire and
- 6:17other venues obviously, and I agree, I think the common Man touch.
- 6:25I think that's a nice way of putting it. I mean, I certainly
- 6:29they had a very accessible show, and that was part of the appeal to
- 6:33me when I was watching it. You know, when I was twelve thirteen
- 6:36years old, when I really fell in love with the show was that it
- 6:40was accessible and I didn't know Jack Diddeley squat about movies and film criticism at
- 6:46that time. And I never felt watching the show at that time that you
- 6:53know, I didn't feel excluded or that I didn't belong or that I,
- 6:57oh, I'm not smart enough or I don't know enough about movies to watch
- 7:00the show. They always it was a very welcoming show, and it was.
- 7:08Yeah, it was accessible to a lot of different people. You did
- 7:11not have to be a expert in the film criticism to enjoy Ciskel and Ebert,
- 7:18and I think the size of their audience probably speaks to that, you
- 7:23know, they had in their heyday, they had millions of people watching every
- 7:27single week. I don't know if you're watching the Max Television show about Julia
- 7:32Child the second season just started. I haven't seen it. Well, she
- 7:38beat him by, you know, maybe a decade or so in terms of
- 7:41her impact on public television. But just as she in the sixties became this
- 7:46national sensation and all the other public televisions were picking up her local Boston show,
- 7:51the same thing happened to Gene and Roger. And I remember not only
- 7:55of course reading them as I did religiously, probably starting in the early eighties,
- 8:00but even prior to that as a kid watching them on TV. Gene
- 8:03also, as you know, and as you document in your book, was
- 8:07doing criticism for the local CBS affiliate as well as doing his column for the
- 8:13Chicago Tribune, Ebert for The Times. They made an impact, certainly locally
- 8:20and also and I'm so glad, and as you point out, timing is
- 8:24everything for both of these guys, especially at the start of their careers,
- 8:28because they both started in the late sixties. I want to say Ciskel in
- 8:31sixty seven, rather Ebert in sixty seven, Ciskel in sixty nine. And
- 8:37this is right at the vanguard of the New Hollywood movement, when we were
- 8:41moving away from the studios, and movies like Easy Writer were suddenly disrupting the
- 8:46movie business and people were paying attention. And here come these two young books.
- 8:50Thank god, the editors at both place had the you know, at
- 8:56least, you know, the right moment to go, oh, let's get
- 8:58this young guy. In the case of Ebert, the standing sometimes critic just
- 9:03happened to be retiring at that moment and Ibert can replace. Yeah, tell
- 9:07tell us those how both guys broke in to doing film criticism real fast?
- 9:11Oh yeah, sure they Your years were right. You don't know where I'm
- 9:16working today, but you know where where and when Ciskel and Ebert started the
- 9:22years the location, So kudo's on that. Yes, Ebert got his gig
- 9:30first nineteen sixty seven at the Sun Times. You're exactly right. The film
- 9:33critic at the time, Lady by the name of Eleanor Keene, who is
- 9:39not to no offense to the estate and the heirs of Eleanor Keen, not
- 9:45really remembered for her critical works and is largely known as This kind of trivia
- 9:50thing is that she was the Chicago's Suntimes film critic before Roger Ebert. She's
- 9:56the Wally Pip of film criticism. That's a baseball thing, the guy that
- 10:01Lou Garrick replaced, going exactly, Yeah, she retired and they needed yeah,
- 10:07they needed a replacement, and exactly what you said. Yeah, it
- 10:11was this very exciting time for American movies. There was a youth movement in
- 10:18Hollywood. The studios were doing so poorly that they began to kind of recruit
- 10:26young people to come in and make new movies. And that is how we
- 10:30got films like Easy Writer and Bonnie and Clyde and you know, on and
- 10:33on and on. That's the whole that whole period. And so, yeah,
- 10:37newspapers started looking for younger people to write about these movies that were connecting
- 10:43with a younger audience. And you know, Ebert was at the time in
- 10:46his early twenties, maybe maybe mid twenties. Maybe you know, I would
- 10:50have to look back. Maybe he was like twenty three twenty four, and
- 10:56he was working writing you know, column and stuff for the Sun Times.
- 11:01He was actually trying to pay his way through grad school, getting his PhD
- 11:05at the University of Chicago. He did not dream of being a film critic.
- 11:09That was not his career goal. He had no plan of ever doing
- 11:13that, and it just so happened. He was at the paper when the
- 11:18critic retired, and it was actually the I believe, the publicist for maybe
- 11:22Warner Brothers in Chicago, had liked something he had written about one of their
- 11:28movies. Maybe he went to cover a junket, a Warner Brothers junket,
- 11:31and he had done a good job, and this publicist I believe by the
- 11:35name of Frank Casey, said to the editor, you know that Ebert kid
- 11:39is pretty good. You should give him the job. And supposedly that was
- 11:41it. That's how he got the job. He didn't necessarily want it or
- 11:46push for it, and he had the job essentially until he passed away,
- 11:52you know, decades later. Cisco was a few years later, sixty nine,
- 11:56nineteen sixty nine, and he did push a little more forward in his
- 12:01case. The film critic at the Chicago Tribune at the time, a gentleman
- 12:05by the name of Clifford Terry, was leaving he wasn't retiring. He was
- 12:11leaving to go do a fellowship at Harvard, I believe. And the initial
- 12:18plan at the Tribune was they were going to have whoever was around fill in
- 12:22whenever they needed a movie review. They would just kind of reviews by committee.
- 12:26Basically, whoever's available, whoever's free this week, you'll review this movie.
- 12:31And Ciskell, who was working at the paper not for very long by
- 12:35that point, had gotten a job in like the neighborhood news department. He
- 12:39heard about this and he decided, I like movies. I could do that
- 12:43job. And he wrote a letter to the editor of the editor who was
- 12:50in charge of that position, basically saying, your idea is bad. Don't
- 12:52do that. We're going to be that would hurt the Tribune. What you
- 12:56should do is give one person the job, and it should be me.
- 12:58And he's slid the letter under the editor's door, went home that night,
- 13:05assumed he would not hear anything back, and the next day when he came
- 13:09in, he was called into the editor's office and they said, okay,
- 13:11we're giving you the job. And he did later get sort of quasi demoted.
- 13:18There was this whole kind of let's talk about that. Yeah, we
- 13:22could talk about that later. There was a whole thing, but essentially he
- 13:24remained at the Chicago Tribune also until the end of his life in various capacities,
- 13:31film critic, film columnist, whatever it was. And it sounds like
- 13:35a very fanciful story. But supposedly, many years later, someone who worked
- 13:41in the on staff at the Tribune investigated it and found in Gene Siskel's personnel
- 13:48file the letter that he had written to the editor pitching himself for the job.
- 13:52So apparently not a you know, not a not a tall tale,
- 13:58not an urban leg And supposedly Ciskel, when he was presented with this letter,
- 14:03had said, you know, I've told this story so many times I
- 14:05almost thought I made it up. But there you go. Here is the
- 14:09proof. So there that's the story of how they got their jobs well for
- 14:13newspapers, not you know, obviously this is this is six and eight years
- 14:18respectively before they started the TV show Well and talk about their producer, because
- 14:26again you'll forgive the allusion to the TV show Julia, but in the TV
- 14:31series on Max, they really make a big deal about the woman behind the
- 14:37French chef, the producer and how important she was in helping Julia Child transition
- 14:41from cookbook author to television person. And this is a great part of your
- 14:46book in terms of how important this this woman was. Yeah, so you're
- 14:52referring to this woman named THEA Flum who they always credited. You know,
- 14:56she was not the creator in the classical t the sense of Cisco and Eebird
- 15:01or you know, all the various names that it had through the years.
- 15:05She did not work on the original pilot. She was brought in after the
- 15:09original pilot by the Chicago public television station who created the show and who was
- 15:18airing the show, WTTW, and she was she had was like recently on
- 15:22staff there and the pilot for the show was not fantastic. And I'm being
- 15:26generous, and they were looking for kinda to well, maybe there's something here,
- 15:31but this isn't it. We need fresh ideas, we need new blood,
- 15:35we need some we gotta we gotta work on this. And they one
- 15:39of the executives at the network asked her, would you be interested in doing
- 15:45a show about movies? And she said yes, and so they handed her
- 15:48the pilot and Gene and Roger, who were the hosts of the pilot and
- 15:54said good luck. And what I interviewed her, and what she told me
- 15:58actually was that they had given her cart blanche. If she had wanted to
- 16:02replace Ciskel or Ebert, she could have. It could have been Siskel and
- 16:07I don't know Joe Blow, who knows, it could have been Ebert and
- 16:11somebody else. But she felt that they were the right guys. They just
- 16:15needed work. And yeah, they always said that she was the one who
- 16:18kind of turned them from these newspaper critics who had had a little, you
- 16:22know, a little experience on TV, but were not great yet, certainly
- 16:26not good at interacting with each other on camera. They weren't good at interacting
- 16:32with each other off camera either. They didn't like each other at the time,
- 16:36so that didn't help. But she really worked with them very hard in
- 16:40the in the early years of the show, really like kind of drilling down
- 16:42into writing for television versus writing for newspapers. How to be on camera,
- 16:48how to be kind of natural and comfortable on camera, how to talk,
- 16:52how to how to sound like an expert with while still maintaining you know,
- 16:57that common man touch. However you put it, all of those things.
- 17:00They always said that she was really really important and instrumental to the success of
- 17:07the show long after, you know, she was involved with it. She
- 17:11worked at PBS, and you know, she was the producer for a number
- 17:15of years, then she became the executive producer. And then when Gene and
- 17:18Roger left to go into syndication in the early nineteen eighties, she did not
- 17:22go with them. She stayed at PBS working on other shows, and so
- 17:26she you know, she was only really involved with those first six seven years
- 17:30ish, but they always said that she was hugely important to the long term
- 17:36success of the show well as an early viewer. They had their act down
- 17:41by the time they did go into regular television syndication, first with the Tribune
- 17:45Company then Buena Vista. They when they were competitors, is this right,
- 17:52one actually kind of sabotaged the other in terms of a specific story or in
- 17:59stay well they well, they were constantly trying to mess with each other.
- 18:03Ciskel more than Ebert, at least according to the stories I was told,
- 18:08he was the even you know, like they were both very competitive, but
- 18:11he was the hyper competitive of the two, and he was the one who
- 18:15was very a little more kind of confrontational about it and would Yes, he
- 18:21would go to any length according to you know, the stories that are told.
- 18:26Some of them, you know, there's there's sort of a Rachamon quality
- 18:30to some of them because you hear different versions from different sources. But the
- 18:37famous one that gets told a lot about, yeah, sabotaging some someone was
- 18:45Gene sabotaging Roger. And I heard different versions of the story, but at
- 18:49least one person who told me the story claimed to be in the room when
- 18:52it happened. So I'll tell you the version that they told me, which
- 18:56was, this is a producer on the show in the PBS days, And
- 19:03I guess they had this conference room where they would have meetings and such,
- 19:07and it also had a very large conference room table that for whatever reason,
- 19:14and I don't know why I asked this question, and it didn't get a
- 19:17great answer for it. Supposedly, Gene, in between tapings or if they
- 19:22were taking a break, he would sometimes like to like go lay under this
- 19:26table. He would like ball up his sport code and use it as a
- 19:30pillow and take a fifteen minute nap under this table. Maybe I guess maybe
- 19:33there was no windows or something, and when you turn off the lights.
- 19:37It was dark. I don't know, but supposedly, according to the story,
- 19:41he was sleeping under this table. This other, this producer was in
- 19:45the room, excuse me, working when Roger came in to use the telephone
- 19:52and called up the publicist for Natasia Kinski, who at the time was very
- 19:56hot actress hot in t I'm not speaking physically, although they thought she was
- 20:03a very hot actress, was a lovely young actress, but she certainly was.
- 20:06She was very issues. She was an up and coming kind of sex
- 20:11symbol of that time. Yet people among the early ladies movies, yes,
- 20:15oh yeah, and they were big fans of her. And Roger was supposed
- 20:21to interview her, and so he called to confirm an interview that he was
- 20:23supposed to have, let's say, the next day. Hi, this is
- 20:27Rogeriebert. I'm calling to confirm the interview. Yes at this time, yep,
- 20:30okay, very good. And he hangs up and he leaves, and
- 20:34according to the story, he never notices Jane sleeping under the table. And
- 20:40Jane wakes up while this is happening, and here's the conversation. And when
- 20:45when Roger leaves, Jene gets up goes to the phone dials the publicist that
- 20:49says, oh, hi, this is Roger's assistant. Oh, I'm so
- 20:53sorry. He just realized he has a conflict. He has to cancel that
- 20:59interview. I'm so I'm very sorry about that. Yes, we'll have to
- 21:03cancel that. We'll do it some other time. And supposedly, you know
- 21:07the according to the producer, he claimed that he was sitting there while this
- 21:11happened, and that the sort of the end of the story was Ciskel turning
- 21:15to him and saying, you don't say one word about this another effort,
- 21:22and that was the end of the story. You know, I got to
- 21:26know and I would not claim to be a friend of either man, but
- 21:30I did get to know on an acquaintance level, Jeene Ciskel, as you
- 21:33point out in the book, massive sports fan, massive gambler and in a
- 21:37good way fun gambler, And had the fun of being with him at the
- 21:41OTVS occasionally when he would be betting on the horses. I'll tell you a
- 21:45story about that a little bit. But based on what you saw, you
- 21:48would think Jeane was the more passive area dite. You know, he was
- 21:53the country club guy. I mean, both guys were definitely Chicaugas neither guy
- 21:57very telligenic. For people who don't remember watching them, you could certainly see
- 22:02fantastic reviews that do hold up on YouTube all over the place. And we
- 22:08would know from not being telegenic. Let's make that clear, good lord,
- 22:12Yeah, from experience. Let's apologize to the people that are actually what we
- 22:17know from what we're talking about. Yeah. Absolutely, And also, you
- 22:21know, Chicago always had, unfortunately because of New York and LA, that
- 22:25underdog kind of vibe. We couldn't help it. But Gen and Roger were
- 22:30exceptions. But Roger especially, and I say this as a heavy set man
- 22:33myself, definitely not intelligenic. And and the things that their producer did to
- 22:38kind of tweak the show, they didn't change much, but it was just
- 22:42subtle enough. I mean, Roger still wore a lot of plaid, as
- 22:47you'll see if you watch a lot of the old reviews they did on especially
- 22:51this that's okay, thank god they weren't wearing leisure suits. Absolutely, but
- 22:59but yeah, you know, you would think that Roger would be And even
- 23:02when they did kind of graduate to their natural television personas, Roger seemed to
- 23:07be more of the attack dog or whatever. And also, as you say,
- 23:15I always regarded them as classic Chicago newsmen, and it was so much
- 23:18fun being in broadcasting in Chicago in the nineties and really getting to see newspaper
- 23:25men like them up close. And they really were. I mean, I
- 23:27know that Roger one of his heroes, of course, was the great Mike
- 23:33Roiko, who was a wonderful columnist, very very funny at just kind of
- 23:37a classic newsman, just pounding out his stuff. In fact, the Belushi
- 23:41movie, as I'm sure you know, con Nell Divide Belushi's characters basically based
- 23:47on Roiko and Roiko. They knew each other, Rko and Belus, she
- 23:49knew each other. But yeah, you know, oh that's hilarious, Michael
- 23:55says, Jeane sounds like George Constanzo with the death story. Yeah kind of
- 24:00man, that's awesome. But yeah, he would have bungled it though.
- 24:02But yeah, there is a slight Yeah, there's I guess I could see
- 24:04the Costanza ish quality there. Sure. Yeah, And Michael says, YouTube
- 24:10keeps putting up random clips about the movies in my feed. They're addictive.
- 24:14I particularly like it when they bashed a movie. I love that because at
- 24:17least they had a great point of view. No, absolutely well in fact,
- 24:21and I'm so glad you documented in the book that great time that Paul
- 24:26McCartney was in on a press jucket forgive my regards to Broad Street, a
- 24:30horrible eighties movie that Paul thought was a good idea, and Jean didn't hold
- 24:36back, and Jean really told them this is a terrible movie, and you
- 24:40know, went on and on, and McCartney essentially is like, I can't
- 24:42believe I'm sitting here letting you rip my movie in front of me. And
- 24:48that was the journalistic integrity and Roger too Man and Roger they stuck to their
- 24:52guns. I mean they really they didn't give anybody a pass. And they
- 24:56came at a great time. I mean again, they started in in the
- 25:00seventies with their TV show, but as the VHS world evolved and it became
- 25:07more affordable to have VHS tape players and rentals became a thing, they were
- 25:12right there and my gout as I'm sure that it was the case for you
- 25:15as well, and there are a few years between us, but they really
- 25:18helped my movie education and luckily living in Chicago, It wasn't like New York
- 25:25and LA but close enough where we would get the art movies and they would
- 25:29come to the various small theaters and stuff, and you know My Dinner with
- 25:33Andre Diner other great movies of the eighties that were little but significant movies.
- 25:40It was really the power of them saying, go see this movie. This
- 25:44is great, and it was. I mean, you know, we were
- 25:47all gonna see the Sean Connery movie of the moment, or Nicholson or Meryl
- 25:52Street, name your favorite actor or actress and stuff. But these are the
- 25:55guys that are like, wait a minute, go see this one. This
- 25:59one is good. It's worth your time. And that was very valuable in
- 26:03a pre cable five hundred channel world. Yeah, I mean absolutely, I
- 26:10agree with everything you said. I mean, yeah, I am a little
- 26:12younger than you, but I mean it was still a world without the Internet,
- 26:17without YouTube, without cell phones, without yeah, without the ability to
- 26:22you know, stream thousands of movies. Literally, I mean, if you
- 26:27wanted to from your without getting off your couch on your cell phone, I
- 26:33mean, that's not a good way to watch anything, but you could theoretically
- 26:37do it. Yeah, I mean, when I'm watching the show in the
- 26:41early nineties was when I became a massive fan. It was still yeah,
- 26:45the world of vhs. I guess laser discs were a thing, but I
- 26:48never had a laser disc player as a kid. I've never had a laser
- 26:52disc player in my entire life, to be honest. But so but yeah,
- 26:56I grew up in suburban New Jersey, so so yeah, some of
- 27:00those movies you're talking about, Like, I didn't have a theater near me
- 27:03that really played many of them, but I had the video store, and
- 27:07so yes, I would keep a running sort of mental tallly of what are
- 27:11the movies that I want to see that Gene and Roger have recommended that sound
- 27:15great, that that aren't playing at the multiplex, that I need to keep
- 27:19an eye out for when they come to Easy Video or Movie home Center or
- 27:26eventually we did get a Blockbuster, but that was I was pretty late in
- 27:30coming to where I grew up. I was Easy Video was the video store
- 27:33that I used to go to, and it was a video home center a
- 27:38movie home center. Maybe it was both, maybe it changed over the years.
- 27:41That was another one that I used to go to all the time that
- 27:45really hung in there until way past it. I'm you know, it closed
- 27:49eventually, but it was still around in like the mid two thousands, and
- 27:52you're like, I am the only person who comes into this video store.
- 27:56And you could you could tell because the owner was like always excited when I
- 28:00came in, because I would. He was like, hey, Matt,
- 28:03how's it going. Yeah, yeah, you know, it's five movies for
- 28:07five days for five dollars today, And I'm like, that's why I am
- 28:10here. Yep, that's anyway. Yeah, they they had this. They
- 28:15absolutely were. I mean you touched on a lot of things, but yes,
- 28:19they were really wonderful at recommending movies, small movies, getting people to
- 28:27give a chance to little movies that they might not have otherwise watched. I
- 28:32know that was certainly true of me as a kid. Movies I would never
- 28:37have heard of at the time, not just new movies, too, older
- 28:41movies, because they did home you know, home video picks and LaserDisc pick
- 28:45of the month and all that, and they would spotlight older movies, black
- 28:48and white movies, foreign movies, documentaries. Yeah, they they all that
- 28:55stuff absolutely, And yes, you're also quite right that they you know,
- 29:00they had that, they had that newspaper journalism background, and they brought it
- 29:04to TV and as big as they got, and they got pretty famous and
- 29:08pretty big. I mean, they never lost that. You know. They
- 29:14never sold out. You know, even if you want to say they sold
- 29:18out in the sense that they were working for Disney for fourteen years or whatever
- 29:21it was and making millions of dollars, if you want to call that selling
- 29:26out, sure they sold out, but they never sold out their principles.
- 29:30You know. It wasn't like they were, oh, we work for Disney
- 29:33now, oh, Oliver and Company, two thumbs up. You know,
- 29:36that was never their thing. And yes, as you noted, they you
- 29:41know, they would review things and they would talk to occasionally they would do
- 29:48in that interview that Geene ciscl Paul McCartney thing was on the local CBS affiliate
- 29:52that you mentioned. W But they did occasionally air junket in the nineties especially,
- 29:57they did it. There was a period where would go and do junket
- 30:02interviews sometimes and put those on the show. And Jeane would be on the
- 30:06show doing junket interviews and saying similar similarly, blunt, similarly unkind things to
- 30:15the faces of huge stars and directors who I'm like a Paul McCartney. I'm
- 30:19sure are not used to hearing criticism like that to their faces. If ever,
- 30:26you know, God only knows the last time someone told Paul McCartney,
- 30:30you know, whatever you just made whatever is a piece of crap. Ciskel
- 30:33could have been the first person to do it in decades to Paul McCartney by
- 30:37that point, because we're talking about like the early mid eighties, you know,
- 30:41so this is like twenty years past Beatlemania. Absolutely, you know,
- 30:47Paul McCartney's a god. Oh Paul, this is wonderful. Everything is wonderful.
- 30:52And yes, you summarize that quite rightly. But yeah. He also
- 30:55had incidents with Madonna. I told Madonna like why are your or yes,
- 31:00Madonna, why are your movies so terrible? Why you why can't you make
- 31:04better? Why isn't your movie career as good as your music? Yeah?
- 31:11Or he told he asked Eddie Murphy to his face, like why, uh,
- 31:17why don't you work with better directors? Don't you think your movies would
- 31:19be better if if you work with beat directors? And when you directed yourself
- 31:23that didn't work out at all? Like he really he really had that,
- 31:30yes, and he was fearless about saying he would speak his mind, and
- 31:34I mean, I love it. I think it's a very admirable quality.
- 31:40Maybe not if you want to be friends with the guy because he's going to
- 31:41tell you what he thinks, or maybe it is admiral. I don't know,
- 31:45but as a critic you can't. I mean, it's one of the
- 31:47most essential qualities, and not every critic has it. You know, a
- 31:52contemporary of there's Gene Shalat, who was on The Today Show at least weekly,
- 31:56if not more, was kind of a glad handing film critic. Rex
- 32:00Reid was the polar opposite. And I always felt, and especially as someone
- 32:04who grew up in Jersey, I wonder what you thought. And I don't
- 32:07know where he was in his career in the nineties per se, but he
- 32:10had kind of always this elite attitude that seemed detached from from the public,
- 32:16whereas you know Gene and Roger. I'm so glad you mentioned Eddie Murphy.
- 32:20I was going to bring that up, and I remember specifically, I want
- 32:23to say it was dream Girls where or maybe it was a previous failure of
- 32:28Murphy. What movie that interview is for? But it's from the mid nineties.
- 32:32I was gonna say. He would say it time and time again,
- 32:35and I remember distinctly watching at the movies if it was the nineties, and
- 32:38him saying, I've said this Daddy Murphy before. He's very talented, but
- 32:43he needs the right director to really, you know, exploit the best from
- 32:47him and everything. And yeah, man, no, these guys, they
- 32:51weren't in Hollywood to make friends. They took their job seriously and felt an
- 32:57obligation to call them as they saw them. And I love too that you
- 33:01and I'll let you say it. But both had a different philosophy of what
- 33:06they felt a film critic was and what their job was. Feel free.
- 33:12Well, but you mean you say they were in Hollywood or whatever, but
- 33:15they I mean they, I mean they were making a television show for a
- 33:20Hollywood company. But they never left Chicago, I think, which pretty notable
- 33:24and I think speaks also to their sort of refusal to sell out or to
- 33:30go to quote unquote go Hollywood. You know, they never really did that.
- 33:35But yes, they did have different sort of critical philosophies, you know,
- 33:40and I think that was important because again, if they had the same
- 33:45philosophy and they saw everything the same way. It would not have been a
- 33:47very interesting show because the whole show was founded on the idea of opposing viewpoints
- 33:52in different viewpoints. But yeah, Gene, you know Gene always you know,
- 33:57he had a background as a you know, a newspaper man, and
- 34:00that was kind of how he saw his job. Is I'm a reporter,
- 34:05and you know, I'm reporting on what I'm seeing. It's no different than
- 34:08a reporter going to a fire and reporting on a fire. I'm reporting on
- 34:13the fire, only in this case, the fire is not a fire.
- 34:15It's i don't know, backdraft a movie about a fire, and I'm telling
- 34:21you what I thought about it, what I saw, and YadA, YadA,
- 34:22YadA. And I mean, Rogers certainly also had a journalistic background,
- 34:29but he saw things maybe slightly differently, and he often would compare the role
- 34:35of a critic to the role of like a teacher. And he also was
- 34:38a teacher. You know, he worked for many years doing like teaching classes
- 34:43at the University of Chicago. You know, we never got I don't think
- 34:45he ever got that PhD as a matter of fact, that he was working
- 34:49on. But he soon became a teacher there and he taught like night classes,
- 34:53you know, adult education classes there for decades, pretty much up up
- 34:59until he lost the ability to speak, I think. And in fact,
- 35:01someone at my book signing last week in Chicago told me a great story about
- 35:08being in one of Roger's classes. Took a class with Roger at the University
- 35:13of Chicago and said he was a great teacher and we loved the class.
- 35:19And sometimes when class was over, he would show movies and we were allowed
- 35:25to stay and occasionally, he said, Geene Siskel would come and watch.
- 35:29Maybe they were showing maybe they were almost like screening movies, like press screening
- 35:32style. I don't know, but he said on this particular occasion, there
- 35:37was a movie after class and Gene was supposed to come and didn't show up.
- 35:40He was late. He came an hour late, and when he showed
- 35:44up, Roger yelled at him, He tore him anew you know what,
- 35:49and in front of the whole class, screaming at him, and then Jeane
- 35:52was screaming back at him, and he said it became this huge screaming match
- 35:55that went on and on, and he was like and he was thinking,
- 35:59Wow, they really don't get along. When he was. You know,
- 36:02so that was a fun, fun story. But yeah, Roger thought of
- 36:06himself or saw the role of a critic as kind of a teacher trying to
- 36:10I don't know, impart what they had learned or what they had seen in
- 36:15a movie. But I mean he also had a strong newspaper background as well.
- 36:21But yeah, I mean again, if they saw things the same approach
- 36:24their reviews, the same show wouldn't have worked right, it would have been
- 36:29boring. No, it was the chemistry. It was the conflict and again
- 36:31massaging that disagreement to a level of fun watching. Hey, you know again,
- 36:40I spent twenty years in sports radio, and it was more fun when
- 36:45you had a Yankee and a Mets fan on yelling at each other, when
- 36:47you had as opposed to two Yankee fans or two Mets fans and everything's great
- 36:52or everything sucks. No, you're right about that. I want to go
- 36:55back to as you said, because while both men stayed for a lifetime at
- 37:00their newspapers, when they moved their syndicated show as from the Tribune's television arm
- 37:08to Disney and Buena Visit to a much bigger and better deal, and shame
- 37:14on the Tribune for not recognizing that just taking them for granted, that's kind
- 37:17of why it happened. But despite their competitiveness, I think Ebert was ready
- 37:25to give Gina a hell of a solid and you know what I'm talking about,
- 37:30don't you. Oh sure, yeah, yeah, you're talking about yeah.
- 37:32So right, So, when they went to syndication for the first time,
- 37:38as you said, they were their first syndicated show after PBS, was
- 37:43at Tribune Entertainment, which is the was the company that owned the Chicago Tribune.
- 37:47So for it was great for at that time. That was great for
- 37:50Gene and that was great for the Tribune because they could like promote Jane's reviews
- 37:54in the Tribune and vice versa. You know, watch our film critic on
- 38:00television, read our film critic on our paper, right, So that was
- 38:04great. But the problem was, as you said, when they left after
- 38:07four years and went to Disney, suddenly Tribune was kind of a little annoyed
- 38:13about that. And essentially, yeah, they demoted Cisco. They sort of
- 38:17took the lead film critic job away from him and gave it to I think
- 38:23Dave Kerr was his Ciscol's first replacement, and this is it's like a long
- 38:30and convoluted story about like why did they do this, What was the official
- 38:36reason, what was the real reason, what was the stated reason. There
- 38:38were different excuses, like you know, they would claim that they were worried
- 38:44it would be a conflict of interest because now he was working for a studio,
- 38:47or they would say, well, he's going to be too busy with
- 38:50the new show to do his job, to do that job, YadA,
- 38:54YadA, YadA. Well, ultimately what happened was he was given sort of
- 39:02a gig as kind of a column list. He would, you know,
- 39:05he would do capsule reviews, he did features. He was still kind of
- 39:08the face of the film section at the paper, but he was writing less
- 39:14and he did less of the main big reviews, right, And what you
- 39:20were alluding to there was the fact that while this is going on, like
- 39:24you know, he's kind of having to negotiate kind of his new job and
- 39:30it's not going well at the people. I think there was also a new
- 39:34boss or a relatively new boss at the at the paper at the time,
- 39:38so that might have been part of it, and it was looking like maybe
- 39:44he would just not have his job there at all. At one point,
- 39:46and supposedly what happened was Roger was, you know, concerned enough about Gene
- 39:54that he went to his bosses at the Sun Times and said, if they're
- 40:00not going to hire him, you should bring him here and we could both
- 40:04do the reviews here. And supposedly the bosses said to him, would you
- 40:10be willing to do that because they were such peers competitors for so many years,
- 40:15and he claimed he would, and nothing ever came of it, but
- 40:20it seemed, you know, it's quite telling that after these guys, who,
- 40:22as we had talked about already, did not like each other in the
- 40:25beginning and were at times sabotaging one another, had kind of grown to this
- 40:30place where one would kind of stick up for the other and even potentially,
- 40:37you know, give a little of his job up to kind of help help
- 40:40the other one out. It didn't happen, but the fact that he was
- 40:45willing is still, yeah, pretty notable. Roger was pretty public with that
- 40:49story. Again, being in Chicago radio as I was, both they would
- 40:52come on the stations I was at, but also other stations as well,
- 40:57and yeah, Roger used to tell that story and he's like, hey know,
- 41:00I was happy for that to happen. Can you imagine one newspaper having
- 41:02the two best critics would have been It would have been great for whatever paper.
- 41:07It was huge, but Jane was and even as lousy and frankly,
- 41:12I'm saying this, as lousy as the Tribune was treating Gene, he felt
- 41:15disloyalty. You know, hey man, they they took a chance on me
- 41:19back in sixty nine. He had this fierce even though he was kind of
- 41:22demoted, but as you say, he was, he still wrote features for
- 41:25the Tribute. He was still there. It was for the regular paper.
- 41:29So yeah, he was still there. But you're right, no, because
- 41:31it and it really and again as a reader, I was just like,
- 41:35I got nothing against Dave Kerr, but it's like, you know, replacing
- 41:40you know, Mickey Mantle with the bat Boy or whatever. And again I
- 41:44don't mean that in any although it sounds disparaging to poor Dave Kerr, but
- 41:47you actually, yeah, is a good critic. He is a good critic.
- 41:53He's a curator here in New York. But he's a very good but
- 41:57he's but he wasn't Gene and he wasn't Roger, and they were they I
- 42:01mean you know, and every big city and especially in the more smaller media
- 42:07times, all these people were gods. I mean, you know, they
- 42:10make fun of it in the movie Anchorman, the Will Ferrell movie, but
- 42:15it really was like, no, these local news and local newspaper people,
- 42:20they were it. The beginning of the conversation and the end of the conversation.
- 42:23Oh you think it sucks, well, Jean Siste likes it. Oh
- 42:27all right, well maybe I should rethink it or whatever, or at least
- 42:29give it another pass and decide. No, they brilliant men. I love
- 42:34their writing. I love their television work as well. And you capture all
- 42:38these great stories from all these people that were around, and it is very
- 42:42Rassamond, I think in the best way. And somewhere in there is the
- 42:45true story in some of these little anecdotes and stuff. But no, man,
- 42:49you did a hell of a job. It's a fantastic book and these
- 42:52guys deserve it. And yet there was just something about these guys, as
- 42:57we said, ripping stars in person and stuff. There's that great Johnny Carson
- 43:00clip that I even just saw before you even sent me the book, and
- 43:06it's them on Carson with Chevy Chase and I think it was Three Amigos,
- 43:09and they were not fans of The Three Amigos, And when it first came
- 43:15out, it wasn't a very popular movie. That's kind of a slow cult
- 43:19movie, positive burn and I even I when I first thought, I'm like,
- 43:22really that's it. I guess it's okay. But yet, like literally
- 43:28sitting next to Chevy on the couch, I believe it was Gene that was
- 43:32just like it was that right, It was Roger actually yes, but I
- 43:37mean they both disliked that movie. But yeah, I mean for the person
- 43:44who was watching who said that, you know, like they keep getting those
- 43:46recommendations on YouTube. I mean, that's another one to look up if you
- 43:51haven't been given that one by the algorithm. It's an amazing clip. Yeah
- 43:57they yeah. Again, this is another example of telling a at the time,
- 44:00I mean, at the time, one of the biggest comedy stars on
- 44:04the planet, your movie stinks. They were he was, and it was
- 44:09you know, it's the Tonight Show with Johnny Carson and Chevy is the first
- 44:14guest and he's there to promote Three Amigos, that is his new movie.
- 44:19So it's the whole interview you know, you can only imagine, oh yeah,
- 44:22this is you know, and telling stories and encouraging people to go see
- 44:25Three Amigos. That's the only reason he is there. And then they come
- 44:31out next, and eventually Johnny says, you know, I almost hate to
- 44:40ask, which, come on, give me a break. I hate to
- 44:45ask, but is there is there a worst Christmas movie this year? And
- 44:50it was Roger who's like, you know, I can't and I can't recommend
- 44:54Three Amigos not a good movie. And you know, he says something like
- 45:01you know, and Chevy, you know, and this is again, it's
- 45:04a Tonight show where at least then you know, the tradition was you do
- 45:09your interview and then you just hang out on set for the rest of the
- 45:13show. You slide down the couch next to Ed McMahon. So it's not
- 45:17just Chevy was there. He promoted his movie, he waved goodbye, and
- 45:22he left. He's literally sitting next to Roger Ebert as he's saying these things.
- 45:29And I mean it's a great segment because Chevy of course plays it beautifully
- 45:35and it's sort of like, you know, hamming it up. But yeah,
- 45:37like Roger is, you know, saying Chevy has made very funny movies
- 45:42and you know, and it's just this is and I think Chevy even says
- 45:45like and with your help maybe I'll do it again someday or something like that.
- 45:50But but yeah, it's an amazing, amazing moment in talk show history.
- 45:57It's worth worth seeking out on YouTube. Man, how would you categorize
- 46:01where film criticism is today? Because it is different, It is a different
- 46:06world, and with things like Rotten Tomatoes that also give audience feedback as much
- 46:13screen time as they do critics and stuff, how do you see things in
- 46:19your world today? Well, yes, it is a very different world,
- 46:22in some ways better, in some ways worse, I mean, and in
- 46:27different ways better and in different ways worse. I mean, you know,
- 46:32yes, Rotten Tomatoes has you know, kind of in some ways is kind
- 46:37of an evolution or a different, slightly tweaked model of the whole thumbs of
- 46:43Ciskel and Ebert, which we haven't talked about two thumbs up two thumbs down,
- 46:45which yes, in its day, I mean very famous and popular still
- 46:50famous people still say two thumbs up about movies or almost anything. And that's
- 46:55where the phrase came from. Giving thumbs up to things didn't come from Ciskel
- 47:00and Ebert, but saying two thumbs up or two thumbs down, that was
- 47:06that was them. Yeah, these opposing critics agree, and certainly to a
- 47:10national audience. I gotta go see this movie if they both like it,
- 47:15right, So, uh, you know that was them, you know,
- 47:16And now Rotten Tomatoes has you know, it's it's it's like taking that binary
- 47:22idea and made it even more mathematical, which you're taking the most subjective thing,
- 47:27which is reactions to art, and giving it a number, which it's
- 47:30problematic to say the least. But look on the flip side, I don't
- 47:37think most people, or even many people at all, use it this way.
- 47:40But if you want to just look at Rotten Tomatoes as a place to
- 47:44find actual reviews that you're then going to read, can be a useful resource
- 47:49for that. Now, Unfortunately, I don't think I would love to know
- 47:52how many people use Rotten Tomatoes that way. As someone whose reviews are on
- 47:57Rotten Tomatoes, I can tell you the traffic I get from Rotten Tomatoes is
- 48:01not that extensive. I can tell you that much for sure. But maybe
- 48:07some people use it that way, and if they did would that would be
- 48:10nice, So it perhaps could have some efficacy. It's just that people don't
- 48:16use it that way. And you know, there are there certainly are much
- 48:21fewer people like Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert in terms of I have a full
- 48:25time job as a person who reviews movies, and I have health benefits,
- 48:30and I work at a newspaper. I mean, there's no newspapers anymore anyway,
- 48:34So that's another wrinkle. It's sort of an interconnected issue to a larger
- 48:38one about journalism and the media and things like that. And that's all disconcerting
- 48:45and upsetting and troubling, especially for someone who tries to make a living doing
- 48:47this. On the flip side again, you know, you could see these
- 48:52things from different angles, like there are more people doing interesting things in the
- 48:57world of criticism than certainly in Gene and Rogers day than ever before. On
- 49:02podcasts, you know, uh, on on YouTube, which we're also apparently
- 49:10on right now, and and you know, and online in so many different
- 49:15places and ways. You don't need to have the backing of the Chicago Sun
- 49:21Times or the Chicago Tribune or WTTW or Buena Vista Television to have a movie
- 49:27review show or a movie review podcast, or a movie review letterboxed feed or
- 49:32a movie review Twitter account or whatever. There's more ways to communicate and to
- 49:39engage with movies and with other movie lovers than in that day. And that's
- 49:45a good thing. I think not everyone is worth listening to or reading,
- 49:51but there are a lot of wonderful people out there who are. And so
- 49:57yeah, it's a it's a very it's a complicated issue, and it's again
- 50:05it's it's it's not all good and it's not all bad. I would say,
- 50:09well, and I'm glad you're part of that critique world, Matt.
- 50:13Despite my saying in rather than screen crush, I do have I've always valued
- 50:17your opinion when it comes to this stuff, and you're you're in in the
- 50:22words of God, damn it. Now I'm blanking uh freaks. You're one
- 50:28of us, you know, you're Yeah, I mean that in the best
- 50:32way, man, you know, Okay, thanks, thanks, thanks?
- 50:37Uh No, no, well, certainly you know you've been on before when
- 50:39you wrote your Great Spider Man book and we've talked about films, uh,
- 50:45you know, uh and what's happening in the uh in the nerd the geek
- 50:49world as far as film and television goes. And you've had you had an
- 50:52excellent podcast that you used to do SVU Special What what did SVU Screaming Dreaming
- 51:00Video Unit? Indeed Film Spotting SPU. Yeah, yes, part of the
- 51:04Film Spotting Group of Chicago, another Chicago institution of film criticism. Yeah.
- 51:09Absolutely. Man. Before I leave, Gene and Roger two things. One,
- 51:15I always was excited during the Chicago Film Festival because they carved out a
- 51:21Roger Ebert Night where he would show some obscure movies and things. And that's
- 51:24when I learned about Errol Morris, the wonderful documentarian who gave us the Thin
- 51:30Blue Line and oh god, I forget the name of the pet cemetery,
- 51:36what's it? Gates Skates of Heaven. Absolutely, and Roger had an attachment
- 51:40to the rock station. I worked at WXRT, and our program director,
- 51:45Normal Winer, used to keep a cassette and it was an air check of
- 51:49Howard Stern. Howard was trying to get a job at w XRT, and
- 51:52this is years before he became the king of all media and everything. But
- 51:57he had Roger as a guest done and he's like you're from Chicago. I
- 52:00go, yeah, that WXRT. What a terrible station. You know.
- 52:01I tried to be the morning guy there and Eve It's like Howard, it
- 52:05would have been a horrible fit because your personality, guy, the personality of
- 52:09w XRT is the music. It's the best rock station in the world,
- 52:14and it would have been horrible. But I'm not going to talk bad about
- 52:15the station. Norm Winer and those guys they know what they're doing. And
- 52:19Howard tried to fight him on it, and Roger wouldn't budget. What Howard
- 52:22didn't know was when Norm came to Chicago, Uh, he lived in a
- 52:27coach house on Roger's property, and so Roger was his landlord for the first
- 52:32year or so that he was in town, and they stayed friends. And
- 52:37it was this great badge of honor that Rogerriavert was defending my boss, uh
- 52:42to Howard's there and saying, hey man, you're not wrong, you're a
- 52:45great you're a great radio guy. But you would have been horrible an XRT,
- 52:47and they would have been done to hire you, and no bad news.
- 52:51This is a great radio station. And then when it comes to Jean
- 52:54Genius to hang out, you know, again, massive massive Bulls fan,
- 52:59massive Chicago bull So he'd come to the score of my sports talk station a
- 53:01lot. And one one day at the OTBS it was for the Breeders Cup.
- 53:07Me and a bunch of the scory guys went to spend the day,
- 53:08you know, betting on the horses, and Jean walked in and we're like,
- 53:12Gene, hey, sit down, hang out with us and stuff.
- 53:14And he looked troubled and we're like and he's like, guys, I appreciate
- 53:17it. You know, I kind of need to be alone. And you
- 53:20even say in the book that he was kind of aloof and things, and
- 53:22we understood that, but there was something definitely bothering him. We found out
- 53:25about a week later that that's when he got the diagnosis for his brain cat
- 53:30seroor what gets away from Yeah, yeah, And truly we're all just like,
- 53:36oh man. And I even remember I was in New York covering an
- 53:38HBO fight boxing and was in my hotel room watching New York One when we
- 53:45got the sad news that Jean passed away and everything, and it's just like,
- 53:47wow, you know, good good guy. Roger another good guy,
- 53:52and the great thing about Roger and again, it's covered in your book.
- 53:55It really felt to me like sadly when he lost the ability to speak,
- 54:00that's ironically when his voice got that much stronger, and I think his writing
- 54:06just went up a notch because that was the only way he could communicate.
- 54:10Yeah, absolutely absolutely, and that Yeah, I'm sure people have seen or
- 54:14maybe they haven't, but they should see if they're interested in that. Like
- 54:16the documentary Life Itself, which is based on his memoir, his book,
- 54:23you can sort of see some of that in there. But yeah, I
- 54:27mean I was a huge fan of Rogers writing, and really, you know,
- 54:35we talked a little about how, you know, I discovered the show
- 54:37as a kid, and I was a huge fan of the show, and
- 54:40then Gene unfortunately, as you mentioned, passes away, and then I go
- 54:45off to college and you know, it becomes Ebert and Roper, which I
- 54:50still would watch when I could, But that was when I really got into
- 54:54Ebert's writing. And it also helped that this is when the internet was really
- 54:59coming into its own and you could I could now finally read Roger's reviews in
- 55:02the sun Times because they were published on the Suntimes website every Friday. I
- 55:07never was able to do that before I could buy like his books when he
- 55:12would put out a new book, which I did, but you know,
- 55:15to read his review you know, when the Phantom Menace comes out or whatever
- 55:19or I don't know, you know he or what, Yeah, any movie.
- 55:25If I wanted to read that, you know, his review of Spider
- 55:28Man two, I couldn't. You couldn't read it untilund around. You know,
- 55:31it was like right around two thousand, nineteen ninety nine, two thousand
- 55:35is when I remember at least discovering that they were up there. And every
- 55:39Friday, his whole everything he wrote in the paper was online. Yeah,
- 55:44that was just an incredible blessing for a nerd like me, because yeah,
- 55:49I would read, I would read it. I would read every every every
- 55:52Friday was a ritual. Every Friday I would go and read his his stuff.
- 55:58But yes, and and as good as he was then, Yeah,
- 56:00when he lost the ability to speak because he had had cancer and his jaw
- 56:07and his salivary gland and again Ciskel had cancer as well, passed away of
- 56:12cancer, very very young, far too just shockingly young, yes, fifty
- 56:16three. Yeah, when he lost the ability to speak, he like his
- 56:22writing only got better, and you can go read you know, if you
- 56:25read Life Itself, the memoir, you can get a taste of that because
- 56:29it was written, you know, after all of that happened. So it
- 56:31was, and it's kind of some of its adapted or expanded from some of
- 56:36the stuff he was writing, like for his blog and for the Sun Times
- 56:38website. So yeah, it's a it's a really amazing that's an amazing book.
- 56:44But it doesn't have a lot of Ciskel and Ebert in it, which
- 56:46is why I felt okay writing a Ciskel and Ebert book. You know,
- 56:52that's that's the Roger Ebert book. It's not really the Ciskel and Ebert book.
- 56:57And that was sort of where I was hoping to Phil a niche there
- 57:01or Phil a sort of an area that it's He certainly talks about Gene in
- 57:08the book and the show in the book, but it's like three chapters in
- 57:13like a three hundred and something page book. It's not the whole. It's
- 57:16it's really a tiny little bit of it. Oh no, I think you're
- 57:20right. And also, again much like the Beatles and what they did in
- 57:22their solo careers after they broke up, you really, it's it's important to
- 57:27focus on that prime time when they were together and were really making great media
- 57:34and great both be in print and television. Michael had a question regarding Ebert's
- 57:38website it is still going on strong today roderibert dot com. Did he pick
- 57:43the writers for that site? So certainly at the time he did. I
- 57:47mean a lot there were, you know, people that were writing on the
- 57:52site even before he passed away doing He used to have, like I think
- 57:57they were called the far flung correspondence. If he found someone who was writing
- 58:01on a blog, maybe they were freelancing, someone he liked, he would
- 58:06say, oh, you should write for my website. And so some of
- 58:10those people are still working there. And there were other critics that he liked
- 58:15or worked, you know, that he would identify. Now this is now
- 58:20ten years ago, so I can't I can't say for certain that every single
- 58:23person who's writing there now was you know, hand picked by Roger. I
- 58:29think that's probably unlikely certain but certainly, especially in the beginning, they were.
- 58:35And his widow, Chaz is still you know, the head of the
- 58:38website, and she's the one who is certainly vetting everyone over there, and
- 58:44I mean, if anyone would know who he would have wanted writing for the
- 58:47site, it is her. And she does a great job, and she
- 58:51was a great partner for him, and I saw evidence of that in person.
- 58:55And no, she's she's a terrific woman. She really is. I
- 59:01I as we I was gonna say a film that surprised me. He was
- 59:06always a friend to the nerd genre of films, not just superheroes. One
- 59:12of my favorite reviews that I remember as a kid, and I don't remember
- 59:15the title of it, but I remember the review. It was one of
- 59:17those ultimately a wound up on Cinemax as an after hours TNA teen movie,
- 59:23and and and he gave it three stars, and he said, listen,
- 59:27right up front, He's like, all right, I want to be clear,
- 59:30this is a teen tits and ass movie, and it's not for everybody,
- 59:35but if you are a fan of the genre, this actually has a
- 59:39story. They actually make an effort to give us three dimensional characters. And
- 59:45I was really charmed by this movie from a storytelling standpoint, beyond the tits
- 59:52and ass and I and again this I'm like, this is why we love
- 59:55you, Roger. And I even told him that when I when I met
- 59:58him at one time at the film festival, and he laughed and he goes,
- 1:00:00oh, I know what you're talking about. I don't remember the movie.
- 1:00:04He goes, I know exactly what you're talking about, and he probably
- 1:00:06told me the title as well. But it was great. And that's again,
- 1:00:09that's what we always appreciated about Roger, although he hated kick Ass,
- 1:00:15and the reason why he hated kick Ass was seeing Chloe Moretz and I forget
- 1:00:21the rest of her three Roy Grace Murrettz, thank you very much. That
- 1:00:25scene and I don't mean the left because it is horrible, but it was
- 1:00:30a parody when Nick Cage as her father, is preparing her for violence that
- 1:00:35they're going to face when they're playing, when they're being these vigilantes stopping crying
- 1:00:39and he and he has the shotgun and she's wearing the she's wearing very obviously
- 1:00:44a bulletproof vest, but the recoil from being shot by the shotgun, like
- 1:00:49it shows like she gets thrown back like five feet or whatever, and she's
- 1:00:53this little girl and I get it, and he's just like that was horrible.
- 1:00:57That was horrific. I can't believe they did and it really kind of
- 1:01:00clotted the rest of his review of the movie. And I'm like, wow,
- 1:01:04okay, Roger, because you know, he loved Dark City, he
- 1:01:07loved the Star Wars movies. He loves yeah, you know, but yeah,
- 1:01:09that was like an exception. Yeah, well, I mean he was
- 1:01:14he grew up a science fiction fan, Roger. Did you know he he
- 1:01:19was kind of an old school sci fi nerd. Really, you know,
- 1:01:22this is we're talking about the nineteen fifties and maybe a little into the nineteen
- 1:01:27early nineteen sixties. And he wrote about how in that period he loved science
- 1:01:32fiction magazines. He read science fiction fanzines, which was essentially internet culture before
- 1:01:38and internet. It was the fans reacting to the things that they liked,
- 1:01:44putting out their own magazines. He had his own fanzine that he published,
- 1:01:49you know, as a kid. Essentially he was basically I think he was
- 1:01:52thirteen maybe when he was doing this in his house and like mailing people copies
- 1:01:57of it. And he would write letters to other fanzines, to other science
- 1:02:02fiction magazines, some of which you can find they've been you know, people
- 1:02:07have sort of once in a while you'll see one on Twitter or on Facebook,
- 1:02:12someone will discover I was reading this old issue of Amazing Science Fiction and
- 1:02:15there's an there's a in the letters to the editors and there's a letter from
- 1:02:20Roger Ebert in Urbana, Illinois or whatever. So yeah, so he had
- 1:02:24that kind of in his DNA that he loved that sort of stuff. Gene
- 1:02:29mostly hated that stuff, Jane was. It would often complained about science,
- 1:02:34specifically science fiction. He did not like dark science fiction movies. He would
- 1:02:37always complain on the show where are all the up? Why is every movie
- 1:02:43about the future depressing and dark? Who's going to make a movie that shows
- 1:02:46that the future is going to be okay? I mean, Gene, I
- 1:02:52hate to break it to you, maybe it won't be okay. I mean,
- 1:02:53I love the optimism, but I don't know. So, yes,
- 1:02:58he always did appreciate genre films. And you know, he didn't love every
- 1:03:04superhero movie you mentioned. Kick. He didn't give Tim Burton's Batman a thumbs
- 1:03:08up review. He didn't like that movie. And there's other examples, but
- 1:03:13sure most of the big ones. He uh, yeah, he gave a
- 1:03:16lot of those movies positive reviews. I mean, I don't know why you're
- 1:03:21surprised he liked a movie with TNA in it. John the Guy wrote Beyond
- 1:03:25the Valley of the Dolls with Russell absolutely his his well, I didn't know
- 1:03:31that then broke but his his His love of TNA was not a secret,
- 1:03:38certainly not. And that movie is such a mess in the best way.
- 1:03:44It is one of those fun it's a fun crazy movie. It is absolutely
- 1:03:51and the subject of one of Gene Cisco's funniest reviews because he gave it zero
- 1:03:54stars. And you just mentioned didn't mention Er by name, but did say
- 1:04:01the neophyte screenwriter of this motion picture, who russ Meyer, who has made
- 1:04:09good movies in the past, has saddled himself with, must be to blame.
- 1:04:15Why if I've enjoyed russ Byer's other movies, it must be that he
- 1:04:19saddled himself with this neophyte screenwriter who was Rogerriebert his chief competitor. Hilarious and
- 1:04:30yes, and like twenty twenty five years later, maybe you know, like
- 1:04:34the one anniversary in the early nineties, whatever it would have been Entertainment Weekly
- 1:04:40had him had Gene re review it. Maybe it was coming out on DVD
- 1:04:45for the first time, and He quoted his review and said, now that's
- 1:04:48pretty harsh. So what did I think this time? I think I was
- 1:04:51too nice nice to it the first time. It's terrible. It's even worse
- 1:05:00if you're wondering, like why did these guys not like each other? Or
- 1:05:02what was I mean? And just imagine if you made a movie and that
- 1:05:05guy wrote that review and then you had to do something like this and like
- 1:05:10talk about debate that person every week on camera. There you get back no
- 1:05:16again, And I mean just little anecdotes like to keep peace because they'd even
- 1:05:21fight over what to get for lunch that it was finally democratically decided they will
- 1:05:26have the same lunch every day. There will be no choice. We get
- 1:05:30the same lunch every time. Yeah, I got sick of the argument.
- 1:05:34Yes, I'll I'll let people read the book to find out about that.
- 1:05:39But no, man, fantastic, all right? And may I ask do
- 1:05:43you mind it? Do you mind a little bit more time? Because I
- 1:05:45know it's late, you're time? Yeah, a couple more minutes, sure,
- 1:05:47okay, because I gotta ask you. Everyone is this has been a
- 1:05:53rough year for the superhero genre, and I would blame the filmmakers and I
- 1:06:00disagree with the variety cover that I'm sure you're aware of that specifically picked on
- 1:06:05Marvel in terms of their current product, not to say that I I don't
- 1:06:12agree with them, I completely agree with them. That. Yeah, the
- 1:06:15the Phase four and Phase five of the Marvel cinematic universe has been frankly disappointing,
- 1:06:19with very few exceptions Guardians of the Galaxy three, I would say,
- 1:06:24the last Spider Man movie, I would say, uh, I liked I
- 1:06:28liked Falcon in the Winter Soldier for the TV shows, but and certainly DC
- 1:06:33with their movie product. You know, they're they're basically cleaning out the closet
- 1:06:39to prepare for James Gunn's you know, eventual takeover once we see it.
- 1:06:45But where do you think the superhero genre is as far as film and TV?
- 1:06:51It it's a I think it's not certainly not the best time, but
- 1:06:57it might be one of the more interesting times because it is a bit of
- 1:07:00a mess right now. And for so long, you know, people would
- 1:07:04say, well, when are people going to get sick of these movies?
- 1:07:08And it did not happen. They kept, you know, pretty much for
- 1:07:13twenty ish years. Yes, the whole genre just kept going, you know,
- 1:07:17like this expanding up and up and up, and you know, film
- 1:07:21and TV, and it just seemed like this never ending you know, the
- 1:07:28never ending battle for truth justice in the American way. I mean, that's
- 1:07:31what it seemed like. And you know, I don't think we have reached
- 1:07:34the end by any means, but it does seem like we have probably hit
- 1:07:40the first contraction in a while where people are suddenly going, let's ease off
- 1:07:45the pedal a little bit. And it seems like we're going to be seeing
- 1:07:49certainly less Marvel TV shows from what it sounds like, maybe not that many
- 1:07:57less movies. It seems like they've realized that, you know, the movies
- 1:08:00was where they were making when they were really you know, doing well.
- 1:08:03That was where they were making billions of dollars at a at a clip.
- 1:08:09And the TV shows seem to have hurt their bottom line in multiple ways,
- 1:08:14one being there expensive to make, and then you throw them up on a
- 1:08:16streaming service and nobody has to pay to watch them beyond the couple of bucks
- 1:08:20they pay a month, and then in just the idea of diluting the brand
- 1:08:27and making it so that you know, it's like well, what why do
- 1:08:30I pay twenty dollars to see this one over here? When I pay eight
- 1:08:34bucks a month to see all of these other ones over here and never leave
- 1:08:40my house? And is this one really that much better than all of these
- 1:08:44other ones? And I think when you get into that's where you when you
- 1:08:47do that, you get into it. That's a dangerous area to be in
- 1:08:51for anybody, not just Marvel or DC any when when you're giving customers that
- 1:08:57choice, that's that's it. I mean, because and I say that as
- 1:09:01someone who loves going to the movies more than almost anything else I could be
- 1:09:06doing with my time. I went to the movies last night. I put
- 1:09:09my kids to bed and then went to the movies. I said goodbye to
- 1:09:12my wife and I went to the movies. What'd you see? I saw
- 1:09:15Godzilla Minus one. I was gonna I'm so glad, man, I was
- 1:09:18gonna ask about that, but go on as great and I had a great
- 1:09:23time. I was glad I saw it. I was glad I saw it
- 1:09:25in a theater. And I say all of that, and I still I
- 1:09:29can't blame anyone who goes like, why should I pay twenty dollars to see
- 1:09:32the Marvels when I know it's gonna be on Disney Plus in three months,
- 1:09:39and I know and literally the week that it opens, there's a there's a
- 1:09:43Disney Plus show going on right now. I watched a new episode of Loki
- 1:09:47and now you want me to go tonight to a theater at pay It's like,
- 1:09:55you know, like I'm the most pathetic, dorkiest person alive, and
- 1:10:00even I am starting to go this is a lot. Is a lot,
- 1:10:02guys, There's a lot of stuff. I gotta watch all of it.
- 1:10:06I mean, I I just I just watched this thing. I gotta watch
- 1:10:10this thing. It's it. I I so it's it is a It's going
- 1:10:16to be an interesting year or two in that world to see how how these
- 1:10:20companies respond, how Marvel responds, whether they do start making less stuff.
- 1:10:27And certainly I'm very curious about what these new DC things movies and shows apparently
- 1:10:33are going to look like. Because you know you mentioned I agree with you.
- 1:10:39I think the best thing Marvel has done in the last couple of years
- 1:10:42was the last Guardians of the Galaxy movie, and the guy who did it
- 1:10:45left and now he's doing now he's working for the other company, so he
- 1:10:49certainly seems to have you know, have the secret at the moment, so
- 1:10:54it will be very interesting to see what he does with Superman and overseeing all
- 1:10:57these other projects as well. I liked his Suicide Squad movie too, Yeah,
- 1:11:01I did too. I mean, I thought the Guardians movie was better,
- 1:11:04but I liked his Suicide Squad. And Peacemaker was was pretty good.
- 1:11:09Just a great TV show, one of the better ones of these recent you
- 1:11:12know, a streaming superhero interconnected hullabaloo shows. And I liked I liked peace
- 1:11:19Maker, and I liked Suicide the Suicide Squad not yet the second one Squad.
- 1:11:27And regarding and I'm so glad you saw. I haven't seen the Godzilla
- 1:11:30Minus one yet, that is, and I'm sure most of the audience knows
- 1:11:33that's the Toho movie. I gotta confess I have not seen the legendary Titan
- 1:11:41movies as they categorized them, the Godzilla and King Kong modern American movies.
- 1:11:46And was worried going into Monarch, the Apple streaming show that our buddy Matt
- 1:11:53Fraction is the co creator and co show runner of, and I'm like,
- 1:11:58well, it's Matt. I got a one because we're friends and I'll probably
- 1:12:01have them on word blowin. And I was so relieved. I love it.
- 1:12:05Man, it's four episodes in. It is so good and it really
- 1:12:11I was relieved I didn't have to you know, I'm Matt, that's that's
- 1:12:14great. Gee, well done, I guess. Yeah, I've always seen
- 1:12:16the first Yeah, I've only seen the first episode of that. But it
- 1:12:19is. Yeah, it is good and it's certainly the best, the best
- 1:12:23thing in that god forsaken the universe of of Yeah. Otherwise, the movies
- 1:12:29I have not found to be particularly okay, any of them particularly worthwhile.
- 1:12:34So yes, this, this new Godzilla movie I thought was better than all
- 1:12:38of them. I'm put Monarch aside because it's still going and I'm behind anyway,
- 1:12:43but yes, I would. I would. This, this new Toho
- 1:12:48Japanese Godzilla movie is so much better than any of those other American and I
- 1:12:56was thinking it watching it. I was like, this doesn't seem that hard.
- 1:12:59They make it looks so easy. I mean, I'm sure it wasn't
- 1:13:01easy to make, but they just have it down. It's just so good
- 1:13:05and so satisfying, and it's a good monster movie. It's a good disaster
- 1:13:10movie. But it also has great human characters and you care about them,
- 1:13:15and it has ideas, and it's got thoughts in its head, and it's
- 1:13:18an actual movie. It's not just a big c you know, cgi fest,
- 1:13:25and the effects are actually good. Godzilla is scary. It's like,
- 1:13:30why has it all these other this, other, these American companies with I'm
- 1:13:34sure much more money. Why why couldn't they do this? I don't know,
- 1:13:40but I'm glad that this movie is here, and at least in New
- 1:13:44York you could see it in a few places. I don't know if it's
- 1:13:45playing in Chicago. It is absolutely is as a good movie. I guess.
- 1:13:50Ken Dog tells us the trailer recently, Yeah, just today. I
- 1:13:54yeah, I just saw that an hour or two ago. Yeah, it's
- 1:13:57like Godzilla and Kanng are buddies and they're running around inside the hollow wers.
- 1:14:02This will be the way some kind of like metal, like a like a
- 1:14:06robot fist. Unless I didn't see the trailer right, it looks like he's
- 1:14:11got like a yellow robot fist. Well, I hope the glove like he's
- 1:14:16wearing like the Nintendo Power glove or something. I don't know. I hope
- 1:14:21Matt that's good. I hope it's I hope Matt has had an influence on
- 1:14:26whatever. It would be good, that would I'm sure that would improve things.
- 1:14:30They they were they've been working on this TV show for five years.
- 1:14:32I mean, obviously COVID didn't help as far as the delays getting it finally
- 1:14:36on screen. But and I'm really glad you mentioned She's CGI because and and
- 1:14:42again I want your opinion on both of these things. First of all,
- 1:14:45I agree with you there will be likely be less superhero TV and film,
- 1:14:50but I don't think it's going away. I think, much like the Western,
- 1:14:55they've kind of planted their their feet in the movie world and the genre
- 1:15:00is here to stay. We might see less, but I think a big
- 1:15:02problem with the current crop of films is that third act hero versus CGI threat
- 1:15:12and it's getting boring and it's the same thing over and over again. An
- 1:15:16exception, and I don't know if you saw it. I saw it on
- 1:15:18Amazon and now in blanking on who the studio was, it was one of
- 1:15:24the smaller studios, but Stallone's movie was it called Samaritan, that is what
- 1:15:29it was called. I didn't. I don't think I ever did see that.
- 1:15:31I don't need to catch that. I thought it was entertaining because it
- 1:15:34was two guys fighting. It was certainly made for a smaller budget than these
- 1:15:40movies that cost two hundred million dollars just to make, and then have that
- 1:15:44billion dollar imperative of well, if we're going to see a profit, it
- 1:15:48better make at least eight or nine hundred million dollars, which is like,
- 1:15:53how dare and not to sound like some greta I forget the kid's name,
- 1:15:58the environmentalist, how dare you like have that that that thought in your mind
- 1:16:04that well, it has to make this much money? Well, f you
- 1:16:08who told you to made such an expensive movie? And you go back to
- 1:16:11that first Deadpool movie and that was made for less than one hundred million dollars
- 1:16:15and it made six hundred million at the box office and was a big hit
- 1:16:19and a big profit. I don't know. But again, thoughts on the
- 1:16:23genre itself, and also that that third act cgi problem that I see,
- 1:16:29Well, I think there you're talking about two I would say interconnected problems,
- 1:16:33one being I think the effects in some of these movies, not all of
- 1:16:39them, but in a lot of them. They've just the quality seems to
- 1:16:43be very uneven. And you know, we've i've certainly I don't have any
- 1:16:46inside sources here, but you read these articles about, you know, with
- 1:16:50anonymous quotes from VFX workers who say that the conditions on these movies are miserable,
- 1:16:59and you know, and and not just with Marvel, although there's there
- 1:17:02seems to be more more articles about Marvel, maybe just because that's what gets
- 1:17:08traffic on the web, I don't know, but just that you know that
- 1:17:11the studios have these outrageous demands for they have all these effect shots they need
- 1:17:15done, and they don't want to pay for them, and they don't have
- 1:17:17any time to get them done, and the result is, you know,
- 1:17:20CGI slop basically, And I think it seems like that's happening more and more.
- 1:17:28And that's kind of what I was saying with this Godzilla movie, where
- 1:17:30it actually looks great, you know, for again, a movie that I'm
- 1:17:33sure cost a lot less than some of these big movies that have come out
- 1:17:39this year. You know, like some of the effects in The Flash.
- 1:17:42I thought a movie that I overall kind of enjoyed, I have to say,
- 1:17:45but some of the some of the effects in it were just you know,
- 1:17:49like Uncanny Valley nightmares. So you know, that's one issue, and
- 1:17:56then I think the second issue is that again, there's so many of these
- 1:18:00that it's hard how many different ways can you show one person punching another person?
- 1:18:08You know, I think we can all think of twenty years ago,
- 1:18:13or I certainly can. The first time you saw Spider Man swinging in Sam
- 1:18:17Raimi's Spider Man was like, a it's a good thing. I'm sitting down,
- 1:18:23I might faint kind of a moment for a comic book fan. It
- 1:18:26was transcendent. Not to get sappy on you, I'm with you, but
- 1:18:30it was ye. And there's other EXAs you know, and like the first
- 1:18:35Iron Man movie when he's flying around, it was like, wow, this
- 1:18:40is something novel and new. And you know, the way that they were
- 1:18:44integrating the character flying through the air and downy in that kind of you know,
- 1:18:49heads up display space. It all it felt fresh and exciting, and
- 1:18:57I feel like you get that feeling less and less these days. Some of
- 1:19:00it is inevitable. Maybe some of it is just that we that it's just
- 1:19:04impossible to excite people when you have so much stuff, or maybe we need
- 1:19:10to maybe there needs to be some I don't know, new ideas, new
- 1:19:13blood, I don't know. But I think that's the other issue that you're
- 1:19:16talking about is that, yes, I understand what you're saying about the third
- 1:19:19act. A lot of these movies, the effects aren't that great, But
- 1:19:24even if they were better, would would it make that much of a difference
- 1:19:28if it's still just a bunch of people punching each other, or if it's
- 1:19:31there's a laser in the sky and we have to stop it, Like how
- 1:19:34many times do we need to see that? It's we need I think that
- 1:19:40feeling that I'm describing, You need a movie that gives you that. And
- 1:19:44when you look I think when you look at the movies that still are doing
- 1:19:47well at the box office, be they superhero movies or not, those are
- 1:19:51the ones that are giving people those feelings, you know, like, I
- 1:19:56mean, this is not a superhero movie, but I think really people gave
- 1:20:00them something that they didn't haven't hadn't seen before. We're excited to see,
- 1:20:06uh, you know, So I think that's what's uh, that's the Those
- 1:20:14are the two I guess issues I would say that are the problem that you've
- 1:20:17kind of put your finger on there. No, I'm with you, man,
- 1:20:20it's a better writing innovation. Uh some innovation. That's a good word
- 1:20:27for what you could use. Well, you described it in terms of,
- 1:20:30you know, getting getting in Iron Man's helmet and seeing his read out,
- 1:20:34something I never thought of reading the comics back in the day. So yeah,
- 1:20:40no, I I they got to give us something else and something fresh.
- 1:20:43I completely agree with that. Well, Matt, this this book and
- 1:20:46the Spider Man book that he wrote a couple of years ago as well.
- 1:20:49Are you prepping your next book? Uh? Well, see, I'm trying
- 1:20:55to. Yeah, we're trying to figure out what a next book could be.
- 1:20:58At this point. I have had some ideas. Nothing has quite come
- 1:21:00together yet, but we'll see. One of the things certainly like to keep
- 1:21:05writing books. I love doing it. So something you used to do as
- 1:21:09well was you went through a lot of the history of superhero films, going
- 1:21:14back to the Cliffhangers and things like that, and I loved it. And
- 1:21:16I don't know if that is a I mean, you were doing them as
- 1:21:19as a blog posts, essentially on screen crush, not on indie wire.
- 1:21:24As I recall, but yes, yeah, that was a column screen Crutch
- 1:21:28stuff. We did one series that was about four six, five six years
- 1:21:35ago now, but yeah, I love doing that the problem. Yeah,
- 1:21:38so that was years ago. When I started at screen Crush, I had
- 1:21:44a boss and like you know, a person who was in charge of the
- 1:21:46site, and I was able to just kind of be the writer and I
- 1:21:49could write about things. And I did that column, and my hope was
- 1:21:54I was going to do write about every single comic book movie that had ever
- 1:21:57been made in chronological order. And I started with Yeah, as you mentioned,
- 1:22:00the serials because those were the original superhero movies. The Adventures of Captain
- 1:22:05Marvel was the very first one ever made, and so I started with that
- 1:22:09and then I was going through sequentially. And while I was doing that was
- 1:22:14when my boss left the company to go do it something else, and they
- 1:22:18kind of handed me the whole website and it just became impossible to do it,
- 1:22:23basically because the time commitments were too much and it just it became too
- 1:22:29hard. But I always wanted to do that. Well, if you own
- 1:22:32the DVD of the Captain Marvel serials, if it's from Keno, I wrote
- 1:22:35the booklet essay that's in the Keno version of the Adventures of Captain Marvel,
- 1:22:43and I was a darn good essay, I have to say. I went
- 1:22:45to I did went to the New York Public Library and dug up the director's
- 1:22:50memoirs, which were out of print for about years, and got some quotes
- 1:22:56about the making of it from from him, from William Whitney I think is
- 1:23:00his name, But yeah, so it was I love doing that. That
- 1:23:04was a really fun, fun project to do, but it was very time
- 1:23:09well because I mean every serial they're they're not really meant to be watched altogether.
- 1:23:15So I'm trying to do it. Maybe if I had done it where
- 1:23:17every week I wrote about a new chapter, I could have pulled it off.
- 1:23:19But I was trying to write about once a week a four hour serial.
- 1:23:26That was That was tough. And they were also not all of them
- 1:23:29were of the quality of the Adventures of Captain Marvel. Some of them were
- 1:23:32really crummy. Some of them were very repetitive. Yeah, so it just
- 1:23:39kind of kind of got away with me. I got away from me.
- 1:23:41I've often thought about how could I do it in a way that I could
- 1:23:45do it now, because it's so hard for me now to do stuff like
- 1:23:48that because I just don't have the time. But someday, Yeah, I
- 1:23:51mean the old ones, the ones that I wrote, are all still up
- 1:23:54there. You could find them if you. I think it was called just
- 1:23:57the History of Comic Book Movies was the name of them. And they're all
- 1:24:00inter linked, so if you find the first one, the Adventures of Captain
- 1:24:02Marvel, you should be able to go from one to the next to the
- 1:24:06next. I think I did somewhere between five and ten, which isn't very
- 1:24:11much, but no, and there were a ton of them, so it
- 1:24:14was just yeah, I mean I did, yeah, a bunch of cereals.
- 1:24:17I got to one. Did I get to Superman in the moment?
- 1:24:23Or did I do that as a separate, standalone thing at some point?
- 1:24:26I might have. I don't remember if I did that as part of the
- 1:24:28column or not. I know I read the spice. You did Spy Smasher,
- 1:24:31didn't you. Spy Smasher was second or third? Yes, Spy Smasher
- 1:24:34is awesome. It's crazy watching Captain Marble throw gangsters off the top of us
- 1:24:41look great, great cereal. I mean, there weren't that many effects they
- 1:24:46could pull off in nineteen thirty nine or nineteen forty one or whatever. It
- 1:24:50is, throwing people off a building, we could do that. Let's let's
- 1:24:54show. But you got to give them credit for the flying I mean,
- 1:24:58yeah, you know I effects for the time, and especially in Captain Marvel
- 1:25:02they're not bad actually, And you know they that started as a Superman project
- 1:25:09and couldn't come up with a deal with National the yill right exactly, Captain
- 1:25:15Marvel, and it's no, it's one of the best, no, you
- 1:25:17know, and I really do find that fascinating. Even for a couple conventions,
- 1:25:21would do panels to remind people that this even even going back to the
- 1:25:27Superman seventy eight Richard Donner movie that it's like, you know, this was
- 1:25:31done back in the forties and much like today with film and television, it
- 1:25:36was film and radio. I mean you had Lone Ranger, Green Hornet,
- 1:25:40but even the Blue Beetle had his own radio series. Uh you know,
- 1:25:45so there were other super I mean the Green Lama super Air that did not
- 1:25:49survive the are you incredibly old? Well, and that as you know,
- 1:25:56growing up in the five channel world, my pati view only I know you
- 1:26:00are, it's a good tomorrow. You're right, but you're but you're right.
- 1:26:03I mean, look, if you are sick of uh CGI slop,
- 1:26:10I think I was the phrase that I pulled out of my tucks. If
- 1:26:14you're sick of that. But you want something different, something superhero, we
- 1:26:19try Adventures of Captain Marvel. There's no CGI, but there's a lot of
- 1:26:26guys like, you know, stuntmen taking actual you know, chairs and breaking
- 1:26:31them over people's backs. If you want to see guys like throwing themselves at
- 1:26:35each other and just beaten the living crap out of each other and punch,
- 1:26:41you know, throwing each other off of buildings, trains Captain Marvel. Spy
- 1:26:45Smasher the one John mentioned that's probably the best of all of those cereals,
- 1:26:50That Spy Smasher, which is based on a comic too, but not that
- 1:26:54anyone remembers it. I've certainly never read an issue of Spy Smasher. Point
- 1:27:00the Spy Smasher is awesome, Like it is just a great crazy action movie.
- 1:27:04Like if you want capes and masks, no, I'm with you,
- 1:27:09man. Well, and even if you don't have four hours to spend on
- 1:27:12an entire cereal. Uh. This week on Turner Classic Movies, they did
- 1:27:15a whole afternoon of Tarzan, or really from the morning through the late afternoon,
- 1:27:19they did Tarzan Movies. Tarzan's New York Adventure. I think it's like
- 1:27:24forty or forty one. It's a superhero movie, and it is so great
- 1:27:28because there are scenes of Tarzan just in the loincloth on a New York balcony
- 1:27:33about to leap from skyscraper to skyscraper. And then they also have seen some
- 1:27:39of them in a full suit doing his Tarzan stuff. And this is even
- 1:27:43though Johnny White smother starting in the thirties, he still had the build.
- 1:27:45He said, it's before he got too fat, and they made a bungle
- 1:27:48gym because that's what happened to him when he couldn't fit in the loin cloth
- 1:27:53anymore. I give it's like was it Mark Wade's Ksar Run when he put
- 1:27:58him in It sounds just like his care comics, which I'm sure was inspired.
- 1:28:01I'm I'm a doctor later this month, and I have a feeling I
- 1:28:06love that a kid I had all those issues. You're killing me, man,
- 1:28:11that's great. Let's say, uh yes, Well, Mike says that
- 1:28:15I remember when the Cubs won the World Series in nineteen oh eight. No,
- 1:28:18not that bad. I'm not a I'm not a time lord. I'm
- 1:28:20not a time lord, even though Ken Dock says I have a tartiste stat
- 1:28:25somewhere. By the way, I don't know if. I don't know if
- 1:28:27you're watching the new Doctor Who. But it's I've enjoyed it. I've really
- 1:28:30enjoyed it. Yeah, I've heard it's good. I have not Doctor Who
- 1:28:32is like a bridge too far even for me. It's like the one thing
- 1:28:36I've never been able to get into, you know what. I've kind of
- 1:28:41gotten out of the habit of and I'm trying to get back into it.
- 1:28:44But I just don't have the desire our fantasy movies. I know how Sad
- 1:28:46Dragon season two is starting up again. I don't know if I can get
- 1:28:50up the enthusiasm anymore for that, or you know, the tolkien esque sort
- 1:28:55of fantasy world of warcraft, you name it. It's like, I don't
- 1:28:59know again. I I still love superhero stuff, and I used to love
- 1:29:01the fantasy stuff, but something happened. I don't know. I don't know
- 1:29:05anyway, I'll wrap up with you, Matt, you've been kind of stay
- 1:29:09awake. It's late your time. Opposable thumbs everybody. How Ciskel and Ebert
- 1:29:13changed Movies Forever tremendous book by Matt Singer. It really does these guys justice
- 1:29:20and reminds everyone of a time when there were fewer critics. But these guys
- 1:29:26really again had their fingers on the pulse of what people wanted to see and
- 1:29:30then really drove people to a lot of movies that maybe they wouldn't have seen
- 1:29:34had it not been for a ciscl and Ebert on in printer or on TV
- 1:29:38telling us about great movies. So well done that. Congratulations, thank you,
- 1:29:43thank you. I appreciate it. I want to hear more OTB stories
- 1:29:45sometime about Jeane ciscal and the OTB. People told me stories there some in
- 1:29:50the book. Richard Roper did actually talked about going to the OTB with Jean.
- 1:29:57He was another he's another gambling fan or was. I don't know,
- 1:30:00Maybe I don't know, I know, but he talked to I mean,
- 1:30:02when I interviewed him for the book, he specifically said, like you know,
- 1:30:06obviously he worked with Roger later and Ebert and Roper and they were colleagues
- 1:30:11at the Sun Times. But he said, I was initially closer with Jane
- 1:30:15because we gambled together. We like to go to the OTB. So there
- 1:30:17you go. Yeah, but I want to hear I want to hear more
- 1:30:19of these stories some other time. Richard Richard was an upper classman at Illinois
- 1:30:25State when I was there and I was a freshman. We didn't know each
- 1:30:28other, but later on became aware of the fact that we were almost almost
- 1:30:34there and we would have likely run into each other if we were closer in
- 1:30:38age, just because of the radio station and the newspaper down there and stuff
- 1:30:42the Daily Thedet. So thank you, Matt, Thank you very much,
- 1:30:46everybody, thanks for watching. Let me give you a preview what's coming up
- 1:30:49this week, and it's going to be at various times around this time.
- 1:30:53Tomorrow night, I'm gonna talk to Gabe Hardman. He's got a brand new
- 1:30:56Braven Bolt story with Batman and Aquaman, so we'll be discussing that. That'll
- 1:31:00be a lot of fun. Tuesday, I'm gonna be on a guest on
- 1:31:03a show and we're gonna be discussing comics and it'll be on the Word Balloon
- 1:31:08Feed, We're going to talk about Thy Kingdom Come the jsa arc of stories
- 1:31:14where the Kingdom Comes Superman wound up on Earth one and was with the Justice
- 1:31:19Society for more issues than I thought. It was only a six issue story.
- 1:31:24This is like eighteen issues and two annuals. It was kind of crazy.
- 1:31:29But that's that's gonna be on Tuesday. And then Wednesday. What the
- 1:31:32hell am I doing Wednesday? Oh, Geoff Johns, Jeff Johns is gonna
- 1:31:35We're gonna record something. John's Yeah, sorry, you know whatever exactly So,
- 1:31:43and then I'm doing another show on Thursday where I'll have a discussion with
- 1:31:46another good friend. So I'll tell you more this week. But it's a
- 1:31:49it's a full week on word Balloon Live. I hope you'll join me.
- 1:31:51Thanks a lot, too, Mad, Thanks everybody for watching, and good
- 1:31:55questions and good comments. Until next time, Stay safe, stay happy,
- 1:31:59stay healthy,