Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / Why the Treasury's Buyback Plan Might Backfire
Transcript
- Lucas: So the thirty-year Treasury is yielding five point two three percent. And that number, more than any other, is telling us the Treasury's own plan to calm the bond market might be doing the opposite. Luna: Five point two three on the long end, while the three-month bill is at three point eight seven. That's a spread of over a hundred and thirty basis points. The market is demanding real compensation for holding long-term debt. Lucas: Yeah, and it's why the buyback story matters. Look, we talk a lot on this show about the mechanics of the debt. But today I want to focus on one specific tool that Treasury Secretary Bessent has been pushing — buying back the government's own bonds — and why it might backfire. Luna: Before we dive in — if walking through the economy with us has made something click, the smallest gesture goes a long way. A coffee's worth, even. That's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It keeps this show ad-free. Lucas: Yeah, we don't have commercials, and that's only because some of you decide to chip in. And we're grateful. Okay — back to the buybacks. The idea is simple: the Treasury uses cash from its general account to repurchase outstanding bonds, especially older, higher-coupon ones, to reduce its future interest costs. Luna: But it's not simple in practice. Because where does the cash come from? The Treasury General Account — that's the government's checking account with the Fed. And that balance has been hovering around a trillion dollars lately. Lucas: Right. And that's the core tension. Bessent is essentially taking money that sits idle in the TGA and using it to buy back bonds. On paper, that lowers the outstanding debt — but it also injects cash into the banking system, which can be stimulative at a time when inflation is still above target. Luna: And the markets have noticed. The CNBC headline yesterday was literally 'Bessent's bond gambit aimed at calming markets is instead stirring inflation worries.' That's the crux. Lucas: So let's unpack why a tool that sounds prudent — buying back debt — could actually push long-term yields higher. First, there's the signal. When the Treasury starts buying its own bonds, it looks like it's trying to manipulate the yield curve. And the market hates that. Luna: But doesn't the Fed do that all the time with quantitative easing? What's the difference? Lucas: Big difference. The Fed creates reserves to buy bonds, and it's explicitly a monetary policy tool. The Treasury is supposed to be fiscal — it decides how much to borrow and when. When the Treasury starts buying, it blurs the line. Investors start asking: are they doing this because the auctions are failing? Are they trying to prop up the market? Luna: And that creates a credibility problem. If investors think the Treasury is scared about demand, they demand a premium for holding longer-dated paper. That pushes yields up, not down. Lucas: Exactly. And we're seeing some of that now. The ten-year yield has climbed to four point six nine percent, up from four point six five just a few weeks ago. The thirty-year is above five point two. These are levels we haven't sustained since before the financial crisis. Luna: But wait — isn't the buyback also supposed to reduce the supply of bonds, which should push prices up and yields down? I mean, basic supply and demand. Lucas: In theory, yes. But the reality is more complicated. The Treasury plans to fund these buybacks by issuing new short-term bills. So they're not actually reducing the total debt — they're just shortening the maturity structure. They're swapping long-term debt for short-term debt. Luna: So they're taking money from the TGA to buy long bonds, but then issuing bills to refill the TGA. That's a wash on the total debt, but it does change the composition. Lucas: Right. And here's the kicker: short-term rates are lower than long-term rates right now. The two-year is at four point one nine, the thirty-year is five point two three. So in the short run, swapping long for short saves money on interest costs. But it also makes the debt more sensitive to refinancing risk. If rates stay high, the Treasury has to roll over those bills at ever-higher yields. Luna: And that's exactly what the bond market is worried about. They're not stupid — they see the Treasury taking on more short-term debt, and that adds to the term premium. That might be why the 30-year is pushing higher despite the buyback program. Lucas: Let me put some numbers on it. The federal debt is now over thirty-nine trillion dollars. Debt to GDP is at one hundred and twenty-two point six percent. The deficit for the last fiscal year was one point seven seven trillion dollars. That's a massive amount of new supply coming every year. The buyback program is a drop in the bucket compared to that. Luna: So you're saying the buyback is basically cosmetic? It might make the Treasury feel better, but it doesn't change the fundamental trajectory. Lucas: It's worse than cosmetic in a way, because it risks undermining the Treasury's credibility. And once you lose credibility in the bond market, it's very hard to get it back. We saw that in the U.K. with the Truss mini-budget in 2022 — the market revolted, and the government had to reverse course. Luna: That's a good comparison. But is there a scenario where buybacks actually work? I mean, Japan has been doing yield curve control for years, and long-term rates there are still near zero. Lucas: Japan is a different beast — they have persistent deflation, a captive domestic investor base, and the central bank is willing to buy unlimited amounts. The U.S. Treasury doesn't have that luxury. The Fed is currently in tightening mode, not easing. And the dollar's role as the global reserve currency means foreign investors are watching closely. Luna: And those foreign investors — they're already nervous about the debt trajectory. If they start dumping Treasuries, that could spiral. Lucas: Right. And that's why Bessent's move is so risky. He's essentially trying to calm the market with a tool that raises more questions than answers. The headlines are already reflecting that — 'Bessent could tap near $1 trillion TGA to fund bond buybacks' — and the reaction has been, 'Okay, but what does that actually solve?' Luna: But hold on, isn't there also an argument that buybacks help with liquidity? You know, in the secondary market? Some of those older issues are hard to trade, and buying them back could make the market more efficient. Lucas: That's a fair point. There is a legitimate liquidity argument, especially for illiquid off-the-run bonds. But you can do that with a small, targeted program. You don't need a trillion-dollar operation to improve liquidity. The scale suggests a different motive — maybe trying to put a floor under prices. Luna: So what would that look like? I mean, if the market perceives it as a form of price manipulation, that could backfire spectacularly. Lucas: Exactly. And we're seeing early signs. The 30-year yield has actually risen since the buyback news broke. It's at five point two three, up from five point one nine a week ago. If the goal was to calm long-term rates, it's not working. Luna: And the yield curve is steepening — the ten-year minus two-year spread is at fifty basis points and holding. That's a sign that investors are demanding more compensation for duration risk, which is exactly the opposite of what the Treasury wants. Lucas: So where does this leave us? The Treasury is stuck between a rock and a hard place. They need to refinance a massive amount of debt, but they're worried about the cost. They're trying to manage the maturity structure, but the market isn't cooperating. And they're using a tool that, in the eyes of many, signals weakness rather than strength. Luna: Is there an alternative? I mean, what could the Treasury do instead? Lucas: Well, the honest answer is: focus on the actual deficit. The buyback is a band-aid. The only real fix is getting the fiscal house in order — either raising taxes or cutting spending, or both. Until then, the market will keep demanding higher yields to compensate for the risk of holding U.S. debt. Luna: But that's politically hard. And the election cycle makes it even harder. Lucas: No question. But at some point, the bond market will force the issue. We saw a preview of that in 2023 when the 30-year hit five percent and the Treasury had to adjust its issuance plans. Now we're back above that level, and Bessent is trying to fight it with buybacks. It might work for a while, but it's not a sustainable strategy. Luna: So what should listeners watch for in the coming weeks? What would signal that the buyback is actually working — or failing? Lucas: Watch the 30-year yield. If it stays above five percent, that's a clear signal the market isn't buying the Treasury's story. Also watch the auction results — if there's weak demand at the longer end, that's bad news. And keep an eye on the term premium; there are estimates that it's been slowly climbing, and if it jumps, that's a red flag. Luna: And one more thing — the inflation data. If the buyback program is seen as stimulative, that could feed into inflation expectations, which would push long-term yields even higher. Lucas: Right. It's a classic feedback loop. The Treasury thinks it's solving a problem, but it might be making it worse. The next few months will be telling. For now, the buyback plan is a high-stakes experiment, and the market is the judge. Luna: And the verdict so far? I'd say it's not looking good. Lucas: Yeah. The bond market is a harsh judge. And it's not impressed.