Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the Zeigarnik Effect Keeps You Thinking About Work
Transcript
- Lucas: You know that feeling when you leave the office and you can't stop thinking about that one email you haven't sent? Or the project report that's 90 percent done but that final 10 percent is just sitting there in your head? Luna: Oh, absolutely. It's like my brain has a pop-up ad that won't close. And it's always the unfinished stuff, never the thing I completed. Lucas: That's actually a well-documented psychological phenomenon called the Zeigarnik Effect. Named after a Soviet psychologist, Bluma Zeigarnik, who noticed something interesting in a Berlin restaurant in the 1920s. Luna: Wait — a restaurant? What did waiters have to do with psychology? Lucas: Everything, as it turns out. Zeigarnik observed that waiters could remember complex orders for tables that hadn't paid yet, but as soon as the bill was settled, they completely forgot the details. The incomplete task — getting paid — kept the order fresh in memory. Completion erased it. Luna: So our brains are basically designed to hold onto unfinished business. That explains a lot about my Sunday night anxiety. Lucas: Right. Zeigarnik went back to the lab and ran experiments where people performed simple tasks — puzzles, arithmetic — and then were interrupted halfway through. Later, when asked to recall what they'd been working on, they remembered the interrupted tasks about twice as well as the completed ones. Luna: So interruption actually improves memory of the task. That's counterintuitive. Lucas: It is, and it has huge implications for office politics and productivity. Let's start with the productivity angle. If you're constantly switching between tasks, your brain holds all of them in an active 'open loop' state. That mental load taxes your focus. Luna: Which is why multitasking feels so exhausting. You're not actually doing multiple things — you're just accumulating open loops. Lucas: Exactly. But here's the strategic flip side: you can use the Zeigarnik Effect deliberately. One technique I've seen work is what some call the 'open-loop close.' If you're stuck on a problem, leave it mid-step before a break. Your brain will keep working on it in the background. Luna: So instead of finishing a paragraph, stop mid-sentence. Then when you come back, the momentum is still there. Lucas: Exactly. Ernest Hemingway famously used this — he'd stop writing when he knew what came next, so the next day he could pick up easily. But it works for spreadsheets, code, even meeting prep. Luna: I've also noticed this in meetings. If someone presents a half-baked idea and then says 'I'll circle back,' my brain flags that as incomplete. I end up thinking about it more. Lucas: And that's the political angle. You can use interruption strategically to keep your ideas top of mind. If you want a proposal to get more attention, present it but leave one key question unanswered. Colleagues will mentally chew on it. Luna: But there's a fine line between strategic and annoying. If you're always leaving things hanging, people might just think you're disorganized. Lucas: Right, you have to be intentional. The Zeigarnik Effect is strongest when the task is nearly complete — 90 percent done. If you leave something at 50 percent, the brain might just drop it entirely. The tension is highest near the finish line. Luna: So the sweet spot is to get to almost done, then pause. That way the loop is tight, and the brain really wants to close it. Lucas: Exactly. And this is also why deadlines work. A looming deadline creates a sense of incompleteness that your brain can't ignore. Parkinson's Law — work expands to fill the time available — is partly just the Zeigarnik Effect in slow motion. Luna: Speaking of deadlines, I want to pause for a second. Lucas, we've been doing this show for a while now, and one thing I've heard from listeners is that the episodes help them think through career moves and decisions. I know I've used some of these concepts myself. Lucas: Same here. And honestly, the reason we can keep the show ad-free and focused on real content is that some listeners choose to support us directly. If this podcast has helped you navigate a tricky situation at work, or just given you a new lens, you can buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, ever. Luna: Yeah, it's a small way to keep the conversation going. And we really appreciate it. Now — back to open loops. You mentioned managers can use this, too? Lucas: Yes. A good manager can leverage the Zeigarnik Effect to keep teams engaged. For example, instead of assigning a whole project at once, break it into phases and celebrate each completion. Each finished phase clears a loop, which feels good, but the next phase creates a new one. Luna: So it's like a series of small dopamine hits. Finish a task, get the reward, then immediately open a new loop. Lucas: Exactly. And the opposite is true too — if you have too many open loops without any closures, you get overwhelmed. That's when people start dropping balls. Luna: I think that's why to-do lists are so popular. Checking an item off literally closes a mental loop. But if the list is too long, it's just a collection of open loops. Lucas: Right. The key is to limit the number of active open loops. Some research suggests the average person can hold about three to five tasks in active memory. Beyond that, the Zeigarnik Effect backfires — the brain just starts ignoring things. Luna: So if you're juggling ten projects, you're not really juggling. You're just dropping most of them. Lucas: Pretty much. And that's where the politics comes in. If you want to be seen as reliable, you need to close loops publicly. Send that follow-up email. Mark the task done in the shared tracker. Verbalize completion in a meeting. Luna: Because if you don't close it visibly, people assume it's still open. That can hurt your reputation. Lucas: Exactly. The Zeigarnik Effect applies to other people's perception of you too. If you leave a task dangling, they'll keep wondering about it — and not always in a good way. Luna: So the practical takeaway is: be intentional about what you leave incomplete, and deliberate about closing loops when it matters. Lucas: Yes. Use the effect for creative momentum — stop at a point where the next step is obvious. Use it for influence — present incomplete ideas that invite collaboration. But also use it for trust — close loops on commitments so people know you follow through. Luna: I think the biggest trap is the procrastinator's paradox. You put off a task because it feels hard, but the open loop eats up mental energy, making everything else harder. Lucas: That's the Zeigarnik Effect as a tax, not a tool. The fix is to break the task into the smallest possible next step. Instead of 'write the report,' write 'open the document and write the first sentence.' That tiny closure can break the loop. Luna: Interesting. So the effect cuts both ways — it can paralyze you or propel you, depending on how you use it. Lucas: Exactly. And knowing that is half the battle. Once you recognize that nagging feeling as a cognitive quirk, you can decide whether to close the loop or let it simmer. Luna: Alright, so next time I'm lying awake at 2 a.m. thinking about that unfinished spreadsheet, I'll tell myself it's just the Zeigarnik Effect. And maybe I'll get up and write one cell. Lucas: One cell is enough to close the loop. And then you can sleep. That's the power of understanding how your own mind works.