Latest / Neon Protocol / Designing for Presence
Transcript
- Gene Feldman: I loving having AI AI and every AI and everything. Dan Meeks: Celantra. Gene Feldman: All right, everybody. Welcome to the next episode of Neon Protocol. I'm Gene, and with us we have Damon, Mike, and Dan from the Neon Protocol team. And today we're being joined with Corey Seifert, who is I'll let him introduce himself, but absolutely fantastic storyteller who brings a very unique lens to this immersive technology and some of the solutions that we talk about on this podcast. So, Corey, before I even go any further, I'll let you actually go ahead and introduce yourself to us. Coray Seifert: Sure, yeah. Hi, ⁓ Corey Seifert. I've been in games and simulation technology for about 20 years. ⁓ kind of got my start in the ⁓ you know, triple A shooter space. ⁓ over the sort of the back half of my career, I've been more on the ⁓ emerging tech side, a lot of XR, ⁓ a little bit of AR, ⁓ you know, ⁓ just as we're starting to dip our toes into it. Most recently I was at Meta. ⁓ before that I was at NVIDIA and Autodesk. ⁓ recently started a publisher for primarily XR content, but also PC console ⁓ called Dark Arts Syndicates. I'm the chief creative officer there. Gene Feldman: Nice. So and we also had Mark that joined. I d I wanna make sure I don't forget about him. ⁓ no, that's actually fantastic. ⁓ so ⁓ rather than asking about that if you were part of the collateral damage, you know, that that a lot of the XR industry is going through right now, and I think w we could probably trauma bond over that for the next three or four hours. ⁓ especially even with Lenovo's announcement, I guess, earlier today that they're they're closing shop on their XR and they're moving everything to Coray Seifert: Ha ha ha. Gene Feldman: to wearables. So we'll see what the fallout of that is. But rather than talk about that, I would actually love to know more, and I think we all would of this of the dark arts. Not that we please share the dark arts with us. No, it's more of, you know, ⁓ let's talk the let's bring out the positive of what you're doing because I think it also really helps to know, you know, just your background of storytelling, even that you write novels and you've really Coray Seifert: Ha Well Yeah. Gene Feldman: expand it so I'd really love to know what what this what the dark arts company not the dark arts practice is for. Coray Seifert: Sure, yeah. And and if you'll if you'll forgive a brief ⁓ tangent, I the I I, you know, was a game writer for twenty years. I found myself kind of moving more into the leadership side, ⁓ and it became harder and harder to write professionally, right? You just sort of get sucked into all these meetings all day and you don't have time to lay down twenty versions of I'm reloading. ⁓ so I missed it quite a bit and I started to explore long form fiction. And my first book was or my first manuscript I should say, I didn't actually get it to publish yet. ⁓ was a a book called Time Augmented, where this plucky group of scientists need to use augmented reality technology to find a cure for a global pandemic. And I wrote it before COVID, which was weird. ⁓ yeah. So that was a that was an interesting one. And the reason I the reason this is super relevant is one of my beta readers for that was Melissa Brown, global ⁓ former global head of developer relations for meta who ⁓ I'm convinced hired me at Meta in part because of my very shitty first manuscript. ⁓ because it was, you know, all AR futurism. I wrote a whole novel about like how cool AR is gonna be, you know, plus dinosaurs. And the I think that that like love of of futurism has been a through line in my career, right? ⁓ Autodesk, I got to work on like these like cool early samples with DK2. Gene Feldman: Nice. Yeah. Coray Seifert: ⁓ NVIDIA was a lot of like digital twin kind of stuff, and obviously at Meta we just published a ton of games. ⁓ the thing that we're doing with dark arts is basically the big lessons we learned at Meta, which they're not terribly different than any software development, but they're maybe exacerbated by the modern audience. You know, the the modern audience we're finding is ⁓ hesitant to engage in new content because everyone's got these games and products that have, you know. biweekly updates, long roadmaps, annual battle passes. It's it's just like a feast of content. And so people are like, yeah, I've got my three or two or one or or three, whatever. However many games I play, I'm I I'm fully scheduled for my gaming, right? And the only way that we found you break through with that is you do not the traditional, hey, let's throw $20 million at something and see if it sticks. You do 10 quick little prototypes, send it out to like these online communities and then see what sticks and reinvest in that. So that's kind of like the model behind dark arts. It's build with the community, build with this very modern ⁓ development sensibility. And ⁓ obviously, you know, XR is a big part of that. And I think, you know, if you're starting a business now and you're not looking at wearables slash AR, ⁓ that's a pretty hard way to ⁓ start things and get momentum. So obviously we have a a a toe in that. Gene Feldman: ⁓ of course. Well, you have to follow the wildfire wherever, wherever it may lead, because we we're hoping it'll eventually lead back to it. You know, I mean, I still remember yesterday I was ⁓ a post in LinkedIn came up saying the XR immersion boom is up right upon us. You know, and then today you read about Lenovo and it's like, all right, you know, we we maybe we need to take a step back for a second and kind of reevaluate. Dan Meeks: Yeah, but Corey you got a point there, man. I just I just replaced the batteries in my PS3 controller and I just finished Ratchet and Clank and you know what? That's twenty years ago and I still love it. And you know, it's it's hard to top it. ⁓ and and you you you raise a point, well, this is for everybody. We have so many things competing for our attention, you know. ⁓ you can only wear one headset at a time, trust me, I've tried. ⁓ so you know, there's all all you know, we're Coray Seifert: Yeah. Dan Meeks: We're blessed with all these amazing things that we can do and what little free time we have. And so it's hard to compete. It really is. Gene Feldman: Yeah, and and I also find the game itself makes it hard as well. Whereas twenty years ago, you know, it was okay, a game every month would get released and it was a pre it was a rel you know, sometimes they're relatively good, but every game had that same price point. Now you can buy all these different games, you could get all these different levels. And what I found is by having all this add on content and I I think Corey, is where I really want to pick your brain because the storytelling is what I love. Is we've lost the idea of the story behind the game. You all we're looking for is the the game, you know, the the game strategy of here's your prize, here's your prize, here's your prize, rather than having the story carry the game. Whereas even the silly games, the story was fantastic. Like Link, I think we all say Legend of Zelda is one of our most favorite games. Wasn't the most high tech game, but the story was beautiful. Coray Seifert: I think, yeah, the what's what's wild is I think that statement rings true, especially if you look at the past, call it 10 years of you know, game development and publishing. ⁓ what's interesting is to to the point that we're just talking about, it's all becoming a red ocean, right? Like mobile free-to-play is really hard to make money in right now, right? ⁓ online. First person shooters live operations, tons and tons of competition, all of it executed at a impossibly high level. And so if you go to the the first principal's numbers, right? Who's, you know, what what segments are growing? Basically, the only segments that that grew last year, or the only segments, was like indie games on PC, which had 30% growth, while everything else was like flat or less than 10%. and I think there's some very cool examples, one of which I'm obsessed with and I would love to spend the entire podcast talking about. It's called Dispatch. It's barely a game, but the writing and acting, it's ⁓ it's got ⁓ gosh, the the ⁓ the guy from ⁓ breaking bad. Yeah, science. ⁓ Aaron ⁓ that guy. I should know this. He's an incredible. He did an amazing job with the main character, just just phenomenal writing, phenomenal acting, Mecca Man, exactly. Mark G: Mecca Man. Coray Seifert: ⁓ I will look up his name. I he's super famous and I'm just blanking right now. But like that game, barely a game, only a story to tell, really, and it is incredibly successful. Gene Feldman: ⁓ well, I still there's one game I still go back to. I I think it's ⁓ the gameplay was very much pick your ending, but heavy rain that was on the PlayStation. That story was just I mean, it w to me it it was the first time I truly felt like I was playing a movie. It really did. And yeah, and so this kind of gets into that question, not to completely derail the conversation from games. I think we could all talk about the games and all this all that night long. Coray Seifert: Of course. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. It's that feeling. Gene Feldman: But when we when I we were preparing for tonight, one of the questions that really kind of came into my head because I've done ⁓ enterprise VR, and I think we you know all of us in the committee, we've all shared our war stories of doing enterprise VR. And one of the things I started noticing about enterprise VR is there's no story behind it. So like you'll find the safety trainings. Mark G: It depends it depends where you work. I'll leave it at that. Coray Seifert: Ha ⁓ Gene Feldman: No, no, which Mark I appreciate 'cause the safety trains I saw at at I've seen at several companies, it's just putting them in a situation where you have to go up the scissor lift. Well, why do I have to go scissor lift? One Mark G: It's procedure bas, not story bas. Mike Vann: Yeah. Gene Feldman: Ex but could a stor I guess that now this is where the question comes into it. Could story based help the integration of it? Is there greater value and have it story versus procedure based? Let the battle of wits begin. Mike Vann: ⁓ I mean many of us here have have a gaming background. I mean, some of the first immersive stuff we did for enterprise, large enterprise was gamified training in the browser, 3D. I mean, I'm gonna date myself a little, but that's okay with you guys. Shockwave, like, hey, can you help us train the people that are selling these cars or making these, you know, in building these these buildings? Coray Seifert: Huh. Nice. Mike Vann: ⁓ and if you gamify it correctly and you give people incentive and you let them compete, it works. If you put a story on that, it works great. Now they're not able to be as creative or take it as far, but you know, that that's that supported a whole bunch of small developers for twenty years ⁓ working on serious games, right? Dan Meeks: Well there there's also Gene Feldman: Yeah, but when I I guess where I'm coming is like when the budget comes into play, okay, w y I've seen people sacrifice the story for the process. So sorry, Dan, I cut you off. I'm sorry. Damon: Actually I've seen people sacrifice the story for the cost. Dan Meeks: Well, also at the same time, like any kind of computer based training, at least in front of a screen. I mean, we all love XR here. But ⁓ any kind of C B T as we used to call ⁓ that we had to do, we're like skip, skip, skip, skip, you know, 'cause we felt like it was a punishment. You know, so then you introduce a story, it's like, I don't wanna hear your goddamn story. I just wanna knock this out. You know? So I don't know, sometimes it's like a story isn't appropriate because it's like you're just gonna make me angry. Like the it might be beautiful, it might be compelling, it might Damon: That's Coray Seifert: Ha ha Gene Feldman: Yeah. Dan Meeks: change my behavior forever. ⁓ by time and a place. Coray Seifert: ⁓ yeah, actually I have I have a great example of time and a place. So, and this is gonna this is gonna be a weird connection, but ⁓ one of the projects we're currently working on, we're helping a company called XRT do ⁓ training simulations for medium armor vehicles for the Marines, right? You know, that's kind of complicated. It can go on land, it can go on water, there's it's a boat and a car, it's a whole thing, right? And ⁓ when you hear the simulation running, it sounds like a game of Dungeons and Dragons, but you know, Call of Duty modern warfare themed. Cause you'll cause the person on dispatch does all this cool I can't even replicate. It's like, it's like, Cappy, you've got three hostiles on your 104, moving to position, Delta. Like, and like I'm like, guys, I you gotta write this stuff down and like make a movie out of this. This is awesome it's like round on target. Like it sounds so badass. ⁓ but it's not a linear story, right? It's like a it's almost like Dungeons and Dragons. Like there's like a a a DM, a GM And then the crew is like completing this training objective, ⁓ and that's how they make it really cool. It's not exactly authored story, but it is ⁓ yeah, I I I need to play D and D with that group. Incidentally it was Aaron Paul from Breaking Bad. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Mike Vann: ⁓ yeah. Gene Feldman: You know what? That's something we could start too, a neon protocol D<unk>D group. Coray Seifert: Right? There you go. Mark G: Yo, ⁓ there does exist ⁓ what I call the ARP groups for XR. You know, a bunch of us do, you know, foundry and stuff like that as a way to de spress, you know, what's going on. But yeah. So Yeah, Corey can probably share some awesome D and D stories. Yeah. Coray Seifert: ⁓ I I think actually I if I could share one that I really enjoyed. It was ⁓ so I I probably should have mentioned I I kind of got into VR first at ⁓ ex a company called Experiment Seven. ⁓ we made Catan VR ⁓ and we did a game called Dungeon Chess, which is chess with the the D D characters. And when we were pitching that, they invited us to a VIP Dungeons and Dragons game at GDC. This is the coolest thing I've ever done. Gene Feldman: No go for it. Coray Seifert: And the j the the DM was Chris Perkins, ⁓ who is running ⁓ was it Acquisitions Incorporated and it was like one of the designers on all of D, right? And I was there with ⁓ Chris Journey, who is the head of publishing at at Meta. And so we all rolled up, you know, some you know, one shot characters. And you know, the only thing that we could customize was our name, right? Because you know, you got like two hours, right? So everyone goes around the table and it's like, I'm Ragnor the Great. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Coray Seifert: Right? I'm et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. And then Chris Journey says his character name, which was something great, right? And then I said, I'm Chris Journey. Which Chris Perkins lost his shit. So I actually got Chris Person to like he did like the equivalent of like shooting milk out your nose. ⁓ and so at a VIP D D game. And the whole time, then Chris Perkins would go, Chris Journey, what do you want to do? And he would look at me sitting next to Chris Journey. It was amazing. It was I will never do a funnier thing than that. Ha ha ha. Gene Feldman: That's awesome. I'm like the only way you could top it is just tell him he doesn't know the rules to the game. Coray Seifert: At one point and actually I don't know if you can see behind me, I have a framed ⁓ players handbook first page. It's signed by Chris Perkins, and under it it says, Where are the decapitation rules? Because I cut off I cut off someone's head and wanted to use it as as a projectile, and this is when they were first rolling out ⁓ fifth edition. And he's like, I I think we have to buff up our decapitation rules. It was good. Damon: Ha ha Dan Meeks: Wow. What's what's the tactical for a cranium? Damon: Okay, show over. Let's g let's go. Nothing's better than that. Coray Seifert: I mean I peaked a couple of years ago, let's admit it, but Dan Meeks: Yeah. Mark G: Happens to all of us. Happens to all of us. Gene Feldman: Absolutely. We're all on the second on the second incline. I just look at it as I'm sissy fuss. The rock has rolled down. Now I'm just pushing it right back up again. Coray Seifert: Mm-hmm. Yep, this is the way. I definitely took us offline, sorry about that. Gene Feldman: No, no. But ⁓ no, because w I well, we're having fun with games. And I think this actually can lead into the into a really good topic is cause the gaming industry I think has always been a really good kind of indicator of where technology's gonna go or ⁓ you know how it's gonna be presented. Cause we're able to test a lot in games before we bring it to a function. Now getting with that. You know, and going back to like being able to play games from any any platform to be, you know, to be able to go through. One of the big gaming companies recently has has been making some relatively big news because they're going they want to go to an all-digital subscription platform where instead of being able to buy the game, you buy a license to the game and you apparently have to check, I think it's you have to check in once every 30 days. I don't know, I could be mistaken, so nobody quote me on that, but I know there's like different requirements. Mark G: Might it might be initially ninety days. I think it might be initially ninety days. Gene Feldman: Yeah, but in our word, yeah, but you can't be offline. There's a there's a lot and so the the question of do we own it digital, do we own it physical? But with it with this company doing that and another company who with their new CEO is kind of going back to the old style, j you know, with you being in the industry, I guess, what are your thoughts with what's going on? I I would really love to know could you know from For those of us that aren't used to the the gaming industry. Coray Seifert: Sure. No, it's it's it's a fascinating ⁓ conundrum, right? Like if you look it on the surface, it's like, ⁓ those guys are being evil and those guys are not being evil, right? And like, yeah, I don't know, maybe maybe they are, or maybe they aren't. I but what's what's really I think more interesting is what the consumer response is, because the games industry exists 'cause of consumers and consumers tell us what they want and then we make it. So if you know Company A says, Yeah, you don't get a a physical copy, you got to check in every ninety days or whatever And gamers hate it, that company's gonna go out of business and get eaten really quickly. If gamers don't care, they're gonna do great because they like the financial benefit to them of being able to ensure like, you know, basically zero percent piracy, high integrity ⁓ for like cheating and hacking, you know, there's a bunch of ancillary benefits that come with that. ⁓ and then vice versa, right? If people care that they get a physical copy and that there's like license integrity on the individual. Mike Vann: Okay. Coray Seifert: Great, that that company is going to reap the benefits and the other company will be at a competitive disadvantage. And because there's so many people making games at such a high level, if you're not doing what consumers want, you're done. It's and it's not even like a like a ⁓ you're gonna backslide for 10 years and you'll eventually go out of business. Like you all see what happens, right? So I I think what's what's gonna be fascinating is what's the consumer response to that over the next like six, twelve, eighteen months, and then how do people react? So I think if if you talk to your average person in the industry, They're like, yeah, that's a that's a that's a big situation. I wonder how it's gonna play out. Yeah. Gene Feldman: Well no, it makes me ⁓ yeah, it it just makes me curious because it seems like the gaming industry, I I think we've joked about it, but is really kinda leaning into the subscription based where it's you're paying licensing now rather than paying for ownership. Coray Seifert: That's I mean, that's interesting. It I think it depends on how you measure it. ⁓ so so one of our things that we observed working at at Meta was like a lot of your free-to-play games got a lot of the ink, right? Because it's just tons and tons of players. Everyone can just jump in. It's easy to log back in. It it helps with retention engagement, right? They're they're they're and they're super for platforms. So platforms want to put them right on the cover because you know that's what platforms want. They want retention, they want engagement. ⁓ and then revenue follows. What's interesting is that if you look at the top grossing games and the games that actually like stay or companies that stay alive, most of those are premium, right? Because your average user doesn't put any money in and your average spending user puts very little money in. And most free to play games launch face plant and go out of business. We ⁓ we have a bit of survivorship bias because we only see the ones that are successful. So for us, you know, as gamers ⁓ or even just people looking at the industry. It feels like the only games that are successful are these like subscription based free-to-play ones. But if you ⁓ work on the platform side and you're looking at the revenue and the companies that actually continue to like ship games and stay in business and and continue to to make a profit, it's you know, I you know, it it probably changes every six months, but ⁓ you'd be shocked at how many premium first developers are actually making the money and actually staying in business. Gene Feldman: Mm-hmm. Coray Seifert: ⁓ you know, relative to the sort of like churn rate of free to play. But you are right though, in that like the thing we see, it's a lot of free to play, it's a lot of subscription based, it's a lot of live services. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Dan Meeks: Well s something I don't understand about the industry at large, ⁓ my favorite game is VTOL VR. And as far as I know, it's made by one guy. And it it's actually an inspiration for me in my business, because it's like if one guy can build all that, I can build a lot of stuff too. So that's that's one of the thoughts I have when I wake up in the morning. So I kinda gotta wonder, if you got a thousand employees and it costs two hundred million dollars. Coray Seifert: Nice. Dan Meeks: To make a game and one dude did it, probably already working a ninety five. These things don't add up in my head. I don't fully understand this. How does this work? Gene Feldman: Yeah. Well it's well it's look look at ⁓ the guy that created ⁓ Minecraft. Coray Seifert: Yeah, notch. Mm-hmm. Mike Vann: Yeah. Gene Feldman: Yeah, I mean, are you kidding me? Not only did his game become a s a sensation, what I I mean, I kind of feel like overnight, but it ended up teaching k computer science. I mean, it just completely unbelievable what he was able to do with it. Coray Seifert: Yeah. Yeah, I I think the again it's like a little bit of survivorship bias because like if you think about how many like solo devs release games ⁓ that don't do anything, which is not to say that they're not great games, right? Great greatness, game quality is often completely divorced from can you make money on it? Because that's a question of publishing and market fit. ⁓ but think about how many, you know, people make fantastic games as solo devs and they don't turn into Minecraft or V VTOL I guess. You actually I know if VTO a one runaway hit. But That that sort of like lottery ticket of of the solo dev that makes it big is definitely the the vast, vast, vast, vast majority. But again, it's impossible for us to see all of the failures because how could you, right? Like where w w where in that in your lived experience do you encounter failed games unless you made them, right? ⁓ yeah. Mike Vann: Yeah. But but Corey, that's accelerating, right? I mean, with t with just technology that's available now, the number of developers and creatives out there that are able to publish games across all these different platform models is just it's just accelerating. So I mean it almost feels like game development is starting to become like social creators. There's that many of ⁓ you know? Gene Feldman: Yeah. Mark G: Hundred percent, yeah. Coray Seifert: Yes, though the I think to the earlier question of like why do you need a thousand people working for ten years on a game? ⁓ there's certain segments that have specific demands, right? Like open world RPGs. I don't know that there's too many of those that have been made by a solo creator, right? That's why you need, you know, a vast, vast team. And so few teams can actually pull those off that they're they're quite lucrative when they land. The games industry, to be fair, and to your point, has always had a very low hit rate, right? Any individual game investment, it's like ten percent chance of making it eat back, big back your investment at best, right? But if you're in that ten percent, often you're making back you know a thousand X your investment, even if you are a thousand people working for ten years, right? Dan Meeks: So so does that kind of inform how you do things with dark arts where it it you know, I I don't want to say VC, but it it almost seems to have a V C approach where you're like, Well let's try these smaller things and see if they hook and see if we can get it off, you know, to to larger level. Coray Seifert: ⁓ yeah. Exactly. Yeah, exactly. And and you know, that's the the the beauty and tragedy of the games industry is that you can have an idea and deliver it at the highest possible level. And if you're not just I don't if and it's it's a bit of random luck, right? If it's not the right idea at the right time and the right audience sees it, it you won't sell. And which is like I don't know of many other industries where you can be perfect and just face plant on launch. It's like games are so fickle. So for us, we sort of are like, okay, let's let's not go and make one bet and ride everything on it. Let's make 10, you know, quarter bets and see of those 10 quarter bets, which three look like they have a lot of promise. Okay, let's make those three full bets and make another 10, you know, little sort of investments. And that's what we saw at Meta led to the best results. And honestly, a lot of those were solo devs who are sort of like creating this really interesting new idea that Damon: Mm. Coray Seifert: you know, had that combination of like quality and luck, you know, where they just happen to have the right idea at the right time and they could bring it to market. It's but what what's the the the fascinating part of it is I don't think the games industry has fundamentally changed. I think game development has democratized to your point, right? It's a lot easier for anyone to make a game. And with like the way AI tooling is you know allowing individuals to produce a little more. I I don't think you can actually replace a person with an AI for the record. Not unless you want a bunch of spaghetti code yet to clean up later. But, you know, better tooling over the past 10 years, AI tooling over the past two to three years, we can we can ship things faster, whether it's triple A or a solo dev. So curation is becoming a much more like robust funnel. There's so many more games out there. So that's Mark G: Mm-hmm. Coray Seifert: You know, again, back to the dark arts thing. It used to be you could launch a social or mobile game and just have a really big user acquisition budget, spend it on Facebook and AdWords and you know all the what you know the standard stuff. You just spend it on an ad network, optimize it, and off you go. You then you just sort of tune your ⁓ cost per or excuse me, your lifetime value against your cost per install and you know, Bob's your uncle, you have a game. The problem is now it's so hard to acquire users for a reasonable price because there's so much content out there that you have to sort of rethink the way you approach your users. And for us, the thing that we saw working was going community first, right? Discord communities, you know, short form video influencers who have their own communities. ⁓ back to dispatch, right? Dispatch I think was brilliant because, you know, Aaron Paul is a world world class actor. And he's backed by the critical role team. They're all world class actors. They have a bunch of other actors who are fine, but they're not actors. They're influencers, right? They're basically people who have like big online presences. And what do you think they did when they were star characters in a video game? They they posted the shit out of it, right? So I think that level of like innovation in terms of like how you frame your game and ship to those communities, that's the big thing. That's how you get through that discovery wall that to to your core point. is getting so full of games that you have to find a way around it. Mark G: Yeah, so while we're talking about this, right, one of the questions we always ask, right, is sort of what's what's specifically for like indies, right, and those and in that market? Because I'm loving the idea of make a game the community wants, not what the triple A exec wants, right? ⁓ so what's the implications, in your opinion, for for indies and IP when we have legal rulings like now, if you use AI, it's discoverable by default. When you're using these AI tools for production, right? You know, we're doing interesting stuff on the enterprise side, but now we have a lot of pressure by management or whatever you want to call it to use these tools, but yet it now is creating a scenario where this IP that we would traditionally see as our own now is discoverable because we're using an AI-enabled tool. What's kind of your, your, your play on it? Coray Seifert: ⁓ I've got a spicy take. How spicy do you wanna get? Are we are we good with like Scoville spiciness? Okay, all right, awesome. Awesome. ⁓ yeah, my Yeah Yeah Mark G: This is a this th this is a podcast, bro. You can get as spicy as you want. Gene Feldman: Absolutely. Yeah. Now if somebody wants to sponsor, contact us. We're open. Damon: We don't have sponsors to worry about. Dan Meeks: Yeah. I was about to say G Gene would like a sponsor though. Mark G: Insert ad here. Coray Seifert: I won't be offended. Yeah. Gene Feldman: Yeah, we're open. Don't discourage sponsorship by any stretch. Coray Seifert: I will not be offended if like yeah. If you cut my my rant and replace it with an a an a clawed ad, I will not be offended. Like I I get it, it's business, right? ⁓ no, I mean you bring up a fantastic point, and that is why I don't use AI content in anything I ship on any platform. I I love AI tooling. I don't I'm not like you some sort of LED, right? It's it's awesome. Damon: Careful. Mike Vann: Mm. Coray Seifert: It's great for brainstorming. It's great for like your sort of ideation phase, because it's it's it's like rubber duck programming or or or ideation, rubber duck design, where you talk to a rubber duck and it you know you come up with better ideas just by saying stuff, right? ⁓ it's like that times a thousand. But for two specific reasons, I don't let any of that content into anything we make, right? Our you know, marketing copy, our web copy, our trailers. We don't let anything that hasn't been touched by human hands in there and we try to eliminate any you know like stock AI content that we sort of like ingest. We try to keep that out. Like sometimes it's hard, right? With like ⁓ you know, if you do a Google search, right? That's now AI empowered, right? If you use Premiere, it's hard to sort of like squint and see like, is this you know, i i if I ⁓ hit the the remix button, is that AI? What kind of AI? Is that large language model AI? Anyway, when we can choose not to, we don't. And the two reasons are one, legal exposure, because I don't want in, you know, let's say you have a s a hit product, right? You're you're a couple million in, all of a sudden someone comes to you after a class action lawsuit in five years, and now you have negative that much money, right? That's the worst possible case and the most soul crushing thing you could ever deal with. ⁓ and the second part is I don't like the style. Mark G: Yeah. Coray Seifert: You know, AI content has a specific style and it sucks. It's just not good. You know? And if you if not good is good enough, which is I'm not like dunking on people who make games that have to ship quickly and you know, of the holy trinity of good, fast and cheap. If they have to do fast and cheap and they just have to get something out the door, hey, we we've all gotta earn a paycheck, right? If you want something good, you don't ship it with AI. Gene Feldman: Yeah, because I almost look at that it AI AI has issues with the reward system that gamification requires. In other words, we we can go to a group of people and the the game the priority of the game could always be different. You know, in other words, so what's important in one area of the country is not important in another. And AI, I don't think could make could adjust for those. It would be a very kind of generic response and it just it wouldn't connect. And that's where I think it gets back to the storytelling. The storytelling is more than just explaining the situation. It's more than just setting a scene. Storytelling is a unique art form. I mean that sorry, I I'm an old history major. So store you know history goes back to the whole storytellers. And the idea of being able to create give people an emotional connection that enables the technology to really show its full value. I'm getting kind of deep and philosophical on this. Dan Meeks: Well no, I was I was gonna one up on that. ⁓ I I think you you gotta have the human in the loop because ⁓ I don't know, I I I fancy a lot of Carl Jung and archetypes. There there are some very ancient stories that are so ingrained we don't even recognize them. and and so we end up telling these stories even though we never heard them before. ⁓ and it's it's it there there's something really magical and amazing about that. ⁓ Coray Seifert: No, you you ni you hit the nail on the head. Yeah. Dan Meeks: So and and you know, a a damn clanker just can't do that, you know, and I hope it never does. Gene Feldman: No. I mean th think about how many people cannot go without finishing this f you know, without say you know, saying no and knowing is half the battle. You know? I mean like I always bring up that I think it's so f you know, with cartoons today, yes, I'm an old grump. Cartoons today are not as good as they were when we were kids. I I I will say it. Coray Seifert: Ha ha. Dan Meeks: Yeah, ⁓ true. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Mark G: They definitely were as suggestive as when we were growing up. Gene Feldman: They were suggestive, but all almost all of our cartoons had morality at the end or had some type of lesson we were told. Even the animaniacs had the wheel of morality, you know it. Mike Vann: Gene, you still watching Saturday morning cartoons? Are you still doing that? I mean, I I've I'm giving you props. That's awesome. Gene Feldman: I I still do every Saturday morning I watch two hours of Saturday morning cartoons. Mark G: Hey Mike, don't dunk on Gene, man. You know, we're all busy on Sunday morning, Saturday morning with the kids. Mike Vann: I I might try this. I I might try it. Gene Feldman: Yeah. s serious I I lay in bed, I watch Dan Meeks: There's a few YouTube channels that are just V CR playings of Saturday morning cartoons from the eighties. It's amazing what you could find. Yeah. Gene Feldman: Yeah. No. Mark G: Yo, at lunch today I was watching Gotchaman. Come on. Come on. Gene Feldman: No, I what right now I've been watching Thundercats Mask. I'm on a huge mask revival because the toys they're they re released all the toys. So I am on a huge mask revival. Silverhawks and then Voltron because the new Voltron movie's getting ready to come out. So and I w Mark G: Wow. Mike Vann: There you go. Mark G: Hey, Silverhawks was just a rematch of Gotchaman. Come on. Coray Seifert: Nice. Gene Feldman: Yes, it was. But Silverhawks was I'm sorry, the costumes were so awesome. But I mean, have you heard? So we've got ⁓ Thundercats movies get got greenlit. ⁓ Voltron is done. And then they did green light Robotech. So Mark G: ⁓ that's my generation right there, you know, but you know, I mean even look at like you know, I used to work for Viacom, so it's like the live action of Avatar again. It's literally the same animated story, but live action, right? You know, you know the economy is bad when you know studios are doing that. Damon: No AI schlock. Dan Meeks: But yeah, too. Coray Seifert: Yeah. Gene Feldman: Yeah, but then I also look at Masters of the Universe. I I really do think Masters of the Universe, it it it reignited the fun of going to the movie. Because and I'm not saying it's the greatest movie in the world. Okay. I'm I'm not saying that. I loved it. But the thing is, the whole thing was just fun. It was like going to Flash Gordon again. Damon: Good. Thought about that one in a long time. Gene Feldman: It it I mean, you had Brian May's guitar ringing through the theater. Yeah, I mean, it was just and so for me, I think we, you know, and I I get on this thing that we we get so wrapped up with wanting to tell the serious, gritty story, you know, the the story that's gonna change the world. And we forget that sometimes we just want lowbrow, non-stressful fun. You know. Coray Seifert: Yeah. Dan Meeks: I'm so tired of deconstruction. So tired of it. Coray Seifert: Yeah. Mike Vann: Mm-hmm. Gene Feldman: That's it. Mark G: I believe that's why I that's why people still play bejeweled, so you know. Coray Seifert: I will I will say Damon: I I will say that, you know ⁓ Dan Meeks: Yeah, but Corey, to to your point, like like AI is a great sous chef. You know, I I use mine as a junior dev to make boilerpoint boilerplate code and things that jog my memory, but you know, it's it's the main chef that's doing the cooking, you know, that you could taste the love, so to speak, you know. And that that's something that you and you don't want to give it up because aiming is a human enterprise. It needs to stay that way. ⁓ yeah, that's my point on it. So yeah. Coray Seifert: That is true. Gene Feldman: Mm-hmm. Coray Seifert: Yes. No, it's it's a great point and like no point. ⁓ No, it's like and the you know the way that we're approaching large language models, right? It's it's a big averaging machine, right? And that's its strength and its weakness. This the the strength of it is if you're ever sort of working on something a little crazy and you sort of need to gut check against the best practice, it's great at that. Gene Feldman: And that's my point and that's all. Coray Seifert: And that I find if I have a weird idea, I can validate it against the norm by asking a large language model what it thinks, right? The trick is, you know, if you are using AI content directly, you're getting averaging machine content. And the thing that's selling right now, as we talked about earlier, right, that thirty percent growth is weird ass games. And yes, it's the same stories that we've always heard, right? You know, ⁓ Dispatch is ⁓ you know, fallen hero meets new tribe and becomes assimilated. We we've all read that story ten times and it's always great, right? But it's absolutely a fresh take, you know, it's it's the superhero dispatcher, right? And there's no way like AI is gonna come up with anything original because it can't. It's an averaging machine, right? Dan Meeks: So so before we we started recording, we were talking about your friend that does chip and dale band. But y you got you got you got me thinking about something. Damon: Right. Coray Seifert: Ha ha ha. Gene Feldman: Chippendale Rescue Rangers. Chippendale Rescue Rangers. Let's let's expect. Damon: Not the dance. Not the dancers. Right, right. The cartoon. The cartoon. Yeah. Coray Seifert: Yes, important distinction. Dan Meeks: ⁓ sorry, my bad. Mike Vann: Yeah. Dan Meeks: So what but what but what I'm getting at is ⁓ Coray Seifert: No hate, no hate for chippandales. Dan Meeks: A lot of people don't have the skill to create something, but they got the story in their heads. So do you foresee, because we were talking about, you know, the these things need to be social in nature, and we're we're looking for these tiny groups to make it bloom. ⁓ what do you think about small groups making their own games and then they become viral essentially because of somebody who's not a game developer has has spent all their time invested into creating this thing that might be buggy as hell, ⁓ because it's full of you know, of spaghetti code, but it's it's a great, great story. ⁓ what do you ever think that's gonna happen in the future? Or is or is there just something that's gonna stop that from happening? Coray Seifert: No, I think I think that is I I think that is something that ha that is perhaps more likely to happen with the help of AI because it it does help you sort of get ⁓ past that initial fear of how the heck am I gonna do this? I I'll one of the things I love is ⁓ in Unreal, right? You're you're working on something, you're like you're stuck, you're like, I I gotta get this light blinking. Why will this light not blink? And you ask the AI and it's like dummy, you forgot to do this. Okay, shoot, okay, thank you, right. That's it's fantastic for and like how many great games did we never get to play because someone rage quit because they couldn't get the light to blink, right? But I will say that ⁓ there's a s there's a big difference between the initial spark of brilliance that like creates the these great moments. And and those moments absolutely can and always have come from non-game developers, right? If it's something the market is not delivering. Mike Vann: Yeah, a lot. Mark G: Exactly. Coray Seifert: And you deliver it. If you it's the first modern combat open world game with helicopters. Even if it's super janky, people love it, right? It's the first game where you roll around a piece of garbage and it keeps getting bigger and then you're picking up buildings, right? People love it, right? If you just if you're tapping into that core fantasy that's been under serviced, you can find success. Scaling it is a different story, right? That's where you probably need to hire a team of talented game developers to help you actually like. Mike Vann: Yeah. Coray Seifert: build production code and systems. ⁓ because it's it's ⁓ it's both sad and and Schadenfreude to see people who are like, ⁓ I've got a hit game, take that. Nerds. And then ten months later they're like, I really need someone to help me refactor this code. Gene Feldman: Well well y you you remind me of the ⁓ go ahead, Mark. Mark G: I you you're you're kind of just I was just gonna say quick, you know, like to me, you're describing the Valheim experience, right? Like during COVID, why did Valheim survive? 'Cause people are like, I want the ability to virtually walk in an endless world in nature because I can't right now. And it's like there's a great game, and then all of a sudden it's like it picks up. And then they're like, Yeah, it's gonna take about three years to actually get out of beta, you know? So exactly. Coray Seifert: Yes, yeah. Yep. Yep. For sure. Gene Feldman: Well, for me it's it goes back to which I thought was one of the greatest ideas was there was a TV show called Defiance a couple of years ago. I may be loyal because it occurred in the a post apocalyptic future in Defiance, Missouri, which is right down the street, and it was with the arch, but it had a game tied into it. So the TV show was up at Defiance, the old w remnants of St. Louis, the game occurred in LA. Coray Seifert: okay. Gene Feldman: And the game was supposed to fall in line with the TV show. So as you watch something on the show and you pl and then you logged into the game, it was to reflect from the show. They didn't think about like reruns. You know, ⁓ you know, people are not going to start right when the TV show starts. So now they're jumping in, there's all this different content. And then the con they weren't able to keep up with the content with and so ⁓ you can bim to watch the show. The show's great. Mark G: I can't binge watch this? What? What? Gene Feldman: ⁓ well the first two seasons are good. Third season gets a little wonky. like like a show about post-like a pop St. Louis is not wonky enough to begin with. Mike Vann: So I'm gonna throw it all the way back to hardware. I wanna know. I wanna know where we're going. Like it seems I mean, what's the future of gaming and how does XR and wearables play into that? Like what's I ⁓ it's a big question, but I could see I can almost see some future where we have all these devices and they might be able to be woven into game experiences, but I'm not sure how really how that's gonna happen because yes, I mean Gene Feldman: Go for it. Coray Seifert: Mm. Mike Vann: VR, we can see it, we know how that works. But when I've got all this other stuff that potentially is gonna actually be in the market, how how is that stuff gonna play in gaming? And it might be that it's part of the community, it's part of the experience, it's not part of the core gameplay, right? Coray Seifert: Yeah, yeah, and and ⁓ it's funny, so so Mark is ⁓ writing a chapter for a book I'm I'm a book series I'm working on. I probably should have mentioned this maybe earlier, but ⁓ it's a it's a book on XR, VR, and AR. ⁓ and it's it's it's you know a pretty broad survey of all of it. But the main concept of of all three books is the future is spatial, the future is AR, right? We're gonna laugh and be like, ha ha ha. Remember when we had monitors? Mark G: It's okay, it's okay. Coray Seifert: And cell phones, and we'll all laugh, and our our grandkids will look at it like, what the hell are they talking about? ⁓ so old, put them at home. So ⁓ the future is there's no, there's it's like it's basically a manifest destiny, right? The future is AR glasses for your you know, sort of you know, incidental contact with technology, some form of VR glasses, whether you're plugging that headset into something or you have a dedicated headset. Probably it looks a lot like a ⁓ Cambrian explosion of devices. And then, you know, a dozen form factors kind of become the dominant output. ⁓ it's an exciting future and it has the most boring gate ever. And that very boring gate is solid state batteries. Once we have solid state batteries that like charge really fast, have much better thermals, ⁓ they have much better life. We're and we're talking, you know, three to four times ⁓ you know, both the battery life, the charge rate, and the thermals for once they're at scale, a fraction of the cost with like a little bit more safety. ⁓ that's the moment. And so like imagine the most boring possible thing. It's like, well, instead of a liquid electrolyte, you use a solid salt, the battery, you know, it's it's that's the difference between now and the future. And so I think it's gonna be here sooner than we think. Once we start seeing solid state electrical vehicles, ⁓ then it's just a matter of scale and miniaturization and making things cheaper. So we're we're only a few years out from that. My ⁓ my my prediction is five years from now, it's gonna the world will look quite different because not as many people will have, you know, cell phones in front of them, not as many offices will be full of monitors. ⁓ it's gonna it's gonna be a very different world and it's gonna be a lot sooner than people think. Dan Meeks: Nope, I I think you're spot on. I I learned a random fact. I'm I'm full of random facts up here. ⁓ the Europeans stayed away from Africa until quinine was invented. Because of malaria. If you're a European and you went to Africa, you died. So ⁓ it wasn't until quinine and then, you know, all the history after quinine with that. So you're you're spot on. It's all about the power. And I may add, it's also ⁓ handling optics in different types of weather. Mark G: You pretty much did. Dan Meeks: ⁓ 'cause some in my field of work, one thing that we run into is if you cold soak a headset, all the water condenses on the inside of the lenses and then in on the inside of the electronics. So having something that can stand going in in and out of different types of weather. I mean the these cell phones, we pretty much knocked it out. They're they're kind of sealed and there's a little escape valve, but ⁓ you know, HMD's not really the case. ⁓ Mark G: I don't know what you're talking about. I wear glasses all the time and it never, never fogs. Nope, nope, not at all. Never. Especially at that moment in like Island of Tabor when, you know, five players are killing me and I I just totally I never fog up. Nope. Nope. Not out of frustration. Never happens. Nope. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Coray Seifert: Ha. Dan Meeks: Never never had that issue, Damon: Ha ha ha. Dan Meeks: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Damon: ⁓ no. Coray Seifert: I mean that's that's a that's actually the perfect metaphor, right? Because if you think like what are we on? Quest three? So what was the Apple three like, right? I think if you dropped it too hard, your entire mobile history was deleted, right? You know? You didn't mean you did you couldn't get a new phone, you had to get a new phone number. I don't know. Yeah, I don't know if y'all remember an Apple three or whatever the third version of Android was, but pretty pretty primitive stuff. We're on seventeen now, so like Damon: Ha. Mark G: The iPhone three, yes, yes. Something Coray Seifert: What's the quest seventeen gonna look like? I think that's the question. Gene Feldman: ⁓ well well and when people realize that, you know, I think this is why a lot of us are still kind of like, okay, why are we on this step back from the immersive immersive world? Because ten years ago was the Google cardboard. You know, I mean that it took us ten years to get to this point. And Mark G: Yeah. Yeah. Mike Vann: That's getting back there. Coray Seifert: Is that an iPhone three? Gene Feldman: Yeah. Mark G: That is an iPhone three, yep. Mike Vann: That might be. I got I got ⁓ I think I've got ⁓ all, but ⁓ it's one of ⁓ Coray Seifert: That's impressive. Mark G: Yeah, yeah, Corey, this is a pretty scary group because I'm fighting the urge right now to actually get my modular three dot VR headset and bring it into frame. ⁓ because yeah, you know, back at the turn of the century of, you know, Y two K, we would actually make a modular VR headset. So yeah, no, I'm just fighting it right now, you know, ⁓ but but yeah, we we are a bunch of hardware nerds. Coray Seifert: Ha ha ha Mike Vann: Ha ha. Gene Feldman: no Damon: Yeah, yeah. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Corey, you should seen it. Yeah, you should seen it. We wrote a time ⁓ timeline on emer on EXR and between the us and Bob Stone, a majority of the pictures were our personal pictures of devices throughout the years. Coray Seifert: Ha. That's awesome. Mark G: It's a big big nerdy group. Yeah. So hey, on that note, I just wanted to ask one more question to Corey because I know he's kind of the man in this area that I'm about to ask him on. And basically the idea is, you know me, I'm always about you're a brilliant resource when it comes to new developers, right? So one question I want to ask you before this ends is when you're conceptualizing an interactive space, how do you prevent specifically like when you were back with Meta, right? How did you prevent Gene Feldman: But yeah. Coray Seifert: Thanks, buddy. Mark G: The tech first trap when you're designing, right? What's you know, are there gimmicks, you know, are there concerns that we have to think about when we're designing these experiences? And I'm asking this for that developer that's listening to this podcast three years from now. That is the question. How do you get around it? Coray Seifert: Mm. Yeah, no, it's and that's it that is a fantastic question because the the the products that we often saw you know fall well short of expectations were the ones that were business and tech focused. You know, it would be okay, we think MR is the next big thing. So we have developed a checks notes, puzzle game, right? Like those didn't work because there's no love. There's no, you know, I've always wanted to do this one thing and Gene Feldman: Nice. Coray Seifert: Finally, I can do it because of this technology, right? Those were the games that resonated. And and to be fair, it wasn't always something that was created for the platform, right? Like Super Hot, for example, one of the best VR games. It just happens to be best on VR. It was originally a PC game. ⁓ you know, ⁓ Cubism, right? I think Thomas makes that for every platform that exists. But the the through line to all of these successful products is Mark G: Mm-hmm. Coray Seifert: That core nugget of gameplay, or even if you're thinking about enterprise work or serious work or education work, that core just zero to five second loop of ⁓ that felt really good, or ⁓ this lets me do something I've never been able to do, you know, that's the thing to build around, right? Not a business case, not a new piece of tech, right? If that new piece of technology enables A new experience that you've always wanted, a new zero to five second experience that you've always wanted to do. That's powerful, right? And now you're you're in that spot where you ⁓ are on the bleeding edge. But it's really that zero to five second loop. And then for us, and and back to the dark arts thing, the thing we're always talking about is like finding the magic. And the magic for us is a game that has that zero to five second loop, but then you play for five seconds and you can imagine what. an hour or 12 hours or a hundred hours is because you can imagine all of the nouns and verbs and all the things you're gonna do. And that's the magic stuff. So if you're starting a new game, don't focus on the technology, focus on the zero to five seconds and make sure it's a zero five seconds that you can then project out right an hour, a week, a month, a year. Dan Meeks: I I think you're touching on something that that's kinda sad about XR is that a everybody that tries it is like, Wow, this is magical, this is amazing and then they never do it again. 'Cause they're like, dude, box checked, I'm done. This is th that was awesome. And yeah, so to your point, it's cool, but I also want to do it again. Yeah. Coray Seifert: Mm. Damon: Ha ha. Gene Feldman: That's Yeah, as well as I think too many people get it for a holiday gift and they're told you need to do Richie's walk the plank. No, that is the whoever created it, buddy, I love the game, love the Christmas sleigh, but that is not the experience to start with. You know. Coray Seifert: Yeah. Mark G: Mm-hmm. Damon: Ha ha Coray Seifert: That's a good one for Thanksgiving if you want a funny video of grandma freaking out. But yeah. No, I y you're spot on. And but who here's the thing, right? We're gonna all laugh and be like, remember, you know, Richie's plank on on Quest One? That was crazy because you know, the first cell phones, not even the the iPhone, right? But what came before the iPhone, right? You wouldn't use it that much. Yes, even before the like the Nokia brick, right? Gene Feldman: Yeah. Mark G: Newton. Coray Seifert: You wouldn't use it that way that much because it wasn't ingrained into our daily life, right? When we have this like, you know, very boring moment of yay, we have solid state batteries, right? And everyone has AR headsets on all day. It's the same tech stack, it's the same ecosystems, it's the same developers. That's when VR is gonna have that moment of everyone being like, ⁓ man, remember, remember Richie's blank? We should play that again. And I think you're gonna see some fantastic, like, Retention numbers, re engagement numbers, all these people being like, Wow, I turned on my headset for the first time in ten years and I love this. That's gonna be the moment. Mark G: Yeah. You're saying that Atari moment for us, right? Yeah, it's basically what it equates to. It's the Atari moment, but for the millennials right now that have VR headsets and are kinda like, ⁓ meh, I'm gonna go back to my PS four or PS five. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Coray Seifert: Yes. Well said. Exactly. Gene Feldman: Well well and I think Nintendo captured that every time they had a new system because they would bring they would dust off Mario and Mario would would make everything right again. I mean Super Mario Bros. three, I hate that game. Because I it's just it's not Mario. I admit it. I can't s it's the one it's the one with No, I think th Coray Seifert: Exactly. Damon: ⁓ yeah. Coray Seifert: Wait, is that two? I thought two was the one with the weird non Mario Gene Feldman: Three I thought was the one w where he gets the foxtail. And there the little map with Luigi was not a f not a fan of it. Coray Seifert: ⁓ right. No. Okay, that was yeah. Mark G: Mm-hmm. Coray Seifert: That's a bit of a hot take. That's a little too spicy for this call, I think. I mean ⁓ Gene Feldman: I i it really is. But don't get me wrong, I love I love Mario games, but Nintendo really had a good I know. Damon: Ha ha ha ⁓ But those developers are dead to you, Gene. Yeah, there you go. Now we gotta do Claude ads. Great. Mike Vann: W we just X'd out one possible sponsor right there. Mark G: They just did Harikari. Good job, Gene. They just did Harikari. Good job. Gene Feldman: Yeah. No, hey, I know. Nintendo, I still love you. The Game Boy, ⁓ still far way ahead of its time because the five second thing. I mean, think even the how effective the Game Boy was. I mean, Nintendo just has a really good reputation of what you're describing. ⁓ so yes, I'm I'm giving love to Nintendo, Mario. I am so sorry. ⁓ Damon: So is is this the point where we don't give love to meta because they suck? Mark G: You have to insert Japanese translation at this point. Coray Seifert: We we love meta. We love meta. Meta's still the biggest investor in ⁓ XR, VR, MRR. Pick your R. They're still the ones putting the most money in. Have they made some very poor decisions with staffing? They certainly have. They certainly have. I believe Zach even admitted that. He was like, you know, I shouldn't have let Corey go. That was a mistake. Yeah, yeah. Mark G: We we do. Yeah, yep, yep. Gene Feldman: I think I did see your name in the headline. Damon: Wait a second. Quick, ask the ask AI. Gene Feldman: But well I Mark G: A few of the people listening to this podcast that are are that know me, yeah, that was a bad mistake with Corey. ⁓ yeah. Hey HTC, maybe you wanna call him? ⁓ you know. Coray Seifert: Thanks, man. Gene Feldman: Yeah. But it to me, I think this now gets into another issue that we could talk a whole nother hour about. I don't want to open the can of worms yet, but it's really to me leadership making a lot of these need knee-jerk reactions, and they're changing course like every 36 hours. And I think that's Coray Seifert: Nice, nice. Isn't Mark G: Yeah, we might have to censor the podcast at this point because ⁓ you know, there could be a certain legal liability based on certain comments that commentators on this ⁓ podcast are about to say. Okay, cool. I got it in there. Damon: Ha. Coray Seifert: Well Gene Feldman: Okay. Fair enough. But anyways, well we are so I will we yeah, we're not gonna open that can of worms on this episode. ⁓ but we are near the end. So first, Corey, thank you so much for joining us. ⁓ the one thing we generally type to ask is for a final protocol where we ask from our guest, you know, if there's a piece of advice, if there is ⁓ a ⁓ trend, something that they've been dying to share of something they've been you know, of something coming up or advice or really kind of what would be your final protocol if you could share with this audience one thing either you've learned or you're kind of facing? We would love to hear it. Coray Seifert: Sure, yeah. And it that's actually a pretty easy one. ⁓ go play around with any AR headset you can get your hands on. And even if you can't get your hands on the headset, go make a prototype. In the short term, all of the platforms are looking for people who have shipped on their platform and nobody has, right? There's no way to make money. There's no store yet. So go ship tic-tac-toe, or the simplest thing that you can ship, and now you are. One of an extremely small handful of people who have shipped a commercial application on an AR headset, and now you are immediately shortlisted by these AR platforms as someone they can go to for partnerships in the future. In the long term, you know, the speculative AI boom is is probably winding down. There will still be continued investment, but the super speculative investment is probably gonna go to AR. So if you want that stupid money. Now is the time to start messing around with hack projects in AR. Damon: I think you just made Dan's night. Gene Feldman: Nice. I know. Coray Seifert: Ha ha ha. Mike Vann: Dan's out. Gene Feldman: I love it. Mark G: Is virtual avatar is dancing in the background for those that don't have the visuals. Damon: Yes. Yeah. Coray Seifert: Nice. Nice. Let's go. Gene Feldman: Yeah. So, ⁓ yeah, I'm never gonna live that down. All right. So, ⁓ so first off, so again, thank you guys for all joining. Thank you for if you're listening. ⁓ thank you for listening. Thank you for joining. Please like, share, follow our pages. ⁓ really helps out. If you have any questions, thoughts, or ⁓ if you are somebody who is creating something and you would like to bring it to us and share out. Damon: Let's a go. Gene Feldman: Please, we would love to hear your story. So, Corey, thank you so much for joining. And guys, ⁓ in the group, thank you for joining. And we'll see everybody next time on Neon Protocol. Mark G: Take care everybody. Thanks for coming, buddy. Coray Seifert: Hmm. Thanks all. Damon: Thank you.