Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Tech IPOs Manage Post-Lockup Insider Selling
Transcript
- Lucas: If these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, and you want to keep them ad-free, honestly, if today was worth a coffee to you, that's the link — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, support keeps the lights on. Now, let's get into the noise around lockup expiries, because everyone panics when they hear insiders might be selling. Lucas: Right, and that panic is usually misplaced. The real story isn't just that shares are hitting the market, but how they're being sold. Look at the recent behavior from companies like Palantir and Roblox. Their insiders aren't dumping everything in a single day; they're using structured plans to spread out sales over months or even years. Luna: So you're saying the speed of the sale matters less than the mechanism behind it? Lucas: Exactly. It comes down to Rule 10b5-1 plans. These are pre-arranged trading schedules that executives set up before they have access to material non-public information. The key here is that these plans remove the ability to time the market based on insider knowledge. When you see a steady stream of sales, it often means the executive planned this months ago, possibly when the stock was lower. Luna: That’s a crucial distinction. If I see a founder selling ten percent of their holdings over two years, is that really different from someone liquidating half their stash in a week? Lucas: It’s fundamentally different. A rapid liquidation can signal a loss of faith in the company’s near-term prospects or a personal liquidity crisis. But a staggered approach through a 10b5-1 plan is often just diversification. Think about it: most founders have tied up their entire net worth in one illiquid asset for a decade. Once that lockup expires, they’re naturally going to want some cash in their pockets for taxes, lifestyle, or other investments. Luna: I’ve seen founders talk about the tax burden being huge right after an IPO. They’re sitting on paper gains they didn’t even realize would be taxed until the moment the shares vest. Lucas: Precisely. And the SEC requires disclosure within two business days of any trade. So when you see a filing, it’s not necessarily a red flag. It’s data. For example, look at Palantir’s early post ipo period. Executives were selling, but they were doing so systematically. Investors who panicked sold at lows, while those who understood the 10b5-1 mechanics held steady. Luna: But doesn’t the sheer volume of shares flooding the market still depress the price, regardless of intent? Lucas: Supply and demand always matter. However, market makers and institutional investors absorb a lot of this flow. What really moves the needle is whether the selling is accompanied by a change in guidance or a drop in revenue forecasts. If the fundamentals are strong, temporary supply shocks from insider selling tend to get bought up quickly. Look at Roblox recently. Despite significant insider activity, their user engagement metrics remained robust, which kept the stock relatively stable compared to peers with weaker unit economics. Luna: So the lesson is to look at the fundamentals first, then use insider selling as a secondary filter rather than a primary trigger? Lucas: Yes. And you need to look at the percentage of total holdings being sold. If a CEO sells five percent of their total position, that’s likely just diversification. If they sell fifty percent, that warrants a closer look. Also, check if multiple insiders are selling simultaneously. Coordinated mass selling is a stronger warning sign than isolated individual sales. Luna: What about the timing? Do insiders tend to sell more when the stock hits all-time highs? Lucas: They certainly do, but again, it depends on the plan. If the 10b5-1 plan was set up six months ago, they might be selling now even if the stock has rallied significantly since then. That actually shows discipline. On the flip side, if an executive modifies their plan mid-stream to accelerate sales during a rally, that’s much more concerning. It suggests they’re trying to capitalize on momentum rather than sticking to a long-term financial plan. Luna: Modifying plans mid-stream feels risky for their reputation too. Don’t boards frown on that? Lucas: They definitely do. It looks like opportunistic timing. Most boards require rigorous justification for any changes to 10b5-1 plans, especially during blackout periods. But it does happen. You’ll see headlines about executives halting sales during earnings windows. That’s compliance. The real insight comes from comparing the sale price against the company’s internal projections. If insiders are selling at prices where they previously said the stock was undervalued, that’s a contradiction worth noting. Luna: Do you think retail investors are getting better at parsing this data, or are they still reacting emotionally to the headlines? Lucas: It’s improving, but slowly. Retail platforms now show insider transaction data prominently. But the context is often missing. A headline might scream 'CEO Sells Shares,' without mentioning it’s part of a pre-arranged plan covering only three percent of their holdings. Smart investors are learning to dig into the SEC filings directly. They’re looking at Form 4s to see the exact number of shares and the average price. Luna: Form 4s are dense reading though. Not everyone has the time to decode those every week. Lucas: True. That’s why third-party aggregators are becoming essential tools. They summarize the trends, highlight unusual deviations from historical patterns, and flag potential conflicts. But ultimately, the investor needs to develop a mental framework for what constitutes normal behavior versus anomalous behavior for each specific company. Luna: Anomalous behavior... like selling when the company is cutting its workforce? Lucas: Exactly. If a company is announcing layoffs or restructuring, and insiders are simultaneously increasing their sales, that’s a major red flag. It suggests they don’t believe the turnaround plan will work. Conversely, if insiders are buying shares during a downturn, that’s a powerful bullish signal. It aligns their interests with shareholders during tough times. Luna: Buying during a downturn is rare though. Most people prefer to wait for clarity. Lucas: It is rare, which is why it’s significant. When you see insider buying, pay attention. It’s much harder to fake conviction when you’re putting your own money at risk. Selling is easier; it’s often just logistics. Buying requires belief. So, if you’re evaluating a tech IPO candidate, watch the buying activity closely. It’s a leading indicator of management confidence. Luna: So we have selling as a neutral to negative signal depending on context, and buying as a strongly positive signal. Got it. Lucas: Correct. And don’t forget to look at the overall ownership percentage. If insiders still hold a significant stake—say twenty percent or more of the float—they remain heavily incentivized to grow the stock price. High insider ownership acts as a anchor against short-term volatility. Luna: What about the role of venture capital firms exiting? Does that muddy the waters? Lucas: It does, but VCs are subject to different rules than founders. They often have contractual restrictions on selling early on. When they do start selling, it’s usually because their fund is nearing maturity and they need to return capital to limited partners. It’s not necessarily a reflection on the company’s health. It’s portfolio management. Distinguishing between VC exits and founder sales is key to interpreting the signal correctly. Luna: So VC selling is often mechanical, while founder selling can be personal or strategic? Lucas: Spot on. Founders have emotional ties to the brand and the mission. VCs are purely financial. If a founder is still holding onto the majority of their shares despite opportunities to sell, that speaks volumes about their long-term commitment. It shows they’re playing the decades game, not the quarters game. Luna: That’s reassuring for investors worried about founder flight risk. Lucas: It should be. Flight risk is a legitimate concern in tech, especially after the grind of an IPO process. But sustained insider retention is one of the best proxies for cultural stability. If the leadership team stays invested, the culture tends to follow. Luna: Are there any exceptions where high insider selling is actually good news? Lucas: Rarely, but yes. If an executive is paying off significant debt incurred to finance their investment in the IPO, or funding a divorce settlement, those are personal reasons unrelated to company performance. The SEC filings sometimes disclose these reasons. If you see 'tax withholding' or 'debt repayment' listed, it’s usually benign. Ignore the noise and focus on the net new shares sold. Luna: Tax withholding makes sense. Companies often force employees to sell shares to cover tax liabilities upon vesting. That’s automatic, right? Lucas: It is. Those are called TSA, or Tax Security Agreement sales. They’re mandatory and represent a tiny fraction of total insider transactions. Don’t let them distract you. Focus on voluntary sales where the executive has a choice. Those are the ones that reveal true sentiment. Luna: Voluntary sales. Okay, that’s a clear line to draw. Lucas: Exactly. As we move through this quarter, keep an eye on the upcoming lockup expiries for several major software names. Instead of fearing the flood, analyze the flow. Who is selling, how much, and under what plan? That’s where the alpha lies. Luna: And if the flow is steady and planned, maybe we shouldn’t react at all? Lucas: Maybe not. Sometimes the best trade is no trade, especially when the signal is ambiguous. Patience pays off in these moments. Luna: Agreed. So, next time you see a headline about insider selling, take a breath and check the plan details first. Lucas: Do that. And remember, context is everything in public markets. One data point rarely tells the whole story. Luna: Right. Let’s see if the rest of the quarter holds similar patterns or if we see some sudden shifts in conviction. Lucas: We will. Keep watching those Form 4s, and I’ll see you next time.