Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the Sunk Cost Fallacy Traps You in a Bad Job
Transcript
- Lucas: So a couple of years ago I was talking to an accountant, mid-fifties, he'd been at the same regional firm for almost twenty years. He told me he'd been offered a manager role at a larger firm, better pay, more interesting clients, but he turned it down. And when I asked why, he said, 'I've already put twenty years into this place. I can't walk away from that now.' Luna: That's the sunk cost fallacy doing its thing, right? That's exactly the phrase that comes to mind. Lucas: Exactly. And it's such a clean example because the twenty years are gone either way. Whether he stays or leaves, he doesn't get those years back. But our brains treat them as an investment that has to pay off, so we stay in jobs we've outgrown, projects that are going nowhere, entire careers that don't fit anymore. Luna: And I think careers might be the most fertile ground for this fallacy because time is the one resource you can't ever get more of. Money you can earn back, but the years you spend in a job, that's it. Lucas: Right. And it's not just big decisions like a job change. It shows up in little everyday politics too. You've been championing a project for six months, it's clearly not working, but you keep pushing because you don't want the effort to feel wasted. You've been mentoring someone who isn't responding, but you stick with it because you've already invested so much time. Luna: So how do you actually break that loop? Because logically we all know the past is irrelevant to the future, but it still feels like walking away is losing. Lucas: The first step is to catch the language. When you hear yourself say 'I've already put in so much time' or 'I can't give up now,' that's the flag. The past is a fact, but it's not a reason to stay. The only question that matters is: given where I am now, what's the best move forward? Luna: That's almost like what they teach in poker, right? The money that's already in the pot is not yours. You only look at the odds going forward. Lucas: Exactly. And there's a nice exercise for that. When you're weighing a decision like whether to leave, ask yourself: if I were in this exact situation but had just arrived, knowing what I know now, would I choose to stay? If the answer is no, then you're staying purely because of what you've already put in. Luna: That's a good one. I'd also add that sometimes we overvalue the time because we're afraid of what people will think. Like, if you leave after ten years, people might say 'oh she's so disloyal' — but actually they probably won't think about it at all. Lucas: That's the social layer of the sunk cost. We worry about how it looks to leave after a long tenure, as if the time itself is a badge of honor. But your colleagues and future employers aren't going to subtract those years from your value. They're more likely to see it as experience. Luna: And there's also a subtle way the sunk cost shows up in office politics: when you've publicly backed a proposal, you keep defending it even when the data says you're wrong, because you don't want to admit you were wrong in front of everyone. Lucas: Yes, that's the reputational sunk cost. You've staked your credibility on something, and now you feel you have to stay the course to protect your reputation. But in reality, the quickest way to regain credibility is to acknowledge the change and pivot. People respect that way more than stubbornness. Luna: So what about the person who's been at a company for five years, they're unhappy, but they keep saying 'maybe it'll get better'? How do you know when it's truly time to go versus just a rough patch? Lucas: That's the key question. The sunk cost fallacy doesn't mean you should always leave. Sometimes staying is the right call because things genuinely will improve. The trap is when you stay not because of forward-looking reasons, but because you're anchored to the past. So you need to set some concrete criteria: what would need to change for you to be satisfied? Give it a timeframe. If those criteria aren't met, you leave. Luna: I like that. It's like a decision rule you make when you're not in the heat of the moment. Because right now you might be clouded by the sunk cost, but if you set the rule earlier, you can trust it. Lucas: Exactly. And I'd add one more practical tool: find an outside perspective. Because the sunk cost is so internal, a friend or a career coach who doesn't carry the history can ask you that simple question: 'If you were starting today, would you choose this?' And they can hold you accountable to the honest answer. Luna: So it's almost like you need to separate your past self from your present self. Your past self made a decision based on what they knew then. Your present self has new information. It's not a betrayal to change course. Lucas: Right. And that's actually the healthiest way to think about your career: it's not a single bet you have to see through. It's a series of decisions, and each one should be made on the merits of that moment. The years you spent somewhere aren't wasted just because you leave. They gave you skills, relationships, and knowledge that you take with you. Luna: I've even seen the sunk cost show up in the way we talk about retirement. Like, 'I've been at this job for thirty years, I can't stop now' — even though they hate it and could afford to retire. It's like they're afraid of the void. Lucas: That's a great point. Sometimes the sunk cost is about identity. We define ourselves by the work we've done, and leaving feels like losing a part of who we are. But your career is something you do, not something you are. You can change it without losing yourself. Luna: And I think that's why this episode matters, especially for anyone in their forties or fifties who feels like they're too far along to switch paths. But the data shows that people who change careers later in life often report higher satisfaction, because they're finally aligned with their values. Lucas: For sure. And this is our 150th episode, which is a nice milestone. I think we've covered a lot of the cognitive biases that shape office life, but this one feels particularly sticky because it's so personal. It's not just about a decision; it's about our sense of self. Luna: Yeah, and I'm glad we're doing this one today. It's one of those things that, once you see it, you see it everywhere. I've already caught myself thinking about a project I've been pushing for months. Lucas: And that's the first step, right? Just noticing the pattern. So next time you're in a meeting and you hear yourself say 'we've come too far to turn back now,' pause. Ask yourself: if we were starting fresh today, with the same information, would we still choose this path? If not, it's time to change course. Luna: I think that's a great takeaway. But before we wrap up, I want to mention something that's been on my mind a lot lately, which is how we keep this show going without any ads. It's genuinely because a small group of listeners chip in a few dollars a month through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's what pays for the recording time, the editing, all of it. Lucas: Yeah, and that's the only reason we can keep making these episodes ad-free. If you've gotten something out of the show, and especially if an episode like this one helped you think through a career move, a coffee a month is a easy way to make sure it stays that way. No pressure, but we appreciate everyone who does. Luna: And it's genuinely a small group that keeps it going. That's pretty cool to think about. Lucas: Alright, back to the sunk cost. Because the thing is, once you see it, you can start making decisions from a clean slate. And that's what we're aiming for in our own careers, too. Luna: So here's a final thought: what if we all treated our careers like a portfolio, not a marriage? You're allowed to rebalance, to sell off what isn't performing, and to invest in new opportunities without feeling like you're betraying the past. Lucas: That's a nice frame. And it ties back to that accountant. If he had asked himself that forward-looking question, he might have realized that the new job was actually the better investment, regardless of the twenty years behind him. But he let the past make the decision for him. Luna: And we've all been there. The goal isn't to never feel the pull of sunk costs, it's to recognize it and then ask: what's the best move from here? Not what did I do then? Lucas: Well said. That's the question to carry into your next big decision. What's the best move from here? Thanks for being with us on episode 150, and we'll see you next time.