Latest / Ego and Other Things / What Is Freedom?
Transcript
- William: What is freedom? That's gonna be the question that we're talking about today. And I think it'll be useful just to get straight into it and mention the common framing that philosophers use today to talk about freedom, which comes from Isaiah Berlin's famous distinction between positive and negative freedom. And then from there, kind of just to layer on my own understanding. of this of this concept of freedom. Now, when most people think about freedom, I think especially in the West and especially in places like the United States, they're used to thinking of freedom as something like freedom from coercion, freedom from force, the the ability to kind of, you know, do whatever we want, whatever comes to our mind, without somebody directly interfering with us or or preventing us. from from acting on whatever it is that we want to do. Now that kind of conception of freedom lines up pretty well with Isaiah Berlin's notion of negative freedom. The freedom, the idea that you have the the freedom from coercion, the idea that you have freedom from somebody imposing themselves physically or by threat on you without your consent. But as Isaiah Berlin points out, this isn't the only kind of freedom that gets that gets talked about. There's also this notion of positive freedom. And positive freedom is the idea that you would have the basic resources or time or opportunities to actually act for the sake of whatever it is that you want to do. So somebody might have negative freedom in the sense that nobody's going to interfere with them if they want to, let's say, start a business or start a a YouTube channel or something like that. But that kind of freedom is sort of useless to a person who is, you know, sort of so destitute that they don't have the money or the resources to get a loan or buy a phone or have the time and luxury to actually act for at, right? So somebody who I don't know, a a homeless person who doesn't have a place to live and struggles to find food on a day-to-day basis and doesn't really have a a a secure area, so to speak, and no access to education, no access to the basic necessities of life, even if nobody physically imposes on them, nobody uses direct physical force or threat against them, that kind of freedom is sort of useless. To them because they can't actually they're so hemmed in by the needs of survival, the basic necessities of life, that they can't really do anything else. And usually this conversation gets wrapped up in a broader political conversation between the left and the right, or at least between sort of libertarian leaning people and more state. focused people because a libertarian will argue something like, well, all that people in society needs to function is to be free from force and sort of everything will work work itself out. Whereas the statist or somebody who is advocating for more state power in a particular area is going to say something like, Well, well, we need a safety net, we need things like Medicare and Social Security, welfare programs, unemployment insurance, these different kinds of programs in the background that will help people to get to a place where they can actually take advantage of of the sort of negative freedom, right? The the freedom from coercion, the freedom from force in violence. And so there is this idea that we have to establish some positive freedom, some basic security in life in order to enable the usefulness of something like negative Freedom, right? The ability to sort of freely express and act for what one truly values, which one can't do without some sort of access to basic resources. And I think it's a useful framework to start from, at least it's it's a common framework to start from. And it's it's basically true in the sense that if you distinguish things in this way, that these two types of freedoms sort of depend on one another in in a significant way, as as I just sort of pointed out. but I also in in my own thoughts I'm skeptical of the distinction. In some sense the distinction feels artificial to me. I think there's another way of talking about it, perhaps terms that are more inclusive to the to this concept of freedom. and And I kinda wanna work that out a little bit here or or try talking about it a little bit more concretely here. And maybe we can get to a better idea, or maybe I can get to a better idea of what I mean when I talk about freedom and its relative usefulness to people on a daily day on a daily basis in the pursuit of a meaningfully good life. Because the the terms that I would actually use to describe the split that Isaiah Berlin makes are i is into liberty on the one hand, representing negative freedom, and power on the other hand. And I think liberty is basically in line with the the general concept of positive freedom. I would say one is at liberty to do something if they are free from physical force and violence or coercion or threats against their life, whether it is from an individual or whether it is from sort of the world, the existential, right? So Person wants to be a sort of Olympic swimmer, for example, but is limited by their genetics. They're sort of just born into a body that simply can't compete at an Olympic level when it comes to swimming. they are not, in one sense, at liberty to compete in Olympic swimmings because of the genetic limitations that they've been given, and because of the given rules of the Olympic sport. And So I think that that broadly covers it though. I think you have to include the existential limitations, the existential force. I think that counts as much as human-derived force and the experience of those things are the same, the experience of a kind of tragedy, the experience of a kind of victimhood. we experience something like tornadoes ripping through our houses in a similar way that we experience people using physical force and violence, robbing, attacking, these kinds of things. As bad and as tragedies. The only real difference when we're looking at human beings is this sense that they could choose otherwise, that they have a responsibility, right, to to refrain, in a way that you wouldn't obviously expect of something like a tornado or genetic lottery or something like that. But I think the concept of liberty extends more or past just how people act against you. How the world itself, how the existential itself constrains you on a day-to-day basis or throughout your life. And then the other term, power, is what I would describe positive freedom. Power is the idea that I have the ability, the the actual capacity to act for the sake of, to positively act for the sake of what it is that I want in my life, that I have. the skills or the resources or the access to opportunities that Are necessary for whatever it is that I want to do in life. So if You wanna be something like a a famous Hollywood actor, for example. You would w need to have some sort of a nascent ability to to act, and you would need to have some connections probably in the industry, or You would even have time to go out to audition. You would need to be able to wow people with your talents and your abilities in some kind of way to get a kind of role in Hollywood, especially if you wanted a big role, right? And these are all things that you develop or you seek out through through your own power, through what you can actually do, right? Whereas if somebody pointed a gun at your head and said, hey, if you ever act in your entire life, I'm gonna, I'm gonna hunt you down and and find you. That would be an example of, well, you're not at liberty to become an actor because of, you know, either government intervention or somebody's threatening you in some way. But if you're at liberty to go be an actor, but you're just not very good, or you don't have the connections with the time with the resources, then you don't have the power to become an actor. And I like the term power because it denotes something that is beyond the basic resources or or the social opportunities. the idea of power denotes something that is that is also internal. One's internal ability to actually act for the sake of what they value in terms of their talents and their interests and what they've chosen to pursue in the past and who they are in in their their given abilities in in the present. more than just, you know, whether they have food and shelter and and access to opportunities and social connections. It includes that, okay, what is the person actually capable of doing, which can often be the kind of bottleneck that constrains somebody from achieving what they want in their life. And particularly along this axis of of choice in terms of what they've done. In the past. You can exclude yourself from opportunities because of the choices you've made in the past. You can exclude yourself from greater wealth because of the choices that you made in the past. And those choices matter in terms of the context of the power that you have in the present moment. And you are, in a sense, responsible for the choices, for those historical choices and the level of. the level of power that you have to act for the sake of what you want in the moment. So I think the the idea of power is a little bit more expansive than what Isaiah Berlin talks about. And I think both of these concepts, liberty and power, can be wrapped back into a concept called to to actually autonomy, to the idea of autonomy. And I think that Well, I don't know. I don't know if if autonomy necessarily replaces the word freedom or what freedom is without autonomy. I think of freedom in terms of autonomy, in terms of this combination of liberty and power, because freedom is something, in one sense that is often talked about in a social sense, or it's talked about in terms of groups, like is this group free, is this society free? And I don't know if freedom necessarily works on a on a social level. I think it tends to work on an individual level. And I think the word autonomy gives a certain individual connotation to it and asks, not, you know, is this society free, but is this does this individual have control over their life? And much of what freedom comes down to in terms of its usefulness is that question: does this Person, right, have control over the outcome of their life. Can they objectify, can they truly objectify what it is they really value in the world around them? That that's actually what's important in the concept of freedom, whether the individual has control and objectifying the values that they have. And I often use the term autonomy in place of the term of freedom because I think it denotes that wider sphere of what really matters to the meaning to a meaningfully good life. So I often don't talk in terms of freedom, or if I do, it's it's to me, it's in one sense shorthand for autonomy, which is a more centralized concept that that is rooted in the individual. And also does something more, by the way, than denotes liberty and power, because there are more concepts that come into that. idea of autonomy. For example, authenticity is a part of that that axis of autonomy. one can be at liberty to pursue their values, one can have the capacity to pursue their powers, but still lack autonomy and still be unfree in this sense because they don't know what it is that they actually value and because they've never given been given the opportunity to to act really action act for the sake of what they value. They are I they were socialized as a child, they were threatened in force as a child. They had to become whatever they needed to become in order to please their parents or their peers, in order to get love. And acceptance and survival in order to get knowledge, in order to know how to actually operate in the world. And in that way, they were at a very young age conditioned to become what they needed to become in order to get along in the world around them. And then of course, many adults never get the opportunity to become aware of that kind of conditioning. it often gets reinforced later in further waves of cultural conditioning in terms of your needs for a job. And your needs again to sort of get get along in society, even if you don't use force and violence. And that that kind of continual conditioning alienates somebody further and further away from what they truly value, who they would be without the conditioning, who they would be without the structure of violence from society and from the state and from the parent-child relationship. Which is closer to who that person actually is. Who a person actually is gets very little playtime in a person's life unless they become explicitly aware of that kind of conditioning and then actively work against it, sort of uncover the layers of the false self that they've been buried in, get to the bottom of a non-solid self, a very fluid self, an instinctual kind of self. And then rebuild a solid identity from that. That kind of work, Is often required for someone to even understand what it is that they truly value. And I wouldn't consider somebody free or autonomous, that is in control of their life for the sake of what they value, without that kind of work, without some degree of authenticity, or at least moving purposefully in the direction of authenticity, in the direction of their true self. And so That would be another l layer to this concept of autonomy, which the term freedom doesn't necessarily denote. Freedom is often too much applied to the objective world around us. Like I said, the social world around us. Am I free in relationship to the state? Am I free in relationship to the people around me? Do I have the the objective resources to actually achieve what I want? It's never about am I internally free, right? Am I free to know who I am and to act on those true values. Really something like, am I free from the objectivity itself, right? Am I who I am despite the social relations, right? Am I who I am despite the resources around me? there's a certain kind of freedom that I think gets ignored in something like poverty, in something like ostracism or rejection, in something like failure, that we don't necessarily always Appreciate the man who is really free is the kind of man who knows himself even when His life is a constant struggle, even when he has no time to sort of, I guess, objectify himself, right? His his real values bleed out into his entire life, even when that life is constrained by survival. He's willing to sort of push himself against the expectations of the world and the so called necessities of the world for the sake of what. He is and what he values and what he knows to be true. I think a lot of times you see this in Christianity, where some of the the most famous people that that we know, like Benjamin Leigh and Diedrich Bonhoeffer, many of the martyrs, and even Jesus himself, were in situations of tragedy, in situations of poverty, in situations where the whole world hated them and Their head was on the chopping block. And in those moments of of struggle, they were more free than they had ever been in their entire lives. I'll tell you about this. Somebody like Viktor Frankel is another example, Alexander Solzinchin, where in in the in the moments of Of struggle and pain and persecution, because they were able to reassert the truth of themselves and reassert the truth that they knew they knew to be true, regardless of the world around them, and regardless of how that world was breaking them down day by day or attempting to break them down, they were still able to reassert meaning when it came to Viktor Frankel. The dignity of the human being when it came to Bonhoeffer and Benjamin Leigh, the truth of his divinity and and his mission when it comes to Jesus and when it came s came to many of the martyrs who were who were dying for Christ. There is this spirit of freedom that exists Even regardless of the obstacles, in a strange way, it's a sort of transcendental freedom. But I think it's related again to that sense of autonomy, it's related again to that sense of authenticity. It's a sense of I know who I am, I know what I stand for, I know the truth of myself, the truth that I'm I'm fighting for. And that is a kind of and if that that kind of Truth and that sense of self and that sense of you might call mission, if that is able to persist despite persecution, despite threats of survival, despite hunger and pain and suffering and jail and all other kinds of things, if it can survive even death. Right. You're willing to carry you're willing to give up your life for the sake of this truth that that you've understood, right? Or for the sake of yourself. Or for the sake of what is right and good, that is a kind of freedom that isn't really reflected in something like the positive-negative split, right? Because the positive-negative split is saying here are the requirements for you to be free, right? It's you've got to check this list off here before you can be free, right? You have to make sure that people cannot or will not use force and violence against you, and you've got to scrounge together. you know, this amount of resources together in order to to really be free. And and if you're not there, then you can't be free. But the heroes of freedom that we think about in our past are pretty much always the people who asserted their freedom regardless of both of these kinds of constraints. They were r they asserted their freedom regardless of the physical violence and coercion that was used against them. They asserted their freedom regardless of what resources they had available to them. You know, in the face of that, right? In the in the in the face of that, they had freedom. They had a kind of control, right? A kind of will in those moments that couldn't be broken, that isn't reflected in liberty or in power, in positive or negative freedom. It's somewhat again, it's that word autonomy, that's what I like, that's the kind of word I like that I think I did that think I think it denotes it. they had autonomy even in those moments, and they took it up. They took it up there they It's not the same thing as they they didn't allow themselves to become victims. I mean, all of these people knew that they were being victimized, right? And that the people around them were being victimized. They were very open about that, right? So it w it wasn't the sense that that It wasn't the sense that they weren't victims. It wasn't the sense that, you know, somehow th the the tragedy and the suffering and the limitations that they had experienced wasn't bad or evil, right? That's exactly what they were pushing against. That people, hate, should be free from force and people, you know, should have more access to these things, that we should live in a world that promotes people's freedoms and doesn't try to destroy it. At the same time the same time they asserted a certain kind of freedom. They asserted a kind of power, a certain kind of liberty, a certain power, a certain autonomy. There's like a well. There's a foundation there that doesn't seem to be able to be easily broken, at least in some people. And I think that's maybe the foundation from which you start, right? The foundation from which you start in autonomy is this. Authentic grasp of yourself, authentic grasp of the of the good, you might say. And that's your own that is hopefully your unshakable kind of foundation. Because I think that the way that the as I've gone on in my philosophical journey, I used to think way back, right, when I was a teenager, I used to think that that freedom was nothing other than liberty. Freedom was nothing other than sort of negative freedom. It was nothing other than being free from force. And over time, as you have encountered different ideas and understandings of that, not just Western but Eastern. I mean there's Buddhist kind of conceptions of freedoms the sort of detachment ideas. It's become more complex, but mostly I've I've started to gravitate towards this this build-up of freedom or perhaps this hierarchical arrangement of freedom in the in the sense that there is this There are layers to freedom that are each in one sense dependent on the other. And I think the foundation is just what I talked about: this this sense of acknowledgement of the truth. Right? There's you have a mind and a spirit and a will. that has an innate, unbreakable freedom. If you persist in it, you can let it go. You can give up your mind and allow others to think for you. You can give up your will and allow others to make decisions for you. You can give up the truth of yourself and allow yourself to be filled just by the values of the culture and of your family. But there is sort of a a freedom of the spirit that you can hold on to, and that if you hold on to, nobody can really take from you. You have to give it up for somebody to take it from you. And I think again, you see this again and again with the heroes of freedom, right? But from in the from that foundation, freedom can expand in more and more ways. I think the next step into that idea of freedom is Perhaps a greater expansion of knowledge of oneself. So this is where you'd get into the kind of power, right? But this is the internal recognition of power. And the internal recognition of power is this internal recognition of power is what am I capable of, right? In this moment, what can I do? Right? What can I do in relationship to my goodness? or my goal, right? Given my circumstances, what can I do? I remember one way of thinking about this like when I was when I was younger, when I was a kid, even when I was still living in in my dad's house and and early on living with my mom and feeling very constrained, I was not allowed to to do much, right? in a lot of ways. And if I if I stepped outside the bounds of These kinds of rules, then I would be, I would be punished. and even something like reading. I remember I really from an early age, I I loved to read. I like to read. but reading was something that was seen as lazy in my household, right? There i if you were sitting around reading, then you were in in one sense, you were thought of as not in one sense, you were thought of as lazy. You were thought of as though you weren't contributing to the household. Or that you were trying to get away from doing chores or or doing something like that, right? So but I still loved to read. This was something that was something that I recognized about myself, you know, on sort of on an inst instinctual level. And I remember the Harry Potter series would would come out, and my parents were were still about social status, so they wanted to buy me books, they just didn't want me to read them when I had the free time to read them, right? And they talked about the value of intelligence, but then would denigrate any actual expression of that that kind of intelligence. So what I had to do was and my my grandfather who wasn't an avid reader on my mother's side, and was more intellectual, sort of studied history. anyway, he would he would buy me these books and my parents would would condescend to allowing me to have them even if they wouldn't I had to sort of sneak the reading, right? And so I looked at my opportunities that I had, right? And I had a 20-minute walk between my home and my school, and I would have to walk back and forth to school every day. So I would read while I walked and I It was really hard at first because it's difficult to walk and read and it's also kind of dangerous. So but over time I I figured it out. And over the course of the school year, walking back and forth between my home and my school, I read pretty much the whole Harry Potter series. And there was this the this example of like, okay, what do I have? What even if I'm in a constrained situation, there's always some level of opportunity. There's always some level of a chance to express what it is that you value or to improve a skill or to do something, right? Oftentimes I think we give up because it's difficult. We give up because it it takes this constrained effort time and time again to find the small time to do something, the small act that you can take to sort of improve. And you want you're sort of comparing yourself to other people in the moment and you you say, well I don't have the time and the energy and the resources and the skills to do what this person over here is doing. So I'm not going to do anything at all. But there's that base of internal freedom of recognizing, okay, what are my opportunities? What can I do? How can I improve to be able to act for the sake of whatever value that I want, right? And then taking advantage of that to that extent. I mean you you get these. stories of slaves who had learned how learned on their own how to read and to write and Those stories are heroic, precisely because they they took what limited opportunities they had in a terrible situation and took advantage of it in order to improve their situation. Again, think about the story of Victor Frankel being quite literally in in a concentration camp and using what limited opportunities he had to create that sense of. community and closeness and care and love within the groups that he was stuck with, right? Searching for the small moments of meaning, the small things he could do, the consolation, the word the words of consolation he could give to people, the reading of I think he read may have read the Torah or celebrated some sort of Jewish holidays or something like that in these concentration camps. And you know, him despite being in this horribly tragic situation. The fact that he held on to that kind of hope. He held on to what he knew. He held on to what he knew about the goodness of of human beings. And he took the tiny, the tiny moments that that he had and and what he was capable of and used that for good, right? I mean talk about the power of human beings, right? And then so that's another lay layer, right? This refusal to let go of your mind, this refusal to let go of your spirit, your will, your understanding of yourself, right, develops into a kind of internal recognition of what opportunities do I have and what can I do, and taking that very seriously, right? And then from there, you have this layer of liberty, of You recognize this greater need for liberty or this greater desire for liberty. The fact that you need to be free to act for the sake of what you value in order to act for the sake of what you value, right? And you always have a certain sphere of that that you can hold on to, but clearly the world can be more at liberty, right? Can have more liberty. And pushing for that and finding ways to expand that. because that's the foundation for that more kind of external power or that external Yeah, the external positive freedom that we were talking about earlier, where for you to use the resources, the opportunities, the capabilities that you have, you need to be at liberty to actually use them. So a world, you might say Hm. A world you might say. Hmm. it I guess you have to ask yourself the question would you rather live in a world of total total Would you rather live in a world where you had all the basics of life that you needed, right, to pursue a good life, but you couldn't dictate what you would pursue? Or would you rather live in a world where you struggled to survive on a daily basis, but you could dictate what you went after, right? What you acted for the sake of in your life. And I think that on an in Intuitive level, most people would choose the latter. They would choose struggle to survive, but the freedom to act for the sake of what I value rather than having all of my survival needs met, but not being able to do what I want. And I think that speaks to the kind of hierarchical arrangement that I'm pointing at here, is that you need the freedom for the basic resources of life to matter, right? For survival to matter, for education to To matter. For food and water and shelter to matter, right? For jobs to matter, we have to have meaning. We have to have this individually derived meaning. We have to have something that is more than just life itself. You can have all the medical care in the world and abundance of food and live in the in the best house that you can possibly think of, and all of it. ultimately will be empty without meaning, without that individually derived acting for the sake of whatever it is you really value. Not mere survival itself, but what you truly value. And so that's why I think that liberty is sort of more foundational in this hierarchy than is than is power, the external power, the ability to I guess have the basic resources of life. And maybe power maybe the term power is obs obf obfuscating a lot of these things. But So there's that like internal freedom and recognition of the truth of yourself, your spirit. There is that then internal drive to take advantage of what opportunities and resources that you have at hand, regardless of the situation that you find yourself in for the sake of your truth. Then there is the understanding of the recognition of this need for liberty, this need to be to to try to expand. The opportunities for acting. And then there is this need for the basic resources of life, or trying to get that, trying to get that basic resources in you might say a more universal way. And then from there is the greater expansion of capacity to act for the sake of what you value. But you this kind of hierarchical arrangement that I'm talking about here. This is kind of what I'm I'm I'm floating around, or this is this is the idea that I'm floating around. Is that on the one hand, despite the circumstances that you're in, there's always a certain amount of f of freedom that you have. There's always that's available to you that you can take advantage of. The the world around you does not determine whether or not you're ultimately free, whether or not you're ultimately free. You determine. Whether or not you're ultimately free. And any subsequent freedom is meaningless without that recognition of yourself, right? Relic that authentic recognition of who you are. And any any attempt to increase your your power or your resources or your ability to survive at the cost of this more basic freedom is meaningless. Any attempt to expand power positive freedom at the expense of negative freedom is pointless because it interferes with the necessary ingredi ingredients for meaning at all. if You live in a tyrannical state that gives you all the necessities of life, but dictates your life down to the letter, then you live in a kind of meaningless and dystopian state. But if you live in a kind of state where your basic the basic necessities of life are uncertain and your opportunities are uncertain, but you have the power to act to change your circumstances, then There's a possibility of meaning and purpose. There's a possibility that you can still work out what it is that you value and who you really are in the world, even if it's a struggle. And I think again what I really disagree with about the I guess the power or I guess the the positive freedom idea is is just this like, well, we are going to use f force and violence to generate the basics of life, because without the basics of life, these people can't act for the sake of what they really value or have meaning and purpose in their life. there's this presumption that poverty that in poverty you can't have meaning. And I've been I've been, at least relative to American standards, I've been I've been poor my my entire life. And I've still been able to act for the sake of what I value. I've still been able to live a very purposeful and meaningful life, even if I d I've not had you know access to abundant resources or to great social connections or to great educational institutions or whatnot. I mean, there are plenty of advantages just in and of itself being being an American, so I don't want to downplay that there there are advantages in this situation, but The idea that a person who is poor, even a person who is suffering deeply, cannot have purpose and meaning, cannot still act for the sake of what they value in a certain capacity seems I guess reductive to me, or just maybe it just doesn't seem right. And when we talk about okay, well we're gonna use the violence and the power of the state to give everybody food and water and health care and you know, whatever these people determine as the basic necessities of life, or we're gonna give them a certain amount of money every every year in order to enable them to pursue what they value. And we're going to do that through force and violence. it again, it's that principle seems to undermine to me that the the basic freedom to act for the sake of what you value in the first place. I mean there's plenty of the problem is that it's it's I think the main problem that you have is much of much of the violence that's being used, much of the force that's being used to fund those basic elements of the state. They're being taken from people who also use the violence of the state sort of to amass their wealth. So there is that complex nuance in there where You know, much of state politics is one class two classes of people trying to use the violence of the state to For their own interests or for their own sake. And but I think that just kind of speaks to the point of getting rid of force and violence in our society in a categorical way, because the only way that a lot of these people are able to amass so much power and resources in the first place is because of state violence. And then this leaves the the the sort of powerless and the underclass and the poor, with the only option being, or the seemingly option being to take up. the power of the state themselves and and try to utilize it against the rich and the powerful. And I can't exactly sit there and and and say be unsympathetic to that. I can only say that if everybody let go of the gun, then you'd actually have a good society and you know the the we wouldn't have violence and force on either side because it's not like the underclass up taking up the the reigns of the state has necessarily gone any better in in our societies historically. So i i it it comes down to that that that it comes down to that truth that no matter who uses v force and violence, they're going to be victims and you're not necessarily going to be able to control the ultimate outcome or the consequences of that use and force and violence. But also just that it's immoral, regardless of its ultimate consequences, anyway. So I guess it doesn't surprise me and I'm in some ways sympathetic to the fact that the underclass and the underprivil underprivileged have to resort to or at least believe they have to resort to force and violence in order to get the basics of life. I wish that we would just all refrain from it, and that's what I'm going to continue to keep advocating for it because I think that's the ultimate solution. And some people are going to say that's irrational, some people are going to say that's impractical, but that is really the only kind of solution there is. If you want a peaceful world, then you need to restrain, you need to refrain from force and violence. Full stop. Back to the discussion of freedom, though, I think that it is still this in it it is still inherently contradictory to say that the way that we are going to become more free is by using more force and violence to achieve freedom, because force and violence are the opposite of freedom. And if you're advocating for positive freedom or for or the expansion of power, the basic resources of life being given to people on the basis of force and violence. then you contradict the very meaning and the purpose of survival to begin with. The very meaning and purpose of these resources to begin with. The very meaning and purpose of power to begin with, which is in one's ability to act for the sake of what they truly value. So there's a bit of a contradiction there. I think you need universal negative freedom. You need universal liberty to enjoy universal power. And you need, but before you have liberty or power, you need authenticity. You need to hold on to and develop that internal spirit that you have, that internal will, that internal ability to choose, that eternal ability to act for the sake of what you really value because you know who you are within any given situation, any situation of oppression, any situation of destituiteness or struggle or pain, the that kernel of of freedom that that sits within each and every person. And so there's a bit of a hierarchy here, right? I think that that internal kernel is perhaps the most important, I think is the most important aspect to this idea of real freedom or of true freedom. And then I think the expansion of or the advocate advocation for universal liberty, not just liberty where I want liberty, but universal liberty for myself and other people. And then from there, the development of access to resources and opportunities to be able to to pursue opportunities to pursue what one values, right, in the world and providing that for other people. I think insofar and this is not to to downplay Positive freedom. This is not to downplay that that we need resources and opportunity in order to achieve what we really value in life. It's just to say it can't come at the cost of liberty. We must do it through voluntary, peaceful ways, not through the violence of the state. And that's really the essential point that I'm I guess I'm trying to to say here. And I think all of this ultimately, all of this together in the individual, is I guess what you would call autonomy. So maybe the distinction I'm making between freedom and autonomy is a social and individual distinction. Freedom at the at the social level is a world in which people are universally at liberty and universally have the basics that they need to. Pursue what they really value through that liberty. So maybe on a social and structural level, you call that call that freedom, perhaps. But autonomy is all of this from an individual perspective. And autonomy, particularly at that point of Self recognition that choice, that independent choice. That no matter my circumstances, I can know who I am, I can. Trust in my own mind, I can know what I really value, and I can seek opportunities to make that a reality in the world. I can hold on to who I am, holding on to who you are, right? There's that that is an essential part of this concept of autonomy that maybe gets And then gets expanded through liberty and expanded through through power. Well, I don't know. You you guys have to let me know what I think. This is really my first time, I guess, kind of articulating it out loud. I've written some articles on my sub stack more about this. I kinda go into detail and and lay it out more formally. And I think I'm better at articulating what I'm getting at in writing than I am through to speaking. So you'll have to let me know whether this lands or whether you're you're kinda picking up what I'm putting down here. and again I you know, I I would love for for you know, you have any thoughts about this, right? You know, whether it's criticism, or maybe a better way of looking at these concepts, maybe a better way of defining freedom. You know, I would love to to to hear more about that and I would love for you guys to put that down in the comments. But again, this is something that I'm trying to get better at. Again, this this kind of articulation of of these different concepts. And This is probably one of the first goes I've had at freedom. And I'll have to think about it more because I I did kind of struggle with this, stumbled through it a little bit. kind of backtracked. I think I was using the I think I was using a lot of terms just interchangeably in a way that wasn't necessarily correct. So yeah, but I want to kind of get good at this going off the top of my head with the top. This is exactly what I want. Exactly what what I exactly want is to go off the top of my head. kinda have to stumble through it and refine as I go. so anyway, with you guys made it this far, I I appreciate you for watching. And if you if you like this video, please give it a like. You know, if you think that any of this would be would be helpful to anybody else, then please share it with them. And if you want more videos like this, then then please subscribe. And as always, thank you guys for listening and I'll talk to you next time.