Latest / The Film Hobbyist / 8 1/2 (1963): Indulging the Problem
Transcript
- 0:12in and spend some time with the film hobbyist.
- 0:15My name is Lydia, and I love movies. We're here
- 0:32in my attic room. You're sitting on a forest
- 0:36green Walmart futon with a black metal frame.
- 0:40I'm in an old desk chair with cracks in the pleather
- 0:43lining. It's a bit quieter here today now that
- 0:48school has started. Not entirely, though. I still
- 0:52have one kid at home, leaving me a full -time
- 0:55caregiver and a very part -time writer. But my
- 0:59husband and I are beginning the conversation
- 1:01of what might happen in the future with my writing
- 1:04career. at least how to increase my hours enough
- 1:08to finish the book I'm working on. In all my
- 1:13years of trying to juggle artistic interests,
- 1:17child -rearing, and the prospect of earning an
- 1:19income, I've explored several different career
- 1:22paths, but one you may be surprised to discover
- 1:26that I have not entertained in the slightest
- 1:29is that of film criticism. There are many reasons,
- 1:33one being that I have absolutely zero credentials
- 1:37or experience in journalism, another that those
- 1:41jobs are very hard to find and incredibly competitive
- 1:44to achieve, but the biggest of all is the most
- 1:47important. I like getting to choose what movies
- 1:51I watch. I'm glad that I do not have to watch
- 1:56the newest Paw Patrol movie. That show has not
- 1:59entered my home and I have no desire for it to.
- 2:03I'm glad that I did not have to see either Obsession
- 2:07or Back Rooms. As much as I am intrigued by horror
- 2:11as a genre, nope, nope, nope, nope, nope. A professional
- 2:16film critic doesn't really get to choose what
- 2:20movies they see. Someone has to see those movies.
- 2:25Someone has to review them. It's a duty to the
- 2:29public. It's part of the contract. And I want
- 2:33the ability to say no. This doesn't mean I only
- 2:38watch films that are familiar or comforting to
- 2:42me. I'm ready and willing to watch films from
- 2:45different cultures and filmmaking perspectives
- 2:47than mine. I've definitely watched movies that
- 2:51really challenged me and left me with more questions
- 2:55than answers. I read a lot about film from actual
- 3:00film critics, and I am willing to learn even
- 3:04if that means watching something I might dislike.
- 3:08I am careful about the movies I watch. Bleak,
- 3:12heavy films weigh on me and have a history of
- 3:16affecting my mental health, but as long as my
- 3:19research doesn't show up any red flags and I'm
- 3:22prepared for being stretched, I am up for it.
- 3:26Which is how I ended up finally watching Federico
- 3:30Fellini's 1963 masterpiece, Eight and a Half.
- 3:35This film is the perfect package for a cinephile.
- 3:39A black and white, avant -garde Italian film
- 3:43about a director struggling with his art. It's
- 3:47much beloved and lauded. Your favorite director's
- 3:51favorite film. You don't have to look far to
- 3:54find Martin Scorsese or Terry Gilliam gushing
- 3:58about it and how it transformed filmmaking. The
- 4:02most recent Sight and Sound poll, a list of the
- 4:06top 100 films of all time published every 10
- 4:09years by the British Film Institute, had eight
- 4:12and a half listed as the 31st best film by critics
- 4:16and sixth by directors. Like I said, it's an
- 4:21important film by every metric, the kind of movie
- 4:25for which the Criterion Collection exists, which,
- 4:29if you don't know, is a film distribution company
- 4:32that releases high -quality copies of the most
- 4:36important films ever made. It's basically kept
- 4:39in business by academic libraries and cinephiles.
- 4:44I do not describe myself as a cinephile. are
- 4:49a lot of reasons. It's a term that comes with
- 4:53a lot of pretensions and airs and a love for
- 4:57film grain that has never made sense to me. Also,
- 5:01I think Raiders of the Lost Ark is a perfect
- 5:04film and The Godfather is not. Plus, I'm a girl.
- 5:11There are plenty of women who use the term, but
- 5:15it is a very male -centric club. Because movies
- 5:19are considered a very boy -centered niche, and
- 5:22important films are made by important men, especially
- 5:26in the 1960s and 70s, the most important era
- 5:31in all of film. I talked with you back in February
- 5:36about how I don't watch many films from this
- 5:39era. There are a lot of reasons, but a big one
- 5:43is that... For as much as this time period gets
- 5:47talked about as an explosion of women's rights,
- 5:50in film history, that mostly translates to women
- 5:54getting ogled by the camera more before being
- 5:58bedded, battered, or slaughtered. I feel pretty
- 6:02degraded when I watch these films, films for
- 6:05which the term the male gaze exists. Eight and
- 6:10a half. doesn't beat the allegations. Though,
- 6:13as it was released at the beginning of all of
- 6:16this, in 1963, the women are still mostly clothed
- 6:21when they're treated as objects of male desire.
- 6:24Which is something, I guess. Now, let me be clear.
- 6:30This film is absolutely a work of capital A art,
- 6:35about the nature of art and memory. The visuals
- 6:39are stunning, the camera work inventive, the
- 6:42acting marvelous. It's pretty insightful too,
- 6:46which we'll get into. I can see how this film
- 6:50influenced Martin Scorsese and other directors,
- 6:53especially with the non -linear storytelling
- 6:56and the dream sequences. But as much as I appreciate
- 7:00all of these factors, I don't particularly enjoy
- 7:05watching a movie that... Doesn't really see me
- 7:09as a full human being with a life of my own.
- 7:13Eight and a Half tells the story of Guido Anselmi,
- 7:17a famed Italian director struggling to begin
- 7:20his next film, a science fiction work exploring
- 7:24the past and present, because he doesn't actually
- 7:28know what movie he's making anymore. Instead
- 7:31of finishing casting, Guido flees to take the
- 7:35waters at a famed mineral spring. But his anxiety
- 7:39has followed him. A film critic's there who's
- 7:43read his script and thinks it's total trash.
- 7:45His producers come to join him, bringing along
- 7:49screen tests, possible stars, and the out -of
- 7:52-industry financier who's already sunk an absurd
- 7:55amount of money on a life -sized rocket set.
- 7:59His mistress joins him, but then his wife travels
- 8:02to the spa too, along with her female best friend,
- 8:06who never really got along with him. Intertwined
- 8:10with all of these are dreams, fantasies, and
- 8:14memories. The film opens with a phenomenal dream
- 8:19sequence from a first -person perspective, as
- 8:22the camera is Trapped in a car under a bridge,
- 8:26the underpass packed with parked cars, all filled
- 8:30with people staring at him as he tries to kick
- 8:34his way out of the window. And this is his psychological
- 8:38reality throughout, trapped while everyone stares
- 8:42at him. The climax of this film comes as he realizes...
- 8:48He doesn't have anything to say with his new
- 8:51movie and isn't even sure the story he's telling.
- 8:54So he has a fantasy of a press conference in
- 8:58front of the very expensive rocket where everyone
- 9:00is hounding him with questions about the film
- 9:03and what choices he's going to make. It's a panic
- 9:06-inducing nightmare sequence culminating with
- 9:09his ending it all. But then we move back to reality
- 9:13and then to a new fantasy. He chooses, with his
- 9:21fantasy version of his wife's help, to lead the
- 9:24entire cast and crew in a circus ring, directing
- 9:28them to race around the edge to silly music.
- 9:33As I said, this is a pretty avant -garde film.
- 9:37It's experimental and kind of surrealist. The
- 9:41plot is pretty loose, a film that is more a character
- 9:45study. Lots of vibes here, more of that than
- 9:49logic. And it's very much about how this whiny
- 9:53loser views the women in his life. And that's
- 9:56a textual description of this protagonist. He
- 10:00and the film also think he's a petulant man baby.
- 10:06I found out about this film backwards. In 2009,
- 10:10when I was most plugged into new film releases
- 10:13and watched every movie trailer I could download,
- 10:16director Rob Marshall released Nine. As it was
- 10:21a musical, and I love musical theater, I researched
- 10:24it to learn it was a filmed version of the Broadway
- 10:28adaptation of Eight and a Half. Again, backwards.
- 10:33The logline was something about a famed film
- 10:35director reflecting on all his relationships
- 10:38with the women in his life. I assumed there were
- 10:42nine of them, and that was too many fawning figures
- 10:45for me to be interested in. This is a misconception.
- 10:50The numbers have literally nothing to do with
- 10:53the number of women. In 1963, Fellini had made
- 10:58seven films and co -directed another half a film.
- 11:02So this was his eighth and a half film production.
- 11:06The musical continued that tradition by calculating
- 11:09songs as worth half a film, bringing the total
- 11:13to nine. The musical actually only has seven
- 11:16women. The film, though, has 17. The film is
- 11:22aggressively from Guido's perspective. We hear
- 11:26his innermost thoughts. We see his daydreams.
- 11:29The camera flits from now to his memories, and
- 11:33as such, the camera sees the world through his
- 11:37perspective. We see the humor of all the people
- 11:41waiting in line to take the waters at the spa,
- 11:43wilting in their fancy clothes in the hot sun.
- 11:47The camera shows them as comical, the way Guido
- 11:51would see them. There's a delightful self -deprecation
- 11:54in how the camera sees Guido himself, curled
- 11:57up oddly in a chair, falling face -first into
- 12:00a pile of headshots. But Guido's perspective
- 12:04is also how we see all these women. If this film
- 12:10had been made a decade later, the shots would
- 12:13have been more of these women's bodies than of
- 12:15their faces. But the way their faces are shot
- 12:19is to treat women as Whores, there for physical
- 12:23pleasure. Muses, there for still sexual creative
- 12:27inspiration. Or mothers, there to care, scold,
- 12:32or fawn. These women only have value insofar
- 12:37as they relate to Guido. I mean those categories
- 12:41metaphorically, but they are literal as well.
- 12:46There's Saragina, a prostitute of Guido's memory,
- 12:50whom he and his friends paid to dance the rumba
- 12:53with him when they were kids. There's his mistress,
- 12:56who is portrayed as unintellectual and tacky
- 12:59and always asking him for fine things and financial
- 13:02favors for her husband. He thinks of his actual
- 13:06mother and then other female relatives fawning
- 13:09and scolding and caring for him. He has a literal
- 13:14muse, an ideal woman he is constantly daydreaming
- 13:17about, trying to figure out how to depict in
- 13:20his movie, later revealed to be, in real life,
- 13:24a famous actress he's trying to court for the
- 13:27role, but who kind of turns him down. The most
- 13:31interesting women are the ones who turn him down,
- 13:35who burst his bubble. His wife, Luisa, who comes
- 13:39to reconcile with him as a woman in her own right,
- 13:43until she sees the mistress is there too, and
- 13:47that the movie he's making depicts actual conversations
- 13:50from their life, that Guido is struggling to
- 13:54cast the analogs for both her and the mistress.
- 13:59And there's Rosella, his wife's best friend.
- 14:03comes in like a breath of fresh air, finally
- 14:06a woman he can't brush off, who sees right through
- 14:09him. But even she is taken ownership by him in
- 14:13a pretty icky way. Two -thirds of the way through
- 14:18the film, Guido has an extended fantasy about
- 14:21all of the available women in his life living
- 14:24in a harem together. He reimagines his wife Luisa
- 14:28as the perfect Italian mother, managing all the
- 14:32girls perfectly happily, fully domestic. He imagines
- 14:36Rosella as part of it as well, not as a sexual
- 14:40conquest, but a willing guest. A burlesque dancer
- 14:44is grieving being sent upstairs for being too
- 14:47old. Some of the other girls lament the injustice
- 14:50of it, but fantasy Luisa explains this is just
- 14:54the correct way of things. Her character is completely
- 14:58undercut here. Guido's version of her takes away
- 15:02all the agency of previous scenes. I found watching
- 15:07this sequence to be the ickiest experience of
- 15:10the film, as it includes women he saw on vacation
- 15:14as part of his harem. And I just hate the idea
- 15:20of there being some fantasy version of myself
- 15:24existing in some stranger's head. Makes me feel
- 15:29used. The good news is that this film knows this
- 15:36sequence is disgusting and contemptible. When
- 15:41Guido shows up, he's dressed in sheets and the
- 15:44women carry him the way his aunties carried him
- 15:47off to the bath when he was a boy. He's a man
- 15:50baby who just wants women to fawn over him the
- 15:53way those aunties did and inspire him the way
- 15:56his female cousin did with stories of a painting
- 15:59coming to life if they say the magic words. And
- 16:02even in his fantasy, the harem foments an uprising
- 16:06for how badly he treats them. But of course,
- 16:10they don't actually overthrow him. They're too
- 16:13fond of him for that. We are not meant to like
- 16:19Guido. We are meant to see him as absolutely
- 16:23pathetic, an absurd failure. And I say that in
- 16:27this film's favor. It doesn't think his way of
- 16:30looking or thinking about women is good. The
- 16:34problem is... that it commits the same sins it
- 16:38accuses him of committing. All the women are
- 16:42photographed as whores, muses, and mothers. Rosella's
- 16:47the only one who really gets a good dig at him,
- 16:50and she's undercut. The actress Claudia isn't
- 16:54actually his ideal woman, but she's still filmed
- 16:57like one. The end of the film is Guido realizing
- 17:01that he needs help to sort through this project,
- 17:04and he assumes that his wife will be part of
- 17:08that. The film imagines that they will reconcile
- 17:12and that she will take on that role, but why
- 17:16on earth would she? She's probably going to divorce
- 17:19him for a lot of money and not really be unjustified
- 17:22for doing so. Why does this movie assume that
- 17:25she's going to be right there for him when he
- 17:28needs help? The real failure of this movie is
- 17:32that it indulges in the very problem it's trying
- 17:35to highlight. And how would I suggest we fix
- 17:40this? What could make this masterpiece better?
- 17:45Let us see the world from the women's perspective.
- 17:48Give them a scene. Give them a voice. Let's see
- 17:52one of their fantasies. Martin Scorsese realized
- 17:57that. It's why Goodfellas is a gangster film
- 18:01I actually like. The whole film is narrated by
- 18:04Henry Hill, and we see the mob life from his
- 18:08personal perspective. It's elegant and suave
- 18:11in camera work and editing, the way he sees it
- 18:14all. But Scorsese still lets us hear from his
- 18:18wife, Karen. She doesn't get much voice work
- 18:22or much perspective. Her voiceover is a drop
- 18:26in the bucket. But that perspective means she
- 18:29gets to be a full human. We get to see her seduced
- 18:34by the life and then her disillusionment. It's
- 18:39just a few scenes. Makes the whole movie better.
- 18:44Even beyond Scorsese, you could do it with this
- 18:48story. You can totally make a movie about a famous,
- 18:52important director with a long history of complicated
- 18:55female connections trying to make a film he's
- 18:59still figuring out on the go while managing producers
- 19:02and distributors, a film that's intensely personal,
- 19:06a veiled work that is absolutely based on his
- 19:09own life. And that movie you could totally make
- 19:12could be absurdly funny and satirize the film
- 19:15business and contain some avant -garde perspective,
- 19:18and it could still have the women be full humans
- 19:21with a point of view. That movie is real. It's
- 19:26called Sentimental Value, and it came out last
- 19:29year to much acclaim. It was nominated for eight
- 19:33Oscars and won Best International Film. It's
- 19:37directed by a Norwegian, Joachim Trier, and stars
- 19:41Renate Rensvelt and Stellan Skarsgård. Trier
- 19:45is totally riffing on another famous, important
- 19:48director, Ingmar Bergman, but Bergman was a contemporary
- 19:53of Fellini's and I'm sure was influenced by Eight
- 19:56and a Half, so the through line is still there.
- 20:01Sentimental Value tells the story of Gustav Borg,
- 20:05a famed director trying to make a long gestating
- 20:08project clearly inspired by his mother, who committed
- 20:12suicide when he was seven in the house that had
- 20:15been in his family for generations, the house
- 20:18where his daughters grew up. When they were little,
- 20:21he abandoned them and his wife, but as they never
- 20:25actually signed divorce papers, He retains ownership
- 20:29of the house when his wife dies years later.
- 20:32He returns to film his final masterpiece in this
- 20:36house, offering the lead to his adult daughter
- 20:39Nora, now a celebrated stage actress. Nora turns
- 20:44him down flat, and he's left trying to figure
- 20:47out how to make the movie without her. I can
- 20:50imagine a version of this movie that's just about
- 20:53Gustav. about his attempts to make this film
- 20:56where his daughters are just types in his movies,
- 21:00harpies or scolds or little children, where we
- 21:06are meant to see them as ungrateful or obstacles,
- 21:10things, not people. This movie makes the opposite
- 21:17choice. We get Nora's story too. She's a mess,
- 21:24with amusingly depicted stage fright creating
- 21:27a near -clown chase backstage as they try to
- 21:31keep her from locking herself in her dressing
- 21:33room instead of opening her new play on stage.
- 21:36She has her own messy relationship with a married
- 21:40co -star. It's clear she has a long history with
- 21:44depression. And we get to see her love and share
- 21:49joy with her sister. They have their own life
- 21:53and their own relationship away from men. Her
- 21:57sister is married with a son, but she is not
- 22:00a mother. Sentimental value is really good. Its
- 22:07camera work is beautiful. The acting, magnificent.
- 22:11The way the script and the cinematography get
- 22:15you to see the house as a kind of person is brilliant.
- 22:19The satire is both biting and giggle -inducing.
- 22:22I especially liked the running gag about minimalist
- 22:25theater stagings. The ending is poignant and
- 22:29surprisingly reconciliatory, healing and hopeful,
- 22:34even while portraying a trauma. And the women
- 22:39in this movie are people, full humans. with their
- 22:44own dreams and flaws and personal journeys. Eight
- 22:51and a Half is an excellent film. It is also funny
- 22:56and beautiful and magical and insightful and
- 23:01self -deprecating. And when I watch it, I know
- 23:05this movie doesn't care what I think. I don't
- 23:10need to think. In this movie's eyes, my only
- 23:15value is in how I pleasure or inspire or care
- 23:20for a man. And I reserve my right and choice
- 23:26to dislike being seen that way. But thank you
- 23:33for caring about my individual thoughts. and
- 23:40perspectives. Thanks for listening.