Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Can't You Just Put Out a Mediator's Proposal?
Transcript
- 0:01you Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program.
- 0:06Can't you just put out a mediator's proposal?
- 0:09I'm Olive Policastro, Director of Education and
- 0:12Professional Development at Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:14Association, and today I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:17our speakers, Lisbeth Hasse and Michael Timpane.
- 0:21Lisbeth is a neutral with jams and has served
- 0:23as a mediator, arbitrator, negotiator, and special
- 0:26master since 1998, resolving over 1 ,000 matters
- 0:30domestically and internationally across. intellectual
- 0:33property, entertainment, media, technology, and
- 0:36business law. Her sophisticated approach has
- 0:39guided high stakes, multi -party disputes ranging
- 0:42from the Enron related banking litigation to
- 0:45class action arising from the Adelphia bankruptcy
- 0:47to landmark environmental antitrust and copyright
- 0:51cases, as well as complex technology and security
- 0:54matters worldwide. Beyond her extensive ADR practice,
- 0:58Lisbeth mentors emerging mediators and is a frequent
- 1:00speaker and writer on mediation and intellectual
- 1:03property. Michael is also neutral at jams and
- 1:07brings more than four decades of experience resolving
- 1:10complex construction disputes, having handled
- 1:13over 900 matters as a mediator, arbitrator, court
- 1:17-appointed referee, and early neutral evaluator
- 1:20across major public and private projects. After
- 1:24beginning his career as a trial lawyer in construction,
- 1:27surety, and complex commercial litigation, he
- 1:29later combined his litigation career with an
- 1:31active ADR practice. an author on topics related
- 1:36to ADR, construction, and payment claims, and
- 1:39has earned recognition amongst council as the
- 1:42leading arbitrator for construction mega projects.
- 1:45We're so excited to hear what they have to share
- 1:47with us today, so I'm now going to turn it over
- 1:49to them. Well, thank you very much. Yes, indeed.
- 1:55We were, of course, told by the Jams person to
- 1:58introduce ourselves, but I think we can say that.
- 2:01I cannot do that. So that was absolutely terrific.
- 2:04So why don't you get us started? Okay, I'll just
- 2:09jump in. So, and Ali, you said that question
- 2:13so well, it was ringing in my ears from someone
- 2:16else. Generally, it's maybe the younger lawyers
- 2:23who say, can't you just put out a mediator's
- 2:26proposal or someone who hasn't been through too
- 2:28many mediations? Or they say that early on. We're
- 2:33going to talk to you about why That doesn't always
- 2:36work early on, and it can well work later on
- 2:40in the day or in the course of a multi -day mediation,
- 2:46a multi -session mediation. Generally, as many
- 2:50of you know, and maybe some don't, the mediator's
- 2:56proposal is a tool for overcoming impasse. or
- 3:01closing a final gap in a mediation. It generally
- 3:05comes at the end of the mediation. You kind of
- 3:08hope it does, although sometimes it can be a
- 3:12tool part way through for overcoming an impasse.
- 3:17And the common structure is that it's a proposal
- 3:22given to a both sides, they each get the, all
- 3:27of them, however many parties you have, get the
- 3:29same proposal. And it's arrived at by the mediator,
- 3:35the mediator's idea as to the solution that all
- 3:39parties are most likely to agree to. And the
- 3:44responses are confidential such that unless everyone
- 3:48says okay, and consents to the proposal as their
- 3:54settlement agreement, those who say no don't
- 3:58know what the other parties have said. So it
- 4:01does preserve the possibility of continued negotiation
- 4:05without revealing positions. So that's just a
- 4:09quick overview. There's a lot to say about each
- 4:11of those points. And Mike, I'll let you pick
- 4:16up. No, that's, of course, an excellent description
- 4:19of what it is. I think probably most of the folks
- 4:23on this program have been through it. It attributes
- 4:27to continue that discussion are certainly it
- 4:30gets competitive versus cooperative bargaining.
- 4:36As Lizbeth mentioned, the folks should be at
- 4:40impasse. I mean, the idea is to let the parties
- 4:43to the negotiation negotiate as far as they can
- 4:45on their own. And the question, as I agree, Alia,
- 4:49so not just put it, but the way it got asked
- 4:53is just how it comes at you. Is itself a sign
- 5:00usually to me that the parties aren't done bargaining
- 5:03yet and that the main thing about the timing
- 5:06of it as I try to respond to someone who's asking
- 5:08me this question is it's my timing, not yours.
- 5:12You have to leave it to the mediator, I think.
- 5:14as the mediator, I guess I get to make that call.
- 5:18When a mediator's proposal is going to be effective
- 5:22is going to hopefully resolve the case globally
- 5:24and fully, or as Lisbeth mentioned, in certain
- 5:28circumstances, possibly help move a complicated
- 5:31matter forward by getting a piece of it or some
- 5:33key component of it resolved. Permission from
- 5:38both sides, that's really important, I think.
- 5:45A, just ethically, I don't think I should be
- 5:48jumping in like that unless everyone who's a
- 5:50participant to the process has agreed to be doing
- 5:53that. But also, you want buy -in from everybody.
- 5:56I mean, yeah, this is a good idea, and we all
- 6:00are going to listen carefully to what I say,
- 6:03hopefully. I think that the getting permission,
- 6:07too, it also gives you a chance to really explain
- 6:11the process sometimes to parties who haven't
- 6:13been through it. or to people who think they
- 6:16know how it works, but are afraid to ask. And
- 6:20part of my asking permission, which I'm sure
- 6:25you don't do until you really feel like you're
- 6:29ready to put one together too, but part of asking
- 6:32permission is to really reiterate, even for the
- 6:36well -seasoned participants, just how it'll work.
- 6:41Absolutely. Or how you imagine it'll work. Maybe
- 6:44talking about how long each side would have to
- 6:48consider the proposal that you're thinking of
- 6:51putting out. And then it's going to lead to more
- 6:55questions. You're going to be talking about that
- 6:57proposal. They really do want to know what you
- 6:59have in mind. Absolutely. And again, the title
- 7:05of this program and that question just frames,
- 7:10I think, how that's that, you know, if you're
- 7:12getting asked that question, it's almost certainly
- 7:14not the right time. You should be at a point
- 7:16where, no, I've said that's all I'm ever going
- 7:20to do. That's all I'm ever going to do. You know,
- 7:22we've been at this for hours and hours. I told
- 7:24you this would be the most I'd ever do. And both
- 7:26sides, I think, need to be at that point of really
- 7:29being there at impasse and ready for the proposal.
- 7:35um and when exactly that is it's a little harder
- 7:39to define but in general i think it's really
- 7:41important that again it be like elizabeth with
- 7:46certain exceptions the end of the process or
- 7:48at least coming at the the end of a long hard
- 7:50negotiation um which hopefully concluded successfully
- 7:53a media's proposal is second best to the parties
- 7:57getting there on their own and that's That comment,
- 8:02I've told you my bottom line, that's as far as
- 8:04I'm going to go, or I won't take anything less
- 8:07no matter what and I can't. Sometimes you do
- 8:12have to respect that. Sometimes that's true.
- 8:16And your mediator's proposal may end up being
- 8:20that. But you're assuring both sides that you
- 8:26feel they've negotiated well enough to have the
- 8:29options in front of them. And that, you know,
- 8:33there may not be, you know, I mean, here we're
- 8:36talking maybe just about numbers, and we'll talk
- 8:38a little bit more about other things that are
- 8:40in a proposal, too. But, you know, the parties
- 8:47are being pretty honest with you, which you hope
- 8:49by the time you're doing this, they have been.
- 8:53It may be that you can't do a proposal that's
- 8:57much different from what one side or another
- 8:59is telling you. absolutely tolerate now another
- 9:04key attribute of the proposal of course is as
- 9:06we all know often despite best efforts a key
- 9:10decision maker isn't necessarily present um a
- 9:15lot of times out uh you know i'm on the west
- 9:16coast i think elizabeth you're primarily on the
- 9:18west coast as well a problem very frequently
- 9:22is is the time difference and at two two thirty
- 9:25three o 'clock our time folks on the east coast
- 9:27are going home and a proposal certainly if it's
- 9:32a and we'll get to in more detail to exactly
- 9:35what does it look like but typically for me it's
- 9:38something that happens after we've parted from
- 9:40the initial session with an agreement that I'm
- 9:43going to do it and it's something I write up
- 9:45and transmit to people and one that's to in part
- 9:49satisfy the attribute of then it can easily be
- 9:51transmitted to other people whether or not they
- 9:54were participants in the initial session if they're
- 9:57important to making a decision on settlement
- 9:59and So I think a proposal is very useful there
- 10:06if for some reason someone who is absent or couldn't
- 10:11be around at the end of the initial session or
- 10:14sessions where the negotiations concluded needs
- 10:17to be part of the process of settlement. Yeah,
- 10:20and that's an important thing. And to get back
- 10:26to this notion of, you know, this is the number
- 10:30they'll tolerate or they won't tolerate anything
- 10:33lower or anything higher. We don't want our mediators'
- 10:38proposals to be surprises. And very often, more
- 10:44often than not, I almost can't think of a time
- 10:47that I haven't done this. I will tell the party
- 10:51separately what my number is. But the question
- 10:55is, what I ask them is, Will you seriously consider
- 11:00a mediator's proposal at X? Will you give serious
- 11:04consideration to a mediator's proposal at X?
- 11:10That's almost like a preliminary mediator's proposal,
- 11:15but particularly, you know, I don't want to,
- 11:20you know, differentiate the party's too much
- 11:23in this, but sometimes the defendants are coming
- 11:26up with the money. And if it's not there, you
- 11:30don't want to blow it, and you don't want to
- 11:32set the valuation of the case. And they're very
- 11:35much afraid of the mediator setting a valuation
- 11:38of the case. That's why it's so important for
- 11:42both sides, that you get the permission and that
- 11:45you get You have arrived at a point where you
- 11:50can feel comfortable with the proposal and the
- 11:54number that you're putting out. Whether it is
- 11:56to say, will you give serious consideration to
- 11:59this number or to this range or to something
- 12:01below this or not, you really have to spend the
- 12:07time to know that this is not going to be a surprise.
- 12:13Indeed, and it's kind of in the realm of what
- 12:18I at least call trial ballooning. I mean, hopefully
- 12:21we've talked about numbers and potential scenarios
- 12:23all day. This is only the second time Lisbeth
- 12:27and I have done this program. I was very interested
- 12:29to hear you say that, Lisbeth. If I'm getting
- 12:32that verbally far ahead and far along with folks
- 12:35near the end of the day, it would almost be,
- 12:37well, let's just settle it. I mean, if you're
- 12:39all ready to consider this number, aren't we
- 12:41done? But I don't usually do that. I tend to
- 12:46hold back more the mystery of what the number
- 12:48will be, which is kind of more how I saw it done
- 12:52as a young lawyer, but that's an interesting
- 12:55practice. You know, it really depends on the
- 12:58council and the parties and how long you've spent
- 13:00with them, how well you know their case, all
- 13:04of that. Absolutely. But I think avoiding surprises
- 13:08is an important value in this. We've got a question
- 13:13that I think is a good one to ask right now.
- 13:16It says, when asking permission, do you seek
- 13:18permission from the insurance adjusters? If so,
- 13:22what is your experience with insurers and mediators'
- 13:27proposals? I would say yes and excellent. Yeah.
- 13:33I mean, I think it really fits. I used to represent
- 13:36carriers in coverage matters. pretty familiar
- 13:39with the process of evaluating the claim. And
- 13:42then the particular adjuster has to take it to
- 13:44a committee situation usually. And a group decision
- 13:46is usually made about how much money to put on
- 13:49a file. And when the rep runs out of authority
- 13:54that day, but everyone who's been there all day
- 13:57understands that maybe a bigger number might
- 13:59be appropriate, this is the key mechanism, I
- 14:03think, to putting something in writing in front
- 14:06of folks with reasoning to it. why I think this
- 14:09is a good idea, private to that side, of course.
- 14:13So I've had good experience with it. And yes,
- 14:16certainly use it with both adjusters and counsel.
- 14:20Yeah, no, it gives you the opportunity to help
- 14:23the adjuster really to go back home. Whose eyes
- 14:28may be a little wide at the end of the day. We
- 14:30didn't quite understand all this before. You
- 14:32know what I mean? they learned a lot of facts
- 14:36right along with you it's true um and uh you
- 14:41know it makes their job easier to have a mediator's
- 14:44proposal right definitely but back to elizabeth's
- 14:48point of you know how are we getting to the number
- 14:50it certainly isn't and and despite a perception
- 14:55out there i think usually a splitting of the
- 14:58last couple of settlement proposals uh um you
- 15:03know And mediators proposals when I first encountered
- 15:06them would usually be something more like at
- 15:10the end of a long day Parties are down to a fairly
- 15:13small differential and and really on the if they
- 15:16would you kind of a basis the mediator, you know
- 15:18I'm talking guys like Piazza and wolf and you
- 15:20know real legends in my view would sort of if
- 15:23they would you The number right there at the
- 15:27end of the day. And so that was the original
- 15:29way. I sort of saw them Um, I think that works
- 15:33much better if all of the actual decision makers,
- 15:37in other words, in my world, Smith who owns Smith
- 15:40construction and Jones who owns Jones construction,
- 15:43if they're in the room, you know, they're with
- 15:45me that day. Uh, that works much better or, or
- 15:49can work anyway. But when folks are remote and
- 15:51in the case of adjusters and insurance companies,
- 15:54we all have to recognize that flying for a whole
- 15:58day and mediating on the day and then flying
- 16:01back the next day. Nobody likes to do that anymore.
- 16:05They could do three mediations by zoom and you
- 16:08got to respect that. That's become the norm in
- 16:10my view. I don't see a lot of adjusters personally.
- 16:13I just settled one on Tuesday and neither of
- 16:16the adjusters for the carriers in question were
- 16:18there in person. That's very often the case now.
- 16:23But you're certainly not trying to just split
- 16:25a difference usually with the number. It happens
- 16:28sometimes, but I think it's when you've been
- 16:31through a lot. You've done a good job of guiding
- 16:35the negotiation and putting brackets together.
- 16:39Sometimes people are exchanging brackets and
- 16:43you're helping them to come up with the bracket
- 16:45and you're just moving them closer and closer.
- 16:48As we all know, people get closer, they do different
- 16:51things like they get interested in, oh, maybe
- 16:53there's going to be a settlement. But sometimes
- 16:58you just don't want to be the one. the last one
- 17:01to accept the other side's proposal and then
- 17:03it and the mediators proposal is as simple as
- 17:05that it's it's it's it's relieving you of of
- 17:08the feeling that oh maybe I left some money on
- 17:11the table or or right you know I could have nickel
- 17:14and dimed them down a little more well and I
- 17:18think another thing we both stress is that it's
- 17:20not our valuation of their claim or their defenses
- 17:24or our you know, attempt to, uh, judge it or,
- 17:28or, or, or anything like that. It is, and I,
- 17:31I'd be very expressed with people. I put it in
- 17:33my written, uh, kind of summation of what I'm
- 17:35trying to do. It is simply a number. I think
- 17:38you'll both say yes to that's what the number
- 17:42is. I'm not saying who's, you know, I'm, I'm
- 17:44Pat, you know, it's now in the why part. there's
- 17:47some evaluation of why you might want to say
- 17:50yes to this number which I you know is certainly
- 17:52an attempt to persuade a little bit but it's
- 17:54really not my value on it it's it's a number
- 17:58I think you'll both say yes to so please don't
- 18:00you know think I'm judging anyone here I'm just
- 18:03trying to get to a couple of yeses and along
- 18:07with that I think it's the number that you'll
- 18:09both you both could could stretch yourself to
- 18:15agree to, I think it's important to say, and
- 18:18it's specific for this particular point in time.
- 18:22That does a lot. That one helps the parties to
- 18:26evaluate where they are in their litigation,
- 18:28what the risk is, how much time are they going
- 18:31to be spending, what do they get at this particular
- 18:34moment, and they can sort of look at all the
- 18:38columns and do the pros and cons. about that,
- 18:42but it also gives you the opportunity to try
- 18:46again if it fails. This is just a number based
- 18:52on our negotiations today, what we all know,
- 18:55what I've learned from you, what seem to be the
- 19:00party's various interests, not just in this you
- 19:03know who has the strongest legal argument but
- 19:07from from from all the all the aspects of of
- 19:10your uh that i've learned about that are that
- 19:13are at play in this negotiation um for this particular
- 19:18point in time this would be my proposal for settling
- 19:21and i think that's another good point liz bet
- 19:24that is as we've all learned maybe how to use
- 19:27them a little better it's just so important to
- 19:30stay away from it's my judgment, it's my call,
- 19:34it's what I really feel strongly you both should
- 19:36do. And then if they say no, what do you say
- 19:38after that? As opposed to, I appear to have mis
- 19:41-assessed the number that you would both say
- 19:43yes to. But I now think that maybe I just heard
- 19:48another number that you most say yes. And so
- 19:50it does allow you maybe back in a little easier
- 19:53than if you put your judgment on it, if you made
- 19:57the mistake, at least in my opinion, of presenting
- 19:59some kind of personal valuation to them as opposed
- 20:03to uh it's just a number i think you'll both
- 20:06say yes to and then if you did get it wrong hey
- 20:08let me you know let's keep working not um you
- 20:12know they've rejected your judgment or something
- 20:14along those lines it does depend on really good
- 20:18communications i mean coming up with the with
- 20:21the uh media's proposal that has a chance of
- 20:24working does depend on really good communications
- 20:28with with the parties in their separate rooms
- 20:30and the parties being they don't have to tell
- 20:34you everything and sometimes you don't want them
- 20:37to tell you quite everything but they do have
- 20:42to to be open with you and you know sometimes
- 20:47you feel that they're not and you've got to figure
- 20:51out a way to to draw out from them what might
- 20:54work without them feeling too exposed or giving
- 21:00up some information they don't want to give up.
- 21:03And those times I kind of try out things in the
- 21:07rooms, you know, letting them know, I think there
- 21:11might be a 50 % chance you could settle in this
- 21:15range, but, you know, an 80 % chance you could
- 21:17settle in that range and, you know, giving them
- 21:20some, or if you were to give up this particular,
- 21:24you know, length of time on a license agreement,
- 21:28then we might be able to get it at this, or would
- 21:32that make sense to you to do some, you know,
- 21:35I think you've got to be really proactive in
- 21:39letting them know the options that you're seeing.
- 21:42And if you're testing them with them, you can
- 21:45make mistakes in that discussion. I mean, you're
- 21:48having the parties educate you and you're asking
- 21:51them, you know, what do you think about this?
- 21:54Would this kind of thing work? Does it not? But
- 21:58you've got to get some open, meaningful discussion.
- 22:04Going and the candor point is so important. It's
- 22:07it's something that if Elizabeth and I have done
- 22:09our jobs We've stressed from the get -go of the
- 22:13of the process that the reason we generally are
- 22:16private with you the reason we're primarily meeting
- 22:19just with you and in other instances just with
- 22:21the other side is so that we can be candid with
- 22:24each other and Discuss this matter in an open
- 22:27way without the other side hearing anything that
- 22:29we're saying and with my assurance that i will
- 22:32not speak to them about anything that we talk
- 22:34about unless i ask for and receive your permission
- 22:36and so that candor um the way i used to hear
- 22:42a wonderful mediator put it was hey you know
- 22:46lie to me and guess what at the end of the day
- 22:50that might actually work and you know what that
- 22:52means i miss it there was a chance to settle
- 22:55here today and one or both of you way to go congratulations
- 23:04really when we're private please tell me what's
- 23:08possible i'm not going to run over to the other
- 23:10side and say here's where they are i'm going
- 23:13to use that information to try to help you as
- 23:15best i can and if i if it's the first time i'm
- 23:18working with the party lisbeth made this point
- 23:20that might be okay sure my but if you've worked
- 23:23with folks before i think in general people understand
- 23:27that you mean that um and that candor can help
- 23:31everyone you know, if you're in a negotiation
- 23:34where the two -size settlement is actually overlap
- 23:36like this, and so, wow, you want to bargain over,
- 23:39you know, okay, great, but those are rare, right,
- 23:41Elizabeth? Really, it's more that the end games
- 23:45are here, and how are you going to split that
- 23:48difference somehow? And so, candor is crucial
- 23:51to let us know if that's possible. Yeah, which
- 23:56again just, you know, speaks to the timing of
- 23:59the proposal. It's not something you're going
- 24:01to be seeing necessarily at the beginning of
- 24:05the day. I mean, there may be times where, you
- 24:07know, people think they can get a half -day mediation
- 24:12and get it done, and there are cases where you
- 24:14can. They're fairly straightforward. The parties
- 24:16have done a lot of work in advance, or they really
- 24:19know their cases well. They just need a mediator
- 24:22in there to help them close, basically. But other
- 24:25than that, I think that, you know, you need to
- 24:30spend that time and effort to really understand
- 24:35how you're going to bring the parties closer,
- 24:37what they care about, what they don't. And the
- 24:42mediator's proposal is the final tool after others
- 24:47are tried, after you acquaint people with your
- 24:51ideas of options they might not have considered.
- 24:55talked about likelihoods of settlement at different
- 24:58ranges, exchanged brackets, helped them make
- 25:01brackets, all that is ways of testing what their
- 25:06territories really are during the course of the
- 25:08day. Experts have maybe been gathered together
- 25:11to exchange information just between experts
- 25:14and maybe reach a little more consensus and then
- 25:17on a regather. All sorts of things can happen.
- 25:22But if someone, for example, thinks that that's
- 25:25crucial to adjust the other side's position and
- 25:28get them where it would need to be to settle,
- 25:30then they're not ready to settle yet that day.
- 25:32Making a proposal that day would be silly. One
- 25:35side thinks an expert meeting is crucial and
- 25:38needed. And so I think it's more important to
- 25:40sponsor that and make sure both sides are at
- 25:42a point where they're ready to consider their
- 25:45proposal. Because although we certainly, as we
- 25:49just stressed, are putting our evaluation on
- 25:51it, uh it's a lot of stress and effort uh and
- 25:55and to go through it uh when it's not the right
- 25:58time uh cannot only be a waste of that time and
- 26:02effort but uh counterproductive in some ways
- 26:05i've certainly seen you know and i did you know
- 26:10i had a stint as a mediator only at jams 08 to
- 26:1212 and then i had the very interesting experience
- 26:14of you know litigating away again for 12 or 13
- 26:17years and using some wonderful mediators and
- 26:20sitting in the lawyer's chair and watching them
- 26:22do their thing. Hopefully jot down some notes
- 26:26about stuff like that as we went but you know
- 26:30the stress of people really both parties needing
- 26:35to be ready to settle and you got to be as lawyers
- 26:40part of that process with the mediator hopefully.
- 26:42You know my client's not you know, needs this,
- 26:46has to have that, needs this question answered.
- 26:49Those are important things for us to know as
- 26:51well. And we'll do our best to get that information.
- 26:53But obviously sometimes that takes some time
- 26:55and isn't conducive to that day being the day.
- 27:00And if it's not, it's not. And we've got to go
- 27:03work forward to find the day that that is. I
- 27:05think, you know, that leads us right into question
- 27:09a lot of people have is how do you handle things
- 27:11like injunctive relief, non -monetary aspects
- 27:15of a settlement, things in my world, it's what
- 27:19kind of license agreement are we going to have,
- 27:21is this confidential or not, what aspects of
- 27:24it are confidential. If you've got a confidentiality
- 27:30agreement and people have agreed to your number,
- 27:34so to speak, and basic points. Suddenly, you
- 27:38know, there's a liquidated damages proposal from
- 27:42one side that throws everything off. So how much
- 27:45are you going to cover in that mediators proposal?
- 27:48How much needs to be covered to settle this type
- 27:51of case? Those are important things to get clear
- 27:54about, really from the outset, even in your pre
- 27:58-mediation discussions. Absolutely. And it's
- 28:02hopefully a product of Lizbeth and I and council,
- 28:07you know, understanding that as we work through
- 28:09a day of mediation, we certainly should address
- 28:11not just and look, I'm from the construction
- 28:14world. So in general, money is not just number
- 28:17one, but but but only, but certainly things in
- 28:22my world that come up like Lizbeth just mentioned
- 28:24are, oh, well, sure, so long as they indemnify
- 28:26me against XYZ in the future, right? Or sure,
- 28:29so long as they build me this extra garage, which
- 28:32is like you're going to do a whole other construction
- 28:34project together, what are you crazy? That's
- 28:36not going to be a good idea. But hopefully we've
- 28:40all understood that as You know, sometimes that
- 28:43money discussion, I'm right there wrong. You
- 28:45know, that's always a little bit tough. What
- 28:46can we agree on? Hey, at one 30, maybe we take
- 28:48a break from all that. And what are the other
- 28:50components of settlement? Well, we we would need
- 28:53a release with the standard three. OK, that's
- 28:56great. We both agree on that. We would need confidential.
- 28:58OK, we can agree on that in this best world,
- 29:02whatever those fancy injunctive type situations
- 29:05are that sound fascinating to me, but aren't
- 29:08typically something I get into on the construction
- 29:10side. Often the scope of the release, I'm sure,
- 29:15is important for you. Absolutely. And it can
- 29:17usually be agreed on. And so, OK, now we're starting
- 29:20to agree on a few things. And then not only is
- 29:23that a kind of a momentum builder, but very important,
- 29:26as was just noted, if we're going to make a proposal
- 29:29at the end, we sure better address all the key
- 29:32terms of settlement or we risk. Well, yeah, but
- 29:36and then whoops, you know, we forgot those two
- 29:39things. And now we're, you know, we're back at
- 29:41the table. Yeah, so so that that's important
- 29:44to the timing is when when do we? You know, hopefully
- 29:48before you've started your your mediation session,
- 29:50you know, what kinds of non -monetary issues
- 29:54there are You know came up just I'm just thinking
- 29:57of Tuesday The contractor late in the day is
- 30:00the county gonna still let me bid their jobs
- 30:03I Wouldn't even ask them because then they'll
- 30:08go. Oh, are we allowed to debar you? Oh so you
- 30:11know that i have my job back here's advice you
- 30:13didn't ask before but i don't think we should
- 30:15try to make that a term of the agreement right
- 30:17and then yeah later in the day uh if my surety
- 30:22pays all this money what are they going to do
- 30:23and i said without it again that's that that's
- 30:26a question you're gonna have to discuss with
- 30:29them uh that's a component that i can't address
- 30:33as part of this deal they're just going to want
- 30:34to carve that out and talk to you about that
- 30:37later Um, and so that had to be a component of
- 30:40the deal was that anything between the surety
- 30:42and the contractor had to be expressly carved
- 30:45out and set to the side. And so those were the
- 30:48two things that came up, you know, three, three
- 30:5030. So that, and as Elizabeth said, that's unfortunate.
- 30:52You should rather have that addressed, uh, earlier
- 30:55or even in a pre -mediation call if the briefs
- 30:57were really good. Um, but it's surprising something
- 31:00this this county sent me a brief and shows up
- 31:04and go and there's nothing about liquidated damages
- 31:06or holding any money oh we're holding 210 000
- 31:08of course for because the project was late and
- 31:11i said well i was hoping you wouldn't say that
- 31:13because there's nothing about that in your brief
- 31:17And so off we went from there. Yeah. So that's
- 31:20a contextual point that went straight to the
- 31:24center of the dispute. So that's interesting.
- 31:27Yeah. Those are the things you don't want to
- 31:28find out about too late. And so how do you avoid
- 31:31that? How do you avoid not necessarily what are
- 31:36the non -monetary items? Because hopefully you
- 31:40have discussed those. You know that if these
- 31:43are business affiliates that have done work with
- 31:47each other for a long time whether or not they
- 31:50want to continue the relationship or whether
- 31:53they've got another product line that's important
- 31:55that this company is also involved in that we
- 31:58could, you know, work with along with coming
- 32:01up with a settlement of this case, those sorts
- 32:04of dynamics you have explored or know they exist
- 32:08before you start your session. Although not always,
- 32:12you know, suddenly a business person can show
- 32:15up at the mediation who hasn't been part of the
- 32:18preparation and talk about this other project
- 32:22that may be quite useful to have as a component
- 32:28of both. And boy, an ongoing relationship, if
- 32:33it exists or can be salvaged, can be such a useful
- 32:38place to explore some non -monetary components
- 32:42that might help a lot to get the matter settled.
- 32:46I always if I'm in what I call a zero -sum day
- 32:49and a lot of construction cases tend to be that.
- 32:53I mean by the time I see them these people all
- 32:55hate each other. There's no possibility anybody
- 32:59in the room is doing any business with anybody
- 33:01else in the room in the future and those are
- 33:03those you know that's zero -sum that's just you
- 33:05know bang bang bang every dollar you don't get
- 33:07I get you know there's no other way around that
- 33:09but if there are some ways to move the matter
- 33:12forward that aren't monetary. Boy, you really
- 33:15need to think about those and brainstorm those
- 33:18with folks. Hey, no ideas of dumb one right now.
- 33:21Any other ways that might help you get to a resolution
- 33:24with those folks over there? Well, yeah, I hear
- 33:27there's this job coming up. And if I got on the
- 33:29business for that, that'd be great. Well, let
- 33:31me go see whether that's something that could
- 33:33be discussed. And you can remind them that we're
- 33:36in a confidential situation. We can discuss this
- 33:40stuff. the discussion goes outside this room
- 33:43is something we all have to agree on between
- 33:47the parties. They're going to talk about some
- 33:51other project. But it makes for some pretty fruitful
- 33:56discussions sometimes. Absolutely. Things that
- 33:58really help the business people. You know, there's
- 34:02a useful tool for making sure you've got everything
- 34:07in your mediator's proposal. as far as some of
- 34:11the smaller non -monetary but important points
- 34:14of confidentiality, timing of the payment of
- 34:19the settlement consideration, those kinds of
- 34:28things that go into a settlement agreement. At
- 34:32a certain point you should be asking counsel
- 34:35if they have a template. Do they have a template
- 34:38we can share? It's time to share that template
- 34:42because you've been negotiating for a while.
- 34:47People can look at it with new eyes towards,
- 34:52is this a settlement agreement I can live with?
- 34:55Are there holes in it? Is something missing?
- 34:58And that'll really help the mediator's proposal
- 35:03when you eventually give it. close to full settlement
- 35:11agreement. We don't need pages and pages, but
- 35:13something that really does touch on all the material
- 35:16points. Because you just jot down whatever the
- 35:21deal points as you understand them. Let me understand
- 35:24from your perspective what you need me to get
- 35:27agreement on. And please be comprehensive. Often
- 35:31in my world there's a whole bunch of paperwork
- 35:32that's needed at the end. I need this stop notice
- 35:35released. I need a bond releasing. I need this
- 35:37bond. You got to unwind this Gordian knot they
- 35:40put themselves in, you know? And so you just
- 35:44slow down. If they think you're close on the
- 35:48number, people get really kind of good and constructive,
- 35:51in my experience, about getting these things
- 35:53agreed to. And lawyers are so, at least in my
- 35:59experience, the sophistication now with a form
- 36:02of the agreement on your laptop. Most lawyers
- 36:05I deal with, it's right there. And if they spend
- 36:0810 minutes on it, it's tailored to this case
- 36:10and very close. And as you point out, Elizabeth,
- 36:13highlights right in it the key deal points that
- 36:17you need to make sure you have agreement on.
- 36:20Yeah. So it's important that that gets shared
- 36:22and that you pick the right time for suggesting
- 36:25that to the parties. And they may both have one.
- 36:30Maybe only the defense side does. you do not
- 36:36want to be looking at a new form after people
- 36:40have accepted a number or two terms of the settlement
- 36:44proposal and you think you're done and then it
- 36:48all opens up for another pretty important reason.
- 36:52I'm often left asking the owner near the end
- 36:55of the day, do you want a warranty from this
- 36:58contractor that you hate or would you rather
- 37:00have a few more dollars? and then we'll get the
- 37:03warranty out of the non -monetary. So the point
- 37:06I'm making is if certain non -monetary components
- 37:12can be monetized, that's in my view usually cleaner.
- 37:17It avoids a continuing relationship between people
- 37:20who may not want it. Other times you've got people
- 37:23who have to have it. So it's a good idea to talk
- 37:28about a procedure for the future. If we end up
- 37:32with another dispute, this is the process we're
- 37:35going to go through. I've had those where people
- 37:38are licensed or licensee, how they're going to
- 37:44address a dispute in the future. And that's part
- 37:47of the settlement. And that's an appealing part
- 37:50of your mediator's proposal, too, if you can
- 37:53have that as part of it. So Elizabeth, should
- 37:56we talk a little about multi -party cases? Certainly
- 38:02a complication in a proposal process as anyone
- 38:05can discern, right? If there's two parties, okay,
- 38:07three, four, six, twelve, you know, it starts
- 38:11getting quite complex as you think about it to
- 38:15get twelve yeses to just about anything, right?
- 38:19So it's something to consider obviously in those
- 38:23types of cases. um i'm sure you have a lot of
- 38:27them because i i'm thinking the times when i've
- 38:31had well they've had a number quite a few multi
- 38:35-party cases but i don't think i've had a real
- 38:38estate case where that what hasn't been a multi
- 38:41-party case uh yes and uh all too there's a world
- 38:45of claims that at least in california is often
- 38:48called construction defect where it's pretty
- 38:50standard stuff complaint against the general
- 38:53to then be translated into 16 cross -complaints
- 38:55against the 16 subcontractors, all of whom have
- 39:00interlocking additional insured obligations and
- 39:03things of this nature to each other. And in cases
- 39:07of that nature, the people who participate in
- 39:10them are very sophisticated at how they allocate
- 39:12defense costs between and amongst themselves
- 39:15and things of that nature. But when it comes
- 39:17around to if you can't get such a case resolved.
- 39:23What's really key, well, frankly, in that construction
- 39:28defect realm I just mentioned, a lot of the mediators
- 39:31who operate a lot in that realm, and I've done
- 39:33quite a bit of it, are pretty facile with it.
- 39:35And so they do understand the realm and maybe
- 39:39even an eight or a 10 -sided proposal that really,
- 39:43you don't have yeses from any of them yet. has
- 39:46a better chance. But in general, when I'm confronted
- 39:49with that situation, it's really important for
- 39:51me to try to get that number down. I need to
- 39:55have six of those parties in the bag and only
- 39:59really be making a proposal to five of them or
- 40:02three of them or some other number. In those
- 40:06cases, to me, if I don't have an understanding
- 40:12of yeses in a certain number of the rooms, just
- 40:17mathematically. Me making a proposal is not exactly
- 40:19the greatest thing in the world and if I do,
- 40:21I gotta make what I call a really soft one. You
- 40:24almost put in it. This is a bit of a guess. So,
- 40:27if I'm wrong on two or three of you, let's keep
- 40:29talking. Uh huh. Uh you know what I mean? Uh
- 40:32so you gotta almost temper it a little bit. uh
- 40:35uh sometimes uh but uh yeah multi -party cases
- 40:38are tough and uh the key component again to just
- 40:42repeat myself is if possible just shrink that
- 40:45number somehow as best you can because as anyone
- 40:49can discern you know a proposal to two or three
- 40:52folks is so much easier to hopefully get three
- 40:55yeses to than than nine ten twelve that's very
- 40:59very difficult right and and you know a lot of
- 41:02multi -party cases maybe not so much in the construction
- 41:08dynamic, but a lot of them do, there's just multiple
- 41:15defendants. And so you're gonna work with that
- 41:19group and come up with a proposal that works
- 41:23for the group as a whole. before you're putting
- 41:27out a proposal to the entirety of the participants,
- 41:32parties in the case. Absolutely. Or you get agreement
- 41:37as to who are the lead negotiators to work with
- 41:42you from the defense group and come up with something
- 41:47that you then bring back to that group as a whole.
- 41:52So there are many ways in which to come up with
- 41:57the mediator's proposal, or just the proposal
- 42:00of the group, maybe, that then becomes an element
- 42:05of the mediator's proposal. That's an excellent
- 42:07point that I forgot to mention. This room, which
- 42:13might have three insurance carriers, all of whom
- 42:15insured the same policy holder that's involved
- 42:17in the dispute I'm talking about, I need X from
- 42:20that room. I don't mean you three insurance carriers
- 42:24to get into the business of how you are going
- 42:26to divide that up. You're frankly much better
- 42:27at that than I. You'll essentially be insulted
- 42:30if I try to come in that world for you. You know,
- 42:33you might have a deal with them from the last
- 42:34deal and they agree to pay a little more on this
- 42:36one. I mean, there's all kinds of that going
- 42:37on between adjusters, at least in my experience.
- 42:41So yes, I just need this group to come up with
- 42:44this much money can be a proposal and, you know,
- 42:47leave the particular, you know, how the three
- 42:50or four of them in that group get to that number
- 42:52to them. And it can sometimes be a very useful
- 42:55tool when they're frankly better at it and more
- 42:58experienced at it and have done it with each
- 43:00other many, many times in many other scenarios.
- 43:03Yeah, I mean, I think that's a that's a strong
- 43:05point. Going back to that earlier question about
- 43:08the insurers, they have their own course that,
- 43:13you know, they're there to. in good faith, cover
- 43:17the costs of their insured. But they do, as far
- 43:23as their co -carriers go, they do have a history
- 43:27of relationships. They may have some protocols
- 43:30about, you know, they don't drop down to cover
- 43:35for a carrier that's not there. There are some
- 43:38things they just... don't do, or they have a
- 43:40history of regarding as a fair way of cooperating,
- 43:45and you probably don't know what they are as
- 43:48a mediator. And so there's a certain amount of
- 43:52deference to what they come up with in their
- 43:55room. No question. If I suggest that an additional
- 43:59insured carrier should do anything except participate
- 44:01in defense, they just laugh at me because that's
- 44:03the rule. They only participate in defense and
- 44:05don't pay a dime on indemnity. And you just have
- 44:07to say, fine. because that is indeed essentially
- 44:11a rule. And they all understand it. And since
- 44:15they're all AIs over here and primary carriers
- 44:17over there, it works. Hey, when you settle cases,
- 44:23Elizabeth, do we always have to understand why?
- 44:26No. Why partners decide to get where they get?
- 44:32It's not necessarily, I don't need to know all
- 44:34of that. Yeah, no, some people believe in magic
- 44:37numbers and approach that one. You're not going
- 44:40to settle, however much you may be giving them
- 44:44a better offer than they're looking for. The
- 44:47horrifying, almost certainly unprecedented scenario
- 44:51where you had a mediators proposal fail. How'd
- 44:55you try to recover from that? Is there recovery
- 44:58from a failed proposal? Yeah, I think, you know,
- 45:02it can fail for a number of reasons. It can fail
- 45:05because there's some small point we've forgotten
- 45:07about and we can work on that. It can fail because
- 45:13it's a little bit off and we can work on that.
- 45:16um it can fail because it's it's it's way off
- 45:19and then we have to talk about what kind of homework
- 45:22needs to be done in order for the parties to
- 45:24work again but that's just touching the service
- 45:26now how do we do that you know so you're sitting
- 45:30there in your office and you get back an acceptance
- 45:33and a rejection and then in the rejection somebody's
- 45:37written something about what they needed and
- 45:41then so how do you re -approach um without exposing
- 45:48what the parties have said to you, how do you
- 45:52re -approach them, Mike? Well, in the first instance,
- 45:57I have given, Elizabeth, I'm sure you have given,
- 46:00from the outset of describing this entire process,
- 46:03my absolute and personal assurance that I will
- 46:06not ever reveal your affirmative response to
- 46:09the proposal if the other side has said no. They
- 46:12might figure that out, but they won't ever hear
- 46:16it from me uh and but but a corresponding part
- 46:19of that which is always trying to you know bring
- 46:21them in a little bit right is if you do say yes
- 46:24i'm talking to you okay you then get perfect
- 46:27information you're on board and so then when
- 46:30the other side says no i usually call up the
- 46:32yes side and say of course i sent the email out
- 46:34saying regrettably the media's proposal has failed
- 46:37which is all i say uh and then i call the side
- 46:40that said yes and said how do you want to play
- 46:44this I'm yours. You know what I mean? I swore
- 46:50I wouldn't do anything here. I mean, the assurance
- 46:53I gave you is I'd shut the hell up if this happened.
- 46:57And I just had one a few months ago where that
- 46:59assurance held up for about three weeks. And
- 47:02then the party who said yes called me up and
- 47:05said, well, would they reconsider your proposal?
- 47:08I said, well, if I even ask them, they'll kind
- 47:11of start thinking. You said, yes. And they go,
- 47:13we understand that. We want you to get back in.
- 47:15I said, great. And there was my window. I'm back
- 47:17in. And I got the case settled a couple of weeks
- 47:20later. So I really feel like, to me, it's real.
- 47:27Now, if both sides said no, then that's one of
- 47:31the scenarios you just mentioned, Lizbeth, where,
- 47:33wow, I missed it by a lot. You guys, somebody's
- 47:36got a lot of work to do here, or both of you
- 47:40do. uh and that's important to let folks know
- 47:42I think uh you both said no yeah okay just so
- 47:46you both know that but even then I think I need
- 47:48I think you need permission to to to do even
- 47:51do that even do that anything beyond the proposal
- 47:56failed I think I need permission to keep discussing
- 47:59with folks but the trick is as you know Elizabeth
- 48:02I think is don't as a mediator don't just sit
- 48:04there and not seek that permission sure yes don't
- 48:07try to get it no it's very important i mean i
- 48:09miss the number i'm sorry but i think i can still
- 48:13be of assistance yes yeah and i think it's it's
- 48:16important for the mediator to be bold in that
- 48:19situation and not assume that you're a failure
- 48:21right the proposal was a failure we had more
- 48:25work to do um I think I can help you with it.
- 48:29I've learned a lot from you. You know, maybe
- 48:32we needed to go down this road a little more.
- 48:34Maybe we need to explore this and maybe such
- 48:36and such needs to be at the table. Um, you know,
- 48:40thinking hard about because actually Sarah, you
- 48:44sort of mentioned it was one side says yes and
- 48:46the other side says no, but their email back
- 48:49to you says, but we would do this. So they just
- 48:51keep the, you know, propose number, but we would
- 48:54do this number. That's very close to it or something
- 48:56like that. Well, I usually would give the yes
- 49:02side that information. To me that email essentially
- 49:06said make sure they understand this. So why not
- 49:09call the yes side and say you look like you saw
- 49:11the email the proposals rejected but actually
- 49:13their response to me said they do this number.
- 49:16What do you want to do? They're usually not going
- 49:20to say yes to that but they are probably bargaining
- 49:22somewhere between the two and you know. Yeah,
- 49:25I think that happens quite a bit. I often tell
- 49:30folks, if I'm close and you're gonna say no,
- 49:35I wouldn't mind you telling me, but I would do
- 49:37this. I mean, I appreciate that information.
- 49:41I hesitate to encourage that too much. This is
- 49:48really it for this time. We've done as much work
- 49:52as we can at this. We've all worked really hard.
- 49:55We know our options. um as we put it that's a
- 50:02very good point every click we come off the silver
- 50:06bullet this is it this is the end you know if
- 50:08you guys don't all say yes to this i'm gone you'll
- 50:11nobody will ever hear from me again this is it
- 50:13my silver bullet with every softening of that
- 50:16we do you're right then is the proposal going
- 50:19to have as much force and have as much chance
- 50:21feeling like oh i'm going to settle not Oh, I
- 50:26hear you get a little more any suggestion, right?
- 50:30Or a little pay a little less. Yeah. So, um,
- 50:36so, yeah, so it's not that, uh, sometimes in
- 50:42my judgment, it has been important for the person
- 50:44who wants the money to understand that even in
- 50:47a proposal scenario, the other side's not going
- 50:49to say yes to that. Yeah. Yeah. I probably told
- 50:52them that. 50 times that i just tell you they're
- 50:55never going to say yes to that much money i think
- 50:57they will uh you know and so you know sometimes
- 51:03not often you know and then you got to recover
- 51:06from it and get back in but yeah yeah they said
- 51:09no to it and i told you they would i honored
- 51:12what you told me so you would put out the proposal
- 51:15even feeling like you're certain somebody's gonna
- 51:18say no you can i'm not saying this never happened
- 51:21uh -huh maybe it's because you feel they have
- 51:26to go through that exercise and get the no or
- 51:30what? Sometimes the lawyers even told me that.
- 51:33Uh huh. You gotta propose. I tell people I don't
- 51:36want to waste the proposal that it's very important
- 51:39and I'm sure you do too that it's very important
- 51:43for me not to put out a proposal that I am close
- 51:46to certain is going to get rejected. Let's let's
- 51:50not do it. These would have been parties or council
- 51:53I'd worked with multiple times before, before
- 51:56it was done like that, absolutely. Yeah, I mean,
- 52:01because it's not so much that you kill your own,
- 52:06I don't think you do, but you could be putting
- 52:10out, you know, some evaluation that it's not
- 52:18people see the media as embracing it. As I've
- 52:23worked into a case and I've gotten to understand
- 52:25what's happening by three or four o 'clock or
- 52:27certain by the second day I mean I'm usually
- 52:29ready to do the old hey on this I give you that
- 52:32on this I give you that on this one I give you
- 52:33that I think on this one you'll come out someone
- 52:35like here you spend this much an attorney's fees
- 52:37you know this much time is going to go by so
- 52:40some number like this if I'm you would be something
- 52:43I would consider you know I mean you know just
- 52:45that kind of right leading them to why they might
- 52:49consider some reduced or negotiated number. Certainly,
- 52:53I've used that tool as it's a bit of an evaluation
- 52:56by me as we roll through the day of how if I'm
- 52:59your arbitrator and you bounced it off me, it
- 53:01would come out somewhere like here. That's usually
- 53:03how I try to phrase it, I think. And by the way,
- 53:06if they're going to arbitration, I'm usually
- 53:08pretty good buddies with the arbitrator. So at
- 53:11least in this state and hopefully you're we're
- 53:16trying to settle based on you know somewhat objectively
- 53:19predicted outcomes so hopefully you know you
- 53:22know that can get discussed and then you know
- 53:24i keep it out of the proposal but often during
- 53:27the course of a day i've kind of engaged in that
- 53:31bit of mild evaluation as we've worked you know
- 53:33through the afternoon okay i think we should
- 53:37probably ask them if they have questions because
- 53:39here's one near the end of our how do all of
- 53:42these techniques fit into a b a opinion five
- 53:45one eight Keith, could you type in, are you familiar
- 53:49with ABA Opinion 518, Lizbeth? Well, I think
- 53:54it addresses... Self -determination? Misleading
- 53:58communications, but maybe somebody could give
- 54:01us the... We don't have a ready response, but
- 54:07maybe we do if we know exactly what it is. I
- 54:10believe it's about avoiding misleading communications.
- 54:17Absolutely. um and it's addressed to a lawyer
- 54:20and probably uh to to um neutrals also does somebody
- 54:30have uh um i don't think they can they can speak
- 54:33to us no i'm that's not it yeah okay a b a i'm
- 54:42sorry yeah it's uh it says a b a uh 580 clarifies
- 54:49a lawyer's duties when acting as a third party
- 54:51a neutral mediator and it is about not showing,
- 54:58not using misleading communications, but I don't
- 55:01have the full language in front of me. Dishonesty,
- 55:05fraud, deceit or misrepresentation, never. Yeah,
- 55:09no, that is not part of the toolbox of the mediator.
- 55:14I mean, sometimes people do think that a mediator
- 55:16is there to say, oh, that won't work, or just
- 55:22to drive GM parties together by over -representing
- 55:28or misrepresenting or exaggerating another party's
- 55:32side. But I find that you know, one, I don't
- 55:36do it. And two, I don't think it works for for
- 55:39coming to to usually doesn't work for coming
- 55:42to. Well, I was I participated in a northern
- 55:46district. They ran a fantastic ADR program, still
- 55:50do. It was one of the early seed programs in
- 55:52the country, frankly. And they brought in a few
- 55:54folks like me, commercial mediators, and said,
- 55:57Do you ever go beyond simply carrying? facilitating
- 56:00the communication back and forth. I mean, do
- 56:02you actually bring your own evaluation into it
- 56:04and do things of this nature? And we were all
- 56:07like, well, yeah. Do you push people? You know,
- 56:13yeah. And it's a bit of a rough and tumble world
- 56:15I operate in. I don't deny it. But any deceit,
- 56:19misrepresentation, absolutely never. Yeah, I
- 56:23just that's not what we're there for. We're there
- 56:26to know. I'm always trying to get my absolute
- 56:29best guess of what parties want to what's possible.
- 56:32What do you and what their situations are to,
- 56:34you know, avoid dishonesty and and those statement
- 56:40that is in your best interest. Yeah, I mean,
- 56:43I don't have any interest. I try to tell folks
- 56:46all the time, if they pay that number you just
- 56:48said, my goodness, we'd settle, right? I mean,
- 56:50if they'll do it, if they'll pay that number
- 56:52you just asked for, let's go home. I'm fine with
- 56:54that. I'm happy. I don't care what number. Yeah.
- 57:00Yeah. And I think, you know, it's not necessarily
- 57:03the best interest of the mediator to get a settlement
- 57:06either. I think the best interest of the mediator
- 57:09is to be sure the parties have, know the options
- 57:14that they have. and you've gotten as much information
- 57:18in front of them as to what the other side would
- 57:22do to settle the case as you can and as you're
- 57:26given permission to. Very often you are talking
- 57:30about confidential things with one party or the
- 57:33other in the room usually and it's important
- 57:36to understand as you leave that room what you're
- 57:40allowed to talk about and what remains confidential
- 57:43in their room. And that's another thing I make
- 57:49sure that I know before I march off with some
- 57:52new ideas to the other side. Anything else? Oh,
- 58:011059. I think extra credit's coming if I understand
- 58:06it. We may have talked their ears off. You guys
- 58:10explain to us as everybody gets even more CLE
- 58:12credit if we go past 11 o 'clock. Yeah, I mean
- 58:17I mean we are talkers because I think that's
- 58:19part of it's an important part of being the mediator
- 58:22You know is to be able to look at the subject
- 58:26matter talk about it from an informed position,
- 58:30but spontaneously at the same time and and really
- 58:34think creatively on your feet and Communicate
- 58:38well what you're thinking about so if we talk
- 58:43your ears off. That's part of part of what we
- 58:46do. So we appreciate everyone's attention for
- 58:49sure and being here today and hope everyone has
- 58:52a great rest of their day. I'm not seeing any
- 58:54more questions and I don't know if Aliyah is
- 58:57still with us or how we close this out. This
- 59:01concludes today's presentation. I'd like to thank
- 59:04Elizabeth and Michael for an excellent presentation
- 59:06today and for educating our members and also
- 59:09a lovely thanks to our audience for joining us.
- 59:12Have a great day, everyone. Thank you.